00:02 - WELCOME TO

00:07 - IN COURT. IT'S MY FIRST

00:08 - OPPORTUNITY TO HEAR AS THE

00:11 - CHIEF JUSTICE WANT TO THANK ALL

00:13 - MY CALL WE'VE BEEN SO

00:15 - GRACIOUS IN

00:16 - YOU AND THEN OBVIOUSLY

00:19 - ESPECIALLY WANT TO THANK MY

00:21 - DEAR FRIEND AND COLLEAGUE.

00:23 - SAILOR THE REMAINS A VALUABLE

00:26 - MEMBER

00:26 - FOR HIM. THE EERIE PLACE FOR

00:29 - THE MEDIA IS THE VISOR IN

00:31 - COLLEGE AND AND I IN

00:34 - IN SHOWS THE CAUSE

00:36 - IF YOU THE ONE YEAR WE OUGHT TO

00:43 - WHERE ME

00:46 - I LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING THE

00:48 - BACK END. IT WILL BE

00:51 - IN THIS SAME DIRECTION TO

00:53 - KEEP THE BAYLOR LEAD TO A FINE

00:55 - FOR THAT I'M PROUD TO BE A

00:56 - MEMBER OF THE NOW TO BE THE

00:57 - KEY. OUR FIRST

01:02 - IT IS I DO SO OR AT FIRST IS

01:05 - THE EURO WORKERS COMPENSATION.

01:07 - AND IT POSED

01:08 - TO ME IN A ROW IT'S HE WHO

01:11 - ENTERED THE BACK IT.

01:13 - I THINK IF YOU WERE RIGHT.

01:16 - THE COUNCIL WHICH IS HEADED BY

01:18 - MISS APPREHEND. CERTAINLY THAT

01:21 - WOULD BE IN ALL

01:21 - OF US. IN 2,400 STRONG SUFFERED

01:25 - A WORKPLACE INJURY. AFTER WHICH

01:28 - HE WAS

01:28 - THE THIS SCRIBE MEDICATION FOR

01:31 - TO DISPENSE BY A PHARMACY WHICH

01:33 - WOULD BE A TELE HERE

01:35 - ITALY REVIEW WITH THE WORKERS

01:38 - COMPENSATION AND WITH THE

01:40 - PHARMACY. IT'S NOT PERMITTED TO

01:43 - CHANGE. IT WAS THE TURN

01:45 - CLAIMANTS RELEVANT MEDICAL

01:46 - TREATMENT. IT INCLUDES THE

01:48 - FIFTY-FIFTY WE'RE NOT

01:50 - REASONABLE OR NECESSARY.

01:53 - THE COMMONWEALTH COURT UPHELD

01:55 - THAT PROSPECTIVELY ONLY NOR THE

01:59 - PROVIDERS SUCH AS THIS PHARMACY

02:01 - SHOULD BE AFFORDED NOTICE AND

02:02 - THE OPPORTUNITY TO ESTABLISH

02:06 - THIS EVENING

02:07 - IN POINT OF THE PERMANENT

02:08 - MEDICAL TREATMENT IS NECESSARY

02:10 - FOR

02:11 - A REASON THEY DID BRADLEY BIG

02:13 - ISSUE IN A STATE WHERE THE

02:14 - PRICES ARE HAS BEEN ON TREATING

02:16 - PROVIDERS WHICH IS

02:17 - THE PHARMACY. IF I'M READING

02:20 - THIS IN YOU KNOW THERE'S A NEW

02:21 - U.

02:22 - THIS COURT TO WORK IS DONE.

02:33 - BEFORE YOU FOR A REPRESENT BEEN

02:35 - REPRESENTS THE WORKERS

02:36 - COMPENSATION BUREAU AND THE

02:37 - OTHER. I MEAN SURE ARE.

02:41 - YEAH, I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE GOING

02:42 - TO DIVIDE YOUR TIME. THE POLICE

02:44 - SAID IN ADVANCE THAT WE HAVE.

02:47 - TO THE DEFERRED TO IN THE PAST

02:48 - BEEN NO PILING ON

02:53 - IF WE ASK THE QUESTION.

02:55 - THE FIRST TO YOU TO ARGUE THAT

02:57 - IS BETTER

02:57 - ADDRESSED THAT FEEL FREE TO

02:59 - TELL US VOTING EVERY

03:01 - WHOEVER WOULD ARGUE SECOND WILL

03:03 - REMEMBER TO GET

03:04 - IT WITHOUT IF YOU'RE SIPPING

03:07 - OVER EACH OTHER AT THIS.

03:09 - I WILL RESPECT TO STOP.

03:12 - WHOEVER IS ARGUING FOR SLEEPING

03:13 - IN HIS CELL 5 MADE SOME MISTAKE

03:15 - WITH THE SNOW AND PROCEED.

03:17 - THE 2 MINUTES, IT THERE.

03:19 - MUCH WE WILL TRY VERY HARD TO

03:21 - NOT INTERRUPT.

03:25 - MY NAME IS KELLY SMITH AND I

03:26 - REPRESENT THE DEPARTMENT OF

03:27 - LABOR AND INDUSTRY AND IS 0

03:29 - WORKERS COMPENSATION THIS

03:30 - MATTER.

03:31 - I WILL ADDRESS YOUR QUESTIONS

03:33 - REGARDING SEPARATION OF POWER.

03:34 - THE CONSISTENCY OF THE

03:36 - DEPARTMENT'S REGULATIONS YES,

03:38 - AND MY COLLEAGUE MISTER MCCOY.

03:40 - WE'LL ADDRESS QUESTIONS

03:41 - REGARDING THE IMPACT OF THE

03:43 - HOLY ON INSURANCE CARRIERS THIS

03:45 - IS.

03:46 - THE PENNSYLVANIA WORKERS

03:48 - COMPENSATION ACT EXISTS TO

03:49 - COMPENSATE INJURED WORKERS FOR

03:51 - WEIGHT LOSS AND MEDICAL

03:53 - EXPENSES COM FIREWORK-RELATED

03:54 - INJURIES. IT DOES

03:56 - NOT EXIST. FOR THE

03:57 - BENEFIT FOR TO COURT TO CREATE

04:00 - A RISK FREE BUSINESS MODEL FOR

04:02 - PHARMACIES AND OTHER NON

04:03 - TREATING AND PEACE. THAT'S

04:05 - SIMPLY FILL THE ORDER THE

04:06 - TREATING PHYSICIAN.

04:11 - WITH A ONE SENTENCE HOLDING

04:13 - ON THE UTILIZATION REVIEW

04:15 - PROCESS A PROCESS THAT WAS NOT

04:16 - EVEN BEFORE IT.

04:18 - THE CASE BEFORE COMMONWEALTH

04:19 - COURT WAS A MEDICAL FEAR OF YOU

04:24 - IN THAT ONE SENTENCE THE

04:26 - COURT SIGNIFICANTLY ALTERED THE

04:27 - LEGISLATIVE SCHEME CREATED BY

04:29 - THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THE QUICK

04:31 - ACTION ON MATCHING THAT'S KINGS

04:33 - A VIOLATION OF THE SEPARATION

04:34 - OF POWERS DOCTRINE THAT CAN

04:35 - ONLY STAND IF IT IS NECESSARY

04:37 - TO REMEDY THE PROCESS VIOLATION.

04:40 - HERE THERE IS NO DUE PROCESS

04:41 - VIOLATION REPORT WAS WRONG.

04:44 - WE KNOW THAT BECAUSE THE UNITED

04:46 - STATES SUPREME COURT IN THE

04:48 - SOLID CASE INTERPRETING THIS

04:50 - PRECISE SECTION. THE

04:52 - PENNSYLVANIA WORKERS

04:53 - COMPENSATION ACT. HOW THAT

04:55 - THERE CANNOT BE IN A TITLE

04:56 - MEANT MEDICAL PAYMENT FOR

04:58 - MEDICAL BENEFITS.

04:59 - UNLESS AND UNTIL NOW THE

05:01 - TREATMENT IS DETERMINED TO BE

05:02 - REASONABLE

05:03 - AND NECESSARY THAT IS WHAT THE

05:05 - UTILIZATION OF THE PROCESS OF

05:07 - DRESSES. BY

05:08 - CREATING A THE RIGHT TO

05:10 - INTERVENE IN THOSE PROCEEDINGS.

05:13 - A COURT HAS

05:14 - SIGNIFICANTLY UPSET A

05:16 - COMPREHENSIVE LEGISLATIVE

05:18 - SCHEME DETERMINED TO DO IT IS

05:20 - TO SPIRITS AND GIVEN A ROLE TO

05:22 - THE PARTY THAT HAS NOTHING TO

05:23 - OFFER TO THAT PROCEEDING.

05:25 - THESE NIKE T'S DO NOT THERE

05:28 - ARE CLIMATE. THEY ARE NOT AWARE

05:30 - OF CLAIMANTS. THE DIAGNOSIS.

05:32 - IT HELD BACK

05:33 - THEN THE TREATMENT PLAN FOR THE

05:35 - CLIMATE THEY MERELY FILLING

05:37 - ORDERS. THEY HAVE NOTHING TO

05:38 - OFFER WITH REGARD TO REASONABLE

05:39 - DESOUSA CITY, SOMETHING THAT IS

05:41 - DETERMINED BY A SPECIALIST OF

05:44 - LIGHT LICENSE.

05:46 - AND SPECIALTY TO BE TREATING

05:48 - PHYSICIAN. THE BIG FEAR HERE

05:50 - TO MINUTE.

05:53 - WELL QUESTION FROM MY

05:55 - COLLEAGUES.

05:55 - THEY COULD ALWAYS ACT, BUT

05:57 - HONESTLY, THE FIRST OUT.

05:59 - I'M NOT SURE INCORRECT

06:05 - IT'S THE END OF THE SEPARATION

06:07 - OF OUR FACEBOOK SITE THAT A

06:10 - LONG WAY TO APPROACH IF

06:12 - IN DOUBT. THIS REPORT

06:15 - GRANNY WE HEARD THAT

06:17 - THE STATUTE. FACE OF THE STATUE

06:20 - BY THE PROCESS OF BEING HERE

06:23 - YOU'LL OF THE COURT GOING BACK

06:25 - TO MORE MARBURY

06:26 - VERSUS MADISON. THE 4TH THE

06:28 - CONSTITUTION AND THAT'S

06:29 - CERTAINLY NOT A DEPRIVATION NY

06:32 - INFRINGE ON THE SEPARATION OF

06:36 - PROCESS VIOLATION EXIST I AGREE

06:38 - WITH YOU YOU'RE ON.

06:39 - AND HERE IS THAT NEW I LISTEN

06:41 - TO THIS THERE'S MORE TO IT THAT

06:44 - WAY.

06:47 - I THOUGHT I JUST DID ARGUE THAT

06:48 - WAY YEAH.

06:50 - THE CAPITAL THIS IS JUSTICE

06:51 - PARTY AS WE KNOW FROM FOLLOWING

06:54 - A DEPRIVATION DUE PROCESS FOR

06:56 - THE DEPRIVATION OF A

06:57 - PROPERTY INTEREST. HOW IS IT

06:59 - NOT BE ARGUED THAT THE PROPERTY

07:02 - INTEREST FOR THE PHARMACY

07:04 - IS ACTUALLY.

07:05 - IT'S A FINANCIAL EXPENDITURE

07:08 - IN PURCHASING THOSE OUR

07:10 - PRODUCTS THAT ARE

07:11 - BEING DISPENSED. HER A VALID

07:13 - PRESCRIPTION AT THE TIME OF

07:15 - DISPENSING HOUSE BAT NOT

07:16 - CONSIDERED CONSTRUED SEPARATE IN

07:18 - THE HEART. THEIR ABILITY IS A

07:21 - VIOLATION OF DUE PROCESS FOR

07:22 - YOU ARE NOT INCLUDED THAT.

07:25 - BECAUSE YOU

07:26 - ARE NOT CARMEN YOU IT'S NOT TO

07:29 - DETERMINE

07:30 - PAYMENT ISSUES IN GENERAL IT'S

07:32 - THE TERM GETS TO DETERMINE

07:33 - PAYMENT UNDER THE WORKERS

07:34 - COMPENSATION ACT AND IF THE

07:36 - TREATMENT IS NOT REASONABLE AND

07:38 - NECESSARY REGARDLESS OF ANY

07:39 - EXPENDITURE. IT CAN'T BE

07:41 - REIMBURSED BY THE WORKERS

07:42 - COMPENSATION INSURANCE CARRIER.

07:44 - AND WHEN YOU HEAR THAT COULD

07:46 - TAKE THIS TO THE LOGICAL

07:47 - EXTREME. IF THEY'RE NOT

07:49 - PERMITTED TO RECOVER

07:50 - FROM THE INSURANCE WHERE ARE

07:51 - THEY SUPPOSED TO GET THE

07:52 - RECOVERY FROM THERE ARE.

07:54 - AND THE NUMBER OF FACTUAL

07:56 - SCENARIO QUITE FRANKLY YOUR

07:58 - HONOR AND I WOULDN'T WANT TO

07:59 - SIT HERE AND SPECULATE OR RUN

08:00 - THROUGH THEM ALL CERTAINLY

08:02 - THERE COULD BE OTHER LIBEL

08:04 - INSURANCE CARRIERS. MANY TIMES

08:06 - WORK-RELATED INJURIES ARE I

08:08 - PROMISED LIABILITY OR 3RD PARTY

08:10 - COURT CASE. IF THERE ARE ANY

08:13 - NUMBER OF OTHER OTHER PLACES

08:15 - THEY COULD GO. IN ADDITION

08:17 - TO THAT THIS IS A SYSTEM THAT

08:19 - THEY HAVE ENTERED INTO KNOWING

08:21 - THE RISKS.

08:24 - AND IT'S A BUSINESS MODEL THAT

08:25 - THEY'VE CHOSEN.

08:31 - NOT PLAYING GOOD

08:32 - HOCKEY PRACTICE. WHY ISN'T THE

08:35 - PATIENT ULTIMATELY RESPONSIBLE

08:37 - FOR THE TEAM AND FOR THOSE DRY

08:39 - SEASON IS IN ANY TYPE OF

08:42 - ESSENTIALLY GET DIE IN DONA T

08:44 - I. I MEAN I

08:47 - GUESS I'M I'M A LITTLE BIT

08:49 - CONFUSED AS TO WHY THE PATIENT

08:50 - IS OFF THE BLOCK IT ANY

08:52 - INSURANCE CARRY YOU GUYS IN PAY.

08:58 - HAVING CLAIMANTS PAY

09:00 - FOR TREATMENT THAT BEING SAID I

09:02 - DON'T KNOW THAT IT IS ENTIRELY

09:04 - CLEAR THAT THEY ARE.

09:06 - I DON'T THINK THAT'S REALLY

09:07 - BEEN LITIGATED IN THIS.

09:09 - BUT LET ME LET ME FOLLOW UP

09:10 - WITH THAT THE ACT IS CLEAR THAT

09:12 - THEY

09:12 - DON'T FAVOR. I EMPLOYEES WHO

09:16 - ARE INJURED

09:19 - GET REASONABLE NECESSARY

09:21 - TREATMENT TO HAVE A.

09:23 - I YOU KNOW

09:24 - THE DIED AFTER UNDERGOING THE

09:27 - TREATMENT THAT THAT IS GIVEN

09:29 - INCLUDING PHARMACIES ONE SAYS

09:31 - THAT HER MONEY TO BE MADE THAT

09:33 - IT'S NOT REASONABLE OR

09:34 - NECESSARY. IT DOES IT

09:37 - DOESN'T FAT AND YOU KNOW YOU RE

09:39 - GETTING TIRED NOTION THAT

09:41 - THE YEAH GUYS I FAVOR THE

09:44 - PATIENT

09:46 - I AGREE WITH YOU THAT ONCE IT

09:48 - IS DETERMINED NOT TO BE

09:49 - REASONABLE AND NECESSARY IT'S

09:50 - NOT TREATMENT UNDER THE WORKERS

09:51 - COMPENSATION ACT AND THAT POINT

09:54 - OUTSIDE OF THAT

09:55 - THE PURVIEW OF THE WORKERS

09:56 - COMPENSATION AUTHORITY TO PAY

09:58 - FOR IT.

10:01 - BE SAYING AT A PLACE IN THAT

10:03 - THE INJURY THEY CAN STAY IN THE

10:05 - 4 THINGS GO THE BLANK SO

10:07 - DIFFERENT.

10:09 - NO DIFFERENT IF THE

10:10 - TREATMENTS NOT NOT REASONABLE

10:12 - OR NECESSARY, IT'S NOT RENDERED

10:13 - UNDER THE ACT AND THAT NONE OF

10:14 - THE ACT PROVISIONS APPLY.

10:16 - AND I CAN I JUMP IN AND ASK

10:18 - YOU A FOLLOW-UP ON THIS

10:19 - QUESTION. THE COUNCIL.

10:23 - 2 DIFFERENT

10:24 - THINGS HERE RESPONSE TO MY

10:26 - COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS ON THE ONE

10:27 - HERE. IT SAID YOU COULD

10:29 - IMAGINE, IMAGINE THE NUMBER OF.

10:34 - IF YOU LOSE THE SOUTH SIDE OF

10:35 - THE LOT LIKE SUFFOCATION THEORY.

10:45 - A VISION OF CONTRACT CLAIM BY

10:47 - THIS ATION I'M SORRY BY THE

10:56 - AS YOU ALLUDED TO EARLIER, THIS

10:58 - IS THE COST OF DOING BUSINESS.

11:04 - SO THAT IS SOME CAUSTIC ALWAYS

11:07 - GOOD TO HAVE.

11:16 - I THINK IT COULD BE EITHER

11:17 - YOU'RE ON BASED ON THE FACTS OF

11:19 - ANY PARTICULAR INDIVIDUAL CASE.

11:22 - IT'S NOT EVERY CASE IS GOING

11:24 - TO HAVE THE SUMMER EDITION

11:26 - POSSIBILITY OR A 3RD PARTY

11:28 - ACTUALLY ASSOCIATED WITH IT BUT

11:29 - SOME WELL.

11:31 - SETTLE I THINK IN SOME

11:32 - CIRCUMSTANCES THERE MAY BE

11:34 - OTHER PAY OR IS

11:35 - AVAILABLE AND IN OTHER

11:36 - CIRCUMSTANCES IT MAY BE A COST

11:38 - OF DOING BUSINESS THAT

11:39 - SOMETHING PHARMACIES RIGHT.

11:41 - YES, AGAINST ALL HERS OUTSIDE

11:43 - OF THE WORKERS. THE

11:43 - STATION ACT. SO IF YOUR

11:45 - QUESTION FROM THE INSURANCE

11:47 - CARRIERS PERSPECTIVE MIGHT BE

11:48 - BETTER ADDRESSED. THE MYSTERY

11:50 - OF WHO I. THE YOU

11:52 - KNOW ONE SITS OUTSIDE THE

11:53 - PURVIEW OF THE APP IT'S NO

11:55 - LONGER. IT'S NO LONGER

11:57 - APPROPRIATE.

12:01 - THE LIVE ACTION REVIEW PROCESS.

12:10 - IF IT APPEARS.

12:12 - IF THE IF THE

12:15 - THAT'S THE QUESTION YOU LIKE

12:17 - THE SAME SUMMER.

12:21 - WE WOULD REQUEST

12:22 - THAT YOU. REVERSE THE

12:24 - COMMONWEALTH COURT TO THE

12:25 - EXTENT THAT THEY MADE THIS ONE

12:27 - SENTENCE PULLING. ALTERING

12:29 - UTILIZATION REVIEW PROVIDE FOR

12:31 - NOTICE WITHOUT EVEN TELLING US

12:33 - WHO IS TO GET THAT NOTICE.

12:34 - THANK YOU.

12:39 - THIS MORNING. MY NAME IS COY

12:41 - ABOUT THE CARE I JUST HAVE ONE

12:43 - QUICK OPENING STATE WHICH IS

12:45 - THE PENNSYLVANIA WORKERS

12:46 - COMPENSATION THAT IT'S A

12:48 - LEGISLATIVE REALLY CREATED

12:49 - SCHEME TO GOVERN THE

12:51 - RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE FOYER

12:53 - IN JAPAN FOR YOU. THE PROBLEM

12:56 - WITH THIS WHOLE THING IS

12:57 - IT MAKES THE NON HEALTH CARE

13:00 - PROVIDERS. A BENEFICIARY UNDER

13:03 - THEY'RE JUST FACTS

13:04 - THOUGH THINGS ARE LITIGATED

13:06 - IN THE PROCESS FOR THE FIELD IS

13:08 - BEING HELD CLAD ONLY IN HIS

13:11 - BOOK AND YOU ARE THAT TOOK PLACE

13:12 - YEARS AGO. SO THE ONLY THOSE

13:15 - OPEN STATE IN THE WEST.

13:20 - YOU JUST TO BE FAIR THE

13:25 - THE RECORD WAS ASKED ABOUT.

13:27 - ONCE IT'S OUTSIDE

13:29 - WORKERS COMP IS IT JUST A

13:32 - THERE'S 3 IN CONTRACT. COOL

13:35 - YOURS FOR ITS MIDST, THE.

13:39 - THE DRUG. IT PROVIDES BROAD YOU

13:41 - HAVE AN HOUR THE

13:43 - BOY TO IF YOU'RE NOT PAID FOR

13:45 - IT YOU CAN BRING AN ACTION

13:47 - AGAINST THE DEVIL YOU PROVIDE

13:48 - THE RIGHT. IT'S A CASE. IF THE

13:51 - MONEY WOULD BE WRONG.

13:54 - IT'S TO HOW THE POLICY UNDER

13:56 - THE ACT SO I CAN PLAY IN THE

13:58 - WEST. I'M SORRY. IT'S FEELING

14:01 - FOR A SECOND.

14:02 - THE UNIVERSE A GROUP YOU SAID

14:04 - THAT. IN THIS MEDICAL

14:07 - PATIENTS NOT IS THE COURT

14:08 - NECESSARY. YOU ARTICULATE YEAH.

14:14 - YOU HAVE NO OBLIGATION, OKAY.

14:30 - I'M TRYING TO THINK OF THIS

14:31 - WOULD WORK MYSELF GO AHEAD.

14:33 - SO SO WHAT I WOULD SAY THE

14:35 - PURPOSE OF UTILIZATION OF THE

14:37 - BUSES IS ON WHAT MEDICAL

14:39 - PROCEDURE IS BENEFICIAL TO

14:41 - INJURED. WORK. IT IS NOT A REAL

14:44 - RECOVERY PROCESS. THERE IS A

14:46 - LIST IN THE SYSTEM BY THE

14:48 - CLINIC IS IT MEDICAL THAT

14:51 - WHATEVER IS BEING PROVIDED THE

14:53 - YEARS OF WORK.

14:53 - IT'S NOT UNUSUAL NECESSARY IN

14:56 - UNDER THE WORKERS COMPENSATION.

14:58 - IT'S NOT GOING TO

15:00 - THEY'LL. WE KEEP TALKING ABOUT

15:02 - THE BUSINESS MODEL IS IN EFFECT

15:04 - FOR THE BILL HERE.

15:05 - THERE'S A LOT OF THESE

15:07 - PHARMACIES RECEIVE

15:08 - THE PRESCRIPTIONS ALL AND THEY

15:10 - JUST START FEELING THE

15:12 - DIFFERENT THAN IF YOU WERE TO

15:13 - GO TO A CVS OR WALGREENS.

15:16 - THEY CONTACT THE

15:17 - INSURANCE COMPANY. THEY DIDN'T

15:19 - TELL YOU EITHER WE'RE GOING TO

15:20 - LIVE OR YOU MAY OVERLOOK.

15:23 - HERE THERE'S A DIFFERENT

15:24 - PROCESS.

15:25 - AND THERE'S ALSO SOME QUESTIONS

15:27 - THAT YOU'RE

15:27 - DIFFERENT LEVEL AS TO WHETHER

15:29 - THE POSITIONS WERE EVEN WRITING

15:33 - VOTERS. SO IT IS A BUSINESS

15:35 - MODEL.

15:37 - TO ENSURE THAT THE PHARMACIES

15:39 - AS SOON AS THEY FILL A

15:40 - PRESCRIPTION. THEY'RE GOING TO

15:41 - GET IT AND THE ARGUMENT IS THAT.

15:44 - BECAUSE A PLACE OF HIS OWN

15:47 - PEOPLE AND THE NECESSARY.

15:48 - WE

15:48 - SHOULD PARTICIPATE THE FOCUS OF

15:50 - THAT PROCESS IS ON THE PERSON

15:52 - BEING TREATED AND

15:54 - THE PEOPLE WHO ARE INVOLVED IN

15:55 - THAT THE PERSON BEING TREATED

15:57 - IN THE DOCTOR USE OR OTHER

15:59 - MEDICAL JUDGMENT TO DETERMINE

16:01 - THE TREATMENT PLAN FOR THIS

16:02 - INDIVIDUAL.

16:03 - SO IF THE BILLS THAT'S THE

16:05 - DECISION THE RISK THAT THE

16:07 - FUNDS. AND I GUESS ANOTHER

16:09 - FRONT THAT'S WHAT I WOULD SAY

16:10 - IS THAT THE MEDICAL BILLING IN

16:11 - GENERAL UNDER.

16:14 - BECAUSE WE HAVE LOST A GAME.

16:15 - LET'S SAY THERE'S A BILL FOR

16:17 - $100. THE MEDICARE VOTE THE

16:19 - BUILDING USED TO 16 O THE

16:22 - MEDICAL PROVIDER IN THE

16:24 - INTERVIEW SAY WELL UNDER THAT O

16:26 - D IT SHOULD BE A HOT. THAT IS

16:28 - THE TERM LIMITS 60 AT BARS.

16:33 - IN MEDICAL THE BODY TISSUE

16:38 - EVEN THOUGH WE BUILD A 100

16:40 - WE'RE NOT GOING TO GET IT

16:41 - THAT'S A BUSINESS RISTAINO WHEN

16:44 - THEY CAME ACROSS.

16:45 - CAN I JUMP IN OTHER BUSINESS

16:47 - CHRIS POINT COUNCIL.

16:50 - IN IN DECIDING THIS CASE IS IT

16:52 - APPROPRIATE OR IS IT NOT

16:53 - PROCREATE FOR THIS COURT TO

16:56 - THINK ABOUT.

17:11 - MY TAKE IN RESPONSE TO A

17:13 - REVERSAL HERE IN OTHER WORDS

17:16 - ARE THERE.

17:18 - CONSUMER AND FRIENDLY MEASURES

17:21 - THE LACK OF A

17:21 - BETTER TERM OF THE ONE MIGHT

17:23 - ANTICIPATE FARMERS PHARMACIES

17:25 - TAKING. IN ORDER TO PROTECT

17:27 - THEMSELVES. AGAIN.

17:36 - SEE WE OUT THOUSANDS.

17:44 - IS IT IS IT FAIR.

17:52 - IT'S SOMETHING HE'S TOTALLY OUT

17:54 - OF BOUNDS IN YOUR VIEW.

17:56 - I SEE A VOTE FOR THIS REASON.

17:59 - THE WORKERS COMPENSATION SCHEME

18:01 - WAS CREATED BY THE LEGISLATURE

18:03 - AND THEN DETERMINE WHO THE LINE

18:05 - TO BENEFIT.

18:06 - WHAT A GAME TO GO BACK TO

18:08 - THE GO THE POLICIES ARE BASED

18:10 - WAS SAYING BECAUSE WE PROVIDE

18:12 - THERE IS LITTLE TO WIN THE NBA.

18:14 - IF WE GO INTO THE SOCIAL MEDIA.

18:17 - THE DECISION IF THEY DON'T GET

18:19 - THEIR BILLS. THEY DON'T JUST IN

18:21 - ALL FIELDS. THE CLEANUP.

18:24 - BUT NOW WE'RE

18:25 - DOING IS TRYING TO NOT WE BUT

18:27 - THAT THE FARM TO TRY TO CHANGE

18:28 - THE PROCESS WHEN IT COMES TO US.

18:32 - WHEN TITLE TO GET IN IN IN

18:34 - STAYING IN THE GREAT ISSUES OF

18:35 - THEM ALMOST ANYONE ELSE.

18:37 - AND IF I WOULD KILL YOU KNOW

18:40 - WHAT TO SAY THE LEAST EFFECT

18:41 - FOR THE

18:42 - 2 QUICK. THE ONE WITH A LOT OF

18:44 - THESE IS THE MAYOR OF THE MOTOR

18:46 - VEHICLE ACCIDENT OR SOMETHING

18:47 - ELSE. THERE MAY BE WHICH IS

18:51 - WHAT MICHAEL GOVE THE

18:52 - MOVIE REALLY AND SO THERE MAY

18:54 - BE ANOTHER INTERNSHIPS OR

18:56 - SYMBOL NEVER BEEN ON THE BOOKS.

18:59 - BUT ALSO WHEN WE COME

19:00 - BACK TO THIS FROM THIS.

19:04 - THE WAY FILLING THE WORKERS

19:06 - COMPENSATION. THEY'LL GO.

19:09 - IN OVER A DEBATE. THEY'RE SO

19:11 - WHY GO TO THE FIELD FOR 6 OR 7.

19:14 - THERE'S SOME PRETTY MUCH WHAT

19:16 - DOES A LOT OF PRETTY

19:17 - SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF.

19:20 - AND WHAT'S BEING SAID NOW IT

19:21 - WILL EVEN KNOW ABOUT THE BILL

19:23 - ILL IT BUT

19:25 - FOR ME AND NOW THEY'RE GOING TO

19:27 - RESET ENTIRE PASTA THOSE THEY

19:30 - DID KNOW THEY

19:38 - IN SEOUL. THAT'S WHAT WE SAY IN

19:40 - THE BUSINESS MODEL.

19:43 - ALL BECAUSE OF THINGS THAT ARE

19:45 - A LOWER LEVEL POSITION ONLY.

19:54 - SELL IT. AND YES, IT'S WORKED

19:56 - FOR HIM.

20:00 - IS THAT GOOD.

20:02 - AND PHARMACIES COULD STOP

20:04 - ACCEPTING A WORKERS

20:05 - COMPENSATION.

20:07 - AND THAT'S OBVIOUSLY GOING TO

20:09 - HAVE A.

20:14 - REST IT'S NOT WORTH THE RISK.

20:17 - WHAT I WOULD SAY THAT

20:18 - IS GOOD ONLINE PHARMACIES IN

20:21 - MORE RECENT PHENOMENON.

20:23 - IT WAS HIS HAVE BEEN FILLING

20:24 - PRESCRIPTIONS FOR WORK INJURIES

20:26 - AND INTO THE 40'S FOR

20:28 - THEY COULD.

20:29 - I UNDERSTAND YOU DON'T HAVE

20:30 - TO THEREFORE NOT GOING TO GET

20:31 - PAID THEY MAY NOT.

20:34 - NORMALLY THINGS ARE SET UP AND

20:35 - RUNNING. IN WHAT

20:37 - I MEAN IT PROVIDED WITH THE

20:39 - INFORMATION TO BUILD THE BASE

20:41 - OF THE FALLS THAT THAT'S

20:42 - HAPPENED

20:42 - SIGNIFICANT MEDICAL. WHAT STORM

20:45 - CHANGE HERE IS WE'RE DOING

20:46 - THESE COME FROM CLEAN. ALL IT

20:49 - IN.

20:50 - THE OMEN FOR MISSES THE

20:52 - PRESCRIPTIONS AND WE'RE GOING

20:53 - TO COME CLEAN LITTER. THE ONE

20:55 - TO $3,000. THERE'S AN AUTOMATIC

20:58 - PLEA EVERY MONTH.

21:01 - THAT'S THE DYNAMIC COULD

21:02 - CHANGE. AND I THINK WE SHOULD

21:04 - JUST PAY THE BILL THERE'S A NEW

21:06 - ENTITY BOWL AND THEY'RE SAYING

21:08 - THAT WELL BECAUSE THE BUILDING.

21:11 - LIFE JUST THE CHIEF JUSTICE

21:13 - THERE WAS IN THIS ONE HAS BEEN

21:15 - ASKED BEFORE AND GOT LOST

21:17 - BECAUSE I

21:18 - PLAYED WITH THE PHARMACY INTO

21:20 - PLACE AND THE QUESTION I FOLLOW

21:22 - THROUGH. BUT BOTH JUST AS DONNA

21:24 - WHO EARLIER JUST THE WAY IT IS

21:26 - IN JUST A MOMENT TOO. IT IS

21:29 - OUTSIDE THE COFFEE. BECAUSE THE

21:31 - UTILIZATION RATE YOU TURN.

21:34 - WHAT'S OCCURRING BETWEEN THE.

21:38 - CLAIMANTS IN THE FARMERS.

21:40 - THE REASON A

21:42 - BORDER NECESSARY. WHAT FOODS

21:44 - THAT WE FACE IN CONTRACT LAW.

21:46 - THE PHARMACY WHO HAS SINCE

21:50 - THESE FEES, GREENS TO THE.

21:56 - TO SUE THEM FOR THE MONEY.

22:00 - CALL WITH THE CLUE THAT IF

22:02 - WORKERS COP IS INVOLVED.

22:05 - I DON'T KNOW IF I COULD

22:06 - NECESSARILY TELL YOU WHAT THAT

22:07 - WOULD

22:08 - PRECLUDE THEM BECAUSE I HAVE

22:10 - BEEN REPRESENTING HIM TO WORK

22:12 - IN THE BUILDING TODAY SHE BUT I

22:13 - WILL SAY THIS.

22:14 - IT'S LIKELY THAT NO LONGER BE

22:16 - RESPONSIBLE. AND THERE WOULD BE

22:18 - A DETERMINATION THAT THE

22:19 - MEDICATION WAS NOT NECESSARY.

22:21 - IN THE VIEWER PROCESS.

22:24 - WHAT IS ASSESSING THE JUDGMENT

22:26 - OF THE PHYSICIAN WHO WROTE

22:27 - THE PRESCRIPTIONS. THESE

22:29 - PHARMACIES RECEIVE A

22:30 - PRESCRIPTION IN SIMPLE STILL

22:32 - THE EXERCISE OF JUDGMENT.

22:34 - NOW HOW THEY DECIDE TO SHORE.

22:37 - THEN I DID SPEAK TO THEIR THEIR

22:40 - OLD ECONOMIC NOW IS WHETHER THE

22:42 - WHITE BALL. IT WOULD BECAUSE

22:43 - THAT'S GOING TO GET.

22:48 - OPEN QUESTION FOR

22:50 - WHATEVER REASON AS THE WEATHER

22:52 - THE PHARMACY WHO PROVIDES THEIR

22:54 - KIDS TO BE A PATIENT

22:57 - WHICH WHICH MAY BE REASONABLE

22:58 - AND NECESSARY FOR THE CONDITION

23:00 - OF THE

23:00 - PATIENT HAS IT MERELY MAY NOT

23:03 - BE HIGH AND INJURED. SO IN YOUR

23:06 - VIEW IS SET TO OPEN QUESTION

23:08 - WHETHER THE PHARMACY, IT'S A

23:09 - QUESTION THAT WE LIKE IT INTO

23:11 - IS THAT

23:12 - WHAT'S THAT IT'S THE WIND FARM

23:14 - ASLEEP AND BRING THE ACTION

23:15 - DIRECTLY AGAINST THE PLAME CASE.

23:18 - WHO LIKE IT WAS DETERMINED

23:20 - THAT THAT WAS NOT REASONABLE

23:22 - AND NECESSARY IN NEWARK.

23:25 - WHAT I DON'T THINK THAT THE

23:26 - NEXT STEP.

23:28 - THE COUNCIL, THIS IS 91

23:30 - FOLLOW-UP QUESTION ON THAT.

23:32 - WHY USE IT YEAH THAT.

23:36 - A PROVIDER OF I'M AN OLD.

23:40 - SERVICES

23:41 - LIKE THAT. FROM LOOKING TO

23:44 - PATIENTS FOR PAIN.

23:47 - IT COULD BE IT.

23:50 - ORDINARY PROVISION THAT I THINK

23:53 - YOU WOULD HAVE. THE VOTER

23:55 - SOMEONE WOULD TALK ABOUT.

24:05 - WHICH I

24:07 - IT'S A COUPLE SCENARIOS EVEN

24:09 - ADD ON THAT THERE MAY BE SOME

24:11 - THAT PROVIDE BUT BEFORE THAT

24:13 - THEY DO NOT TREAT IT WORKED.

24:15 - BECAUSE THEY DON'T WANT TO BE

24:16 - INVOLVED IN THE

24:17 - PROCESS FOR THEY KNOW THE TRUTH

24:19 - WOULD SAY WOULD BE

24:22 - LITIGATION FOR SIGNIFICANT

24:23 - AMOUNT OF COAL. THE DOCTORS WHO

24:25 - TREAT THESE PATIENTS. THEY WERE

24:28 - ON THE ROOF OF THE BUILDING ON

24:29 - THE FACE IF YOU HAVE TO WORK

24:31 - FOR YEARS IN A LITTLE BIT FOR

24:33 - YEARS AND THEY DON'T WIN THEM.

24:35 - INSIDE OUT OF A TREE.

24:39 - THIS IS DIFFERENT

24:40 - THAN HERE ON THE FOOTBALL.

24:46 - WE'RE TOLD IN

24:47 - LAW OFFICES. WE HAVE A DUE

24:50 - PROCESS.

24:51 - AND WHAT WHAT

24:55 - THEY DON'T KNOW WHY THEY'RE NOT

24:58 - ON THE WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO

25:00 - SAY WHO SERVED US WELL INTO THE

25:02 - ACT. SO THAT NOW WE HAVE IS WHY

25:04 - WE'RE THERE.

25:12 - THEY'RE

25:13 - NO MORE QUESTIONS IS THERE

25:14 - ANYTHING YOU'D LIKE TO SAY

25:15 - INSULATION.

25:18 - THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

25:22 - GOOD MORNING MEMBERS. THE COURT

25:24 - MAY PLEASE THE COURT.

25:25 - I'M DANCING GO ON BEHALF OF

25:28 - KEYSTONE RX.

25:30 - WHAT THE COURT HAS HEARD IN

25:32 - THE INITIAL PARTS OF THIS

25:33 - ARGUMENT. IT IS ONE NOTHING

25:37 - ADDRESSING THE LEGISLATIVE

25:38 - SCHEME THE ACTUAL LEGISLATION

25:41 - INFLATION OF THE DIFFERENT

25:43 - PARTICIPANTS AND THE DIFFERENT

25:45 - PROCESSES AS JUSTICE TANI YOU

25:48 - TALKED ABOUT WE HAVE A NON

25:50 - HEALTH CARE PROVIDER WE'VE

25:52 - HEARD THAT RAYS THROUGHOUT AND

25:55 - WHAT THE COURT HAS NOT

25:57 - ADDRESSED OR HAS NOT EVEN BEEN

25:59 - RAISED IS HOW THIS CASE

26:01 - AROSE HERE UNDER THE DUE

26:03 - PROCESS VIOLATION OF HER.

26:06 - WHAT WE HAVE HERE IS IN ON

26:08 - HEALTH CARE PROVIDER

26:09 - IN THIS CASE A PHARMACY COULD

26:11 - BE AN MRI FACILITY IT COULD BE

26:13 - A MEDICAL EQUIPMENT DISPENSARY

26:15 - IT COULD BE A PHYSICAL THERAPY

26:17 - FACILITY. THEIR PROCESS BECAUSE

26:20 - THEY ARE NOT HEALTH

26:21 - CARE PROVIDERS IS TO FILE WHAT

26:24 - IS CALLED A THEORY

26:26 - BECAUSE THE UTILIZATION REVIEW

26:29 - SYSTEM UNDER THE PLAIN LANGUAGE

26:31 - OF THE ACT

26:32 - ONLY APPLIES TO ALL TREATMENT

26:35 - PROVIDED BY A

26:37 - HEALTHCARE PROVIDER, A PHARMACY

26:39 - THAT DISPENSES MEDICINE IS NOT

26:41 - A HEALTH

26:41 - CARE PROVIDER. IT IS AS JUSTICE

26:43 - DONAHUE SAID A MEDICAL SERVICE

26:46 - PROVIDER IN AN MRI FACILITY

26:48 - THAT THAT PERFORMS

26:50 - AN MRI. THEY DON'T THEY FOLLOW

26:52 - THE INSTRUCTIONS OF.

26:55 - DOCTOR A HEALTH CARE PROVIDER.

26:57 - THE HEALTH

26:57 - CARE PROVIDERS HAVE THE

26:59 - UTILIZATION REVIEW SYSTEM WHERE

27:01 - THEIR TREATMENT.

27:02 - IT CAN BE CHALLENGED IF IT IS

27:04 - NOT REASONABLE OR NECESSARY.

27:06 - PROVIDE AND HE'S

27:08 - MEDICAL SERVICE PROVIDERS THE

27:09 - PHARMACIES THE MRI CENTERS.

27:11 - THEY MUST PROCEED THROUGH THE

27:13 - FEE REVIEW PROCESS WHERE

27:16 - THEY'RE MATTERS ARE HANDLED

27:18 - THROUGH AN ADMINISTRATIVE

27:19 - PROCESS, THEY FINALLY FEEL

27:21 - REVIEW APPLICATION. WHAT

27:23 - HAPPENED HERE AND WHAT HAPPENS

27:25 - FREQUENT 6 FREQUENTLY

27:27 - AND WHERE THE DUE PROCESS

27:28 - VIOLATION OF THE CURVE

27:29 - IS THAT THE MEDICAL

27:32 - SERVICE PROVIDER THE FILES THE

27:34 - THEME REVIEW ANY DOES

27:36 - DISMISSED SUMMARILY BECAUSE

27:39 - THERE WAS A REALIZATION REVIEW

27:41 - PERFORMED UP NOT DOCTOR WHO

27:44 - PRESCRIBED THE MEDICINE THE

27:45 - TEST, WHAT HAPPENED.

27:48 - PROVIDER THE

27:49 - SERVICE PROVIDER IS NEVER AWARE

27:52 - OF THE UTILIZATION REVIEW,

27:55 - THEY'RE NOT A PARTY TO IT.

27:57 - THEY HAVE NO INPUT,

27:58 - THEY'RE NOT EVEN AWARE IF IN

27:59 - FACT AS CAN HAPPEN.

28:01 - THE DOCTOR. PRESCRIBE WHATEVER

28:04 - THE TREATMENT THE MEDICATION,

28:06 - EVEN PARTICIPATED AND ALLOW THE

28:09 - DETERMINATION TO GO THROUGH.

28:11 - SO BECAUSE THEY FILE A FEE

28:13 - REVIEW. THEY ARE BARRED FROM

28:15 - EVEN

28:16 - SEEKING PAYMENT A BIG CAUSE OF

28:18 - THE UTILIZATION REVIEW THAT

28:20 - WAS PERFORMED WITHOUT THEIR

28:22 - KNOWLEDGE WITHOUT THEIR NOTICE

28:23 - WITHOUT THEIR PARTICIPATION.

28:25 - AND I JUMP IN

28:53 - GIVEN THAT YOU'RE FAR.

29:00 - IF I'M READING YOUR HONOR'S

29:02 - QUESTION RIGHT.

29:04 - THIS STATUTE ITSELF ONLY ALLOW

29:06 - FOR A UTILIZATION REVIEW OF

29:08 - TREATMENT PROVIDED BY A

29:10 - HEALTHCARE PROVIDER. IT DOES

29:12 - NOT PROVIDE FOR REVIEW OF

29:15 - THE SERVICES

29:16 - BECAUSE THOSE ENTITIES OR FLY

29:18 - OR PERFORMING A MINISTERIAL

29:19 - FUNCTION AND IN FACT THE ACT

29:21 - THE PENNSYLVANIA LAW

29:23 - DOES NOT INCLUDE PHARMACIES MRI

29:26 - CENTERS AS A WHOLE LOT QUITMAN

29:28 - DISPENSARIES WITHIN THAT SO

29:31 - THEY ARE NEVER EVEN REPORTED

29:32 - NOTICE THAT THEY ARE

29:35 - IN TITLE TO PARTICIPATE AND

29:38 - THEY HAVE

29:39 - NO OPPORTUNITY TO ASSERT THEIR

29:41 - RIGHT TO PAYMENTS SO THEY ARE

29:43 - BEING DENIED PAYMENT WITHOUT

29:45 - NOTICE IT SET IT FREE THE 3

29:47 - BALL.

29:49 - ISN'T IT THE CASE UNDER THE

29:51 - STATUTE AND IS IT CONSISTENT

29:53 - WITH SULLIVAN.

29:58 - A SITUATION WHERE.

30:08 - TO TREATMENT MEDICAL TREATMENT

30:10 - THAT'S NECESSARY. THESE IN A

30:12 - BOWL.

30:38 - THE RISK OF DRESSING PROCESS.

30:40 - THE REASON YOUR HONOR IS

30:41 - TWOFOLD FIRST GOING BACK TO SO.

30:44 - SOLOMON STANDS FOR THE

30:45 - PROPOSITION THAT THE HEALTH

30:48 - CARE PROVIDER IS RECEIVING DUE

30:50 - PROCESS BECAUSE IT CAN

30:52 - PARTICIPATE IN THE UTILIZATION

30:54 - REVIEW PROCESS. THAT

30:57 - IS CORRECT THOSE ENTITIES

30:59 - RECEIVE DUE PROCESS THEY

31:01 - RECEIVE NOTICE THE OPPORTUNITY

31:03 - TO PARTICIPATE

31:04 - ITS CENTER. THE ANTHONY IS THAT

31:06 - WE ARE DISCUSSING IN THIS CASE

31:08 - OR MEDICAL SERVICE PROVIDERS.

31:11 - THERE ARE NOT THEN DO NOT

31:13 - RECEIVE THAT SAME AND

31:15 - RAM IT. THE ACT ITSELF DOESN'T

31:19 - PROVIDE FOR THEM TO PARTICIPATE

31:22 - IN THAT PROCEDURE,

31:23 - PRESUMABLY BECAUSE THEY ARE

31:24 - PERFORMING EVEN READ DISPENSARY

31:27 - OR SOME OTHER

31:28 - NON DIAGNOSTIC PROCESS. SO AS

31:32 - A RESULT.

31:33 - SULLIVAN ITSELF, IT DOESN'T

31:36 - APPLY THIS IS MORE AKIN OF

31:38 - ANYTHING TO BACK SALARY BECAUSE

31:41 - IN BACK SALARY, THE WORKER WAS

31:43 - DENIED PAYMENT WITHOUT ANY

31:44 - HEARING. IN THIS CASE,

31:47 - THE PHARMACY OR THE WHATEVER

31:50 - THE SERVICE

31:51 - PROVIDER IS IS DENIED ITS RIGHT

31:54 - UNDER THE PEER REVIEW, TOO TO

31:56 - CHALLENGE IT. AND WHILE YES,

31:59 - THE WORKERS COMP SYSTEM IS A

32:01 - RISK SHIFTING SYSTEM. THE

32:03 - ENTITIES HERE. THAT ARE

32:06 - PROVIDING SERVICES RATHER THAN

32:08 - HEALTH CARE.

32:10 - OUR LEFT WITH NO METHOD TO

32:12 - EITHER US OR WE'RE TO PROTECT

32:15 - THEIR RIGHTS AND THAT'S THE

32:17 - DISTINCTION. ALL RIGHT. IN

32:20 - FACT THIS.

32:20 - IT LET ME LET ME JUST I I

32:23 - FOLLOW UP ON.

32:26 - WHAT PRECISELY WADE IN MEDICAL

32:29 - CARE BAY. PROVIDERS

32:33 - THE SHOE THE ISSUE BEING THAT

32:35 - REMAIN IN THE UTILIZATION

32:37 - REVIEW COMMITTEE IN THIS

32:39 - SERVICE. ITS SERVICE PROVIDER

32:41 - SAID NEVER MADE

32:43 - A DETERMINATION THAT WHAT THEY

32:46 - ARE PROVIDING REASONABLE AND

32:47 - NECESSARY.

32:49 - WHAT DO THEY BRING TO THE TABLE

32:51 - IN THE UTILIZATION

32:52 - REVIEW PROCESS THEY'RE RIGHT

32:57 - BE

32:58 - REASONABLENESS IN THIS ACTIVITY

33:01 - OF THE PRESCRIPTION THAT'S

33:03 - BEING GIVEN FOR THE TREATMENT

33:05 - BY THE MEDIA CAN DO IS PART OF

33:07 - THE PROCESS.

33:07 - WHAT WHAT WHAT WOULD YOUR

33:09 - CLIENT DO AT THE MIDDLE OF A

33:11 - REVIEW COMMITTEE HEARING.

33:13 - THAT THAT'S THE CHALLENGE

33:14 - THAT WE ADDRESS.

33:17 - DONAHUE IN THE

33:18 - COMMONWEALTH COURT. AND IT'S

33:21 - THE PROBLEM THAT I THINK THE

33:22 - ACT ACTUALLY

33:24 - IF WE FOLLOW A STATUTORY

33:26 - CONSTRUCTION ACT ANALYSIS.

33:29 - WE ARE ADDRESSING IT.

33:30 - THE ACT ONLY IN THE DEFINITION

33:33 - OF UTILIZATION REVIEW

33:35 - TALKS ABOUT REASONABLENESS

33:38 - TREATMENT PROVIDED BY A

33:40 - HEALTHCARE PROVIDER AND IN

33:42 - THE ACT, THE HEALTH CARE

33:44 - PROVIDER IS THE ONE

33:46 - WHO WOULD BE DENY PAYMENT IF

33:48 - TREATMENT IS NOT REASONABLE

33:49 - AND NECESSARY. WHAT WE HAVE

33:51 - HERE IS THE EURO GOING A STEP.

33:55 - AND THEN ACTING REGULATIONS THAT

33:57 - BRING NON HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS

34:00 - UNDER THE AMBIT A PROVISION

34:02 - ONLY FOR HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS.

34:04 - I WOULD SUGGEST THAT THE MOST

34:06 - APPROPRIATE METHOD BASED ON THE

34:09 - PLAIN LANGUAGE OF THE.

34:12 - THAT THE ONLY ENTITIES THAT CAN

34:14 - BE TONIGHT PAYMENT

34:16 - FOR TREATMENT. OUR HEALTH CARE

34:18 - PROVIDERS AS IT SAYS IN

34:21 - THE ACT AND THAT THOSE

34:23 - OTHER ENTITIES IT WOULD NOT BE

34:25 - DENIED PAYMENT BECAUSE THEY'RE

34:26 - NOT PROVIDING TREATMENT THEY

34:28 - ARE SIMPLY DOING AS YOUR HONOR

34:30 - SUGGESTS THE SPENCE IN MEDICINE

34:32 - PERFORMING A TASK ETCETERA SO I

34:35 - WOULD SEE PAST THAT.

34:40 - A PLACE FOR PARTICIPATION IS IN

34:43 - THE UTILIZATION REVIEW. BUT WHAT

34:46 - THE BUREAU COULD HAVE GONE

34:48 - BECAUSE THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF

34:50 - THE EURO JACKLEY FAILING TO

34:53 - CREATE APPROPRIATE REMEDIES TO

34:55 - CREATE AN APPROPRIATE SERIES OF

34:57 - REGULATIONS. BUT WHAT THE

34:59 - BUREAU SHOULD HAVE GONE WAS

35:01 - CREATE A PROCESS WHEREBY

35:03 - THESE MEDICAL SERVICE PROVIDERS

35:06 - WHO ARE NOT THE ENTITIES.

35:08 - THIS CUSTOM ME YOU

35:09 - ARE PROVISIONS IT WOULD BE

35:11 - NOTIFIED OF THE RESULTS.

35:14 - UTILIZATION REVIEW AND WOULD

35:16 - NO LONGER RECEIVE PAYMENT FOR

35:18 - FUTURE CARE. BUT FOR THAT FOR

35:21 - THE MEDICINE THEY DISPENSED FOR

35:23 - THAT THE TESTS THEY PERFORMED

35:25 - THEY WOULD BE PAID BECAUSE

35:27 - THERE IS NOTHING IN

35:28 - THE ACT THAT SAYS THAT ANY

35:31 - ENTITY OTHER THAN A HEALTH CARE

35:33 - PROVIDER THAT WOULD BE BARRED

35:36 - FOR PAYMENT AND THE EURO.

35:38 - IT TOOK THIS STEP FURTHER IN

35:40 - WHAT THEY IT DID WHEN THEY

35:42 - CREATED THESE REGULATIONS.

35:46 - TO KEEP THEIR VERY CONFUSED ME A

35:49 - LITTLE BIT.

35:50 - AND AS I READ THE ACT AND

35:52 - SIMPLY CLEAR THAT ONE IN A 1, 6,

35:59 - IS HE IS THE COMMONWEALTH COURT

36:02 - DETERMINED IN HIS SIDE THAT IS

36:05 - NEEDED TO PROCESS RIGHT.

36:07 - THE YEAR. THE YOUR CLIENT TO

36:09 - PARTICIPATE MUELLER HAS

36:10 - A PREVIEW IS IT PRECISELY AS IT

36:14 - IS DESCRIBED IF I UNDERSTAND IT

36:16 - IN IN IN DAD IS DEAD. THE

36:18 - MEDICAL PROVIDER GET

36:19 - UTILIZATION REVIEW AND THE NON

36:22 - MEDICAL TREATMENT PROVIDER KIDS.

36:28 - IN THE REVIEW IS.

36:30 - IF YOU KNOW THIS THE

36:33 - REVIEW HAD AS DO WITH THEM ONE

36:35 - THING

36:36 - I'M OUT IN HIGHLAND IS A NEW

36:38 - DAY REVIEW RE REASONABLENESS

36:40 - NECESSITY.

36:42 - IS THAT HOW YOU READ THE APP IF

36:43 - YOU LEAVE THE EU

36:45 - THINK THAT THE COMMONWEALTH

36:47 - COURT EVERY POINT HIS RED THE

36:48 - APP WRONG. AND YEAH, YOUR

36:51 - CLIENT. GOOD HAVE YOU HERE.

36:54 - WE BELIEVE

36:56 - THAT IF I AGREE WITH YOUR

36:59 - ANALYSIS OF THE LANGUAGE OF THE

37:01 - ACT LIKE I COMPLETELY AGREE

37:02 - WITH WHERE.

37:07 - THAT'S HELPFUL TO ME THANK YOU.

37:09 - IF YOU AGREE WITH THAT WITH

37:10 - THIS REALLY IS IS A

37:12 - CONSTITUTIONAL ATTACK IN THE

37:14 - NEXT 5 AS I SAID AT THE OUTSET

37:16 - OF MARBURY VERSUS MADISON, A

37:18 - CONSTITUTIONAL ATTACK ON THE

37:20 - WORKER'S COMP THEN AT THE FRONT

37:26 - YOUR CLIENT, YOUR

37:28 - IT'S THE $4,000 TO 15 AND HAS

37:31 - NO GRANDE TO GET BACK IN YOUR

37:33 - VIEW OF THAT CRIME TO DUE

37:34 - PROCESS. SO THE ACT THIS FLIGHT

37:36 - BECAUSE THE ACT DOESN'T GIVE

37:37 - YOU. IT WAS A PREVIEW.

37:40 - THE

37:43 - I WOULD INTERPRET IT SLIGHTLY

37:44 - DIFFERENTLY NEW WANTS THE APP

37:46 - IT DOES I CREATE IN THIS

37:49 - CIRCUMSTANCE, A REMEDY

37:52 - TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF THE

37:54 - MEDICAL SERVICE PROVIDER IT

37:56 - PROTECTS THE HEALTH CARE

37:58 - PROVIDER AS IT'S SUPPOSED TO DO

38:00 - THE HEALTH CARE.

38:01 - THE ART FLYING INTO THE

38:03 - PHARMACY OR AS I SAID ALL THESE

38:05 - OTHER MEDICAL SERVICE PROVIDERS

38:07 - DO NOT FALL UNDER THE

38:08 - DEFINITION UNDER THE ACT OF A

38:10 - HEALTH CARE PROVIDER IF THEY

38:11 - ARE BEING THE NOMINEE CAME IN

38:14 - IN A PROCESS THAT ON ITS FACE

38:17 - DOESN'T APPLY

38:18 - TO THEM, BUT GIVEN NO

38:19 - ALTERNATIVE BECAUSE THE HEROES

38:21 - REGULATION OR FEAR REVIEWS

38:24 - SAYS THAT'S A THEORY YOU

38:27 - IT'S GOING TO BE RETURNED IF

38:29 - AMONG

38:30 - 3 REASONS THE INSURER HAS FILED

38:32 - A REQUEST FOR UTILIZATION

38:34 - REVIEW. IT TAKES

38:36 - THE ENTITY. THE PROVIDE THE

38:38 - TREAT THE SERVICE PROVIDER OUT

38:40 - OF THIS.

38:42 - IT GIVES THEM NO

38:43 - METHOD WHATSOEVER TO ASSERT

38:45 - WERE TO BE COMPENSATED FOR WHAT

38:48 - THEY HAVE GONE WHATEVER IT MAY

38:50 - BE. AND IN THIS CASE INVOLVED.

38:52 - YES IT INVOLVED. THE

38:54 - MEDICATION, YOU'RE ALSO

38:55 - INVOLVED. THE RUDIMENTARY

38:57 - MORE TRADITIONAL MEDICATIONS AS

38:59 - WE'RE IT'S JUST HIS TIME.

39:02 - IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THERE ARE

39:03 - ONLY 2 POSSIBLE REMEDIES. ONE IS

39:07 - THAT AFTER ME GO TO THE

39:08 - LEGISLATURE AND PLEAD FOR

39:10 - THEM TO AMEND THE STATUTE AND

39:13 - THE OTHER IS STAFFED UP YOU

39:16 - JUST DESPAIR CHIEF JUSTICE

39:17 - PAIR SAID HAVE A DIRECT ATTACK

39:20 - ON MCCAIN'S CONSTITUTIONALITY

39:22 - OF THE WORKERS COMP ACT ITSELF.

39:24 - THOSE ARE THOSE ARE THE

39:25 - 2 POSSIBILITIES, CORRECT.

39:26 - THE ESTIMATE FROM THE OUTSET OF

39:29 - THESE CASES.

39:31 - AND AS THIS COURT KNOWS THE

39:33 - COMMONWEALTH COURT HAS THEN

39:34 - ADDRESSING THESE ISSUES.

39:37 - EXTENSIVELY WE HAVE

39:39 - ASSERTED THAT THE UNDERLYING

39:41 - PROCESS, THE DRIVE ANTHONY'S OF

39:45 - DUE PROCESS

39:46 - THAT THE ENTIRE THAT PORTION OF

39:49 - THE ACT AND WHILE YES,

39:52 - THE IDEAL. REMEDY

39:54 - IS FOR THE LEGISLATURE

39:56 - TO TAKE AND AN

39:58 - ARTFULLY DRAFTED A PIECE OF

40:01 - LEGISLATION OR SECTION OF THE

40:02 - ACT AND REVISE IT. THIS COURT

40:05 - ALWAYS HAS THE ABILITY TO STEP

40:09 - IN AND TO ADDRESS WHERE THERE

40:11 - IS A CONSTITUTIONAL

40:13 - AND I SAY GO TALK JUST SAILOR.

40:18 - YOU COULD ASK THAT THE

40:18 - COMMONWEALTH COURT THE FARM

40:20 - THAT'S WHY YOU'RE HERE FOR AND

40:21 - THEN YOU'RE FINE.

40:23 - I I WE WOULD BE WE WOULD

40:25 - ACCEPT THAT. I HAVE IN

40:27 - ADDRESSING THIS THIS COURT

40:29 - COULD FROM THE COMMONWEALTH

40:31 - COURT.

40:32 - AND ALLOW THE BRAIN AND THE

40:33 - COMMONWEALTH COURT. THE WHY YOU

40:35 - GOT REALLY AND THEY CREATED THE

40:37 - REMEDY WATER.

40:40 - WHY ARE YOU BETTER 5 OF THEM.

40:42 - WE ALL ARE, BUT I RECOGNIZE

40:44 - THAT THERE TURNING TO IS THAT

40:46 - THIS COURT COULD WATCH YOU WE

40:48 - CAN SHARE ALL STARTED. WELL GO

40:50 - AHEAD FOR YOU.

40:54 - I MY CLIENTS AND I WOULD BE

40:56 - FINE IF THIS COURT ALLOW.

40:58 - THE COMMONWEALTH COURT

40:59 - OPINION TO STAND IT COULD ALSO

41:02 - CREATE EAT, YOU KNOW ORDER A

41:04 - HYBRID MODEL THERE ARE THERE

41:05 - ARE VARIOUS SORT OF YOU KNOW

41:07 - THERE'S A CONTINUUM

41:08 - OF REMEDIES THE TIME FOR IT

41:11 - SAID, BUT MY PREFERENCE CAN I

41:14 - JUMP IN ON THIS HYBRID APPROACH

41:15 - YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE.

41:17 - IT SEEMS TO ME THERE'S A

41:18 - SCHIZOPHRENICS ASPECT. ON THE

41:21 - ONE HAND.

41:29 - IT'S THE PERSNICKETY ABOUT

41:31 - REGULATIONS THAT ARE.

41:37 - THE MARGIN. YOU'RE ALSO ARE

41:38 - DOING THERE IS IN FACT A DUE

41:40 - PROCESS VIOLATION.

41:48 - THE CASE THAT YOU WANT TO

41:50 - CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN ISSUE IN

41:51 - YOUR BRAIN.

41:53 - THESE REGULATIONS.

41:58 - YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO SHOW A

41:59 - SPECIFICALLY I THINK.

42:03 - CONSISTENCY BECAUSE THE BOTTOM

42:05 - LINE. IS IN THE STATUTE

42:07 - IS THAT YOUR CLIENT IS LOT DOES

42:09 - NOT HAVE A SEAT AT

42:10 - THE TABLE AND THE UTILIZATION

42:12 - OR IN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

42:13 - CREATED IN AND AND SO I DON'T

42:16 - KNOW WHY DR. MAKING

42:17 - DOESN'T BELONG IN THE GENERAL

42:18 - ASSEMBLY RATHER THAN IN THIS

42:19 - COURT.

42:24 - AND THE OTHER AND THIS

42:25 - HEARKENS BACK TO WHAT I SAID AT

42:27 - THE OUTSET OF THE ARGUMENT.

42:28 - THE ACT, THE UTILIZATION REVIEW

42:32 - AS SOLEY ADDRESSING TREATMENT

42:35 - PROVIDED BY A HEALTHCARE

42:37 - PROVIDER.

42:39 - IT DOES NOT ADDRESS

42:40 - TREATMENTNOT TREATMENT AND WORK

42:43 - DONE BY A SERVICE PROVIDER

42:45 - DISPENSING PERFORMING A TASK

42:48 - THAT CENTER

42:49 - IT IS THE IMPLEMENTATION OF

42:52 - THAT PROVISION BY

42:53 - THE BUREAU THAT EXPANDED THE

42:55 - LANGUAGE OF THE UTILIZATION

42:58 - REVIEW TO SERVE AS A BAR,

43:01 - 2 PARTICIPATION OR PAYMENT TO

43:04 - MEDICAL

43:04 - SERVICE PROVIDERS THAT CREATED

43:07 - A CONSTITUTIONAL INFIRMITY AND

43:09 - IS WHY WE ARE.

43:12 - ABOUT IT. YOU KNOW NOT FOLLOW

43:14 - UP TO ME AFTER THE QUESTION

43:16 - THAT I KNOW YOU'RE OPPOSING

43:18 - COUNCIL. WHY CAN'T

43:20 - YOUR CLIENT LOOK TO BE PATIENTS

43:23 - FOR PAIN.

43:24 - THE LINE YOU CANNOT LOOK TO

43:26 - THE PATIENT

43:28 - FOR PAYMENT BECAUSE THERE IS A

43:30 - SPECIFIC PROVISION IN THE ACT

43:32 - AND IN THE REGULATIONS

43:35 - THAT PRECLUDES SEEKING PAYMENT

43:38 - DIRECTLY FROM AND THE

43:40 - INJURED WORKER AND WITH

43:42 - REGARD TO

43:44 - THE PHARMACIES WERE THE THE

43:46 - ENTITIES SUBJECT TO A FEE

43:48 - REVIEW IN THE REGULATIONS

43:50 - SECTION ONE 27.21, 1,

43:52 - FOREIGNERS SUCH REALLY. SO

43:55 - IT IS PRECLUDED AND IT'S ALSO

43:58 - IN 3 '06,

43:59 - 1, 7, THAT PRECLUDES THAT TYPE

44:03 - OF FEELING SO THEY'RE

44:04 - LEFT WITHOUT ANY ABILITY TO

44:07 - COLLECT PAYMENT. I DON'T MIND.

44:09 - WE GOT I TRULY DON'T

44:14 - IT'S SO THOSE

44:15 - SESSIONS ENDING THE SESSION

44:17 - THERE BASED UPON THE

44:18 - PRESUMPTION THAT WORKERS

44:19 - COMPENSATION. IF THEY ARE

44:22 - AVAILABLE.

44:29 - GET IT EVEN IF THEY ARE NOT

44:31 - CONTENT MIGHT BE A IF

44:33 - YOU'RE FINE. IF YOU'RE LOOKING

44:35 - TO PATIENTS AFTER BEST PRACTICE

44:37 - ARGUMENT. BUT THAT'S NOT.

44:40 - MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT HOW

44:42 - THAT WORKS. MEAN IF

44:44 - IF E SERVICES PROVIDED IS NOT

44:47 - POSSIBLE UNDER THE ACT. THE AND.

44:54 - RIGHT SHE

44:55 - COULD DO THE PACE YOU FOR BEING

44:58 - MADE OF ACCORDING TO THE GOLD

45:00 - AND THAT WERE PROVIDED TO THEM.

45:04 - OKAY THAT'S THE CASE AND ME.

45:07 - ANOTHER WAY OF LOOKING

45:08 - AT YOUR ARGUMENT IF YOUR CLIENT

45:13 - WORKERS COMPENSATION, YEAH AND

45:16 - THAT IS JOHN A LOT THE MANNER

45:18 - IN WHICH THE A STATUE.

45:22 - NO MORE OF AN.

45:24 - LEHMAN IS GUARANTEED WE LIVE IN

45:27 - IT. IT'S JUST NOT HOW IT WORKS

45:30 - HERE. I GET. IT A LADY.

45:37 - AND THAT IS

45:38 - WHY COMMONWEALTH COURT. THE

45:40 - ORDER THAT THE EURO.

45:42 - CREATE A PROCESS TO ALLOW MY

45:45 - CLIENTS TO INTERVENE IN THE

45:48 - UTILIZATION REVIEW PROCESS TO

45:51 - PROTECT THEIR RIGHTS.

45:53 - I FEEL OBLIGED TO PICK OUT A

45:55 - TOUGH START TO QUESTION.

45:56 - YES, JUST A FOLLOW-UP TO JUST A

45:59 - START TO HIS QUESTION AND

46:00 - MARKETING BRAD TO A QUESTION BY

46:04 - TO JUST A SAILOR.

46:05 - IT SEEMS TO ME THAT

46:07 - THE PHARMACIES A REMEDY IN A

46:10 - SENSE IS THEY DON'T HAVE.

46:12 - TO SHOES

46:14 - THE 2.

46:16 - CAJUN WORKERS CALL

46:18 - PLANNED ASKED TO

46:20 - CHOOSE TO FILL PRESCRIPTIONS IN

46:23 - THIS COULD CHOOSE

46:25 - NOT TO ACCEPT THIS TYPE

46:29 - CLIENT THIS TYPE OF INJURED

46:30 - WORKER THIS TYPE OF WORKERS

46:32 - COMPENSATION. INSURANCE SCHEME

46:35 - THEY THEY DON'T HAVE THEY DO.

46:37 - CORRECT.

46:38 - YES, BUT THE DIFFICULTY IS

46:40 - THE PURPOSE OF THE WORKERS

46:41 - COMPENSATION AT THE PRIMARY

46:44 - PURPOSE IS TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE

46:47 - MEDICAL TREATMENT AND CARE TO

46:49 - INJURED WORKERS THEY'RE ABLE TO

46:50 - RETURN TO WORK. SURE YOUR

46:52 - HONORS.

46:55 - IS THIS ON THE BASIS OF THE

46:57 - QUESTION IS EXCEPTED THEN YOU

47:00 - BE.

47:01 - BECAUSE ALL OF THESE ENTITIES

47:03 - HAVE NO ABILITY TO PARTICIPATE

47:05 - IN THE

47:05 - UTILIZATION REVIEW. IT MEANS

47:07 - THAT NOT ONLY WILL PATIENTS

47:09 - INJURED WORKERS

47:10 - POTENTIALLY HAVE AND INABILITY

47:12 - TO

47:12 - OBTAIN MEDICATION. THEY'LL HAVE

47:14 - AN INABILITY TO OBTAIN

47:16 - DIAGNOSTIC TESTS MRI CAT SCANS

47:20 - MEDICAL TESTING THEY'LL HAVE

47:22 - THE SAME CHALLENGE

47:24 - TO GET PHYSICAL THERAPY WILL

47:26 - HAVE THE SAME CHALLENGE TO GET

47:27 - DURABLE EQUIPMENT AND WHILE

47:29 - YES, YOU HAVE TO BALANCE THE

47:31 - RISKS THE ACT WAS NOT DESIGNED

47:34 - TO SHIFT

47:35 - THE RISK OF ALL OF THOSE TYPES

47:38 - OF CARE. ONE TO

47:39 - THOSE PROVIDERS WITHOUT ANY

47:42 - ABILITY FOR THEM TO PROTECT THE

47:43 - RIM.

47:49 - THAT SEEMS TO BE

47:50 - THE PRESIDENT. THE GENERAL

47:52 - ASSEMBLY HAS LAID ON YOUR

47:53 - DOORSTEP.

47:57 - MAKE SURE TO CHANGE THE LAW TO

47:59 - ADDRESS THE THE UNFAIRNESS JUST

48:01 - PALPABLE SECTION AREAS.

48:06 - HE SAYS BY

48:07 - SELF ENSURING BY SPREADING THE

48:09 - RISK.

48:11 - BY REFUSING THESE KIND OF

48:13 - PATIENTS WC PATIENTS THAT IS.

48:16 - IN THE MAN UNDER SOME CONTRACT

48:18 - VERY I MEAN

48:19 - IF YOU SEEM TO BE COMING TO US

48:21 - IN IN SORT OF A MODALITY COURT

48:23 - OF JUSTICE. AND THAT'S REALLY

48:26 - NOT ARE. WELL IS IT.

48:28 - WELL THIS COURT'S ROLE IT

48:30 - WOULD BE TOO

48:32 - TO ADDRESS DUE PROCESS

48:34 - VIOLATIONS WHICH IS THE ISSUE

48:37 - HERE AND IN ADDITION. I MEAN

48:39 - IT'S FOR THE

48:41 - UTILIZATION REVIEW PROCESS ONLY

48:44 - APPLIES TO HEALTH CARE

48:45 - PROVIDERS WHICH HAS BEEN

48:47 - CHANGED BY THE BUREAU'S

48:49 - REGULATIONS IN A MANNER

48:51 - THAT CREATED THIS DUE PROCESS

48:53 - VIOLATION BUT THIS SPORT ALWAYS

48:55 - HAS THE ABILITY TO ADDRESS DUE

48:57 - PROCESS VIOLATIONS. THAT THE

49:00 - LAW GOES BACK AS THE CHIEF

49:03 - MARBURY VERSUS MADISON.

49:04 - THIS IS SAFE BUT CHIEF

49:06 - JUSTICE BARRETT IN YOUR TIME

49:08 - AND YOUR MONEY TOO. WE USE THIS

49:12 - ROUTE.

49:13 - YOUR CONTENTION IS THAT THERE'S

49:15 - A DEPRIVATION OF DUE PROCESS.

49:17 - IN THE AFTER THE BREAK.

49:20 - OBVIOUSLY THERE'S NO LIFE OR

49:21 - LIBERTY AND SO YOU HAVE TO

49:23 - CLAIM A BEST FIT

49:25 - CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED

49:27 - PROPERTY.

49:28 - IT'S ME MUCH MUCH GREATER JUST

49:31 - A QUICK. THANK YOU THAT YEAR, A

49:34 - BUSINESS THAT IT STANDS FOR.

49:38 - AND IN IN HAS IN THE CAR YOU

49:40 - SEE DOUBLE IT HAD A SICK

49:42 - PATIENT OF THING.

49:43 - BUT I DON'T SEE WHERE WE UNIQUE

49:45 - FROM ANY OTHER BUSINESSES.

49:48 - IT'LL MAKE THIS IS IF YOU DO

49:50 - THAT YOU HAVE SOME BOSSES STILL

49:52 - HAVE.

49:53 - MANY WERE GOING TO DIE. BUT I

49:55 - JUST DON'T SEE WHERE YOUR

49:56 - EXPECTATION CARS THAT HIS 3

49:59 - BEST INTERESTS.

50:03 - MISTER CHIEF JUSTICE GOES

50:04 - BACK TO THE SULLIVAN CASE WHERE

50:07 - THE SUPREME

50:08 - COURT FOUND THAT THERE WAS NO

50:10 - DEPRIVATION IN THE UTILIZATION

50:12 - REVIEW PROCESS, THE HAWES THE

50:15 - MEDICAL

50:15 - CARE PROVIDERS HAVE THE ABILITY

50:18 - TO PARTICIPATE IN THE

50:19 - UTILIZATION REVIEW BEFORE THEY

50:21 - WERE DEPRIVED OF THEIR RIGHT TO

50:23 - COMPENSATION FOR TREATMENT.

50:26 - WHEN YOU APPLY THAT IN

50:27 - THIS CASE THAT SAME PROTECTION

50:30 - DOES NOT APPLY TO MEDICAL

50:32 - SERVICE PROVIDERS SO WHERE THE

50:35 - SUPREME COURT FOUND THAT

50:37 - THE ACT PROTECT

50:38 - DUE PROCESS. THEY PROVIDE DUE

50:41 - PROCESS TO MEDICAL

50:43 - CARE PROVIDERS THAT SAME

50:46 - ANALYSIS BALES 4 CLIENTS SUCH

50:49 - AS MINE.

50:53 - ANY FURTHER FROM THE COURT.

50:56 - THANK YOU. THANK YOU

50:58 - IN EVERY BITE.

51:00 - WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A

51:01 - FIVE-MINUTE BREAK THROUGH ALL

51:03 - OF OUR STAFF

51:05 - AND THE COUNCIL GO ABOUT THEIR

51:07 - DAY AND TO GET

51:08 - YOU OUT. SO WE'LL STAND IN A

51:10 - TERM OF 5.

51:44 - THE NEXT APPEAL

51:45 - IS KIND OF CONSOLIDATED SCHOOL

51:47 - DISTRICT FORCES, THE CHESTER

51:48 - COUNTY BOARD OF ASSESSMENT

51:49 - APPEALS

51:50 - AND AUTISM REPRESENTING ON HIS

51:53 - OWN MISS SHARON

51:54 - AFTER POWER REPRESENTING

51:55 - TENANTS SCHOOL DISTRICT IS

51:57 - MISTER SCOTT

51:57 - OUR WEATHER REPRESENTING

51:59 - CHESTER COUNTY IS MISTER

52:01 - ANTHONY IM BROOKE.

52:08 - THIS CASE INVOLVES A

52:10 - CONSTITUTIONAL CHALLENGE.

52:11 - THE SCHOOL DISTRICT METHOD FOR

52:14 - MONEY WHICH PROPERTY ASSESSMENTS

52:15 - SCHOOL FIELD. THE APPELLANT

52:17 - CONTENDS THAT THE SCHOOL

52:18 - DISTRICT VIOLATED THE UNIFORM

52:20 - OF THE PFIZER THE

52:21 - PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION BY

52:23 - EMPLOYING A METHOD SUBDIVIDED

52:25 - REAL ESTATE IN THE HISTORY FACE

52:28 - ON ON A VERY STRESSFUL AND TAKE

52:31 - THEIR PLACE. THE

52:33 - REAL ESTATE EAR COMMERCIAL

52:35 - VERSUS RESIDENTIAL

52:36 - REAL ESTATE. THE SCHOOL

52:38 - DISTRICT IN THE COUNTY BOARD OF

52:39 - ASSESSMENT ARE DUBIOUS AS THE

52:41 - DECISIONS THE COURT. THE

52:43 - UNIFORMITY CLAUSE AND

52:46 - THIS COURT ACCEPTED REVIEW FOR

52:50 - PEOPLE THAT'S

52:51 - THE BASIC AFTER A RELATIVELY

52:54 - RECENT VALLEY FORGE DECISION.

52:58 - IF I GOT THAT PRETTY CLOSE TO

53:00 - CORRECT MISS THE FOLLOW.

53:01 - THEY'RE ARGUING FOR A FELONY.

53:03 - THEY ARE DOING Q. IT.

53:07 - THEY PLACE THE COURT MY NAME

53:09 - IS HOLLOW AND I REPRESENT THE

53:11 - HOLLAND ON HIS OWN DEVELOPMENT

53:13 - CORPORATION.

53:15 - TO MEET THE CONSTITUTIONAL

53:16 - MANDATE TO THE TAXING

53:17 - AUTHORITIES THAT ALL TAXES

53:19 - SHELLEY THE SAME CLASS.

53:22 - IT REQUIRES THAT THE CONTACT

53:24 - THE MEASURE AND THEN NOTHING

53:26 - AND WHO WOULD BUY THE TAXING

53:27 - AUTHORITIES ARE YOU KNOW ONLY A

53:30 - FULL CAREER PRESENT AND THERE

53:31 - BE UNIFORMITY IN THE TAX BURDEN

53:34 - IN HOPES THE STATE THIS COURT

53:36 - FACE FOR THE FIRST TIME THE

53:37 - ISSUE DIRECTLY BEFORE THE COURT

53:39 - TODAY AND ACCORDING TO THEIR

53:41 - DEFENDED THE PLANE. THE NEW TAX

53:43 - THRESHOLD BASED ON THE SIZE OF

53:45 - THE STATE

53:46 - IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL. SINCE THAT

53:48 - TIME THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

53:50 - AND ITS POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS

53:52 - HAVE REPEATEDLY ATTEMPTED TAX

53:53 - SCHEMES WHICH HAVE SOME AND

53:56 - DIFFERENT MEASURES

53:57 - THEN ON AND EACH TIME THIS

53:59 - COURT HAS STRUCK DOWN SCHEME.

54:02 - 2 RECENTLY ANNEXED TELL THE

54:03 - SPORT CENT LESSON PATIENTS FACE

54:05 - SALLING ON

54:06 - THE QUANTITY. DOWN THE PROPERTY

54:09 - TAX OR ARBITRARY AND

54:10 - UNREASONABLE. BECAUSE ALL REAL

54:13 - ESTATE IS ONE CLASS. THE TEST

54:15 - HISTORY FALL IT MAINLY TO

54:17 - EXAMINE THE EFFECTIVE TAX RATE

54:19 - TO SIMILARLY SITUATED PROPERTY.

54:22 - THE TASK IN THE SUPPLY HEAR WHY

54:26 - 1 MILLION DOLLARS SPECIAL

54:27 - ASCENSION PROPERTIES. BOTH OF

54:29 - WHICH HAVE AN ACTUAL DOWN IN

54:30 - MORE PLACES 2 MILLION DOLLARS

54:32 - THE FIRST OF WHICH IS CURRENTLY

54:34 - ASSESSED AT ONE GO IN THERE GET

54:36 - AND THE SECOND OF WHICH IS

54:37 - ASSESSED AT 1.1 NOW. A CLIMATE

54:41 - RUSH HOME, THE FIRST PROPERTY

54:43 - WOULD BE APPEALED.

54:44 - RAYS TO 2 MILLION DOLLARS AND

54:46 - AN EFFECTIVE TAX RATE OF

54:48 - 1.9%. THE SECOND PROPERTY

54:50 - POLICE CAPE APPEAL. THEY OWN

54:53 - 1.1 MILLION IN EFFECT A TAX

54:55 - RATE, 1.1% TO

54:58 - IDENTICAL PROPERTIES. BOTH FOR

55:00 - 2 MILLION THE MARKET. ONE

55:02 - EFFECT OF TAX RATE IS NEARLY

55:04 - DOUBLE THAT

55:05 - V A ALL BECAUSE OF THE BASE

55:07 - WILL MOVE FULL STEAM,

55:08 - IT'S A DIFFERENT MEASURE IN

55:10 - TAXATION. ONLY WHEN

55:12 - THE AUNT, THE METHOD AND THE

55:14 - MEASURE ARE YOU FOR AND UNDER

55:17 - PRINCIPLE APPLICATION OF THE

55:18 - LAW FRIENDS AND WE ACHIEVED

55:20 - CONSTITUTE FOR YOU OR ME IN

55:22 - TAXATION.

55:27 - IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT THAT.

55:30 - THE DECISION THE THIS WAS NOT

55:33 - A DELIBERATE. TO A

55:36 - PARTICULAR CLASS. BUT RATHER

55:38 - THE PURPOSE WAS MAKING A

55:39 - PRUDENT FINANCIAL. A IF YOU

55:43 - BELIEVE THAT'S JUST PRETEXTUAL

55:45 - THAT THAT APPROACH WHAT WHAT

55:47 - ARE YOU SAYING HERE.

55:49 - YES GET THE I HEAR 2 QUESTIONS

55:52 - THERE JUST HAS TO ONE IS TO THE

55:54 - COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS THAT

55:56 - MCCONNELL COURT WAS INFLUENCED.

55:58 - WE JUST THE SCHOOL'S RATIONALE

56:00 - AND THEN ALL SNOW WHETHER

56:02 - IT BE SCHOOLS RATIONALE IS

56:04 - PRETAX IN SINGING AND THE

56:06 - ANSWER TO THE PRETEXT QUESTION

56:08 - FIRST. WHAT

56:12 - WE'RE SEEING. WHAT WE'RE SEEING

56:17 - ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS.

56:21 - RATHER

56:22 - THAN ALLOW A TAXING DISTRICT TO

56:24 - HIDE BEHIND FACIALLY NEUTRAL

56:26 - SCHEME AND SAY DON'T LOOK AT

56:28 - THE IMPACT IN FACT AND THOSE

56:31 - THAT WE'RE FEELING.

56:34 - FORD IS

56:35 - ALLOWING SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO

56:36 - NOT HAVE A POLICY

56:38 - IN WRITING THAT'S IN THE COUNTY

56:40 - IS WHERE THEY SAID THIS SPORT,

56:41 - IT REQUIRES THAT THE POLICY

56:43 - BEING WRITING THEY'RE REQUIRING

56:45 - POLICY THEY'RE ALLOWING

56:47 - POLICIES TO BE AN ACTIVE 5

56:48 - YEARS AFTER THE DEAL WAS TAKEN

56:50 - THAT'S THE COMMONWEALTH COURT.

56:52 - IN A SCHOOL DISTRICT MAY 2020.

56:55 - AND THEY'RE ONLY REPORTING THE

56:57 - PROPERTY OWNER. REQUIRE

56:59 - ALLOWING SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO

57:01 - HIDE BEHIND SELF-SERVING

57:02 - STATEMENTS THAT SAY WE MET HIM

57:04 - HE SAYS WE JUST DIDN'T FIND

57:05 - THEM.

57:07 - COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS.

57:10 - A COURT IN HE'S ALONE IN THIS

57:12 - CASE.

57:15 - WE FEAR THAT THIS SPORT AND IN

57:17 - VALLEY FORGE ALLOW A BALANCE

57:20 - BETWEEN SCHOOL DISTRICTS COST

57:22 - BENEFIT AND THE REQUIREMENT OF

57:24 - UNIFORM. THAT'S NOT CONSISTENT

57:27 - WITH THE SPORTS

57:28 - HOLDING BOTH THAT UNIFORMITY IS

57:30 - THE

57:30 - PREEMINENT PRINCIPLE AND ALSO

57:32 - WE LOOK TO THE SALISBURY

57:33 - DECISION OF THIS COURT.

57:36 - THAT THAT CRASH

57:37 - SPOTIFY WAS SQUARELY ADDRESSED

57:40 - AND REJECTED BY THE COURT AS A

57:42 - BALANCING AGAINST UNIFORM.

57:48 - IF YOU LOOK AT I COULDN'T

57:50 - FOLLOW UP.

57:54 - IN CASE, I

57:55 - MEAN THAT THE TAXING BODIES,

57:57 - THEY'RE SET UP ONLY THE TAX

57:59 - COMMERCIAL ENTITIES HERE THEY

58:01 - TOLD THE GUY GO OUT.

58:05 - OTHERS IN THE REACH OF

58:06 - YOUR ART YET BECAUSE ADULTS ARE

58:08 - ENDED BACKS UP TO BE CONSTRUED

58:10 - GUESS YOU'RE RIGHT. THIS COMES

58:11 - UP WITH US THE MOVIE A SUMMARY

58:13 - JUDGMENT.

58:23 - THE GUNS AND GOT OUT

58:25 - DOWN MILLIONAIRE'S ROW AND

58:28 - 13 PROPERTIES THAT HE AND HIS

58:30 - EXPERT YOU

58:31 - FELT WERE A LIKELY TO BE UNDER

58:33 - ASSESS. STANCH LEADER SAYS AND

58:35 - GO AFTER.

58:40 - ISN'T IT. THE CASE.

58:45 - THE B B'S.

58:48 - THE TAXATION.

58:54 - WHEN ANYBODY THE ATTACK

58:55 - BEARS OR SCHOOL DISTRICTS

58:57 - BRINGING APPEAL.

59:02 - WITH RESPECT TO THE QUESTION

59:04 - ABOUT HOW THEY SELECTED APPEALS

59:07 - AND THE DISTINCTION ON THE

59:08 - BACKS OF AL GORE.

59:15 - ALL HIGHLY DOWN

59:17 - COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES. THAT'S

59:18 - IN THE RECORD AT ONE 85.

59:20 - AND THERE ARE 9,500 PROPERTIES

59:23 - IN DISTRICT. SO IT MAKES NO

59:25 - MATTER IF IT'S 12 MILLIONAIRES

59:27 - OR CALL MARSHALL PROPERTY

59:28 - OWNERS. THE OTHER WAY THE

59:31 - EFFECTIVE TAX RATE

59:32 - IS GOING TO BE HIGHER FOR THE

59:34 - FALL PROPERTIES THAT THE APPEAL

59:36 - FOR THE POLICE

59:37 - SITUATED PROPERTIES SO I CAN

59:39 - SIT WITH PROPERTIES WILL BE

59:40 - PAYING DIFFERENT EFFECTIVE

59:42 - TAX RATES DEPENDING ON WHETHER

59:44 - THEY GOT HIT OR NOT HIT BY THE

59:46 - SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR PEEL.

59:49 - THE COUNCIL JUST AS YOU MAYBE

59:52 - I'M SENDING AND WHAT OUR GIVE

59:54 - ME GIVE YOU THE WIFE.

59:56 - I THOUGHT THAT YOUR ARGUMENT

59:58 - WITH PREMISED ON THE NOTION

59:59 - 059 THAT THERE WAS DISPARATE

01:00 - 02.589 TREATMENT BETWEEN COMMERCIAL

01:00 - 04.589 AND RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY IS

01:00 - 06.000 THAT NOT WHAT YOU ARE GIVEN.

01:00 - 09.249 THAT IS AN ARGUMENT AS WELL

01:00 - 10.360 JUST AS TONY YOU.

01:00 - 12.559 AND PRIMARILY IS THAT

01:00 - 14.229 THEY HAVE SELECTED BASED ON A

01:00 - 16.499 MONETARY THRESHOLD WHICH IS SET

01:00 - 17.719 FORTH IN THEIR ASSAULT AND

01:00 - 19.689 EMAIL THAT SAYS ALL PROPERTIES

01:00 - 22.380 THAT ARE UNDER SAYS. AND ALL.

01:00 - 27.739 OF THE CASE ARE THAT THEY ALSO

01:00 - 29.540 ONLY FIELD MARSHAL PROFIT.

01:00 - 31.750 WE BELIEVE THAT THE

01:00 - 33.349 MORE FORD'S AND THE

01:00 - 35.479 COMMONWEALTH COURT HAVE

01:00 - 37.289 NARROWLY CONSTRUED VALLEY FORGE

01:00 - 37.890 TO MEAN THAT

01:00 - 40.769 IT'S OK TO APPEAL. MARSHALL SO

01:00 - 42.689 LONG AS YOU CONSIDER APPEALING

01:00 - 43.690 PRESIDENTIAL.

01:00 - 46.860 YES, MY NEXT

01:00 - 49.959 COMING INTO THIS ARGUMENT I

01:00 - 52.639 WOULD WORKING AND GAVE

01:00 - 55.589 THE IMPRESSION THAT YOU RE VERY

01:00 - 57.669 I THINK MY FAME WAS BASED ON

01:00 - 01.259 THE COMMERCIAL VERSUS BUT THE

01:01 - 02.660 CAJUNS OF PROPERTY.

01:01 - 05.639 IT ELAINE I WANT TO FOLLOW

01:01 - 06.869 THROUGH ON THAT BECAUSE I THINK

01:01 - 08.169 THAT WHAT YOUR ARGUMENT IS THAT

01:01 - 09.719 THINK THAT WAY THAT THE

01:01 - 11.119 COMMONWEALTH COURT ADDRESSED

01:01 - 12.120 THE STATE.

01:01 - 15.159 YOU KNOW A NEW RECORD THAT

01:01 - 16.620 THERE WERE IN ANY.

01:01 - 19.299 A RESIDENT FELLOW PIECES

01:01 - 22.079 OF PROPERTY THAT WERE EXCLUDED

01:01 - 23.700 FROM THIS ASSESSMENT PROCESS.

01:01 - 26.920 ISN'T IT YOUR CLIENT.

01:01 - 36.609 BRIAN ARE BASED ON THE

01:01 - 38.290 ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS

01:01 - 40.409 HERE ARE THE SCHOOL THE FIRE

01:01 - 42.489 LONG HAUL PROPERTIES ALL OF

01:01 - 43.680 WHICH ARE MARSHALL.

01:01 - 47.369 THEIR OWN ACTIONS DEMONSTRATE

01:01 - 48.849 THAT THEY SELECTED WHO

01:01 - 49.850 PROPERTIES FOR

01:01 - 55.069 MEAN IT IN ACTION LARRY I

01:01 - 56.609 DIDN'T WORRY THAT THE ANSWER

01:01 - 57.040 WOULD BE

01:01 - 59.279 EVIDENT REQUESTED WHERE IS THE

01:01 - 00.749 EVIDENCE THAT THERE WERE ANY

01:02 - 03.259 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY IN FACT IN

01:02 - 05.489 DISTRESS THAT FELL WITHIN THE

01:02 - 06.490 CRITERIA.

01:02 - 08.459 THAT IS NOT IN THE RECORD,

01:02 - 11.090 YOU KNOW. ISN'T THAT YOUR BIRD

01:02 - 14.489 TO ESTABLISH THAT THERE WERE

01:02 - 16.589 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY IN ORDER

01:02 - 17.590 TO.

01:02 - 21.219 WAYSIDE VERY BIG THING BETWEEN

01:02 - 22.369 RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL

01:02 - 23.370 PROPERTY.

01:02 - 32.829 AND UNFAIR BURDEN ON

01:02 - 34.749 THE TAXPAYER. THEY HAVE TO

01:02 - 36.079 PROVE ABOUT WHAT THE SCHOOL

01:02 - 38.209 SELECTION SKI MASK AND THERE'S

01:02 - 38.590 THE MATTER

01:02 - 40.919 PUBLIC POLICY SINCE THE SCHOOL

01:02 - 42.779 HAS A CONSTITUTIONAL MANDATE TO

01:02 - 45.919 IMPLEMENT ITS POLICY. UNIFORMLY

01:02 - 47.050 AND TRANSPARENTLY.

01:02 - 49.339 IT SAID TELL US WHAT THE

01:02 - 51.429 HOMELESS WEEKENDS AND ONCE WE

01:02 - 52.589 DEMONSTRATE AN OPERATION

01:02 - 55.359 IN FACT THE POLICY UNFAIRLY 3

01:02 - 57.329 TO ONE LAST FOR SOME DEVICE, A

01:02 - 59.439 COST. THE INQUIRY ENDS AND THE

01:02 - 00.290 GREEN SHIFTS TO THE

01:03 - 02.059 SCHOOL DISTRICT TO PROVE THIS

01:03 - 03.479 POLICY IS NOT THAT WE

01:03 - 06.029 DID NOT IMPLEMENT THE POLICY

01:03 - 07.040 AND FUNDING REFORM.

01:03 - 14.749 I MENTIONED THIS

01:03 - 17.089 IS HERE FROM SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

01:03 - 18.480 THE COMPANY IS THAT CORRECT.

01:03 - 20.809 IT WAS A MOTION TO QUASH A

01:03 - 22.010 MOTION TO DISMISS.

01:03 - 23.319 THE MOTION THE NEXT I DO

01:03 - 24.870 RECALL THAT THE MOST THE CLOCK.

01:03 - 27.470 THE INDICTMENT TRIAL COURT.

01:03 - 32.770 SCHOOL IS CELTICS EMAIL.

01:03 - 35.820 THE MAIL TO SELL IT SAID.

01:03 - 37.390 I TAKE.

01:03 - 40.169 IT WOULD GIVE US ADVICE IS WHAT

01:03 - 41.959 IS MOST ON THAT UNDER A

01:03 - 44.759 SET INSUFFICIENT SUFFICIENT TO

01:03 - 46.659 JUSTIFY COST EFFECTIVE TAKING

01:03 - 48.559 THE FIELD THAT WHAT YOU'RE

01:03 - 50.759 REALLY SAYING IF YOU BELIEVE

01:03 - 51.760 THAT.

01:03 - 57.140 THE CONSULTANT

01:03 - 59.469 ALSO SAD. I RECOMMEND THAT YOU

01:03 - 01.019 FEEL THE SMALL PROPERTIES ARE

01:04 - 02.020 DESPITE KNOWN.

01:04 - 04.550 IF YOU'RE

01:04 - 06.429 HUMAN THAT YOU HAVE OF GETTING

01:04 - 08.130 YOU IN THESE 2 MATERIALS BACK.

01:04 - 11.700 AS TO WHETHER THE WHO IS GREAT.

01:04 - 16.810 THEIR ASSESSMENT BASED ON.

01:04 - 18.890 THE MOST UNDER A DESK

01:04 - 20.700 OR THE VIDING IT

01:04 - 21.989 PROPERTIES WORTH A MILLION OR

01:04 - 23.089 LESS A MILLION AND WE WANT TO

01:04 - 24.090 TRY THAT.

01:04 - 28.959 THE THE E-MAIL THAT YOU

01:04 - 30.919 REFERRED TO A CONSULTANT FOR

01:04 - 32.410 THE SCHOOL MANAGER SAYS

01:04 - 34.119 APPEAL THE MOST UNDER SAYS

01:04 - 35.649 PROPERTIES WITHOUT REGARD TO

01:04 - 36.650 CLASS.

01:04 - 41.159 SO SERVING STATEMENTS WHO ARE AT

01:04 - 43.129 THE SCHOOLS MENTIONED EVERY WE

01:04 - 44.509 FEEL SOME PROPERTIES THAT ARE

01:04 - 46.859 ON RECESS. IF SCHOOLS ARE

01:04 - 49.379 ALLOWED TO REHEARSAL POLICY

01:04 - 51.540 THAT'S BAD NEWS THAT HAPPENED.

01:04 - 52.999 WE CAN NEVER ENFORCED

01:04 - 54.000 UNIFORMITY.

01:04 - 57.099 THAT'S WHY LOOK TO

01:04 - 58.879 THE OPERATION THAT BACK TO WHAT

01:04 - 00.080 THEY ACTUALLY FEEL.

01:05 - 01.530 THIS FOLLOWED.

01:05 - 05.329 AGAIN I'M NOT A PURELY ON

01:05 - 06.499 SUMMARY JUDGMENT THERE ON A

01:05 - 07.500 MOTION TO QUASH.

01:05 - 09.489 WHEN HE HAVE AN ISSUE

01:05 - 10.729 OR NOT HAVE AN ISSUE IS THIS

01:05 - 11.839 THE DAWN WHO SAID YOU HAVE TO

01:05 - 13.329 BRING UP EVIDENCE CREATED

01:05 - 14.330 JANUARY.

01:05 - 17.440 WERE YOU A CRUEL. THAT

01:05 - 20.060 IT IS THIS IS A IT'S A.

01:05 - 23.290 CROWN COURT AFTER 2 HEARING.

01:05 - 25.669 THE TERMINALS THAT'S THE

01:05 - 27.619 ASSESSMENT OCCURRING HERE IF

01:05 - 30.499 THEY SLOWLY ON WHAT IS THE MOST

01:05 - 32.509 UNDER SAYS PROPERTY THAT DOES

01:05 - 34.040 NOT VIOLATE UNIFORM.

01:05 - 39.049 I THINK WE NEED TO HAVE A

01:05 - 40.429 STANDARD FOR WHAT THE MOST

01:05 - 42.789 ONEROUS ESTIS I THINK IF WE

01:05 - 44.949 ALLOW SCHOOLS TO HAVE A STANDARD

01:05 - 46.809 THAT SAYS THE APPEAL SOME BUT

01:05 - 48.679 NOT OTHERS IN HOLMES APARTMENT,

01:05 - 50.909 I KNOW IT WHEN I SEE IT THAT'S

01:05 - 52.180 NOT THE STANDARD AT ALL.

01:05 - 56.399 POWERFUL THEREFORE ARE YOU

01:05 - 57.400 SAYING DAS.

01:05 - 59.309 THAT'S THERE FOR SCHOOL

01:05 - 01.730 DISTRICTS HAVE TO APPEAL EVERY.

01:06 - 08.159 THEY VIEW IN IN THEIR CATCHMENT

01:06 - 09.790 AREA OR NO 9.

01:06 - 12.469 THE FACE. I MEAN THAT YOU DON'T

01:06 - 14.880 ACCEPT. ANY CRITERIA.

01:06 - 19.999 SPORT LENA, 3 OPTIONS FOR

01:06 - 22.639 SCHOOL DISTRICTS BY THAT AND

01:06 - 24.129 REJECTED THAT THE ONLY OPTION

01:06 - 25.679 TO THEM IS TO APPEAL ALL

01:06 - 27.460 PROPERTY AND THE OPTIONS ARE.

01:06 - 29.650 OF COURSE NOW THE PRINCIPAL.

01:06 - 33.609 RAISING NO INJURY OR ASKING FOR

01:06 - 34.990 A COUNTYWIDE REASSESSMENT.

01:06 - 50.409 IF MISTER LUKENS HAD

01:06 - 51.430 CONTINUED DRIVING.

01:06 - 56.030 REALLY WEALTHY NEIGHBORHOOD.

01:06 - 59.419 SENT AN E-MAIL BACK TO THE

01:06 - 00.559 DISTRICT IS THAT I THINK THESE

01:07 - 02.759 13 ARE LIKELY TO BE ADDRESSED

01:07 - 04.859 BY MORE THAN YOU

01:07 - 06.559 KNOW, BUT BUT MORE THAN A

01:07 - 07.560 MILLION TO MARKET.

01:07 - 10.719 WOULD YOU BE STANDING IN FRONT

01:07 - 13.879 OF US IN SAYING THAT IN A FORM

01:07 - 16.050 OF THE CAUSE. A VIOLATION.

01:07 - 21.409 MONETARY PRESS ON THE RIGHT

01:07 - 22.410 LINE AND STAND.

01:07 - 24.979 IS A NEW YORK OR

01:07 - 27.539 ANY VIOLATION BECAUSE IT SAYS

01:07 - 29.179 TO PERFECTED RATES FOR PEOPLE

01:07 - 30.539 JUST UNDER AND JUST OVER THE

01:07 - 32.569 THRESHOLD. JUST AS IN MOUNT

01:07 - 34.349 AIRY AND JUST AS THEN

01:07 - 37.209 NEXT TELL AND ALL OTHER CASES

01:07 - 38.719 IN WHICH THIS COURT HAS A VALUE

01:07 - 40.299 DEFECTIVE HATCH MAKING A LINE

01:07 - 41.330 IN THE SAND IS STRONG.

01:07 - 43.619 WAIT A MINUTE YOU'RE I THINK

01:07 - 45.419 YOU'RE IMPROVING ON YOUR ON

01:07 - 47.229 YOUR RECORD SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR

01:07 - 48.230 ON MOTION HERE.

01:07 - 58.259 IF YOU'RE DOING SO IN THE

01:07 - 01.270 STRAIT ONLY OF THE EMAIL EAR.

01:08 - 08.879 THERE IS NO COST BENEFIT

01:08 - 10.260 ANALYSIS ALLOW.

01:08 - 14.800 TITLE TO UNDERTAKE.

01:08 - 20.140 THEY THEY WILL BRING THEM.

01:08 - 25.990 TESTS DOWN JUST WHY.

01:08 - 31.009 IT'S THE SCHOOL DISTRICT

01:08 - 32.779 POLICIES BASED ON BEFORE NOW

01:08 - 34.650 THE PRINCIPAL I THINK IT STANDS.

01:08 - 36.729 THEY USING

01:08 - 38.809 THE COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS AS

01:08 - 40.349 THEIR EXPLANATION FOR CHOOSING

01:08 - 42.189 SOME MORE NOW THAT OTHERS I

01:08 - 43.469 DON'T THINK STANDS UNDER THIS

01:08 - 45.819 COURT'S PRECEDENT I THINK COMES

01:08 - 48.239 TO THE UNIFORMITY REFORM AND

01:08 - 49.750 THE HIGHER THE COST TO SHIP.

01:08 - 53.339 IT'S JUST A VERY GOOD

01:08 - 55.579 BUT REALLY THEY'RE GENERALLY

01:08 - 57.260 WEEK ASIDE QUESTIONS, THE LAW,

01:08 - 59.519 YOU KNOW YOU'RE 30 AROUND THE

01:08 - 00.959 REALLY HAVE A BASIC FACILE

01:09 - 02.829 DISPUTE THAT YOU'RE REALLY JUST

01:09 - 05.069 SAYING TO US IS I MY CLIENT

01:09 - 06.530 DOESN'T BELIEVE SCHOOL DISTRICT

01:09 - 08.379 WHEN SCHOOL DISTRICT SAYS WE

01:09 - 10.469 BASED OUR ASSESSMENT ON MOST

01:09 - 11.470 UNDERSTAND.

01:09 - 13.899 THAT'S THAT'S THE SUM AND

01:09 - 15.609 SUBSTANCE OF THE ARGUMENT NOT

01:09 - 16.810 REALLY FIGHTING ABOUT THE LAW.

01:09 - 19.850 THAT IS THAT UNFAIR TO YOU.

01:09 - 24.929 RECORD OF THE SCHOOL'S OWN

01:09 - 26.279 STATEMENTS FROM THE ONLY

01:09 - 27.930 EVIDENCE THAT WENT IN ON 5.

01:09 - 29.280 THE SCHOOL.

01:09 - 31.359 I ASKED THE CONSULTANT TO LOOK

01:09 - 32.360 AT ALL THE PROBLEMS AND ARE

01:09 - 33.829 ASSESSED AND THE RETURN THAT

01:09 - 35.219 THEY THOUGHT IS PROPERTIES ON

01:09 - 36.609 YOUR MONEY IN DOLLARS AND

01:09 - 38.399 RECESSED AND THE SCHOOL ADOPTED

01:09 - 39.929 THAT ON THE BASIS OF THE

01:09 - 41.279 RECOMMENDATION OF ITS AGENTS.

01:09 - 42.639 SO I THINK THE FACT IS THE

01:09 - 44.929 SCHOOLS, A POLICY BY INTO

01:09 - 45.380 ACTION.

01:09 - 47.250 THE TRIAL COURT DISAGREED.

01:09 - 50.279 THE QUESTION IS THE ROUTE 45

01:09 - 52.119 BEFORE A RECORD SUFFICIENT

01:09 - 54.309 PERMITTED TO DISAGREE. AND

01:09 - 55.799 THAT'S ALL THIS CASE IS REALLY

01:09 - 56.800 ABOUT.

01:10 - 02.710 I THINK THAN THE.

01:10 - 05.270 SCHOOL

01:10 - 07.249 HAS TO BE HOME TO THE ACTIONS

01:10 - 09.149 THAT IT ACTUALLY FELL AS

01:10 - 10.669 OPPOSED TO THE

01:10 - 12.559 ACTIONS THAT DAY OR THE

01:10 - 14.169 STATEMENTS THAT IT MAKES AFTER

01:10 - 15.800 THE FACT ABOUT WHAT IT MEANT BY

01:10 - 19.340 YOU WANT YOU WANT THERE TO

01:10 - 22.559 EYES FROM THIS INCOMPLETE

01:10 - 24.389 RECORD THAT THERE'S CLEAR

01:10 - 26.339 EVIDENCE OF PROJECTS. I GUESS

01:10 - 27.940 BASICALLY JUST ON THE SPRING.

01:10 - 31.360 THE OUTPUT. IT WAS 12% DROP.

01:10 - 36.970 THEY SAY YOU DON'T HAVE 5.

01:10 - 40.210 ACTUAL IN ANY ANY ONE GROUP.

01:10 - 42.869 IT FEELS WE'VE GOT A FORM OF

01:10 - 43.870 THE VIOLATION.

01:10 - 48.520 IT NEEDS TO UP FRONT.

01:10 - 52.909 HOLDING THE BOARD TO UNDERTAKE

01:10 - 54.999 WOULD NET HANDCUFFED JACKSON

01:10 - 56.000 BOUGHT.

01:10 - 01.269 AND DON'T EXPECT A GREAT LINE

01:11 - 02.889 HERE TOO IS AN AUTHENTIC 3 IS

01:11 - 05.129 IN NOW. BUT IF THEIR POLICIES

01:11 - 07.449 APPLY PROPORTIONAL IT SHOULD BE

01:11 - 09.279 GOING IN PRESIDENT SHOULD BE

01:11 - 11.099 DRAWN IN MARSHALL. IT SHOULD BE

01:11 - 12.649 DRYING IN HIGH VALUE PROPERTIES

01:11 - 13.650 AND ALL ABOUT.

01:11 - 15.839 IT SHOULD BE BASED ON THE

01:11 - 18.280 PROPORTION. A CALL FOR OFF THE

01:11 - 20.109 PROPERTIES ASSESSMENT IS

01:11 - 21.699 COMPARED TO THE MARKET AS

01:11 - 23.200 OPPOSED TO A GREAT LINE STAND.

01:11 - 26.929 THAT FOLLOWED A SURE ARGUMENT

01:11 - 29.729 IS THAT. IS I UNDERSTAND IT ON

01:11 - 31.929 THE RECORD. THE

01:11 - 33.469 SCHOOL DISTRICT ADOPTED A

01:11 - 37.049 POLICY RECOMMENDED. BY THEIR

01:11 - 40.430 CAN SOLVE. THE UNDERTAKING PEEL.

01:11 - 43.409 AND HE SAID THAT HE IS ELECTED

01:11 - 45.829 OR TARGET OF PROPERTY. THE HIGH

01:11 - 47.059 PROBABILITY OF BEING

01:11 - 48.419 UNDERSTAFFED BY MORE THAN A

01:11 - 50.139 BILLION DOLLARS IN MARKET BY

01:11 - 51.140 CORRECT.

01:11 - 54.400 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT CREATED

01:11 - 55.620 BLACK.

01:11 - 58.819 PROPERTIES THAT THEY WERE GOING

01:11 - 00.280 TO GO AFTER YOU'RE CORRECT.

01:12 - 03.609 YES THAT YOUR ARGUMENT THAT

01:12 - 04.610 YOU PERMISSION.

01:12 - 06.869 AND SECONDLY ON YOUR APPEAL OF

01:12 - 08.829 THE COMMONWEALTH COURT. THE

01:12 - 10.209 CHALLENGE NOW TURNING THE FACT

01:12 - 11.629 THAT THESE ENDED UP BEING A

01:12 - 12.630 COMMERCIAL PROPERTY.

01:12 - 15.199 THE DOCKING A MONETARY

01:12 - 17.009 THRESHOLD EFFECTIVELY TARGET

01:12 - 18.010 ONLY THE PROPERTY.

01:12 - 20.799 IT ACTUALLY MARKET FIRE OVER A

01:12 - 22.630 MILLION DOLLARS. THE RECESS.

01:12 - 29.019 MASTER WE KNOW THAT IT'S A LOT

01:12 - 30.070 AND I THINK IT'S TRUE.

01:12 - 32.769 IT CREATED A CLASS BECAUSE IT'S

01:12 - 35.089 MATHEMATICALLY POSSIBLE THAT

01:12 - 35.460 DRAMATIC

01:12 - 37.949 BE POSSIBLE. THE PROPERTY WOULD

01:12 - 39.609 ACTUALLY MARKET BY LESS THAN A

01:12 - 41.099 MILLION DOLLARS. THE

01:12 - 42.580 UNDERSTAFFED BY MORE THAN ONE.

01:12 - 45.020 THEY'RE PRETTY. YES.

01:12 - 55.969 IF YOU'RE TARGETING AND I

01:12 - 57.310 UNDERSTAND THE REASON I'M NOT.

01:12 - 00.480 LET'S GO AFTER THE PROPERTY.

01:13 - 03.449 WE CAN MAKE THE MOST MONEY THAT

01:13 - 04.710 SPENDING READ MY MIND.

01:13 - 08.439 THE ARGUMENT IS USING A CATTLE

01:13 - 09.440 CALL THE UNIFORMITY.

01:13 - 11.160 YES, YOUR HONOR.

01:13 - 19.629 THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO THE

01:13 - 21.849 CAUSE. NOBODY HAS ANY FURTHER

01:13 - 25.659 QUESTIONS BEST A LEE. AGAIN THE

01:13 - 28.489 CASE WHERE. 2 COUNCIL ARE GOING

01:13 - 30.549 TO BIDE THEIR TIME. ITALY'S

01:13 - 32.110 DOES NOT IT WAS AT.

01:13 - 38.459 AND JUST AS THERE ARE MORE

01:13 - 39.779 JUSTICES MAY IT PLEASE

01:13 - 41.609 THE COURT. SCOTT WITHERS OF

01:13 - 43.649 LAND MCELWAIN ON PATH YOU FELL

01:13 - 45.419 IN THIS MATTER CAN I CAN TELL

01:13 - 47.749 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. SCHOOL

01:13 - 48.750 DISTRICT WILL HE.

01:13 - 51.369 IF THIS BEARS INSTRUCTION GIVEN

01:13 - 52.980 AT THE OUTSET NOT TO PILE ON

01:13 - 54.709 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT WILL DRESS

01:13 - 55.949 UNIFORM THE ARGUMENTS THAT THE

01:13 - 57.570 APPELLANT AND

01:13 - 59.769 MISTER BREAKDOWN ON BEHALF OF

01:13 - 01.549 THE CHESTER COUNTY WILL THE

01:14 - 01.880 DRESS THE

01:14 - 03.249 BOARD'S POSITION AND THE

01:14 - 04.689 PRACTICAL EFFECT OF THE RELIEF

01:14 - 06.219 REQUESTED ON THE TAX ASSESSMENT

01:14 - 07.220 SYSTEM AS A WHOLE.

01:14 - 09.719 THE RIDERS, THE SCHOOL DISTRICT

01:14 - 11.979 CREATED NO CLASS IN THIS

01:14 - 13.689 APPEAL. THE SCHOOL DISTRICT

01:14 - 15.649 HAS NOT DIVIDED REAL ESTATE

01:14 - 17.409 INTO TO SELL FAST PATIENTS, A

01:14 - 18.819 PROPERTY. THIS TECH

01:14 - 21.329 THEY'RE LEGIT THE ENTIRETY OF

01:14 - 22.929 THAT ARGUMENT IS BASED ON A

01:14 - 24.819 READING OF THE EMAIL FROM

01:14 - 27.609 MISTER LOU. THAT IS EXHIBIT THE

01:14 - 29.920 2 CROWDS OF UP TO 2. AND WHEN

01:14 - 32.999 IN THE WRECK. THERE MR. LUKENS

01:14 - 34.720 RIGHTS, THE FOLLOWING

01:14 - 36.749 IS A LIST OF PROPERTIES WITH

01:14 - 38.589 ANYTHING HAVE A HIGH

01:14 - 39.909 PROBABILITY OF BEING UNDER

01:14 - 41.839 ASSESSED BY MORE THAN 1 MILLION

01:14 - 42.930 DOLLARS OF MARKET VALUE.

01:14 - 47.719 THE TAX PAYER BELIEVES THAT

01:14 - 48.890 THIS ESTABLISHES

01:14 - 50.319 SCHOOL DISTRICT DIVIDED THE

01:14 - 52.039 REAL ESTATE INSTITUTE SO FAST

01:14 - 54.039 THAT PROPERTY THAT IS

01:14 - 57.069 PURE SPECULATION. THE EMAIL DID

01:14 - 59.329 NOT SAY. WE CONSIDERED

01:14 - 01.479 ONLY PROPERTIES WITH ACTUAL

01:15 - 02.760 MARKET VALUE OF MORE THAN

01:15 - 05.029 1 MILLION DOLLARS FOR POTENTIAL

01:15 - 06.900 APPEALS ASSESSMENT APPEALS.

01:15 - 08.999 THAT'S NOT WHAT ANY MEAL SETS

01:15 - 11.329 THE ONLY WAY YOU CAN FIND THE

01:15 - 12.919 SCHOOL DISTRICT CREATED TOO

01:15 - 16.039 FAST HERE IS TO SPECULATE AS TO

01:15 - 18.989 THE MEANING OF MANY. MISTER

01:15 - 20.859 WHETHER THAT LET ME ASK YOU

01:15 - 22.309 THIS THEN I WOULD BE

01:15 - 24.039 MATHEMATICALLY POSSIBLE FOR ANY

01:15 - 25.959 PROPERTY WAS ACTOR MARKET BY

01:15 - 26.960 LESS THAN A MILLION.

01:15 - 28.469 THE UNDER ASSESSED BY MORE

01:15 - 29.470 THAN THAT.

01:15 - 32.090 I DON'T THINK IT IS POSSIBLE.

01:15 - 33.890 THAT'S A CLAIM TO SAILORS.

01:15 - 35.609 BUT THAT'S BUT THAT

01:15 - 37.929 IS NOT THAT'S AN ASSUMPTION

01:15 - 39.819 THAT THIS SENTENCE WHICH AND BE

01:15 - 41.979 CONSTRUED AS AN OBSERVATION IN

01:15 - 43.219 THIS COUNTRY IN MANY DIFFERENT

01:15 - 44.229 WAYS, THE

01:15 - 46.619 ADS SAY SPECULATION THAT THIS

01:15 - 49.049 SENTENCE MEANS HE DIVIDED IT

01:15 - 51.839 INTO 2 CLASSIFICATIONS AND THAT

01:15 - 53.650 WAS HIS SELECTION METHODOLOGY

01:15 - 55.689 THAT SENTENCE SAYS NO SUCH

01:15 - 56.690 THING.

01:15 - 59.359 AND YOU PAY FOR THE TAX PAYER

01:15 - 01.149 TO HAVE ESTABLISHED THAT IT

01:16 - 02.589 WOULD HAVE BEEN TO CALL THIS

01:16 - 05.320 WITNESS. AND WHAT THAT MEANT

01:16 - 07.979 THE TAXPAYER DIDN'T DO THAT AND

01:16 - 10.039 JUSTICE WECHT SAID THIS IS A

01:16 - 11.889 CASE WHERE THE COURT IS

01:16 - 14.119 BEING ASKED THE SURMISE FROM AN

01:16 - 16.239 INCOMPLETE RECORD THAT THERE

01:16 - 17.790 WAS SOME KIND OF DISCRIMINATION.

01:16 - 20.619 THE RECORD ON THE UNIFORM IN

01:16 - 21.640 PLAIN IN THIS CASE

01:16 - 23.849 IS COMPLETELY DEFICIENT.

01:16 - 25.449 IT CONSISTS OF 3 E-MAILS AND A

01:16 - 25.780 LITTLE BIT

01:16 - 27.419 OF TESTIMONY AND SHE FACES

01:16 - 29.119 THERE TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION

01:16 - 31.069 EARLIER ABOUT THE PROCEDURAL

01:16 - 31.630 POSTURE OF

01:16 - 33.709 THIS MOTION. A PRETRIAL MOTION

01:16 - 34.909 TO DISMISS WAS FILED BY THE

01:16 - 35.910 TAXPAYER.

01:16 - 38.059 BECAUSE NO PRECIP. HE WAS FILED

01:16 - 39.739 IN THE TRIAL COURT. I WAS NEVER

01:16 - 40.860 RULED ON FREE TRIAL.

01:16 - 42.429 SO AT THE BEGINNING OF THE

01:16 - 43.889 ASSESSMENT TRIAL IN THIS

01:16 - 45.650 MATTER. THE TRIAL COURT.

01:16 - 49.149 THE TAXPAYER IF THEY HAD ANY

01:16 - 50.279 EVIDENCE TO PUT ON IN THEIR

01:16 - 52.419 UNIFORM, IT TAKES AND THE SOLE

01:16 - 53.589 EVIDENCE THEY PRESENTED WITH

01:16 - 54.670 THOSE 3 E-MAILS.

01:16 - 57.179 THIS IS A COMPLETELY DEFICIENT

01:16 - 58.349 AND ACCURATE THIS KIND OF

01:16 - 01.269 VIOLATION. THE WINNER. THE AIR

01:17 - 02.589 AGAIN I'M JUST FOLLOWING UP TO

01:17 - 03.650 MAKE SURE I UNDERSTAND.

01:17 - 06.599 THE CROWD THAT HE REALLY DID

01:17 - 07.600 CHANGE.

01:17 - 09.850 TRACK YOUR ON

01:17 - 11.509 THE BACK IN THE EVIDENTIARY

01:17 - 12.989 HEARING BEFORE JUDGE THINKING

01:17 - 13.630 IS THAT CORRECT.

01:17 - 16.129 THE WRECK. IF YOU MENTION

01:17 - 17.549 THAT HE TOO IS THE TRIAL

01:17 - 19.619 EXHIBIT. THERE WAS A FESTIVE

01:17 - 20.620 CROWD.

01:17 - 24.700 IN IN THERE FOR JUDGE SHAKEN.

01:17 - 27.449 SOME EXTENT THAT MAY BE EVERY

01:17 - 28.450 STEP.

01:17 - 30.999 HAS MADE A FACILE

01:17 - 33.899 THE TERMINATION THE REJECTING

01:17 - 36.379 THE VI SUMMIT. HIS TOP

01:17 - 37.869 OF IT. PRIVATE COMING FROM

01:17 - 38.430 RIGHT OR ON

01:17 - 41.669 THE WAY REJECTING THAT WE

01:17 - 42.700 MILLION DOLLARS

01:17 - 45.369 PLUS THE RATHER EXCEPT THING

01:17 - 48.029 THE THE EMAIL THAT I REFERENCED

01:17 - 50.720 EARLIER HIS FATHER IN WHICH

01:17 - 54.460 THE SCHOOL

01:17 - 58.659 NO SPECIFICALLY REQUEST FROM

01:17 - 00.019 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT ITSELF TO

01:18 - 00.400 THE SCHOOL

01:18 - 02.899 DISTRICT SAID LOOK IT IS ONLY A

01:18 - 04.039 MATTER OF WHAT'S UNDER THE

01:18 - 05.670 DESK. THOUGH SANDERS.

01:18 - 09.229 SO WE WE DON'T HAVE HE SAID SHE

01:18 - 10.779 SAID WE HAVE A FACTUAL FINDINGS

01:18 - 12.190 BY TRUMP. CORRECT.

01:18 - 14.040 I WOULD AGREE WITH YOUR

01:18 - 15.860 RECITATION KEEP A SPARE YES.

01:18 - 20.660 RECORD WE DON'T HAVE.

01:18 - 23.729 A RECORD THAT THE SCHOOL

01:18 - 25.829 DISTRICT HAS TREATED SO CLASSIC

01:18 - 26.480 VACATIONS OF

01:18 - 28.309 PROPERTY DIFFERENTLY AS FOR HIM

01:18 - 29.869 TO FINALLY FOR THE SPORTS

01:18 - 30.870 JURISPRUDENCE.

01:18 - 33.459 NOW FINALLY BACK AND NOT ONLY

01:18 - 35.339 DOMINATE THIS. BUT I THINK IT'S

01:18 - 37.430 THE HOMEMADE THE ARGUMENT THAT

01:18 - 39.699 ONE. THERE'S

01:18 - 41.599 A QUESTION IS THE WHETHER OR

01:18 - 43.839 NOT SCOTT DOUG REAL QUICK BY

01:18 - 46.179 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. MILLION A

01:18 - 47.899 LOT OF MILLION BETTER THAN

01:18 - 49.800 THAT. IF THE BRIDE. YOU.

01:18 - 54.820 IF YOU DON'T SAY.

01:18 - 56.759 I DON'T FEEL I DON'T

01:18 - 58.169 UNDERSTAND HOW THE BURDEN COULD

01:18 - 59.170 POSSIBLY SHIP.

01:19 - 01.969 ACTUALLY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:19 - 02.500 ARE PRESUMED TO

01:19 - 04.769 BE CONSTITUTIONAL ITS STATUTORY

01:19 - 06.219 GRANT OF AUTHORITY HERE IS THE

01:19 - 07.889 FAMED 53 PH

01:19 - 11.729 D S 858855 WHICH AUTHORIZES

01:19 - 13.030 APPEAL BY SCHOOL DISTRICT.

01:19 - 14.489 THAT'S PRESUMED TO BE

01:19 - 15.490 CONSTITUTIONAL.

01:19 - 18.019 AS STATED BY THIS COURT AND

01:19 - 21.199 FISHER CONTROLS IN 1977 A

01:19 - 22.669 TAXPAYER COMPLAINING THE

01:19 - 24.100 ADMINISTRATION OF THE TAX.

01:19 - 25.749 THE HIGHLIGHTS ITS RIGHT TO BE

01:19 - 27.759 TAXED UNIFORMLY WITH OTHERS IN

01:19 - 29.349 ITS CLASS. LET'S DEMONSTRATE

01:19 - 30.999 DELIBERATE PURPOSEFUL THE

01:19 - 31.910 DISCRIMINATION IN THE

01:19 - 32.590 APPLICATION OF

01:19 - 34.459 THE TAX BEFORE CONSTITUTIONAL

01:19 - 35.490 SAFEGUARDS ARE VIOLATED.

01:19 - 37.080 SO.

01:19 - 39.009 HERE YOU HAVE A TAXPAYER

01:19 - 40.719 ALLEGING THIS STATUES COST

01:19 - 42.799 UNCONSTITUTIONAL. AND I'M NOT

01:19 - 44.609 AWARE OF ANY CONSTITUTIONAL

01:19 - 45.919 CHALLENGE THE STATUTE IN

01:19 - 48.159 PENNSYLVANIA. THE BURDEN IS ON

01:19 - 49.160 THE STATE.

01:19 - 51.449 THE APPROVED THE BASE STATUTE

01:19 - 53.570 IS NOT UNCONSTITUTIONAL.

01:19 - 55.739 THAT SHIFT TO THROW THINGS ON

01:19 - 57.549 THEIR HEAD. I RESPECTFULLY

01:19 - 59.770 SUBMIT IT WAS THE TAX THERE'S

01:20 - 03.469 WHEN RAISING THE UNIFORM, THE

01:20 - 05.399 CLAIM. 2 PRESENT

01:20 - 08.179 SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE OF THAT

01:20 - 09.619 PLANE TO CARRY THEIR BURDEN

01:20 - 11.459 OF PROOF THAT'S YOUR EYE WHEN

01:20 - 13.019 YOU POSSIBLY HAVE A BRITISH

01:20 - 13.250 SHIP.

01:20 - 16.299 THE WEATHER CENTER. AGAIN

01:20 - 17.709 THEY'RE STEPPING BACK AND

01:20 - 18.790 LOOKING AT THE GAME.

01:20 - 22.539 AND WITH AQIM WHICH IS IT'S A

01:20 - 24.669 CRIME BASED ATTACK ON THIS THE

01:20 - 25.670 OCEAN.

01:20 - 27.509 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT UNDERTOOK

01:20 - 28.510 THIS PROCESS.

01:20 - 30.949 THEY FORGET ABOUT THE PROPERTIES

01:20 - 32.959 ARE REMOTE. THE DIRECTIONS THAT

01:20 - 34.649 I UNDERSTAND WEST REVIEW ALL

01:20 - 37.019 CLASSES OF PROPERTIES, INCLUDING

01:20 - 38.619 COMMERCIAL READ YOU GO TO AN

01:20 - 40.479 OTHERWISE FOR PURPOSES OF THE

01:20 - 41.360 DATA FIND

01:20 - 43.429 THE MOST AND RUSS A PROPERTY TO

01:20 - 44.900 GET BY THE CLASS OF THE FIELD

01:20 - 46.210 THAT CORRECT.

01:20 - 50.219 NOW IF THAT CREATED TO PASS THE

01:20 - 51.220 MOST ACCURATE.

01:20 - 54.640 SO MY HOUSE MAYBE AND ARE SET.

01:20 - 56.600 IT'S NOT THE MOST PART.

01:21 - 03.350 FORGET THE JUSTIFICATION.

01:21 - 08.029 IT'S GOING TO BE THERE HAS TO

01:21 - 10.269 BE SAID SOME CRITERIA AND YOU

01:21 - 11.950 COULD ARGUE ABOUT WHAT OR WHY

01:21 - 14.900 THEIR STANCE SET UP A LOT.

01:21 - 19.529 SO BY THE TAXPAYER OR MAY NOT

01:21 - 22.229 FALL INTO MOTION. I'M JUST

01:21 - 23.230 UNDER US OUT.

01:21 - 25.789 THAT'S IT SEEMS TO BE THAT WHEN

01:21 - 27.419 YOU'RE LOOKING AT HIM. THE

01:21 - 28.520 UNIFORMITY CLAUSE.

01:21 - 31.259 WHAT IT SAYS YOU HAVE TO TREAT

01:21 - 32.300 ALL TAXPAYERS

01:21 - 34.769 UNIFORM, THE TEARS, YOU'RE

01:21 - 36.170 TREATING DIFFERENT TAXPAYERS.

01:21 - 38.559 JUST EARLIER THE PENDING ON

01:21 - 40.209 WHETHER THEIR PROPERTY. THE

01:21 - 41.210 MOTION.

01:21 - 44.219 BUT IF THE IF IF THAT'S THE

01:21 - 46.239 LAW COMMONWEALTH AND COST

01:21 - 48.069 BENEFIT ANALYSIS IS NEVER GOING

01:21 - 50.149 TO KASEY KAHNE STUDIES ON THE

01:21 - 50.640 BENEFITS OF

01:21 - 52.189 THE HOUSES BECAUSE THEY'RE

01:21 - 53.299 SAYING LOOK WE DON'T WANT TO

01:21 - 54.250 YOU KNOW WE WANT TO MAKE THIS

01:21 - 55.250 COST EFFECTIVE.

01:21 - 57.249 I UNDERSTAND THAT THAT

01:21 - 59.459 CREATES. SO WE'RE NOT WE'RE NOT

01:21 - 59.670 GOING TO

01:21 - 01.549 DO IT. COUNTY EARLY SCHOOL

01:22 - 02.989 DISTRICT WIDE REASSESSMENT

01:22 - 03.990 GOING TO COST US A LOT.

01:22 - 05.549 THEY'RE PROBABLY NOT GOING TO

01:22 - 07.059 TARGET THE PROPERTY AND ARE SET

01:22 - 08.619 FOR 50,000 BECAUSE IT'S NOT

01:22 - 09.889 GOING TO BE HERE THAT YOU'RE

01:22 - 11.130 CREATING 2 CLASSES.

01:22 - 14.299 UNDER ASSESS WHAT DOES THAT

01:22 - 14.600 MEAN.

01:22 - 16.309 WELL I THINK WE HAVE TO READ

01:22 - 17.779 THAT WHOLE SENTENCE JUST A

01:22 - 19.549 SAILOR, IT'S THE MOST AND ARE

01:22 - 20.060 ASSESSED

01:22 - 22.399 AND THE FISSION TO JUSTIFY THE

01:22 - 24.119 COST AND EXPENSE OF TAKING SUCH

01:22 - 26.209 AN A P THAT'S WHY WOULD I WOULD

01:22 - 27.950 RATHER STICK. THANK YOU.

01:22 - 31.780 THE

01:22 - 34.379 THE BURDEN OF PROOF AND SOME

01:22 - 35.909 PLASTIC HAITIAN ARGUMENT, THE

01:22 - 38.169 ONLY OTHER THING IS ARGUMENT

01:22 - 39.160 THAT THIS IS AN

01:22 - 41.209 INTENTIONAL DISCRIMINATION AND

01:22 - 42.479 THERE'S THIS IS AKIN TO A

01:22 - 43.600 DISPARATE IMPACT CASE.

01:22 - 46.259 AND AND WE THINK THAT FAILS

01:22 - 47.989 BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE 2 CLASSES

01:22 - 48.990 HERE.

01:22 - 52.019 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT IS NOT

01:22 - 53.449 SYSTEMATICALLY EXCLUDING

01:22 - 54.679 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES FOR

01:22 - 56.680 APPEAL. THAT'S JUST THEN HIM.

01:22 - 59.339 IT IS TAXPAYERS

01:22 - 01.759 BURDEN HERE AND WE DON'T KNOW

01:23 - 03.809 ON THIS RECORD THAT RESIDENTIAL

01:23 - 05.060 PROPERTIES WERE EXCLUDED.

01:23 - 07.439 AND THE REASON WE DON'T ON THIS

01:23 - 08.919 RECORD BECAUSE THE PACK THERE

01:23 - 09.949 DIDN'T BUILD A RECORD

01:23 - 11.159 SUFFICIENT ANSWER THAT

01:23 - 13.179 QUESTION. COUNCIL COUNCIL CAN I

01:23 - 13.910 STOP YOU THERE.

01:23 - 15.359 IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN THE

01:23 - 16.549 RECORD 36 AM

01:23 - 20.119 53 K. THE BASIS FOR THE LACK OF

01:23 - 22.349 THE RECORD IS YOUR. HI AND

01:23 - 23.690 REFUSAL TO AND FROM.

01:23 - 28.719 WHEN THEY ASKED ARE YOU

01:23 - 30.579 SCHEDULED OR WHY YOU TRUMP

01:23 - 32.579 OWNS PROPERTY. YOU REFUSE TO

01:23 - 34.060 ANSWER IN DISCOVERY.

01:23 - 36.389 AND NOW YOU KEEP USING YOUR

01:23 - 39.110 REFUSAL TO ANSWER. SO ATTACK

01:23 - 42.519 A BOMB COUNCIL'S POSITION WHICH

01:23 - 43.520 IS SUPPORTING

01:23 - 45.329 2 FORMER CHIEF JUSTICE SAILORS

01:23 - 46.809 ARGUMENT THAT YOU DEVELOP A

01:23 - 48.689 CLEAR IN YOUR OR YOUR JUMP THAT

01:23 - 49.690 WITHOUT TELLING US.

01:23 - 52.669 TRUMP TELL. WHAT WAS THE BASIS

01:23 - 53.700 FOR THIS ASSESSMENT.

01:23 - 57.069 JUST A STOCKY I BELIEVE

01:23 - 58.239 THERE'S I'M A POSSIBLE

01:23 - 59.879 MISUNDERSTANDING. I'M SCHOOL

01:23 - 01.119 DISTRICT IN RESPONDING IN

01:24 - 03.629 ROCKPORT IN REFUSE TO RESPOND

01:24 - 04.630 AND DISCOVERED.

01:24 - 06.859 THE THE ISSUE IS THAT NONE OF

01:24 - 08.440 THE DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

01:24 - 09.350 ALTHOUGH THEY WERE

01:24 - 11.369 POSSIBLY ADMISSIONS ARE MOST

01:24 - 12.569 THEY WERE ADMISSIONS BY SCHOOL

01:24 - 13.749 DISTRICT. WE'RE NEVER ENTERED

01:24 - 15.299 INTO EVIDENCE IN THIS CASE, I'M

01:24 - 16.659 NOT PART OF THE EFFORT THAT'S

01:24 - 18.489 THE PROBLEM. THE SCHOOL

01:24 - 19.709 DISTRICTS IN IRAQ, THE

01:24 - 21.259 TAXPAYERS IN IRAQ OF COURSE IN

01:24 - 22.729 SCHOOL DISTRICTS RESPONSES ARE

01:24 - 24.009 NOT PART OF THE RECORD BEFORE

01:24 - 25.760 THE SPORT. THAT'S WHY.

01:24 - 28.549 AND SO IT'S

01:24 - 29.729 NOT THAT WE DIDN'T ANSWER THAT

01:24 - 30.720 WILL BE ANSWERED FROM SCHOOL

01:24 - 32.579 DISTRICT IS BEING WEEK. WE

01:24 - 34.059 ANSWER THEM, THEY'RE NOT PART

01:24 - 36.029 OF THE RECORD THE SOLE RECORD

01:24 - 37.610 IN THIS CASE AND IT'S 3 E-MAILS

01:24 - 38.530 AND THAT'S

01:24 - 40.449 THE PROBLEM. THE COUNTY POLICE

01:24 - 41.909 AT THIS TIME HE LET ME FOLLOW

01:24 - 43.770 UP AND CARRIED ME THROUGH 5

01:24 - 46.939 THEY'RE COMING AT YOU AND THEY

01:24 - 49.619 SAY THAT THEY REGARDLESS SO I

01:24 - 51.459 THINK THINGS HAVE A LONGER

01:24 - 53.510 LASTING 9. YEAH.

01:24 - 58.120 WHAT IS IT IN YOUR VIEW THAT

01:24 - 00.989 THE CAST THERE HAD TO BE KEPT

01:25 - 03.590 ALIVE IN ORDER TO CHEF THE VERY

01:25 - 06.130 I'VE TO BE OKAY.

01:25 - 08.859 I MEAN THEY'RE THEY'RE DISHING

01:25 - 11.540 AS IN MY VERY THRESHOLD.

01:25 - 16.419 AND THE RESULTS WERE THAT THERE

01:25 - 18.579 ARE ONLY 12. IT HAS

01:25 - 20.689 SENT ME THOUGH AND THEY ALL FIT

01:25 - 21.490 WITHIN THAT ONE

01:25 - 24.209 VERY SPECIAL. WHAT WHAT HOW IS

01:25 - 25.919 IT THAT YOU WOULD HAVE HAD THE

01:25 - 26.630 PAST EAR

01:25 - 29.089 COME FORWARD. WE HAVE IN TERMS

01:25 - 30.909 OF THE GAME OR THE DAY SHIFT

01:25 - 32.520 THE BURDEN TO WHY YOU'RE FINE.

01:25 - 35.150 I THINK THEY WILL HAVE TO SHOW.

01:25 - 36.890 THAT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT.

01:25 - 39.389 PROGRAM APPEALING THE

01:25 - 41.259 ASSESSMENTS OF ONE SUB

01:25 - 43.010 CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTIES,

01:25 - 44.920 IRAN ACCORDING PROPERTY RIGHT.

01:25 - 47.160 WHICH THEY DIDN'T DO.

01:25 - 50.259 THEY THEY GETTING BACK TO I

01:25 - 52.389 GUESS THE SAILORS DIED I

01:25 - 56.279 EARLIER QUESTIONING. I'M THE THE

01:25 - 58.689 CLASSIFICATION WAY PROPERTY

01:25 - 00.360 WITH A VALUE IN EXCESS OF

01:26 - 01.450 1 MILLION DOLLARS.

01:26 - 05.070 WHY WHY WHY ISN'T WHY IN BACK.

01:26 - 07.720 ESTABLISHED ON THIS GRAPHIC.

01:26 - 10.179 THAT FACT IS NOT ESTABLISHED

01:26 - 11.599 ON THIS RECORD BECAUSE IT'S

01:26 - 13.849 BASED ON A SINGLE SENTENCE FROM

01:26 - 16.619 MISTER LUKENS EMAIL IN EXHIBIT

01:26 - 17.620 HE TOO.

01:26 - 19.309 THAT DOES NOT

01:26 - 21.319 SAY WHAT THE TAXPAYERS

01:26 - 23.249 PURPORTING IT SAYS IT DOES NOT

01:26 - 25.740 SAY THAT THE BASIS UPON WHICH

01:26 - 29.150 MISTER LUKENS IT DETERMINED

01:26 - 31.489 WHAT PROPERTIES RECOMMEND FOR

01:26 - 33.959 APPEAL MIZE THEIR PROBABILITY

01:26 - 35.349 OF BEING UNDER SAYS 5 MILLION

01:26 - 36.350 DOLLARS.

01:26 - 38.699 AND SAY I WAS TAKEN IN

01:26 - 40.869 ISOLATION DOESN'T SHOW THAT AND

01:26 - 42.649 HOW ABOUT THAT SENTENCING

01:26 - 44.240 INJUNCTION WITH THE BAT.

01:26 - 46.479 THAT THE 12 APPEALS THAT WERE

01:26 - 49.220 TAKEN IN ALL PROPERTIES.

01:26 - 52.069 YEAH, THE VALUE IN EXCESS OF A

01:26 - 55.469 MILLION DOLLARS IN A BATHROOM

01:26 - 56.590 WHERE THEY NEED TO GO.

01:26 - 58.909 I DO NOT BELIEVE SO YOUR

01:26 - 00.839 HONOR THEY DO NOT AND THERE'S

01:27 - 02.550 NO MEN AND HOLDING UP TOGETHER.

01:27 - 03.710 THERE'S NO

01:27 - 05.799 EVIDENCE THAT THAT WAS THIS

01:27 - 08.799 METHODOLOGY THAT THIS THAT'S

01:27 - 09.800 ALL TO USE.

01:27 - 11.789 IT'S JUST AS POSSIBLE THAT HE'S

01:27 - 13.279 MAKING AN OBSERVATION.

01:27 - 14.280 FOLLOWING IS A LIST OF

01:27 - 16.019 PROPERTIES IF THEY HAVE A HIGH

01:27 - 18.129 PROBABILITY AT THE STANDARD

01:27 - 19.799 THAT HE USED WE DON'T KNOW WHEN

01:27 - 21.649 THE ONLY WAY WE COULD KNOW IT'S

01:27 - 23.880 HAD TACKS AIR CALLED WITNESSES.

01:27 - 27.350 THE EVIDENCE

01:27 - 29.969 COULD ESTABLISH THE TAXPAYERS

01:27 - 32.290 BURDEN HERE AND ON THIS RECORD

01:27 - 33.800 HAVE NO SUCH EVIDENCE.

01:27 - 36.449 MISTER WHEN THEY START TO

01:27 - 37.630 JUST THEY'RE NOT.

01:27 - 39.609 MAYBE I'M MISSING SOMETHING BUT

01:27 - 41.539 IT DOES SEEM TO ME TO FIND A

01:27 - 43.689 BATCH OF THE U IT'S THE STARTED

01:27 - 46.010 BY THE TRIAL COURT THAT RECORD

01:27 - 47.529 EXCITED IN

01:27 - 49.789 YOUR FAVOR THAT RECORD IN THE

01:27 - 51.349 SIDE AGAINST YOU

01:27 - 54.099 PROBABLY SAID. YES TO LOOKING

01:27 - 55.869 AT THIS EVIDENCE IN INTERESTING

01:27 - 58.559 TOO TO THE WITNESSES. I THINK

01:27 - 00.110 THAT THE SCHOOL DID IN FACT

01:28 - 03.040 WHAT IS THE GATES IN SUBTERFUGE

01:28 - 04.240 AND THERE WAS THE

01:28 - 08.890 PROPERTIES AND MILLION DOLLARS.

01:28 - 10.900 WITH THE VALUE OF A

01:28 - 12.929 MILLION DOLLARS THOUGH TO LOSE

01:28 - 13.420 THE CASE.

01:28 - 15.229 IT THINK SO BECAUSE THEN

01:28 - 17.330 YOU'RE SAYING IT JUST IS FAIR

01:28 - 19.279 IS THAT TRIAL COURT HAS

01:28 - 20.739 DETERMINED THE

01:28 - 22.559 SCHOOL DISTRICT. HAS

01:28 - 24.679 IMPLEMENTED A PROGRAM OF ONLY

01:28 - 26.669 APPEALING ASSESSMENT OF ONESELF

01:28 - 28.859 CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY AND

01:28 - 30.189 HERE YOU DON'T HAVE SUCH

01:28 - 32.239 A FINDING AND I DON'T THINK YOU

01:28 - 33.939 CAN GET TO THAT UNIFORMITY

01:28 - 34.979 INCLUSION THAT HAS BEEN A

01:28 - 36.079 VIOLATION OF THE UNIFORM

01:28 - 37.760 BECAUSE ON THIS RECORD.

01:28 - 40.110 ACTUALLY THEY'RE HERE.

01:28 - 43.929 THE RESPONSE THAT YOU JUST AS

01:28 - 44.930 THERE'S QUESTION.

01:28 - 58.280 BRING US ANY OF THESE

01:28 - 59.280 PROPERTIES.

01:29 - 04.149 AND IN HIS HEAD HE RESPONDED

01:29 - 05.750 WELL LIVED. I THOUGHT.

01:29 - 07.649 ATTORNEYS FOR THE WAY TO GO

01:29 - 08.650 HERE.

01:29 - 12.529 I WOULD HAVE AN ENORMOUS AND

01:29 - 14.229 PROBABLY INSURMOUNTABLE PROBLEM

01:29 - 16.359 JUST AS WELL. AND THANKFULLY, I

01:29 - 17.779 DON'T HAVE THAT PROBLEM BECAUSE

01:29 - 19.429 THIS RECORD DOESN'T SUPPORT AND

01:29 - 20.430 HAVING A PROP.

01:29 - 23.789 AND AND THEN TO CONCLUDE

01:29 - 25.009 JUSTICE WECHT THAT I'D LIKE TO

01:29 - 26.040 PULL YOUR QUESTION.

01:29 - 28.479 AND THAT WAS POSED TO THE OTHER

01:29 - 30.879 SIDE IN THIS CASE, THE TAXATION

01:29 - 32.709 PARENT, I'M THE BEST SERVED BY

01:29 - 34.290 THE ASSESSMENT APPEALS PROCESS

01:29 - 35.849 AND I WOULD SAY YES JUSTICE

01:29 - 38.419 WECHT INDIVIDUAL FEELS WHETHER

01:29 - 40.339 BY TAXING AUTHORITY FOR AN

01:29 - 41.760 INDIVIDUAL PROPERTY OWNER,

01:29 - 44.239 ALWAYS ENHANCED UNIFORMITY BY

01:29 - 44.830 LOWERING THE

01:29 - 46.939 COEFFICIENT DISPERSED IS THE

01:29 - 48.129 VARIANCE FROM THE COMMON

01:29 - 49.130 ASSESSMENT RATIO IN THE

01:29 - 51.269 DISTRICT. SO ALL ASSESSMENT

01:29 - 52.860 APPEALS ENHANCEMENT OF FOR ME

01:29 - 54.229 IT'S THE FAILURE

01:29 - 56.959 TO APPEAL THE PERFECT AWAITS 9

01:29 - 58.189 UNIFORMITY AND THAT'S WHAT THE

01:29 - 00.079 TAXPAYERS TRYING TO EFFECTUATE

01:30 - 02.149 HERE IS THEY WANT TO

01:30 - 03.110 KICK THIS THE

01:30 - 05.309 TAX ASSESSMENT FEEL HER BEST TO

01:30 - 07.409 MAKE NON UNIFORM BEING A TAXING

01:30 - 09.229 DISTRICT, NOTHING ON THIS

01:30 - 11.499 RECORD SHOWS THE RESIDENCES ARE

01:30 - 12.280 UNDER ASSESSED

01:30 - 13.719 IN CANADA. SO THE SCHOOL

01:30 - 15.099 DISTRICT FOR THE RESIDENTS WERE

01:30 - 16.720 CONSIDERED BY THE CONSULTANT

01:30 - 18.289 AND WE WOULD THE SCHOOL

01:30 - 19.459 DISTRICT WOULD RESPECTFULLY

01:30 - 21.499 REQUEST. THIS HONORABLE COURT

01:30 - 23.089 AFFIRMED THE ORDER OF THE

01:30 - 25.319 COMMONWEALTH COURT. THANK YOU

01:30 - 26.320 VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME.

01:30 - 31.009 THEY'VE BEEN WELL ARGUE AND

01:30 - 32.110 ANYTHING YOU'D LIKE TO ADD.

01:30 - 35.050 GOOD MORNING. PLEASE THE

01:30 - 37.619 BUT VERY ANTHONY BURKE ON

01:30 - 38.679 BEHALF OF THE CHESTER COUNTY

01:30 - 39.860 BOARD OF ASSESSMENT APPEALS.

01:30 - 41.709 I JUST WANTED TO MAKE 2 BREAK

01:30 - 43.529 POINTS. WHEEL ON THERE WERE

01:30 - 45.350 SOME QUESTIONS ON THE RECORD.

01:30 - 48.069 IN THIS MATTER. IT IS FAIRLY

01:30 - 51.389 UNUSUAL TO HAVE A. I MEAN THE

01:30 - 52.130 BOARD HEARS

01:30 - 53.939 HERE IS AN IS A PARTY TO ALL OF

01:30 - 55.189 THE UNIFORMITY CHALLENGES IN

01:30 - 57.589 CHESTER COUNTY. WE TYPICALLY

01:30 - 58.899 WILL SEE WITNESSES CALLED WE

01:30 - 00.200 SOMETIMES HAVE REQUESTS

01:31 - 01.829 THEY ARE TYPICALLY GRANTED FOR

01:31 - 03.480 A SEPARATE EVIDENTIARY HEARING

01:31 - 05.969 WHICH PRECEDED SPEED VALUATION

01:31 - 07.069 TRIAL ON A

01:31 - 09.129 SEPARATE DAY. WE'VE HAD EXPERTS

01:31 - 10.829 CALL THAT UNIFORM ON BEHALF OF

01:31 - 11.830 THE TAXPAYER.

01:31 - 14.009 6 OF THE TYPES OF QUESTIONS ON

01:31 - 15.050 THE RECORD THAT THE COURT.

01:31 - 18.120 ARE GOOD AND THEY USUALLY ARE.

01:31 - 22.739 AND THAT WASN'T DONE HERE FOR

01:31 - 23.620 THE REASONS THAT HAVE ALREADY

01:31 - 25.759 BEEN DISCUSSED. AND I DO THINK

01:31 - 27.299 IT'S THE TAXPAYERS BURDEN THAT

01:31 - 28.479 COULD BRING A FULL RECORD TO

01:31 - 29.480 THE COURT.

01:31 - 32.189 THE PRIMARY POINT OF BEING A

01:31 - 33.409 PARTY TO EACH ONE OF THE

01:31 - 36.519 UNIFORMITY CLAIMS IS SIMILAR TO

01:31 - 38.329 WHAT JUSTICE WECHT. A

01:31 - 40.099 QUESTION EARLIER WHICH IS RIGHT

01:31 - 41.839 NOW YOU YOU HAVE A A SORT OF A

01:31 - 43.849 BALANCE IN THE SYSTEM IN THAT

01:31 - 45.879 YOU HAVE TAXPAYERS WHO ARE WELL

01:31 - 47.059 EQUIPPED WHEN THEY BELIEVE THAT

01:31 - 48.219 THEY'RE PAYING TOO MUCH THAT

01:31 - 49.549 THERE WERE OVER ASSESSED THE

01:31 - 51.190 FILE CHALLENGES ON THEIR BEHALF

01:31 - 53.089 AND ON THE ON THE FLIP SIDE YET

01:31 - 54.090 SCHOOL DISTRICTS

01:31 - 55.649 BETTER ABLE TO IDENTIFY

01:31 - 57.249 PROPERTIES THAT ARE SEVERELY ON

01:31 - 58.969 ASSESSED AND BRING THEM BACK TO

01:31 - 01.189 MARKET VALUE. AND THE SYSTEM

01:32 - 02.829 GENERALLY WORK PRETTY WELL

01:32 - 03.830 RIGHT NOW.

01:32 - 06.219 YOU GET TO A CLOSER

01:32 - 08.269 MARKET VALUE. YOU GET A VALUE

01:32 - 09.489 THAT EQUATES TO WHAT THE

01:32 - 10.780 PROPERTY IS ACTUALLY WORK.

01:32 - 13.019 THE BOARD'S CONCERN IN

01:32 - 15.329 TERMS OF THIS ASSESSMENT SYSTEM

01:32 - 16.799 AS A WHOLE IS THAT THE RELIEF

01:32 - 18.040 THAT'S BEING REQUESTED.

01:32 - 20.119 I'M DOESN'T REALLY SET FORTH A

01:32 - 21.889 WORKABLE STANDARD. IF

01:32 - 23.249 A SCHOOL DISTRICT NOT ABLE

01:32 - 24.849 TO CONSIDER THE AMOUNT IN

01:32 - 26.249 CONTROVERSY IF THEY'RE NOT ABLE

01:32 - 27.680 TO CONSIDER THEIR OWN COSTS.

01:32 - 29.619 THEY'RE GOING TO BE EFFECTIVELY

01:32 - 30.939 SEVERELY CURTAILED ARE

01:32 - 32.700 PRECLUDED THE FILING

01:32 - 34.739 ASSESSMENT APPEALS. YOU KNOW

01:32 - 36.829 MOST ANY CASES, SOMEONE MADE

01:32 - 37.700 THE POINT EARLIER

01:32 - 38.869 THEY'RE GOING TO EFFECTIVELY

01:32 - 41.109 PUSHED IT TO PEELING ALL OR

01:32 - 42.879 NONE OF IT, NONE OF IT AND

01:32 - 44.039 THAT'S NOT GOING TO PROMOTE

01:32 - 46.119 UNIFORMITY THAT'S GOING DISRUPT

01:32 - 47.170 THAT ACTUALLY ISN'T

01:32 - 48.160 AND WE'RE GOING TO HAVE AN

01:32 - 49.399 ASSESSMENT SYSTEM WHERE IT'S

01:32 - 51.559 BASICALLY ONE SIDE WHERE ONE

01:32 - 53.399 SIDE OF THE EQUATION CAN FILE

01:32 - 54.409 AN APPEAL WHEN THEY THINK IT'S

01:32 - 55.040 TOO HIGH.

01:32 - 56.729 BUT THERE'S NO MECHANISM FOR

01:32 - 58.289 ANYONE TO CHALLENGE IT WHEN THE

01:32 - 00.919 ASSESSMENTS THAT'S NOT GOING TO

01:33 - 01.280 PROMOTE

01:33 - 03.139 UNIFORM MONEY THAT'S NOT GOING

01:33 - 04.859 TO HELP FAIRNESS IN THE COUNTY

01:33 - 05.730 ARE IN THE CALM WITH AS A

01:33 - 07.989 WHOLE. WE THINK THAT'S PROBABLY

01:33 - 08.990 WHY YOU SEE

01:33 - 10.639 SO MANY IN HIS CREASE FILED IN

01:33 - 11.929 THIS MATTER FROM PHILADELPHIA

01:33 - 13.019 SCHOOL DISTRICT TO THE

01:33 - 14.489 PITTSFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT IN

01:33 - 15.609 SMALLER SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN

01:33 - 17.519 BETWEEN THAT THERE IS A REAL

01:33 - 19.519 CONCERN, PARTICULARLY WITH HOW

01:33 - 21.369 SPARSE THIS RECORD IS THAT IF

01:33 - 22.709 THE COURT WERE TO GRANT ANY

01:33 - 24.010 RELIEF TO THE TAXPAYER.

01:33 - 25.899 IT WAS UNNECESSARILY UP AND THE

01:33 - 28.440 TAX SYSTEM AS A WHOLE AND

01:33 - 30.439 THE SYSTEM NO

01:33 - 32.709 LONGER WORKABLE SO WITH THAT WE

01:33 - 34.459 WOULD ASK THE COURT TO YOU FROM

01:33 - 35.220 THE COMMONWEALTH COURT'S

01:33 - 36.220 DECISION.

01:33 - 39.709 AND THE QUESTION THAT OFTEN THE

01:33 - 40.710 BEST.

01:33 - 43.359 THANK THANK YOU. MISTER BARR

01:33 - 44.679 AGAIN AS I SAID WELL WELL

01:33 - 47.109 ARGUED BY ALL. I WILL TAKE A

01:33 - 48.959 FIVE-MINUTE BREAK AGAIN AND

01:33 - 50.069 WILL BE OUR 3RD DAY IN THE

01:33 - 51.070 MORNING.

01:34 - 24.979 THE NEXT ARGUMENT

01:34 - 26.419 IS GREENWOOD GAMING AND

01:34 - 27.420 ENTERTAINMENT FORCES, THE

01:34 - 27.820 COMMONWEALTH

01:34 - 29.529 OF PENNSYLVANIA, PERFECTLY

01:34 - 31.059 CALM. ALL IS MISTER MICHAEL

01:34 - 32.869 STRAIN CHIEF REPRESENTING

01:34 - 34.809 GREENWOOD GAMING IS MISTER MARK

01:34 - 35.810 STUART.

01:34 - 43.019 THERE ARE SOME DIFFERENT

01:34 - 44.020 COUNTY COMMUNITY.

01:34 - 46.519 IN THIS CASE, THE CONGO A

01:34 - 48.640 CHALLENGE FOR SHORT ORDER.

01:34 - 51.819 I REGRET THAT THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:34 - 53.419 BOARD OF FINANCE REVENUES,

01:34 - 54.950 DENIAL OF A CASH REFUND.

01:34 - 57.099 IN GREENWOOD GAMING AND

01:34 - 59.559 ENTERTAINMENT INC THE LADY

01:34 - 00.699 GREENWOOD GAME

01:35 - 02.030 GAMING'S DISTRIBUTION.

01:35 - 03.749 HOT TO AN EVENT TICKETS.

01:35 - 04.620 THE PATRONS AT

01:35 - 06.939 PARX CASINO. THE QUESTION

01:35 - 08.679 PRESENTED IS WHETHER CONCERT

01:35 - 10.519 AND EVENT TICKETS. IT BY

01:35 - 13.269 CASINO PATRON. THE RESULT OF

01:35 - 15.370 PLAYING IN THE SLOT MACHINE.

01:35 - 18.009 IT BECAME THE COST OF SERVICES

01:35 - 19.219 FOR PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION,

01:35 - 21.699 11 '03 AND THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:35 - 22.300 RACE IS

01:35 - 24.619 DEVELOPING GAMING. THE TICKETS

01:35 - 26.249 ARE DEEMED TO BE SERVICES THAT

01:35 - 27.939 YOU KNOW CANNOT DEDUCT THE BANK

01:35 - 28.940 TO HER

01:35 - 30.639 FROM ITS GROSS TABLE GAME

01:35 - 32.529 REVENUE GROWTH TERMINAL REVENUE

01:35 - 34.099 FOR PURPOSES OF CALCULATING

01:35 - 35.219 RELATING RELATED

01:35 - 37.479 AT VERTICALLY. IF THEY'RE NOT

01:35 - 38.699 THEY'RE THIS CRISPY IT SAYS

01:35 - 41.569 INCURRED IN THE FLYING THESE

01:35 - 43.819 THESE TICKETS ARE NOT ABLE BY

01:35 - 46.360 THE CASINO. MOVE IN

01:35 - 48.509 WATCHING THE DIFFERENCE THAT

01:35 - 49.510 CORRECTLY.

01:35 - 53.299 THE RNC I APOLOGIZE, THANK YOU

01:35 - 54.350 FEEL FREE PLEASE.

01:35 - 56.180 THANK YOU MISTER CHIEF

01:35 - 57.409 JUSTICE AND MAY IT PLEASE THE

01:35 - 58.689 COURT MICHAEL SCREEN SEE THE

01:35 - 00.039 PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ATTORNEY

01:36 - 01.179 GENERAL ON BEHALF OF THE

01:36 - 02.869 COMMONWEALTH. THE COMMONWEALTH

01:36 - 04.109 COURT ERRED WHEN IT CONCLUDED

01:36 - 05.779 THAT A CASINO NOT DISTRIBUTING

01:36 - 06.530 SERVICES TO

01:36 - 08.339 ITS PATIENTS. THEY GAVE HIM

01:36 - 09.539 FREE ADMISSION TICKETS TO SEE

01:36 - 11.729 KUZ AND SHOW WHO PERFORMS LIKE

01:36 - 13.240 SHARE AND J C.

01:36 - 15.649 GLADYS EVERYTHING TO THINK THAT

01:36 - 16.799 WE CONCEDED THAT ADMISSION

01:36 - 18.290 TICKETS ARE PERSONAL PROPERTY.

01:36 - 19.899 BUT OUR POSITION HAS BEEN

01:36 - 21.909 CONSISTENT. THEY ARE DUE TO THE

01:36 - 23.559 COMMONWEALTH COURT THAT SHOULD

01:36 - 25.079 HAVE FROM THE BOARD OF FINANCE

01:36 - 26.419 AND REVENUE CONCLUSION THAT IT

01:36 - 28.829 IS QUOTE THE NATURE OF ITEMS OR

01:36 - 30.899 SERVICES INVOLVED THE GERMAN

01:36 - 32.189 FOR THE COST OF THE TICKET AS

01:36 - 34.209 THE DOCTOR. AND WE CONSISTENTLY

01:36 - 34.980 MAINTAIN THAT THERE'S A

01:36 - 35.980 DISTINCTION BETWEEN THE

01:36 - 37.739 TICKETS THEMSELVES AND WHAT

01:36 - 39.929 THEY CONVEY REPRESENT. THAT'S

01:36 - 41.149 THE SAME ARGUMENT WE'RE MAKING

01:36 - 41.880 HERE YOUR HONOR

01:36 - 43.679 AND CERTAINLY MY AREAS NOT

01:36 - 45.269 ARGUING WAIVER A LOT OF THE

01:36 - 47.259 CASE THAT EVEN IF THE COURT

01:36 - 48.230 CONCLUDES THAT ADMISSION

01:36 - 49.850 TICKETS ARE PERSONAL PROPERTY.

01:36 - 50.570 THAT IS

01:36 - 52.839 NOT DISPOSITIVE THE COURT STILL

01:36 - 53.919 HAS TO ANSWER WHETHER IT'S

01:36 - 54.460 SERVICE IS

01:36 - 56.899 BEING MADE AN EXAMINATION OF

01:36 - 58.229 SECTION 11 '03 BEARS

01:36 - 01.229 THIS OUT SECTION 11 '03 ALLOWS

01:37 - 02.629 FOR A REDUCTION OF QUOTE ANY

01:37 - 05.049 PERSONAL PROPERTY THEN MODIFY

01:37 - 06.509 THAT BY EXCLUDING FROM THE

01:37 - 07.589 DEDUCTION FOOD AND

01:37 - 10.159 REFRESHMENTS. FOR EXAMPLE, THE

01:37 - 11.150 COFFEE BEANS, AND CERTAINLY

01:37 - 12.959 PERSONAL PROPERTY. THEY'RE EVEN

01:37 - 13.400 TRADED AS

01:37 - 15.519 A COMMODITY. THE CASINO STARTED

01:37 - 17.029 HANDING OUT BAGS OF STARBUCKS

01:37 - 18.089 COFFEE BEANS THAT WOULD

01:37 - 20.229 BE EXCLUDED. THE BEANS ARE BOTH

01:37 - 22.739 PERSONAL PROPERTY EVEN IF

01:37 - 24.389 AN ADMISSION TICKET IS IN

01:37 - 24.950 TANGIBLE

01:37 - 26.719 PERSONAL PROPERTY, THOUGH FOR

01:37 - 28.029 REASONS I'LL EXPLAIN LATER, WE

01:37 - 30.009 BELIEVE IT OR NOT IT CONVEYS

01:37 - 31.529 A SERVICE AND SO MUST BE

01:37 - 32.749 EXCLUDED FROM THE PERSONAL

01:37 - 33.750 PROPERTY.

01:37 - 35.619 NOW THERE ARE SEVERAL REASONS

01:37 - 36.799 WHY ADMISSION TICKETS

01:37 - 37.880 CONSTITUTES SERVICES.

01:37 - 40.879 ALTHOUGH BEGINNING AT NOTHING

01:37 - 42.990 TO FIND SERVICES THAT TURN IS

01:37 - 45.109 AN AMBIGUOUS THE COURTS AROUND

01:37 - 46.599 THE COUNTRY, INCLUDING SEVERAL

01:37 - 48.799 STATE COURT OF LAST RESORT OF

01:37 - 49.909 ALL THE FOOD THAT WHEN IT

01:37 - 50.930 MISSION TAKE IT IS

01:37 - 52.929 SEOUL. WHETHER IT BE TO A

01:37 - 54.710 BASEBALL GAME USING CAR.

01:37 - 57.329 FOR A BOAT RIDE OUT THE TRAFFIC

01:37 - 58.790 IS BEING SOLD WITH THE SERVICE.

01:38 - 01.839 ADMISSION TICKETS ARE SOME OF

01:38 - 03.639 THE MOST COMMON PROBLEMS THAT

01:38 - 05.300 CASINO TRIBUTE TO HIS PATIENTS.

01:38 - 07.060 NEARLY ALL OF THESE AT A

01:38 - 08.709 JURISDICTION CASES CITED, I

01:38 - 11.060 MEAN GREET PREDATE THE GAMING.

01:38 - 13.819 I JUST THINK THEY'RE COUNCIL I

01:38 - 14.820 THINK WE GAVE YOU 2

01:38 - 17.190 IN THAT.

01:38 - 21.270 YOU'RE TALKING COPS.

01:38 - 24.309 LEGISLATURE KNEW HOW TO ADDRESS

01:38 - 26.320 THAT DIDN'T THEY FELL SQUARE.

01:38 - 29.570 THEY INCLUDED ENTERTAINMENT.

01:38 - 32.969 THEY THEY EXPRESS LEE WHO DID

01:38 - 34.650 QUOTE ENTERTAINMENT UNQUOTE.

01:38 - 36.130 HERE.

01:38 - 38.920 THEY EXPRESSLY DID NOT.

01:38 - 41.669 INCLUDE THE ENTERTAINMENT

01:38 - 43.820 BODY STATE IS AND A FINE.

01:38 - 48.819 WHY ISN'T IT JUST

01:38 - 51.200 AS PLAUSIBLE AND IN THE

01:38 - 54.159 THE STREET OF COURSE, I'M IN

01:38 - 56.129 FAVOR THE TAXPAYER. WHY IS IT

01:38 - 57.450 JUSTICE POSSIBLE.

01:38 - 59.999 ITS SERVICES INCLUDE

01:39 - 01.489 ENTERTAINMENT BECAUSE THAT'S TO

01:39 - 02.490 FIND ELSEWHERE.

01:39 - 05.919 THEY BE THERE AT THE SPA

01:39 - 08.019 SERVICES FOR EXAMPLE, WHICH A

01:39 - 09.310 LOT OF THESE PLACES.

01:39 - 13.180 MAYBE THAT MAYBE THERE.

01:39 - 15.330 YOU KNOW, MAYBE THEY'RE

01:39 - 16.809 THINKING ABOUT ALL I DON'T

01:39 - 17.810 KNOW, BUT.

01:39 - 20.100 BUT ISN'T IT JUST

01:39 - 22.379 AS REASONABLE. THIS REVISED IT

01:39 - 24.109 SAYS THAT GETTING TO THEIR TEAM

01:39 - 26.360 HERE INCLUDED ELSEWHERE.

01:39 - 30.999 IT'S FOR JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE OR

01:39 - 32.000 WHATEVER.

01:39 - 34.129 WELL AS YOU ALLUDED TO I THINK

01:39 - 35.880 SERVICE IS BROADER THAN THAT.

01:39 - 37.529 IN A STATEMENT AND I THINK

01:39 - 38.530 THEY HAD IN MIND.

01:39 - 40.209 SOME OF THE MANY DIFFERENT

01:39 - 41.529 KINDS OF SERVICES THAT A CASINO

01:39 - 42.999 MAY OFFER LIKE SPA SERVICES

01:39 - 44.920 HAIR CUTS, THEY ALSO LAWN.

01:39 - 47.389 I KNOW SOME CASINOS WHICH I'LL

01:39 - 49.329 CANCERS. THEY THINK THEIR

01:39 - 51.239 INTENT. IT WAS TO USE SOMETHING

01:39 - 52.949 BROUGHT EXTRA A LOT OF THE

01:39 - 54.899 THINGS THAT THE IT'S

01:39 - 56.990 THE WAY A REGULAR BASIS.

01:40 - 03.540 IT MAY GET IT DONE YOU 5. THE

01:40 - 07.279 IN DEFINITIONS SECTION OF

01:40 - 09.429 THE ACT ALL THOSE FINE

01:40 - 12.719 COMPLEMENTARY SERVICE. WHEN YOU

01:40 - 16.569 AND YOUR I THINK AGREE

01:40 - 18.689 THAT WAY THE LEGISLATURE WHEN

01:40 - 20.849 THEY DID AND THE CAPTURING THIS

01:40 - 22.120 6 SCHOOLS IN PLACE.

01:40 - 24.149 SERVICE DAYS. THEY'RE THE

01:40 - 26.379 THINGS THAT ARE CALM. WORK ON

01:40 - 28.270 SATURDAY GIVING BY THE CASINO.

01:40 - 31.849 IS THE GREEN MAN THAT WAY I'D

01:40 - 34.259 BE IN CANCUN WAY THE LATEST TO

01:40 - 34.400 IT.

01:40 - 38.979 FOOD. AND 3 SURVEY IS THAT IS

01:40 - 40.070 DEFINED IN THE AREA.

01:40 - 43.439 ID BE ACTIVE GOING

01:40 - 45.509 COMPLEMENTARY SERVICE SAYS ANY

01:40 - 47.619 WHY HE STARTED THIS OR I NEED

01:40 - 48.620 THEM.

01:40 - 50.749 IT PROVIDED

01:40 - 52.849 TO INVADE ALL AT NO COST FOR

01:40 - 56.289 EVERY 5. WE GENERALLY WE COULD

01:40 - 58.089 NOT GENERALLY AVAILABLE TO THE

01:40 - 00.029 PUBLIC AND DECEMBER 30TH GAME

01:41 - 01.030 IS.

01:41 - 03.489 I DON'T THINK WE READ THE

01:41 - 04.779 DEFINITION OF COMPLEMENTARY

01:41 - 05.780 SERVICE.

01:41 - 08.160 IS THAT WHAT YOU MEAN BY

01:41 - 10.540 TRYING TO GET YEAH, I MEAN I

01:41 - 16.289 AND I COULD BE DISCOUNTED OR

01:41 - 18.500 FREE. I DON'T I I THINK IT'S

01:41 - 20.299 YOU KNOW ONE. I DON'T KNOW WHY

01:41 - 21.660 ENTIRELY IN QUESTION.

01:41 - 24.170 IT WAS IN THE CAR.

01:41 - 27.369 IT IS CLEAR IS THERE IS AN

01:41 - 29.240 UNDERSTANDING AS TO WHY.

01:41 - 33.069 I'VE BECAUSE THEY'RE HERE TO BE

01:41 - 36.099 AN BETWEEN I THE

01:41 - 37.880 PARTY HERE THAT WOULD

01:41 - 44.889 I IN FACT IN A SECOND THAT

01:41 - 46.440 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ARE

01:41 - 48.959 KHAN THAT ARE HANDED OUT BY

01:41 - 49.960 CASINO.

01:41 - 53.539 CORRECT I THINK THAT YET SAID

01:41 - 54.989 ANYTHING THAT THE CEO AND OUT

01:41 - 55.990 AS PART OF.

01:41 - 58.640 TABLE GAME OR A

01:41 - 00.459 SLUSHY MESS THAT WOULD BE A COP

01:42 - 01.779 SOMETHING THAT EITHER FREE OR

01:42 - 02.250 DISCOUNTED.

01:42 - 04.580 THAT DOESN'T GET US TO A FACT

01:42 - 07.339 COOL A FACTUAL QUESTION HERE

01:42 - 08.930 THAT I'M JUST NOT SURE IS

01:42 - 15.719 THE LEGISLATURE WAYS YOU CAN

01:42 - 17.780 THINK TO IN COMBAT

01:42 - 19.509 IN THIS EXCLUSION WE'RE

01:42 - 22.139 COMPLEMENTARY SERVICES AND THAT

01:42 - 23.670 IS DEFINED IN THE GAP.

01:42 - 26.209 WHAT DO WE HAVE ON THE RECORD

01:42 - 30.369 TO ESTABLISH WHAT. OUR INDEED

01:42 - 31.370 GREAT.

01:42 - 36.209 THE FACT THAT THE FAMILIES OF

01:42 - 37.320 THE BETTER ADD TO IT

01:42 - 38.729 THAT INCLUDED A LOT OF

01:42 - 40.309 DIFFERENT THINGS ALL THE THINGS

01:42 - 41.899 THAT WERE COVERED THAT COME UP

01:42 - 43.509 TO CHALLENGE AND THINGS THAT WE

01:42 - 44.549 DID I THINK THEY RECEIVED

01:42 - 45.200 ALMOST A MILLION

01:42 - 47.429 DOLLAR PRODUCTION. FOR A LOT OF

01:42 - 48.839 DIFFERENT THINGS LIKE THAT AND

01:42 - 49.970 BAGS AND IPADS.

01:42 - 52.029 AND I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY

01:42 - 53.139 DISPUTE AS TO WHETHER THESE

01:42 - 54.220 WERE BUT I'VE GIVEN

01:42 - 57.689 AND TO BE GIVEN OUT IS EITHER

01:42 - 58.720 FREE OR DISCOUNTED.

01:42 - 01.269 AND AGAIN IT INCLUDES A WIDE

01:43 - 02.970 RANGE OF THINGS AND THE.

01:43 - 04.809 THAT'S WHERE AND STRUGGLING

01:43 - 05.909 WITH THIS AND I HAVE TO TELL

01:43 - 07.610 YOU THAT THIS CASE HAS TO STOP.

01:43 - 12.469 WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS THE

01:43 - 13.910 COMMONWEALTH DECIDE WHAT

01:43 - 19.679 I LOVE IT AND ME WHAT IT CAN BE

01:43 - 20.980 A IS A.

01:43 - 24.519 BACK WE'LL ISSUE THAT'S GIVING

01:43 - 26.580 DEFINITION IN THE INDUSTRY.

01:43 - 30.649 I HAVE A HARD TIME ACCEPTING

01:43 - 33.389 THE PROPOSITION THAT I TAKE IT

01:43 - 34.969 TO A CRIME THERE MAY BE OR MAY

01:43 - 37.049 NOT BE A CONFLICT. I DON'T KNOW

01:43 - 39.459 THAT ANY COMPLEMENTARY SERVICES

01:43 - 40.770 ANYONE I THINK 3RD BASE.

01:43 - 45.059 IT IS PROVIDING IN FAYETTEVILLE

01:43 - 46.060 AT NO COST.

01:43 - 48.479 HAD WE NOT HAD GROWN INTO THIS

01:43 - 49.639 MESS. IF YOU

01:43 - 52.389 LAY SHUN BETWEEN THE PARTIES AT

01:43 - 53.789 WHAT WE'VE BEEN HANDED TO BE

01:43 - 54.870 CAPTURED HERE.

01:43 - 57.190 I WOULDN'T BE

01:43 - 58.999 GOING DOWN THE LINE OF

01:43 - 00.299 QUESTIONING BUT THERE IS

01:44 - 01.989 APPARENTLY SOME AGREEMENT THAT

01:44 - 02.990 FAST.

01:44 - 04.869 I'VE THE LEGISLATURE WITH THE

01:44 - 07.020 CAMPAIGN PUBLISHED HERE AND.

01:44 - 09.569 I WAS SAYING IT'S A CAR DOESN'T

01:44 - 10.550 MAKE IT COMPARABLE

01:44 - 13.589 OR DIE. I SEE THOSE A LOT OF

01:44 - 14.290 FUN TO MAKE IT

01:44 - 17.049 9 O'CLOCK. I'M REALLY

01:44 - 18.219 STRUGGLING WITH THEIR

01:44 - 19.939 GRANDMOTHER THAT WE'RE DEALING

01:44 - 20.940 WITH HERE.

01:44 - 24.509 WELL I THINK IT GOES BACK TO

01:44 - 26.269 THE COMMONLY UNDERSTOOD MEANING

01:44 - 27.270 OF THE TERM.

01:44 - 29.979 IN THE SAME SERVICES, IT'S

01:44 - 31.519 SOMETHING THAT GIVEN AWAY FOR

01:44 - 34.129 FREE OR DISCOUNTED TO TO THE TO

01:44 - 34.760 THE NATION

01:44 - 37.319 AND I THE CASINOS HAVE A LOT OF

01:44 - 39.039 LEEWAY LEEWAY IN TERMS OF

01:44 - 42.059 CREATIVITY BE. WHAT GREAT WHAT

01:44 - 43.390 CAN BE ADOPTED OR NOT.

01:44 - 50.389 I THINK THE REGULARLY IT DIED

01:44 - 51.610 IN THE SUNGLASSES.

01:44 - 54.540 WELL I PUT THE PROPERTY.

01:44 - 56.749 IT COULD BE IT COULD BE

01:44 - 59.049 A CALM. THE DATA BACK THAT'S

01:44 - 00.880 THE PROBLEM I HAVE YOU HERE

01:45 - 03.209 WITH THAT THE MANNER IN WHICH

01:45 - 05.000 THIS ISSUE HAS BEEN GREAT.

01:45 - 11.419 TOO HOT BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T

01:45 - 13.189 WANT THE CASH THERE'S IN

01:45 - 14.989 THE COMMONWEALTH. THE BEAR THE

01:45 - 18.109 BURDEN OF THE CONS. HOW

01:45 - 20.620 WE SIGH WHY THAT.

01:45 - 24.309 ME IN THE INDUSTRY IN

01:45 - 27.449 PENNSYLVANIA. AND

01:45 - 30.249 I KNOW AND 3RD BASE, I MEAN

01:45 - 31.250 ANYTHING.

01:45 - 34.030 I SERVICE COULD BE MANY THINGS I

01:45 - 37.719 IF YOU WANT IF YOU IF YOU

01:45 - 38.880 WANT TO COMPARE AND CONTRAST.

01:45 - 41.069 THE WHAT SERVICE WHAT PERSONAL

01:45 - 42.359 PROPERTY. I THINK SOME OF THEM

01:45 - 44.689 PULLS. CAN CAN SHOWCASE THE

01:45 - 45.690 DIFFERENCE.

01:45 - 47.819 IT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AN

01:45 - 49.659 ANIMAL BETWEEN PERSONAL

01:45 - 51.179 PROPERTY AND SERVICES HUMAN

01:45 - 52.799 LABOR. EFFORT

01:45 - 54.190 OR SKILL. IF YOU THINK OF

01:45 - 55.869 THANKS TO DEFEAT A STOCK

01:45 - 57.210 CERTIFICATE WHICH INVOLVED.

01:45 - 00.539 THE VALUE OF ALL THE TANGIBLES

01:46 - 01.870 AND INTANGIBLES OF THE COMPANY

01:46 - 05.579 OR THINK A BANK ACCOUNT THAT'S

01:46 - 07.379 THE PROMISE TO REPAY INSURANCE

01:46 - 09.709 POLICY WHICH IS THAT A PROMISE

01:46 - 10.590 TO PAY MONEY UPON THE

01:46 - 11.799 OCCURRENCE OF THE SPECIFIED

01:46 - 13.599 THAT NONE OF THOSE INVOLVED IN

01:46 - 14.600 THE LABOR WHERE.

01:46 - 16.489 IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT A NAIL

01:46 - 18.149 SALON OR IN STYLE A

01:46 - 20.320 SPA SERVICES OR WEREN'T ABLE

01:46 - 24.160 IN THE LABOR SKILL OR DIE.

01:46 - 26.870 IT'S A QUESTION OF THE COUNCIL.

01:46 - 30.339 YOU GIVE ME A TICKET. SO THAT

01:46 - 32.869 EVERY LIKE CONCERT. PUTTING

01:46 - 34.599 ASIDE, I WOULD THAT'S GREAT

01:46 - 35.960 VALUE THAT PERSONALLY.

01:46 - 43.920 AND WHY CAN'T

01:46 - 45.429 I JUST YOU THERE'S NO NOT

01:46 - 46.809 TRANSFER ABILITY PROVISION

01:46 - 48.530 HERE. WHY IS THAT.

01:46 - 55.319 I THINK IT GOES BACK TO THE

01:46 - 57.249 OVERARCHING APPROACH IN FACT

01:46 - 58.599 STAGES WHICH IS TO DEAL WITH

01:46 - 01.359 REALITY. BUT WITH PEOPLE ASKING

01:47 - 03.480 US TO JUST REWRITE THE STATUE

01:47 - 05.779 TO CONFORM WITH OUR NOTION OF

01:47 - 07.290 QUOTE, A REALITY.

01:47 - 15.480 AND

01:47 - 17.599 HAVING TO IT'S TRUE WHAT THAT

01:47 - 18.800 MEANS BAD THEY'VE BEEN SORT OF

01:47 - 20.140 DOING THE RIGHT THING.

01:47 - 28.619 IT WOULD IT WOULD BE WHAT WE

01:47 - 30.339 GENERALLY YOU FOR I MEAN MOST

01:47 - 31.769 PEOPLE DON'T TAKE IT TAKE IT

01:47 - 33.519 AND GIVE IT AWAY OR PUT IT

01:47 - 35.959 UNDER GLASS IN MY AREA SAID THE

01:47 - 37.709 VALUE IS ACTUALLY GOING TO SEE

01:47 - 38.710 IT.

01:47 - 40.589 THAT'S ENOUGH AND GIRLS

01:47 - 41.590 TOGETHER.

01:47 - 44.530 I MEAN THE FACT THAT IS

01:47 - 46.080 TRANSFERABLE I THINK IT'S NOT

01:47 - 48.909 I UNDERSTAND IT'S TRANSFERABLE

01:47 - 50.909 AND THAT A PERSON COULD USE IT

01:47 - 51.910 TO GAIN CASH.

01:47 - 54.499 I THINK WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT

01:47 - 56.519 THE OVERARCHING HOUSE INTENDED

01:47 - 58.419 TO BE USED WHICH IS TO REWARD

01:47 - 59.599 THE PERSON WHO RECEIVED THE

01:47 - 00.600 TICKET.

01:48 - 11.629 THIS IS THERE ANY DIFFERENCE

01:48 - 12.760 BETWEEN THE

01:48 - 16.569 PUTTING ON A CONCERT

01:48 - 19.239 PERFORMANCE OF ITS OWN INSIDE

01:48 - 21.639 THE CASINO AND TELLING EVERYONE

01:48 - 23.889 IN ATTENDANCE. THE CASINOS ARE

01:48 - 25.840 WELCOME TO ATTEND THE CONCERT

01:48 - 28.619 AND BUT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT

01:48 - 31.479 HERE OFF PROMISES. CONCERTS AT

01:48 - 32.480 SOME ARENA

01:48 - 34.459 WHERE THE CASINOS GIVING OUT

01:48 - 35.949 TICKETS IS THERE ANY DIFFERENCE

01:48 - 37.830 IN THOSE 2 THINGS TO TERMS OF

01:48 - 39.140 SERVICES.

01:48 - 40.819 I DON'T THINK THE STATUTE

01:48 - 42.399 MAKES THAT DISTINCTION BETWEEN

01:48 - 43.690 BEING THE SERVICE PROVIDER

01:48 - 45.250 SOMEONE ELSE TO PROVIDE IT.

01:48 - 46.849 I KNOW THE COMMONWEALTH COURT

01:48 - 48.149 MAJORITY MADE THAT DISTINCTION

01:48 - 49.100 BUT AGAIN NOTHING

01:48 - 50.399 THERE'S NO DISTINCTION IN

01:48 - 51.729 STATUTE IN AND I THINK THAT

01:48 - 52.730 WOULD BE A WAY FOR.

01:48 - 55.990 THE CASINO TO AVOID FACTOR

01:48 - 57.770 IN FACT BY

01:48 - 01.229 HIRING A 3RD PARTY TO DO IT FOR

01:49 - 02.629 HAVING YOU KNOW HAVING THEY CAN

01:49 - 05.149 PUT A A DAUGHTER IN. YOU

01:49 - 06.809 KNOW AND AS LONG AS THAT PERSON

01:49 - 08.669 THE INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR THAT

01:49 - 10.100 WOULD ALLOW THEM TO AVOID HER.

01:49 - 11.469 THE WAY THE TAX AND I DON'T

01:49 - 13.359 THINK THAT'S WHAT THE GENERAL

01:49 - 14.390 ASSEMBLY HAD IN MIND.

01:49 - 17.450 THEN THEY CREATED THIS CELL.

01:49 - 19.390 THE SPECIAL PROPERTY BUT THE

01:49 - 27.850 AND THIS IS JUST VERY BIG.

01:49 - 30.350 IT JUST ISN'T

01:49 - 32.729 THE SIDE. I THOUGHT IF THE BANK

01:49 - 34.899 RESCUE IN WHAT TYPE OF PROPERTY

01:49 - 35.530 THAT WAS

01:49 - 37.709 IT IS PRETTY USELESS

01:49 - 40.409 RESPECTFULLY TO BE IN THIS

01:49 - 41.500 POSITION OF THE CASE

01:49 - 43.479 THERE'S 3 KINDS OF PROPERTY IN

01:49 - 44.579 THE WORLD AND THAT'S ALL THERE

01:49 - 46.619 ARE REAL PROPERTY AND THE FIRST

01:49 - 49.159 BUILDING IN AND. THERE'S NO

01:49 - 51.639 QUESTION THESE THESE TEA PARTY

01:49 - 53.069 TICKETS ARE IN TANGIBLE

01:49 - 54.070 PERSONAL AIDE.

01:49 - 57.450 IT'S JUST AS A $1000 BILL.

01:50 - 02.059 BUT I DON'T THINK THAT HELPS US

01:50 - 02.610 TO ANSWER

01:50 - 04.539 THE QUESTION. THAT'S THE THING

01:50 - 06.219 IS YOU CAN SHOVEL SERVICES THE

01:50 - 07.480 QUESTION HERE IS WHETHER

01:50 - 09.130 THEY'RE NOT SERVICES.

01:50 - 14.899 THAT'S THE STORY WITH US I GET

01:50 - 15.900 THAT OFF MY CHEST,

01:50 - 20.089 IT SEEMS TO ME ARE YOU FAMILIAR

01:50 - 21.590 WITH THE THE

01:50 - 26.149 PRECEPT OF HIS INJURED NECK IN

01:50 - 27.150 THERE.

01:50 - 29.719 THERE YOU HAVE THERE A RISK TO

01:50 - 31.659 THE SPECIFICS TODAY GENERAL THE

01:50 - 33.440 GENERAL FOLLOWS THE REP.

01:50 - 34.790 YES, I'M AWARE.

01:50 - 37.669 THE LEGISLATURE. IT BEGAN

01:50 - 39.170 THAT'S BEEN AROUND 4,000 NEW.

01:50 - 40.750 THE LEGISLATURE.

01:50 - 44.119 TRAVEL EXPENSES FOR THE

01:50 - 46.340 FRESHMAN 5.33 AND THE LIKE.

01:50 - 50.860 AND THEY DIDN'T

01:50 - 53.329 DO THAT. SO YOU WANT TO KNOW IS

01:50 - 55.540 DOES IT WORK IS 12 FOR

01:50 - 57.549 FOR YEARS. AND THEY LEAVE

01:50 - 59.629 US WITH THE INTERPRETER

01:50 - 01.449 OBLIGATION TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT

01:51 - 01.640 WHICH

01:51 - 03.929 SERVICES ARE THAT'S JUST THE

01:51 - 06.390 THOUGHT OF YOU SAID THE CONCEPT

01:51 - 08.039 IF YOU AGREE WITH THAT OR

01:51 - 09.040 DISAGREE.

01:51 - 12.770 I THINK THE QUESTION WAS WHAT.

01:51 - 14.179 WHAT THE SERVICE AND WHAT ARE

01:51 - 15.469 THE QUALITIES OF SERVICES AND

01:51 - 16.890 NOT WHETHER THEY'RE THERE COPS,

01:51 - 18.179 THEY DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY

01:51 - 20.019 DISAGREEMENT AMONG THE PARTIES

01:51 - 21.330 THAT THESE WERE KEY COM.

01:51 - 25.509 THE AND ONLY THROUGH THE VISA

01:51 - 26.639 CAPS THERE'S NO DOUBT

01:51 - 28.279 ABOUT IT. BUT THAT DOESN'T

01:51 - 30.309 NECESSARILY ANSWERED DISPATCH

01:51 - 32.040 FREE EXPRESSION FROM ANDRO

01:51 - 34.559 THEY SING WHICH IS ARE THEY

01:51 - 35.560 SERVICE.

01:51 - 41.710 IF WE CAN PROVE IT.

01:51 - 44.569 IN A MOMENT THAT WE CONSTRUE

01:51 - 47.069 SERVICES AS YOU LIKE. DOESN'T

01:51 - 48.430 THE ON THE ROAD TO COME.

01:51 - 51.869 UNBELIEVABLY WHY THERE'S THIS

01:51 - 52.870 IS EVERYTHING.

01:51 - 56.759 AGAIN I THINK HE WOULD FOLLOW

01:51 - 58.500 THAT FINALLY UNDERSTOOD EVENING.

01:51 - 01.159 BASED ON THE 6 CASES WE CITED

01:52 - 01.450 THAT ALL

01:52 - 03.119 REFERRED TO A MISSION TO GET

01:52 - 05.029 THE SERVICES THAT WAS ALL THOSE

01:52 - 07.280 CASES ALMOST ALL IN ONE DAY.

01:52 - 10.220 THE ANATOMY ACT THE GAMING AND.

01:52 - 14.169 IF YOU LOOK AT THE 1996 TEXT

01:52 - 15.949 PEACE SIGN OR IF I AGREE WITH

01:52 - 17.839 YOU. THE MOVIE THAT

01:52 - 19.379 WAS THAT THAT TALKED ABOUT THE

01:52 - 21.139 MISSION TICKETS TO CONCERTS AND

01:52 - 22.470 SHOWS AND SPORTING EVENTS.

01:52 - 26.819 AGAIN AS HAS THE SERVICES AND

01:52 - 27.880 THOSE ALL DAY.

01:52 - 30.479 THE GAMING. THEY RELY ON THAT

01:52 - 32.419 AND ALSO SOME OF THE EXAMPLES I

01:52 - 33.529 GAVE YOU ARE AT THE DIFFERENCE

01:52 - 35.729 BEING BETWEEN THE SERVICE IS

01:52 - 36.190 INVOLVED

01:52 - 38.799 IN LABOR. IF THE CASINO WANT TO

01:52 - 40.779 START HANDING OUT A STOCK

01:52 - 42.309 CERTIFICATES TO AMAZON OR APPLE

01:52 - 44.449 THAT THE PERSONAL PROPERTY AS

01:52 - 46.590 OPPOSED TO. HERE WEEKEND

01:52 - 48.709 INVOLVED THE LAKERS. I THINK

01:52 - 50.070 THAT THE LIMITING PRINCIPLE.

01:52 - 53.599 THEY'VE ALSO MY ADVERSARIES IN

01:52 - 55.189 ADDITION IS INCONSISTENT

01:52 - 57.479 BECAUSE IF YOU LOOK AT AGE OF

01:52 - 59.669 THE REPRODUCE RECORD. GREEN WAS

01:52 - 00.900 SPENT $8,000.

01:53 - 04.569 JAY Z TICKETS. THEY ONLY THEY

01:53 - 06.900 ONLY SAW A REFUND FOR 6,000

01:53 - 08.650 BECAUSE 25%

01:53 - 10.649 OF THOSE TICKETS WAS FOR FOOD,

01:53 - 11.849 BUT THEY RECOGNIZE THE

01:53 - 12.939 PRINCIPLE THAT YOU HAVE TO LOOK

01:53 - 14.719 PAST THE TICKET. THE SEE WHAT'S

01:53 - 15.839 BEING MADE AND WE DIDN'T

01:53 - 18.320 CHALLENGE THAT FOR US. A

01:53 - 22.969 IT'S JUST YEAH, IT SEEMS THE

01:53 - 23.970 THAT.

01:53 - 26.729 IT SEEMS TO ME THAT YOUR

01:53 - 29.439 COMPARISON TO AND AMAZON GIFT

01:53 - 30.440 CARD.

01:53 - 33.409 AND I SAID IF IT MEANT LIKE A

01:53 - 35.159 STOCK CERTIFICATE NOT A GIFT

01:53 - 38.159 CARD IF PARTY. BECAUSE IT'S A

01:53 - 39.160 PERSONAL PROPERTY.

01:53 - 45.120 IT SEEMS TO ME TO BE.

01:53 - 46.469 A CONSISTENT WITH WHAT

01:53 - 47.889 JUSTICE WECHT WAS GETTING A

01:53 - 49.420 LITTLE BIT AGO THAT.

01:53 - 52.929 IF YOU GIVE ME AS A CALM, A

01:53 - 55.649 TICKET TO AJC CONCERT. I KNOW

01:53 - 57.579 INTERESTING DOLLY SO I MIGHT

01:53 - 00.350 SELL. SO SEE HOW.

01:54 - 03.340 IS DISTINGUISHABLE THEM

01:54 - 05.999 FROM AN AMAZON GIFT CARD THAT

01:54 - 07.529 WOULD HAVE FOUND YOU BECAUSE

01:54 - 09.439 THIS A PIECE OF PERSONAL

01:54 - 11.869 PROPERTY WHICH I TAKE IT TO ITS

01:54 - 14.039 PERSONAL PROPERTY. WHICH I'M

01:54 - 15.329 NOT INTERESTED IN SEEING

01:54 - 17.209 OUR TRANSFER. I CAN GIVE IT TO

01:54 - 19.049 SOMEONE ELSE OR I CAN COME SELL

01:54 - 20.930 IT TO SOMEONE ELSE OR FOR MONEY.

01:54 - 23.749 I UNDERSTAND THAT BUT I THINK

01:54 - 24.910 THAT MIGHT BE TRUE FOR.

01:54 - 26.439 OTHER THINGS THAT ARE WHO DID

01:54 - 28.739 LIKE THAT IF THE CASINO WAS

01:54 - 29.840 OFFERED I'D TAKE IT.

01:54 - 32.229 IT'S A GUIDED TOUR TICKETS TO

01:54 - 34.079 SEE LIBERTY THOUGH, BUT TAKE IT

01:54 - 35.649 FROM PHILADELPHIA TO

01:54 - 37.569 THE CASINO. CERTAINLY SOME OF

01:54 - 39.160 THE TRANSFER THOSE PATIENTS

01:54 - 41.409 STILL BE EXCLUDED. I THINK IT'S

01:54 - 43.059 AGAIN YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT THE

01:54 - 45.140 NATURE OF WHAT BEING IN VAIN.

01:54 - 47.459 AND WAS BEING CONVEYED IT IS A

01:54 - 48.489 SERVICE THEY THINK THAT THE

01:54 - 50.419 LIMITING PRINCIPLE, NOT WHETHER

01:54 - 51.559 PEOPLE CAN DO WHATEVER THEY

01:54 - 53.540 WANT. AND I'M PROUD OF THAT.

01:55 - 06.579 WELL I THINK AGAIN YOU HAVE

01:55 - 07.699 SERVICES BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO

01:55 - 09.129 LOOK AT WHAT'S BEING CONVEYED

01:55 - 10.779 IN AND PERSONAL PROPERTY, THE

01:55 - 11.969 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THOSE 2 IS

01:55 - 12.970 HUMAN LABOR.

01:55 - 16.169 SO AGAIN I THINK YOU HAVE TO

01:55 - 18.089 LOOK AND IT IT IS IT DOESN'T

01:55 - 20.060 INVOLVE THE LABOR STILL ADVISE.

01:55 - 23.099 LIKE A BARBER OR SHOE SHINER A

01:55 - 24.599 DRY CLEANER AND THAT'S THE

01:55 - 25.600 DIFFERENCE.

01:55 - 29.939 HAHA ONE STEP AND JUST WHAT CAN

01:55 - 30.940 I INTERRUPT FOR ONE

01:55 - 33.669 COUNCIL CONSUL, WHY DON'T YOU

01:55 - 34.670 VOTE.

01:55 - 36.819 IF IT MAY BE INFECTED IN THE

01:55 - 39.079 FIRST BILL PROPERTY IT REALLY

01:55 - 41.490 MADE SELLING THE STATE THIS

01:55 - 43.649 IS THE PERSON THAT'S GOING TO

01:55 - 44.819 SING EITHER YOUR THEORY OF THE

01:55 - 46.889 CASE THAT I RECOGNIZE YOUR

01:55 - 48.160 HONOR THAT THERE IS AN OVERLAP.

01:55 - 50.659 THEY BOTH INVOLVE SOMETHING

01:55 - 52.399 THAT YOU CAN SHOVEL AND THEY

01:55 - 53.839 BOTH INVOLVE SOMETHING

01:55 - 56.039 THAT REPRESENTED. I MEAN THE

01:55 - 57.099 STOCK CERTIFICATE WOULD BE

01:55 - 58.659 INTANGIBLE AND A REPRESENTATIVE

01:55 - 59.660 OF THE VALUE OF THE CAR.

01:55 - 01.549 IT ALSO INVOLVED IN SOMETHING

01:56 - 03.369 THAT INTANGIBLE AND IT'S

01:56 - 05.219 REPRESENTATIVE HOWEVER, THE

01:56 - 06.329 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THOSE 2

01:56 - 08.850 AGAIN IS IN LABOR STILL ADVICE

01:56 - 10.010 AND I THINK THAT'S THE

01:56 - 11.299 DISTINCTION THAT'S THE

01:56 - 12.709 DICTIONARY DEFINITION WHICH

01:56 - 14.219 WHICH SUPPORTS OUR VIEW AND I

01:56 - 16.139 THINK IF YOU MAKE THOSE

01:56 - 19.119 DISTINCTIONS BETWEEN. STOCK

01:56 - 20.159 CERTIFICATES OF INSURANCE

01:56 - 21.849 POLICIES. THE CURRENT AND

01:56 - 24.429 RUBBLE, THEIR SERVICES WHICH

01:56 - 27.199 MARK HUMAN LABOR THAT'S THE AND

01:56 - 28.360 I THINK THAT'S THE PRINCIPLE.

01:56 - 31.699 IT IS JUST LIKE THAT FOLLOWED

01:56 - 33.110 IT. THERE WERE FOLLOW-UP.

01:56 - 37.250 WELL I JUST I BRIEFLY ASK

01:56 - 50.260 COMMUNICATE TO THE

01:56 - 52.260 LEGISLATIVE BRANCH. IT BOASTS

01:56 - 54.009 IT GOT BETTER IN THIS

01:56 - 55.789 OTHER SECTION. YOU PUT IT IN

01:56 - 57.350 THIS SECTION. 2.

01:56 - 00.160 YOU'RE

01:57 - 02.439 SOMEBODY SUGGESTED. ALL WHILE

01:57 - 03.440 AT WORK.

01:57 - 11.830 ON THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY'S.

01:57 - 16.949 I UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT AND

01:57 - 18.499 THEN GET YOUR EYES AND

01:57 - 19.710 CERTAINLY COULD BE CLEAR.

01:57 - 21.519 I THINK IT'S CLEAR ENOUGH HERE

01:57 - 22.959 BASED ON THE CASE OF THE SITE

01:57 - 25.309 AND EVERY JURISDICTION. BASED

01:57 - 26.639 ON THE ECONOMY, THE COMMONLY

01:57 - 29.199 UNDERSTOOD MEANING. SERVICES

01:57 - 30.639 AND SOME OF THE EXAMPLES WE

01:57 - 31.100 PROVIDE IT

01:57 - 32.999 THAT NOW IF I COULD JUST

01:57 - 35.329 TRANSITION WE THINK IT'S AN

01:57 - 37.569 AMBIGUOUS THE TERM SERVICES BUT

01:57 - 38.490 I CAN RECOGNIZE THAT THERE

01:57 - 40.699 MIGHT BE. IF THERE WAS SOME

01:57 - 41.700 AMBIGUITY.

01:57 - 43.759 I THINK THE COMMONWEALTH COURT

01:57 - 45.409 ERRED BY FIRST GOING TO THE

01:57 - 47.219 STRICT CONSTRUCTION. THIS COURT

01:57 - 49.599 HAS SAID IT LEAST 3 TIMES SINCE

01:57 - 50.799 GREENWOOD GAMING WAS LAST YEAR

01:57 - 53.239 IN 2014 THAT AND A DECADE, A

01:57 - 54.929 NIGHT OF OTHERS AND IT'S FUNNY

01:57 - 56.439 TRANSPORT THAT THE RULES ARE

01:57 - 58.009 STRICT CONSTRUCTION IS A TOOL

01:57 - 59.749 OF LAST RESORT AND THAT

01:57 - 01.549 YOU'LL BUY SOME OF THE FACTORS

01:58 - 04.399 OF SECTION 1921. FIRST LET ME

01:58 - 07.389 FOCUS ON 2 OF THOSE. HERE ONE

01:58 - 09.509 WOULD BE THE CONSEQUENCES, A

01:58 - 11.409 PARTICULAR INTERPRETATION AND

01:58 - 12.969 DEFERENCE OPPOSITION ON THE

01:58 - 15.110 CONSEQUENCES IS THAT THIS WOULD

01:58 - 18.319 IF A TICKET IS DETERMINED THAT

01:58 - 21.649 HAS COME FOR JURY THEY'RE GOING

01:58 - 23.150 TO BE LOTS OF WAYS FOR

01:58 - 25.229 THE CASINOS TO AVOID ATTACKS.

01:58 - 26.749 I KNOW YOU SOME MAYBE

01:58 - 28.909 MORE OF A STREAM EXAMPLES BUT

01:58 - 29.850 THE USE OF TICKETS IS

01:58 - 32.389 WIDESPREAD AND AGAIN I THINK

01:58 - 34.689 THEIR POSITION INCONSISTENT YOU

01:58 - 36.299 CAN TAKE SOMETHING THAT IS

01:58 - 37.970 EXCLUDED LIKE AN AIRLINE TICKET.

01:58 - 40.609 OR TRAVEL EXPENSES ARE ARE

01:58 - 42.319 EXCLUDED. BUT UNDER

01:58 - 43.679 THEIR INTERPRETATION OF AIRLINE

01:58 - 45.910 TICKETS AND GET THEM. THE DUTCH

01:58 - 47.399 BECAUSE IT INVOLVED A TICKET OR

01:58 - 49.109 A BUS TICKET. THERE ARE

01:58 - 51.139 OPPOSITION OF THE R R IT IS

01:58 - 53.010 MORE REASONABLE IF A PATIENT.

01:58 - 56.309 OTHERWISE YOU JUST AVOID THE

01:58 - 59.570 FEE. I UNIT HERE ON EARTH.

01:59 - 05.500 YOU NEED ME.

01:59 - 07.300 AND BEFORE

01:59 - 09.259 YOU CONCLUDE, THEY SAID

01:59 - 10.449 SOMETHING EARLIER AND NOW

01:59 - 11.450 YOU'RE BACK TO IT.

01:59 - 15.379 IT UP TO SEE YOU KNOW. OTHERS

01:59 - 16.880 SAY 4.

01:59 - 19.959 TICKETS FOR 4 AND FRANKLY

01:59 - 21.559 I DON'T SEE ANY RELEVANCE TO

01:59 - 22.849 THEIR ANY ANY IMPORTANCE TO

01:59 - 25.400 WHETHER IT'S SOMETHING OR

01:59 - 30.850 THEY GO SEE THE LIBERTY BELL.

01:59 - 32.640 THEIR INDEPENDENCE HALL.

01:59 - 36.900 YEAH, IT IS A GUIDE FOR YOU.

01:59 - 38.780 IS THAT YOU'RE

01:59 - 40.399 SEEING SOMEONE DELAY HUMAN

01:59 - 41.789 LABOR OF SOMEONE WHO HAS THE

01:59 - 42.230 SKILLS.

01:59 - 43.350 WHO CAN TELL YOU THE WHOLE

01:59 - 44.560 HISTORY OF LIBERTY BELL.

01:59 - 50.149 ANY OTHER YOU KNOW I TORE IT,

01:59 - 51.559 I DON'T KNOW IF THEY CHARGE I

01:59 - 52.859 DON'T THINK THEY CHARGED THE

01:59 - 54.109 LIBERTY BELL THAT IS THE FIRST

01:59 - 57.469 SECOND. THAT'S NUMBER 5 IF I

01:59 - 58.470 MAY.

01:59 - 00.220 RIGHT I STILL THINK YOU'RE

02:00 - 01.529 RECEIVING A SERVICE I THINK

02:00 - 02.530 IT'S CLEAR THAT.

02:00 - 04.649 BUT I STILL THINK YOU'RE BEING

02:00 - 06.420 ENTERTAINED THE SOME DEGREE.

02:00 - 08.959 THE ONE LAST THING

02:00 - 11.839 I WANTED TO SAY YOUR HONOR I WE

02:00 - 13.539 WE MENTIONED A DIFFERENCE IS

02:00 - 14.540 THAT AS ANOTHER.

02:00 - 16.959 A FACTOR THAT WE USE IN OUR

02:00 - 19.080 FAVOR AND I KNOW THERE'S A

02:00 - 21.019 SOME DISAGREEMENT, MAYBE THE

02:00 - 22.409 COURT EVERY DAY ABOUT HOW MUCH

02:00 - 23.530 DEFERENCE SHOULD BE GIVEN.

02:00 - 26.969 I JUST WANT TO POINT OUT I

02:00 - 28.289 THINK THIS IS A BULLET IN FOR

02:00 - 30.179 THIS MIGHT BE A LOWER LEVEL OF

02:00 - 31.180 EFFORT.

02:00 - 34.039 BUT WE ARE POSITION IS THAT IF

02:00 - 34.480 YOU ARE

02:00 - 36.679 INTERPRETATION IS A REASONABLE

02:00 - 38.230 ONE IT DOESN'T CLEARLY VIOLATE

02:00 - 40.329 THE LEGISLATURE'S INTENT AND

02:00 - 40.780 AGAIN I WOULD

02:00 - 43.249 THAT'S HIM THE KEEP MAKING THE

02:00 - 44.250 SAME POINTS BUT

02:00 - 46.069 AGAIN WE'RE LIVE IN THOSE 60'S

02:00 - 47.960 IS REFER TO ADMISSION TICKETS

02:00 - 51.489 THEN YOU'RE MOVING BACK TO YOUR

02:00 - 53.749 POINT IT FOR YOU THAT JUMP OFF

02:00 - 55.099 OF HIS DEATH. BEFORE YOU

02:00 - 56.500 CONCLUDE, AND DEFERENCE.

02:00 - 59.299 EVEN WHERE THE COURT IS

02:00 - 00.890 INCLINED TO THEM.

02:01 - 04.230 TO INVOKE DEFERENCE.

02:01 - 09.129 IF YOU HAVE A LAW ON LEGISLATIVE

02:01 - 10.649 THERE'S NO LEGISLATIVE ROLE

02:01 - 11.650 HERE.

02:01 - 15.549 IF NO ONE KNOWS THE ANALYSIS

02:01 - 17.570 WHATSOEVER SO IN A CERTAIN.

02:01 - 20.189 AND IT'S NOT BY THE GAMING

02:01 - 21.620 BOARD WHICH PRESUMABLY HAS THAT

02:01 - 23.669 SHE'S HERE. BUT IT'S QUITE

02:01 - 24.670 APART.

02:01 - 29.789 HOW IS GAMING IN THE IN THE

02:01 - 32.010 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, HOUSE

02:01 - 34.299 SUCH SAID THAT WE SHOULD SIMPLY

02:01 - 36.299 DEFERRED WITH SOMEBODY SOMEBODY

02:01 - 37.810 WROTE A BULLET THAT ABOUT SAYS.

02:01 - 40.540 THIS PARTICULAR MISSION.

02:01 - 42.559 IT'S TAXING I UNDERSTAND THE

02:01 - 43.779 GAMING COMMISSION IF THIS HAD

02:01 - 44.889 TO DO WITH THE INTEGRITY OF THE

02:01 - 47.169 GAME OR LICENSES. THEN YES, I

02:01 - 48.689 ACTUALLY DO A LOT OF THAT WE'LL

02:01 - 49.969 BE IN TOWN NO DEFERENCE THAT

02:01 - 50.982 SINCE WE'RE DEALING WITH IT

02:01 - 52.639 ATTACK THE TAXING PART OF THE

02:01 - 55.109 GAMING APP THAT DEAL OR HAS THE

02:01 - 56.959 EXPERTISE ON THAT AND THAT

02:01 - 58.899 SHOULD BE ENTITLED TO SOME TO

02:01 - 00.899 SOME DAY. AND I THINK AGAIN

02:02 - 02.139 THEY'RE RELYING ON THE COMMONLY

02:02 - 04.069 UNDERSTOOD MEANING SERVICES THE

02:02 - 06.380 FACT THAT THESE TYPES OF CALM

02:02 - 09.309 OR VERY POPULAR THINGS THAT THE

02:02 - 10.959 CEOS HAVE BEEN GIVING OUT FOR

02:02 - 12.029 DECADES AND THAT WITH THE

02:02 - 14.040 LEGISLATURE. IT HAD IN MIND.

02:02 - 17.239 I HAVE NOTHING FOR THE AGAINST

02:02 - 18.080 ONE OTHER THING I WANT TO

02:02 - 19.309 MENTION YOUR HONOR BEFORE I

02:02 - 21.149 CONCLUDE I THINK I KNOW WE

02:02 - 21.800 HAVEN'T TOUCHED ON IT

02:02 - 23.509 AT ALL AND I THINK THE OPEN

02:02 - 24.769 DISSENT WITHIN THAT THE

02:02 - 25.740 COMMONWEALTH COURT MAJORITY

02:02 - 28.780 RELIED ON. WAS NOTHING TO DO IT

02:02 - 30.649 BACK TO MY HEAD TO PENNSYLVANIA

02:02 - 31.879 CONSUMER PROTECTION. THEY WERE

02:02 - 33.050 LIKE IN THE CASE WHEN THERE

02:02 - 35.729 WHICH YOU SEE SEE ARTICLE 9

02:02 - 38.260 DAYS AND UNDER THAT ARTICLE 9

02:02 - 39.969 EVEN REAL PROPERTY INTERESTS

02:02 - 40.770 ARE CONSIDERED PERSONAL

02:02 - 43.099 PROPERTY AND EVEN A MORTGAGE

02:02 - 44.809 FOR A LEASE. SO I THINK THOSE

02:02 - 46.829 2 CASES AND NO BEARING ON

02:02 - 47.849 QUESTION I THINK THE CASE WILL

02:02 - 49.989 BE CITED MUCH MORE PERSUASIVE

02:02 - 51.559 THAN ANY HONEST JULY AND

02:02 - 53.099 THOSE WITHOUT THERE'S NO

02:02 - 54.680 QUESTION ABOUT OF A RESTAURANT.

02:02 - 58.270 THANK YOU MISTER STUART.

02:03 - 01.789 AND GOOD MORNING. AND THEY

02:03 - 02.090 PLEASE

02:03 - 03.619 THE COURT. MARK STEWART WITH

02:03 - 04.849 AKRON SIEMENS FOR GREENWOOD

02:03 - 05.870 GAMING AND ENTERTAINMENT.

02:03 - 07.480 THE YEAR HONORS.

02:03 - 08.440 WE SUBMIT THAT THE

02:03 - 09.579 COMMONWEALTH'S ARGUMENTS ARE

02:03 - 11.040 UNDERMINED AND 3 KEY WAYS.

02:03 - 12.719 FIRST BY THE LANGUAGE OF THE

02:03 - 14.679 STATUTE AS HAS BEEN DISCUSSED

02:03 - 16.259 EVENT TICKETS IS NOT LISTED

02:03 - 16.610 AMONG THE

02:03 - 19.279 5 ENUMERATED EXCEPTIONS IN

02:03 - 21.299 SECTION 11 '03. AND IT SHOULD

02:03 - 23.129 BE RIGHT MAN AND IT'S ABSENCE

02:03 - 24.519 SHOULDN'T BE IGNORED FOR

02:03 - 27.519 THE SPIRIT. SECTION 11 A 3 ALSO

02:03 - 29.469 BROADLY CAPTURES QUOTE UNQUOTE

02:03 - 31.309 ANY PERSONAL PROPERTY, THE

02:03 - 32.699 EXCLUSION APPLIES TO ANY

02:03 - 34.239 PERSONAL PROPERTY, WHICH

02:03 - 35.889 INCLUDES INTANGIBLE RIGHT TO

02:03 - 37.629 ATTEND AN EVENT AND OCCUPY A

02:03 - 39.859 SPECIFIC C AND A VERY

02:03 - 41.739 SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THE COST

02:03 - 43.549 OF A TICKET IS TIED TO THAT

02:03 - 45.249 INTANGIBLE RIGHT. I BOUGHT

02:03 - 46.259 TICKETS IN THE NOSEBLEED

02:03 - 48.009 SECTIONS WHEN I FOUND TO SEE A

02:03 - 49.319 BASKETBALL GAME. THE

02:03 - 51.120 CELEBRITIES WHO SAT COURTSIDE

02:03 - 52.949 THEY HAVE VERY DIFFERENT PRICE

02:03 - 55.230 THAN I DO. FOR THAT SEAT

02:03 - 56.080 AND THAT

02:03 - 57.999 COST THAT VALUE IS DIRECTLY

02:03 - 59.669 TIED TO PERSONAL PROPERTY

02:03 - 00.800 ASPECT OF THE TICKET.

02:04 - 03.609 MISTER STEWART IT STARTS THE

02:04 - 05.400 CELEBRITIES ARE PROBABLY CALL.

02:04 - 08.800 IN FACT AT ONE POINT YOUR HONOR.

02:04 - 11.879 ADDITIONALLY IN TERMS OF THE

02:04 - 12.919 INCONSISTENCY WITH

02:04 - 15.349 THE STATUTE SECTION 11 '03

02:04 - 17.479 SPECIFICALLY FOCUSES ON WHAT

02:04 - 18.869 THE CASINO FLOOR AND PUT

02:04 - 21.000 DISTRIBUTE TO THE PLAYER.

02:04 - 23.079 THE CASINO AS HAS BEEN

02:04 - 24.639 DISCUSSED, THERE'S NOT PERFORM

02:04 - 27.009 ANY SERVICE HERE. WE DO NOT I

02:04 - 28.849 FEEL THE GROUND BALL PLANETS

02:04 - 29.400 FORM MEANT FOR

02:04 - 31.719 A TOUCHDOWN. WE GIVE CAN DOUBLE

02:04 - 32.919 IN IN TANGIBLE PERSONAL

02:04 - 35.349 PROPERTY TO THE PLAYER. AND AS

02:04 - 37.029 WAS AND

02:04 - 39.159 THE QUESTIONS THE SCENARIO THAT

02:04 - 40.609 THE PLAYER HAS THE UNFETTERED

02:04 - 42.019 RIGHT TO DISPOSE OF THAT

02:04 - 43.870 TICKET. HERE SHE CAN SELL IT.

02:04 - 46.059 THEY CAN GET IT. THEY CAN JUST

02:04 - 47.559 NOT SHOW UP IN

02:04 - 49.089 THAT SCENARIO UNDER THE

02:04 - 51.379 COMMONWEALTH, YOU BECAUSE THEY

02:04 - 52.980 NEVER RECEIVED THE SERVICE.

02:04 - 54.759 THE CASINO APPARENTLY NEVER

02:04 - 56.040 DISTRIBUTED THEM ANYTHING.

02:04 - 58.439 THAT'S CLEARLY NOT THE CASE WE

02:04 - 00.559 DISTRIBUTED DOWN A TANGIBLE AND

02:05 - 01.889 INTANGIBLE PARKER A

02:05 - 04.320 PERSONAL PROPERTY. WISH DAY

02:05 - 06.510 DISPOSED OF. THE

02:05 - 08.040 AND THAT

02:05 - 10.009 HAS UNDERMINED THEIR POSITION

02:05 - 11.349 IS THIS COURT'S DECISION AND

02:05 - 12.799 WHAT'S BEEN REFERRED TO A SCREEN

02:05 - 15.119 WITH ONE AND THE DIRECTIVE TO

02:05 - 16.350 STRICTLY COME TRUE.

02:05 - 18.499 THESE DEFINITIONS IN THE LIGHT

02:05 - 20.119 MOST FAVORABLE TO THE CALM TO

02:05 - 21.250 THE TAXPAYER EXCUSE ME.

02:05 - 24.430 IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE AS.

02:05 - 26.109 REFERENCE WAS MADE TO THE RULE

02:05 - 27.110 OF LAST RESORT

02:05 - 28.929 AND WE'RE NOT TRYING TO APPLY

02:05 - 30.949 THE PRECEPT FOR THE DIRECTIVE

02:05 - 32.749 FROM FROM GREENWOOD ONE SOME

02:05 - 33.010 OTHER

02:05 - 35.249 TAX STATUTE. THE GREENWOOD ONE

02:05 - 36.959 INTERPRETED THE EXACT SAME

02:05 - 40.129 CAUSE THAT WE ARE DISCUSSING

02:05 - 42.550 HERE IN THIS CASE. IT'S A

02:05 - 45.149 APPLAUSE NUMBER 3 UNDER SECTION

02:05 - 47.110 11 '03. ONE

02:05 - 49.899 SO IT CAN HAVE A CLAUSE

02:05 - 51.779 THAT IS PARTIALLY STRICTLY

02:05 - 53.109 CONSTRUED IN THE TAXPAYERS

02:05 - 54.949 FAVOR, BUT PARTIALLY NOT

02:05 - 56.140 STRICTLY TRUE FACTS.

02:05 - 00.049 AND FINALLY THE KIND OF MIND BY

02:06 - 01.849 THE FACTS OF RECORD AS WAS

02:06 - 02.929 REFERENCED. THEY WERE

02:06 - 04.859 STIPULATED AND THE COMMONWEALTH

02:06 - 06.449 HAS AGREED TO ALL THE FACTS

02:06 - 07.839 REQUIRED TO ESTABLISH THAT THE

02:06 - 08.840 TICKETS OR BOTH

02:06 - 11.059 TANGIBLE AND IN TANGIBLE

02:06 - 12.619 PERSONAL PROPERTY AND THEY

02:06 - 13.999 STIPULATED TO THE COST OF THE

02:06 - 16.489 SAME. IN

02:06 - 19.029 TERMS OF THE ARGUMENT ABOUT

02:06 - 20.819 WHETHER THE THE COMMONWEALTH

02:06 - 22.809 COLUMN COURTS, A MAJORITY

02:06 - 24.380 DECISION WAS UNREASONABLE.

02:06 - 27.549 I DON'T THINK THAT CAN BE FOUND

02:06 - 30.520 HERE BECAUSE OF THE EXPRESS

02:06 - 33.159 EXCEPTIONS IN SECTION

02:06 - 34.739 11 A 3 AND AS

02:06 - 37.139 WAS DISCUSSED. EVENT TICKETS

02:06 - 38.399 AND ENTERTAINMENT ARE NOT

02:06 - 39.769 INCLUDED IN THAT EXPRESS

02:06 - 40.200 LISTING.

02:06 - 42.370 THIS IS THE 3RD. US.

02:06 - 46.049 THANK THE OPEN TO PROCREATE

02:06 - 47.780 LEE. LET ME ASK

02:06 - 50.340 IT YOU MENTION THAT THEY DID

02:06 - 52.369 THAT THE LEGISLATION IF NOT

02:06 - 55.079 MENTION IT SPECIFICALLY THAT TO

02:06 - 57.189 ME IS IT. WELL THE

02:06 - 59.369 WAY BECAUSE THERE'S AN INFINITE

02:06 - 00.659 NUMBER OF THINGS THAT COULD BE

02:07 - 02.279 MENTION SPECIFIC WE'RE NOT

02:07 - 03.749 SPECIFICALLY SO THE

02:07 - 05.319 LEGISLATURE'S A IS A IS A

02:07 - 06.639 DISCUSSED WITH YOUR OPPOSING

02:07 - 08.479 COUNSEL. IT IS SAID AND THE

02:07 - 10.210 LIKE THEY DID NOT.

02:07 - 12.859 SO THE QUESTION COMES DOWN TO

02:07 - 13.860 WHAT THE START.

02:07 - 16.579 CAN YOU DEFINE IT AS SERVICE

02:07 - 17.779 FOR ME AND TELL ME WHAT'S

02:07 - 19.870 INCLUSIVE ID.

02:07 - 24.109 ONE COMMITTED TO THE PLATE IS

02:07 - 25.110 OUTSIDE.

02:07 - 27.760 YES, MISTER CHIEF

02:07 - 31.489 WELL I THINK THE DEFINITION

02:07 - 33.029 OF OF THE SERVICE HAS BEEN

02:07 - 35.589 POSITIVE. IT'S IN LABOR ITS

02:07 - 38.809 EFFORT. AND THE LIKE AND PARSE

02:07 - 42.109 THE IT DID NOT PERFORM ANY. OF

02:07 - 44.179 THOSE HUMAN LABOR OR SERVICES

02:07 - 45.629 IN THIS INSTANCE WHEN HE GAVE

02:07 - 48.740 WAS. READILY IDENTIFIABLE.

02:07 - 51.319 RIGHT AND TANGIBLE PROPERTY

02:07 - 52.750 THAT THE SUBJECT OF OWNERSHIP

02:07 - 55.189 AND THAT WAS TRANSFERABLE AND

02:07 - 55.810 THAT MAKES IT.

02:07 - 57.100 ANDERSON PROPERTY.

02:07 - 59.409 I'M SORRY I APOLOGIZE HE CAN

02:07 - 00.410 CREATE.

02:08 - 02.599 AND WELL I UNDERSTAND YOUR

02:08 - 04.279 HONOR'S A VIEW THAT IT MAY NOT

02:08 - 06.769 BE DISPOSITIVE EVENT TICKETS

02:08 - 08.449 ARE NOT LISTED. IT CERTAINLY

02:08 - 09.450 SHOULD.

02:08 - 11.839 INDICATE THAT THE POSITION IS

02:08 - 14.309 NOT REASONABLE. THE DECISION OF

02:08 - 15.749 THE OF THE KIND OF COURSE NOT

02:08 - 17.920 REASONABLE AND THEREFORE.

02:08 - 19.580 IT THE TICKETS

02:08 - 23.329 CLEARLY AND UNAMBIGUOUSLY BE A

02:08 - 25.109 SERVICE AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO

02:08 - 26.789 KNOW THAT NOT ONLY DID THE

02:08 - 28.669 LEGISLATURE NOT INCLUDE EVENT

02:08 - 29.839 TICKETS FOR ENTERTAINMENT

02:08 - 31.699 EXPENSES. WHEN THEY PASSED THE

02:08 - 33.880 ACT IN 2004. BUT IN

02:08 - 36.179 2010 WHEN BAY AMENDED

02:08 - 38.159 TO ADD THE DEFINITION OF GROSS

02:08 - 39.579 TABLE GAME REVENUE, WHICH IS

02:08 - 41.219 ALSO AN ISSUE HERE. THEY

02:08 - 43.099 DIDN'T END AND WE'RE CERTAINLY

02:08 - 44.630 EVEN MORE AWARE OF THE EVENT

02:08 - 48.010 COPS THEN THEY WERE IN 2004.

02:08 - 50.189 THEY GAINED IN HAD AT INTO THE

02:08 - 52.179 STATUE AND THEY DID AT IT AGAIN

02:08 - 53.319 WHEN THEY AMENDED THE LAW WHEN

02:08 - 53.940 TO 17.

02:08 - 57.140 THE MCCAIN CAN GET THERE AGAIN.

02:08 - 00.110 YOU SEE HIM PLAY

02:09 - 01.899 GREAT IMPORTANCE TO AND I NOTED

02:09 - 03.719 THIS IN YOUR FACE OFF ON THE

02:09 - 04.390 FACT THAT THERE'S

02:09 - 06.709 A TICKET. SO ASSUMING THAT WE

02:09 - 09.399 HAVE THE KING OF SAUDI ARABIA

02:09 - 10.400 PART.

02:09 - 13.419 AND HE'S GOT A LINE OF CREDIT

02:09 - 15.329 FOR HIS GAMING OF A BILLION

02:09 - 17.090 DOLLARS AND HE LOVES

02:09 - 20.539 JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE AND IN IN THE

02:09 - 22.929 CASINO BRINGS JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE

02:09 - 25.139 TO HIS TABLE IN JUST HIS NUMBER

02:09 - 26.969 LAKE SINGS IN THE SONG. THE

02:09 - 28.130 SERVICE OR NOT TO SERVE.

02:09 - 32.259 JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE PROVIDED

02:09 - 34.019 A SERVICE TO THE KING OF SAUDI

02:09 - 36.270 ARABIA, THE CHIEF JUSTICE THAT

02:09 - 37.360 IN PART

02:09 - 39.489 DID NOT THE PARK'S FACILITIES

02:09 - 40.869 COMING I MEAN JUST THINK YOU'RE

02:09 - 42.079 CUTTING WITH A VERY SHARP

02:09 - 43.620 KNIFE. I WOULD SAY THAT IT

02:09 - 46.169 THAT PART THE MONEY THAT PARKS

02:09 - 48.479 PAY AND THAT INSTANCE ABOUT

02:09 - 50.359 THIS YOU'RE NOT POSITIVE PART,

02:09 - 52.139 HEY JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE TO SING

02:09 - 53.140 TO HIM.

02:09 - 55.410 BUT YOU CAN'T SEPARATE.

02:09 - 56.999 THE DOLLAR BUT THE GUYS TO

02:09 - 59.269 LOSE 500 MILLION YEARS IT WAS A

02:09 - 00.270 BIG DEAL.

02:10 - 01.809 IT'S GOING TO THE STATE HAS

02:10 - 04.000 TO GET 55% OF THE REVENUE.

02:10 - 07.029 JUST TO SPARE. IT'S JUST

02:10 - 07.520 THIS TIME.

02:10 - 09.739 I BELIEVE IN ALL THE MANY

02:10 - 11.149 YEARS AND I'VE BEEN SITTING ON

02:10 - 12.150 THIS BENCH WITH YOU

02:10 - 14.059 I BELIEVE THAT'S MY FAVORITE

02:10 - 15.479 HYPOTHETICAL YOU'VE EVER

02:10 - 16.480 POSSIBLE.

02:10 - 19.110 THAT DOES IT FEEL THANK YOU.

02:10 - 24.459 LET ME SEE IF I UNDERSTAND WHAT

02:10 - 26.890 YOU'RE SAYING SERVICES SEE IT.

02:10 - 30.050 OUR SERVICES THAT ARE PROVIDED.

02:10 - 33.780 HI EMPLOYEES A BIG YOU KNOW.

02:10 - 36.110 CERTAINLY THAT WOULD BE

02:10 - 37.679 CORRECT YOUR HONOR THAT WOULD

02:10 - 39.430 BE INCLUDED IN THE TERMS.

02:10 - 42.169 NO I'M NOT INCLUDING I'M

02:10 - 44.470 SAYING IS THAT SERVICES ARE.

02:10 - 47.749 IT ONLY INCLUDES 30 DAYS

02:10 - 50.659 THAT ARE PROVIDED BY EMPLOYEES

02:10 - 51.660 OF THE SCENE.

02:10 - 56.300 IN ADDITION TO WORK OR BE SEEN.

02:10 - 01.310 THEY >>CAME TO A CREAM PIE.

02:11 - 04.929 THE AIM IS TO EMPLOY BY THE

02:11 - 06.999 CASINO. IS AT

02:11 - 09.679 THE SERVICE THAT IS EXCLUDED

02:11 - 10.890 FROM THE PROPERTY.

02:11 - 12.940 THAT IS A SERVICE.

02:11 - 15.339 IT'S PROVIDED BY THE CASINO

02:11 - 17.759 ABSOLUTELY AND I THINK IT

02:11 - 21.019 IS TRANSPARENT. PRETEXT AND

02:11 - 22.289 THAT REGARD AND IT ALSO WOULD

02:11 - 23.420 NOT REALLY A WORD.

02:11 - 25.999 THE HOLDER ANY INTENT OR AID

02:11 - 27.159 WOULD NOT HAVE A SEPARATE AND

02:11 - 28.510 DISTINCT USE OR COST.

02:11 - 31.969 THEIR WAY IN AND GIVE THE

02:11 - 34.179 MONEY BACK IN YOUR ROOM, THIS IS

02:11 - 36.979 THE I I SAW ONE AND THIS IS

02:11 - 39.720 VITAL FREEMAN SOUGHT.

02:11 - 42.320 THAT IT HAS NO COST TO THAT

02:11 - 44.029 TO THE CASINO. THEY THINK

02:11 - 46.800 IT IS THE SERVICES PROVIDED.

02:11 - 49.289 AND YOUR HONOR NOTED

02:11 - 50.080 IN THE DEFINITION OF

02:11 - 51.969 COMPLEMENTARY SERVICES FOCUSED

02:11 - 54.509 AREAS ON THAT WHICH IS PROVIDED

02:11 - 55.510 BY THE SEA.

02:11 - 57.639 THE COUNCIL THIS IS JUST THE

02:11 - 59.489 FACT THAT MY UNDERSTANDING US

02:11 - 00.100 SETTING

02:12 - 02.999 BASED ON. I HOPE SHE JUST IS

02:12 - 03.740 JUST STARTING

02:12 - 05.899 JUST SAID IF THE PURPOSE IS TO

02:12 - 07.669 FIND IT WITHIN THE 4 WALLS OF

02:12 - 09.950 YOUR CASINO. IT'S A SERVICE.

02:12 - 12.259 EVEN IF A TICKET IS PROVIDED TO

02:12 - 13.560 OBTAIN THOSE SERVICES,

02:12 - 15.929 HOWEVER, IF THE TICKET IS FOR

02:12 - 17.279 SOMETHING OUTSIDE

02:12 - 19.969 THE CASINO. A CONCERT A

02:12 - 21.359 CONVENTION CENTER THERE ARE

02:12 - 24.180 MORE. THE FOOTBALL STADIUM.

02:12 - 25.779 THEREFORE URGE PERSONAL

02:12 - 27.920 PROPERTY OR IF YOU NOT TO SAY

02:12 - 29.690 THEY'RE TRYING TO DISCERN.

02:12 - 34.909 THE STATUE FOCUSES ON WHAT

02:12 - 36.090 THE CASINO DISTRIBUTE.

02:12 - 40.199 IN THESE INSTANCES THAT

02:12 - 41.650 YOU REFERENCE THIS TRAIN.

02:12 - 44.810 A PIECE OF PERSONAL PROPERTY.

02:12 - 47.079 THEY COMPRISE ABOUT TANGIBLE

02:12 - 49.170 AND INTANGIBLE THE PROPERTY,

02:12 - 50.939 THE SERVICES PERFORMED BY

02:12 - 52.729 SOMEBODY ELSE IF THE CASINO

02:12 - 54.569 ACTUALLY PERFORM SERVICES

02:12 - 55.570 INSIDE.

02:12 - 57.519 CASINO THEN OBVIOUSLY THE

02:12 - 58.729 CASINOS DISTRIBUTING THE

02:12 - 59.940 SERVICE IN THAT INSTANCE.

02:13 - 02.910 BUT THERE IS AND INTANGIBLE I'M

02:13 - 05.009 A GUY FINISH THE QUESTION I

02:13 - 07.480 THOUGHT. THERE'S AN INTANGIBLE

02:13 - 08.859 RIGHT THAT HAS

02:13 - 10.459 A VALUE AND THERE'S ALSO A

02:13 - 12.109 SERVICE PROVIDED BY A 3RD PARTY

02:13 - 13.199 AND THAT GETS BACK TO THE WHOLE

02:13 - 14.479 POINT OF WHEN

02:13 - 17.099 A PLAYER IS THE FOCUS FOR THE

02:13 - 18.620 CASINO GIVE TO THE PLAYER.

02:13 - 20.679 WHEN THAT PLAYER THEN TRANSFERS

02:13 - 22.159 THE TICKET THE SOMEBODY ELSE

02:13 - 23.659 WHETHER BY SELLING IT OR GIVING

02:13 - 25.609 IT AWAY. THE SERVICE IS

02:13 - 27.019 ALTERNATELY PERFORMED BY

02:13 - 28.480 SOMEONE OTHER THAN THE CASINO

02:13 - 30.929 AND IT'S. RECEIVED OR

02:13 - 32.539 EXPERIENCE BY SOMEBODY OTHER

02:13 - 34.429 THAN THE WEATHER. IT'S

02:13 - 36.740 SURROUNDED STAYING AND I COULD.

02:13 - 38.809 IT'S TIME TO YOU AGAIN, AND

02:13 - 39.640 YOU KNOW I THOUGHT

02:13 - 41.369 PARTLY BURIED, IT MAY BE

02:13 - 43.149 BEATING THE GET COURT. BUT I

02:13 - 44.220 DON'T FIND IT HELPFUL.

02:13 - 47.000 IT'S TYPICALLY IT

02:13 - 49.250 OKAY SO

02:13 - 51.929 THE CASINO GIVE 80 GRAND A

02:13 - 53.620 TICKET TO GO TO MORE

02:13 - 56.069 IN PHILADELPHIA. WE CAN NO

02:13 - 58.290 RELATIONSHIP TO YOUR SEAT.

02:13 - 00.790 IS THAT EXCLUDED.

02:14 - 04.860 IT'S TYPICALLY LOOTING IS.

02:14 - 08.519 IT WOULD BE NO EXCLUDED IT'S

02:14 - 09.650 BEEN YES, YOUR HONOR.

02:14 - 16.789 THAT BEING SERVED BY OR IN A

02:14 - 19.479 CITY YOU KNOW MANY MANY

02:14 - 22.599 MILES AWAY. I SEE NO IT'S GOING

02:14 - 23.600 TO BE.

02:14 - 27.079 THERE'S NO DISTINCT EYE AND

02:14 - 28.289 THAT SITUATION THAT WOULD BE A

02:14 - 30.289 CLEAR PRETAX THAT WHAT'S GOING

02:14 - 32.779 ON. THERE'S NO. THERE'S NO

02:14 - 35.499 INDEPENDENT VALUE THAT TICKET

02:14 - 39.679 THERE'S NO. HAHA I THINK

02:14 - 40.450 THERE'S A TICKET.

02:14 - 42.959 IT DOESN'T SAY NOT FOR TODAY

02:14 - 44.850 NOT FOR BILL I'M SAYING IT.

02:14 - 46.970 THEIR FOOD AND MORE.

02:14 - 49.389 IT'S 08:00AM IT SEEMS TO ME

02:14 - 50.909 THAT IF JUSTICE TANI WHO IS A

02:14 - 53.749 VEGETARIAN. THERE ARE MORE THAN

02:14 - 55.539 SHE COULD GIVE ME THAT TAKE IT

02:14 - 57.240 AND I COULD GO LEAD TO STAY.

02:14 - 58.830 CORRECT.

02:15 - 03.780 IT JUST DOESN'T CARE.

02:15 - 08.519 THE LEGISLATURE WAYS HIM THING

02:15 - 09.520 TO IT.

02:15 - 13.539 LOU FROM THAT LAKE IS I I I

02:15 - 14.540 DID NOT.

02:15 - 18.149 IF YOU'RE PUTTING DOWN, SO YOU

02:15 - 20.629 SEE THEM FALL IN TRAVEL

02:15 - 21.630 EXPENSES.

02:15 - 24.849 LET'S SAY INSTEAD OF REIMBURSING

02:15 - 27.479 TRAVEL EXPENSES. THE CASINO

02:15 - 30.019 SANDS, A HIGH ROLLER AND

02:15 - 31.999 AIRLINE TICKET. THEY GET THEM

02:15 - 33.000 TO THE CASINO.

02:15 - 35.819 IT IS ARE

02:15 - 38.109 NOT TRANSFERABLE NO I CAN'T BE

02:15 - 40.499 USED BY SOMEONE ELSE. I MEAN IS

02:15 - 43.400 THAT IT UNDER YOUR EYE

02:15 - 46.779 EXCESS, NOT PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE

02:15 - 47.870 IT'S A TICKET.

02:15 - 50.160 THE AIRLINE.

02:15 - 51.799 AN AIRLINE TICKET IS AN

02:15 - 53.549 ACTUAL TRAVEL EXPENSE WHICH IS

02:15 - 56.070 A LIST AND. EXPLOSION.

02:15 - 57.940 IT'S NOT I'M NOT

02:15 - 59.729 TRYING TO FORCE THERE TO GET

02:15 - 02.079 INTO A SERVICE. IT'S ONE OF THE

02:16 - 03.080 LIST OF US JUSTICE.

02:16 - 05.409 BECAUSE THE POINT IS AS MY

02:16 - 06.610 COLLEAGUES OF THE LOOSE DATA.

02:16 - 08.350 THE ISSUE ISN'T.

02:16 - 10.539 ON THE PREMISES

02:16 - 12.389 OR OFF THE PREMISES OR WHETHER

02:16 - 13.609 THERE'S A PIECE OF PAPER THAT'S

02:16 - 15.919 ABOUT YOUR TICKET. IT'S IT'S

02:16 - 18.399 WHAT TRUMP'S THERE IS THAT THIS

02:16 - 19.650 LEGISLATURE SAID.

02:16 - 27.019 SO YOU DON'T MAINTAIN THAT TO

02:16 - 28.020 DOCK.

02:16 - 33.370 BECAUSE THE LEGISLATURE SAID.

02:16 - 43.359 HUMAN ISSUE WHEN BECAUSE IT'S

02:16 - 44.799 IN THE U.S. THERE IS THAT THE

02:16 - 45.230 ARGUMENT.

02:16 - 46.829 THAT IS ULTIMATELY THE

02:16 - 47.920 ARGUMENT YOUR HONOR, YES.

02:16 - 50.989 THE END OF THE DAY THAT IS IF

02:16 - 53.879 WE WOULD SEE THAT IS IT'S IT'S

02:16 - 56.179 AN AMBIGUOUSLY NOT COVERED BY

02:16 - 57.659 SERVICES BUT TO THE EXTENT THAT

02:16 - 59.299 THEY OBVIOUSLY WERE DISCUSSING

02:16 - 00.300 AND DEBATING IT

02:17 - 02.739 AND THERE'S BOUND TO BE SOME

02:17 - 04.799 AMBIGUITY IT HAS TO BE RESOLVED

02:17 - 07.479 IN FAVOR OF THE TAX. WHICH IS

02:17 - 08.380 WHAT THIS COURT HELD IN

02:17 - 09.380 GREENWOOD.

02:17 - 11.899 AND IN REGARD TO THE SAME VERY

02:17 - 12.900 SAME CAUSE.

02:17 - 17.149 AND IF I MAY WANT TO SAY ONE

02:17 - 18.789 MORE THING ON ON THE POINT OF

02:17 - 19.790 REFERENCE.

02:17 - 22.520 AND IT'S IT WAS DISCUSSED

02:17 - 24.609 OBVIOUSLY THE HARM IN CASE

02:17 - 25.829 UNLESS DEFERENCE TO 9

02:17 - 27.620 LEGISLATIVE RULES. IT'S

02:17 - 29.179 THE PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT TO

02:17 - 30.929 NOTE THAT THE DEPARTMENT'S OWN

02:17 - 31.990 REGULATIONS HERE

02:17 - 34.849 AT 61 P A CODE SECTION 3 DIE

02:17 - 35.850 FOR.

02:17 - 38.519 DISCUSSES AND STATES THAT TAX

02:17 - 40.649 BULLETINS ARE QUOTE UNQUOTE FOR

02:17 - 43.349 INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND

02:17 - 44.070 QUOTE SHOULD

02:17 - 47.239 NOT BE IT RELIED ON OR USE IN

02:17 - 48.210 TAX APPEALS

02:17 - 50.969 END QUOTE THE TAXPAYER CANNOT

02:17 - 52.919 RELY ON THIS TASK FORCE IN OR

02:17 - 55.379 USE AN IMPACT FEEL THE COURT

02:17 - 57.720 SHOULD CERTAINLY NOT A 4020.

02:17 - 59.570 MISTER

02:17 - 01.879 SPIRIT BEFORE BEFORE YOU AND I

02:18 - 03.870 JUST WANT TO TRY TO.

02:18 - 07.199 SEE IF IF I'M NOT SURE HOW MY

02:18 - 09.099 COLLEAGUES FOR DOING THAT, BUT

02:18 - 11.210 IF I CAN ACTUALLY UNDERSTAND.

02:18 - 18.319 THE PRINCIPAL. A JURY OF YOUR

02:18 - 20.419 ORGANS. THE BUSH. LET ME JUST

02:18 - 21.579 START QUICKLY WITH WHAT

02:18 - 24.519 YOUR NIGH. YEAH, YOU'RE NOT

02:18 - 26.009 ARGUING THAT IT MAKES ANY

02:18 - 27.890 DIFFERENCE WHETHER THE SERVICE.

02:18 - 30.229 IT'S THAT. THE B

02:18 - 32.899 AND C IS ON SITE ARE OFF IS

02:18 - 33.900 THAT CORRECT.

02:18 - 36.620 IF IT'S

02:18 - 38.329 DISTRIBUTED BY THE CASINO ON

02:18 - 39.849 SITE WE BELIEVE ARE PERFORMED

02:18 - 41.179 BY THAT YOU KNOW I THINK IT

02:18 - 42.460 DOES MAKE IT. YES RIGHT.

02:18 - 45.570 IF YOU'RE REALLY TRIED THIS.

02:18 - 47.729 YOU KNOW WE'VE SEEN DOESN'T

02:18 - 49.040 MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE BECAUSE IT

02:18 - 51.259 CATCH BILL IF IT'S DONE

02:18 - 53.259 DIRECTLY BY THE CASINO MY HYPO

02:18 - 55.259 THE BOSS COMES AND SINGS TO THE

02:18 - 57.690 GAME OR THAT YOU PROVIDE IT.

02:19 - 04.699 I THINK PROVIDING THE TICKET TO

02:19 - 06.379 A SPRINGSTEEN CONCERT. IT

02:19 - 08.349 PROVIDES IN TANGIBLE PERSONAL

02:19 - 10.699 PROPERTY AND ON THE STIPULATE

02:19 - 12.079 STIPULATED RECORD TANGIBLE

02:19 - 13.319 PERSONAL PROPERTY BECAUSE I

02:19 - 15.619 WOULD HAVE THAT TICKET. TRAINED

02:19 - 17.610 ON MY WALL, IT WAS THE BOSS.

02:19 - 19.789 AND FRANK THAT IS A GREAT

02:19 - 21.479 MARKET ON AMAZON FOR TICKETS

02:19 - 22.930 LIKE THAT TO THE SOUTH BUT.

02:19 - 26.429 I SAY THE OPPOSITE WAY LAST

02:19 - 27.600 QUESTION YOU KNOW WHAT.

02:19 - 30.729 TRY IF YOU COULD IT JUST ONE

02:19 - 32.909 SENTENCE OR 2. THEY TELL US

02:19 - 35.210 EXACTLY WHAT A SERVICE. IT IS

02:19 - 36.510 UNDER THE SUSPECT.

02:19 - 39.370 THE SERVICE IS.

02:19 - 47.350 HELP OR ADVICE.

02:19 - 48.769 PROVIDED AND

02:19 - 51.139 PERFORMED DISTRIBUTED WHO BY

02:19 - 52.400 THE CASINO FOR THE PLAYER.

02:19 - 56.469 SO A SPA TREATMENT. THE VALET

02:19 - 57.470 PARKING.

02:19 - 00.569 THE POKER MASSAGE AND THEY

02:20 - 02.010 PROVIDE TO THE POKER PLAYER.

02:20 - 04.549 THOSE ARE SERVICES THAT THE

02:20 - 06.509 CASINO DISTRIBUTES TOO. THE

02:20 - 07.510 FIRE.

02:20 - 08.929 THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY

02:20 - 09.930 QUESTIONS FOR ANYONE.

02:20 - 12.269 IF THERE'S ONE FOLLOW-UP IN

02:20 - 14.979 PERFORMED. WHY AN EMPLOYEE AT

02:20 - 17.099 THE CASINO IS THAT PART OF YOUR

02:20 - 18.100 QUALIFICATION.

02:20 - 22.259 IT RUINED IT COULD BE BY THE

02:20 - 24.530 CASINO WITH US THAT IS IN PLAY.

02:20 - 29.789 NARROW DEAD. CONTACT IF YOU'RE

02:20 - 30.790 ON.

02:20 - 33.310 BY THAT SCENE.

02:20 - 41.199 THE FIRST THANK YOU VERY MUCH

02:20 - 42.859 THE KURDISTAN RECESS FOR ONE

02:20 - 43.860 HOUR FOR LUNCH.

02:20 - 45.779 THANK YOU YOUR HONOR. THE

02:20 - 46.780 RIGHT ONE.

02:21 - 20.550 SO THE

02:21 - 22.779 NEXT ARGUMENT IS STEVEN PAST

02:21 - 24.189 OWN CHRIS KEATES VERSUS THE

02:21 - 25.999 CITY OF PITTSBURGH ZONING BOARD

02:21 - 27.039 AND NORTHSIDE

02:21 - 28.040 LEADERSHIP CONFERENCE

02:21 - 29.729 REPRESENTING APPELLANTS

02:21 - 30.869 BUSINESS PATRICIA

02:21 - 32.779 HOME REAL REPRESENTING NORTH

02:21 - 34.249 SIDE LEADERSHIP IS MISTER

02:21 - 35.790 STEWART SEE CALLED YOU.

02:21 - 39.390 THE AFTERNOON EVERYONE.

02:21 - 42.660 IT TO YOU. BEFORE THE COURT.

02:21 - 44.170 TO ISSUE.

02:21 - 49.389 THE DECISION ISSUED BY

02:21 - 50.959 THE 5TH. WE'RE SHOWING BOARD

02:21 - 52.739 OF ADJUSTMENT THE REAL THING

02:21 - 54.549 VARIANCES AND EXCEPTIONS TO THE

02:21 - 56.380 NORTH SIDE NEEDED TO COUNCIL

02:21 - 59.409 ALLOWING IT TO THEM. FOREST

02:21 - 01.879 HILLS OF ITS PROPERTY LOCATED

02:22 - 03.629 ON THE CITY ITS FIRST NORTH

02:22 - 04.630 SIDE.

02:22 - 07.249 I TELL HIM SIR CITIZENS MAY

02:22 - 07.860 APPEAR TO THE

02:22 - 09.419 PUBLIC HEARING AND THE

02:22 - 10.579 NORTHSIDE LEADERSHIP TO

02:22 - 12.459 APPLICATIONS AND OPPOSED TO THE

02:22 - 13.969 PLACE THE VARIANCE AND

02:22 - 14.970 EXCEPTIONS.

02:22 - 17.419 THERE'S REMEMBER THERE ARE 3

02:22 - 18.669 MEMBERS IS OWNING BOARD OF

02:22 - 20.109 ADJUSTMENT AND THEY PROVIDED AT

02:22 - 22.429 THE HEARING. ONE MEMBER IT WAS

02:22 - 24.279 LATER DETERMINED WAS ALSO ON

02:22 - 26.159 THE NORTHSIDE LEADERS TO 40

02:22 - 27.349 DIRECTORS AT THE TIME OF THE

02:22 - 29.359 HEARING AND THE DECISION ON THE

02:22 - 30.010 NORTH SIDE.

02:22 - 31.499 THE LEADERSHIP OR ITS

02:22 - 33.179 APPLICATIONS AT THE CONCLUSION

02:22 - 34.180 OF

02:22 - 36.289 DIRECTED TO GET THIS. NO

02:22 - 37.539 FINDINGS OF FACTS AND

02:22 - 38.739 CONCLUSIONS OF LAW FOR

02:22 - 40.669 ADDITIONAL 2 WEEKS. AFTER THE

02:22 - 42.319 TRANSFER THE BILL AFTER

02:22 - 43.339 ADDITIONAL FINDINGS WERE

02:22 - 45.199 SUBMITTED THE NORTH AND AGREED

02:22 - 46.809 SEVERAL CONTINUE INTO THIS

02:22 - 48.729 ZONING BOARD. THE ISSUE HIS

02:22 - 49.170 DECISION.

02:22 - 51.809 THE BOARD. IT IS MORE SIZE

02:22 - 52.900 APPLICATIONS ON

02:22 - 57.319 8/23/2018. THE BOY TO THE STAND

02:22 - 59.139 ON APPEAL BY THE TRIAL COURT IN

02:22 - 00.140 THE COMMONWEALTH COURT.

02:23 - 02.859 FELONS WHO ARE THE CITIZENS

02:23 - 03.530 CHALLENGE THE

02:23 - 05.409 BOARD'S DECISION. ARGUED THE

02:23 - 07.699 DECISION IS BOY FACED A POINT

02:23 - 08.400 OF CONFLICT

02:23 - 10.189 OF INTEREST IN THAT ONE OF THE

02:23 - 11.589 PANEL MEMBERS OF THE ZONING

02:23 - 12.590 BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT.

02:23 - 18.019 SAT ON THE NORTHSIDE LEADERSHIP

02:23 - 19.729 COUNCIL SUMMIT BASES THAT ON

02:23 - 21.200 YOUR SITE LEADERSHIP COUNCILS,

02:23 - 24.039 A BOARD OF DIRECTORS. THEY ALSO

02:23 - 25.219 OPPONENTS ALSO ARGUE THE

02:23 - 26.719 ZONING. HEARING BOARD'S

02:23 - 28.070 DECISION WITH THEM TIMELY

02:23 - 30.349 THERE WAS ISSUED MORE THAN 45