During the American Revolution, Lydia Darragh eavesdropped on British generals and snuck through army lines to pass information to American troops. Robert Fanelli, author of Lydia's Tale: The Mystery of Lydia Darragh, Irish Quaker, Patriot Spy, breaks down this legend and finds historical context to this piece of American mythology.
00:11 - Today we're speaking with Robert finale
00:13 - author of Lydia's tale the mystery of Lydia darragh.
00:18 - Irish quaker
00:19 - and patriots by
00:21 - now who is Lydia.
00:24 - Will you bearers a woman who lived in Philadelphia in the late eighteenth century
00:29 - when she was here during the American revolution.
00:32 - She was a quaker
00:34 - by birth
00:35 - she was from Dublin Ireland.
00:37 - She came over when she was about thirty with a couple of her kids and her husband.
00:42 - Because Philadelphia scene to
00:44 - offer.
00:46 - Great opportunities for the future and so
00:48 - she and her husband were living in the city.
00:51 - For a number of years before the revolution started
00:55 - and they had a shop
00:56 - where they sold tobacco and
00:59 - spirituous liquors
01:01 - there's a club dram shop
01:03 - and they and she also worked as a
01:06 - midwife and as a nurse
01:08 - and
01:09 - her husband worked as a schoolteacher.
01:13 - And what was Philadelphia like during the revolutionary time.
01:19 - Philadelphia was the largest
01:21 - English speaking city in north america
01:25 - in the later
01:26 - nineteenth or eighteenth century
01:28 - and it was
01:29 - the center of culture
01:32 - and political activity in the American.
01:35 - Colonies the American English colonies
01:38 - so it was a very active place
01:41 - probably about thirty five thousand people living in it.
01:45 - And when the British occupied Philadelphia how did the Lydia react.
01:52 - So
01:53 - In seventeen seventy seven
01:55 - the British launched a campaign to take Philadelphia
01:59 - the American capital
02:01 - and hopefully to defeat Washington's army.
02:05 - They were very successful throughout the year.
02:08 - Of
02:09 - The American army suffered a number of defeats and finally
02:12 - the British were able to march into Philadelphia
02:14 - in September of seventeen seventy seven
02:18 - and occupy the city
02:19 - many of the people fled
02:21 - but the quakers many of them stayed just because cause
02:25 - they were neutral they wanted to stay neutral in this conflict
02:29 - they didn't want to be involved in worldly affairs
02:32 - and they certainly didn't want to support war
02:34 - on either side
02:35 - that was a
02:37 - part of their peace testimony that they would stay away from war
02:41 - so when
02:41 - the British occupied the city.
02:45 - I imagine that
02:46 - the dara family were somewhat dismayed to have
02:49 - an army right there
02:51 - and they set up their headquarters directly across the street
02:55 - from the darras shop
02:57 - where they sold.
02:58 - Tobacco and then food and other numbers
03:01 - number of other things
03:02 - and so
03:03 - I'm not quite sure how they he reacted but they certainly had
03:06 - a
03:07 - Very strong British presence right there
03:09 - and the British needed room
03:12 - to manage their army and so they actually took over
03:15 - a room in the darras house I'm not sure that they were
03:19 - were
03:19 - too happy about that and we talked about quakers a few times what was
03:24 - their real impact
03:26 - in the revolutionary war were they purely against it standing out was there a divide.
03:34 - The quakers have.
03:36 - A number of important teachings
03:38 - one of them is
03:40 - a testimony against war and so when the revolution started to come about
03:46 - they didn't want to have anything to do with it
03:48 - they didn't want to support one side or the other
03:50 - and they
03:51 - exhorted their
03:53 - members
03:54 - to stay out of the fray.
03:58 - And Lydia's story begins when she overhears generals talking about military plans how
04:04 - did she find herself in this situation.
04:08 - So because she lived directly across the street from
04:11 - the fancy house that became the British headquarters.
04:14 - The British occupied.
04:17 - Part of her house and they held meetings there
04:19 - and
04:20 - in late.
04:22 - November early December of seventeen seventy seven.
04:26 - The American army was perched on a set of hills
04:28 - about fifteen miles at it's outside the city
04:31 - and they effectively were besieging the city
04:34 - they were preventing supplies from coming in
04:37 - and they were preventing the British army from marching out.
04:41 - So
04:42 - When the.
04:44 - General hal who led the British army
04:47 - decided that
04:48 - he needed to go out and and move them off the hills either
04:52 - to defeat them or to derive them away
04:55 - and he hoped to do that by.
04:57 - Having a
04:58 - the army secretly march out at night and surprise the Americans and hopefully
05:03 - destroy the os army
05:05 - so.
05:06 - People in the city were aware that something was going on because
05:10 - he can't just move an army of ten thousand men
05:13 - without preparing for it
05:14 - and people in the city saw these preparations going one
05:18 - Lydia darragh no doubt was aware that something was in the wind.
05:23 - One night
05:24 - the adjutant general the British army the guy who manages the army's business affairs
05:29 - came to her and said we're going to have a meeting in your house tonight
05:32 - and we want to make sure that you and your family are all in bed
05:36 - before we have this meeting
05:37 - so we don't want it disturbed
05:39 - and when we're done
05:40 - we'll
05:41 - come and knock on your door
05:43 - and a ask you to.
05:45 - Let us out put out the camp
05:46 - bulls lock up the door.
05:48 - So this raised her
05:50 - interest
05:51 - she was very curious what's
05:53 - going to be talked about at this meeting.
05:56 - One thing that you need to know is that she had a son.
06:00 - Who actually joined the American army and he was a lieutenant.
06:04 - In the American army out there on the white marsh hills
06:07 - and so
06:08 - was concerned about what it's going to happen to him
06:11 - and she was also concerned that if there was a major
06:13 - battle.
06:15 - That a lot of people would lose their lives
06:17 - and as a tenderhearted person
06:19 - she was a nurse and midwife.
06:22 - She
06:23 - hated the thought of
06:24 - bloodshed and if there was something that she could do to prevent it
06:27 - she wanted to do that.
06:29 - So.
06:31 - She eavesdropped on the meeting she slipped out of her bed.
06:35 - Made her way to the door of the room and listened in
06:38 - and she heard the orders being read for this secret night march
06:42 - that the British army was going to launch against
06:45 - the Americans in just a day or two's time.
06:50 - Hearing that.
06:51 - She went
06:52 - back to bed
06:53 - and pretended to be asleep and when they knocked on her door to wake her up
06:57 - she acted like she didn't hear them
06:59 - they had to knock three times
07:00 - to get her attention
07:02 - then she got up and let them out
07:04 - and then she spent a very difficult night.
07:07 - Because
07:08 - on the one hand she's not supposed to be involved in these worldly affairs
07:12 - or in military affairs
07:14 - but on the other hand she sees that there's an opportunity
07:17 - to prevent which he called the effusion of blood
07:20 - to stop a lot of bloodshed by preventing
07:23 - a surprise attack.
07:25 - So
07:26 - Through the night
07:27 - she listened internally.
07:29 - For the voice of god
07:31 - as quakers do
07:32 - so that she will understand what was the proper course of action
07:36 - and by morning she had decided that she needed to let the American army know
07:41 - so that they wouldn't be surprised they'd be prepared
07:43 - and maybe there wouldn't be a battle oh
07:45 - and how was the public opinion on Washington and his troops at this time was the
07:50 - public really supportive of their efforts.
07:55 - The American people
07:57 - by and large did support the revolution that they
08:00 - supported detaching themselves from britain because
08:04 - the British just weren't treating people fairly here
08:07 - and they were
08:08 - treading on people's liberties and so
08:11 - many Americans were
08:12 - upset about this
08:14 - they felt it was time
08:15 - for them to sever themselves from the British government
08:19 - they had been used to governing themselves for.
08:22 - Jackets
08:23 - pretty much the courts
08:25 - and the taxation system
08:28 - the militia
08:29 - everything everything that took place they took care of themselves
08:33 - they had their own
08:33 - self governance and so
08:35 - now they were about to make it real
08:37 - there were certainly some people many people who
08:39 - felt that they should retain their loyalty to England
08:43 - then there were a number of people like the
08:44 - quakers who just didn't want any parts of it
08:46 - they wanted to stay out of this
08:48 - mess.
08:50 - And were patriot spies common during this time.
08:56 - George Washington grew into the role of commander in chief of the American army
09:02 - but by the time of seventeen seventy seven he had been
09:04 - at it for two and a half years and he realized that
09:08 - espionage was a useful tool
09:10 - and so he cultivated spies
09:13 - of people who would give him information
09:16 - in the city of Philadelphia
09:18 - in other places
09:19 - and there were a few people who were actually.
09:24 - Had the role
09:25 - of espionage
09:27 - this was not Lydia darras role she came across this accidentally
09:32 - the the British occupied our house and when she realized that
09:36 - something was
09:37 - afoot.
09:39 - She took it on herself
09:40 - to spy on their meeting
09:42 - and then to
09:43 - take a very great personal risk
09:46 - to take action
09:47 - to bring that knowledge out to the Americans
09:49 - so that they could prevent this major battle
09:52 - from taking place.
09:54 - So Lydia finds his key information what's the next step she decides to do.
10:01 - So
10:02 - With the British army occupying the city of
10:04 - Philadelphia and the American army not very far away
10:08 - the population of Philadelphia area
10:11 - had more than doubled
10:13 - and
10:14 - there was a lot of disruption of agriculture as people joined the army
10:18 - as armies marched through fields
10:20 - and destroyed.
10:21 - Food
10:22 - crops
10:23 - so that the other side couldn't get them
10:25 - so people in Philadelphia
10:27 - where are hungry
10:28 - there was not much food coming into the city
10:31 - the Delaware river was blocked
10:34 - by fortifications of the Americans had put there
10:37 - and the British fleet couldn't really bring food up to the city
10:40 - they had to rely on the wh hinterlands Pennsylvania is
10:43 - very
10:44 - rich agricultural hinterlands to bring food in
10:46 - but the Americans were preventing that from happening.
10:49 - So the British would take care of their own they take
10:52 - care of their soldiers and feed them the best they could
10:55 - and the population of the city had to fend for themselves.
10:58 - So Lydia.
11:00 - Decided
11:01 - the that
11:02 - she would say that she was going out
11:05 - to buy flower
11:06 - for her family
11:07 - and she told her husbands
11:09 - that that's what she was going to do she did not tell him
11:13 - that she was going to take
11:14 - information out to the British
11:16 - I'm sorry to the Americans
11:17 - because he probably would have stopped her.
11:21 - So
11:22 - She said listen I need to go out and get some flower
11:25 - I'm gonna take bag with me
11:27 - I'll go out there to Frankfurt the old Swedish mill.
11:30 - It'll take me most of the day to get out there and I'll be back by by sundown
11:35 - and.
11:36 - What could he say
11:37 - off she went.
11:41 - And would there be any consequences to Lydia if
11:44 - her plan was found out.
11:48 - The consequences would be very serious the British did not like being spied on
11:52 - that unlike having their plans
11:54 - given to the enemy
11:56 - so at
11:57 - at a minimum they would have probably imprisoned her and her family but of the
12:03 - penalty for espionage
12:05 - was execution
12:06 - by anger usually
12:08 - now.
12:09 - I don't know that the British ever hung a woman during the American revolution
12:14 - but there could have been a first time
12:16 - so the risk
12:16 - was very real to her
12:18 - and she did not know that they what they would do that quarter.
12:23 - So all this is going through Lydia's mind as
12:26 - she's traversed sane at to find Washington's army.
12:30 - Who does she run entail.
12:33 - Though she went out the frankford not just because there was a mill there
12:37 - where she could
12:38 - plausibly get some flour
12:40 - but she also knew
12:41 - that there was an American patrol their American
12:44 - cavalry patrol under a man that she knew
12:47 - captain Charles cray of the second continental light dragoons ns
12:53 - and he was out there with a small group of men
12:55 - and they would.
12:57 - Ride around in the
12:58 - in the Frankfurt area to try to keep tabs
13:01 - on what the British were doing
13:03 - so she knew that by going out there if she
13:06 - left the mill
13:07 - and wandered around a little bit
13:09 - pretty soon she would probably come across
13:11 - some Americans and she could.
13:13 - Communicate with the Charles Craig about what she knew.
13:19 - And how did he react to the news.
13:24 - When she saw him
13:25 - he said to her.
13:27 - Masses dara what are you doing out here.
13:30 - This is
13:30 - pretty far from home
13:32 - and
13:33 - and she said well.
13:35 - Could you dismount
13:36 - and walk with me for a moment.
13:39 - So he got off his horse and the two of them walked
13:41 - aside from his tour groups
13:43 - and she conveyed to him
13:46 - her message
13:47 - the secret that she had learned
13:49 - about
13:50 - who was coming when they were coming and how many troops were coming
13:54 - and
13:55 - he took that very seriously he thanked her
13:57 - and rode off to headquarters
14:00 - to warn the Americans with the British
14:02 - are on their way.
14:05 - But then she went and
14:07 - back to the mill.
14:08 - Picked up her bag
14:10 - twenty eight pounds of flour
14:12 - and marched.
14:14 - Five to six miles back to her house
14:17 - on a cold wintery afternoon
14:20 - with this heavy load
14:22 - to try to make it clear to anybody was watching
14:25 - that she was just an an innocent mission.
14:29 - So Lydia
14:30 - has succeeded in her mission she comes back home
14:34 - how is life
14:35 - like when her when she gets back she has to act like nothing happened.
14:41 - Exactly and so she couldn't tell anybody her secret for fear it would get out
14:45 - she didn't even tell her husband her husband was a
14:48 - known to be a bit of a talkative man so she was very carefully conceal this
14:52 - from him
14:53 - from her family
14:54 - from her neighbors from everybody
14:56 - and have
14:57 - about
14:58 - four days later the British army marched back into town
15:02 - then
15:02 - the headquarters staff marched right back
15:05 - for the house across the street
15:07 - possibly they were
15:08 - meeting in her room again
15:10 - and she just kept her mouth shut she didn't want to
15:12 - reveal anything
15:14 - but.
15:16 - The British felt that somehow the word had gotten out.
15:19 - Somehow
15:21 - the Americans were aware of their plan and were ready for them
15:24 - and they wanted to know why.
15:27 - So the adjutant general came to her one evening
15:31 - and said mrs dara I'd like to speak with you open
15:34 - up the room where we meet and she went up there with him
15:38 - and he asked her some questions.
15:40 - He wanted to know was anybody
15:43 - in your family awake
15:45 - while we were having this meeting
15:47 - and she said
15:48 - will know I put everybody to bed by eight o'clock
15:51 - and they said well I know you are asleep because
15:53 - we had to knock three times to wake you up
15:56 - and she didn't say anything
15:58 - and he said well I just don't see
16:00 - how the Americans could have gotten word of what we were doing.
16:04 - Unless the walls had ears.
16:07 - She just.
16:08 - Led him to Roy's own conclusions
16:10 - and didn't say anything and.
16:12 - He walked
16:13 - he walked out
16:15 - laughter and they never did find out what she did
16:18 - they were in the city for ten months and it probably wasn't until they
16:22 - left in June of seventeen seventy eight
16:25 - that she felt comfortable even tell eyeing her husband what had happened.
16:30 - And then Lydia leave a journal or any writings of her story how did this
16:35 - event
16:36 - become publicized.
16:40 - We have.
16:41 - Two.
16:43 - Signatures by Lydia darragh forwards Lydia darragh twice
16:47 - that's it.
16:48 - She left
16:49 - no written record
16:50 - of any kind.
16:53 - Even though
16:54 - the quakers were graded
16:55 - a riveting diaries and journals
16:57 - she never did if she did
16:59 - anything that she wrote was lost
17:01 - but she told her story to her family and to her friends.
17:05 - She told them what had happened that night
17:07 - and what had happened
17:09 - the next day
17:10 - and what the outcome was
17:12 - and
17:12 - she he was a very
17:14 - intelligent and educated woman
17:16 - and a bit of a rock and tour she liked to talk to people
17:20 - and she.
17:23 - Crafted
17:24 - are really a well knitted story
17:27 - it it
17:28 - it makes good sense
17:30 - the way that she told she was very artful and the way she told it
17:33 - and that way people could remember it
17:35 - that made an impression on people
17:37 - and some people did remember it and even after her passing
17:40 - and seventeen eighty nine
17:42 - people in Philadelphia villa
17:43 - especially quakers
17:44 - continued to tell this story
17:46 - now and your buck Lydia's tales
17:49 - you mention that there's two versions of Lydia would you like to go in about that.
17:54 - Well
17:55 - I really am talking about the difference between Lydia
17:58 - the woman that nobody really knows very much about
18:02 - and Lydia's tale Lydia's story
18:04 - which people did know
18:06 - so I wanted to write about both things both about
18:09 - who Lydia darragh really was if we could find out
18:12 - and.
18:14 - What happened with her story how did he grow out of it change
18:17 - had it morphed over the years to become
18:20 - a popular piece of American mythology
18:23 - so I wrote about both things.
18:27 - And how do you properly explain historical events when they were so long ago and
18:32 - there's not pure writing on them.
18:36 - So in understanding her Lydia darragh was I had to consult numerous
18:41 - little
18:42 - historical records
18:44 - and there would be a little piece of information
18:46 - here a little piece of information there
18:49 - and I saw these things out.
18:51 - Over a period of about six years
18:54 - and knitted them together
18:56 - to get an idea of who she was who were finally was
18:59 - what her middle you is like what her neighbors and her friends were like
19:03 - and what it was like for her to live in Philadelphia at that time.
19:10 - Were there any major differences in betweens one
19:13 - person's retelling of the story versus another.
19:17 - So.
19:19 - When
19:20 - the public learned about Lydia
19:22 - tail it was fifty years after the event
19:25 - it wasn't until eighteen twenty seven
19:28 - that someone actually published her story
19:31 - a man named
19:32 - Robert Walsh.
19:34 - He got the story.
19:37 - From.
19:39 - The mother of a friend of his.
19:41 - A woman named Hannah Haines
19:44 - and he happened to be at their house in here and heard them talking about
19:48 - what Lydia dara had done during the revolution
19:51 - and he thought well this is a great story I've got to get this
19:54 - and so he asked her to write it down for him
19:56 - and she did and he took and published it.
19:59 - Up to that point nobody except
20:01 - some folks in Philadelphia ap.
20:04 - Excuse me we're aware
20:05 - that this had taken place.
20:09 - Other people had heard the story from
20:11 - Hannah Haines as well John.
20:14 - Watson John fanning Watson being one of them and he wrote about it just
20:18 - two years later
20:19 - and so within
20:20 - a couple of years
20:21 - there were several publications
20:23 - that just told Lydia's story as it was.
20:28 - A long time passes
20:30 - people know the story people talk about it
20:32 - people
20:33 - do you
20:34 - teach their children about it.
20:37 - But in the eighteen nineties
20:40 - another historian whose name was Derrick
20:42 - Henry Derrick very much like dara
20:45 - was interested in her story
20:47 - probably because of the similarity of their names
20:49 - and he decided to a little research and he
20:52 - tracked down
20:53 - her descendants
20:54 - and he
20:55 - got the story from them
20:57 - what they told that they continued to tell
21:00 - and it was very very close to the story that
21:02 - Lydia darragh told but there were some differences
21:06 - and.
21:07 - It's a little difficult to know whether she went out
21:10 - for flour as the Hannah Haines version tells us
21:14 - or whether she told the people
21:16 - at the gates that she was going out
21:18 - to visit her children
21:19 - because he had young children who were staying outside the city
21:23 - to stay out of harm's way and so we don't really know for sure
21:26 - which those things was true.
21:30 - And when did you first learn about Lydia and her story.
21:36 - Because I grew up
21:38 - and live on the site of the battle of edge hill which was
21:43 - which took place on December seventh seventeen seventy seven
21:46 - always been interested in that and
21:48 - over the years I've done a lot of research
21:51 - on it
21:52 - and one of the things that I heard early on
21:54 - was as Lydia's tailed the original version of Lydia's story that she
21:59 - warned the
22:00 - Americans so that the British army could not surprise them
22:04 - and I asked myself well.
22:06 - Interesting story as a trope
22:08 - and I
22:10 - started to dig into it and I I've just got more and more interested
22:14 - in.
22:15 - In finding the original roots of the story which took some doing
22:19 - and and and then
22:21 - trying to verify
22:22 - what she said was was she said true could that really have happened
22:26 - as it turns out almost everything
22:28 - that she talked about
22:30 - his verifiable even though there are not a lot of corroborating
22:34 - records that exist today
22:36 - but you can easily tell
22:38 - that this this is real stuff
22:40 - nobody knew about Charles Craig the man that she gave the information to
22:45 - he had died.
22:47 - Just a couple of years afterward
22:49 - and
22:50 - people did not
22:51 - really know his name
22:53 - they knew his brother's name they thought maybe
22:55 - it was his brother that she told the the the
22:58 - the secret to.
23:01 - So
23:02 - Just the fact that she he said it was.
23:06 - Captain.
23:07 - Craig
23:08 - gave
23:09 - a clue there
23:11 - that that she was telling the truth cause nobody else really knew that the sky was
23:14 - out there around Frankfurt at the time.
23:18 - And after all your research what's your major takeaways from this moment of history.
23:25 - What
23:26 - dara was an interesting person who is a for
23:29 - civil.
23:30 - Although she didn't leave
23:32 - any writing
23:33 - about herself.
23:34 - She was well off enough that there were enough records about her
23:38 - that you could learn
23:40 - something about her background
23:41 - and the fact that she was a quaker was a big help
23:44 - because the quakers kept very careful records
23:46 - much more careful than almost anybody else
23:49 - at the time
23:50 - very detailed records and so
23:52 - there was a lot of little bits of information where we could learn things about her.
23:58 - So I just
23:59 - do
24:00 - Got more and more interested in what kind of a person she was
24:03 - she was a nurse who was a midwife she was a shopkeeper
24:06 - she was a very faithful quaker
24:09 - and she was a patriot
24:11 - of gradually.
24:13 - As
24:13 - The revolution started to take place she and her family.
24:17 - Came down on the side of
24:20 - the image Oregon cause
24:21 - and they decided that they would support that
24:24 - even at risk to themselves
24:26 - and the even at risk to their
24:29 - place
24:30 - and standing in the quaker community
24:32 - and
24:33 - Lydia
24:34 - and her
24:35 - one daughter and one of her sons were all disowned
24:38 - by the quakers
24:39 - and the
24:40 - the the sun because of his involvement with the army
24:43 - the daughter because she married at a meeting and liddy herself.
24:48 - Ostensibly because.
24:51 - She
24:51 - was not attending the quaker meetings as she should
24:55 - but the the friends the quakers knew that she was actually.
25:00 - Attending meetings of a breakaway quaker group.
25:03 - That breakaway quaker group known as the freak quakers.
25:07 - Got together because so many people had been.
25:12 - Read out of meeting.
25:14 - Because of their support for the revolution
25:16 - and they founded their own version of quakerism
25:18 - when the main quaker meeting got wind of this
25:22 - they and they.
25:24 - Basically.
25:26 - Read her out of the meeting.
25:29 - We've been speaking with Robert finale
25:31 - author of Lydia's tale the mystery of Lydia darragh Irish quaker patriot spy
25:37 - thank you for your time.
25:39 - Thank you.
25:45 - I.