[10.24.26] PA Historical Association program on politics and political economy, 1960-2000 in Northampton Community College in Bethlehem.
00:01 - (upbeat music)
00:09 - So this is the session, Politics and Political Economy in 1960 to 2000.
00:14 - I'm Tristan Milazzo, and my current title is
00:16 - Community Engagement Coordinator at Numbers First.
00:19 - Probably the formal relevant piece is that I was a Shippensburg University grad.
00:24 - My concentration there was local and community history.
00:26 - So a few papers here.
00:28 - I very much tuned into, and even more so.
00:31 - So my current role, I do sponsorships,
00:33 - volunteer opportunities and business developments events at Numbers First.
00:37 - So there's a few pieces of these papers that I was very much interested in.
00:41 - And I think you're going to see today, we're gonna go in order of the program,
00:45 - which I think will be very helpful because if you read them in that order as I did,
00:49 - you're going to get very much a national look at Pennsylvania in the field.
00:54 - We're gonna constrict down to Pennsylvania overall
00:56 - and then do a hyper local, what I would call,
00:58 - third space, local community aspects of this.
01:01 - So I think you're gonna see that very nicely today.
01:03 - It'll be a great way to end the day for us.
01:06 - So I'm going to introduce all three panelists first and I'll let them kick it off.
01:10 - And I always think for grad students Q&A is always more helpful.
01:13 - So I will not do any more comments at the end
01:15 - once they're done, we'll roll into any questions
01:17 - to get them extra content that they might
01:20 - need for papers if they're going back into it.
01:22 - So first on our docket today will be Tom Bloss, Tom
01:26 - received his undergrad degree from Mercyhurst University.
01:29 - He holds a master of science degree and strategic intelligence
01:32 - from the National Intelligence University and a master of science.
01:35 - Degree in adult learning and leadership from Kansas State University.
01:38 - Tom retired from the U.S. Army.
01:40 - After his uniform service, Tom served
01:42 - as the Department of the Army Civilian Instructor of organizational leadership
01:46 - at the Army Management College at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas.
01:50 - Today's Tom is a graduate student of applied history at Shipensburg University.
01:54 - Then we have Kayleigh Becker, George, who just came in with a promotion.
01:58 - So we had to update her bio on the spot.
02:00 - Kayleigh Becker, George the Shipensburg University student,
02:03 - getting her master's degree in applied history with plans to graduate in December.
02:07 - She discovered her love of public history
02:09 - and local history while getting her bachelor's degree in history and anthropology
02:12 - at Indiana University of Pennsylvania and has made working in museums her life goal.
02:16 - She currently works as the graduate assistant for the
02:18 - Fashion Archives and Museum of Shipensburg University
02:21 - and has just been promoted to lead service, lead visitor services
02:26 - assistant at the Seminary Ridge Museum in Gettysburg.
02:29 - Hot off the presses.
02:31 - And then finally, Carlin Deal is a current Shipensburg
02:34 - grad student and went to Shipensburg University
02:37 - for undergrad in history with a minor in anthropology.
02:40 - She spent a semester abroad last year in South Korea where she was a student teacher.
02:44 - She volunteered and interned with her local historical
02:46 - society, the Cumberland County Historical Society
02:49 - where she worked in the education department.
02:51 - She worked at the same theater since she was
02:53 - 17 and still works there as a manager today.
02:55 - Her local independent theater in place of work,
02:57 - served as an inspiration for her research that you'll hear about today
03:00 - and her passion for film and exhibition history.
03:03 - She plans on teaching full time in the future
03:05 - and would like to continue doing research in the film exhibition.
03:09 - So Tom, if you want to come on up,
03:11 - I think we're ready to go.
03:12 - We'll see if everything's working.
03:15 - - Well, thank you for attending the panel today.
03:17 - Certainly, certainly appreciate it and allowing us to share our research with you.
03:23 - The title of my paper is Revealing Pennsylvania's
03:27 - Role in the 1960 Democratic National Convention.
03:30 - Now why this convention is particularly significant
03:33 - is that it identifies two future presidents in the same
03:38 - nomination process that will serve in a four-year period.
03:42 - And those presidents are John F.
03:44 - Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson.
03:48 - So it's pretty significant convention in itself.
03:51 - And my paper argues that the Pennsylvania delegation
03:54 - played a significant role in that convention.
03:57 - Not only for JFK's nomination, but Lyndon Johnson's as well.
04:02 - And that's not typically known,
04:04 - the role that Pennsylvania played with Johnson nomination.
04:09 - Am I interested in this topic stems from, I was reading a biography of Johnson.
04:13 - And in that it says just the weekend before the convention,
04:20 - Johnson says everything depends on Pennsylvania.
04:23 - Why?
04:24 - - I gave a little explanation.
04:27 - Pennsylvania was uncommitted, so forth.
04:30 - But it didn't explain why.
04:32 - So I wanted to research why that was.
04:33 - So really the question was, what role did the Pennsylvania
04:36 - delegation play in the 1960 historic, 1960 convention?
04:41 - So I really focused on a very narrow topic with broad-based implications.
04:47 - And to do that, I looked at the archives of the University of Pittsburgh
04:54 - and to look over some interviews that were done previously with the people involved.
04:59 - And the JFK Online Library, I also looked at
05:03 - the oral histories there, which is immense.
05:06 - I mean, they've really done a great job for researchers to put that online.
05:09 - And then the Lyndon Baines Johnson Library as well, not quite as robust, but useful.
05:16 - So that was all the answer to the research question.
05:19 - Newspapers, of course, were used as well for this research.
05:23 - And what I'll do is I'll provide a little background information
05:26 - so you understand what I'm coming from, talk about the
05:28 - pre-convention, the convention real quick and conclusion.
05:33 - I talk a lot about the delegation, but I think you'll pick this up.
05:36 - I'm talking about Lawrence, Governor Lawrence, and I have the delegation at the time.
05:41 - But the delegation itself, it's both was critical as you'll find out.
05:50 - Great.
05:53 - So the background information itself,
05:56 - at the convention, there are three major candidates that are announced.
06:00 - You've got Johnson Kennedy and Stuart Simington, Missouri Senator.
06:05 - And then there's a wild card out there, at least Stevenson, he doesn't announce.
06:09 - But he's willing to accept a nomination.
06:11 - He was the party's nominee in 52 and 56.
06:14 - He's willing to accept a nomination if offered.
06:17 - If offered.
06:18 - So he's kind of a wild card out there.
06:20 - If he enters a race, it kind of changes things.
06:23 - Now the real key here is that 761 votes.
06:26 - That's what it takes to win the nomination.
06:30 - And why that's important is, Kennedy realizes he's got to get it on the first ballot.
06:34 - If it goes to the back rooms, you know, smoke filled back rooms
06:37 - in a party leadership.
06:39 - And the second, third, so forth.
06:40 - Battle or a conference ballot.
06:44 - Then compromise candidate happens.
06:49 - So Kennedy realizes he's not,
06:51 - his chances are slim if it goes beyond the first ballot.
06:53 - He's got to hit that 761.
06:57 - Pennsylvania has 81 delegates.
07:00 - Conquable to California, which also has 81 delegates.
07:03 - New York has 114.
07:05 - So and they're the largest.
07:07 - Pennsylvania being uncommitted and a delegation its size
07:12 - gets a lot of attention.
07:14 - Gets a lot of attention from the press, the public and certainly the candidates.
07:20 - Governor Lawrence.
07:24 - At the time of the convention,
07:26 - he's at the very top of the Democratic part.
07:29 - He is brave at the Pentagon.
07:30 - Matter of fact, when they have their meetings,
07:32 - he's the chairman and he's the spokesperson for the group.
07:36 - Story and career begins his political career at,
07:38 - you know, 14 working working for another politician.
07:42 - But, you know, he's held key roles at the county
07:46 - level, at the state level, national level.
07:49 - He was secretary of the commonwealth during the Earl administration.
07:53 - So basically ran the state at that time.
07:55 - Sorry.
07:56 - If you're well.
07:58 - All right.
07:59 - And he was also four-term mayor of Pittsburgh.
08:02 - And that's where he gets his fame from.
08:05 - And then, of course, Governor of Pennsylvania.
08:08 - So very influential at the convention itself.
08:11 - I bring up the religion issue,
08:12 - because it really shamed, it formed his thought
08:16 - process before the convention, Lawrence's.
08:18 - He runs for governor.
08:20 - He thinks he's going to win by a landslide.
08:22 - Right.
08:23 - He's got a national name recognition from being mayor
08:28 - and the Renaissance, Pittsburgh Renaissance.
08:30 - And he runs against a political unknown, Arthur T.
08:32 - McGonagall, never run for public office before.
08:36 - He should win by a landslide.
08:37 - He barely beats him.
08:39 - And it gets him thinking, it's because I'm going to get,
08:44 - you know, it's Catholic, that's what hurt me in the Pennsylvania election.
08:48 - He's thinking Kennedy cannot possibly win at the national level.
08:51 - So that's kind of shaping his thought process going in.
08:54 - He's a powerful individual at this time.
08:59 - The pre-convention, Pennsylvania, again, is uncommitted.
09:03 - The press are calling them king-makers and all eyes
09:07 - are on Lawrence and the delegate Pennsylvania delegation.
09:10 - So there are significant players in this
09:13 - by virtue of what the press reports are.
09:16 - The primaries at this time mean very little.
09:19 - There's only 16 of them.
09:21 - Matter of fact, Johnson and Simonton don't even bother.
09:26 - You know, because they figure, if it goes into a second ballot,
09:29 - it goes to the back rooms, party leadership will determine
09:32 - who the nominee is going to be.
09:34 - Matter of fact, they're banking on it.
09:35 - They know that if Kennedy wins on the first ballot, you know, it's over.
09:38 - So they've got to, as long as anybody, they don't care who the delegate's vote for.
09:43 - As long as it's not Kennedy, right?
09:47 - So Kennedy doesn't enter the Pennsylvania
09:50 - primary, but he gets 183,000 right in votes.
09:54 - That gets Lawrence's attention, 183 right in votes.
09:58 - It's his attention.
09:59 - West Virginia primary rolls around.
10:01 - A state with over 95% Protestant, you know, population.
10:06 - If Kennedy can win there, he can demonstrate.
10:09 - He's running, I guess you were hungry, he drops out after
10:11 - that primary, but he's running against a Protestant.
10:13 - If he can show that he can win in that state, he can
10:16 - win nationally, that's what his thought process is.
10:19 - And he's right.
10:20 - He wins by a significant margin.
10:22 - That really gets Governor Lawrence's attention.
10:24 - He's in Europe at the time on a vacation,
10:27 - and he's with the gentleman that you see on the slide here,
10:30 - Matthew McCluskey, who is the Democratic National Committee
10:34 - treasurer, wealthy businessman for Philadelphia, and he's with Lawrence.
10:39 - And he says Lawrence at that time told him
10:42 - that he would give his right arm to see Kennedy as president.
10:46 - So now his thought process has certainly changed.
10:49 - That's not widely known in history out there,
10:52 - but he, you know, that's from McCluskey himself in the interview.
10:58 - So I'm thinking at this point, again, not in literature, and what I reviewed,
11:03 - I think at this point that Lawrence did, that he had made up his
11:07 - mind by that point, but his own son claims that he didn't know,
11:13 - where his dad was, how his dad was gonna vote
11:15 - at the convention until they were at the arrive.
11:18 - But I believe he had made up his mind.
11:20 - The reason is Lawrence and Los Angeles,
11:23 - when he gets there, a senior Kennedy advisor meets up with him, and he says,
11:28 - I would like to speak to Senator Kennedy when he arrives.
11:31 - And when Kennedy arrives on Saturday just before the convention,
11:36 - so because he wants to speak to Kennedy, obviously he's got something in mind.
11:40 - He wants to tell him something.
11:42 - So when Kennedy arrives at very first meeting, he has his with Lawrence.
11:48 - He basically goes directly from the plane to talk with Governor Lawrence.
11:52 - At that meeting, Governor Lawrence says,
11:55 - you're going to get the majority of the Pennsylvania delegates.
11:59 - You've got my backing, senior party leadership,
12:02 - thinks that you should ask Johnson to be a running mate.
12:08 - And Kennedy says, I've done the math, and I agree with you,
12:11 - but I don't think he would accept a second spot on the ticket.
12:16 - Lawrence assures him that he will.
12:18 - Now this is where McCloskey shares another interesting story.
12:22 - He said that basically that this, when they were, they had met Johnson,
12:32 - they actually talked to Johnson and beforehand.
12:35 - Nobody, this isn't in the history book, but they had met
12:38 - with Johnson and asked him if he would accept the VP role.
12:41 - They had a larger conversation than that.
12:43 - But asking if you'd accept the VP role.
12:44 - And Johnson said, I'm a Democrat, a good Democrat.
12:47 - I'll do what my party asked me to do.
12:49 - So McCloskey and Lawrence, I'll get each other like to be here.
12:51 - You know, we hear what he thought we heard.
12:54 - And McCloskey says that Lawrence shared that information with him at that meeting.
13:05 - So at the convention itself, the first day, the Pennsylvania delegation meets.
13:10 - And Lawrence, it's the first time
13:11 - that Lawrence tells his delegation that who he's going to back.
13:16 - And they vote.
13:19 - He gets, our Pennsylvania gives Kennedy 64 delegate votes.
13:24 - Lawrence announces that, the press is like it's over.
13:27 - We know where Pennsylvania is going, the John, our Kennedy will get the nomination.
13:31 - And he does.
13:32 - On Wednesday, when they hold the official vote, he gets eight hundred and six votes.
13:38 - That's important, that's significant.
13:39 - Because it's only 45 votes over the 761 required.
13:44 - Had Pennsylvania, so that answers part of my research question.
13:47 - Had Pennsylvania not gone with Kennedy,
13:52 - then he wouldn't have got just by virtue of the Pennsylvania delegate vote,
13:56 - he would not have got it on the first ballot.
13:58 - And it could turn out completely different.
14:01 - But where I think the research really
14:05 - that I was conducting kind of shed something new.
14:08 - And this isn't widely known or in the history books out there.
14:11 - But the morning after Kennedy's nominated, he contacts Lawrence.
14:17 - And this is in Lawrence's interview at the JFK Library.
14:22 - He contacts Lawrence and says, "I need to speak with you.
14:25 - " And okay, what do you want to talk about?
14:26 - No, I need to speak with you.
14:27 - Please come down and head quarters.
14:30 - He goes down, there's some senior leaders
14:32 - milling about, they go into a private room, the bathroom.
14:36 - There's only private room to add.
14:38 - And Kennedy just wants reassurance that Johnson will accept.
14:41 - He says, "I'm going to go talk to him.
14:43 - " And I just wanted, he'd want to reassurance
14:45 - that he would accept as a party leadership was on board.
14:48 - And he assured him that was the case.
14:53 - And so I can't go into the whole story.
14:56 - But there's a lot of confusion after that.
14:59 - And from the time that Johnson was asked
15:02 - and throughout the day, there was a lot of confusion.
15:04 - But later that afternoon, Kennedy announces it.
15:07 - He's going to be his vice presidential nominee
15:10 - and that Governor Lawrence would deliver
15:13 - the address, the nomination speech, what you see here.
15:17 - Now, so that's a pretty, he was selected for a reason.
15:21 - Now, I think even a larger clue really is,
15:26 - his personal assistant for many years, Walter Geezy,
15:29 - said just before, Lawrence went up to deliver the speech
15:33 - that you see here, that Johnson pulled him off to the side
15:36 - and said, "Dave," and this is a direct quote,
15:39 - "Dave, I'll never forget to my dying day "what you've done for me.
15:43 - " So that's pretty significant as far as the role.
15:46 - I mean, Johnson himself is acknowledging that Lawrence played a role in that.
15:51 - But I had to also find out whether Walter Geezy
15:55 - was just building up his boss, what's this, hero worship kind of thing.
15:59 - And I did do quite a better research on Geezy
16:02 - himself and I can say for absolute certainty,
16:05 - this is not an individual that would make up the story.
16:08 - He's very, you know, very straightforward
16:10 - and that's probably why he worked for Lawrence for so long.
16:12 - I would give that quote a high degree of credibility.
16:15 - Again, another clue that Johnson,
16:18 - or that Lawrence played a role in Johnson's nomination as well.
16:21 - And this is kind of a side, but it's still not same thought processes.
16:27 - Lady Bird Johnson years later in an interview and I'm paraphrasing a bit here.
16:33 - She states that Governor Lawrence nominated him was a pleasant thing for Lyndon,
16:37 - because Lawrence of Pennsylvania was one of the old time Democratic politician,
16:41 - sturdy, respected, high class, fine man and Lyndon's book.
16:45 - So for future historians, I would really,
16:50 - I would suggest that they look into Lawrence,
16:52 - Governor Lawrence and the role that he played in this as well.
16:56 - It's not part of the story in your typical accounts
17:00 - of how, and Johnson's nomination is still debated today.
17:08 - Again, Pennsylvania and the power broker role.
17:10 - What I would just mention is, right after the first caucus on Monday,
17:15 - the Washington Post reports, there have been other
17:18 - pro-cannity breaks, but this was the big one, the clincher.
17:21 - And in their total roll up of the convention itself, he, the Post writes,
17:28 - "It was Lawrence, of course, who publicly nailed it down
17:30 - "for Kennedy when he announced Monday morning
17:32 - "that Pennsylvania would go for the senator.
17:35 - " I've already mentioned how he was, his involvement in Johnson's nomination,
17:39 - not what I do known, and my recommendation, future historians consider Lawrence
17:45 - when they're debating the whole nomination process for Johnson.
17:49 - And does it add to Pennsylvania's historical legacy?
17:54 - Perhaps I'm a little by the amount of research
17:57 - that I've done, but I can confirm Pennsylvania did play
18:00 - an absolute sense for a role in that convention.
18:03 - And as you can see with the pictures here, it was a consequential convention.
18:08 - So that adds to Pennsylvania's historical legacy.
18:12 - And with that, I will stop talking.
18:15 - (audience applauding)
18:18 - Thank you, thank you.
18:21 - - All right, hello everyone.
18:23 - Thank you so much for coming out.
18:24 - I am excited today to present my ongoing research
18:27 - on the history of the Pennsylvania Historical Museum Commission.
18:31 - This specific topic is focused in on the 1980s,
18:34 - and specifically this start of viewing history
18:37 - as an enterprise, or reevaluating the stance on it to be more of a business.
18:44 - So I do have a confession, if y'all will allow me a confession.
18:47 - This project actually started out of frustration,
18:51 - trying to break into the museum field, not being able to find a job,
18:55 - just trying to understand where, what circumstances it brought me to this point,
19:00 - led me into looking at the institutional history
19:03 - of the PHMC, Pennsylvania's prime historical organization.
19:07 - And it then spiraled into this larger understanding
19:10 - of what we do as historians, and importantly, who backs us and what we do,
19:14 - and why that is so important to the stories we are trying to tell.
19:18 - So, are gonna be, I forgot to set a timer on
19:21 - myself, so I don't ramble for a while, okay.
19:25 - So, when I was starting this project,
19:28 - I actually wanted to cover pretty much the
19:31 - entirety of from like the '60s to the modern day.
19:34 - Eventually, I was taught to down.
19:36 - So what I'm specifically looking at for this case
19:39 - is how did the federal and state government's
19:41 - economic situation affect the PHMC in the 1980s?
19:45 - And as a consequence, how did the PHMC implement new policies and procedures,
19:49 - and an attempt to mitigate some of those adverse effects?
19:52 - And what changes did the institution undergo that can still potentially impact us
19:57 - to this modern day doing history in Pennsylvania?
20:01 - So, the previous scholarship was a little difficult to track down.
20:05 - Of course, I got a broad overview of museums in general
20:07 - from Johnny Simmons and his work Museums of History.
20:11 - But I also was able to uncover the Pennsylvania Historical
20:15 - Museum Commission of History by Roy Nichols.
20:17 - The only problem is that work only goes up to the mid-1960s.
20:21 - So pretty much my entire span that I need to cover
20:24 - was untouched in there, but it was really important
20:26 - for providing me context on the origins of the organization.
20:30 - I was also able to find a couple of wonderful massive
20:32 - CCs that addressed both the site data session
20:36 - by the PHMC and also just generally the effects of neoliberalism on museums.
20:43 - So neoliberalism is kind of one of the hot topic words of this.
20:46 - I've been trying to use it a little less
20:47 - 'cause it's more of a modern term for this idea
20:50 - of interest in free market and privatization.
20:55 - And we're starting to see a lot of that, especially in the 1970s as it's on the rise
21:00 - with some economic crises in the United States.
21:02 - And because of the implementation of it by President Ronald Reagan in the 1980s,
21:09 - so we're starting to see a big shift towards that.
21:11 - So that was an entire separate part of my research
21:13 - that eventually I had to weave into this larger narrative on the PHMC.
21:19 - For primary sources, I used a lot of the Pennsylvania Heritage Magazine.
21:22 - It's online, it's free, it's easy to access.
21:25 - So that gave me a good perspective
21:26 - on the internal opinions of the PHMC as all this was going down.
21:30 - But there was another really important document to this.
21:33 - The enterprise of history in Pennsylvania, the '80s was a document from the PHMC
21:39 - that was an internal review of all these changes they had made.
21:42 - The entire purpose of this nearly, more than 200 page document
21:47 - that covered individualized reports on 157 different areas
21:50 - of operation in the PHMC was to evaluate these changes they had made for the '80s.
21:55 - However, in these PA state archives, there's only an incomplete copy of this.
22:00 - And I actually cannot find a published version.
22:03 - It was announced in the Heritage Magazine
22:06 - something that would eventually other people would
22:08 - be able to see that was the implication of it,
22:10 - but I was actually never able to find it published.
22:12 - So I'm a little interested to see what happened to it at some point.
22:15 - So that also helped me bridge the gap in the history
22:19 - of the institution because executive director, Dr.
22:22 - Larry Ties, he actually did an introduction that included the history
22:25 - of the PHMC during some of those missing years for me.
22:28 - And then of course I used the Pennsylvania Governor Executive Budgets and newspapers.
22:32 - So to get a little bit into the history of the PHMC,
22:35 - it was actually started technically as the Pennsylvania
22:38 - Historical Commission, which was founded in 1913.
22:42 - One of the big duties of this organization
22:45 - was the preservation of Pennsylvania history.
22:46 - And also it maintained the historic marker program,
22:50 - which makes that pretty much the oldest
22:51 - program that the PHMC currently still oversees.
22:55 - So Nichols actually describes this time
22:57 - as a time of small beginnings and little support
23:00 - because they were having trouble isolating or locking
23:04 - down consistent revenue sources for the organization.
23:08 - A lot of it was reliant on whatever governor was in office
23:10 - and there was a lot of politicking and having to generate private funds,
23:14 - which they did have the right to do even from the beginning.
23:17 - However, in the 1930s, we start to see this shift,
23:20 - thanks to the new deal and all these other legislative acts
23:24 - that are trying to simulate the United States economy.
23:27 - And as a result, the PHMC is gonna, or the PHC at the time,
23:31 - is also gonna be acquiring a public funding.
23:33 - And the interesting thing, the important thing about public funding
23:36 - is that it implies that you need to be doing
23:38 - public programming and appealing to the public if you're
23:40 - using their money, you have to be appealing to them.
23:43 - And that is an interesting thing, especially in the history of museums as a whole,
23:46 - which used to be primarily private institutions,
23:49 - people's personal collections, collecting for fun,
23:52 - and now we're starting to see this evolution,
23:55 - you further evolution into this public service role.
23:58 - So in 1945, this is really exemplified
24:01 - when the PHC is dismantled and then it is reworked
24:04 - into the PHMC, which will also include the state archives
24:08 - in the state museum, which had already been around,
24:10 - but now they are officially under the PHMC's responsibilities.
24:14 - So this is actually part of a larger bill
24:17 - that had been proposed for the PHMC/PHE2 maintain
24:25 - the documents from World War II.
24:27 - So it was actually kind of pushed into that bill
24:28 - a little bit, that's where the PHMC comes from,
24:31 - is 'cause they are facing increasing responsibilities due to World War II.
24:35 - And this general fervor for history in the United States post-World War II.
24:39 - We're starting to see a really high period of
24:41 - that in terms of interest, a lot of museums,
24:44 - other historical institutions are gonna be founded
24:46 - during this time over the next few decades.
24:49 - So as a result of this, we're seeing a massive period
24:52 - of growth for the PHMC between the 1950s and the 1960s.
24:57 - And there is just this general excitement about history,
25:00 - everyone is preparing for the buy centennial in the '70s.
25:03 - And the PHMC is going to acquire a lot of properties
25:06 - during this time, especially a lot of properties, a lot of artifacts.
25:09 - And then the US economy crashes.
25:12 - We hit the 1970s and the OPEC oil crisis hits the 1973
25:19 - recession starts and the previous economic systems
25:24 - of the United States in bed of liberalism, the Canadian policies, all of that combined
25:29 - into a perfect storm and the United States is gonna be faced with a budget crisis,
25:33 - which is gonna put the Pennsylvania state budget into a crisis.
25:37 - And that's gonna put the PHMC into a crisis.
25:40 - It all connects.
25:42 - So as we're starting to set the stage here,
25:45 - we actually see that to the Pennsylvania Historical Museum
25:49 - Commission is going to have their funding cut a little bit,
25:54 - especially in the late '70s there, as we are building up into the 1980s
25:58 - and executive director William Moore and one of his executive director reports
26:03 - in the Heritage Magazine is actually gonna mention
26:05 - that they have too many sites and too many
26:07 - responsibilities and not enough people to manage all of it.
26:10 - So this is gonna lead to a 1980 review by the governor's budget office
26:15 - that is actually not going to paint the PHMC in a terribly great light.
26:18 - It is going to compare it to Fiverr Mickey's
26:21 - closet, which is an old reference where, you know,
26:23 - the guy opens the closet, stuff comes tumbling
26:25 - out 'cause he's just so terribly unorganized.
26:27 - And it's going to say that they have a lack
26:31 - of organization in that they cannot properly manage the funds they have at the time.
26:35 - And there will also be a later report from Dr.
26:38 - Larry Ties about how that was, I mean, pretty true they had,
26:42 - they had a large but unmanaged collections as he would say.
26:45 - So the executive director where he was going to
26:48 - offer to resign, but he's actually gonna stay on
26:50 - for another year until the PHMC is deciding to look further
26:54 - and try to find someone who will privatize the organization
26:58 - and that is the exact word they're gonna use when they're talking about this.
27:02 - And he is going to come on board and that is why
27:03 - we're going to start seeing some of the big changes.
27:06 - Before we get into the changes themselves though,
27:08 - I do want to just show my fancy little graph I made of the budgets of the PHMC.
27:13 - Specifically, it's state allocation.
27:15 - This is the state allocation line on the Pennsylvania governor budgets.
27:19 - And so the bottom line there, that is the non-adjusted version of the budget.
27:24 - That shows that there was actually,
27:26 - it appears a steady increase over the years.
27:29 - With the exception, if you see that big spike there in '75,
27:33 - that was just because the Pennsylvania State government
27:35 - did a 15 month budget that there was nothing really special
27:38 - about that year than the fact that it was a special budget.
27:40 - So that's why it's so abnormally out of place.
27:44 - So when I originally looked at this,
27:45 - I was like, oh, so their budget was increasing every year.
27:47 - And then I remembered that we are in a time of extreme inflation.
27:51 - So I actually took all of the budgets and I adjusted them
27:54 - for inflation and that is what that top line there is.
27:57 - And that line shows that any increases they were seeing
28:01 - was mostly just keeping pace with the economy.
28:04 - And in some cases, not even entirely,
28:06 - you can actually see, especially in this time period
28:10 - right here, these late '70s moving into the '80s,
28:13 - they're actually facing an almost quiet cut where they are not receiving the increase
28:18 - they would need to actually genuinely keep pace
28:21 - with inflation, which is putting them in a situation
28:23 - where they have all this stuff to manage and not enough money to do it.
28:27 - So this right here is kind of what we're looking at as we are
28:31 - moving into the '80s and the need for these changes to happen.
28:36 - So first and foremost, we get into the policy and staffing changes.
28:40 - Leading up to all of this, the PHMC had went from roughly
28:43 - 500 to 300 employees, nearly half of their workforce got cut.
28:47 - The Pennsylvania Historical Marker Program, like I mentioned earlier, oldest program,
28:50 - it had one historian running it and it had one part-time maintenance worker,
28:54 - which was not enough for the thousands of markers, especially 'cause trust me,
28:57 - they put up a lot of markers after World War II.
28:59 - It was during that fervor, there were so many
29:01 - markers they were unable to manage them all.
29:03 - So they had to find some way to make up for
29:06 - this and to reduce their overall labor costs.
29:09 - And one of the ways they did this was by changing the way they hired people.
29:14 - So with their sites, they started to close them during off seasons,
29:17 - particularly January and February, something that we can still mostly see today.
29:21 - And as a result, they were able to reduce the amount of full-time staff
29:25 - they needed and instead they would have part-time or seasonal workers instead.
29:29 - This would also lead to an increased reliance
29:30 - on volunteer work and evolve this sounds familiar.
29:32 - It's because it still trends that we see in the museum world today
29:36 - with this emphasis on volunteer work and the local community supporting
29:42 - museum endeavors to make up for any potential gaps in the
29:45 - budget that cannot be used to pay for full-time employees.
29:49 - And speaking of the sites, we actually get into
29:51 - one of the really big parts of this time period.
29:54 - And that is the property placement program.
29:57 - At the time of this, the PHMC just had way too many sites.
30:01 - I know I have up there approximately 48.
30:03 - It's actually closer to 57 sites that they just cannot manage.
30:07 - They are going unoccupied and they are facing vandalism
30:11 - and they are falling into disrepair because they can't put the preservation efforts
30:15 - into it because they don't have anyone to do it.
30:18 - So they have this reduced staff and budget and all these sites.
30:21 - So they decide, okay, this isn't sustainable.
30:24 - We need to find the quote highest and best use, unquote, for these sites
30:28 - that will potentially offload some of this cost on us.
30:32 - So they're going to take all of these sites and the property placement committee
30:35 - is going to get together to rank them based on three core attributes.
30:38 - And that is historical integrity, historical
30:40 - interpretation and historical significance.
30:42 - And from that, they're going to place them
30:44 - into three categories, most less or least important.
30:48 - What they're going to end up coming up with is that there are going to be 22 sites,
30:53 - marked as most important, 15 is less important and 20 is least important.
30:58 - And of those, the way they're going to deal
30:59 - with those afterwards is that if they're considered less or least important,
31:02 - they're going to be any combination of least outsold
31:05 - or placed into management agreements as an attempt to get them out of the PHMC's
31:09 - direct overseing, but they will actually still remain in charge of most of them.
31:14 - There are some that are actually also least out
31:16 - there, given to other government entities as well.
31:19 - However, it is worth noting that they are actually
31:22 - going to face some backlash from the community in the process of this.
31:24 - And so five additional sites are going to get
31:26 - moved into the PHMC is keeping them category.
31:29 - And they will actually not even be able to complete the program until the 1990s.
31:34 - That is when the Blue Ribbon Committee is going to take over
31:37 - and they're going to basically do the whole project again.
31:39 - And they are going to be left with 22 sites,
31:43 - which I actually have a little spreadsheet of here.
31:45 - So this isn't entirely accurate.
31:50 - There are some things that have changed.
31:52 - Some names have changed.
31:53 - Some got merged.
31:56 - But it just shows the rough view of what it looked like.
32:00 - So here we have all the stuff that was presented at 1981 report.
32:03 - There's roughly 45 here.
32:05 - And then in the 1997 report, we can see how many of those
32:09 - were moved out by the time of the late '90s.
32:11 - And the ones highlighted were ones that were not--
32:13 - I could not find in the 1981 report,
32:15 - but they are there now in the 1997 report by the committee.
32:18 - And then we get to the present sites.
32:20 - And so you can kind of see that more than half of
32:23 - the sites were actually de-assessioned at some point.
32:26 - And this helped by not just reducing the cost on the PHMC
32:33 - to take care of these, but it also brought in additional income streams for them.
32:37 - There was actually a lot of income that they could generate from leasing them out.
32:43 - I believe there was one year, it was like $45,000 to $50,000
32:46 - they were able to generate as income just from enacting some of these new programs.
32:53 - And then we also have the associate groups.
32:56 - So associate groups have always been an important part of the PHMC in its history.
33:02 - But now we actually start to see them taking the
33:03 - real forefront as instrumental to the organization.
33:06 - And we see that a lot, especially with the friends
33:08 - of the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission.
33:11 - The organization was started in 1983.
33:13 - Though it had been in talks for a couple years.
33:15 - And its goal was to assist the PHMC
33:17 - in generating private income through donations and memberships.
33:20 - They are the private part of a public private partnership,
33:23 - which is a long-term arrangement between a government
33:26 - and a private sector institutions that are designed
33:29 - to help support these public institutions by generating other income for them.
33:35 - So they got there 501(c) tax exemption status in 1983.
33:39 - And then after that, they were an instrumental part,
33:42 - especially in raising money for some programs like the traveling history program
33:47 - where they were actually able to help raise $100,000
33:50 - to get the vehicle replaced whenever it was falling into disrepair.
33:54 - They are actually still around today.
33:56 - They're called the Pennsylvania Heritage Foundation.
33:58 - And they actually run the Pennsylvania Heritage Magazine,
34:00 - which is an important part of the research I did for this.
34:03 - There was also the preservation fund of Pennsylvania.
34:06 - That was a fund that was set up and managed by
34:10 - the PHMC, although it had separate allocation.
34:13 - And it is also still around.
34:14 - It's called preservation Pennsylvania.
34:17 - So some other associate groups, there were 24 of them
34:20 - in addition, across them, they had 9,500 members
34:25 - and contributed 99,000 hours in labor in 1984.
34:30 - And that number actually just continued to go up for 1985.
34:34 - So that also just helped them.
34:36 - They had people doing the labor that they needed, but they didn't have to pay them.
34:40 - It was a real communal support that they were able to get
34:45 - to help them get through this harsh time period for them.
34:49 - So some of the conclusions that I drew from looking at this
34:54 - is that this dire economic situation in the United States,
34:58 - it halted this period of unprecedented growth for the PHMC.
35:01 - And it put them on the back foot.
35:02 - It put them in a really bad situation that they had to learn how to overcome.
35:06 - And so they implemented all of these cost saving protocols.
35:09 - And they started to lean more into private funding streams.
35:12 - And it did work out for them.
35:13 - In fiscal year 1980 through 1981,
35:17 - the PHMC got roughly $10 million in total state resources
35:20 - and another million dollars from other income.
35:24 - But by fiscal year 1985 to '86, the PHMC received $14
35:27 - million from the state and $5,800,800,000 from other sources.
35:34 - So they were able to really expand their programming.
35:37 - And they entered what I heard some people refer to
35:39 - as a bit of a golden age for the organization in the '80s.
35:42 - And a lot of those changes are still around today.
35:46 - They may have changed names, but they are still part of the operation of the PHMC.
35:51 - So that does lead me to my further research
35:53 - because I do want to continue working on this project.
35:56 - There's a lot more to cover.
35:57 - I want to do an in-depth analysis of the PHMC budgets for the years in question.
36:01 - There are hard to access online,
36:02 - and I didn't have all the time I wanted to go to the state
36:04 - museum and also, despite this entire project being oriented
36:08 - around budgets, I actually don't know that much about public budgeting.
36:10 - So I took an entire class on it.
36:12 - The semester, so I'll get back to you in December
36:13 - to see if I actually understand it better.
36:15 - But that is the goal.
36:17 - The goal is to actually be able to really look into
36:19 - these budgets and dig into what the PHMC had going on.
36:23 - I also want to investigate that document
36:25 - that I cannot figure out where it came from, where it went.
36:28 - And I want to see if I can potentially even talk
36:31 - to some people who worked in the PHMC at the time
36:34 - and introduce more of an oral history component into this.
36:38 - I was going to do that in the month since I started this project,
36:41 - and then I got busy because grad school was busy.
36:44 - So I didn't have time to do it yet, but I want to.
36:47 - And then I also want to expand this research
36:49 - to not to situate it more in the rest of Pennsylvania
36:52 - in museum and museums and historic institutions,
36:55 - but also potentially even as far as the rest of the United
36:57 - States to understand how we perceive history, because there is a very important story
37:03 - to be told there about who's funding our history and why they're doing it.
37:07 - And especially recently, the project
37:10 - has taken on a different meaning, especially recently,
37:13 - with what we're seeing just in the United
37:16 - States and the threat that the field is under.
37:19 - And a lot of it, I even wrote somewhere in my conclusion
37:24 - that I was getting my bachelor's degree in history
37:27 - with intent to go into the field when I first got
37:29 - the news that President Trump's administration
37:34 - was leveraging the funding of the NEH and the NIH
37:39 - and attempting to basically threaten to pull their funding
37:43 - if they didn't orient history towards the way that he believed it should be told.
37:47 - And that puts us into this awkward position of,
37:51 - is it more important to continue to tell history
37:55 - even if we have to change the way it's told
37:57 - overrunning the risk of not being able to tell it at all?
37:59 - And I feel like understanding the revenue sources
38:02 - and who is funding us and who is allowing us
38:04 - to tell what stories is essential in that, which is not to accuse the PHMC of anything
38:08 - just to put it on this wider scale of why this is so important
38:11 - to me and why I feel like it's something that needs to be deeply analyzed.
38:15 - So in the future, I wanna maybe expand it back a bit,
38:17 - understand a bit about the PHMC in the '50s and '60s and then also take it forward,
38:21 - understand the changing narrative around museums as education in the '90s,
38:24 - bring it into the 2000s and see kind of what these policies
38:28 - set the PHMC up for, whether or not it was still,
38:33 - whether or not they've provided us long-term stability
38:35 - and how we can examine this as the PHMC exemplifies
38:40 - this challenge of understanding our funding and figuring out
38:43 - how we can make it work to best serve the public their history.
38:47 - So thank you very much.
38:49 - (audience applauding)
38:55 - - So my name is Carlin, as it was introduced earlier.
38:58 - For my project, I focused on some of the local
39:02 - theaters within my area and it's name that I gave it
39:06 - is saving the screen, communities, colleges,
39:08 - and the preservation of independent theaters
39:10 - in Central Pennsylvania because I love a long title.
39:13 - So, and then up there is just kind of like a,
39:17 - a cat bashed picture of like inside of the majestic
39:20 - theater and the outside of the majestic theater.
39:23 - Okay, so the sources that I relied on for this project as
39:26 - you're gonna see going in, it's a very newspaper heavy.
39:31 - I think overall a lot of the local archives
39:34 - really didn't cover the theaters in their files.
39:37 - I think from what I saw, I would just get like a file,
39:41 - there'd be some notes in some like handwritten
39:43 - notes of an interview that I'm not sure happened
39:47 - and then like maybe a picture that a lady down the street took.
39:50 - So, there's a lot of collective memory that I was drawing on.
39:55 - There's actually this database online that's called cinema treasures and it's a place
39:59 - for people to upload pictures and advertisements from local theaters.
40:03 - And honestly, that was super helpful
40:05 - for just finding images because they took the pictures
40:08 - themselves, they would date them, they'd say,
40:10 - oh, I took this in my backyard as a view of the college cinema in Shipensburg
40:15 - and particularly with Shipensburg, it was just hard to find things.
40:19 - So, it was really nice being able to rely on people
40:21 - kind of keeping the collective memory alive.
40:24 - That including like this like Facebook group where there was like a bunch of people
40:28 - like talking about memories they have of the theater before it closed down.
40:32 - Those are super helpful resource for me in like researching.
40:36 - And then for the historiography for this, it's pretty limited.
40:41 - So, obviously film as a discipline within history
40:44 - is pretty popular but the study of film exhibition itself
40:48 - is somewhat an untapped market of research.
40:51 - The best book that I could find for is actually a collection of essays
40:56 - by Catherine Fuller Ceeley and it's called, if I can find it.
41:04 - Sorry, Hollywood in the neighborhood historical case studies of local movie going.
41:09 - It's essentially just a bunch of different essays
41:11 - of local theaters and how people interacted with them.
41:15 - But there's also this ethnographic study within it
41:17 - that's probably the most useful for my paper because of scale.
41:23 - And it actually has one of my favorite names I've ever read from a scholarly article.
41:27 - The name is Bad Sound and Sticky floors.
41:30 - An ethnographic look at the symbolic value of historic small town movie theaters.
41:35 - So in general, they're kind of coining this new film
41:37 - history outside of just studying the movies themselves
41:40 - and instead studying like the cultural relationship
41:43 - between the theaters and the people going to them.
41:45 - And that's kind of what I wanted to focus on.
41:47 - But I also wanted to set it against a national scale of decline
41:51 - because a lot of theaters nationally were struggling during these times.
41:54 - And I wanted to take on different case studies
41:57 - because I think as the research yields,
42:01 - communities are kind of the most important part
42:04 - of keeping a theater alive, especially in this day and age.
42:06 - But communities and institutions are the reason
42:08 - the two examples that did make it made it in the end.
42:13 - So for my research, I wanted to contextualize
42:16 - independent theaters outside of their intrinsic value to the community.
42:20 - So the Carlisle Theater, Majestic Theater, and Gettysburg
42:23 - and College Cinema are case studies kind of demonstrating
42:27 - that independent theaters weren't just passive
42:29 - victims of this national broader decline.
42:31 - Their experience actually suggests that suburbanization,
42:34 - multiplex competition and home entertainment created similar pressures.
42:38 - But local relationships ultimately shaped where their outcomes were.
42:43 - And essentially, I'm highlighting this relationship
42:45 - that a lot of scholars have already focused on,
42:48 - like the relationship that people have with their theater.
42:51 - But I wanted to kind of show the back and forth
42:53 - that the theater has with the community
42:55 - because the community ultimately is what keeps the theater in business and frequency.
42:59 - Because there's a lot of outside forces that kind of tempt
43:02 - people to no longer be loyal to their local movie theaters.
43:06 - And there's just kind of a long history
43:07 - of independent theaters trying to keep attendance
43:10 - within their communities and trying to stay within their communities.
43:14 - So we start in the 1920s through the 1940s,
43:18 - which is actually considered the golden age of movie going,
43:21 - which I didn't know until coming into this paper.
43:25 - Millions of Americans were attending the theater each week.
43:28 - And downtown theaters were very benefited
43:30 - from the foot traffic of just downtown life.
43:32 - You would go get dinner with your family,
43:35 - do shopping with your mom, and then you would go see a movie.
43:37 - Because there's a giant flashing marquee
43:40 - in the middle of the street that's telling you that this
43:42 - is playing, and then you would just stop and go see it.
43:45 - It's just part of everyday life.
43:48 - And then there's a bunch of different film scholars
43:50 - that kind of highlight that it's operated for a site of leisure and entertainment.
43:56 - And that this entertainment kind of begins
43:58 - on the sidewalk structurally because of the mat name, because of the Marquis.
44:03 - So you can kind of see how structures are automatically
44:08 - playing into how people are viewing these theaters.
44:11 - So the comfort theater is actually the Carlisle theater.
44:14 - Some of the names are going to get confusing over time because they flip names.
44:17 - Each one of them flips names like twice.
44:21 - But the comfort theater is the Carlisle theater later on, but for now the comfort.
44:26 - So the middle thing there is actually an advertisement for its opening.
44:32 - They opened in May of 1939, which is actually
44:35 - the end of the golden age of film going.
44:38 - But it still didn't really matter at that point.
44:40 - It was still embedded in a cultural life.
44:42 - It was just less population attendance.
44:44 - The Carlisle Sentinel announced its formal opening
44:47 - as a new home of motion picture entertainment.
44:50 - I think the word home here is really important,
44:53 - because instead of it just suggesting it as this theater,
44:58 - it's a familiar communal space that people could view
45:00 - as a part of their home and go to as a part of their home.
45:03 - And it also had just this location in the downtown.
45:06 - That was pretty well located in between a lot of--
45:09 - other businesses and restaurants, which, as I mentioned earlier,
45:13 - was really integral in getting people to go to the theater.
45:17 - So Gettysburg's Majestic Theater opened before that.
45:20 - It opened in 1925.
45:23 - And it was attached to a central hotel that is over there.
45:27 - It doesn't have as many pictures or endorsements.
45:30 - It's quite simple.
45:32 - It immediately was integrated into the life of the people living in Gettysburg.
45:37 - They're already-- as soon as they began advertising,
45:39 - they're talking about how many jobs they're
45:41 - going to create for local community members.
45:44 - They're talking about how they're going to be holding events.
45:47 - They're immediately going beyond the role of just a theater
45:50 - and trying to establish themselves within the community.
45:54 - There's actually an oral history documentary
45:56 - from Gettysburg College that includes an interview that
45:59 - describes presidents actually gathering there for wartime information.
46:03 - So they would all collectively gather and get updates
46:05 - about just war times and spend time together outside
46:09 - of just going to see a movie or going there for entertainment.
46:12 - And then Shippensburg's Victory Theater
46:15 - was built downtown in 1920 before any of the other theaters.
46:19 - And it was later known as the College Cinema
46:21 - because this one also closed your May opened.
46:24 - It was embedded into community life immediately.
46:26 - But some of those-- it being embedded wasn't necessarily
46:30 - always a good thing and I'll get into that right now.
46:33 - So it had to be closed on Wednesday nights
46:35 - to accommodate the community's church going behaviors.
46:39 - So Shippensburg was a very religious neighborhood or a very religious place.
46:43 - So on Wednesdays, the idea of showing a movie was just genuinely unthinkable.
46:49 - Like they need to be in church.
46:50 - They can't go see a movie.
46:52 - You're not allowed to be open on Wednesdays.
46:54 - It was just a collective role that the community imposed on the theater itself.
46:58 - And also for all of these theaters, they weren't allowed to show movies on Sundays
47:03 - from the beginning because Sunday is also church time.
47:05 - So for the other two, they're missing one out of the week.
47:08 - But for the Shippensburg Theater,
47:10 - it's missing two days of revenue, a week, no matter what.
47:14 - I think this relationship is really important
47:17 - and illustrating that both the strengths
47:20 - and the limitations of local cultural expectations.
47:22 - All three theaters were central community institutions,
47:25 - but the values that kind of helped to find them
47:28 - as that were also some of the biggest constraints
47:30 - on their operations and like during economic hardship.
47:34 - So by the 1970s, the position of downtown theaters was becoming unstable.
47:39 - And actually I'm gonna go to my next slides
47:40 - 'cause I keep doing this where I skip them.
47:43 - But we have the giant advertisement for the newcomer for coming.
47:48 - This one's really interesting to me for a few reasons.
47:53 - They're kind of like advertising that it's fireproof.
47:56 - This has deep meaning for Carlisle because we've had two theaters burned down.
48:02 - First was the Orpheum before this.
48:05 - And that one closed after it burned down actually.
48:07 - And then the Strand Theater, which was kind of the parent
48:10 - company to this theater, that one also burned down.
48:12 - So Carlisle's very passionate about not wanting it to burn down.
48:16 - So they're really driving the point home, it's fireproof, you're safe.
48:21 - And then air conditioning is also a really big thing.
48:23 - All of these theaters are like come in,
48:25 - we have air conditioning 'cause that's a big selling point.
48:29 - And then over there, that's from the Cumberland County Historical Archives.
48:32 - They have kind of this picture of what the snack bar looked like,
48:35 - which is really fascinating to me because I work in a theater.
48:39 - And mine doesn't look like that at all.
48:40 - So it's just cool to see it going back.
48:42 - And kind of like the communal space, it's hard to see there.
48:45 - But the structures inside of the buildings
48:48 - were really like integral to how people would talk in the lobby.
48:52 - Like they really wanted people to just sit
48:53 - and discuss in the lobby and take their time and spend more money on Popcorn
48:57 - and talk about going to see another movie next week.
49:00 - It was all part of this big plan to get them back in for another movie.
49:05 - And then this is actually in Carlisle.
49:08 - It's during the world premiere of the Jim Thorpe movie,
49:11 - which Jim Thorpe's a really big deal in Carlisle.
49:13 - So this is not a surprising crowd.
49:15 - But it kind of just illustrates how busy
49:18 - it would get at times like right into the theater.
49:20 - This is in the '50s.
49:22 - But I just find this photo really fascinating
49:24 - because I can't remember the last time I saw Carlisle like packed like that.
49:29 - I mean, maybe the car show, but even then like probably not.
49:34 - And then these are from the Gettysburg theater
49:36 - and over to the left, it's their snack bar.
49:39 - Again, it's kind of like that very formal like kind of uppity snack bar.
49:43 - And then here we have a different use for it.
49:46 - They actually had a war bond rally in the lobby of the theater.
49:49 - The theater, like I already talked about,
49:52 - was kind of immediately part of so many different things.
49:55 - It wasn't just a theater.
49:56 - It had so many roles going into it immediately.
49:59 - Okay, and then my sources for the Shipensburg theater were limited in general.
50:05 - This was actually from someone who like gave it to the database that I found.
50:10 - And it's just like a pamphlet of what they're showing.
50:13 - And then it's kind of talking about the newspaper articles
50:16 - talking about how the residents were really pleased with the theater being there
50:20 - and that it had good attendance and the opening was successful.
50:24 - So it's kind of just hammering down the same points
50:26 - that they were becoming community institutions.
50:29 - There were still some issues right from the like Gekko,
50:32 - but they were well integrated into their communities.
50:35 - I think we'll stop here.
50:38 - So in Shipensburg, oh, by the 1970s, a position of downtown theaters had become
50:43 - increasingly unstable, post-war suburbanization,
50:47 - moved commerce and entertainment away from the town centers
50:51 - and moved it towards shopping malls where different things were being opened
50:55 - and you could kind of get everything where you wanted all at once.
50:57 - And this was kind of displacing the downtown districts.
51:01 - Because traditional theaters relied on the street level
51:03 - visibility, declining foot traffic, was immediately affecting
51:07 - their attendance and presence within daily community life.
51:11 - The rise of television, too.
51:13 - I mean, obviously the rise of television from the
51:15 - Gekko was a huge issue, but this is also the time
51:18 - that VHS and home entertainment was becoming more and more popular.
51:22 - So people being able to watch homes within their own
51:26 - movies, kind of, for a lot of people defeated the purpose
51:29 - of leaving their homes to go and see a movie in person.
51:32 - And we see this a lot today as well with streaming.
51:36 - So the Shipensburg decline was actually shaped
51:41 - by cultural and legal conflicts as well as the economic conflicts.
51:45 - The Victory Theater closed in 1971
51:47 - and College Cinema opened that December as ownership changed.
51:51 - And then we can see, I have it up here,
51:53 - but there's a lot of stuff going on within the community about them being quite upset
51:59 - about the concept of movies being shown on Sunday.
52:03 - So in 1975, the Cumberland County District Attorney
52:06 - is ordering theaters to see Sunday operations unless voters approved them.
52:11 - For my knowledge, Carlisle and Gettysburg,
52:15 - they did approve, or Carlisle, just Carlisle, approved having the Sunday movies,
52:20 - but there was a lot of tension in Shipensburg
52:23 - over whether or not they would be allowed to show
52:25 - the Sunday movies and eventually the community
52:28 - won and they didn't show any movies on Sundays.
52:31 - So there's a lot of things happening.
52:34 - Shipensburg voters are deciding the movie
52:36 - issue, articles are outlining the possible fines
52:39 - and enforcement actions they would face if they did show movies.
52:42 - There's an editorial I found that argued that such laws could
52:45 - not change the heart, kind of like going into the community.
52:48 - They couldn't change their heart towards the theater.
52:51 - They didn't view it in a way
52:53 - that it should be showing Sunday movies.
52:56 - And then I think this is really important
52:58 - because the theater was no longer just a shared cultural space.
53:01 - It's sort of solely becoming a contested site
53:04 - where different ideas about community identity are kind of being negotiated.
53:10 - And then we see the Victory Theater attempting to adapt.
53:13 - They do advertisements promoting a dollar night and screenings in 1972
53:19 - and like they were emphasizing affordability to try to draw people in.
53:22 - Yet the lower prices didn't really resolve their deeper cultural restrictions.
53:27 - And then multiplexes at the same time, which were opening
53:30 - in the area, they didn't face the same restrictions.
53:33 - So they were just ultimately just getting trampled
53:35 - by the fact that they couldn't keep up economically.
53:40 - And then here's the closing of the theater.
53:42 - Actually closed the Victory Theater and then reopened as the college cinema.
53:46 - It was repurchased.
53:49 - Down there is an advertisement for it and then another advertisement.
53:53 - They actually reopened around Christmas and they started
53:56 - with a Christmas Carol, which I thought was interesting.
53:58 - I think it's kind of, this is definitely reaching,
54:01 - but after having so many conflicts about church and stuff like that,
54:04 - I think it's interesting that they're choosing
54:06 - Christmas to like really drive the point home.
54:09 - And then that's actually just an archival photo of the college cinema.
54:12 - And there's a decent amount of photos that people have like unintentionally took
54:16 - of the college cinema 'cause it's on a pretty well based street.
54:19 - So people would take a picture of something else
54:21 - and then there's the college cinema in the background.
54:23 - So that was helpful for finding photo sources.
54:27 - Okay, and then the Carlisle Theater experience a very different form of decline.
54:32 - 1980 Evening Sentinel interview recalled that the theater
54:35 - was very successful until the tube television came out
54:38 - and that it had once been a focal point of the community.
54:42 - By then the theater was raising prices and enforcing stricter rules.
54:46 - janitor actually interviewed in that same article and he said he believed the quality
54:51 - had declined under changing ownership and management.
54:54 - And I think these accounts are really telling
54:56 - because it's a worker who's openly talking about their workplace into a newspaper.
55:02 - That's pretty, it's bold, so he means it.
55:05 - So these accounts are kind of suggesting not only the
55:08 - economic strain, but a weakening of pride and familiarity
55:11 - that it once tied the community to this building.
55:14 - And then multi-plexes are kind of like the iceberg that sunk the Titanic.
55:19 - Like this is where it's all down from here for these places.
55:23 - So the Chambersburg Mall Cinemas opened with four screens in 1984.
55:29 - It had surrounding shops and restaurants
55:32 - and it created an intense amount of competition for Shipensburg's college cinema.
55:36 - In May of 1985, the MJ Carlyle Mall Cinema 3 advertised its grand opening.
55:41 - It had three screens and simultaneous film choices.
55:45 - Gettysburg newspaper at the same time is advertising
55:49 - nearby theaters with multiple screens and new blockbusters.
55:53 - Independent theaters were facing additional pressures
55:55 - from local objections to our rated films and expectations that programming
55:59 - would reflect the conservative and family-oriented community standards.
56:03 - But these multi-plexes weren't subjected
56:05 - to those same standards from a company standpoint
56:08 - and they weren't part of the community.
56:10 - So they kind of got around the no Sunday films immediately.
56:14 - So I think this is pretty telling but the college cinema closed in 1985,
56:19 - which is exactly a year after the Chambersburg multi-plex opened.
56:24 - And the Carlisle Theater closed in 1986, which is
56:27 - exactly a year after its respective multi-plex opened.
56:32 - In an interview that the Shipensburg Historical Society had,
56:37 - they interviewed William Dulk who actually recalled that Shipensburg residents
56:40 - had ceased to support the theater and that profitable attendance after the mall
56:45 - when the theater, or when the mall theater opened was just nonexistent for him.
56:49 - So there's just like kind of almost like a few,
56:52 - almost like very bitter and like last quotes
56:55 - that he gave before giving up the theater and just letting it sit there.
57:01 - So I think this account, alongside the earlier Sunday film controversy
57:05 - is pretty revealing about the theater's relationship within its community.
57:09 - And it had already weakened
57:11 - before the multi-plex arrived obviously same with Carlisle.
57:13 - There was already weakening relationships happening there.
57:16 - Unlike Carlisle where the residents organized to reopen
57:20 - their theater, Shipensburg didn't produce a comparable
57:22 - preservation campaign and it just remained closed.
57:26 - The Majestic Theater followed a pretty different path
57:29 - and opened through this period, it stayed open
57:32 - and Gettysburg College actually purchased it in 1988,
57:35 - which is about when a lot of this is happening as well.
57:38 - So it's kind of getting, they were reporting a decline in attendance
57:42 - and the college kind of steps in and purchase it,
57:46 - purchases it to keep it open during these difficult times.
57:49 - So this early intervention distinguishes the Majestic from Carlisle and Shipensburg.
57:53 - The theater had previously undergone some changes that residents weren't big fans of
57:58 - and they were calling it a generic multi-plex
58:01 - and a dingy lifeless place in some newspaper articles.
58:04 - And by 1990, the college and township
58:06 - were considering renovation plans to kind of negate this.
58:09 - But community support didn't mean that they were unanimous,
58:13 - like, unanimously agreeing about what preservation should look like.
58:17 - I actually found a 1991 article like right to the newspaper
58:22 - article from a 17-year-old girl who actually wrote
58:25 - to the Gettysburg Times about the proposed alterations
58:28 - and she describes Gettysburg's theaters one of its landmarks
58:31 - and she doesn't want it to lose all of its character and charm.
58:34 - And that really was important to me to see
58:37 - because it's a young person who's kind of like putting their voice out there
58:41 - and saying what that role has been in her life,
58:44 - like that she views it as a piece of her community.
58:49 - And then her response kind of just demonstrates
58:51 - that the theater's still important to the local identity,
58:54 - even among its younger residents, while exposing that there's this tension
58:58 - between the historical authenticity and modernization,
59:01 - which is something that the Carlisle theater also faced after reopening.
59:05 - Through the 1990s, the Majestic continued to host films
59:07 - and other events, including graduation commencements.
59:10 - One of its most unique uses that kind of threw me off guard
59:13 - when I found it is actually served as a dormitory building.
59:17 - So they actually renovated the upper floor
59:19 - and let students sleep there and live there,
59:22 - as like, I don't know, they just lived in there.
59:27 - And then there was a lot of reports about this concerning lease that was going to end
59:31 - in August 1998 or August 1999, and that the possibility of the
59:37 - theater getting leased to a larger company, which was RC theaters,
59:41 - which is actually the theater that took over the MJ cinema.
59:45 - So there is actually an RC in Gettysburg and an RC in Carlisle.
59:51 - But Gettysburg College actually publicly kept going
59:55 - with its project towards the theater, and they started this early cost estimate
59:59 - 760 of renovation converting it to Performing Arts Center,
01:00 - 05.600 and that early cost started at $5 to $12 million
01:00 - 10.160 that they were willing to put into the theater actually turned into $16 million.
01:00 - 14.280 So 500 companies and individuals donated
01:00 - 17.680 and the college secured an $8.5 million commonwealth
01:00 - 20.440 of Pennsylvania Economic Read Development Grant.
01:00 - 23.360 They added $15,000 square feet
01:00 - 26.720 to expand the building's capacity for its new programming.
01:00 - 32.600 And then rather than returning to film exhibition or show exhibition,
01:00 - 36.040 it became a multifunctional cultural space for community meetings.
01:00 - 40.400 It kind of almost went back to its roots, 'cause as it was created,
01:00 - 43.160 it started out as a community space for many different things.
01:00 - 45.160 But they even tied in like college events
01:00 - 47.640 and stuff like that, like graduations and everything like that.
01:00 - 53.280 It served as like an extra theater for the college to use for all kinds of events.
01:00 - 55.080 So although the building survived,
01:00 - 58.720 it's purpose changed considerably from its original role as a movie theater.
01:00 - 02.680 The expansion into live performance is cultural programming.
01:01 - 05.360 It reflected this effort to make the building economically
01:01 - 09.480 sustainable whilst still retaining its historic significance.
01:01 - 11.760 And then Carlisle's kind of a contrast
01:01 - 17.400 'cause it begins their program after the theater at a head already closed, I think.
01:01 - 19.960 Oh man, I'm so behind.
01:01 - 22.520 Okay, this is stuff about the majestic theaters
01:01 - 25.640 reopening, the bottom I thought was interesting.
01:01 - 29.785 There was apartments at the top of it before they
01:01 - 32.840 kind of sold it off or before they purchased it.
01:01 - 37.160 And then those like low income residents were displaced after the purchase.
01:01 - 44.880 Okay, in Carlisle, we see community support after it closed, they formed in 1989.
01:01 - 47.360 They have this newsletter where they're constantly
01:01 - 50.600 telling people their plans for reopening the theater.
01:01 - 52.360 There's a picture of it.
01:01 - 55.720 And then there's also just regular periodic newsletters
01:01 - 58.380 getting released that I got to look through.
01:01 - 01.240 Kind of seasonally about their plans, their donors.
01:02 - 04.760 There's a lot of donations coming from local businesses within Carlisle.
01:02 - 08.280 There's a lot of donations coming from the Gettysburg College as well.
01:02 - 11.320 And they actually have a lot of important events
01:02 - 16.520 at Gettysburg or at Dickinson College where they're asking for funding,
01:02 - 19.760 telling about the theater's history within the community.
01:02 - 21.968 So after all the fundraising, they actually
01:02 - 24.000 reopened in 1993 and they're still open today.
01:02 - 29.520 They hosted a bunch of different events that are kind of connected to the community.
01:02 - 33.160 And overall they were able to keep the theater open
01:02 - 37.080 through donations and they still have the friends of the Carlisle theater.
01:02 - 40.240 It still exists today and it's fed through donations.
01:02 - 42.440 And Dickinson also has interns going in there
01:02 - 46.320 and they have this like kind of mutually helpful
01:02 - 49.840 and beneficial agreement of working together for a lot of different things.
01:02 - 54.360 So I think overall this yielded that the two surviving theaters
01:02 - 57.040 revealed this like distinct, yet interconnected model
01:02 - 58.480 of preservation.
01:02 - 00.682 Gettysburg supplied direct ownership financial
01:03 - 03.200 support and long term institutional leadership.
01:03 - 06.480 And the Carlisle Theater relied on organized fundraising
01:03 - 08.880 volunteers and this like grassroots commitment
01:03 - 11.480 to historic preservation with Dickinson College
01:03 - 15.480 kind of providing additional labor and resources where it was needed.
01:03 - 18.120 Both colleges functioned as cultural anchors
01:03 - 21.920 although the rules differed substantially in how much they were involved.
01:03 - 24.520 And then Shipensburg's College Cinema had no comparable
01:03 - 28.240 organized campaign or institute to help it when it closed.
01:03 - 31.800 So it just didn't have the same effect.
01:03 - 34.160 The history's also fit with this like
01:03 - 37.840 or statewide scale and I think I'm almost out of time.
01:03 - 42.840 So, okay, in conclusion, these theaters essentially
01:03 - 47.600 demonstrate that independent theaters weren't simply
01:03 - 50.880 businesses made obsolete by changing entertainment habits.
01:03 - 53.400 They were community institutions whose survival depended
01:03 - 55.920 on whether residents and local organizations
01:03 - 59.240 continued to see them as worthy of maintaining.
01:03 - 01.600 I think this research is important going forward
01:04 - 04.800 because theaters have been facing the same cyclical pattern
01:04 - 09.280 throughout the years of economic decline based on social patterns.
01:04 - 12.120 I mean, COVID was absolutely crippling
01:04 - 15.400 to a lot of theaters, including now the multiplexes.
01:04 - 18.760 I know a lot of technically smaller film companies
01:04 - 22.800 or theater companies are really struggling to stay open
01:04 - 28.200 following changing behaviors and social patterns after COVID, and I'll end there.
01:04 - 31.200 (audience applauds)
01:04 - 40.680 I will open it up to Q&A, but to the surprise of no one, I do have a comment.
01:04 - 43.160 So if you take off my members first hat
01:04 - 46.080 and then the PHA hat, there is indeed another hat
01:04 - 48.040 for the Association of Fundraising Professionals
01:04 - 50.760 of Central PA, of which I am board president.
01:04 - 53.960 And I think Carlin and Kate Lee can throw this out there.
01:04 - 57.160 It's just the comment on it, but you are really seeing
01:04 - 01.000 the tension of nonprofits, but also the museum world.
01:05 - 02.960 That a nonprofit is a third sector,
01:05 - 05.760 so you're really seeing the tension of government wanting
01:05 - 08.360 to be involved and the private sector wanting to be involved.
01:05 - 12.320 And sometimes they're the third sector or sometimes they're the government sector.
01:05 - 15.000 So I think you're seeing a lot of that happening.
01:05 - 18.080 And I was just at one of our events on Wednesday,
01:05 - 19.720 and somebody had said, which I think is good
01:05 - 21.920 to just leave you both with as grad students,
01:05 - 25.240 that any other business that is 100 years old,
01:05 - 28.560 you would never expect to always have a good season.
01:05 - 31.800 And why are we taking nonprofits bad season currently
01:05 - 34.600 as the last season that they're going to have?
01:05 - 38.440 So a lot of what my job is as president is to not only educate fundraisers,
01:05 - 41.520 but also kind of reinvigorate their positivity
01:05 - 44.880 towards the sector because there's a lot of hard days,
01:05 - 48.000 but that doesn't mean it's the last say in the days you're going to have.
01:05 - 50.960 So somebody had said that out at our event, and I was like, that's so good.
01:05 - 53.760 I'm going to write that down until everybody that for the next couple of months.
01:05 - 56.600 But as you're graduating, just kind of keep that in mind.
01:05 - 57.560 It does not all bad.
01:05 - 00.080 It will not always be bad, hopefully.
01:06 - 02.640 But are there any questions from the audience?
01:06 - 04.440 We have a few minutes before we end.
01:06 - 07.120 - I just have a quick one for kind of me actually,
01:06 - 12.920 because this is failing and telling me fine.
01:06 - 15.520 [LAUGHTER]
01:06 - 19.000 But I was kind of curious about what your views are.
01:06 - 26.160 I think about Kennedy as being sort of this part of the last fraud in the middle.
01:06 - 28.920 Just one of the greatest aside, eventually, with Elle J.
01:06 - 35.600 And Kerry talking about neoliberal policies coming to effect efficiency.
01:06 - 45.240 What do you think right now in the moment we're sort of future neoliberal policies?
01:06 - 50.800 I don't know whether we're in a moment now where neoliberalism is related.
01:06 - 54.800 Now, I mean, we're getting to a review of the discussion.
01:06 - 59.160 But probably the inspiration is what we have to do.
01:06 - 00.760 Eat and charge, you mentioned.
01:07 - 01.840 That's it.
01:07 - 06.440 So I just am curious about taking it back to this.
01:07 - 10.520 Why didn't you be able to rise and deal with those?
01:07 - 15.600 Yeah, so I actually think about this a lot in the sense
01:07 - 17.320 that this is actually where the paper was originally
01:07 - 19.120 going to stretch to the modern day, talking
01:07 - 24.554 about how the impact of neoliberalism on the United
01:07 - 27.280 States reinvigorated the United States in a time
01:07 - 29.480 where it was needed, but set up no potential
01:07 - 32.000 for long-term stability, if that makes sense.
01:07 - 34.972 And I actually was more struggling to find positive
01:07 - 38.120 reviews of neoliberalism online when I was looking into it.
01:07 - 41.920 And a lot of the stuff I was reading was highly critical economically.
01:07 - 46.080 And so I think that it is a very interesting avenue to explore.
01:07 - 48.520 And I do want to explore it further.
01:07 - 53.080 But I can also say that to the second part,
01:07 - 56.080 this question between, are these policies
01:07 - 59.560 as this privatization, good for museums or bad for them?
01:07 - 04.513 I think it's hard to tell because we do get these
01:08 - 09.640 situations like now where someone gets into office,
01:08 - 13.280 and they decide they just want to gut some funding,
01:08 - 18.040 and they can, unless they have some sort of private funding to back them up.
01:08 - 22.120 But who's to say that that private funding is always going to be morally upstanding,
01:08 - 25.399 and it's going to let them do whatever they want to do.
01:08 - 30.920 And we kind of see this age-old conflict playing out now
01:08 - 36.120 where it's we have to go where the money is.
01:08 - 38.359 So how do we maintain our historical integrity during that?
01:08 - 40.560 And I don't think there's a clean answer to that.
01:08 - 44.200 I think that in an ideal world where politicians
01:08 - 46.256 are the absolute pinnacle of moral upstanding
01:08 - 49.200 behavior, we wouldn't have to worry about it.
01:08 - 50.640 I don't think we're quite living there.
01:08 - 53.640 Forgive me my hot take.
01:08 - 57.800 So I think that we just have to learn how to balance these and make sure
01:08 - 59.279 that we're keeping out for checks and balances
01:08 - 01.960 and making sure that we're staying very loud about it,
01:09 - 06.439 and not letting ourselves go quietly into the night, one might say.
01:09 - 12.040 So actually, in Carlin, here's the kind of thing that you're talking about.
01:09 - 14.359 That was going to be my add-on study.
01:09 - 15.760 Carlin shows us what happens.
01:09 - 17.880 We don't have that public-private partnership.
01:09 - 20.000 I mean, it's a little bit different
01:09 - 23.800 than the kinds of public partnerships that the Kayleigh
01:09 - 26.920 talked about, but largely, these are public-private partnerships.
01:09 - 30.439 And without them, you have an abandoned bill that you're taking out.
01:09 - 32.760 I was like, you're taking out my partner.
01:09 - 37.442 In general, I think the Carlin Gettysburg
01:09 - 41.000 theaters are just perfect examples of what happens
01:09 - 43.680 when you don't put in the money into these theaters.
01:09 - 46.240 I think Gettysburg obviously didn't fully fund it.
01:09 - 48.279 They also got funding from the state,
01:09 - 50.040 and the state was actually interested in funding,
01:09 - 52.880 which I thought was interesting looking into it.
01:09 - 55.120 I mean, this is the historic preservation project.
01:09 - 59.480 And they funded it quite well with a lot of money.
01:09 - 01.520 And I haven't seen similar funding for the Carla Theater.
01:10 - 05.920 I think it is mostly funded by residents still to this day.
01:10 - 10.440 So it's like the tension of the town being willing to keep it open.
01:10 - 14.080 Are they financially okay with what it's going to be to keep it open?
01:10 - 20.600 Because from a general standpoint, and from like, for working for a theater film
01:10 - 24.120 or showing film isn't profitable, it's just not.
01:10 - 26.920 Showing movies, showing modern movies, showing old movies,
01:10 - 30.320 any form of film, it's not going to be profitable because of copyright.
01:10 - 33.800 And it's just, even-- - If you're a popcorn seller, right?
01:10 - 34.640 - Yes, we did.
01:10 - 36.600 It's essentially, we're food sellers.
01:10 - 40.160 Like the only way to make money as a theater is off of concessions.
01:10 - 43.200 So ticket sales don't really matter.
01:10 - 46.280 In the end, like what matters is people buying popcorn.
01:10 - 49.240 Yes, but also being willing to help fund the theater
01:10 - 51.853 in their town, it's going to always end up
01:10 - 54.600 being, I feel like a community-based project
01:10 - 56.249 to keep a theater open because they're just
01:10 - 59.240 not profitable from an economic standpoint.
01:10 - 00.800 - We're right at time, but Tom, is there anything
01:11 - 02.440 you want to throw into that question before we get--
01:11 - 05.480 - No, no, no, let's call it quits.
01:11 - 07.600 (audience laughs)
01:11 - 09.560 - All right, well, thank you, everyone.
01:11 - 12.560 (audience applauds)
01:11 - 17.160 (dramatic music)