Election review with Alison Dagnes, Political Science Professor at Shippensburg University.
00:00 - The following program is sponsored in part by customers bank.
00:07 - [MUSIC]
00:14 - Allison Dagnes, political science professor at
00:18 - Shipensburg University, what motivated voters to cast
00:22 - their ballots in Pennsylvania's midterm election?
00:26 - I think that the motivating factor in Pennsylvania
00:28 - was the same motivating factor everywhere.
00:31 - It began with the economy and branched out from there.
00:35 - It seemed that the sense of the American public was one of frustration,
00:41 - ambivalence, fear, concern, and I would argue a lot of people felt ignored.
00:50 - Right now, we're in a climate that feels uncertain and unsteady.
00:58 - And so, as a college professor, I can tell you that my students are looking ahead,
01:04 - wondering what AI is going to do for their jobs and their future.
01:08 - My students who have graduated with whom I still keep in touch,
01:12 - they are now concerned about buying a house because interest rates are very high
01:17 - and they're worried they're never going to be able to afford to do that.
01:21 - The problems that face the country right now are pretty sizable.
01:26 - And it also feels at the exact same time that a lot of elected officials are not
01:33 - really tuned in to the fact that gas prices are high.
01:37 - And if you live in rural areas, as many of us
01:40 - do, that it gets very expensive very quickly.
01:43 - That the price of diesel is going to affect food prices,
01:47 - and that makes the weekly trip to the grocery store very expensive.
01:52 - Et cetera, et cetera, I've got a lot of kids who
01:54 - are farm kids, and so fertilizers got up a bunch.
01:57 - It just feels right now that things are very wobbly,
02:00 - and even though I have plenty of friends who are economists who tell me
02:04 - that the fundamentals of the economic system in the United States is fairly sound,
02:10 - it also feels at the same time like things are spiraling out of control.
02:15 - And so for all of those reasons, I think Americans were eager for a change.
02:21 - And so in Pennsylvania and in the other 49 states,
02:24 - I think that's why people went to the polls in very high numbers.
02:28 - So all these concerns you've enumerated were
02:31 - manifested in good turnout for midterm election?
02:34 - It seems like it. We'll get, you know, hard data in soon about what the turnout was.
02:40 - But for a midterm election, it does seem, especially in states in the South,
02:46 - that there were large populations of black voters who were making their voices heard,
02:52 - especially after the Calais Supreme Court
02:54 - decision, that really gutted the Voting Rights Act.
02:58 - It seems as if people said, you know what, you can't take this democracy away from me,
03:04 - and the power that I have is the power of the vote.
03:07 - It is the power to have my first amendment voice be heard at the ballot box.
03:13 - And so a lot of Americans went out,
03:16 - I think, to vote in the midterms where they might not have,
03:19 - if things felt a little bit more comfortable,
03:21 - they might have been okay with staying at home,
03:23 - because that's also your first amendment, right?
03:26 - What about the Democrats' success at the polls on Tuesday?
03:30 - In your mind, what accounts for it?
03:32 - Donald Trump.
03:34 - This was a wholesale rejection of Donald Trump.
03:38 - I think that for a bunch of different reasons that we can get into,
03:43 - if you want, that the second season of the Trump show started off with a real bang,
03:50 - and that it became very clear that the destabilizing
03:54 - policies that many voters had supported in theory
03:58 - when in reality turned out to be something that was
04:00 - quite enigmatic to what it was that they believed in.
04:04 - In addition to that, I think that with the high prices and the uncertainty out there,
04:11 - that President Trump has been distracted by
04:14 - things that are not relevant to everyday lives.
04:18 - You know, it's concerning beautification projects in Washington, D.C.
04:22 - And he has enriched himself quite dramatically.
04:26 - And at some point, he said, you know, I know
04:28 - gas prices are high, but we're getting rich.
04:31 - And the question that my students had for me was, who's we?
04:34 - And I think that that resonated, not just with
04:36 - my students, but with a whole lot of people.
04:42 - And so it all, to me, it all comes back to him, which is normal
04:46 - in a midterm election to be a referendum on the party in power
04:50 - and that party in power is always going to be the president.
04:53 - But in this case, with the tariffs on, you know,
04:56 - quote unquote, liberation day a year and a half ago,
05:02 - with the unforced, unsupported, you know, uncountable war in Iran,
05:10 - that Americans sort of felt, you know, wait, where are you doing these
05:14 - things that end up hurting me without a seeming care in the world?
05:18 - And that is a very big problem.
05:21 - Because in truth, the war in Iran did cause prices to go up,
05:25 - especially when it came to gas and diesel and fertilizer.
05:31 - You know, but also I've got students, I was just giving a class and I pointed at two guys
05:34 - who sat together and I said, you're in ROTC, you're the ones who are going to be deployed.
05:39 - I don't, I will of course send you care packages.
05:42 - I just don't want you to go, you know, and then the
05:44 - young lady sitting in front of her boyfriend's a Marine.
05:47 - And, you know, and she got like a little teary because
05:50 - she was like, I don't want my boyfriend to go away.
05:54 - But it affects people, the military are just chess pieces. They're people
05:58 - with families and sons and daughters and boyfriends and girlfriends.
06:02 - And all of these actions are seemingly done,
06:05 - if not haphazardly, then certainly on the fly.
06:10 - And that does not really engender a lot of
06:13 - confidence in leadership and indecision making.
06:23 - And I think the American public as boring as policy is and as exciting a campaigner as Donald Trump was, I
06:27 - think people just want some policy to hold on to, to make them feel better about the folks who are in charge.
06:35 - As a result of the election and we're now looking closely at Pennsylvania, Democrats have
06:38 - the majority in both House and Senate chambers and we have a Democratic governor, of course.
06:43 - Well that expedite the legislative agenda.
06:47 - As a spec, so certainly working without, you know, a
06:50 - party opposing you in the majority is going to be easier.
06:55 - Governor Shapiro calls it the trifecta and it certainly
06:59 - will make passing policy and passing laws much easier.
07:03 - I guess for Republicans who might be concerned, oh no, this is going to
07:07 - be the start of, you know, a flood of lefty policies that I don't like.
07:17 - I don't think you have to worry about that. Governor Shapiro has really made a name for himself in the state
07:21 - and nationally for being not only bipartisan, but for seeing politics as a way to as he says get stuff done.
07:35 - And the way that he's able to get stuff done is by working with members of the Republican Party and, you know, and not
07:39 - striving for some ideological purity test, but really striving for good. And so I think more things will get through faster.
07:52 - I think that that having the Democrats have control of both the state House and the state Senate is going to allow the permission structure for Republicans
07:58 - to get on board, because if there's a policy that might be good for their constituents and they're in the minority, you might as well vote for it, right?
08:19 - Your constituents will be happy and you don't really have much to fight with. And so that could, I think, enable a lot more collaboration cooperation and maybe some really good laws that get passed with bipartisan
08:23 - support, which would be a wonderful thing because that if we learn nothing from yesterday, the exit polling all showed that Americans across the country desperately, desperately want more bipartisanship.
08:27 - What was the key to Shapiro's success on Tuesday? Was it enough to be a Democrat?
08:41 - I think being a Democrat helped. I never think it's just one thing. I think being a Democrat yesterday helped and we saw that all around the country.
08:46 - But I think that Shapiro has really worked hard in the last four years to make a name for himself as somebody who wants to work for all Pennsylvanians.
08:59 - So I think it's probable that he wants that name to extend further than just the borders of Pennsylvania to the other states
09:03 - of the country. But if that's the way he is going to harness his ambition, then I'm all for it because it's not negative.
09:09 - It's not divisive. It is, in fact, collaborative and working together in order to
09:12 - make the lives of Pennsylvanians better. And that makes that gives me some confidence.
09:23 - Well, let's talk about his opponent, Stacey Garrity. She failed in her attempt to unseat Josh Shapiro as
09:27 - governor. So tell us what you observed about her campaign and how did she try to make an impression on voters?
09:50 - I think one of the problems is I don't really know very much about Miss Garrity. I don't. I think I wish I knew more. I don't get the sense
09:55 - that her campaign was really operating on all cylinders and that it was trying as hard as it could to make Garrity front of mind for voters.
10:12 - And that's a problem because Shapiro for whatever you say about him and I know people have problems with his ambition. He's a very charismatic
10:17 - guy and to combat that with politics that doesn't rest on that kind of charm is going to fall flat and I think that's what happened.
10:22 - Alison Shapiro and Garrity brought the subject of data centers
10:25 - into this campaign. Do you think that struck a chord with voters?
10:38 - Oh, sure. Governor Shapiro was sort of notoriously in favor of data centers until he was opposed to it. But then he was
10:42 - opposed to it. And the will of the people, the people have spoken. The people do not like data centers. They just don't.
10:56 - So much so that I read recently that the head of I think open AI or inotropic has renamed data centers into something that's like using
11:01 - different words like a collaborative environment of data and technology and I'm like, okay, well, we're going to get onto that one too.
11:14 - But that's how poisonous the term became and it became poison very quickly. And so the folks who were in charge, I don't
11:18 - think really understood how angry the public was about these things until it for some of them until it was too late.
11:32 - Governor Shapiro was not, he keyed in pretty quickly that people didn't like them. Well, this is interesting as well because at the last minute
11:37 - the campaign, Garrity injected the idea of skill games into the campaign and tell us briefly how much political capital was to be had from that.
11:52 - And I don't think very much. I think I feel like skill games really kind of peaked as an issue in the primary era. And then there's been legislation
11:56 - since then. And then it just sort of died away a little bit. And so one of the rules of campaigning is you have to go where the voters are.
12:00 - And the voters were not talking about skill games now.
12:03 - Skill games feels very, you know, April to me.
12:14 - A few minutes ago, Allison, you said you didn't know a whole lot about Garrity, but we know a couple things about her. Of course, she won two terms as
12:20 - state treasurer and now that she's failed in this attempt to run for governor, does she strike is the kind of person who will run for elected office again.
12:31 - That's a good question. I don't really know. I mean, she's going to remain as as treasurer. It sure seems as if
12:35 - she can do a good job as treasurer that there might be a future for I don't know what her goals and ambitions are.
12:44 - Also, this, you know, as they say, politics ain't beanbag. It's a lot of work. It's a lot of times a lot
12:48 - of effort. And so this may have been the thing that says to work, maybe I'm okay with where I am right now.
12:54 - Well, now that Josh Shapiro is the projected winner for governor in Pennsylvania, what about the
12:58 - latest on his presidential aspirations? We've been hearing about that for at least six months.
13:06 - Oh, yeah, six, 10 years. Yes, I mean, he's, you know, it's,
13:09 - it's, I like to call it the worst step kept secret in politics.
13:17 - Right now with an open seat in 28 on both sides, right?
13:20 - So there's no incumbent who's going to try and run again in 2028.
13:36 - It gives the Democrats who have a very deep bench, a wide availability of possible candidates. And I think Shapiro's obviously
13:41 - going to be one of them, which is, I think fantastic because he's going to be running against other very high quality folks.
13:53 - Now, to be fair, he's running against a bunch of governors of swing states.
13:56 - So he is one of several. He's running against a bunch of male Jewish youngish men.
14:03 - And so that makes him again in kind of a cluster. He's not going to be able to stand out
14:06 - from his demographics. He's not going to be able to stand out from his position right now.
14:15 - So what I think that's going to do for him is force him into looking ahead and reading the
14:19 - tea leaves to see what's the best position for him if he does want to run for president.
14:37 - And I think it also would be a good idea for him to think about what he might want to do if that does not come to fruition because, to me, he has all the potential
14:43 - in the world. And, and so it's not just that he could position himself very nicely for advice presidential run, although I think that would be successful.
14:52 - In two years, he could run for the Senate against John Federman and they have notorious beef with one another. So I think that would be both personally and
14:58 - professionally gratifying to beat John Federman in a Senate race, although I don't think the Federman's really positioning himself to run again, but we'll say.
15:07 - Also, President Trump and Doge gutted about 20% of the federal government, which means that whomever
15:11 - is president next if they are a Democrat, they have to fill a lot of very important seats very quickly.
15:21 - And so, of course, Governor Shapiro is going to look ahead and realize my goodness. There are 15 cabinet
15:25 - seats out there that have a tremendous amount of impact and many of these offices have been decimated.
15:41 - And so whomever is going to be the next secretary of education, secretary of agriculture, secretary of defense goodness, the
15:46 - attorney general, they have a perculean battle ahead to build up these institutions and make a phenomenal amount of difference.
15:53 - And so it's probable because I suspect that Josh Shapiro is a pretty bright guy and understands
15:56 - politics possibly better than me with a PhD in this, but that's okay because he's living the life.
16:13 - I think that he probably is looking ahead to go, okay, if it's not president, it's attorney general, you know, might be pretty sweet, that might be
16:17 - a good job and a job of not just title because that does not seem to be his motivating factor, but a job of great significance and huge importance.
16:21 - I mean, the Department of Justice is going to have to
16:24 - be fundamentally rebuilt and that is no small matter.
16:38 - Let's move on to races in Congress here at PCN, we concentrated on a number of races and the first one would be Congress in district one and that
16:42 - involved Brian Fitzpatrick, the Republican, the incumbent and Bob Harvey, the Democrat at Bucks County commissioner, he prevailed in this race.
16:46 - What were you able to observe there?
16:51 - That was an interesting, interesting race. Brian Fitzpatrick, by all accounts, he was the most
16:54 - bipartisan member of Congress. He raised a tremendous amount of money, especially compared to Harvey.
17:09 - He was a very, very popular congressman and from both sides, Democrats liked him, Republicans liked him, and he had
17:13 - one several times in races where the thought was, I don't know about this, but he held on and yesterday he did not.
17:19 - I think that his seat got caught up in the Democratic wave
17:23 - of yesterday, the blue nami as some people are calling it.
17:34 - And so it changes, obviously the partisan makeup of our congressional delegation quite
17:38 - a bit to have four new Democrats who are going to be going to Washington in January.
17:42 - But, you know, Brian Fitzpatrick is nice. I sincerely hope this is
17:45 - not the last way here for him because he's a truly impressive person.
17:51 - Let's move on to district seven and that would involve Ryan
17:54 - McKenzie, the Republican incumbent, Bob Brooks, the Democrat.
18:01 - He is the president of a fire fighter association. I wonder Allison
18:05 - if that resembles a significant voting block and he won anyway.
18:09 - He did win anyway.
18:13 - The Brooks campaign, he was a great, he was a great candidate, he was a great pick.
18:19 - And I'm not sure if that was a Washington decision or
18:22 - a Harrisburg decision, but he was a terrific candidate.
18:32 - And I just think that again, the title wave of anti-Republican slash anti-Trump
18:37 - sentiment, really just in that race, just swamped absolutely everything.
18:41 - Well, let's move on to district eight and that would be Rob.
18:51 - He's the Republican incumbent there and Paige Cognetti,
18:55 - Democrat, Mayor of Scranton, prevailed in that race.
19:08 - What I think about next was the tremendous gap this time around in the last time that
19:11 - these three races were called two years ago. Each were called an under two points, right.
19:16 - So they were very, very, very close. Yesterday, I believe Cognetti won by 10.
19:24 - So that Brooks won one by 12. This was a huge shift. This was a monster of a shift.
19:31 - And so I believe that all three of these races for
19:34 - Pennsylvania won for Fitzpatrick, that was five points.
19:39 - And that makes more sense because he really was so just entrenched in the district.
19:49 - These three races for them to switch from, you know, one point something over to
19:53 - nine, ten, twelve, really proved that this was a monster of a night for the Democrats.
20:01 - Let's move on to district ten and that would be the race involving Scott Perry, the incumbent
20:05 - Republican, and Janelle Stelson, the former news broadcaster, prevailed in that race.
20:11 - Scott Perry had been in that office for several years. In fact, Janelle Stelson
20:15 - had challenged him two years ago and came close to beating him this time she did.
20:23 - Correct. It was a grudge match. Which happens actually very frequently in house races.
20:27 - And so Stelson came out swinging this time. She raised more money than Perry did.
20:41 - You know, Perry was aligned so closely with Donald Trump that there was no escaping it. And so as much as he tried to sort of
20:46 - do mobilization instead of persuasion, because he didn't have much to use for persuasion, the mobilization just wasn't enough.
20:53 - And in a time of uncertainty, like we have right now, you know, calling folks names and saying
20:57 - that gas prices are high because of something that it wasn't. That's just not going to work.
21:06 - Let's move on to district seventeen and a continuation of what you called the blue wave. Chris Delusio,
21:10 - the Democrat, the incumbent, won over Tony Guy, the Republican, and he's a Beaver County sheriff.
21:23 - What did you see going on there, Allison? I thought that was another interesting race. It was not necessarily particularly close, but that district
21:28 - has been one that has been close in the past and so I understand, you know, wanting to sort of take a look and see what was happening there.
21:44 - But again, I think candidate quality was that really was one of the fundamentals of this election and he was a very, very good
21:48 - candidate. And so it's hard to, in a time when the out party has a leg up in terms of candidate quality in terms of fundraising.
21:53 - And then just the vibes of the country all around. It's really, it
21:57 - would be really hard for a Republican to try and win against that.
22:08 - Let's go beyond the results and consider the avatar advertising. You know that we were bombarded by commercials
22:12 - on TV online. Did you perceive a theme or a thread running through the campaign commercials this season?
22:22 - I did. The advertising was fascinating because I think when all of a sudden done, there
22:25 - will have been $12 billion, $12 billion spent on advertising in America for these midterms.
22:35 - And this is without a presidential race. So we're talking about a lot of ads. And those ads are not
22:38 - only on television, obviously, and anybody who owns a TV, as I do, boy did I see my fair share of ads.
22:54 - As I'm sure everybody else did, but my students were seeing a bunch of ads on their streaming services
22:58 - on their Twitch games on, you know, the forums that they go to that I don't know what they are.
23:15 - The themes I think were fairly consistent with the themes of around the country. So, and they were different by party. So the Republican party was really working on mobilization.
23:22 - It was a lot of fear mongering, saying that if the Democrats are elected, they are going to, in many cases, you know, they're going to, your child will go to school,
23:35 - kindergarten as a boy and be mandatory transition and sent home as a girl. You know, the ads said if they are elected, I saw a bunch of ads that said that Janelle
23:41 - Stelson and Nancy Pelosi, we're going to work together and I thought, well, that's strange because Nancy Pelosi's retired, you know, that didn't even make any sense.
23:51 - So that was certainly one of the things that the Republicans tried as hard as they could do to mobilize their folks to
23:55 - say, all right, we get it, we don't have very much, I think Vice President Van said, just give us a little more time.
23:59 - And so that's not a great message. Like if you're saying, please
24:02 - give us more time, that means we didn't use our time very well.
24:08 - And instead of that, they said, forget about us, they are the bad part. So that's what the
24:11 - Republican messaging was. And the Democratic messaging was dominant anti Trump, you know, it didn't.
24:21 - In fact, one of the Senate candidates in, I believe it was New Hampshire, cut an ad that said,
24:24 - my opponent says that I love Donald Trump and I'm basically his son, I've never even met the man.
24:40 - Okay, that's a really strange ad to run. So it was a lot about Donald Trump because Donald Trump is so wildly
24:44 - unpopular right now. He is polling in the mid 30s, which is historically low for an incumbent president.
24:52 - And so tying any of the Republicans who are running to somebody bad unpopular, that
24:55 - made a lot of sense. And also, you know, the Republicans have been running the show.
25:00 - So if you're unhappy, you do have somebody to point at and
25:03 - that's not making things out that's just sort of noticing.
25:14 - Alison, I have a hunch, your students were talking about the spot, the political ad that the Garrity campaign put
25:18 - out that involved a deep fake AI generated Shapiro. Tell me, what did these young people have to say about this spot?
25:31 - They were so confused. I guess they thought, who's going to fall for this? This is just, you know, the term
25:35 - is slop. This is just slop. This is awful. And truthfully, I didn't quite understand what the purpose was.
25:41 - I suppose there might be some folks who if they aren't paying too, too much attention might be a
25:44 - little confused, but all you have to do is turn around and look at and go, well, that's not right.
25:56 - And so my concern is that in two years, AI is going to be so good. We're not going to be able to tell the difference
26:00 - and that's going to be really scary. But for right now, that was a very strange move. I'm not sure what the goal was.
26:10 - Well, your students have lots of sources of information, certainly a lot more sources that I had when I was a
26:14 - young person. What advice do you give to them on separating fact from fiction? Try to address that in a minute.
26:20 - We have a very, very hard rule in my classes. We all agree collectively to have
26:24 - a site that we will check our information on and it has to be a news service.
26:31 - So Reuters or the Associated Press and I let the students pick because that's just the
26:35 - facts, ma'am kind of service where you can go and you can get some real verified information.
26:48 - And then otherwise, I always for all of my students on our learning site, go ahead and put up about 20 different news sources. Some on the
26:53 - left, some on the right, some, you know, mainstream down the middle, different polling sites where they can get real fact based information.
27:08 - And then the government also is a great source for fact based information, especially about elections because the federal elections commission will report earnings and fundraising and all of
27:11 - that sort of good stuff. And now our secretary's state will be coming out with all the data that I know you and I are going to be very excited to dig into about who voted for who, where and why.
27:16 - Last question. What's the big takeaway for you after this election?
27:24 - I really think that this was a resounding plea for some help by the people.
27:40 - And I think that all elected officials, not just President Trump, not just the Republicans, all elected officials have to heed this call and
27:44 - listen to the public who are saying, we don't like either of you, we need help and you better start fixing the problems that we have hired you.
27:49 - We are paying you to fix. And so my big takeaway is elected officials.
27:53 - You got a couple of years, put on your running shoes and get to the point.
27:57 - Allison Dagnes, political science professor at Chippensburg University. Thank you.
28:03 - Thank you.
28:18 - [Music]