[10.23.26] PA Historical Association program on women and children in early America in Northampton Community College in Bethlehem.
00:00 - (upbeat music)
00:09 - - We're about to get started.
00:11 - Thank you for hanging in until five o'clock.
00:13 - We know we're standing between you and dinner.
00:18 - So thank you for being here.
00:19 - Thank you for coming to my campus.
00:21 - It's a privilege to serve as the Vice Provost of Academic
00:24 - Affairs here at Northampton Community College.
00:28 - I'm also a long-term member of the Pennsylvania Historical Association.
00:33 - I want to give a shout out to the Pennsylvania
00:35 - cable network for being in the house today.
00:39 - Thank you for being here.
00:41 - That's great.
00:42 - It's a quirk of fate that in the '90s,
00:44 - when I did my first paper as a graduate student at
00:48 - Penn State, Pennsylvania cable network was here.
00:51 - So we have three graduate panels to the papers today.
00:57 - We'll go in the order of the program, giving people about up to 20 minutes,
01:03 - and then have time for a conversation afterward.
01:06 - Okay, Ben is up first.
01:15 - - All right, so I am Benjamin Workley.
01:18 - I'm a graduate student at James Madison University.
01:21 - And this is my presentation about women and children
01:24 - as prisoners of order in the American Revolution.
01:26 - So just to kind of, first of all, get about something here with this.
01:31 - The framework of this is that these women and children are prisoners themselves.
01:35 - And this is kind of, I know I have argument up there.
01:38 - This is kind of the central point that I'm
01:40 - getting at here, is that these women and children
01:42 - who, for the most part, followed the British military,
01:46 - they were mostly the wives and obviously children,
01:50 - sons and daughters of these members of the British military.
01:54 - And they themselves were prisoners of order.
01:56 - They were subject to confinement.
02:00 - So, where we kind of start off with this, is in Lancaster County in 1775.
02:06 - This is kind of the first real group.
02:08 - There were some prisoners captured in Lexington and Concord up in Massachusetts.
02:12 - But this is the first real group of prisoners
02:14 - that the United States has to deal with.
02:17 - And they come from the seventh and 26th regiments of foot.
02:20 - The seventh regiment has 250 men and 60 women.
02:24 - We don't know the genders of the 130 prisoners who come from the 26th regiment.
02:28 - Makes me assume they're probably mostly men,
02:30 - but I can't speculate off of that beyond that.
02:34 - And these men and women had been captured
02:36 - at British garrisons at St. John's and Chombre
02:40 - and what is now Quebec up in Canada during, what would ultimately end up becoming
02:45 - the Patriots unsuccessful Canadian campaign.
02:48 - And in November, November 17th, 1775, the Continental Congress
02:53 - ordered these POWs to be sent to Reading, Lancaster, and York.
02:58 - Now this is a big problem for them.
03:02 - How do we feed these prisoners?
03:04 - The prisoners arrived with only two days' worth of provisions.
03:07 - An innkeeper and member of the Committee of Safety
03:09 - by the name of Matthias Slow had volunteered to
03:12 - serve as like a temporary provisioning agent.
03:14 - And Congress very quickly stepped in
03:16 - and appointed a loyalist by the name of David Franks
03:19 - to serve as the permanent provisioning agent.
03:22 - Now Franks' appointment did not solve all of these problems, in
03:26 - part because Franks refused to supply the women and children.
03:30 - He cited, he basically passed the problem
03:33 - off onto General William Howe of the British military,
03:37 - who was at that point in time the commander in chief
03:39 - of the British military, claiming that he had not
03:44 - provided provisions for these women and children.
03:47 - So therefore, Franks could not possibly pay for them.
03:50 - So these women and children, very quickly,
03:53 - petitioned the local Committee of Safety in Lancaster begging for provisions.
03:59 - I don't have the exact words of their petition, however,
04:02 - in a letter to the Continental Congress, one of the heads of the Lancaster Committee,
04:06 - says that they had basically expressed that
04:09 - they, quote, that they must inevitably perish
04:12 - unless relieved from their present distress, end quote.
04:15 - And so the Lancaster Committee has an issue to solve.
04:19 - How do we provide for these women and children?
04:22 - They choose to be compassionate towards them.
04:24 - They choose to provide food and shelter
04:28 - for these women and children at public expense is the exact wording of that.
04:33 - In fact, the last line of this is one, I have the full quote of the end of it,
04:37 - but the last line of this I find to be very interesting.
04:40 - We are strongly inclined at the first moment to assist them in their distress.
04:44 - Our feelings as men, evidently pointed out to
04:48 - those people as real objects of compassion.
04:51 - In this line, the as men, we are seeing that these women and children
04:56 - are they're sympathetic because of their gender and age, essentially.
05:02 - And that this may have been partially
05:04 - where the Lancaster Committee's compassion came from.
05:08 - So the next place we're going to talk about,
05:11 - and I have a little map to show you guys where this is, is what ends up being known
05:16 - as the Walnut Street Prison in Philadelphia.
05:18 - We've not called that at this point in time, it was called the New Jail.
05:22 - It had been built in 1773.
05:24 - And number 38 up there is the State House,
05:27 - or as we would now call it today, Independence Hall.
05:31 - Whilst number 45 is the New Jail, as I will be calling it,
05:35 - as it was called in all of the primary documents.
05:39 - And this jail was run by Thomas Bradford, the Deputy, the man who had been appointed
05:46 - by the Continental Congress to be Deputy
05:50 - Commissary of Prisoners of War for Philadelphia.
05:54 - And in this role, he basically ran the prison.
05:57 - He was in charge of provisioning them.
06:00 - He was in charge of regulating them.
06:02 - This was his role.
06:03 - Many, many, many prisoners petitioned him.
06:06 - And one of these petitioners is a woman by the name of Hannah Mormon.
06:11 - Her name is also sometimes transcribed as Hannah
06:13 - Norman, but I'll show you the signature later,
06:16 - I personally read it as Mormon, but regardless.
06:21 - Very, very, very little is known for certain about her life.
06:25 - She was a woman who was serving with the 17th Regiment of Foot.
06:28 - She likely followed her husband as most women with the British military did.
06:33 - However, the identity of her husband is completely unknown.
06:37 - I don't know who he was.
06:40 - And that she was a prisoner of war in the new jail in August of 1779.
06:45 - She is also a standout because she is one of the only,
06:49 - not one of the only, one of, I believe two sources that I
06:54 - have directly in the words of these female prisoners of war.
06:58 - This is them speaking themselves.
07:01 - Only two of them that I'm aware of.
07:02 - And I can talk about the other wondering questions.
07:04 - If you're curious, she's not in Pennsylvania though.
07:08 - Mormon petition's Bradford talking about how
07:12 - she had been, quote, "much afflicted with sickness"
07:14 - for most of her time, but that she had recently recovered from it.
07:19 - And then she asks Bradford to, quote,
07:22 - grant me liberty to walk out of the jail once or twice a week
07:26 - so that she could be capable of procuring some nourishment
07:29 - which she felt she was unable to do in her current state.
07:34 - Now, her petition is very simple.
07:37 - She simply wants to be healthier because she is sick
07:42 - and as many prisoners within this festering,
07:45 - horrible conditions of the new jail were afflicted.
07:50 - Now, something else that is extraordinarily notable,
07:52 - beyond the fact that she petitioned at all, is her signature here, where she signs,
07:57 - as your most humble and obedient servant, Hannah Mormon, 17th Regiment of Foot.
08:04 - The notable thing for this, for those who may not be as familiar
08:07 - with historiography around women during, within the British military,
08:11 - is the fact that she signs as 17th Regiment of Foot,
08:14 - not Hannah Mormon husband of blah, blah,
08:16 - blah, serving with the 17th Regiment of Foot.
08:18 - She is stating here that she is serving with this regiment.
08:22 - She, at the bare minimum, that she sees herself within that role.
08:28 - She is an active member of this military organization.
08:31 - She is not passively accompanying it.
08:36 - And we also see women pop up in other petitions
08:38 - such as William Dinsmore of the 71st Regiment,
08:41 - who was, quote, "A married man who has his
08:44 - wife and two children with him in the jail.
08:48 - He states in his petition that the provisions
08:51 - he was receiving were not enough to feed him, his wife and two children.
08:55 - He also states that his wife had attempted to find work in Philadelphia.
08:59 - However, she, and that she, quote, "had good hands,
09:03 - "but had been turned away by all of the local
09:06 - people "who she had applied to work for,
09:08 - "because they did not want to provide for her two children.
09:11 - "Because as a part of that deal, if you took her in,
09:13 - "you also would have to take in her two children "and take care of them.
09:17 - " So Dinsmore talks about himself as a rope maker from Glasgow, Scotland.
09:23 - So he even talks about where he was from in here.
09:26 - And he talks about his connections in Philadelphia from
09:30 - Scotland, where he says, "Basically this guy is my reference.
09:34 - "I need a job so that way I can feed my wife and child.
09:38 - " So this gets back to what we talked about earlier with Lancaster.
09:41 - This was still an ongoing issue at this point in the war.
09:45 - Such an issue for that even men themselves
09:47 - felt the need to get jobs outside of their prisoner confinement,
09:52 - making rope that likely would go on to ships
09:55 - to then kill other British people to be used in the war against them.
10:00 - But that didn't matter to them.
10:01 - What mattered to them was providing for their families.
10:06 - So the last place I want to talk about,
10:10 - and I'm going to spend quite a bit of time on this,
10:11 - because this is where a lot of my research has
10:13 - focused, is a location by the name of Camp Security.
10:16 - Located right outside of York about four miles from it,
10:20 - where that little asterisk is, that's where Camp Security was.
10:24 - Just a very, very quick overview of it.
10:26 - It opened in August of 1781, and operated until May of 1783,
10:31 - when the British prisoners of war were returned back
10:35 - to Britain following the provisional peace and the end of the war.
10:39 - It was initially built to house and listed men and
10:43 - family from what was known as the convention army,
10:46 - the soldiers captured at Saratoga in 1777.
10:49 - But it also housed British troops captured
10:51 - at the Battle of Yorktown in Virginia in 1781,
10:54 - whom I will be referring to as the Cornwallis prisoners,
10:58 - because calling them the Yorktown prisoners is confusing,
11:01 - because York is called Yorktown in the period, Yorktown, Virginia, York,
11:06 - I'm just gonna solve it by calling on the Cornwallis prisoners.
11:09 - And, as you will see here, they are called the Cornwallis Army in primary documents.
11:15 - So, that's why I go with that name.
11:18 - However, so these two groups are very different,
11:24 - and their differences are important to note.
11:27 - Convention army have been captured in 1777,
11:30 - and they had been shuttled throughout the country.
11:32 - First to Massachusetts, then marched 700 miles
11:35 - down to Virginia, and then marched all the way back up
11:39 - through the Shenandoah Valley to Winchester, Virginia,
11:41 - then through Maryland, then to Lancaster, and then to York.
11:45 - So, they'd been through a lot before getting here.
11:49 - And, I can talk more on that if your super cares about that.
11:52 - But, the Cornwallis prisoners, not prisoners for quite as long.
11:56 - They have been captured in 1781 in Virginia, as I said,
11:58 - moved to Winchester, then moved up to PA, pretty short story.
12:03 - Now, one of the biggest differences between these two,
12:06 - and this is super important to note, the presence of women and children
12:10 - amongst both is very different.
12:12 - Among the convention army who's called Burgoyne's Army
12:15 - in this document, there are 146 women, and 180 children know it's cut off.
12:22 - So, exact numbers are hard to figure out.
12:24 - The Cornwallis prisoners, on the other hand,
12:27 - had 36 women, and nine children.
12:30 - So, I have some theories on why these were so different.
12:35 - But one thing that's important to note
12:36 - is that these numbers, they fluctuate a little bit,
12:39 - but they stay, at least while they're at camp security, pretty consistent.
12:43 - Here's some later provision returns from July 25th through the 31st,
12:47 - where there are about 170 women with the convention army,
12:52 - and two, oops, sorry, I skipped ahead there.
12:55 - There are about, yeah, 100, thank you, Jonathan.
13:04 - And, yeah, but I'm sorry, I lost my spotlight notes.
13:10 - That's really bad.
13:12 - 134 women and 173 children in this return.
13:17 - Now, and whilst with the Cornwallis prisoners, there
13:21 - are 39 women and 11 children, so a slight increase.
13:26 - Earlier in the war, when the convention army
13:29 - is being held in Lancaster, there's another return
13:32 - for them, where there are 170 women and 238 children.
13:37 - Now, just to anticipate a question here,
13:41 - the number is not lower because more of the women are dying.
13:44 - It, one of the explanations is actually
13:47 - that they left a whole bunch of them in Lancaster
13:49 - because they were sick, and they were getting better,
13:52 - and they didn't want them to risk the crossing
13:54 - of the Susquehanna River, or to spread disease
13:56 - within the other camp, so they simply kept them there.
14:00 - And there were about 19 women and 26 children
14:03 - who were left behind, so even when they get to camp security,
14:06 - there was already only 151 women, and 212 children, though
14:10 - more children are dead, but we'll get into why in a minute,
14:14 - those might not necessarily have been the best numbers ever.
14:22 - So, one important thing to understand about camp
14:25 - security is that it was a prisoner of war camp
14:28 - with two distinct sections, and this gets to how we know
14:32 - a little bit about the experiences of the women
14:34 - and children here because it's very different.
14:37 - Then, how Hannah Mormon experienced her captivity in the Philadelphia New Jail.
14:42 - The stockade, which you can see here on the bottom,
14:45 - left side, these are drawings that are attributed
14:48 - to a prisoner of war, they may have been done
14:50 - by one of his descendants, they may have been done by him, it's not exactly clear.
14:55 - And the stockade was where most of the Cornwallis prisoners
14:58 - were held in the "Missy and the poorly behaved"
15:01 - prisoners were held there, so mostly the single men.
15:04 - The village, the one you see on the top,
15:07 - was mostly the convention army and some more
15:10 - well-behaved prisoners from the Cornwallis prisoners.
15:15 - By some accounts, by the spring of 1782,
15:17 - this section may have very well just been completely
15:19 - unguarded, and this is where most of the families,
15:22 - including the women, their husbands, and their children,
15:24 - were housed, was in what becomes known as the village.
15:27 - It's also mockingly called Camp Indulgence by the other prisoners because they felt
15:33 - as if these prisoners were being indulged too much, and they were jealous of them.
15:38 - And to kind of help visualize this, here's kind of a map of it,
15:42 - where Camp Indulgence is, if you're physically
15:45 - there, this is very present, I should know,
15:47 - 'cause I was there over the summer.
15:49 - Camp Indulgence is up on a hill, and the stockade is down there.
15:54 - So these, the prisoners who were mocking them
15:57 - were literally looking up to the top of a hill
16:00 - and seeing every day reminded of the kind of inadequacies.
16:05 - And so, from, we get some sense of what life at the camp
16:10 - was like through the memoir of one of the prisoners, a man by the name of Roger Lamb.
16:14 - Lamb talks about wanting to escape, and he critiques some of his prisoners
16:19 - for having lost the animation which ought to abreast a soldier.
16:25 - And in an unpublished version of this memoir, which
16:27 - is handwritten, he chides them as being lazy outright.
16:31 - He outright says that they were lazy, that they had lost their opportunity to escape.
16:37 - But we get a very interesting contrasting quote, where he says that he was astonished
16:42 - by the spirit of their industry, referring to how the men, women, and children
16:47 - had taken on different trades, such as making lace, buckle, spoons,
16:52 - and exercising other mechanical trades, which they had learned in their captivity.
16:57 - These trades were important because this was,
17:01 - we learned from another part of Lamb's memoir, that many of these women and children
17:04 - were not only making things, things that we know were used at the camp
17:09 - through some of the archeology that's been done.
17:11 - But we also know that these things were sold in town
17:15 - in part because some of them were on bail and pass,
17:20 - meaning that so as we see here, 22 women and 24 children
17:25 - had been bailed out or placed on pass, meaning that they could leave the prison,
17:29 - do whatever they wanted, go throughout the community.
17:34 - Many of them, in addition to working their trades,
17:37 - may very well continue to work in similar roles,
17:39 - to what they had worked as camp followers earlier in the war,
17:42 - as washer women, mending clothes, cooking, cleaning,
17:45 - very much continuing to serve within their domestic roles,
17:48 - whilst also working trades to help feed their families.
17:53 - We also get, and I'm gonna bridge this part a little bit, just in the sake of time,
17:58 - we also get some idea of how these prisoners related to the guards at the camp
18:03 - through the pension testimony of a guard by the name of Andrew Anderson.
18:07 - Anderson recalls that the women would come up and converse
18:10 - with him and talk about how they were happy to be captive.
18:14 - And I do believe him in this because this lines up with what Lamb was saying,
18:18 - that these women, that these prisoners were happy with their confinement.
18:22 - When he would go up and ask them to escape, they would say, no, we don't want to.
18:26 - We're happy here.
18:27 - Why would we cross the Susquehanna River, go through the Lehigh Valley,
18:31 - go through all this wilderness, and everything just to do what?
18:34 - Get back to military discipline in New York City, why would we do that?
18:39 - And we see here that many of these people also may have even had casual relationships
18:45 - with the guards as I'm calling the meaning friendships,
18:47 - because they felt comfortable enough to simply walk up
18:50 - and talk to them and say like, oh, how's your day going?
18:52 - Yeah, talk about our confinement a little bit,
18:56 - which is a very different thing to get into some of the conclusions.
19:00 - She's a very different situation than what we observed in Philadelphia
19:04 - with this more confined and strict, regimented life for them.
19:09 - The urban prison of the New Jail was more harsh
19:12 - whilst in both Lancaster and Pencil and York, we can see these more lax conditions.
19:20 - We also see the prisoners engaging in labor throughout it.
19:26 - And in both York and Philadelphia,
19:29 - to feed themselves because they were not being provided for.
19:33 - So they said, we will provide for ourselves,
19:36 - rather that if the government has failed to provide for us
19:40 - as is its duty within the British military, we will provide for ourselves
19:44 - because we want so strongly to remain as our family units.
19:48 - We also see with camp security, the fact that the presence of women
19:52 - altered the physical layouts of these
19:55 - encampments with a separate section being created
19:59 - for the female prisoners and their families to live in,
20:03 - that was laxer because, and this gets to another point that I wanna make with this,
20:08 - they influenced the male prisoners to escape at far lower rates.
20:12 - Why this is, I'm not exactly sure,
20:15 - but my kind of working theory is that
20:17 - the male prisoners may not have wanted to put
20:19 - their families through this arduous track.
20:23 - But also at the same time, they were comfortable.
20:26 - They were living, working trades, getting money,
20:29 - working as, I mean, and even the name of it.
20:33 - Up here, a lamb or whoever drew it calls it,
20:35 - Burgoyne's town or it's called the village.
20:37 - It's not called the fortification.
20:40 - It's, they use the terminology of civilian settlements
20:47 - when referring to this location.
20:50 - And just to get back to the whole start and the point
20:53 - that I made at the beginning of this presentation.
20:56 - These women and children were active participants
20:58 - within the system of prisoner confinement.
21:01 - They were prisoners themselves.
21:03 - They were not accompanying prisoners.
21:05 - They were prisoners.
21:07 - Much as how they did not accompany the army.
21:10 - They were members of it.
21:12 - They were active members of it.
21:14 - And that they were an essential part of this whole system.
21:17 - Thank you all.
21:19 - (audience applauding)
21:38 - See if the court is gonna work for you.
21:40 - Oh, it does.
21:41 - Okay, good.
21:46 - Okay, right, I'll try to, oh, sorry, I'm trying to, ah.
21:50 - Let's, let's, oh, I guess we get lovely toppin' there.
22:02 - Okay, so for mine, over the summer, I did an internship at Brannewine Battlefield.
22:08 - It's in Chatsport, PA, which is about two hours south of here.
22:12 - And so as part of that internship,
22:15 - I have my experience, my background in gender history,
22:20 - which I feel was lacking from it.
22:23 - And so I wanna do my presentation talking about what the existing narrative is,
22:28 - what the tours are, and adding a gendered lens to that.
22:32 - So, the first of which being, this here is part
22:38 - of the reconstructed house on Brannewine.
22:40 - There's two houses.
22:43 - The ring house, there are Benjamin Ringhouse,
22:45 - which is where Washington's headquarters were.
22:49 - Unfortunately, the original house burnt down in 1930.
22:52 - And it was reconstructed, and the state took it by eminent domain around 1950,
22:57 - and turned it into Brannewine Battlefield State Park.
23:03 - And so then, of course, the tours, I'll give you a bit of a brief tour.
23:09 - They talk about the origins of the Revolutionary War,
23:13 - everything with the aftermath of the French and
23:16 - Indian War, causing tensions between the specifically
23:19 - the American colonies, how those were being delegated,
23:23 - with their own unique policies compared to other colonies
23:27 - of the British Empire, leading to tension and
23:30 - discontent, which ultimately led to armed conflict.
23:34 - And so, around 1776, Declaration of Independence, and 1777, year later,
23:43 - General Howe, who was mentioned earlier, ended up trying to basically cut off,
23:51 - you know, the head of the snake, so to speak.
23:54 - So, if you wanna travel all the way from New York City
23:56 - to Philadelphia, I mostly included this, because my favorite part of the tour
24:00 - is talking about fire rafts, where he couldn't take Delaware Bay
24:05 - because of all the fortifications, should've all the freeze, which actually,
24:08 - if you ever get a chance to go to Brannewine Battlefield Museum,
24:11 - they have one of those, which is really interesting,
24:14 - my personal favorite artifact there that I had to talk about.
24:18 - And so then Howe, instead, took the Chesapeake,
24:20 - was expecting all this support when he,
24:23 - it said, "Head of Hulk," today, it's Alex Head, Maryland,
24:26 - when they landed there, they took five weeks, hundreds of horses died,
24:30 - and wasn't a great time for the British Army,
24:35 - 'cause they then had the March 30 miles.
24:38 - But, I won't go into the specifics of it 'cause I don't wanna
24:46 - distract from my main point of gender history.
24:49 - But Washington had received poor intel,
24:53 - one of the interpreters at the museum believes
24:56 - that he simply didn't have knowledge of one of the forts,
25:00 - fort is particularly shallow part of a river
25:02 - that's easiest to cross.
25:04 - And so the British Army ended up flanking them
25:07 - through the north, and Washington basically didn't have
25:10 - enough time to compensate, and so the Americans lost.
25:14 - So, that there is the battle itself.
25:18 - But, what I really wanna focus on is the memory of it,
25:24 - because, of course, you have like the battlefield park,
25:30 - but it's not the only one.
25:32 - It's the state park, which, as I mentioned, was taken by eminent domain in 1950,
25:36 - but that's not where it starts, and that's not where it ends.
25:40 - So, this painting here is by a famous painter called Howard Pile,
25:45 - and if you go to the area, if you're traveling the world long, route one,
25:49 - from, say you're going from Philadelphia to Brandi Wine,
25:53 - you will pass a painter's folly, where Howard Pile would train people,
26:00 - and a lot of his paintings focused on Revolutionary War,
26:03 - and the memory of the Battle of Brandi Wine.
26:06 - This was a very significant battle, not only for the region, but also something that
26:11 - I didn't even realize before, I came to this,
26:14 - was that it was the largest battle of the Revolutionary War.
26:19 - The numbers, very a bit, but current numbers estimate about 15,000 on each side,
26:27 - which is massive.
26:31 - It's, of course, difficult to tell because Washington,
26:33 - there's a famous quote, maybe not quite famous,
26:37 - but there was a quote where he didn't know how many soldiers he had to the thousands,
26:42 - like he only knew to the thousands, because there were
26:44 - so many people, and they just didn't have the records.
26:48 - But the point being that Howard Pile developed this memory
26:55 - through his paintings, and then over time,
26:56 - it continued to develop as Revolutionary War history
27:00 - became part of the fabric of what Philadelphia defined itself
27:04 - as, "Chads for being about about 30 miles "from Center City, Philadelphia.
27:10 - " Trust me, I drove multiple times and rush our traffic,
27:14 - that was not fun.
27:17 - But it really depended on this, and really grew around it,
27:24 - and there's a lot of memory.
27:25 - There's various streets named after both British and American generals.
27:29 - There's Brandywine Street.
27:31 - There is a lot of state parks, not state parks.
27:36 - Local parks, parks in addition to the state park.
27:40 - Not only is the state park a massive one that was started
27:46 - in 1950, it was also considered the first treasure
27:50 - of the Commonwealth, which I don't know the distinction
27:53 - exactly between that and a normal possession
27:58 - by the Commonwealth, but it's an honorific
28:01 - that marks this as something unique to Pennsylvania
28:05 - and shows the value that these locals of Chads for really celebrate.
28:13 - So that's the battle itself and what I like to talk about on my tours,
28:21 - but it's really important to add this more social ends to it
28:25 - because when we're giving military history,
28:30 - we tend to focus on the militaristic aspect,
28:33 - especially part of my training was going on these
28:37 - various tours and shadowing other volunteer tour guides,
28:40 - and they all talked about the military movements.
28:43 - And there were a lot of people that talked about
28:46 - maybe someone who lived in the area such as this
28:49 - here is the Benjamin Ringhouse from the front,
28:52 - from the perspective of Route 1/Baltimore Path Pike.
28:59 - That you may talk about the house owner,
29:04 - Benjamin Ring, and there are some people that talk about Quakers
29:08 - because of course I'm sure that plenty of
29:10 - people know about Quakerism, their pacifism,
29:14 - but there are little things that I didn't see on
29:17 - the tours and actually corrected a tour guide.
29:20 - Talking about March 17th, 1777, a law
29:24 - that required all PA men to serve in the local militia,
29:28 - which of course to me, I personally found a little drawing
29:33 - considering the first amendment that would come
29:35 - out about a decade later, but at this time,
29:40 - they didn't really care about religious freedom,
29:43 - they were focused on the war effort, and the interpretation at the site
29:47 - does largely focus on the civil war aspect of this.
29:53 - And the reason why I'm talking about all of this
29:56 - is to contextualize not only the women's experience as Quakers,
30:01 - but also as Pennsylvanians and living in this very complex climate around them
30:08 - that in a very rural area, they would have had the
30:14 - access to the knowledge to newspapers from their husbands
30:19 - who might have heard it at the local pub if they were
30:22 - illiterate, or they might have read it in a newspaper,
30:27 - but these women also didn't have the political power
30:30 - to participate in the same degrees as their
30:32 - husbands, and so they had a very complicated space.
30:39 - So I believe my next slide has a horrible historical
30:45 - reproduction, so fair warning there.
30:49 - You get to see that lovely, lovely face that I show everyone that I can,
30:54 - you even see the threads behind the very sheer fabric there.
30:59 - But for this slide, what I really want to talk about though
31:02 - is finally adding that gendered lens to it,
31:05 - where instead of talking about the Benjamin Ringhouse
31:08 - and another house on the property that does talk a lot
31:11 - about the social history is it getting Gil Penn House.
31:14 - And instead of talking about them, these properties where the focus is on the men,
31:19 - because the men left behind the documentation,
31:21 - focusing on the women and the children that lived there,
31:26 - where women, Quaker women in particular, had the standard of mother of Israel,
31:33 - where they were supposed to be these homemakers
31:37 - and these hosts, where there were Quaker women that did travel in ministry,
31:43 - which was a very important part of Quakerism.
31:46 - Despite that, most women would be hosts to these traveling ministers,
31:52 - and that was seen as important to their religion
31:56 - and their expression of femininity under Quakerism.
31:59 - And not only that, general at the time, women were caretakers for their families.
32:05 - They raised the children, they fulfilled their rules
32:08 - that their husbands may have needed help with
32:10 - if they couldn't complete all of the farm work,
32:12 - their husband, they would help their husbands.
32:15 - And another important thing is children get sick.
32:19 - So if your child is sick, you would take care, the mother would take care of them,
32:25 - or call a midwife to help come and look at the children
32:29 - and see what's wrong and prescribe something.
32:34 - And it's also a struggle because of the strong prejudice.
32:40 - The battlefield focuses a great deal on the Civil War aspect
32:46 - because these women were not only struggling from standard issues of misogyny,
32:53 - coverture laws that limited their rights and lack of political participation,
32:57 - but they also, in theory, had this egalitarian society that they were still women in,
33:04 - and they were still forced to fulfill this role of being the mother of Israel
33:08 - or being this homemaker and being this ideal woman.
33:12 - And this picture is another power pile painting that I thought would be thematic.
33:21 - Then there's the issue of the larger politics of the time,
33:24 - where we often think of the putting out system
33:27 - as very vital to everything outside of the American colonies,
33:33 - their relationship with Britain was being cut off, so people had to produce locally.
33:36 - But a study done by, oh, I forget the exact author's name,
33:45 - this scholar's name, Laura Utrecht,
33:51 - who also talked about Martha Ballard and was infamous for that, or famous for that,
33:58 - wrote an article examining how much fabric was needed
34:03 - and how much people could actually produce, and she found a major disparity there.
34:10 - So you have these economic systems
34:13 - where many of the farmers in the Brandi Wine
34:14 - Valley are depending on exploitation of Britain,
34:17 - of their wheat, Brandi Wine Valley was famous for their wheat.
34:22 - Suddenly they couldn't do that anymore.
34:24 - And so they were expected to start producing
34:28 - the same amounts as before, still provide for their family the same amount as before,
34:32 - and yet they didn't have the same access to trade.
34:36 - And then that extra labor would be put on wives
34:39 - and children, which would be especially difficult
34:42 - whenever women are already doing as much as they can.
34:46 - And so the economic system was just heavily dependent
34:51 - on the extra labor of women around the Revolutionary War,
34:54 - which would have been made worse around the Battle of Brandi Wine,
34:57 - because what I forgot to mention earlier is that when the British won,
35:00 - they stayed in the area for five days, which meant a lot of pillaging.
35:05 - They went into houses and took as much as they could,
35:09 - which was very difficult when you know your stress from a battle having occurred
35:15 - on your front door step and trying to protect your family.
35:18 - And then all the soldiers stay in the area
35:22 - and take as much of your furniture for firewood
35:25 - and as much of your food to eat as they can.
35:29 - In fact, Chester County has an atlas.
35:32 - If you look at their 1777 atlas, it'll show you all of
35:37 - the places that were recorded to have been pillaged,
35:39 - including the two properties at Brandi Wine Battlefield,
35:42 - the Guinea and Gilpin House, and the Benjamin Ringf House.
35:47 - And so then actually focusing on the battle itself,
35:52 - it was very difficult for women because of all the things I mentioned,
35:56 - economically struggling, falling up to the battle
35:59 - and after the battle with all the pillaging, and lacking political participation.
36:05 - And then having a care for their families, which would have been especially difficult,
36:10 - for example, with Sarah Greg Gilpin, she was the first wife of Gideon Gilpin.
36:17 - And her son, Joshua Gilpin, we don't know for certain when he died,
36:22 - of all the Gilpin children, he was the only one without an exact death date,
36:27 - even of the children that died.
36:32 - But he died in the year and month of the Battle of Brandi Wine.
36:38 - So no matter how you spin it, he either died as a five-year-old
36:43 - before the battle took place, and then this woman and her husband
36:49 - would have been mourning the death with, of course, Sarah Gilpin, if he was sick,
36:54 - she would have had to care for him following up to that.
36:57 - And if he died beforehand, then they'd be mourning
37:00 - during the battle, or he could have died around the
37:02 - time of the battle from sickness or after the battle.
37:06 - At any point, that's an emotional strain on
37:11 - this mother as she's also trying to take care
37:14 - for all their various children of young ages, amidst this large economic system.
37:21 - But I think what I always emphasize on my tours, too, is that of Rachel Ring,
37:27 - who was married to Benjamin Ring, who was pregnant in
37:32 - her ninth pregnancy during the Battle of Brandi Wine.
37:36 - We don't know for certain if the rings left the house,
37:40 - whenever Washington came and requested it for a headquarters door in the battle.
37:45 - But in either case, a major general
37:50 - with in charge of thousands of soldiers
37:53 - came to her front door step, her and her husband, and she was pregnant with a child.
37:59 - And the emotional stress, I've never been pregnant,
38:02 - but I'm very familiar between friends and family
38:07 - that it's not easy, and war on top of that.
38:13 - I cannot imagine.
38:16 - But the other thing that I also forgot to mention is the field hospital.
38:21 - I mentioned earlier that women were predominantly
38:23 - responsible for taking care of sick children.
38:26 - So then the Birmingham Friends Meeting House,
38:30 - they hosted a field hospital for both the British and the Americans after the battle.
38:35 - They were not medically trained in the ways that an army doctor would have been.
38:40 - They would not have had this experience with bloodshed and gunshot wounds,
38:48 - and cannon wounds and other various injuries,
38:52 - yet they were responsible and who would have had the most connection to medicine
38:59 - would have been the women responsible for that
39:02 - in addition to everything else that they were also responsible for.
39:07 - And so in all these ways, like a gendered lens of brain and wine battlefield shows
39:13 - where you have these houses being named for the men,
39:16 - the men left behind the documents, so the interpretation focuses on the men.
39:20 - And yet, when you think about the women and the general rules
39:27 - and general conventions around Quaker women at this time,
39:31 - they would have had many of the same responsibilities of men
39:34 - with the added responsibility of taking care of wounded and children amidst warfare,
39:42 - and it's just overlooked for these heroes of war
39:49 - who fought in that as opposed to the people,
39:53 - the individuals suffering on a local level.
39:57 - Thank you.
39:58 - (audience applauds)
40:25 - Perfect, thank you so much.
40:29 - ( Hi everyone, my name is Shayna Murphy.
40:38 - I'm a Ph.D. student at Binghamton University, and I'll be
40:42 - presenting on my paper, brought to bed at the OMS House.
40:46 - Poor women, pregnancy, and the medicalization of childbirth
40:50 - at the Philadelphia City OMS House, 1790 to 1850.
40:56 - Ruth Johnson entered the Philadelphia City OMS House,
41:00 - the city's casual charity that offered housing
41:03 - and healthcare to the poorest of the poor, on January 10th, 1809.
41:10 - The OMS House administrator who interviewed her
41:12 - would have no doubt noticed her swollen belly
41:14 - as he wrote down her admission information.
41:18 - Ruth, a 24-year-old African-American woman, had come to Philadelphia when she was 11.
41:24 - Since then, she had entered the OMS House
41:27 - once before, six years prior to her pregnancy.
41:31 - In 1809 though, Ruth was single, eight months pregnant
41:36 - and carrying a child whose father had left the city.
41:40 - She lived in the OMS House for the final month of her pregnancy and was likely placed
41:45 - in the Black Obstetrical Ward called The Lying in Ward.
41:50 - When Ruth delivered a mixed-race child a few weeks later,
41:53 - the White Obstetrical student who delivered her infant
41:57 - recorded that her labor was natural and easy.
42:02 - Ruth was just one of hundreds of women
42:04 - who gave birth at the Philadelphia City OMS House
42:07 - during the late 18th and early 19th centuries.
42:12 - At the OMS House, poor women gave birth in a lying in ward and Obstetrical Ward
42:18 - under the care of a physician during a very pivotal period
42:22 - where birth began to transition from a social event that occurred at home among women
42:29 - to a medical event facilitated by a physician, a process
42:33 - that's known colloquially as the medicalization of childbirth.
42:38 - Poor women's labors were often observed
42:40 - in clinical lectures, studied by medical students,
42:45 - completing their residencies in the OMS House
42:47 - and published in Obstetrical articles written by OMS House physicians.
42:52 - Ruth's child birth experience, like hundreds more,
42:55 - shows that contrary to the dominant narratives
42:58 - about poor women's childbirthing practices,
43:01 - that many of them engaged with physicians in key
43:05 - ways in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.
43:10 - Dominant narratives in the historiography of childbirth
43:13 - center on this transformation of childbirth and primarily focus on elite white women
43:19 - who are framed as the main agents in the medicalization
43:24 - of childbirth, who in the mid 18th and early 19th century
43:28 - began to invite physicians into their birthing rooms and turn away from midwifery.
43:35 - So scholars like Judith Walter Levitts
43:37 - focus on see elite white women working alongside male physicians
43:42 - to medicalized childbirth.
43:46 - Levitt does discuss women who gave birth in institutions
43:49 - like OMS Houses, but because of their perceived lack of agency in this institution,
43:55 - fails to analyze their relationship to the transformations in childbirth.
44:00 - In her narrative and many others,
44:03 - poor women did not engage with physician-assisted births until the late 19th century.
44:08 - And then two dissertations and a chapter
44:10 - in an edited collection have examined poor
44:12 - women who give birth in institutions, including,
44:16 - but not limited to the OMS House,
44:19 - but still focus primarily on the physicians
44:21 - who practice obstetrics in these institutions.
44:25 - And without really considering women's role
44:27 - in expanding and shaping this healthcare.
44:32 - Other scholars examine the transformations in
44:35 - childbirth through the lens of race and ethnicity
44:39 - and recount that African American women
44:42 - and immigrant women rejected the medicalization of childbirth
44:46 - and instead retained traditions of midwifery into the 20th century.
44:51 - And both this focus on elite white women and minority
44:55 - communities rejection of medicalized childbirth frame these women
45:00 - as being completely divorced
45:02 - from the medicalization of childbirth.
45:05 - So when I began researching and mining the records of
45:08 - the OMS House, I was surprised to see hundreds of women
45:11 - giving birth during this very pivotal time period where childbirth is just beginning
45:17 - to transition into a medical event.
45:19 - And I became curious as to how these women related
45:21 - to these transformations occurring in medicine.
45:24 - So in my paper, I asked,
45:26 - why did women turn to the OMS House for medical care during pregnancy?
45:31 - What was the relationship between poor women
45:34 - at the OMS House and the broader field of obstetrics?
45:38 - And how did the OMS House as an institution
45:40 - contribute to the medicalization of childbirth?
45:46 - Poor women who are very familiar
45:48 - with the instability of poverty made the best decision possible
45:52 - during very difficult and complicated situations
45:56 - by utilizing the medical services available to them at the OMS House.
46:01 - Not all pregnant women came to the house willingly
46:04 - and all avoided the house until necessary within the walls of the OMS House,
46:08 - women were subjected to coercion and exploitation.
46:12 - And in this presentation,
46:14 - I focus on the strategies that women cultivated
46:17 - and the way that they negotiated with administrators and physicians,
46:21 - but those dynamics of coercion and exploitation and surveillance
46:24 - are still there even if I'm not explicitly referencing them.
46:28 - Many of these women required the house
46:30 - as a medical institution to assist them during pregnancy
46:34 - and childbirth and actively incorporated this poor relief
46:38 - into their strategies during their pregnancy.
46:42 - Their use of the OMS House reflects broader
46:44 - historiographical interpretations, articulated by historian
46:48 - Seth Rothman, that view the OMS House as an establishment
46:51 - that served, surveilled, and suited poor populations.
46:56 - By seeking out and relying on public institutions for maternal healthcare,
47:02 - poor women pushed city officials and physicians
47:06 - to expand the availability of medical aid in the house.
47:10 - While poor women use the institution to meet their financial and medical needs,
47:16 - Philadelphia physicians simultaneously employed the institution
47:21 - to study and advance obstetric through the study
47:24 - of poor women's bodies.
47:26 - And so in my paper, I argue that the needs
47:28 - of both physicians and poor women's converge
47:31 - of the OMS House, which then became a critical space
47:35 - where the medicalization of childbirth occurred
47:38 - through the creation of lying in wards,
47:41 - these obstetrical wards, the training of male physicians,
47:45 - and the publication of obstetrical articles on case studies of poor women.
47:51 - Understanding the circumstances that brought poor women
47:54 - to the house reveals how women's traversed and molded
47:58 - the maternal healthcare system of the 19th century.
48:03 - And though their choices were very limited, they still reflected their evaluation
48:06 - of what they believed would serve their situation best.
48:11 - A number of women who delivered their children in the OMS House were married
48:16 - and carrying children that were considered legitimate,
48:18 - contrary to the narrative that characterized them all as single young women.
48:23 - Married women had a few options during pregnancy outside of choosing the OMS House.
48:29 - They could seek the out-of-door support of the OMS House,
48:32 - which would provide them with a small stipend to deliver their child at home.
48:36 - Or they could give birth at the Pennsylvania hospital,
48:39 - which allowed married women to, which opened a line in ward in 1803,
48:45 - and allowed married women to give birth,
48:47 - only married women to give birth within its doors.
48:50 - The OMS House though offered a package deal for women.
48:55 - It provided them with childcare, interim housing,
48:58 - medical care, which offset the difficulties
49:01 - that they faced finding reliable basic needs, like a food bed and clothing,
49:07 - during this very vulnerable period in their life.
49:10 - Though men to offer permanent housing to those incapable of caring for themselves,
49:16 - pregnant married women made their own use of the OMS House,
49:19 - by strategically employing their time in the institution.
49:23 - Often entering for a brief period of time
49:26 - during their confinement, generally in like their eighth month
49:29 - of pregnancy, their labor, and then their recovery.
49:33 - Using the institutions for their seasonal needs,
49:36 - pregnant women planned for a period of vulnerability
49:40 - by entering the OMS House in advance of their child's birth.
49:43 - This is the admission record of Jane Davenport, who was a 40-year-old Irish immigrant
49:50 - who entered the OMS House several months pregnant,
49:54 - and her husband was likely planning to be away during her child's birth,
49:58 - and so he paid for her to stay in the OMS House
50:01 - for four months, which gave her a respite
50:04 - from work when her last months of pregnancy,
50:06 - reliable housing, food, and a guaranteed medical assistant during birth.
50:12 - Many women came into the OMS House with their children,
50:14 - who would have been cared for in the OMS House nursery
50:17 - when they were recovering for their pregnancy,
50:20 - and they employed these strategies generally to cope
50:23 - with seasons of poverty caused by the absence or loss of their husbands.
50:29 - Other women who came to the OMS House were single mothers.
50:32 - These women were not able to rely on the other welfare institutions
50:36 - in Philadelphia because of their perceived lack
50:39 - of respectability, and they had to make a calculation before entering the OMS House.
50:44 - The OMS House was not interested in financing
50:47 - the births of poor women, and so required them to swear their pregnancy,
50:52 - the official process of naming and documenting the father of their child.
50:57 - This process was meant as a consequence for poor women
51:00 - who entered the home as a means of discouraging
51:03 - the poor from having children outside of wedlock,
51:07 - but it also gave poor women the backing of the state
51:10 - to extract financial support from the fathers of their children.
51:14 - This is Mary Scott who entered the OMS House
51:16 - as a single woman to deliver her infant.
51:19 - When entering the OMS House for her pregnancy,
51:22 - she identified a local gardener as the father of
51:26 - her child who then paid her bond, which provided her
51:29 - with some financial support for her labor and delivery in the house.
51:34 - And by naming the father of her child
51:37 - to the administrators, the guardians of the poor,
51:39 - she ensured not only that her labor would be paid for,
51:43 - but that she also established a record of paternity
51:46 - that could be applied to extract financial support
51:49 - when she left the institution.
51:56 - African American women navigating a rapidly changing,
52:00 - discriminatory world often came to the OMS House
52:03 - to mitigate their struggles during pregnancy and labor.
52:07 - The transition into freedom from slavery
52:10 - and the consistent inequality that they faced
52:12 - in the job market often resulted in destitution and instability.
52:16 - And increasingly throughout the 19th century,
52:19 - women escaping slave states migrated north and
52:22 - arrived in Philadelphia, friendless and alone.
52:26 - In the early 1800s, the OMS House failed to record
52:29 - the previous status of African American women.
52:32 - However, this census from 1837, which documented the standing of Black women
52:38 - in the OMS House reveals several women who were born into slavery.
52:43 - Seven out of 28 of the women in the listed in the Working and Curable Ward
52:49 - were born into bondage and came to Philadelphia
52:52 - from states like Virginia, Delaware, and Maryland.
52:57 - While many Black women, both free and enslaved,
53:00 - generally relied on the knowledge and skills
53:03 - of Black midwives and other African American women during their pregnancies,
53:08 - the poverty and transients they faced at the end of slavery
53:12 - in the mid-Atlantic, likely undermined these communities.
53:16 - And in these situations, they found new ways to meet their needs during pregnancy
53:21 - and labor by relying on the city's poor relief in lieu of these broader networks.
53:28 - Racist segregationist procedures led the OMS House administrators
53:32 - to separate the lying in wards according to race in 1804.
53:36 - So when Ruth Johnson, who I mentioned at the beginning,
53:39 - entered the OMS House, she was assigned to the Black Obstetrical Ward,
53:43 - where she would have met Phyllis Burton, who was a
53:46 - 24-year-old Black woman pregnant with her second child.
53:49 - And they likely spent some time together
53:51 - in the Obstetrical Ward before they delivered
53:53 - their babies, I think, like two weeks apart.
53:56 - Within the birth register, physicians were very careful
53:59 - to record the race of both the child and the mother who gave birth in the OMS House.
54:06 - As you can see here, and they pay a special attention
54:09 - to the children that result from interracial relationships.
54:17 - Throughout these examples, I found that women really need
54:20 - the institutional medical resources of the OMS House to assist them during pregnancy.
54:26 - And in finding ways to cope during their childbirth, they begin to use the OMS House
54:31 - as if it's a hospital with an Obstetrical Ward.
54:35 - They enter the OMS House when they're unable to work,
54:37 - they receive medical care, recover, and then primarily they
54:41 - leave with their infant, which I argue pushes the OMS House
54:45 - to create Obstetrical Services in the institution.
54:50 - Between 1800 and 1801, this is before the OMS
54:54 - House has official resources for pregnant women.
54:58 - Around 13% of women who entered the House
55:00 - entered specifically because of their pregnancy.
55:04 - And only after women have been using the OMS House in this
55:08 - way, is there the creation of the Lying in Ward in 1802,
55:13 - which is actually the second Lying in Ward in the country.
55:16 - The first is that an OMS House in New York City.
55:20 - And then the simultaneously to poor women
55:23 - increasingly needing and requesting the services
55:26 - of the OMS House physicians then became interested
55:30 - in advancing man-vid wifery and the field of obstetrics.
55:34 - And then the efforts of both these groups
55:37 - make the OMS House this center of obstetrical development.
55:41 - I argue that the OMS House placed this role in the medicalization of childbirth
55:46 - through the creation of those Lying in Ward's
55:48 - and also through teaching a new generation
55:51 - of physicians in obstetrics.
55:54 - Local physicians saw an opportunity to exploit the birds
55:58 - and bodies of poor women within the OMS House
56:00 - as a means of advancing their own medical knowledge.
56:04 - The OMS House partnered with the University
56:07 - of Pennsylvania and eventually Jefferson Medical College
56:10 - to allow medical students to complete their residencies within the OMS House.
56:17 - The students are responsible for keeping the birth register, which you can see here.
56:21 - And then this is a ticket to a clinical lecture and kind
56:24 - of like signing up to be in the residency of the OMS House.
56:28 - They offer clinical lectures, they have a museum in the OMS House and medical museum
56:34 - that has a fetal specimen in it and a library that
56:38 - offers several books on mid-wifery and obstetrics.
56:43 - The physicians of the OMS House then go on to teach obstetrics and prominent roles,
56:49 - such as Thomas James, who became the first professor
56:52 - of obstetrics at the University of Pennsylvania.
56:56 - And throughout this process,
56:58 - I found that women, these poor women in the OMS
57:01 - House rather than just like passive recipients
57:04 - of this medical care, play a role in teaching and shaping the field of obstetrics
57:09 - by asserting their autonomy in the birthing room despite this extreme power dynamic.
57:15 - This case is pulled from James Anderson's case book
57:18 - who completed his residency at the OMS House
57:21 - and recorded the birth of two women in 1805.
57:25 - The first woman, Esther Russell, has an incredibly complicated and painful birth.
57:31 - Throughout both Anderson and Dr.
57:34 - Church, the attending physician, Trigendervene, and she rejects.
57:39 - They try to put a poultice on her and she would not submit to a repetition.
57:45 - They try to give her brandy and water, which was likely objected to by the patient.
57:51 - And then in the next labor of this woman Mary Owens,
57:55 - they try to control the position that she's in when she's giving birth.
57:59 - And she basically insists on lying on her back and pulling her knees up to her chest.
58:04 - And in both of these accounts, women asserting their control over their bodies,
58:08 - this indicated to physicians when to intervene, when to stand back.
58:13 - And so they played this kind of indirect role
58:15 - in teaching physicians, this in teaching this new generation of physicians.
58:21 - And finally, the OMS House played a role in the medicalization of childbirth
58:25 - by using these poor women's labor as data to come to new conclusion in obstetrics
58:32 - and then publish these findings in American medical journals.
58:36 - This article published in 1848 compiled data
58:40 - recorded over a period of eight years
58:42 - where around 600 women gave birth in the OMS House.
58:47 - The birth of these poor women were used
58:49 - to make broader conclusions about when women begin
58:53 - and menstruating at the beginning and end of their pregnancy.
58:58 - The typical position of the fetus during birth
59:01 - and several case studies of very difficult births.
59:05 - The women who gave birth in the OMS House became case studies for physicians
59:09 - to make generalizations about obstetrical knowledge in the early 19th century.
59:15 - And examining the OMS House reveals the ways in which poor women played a role
59:19 - in the medicalization of childbirth and how there's this longer trajectory
59:23 - of the necessity of public health care for women and mothers
59:27 - even going back to the late 18th and early 19th centuries.
59:31 - Thank you.
59:32 - (audience applauds)
59:44 - - Benjamin, Jamie and Shayna, thank you very much for your thoughtful work
59:48 - and for being here today.
59:50 - It's really great to see young people in the thick of
59:53 - it doing historical research and entering the field.
59:57 - 453 I'm gonna just toss out one question to get us
01:00 - 04.320 started and that you are in the figure of research.
01:00 - 08.680 Is there anything about that process that particularly appeals to you
01:00 - 13.280 or actually surprised you in the process of doing history?
01:00 - 15.160 - So I think I'm gonna start off.
01:00 - 21.400 I think that the thing that surprised us or was it the thing that we really imagined?
01:00 - 23.400 - I think you surprised as you were both.
01:00 - 31.360 - So the thing that I really enjoy the most is just the act of like finding something,
01:00 - 34.480 that like, this is the most vague statement ever,
01:00 - 36.417 finding something that like other people had
01:00 - 40.040 overlooked or like finding something new.
01:00 - 44.120 The example I use is Andrew Anderson's pension who I mentioned up there
01:00 - 46.025 because some of my colleagues at the Friends of
01:00 - 48.440 Camps Security had already gone over that document
01:00 - 53.120 and they had extracted data that he had talked about his other service there
01:00 - 56.880 and I as part of research for paper I was doing undergrad,
01:00 - 00.160 I just looked back through the pension just out of curiosity
01:01 - 02.560 and I found that quote that I used
01:01 - 06.360 where he talks about the women and children interacting
01:01 - 08.880 with the guards and for me this was massive
01:01 - 11.562 because I had no clue what those interactions
01:01 - 16.120 looked like prior to that and just to me that quote,
01:01 - 19.160 it's such a short quote and it's kind of lives on its own
01:01 - 25.320 but not really 'cause it backs up lambs memoir but it was just for me personally,
01:01 - 30.680 it was this like act of, oh, I found this person or when I found Mormon's petition
01:01 - 38.680 and I for literally, she is one of, I believe maybe 62 total women
01:01 - 41.160 that I can actually account for the names of.
01:01 - 47.040 As prisoners who are most of them are at most, wife of so and so and you know,
01:01 - 50.086 to figure out what their names are, that is something
01:01 - 53.600 I will do someday when I have oodles and oodles of time
01:01 - 57.800 to trace family trees but not right now but anyway.
01:01 - 01.120 - Yeah, I think for me,
01:02 - 05.213 a lot of my research that I wasn't able to
01:02 - 08.480 include talked also about the indentured servitude
01:02 - 13.480 and the, in fact, the property had despite being Quakers
01:02 - 20.320 and enslaved woman who was a child during the Battle of Brandi Wine
01:02 - 24.856 was given a conditional manly mission that she would be sent
01:02 - 29.720 from Ridley Township to Birmingham Township today at Chadsport
01:02 - 32.200 where the battle is to one of the houses there
01:02 - 36.400 and I feel like at least for me personally,
01:02 - 41.560 I really feel like I guess this distracts from the question
01:02 - 47.040 but I really want to include more about that but it's just so frustrating
01:02 - 50.240 how little documentation there is in many regards
01:02 - 54.280 especially with women where I mentioned getting Gilpin had a first wife.
01:02 - 56.520 His second wife is barely mentioned in the record.
01:02 - 58.280 She's not even mentioned in his will.
01:02 - 01.160 Like I didn't even see anything about a widow's third
01:03 - 05.760 in his will and I feel like that absence of documentation
01:03 - 09.760 that I know gender history, I know it's gonna be there
01:03 - 14.760 but it's still frustrating, like shockingly frustrating.
01:03 - 22.120 - Yeah, for me, that it feels to me the most about this research is like, oh, sorry.
01:03 - 22.960 - Sorry.
01:03 - 24.320 - Is that okay?
01:03 - 28.240 Okay, that it feels to me the most was just that
01:03 - 33.360 finding like kind of a gold mine of sources because I had been to several OMS houses
01:03 - 39.720 and primarily they record birds in the admission or like the admission docket
01:03 - 43.680 and so finding like a birth register in an OMS house
01:03 - 46.280 was so exciting to me to find like something
01:03 - 50.040 that I could actually like use and expand this literature
01:03 - 52.892 and then putting that in relation to all of the other
01:03 - 56.640 sources that I've been able to find like lectures
01:03 - 00.440 from the University of Pennsylvania, doctors' notes
01:04 - 02.600 and then these publications, like putting them all
01:04 - 06.440 into relation with each other has been the most rewarding thing for me.
01:04 - 08.080 - Thank you.
01:04 - 09.120 - Who else?
01:04 - 09.960 - Go ahead.
01:04 - 11.560 - I have a question for Shane.
01:04 - 17.300 What's interesting for me to talk in your talk is a bit,
01:04 - 23.000 it seems that there's not a lot of antagonism
01:04 - 28.000 between women and the positions in this space
01:04 - 33.760 or maybe there is, and you can speak for that
01:04 - 40.160 because I'm thinking of it like seven days or 1790, there's a riot in New York City
01:04 - 46.120 because there's a dissonance and there's a tension between four folks
01:04 - 50.400 in the city and doctors called Dr. Trieda, they've explained.
01:04 - 54.068 And so do we see in all the times in these moments that
01:04 - 57.920 tension and that sort of antagonism between their being,
01:04 - 01.214 their caseness, right, so there's sort of being
01:05 - 04.440 views, right, and so is there that tension there?
01:05 - 07.680 - Yes, yes, thank you so much for your question.
01:05 - 10.311 Yes, and so this is something that also surprised
01:05 - 13.080 me was like that the physicians are even open
01:05 - 17.920 to listening to these women, and I obviously,
01:05 - 22.640 the dynamics between practitioner and patient exist,
01:05 - 27.000 and there's definitely a power dynamic and there's definitely moments where they are,
01:05 - 31.600 you know, putting their foot down, but four obstetrics in particular,
01:05 - 36.000 the physicians have only been in this industry for like 20 years, you know?
01:05 - 41.000 So in until like 1850, generally their approach
01:05 - 45.680 was to be more hands-off, both for the morality
01:05 - 48.240 because they were not, it was kind of a little bit taboo
01:05 - 53.840 to be like touching a woman's body, especially when she's in this exposed position.
01:05 - 57.600 And then also, which I'm hoping to go more with this,
01:05 - 02.400 but because that's generally the way that midwives approach child birth
01:06 - 06.720 is to let nature run its course and to not intervene,
01:06 - 11.640 and so when doctors come in with four steps and stuff, women are like, no, like you,
01:06 - 14.960 like we're not gonna have this, you know, and I even have a case from the OMS House
01:06 - 19.440 where they try to do a C-section on a woman in like 1820,
01:06 - 25.080 and she says, no, like I would rather die, and they just, she dies, like yeah.
01:06 - 29.800 And so like I think that, again, there are definitely those tensions that exist,
01:06 - 33.400 but that it develops more over the 19th century
01:06 - 35.960 is where I'm hoping to go with this project.
01:06 - 41.105 As physicians become professional, and this is a part of them
01:06 - 44.760 becoming professional, but they don't have that authority
01:06 - 49.760 over like this field when they first start out, yeah.
01:06 - 54.400 - I have a similar question.
01:06 - 58.880 - Reminds me of Martha Ballard, because her younger book talks about,
01:06 - 01.520 she works so very well for the women's house to help her out.
01:07 - 03.880 The doctor had been there, just given her a bunch of drugs.
01:07 - 04.720 - Yes.
01:07 - 05.560 - We stopped the process.
01:07 - 06.400 - Yes.
01:07 - 10.120 - She said, this ridiculous, you know, they just delayed with Nancy with an aunt,
01:07 - 13.320 so she's misdating and sometimes she works with doctors,
01:07 - 17.520 sometimes she's too, they're at longer heads together.
01:07 - 22.120 - But I think the larger issue is also a professionalization, as you said,
01:07 - 24.292 these women aren't helping them, these men
01:07 - 27.360 professionalize, because the same time as going on
01:07 - 29.600 is what you get a lot of state-clicking Massachusetts
01:07 - 32.600 following their first medical association,
01:07 - 33.941 and they're trying to professionalize this
01:07 - 37.160 all to take, what are the cracks in the green?
01:07 - 41.440 And this is also, we get American medical institutions
01:07 - 44.680 out of school like Morris before during the relationship period
01:07 - 46.800 of the polio period, if you wanted to be a doctor,
01:07 - 48.840 man had to go to Scotland, you should, right?
01:07 - 51.200 - Yes, 'cause there's no way to go to medical school
01:07 - 53.600 in what would be coming to the United States.
01:07 - 55.400 So they're in professionalizing that way,
01:07 - 57.070 they're also getting that first medical
01:07 - 00.520 journal, as you said, they're publishing data.
01:08 - 03.520 This is also the beginning of the clinical portion
01:08 - 06.000 of medical history, where they didn't realize
01:08 - 09.720 they need to observe things, they need to have data,
01:08 - 13.000 they don't just come with their familial theories
01:08 - 16.040 about what happens with someone's body when there's body.
01:08 - 18.439 I think that's a big part of that,
01:08 - 22.292 but I wonder how you would answer Martha Ballage
01:08 - 24.279 concerns about this, and I'll see other thing,
01:08 - 28.800 I wonder about him, I probably could not find his evidence, but birthday is still is.
01:08 - 30.823 But usually the way women's had, they used
01:08 - 33.760 gravity to have a baby, which makes no sense.
01:08 - 36.560 Suddenly, they're not on their backs, I'm in bed,
01:08 - 41.720 and there's supposed to have a child, 'cause I wonder if this is a doctor's picture,
01:08 - 45.120 that this, they heard of her this way, as opposed to using a birth in the school.
01:08 - 47.880 - Yes, it is the doctors, yes, yes, yes.
01:08 - 52.240 Mostly because of the access, they find it easier, and exactly like you're saying,
01:08 - 55.880 also the clinical space, that the patient is in the bed,
01:08 - 58.551 exactly, and that contributes also to the
01:08 - 00.600 dynamic, the power dynamic became physician.
01:09 - 03.560 And yeah, to Martha Ballage too, yeah,
01:09 - 06.600 definitely the same things are happening gradually
01:09 - 09.399 over the 19th century, and I've actually been seeing
01:09 - 12.843 a lot of women that date, they give them a lot
01:09 - 17.720 of opium in the Aum's house, and also because,
01:09 - 20.723 they're unfamiliar, so when these women are in
01:09 - 25.319 pain, they just get giving them loads of opium.
01:09 - 29.600 And, but one thing that's interesting too in the Aum's house, which again,
01:09 - 34.120 I hope to pursue in a future project, is that there are sometimes women there.
01:09 - 37.520 I don't know the extent to what they're doing there,
01:09 - 41.760 but they will sometimes have midwives sign the birth register,
01:09 - 45.160 and it'll say like the people who are present, and there will be a midwife there,
01:09 - 48.094 and so I don't know exactly what her role is
01:09 - 50.279 there, but there are nurses in the Aum's house.
01:09 - 54.652 So yeah, I think like definitely older, it's like, yeah,
01:09 - 58.360 that dynamic is maybe here in the Aum's house too, yeah.
01:09 - 59.520 Thank you for your question.
01:10 - 06.840 - I've got a one, I'm not gonna take it to Aum.
01:10 - 10.480 Then, there are ideas, women and children,
01:10 - 13.120 in fact, this way, I can't, very true to me,
01:10 - 15.280 and I think we need to partner explore that.
01:10 - 17.800 It's certain Aum that only is normally not performing,
01:10 - 20.200 it's normally, and there are ways to find out
01:10 - 24.680 where those people are coming back here, because they're not escaping.
01:10 - 26.880 No less so well, they're not required all of you.
01:10 - 29.080 It's not required all of you else to be services
01:10 - 34.080 that all of Aum will body white males between Aum's and 18 and 53,
01:10 - 35.880 and they're only to be a new way to progress,
01:10 - 37.480 they will just serve as things like the process
01:10 - 39.480 or what a fraction of all of these services.
01:10 - 41.560 So, there will have to be that future.
01:10 - 43.782 I was really curious, and though, I've ever looked
01:10 - 46.640 at how many women were actually on the battlefield.
01:10 - 49.040 It was like a where, how many were in each household.
01:10 - 50.982 And also, where are the women that I didn't
01:10 - 54.240 talk about with the armies, I'd be curious
01:10 - 57.081 about where were they were actually about, or any more.
01:10 - 03.880 And generally, men certainly feel possible that we're gonna go back to the patient
01:11 - 06.320 at where they're being in a field of hospitals.
01:11 - 10.800 And Jane, two questions to move.
01:11 - 13.480 - Is this more of everything than a world?
01:11 - 17.560 'Cause my family, I think, first people have born
01:11 - 21.120 in the hospital, where my parents have been, where that's born at home,
01:11 - 23.960 and I'm not even sure they're back with that.
01:11 - 25.720 So, that's 20 centuries.
01:11 - 29.160 So, there might be more of a burden, or if their question happened to you,
01:11 - 33.320 is when they were talking about the mixed race children, they used certain problems,
01:11 - 41.480 like lactone, wide room, yellow, and that met certain levels of measure.
01:11 - 44.356 - I know he's not surrounded right before they were
01:11 - 47.160 very straight about what, what depth of a world
01:11 - 49.280 were they used when we talked about the mixed race children.
01:11 - 50.880 - Right in the back.
01:11 - 54.720 - They didn't hold the same thing in their relationship.
01:11 - 56.760 So, that's what is my problem, so.
01:11 - 00.920 - Comment on the comment.
01:12 - 04.000 - Well, well, yeah, I will definitely, yes.
01:12 - 06.680 So, yes, definitely, urban, yes.
01:12 - 09.320 100% urban, yeah, which is also what's so interesting
01:12 - 12.720 about this process is that exactly like so many people,
01:12 - 15.799 like even today, remember their parents not like giving
01:12 - 17.800 birth at home, I mean, people still give birth at home.
01:12 - 20.920 So, yeah, it happens like incredibly piecemeal
01:12 - 25.920 over from like 17, you know, 30, then even up to like 1970.
01:12 - 33.720 And again, that definitely depends on the demographics, on race, yeah, so absolutely.
01:12 - 38.034 And then, yeah, they absolutely use these specific
01:12 - 40.800 terms, which is also where I'm interested in going
01:12 - 44.880 with this project is like considering how the arms house
01:12 - 47.560 contributes to those categorizations, right?
01:12 - 50.520 Because this is like right when you're assigned at birth,
01:12 - 53.320 someone is giving you kind of like an official document
01:12 - 54.760 that's putting you in this category,
01:12 - 57.698 that then the administrators are using to make
01:12 - 59.640 decisions about where you go in the house.
01:12 - 01.492 And then once you leave, you've been kind of
01:13 - 04.160 marked with like the certain racial category.
01:13 - 06.200 And then these doctors are publishing.
01:13 - 09.760 And also a lot of these doctors are not from Philadelphia.
01:13 - 11.360 They come to Philadelphia to study
01:13 - 14.920 and then they go back to like whatever South Carolina or whatever a lot of them.
01:13 - 19.760 So, like I'm very interested in how like, what's happening here is contributing
01:13 - 24.200 to those racial categories with like racial science and medicine.
01:13 - 25.880 - And the realization is, what's happening here?
01:13 - 28.880 (muffled speaking)
01:13 - 36.480 - And in terms of the comment, yeah, I,
01:13 - 40.480 for the sake of time, I kind of glossed over it a bit.
01:13 - 42.414 I mostly mentioned, I didn't emphasize this
01:13 - 43.880 as much as I should have in the presentation
01:13 - 46.960 about the militia law, that at least in particular
01:13 - 52.600 with the Brainy Wine Battlefield State Park, the two households were impacted by it
01:13 - 56.760 and they had to pay hefty fines because yeah.
01:13 - 59.360 And that would have impacted the entire family dynamic
01:13 - 03.100 and by extension, the women who were responsible for
01:14 - 06.081 helping with their husbands and- - You're trying to count.
01:14 - 08.120 You're wondering if they didn't have to buy a bottle on either.
01:14 - 10.120 What is written in areas of Iraq?
01:14 - 13.520 - It's difficult to tell.
01:14 - 19.120 My research mostly involves the state park, which is the two households.
01:14 - 21.800 So then of course, the two wives and their various children.
01:14 - 29.380 Of course, I haven't personally went through the Chester County at 1777 Atlas
01:14 - 33.320 and looked at all the different households that would have been impacted by it.
01:14 - 38.320 And by the British, it was a large area though.
01:14 - 44.160 Of course, largely rural, so not a lot of households
01:14 - 49.560 like in comparison to like maybe like what the city would have been, would have seen.
01:14 - 53.880 But it's difficult to tell.
01:14 - 57.480 And there are also other issues too of like
01:14 - 01.560 threats of sexual violence or things to that effect
01:15 - 05.560 of just anything with armed soldiers coming into the area
01:15 - 09.360 and occupying it that would have affected women.
01:15 - 11.040 I don't have any direct sourcing.
01:15 - 14.148 There isn't a lot from the Birmingham Meeting
01:15 - 16.800 House and there isn't a lot about the Quakers.
01:15 - 20.720 The best guess or from my understanding
01:15 - 22.403 is they would have likely went to their local
01:15 - 25.120 religious house because a battle was going on.
01:15 - 27.280 They wouldn't have wanted to stay in their homes
01:15 - 30.720 and there were meetings going on around that time.
01:15 - 32.840 Of course, though, the documentation around there,
01:15 - 36.160 there's one video at Brandi Wine Battlefield that says
01:15 - 39.960 that apparently someone wrote nothing of note today
01:15 - 43.200 even though that wouldn't have been the case.
01:15 - 45.627 And unless that was written before the field
01:15 - 48.880 hospital and various people participating in that.
01:15 - 53.880 But I have to look more and try and broaden my horizon
01:15 - 58.800 when it comes to any documentation, specifically focusing on women.
01:15 - 02.840 But it's very, I've been very frustrated thus far.
01:16 - 07.720 - Which I will make one little comment with the thing.
01:16 - 12.720 Yes, I am aware of, I debated my transcription of her name
01:16 - 15.600 and I thought I might have been wrong.
01:16 - 19.720 But there's a dash before the end that made me read it as an M.
01:16 - 20.880 So that's why that happened.
01:16 - 25.880 But also, the one little note I'll have with the kind
01:16 - 28.280 of them influencing the layouts is that this has to do
01:16 - 30.825 with the kind of way that something that I ended
01:16 - 34.320 up not being able to discuss purely for time was,
01:16 - 37.920 that's a whole other paper, is about how military community
01:16 - 40.520 worked within the prisoner camps.
01:16 - 43.280 It's very much an idea of worked on quite a bit
01:16 - 46.880 over the last few years and we'll probably write something on when I get time.
01:16 - 51.880 But yeah, it ties into how they live within community
01:16 - 56.280 within the camps, right?
01:16 - 57.440 - Well, we're right at time.
01:16 - 59.520 So let's thank the panel for that.
01:16 - 02.520 (audience applauds)
01:17 - 05.320 (audience laughs)
01:17 - 08.080 (dramatic music)
01:17 - 16.700 (dramatic music)