PCNTV
Sign In Home Live Politics History 250th Sports Search Shop Donate Subscribe

ADVERTISEMENT
Pittsburgh's Transformation from Below

[10.23.26] PA Historical Association program on Pittsburgh's transformation from below in Northampton Community College in Bethlehem.

Caption Text Below:    

00:00 - (upbeat music)

00:09 - - Good morning, us here today for our roundtable.

00:12 - The shadow of gleaming towers, Pittsburgh's transformation from below.

00:16 - My name is Dr. Simpson, I'm an associate

00:18 - professor of history at decaying university,

00:20 - and I'd like to thank the Department of History

00:21 - at decaying for sponsoring this session today.

00:25 - And I'd also like to thank all of you for taking time out of your busy scheduled PHA

00:29 - to come and have a great audience and we really appreciate this.

00:32 - So, how the story of Pittsburgh has confronted

00:36 - nearly a century of economic and social change

00:40 - is one that's generated quite a lot of popular and academic attention.

00:45 - It's been held up by both academics and

00:47 - policy makers in the past, and in real time,

00:50 - as evidence that Pittsburgh and its leadership have,

00:52 - either stumbled upon or intentionally created a sort

00:56 - of secret sauce for economic development and urban success.

01:00 - And an important part of the story is also that the Pittsburgh Renaissance is,

01:04 - and you can talk about how we define that

01:07 - today, are both replicatable and transportable.

01:11 - As with all popular stories, there is some truth

01:13 - to this telling, but there's also a great

01:15 - deal of nuance and complexity that's missing.

01:18 - So, I'm delighted to be part of a new generation of Pittsburgh scholars.

01:20 - So, I'm delighted to be part of a new generation of Pittsburgh scholars.

01:22 - Beyond the four of us are gonna be here today,

01:24 - and I wanna acknowledge that there's a really

01:25 - growing group of folks that are writing

01:27 - about Pittsburgh and its post-industrial transition,

01:30 - who are also working on creating new understandings of what Renaissance means.

01:34 - And today, we're gonna start to explore several different approaches.

01:37 - Before we begin though, I'm gonna do the historian thing,

01:40 - as you all are probably aware of, and I

01:42 - wanna kind of provide a bit of brief context

01:44 - for how the Renaissance stories popularly understood,

01:47 - so that as we sort of unpack it, we're all on the same page.

01:51 - So, the popular story of Pittsburgh's Renaissance really begins in the 1940s.

01:54 - So, the popular story of Pittsburgh's Renaissance really begins in the 1940s.

01:56 - When local business leaders, largely Richard King Mellon,

01:59 - looked out at a Pittsburgh that was tired, dirty, and

02:02 - ill-suited for leadership in a rapidly changing United States

02:06 - after the Second World War.

02:07 - And as the story goes, Mellon and other corporate leaders

02:10 - formed the Allegheny Conference on Community Development,

02:12 - and worked hand in glove with elected officials like

02:15 - Mayor David Lawrence, and powerful public authorities

02:17 - like the Urban Redevelopment Authority in Al-Kasan,

02:20 - to remake Pittsburgh's physical and environmental landscape.

02:21 - to remake Pittsburgh's physical and environmental landscape.

02:23 - By the 1970s, the story continues this

02:26 - transformation, which was substantial, was incomplete.

02:29 - And now a new generation of Pittsburgh's leaders,

02:32 - like Mayor Pete Flaherty and Mayor Richard Kalingeri,

02:35 - focused on new ways and new initiatives to remake Pittsburgh that intersected

02:40 - with larger structural economic changes in the United States,

02:43 - particularly incentivizing a growing surface

02:46 - industry, like finance, law, and banking.

02:49 - And a key goal of what became the sort of second version

02:51 - of Renaissance known properly as Renaissance II,

02:54 - was attracting corporate headquarters to downtown

02:57 - and white collar professionals to Pittsburgh's neighborhoods.

03:00 - By the 1990s, the story continues,

03:03 - the collapse of the steel industry tested the

03:05 - gains of Renaissance I and Renaissance II.

03:07 - And education in medicine, or quote, "eds and meds,"

03:11 - took the place of manufacturing, finally

03:13 - cementing the post-industrial transformation

03:16 - of Pittsburgh, one that was given physical form in 2009

03:19 - when the University of Pittsburgh medical centers,

03:22 - then the largest employer in the city put its logo on top of the US steel tower.

03:24 - then the largest employer in the city put its logo on top of the US steel tower.

03:28 - As I mentioned, the outset, this makes a neat and compelling story.

03:31 - It has a clear chronology and it has clear heroes.

03:35 - But as I also said, it's a story that lacks a certain amount of complexity.

03:40 - In 2015, a group of scholars convened by Ted

03:42 - Mueller from the University of Pittsburgh,

03:44 - contributed to a forum in the Journal of Urban History,

03:47 - rethinking Renaissance and working to integrate

03:50 - some complexities into the Renaissance story.

03:52 - More than a decade later, a robust conversation

03:55 - is now emerged among Pittsburgh scholars

03:57 - about how we periodize and how we discuss Renaissance,

03:59 - how we talk about who benefited, and how we discuss who was left out of Renaissance.

04:02 - how we talk about who benefited, and how we discuss who was left out of Renaissance.

04:04 - I really look forward to our conversation today

04:06 - because I think we're going to explore some of these ideas in more detail.

04:11 - So what I want to do is take just a moment before I introduce our four panelists

04:13 - So what I want to do is take just a moment before I introduce our four panelists

04:15 - to talk a little bit about how today's session is going to proceed.

04:20 - Each presenter is going to give a short overview of their

04:23 - work and its relationship to Pittsburgh's Renaissance.

04:26 - We have a quick little bit of a change in terms of the order.

04:31 - Pierce is going to start followed by Dan, then Allen,

04:34 - and then I'll go ahead and provide the last sort of overview here as well.

04:36 - and then I'll go ahead and provide the last sort of overview here as well.

04:38 - I'm going to ask one guiding question.

04:40 - We're going to move up after the presentations here.

04:42 - I'll ask one guiding question.

04:44 - But really, I think what we're all hoping to do is engage

04:47 - with you as the audience and have a back and forth discussion.

04:50 - Not just about Renaissance, but perhaps about what

04:52 - post-industrial development in Pennsylvania means more generally,

04:56 - and think about the ways we can link that

04:57 - Renaissance story to this larger conversation.

05:01 - So let me quickly introduce a presenter so we don't have to go as each one comes up.

05:03 - So let me quickly introduce a presenter so we don't have to go as each one comes up.

05:06 - I'm going to start with Pierce Berry.

05:07 - Pierce is a second year public history student

05:10 - in the master's program at Duquesne University.

05:13 - This work comes from his seminar paper

05:15 - that he's presenting today, connecting the bird,

05:17 - the role of public transit in Renaissance, too.

05:20 - And one of the things that's so really

05:21 - interesting about this paper is Pierce places

05:24 - the Port Authority of Allegheny County, now Pittsburgh Regional Transit,

05:29 - into a central element as part of what's defining and changing Renaissance, too.

05:34 - Dan Holland is special faculty and director of special projects

05:37 - at the Center for African American Urban Studies

05:40 - and the Economy at Carnegie Mellon University.

05:42 - Dan's also a faculty colleague of mine at Duquesne.

05:45 - He is the 2025 scholar in residence at the PHMC

05:50 - and the author of Communities of Resistance

05:52 - and Resilience in the Post Industrial City,

05:55 - a transnational perspective from Leon and Pittsburgh, 1980 to 2010.

06:00 - Dan has presented extensively.

06:03 - He also has extensive community experience.

06:06 - He's a founder of the Young Preservation of

06:08 - Pittsburgh and Dan has worked in the financial sector

06:10 - with Frost Bank, as well as a special advisor

06:13 - to the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland's Pittsburgh branch.

06:17 - Alan Dietrich Ward, who will be our third presenter.

06:20 - Alan is the director of the Graduate School

06:22 - and Professor of History at Shepensburg University.

06:25 - His first book, Beyond Rust and the Fate of Metropolitan

06:28 - and Pittsburgh and the Fate of Metropolitan America

06:30 - was published by the University of Pennsylvania Press in 2015.

06:35 - Dan, sorry, Alan, this one happens when I can't read my hand writing.

06:40 - Alan is also the author of the recent Pennsylvania History

06:44 - Series book, The Cradle of Conservation

06:46 - published by Temple University Press in 2024.

06:48 - And it's a fantastic book for those who you want

06:50 - to teach environmental history in the Commonwealth.

06:53 - Finally, as I mentioned before, I'm an associate

06:56 - professor of history at Duquesne University.

06:59 - My work that I'm going to present today comes from my book published in 2019,

07:03 - the Medical Metropolis, Economic Development,

07:05 - and Health Care and Economic Development

07:10 - in Pittsburgh and Houston.

07:12 - And so my work really looks at Edson Meds

07:14 - as well as the American Health Care economy.

07:16 - So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Pierce.

07:19 - [APPLAUSE]

07:31 - Hello, everyone.

07:32 - Hope you're all doing well.

07:34 - As Dr. Simpson so graciously mentioned, my name is Pierce Berry.

07:38 - I am a graduate student at Duquesne University studying public history.

07:43 - Now, my project is much more of a traditional history.

07:46 - So I'm one of the masochists who decided voluntarily

07:50 - to do a big seminar project while doing all my other classes.

07:55 - And I just want to thank Dr.

07:56 - Simpson for introducing me to this topic and to Pittsburgh's urban history.

08:02 - So what initially inspired me to dig deeper

08:05 - into the Port Authority is my own lived experience.

08:09 - I frequently take the bus to class.

08:11 - I live in the East End of Pittsburgh.

08:12 - So we have these nice buses that connect us in.

08:16 - I'm from South Carolina, a small town.

08:19 - We have one bus, and I've never seen anyone use it.

08:21 - So for me, it's a big upgrade.

08:25 - Maybe from New York, it's not quite as nice.

08:27 - And so that really inspired me to look into the story, dig into its development.

08:33 - And as I explored more about Pittsburgh's Renaissance,

08:36 - I learned that people haven't written much about the Port Authority.

08:41 - I'm going to call it the PAT just for brevity's sake.

08:45 - That's what it has been most commonly been

08:46 - called up until a very recent rebranding to PRT.

08:51 - The overall thesis of my paper is essentially

08:54 - arguing that the PAT was created and imbued with the essence

08:58 - of Renaissance 1, and it acted as a foundational element for Renaissance 2.

09:05 - The PAT's projects in mass transit in the 1970s

09:09 - through the 1980s were considered key elements of Pittsburgh's Renaissance 2.

09:14 - And the PAT was essential to connect the

09:16 - spread out populace and get them all connected

09:20 - to the rapidly developing downtown core for work, entertainment,

09:26 - commerce, everything else, which helped lead to this kind

09:31 - of common conception of the successes of Renaissance 2.

09:37 - Yeah, the bulk of my paper is based on a collection of John P.

09:41 - Robin, who was the chairman of the Urban

09:46 - Redevelopment Authority for Renaissance 2 in 1977,

09:49 - as well as an active member of the PAT's Board of Directors from 1973 to 1993.

09:56 - I cannot thank David Grinnell and the University of Pittsburgh

10:00 - enough for helping connect me with this unprocessed and unpublished collection.

10:07 - So it was a lot of fun to get to dig into that.

10:09 - Additionally, I used articles from the Pittsburgh Post

10:12 - Gazette, as well as the Pittsburgh Courier, to supplement my work.

10:18 - I'm broadly developed in a few sort of sections, as I mentioned earlier, I believe

10:21 - I'm broadly developed in a few sort of sections, as I mentioned earlier, I believe

10:23 - that the PAT was created with this energy of Renaissance 1,

10:27 - the very language that was used to describe

10:31 - the PAT were words like efficiency, modernity,

10:36 - a fuel for economic development.

10:38 - These are all sort of the buzzwords

10:42 - that were used to argue the utility of the Renaissance project.

10:50 - And this is how the PAT comes out of Renaissance 1.

10:57 - The PAT did a wide variety of programs in the 1970s

11:00 - to one submit their legitimacy in Pittsburgh

11:03 - as this major conglomerate of mass transit, which had not existed beforehand.

11:09 - It was just a scattering of 30 somewhat companies

11:13 - that misalaneously wrote buses and trolleys

11:16 - and whatnot all around the city, sometimes overlapping each other.

11:20 - And so what they did is they created projects

11:24 - such as the mini bus loops in the Hill District

11:27 - to try and connect the predominantly black, predominantly

11:30 - working class, lower income community with cheaper fares,

11:34 - as well as Sunday routes, special Sunday routes

11:36 - to take people to and from church and other functions

11:39 - during that time, which were considered widely successful.

11:43 - I also discussed the red flyer buses, which were the earliest mass transit buses

11:45 - I also discussed the red flyer buses, which were the earliest mass transit buses

11:48 - designed to try and zip people in and out of downtown quickly and efficiently.

11:51 - designed to try and zip people in and out of downtown quickly and efficiently.

11:54 - And I also discussed the early action plan,

11:56 - which is sort of the groundwork for the major development

12:00 - projects that we see, the busways and the light

12:03 - rail, which we in Pittsburgh call the tea.

12:07 - Many of the folks who were very key

12:09 - at influential in the Renaissance, in Renaissance 2, considered these projects

12:13 - to be Renaissance projects.

12:15 - Mayor Caligiri specifically calls out the Port Authority

12:19 - as a key element for penetrating the golden

12:22 - triangle, which is the downtown of Pittsburgh.

12:24 - Other key city individuals as well viewed this very clearly

12:28 - as a Renaissance project and even average citizens.

12:33 - I found a pamphlet written by, I believe they were,

12:36 - they were second or fourth graders somewhere around there

12:38 - and they were talking, they did like a little interview

12:41 - with Jack Robin and it was kind of cute interesting,

12:45 - but it showed that you know, your average person

12:46 - considered these projects as Renaissance food.

12:52 - Then my paper moves on to talk about the actual connections.

12:56 - Was it successful, did it deliver on this sort of Renaissance idea?

13:01 - So I talked about specifically the South Busway,

13:02 - So I talked about specifically the South Busway,

13:03 - as well as the East Busway, which we now know as the Martin Luther King Jr.

13:05 - as well as the East Busway, which we now know as the Martin Luther King Jr.

13:08 - East Busway, as well as the light rail project that goes predominantly

13:12 - to the South Hills neighborhoods, South of Pittsburgh,

13:18 - which is for this predominantly white collar class

13:21 - that the city was trying to attract with these sort of downtown developments.

13:23 - that the city was trying to attract with these sort of downtown developments.

13:28 - So we are doing a fairly brief introduction to our research.

13:32 - So I think I will wrap everything up there.

13:35 - I do just want to mention of course in the 1990s,

13:38 - we see a loss of a lot of federal funding for

13:41 - transit, we see a general decline, but despite this,

13:45 - the Pat has remained a consistent staple part of Pittsburgh.

13:51 - It's vital to get people in and out of the city and around, Duquesne is downtown.

13:53 - It's vital to get people in and out of the city and around, Duquesne is downtown.

13:56 - It would be a pain for me to have to try and find parking downtown.

13:57 - It would be a pain for me to have to try and find parking downtown.

13:59 - So it's quite nice for me to be able to take the

14:01 - busway, zip back and forth in just a little while.

14:05 - And so I think it's an important part of the story

14:08 - that hasn't been discussed by scholars enough.

14:10 - And thank you.

14:14 - (audience applauding) All right.

14:30 - Oh, that's my book.

14:31 - Well, welcome everyone and good morning.

14:36 - I want to kind of offer, I won't read all of

14:39 - my remarks, but I have like four bullet points.

14:41 - I want to kind of convey to everyone.

14:43 - But first, I want to express my, also my gratitude to David Grunell,

14:48 - Alan Dietrich Ward, and many others who contributed to a lot of my research here.

14:51 - Alan Dietrich Ward, and many others who contributed to a lot of my research here.

14:55 - During the latter stages of Renaissance in the late 1950s and 60s,

15:00 - attempts were made to create community organizations

15:03 - to address affordable housing issues in particular,

15:06 - often controlled by white downtown elites.

15:09 - Yet much of the damage done by demolition for urban renewal and highway projects

15:11 - Yet much of the damage done by demolition for urban renewal and highway projects

15:14 - in the early 1960s, displaced so many people at

15:17 - corrective actions were too little, too late.

15:20 - That's bullet point one.

15:22 - Two community based organizations governed by residents themselves

15:27 - emerged in the mid to late 1960s and early 1970s, driven in

15:32 - part by black power, but also a desire for more local control,

15:36 - over decision-making and resource allocation.

15:40 - So I argue that without these community based nonprofits,

15:44 - low income and minority communities would have never bounced back,

15:48 - and their contributions improved the city's

15:51 - quality of life, which everyone takes credit for.

15:55 - And as I argue in a forthcoming article in PA History

15:59 - Journal, today, billionaire investors are creating

16:02 - what the nation calls the disneyfication of cities.

16:07 - The heroes of community resistance are often forgotten.

16:11 - The moment calls for a new generation of activists

16:13 - to step up and advocate for neighborhoods,

16:16 - and unless low income and minority communities

16:18 - are intimately involved in the development

16:21 - process, the future of neighborhoods will continue

16:24 - to push low income and African-American residents to the margins.

16:29 - So I just wanna go through a few slides here.

16:32 - And if you probably are aware of what happened

16:35 - in the Lower Hill District during Renaissance,

16:37 - Tina Harris captured this photo in the 40s

16:40 - of what was then called crossroads of the world,

16:43 - where numerous organizations were started,

16:46 - including the Negro League team, the Pittsburgh

16:48 - Croffords, Crawford Grill, Jazz Mecca, et cetera.

16:54 - And within a short period of time, it was all gone.

16:57 - And what Mindy Fola love has documented was a root shock.

17:02 - It's really the removal of social capital,

17:04 - which I go into in more detail in my book.

17:09 - But there was a number, there were a number of folks

17:12 - who were pushing back against the expansion of Renaissance.

17:15 - And one of those is Frankie May Pace,

17:18 - part of the area that was demolished in the early 40s

17:22 - or 50s and 60s is now Frankie Pace Park in the Lower Hill.

17:28 - And she erected this now famous, I think it's in Allen's book as well,

17:32 - beyond Russ, no redevelopment beyond this point.

17:36 - So it was really a kind of a very concerted attempt

17:40 - to kind of push back on the expansiveness of Renaissance.

17:47 - But really, all throughout Pittsburgh,

17:49 - this was going on, south side for Mill expansion.

17:53 - And especially in the north side,

17:54 - I'll be talking later with the Allegheny City Society

17:57 - next month, talking really about how the north side was really

18:01 - ripped to shreds and it could have been a lot worse as well.

18:05 - In Manchester, we're many African Americans live,

18:09 - but also East Allegheny, Allegheny Center and so on.

18:12 - And it was really about 5,000 people were displaced, mostly low income and minority.

18:15 - And it was really about 5,000 people were displaced, mostly low income and minority.

18:18 - And I argue in another article that was published

18:21 - a couple of years ago, that this really was one of the drivers

18:25 - of the civil rights movement in addition to other things.

18:29 - Now, the irony is at this period of time,

18:33 - Pittsburgh passed the second fair housing law in the nation, behind New York,

18:39 - and then Pennsylvania followed shortly thereafter.

18:42 - But for all too many communities that were shutting out,

18:45 - especially in the suburbs, in fact, Roy Luboff writes

18:48 - that numerous suburban communities lacked planning,

18:51 - subdivisions, zoning, and building controls,

18:54 - or out of good provision for enforcement.

18:56 - Equally important, these regulatory mechanisms

18:59 - were not only incapable of producing new housing,

19:02 - but often served to obstruct development because of their lack of uniformity,

19:06 - their use to control the influx of population.

19:10 - So really it was kind of constraining the places where people could move to.

19:15 - And this was what could have been on the north side in particular.

19:19 - Massive highways running right through

19:21 - what has now become the Mexican War Street's historic

19:24 - district, and then slicing down through West Park,

19:28 - that oldest part, West of the Allegne Mountains.

19:31 - And what we ended up with was the demolition

19:34 - of Manchester's commercial corridor, what we now know is the North Shore,

19:38 - where the stadiums are located, and then the East Street Valley expressway,

19:42 - which I'm another article I'm working on as well.

19:48 - And this is what was lost.

19:50 - This was, it looks like the south side or Lawrenceville.

19:55 - And this was the shopping area for Manchester,

19:58 - and it was all demolished for what would become

20:02 - an elevated highway, which the residents now call the wall.

20:06 - And there's discussions about demolishing it and doing

20:11 - other reconnection projects, but a damage was done.

20:16 - In East Allegheny, we had the second oldest

20:18 - African-American congregation west of the Alleginis.

20:22 - The AME Zion Church, which was actually an underground railroad stop as well,

20:27 - one of the first training vocational training programs

20:31 - for African-Americans in the country.

20:33 - Right there, that was demolished.

20:35 - And of course, there's a historical marker

20:37 - that has replaced it on East Ohio Street.

20:40 - But this is one of about 1,500 properties

20:43 - that were removed for the East Street expressway and Valley.

20:49 - And what was interesting is that two projects slowed down

20:53 - all of this, the roadway, that was almost completed.

20:57 - It was finally completed in '89.

20:59 - But in '87, there was archeological dig for the mainline canal.

21:05 - There were two turning basins, locks that were on the North Shore.

21:09 - One was right here in East Allegheny.

21:12 - We're railroad bridge near a railroad bridge.

21:15 - It comes over.

21:17 - And the second project was workers discovered 727

21:23 - graves that otherwise had not been documented from the

21:29 - Beckley Cemetery, which had to be all exhumed and relocated.

21:35 - So all these things were uncovered during this process

21:38 - in addition to the relocation of hundreds of families.

21:44 - But there's a silver lining in all this.

21:45 - And it really digs into what I was saying in my argument

21:49 - that without these community-based nonprofits,

21:52 - the neighborhoods we have now that way elites

21:55 - are all claiming that this is part of

21:57 - Pittsburgh's livability would have never happened,

22:00 - had they not pushed back and created a community-based response

22:04 - to the threats that were facing many of these communities,

22:09 - such as the historic preservation movement, which begins in Manchester.

22:13 - The nation's neighborhood community-based preservation

22:16 - movement begins there.

22:18 - Because people started asking questions.

22:19 - They were pushing back, but also creating solutions

22:22 - for and marshaling resources to create a new

22:26 - vision, a community-based vision from below that

22:29 - would replace all of the top-down types of things.

22:35 - And I've been working with the community recently to document a lot of the processes

22:41 - that are going on right now in the North Shore

22:44 - in the area known as Chateau, the largest

22:48 - construction project west of the Allegheny Mountains.

22:52 - As well, the S-1-8 project, $740 million, and probably we'll go up from there.

22:56 - As well, the S-1-8 project, $740 million, and probably we'll go up from there.

22:59 - We uncovered the fact that through a Freedom of Information

23:02 - Act request that the site is heavily polluted,

23:06 - and they've ignored all plans and attempts to work with the community.

23:12 - And so people are, again, asking questions.

23:14 - And the question we have, or the community has, is anyone listening?

23:19 - Thank you.

23:21 - [APPLAUSE]

23:36 - Good morning, everyone.

23:38 - Thank you to Drew for organizing the session,

23:40 - and thank you to all of you for being here.

23:44 - I'm going to have us cast our gaze a bit wider in two ways

23:52 - that reflect the ways I've been thinking about the Renaissance

23:55 - now for my career, and reflected in my books,

24:00 - and then in an article that I'm up here,

24:05 - and it edits volume by Joel Tarr here in another six months or eight months or so.

24:11 - I was really motivated in thinking about Pittsburgh

24:15 - by the work of Drew mentioned in by Ted Mueller,

24:19 - a historical geographer recently retired,

24:22 - well, not recently retired from the University of Pittsburgh.

24:27 - And Ted's work really placed Pittsburgh

24:32 - within a broader economic, political, social framework, geographical framework.

24:37 - And that was really where I took the starting point for my work.

24:41 - So today, I'm not going to have a single picture

24:44 - from Pittsburgh itself, aside from this one from Homestead, which is not Pittsburgh.

24:48 - And instead, I'm going to talk about the Renaissance

24:52 - more broadly, both in the Pittsburgh metropolitan region,

24:57 - but then also thinking about it in broader terms

24:59 - in terms of the great political and social movements

25:03 - of the 20th century, particularly the environmental

25:07 - movement and the historic preservation movement.

25:10 - And it's both their pre-cursors and then antecedents or sorry, successors.

25:19 - The Renaissance was a story.

25:23 - It was the Pittsburgh story quite literally.

25:27 - It was a brand as much as it was a physical reconstruction

25:33 - and the branding of the Renaissance was sold

25:37 - by the Allegheny Conference in a number of different ways.

25:40 - They were very excited to place Pittsburgh

25:42 - at the Vanguard of post-war to redevelopment.

25:48 - There were people really from all over the world who visited

25:51 - Pittsburgh to try to get that special sauce as Drew called it.

25:56 - And especially those closer to home, the Wheeling West Virginia city--

26:04 - fifth year so miles outside of Pittsburgh that had been overshadowed by Pittsburgh.

26:10 - It saw itself as a competitor in the early 19th century.

26:13 - It lost quite dramatically.

26:15 - But many of the same demographics, many of the same economic issues

26:21 - that affected Wheeling as well.

26:23 - And so Wheeling really looked at Pittsburgh

26:26 - as a potential model for its own Renaissance.

26:28 - There was a Wheeling conference on community development.

26:33 - There was a Wheeling Renaissance.

26:35 - And some of the same players, certainly

26:38 - some of the same foundations, the Claude Worthington Benedictine Foundation--

26:41 - without-- sorry, without getting too far down in the weeds.

26:43 - Some of the foundations that were important

26:45 - in Pittsburgh were also important in Wheeling

26:46 - because the industrial families that created those foundations,

26:51 - their web extended throughout that greater--

26:54 - oh, am I talking about that again?

26:55 - Sorry.

26:56 - I don't know.

26:56 - It must be-- it might be automatically

26:59 - going through my slides, which would be awkward.

27:01 - So anyway, you've got to preview.

27:07 - So the Wheeling story took the same tenants as the Pittsburgh story in miniature.

27:10 - So the Wheeling story took the same tenants as the Pittsburgh story in miniature.

27:13 - I'll give you one example.

27:17 - There you go.

27:18 - Pittsburgh's the decision to remake all of the waterfront

27:24 - is largely for parking, which is kind of an aspect

27:27 - of Renaissance one that we don't think of anymore.

27:30 - The same thing happened to Wheeling.

27:32 - And they were so proud.

27:34 - They were so proud.

27:35 - I mean, this is such small potatoes when you think of the Renaissance.

27:39 - But they were so proud in Wheeling of their Wharf parking garage.

27:43 - I had a lot of spent a lot of time in this parking garage.

27:47 - Wheeling was the closest big city to me growing up.

27:50 - And let me tell you, friends, if Wheeling West Virginia

27:52 - is the closest big city to you, you are from the boondocks, right?

27:56 - is the closest big city to you, you are from the boondocks, right?

27:57 - I parked there in 1994 with my friend Kevin

28:01 - and his big sister, who took us to my first concert,

28:05 - Death Leopard at the Wheeling Civic Center.

28:07 - We parked there for Nailers games, et cetera.

28:11 - So this is really that Wheeling Renaissance

28:14 - that's sought to model itself off of Pittsburgh.

28:19 - So let me then sort of frame the other big framing element to this.

28:23 - And that is that the Renaissance is really

28:26 - the ultimate expression of the conservation movement, right?

28:30 - Pinchos, aphorism, the greatest good for the greatest number over the longest time,

28:34 - was the same vision that motivated R.K.

28:38 - Mellon, the planning association that he was, you know,

28:41 - that he was part and part is enough, really looking to identify what--

28:45 - Oh, see, I did it again, what are the most,

28:48 - what is the highest and best use of any resource,

28:51 - of any space, and then applying government

28:54 - resources, eminent domain, urban renewal authority,

28:58 - private funding with the power of the government to recreate those spaces.

29:04 - That's really the ultimate expression, I think,

29:06 - of the motivation of progressive conservationism,

29:08 - of the city, beautiful movement, et cetera, right?

29:12 - So if we think of that then as the conservation movement

29:15 - and of urban renewal as being expression of it,

29:20 - in much the same way that the environmental movement and--

29:23 - and I think that this is where that close connection

29:26 - between the environmental movement and the historic

29:28 - preservation movement in terms of public policy emerge.

29:32 - It is this opposition to the conservation way of thinking, right?

29:40 - It is sort of destroying natural processes,

29:44 - using this veneer of science, of public policy to overlay it.

29:49 - This really becomes the motivations for opposition

29:52 - to these policies, both in Pittsburgh and elsewhere.

29:56 - And you can see this in wheeling.

29:59 - Ultimately, ultimately, the worth parking garage is torn down, and instead wheeling,

30:07 - it's residents kind of much in the same way as

30:09 - Pittsburgh in the '90s sort of turn their attention

30:11 - to the riverfronts themselves as an asset, right, as a community development tool.

30:17 - Wheeling, no, I'm paranoid.

30:23 - Wheeling follows that same trajectory, right?

30:26 - Of Renaissance and its discontents, right?

30:30 - So let me illustrate this story a bit further.

30:35 - This is such the thing, apparently.

30:41 - When we look at the regional ramifications of Renaissance,

30:47 - great parks and great highways to get to them,

30:49 - which is a quote from Graham Nutting, who

30:52 - was a member of the Allegheny Conference on Community

30:54 - Development, the director of the Carnegie Museum

30:56 - of Natural History, and one of the key members

31:00 - of the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, which

31:03 - in its motivations and its power is an outgrowth

31:07 - of the Allegheny Conference on Community Development.

31:09 - You see the same state power, the same regional vision,

31:14 - the same sort of conservation ethic that gets applied

31:18 - to sort of the Golden Triangle, that gets applied to Central

31:22 - Pittsburgh itself, being used out in the countryside, right?

31:26 - And this notion of urban and suburban residents

31:30 - needing places to retreat from a modernity

31:35 - and that those retreats can take the form of these sort

31:38 - of semi-welderness recreation areas that is part and parcel of the Renaissance story.

31:41 - of semi-welderness recreation areas that is part and parcel of the Renaissance story.

31:44 - Of course, the trick is that if we're talking about Renaissance

31:49 - from below, both in wheeling and in Ohio pile, there are discontents to that, right?

31:55 - Because just like in Pittsburgh, in order for an area

32:00 - to reach its sort of greatest potential use,

32:03 - the previous uses have to be erased from the map,

32:07 - and in Ohio Piles case, this is the entirety of Ohio piles.

32:12 - This is the entirety of Ohio piles downtown, right?

32:15 - So if you've ever gone rafting Ohio pile,

32:19 - that big beautiful riverfront park was downtown Ohio pile 75 years ago, right?

32:24 - And so just like with the opposition,

32:27 - the concern about sort of whole-scale

32:29 - erasure of the industrial city in Pittsburgh,

32:32 - we so too see that in Ohio pile, this sort of

32:36 - results or this ramifications are going to be,

32:41 - are going to be felt in the origins of this populist reaction.

32:46 - Some of which gets channeled into the environmental movement,

32:49 - some of which gets channeled into the historic preservation

32:54 - movement, and some of it gets translated into pure anti-government populism.

33:01 - There's a reason why we don't use eminent

33:02 - domain for anything ever anymore by and large.

33:05 - And that is because it's used so extensively

33:08 - in this sort of renaissance, this conservationist era,

33:12 - has a backlash that we continue to feel today, right?

33:15 - Okay, so for my third sort of example of this,

33:18 - I want to take a look even a little bit further field than wheeling.

33:25 - A hundred years ago, my family farm was right there

33:28 - in the upper right-hand side of your screen,

33:30 - in a little hamlet called Egypt, the Egypt Valley, right in southeastern Ohio.

33:36 - And the great thing about Egypt was it had lovely farmland,

33:43 - and it was over over top of the Pittsburgh Number 8

33:45 - seem of coal, right? We see massive capital that is headquartered in Pittsburgh.

33:53 - This is the Pittsburgh Consolidation Coal Company,

33:55 - which applies that capital to remaking the broader region

34:00 - to serve the interests of urban industrial corporations, right?

34:04 - Now again, the greatest potential use

34:08 - for the Golden Triangle was the Golden Triangle, right?

34:11 - Tear down old industrial buildings, build a white collar city.

34:16 - But in the countryside or in Ohio pile,

34:18 - the greatest possible use that serves the interests

34:22 - of the renaissance is in sort of massive extraction, right?

34:27 - Whether that's extraction of the population

34:29 - to create a recreation area, or that is extraction

34:34 - of the population to create a strip mine, the motivations are the same, right?

34:38 - The motivations are the same, right?

34:40 - Again, it's this conservation, this progressive notion

34:43 - of sort of applying science, applying, you know,

34:46 - and applying the power of government to the landscape.

34:49 - Now, now I will actually purposely change the screen.

34:54 - Here too, we see exactly that same reaction from below, right?

34:59 - There is opposition, there's both extensive support

35:02 - and extensive opposition or to surface mining,

35:06 - particularly as surface mining equipment gets bigger

35:09 - and bigger, and as it gets closer and closer and closer

35:12 - to the community of Barnesville, in this case, right?

35:16 - And so the same sort of sets of tensions

35:23 - that manifest themselves in the Renaissance

35:25 - and that ultimately spell the end of Renaissance one,

35:28 - but lay the seeds for the origins of Renaissance two

35:31 - and then ultimately of Renaissance three, we see out in the countryside as well.

35:36 - And again, in my framing of it,

35:39 - we see this sort of an opposition, a growing opposition

35:43 - to the limitations of progressive conservationism

35:45 - with this sort of anti, with this environmentalism

35:49 - that is going to subsequently emerge.

35:51 - Now, what's interesting, I think, about this site

35:55 - and Drew hinted that we're really looking at, you know,

35:58 - pushing our time frame forward and farther and farther forward.

36:02 - Ultimately, sort of the post-industrial use of this site,

36:06 - just as in the post-industrial site of wheeling, is undetermined, right?

36:11 - If Pittsburgh is a city of Edson-Meds, that's great,

36:14 - we all well know that Pittsburgh is one of the most

36:19 - economically and racially divided cities in the nation, right?

36:22 - So the Edson-Meds, this post-industrial economy,

36:25 - may work well for some, but it is certainly not a panacea

36:28 - of any sense, and it's even more so in the countryside,

36:31 - it's even more so in the smaller communities

36:33 - like wheeling that lost in the industrial race.

36:38 - And therefore, don't have the level of industrial, you know,

36:43 - foundation support and others to help with this transition.

36:46 - We see sort of the post-industrial remnants of this.

36:49 - And ultimately, and this is one of the things,

36:51 - I think, is so interesting about drawing some

36:52 - comparisons between strip mines and state parks.

36:57 - The Egypt Valley is now the Egypt Valley Wildlife Area,

37:00 - when you have no higher purpose for something,

37:02 - you put a sign on it and let the weeds grow in the wild turkeys populate, right?

37:07 - So we have a sense here, I think, then,

37:10 - of the ways in which the evolution of Renaissance

37:13 - can tell us not just about the city center itself,

37:17 - but also about the relationship between urban suburban

37:20 - and rural landscapes, as well as the broader

37:23 - trajectory of these social movements, you know,

37:27 - of conservation, environmentalism, environmental justice,

37:30 - and sort of the evolution of historic preservation.

37:34 - So thank you.

37:35 - (audience applauds)

37:45 - - All right, well, thanks, everybody.

37:47 - I'm gonna wrap it up.

37:48 - I wanna talk a little bit about sort of how my work fits in.

37:50 - I'm gonna take us back a little closer to Pittsburgh.

37:54 - It's really wonderful being able to go last,

37:57 - because you get to hear how everyone else

37:58 - is rethinking about the sort of notion of Renaissance,

38:01 - and I can't wait to get to the discussion.

38:03 - So my contribution today comes from my work

38:05 - on the history of the Med's part of the Edges of Med's economy,

38:08 - which comes out of my first book, the Medical and Trapless Healthcare

38:11 - and Economic Transformation in Pittsburgh and Houston.

38:14 - In both this book and in that 2015 journal

38:16 - of urban history forum that I mentioned earlier,

38:18 - I attempt to complicate the relationship between health and Renaissance.

38:23 - Too often the idea, I think, with the Edges of Med's economy,

38:25 - is that if we build more hospitals, or if we strengthen

38:28 - ties to universities, then everything's gonna be fine.

38:32 - This is a magical solution to post-industrial decline.

38:35 - The problem with that is it prioritizes

38:37 - and incentivizes the needs of those institutions

38:40 - and constrains inclusive solutions to post-industrial malaise.

38:45 - Now, I don't wanna minimize the importance

38:47 - that hospitals and universities play in Pittsburgh's economy.

38:48 - that hospitals and universities play in Pittsburgh's economy.

38:50 - Just look at the numbers.

38:51 - Health systems universities are by far the largest employers,

38:56 - but it's important to clearly state that whatever form of

38:58 - Renaissance we're in and Alan, you mentioned Renaissance 3.

39:00 - Renaissance we're in and Alan, you mentioned Renaissance 3.

39:02 - That's gonna say, I don't know if we're in Renaissance 2.

39:04 - 5, Renaissance 3, Renaissance 4, whatever form we're in,

39:08 - Renaissance was neither accidental nor was it intentional.

39:12 - That's a popular narrative applied.

39:14 - One of the things I tried to do in my work

39:15 - is really point out that it comes from choices made

39:18 - by a variety of historical actors, university administrators,

39:22 - healthcare executives, civic leaders, elected officials,

39:26 - oftentimes these choices are independent of one another

39:29 - and oftentimes they were made without putting civic redevelopment

39:32 - at the forefront of the decision making process.

39:35 - So, I wanna talk briefly.

39:36 - I'm gonna give you kind of a quick overview

39:38 - of how I think health and Renaissance intersect in Pittsburgh.

39:42 - So, health broadly defined has been a central part of the Renaissance story

39:44 - So, health broadly defined has been a central part of the Renaissance story

39:46 - even if we don't always acknowledge it as such.

39:49 - When we think back to the era preceding Renaissance

39:52 - one, Pittsburgh's strength wasn't just steel.

39:54 - We had institutions to train managers and industrial workers

39:57 - like Carnegie Tech and even my own institution, Duquesne.

40:01 - And of course, we had the University of Pittsburgh and it's medical school,

40:04 - which is of a particular interest to both the Mellon and the SCA families.

40:08 - We had independent research institutes like the Mellon Institute.

40:12 - In short, most of the infrastructure that would emerge in the post-ill era

40:14 - In short, most of the infrastructure that would emerge in the post-ill era

40:17 - was already present in these previous decades.

40:22 - There were also a significant number of hospitals in

40:24 - Pittsburgh, including multiple Catholic hospitals,

40:26 - several Protestant hospitals in a Jewish hospital.

40:29 - And that's no small matter.

40:31 - Because the presence of a hospital in a

40:33 - community as several historians of medicine,

40:35 - including Charles Rosenberg have shown us, was an important marker that the community

40:40 - was important enough or wealthy enough to support a complex institution.

40:45 - For Pittsburgh to be able to support not just one hospital,

40:48 - but multiple hospitals in this industrial era

40:51 - was a declaration that Pittsburgh was indeed a city of consequence.

40:55 - But beyond this, just signaling

40:57 - that Pittsburgh could support hospitals.

40:59 - Hospitals and health represented a promise, a promise of health to workers,

41:01 - Hospitals and health represented a promise, a promise of health to workers,

41:03 - and a promise of a healthy workforce to the companies who employed them.

41:05 - and a promise of a healthy workforce to the companies who employed them.

41:07 - Care provided in hospitals and clinics,

41:09 - as well as research and industrial medicine conducted

41:12 - at the University of Pittsburgh, or research and air quality

41:15 - in industrial settings conducted by the Mellon Institute,

41:18 - linked industrial progress and stability to civic health and pride.

41:20 - linked industrial progress and stability to civic health and pride.

41:24 - Pittsburgh's rise to national prominence in the 1950s

41:27 - was the salt vaccine has become kind of a

41:29 - cornerstone in the popular ads and med story.

41:31 - And I took this out in the interest of time and I couldn't find a photo of this.

41:34 - But if anybody remembers, there was a

41:36 - cardboard cutout of salt wearing a pit mask,

41:39 - standing in the peat, overseeing COVID vaccinations.

41:44 - But I think what the story often leaves out

41:46 - is that the sort of salt story in the way that

41:49 - salt was used by the University of Pittsburgh

41:52 - was part of a larger promotion of health-related successes.

41:55 - That Pittsburgh, as well as local elites

41:57 - who are often part of the board of directors

41:59 - and tied to the Allegheny Conference, used to promote

42:03 - Pittsburgh and link health and Renaissance together explicitly.

42:06 - So you have a pamphlet here looking to accept, for example, a William McDhammon,

42:10 - who's work on polio gained national attention.

42:14 - University leaders promoted Benjamin Spock's

42:17 - work and other health-related successes.

42:19 - And this was used to highlight by both conference leaders

42:24 - and the University of Pittsburgh as evidence

42:26 - that Pittsburgh was part of a growing

42:28 - part of a national interest in science and

42:31 - technology, emerging after the Second World War.

42:34 - Where it gets a little bit sticky is that biomedical success in the 1950s and 1960s

42:37 - Where it gets a little bit sticky is that biomedical success in the 1950s and 1960s

42:39 - didn't necessarily lead to direct patenting.

42:41 - We'll talk a little more about that in a minute.

42:44 - But it did lead to a growing ability of universities

42:46 - and medical schools to tap into federal research dollars,

42:50 - something that's become a critical part of the Pittsburgh Medical Economy today.

42:52 - something that's become a critical part of the Pittsburgh Medical Economy today.

42:55 - Biomedical success was also part of a larger embrace of research and technology,

42:59 - led at the university level by Pitts Edward Litchfield,

43:02 - that attempted to link modernity in science,

43:06 - which Pittsburg's efforts to remake itself as

43:08 - a city friendly to white collar professionals,

43:10 - something that several historians have written

43:11 - about in different ways moving forward.

43:15 - And this was an effort that would continue

43:16 - beyond Litchfield's exit from Pitt in the 1960s

43:19 - and we become a cornerstone of Renaissance too.

43:23 - This reputational value then of biomedical research

43:26 - and patient care has continued into Renaissance too and even into the present.

43:28 - and patient care has continued into Renaissance too and even into the present.

43:31 - A good example of this comes in the 1980s

43:33 - and the 1990s with the arrival of Dr. Thomas

43:36 - Darsel and his transplantation program,

43:38 - which showed how complex high value service lines

43:41 - could build reputation and transform hospitals

43:44 - and by extension communities into medical destinations.

43:48 - Patients came to Pittsburg to seek Dr. Darsel's treatment

43:53 - and medical residents came to Pittsburg to learn.

43:57 - Some stayed, but many laughed fanning out

43:59 - across the United States and across the globe

44:02 - taking a little bit of Pittsburg with them

44:04 - as they built their own transplantation programs.

44:08 - I will note though there was an important shift

44:10 - in the relationship between health and Renaissance in the 1980s and the 1990s.

44:15 - Changes in patent law and the emergence

44:17 - of a culture of financialization, sharpened and shifted

44:20 - the relationship between health and Renaissance.

44:23 - As a commercialization of health-related research

44:25 - became profitable and often expected, civic elites embraced biotechnology

44:30 - and advanced manufacturing as an explicit economic development strategy

44:34 - for Pittsburg and other areas of Pennsylvania.

44:37 - This is a bit of a paraphrase,

44:38 - but Pitts Chancellor at the time, Wesley Postfire famously declared

44:41 - the Mon Valley would become the biotech valley.

44:44 - The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania invested heavily

44:47 - in biotech and advanced manufacturing to the Ben Franklin partnership.

44:50 - I don't have it here, but there's a great cartoon

44:53 - they put out of a robot Ben Franklin promoting this.

44:56 - And I've got to see if I can find it somewhere.

44:58 - And groups like the Allegheny Conference made advanced manufacturing by technology

45:00 - And groups like the Allegheny Conference made advanced manufacturing by technology

45:02 - and scientific research, a central part of their strategy documents like Strategy 21.

45:05 - and scientific research, a central part of their strategy documents like Strategy 21.

45:10 - But biomedical research and development was really only part of the way

45:16 - in which health and Renaissance shifted during these years.

45:19 - Decades of rising healthcare costs

45:21 - and care promises that were increasingly hard to fund

45:25 - were also reshaping the American healthcare system from the 70s, 80s, 90s and 2000s.

45:28 - were also reshaping the American healthcare system from the 70s, 80s, 90s and 2000s.

45:30 - During these decades, the fear of large losses caused by trading

45:34 - indigent patients, the perceived cost of epidemic diseases like AIDS

45:36 - indigent patients, the perceived cost of epidemic diseases like AIDS

45:38 - and growing in potential cancer rates, looming healthcare reform,

45:40 - and growing in potential cancer rates, looming healthcare reform,

45:42 - most notably in the early years of the Clinton administration,

45:44 - most notably in the early years of the Clinton administration,

45:46 - and a seemingly credible fear that four profit hospital and healthcare corporations

45:48 - and a seemingly credible fear that four profit hospital and healthcare corporations

45:50 - were gobbling up markets once served by not for profit healthcare institutions.

45:52 - were gobbling up markets once served by not for profit healthcare institutions.

45:54 - Lead healthcare executives like Dr. Thomas

45:56 - Dettry and Jeffrey Romoff to make decisions

45:59 - that prioritize the creation of high value service lines

46:02 - as well as the horizontal and vertical integration

46:04 - of services and healthcare facilities as a way to offset losses in one area

46:08 - and redirect revenue into other growth areas.

46:11 - And here is important to note that these type of

46:14 - healthcare decisions weren't just being made in Pittsburgh.

46:16 - They were being made in health systems across the country

46:19 - and they were reshaping cities dramatically.

46:21 - But in the case of UPMC, these decisions transformed a group

46:25 - of loosely affiliated hospitals and medical schools

46:28 - into a nationally and globally prominent healthcare system.

46:32 - I also note too that there's a lot that's really, we're not talking about here,

46:36 - Pittsburgh had another advantage that other cities didn't necessarily have.

46:40 - Not only did they have UPMC,

46:41 - they had A-HERF which went through its own financial troubles,

46:44 - but they also had a successful insurer in the form of Blue Cross, later Highmark.

46:49 - And during these years, Highmark was also undergoing its own expansion

46:52 - and diversification that helped to reshape the broader healthcare economy as well.

46:54 - and diversification that helped to reshape the broader healthcare economy as well.

46:59 - During these years, and I would say really starting

47:01 - in the 60s, but even earlier than that, healthcare employment continued to grow.

47:06 - Universities and hospitals had long been major employers in Pittsburgh for decades,

47:08 - Universities and hospitals had long been major employers in Pittsburgh for decades,

47:10 - even if it wasn't necessarily publicly recognized.

47:13 - But their importance became much more visible

47:15 - to the general population in the 1990s and beyond.

47:19 - And there was a growing understanding that healthcare

47:21 - employment was not just for white collar professionals,

47:24 - as many of the early sort of narrative of Renaissance.

47:26 - But out in Gabrielle, when it's talked about this, in his work.

47:31 - Contemporary actors throughout the Renaissance

47:33 - one and Renaissance two period recognized

47:35 - that the health economy shared many of the same challenges as the industrial one,

47:39 - including inequality and including low pay scales.

47:43 - But it also brought new challenges related to training

47:46 - and acquiring specialized healthcare knowledge.

47:49 - Now, historians have been working,

47:51 - and this is, I think, an area that's important to focus on

47:53 - as we start to rethink this relationship between health and Renaissance,

47:57 - 'cause historians have been working to tell the story of programs

47:59 - like the Freedom House Ambulance Service and the Medical

48:02 - Career's Opportunity Program at the University of Pittsburgh.

48:05 - That explicitly thought to use healthcare

48:07 - employment as a latter for economic mobility.

48:10 - There's a lot more work here, I think, that needs to be done by historians

48:14 - to look at the way in which prior to sort of the 1990s

48:17 - and the 2000s, explicitly looking at healthcare delivery

48:22 - but also healthcare employment was a key way

48:24 - in which many of the challenges of Renaissance were attempted to be mitigated.

48:28 - And I think it will help us really shift it away

48:30 - from a largely top-down story to one where the

48:33 - actions of everyday Pittsburghers speak more loudly

48:36 - and complicate our understanding of post-industrial change.

48:39 - I want to thank everybody for your attention and what I

48:42 - want to do now is go ahead and invite the panelists forward.

48:45 - I'm gonna offer one, ask one guiding question, but I really want to open it up

48:49 - and let us sort of explore the ways in which

48:52 - we can rethink and retell this Renaissance story.

48:55 - (audience applauds)

49:04 - All right, so thank you everybody.

49:06 - Really enjoyed us.

49:07 - I want to get us started here with a question.

49:10 - And I want to sort of ask a periodization question.

49:15 - So are we still in Renaissance?

49:19 - Are we in Renaissance?

49:21 - Two Renaissance, three Renaissance, four?

49:24 - And I guess the question is, is Renaissance even still a useful

49:28 - way to describe many of these sort of changes we have here?

49:32 - So take it away.

49:35 - Well, I'm gonna argue no for two reasons.

49:39 - One is, as you've mentioned, I think Renaissance really required two things.

49:46 - One was big government, big government expenditures,

49:50 - and also a concerted public-private partnership.

49:53 - I don't see those right now.

49:56 - I see very limited opportunities.

50:00 - And I guess even a third element is one of the underpinnings

50:05 - of Renaissance was to stem the out migration of people.

50:09 - We haven't done that.

50:10 - In fact, we've lost more African-Americans in this last decade than we ever have

50:16 - in the history of Pittsburgh, 13% over the last 10 years.

50:20 - So I think if anything, we need a demographic Renaissance.

50:26 - But I also think that we're starting to see

50:30 - a lot more private equity taking over neighborhood development

50:34 - and other forces kind of out of the control of

50:37 - neighborhoods and even government to some extent.

50:43 - - Do you want to sell answer?

50:44 - - I do, whoever wants to answer.

50:45 - I mean, Renaissance is a branding thing from the start.

50:48 - So I think if you want to pour a lot of money into branding

50:51 - and people take it off, then sure.

50:54 - But I mean, it's a way of periodizing the public policy

50:58 - and narratives that are sort of paramount within Pittsburgh

51:02 - and thinking about how they relate more broadly to the national sector.

51:07 - But I mean, I largely agree that the moment if we're aligning,

51:10 - But I mean, I largely agree that the moment if we're aligning,

51:13 - if we're aligning Renaissance with a particular kind

51:17 - of relatively universal, certainly among elites

51:23 - desire to remake the city in particular ways.

51:26 - I don't think that we have that, we don't have,

51:28 - we certainly don't have that level of capital investment

51:32 - and government power that was, I think, largely

51:35 - associated with those particular moments of time.

51:40 - - Yeah, I largely agree with everything that everyone said so far.

51:44 - I think that the Renaissance, this label, this branding,

51:49 - I think really applies to a specific period,

51:51 - a specific time and energy, but just doesn't exist anymore.

51:55 - I think that, for arguably since the '90s,

51:58 - it's begun and continued to evolve in a different direction.

52:04 - So, yeah, I just don't think that we're still

52:07 - in a Renaissance, I also think that the very kind of idea,

52:11 - the sort of myth of Renaissance is something

52:13 - that we are probably all interested in discussing

52:16 - and exploring what was it actually?

52:21 - On the ground versus what is this sort of myth and story

52:25 - that we've been, you know, told and we've been reading about and exploring.

52:30 - - Excellent, well with that, let's open it up to, let's open it up to the audience.

52:36 - - At what point does the idea of Renaissance go

52:38 - from some paper, some of the public actually belief in,

52:41 - like this is like 50% of the project's done,

52:43 - is it like five or 10 years into the program

52:46 - or granting, what is it in a public actually belief in?

52:53 - - It's a self myth, certainly by the mid-50s.

52:55 - - It's a self myth, certainly by the mid-50s.

52:55 - - It's a self myth, certainly by the mid-50s.

52:56 - Yeah, I mean, it's a self myth.

53:00 - When I say it's a brand, it's a brand as much about

53:04 - internal alignment as it is about promotion elsewhere.

53:07 - internal alignment as it is about promotion elsewhere.

53:09 - So, certainly by the mid-50s, there's this full alignment that Pittsburgh's doing,

53:12 - So, certainly by the mid-50s, there's this full alignment that Pittsburgh's doing,

53:14 - sorry, there's this full alignment that Pittsburgh's doing something special.

53:19 - Even folks, I mean, kind of famously, even folks within the Hill District

53:23 - to support the initial movements of the Renaissance, even the urban renewal.

53:26 - to support the initial movements of the Renaissance, even the urban renewal.

53:29 - Really, I'd say it, so like 55 to 62 or so,

53:33 - there's this, I think, full common consensus about the move.

53:36 - - I mean, of course, there's always, you know,

53:39 - what Richard Mellon didn't care for.

53:41 - You know, sorry, you know, R.K. Mellon's uncle who sued to stop his house

53:43 - You know, sorry, you know, R.K. Mellon's uncle who sued to stop his house

53:46 - You know, sorry, you know, R.K. Mellon's uncle who sued to stop his house

53:47 - from being taken into urban, you know, by eminent domain

53:50 - and lost, which underscored the ability, which allowed eminent domain to be used,

53:56 - even if it was being, the property was

53:57 - being transmitted to another private entity.

53:59 - That's kind of a famous court case.

54:00 - So, there were obviously always those

54:02 - who were posing things on their own individual grounds,

54:05 - but there really is a common consensus

54:06 - within Pittsburgh supporting the Renaissance,

54:08 - again, you know, certainly by the mid-50s, I would say.

54:14 - - Well, if I can just chime in, you know, one of the interesting things when you look

54:18 - at the archives is the stuff that you uncover

54:21 - about the resistance that was happening, even in the 1940s.

54:24 - - Sure.

54:26 - - Unlimited ways.

54:28 - I mean, you are right to a certain extent

54:30 - about the overall gist, and I think, you know,

54:33 - most folks probably supported the downtown Renaissance

54:36 - that does great point-state park and remakes

54:40 - downtown, but as it extended into the neighborhoods,

54:43 - that's when you started to get some pushback.

54:45 - And I talked about the Civic Arena construction,

54:48 - but, you know, the Civic Arena was almost built

54:50 - at Highland Park, a nice leafy, upper-income,

54:54 - white neighborhood, far from downtown.

54:56 - It's near the current zoo that we have there.

54:59 - There's actually a mansion that sits there.

55:01 - That's currently for sale.

55:03 - If anyone has $4 million they want to buy,

55:05 - but there were more test borings being done in

55:09 - 1949, and then the neighborhood got wind of this,

55:12 - and more than 900 people showed up at the City Council

55:16 - hearing to protest the construction of the Civic Arena

55:20 - in Highland Park, and the person who owned that mansion

55:23 - was a wealthy industrialist, king, and pushback,

55:27 - and negotiate with the city, they then looked

55:30 - at possible shedly park as a possible location

55:33 - before settling on the lower hill and designating it

55:38 - as blighted in this kind of using state powers to do this.

55:42 - And the same thing with the, so this is 1949.

55:45 - 1954, this proposed upper route that would have cut through

55:53 - the central north side and cut through the Allegheny West

56:00 - and the park was resoundingly pushed back against

56:05 - by the neighborhood that forced the planners

56:10 - to rethink and shift down closer to the river

56:14 - that ultimately does become route 65

56:17 - and that 28 connector.

56:19 - So I think you see individuals,

56:22 - it doesn't become a large movement against

56:25 - Renaissance until like the late '60s and early '70s.

56:29 - And by then the government funding basically runs out.

56:35 - So I think they're limited depending on who

56:38 - you're talking to and where it's being applied.

56:42 - You see resistance kind of all along the way.

56:45 - But yeah, I think overall, you do have this kind of, this kind of collective mindset

56:51 - until it's their property that's getting taken.

56:55 - - Well, and I think audience and time matter as well.

56:58 - A lot of the pushes you see in the '50s and then again in the '90s

57:02 - with this health-related idea of Renaissance,

57:05 - yes, there is a way in which local leads are speaking to people in Pittsburgh.

57:11 - There's a fantastic photo, for example, of Thomas

57:13 - Dazzle throwing out a first pitch to Pirates game.

57:17 - But they're also using this to speak to a global and international audience.

57:21 - And for the University of Pittsburgh in particular,

57:23 - this is a way in which they're promoting their ambitions

57:25 - to become a larger and more well-respected research university.

57:30 - And so I think the audience and the subject matter also

57:33 - changed the way in which people interact with this Renaissance narrative.

57:37 - Same to me to hand it up.

57:40 - - For me, there's a couple of key points

57:43 - that Alan and Dan have made.

57:47 - One is, it turns out to push back,

57:52 - especially coming out of the field district.

57:54 - So we know that it's ongoing to a certain extent.

58:00 - Thomas Brown was one of chief supporters of the Renaissance

58:07 - in what is the locally-labelist instruction on the board here.

58:13 - There were real casualties there.

58:15 - And I think that you alluded to it not only in Pittsburgh, but also in Ohio,

58:22 - in the gaming period.

58:24 - There were casualties.

58:25 - I specifically just use an example more recently.

58:30 - Backaway in the church was able to have some

58:34 - with QR-H, who, my opinion, I've seen the documents.

58:40 - Curvously, undervalued their property when they moved

58:44 - that church, removed the church from the lower hill.

58:48 - To the extent of something, I'd 600,000 dollars.

58:52 - So I was kind of curious as to, how many other indications of that type of crack

59:00 - is comes up in this umbrella of the Renaissance,

59:04 - how many victims of undervalued with their property, whether it's, you know,

59:08 - can you mention imminent domain or even other existed church?

59:12 - So it's probably handled differently.

59:15 - So have you come across any of that?

59:19 - - Yes, absolutely.

59:20 - In fact, as I'm writing about this,

59:22 - or have written about this in this forthcoming article,

59:26 - I'm gonna submit, so I mentioned Avery A.M.E.

59:32 - Zion on the north side.

59:34 - They had requested three different, or was it four different assessments

59:38 - to get appraisals on their value of their property, everything from 36,000.

59:44 - Now this is 1968, $69.

59:47 - But so everything from like 36,000 to 86,000.

59:51 - And they finally settled on the 86,000.

59:53 - They signed the agreement with the state,

59:56 - and that's what they sold their property for.

59:58 - 080 But many people long after that, we're still complaining about white and black,

01:00 - 07.000 we're complaining that they felt like they got a raw deal.

01:00 - 08.760 And you see the same thing in Manchester.

01:00 - 10.000 So I've seen the documents.

01:00 - 14.040 I've seen how this happened, and one of the things I'm looking to compare,

01:00 - 17.480 and I need to go back to the Pitt Archives and check this,

01:00 - 20.665 but how undervalued were there, 'cause there were other

01:00 - 24.280 churches that were taken during this time as well.

01:00 - 26.920 - And David Lawrence's church.

01:00 - 28.920 - Right, yeah, you're absolutely right.

01:00 - 30.520 Yeah, which was spared.

01:00 - 36.560 And I think most people probably got undervalued

01:00 - 39.680 because the area was designated as blighted.

01:00 - 41.520 So automatically, and it linged,

01:00 - 43.763 and especially with the Eastern Valley Expressway project, it sat for 30 years.

01:00 - 47.000 and especially with the Eastern Valley Expressway project, it sat for 30 years.

01:00 - 50.960 So people were literally waiting to have something happen.

01:00 - 55.000 And so values really beyond the project site started

01:00 - 00.000 to decline, such that they were horribly undervalued.

01:01 - 05.481 And it's only now just starting to come back, but you're absolutely right.

01:01 - 10.280 And I've spoken with the Bethel AME about their property.

01:01 - 17.480 And part of the issue is we don't have all of the documentation to really,

01:01 - 20.280 and I wanna do a, I think AI can maybe help with this.

01:01 - 23.120 But you really look at all of the values,

01:01 - 25.139 'cause there were thousands of properties

01:01 - 28.120 taken with eminent domain, and there's no way

01:01 - 31.320 that they would have been given fair market value for those properties.

01:01 - 33.200 Because if you flip it around and say,

01:01 - 37.200 if we save those, imagine a lower hill district,

01:01 - 42.040 historic district, now, what those properties would be worth.

01:01 - 43.760 So close to downtown and Oakland.

01:01 - 46.000 I mean, they would be in the millions.

01:01 - 48.280 So, I think it's a fair question.

01:01 - 52.320 Can we go with Glenna and then you?

01:01 - 53.321 That's not good.

01:01 - 57.540 - Forgive me, I'm going to happen to be the person to ask a very broad question.

01:01 - 01.160 I'm also speaking as one of the most important things

01:02 - 05.440 where I take it from this park basically back and forth that we work.

01:02 - 08.600 And some people being around to happen to work today

01:02 - 12.520 as a, as some people are looking to be able to see,

01:02 - 14.360 as a different place, a lot of opportunities

01:02 - 19.520 and some sectors, some people can see access and funds to be able to do sectors

01:02 - 24.120 and as data is constant, I think it's all going to be alive.

01:02 - 29.240 One in our enterprise need to be determined to lead to a lot of expenses.

01:02 - 33.320 I'll kind of also want to find some impacts.

01:02 - 37.600 And what kind of need to lead to any unintended consequences

01:02 - 40.600 or the failed policies of ourselves to be ready?

01:02 - 42.280 And how am I going to have to rent

01:02 - 46.560 how certain people will be comfortable and constantly?

01:02 - 48.560 - I think that sounds like a perfect question for peers.

01:02 - 51.160 (audience laughs)

01:02 - 54.080 - Yeah, I know better place to start than public transportation, right?

01:02 - 56.120 - Yes, absolutely.

01:02 - 58.400 As I have kind of mentioned alluded to,

01:02 - 03.800 there's this story of the pat coming in in the 60s and growing in the 70s and 80s

01:03 - 07.080 and connecting all these different parts of Pittsburgh together.

01:03 - 10.600 And of course, one element of that is

01:03 - 14.760 this attempt to connect to the suburbs,

01:03 - 22.600 to try and bring more of this white collar workforce into the city.

01:03 - 26.880 That this is something that we see, and as we get into the 90s,

01:03 - 30.200 we see rapid cuts to public transit funding.

01:03 - 33.440 We see it coming from Washington, we see it coming from the state,

01:03 - 37.280 the local, the county government, all of the different facets.

01:03 - 40.000 Basically, just a stark decline.

01:03 - 42.680 And so something that we can see today

01:03 - 46.714 is we see modernizations and updates to bus

01:03 - 50.120 lines, which are wiping out certain connections

01:03 - 54.800 or reorganizing them in ways that are not what the people

01:03 - 57.578 actually want, the people who rely on these connections to navigate the city.

01:03 - 00.260 actually want, the people who rely on these connections to navigate the city.

01:04 - 06.000 And yeah, I mean, I think that through these service cuts,

01:04 - 09.880 other issues that we face with just getting around the city

01:04 - 13.680 and navigating it, we see these promises

01:04 - 18.680 that were given to us by organizations like the Port Authority

01:04 - 24.520 and like other Renaissance era actors.

01:04 - 28.440 It stings a bit, I guess, you know,

01:04 - 30.880 'cause it's, you know, I've been relying on this for a while

01:04 - 34.200 and now I don't know how I'm gonna get to work.

01:04 - 37.400 - Yeah, I think that's a great question.

01:04 - 42.000 And I think it's a very big question, but you hit on an important point,

01:04 - 44.722 which is thinking about both intentional, intentional

01:04 - 47.760 choices and consequences and unintentional ones.

01:04 - 50.000 And I think that's something that

01:04 - 53.680 Renaissance scholars have long sort of tried to sort of

01:04 - 56.120 tease out the differences between those two.

01:04 - 59.160 And one of the things I appreciate about all of the approaches we've had today

01:04 - 02.040 is we're looking at it in various different elements.

01:05 - 05.280 We tend to like to think of sort of Renaissance one

01:05 - 07.640 as a master plan of Richard King Mellon sitting around,

01:05 - 09.160 that famous image of them all sitting around

01:05 - 11.160 a conference table with a model of downtown.

01:05 - 15.640 I think the documentation that you, we've sort of found in the archive shows

01:05 - 21.760 there's maybe not as much organization or not as much sort of clear sense

01:05 - 25.120 of this is how this is gonna work, perhaps, as we've seen.

01:05 - 28.400 And that's been part of the way that historians have complicated the story.

01:05 - 36.400 - I also think it's important to note as much as, as much as the branding

01:05 - 42.040 and the history emphasizes this sort of white collar focus of the Renaissance.

01:05 - 44.600 Much of the eminent domain in urban renewal programs

01:05 - 47.840 that were done were actually to expand heavy industry in Pittsburgh.

01:05 - 51.000 I mean, just as we saw in the '40s in Homestead

01:05 - 53.583 with the expansion of the Homestead works, Janelle Steel's work, Janelle Steel works

01:05 - 56.600 with the expansion of the Homestead works, Janelle Steel's work, Janelle Steel works

01:05 - 58.920 the process of eminent domain and redemption

01:05 - 02.680 for blight expanded those steel facilities in the city as well.

01:06 - 07.680 So it's very clear and, as you talk about extensively

01:06 - 11.800 in some of your early work and I've talked about as well.

01:06 - 17.920 While industrial parks ultimately become a suburban phenomena,

01:06 - 21.320 that was not the intention of the Lawrence administration as mayor.

01:06 - 24.600 They worked very, very hard to get,

01:06 - 28.440 at the time would have been advanced manufacturing,

01:06 - 29.880 light manufacturing, all of those things

01:06 - 32.153 we associate with Greenfield, suburban, spread

01:06 - 34.720 out industrial parks in Manchester, right?

01:06 - 39.160 And in the city itself, and they simply for a variety

01:06 - 41.600 of different reasons, simply weren't able to do so.

01:06 - 46.600 And so, there was never an intention for Pittsburgh to,

01:06 - 49.560 the notion that Renaissance One was about laying

01:06 - 52.160 the foundation for Edson Medes is not true, right?

01:06 - 54.840 I mean, it's just like that was not the vision at all.

01:06 - 59.200 And while there were some higher education administrators

01:06 - 02.376 involved in the very earliest, you know, iterations of

01:07 - 04.920 Allegheny Conference, they were very quickly sidelined

01:07 - 06.920 in terms of the actual people who were getting stuff done.

01:07 - 09.720 And so, these were industrialists who saw

01:07 - 12.120 the different elements of an industrial corporation,

01:07 - 15.760 which needed finance, investment, and real estate, yes.

01:07 - 18.417 But the real bread and butter was expanding in a modernizing industrial facilities.

01:07 - 20.760 But the real bread and butter was expanding in a modernizing industrial facilities.

01:07 - 24.040 And it's only when international competition

01:07 - 26.520 and competition from other regions, you know,

01:07 - 31.840 sort of make it so that Pittsburgh isn't a, again, it's a complicated story.

01:07 - 35.480 But the core of it is that if it had been up to Archie Mellon

01:07 - 38.021 and David Lawrence, you know, steel would still be in major

01:07 - 41.080 industry in Pittsburgh, there's just no doubt about that.

01:07 - 43.961 It's these later iterations of what do we do when that's

01:07 - 47.360 not going to happen, that you see the shift in focus

01:07 - 50.520 to other kinds of industries and other kinds of people.

01:07 - 53.303 Women become increasingly important in Renaissance Institute

01:07 - 56.520 to the vision of economic development in Pittsburgh.

01:07 - 00.120 You know, increasingly this notion that

01:08 - 04.240 you can have a one-earner male breadwinner in the family,

01:08 - 08.080 increasingly as seen as a detriment to Pittsburgh's economic future.

01:08 - 12.334 And so you see this really strong push to for a pink color

01:08 - 19.600 workforce, which again, has its pros and cons in the long-term

01:08 - 23.880 in terms of actual wages getting paid, right?

01:08 - 27.080 So the story is a complicated one.

01:08 - 29.920 I appreciate that question of, you know,

01:08 - 32.800 what are I'll give an example of a higher pile.

01:08 - 35.880 Depopulating Ohio pile was certainly intentional, right?

01:08 - 38.500 But they were also looking at a community who had massive

01:08 - 42.840 population losses already and with a declining urban infrastructure.

01:08 - 45.439 You know, most of the political and economic elites

01:08 - 49.238 of Ohio pile supported the demolition of the

01:08 - 51.520 downtown because they believed in this vision

01:08 - 54.760 of sort of creating a place where people would want to come.

01:08 - 58.160 So that was very much an intentional vision.

01:08 - 00.920 It had local consequences for individual people

01:09 - 03.479 who lost their properties at just like any imminent domain

01:09 - 07.200 does, but certainly for Ohio pile, building Ohio pile as it did today.

01:09 - 10.319 And this did to at least an extensive access story

01:09 - 12.439 that is, it is Ohio pile was the consequence

01:09 - 14.800 of the urban renewal vision of the Renaissance.

01:09 - 16.359 So I want to make sure we have time to move on.

01:09 - 18.920 I'm going to add one last thing quickly and not comment on this.

01:09 - 21.642 I think we also need to be cautious of

01:09 - 24.960 accepting Renaissance thinking as exceptional.

01:09 - 25.961 And of course not.

01:09 - 27.831 Yeah, think about the ways in which people were

01:09 - 30.640 thinking along the lines of sort of best practices.

01:09 - 33.880 Yeah, the implementation, the actual implementation

01:09 - 36.840 was exceptional, but these are best practices idea.

01:09 - 38.800 Again, and that's why I really try hard to link this

01:09 - 40.311 within the broader conservation city beautiful movement.

01:09 - 41.800 within the broader conservation city beautiful movement.

01:09 - 42.479 Yeah.

01:09 - 44.600 Want to make sure we get the time to your question.

01:09 - 45.760 Thanks, Emily.

01:09 - 49.920 So I'm really going to make sure that you set up the panel

01:09 - 52.920 to discuss that is, we're all part of the continuum.

01:09 - 58.720 This is a new Renaissance 2.5, wherever you categorize that.

01:09 - 01.080 So I like to understand the root reaction and body

01:10 - 04.440 is reacting to what you may be witnessing now.

01:10 - 07.040 And that is a new version of resistance

01:10 - 12.560 to change AI data centers to overlay, actually,

01:10 - 15.181 that we want to just pass by a four-to-one referendum by the people of common.

01:10 - 18.200 that we want to just pass by a four-to-one referendum by the people of common.

01:10 - 20.400 It gives everybody the inherent rights

01:10 - 23.360 to clean everything, water, and the historic setting

01:10 - 28.000 to see the value of the environment, which I see how champions are.

01:10 - 31.960 Integrating, incorporating that is a little strong,

01:10 - 36.960 constitutional framework with, if you're saving the environment

01:10 - 40.880 as a whole, and all of its forms, how are that that invested in everybody?

01:10 - 41.920 Because it's similar to it.

01:10 - 43.800 Because it's like all of the ability rights,

01:10 - 46.360 we have a right to all those values of the environment.

01:10 - 50.080 I don't see any champions, public or private, nonprofit.

01:10 - 53.160 Using that powerful movement, except now,

01:10 - 56.600 the river keeper is in Delaware, in Susquehanna Valley,

01:10 - 58.960 or now challenging the validity of local zoning

01:10 - 01.640 where this is going to do not incorporate protections

01:11 - 04.720 from the onslaught of data centers and tiny buildings

01:11 - 08.280 that are going to overwhelm water, air, electricity.

01:11 - 11.280 And people are rising on the courts to challenge that.

01:11 - 12.940 Based on the fact that these local zoning

01:11 - 15.600 ordinances are supposed to provide those protections

01:11 - 18.600 are not stepping up to local three member supervisors

01:11 - 22.120 in some rural county, through a movement, calling it a day center.

01:11 - 24.760 They want to wear all Mars to the center, whatever.

01:11 - 28.200 They're not adhering to the values that counterwealth

01:11 - 30.360 and local governors are supposed to be protecting

01:11 - 33.160 through local zoning planning development ordinances.

01:11 - 37.800 So, anybody else seeing the words of an environmental rights

01:11 - 42.080 amendment, pushback resistance to, what is globalization?

01:11 - 43.795 We haven't seen through the totally local zombie

01:11 - 46.640 market, or world, and we don't really know how to.

01:11 - 51.080 So, reaction, class, possibilities.

01:11 - 54.720 - Yes, I question you in class a couple of weeks ago.

01:11 - 57.240 So, you want to address that since-- - No.

01:11 - 59.480 (laughing)

01:12 - 05.840 - The, I don't have an easy answer for that anymore than anyone else does.

01:12 - 12.320 I don't think Renaissance really did attempt to apply the greatest good

01:12 - 15.800 for the greatest number over the longest time ethos.

01:12 - 16.640 They did.

01:12 - 20.220 I mean, they felt that that's what they were doing.

01:12 - 25.400 The, they, there certainly is a movement, and that's what I wasn't quite,

01:12 - 27.886 I wasn't quite certain what your question was because there certainly is a movement.

01:12 - 30.000 I wasn't quite certain what your question was because there certainly is a movement.

01:12 - 33.200 I think a broad-based one, as you say,

01:12 - 38.200 to use the inherent rights within the environmental rights

01:12 - 41.380 and amendment, now that it has been given some

01:12 - 44.680 teeth in the wake of lawsuits over fracking.

01:12 - 47.960 I mean, that's really what has given it, has given it teeth.

01:12 - 52.760 There certainly is a movement toward using these broad-based rights

01:12 - 57.520 to set new standards outside of the regulatory framework.

01:12 - 59.560 I think it remains to be seen.

01:13 - 06.320 We have, on the one hand, a real push to reduce the bureaucratic regulation

01:13 - 08.815 that has emerged since the environmental revolution of the late '60s and early '70s,

01:13 - 11.280 that has emerged since the environmental revolution of the late '60s and early '70s,

01:13 - 15.840 what you're referring to and the impulse that you have

01:13 - 19.440 would actually be to increase certain kinds of regulatory hurdles.

01:13 - 22.640 So we're seeing, I think, a continued populist,

01:13 - 26.560 a continued populist backlash against regulation

01:13 - 29.094 at the same time as we see a populist

01:13 - 32.200 backlash against certain kinds of development

01:13 - 35.080 that would be prohibited by other, by regulation.

01:13 - 37.520 I'm not exactly sure where it's going to end up.

01:13 - 40.480 That's, I mean, that's where we are in our politics now.

01:13 - 42.480 - I think we have time for one more question.

01:13 - 44.760 Zach.

01:13 - 47.449 - Yeah, a kind of argument of that, in the back where you were at the beginning.

01:13 - 50.040 - Yeah, a kind of argument of that, in the back where you were at the beginning.

01:13 - 53.440 If we're not living through a period of renaissance

01:13 - 56.640 because I agree with what you guys have said, that's a specific period of time,

01:13 - 01.200 and they do have to have that government fund as a part of that in terms of aspects.

01:14 - 03.890 It does seem like we're living through

01:14 - 06.160 another period of transformation in Pittsburgh

01:14 - 09.100 since we're having to reinvent itself again.

01:14 - 12.260 Thinking back to where the draft, Pittsburgh, was trying to tell a story.

01:14 - 14.800 Thinking back to where the draft, Pittsburgh, was trying to tell a story.

01:14 - 16.520 - Always comes back to sports in Pittsburgh, doesn't it?

01:14 - 17.360 - Yeah, really.

01:14 - 18.200 (laughing)

01:14 - 20.026 But it's trying to tell a story to the nation,

01:14 - 23.120 and to the world of what it's trying to become.

01:14 - 25.025 And I guess what I would like to hear your

01:14 - 28.200 reactions of you, what is this in trying to become?

01:14 - 31.760 Because it does feel like, I mean, especially for the mayor coming down,

01:14 - 33.960 saying the city's going to be broken by here

01:14 - 36.813 so we don't make some changes that Pittsburgh

01:14 - 39.120 is undergoing another transformation

01:14 - 41.640 of just curious what your guys' reactions are to them.

01:14 - 43.280 - I will say it this way.

01:14 - 46.240 For me, Pittsburgh is one of Pittsburgh

01:14 - 48.440 is a great stand-in for the nation as a whole.

01:14 - 49.840 It really is.

01:14 - 52.040 It has producers and consumers.

01:14 - 56.480 It has a wide range of ethnic demographic background.

01:14 - 58.467 The same issues that are affecting Pittsburgh

01:14 - 00.080 are affecting the nation as a whole.

01:15 - 03.000 I don't think that you can separate them out.

01:15 - 06.040 And as a case study, then the tensions within Pittsburgh,

01:15 - 08.920 I think are very useful for us understanding the tensions of the nation.

01:15 - 11.080 So yeah, I would agree with that.

01:15 - 12.440 And I think we also,

01:15 - 16.340 maybe a cautionary tale for those of us who are

01:15 - 19.600 Pittsburgh historians to invest too much in Renaissance.

01:15 - 21.120 In the sense that cities are always trying to tell and retell their stories.

01:15 - 22.760 In the sense that cities are always trying to tell and retell their stories.

01:15 - 29.520 And that's something that happened before Richard King Mellon arrived on the scene,

01:15 - 32.207 something that's put sort of endemic to Pittsburgh as it's cast

01:15 - 35.840 itself as a vision of what an American city should look like.

01:15 - 37.680 And it's something I think will continue.

01:15 - 40.360 What always is interesting to me about Pittsburgh

01:15 - 44.200 as Pittsburgh always seems to punch above its weight class in a number of ways.

01:15 - 46.200 We really look at Pittsburgh's size.

01:15 - 49.400 We often forget that Pittsburgh is really only a city

01:15 - 52.600 of three hundred and five thousand people who are right around there.

01:15 - 54.680 But yet it's a city that we go back to sports, right?

01:15 - 56.360 It has three major sports teams.

01:15 - 58.920 It's a city that seems to have a sort of national

01:15 - 01.960 understanding of what this Pittsburgh story is.

01:16 - 04.360 Or at least what this Renaissance story is.

01:16 - 07.560 You know, going back to watching football

01:16 - 10.920 when the sort of NFL recap of Pittsburgh it is, right?

01:16 - 14.040 It's very much the sort of Renaissance post-industrial story.

01:16 - 17.480 I think Pittsburgh will continue to try to redefine itself

01:16 - 19.320 and to Alan's point, I think that Pittsburgh

01:16 - 23.760 is a really important story, not just of the industrial era

01:16 - 27.640 but also the post-industrial era and hits on many of these kind of key themes.

01:16 - 30.760 But there is that sort of tendency among cities

01:16 - 33.340 and civic elites and also people who live in cities

01:16 - 38.040 to want to tell their story in a particular way.

01:16 - 40.332 And I think that there is a tension between sort of the

01:16 - 42.840 official narrative, the kind of quasi-unofficial narrative,

01:16 - 45.880 the popular narrative and the narrative that, you know,

01:16 - 49.080 I've been in Pittsburgh almost 20 years I guess I can call myself a Yensner now.

01:16 - 52.540 The story, the story that the Yensner's want to tell about their city.

01:16 - 58.920 - Well, and I did grow and still live in the city

01:16 - 02.520 so maybe I've met lifelong Yensner, I don't know.

01:17 - 07.520 But I think we talked about the story of resistance

01:17 - 11.680 in Pittsburgh and I think that's one story but it's also one of resilience

01:17 - 14.680 and I think you look at those who are still are there.

01:17 - 16.720 And I think about like East Allegheny for instance

01:17 - 19.760 that was ripped us under and even Manchester, you know?

01:17 - 24.080 They're still there, they're bouncing back, they're trying to recreate something.

01:17 - 28.680 I think we're at an inflection point though in the city,

01:17 - 32.280 not only demographically, but I think politically,

01:17 - 36.520 I think one big issue that I think permeates

01:17 - 40.760 throughout politics is the big money that gets involved.

01:17 - 44.435 But I think as long as people have a say in how they shape their own communities,

01:17 - 48.440 But I think as long as people have a say in how they shape their own communities,

01:17 - 52.600 then I think we have a chance to really bounce back.

01:17 - 55.800 But what I see is the opposite.

01:17 - 58.200 I see a lot of people losing control of this

01:17 - 01.200 and I see a private equity starting to take over neighborhoods.

01:18 - 03.823 I see these big billionaire developers coming

01:18 - 06.560 in and trying to create this quote, one day,

01:18 - 13.200 the first day attraction and so to speak.

01:18 - 14.760 Look at what happened in Philly, right?

01:18 - 21.120 The 70s sectors were going to move and create a new stadium or arena in Chinatown

01:18 - 26.120 and people pushed back and so it wasn't built.

01:18 - 27.920 And this was just recently.

01:18 - 30.560 But in other cities, you do see this happening

01:18 - 34.600 and I think to the extent that we can empower people

01:18 - 38.320 to have a say and to really build upon this resilience,

01:18 - 41.920 I don't know if we need a branding effort anymore.

01:18 - 44.720 I think people are creating their own stories

01:18 - 48.600 as they go around and people will figure it out.

01:18 - 52.600 I don't know if we need a slogan necessarily.

01:18 - 56.760 And by the way, our minor league soccer team

01:18 - 58.880 did win the national championship last year.

01:18 - 59.800 So just saying.

01:18 - 02.800 (audience applauds)

01:19 - 07.120 Just to make a very brief, I'm very new to Pittsburgh.

01:19 - 10.400 I've lived in Pennsylvania for just over a year now.

01:19 - 12.948 So obviously I have a very different perspective

01:19 - 18.280 on everything but I came here just for grad school.

01:19 - 21.280 I got accepted in a little bit of a assistantship help.

01:19 - 22.680 So I kind of pulled me in.

01:19 - 27.122 And something that I love and value about

01:19 - 29.200 Pittsburgh is something we talk about communities.

01:19 - 30.560 We have all these neighborhoods

01:19 - 35.680 that have the strong identity and sense of who they are, what they are.

01:19 - 37.892 And I think that building upon that,

01:19 - 40.680 building onto community power and development

01:19 - 44.192 and having a livable city, place where I

01:19 - 48.080 can walk to somewhere and buy some groceries

01:19 - 50.640 or get what I need, a place where I can take public transit

01:19 - 53.440 and know that I'm able to get from point A to point B.

01:19 - 57.720 These are things that I think a lot of younger people really value and want.

01:19 - 00.791 And I think that just from that perspective as an

01:20 - 04.000 outsider who's come in, I've really fallen for the city.

01:20 - 07.120 I quite enjoy it in the state and everything as well.

01:20 - 11.800 So I only know the Pittsburgh of today personally

01:20 - 15.348 but I think that it's heading in a overall positive

01:20 - 18.000 direction I think that it can continue to do so.

01:20 - 19.400 - Great, excellent, we are over time.

01:20 - 22.560 But I wanna ask you, I wanna thank you all for being here.

01:20 - 25.040 Please join us for launch, but also please join us for the Student

01:20 - 27.640 Research section later today and see some of the great work

01:20 - 29.114 that students throughout the Commonwealth are doing in Pennsylvania history.

01:20 - 30.680 that students throughout the Commonwealth are doing in Pennsylvania history.

01:20 - 32.280 Thank you all and thank you for your patience.

01:20 - 33.120 Great question.

01:20 - 36.081 (audience applauding) - Thank you.

01:20 - 39.820 (upbeat music)

01:20 - 49.380 (upbeat music)


Related Video
Lehigh River PA Rivers

Lehigh River, PA Rivers

Pennsylvanias Revolutionary Public Memory Museums and America250PA 101125

Pennsylvania's Revolutionary Public Memory: Museums and America250PA 10/11/25

The Art of Violet Oakley History  Culture

The Art of Violet Oakley, History & Culture