PCNTV
Sign In Home Live Politics History 250th Sports Search Shop Donate Subscribe

ADVERTISEMENT
The Carlisle Theatre, History & Culture Shorts

(2025) Opened in May 1939 as the Comerford Theatre, this Carlisle landmark quickly became a cultural hub, drawing audiences for plays, films, and tourism. Now known as the Carlisle Theatre, it remains an active venue, continuing to entertain the community. Join Karl Qualls as he walks us through this historic theatre.

Caption Text Below:    

00:09 - Hi, I'm Carson Devore, and today we're at the Carlyle Theater.

00:12 - Established in 1939.

00:14 - This theater has a ton of history.

00:16 - And today we're going to talk about.

00:26 - Our guest today is Carl Claus.

00:28 - He's the department chair of history at Dickinson College.

00:30 - Welcome to your first piece.

00:33 - And we're here inside the lobby of the Carlyle Theater.

00:35 - Was it always known as the Carlyle Theater?

00:37 - No. It started in May 1939.

00:39 - It opened at the Comerford Theater, and it showed films almost exclusively.

00:44 - In 1950, it was resold.

00:45 - And that's when it became the Carlyle Theater.

00:48 - If you look on the outside, there's a very large facade,

00:51 - kind of a salmon color of some very problematic tiles.

00:55 - It's a very difficult tile, apparently, to to work with.

00:59 - And so the paint peels off, fairly regularly.

01:03 - And so that's going to be refurbished

01:04 - in the coming years, along with a beautiful marquee out front.

01:08 - The marquee is definitely, a product of its age.

01:11 - It shows the late Art Deco style.

01:14 - It's had an unfortunate history because until, the last 20 years

01:18 - or so now, we have handicapped parking under the marquee.

01:21 - Trucks would try to park there.

01:22 - It would hit the marquee, dented, and have to be refurbished.

01:25 - And a very costly refurbished one at that.

01:28 - The lobby you see around you is changed colors.

01:31 - The original color scheme was blue, gold and silver,

01:34 - which was very much in, in the spirit of the times of the late

01:38 - Art Deco, gold was almost always part of Art Deco coloring as well.

01:43 - Silver and black.

01:44 - In 1951, probably the biggest event at the Carlyle Theater,

01:47 - and that was the premiere of Jim Thorpe.

01:49 - All-American Jim Thorpe had been a student at the Carlisle Indian

01:52 - Industrial School, in the early part of the century,

01:55 - and we had the world premiere of the film here with lots of dignitaries on hand.

02:00 - So the 1950s was both the biggest moment of the Carlisle Theater at that point,

02:04 - but it's also the beginning of a fairly long decline as televisions came

02:08 - into people's homes, theaters, cinemas began

02:11 - to, slowly decline in the 1970s

02:15 - when the big cineplex was with maybe 3 or 5 screens came about.

02:19 - That really hurt.

02:20 - And in 1976,

02:21 - the theater had to close for several weeks because of financial problems.

02:25 - When a reopened, it had a decade of still struggling from one year to the next

02:29 - until it finally closed for what it looked like forever in 1986.

02:33 - Several of the downtown merchants were very concerned about losing the jewel

02:37 - of, Carlisle here in central, and in the center of the town.

02:42 - And so they got together to start thinking about what can be done.

02:44 - And for the next several years, they began to raise money and think about ideas.

02:49 - And then when the Carlisle theater group that then became the Carlisle

02:52 - Regional Performing Arts Center, purchased the building for $165,000,

02:57 - the theater reopened not just as a cinema, although films are present,

03:02 - but also as a concert venue, and that was one of the big moneymakers

03:06 - in the early 1990s.

03:08 - Now it has its own, in-house theater

03:10 - troupe called The Players on High that do musical and plays.

03:13 - It has summer workshops for children, and it also puts on concerts

03:17 - for for band, local bands, but also tribute bands and things

03:21 - like that from across the country.

03:23 - You had your students create

03:24 - these posters that tell the history of the Carlisle Theater.

03:27 - What's some of the history that they shared?

03:29 - We looked at everything basically from the last 36 years.

03:33 - We unfortunately don't have any, information

03:37 - except newspaper articles from the first 50 years of the theater,

03:40 - because when it closed in 1986, those materials just disappeared.

03:44 - But I know the executive director actually, Arts fairly well.

03:49 - And, we found boxes and boxes of materials in the basement.

03:52 - And so in the summer of 2003, with one of my students, Emma Rodriguez,

03:57 - we took those boxes and made them into an archive.

04:00 - And then in the fall of 2003, we have a course called Historical Methodology.

04:06 - And my sophomore students then use that archive that Emma and I put together

04:10 - to begin to tell the story of the last 35 years or so of the Carlisle Theater.

04:14 - And so what you can see now in the lobby is some of those, materials.

04:19 - So they talk about some of the volunteers that made this theater happen.

04:25 - And it's, removing Asian revitalization in the early 1990s.

04:30 - Volunteers make this thing run.

04:32 - There's only a few full time paid employees at the theater.

04:35 - So if it weren't for volunteers and also donors, the theater wouldn't happen.

04:40 - What you can also see on some of the walls is discussion

04:43 - of the renovations, especially the big 1 in 1997,

04:47 - but also some of the groups that work in here.

04:49 - Part of the display is about the cubicles or as we know it, the cube.

04:54 - In 1997, Dickinson and the theater collaborated

04:58 - to create an upstairs black box theater that the college has a long term lease on

05:03 - that allows our students groups to do, smaller productions,

05:08 - but also is a consistent revenue stream for the theater.

05:12 - The theater is much bigger than the auditorium and the lobby that you see now.

05:16 - Properties to one side are also retail spaces, the first one

05:19 - being the Singer Sewing Machine Company and Toby's Dress Shop.

05:23 - But it's been restaurants and all kinds of other things over the years.

05:26 - There's also display in here students were obviously fascinated about,

05:30 - what kind of performances were being put on in the 1990s and early 2000.

05:35 - And so they went through and they looked at revenue and ticket sales

05:37 - and did top ten lists for movies and for concert performances.

05:42 - And any of you fans of, Kevin Bacon,

05:45 - the Bacon Brothers performed here many times, and three, I think of the top

05:49 - ten shows in that first 20 years were the Bacon Brothers present, performances.

05:54 - But they also had, B.B.

05:55 - King, the Letterman Kingston Trios, and of course,

05:59 - Celtic groups do particularly well here at the Carlyle Theater.

06:02 - Was there any other theaters in existence whenever the Carlyle Theater opened?

06:06 - Yeah, the Carlyle Theater was one of three at the time, but it's one of a kind,

06:09 - really, to my knowledge, in the midstate and certainly in Carlisle.

06:13 - One, it's the beautiful art Deco that just can't be done.

06:16 - It's way too expensive to produce something like that today,

06:19 - but also just the size and the scope.

06:21 - There's this is by far the largest building.

06:24 - It was the largest construction project in central Pennsylvania.

06:27 - And when it opened in 1939, the auditorium that will be going into,

06:31 - shortly is cavernous.

06:34 - We just don't see places like that in the midstate.

06:37 - And that really allows the Carlisle Theater to do a lot of things

06:40 - that others don't, to put on live theater concerts and seat

06:44 - almost a thousand people.

06:45 - So it it's, it's importance to the community,

06:50 - as a resource for entertainment, but also the knock on effects that it has

06:55 - for local merchants when there's a show in the evening, like school of Rock,

06:58 - which is going to be performed, we, we have other restaurants.

07:01 - If people are coming from our show, they might go to the Comfort Suites

07:05 - and have a hotel room for the night.

07:07 - So there's, there's an economic vitality that comes from the theater

07:11 - that goes beyond the theater.

07:12 - It really stretches into the rest of the Carlisle as well.

07:15 - Before we enter the theater, my favorite part of any movie

07:18 - theater is the concession stand.

07:20 - Did they have one in the early years of the theater?

07:22 - Well, unfortunately, we don't have records from the first 50 years of the theater,

07:25 - but we do from it's reopening in 93 and a little bit before that.

07:29 - So you can see you have

07:30 - all the regular concessions, your sodas, your candies and wonderful fresh popcorn.

07:34 - They pop for every show.

07:37 - Interestingly, when they were beginning to think about the reopening

07:40 - in the early 90s, many of the board members were arguing

07:43 - about whether they should allow concessions.

07:44 - They're worried about popcorn all over the floor.

07:46 - The spilling of the soda, chewing gum was a big issue,

07:50 - not wanting it to be stuck under seats and whatnot.

07:52 - But as you see, they've kind of overcome that and realize that, everybody wants

07:56 - a little popcorn, a soda, maybe some candy when they come see a controversial.

08:10 - So now we're in the actual auditorium itself.

08:13 - Tell us, what would you see if you came here today?

08:15 - Well, you see, we've got, about 900, just over 900 seats.

08:18 - So full capacity for bigger concerts.

08:22 - We also have a, stage in front of us where the concerts would be held.

08:27 - They also have mainstage productions.

08:29 - And there's also a, big video screen up there for their,

08:32 - film series of the Hollywood on High series.

08:35 - So there's all kinds of events in here as well as, civic events can talk.

08:38 - Carlisle, has events in here.

08:41 - The Carlisle band, town band has events in here.

08:44 - So it's a really diversified set of, entertainment, for visitors.

08:49 - And along the back here, we see a balcony.

08:51 - What was that for?

08:53 - So the balcony, originally, when it opened in May 1939,

08:56 - was for the African-American population.

08:58 - It was unfortunately segregated into 1961.

09:02 - So any African-American residents or viewers would have to sit in the balcony

09:06 - where they also had their own, restroom and water fountain.

09:10 - And then after 1961, it was supposed to be integrated.

09:13 - And the balcony is now, for, for anyone's use,

09:17 - one of the most notable features when you walk in the auditorium

09:20 - is this stage that we're standing on.

09:22 - And back in 1939, it was the Comerford Theater.

09:25 - Did it still look the same? No. Very different.

09:27 - The Comerford was one of three cinemas here within a block, in central Carlyle.

09:33 - And so it was mostly just showing movies.

09:35 - So they didn't need a big stage.

09:36 - When it became the Carlyle Theater in 1950, it was still a cinema.

09:41 - But after it reopened in the early 90s, they started wanting to do

09:44 - more stage productions.

09:46 - So the big renovation in 1997 increased the size of the stage.

09:51 - So you could have, in-house plays, in-house musicals,

09:55 - but also larger band concerts because in the very early days

09:58 - after it reopened,

09:59 - a lot of the concerts in here would be taking place

10:01 - outside of the theater to raise money for the theater.

10:04 - And so if we look at the first 20 years of of concerts after the the theater

10:09 - reopened in 1993, only one of those top ten shows actually happened in the 1990s.

10:15 - It was only after 1997 you could have a full stage production,

10:18 - lighting and better music.

10:20 - And so this stage is only,

10:22 - a little less than 30 years old in this kind of size and configuration.

10:27 - And surrounding

10:28 - the stage are these pretty pieces of wall art.

10:31 - Is that considered Art Deco as well?

10:33 - Yes. So just like we were saying earlier, we have these different elements

10:37 - that were preserved throughout the now 86 years of the theater's history

10:42 - to try to trace it back to its 1939 origins,

10:45 - when it was known as the Jewel of Carlisle,

10:46 - because this late Art Deco style was a very elaborate style.

10:51 - So, Carl, we've been talking a lot about the Carlisle Theater's history,

10:54 - but let's talk about it today.

10:55 - What are some of the most popular shows or reasons that people come here?

10:59 - Concerts probably sell the most tickets.

11:01 - Almost this entire, auditorium would be filled on a concert.

11:05 - And those are things like tribute bands for LED Zeppelin or the Beatles or AC,

11:09 - DC or something like that, or a country act.

11:12 - But also local artists, will perform in here as well,

11:14 - so they get a lot of friends and family, that come in as well.

11:18 - Other shows that are popular.

11:19 - Some of the musicals are really popular.

11:21 - School of Rock is opening in about a week and a half

11:23 - from the time we're filming that anything that has kind of a,

11:26 - kids component will bring in, adults, plus kids

11:29 - plus a lot of the actors are kids, so their families will come.

11:31 - And so those are quite popular.

11:33 - Some of that have been, very consistently popular over the last 30 years

11:37 - is Rocky Horror Picture Show and those kind of cult classics.

11:40 - And then also anything that's Celtic, Celtic concerts,

11:44 - so particularly, well, in the midstate.

11:47 - So those are two things, that have shown

11:50 - a great deal of, vitality over the last 35 years.

11:53 - Personally, I'm a fan of Rocky Horror Picture Show,

11:55 - so I can totally see that being a thing here.

11:57 - Do you have any tips for our audience

11:58 - if they want to come in to the crawl out here, what would you suggest?

12:02 - Well, if you come for Rocky Horror,

12:03 - you don't have to bring your own things to throw.

12:05 - You can buy goodie bags in the lobby and you'll be all set

12:07 - for the stage performance.

12:08 - If you don't know how Rocky Horror Picture Show, goes,

12:11 - come to a performance here. Other things to check out.

12:14 - Carlisle theater.org.

12:15 - That's theater with a t r e instead of tr Carlisle theater.org.

12:19 - You can look at their, shows in the Hollywood on High film series.

12:24 - You can look at their upcoming concerts.

12:26 - You can look at the players on high, their in-house, acting troupe.

12:30 - But you can also push the donate button.

12:32 - There are about $150,000 short of to, $2.5 million

12:37 - grant to refurbish this, get new seats, lighting,

12:41 - repair the roof, Hvac, kind of all those things

12:44 - that we don't necessarily see, but really modernizing it to bring the 1930s

12:49 - grandeur into the 21st century technology.

12:52 - Well, thank you very much for being here today.

12:55 - My pleasure.

12:55 - Thank you guys so much for watching PCN talk about the history of the

12:59 - Carlisle Theater. You.


Related Video
Union Retreat Fighting in the Streets Gettysburg Battlewalk

Union Retreat: Fighting in the Streets, Gettysburg Battlewalk

George Gordon Meade Civil War Institute

George Gordon Meade, Civil War Institute

Venango County Historical Society History  Culture

Venango County Historical Society, History & Culture