Sen. Tracy Pennycuick news conference on proposed legislation for insurance coverage for oncofertility benefits
00:00 - Good morning.
00:01 - I want to thank everyone for joining us today.
00:04 - I especially want to thank today's
00:05 - speakers for joining us for this very important announcement.
00:09 - Amanda Rice, the founder and CEO of the Chick Mission
00:13 - and also a survivor, Rachel Dan Check, a cancer survivor,
00:19 - doctor Lindsay Goldblatt, hematology
00:22 - oncology fellow at Fox Chase.
00:25 - Doctor Sally Vitez and doctor Nicole Marchetto,
00:29 - reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialist at Shady Grove Fertility.
00:35 - I also want to recognize my house members,
00:37 - Bridget and Kristen, who are here.
00:40 - Thank you.
00:41 - Thank you.
00:42 - For their efforts as well.
00:46 - There are few words more scary than you have cancer
00:50 - for a young person in their reproductive years.
00:54 - There's the added worry of what kind of cancer treatment am I going to have?
00:59 - And what's it going to do to my fertility?
01:02 - We know cancer treatment can save a patient's life,
01:05 - but it can also damage your reproductive function.
01:08 - We also know that any fertility preservation
01:11 - effort must begin before the cancer treatment starts.
01:15 - Time is truly of the essence.
01:18 - We also know that paying for fertility preservation can be cost prohibitive
01:23 - for most and are inconsistently covered by insurers, leaving many
01:27 - with a nearly impossible choice between future fertility
01:32 - and the ability to solve their cancer.
01:35 - Approximately 5300 adolescents
01:38 - and young adults are diagnosed with cancer each year.
01:42 - Many are not married, are newly married,
01:46 - actively trying to start a family, are not even aware of the fertility risks.
01:52 - And while fertility preservation is recommended by major medical societies,
01:55 - less than 50% of oncologists discuss fertility preservation with patients.
02:01 - That's why we've introduced Senate Bill 1315
02:05 - to require insurance coverage in Pennsylvania for standard fertility
02:09 - preservation for cancer patients who must undergo medical treatment
02:13 - that results in infertility.
02:16 - So this will
02:16 - include egg freezing, sperm freezing, ovarian
02:20 - tissue preservation, storage for up to three years
02:25 - and applies before the treatment begins when intervention is still possible,
02:31 - but it does not include IVF or other fertility treatments,
02:35 - and it includes any exemption for a religious employer
02:39 - due to any potential faith conflicts.
02:43 - To date, 21 states including Connecticut, Delaware, Florida,
02:46 - Georgia, Maryland, new Jersey, New York and Oklahoma have taken
02:50 - this important step to ensure access to fertility preservation
02:54 - for patients facing medical treatment that threatens their fertility.
02:59 - Cancer patients should never have to choose
03:01 - between starting life saving treatment and future family.
03:06 - Protecting parenthood after cancer should be the standard of
03:09 - care here in Pennsylvania.
03:11 - So now it is my great honor to introduce Amanda Rice,
03:15 - the founder and CEO of The Mission.
03:18 - I know it's kind of a crazy title, and I thought it was kind of,
03:22 - but it really catches you.
03:23 - Chick mission provides a needs space hope grants to patients facing cancer
03:29 - that helps to offset the fertility preservation costs,
03:32 - and has supported 850 patients nationwide.
03:37 - Amazing work, Amanda. Thank you.
03:44 - I don't mind my booster seat.
03:48 - My name is Amanda Rice.
03:49 - I'm the founder and CEO of the Chick Mission, which is a creative name.
03:54 - It definitely it gets you.
03:56 - But I'm also a three time cancer survivor.
03:59 - Generations of my family, including my mom
04:02 - and my grandparents, called Luzerne County home.
04:05 - And I spent a lot of my youth driving, listening to the top 40
04:10 - and visiting my grandparents at Harveys Lake.
04:15 - When I was diagnosed in my 30s, not once, not twice, but three times.
04:20 - I learned to speak the language of cancer pretty quickly.
04:24 - Things move incredibly fast.
04:27 - Appointments, decisions, language
04:30 - you never expected to understand suddenly becomes your daily vocabulary.
04:34 - You don't really have the luxury of processing how you feel.
04:38 - You just move through it.
04:40 - With my recurrence, I was facing
04:44 - chemotherapy, radiation, and long term drug therapy.
04:48 - I had already gone through a mastectomy and multiple surgeries that came with it.
04:52 - But I was one of the lucky ones.
04:54 - I had fertility coverage through my employer.
04:57 - But here's the thing.
04:59 - I wasn't infertile yet.
05:01 - I was being asked to make a decision about something
05:03 - that hadn't happened to me, but very likely would.
05:07 - Like so many patients, I found myself living into, reality is at once
05:11 - fighting for my life while quietly grieving the possibility
05:14 - of losing a family I hadn't even had the chance to build yet.
05:19 - Today we have extraordinary advancements in cancer care.
05:22 - Survival rates are improving.
05:24 - Patients live longer, fuller lives.
05:27 - But our system has not kept pace when it comes to protecting
05:30 - what comes after survival.
05:32 - Fertility preservation is not experimental.
05:35 - It is not elective.
05:37 - It is a well-established, time sensitive medical intervention
05:41 - that must happen before treatment begins.
05:44 - In Pennsylvania, access is still inconsistent and too often out of reach.
05:50 - Patients are given days, sometimes hours, to make these decisions.
05:55 - They are handed costs that can exceed 15 to $20,000.
05:59 - So many people are forced to walk away
06:02 - not because the care doesn't exist, but simply because they cannot afford it.
06:06 - That is not a medical gap.
06:09 - This is a policy gap.
06:11 - I founded the chick mission to step into that exact moment.
06:15 - We provide financial assistance to women facing cancer
06:18 - so they can preserve their fertility before treatment begins today.
06:22 - And today, we have supported over 850 patients,
06:25 - committed more than $5.5 million in funding, and built a network
06:30 - of over 100 partner clinics nationwide, including here in Pennsylvania.
06:35 - We've seen what happens when this barrier is removed.
06:38 - We've seen patients move forward with treatment
06:40 - without carrying the additional burden of losing their future family.
06:44 - We have seen what it means not just to survive, but to have options
06:47 - after survival.
06:49 - In Pennsylvania, as in many states, coverage
06:51 - is not guaranteed for patients facing intergenic infertility.
06:55 - Infertility caused by necessary medical treatment.
06:58 - A side effect, and that means access is uneven,
07:02 - it's unpredictable, and it is fundamentally inequitable.
07:06 - Legislation changes that.
07:08 - Passing comprehensive fertility
07:10 - preservation coverage ensures that patients across the state receive
07:13 - consistent, timely access to care regardless of income or circumstance.
07:19 - It integrates fertility preservation into standard oncology care and removes
07:23 - the financial barrier at the exact moments patients are least equipped to carry it.
07:28 - Pennsylvania has the opportunity to make that the standard, not the exception,
07:32 - because patients deserve more than survival.
07:36 - They deserve the chance to build a life after cancer,
07:39 - and they deserve a system that protects their future.
07:42 - Thank you.
07:49 - Rachel.
07:58 - My name
07:58 - is Rachel Dan, and I'm from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
08:02 - Two years ago, I was diagnosed
08:04 - with stage three ovarian cancer.
08:08 - At the time, I was newly married
08:10 - and my husband and I were trying to start a family.
08:13 - After about six months, we were told it was still normal.
08:17 - But when it didn't happen, I kept pushing for answers.
08:21 - I had a routine appointment.
08:22 - I asked for additional screening.
08:25 - Eventually, we saw a fertility specialist where testing revealed
08:29 - what looked like a cyst that needed to be removed.
08:32 - But we were hopeful that it was something benign.
08:35 - I went into surgery expecting a routine procedure,
08:39 - but when I woke up, everything had changed.
08:43 - That first was cancer
08:47 - stage three ovarian cancer at age 30.
08:51 - Overnight I went from trying to get pregnant to being told
08:55 - this was my last chance to preserve my fertility before treatment began.
09:00 - I moved immediately into
09:02 - a fertility preservation cycle because there was no time to wait.
09:05 - That window is incredibly small, and if you miss it, it's gone.
09:09 - And then treatment started.
09:11 - Months of chemotherapy, a major surgery, and the loss of my remaining ovary.
09:16 - Even after that treatment continued.
09:20 - Of everything cancer took for me.
09:22 - The possibility of not being able to have my own family was the hardest part.
09:26 - Because you're not just fighting to stay alive.
09:29 - You're also trying to hold on
09:30 - to a version of your future that suddenly feels uncertain.
09:34 - Today I'm one year and eight months out from active treatment,
09:39 - and now I'm beginning to think about what building my family could look like
09:42 - with the options that fertility preservation gave me.
09:46 - I'm one of the lucky ones, but not everyone gets that chance.
09:51 - Many patients aren't referred in time.
09:53 - Many cannot access fertility specialist quickly enough,
09:57 - and many simply cannot afford it.
10:01 - I know firsthand how devastating this experiences,
10:05 - and I also know that access to fertility preservation
10:08 - is not guaranteed, especially here in Pennsylvania.
10:11 - We have to do better because no one should hear the word cancer
10:16 - and at the same time lose their chance at a future family
10:19 - simply because they did not have access to care in time.
10:23 - That is why this matters not just for me,
10:27 - but for every patient who will sit in that chair next.
10:37 - Move that bag. Is.
10:48 - Good morning, and thank you so much for the opportunity to speak today.
10:52 - My name is Lindsay Goldblatt, and I stand before you today in two roles
10:55 - as a physician and my second year of oncology fellowship training
10:59 - and as a patient
11:00 - whose life has been shaped by cancer long before I ever wore a white coat.
11:04 - Cancer has always been a part of my story.
11:06 - My grandmother died of ovarian cancer before I was born, and I watched my mom
11:11 - battle and survive breast cancer twice before I turned 18 at age 20.
11:15 - I learned that I carry the BRCA one mutation, the same mutation
11:19 - that was responsible for my parent, my grandmother, and my mother's diagnosis.
11:23 - That moment reframed my future almost instantly.
11:27 - I was faced with a series of deeply consequential decisions at a young age
11:31 - whether to undergo risk reducing mastectomy, when to remove my
11:35 - ovaries and accept premature menopause, and how to plan if
11:39 - and when I wanted to have children before making all of these decisions,
11:44 - all while pursuing a career in medicine.
11:47 - Among all of these decisions, fertility
11:49 - preservation was the most complex and the most difficult.
11:53 - It meant navigating insurance and ambiguity and prior authorizations,
11:58 - coordinating time sensitive care, undergoing daily hormone injections,
12:02 - managing a very physically demanding process with significant side effects.
12:07 - I also experienced complications from that
12:10 - that landed me in the hospital for a week.
12:13 - Now, as an oncologist, I see much.
12:16 - I see how much more urgent and constrained this becomes for patients
12:19 - newly diagnosed with cancer.
12:21 - We often need to start chemotherapy within two weeks,
12:24 - and many of these treatments carry significant risk of permanent infertility.
12:28 - So in this narrow window of time, we ask patients to complete fertility
12:32 - preservation before treatment begins.
12:34 - And yet, many patients never pursue it.
12:37 - Not because they don't want children, not because they don't value their future,
12:41 - and not even because they're intimidated
12:42 - by the physical demands and potential complications,
12:46 - but because of the financial barriers, which, ironically,
12:49 - is the one part of this process that we all have the power to change.
12:53 - Inconsistent insurance coverage, unclear approvals,
12:56 - out of pocket costs that can reach the tens of thousands of dollars,
13:00 - create obstacles at the exact moment patients are least able to navigate them.
13:05 - As a result,
13:06 - we see patients who survive cancer but later grieve the loss of a family.
13:10 - They were never given the fair chance to create.
13:13 - We celebrate survivorship, and rightly so,
13:16 - but survivorship must include the possibility of full life afterward.
13:20 - The ability to build a family should never depend on zip
13:23 - code, employer or financial privilege.
13:26 - I stand here today both as a physician advocating for my patients
13:30 - and as someone who understands personally the way of these decisions.
13:35 - I was fortunate, but many are not.
13:38 - They deserve better.
13:39 - And saving a patient's life should not cost them their chance to create one.
13:44 - I urge you to support this legislation that ensures comprehensive, timely
13:48 - and equitable insurance coverage for fertility
13:50 - preservations for patients facing treatments that threaten it.
13:54 - Thank you.
14:07 - Good morning.
14:08 - My name is doctor Sally Vitez and I am a double board
14:11 - certified Ob-Gyn and reproductive endocrinologist.
14:16 - I care for patients who are navigating fertility decisions.
14:20 - At the same time they are processing a cancer diagnosis.
14:25 - I meet patients at one of the most vulnerable moments of their lives,
14:30 - and what I see repeatedly is that the hardest part
14:34 - is not always the medicine, it's the gap around it.
14:38 - With modern medicine, we can save the patient's life in the cancer center.
14:43 - We can support fertility building in the fertility setting,
14:46 - but there is often a disconnect between those two points in care.
14:51 - Fertility preservation for patients facing cancer is time sensitive,
14:56 - and there is a narrow window between when treatment
14:59 - begins and intervention is still possible.
15:03 - Patients are trying to understand what is happening.
15:06 - What will treatment involve and what the next steps look like,
15:10 - often all at once.
15:12 - When fertility is introduced into that conversation, something changes.
15:18 - The discussion expands beyond diagnosis and treatment of cancer,
15:22 - and it includes the possibility, the possibility of life after cancer.
15:28 - And that moment. That moment matters.
15:32 - It allows patients to think about themselves
15:35 - not only as someone undergoing treatment,
15:38 - but as someone who will come through it.
15:41 - And that shift is often fragile, because very quickly
15:45 - the conversation turns to logistics, to coordination and financial limitations,
15:51 - rather than what that future could actually look like.
15:55 - When I sit with a young woman who has just been diagnosed with cancer
15:59 - and explained to her that we can freeze her eggs before treatment begins,
16:03 - I watch something shift in her eyes.
16:06 - She feels hope.
16:08 - Hope sometimes.
16:10 - For the first time since hearing her diagnosis for a life after cancer.
16:15 - And often I watch that hope collapse when she learns
16:19 - that her insurance will not cover it and she cannot afford it.
16:23 - From a clinical standpoint, fertility preservation is well established.
16:28 - It is part of how we counsel patients prior to treatment,
16:31 - and it is our standard of care.
16:34 - The challenge is not whether we can provide that care.
16:37 - It's whether patients can move from being informed and able to actually act.
16:42 - This is not a question of science.
16:45 - It's not a question of medicine.
16:46 - It is a question of access.
16:49 - We have the science.
16:51 - We have the protocols.
16:52 - But we have a system where too often dollars
16:56 - and cents determine whether a patient can access that care.
17:00 - And that is what needs to change. Thank you.
17:12 - Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
17:14 - My name is Doctor Nicole Marchetto and like Doctor Vitez,
17:18 - I am a double board certified gyn and reproductive endocrinology
17:23 - and infertility specialist at Shady Grove Fertility, a US fertility partner
17:28 - in Uncle Fertility.
17:29 - We operate on a timeline that most people cannot fathom.
17:33 - A patient is diagnosed with cancer and within 24 hours
17:36 - she is in my office, still processing the worst news of her life.
17:40 - And I must tell her that the very treatment designed to save her
17:43 - life may also take away the ability to have children.
17:46 - Within two weeks, we need to complete an egg retrieval before chemotherapy begins.
17:51 - There is no time to fundraise.
17:53 - There is no time to seek loan approval.
17:56 - There is no time to appeal.
17:58 - An insurance denial.
18:00 - Every day of delay is one day
18:02 - closer to treatment and a day further from parenthood.
18:06 - Cost should never be the reason a patient runs out of time.
18:10 - We tell our patients to be hopeful, to fight, to picture their future.
18:14 - But what kind of future are we offering when we save their life and strip away
18:18 - their chance to become a parent simply because their insurance says no?
18:23 - These patients are being asked to survive,
18:26 - and then they are told that the life waiting on the other side
18:29 - may not include the family they have always imagined.
18:32 - This is not a side effect of cancer.
18:34 - It is a side effect of policy.
18:37 - The science is ready.
18:38 - The protocols are ready.
18:40 - The patients are ready.
18:42 - It is the insurance companies that are holding us back.
18:45 - I've had the privilege of helping cancer survivors
18:47 - conceive and carry pregnancies after chemotherapy treatment,
18:51 - using the eggs that they have frozen before their world turns upside down.
18:55 - Those moments are why I went into medicine.
18:58 - But I have also sat with survivors
19:01 - who could not afford preservation prior to treatment, who completed treatment
19:05 - cancer free
19:06 - and are in remission, who then learned that they were permanently infertile
19:10 - and had not had the opportunity to freeze their eggs prior.
19:15 - Both outcomes happen in the same hospitals,
19:17 - in the same centers, with the same doctors using the same science.
19:21 - The only difference is money.
19:24 - This is not a medical failure.
19:25 - Rather a policy failure.
19:27 - We are looking for your help to change that.
19:30 - Thank you.
19:38 - So, as you can tell,
19:39 - there's a lot of passion behind Senate Bill 1315.
19:42 - And we are going to ask all of you to help us get it across the finish line.
19:46 - Because no person should ever have to decide
19:49 - between a future family and a cancer treatment.
19:53 - So I want to thank you all for coming today,
19:55 - and I want to thank these amazing women.
19:56 - So please, let's give them a round of applause.
20:01 - Thank you
20:02 - guys very.
20:05 - Thank you.