00:12 - THE HONORABLE JUDGE IS OF THE

00:13 - COMMONWEALTH COURT OF

00:13 - PENNSYLVANIA OH YEA YEA YEA.

00:16 - >>ALL PERSONS HAVING BUSINESS

00:18 - BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH COURT

00:19 - OF PENNSYLVANIA SHALL DRAW NEAR

00:20 - AND GIVE THEIR TENSION FOR THE

00:21 - COURT IS NOW SITTING. GOD SAVE

00:23 - THE COMMONWEALTH IN THIS

00:24 - HONORABLE COURT. THE HONORABLE

00:26 - PRESIDENT JUDGE MARY HANNAH

00:27 - LEAVITT PRESIDING.

00:30 - >>GOOD MORNING AND WELCOME TO

00:32 - PROVE IT. BACK SOME OF THE

00:35 - COMMONWEALTH COURT.

00:39 - ARE THE RULES OF THE ROAD ARE

00:41 - WELL KNOWN TO MANY OF YOU, BUT.

00:44 - IF BEAR THEY

00:45 - BEAR REPEATING ITS SIDE ON AND

00:48 - ON BOND. OKAY HAS 15 MINUTES.

00:53 - THE PETITIONER OR THE APPELLANT

00:55 - MAY RIVER SOME OF THAT 15

00:57 - MINUTE HER REBUTTAL.

01:00 - OF COURSE, THE FIRST CASE FOR

01:01 - CALLING THERE HAS BEEN AN

01:03 - EXCEPTIONAL RULING MADE BECAUSE

01:05 - OF THE 5 WILL HAVE 20 MINUTES.

01:10 - I I RECOMMEND THAT YOU GET TO

01:13 - THE HEART OF THE YEAR ISSUE

01:14 - JUST AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.

01:16 - AND THE JUDGES HAVE READ ALL

01:18 - AGREE. AND WE ARE READY

01:21 - TO GO.

01:22 - 15 MINUTES 20 MINUTES MAY FOUND

01:24 - LIKE A LONG TIME BUT ECHOED BY

01:27 - VERY QUICKLY AND WITH AND THE

01:29 - COURT WILL CALL HER KATE

01:31 - WHICH IS IN RE CHESTER WATER

01:34 - AUTHORITY TRUCK. THIS IS AN

01:36 - APPEAL OF THE CITY OF TRACTOR.

01:39 - THE APPELLANT FROM THE FIRST

01:41 - PAGE OR THE CITY OF CHESTER

01:43 - FOR PENNSYLVANIA. WHICH HAVE

01:45 - APPEALED TO ORDER OF THE

01:47 - DELAWARE COUNTY

01:48 - TRIAL COURT TONIGHT THEIR

01:50 - REQUEST FOR A DECLARATION THAT

01:52 - THE CITY HAS THE AUTHORITY TO

01:55 - REPORT THAT THE ASSET ALL OF

01:57 - THAT RAPTOR WATER AUTHORITY AND

01:59 - TO SELL THOSE ASSETS

02:01 - AND TO DISSOLVE THE WATER

02:04 - AUTHORITY.

02:06 - DID HE SEEK TO SELL

02:07 - 30 AS PART OF AN EMERGENCY PLAN

02:11 - TO ADDRESS IT GOING FINANCIAL

02:13 - CRISES. THE UP HELLY

02:16 - ARE THE CHESTER WATER AUTHORITY

02:19 - THE CHESTER COUNTY

02:21 - RAVINE OR WHICH PART OF THE

02:23 - CITY PREQUEL ARGUE THAT THE

02:26 - CITY NO LONGER HAVE THE SOLE

02:28 - AUTHORITY TO CONTROL THE WATER

02:31 - AUTHORITY BECAUSE THE 2012

02:33 - AMENDMENT TO THE MUNICIPALITY

02:35 - OF AUTHORITY ACT CHAIN,

02:37 - THE FOR THE AUTHORITY.

02:40 - AT THIS POINT THE GOVERNING

02:42 - BODY NOW INCLUDE PERSON

02:44 - APPOINTED NOT ONLY BY THE CITY,

02:46 - A BIKE AFTER COUNTY AND OUR

02:48 - COUNTY. THEREFORE ANY GUN BAN

02:51 - OF THE AUTHORITY OR

02:53 - TO POLLUTION. NOT BE AUTHORIZED

02:56 - BY THE YEAR FOR A T NEW

02:58 - GOVERNING BODY.

03:08 - IT CAN BE ON BEHALF OF THE

03:10 - SENATE.

03:11 - >>THANK YOU YOUR HONOR AND MAY

03:13 - PLEASE THE COURT A BIT TENSE

03:14 - PEOPLE BALANCE FOR IN THE

03:17 - CHEST AND IT IS IT IS CLEAR

03:20 - FROM THIS COURSE DECISION AND

03:22 - THE CLEARFIELD CASE IN

03:24 - CLEARFIELD PRODIGY FOR

03:25 - RETENTION AND FORKS TOWNSHIP

03:28 - THAT 100 SECTION 5622.

03:32 - IF I AS IT WAS WE ENACTED IN

03:35 - 2001. THE CITY HAS THE

03:37 - UNILATERAL RIGHT.

03:39 - UNILATERAL RIGHT TO TAKE BACK

03:41 - YOU SAW AND THIS COURT MAKES A

03:44 - DECISION HAS MADE THAT CLEAR

03:47 - WHEN THIS COURT DECIDED ON THE

03:48 - SECTION 18 UNCLEAR. IT'S

03:51 - PRESLEY FELL IN THE VERY LAST

03:53 - SENTENCE. IT'S A PEN

03:55 - IN THE VERY LAST SENTENCE OF UP

03:57 - AND DOWN THAT COOL

03:58 - IT WILL REQUIRE THAT THE

03:59 - SECTION 18. THE. IN

04:04 - 1945. AND THEN

04:10 - RESOLUTION OR ORDINANCE TO

04:11 - ACQUIRE BEFORE.

04:14 - A RAGING TO PAY WELL THAT DOES

04:15 - IT. THAT IS THE EXPRESS HOLD.

04:18 - OF THIS COURT'S DECISION IN

04:20 - CLEAR IN THE VERY LAST SENTENCE

04:23 - OF THE OF THE OPINION.

04:26 - THAT WAS FOLLOWED UP TO FOR THE

04:27 - KIDS TO HEAR FROM OR WHAT

04:29 - CATCHER FORCED ENTRY. NOW THAT

04:32 - IS THAT IS SO DESPISED

04:33 - OF THE CITY HAVING THE RIGHT

04:36 - THAT YOU SAW ABSENT THE ISSUE

04:38 - ABOUT AT 73. THAT IS

04:40 - SO DESPISED BUT APPLE HAS BEEN

04:42 - FORCED TO ORANGE.

04:43 - IT WAS WRONGLY DECIDED TO CLEAR

04:46 - FIELDS ALONG WITH THE SIDE AND

04:48 - THEY CONTEND THAT THE SUPREME

04:50 - COURT DECISIONS IN THE BIRD

04:52 - CASE AGAIN. SHOW THAT THIS CASE

04:55 - WILL ONLY DECIDE CLEAR WELL

04:57 - IN FACT IN CLEARFIELD THIS

04:59 - COURT DISPOSED OF THAT THEIR

05:00 - YARD. IT'S FOUND IN CLEARFIELD

05:03 - EXPRESSION. THE FIRST AND

05:05 - GAMBLE COULD NOT CONTROL AND

05:07 - THEY AND THEIR FAMILIES FOR

05:10 - IT'S NOT A CASE WHERE THE

05:11 - MUNICIPALITY SHOULD TAKE THAT.

05:13 - IT'S GOING TO TAKE BACK THE

05:15 - AUTHORITY. IT WAS A CASE

05:16 - INVOLVING

05:17 - AN ENGINEER SUING FOR BREACH OF

05:19 - CONTRACT BECAUSE THE AUTHORITY

05:21 - PAY HIM $720,000. AND GAMBLE

05:25 - IT IS A PALIN SORT TAKE BACK IN

05:28 - THE FUN GEMMELL WAS

05:29 - TAXPAYERS SHOULD TRYING TO STOP

05:32 - OR MUNICIPALITIES IN CREATING A

05:34 - PUMPING STATION. IT'S A MATTER

05:36 - OF THEM

05:37 - IS CONTROLLING AS HIS COURT

05:38 - CORRECTLY FOUND IN CLEAR.

05:40 - SO YOU DISPOSE OF AND YOU ALSO

05:43 - SAID THAT ANOTHER MISTER BUSH

05:45 - CAN BE HEARD YOU.

05:47 - >>JUST A DRAFT LEAVING A 5 K

05:49 - FALL. THE.

05:51 - THE PREVENT HIM. THE OPERATIVE

05:53 - PROVISION OF THE.

05:57 - THE MAN AT THE POUND OR

05:58 - M A THE MUNICIPALITY OF

06:01 - AUTHORITY BACK I MEAN WHY WOULD

06:03 - BE.

06:09 - AUTHORITY A TRAIN OR 2, BUT

06:12 - NEVER COME NOT IMPACT.

06:17 - THE CITY.

06:21 - HAVE THE POWER TO TAKE

06:22 - BACK WHEN IT WAS CREATED, BUT

06:24 - WHY IS IT THAT THE CHAIN FROM

06:26 - GOVERNOR.

06:27 - >>HAS NO IMPACT ON THAT

06:29 - AUTHORITY. IF YOU WRITE IT IN.

06:34 - ALL RIGHT, I'M

06:34 - HAPPY TO OBVIOUSLY TO RESPOND

06:36 - TO THAT CRITICAL ISSUE.

06:38 - AND I I START WITH THE

06:40 - PROPOSITION WHICH

06:41 - THIS COURT ADOPTED THE JULIANNE

06:44 - DECISION AND THE SUPREME COURT.

06:46 - IT GOT TO THE DECK OF THE CITY

06:49 - WHICH IS QUITE A SIGHT IN 2020,

06:51 - WHICH IS THAT WHEN YOU LOOK AT

06:53 - A STATUE. IT IS IMPORTANT

06:55 - AND CRITICAL TO SEE WHAT THE

06:57 - STATUTE SAYS AND WHAT IT DOES

06:59 - NOT SHOW AND THAT'S WHAT HAS

07:01 - REALLY CRITICAL. AND COOL AT 7

07:04 - HE WAS TOO FAT.

07:08 - ONE IT SAID THAT THEY HAVE NOW

07:10 - HAVE A NEW BOARD.

07:11 - OF THE AUTHORITY AND THAT WOULD

07:13 - BE A TRIAL COURT I WOULD

07:15 - CONSISTING OF.

07:17 - DELAWARE COUNTY CHESTER COUNTY

07:18 - AND THE CITY

07:19 - INSTEAD OF HAVING A BOARD

07:21 - COMPOSED ONLY BY CITY OF 20 AND

07:24 - 2. IT CHANGES IN OTHERS STATUE

07:27 - WHICH SAID THAT THE PARTY COULD

07:30 - ONLY USE MONEY. IN RESPONSE

07:33 - THE BOYS, THE REGULATED BY

07:36 - NOW THE COUNTY ITSELF CAN YOU

07:38 - JUST IT. IT NEXT THAT AT

07:41 - 73 ITSELF. IT DID NOT INCLUDE

07:44 - ANY LIFE. ANYONE WHO SAYS THAT

07:46 - THIS IS THE JUST THE

07:47 - COUNTY AGREED MODIFYING SESSION

07:50 - 5622 MAY. THE

07:53 - M A SO THERE'S

07:54 - NO LINE IN BEEN THERE A LOT OF

07:57 - FUN, AND AND AS RESULT

08:01 - OF THAT AND POLICE WERE FORCED

08:03 - TO LIVE.

08:03 - THAT INFORAMTION INFORAMTION

08:06 - BECAUSE OF THE CHANGE IN THE

08:08 - NATURE OF THE 4. THEREFORE THE

08:10 - CITY WAS WHICH ONE. THE CITY

08:12 - WANTS THE JOB AND WE HAVE

08:14 - CITING THE HOST THE CASE.

08:21 - THAT

08:21 - YOU CANNOT DRASTICALLY CHANGE

08:23 - THE WALLS BY OMISSION FOR

08:25 - IMPLICATIONS. I SUPPOSE

08:28 - THIS WAS THIS LAW.

08:32 - AND THIS IS PART OF

08:33 - MY YARD. IT'S NOT SOME

08:39 - CLEAR FIELD BASE UNCLEAR THE

08:40 - PROJECT TELL YOUR HEALTH.

08:45 - THIS 5622 A VIRTUALLY IDENTICAL

08:48 - TO SECTION 18. IT IS WAY

08:51 - TOO LATE. YEAH THAT WAS REALLY

08:53 - AN ACT OF

08:54 - 2001 AND LEAVE WHICH SIDE OF

08:55 - THE CASE WHICH THAT POLICE DID

08:57 - NOT RESPOND WE'VE

08:58 - CITED THOSE THE SUPREME COURT

09:01 - AT 2 CASES THE SUPREME COURT

09:02 - HAS BEEN THE WISE AND PATIENT.

09:05 - IN WHICH THE SUPREME COURT OF

09:06 - PENNSYLVANIA SAID ONE OF THE

09:08 - MOST BEST AND SO THE

09:15 - THAT'S ONE OF THE MOST

09:16 - VENERABLE.

09:17 - >>AND FUNDAMENTAL AND IT'S A

09:18 - STATUTORY INTERPRETATION IS

09:20 - THAT WHEN COURTS INTERPRET A

09:21 - STATUTE. AND THEN THAT STATUTE

09:24 - TO REENACT SECTION 18 WAS.

09:26 - IT IS 2001 IS

09:31 - THE THE

09:31 - COURT'S INTERPRETATION. IT'S.

09:35 - INCLUDED IN THE REENACTMENT AS

09:38 - HE SO THE LEGISLATIVE.

09:42 - 56 WHEN HE WAS IN

09:44 - ESSENCE FIRST TO GIVE THE CITY

09:46 - THIS RIGHT. SO THEY WANT TO

09:47 - CHANGE THIS CHRISTMAS

09:50 - THE MOST THING IN AT 73.

09:55 - THE BEACHES AND SO THEY'RE

09:57 - TRYING TO DO IT BY OMISSION.

10:00 - A MISSION FOR IMPLICATION WHICH

10:02 - IS EXPRESSLY PRECLUDED BY A

10:03 - HOST OF CASES, ITS IRON ORE

10:05 - WEEK IN ADDITION YOUR HONOR IN

10:08 - THE SALEM TOWNSHIP IN LIGHT OF

10:10 - WHAT LIFE SUPPORT AN UNIONS.

10:14 - WHICH IS

10:15 - AND A MAJOR BACKS MOST

10:16 - STATUTORY INTERPRETATION.

10:18 - IF YOU SAY SOMETHING AND A

10:19 - STATUE I SAY THE OTHER. IN JUST

10:23 - THE SLIGHTEST. THAT'S A THAT'S

10:25 - A MOTHER.

10:26 - VENERABLE DOCTOR THE STATUTORY

10:30 - >>WHAT COULD NEVER COME.

10:33 - SECTION 18 AND NOW 50 PICK OF

10:36 - THE. BAN BEING.

10:40 - GET TO THE MUNICIPALITY THE

10:42 - FUNCTION OF ALL THE OBLIGATIONS

10:45 - AND.

10:46 - BY THE AUTHORITY WITH RESPECT

10:48 - TO THAT PROJECT. THEY PEOPLE

10:51 - QUIET BUT WE DON'T DENY.

10:54 - THE CHOIR ME THAT IF THE CITY

10:55 - TAKES BACK.

10:57 - >>THE AUTHORITY IT HAS TO OKAY

11:00 - IT HAS BEEN RAISED TO PAY FOR

11:01 - ALL THE OBLIGATIONS

11:02 - OF YOU.

11:05 - >>OBLIGATIONS INCLUDE PAYMENTS

11:07 - OWED TO DELAWARE COUNTY CHESTER

11:09 - COUNTY TOO.

11:12 - I DON'T THINK EVEN IF

11:14 - IT WERE WE'VE GOT THAT AND

11:15 - NOBODY IS DISPUTING THAT ON THE

11:17 - CITY SIDE WE READY.

11:19 - >>WE RECOGNIZE THAT THE SECTION

11:21 - 18 AND NOW IT'S

11:22 - INITIALLY IDENTICAL SUCCESSION

11:26 - WE READY.

11:27 - THAT WE HAVE TO PAY

11:29 - THOSE OBLIGATIONS. WE ARE NOT

11:31 - SURE THE OBLIGATION THAT.

11:34 - REQUIRED THEY TRY TO IMPOSE ON

11:36 - THE CITY ALL THESE OTHER ONES

11:37 - THAT DON'T EXIST IN THE

11:39 - LANGUAGE OF THE STATUTE.

11:40 - THEY TRY TO SUPER BOWL. ON

11:45 - THE CITY FOR EXAMPLE THEY SAY

11:46 - OF

11:46 - THE CITY. DIDN'T FUND THE

11:49 - AUTHORITIES PROJECTS TO BEGIN

11:51 - WITH IT CAN TAKE THEM BACK.

11:53 - WELL THAT'S NOT A REQUIREMENT

11:54 - STATUTE AND INDEED IN 2 OF YOU

11:56 - ON HIS DECISION

11:57 - IN CLEARFIELD AND IN FORWARD

11:59 - TOWNSHIP. THE.

12:02 - IT IS A PALIN HAD NOT BEEN DONE

12:04 - BEFORE THESE PROJECTS

12:05 - AND I BOTH OF YOU AND YET THEY

12:07 - TOOK THEM BACK. IT'S NOT A

12:09 - REQUIRED THE ONLY REQUIRED IN

12:12 - SECTION 18 NOW SECTION

12:17 - IT WAS

12:18 - A RISING. IT IS A TALLY HAS THE

12:20 - MUNICIPALITY. WHICH

12:22 - THE BIBLE, A CITY CATCHES FOR

12:25 - FOLLOW. IT'S THE MUNICIPALITY.

12:27 - IT'S THE PASS A RESOLUTION.

12:29 - THE TAKE BACK THE AUTHORITY

12:31 - CREATED AND THE CITY CREATED

12:33 - THIS IN 1939. TAKE YOU BACK

12:36 - AND. RAISED UP A

12:38 - LITTLE BIT. THAT'S

12:42 - MR. BENTLEY.

12:43 - >>LET THE GAME YOU'RE CORRECT

12:44 - PERMANENT AND THE CITY HAS THE

12:46 - AUTHORITY TO ACTUALLY THAT IT

12:47 - CAN EXERCISE

12:50 - YOU WOULD AGREE TO THE

12:51 - AUTHORITIES GOVERNING BODY OFF

12:52 - THE BOARD ALSO HAS THE

12:54 - AUTHORITY TO CONVEY.

12:57 - BE ACTIVE TO BE UNDER 50 PICKED

13:00 - THOSE DEVON BEFORE CORRECT.

13:03 - WELL AND YOU'RE RIGHT I DO

13:05 - NOT AGREE.

13:06 - >>THAT IF THE CITY HAS THE

13:08 - RIGHT TO TAKE BACK THE

13:09 - AUTHORITY IT'S WHITE AND

13:10 - PRESENT.

13:11 - >>I'M NOT I WOULD JUST GOT TO

13:13 - YOU KNOW AGREE THAT THE STATUE

13:15 - PROVIDE THE AUTHORITY WITH

13:17 - THE POWER TO DO THAT AND CAN

13:18 - BAD THE DOOR TO ASK THAT YOU

13:20 - WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.

13:21 - >>YES I DO.

13:22 - YES I DO YOU ANTICIPATE MY NEXT

13:24 - QUESTION WHICH IS WHEN

13:26 - THE AUTHORITY TO DIVE BACK

13:28 - INSIDE THE POWER AND THE CITY

13:29 - THE 5 FACTORS CITED POWER TO

13:32 - WIN.

13:35 - WHEN IS

13:35 - THERE A FIRST IN TIME FIRST IN

13:38 - RIGHT PRINCIPLE THAT THE COURT

13:40 - SHOULD APPLY HERE.

13:41 - >>AND MY ANSWER THAT YOU IT WAS

13:45 - THE RIGHT

13:46 - IF HE IS IF THE CITY WANTS TO

13:49 - TAKE BACK THE AUTHORITY CREATE

13:51 - IT HAS THAT RIGHT AND I WILL

13:52 - POINT OUT IF THE ARGUMENT

13:54 - ATHLETES MAKE ABOUT FOR SOME

13:56 - TIME. THEY FILED FIRST

13:57 - IN ANTICIPATION OF THE CITY

14:00 - TAKING BACK THEIR VERY TRUST

14:01 - PETITION THAT WE POINT OUT ALL

14:03 - A LIE. THEY'RE VERY TRUST.

14:05 - THE TENSION. IT WAS

14:07 - ANTICIPATED. THE CITY EXERCISE

14:09 - THAT RIGHT. TAKE BACK

14:11 - THE AUTHORITY AND SO THE FACT

14:14 - THAT THEY FILED FIRST MANY.

14:17 - BUT THE CITY HAS AGAIN I POINT

14:19 - TO WRITE HIS OWN DECISIONS AND

14:21 - CLEARFIELD THAT ITS PROJECT

14:23 - WHICH BECAME PORT OF THE

14:25 - LEGISLATIVE INTENT.

14:27 - >>WHEN YOU PLAY THIS GAME, NOT

14:28 - I'M NOT I'M NOT I'M SERVICE THE

14:32 - POWER, I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND

14:34 - IT COULD BE THE BOARD OF THE

14:35 - POWER COULD BE EXERCISED

14:37 - SIMULTANEOUSLY OR

14:38 - CONTEMPORANEOUSLY AND I'M

14:40 - TRYING TO UNDERSTAND IF

14:41 - THAT HAPPENED

14:43 - WHO WHEN THEY BE YOUR ARGUMENT

14:45 - BAD THE CITY TAKE PRIMACY

14:48 - REGARDLESS OF WHEN DETECTOR

14:49 - SIDE OF THE POWER AND THAT YOUR

14:51 - POSITION WHAT YOUR ARGUMENT IN

14:52 - FAVOR OF THE OPPOSITION.

14:58 - THEY'RE RIGHT.

14:59 - >>IN THE CITY SECTION 5622 AT.

15:02 - IS A PRIMARY

15:03 - RIGHT TAKES

15:04 - IS PRESIDENT OF ANY OTHER

15:06 - RIGHTS FOR THE TAKING. IT TOOK

15:09 - A LOOK

15:09 - AT WHERE IT'S ALREADY DID THAT

15:11 - YOU THOUGHT OF IT AS ITS FIRST

15:13 - PETITION STATES ONLY TO AVOID.

15:16 - IN THIS

15:17 - CITY RIGHT. THE TAKE

15:18 - BACK YOUR PHONE THAT'S THE ONLY

15:20 - REASON THEY FILED A PETITION

15:21 - AND IT'S BEEN THE ALLEGATIONS

15:23 - OF THE TRUST PETITION ITSELF AS

15:25 - WE POINT OUT A REPLY. SO SO I

15:28 - DON'T THINK. BUT THE FACT THAT

15:31 - THEY FILED FOR.

15:34 - WHERE THEY FILED THOSE ONLY

15:36 - 2 OF WAR. THE CITY'S DESIRE.

15:38 - IT TAKES BASKETS ARE

15:40 - AND THAT'S

15:43 - FROM ANOTHER QUESTION HERE

15:45 - WHICH IS THESE AUTHORITY HAVE

15:47 - THE RIGHT TO.

15:48 - >>TRANSFER AFTER THAT THE IN

15:51 - THE PROGRAM RIGHT.

15:54 - >>OF ALL THE AUTHORITIES.

15:56 - SO HOW HOW DO WE RECONCILE BOTH

15:59 - TRUE FACTOR COREY GRAHAM OF

16:01 - POWER.

16:02 - >>WELL YOU'RE ALL I CAN SAY IS

16:04 - I THINK IF YOU LOOK AT THE

16:06 - STATUTORY SCHEME.

16:08 - THAT CITY WAS SITTING CREMATED,

16:11 - YOU ARE. THIS

16:12 - WASN'T SOME A MYTHICAL THE

16:15 - CITY CREATED. AND BECAUSE THE

16:18 - CITY OF ADEN IT HAS THE RIGHT

16:21 - TO TAKE IT BACK AND

16:24 - >>MISTER KACZYNSKI I THINK YOU

16:25 - ALSO KNOW DID YOU

16:26 - BRIEF SAID IF THE CITY CREATED

16:29 - BY THE POINT OF

16:30 - THE BOARD FIRST BOTH TIMES THE

16:33 - EVEN AFTER THE CHANGE.

16:34 - YEAH, AND THE FOLLOW-UP

16:36 - QUESTION TO THAT BUT.

16:38 - >>I'M NOT I CAN SAY IS THAT THE

16:39 - CITY. IT'S A FOR 70 YEARS.

16:44 - APPLY TO THE BOARD UP TO 2012.

16:47 - THE

16:47 - 73 YEAR, THE CITY ALONG WITH

16:50 - THE BOARD LUGGAGE.

16:52 - >>THAT WAS INTO THE INTO THE EU

16:55 - POINT OF THE BOARD.

16:59 - FOR 73 YEARS WAS THE

17:01 - SO A BODY.

17:03 - OKAY SO SO BASED ON THAT

17:05 - LANGUAGE IF I UNDERSTAND YOUR

17:07 - POSITION IT'S THAT

17:08 - 156 22. THIS THIS CITY THIS

17:11 - PROJECT WAS ESTABLISHED BY A

17:13 - MUNICIPALITY. IT HAS THE

17:15 - AUTHORITY AND IN FACT DID

17:17 - INCORPORATED BOARD AND SO OKAY

17:20 - SO UNDER THAT AUTHORITY

17:23 - AND I THINK IN CLEARFIELD CASE

17:25 - THE COURT MADE THE DISTINCTION.

17:26 - IT DOESN'T HAVE

17:32 - HASLER

17:33 - OR ENDS AND THE LANGUAGE IN THE

17:36 - 6.22 ANY.

17:38 - CASE TELL US BY RESOLUTION OR

17:40 - ORDINANCE WITH US. INTO COURT

17:43 - SAID. HE

17:45 - INDICATED THAT ONLY A

17:46 - MUNICIPALITY COULD

17:48 - DO THAT. SESSION IS ONLY A

17:51 - MUNICIPALITY CAN PASS AN

17:53 - ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION

17:55 - TO ACQUIRE. THAT'S CLEAR AND

17:59 - IN ADDITION THIS COURT IN ITS

18:02 - PROGENY A

18:03 - CLEAR FIELD EXPRESS WE DECIDED

18:05 - THAT IT DID NOT NEED THE

18:07 - AUTHORITIES CONSOLE.

18:13 - ENJOY THE STATE STILL HAS

18:15 - BECAUSE AT

18:16 - 73 DIDN'T CHANGE. BUT FOR

18:18 - SEVERAL YEARS, HE WOULDN'T BE

18:20 - ALONE. EXCUSE EXCUSE ME, YOU

18:25 - WOULDN'T NEED.

18:27 - YOU CAN SEND

18:29 - 156 BECAUSE THE LANGUAGE IS

18:33 - ALREADY SHELL CONVEY. WE

18:37 - UNDER YOUR ARGUMENT, YOU

18:39 - WOULDN'T NEED CONSENT AND IF

18:40 - IT'S AND THAT IS CORRECT I WAS

18:43 - ONLY TRYING TO POINT OUT

18:45 - >>IN ONE OF YOUR FREE DECISION

18:47 - AND I THINK IT WAS IN THE FALL

18:48 - IT AND FORCE THEM.

18:53 - >>CHALLENGE CIVIL RIGHTS BY

18:54 - SAYING THE AUTHORITY OF THE

18:56 - VICE OF CONSENT JUST

18:58 - A BIT IT COULD GET A SENSE FROM

19:02 - 56 POINTS TO A CLEARLY CLEARLY

19:05 - DO NOT REQUIRE ANY

19:06 - AND WHO THE AUTHORITIES SAY

19:08 - ALONE. THE CITY ALONE HAS

19:10 - ALWAYS HAD THE RIGHT STILL TO

19:12 - THIS DAY. IT'S ONLY IN HIS PAST

19:15 - USE OF POWER. AND HAD THE

19:17 - RIGHT. THE TAKE BACK IN THE CAR

19:19 - AND ALL HAD TO DO WAS TO ONE

19:22 - PASS TO AN END TO PAY THE

19:23 - BILLS.

19:32 - >>WE WILL

19:33 - HEAR NEXT FROM.

19:35 - >>MISTER FRANK.

19:39 - THANK YOU GOOD MORNING,

19:40 - YOUR HONOR. I'M TRYING TO

19:41 - SUPPLEMENT NESTLE DUPLICATE A

19:43 - PERSUASIVE ARGUMENT. MISTER

19:44 - PROTESTING. IN ESSENCE CWA WAS

19:47 - HAPPIER SHOOTERS COLLEGE

19:48 - TOGETHER AN ARGUMENT

19:50 - WHICH IS BELIED BY THE BASIC

19:51 - TENETS OF STATUTORY

19:52 - CONSTRUCTION AND THE SCHOOL

19:54 - AUTHORITIES

19:54 - ACT ITSELF. SO AN UNDISPUTED

19:56 - FACTS AND 3993 9 CITY ALONE

20:00 - INCORPORATED THE CHESTER IN A

20:01 - SCHOOL PARTY AS A RESULT

20:03 - AUTHORITIES UNDER THE N A A IN

20:05 - 1965 THE CITY ALONE

20:07 - AND I COULDN'T ORLEANS CHANGING

20:09 - THE NAME FROM THE SHESHAN IS

20:10 - WITH ALREADY TOO

20:11 - CWA AND IN

20:13 - 1998 THE CITY ALONE WE

20:15 - AUTHORIZE YOU KNOW WE

20:16 - RAISE RESISTANCE. IT'S

20:18 - IMPORTANT FOR THE COURT TO

20:19 - UNDERSTAND THAT CNBC WH POWERS

20:21 - AND AUTHORITY OR SET FORTH AND

20:23 - GOVERNED SOLELY BY THE

20:24 - PROVISIONS OF THE NEW SCHOOL

20:25 - AUTHORITIES ACT IT DOESN'T FALL

20:27 - UNDER THE PURVIEW OF ANY OTHER

20:28 - GOVERNMENTAL OR REGULATORY

20:30 - BODY.

20:31 - THIS WHOLE MATTER STORING YOUR

20:32 - HONOR'S WAS CWA STEAMED I USE

20:35 - THAT WORD PURPOSELY ITS

20:36 - TRANSFER ITS ASSETS TO

20:38 - A TRUST WHICH WILL THEN OPERATE

20:40 - OUTSIDE ENTIRELY THE STRENGTH

20:42 - OF BUT ALSO OUTSIDE THE SCOPE

20:44 - OF ANY REGULATORY BODY AND

20:46 - BEYOND THE REACH OF ANY CITY

20:47 - THAT CREATED AND IMPORTANTLY

20:49 - WHAT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN THERE

20:50 - WERE 3 TRUSTEES

20:52 - AGAIN NOT APPOINTED BY

20:53 - NECESSARILY BY ANY OF THE 3

20:55 - ENTITIES, THE CITY,

20:56 - CHESTER COUNTY OR DOLLAR COUNTY

20:58 - THEN RELEASED

20:59 - IN FACT THE CHESTER WATER

21:01 - AUTHORITY TO GO AHEAD AND

21:02 - CONTINUE OPERATING AS IT HAD

21:04 - ALL ALONG SIMPLY AN EFFORT TO

21:07 - GET AHEAD AND SIMPLY REMOVED

21:09 - THE CITY'S RICE UNDER LET ME

21:12 - JUST FOR A MOMENT. OF COURSE

21:14 - INCREASE IN THIS OCTOBER 27TH

21:16 - ORDER. EARLIER THIS YEAR, THE

21:18 - CITY ISSUE OR THE OR THE TO

21:21 - THE SUBJECTS SYSTEM WHICH

21:22 - RESULTED IN THE CITY RECEIVING

21:23 - 3 THIS. WELL, I'M NOT SURE IT

21:26 - IS FORMALLY OF RECORD IN THIS

21:27 - MATTER, ALTHOUGH IT MAY BE

21:29 - IT WAS DISCLOSED IN THE PUBLIC

21:30 - DOMAIN BY THE CITY ON ITS

21:32 - WEBSITE TO RECEIVE 3 RESPONSES.

21:34 - ONE OF WHICH CLUB WHICH WAS A

21:36 - 410 MILLION DOLLARS.

21:38 - THIS EVIDENCE OF THAT BEING

21:40 - CONSUMMATION OF THE TRANSACTION

21:42 - WOULD ALLOW THE CITY TO

21:43 - ENROLLED IN SHORT ORDER.

21:44 - NOT ONLY PAYS OFF IS EXISTING

21:46 - DEBTS AND

21:47 - THEN SOME THEY CAN ACTUALLY ACT

21:49 - 47 STATUS ALTOGETHER WITH A

21:51 - MUCH BRIGHTER FUTURE

21:52 - GOING FORWARD. IF THE CITY

21:54 - DECIDES THAT WOULD ENTER INTO

21:55 - AN ASSET PURCHASE AGREEMENT

21:56 - WHILE STILL IN ACT 47 STATUS.

21:59 - THE RECEIVER OR THEY SIMPLY

22:00 - NEED TO IMPROVE THE CITY'S

22:01 - DECISION TO GET TO DO SO SO

22:04 - THAT WAS IMPORTANT FOR

22:05 - TO ADDRESS YOUR HONORS I

22:06 - INCREASE IN THE OCTOBER 27 OF

22:08 - THE WATER.

22:09 - DOWN BELOW THE DELAWARE COUNTY

22:11 - COURT OF COMMON PLEAS ON IN HIS

22:14 - 4/24/2020, DECISION.

22:15 - THAT I 73 OF 2012 BASICALLY

22:18 - SEX ESTABLISHED A CITY CHESTER

22:20 - COUNTY AND ORANGE COUNTY AS THE

22:22 - GOVERNING BODY OF CWA

22:25 - AND THAT CONSEQUENTLY ANY

22:26 - CONVEYS CWA PURSUING TO SESSION

22:30 - WE NEED TO BE

22:31 - CONDUCTED AND AUTHORIZED BY

22:33 - THOSE

22:33 - 3 INNINGS SIMPLY STATED YOUR

22:35 - HONOR'S GOVERNOR IS IS NOT AND

22:37 - DOES NOT EQUATE TO OWNERSHIP.

22:40 - THERE ARE 3 SUCCESSIVE SECTIONS

22:42 - IN

22:42 - 5610. THAT ARE DIFFERENT

22:44 - INDEPENDENCE AS A BOARDS OR AS

22:46 - FOR THE FOLLOWING SCENARIO,

22:48 - 5610.

22:49 - ONE IS ALREADY INCORPORATED BY

22:52 - ONE MUNICIPALITY SAYS OUT WHAT

22:53 - HAPPENED HERE IF THE DEALS WITH

22:56 - JOINT AUTHORITIES DON'T GET TO

22:57 - THAT LATER ON MY ARGUMENT, BUT

23:00 - TO DEALS OR JOIN AUTHORITIES

23:01 - EITHER AT THE OUTSET REMOTE

23:03 - MUNICIPALITIES FORMED AND

23:04 - AUTHORITY OR WHERE THERE WAS

23:06 - WARNING THERE'S A VALUE FROM

23:07 - THE AUTHORITY AND THEN OTHER

23:08 - SUBSEQUENTLY JOINT AND THEN OF

23:10 - COURSE WE HAVE 56 10.1

23:14 - WHICH IS WHAT WE'RE DEALING

23:15 - WITH HERE AT 73 TO

23:17 - 5610. SO AGAIN THERE'S NO

23:19 - DISPUTE THERE JUST A SEA OF

23:20 - CHESTER ALONE INCORPORATED CWA

23:22 - AND CONSEQUENTLY HAS

23:23 - ATTENDED RIGHTS. HAS ALLUDED TO

23:27 - BRIEFLY BY MISTER, BUT AS THE

23:28 - COMMISSION IS A PASS

23:31 - IT'S ALREADY DETAINED BACK TO

23:33 - REQUIRE THE ASHES OF THAT

23:34 - AUTHORITY. IT BE A CREATIVE,

23:36 - I'M SATISFIED, CERTAIN

23:37 - CRITERIA. IMPORTANTLY THE

23:40 - 2012 IN MEN

23:41 - TO SEE IF IF THE 6.10 DENY

23:43 - ANY MATTER WHO REFERENCED

23:45 - MENTION THAT DRESS REVIVE OR

23:46 - EVEN A LEAVE ALLUDE TO

23:50 - MISTER FRANK.

23:55 - >>I THINK THE

23:56 - D A.

23:57 - >>AND POLICE POSITIONS THAT THE

23:59 - CITY'S IN PART THE AUTHORITY

24:01 - TO. STATUS IS KIND OF PROJECT

24:04 - THIS KIND OF PROJECT

24:05 - BEING ONE THAT COVERS SERVICES

24:08 - FOR

24:08 - OTHER COUNTIES. SO WHILE

24:12 - 5622 MAY HAVE AUTHORIZED THE

24:14 - CITY TO CREATE THIS PROJECT FOR

24:15 - 18 MISSING HALEIGH IS YOUR

24:18 - POSITION AS I UNDERSTAND.

24:21 - THE CHANGE IN THE. STRUCTURE IN

24:24 - THE SERVICE.

24:26 - STILL QUALIFY AS A

24:27 - TRIBE CHECKED THAT THE CITY WAS

24:30 - AUTHORIZED TO CREATE ANOTHER

24:31 - WHICH COULD CREATE ITS OWN A

24:33 - WATER SYSTEM FOR OTHER

24:34 - COUNTIES.

24:37 - >>USUAL STORY ZACH PERMITS IT

24:38 - TO BLEED OVER IF YOU WILL FROM

24:40 - THE CITY PARAMETERS ITSELF INTO

24:42 - OUTSIDE AREAS.

24:43 - AND WHAT ONE SIMPLY DID YOUR

24:46 - HONOR 8.1 EXCUSE ME. THIS

24:48 - SIMPLY DID WAS GAVE THOSE EXTRA

24:50 - TOUR. EXTRA TERRITORIAL.

24:52 - AREAS GEOGRAPHIC

24:53 - AREAS OR SAY WHILE THEY WORK

24:56 - AND WHILE THE BOARD WAS IN FACT

24:57 - OPERATIONAL IT DID NOT NEARING

24:59 - MATTER IS ACCIDENT THE 6.22 AND

25:02 - THE CITY'S RIGHTS

25:03 - TO GO AHEAD AND PROCESS FIND

25:04 - THOSE 2 CRITERIA MISTER RICH'S

25:06 - DILUTED TO SATISFY EXISTING

25:08 - DEBTS AND PASS THE RESOLUTION

25:09 - OR ORDINANCE TAKING BACK TO

25:11 - YOUR TAKING THAT THE

25:12 - AUTHORITIES ASSETS. IT IS FOR

25:24 - ACTUALLY A

25:24 - BETTER TERM.

25:25 - >>EXPANDED OUTSIDE THE CITY

25:27 - LIMITS. IT REMAINED

25:30 - A PROJECT OF THE SENATE.

25:32 - >>SO ABSOLUTELY UNQUESTIONABLY

25:33 - YOUR HONOR.

25:39 - IN THE

25:39 - ABSENCE OF THE EXPRESS LANGUAGE

25:41 - IN AT 73 A SANCTION THE FORMER

25:44 - CHAIR OF THE CITY'S PROPERTY

25:45 - RIGHTS THERE'S A STATUTORY.

25:47 - THIS TIME, SERIOUS EXTRA

25:48 - CONSTRUCTION PRESUMPTION

25:50 - AGAINST SUCH AN INTERPRETATION

25:51 - BASICALLY CWA IS DOING IS

25:53 - INFLATING THE IMPACT OF ACTS

25:55 - THAT 73. THE PELLYS

25:57 - CONSTRUCTION WOULD NOT GIVE

25:58 - EFFECT TO ALL THE PROVISIONS

26:00 - OF AN ISSUE BUT INSTEAD WHAT IM

26:02 - ASKING LATE. ONE IS

26:06 - AT THE EXPENSE OF THE OTHERS

26:07 - THAT IS JACK 7356 STAFF.

26:10 - IT'S A

26:16 - GOING ON SOMEWHERE THAT

26:18 - FEEDBACK COMING

26:22 - WHAT ABOUT 50 PICKED THOSE 7

26:24 - BEFORE DOESN'T THE AUTHORITY

26:25 - RICK. IT.

26:29 - >>CONVEY THE ACA.

26:32 - YOU BROUGHT THAT UP BECAUSE IT

26:33 - DOES YOUR

26:34 - HONOR BUT IT ONLY DOES SO

26:36 - IT'S A WE GET

26:40 - TO THAT BEFORE MY TIME RIGHT

26:42 - NOW IN 56 THE PRACTICE IS

26:45 - IMPORTANT TO PRACTICE THE 5674

26:48 - BECAUSE BECAUSE EXPRESSLY

26:50 - LIMITS. THE TRANSFER POWERS TO

26:52 - THOSE THAT ARE NECESSARY OR

26:53 - CONVENIENT. RETURN TO.

26:58 - >>BUT THE QUESTION ARE THAT

27:00 - WOULD CERTAINLY HAVE TO BE

27:01 - RESOLVED WHETHER THE TRANSFER.

27:04 - UNDER 50 THINK

27:05 - TO 74

27:07 - WHO ARE THE TYPE OF TRAFFORD

27:08 - AUTHORIZES JUST AS THE CITY

27:11 - BREWERY ACQUISITION. THERE

27:13 - WOULD HAVE TO RESOLVE THAT THE

27:14 - CONDITIONS FOR THE RE

27:15 - ACQUISITION WERE SATISFIED.

27:17 - I'M JUST TRYING TO THE FACTION

27:19 - BELIEVE THAT TOGETHER

27:20 - AND HOW MUCH THEY BE RESOLVED

27:23 - WHEN THE AUTHORITY WANT TO TELL

27:25 - THE AP THAT AT THE

27:26 - SAME TIME. THE CITY WANTS TO

27:28 - ROUTE RETAKE THE AUTHORITY IN

27:30 - THE GULF.

27:31 - >>THE SIXERS 74 WE HAVE TO BE

27:33 - SUBJECT TO

27:34 - 5622. THAT'S THE FUNDAMENTAL

27:36 - PREMISE TIME TO DO BECAUSE JUST

27:38 - LOOK WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE.

27:39 - I THINK YOU CAN LOOK AT AND

27:40 - VACUUM, LET'S LOOK AT IT

27:41 - ACTUALLY WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE

27:43 - WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO GET HIM

27:44 - TO DO IS

27:47 - WE KNOW WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO

27:48 - THINK WE KNOW WHAT THEIR INTENT

27:49 - IS THE QUESTION FOR DOCTOR

27:51 - CONSTRUCTION PERSPECTIVE.

27:53 - >>WHY IS ONE PRIMARY OVER THE

27:55 - OTHER.

27:56 - >>AGAIN I THINK 5622 IS

27:58 - FUNDAMENTAL YOU NEED TO CAN

27:59 - CONDUCT THOSE 2 STEPS

28:01 - THAT WAS NEVER LOSE 2 OR PAY

28:03 - OFF THE DEBTS, YOU BRING IT

28:04 - BACK. THIS IS TALKED ABOUT

28:05 - 56 SITUATIONS,

28:07 - 5674 PRIMARILY TOSS ABOUT WE'RE

28:09 - TALKING ABOUT YEAH TRUCK OR

28:12 - SOMETHING YOU WANT TO CONVEY

28:13 - ACTORS DURING THE NORMAL COURSE

28:14 - OF OPERATIONS 56 OF 74 WAS NOT

28:17 - MEANT TO GO AHEAD AND

28:18 - CIRCUMVENT OTHER PROVISIONS IN

28:20 - 56 IN HIS WILL FOR EXACT WHICH

28:22 - IS EXACTLY WHAT'S TAKING PLACE

28:24 - HERE

28:24 - YOUR HONOR SO GET CASH LEAVING

28:26 - HIS FIRST I THINK IT'S

28:27 - IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND WHAT'S

28:28 - REALLY TAKING PLACE HERE IN

28:38 - >>7 B 4 AND 55TH A DRAFT, YOUR

28:43 - PRINTER CAN FAN SAYS.

28:55 - YES YOUR HONOR I THINK YOU

28:56 - ACTUALLY ACCURATELY STATED

28:58 - THAT.

29:00 - SO IF I CAN JUST FINISH

29:02 - UP TO YES, IT'S VERY GOOD.

29:05 - THANK YOU RON.

29:05 - SO YET AND GET YOUR IS NOT

29:08 - SYNONYMOUS WITH OWNERSHIP

29:09 - ACTION TO 3 MERELY REQUIRE

29:11 - EXTRA TURNS FOR AL GORE TO

29:12 - REPRESENTATION AND ONE SERVICE

29:14 - AN AREA ONE CERTAIN AREA

29:16 - AND IT'S UTTERLY DEVOID OF ANY

29:17 - LANGUAGE CHANGE IN SEES

29:19 - UNILATERAL ACQUISITION

29:20 - RESCINDED IF THE

29:21 - 6.22 AND I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST

29:23 - THE COURT TO SO WAR LET ME JUST

29:25 - BRIEFLY TOUCH

29:25 - OF TIME THE EYE DURING A STORM

29:27 - YOU CAN SEE THE FDA'S POSITION

29:29 - THESE TIER-ONE HIS CONCLUSION

29:31 - THAT IT'S SOMEHOW NOW NESTLE TO

29:32 - JOIN AUTHORITY.

29:33 - THAT FLIES IN THE FACE OF THE

29:34 - EXPRESS LANGUAGE ANY OTHER

29:36 - RELEVANT THROUGH PORTIONS OF

29:37 - THE N A A PUSHING AND THE

29:39 - LEGISLATURE

29:39 - LEFT UNTOUCHED CWA IS NOT NOW

29:42 - NOR HAS IT EVER BEEN USAGE TO

29:45 - NATURE.

29:52 - SERVICE YEARS OUTSIDE OF THE

29:54 - BOUNDARIES, YOU IF

29:56 - YOU'RE WELL.

29:57 - >>YOU'RE WELL OVER YOUR TIME.

29:59 - IF YOU COULD

30:00 - HAMMER I I WE UNDERSTAND YOUR

30:02 - POINT IS THAT THE MATTER DURING

30:04 - AUTHORITIES BUT THERE'S A

30:05 - DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OWNERSHIP

30:07 - AND OPERATION SO IF YOU COULD

30:09 - GO. RIGHT.

30:10 - >>I THINK OFFICIALLY HAS NOW

30:12 - WHEN YOU HAVE YOUR HONOR I

30:13 - APPRECIATE THE EXTRA TIME THAT

30:14 - WAS AFFORDED TO ME AND I IN US

30:17 - OFF ONCE AGAIN. THANK

30:25 - WE WILL HEAR NEXT FROM.

30:33 - WELL, I'M NOT

30:34 - SURE THE ORDER THAT MISTER

30:35 - EMMER OR THAT MISTER CAMP.

30:41 - >>AFTER CAMP.

30:43 - THANK YOU RON.

30:44 - >>IT'S AN OUTSIDER WHO

30:55 - SUNRISE TO A JOB GOING BACK

30:57 - INTO SOME OF YOUR QUESTIONS

30:59 - BECAUSE ANY BETTER

31:00 - FOR YOU. AND I THAT THEY NEED

31:03 - TO BE FOR THE

31:04 - RECORD REST WHO INITIATED THE

31:06 - SECOND HERE

31:07 - THIS IS SO YOU'RE LIKELY TO

31:10 - FEEL ONLY THING I WISH IS FOR

31:15 - VACATION PASS AN EARLY IMPACT

31:18 - HULU'S TO GO FOR DINNER.

31:20 - THERE ARE SEVERAL PASTORS VERY

31:21 - IMPORTANT. WE WILL

31:22 - COME BACK. IT TAKES NOTHING

31:25 - ELSE FROM THE SCENE ONLY

31:27 - ORDINANCE TODAY. IN THIS.

31:31 - THE THINGS THAT MATTER ALMOST

31:34 - CAUGHT FIRE. IN THAT AREA.

31:37 - MY SON. REPEAT

31:39 - THAT AGAIN. IT MEANS THAT

31:45 - IT SAID IN PART BECAUSE A LOT

31:47 - OF

31:48 - THINGS DIFFERENTLY. YOU ABOUT

31:50 - THE CITY'S THINGS OF THAT

31:53 - NATURE THINGS THAT WERE IN

31:54 - PLACE WHEN HE WAS IN THIS CASE.

31:58 - AND RIGHT PRETTY SOON THAT

32:00 - THOSE ARE THOSE ARE IN IT AND

32:02 - WHY WHY THE DOW THIS YEAR

32:04 - TO 4 OTHER ISSUES IN THE

32:06 - INTERPRETATION OF THE AL GORE

32:13 - WHAT CONTROLS YOU.

32:18 - I SEE THE TOURNAMENT.

32:23 - THINKING IT'S A

32:26 - CITY NORTHEAST. 2 INDEPENDENT

32:28 - BASES TO AFFIRM THAT TOO WHO

32:31 - SHOULD AND SHOULDN'T COME FROM,

32:33 - YOU KNOW WHAT ARE SUSPICION ON

32:34 - THE ROAD.

32:36 - THE CITY HERE MEETINGS FOR US

32:38 - SPECIAL SECTION

32:41 - 5622 MAY. ONE OTHER THING IS

32:43 - CELIA WAYS FOR PROJECTS.

32:46 - IT'S YOU KNOW PROJECTS HERE

32:49 - OR NOT SATISFYING OR 2.8 IN

32:52 - THIS TOWN

32:53 - IN THIS IS THESE PROJECTS TO

32:56 - SUSTAIN CURRENT AND FORMER

32:58 - BEING ONE WORKER WHO DID BY

32:59 - FULLY IT IS JUST WORKING ON

33:03 - WORKING ON AND THE CITY OF

33:05 - CHESTER.

33:10 - A FLIGHT SCHOOL TO PROJECT THE

33:12 - CHARACTER WAS TO TELL YOU THE

33:14 - POWER TO ESTABLISH WHO CAN

33:16 - WORK PROPERLY. IN THIS INTENSE

33:19 - SINCE IT IS

33:23 - OF HALEIGH I WAS POWERFUL

33:27 - THERE'S NOTHING IN THESE IN

33:29 - THESE CASES

33:29 - STATUS IS THIS SHOW YOU A

33:32 - PROJECT WHICH IS WELL OUTSIDE

33:34 - THE

33:34 - CITY LIMITS. IT'S SOMETHING

33:35 - THAT THE CITY FINALLY

33:37 - ESTABLISHED TO DO THAT IN FACT.

33:39 - >>BUT MISTER CAN'T WHY DOES IT

33:41 - MATTER TO BE THE PROJECT.

33:45 - IF A SINGULAR PROJECT OF THE

33:46 - CREATION OF A WATER. AND SEWER

33:49 - AUTHORITY.

33:52 - WE'RE READING PROJECT TO

33:55 - WITH.

33:56 - >>AREA OR OR THAT THERE MIGHT

33:58 - BE A SEPARATE PROJECT FOR EVERY

34:00 - SERVICE AREA.

34:04 - >>NO YOUR HONOR IF YOU LOOK AT

34:05 - THE DEFINITION

34:06 - OF PROJECTS IN THE OLD

34:09 - DAYS CITATIONS SECOND IN IT'S A

34:15 - IT IS. IT IS A SPECIFICALLY

34:18 - DEFINED TERM. 2 YEARS.

34:24 - CLUES VARIOUS PHYSICAL

34:26 - THINGS AND OTHER THINGS OF THAT

34:28 - NATURE AND IF YOU HAVE ALSO

34:29 - LOOK AT TAX. SO

34:30 - DEEPLY SELF AND I

34:33 - SEE IS IN THAT SUBSECTION G OF

34:36 - 6610

34:37 - THAT'S FOR SHEDS LIGHT ON THE

34:39 - PROJECT IS BY THE FUNNY THINGS

34:40 - LIKE GOING TO WARM US SPORTS

34:42 - FANS AND OTHER THINGS OF THAT

34:44 - NATURE SO THE CWA

34:46 - ISN'T HE IS NOT SYNONYMOUS.

34:49 - ITS PROJECTS. IT'S FRIDAY, THE

34:51 - CEILING WAYS IS A CORPORATE

34:53 - ENTITIES IN

34:54 - THE STATE AND THE CREATION OF

34:59 - THAT IT'S A IN ORDER

35:03 - THEY INCLUDE THE BATTLE TO SAVE

35:05 - THE TIME EXPANSION OF THE

35:06 - PHYSICAL PLANT ETCETERA SO

35:08 - IF YOU'RE ON A THERE ARE

35:10 - 2 DIFFERENT THINGS IMAGINE WHAT

35:13 - THAT CONNECTION WITH THE

35:14 - DEFINITION IN WE NEED ITSELF.

35:19 - >>MISTER CAN ARE YOU ARE YOU

35:20 - TAKING THE POSITION THAT WHEN

35:21 - THE CITY WHEN IT APPOINTED

35:23 - BOARD MEMBERS CHOSE TO EXPAND

35:26 - SERVICE BEYOND THE CITY

35:27 - BOUNDARIES THAT THE CITY

35:29 - FORFEITED

35:30 - ITS RIGHT TO RECALL THE

35:33 - AUTHORITY AND IS ALL THAT.

35:35 - >>YOU KNOW OUR POSITION

35:36 - YOUR HONOR IS THAT 73%

35:39 - ISSUE, ADDITIONAL TEAMS, THE

35:42 - CWA SOMETHING THAT WAS WHO

35:44 - REALLY WANT TO RISE. FOR A

35:47 - MOTIVE IN

35:47 - MANY JURISDICTIONS A 4 UNIT

35:50 - OPERATING AND WHAT THE

35:51 - OPERATING IN MANY JURISDICTIONS

35:53 - FOR THE ACT WITH A MENTOR ACT

35:54 - THE BETTER THAN ENDED.

35:56 - >>YES, IT WE DO. THAT'S ON

36:00 - THE SCENE. IT

36:03 - >>I AGREE I AGREE BUT THE FEAR

36:04 - THAT WHEN TRYING TO STAND AGAIN

36:05 - IS THAT YOUR POSITION THAT WHEN

36:08 - THE AUTHORITY BOARD WHICH WAS

36:11 - FULLY APPOINTED BY THE CITY OF

36:12 - CHESTER.

36:13 - >>IT SHOWS TO EXPAND ITS

36:14 - SERVICE BEYOND THE CITY.

36:16 - THAT'S GOOD ESPECIALLY

36:18 - GAVE UP ITS PUT AWAY THE STATUE

36:20 - YOU'RE ARGUING THAT BECAUSE THE

36:21 - SERVICES BEYOND THAT WHICH THE

36:23 - CITY IS EMPOWERED TO GIVE AND

36:25 - THAT HE CAN'T TAKE IT BACK AND

36:27 - MY QUESTION IS THEN THE

36:29 - NATIONAL NATURAL WALKER A

36:31 - DEPOSITION IS THAT'S WHY THE

36:34 - BOARD THE AUTHORITY CHOSE TO

36:36 - EXPAND THEIR REACH BEYOND THE

36:37 - BOUNDARY, THE CITY FORFEITED

36:39 - ITS RIGHT THAT A PROJECT BACK.

36:42 - >>I AGREE

36:44 - FIRMS WELL I BY PASS IS A NICE

36:47 - AND FREE.

36:48 - WISH THAT

36:50 - WAY IN BUT BY MAKING UNITY

36:53 - IN UNITY. AWARD WINNING BY

36:57 - MULTIPLE ENTITIES AND CHANGE

36:59 - THE APPLICATION FOR THE 6

37:01 - SCHOOLS IS A SPACE 2 IN A STORY

37:04 - LIKE THIS

37:05 - EITHER WAY IT'S THE 55TH THERE

37:08 - WAS NO CHANGE THE 55TH 22 WANT

37:09 - TO PLAY.

37:10 - >>I'M NOT SAYING THAT THERE WAS

37:11 - A CHANGE TO 56 LEAD TO THE

37:13 - CASE. WHAT I'M SAYING IS THE

37:15 - APPLICATION AND I APOLOGIZE

37:17 - WAS UNCLEAR. WHAT I'M SAYING IS

37:19 - THE APPLICATION OF THE I

37:22 - ACTUALLY TURN.

37:24 - APPLY TO

37:25 - THE CWA AS A RESULT OF THE

37:28 - CHANGES IN A SECOND. I

37:30 - ASKED 73 IN SECTION 56 AND THEY

37:33 - WANT.

37:34 - 4 YEARS LATER THAT ALSO DOESN'T

37:36 - MATTER BECAUSE THE MINUTE THE

37:37 - CITY'S APPOINTED BOARD.

37:39 - >>IT SHOWS TO EXPAND SERVICE

37:41 - BEYOND THE CITY. THIS DAY THE

37:43 - POINT IS BORED FOR BID FOR

37:45 - THE CITY THE RIGHT TO GO BACK

37:47 - TO WORK.

37:50 - >>I DON'T KNOW WHETHER I

37:51 - CAN SAY.

37:54 - IN NOW AT THE TIME OR WHAT HE'S

37:56 - SAYING NOW IT WAS RISING AS

38:00 - IT WAS POORLY OFF

38:01 - THE ROSE. WHY THE MOVIE IS YOUR

38:04 - STATION ABOARD.

38:05 - IT WAS AS A RESULT OF THOSE

38:07 - CHANGES SECOND BY

38:08 - SECOND GRADE IN TERMS OF 56 1,

38:12 - 2, A. LONGER.

38:16 - >>SO YOU'RE SAYING THAT EX 73

38:24 - WHAT WAS ORIGINALLY SECTION 18

38:26 - AND NOW A 5622.

38:32 - >>I'M 6.56,

38:39 - CHASE FIRST OF ALL IT'S IN

38:45 - LESS IMPORTANT.

38:50 - I SURE UNDERSTAND YOUR

38:52 - QUESTION. WHAT I'M SAYING IS

38:56 - THAT. I

38:58 - SUDDENLY 3 NICE TO SEE YOU KNOW

39:03 - HOUSE WAS NOT ABLE TO BUY

39:06 - THINGS DOWN AND THEREFORE 56.11

39:09 - JUST DOES NOT APPLY TO CURRENT

39:11 - LET ME BE CLEAR ABOUT SOMETHING

39:12 - NEW COMING BACK TO YOUR HONEST

39:14 - QUESTIONS. IF WE LEAVE

39:16 - IT THERE. THE COUNCIL FOR.

39:19 - ME WE

39:20 - ARE NOT.

39:21 - >>THE CW IS DURING SCHOOL FOR

39:23 - ANY WAS ARE ASKING THIS COURT.

39:27 - IT'S LIKE IT'S

39:28 - LEANING TOWARDS. SO THE CASE IS

39:30 - THEY WANT TO SEE BECAUSE THAT

39:31 - WAS THE CASE FOR THEY WERE

39:32 - ASKING FOR IT SAYS

39:33 - THE COURT. IT WAS SWEPT THE

39:36 - CITY WE'RE DOING FOR FOR

39:38 - BASICALLY ASKING TO USE

39:41 - THIS COURT TO KANSAS ACTION FOR

39:42 - EASING FOR PATIENTS WHO

39:44 - HER PROBATION AND YOU DON'T GET

39:46 - TO FLY 56 TO 2 MAIN ONES ON ITS

39:49 - FACE.

39:53 - >>I'M STILL HAVING

39:54 - TROUBLE WITH YOUR 5610.

39:57 - ARGUMENT IF ANYTHING APPLY NOW

39:59 - UNDER 5610 E.

40:05 - YOU LET US DECIDE 5622,

40:07 - LANGUAGE. IF THERE'S ANYTHING

40:09 - ELSE TO IMPLY THAT

40:11 - WHAT WHAT LIES UNDER A SOURCE

40:15 - FUNDING BODY.

40:17 - >>AND HE SAYS TO ME IS YOU KNOW

40:19 - IN ORDER TO EVEN BUY 3 TIMES.

40:22 - >>NOW THAT'S NOT THE

40:23 - QUESTION GO. THE QUESTION I

40:25 - HAVE IS WHAT 156 10.

40:28 - SLICE IF YOUR ARGUMENT

40:31 - BECAUSE THAT'S WHERE STATUTORY

40:32 - LANGUAGE IS A 5610 1 IN 2.

40:37 - IS IT TOO. WHAT DO

40:39 - YOU USE.

40:44 - >>SEEMS THE NATURE OF THIS YOU

40:45 - KNOW THE WAY.

40:50 - STATION WILL.

40:52 - >>AUTHORITY WHO LEAGUE OR POINT

40:54 - OF VIE IT WAS A POOL.

40:56 - >>JURISDICTIONS OK AND ASKED

40:58 - THE BOARD.

41:00 - IT CONSTITUTES STATE AUTHORITY

41:08 - WHAT'S NOT THAT DOESN'T ANSWER

41:09 - THE QUESTION. I SEE IT'S

41:12 - ALREADY TO DISSOLVE.

41:18 - >>IF YOU APPLY IN TERMS OF 56

41:21 - THE EXERCISE BUY MORE OF WHO

41:24 - CAN BUY A MEANS OF VALLEY WE

41:26 - WANT TO SHOW OFF THE PROJECT HE

41:29 - SAYS 22.

41:31 - IT'S WILLING TO PAY HER EX.

41:38 - APPLY CENT. IT ALSO

41:40 - DOES NOT BECAUSE THIS COURT IS

41:42 - NOT ON BOARD WHEN YOU BUY

41:43 - A PROBLEM AND WHEN SECTION

41:46 - INCLUDING THE CASES CITED BY

41:48 - HOMES. EAST LINE ONE.

41:52 - IT WAS A CLEAR FIELD ONE WHITE

41:55 - WOMAN WHO WORK IN THIS HOUSE

41:57 - WHICH IS NOW TOO FAST. INSIDE

42:01 - AND OUT.

42:02 - >>IT'S MORE OF YOUR SIDE IS IT

42:04 - THE 5622 A AND

42:07 - WATERWORKS WATER SUPPLY ALL

42:09 - WORKS POINT DISTRIBUTION

42:10 - SYSTEM SWITCHES. THE DEFINITION

42:12 - UNDER 56 '07

42:14 - A 10. JUST BECAUSE YOU MIX IT

42:17 - DOESN'T CHANGE THE NATURE IT'S

42:21 - WORSE A HOUSE FIRE NEVER

42:25 - DOING HERE.

42:27 - >>IS THE PROJECT'S WELL MAKE UP

42:29 - A MORE SYSTEM THIS YEAR.

42:31 - >>OK SO HOW HAS THE PROJECT

42:34 - THAT WAS ESTABLISHED THE

42:35 - LANGUAGE AND OR 5622 MAY IN

42:38 - OTHER WORDS CAN WE KNOW WHAT

42:40 - CAN WE STOP LOAN

42:41 - THAT LANGUAGE. THE PROJECT IS

42:43 - ESTABLISHING IS CHAPTER WAS

42:45 - COURT APPOINTED BY A

42:46 - MUNICIPALITY WHICH WAS THE

42:47 - SCENE. WELL THEY'VE DONE NOW IS

42:50 - EXPANDS UNDERSTAND

42:52 - THE SEA. A FOUR-STORY A PROJECT

42:55 - THAT THE PRICE.

43:01 - >>I RESPECTFULLY I TAKE ISSUE

43:03 - WITH THAT IS THAT THE CHANGES

43:05 - BECAUSE.

43:08 - AS YOU LOOK AT 56 WINS IN THIS

43:10 - STREAK GOING FORWARD IN PRESENT

43:13 - TENSE.

43:17 - IT IS ONLY

43:18 - A CHARACTER. WE'LL SEE HAS THE

43:20 - POWER

43:21 - TO ESTABLISH. YOU SICK IT

43:24 - DOESN'T MUNICIPALITY, I THINK

43:26 - THERE ARE 2 YEARS.

43:27 - >>AUTHORITIES CREATED BY

43:28 - MUNICIPALITIES LIKE ORDER TO

43:30 - HALT TO GO IN.

43:35 - MISSISSIPPIANS.

43:42 - >>I'M NOT SURE ABOUT THEM

43:43 - AND LEARN SO REALLY I THINK

43:46 - THAT HAS TO GO.

43:49 - IF THEY DO HAVE THE AUTHORITY

43:51 - TO PROVIDE WATER.

43:55 - TILL

43:55 - 6, 2, PENALTIES BY THE GREEN

43:58 - AND YOU KNOW AS YOU CAN GET

44:00 - WATER WILL GIVE YOU MORE WATER.

44:03 - IT'S 6 FOLD TO SCHOOLS I COULD

44:05 - STILL WORKS PROJECT JUST 6

44:08 - FEET.

44:14 - >>THIS IS A SPECIFIC MULTI-YEAR

44:15 - STATION FIRE THAT SITS IN THE

44:18 - DEFINITION OF.

44:21 - 56 ANYONE IN THE CITY PROVIDED

44:24 - TO LETTERS AND STATION.

44:27 - WHO WILL GO INTO THE STORE

44:29 - OPERATOR PRIVATE AND FRANKLY

44:31 - YOUR HONOR TO BE TIMELESS TO TO

44:35 - BUT.

44:37 - HIS IDENTITY 6, 1, 2, A 4

44:39 - MINUTE WE'VE GOT AN INITIAL

44:41 - PERSPECTIVE IN

44:41 - 24 HOURS. SO YOU KNOW A CITY

44:45 - LIKE THE CITY OF

44:48 - BOARD AND IT'S SOMETHING PUT

44:50 - INTO THE OPERATIONS OF THAT

44:52 - PROJECT. WHAT IS THE REST OF

44:54 - THE BOARD'S DECISION MEANS THEY

44:55 - CAN SOMEHOW THE PALACE JUST SAY

44:57 - I MEAN I THINK YOU'RE REFERRING

44:59 - TO 5610 ACES EXACTLY WHAT I'M

45:01 - SAYING.

45:02 - >>YOU CAN HAVE A WATER SOURCE

45:04 - STORY WAS INCORPORATED BY ONE

45:06 - USED TO THAT'S THE CITY HERE.

45:08 - THEY CAN FLY WATER SERVICE

45:10 - SEARCHERS TO RESIDENTS IN IT

45:12 - COMES TO PENALTIES AND WE TALK

45:14 - ABOUT THE COMPOSITION OF

45:15 - THE BOARD.

45:27 - COURT

45:27 - KIND BY

45:39 - >>AND THAT MEETING WAS

45:43 - TO THE HIGH COURT. THEY ARE WE

45:45 - WE BOARD MEMBERS OUT 9.

45:47 - IF WE WERE NUMBERS BY THE CITY

45:49 - OF CHESTER TO YOU BY DELAWARE

45:51 - COUNTY IN 3 BY JUST A FEW.

45:56 - AND AGAIN THAT'S WHY I SAY IT'S

45:57 - IT'S IT'S CRITICAL TO LOOK AT

45:59 - THE PRESENT TENSE LINE WHICH IS

46:02 - TERMS OF ITS APPLICATION WILL

46:04 - AFTER ALL. THE

46:05 - ONLY WAY IN FACT THAT WAS HOW

46:08 - WE WOULD AND SIMILAR

46:10 - WHEREAS PRIOR VERSIONS OF THE

46:12 - REALLY MISSING OR IN COURT.

46:14 - IT'S BEEN

46:15 - TAKEN OUT IT'S A DEFINITION WE

46:17 - WAYS OF THE CLINTON WHO FITS

46:19 - WITHIN

46:20 - 5623 FLEET WORKS IF I COULD

46:22 - JUST COME BACK ON SHORT 1 ONE

46:25 - SO I WANT TO SUMMARIZE A COUPLE

46:27 - WHOSE SON WAS LESS A 56 '07.

46:33 - IT IN TERMS OF RECONCILING

46:35 - THOSE 2. A SUPREME COURT CASE,

46:38 - LET'S

46:40 - THE ADDRESS IS THAT WORSE

46:41 - DURING THE SPELLING SAYS

46:42 - BECAUSE OF THE 6, 1, 2, A

46:44 - AUTHORITIES DO NOT

46:46 - TRANSFERRED FRIDAY AND THE

46:48 - SUPREME COURT SAID YES INTENT

46:49 - ON THE 66 OF 78 AND I THINK

46:53 - THAT ISSUE IS ONE OF THE TRIAL

46:55 - LASTED LESS THAN

46:56 - 4 YEARS. AND I SAY IT'S UNCLEAR

46:58 - IT'S A NEW SCHOOL WITH ISSUES

47:01 - LIKE THE CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES

47:02 - RAISED SOME OF THE

47:03 - ENVIRONMENTAL

47:03 - A SON. IT'S A LARGER ISSUE HERE

47:06 - WITH

47:06 - THE STRENGTH OF ON THE MOTION

47:10 - FOR JUDGMENT ON WHO IS ABOUT

47:12 - THE

47:12 - WHOLE CASE. IT'S FOR THE WHOLE

47:16 - SAY. WELL SHOULD WE LOSE IS

47:19 - THAT I

47:20 - I MENTIONED INSIDE WE CAN

47:22 - BECAUSE THERE ARE SEVERAL

47:23 - ISSUES AND SO WE'RE FINE TRIAL

47:25 - COURT RULING THAT 56 AND SAID

47:27 - THE ISSUE WAS

47:29 - IS IT IS STILL ON THE BACK

47:31 - SALUTING FOR E ISSUE THAT

47:35 - THIS COURT. ME FOR OR BUT WHEN

47:39 - THE 2 DAYS TO THAT.

47:44 - EXCUSE.

47:45 - >>SO IF WE IGNORE 56 1, 2,

47:51 - AROUND

47:51 - 6 5622 A YEAR ANY PREVIOUS

47:57 - SAY TO COULEE INTENDED TO GIVE

48:01 - MUNICIPALITY COOL AUTHORITY TO

48:04 - ACQUIRE PROJECT.

48:13 - BUT TO SANTA.

48:22 - IN LINE IN

48:26 - SO WHY DO YOU INTERPRET THIS TO

48:28 - BE CONSISTENT. SO LONG AS

48:30 - THERE'S LOT DAY ATTEMPTS BY THE

48:32 - CITY TO TELL.

48:34 - CHIEF THE 6, 2, 2, 8,

48:38 - THE AUTHORITY CAN DISPOSE OF

48:40 - THE

48:42 - ITS CONTRACT FOR SOMEONE ELSE

48:48 - >>I AGREE TO RECEIVE HIS MEDIA

48:50 - ALREADY HAS HAS THE POWER.

48:53 - 56 7. IF YOU DO WHAT YOU WANT

48:56 - TO DISPOSE OF THE OTHER

48:58 - PROJECTS, HE HAS A

48:59 - NEW LAW AND THAT GOES TO THE

49:02 - POINT I WAS JUST MAKING

49:05 - >>IT'S EASY ON SITE.

49:06 - IF YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THAT AND YOU

49:09 - KNOW IT'S THAT THE LEGISLATURE

49:11 - IN CLEARLY INTENDED

49:13 - 5622 TO PROVIDE THIS ALREADY TO

49:16 - THE INCORPORATING IN THIS UP

49:17 - ALI TO SQUARE PROJECT

49:20 - ASKING US NOW TO IGNORE THAT

49:21 - CLEARLY JUST AND THEN SERVE

49:25 - RESULT. NO NO WE ARE I'LL

49:27 - ADDRESS THAT.

49:28 - WELL ACTUALLY.

49:29 - >>WE ARE ASKING YOU WHY 50

49:38 - ONLY APPLIES TO

49:41 - SOUTH THAT'S NOT TO SUPPORTED

49:43 - BY FOR IT.

49:45 - AND SECONDLY THERE HAS TO

49:47 - BE PRESENT WHEN THE CHARACTER

49:49 - THAT THE MUNICIPALITY HAS THE

49:51 - POWER TO BE SEEN. ESTABLISHMENT

49:54 - RIGHT.

49:56 - YOU KNOW

49:57 - PROJECTS OR MOVEMENT OF THAT

49:59 - CHARACTER THE MOVIE

50:00 - JURISDICTIONAL

50:01 - IN NATURE AND I ALSO LOVED I'M

50:04 - SORRY BUT I HAVE TO ASK YOU

50:05 - THIS HOW DO YOU GET AROUND 5610

50:07 - A POINT TO AND SAY THAT.

50:14 - >>AROUND FOCUSES.

50:16 - IS THIS

50:17 - A STORM.

50:20 - IT SAYS TO ANYONE WHAT THAT

50:22 - SOLUTION TO USE THE CWA.

50:27 - >>BY SERVICE IS SUBJECT TO 5620

50:30 - TO IT.

50:32 - ENJOY THIS IS A THIS IS FROM

50:39 - THE CEO STAN HOOLEY IS NOT A

50:44 - IT'S IT'S NOT A TENSE WAITING

50:47 - LIKE THAT. IT'S A 56 POINT TO

50:49 - WHERE AND WHEN WE FIND SIR IT'S

50:51 - JUST DOES NOT FLY. WE SEE THIS

50:53 - EXTEND A WARM BEFORE.

50:56 - THAT'S AND THAT'S A SERIOUS I

50:57 - THINK I CAN CLEAR.

51:07 - JUST A TWO-POINT SIT WITH THE

51:08 - COURTS AND GOLD IS VERY

51:10 - QUICKLY. THERE WAS REFERENCE TO

51:12 - THE CLEARFIELD LINE OF CASES

51:14 - AND ALSO THE SOUND YOU KNOW

51:15 - CHUCK E SO HERE'S YOUR PHYSICAL

51:17 - PLACE. SO YOU

51:19 - FLY BUT THE COMMENTS STATES

51:23 - WANT AMENDMENTS WELL IN

51:26 - 2001 THAN THIS.

51:30 - BEFORE HE SAYS IT IS NOT

51:32 - ADDRESSING WAS THAT SHE WAS

51:35 - NOT. YOU.

51:43 - LIVING WITH ONE OF

51:44 - THE BOARD AND THE REASON

51:46 - FOR CASE. I THINK WE'RE GOING

51:47 - TO LEAVE HIS WHOLE NO CITY IN

51:50 - 4 FIELD SAYS. IT SAYS THAT FOR

51:52 - ME TO DO THAT THROUGH THE 40'S

51:55 - 50'S 6 ONE TO PAY. IS

51:58 - THE BOARD

51:59 - OF WHO SHOULD GO FORWARD NOT

52:01 - THE CITY I DON'T THINK THOSE

52:02 - 40'S TO GET THEIR LIVES.

52:06 - IN TERMS OF

52:06 - 56 1, 2, A BUT IF HE POUNDS AND

52:10 - IS GOING TO HAVE TO ADDRESS

52:11 - THAT ISSUE IN THE PARK IS ALSO

52:13 - A KEY SITE IN BIRTHDAY TOO.

52:16 - TOWNSHIP DECISION THAT I

52:17 - MENTIONED THAT IS IN SOME OF

52:19 - THE 4 GROUPS.

52:24 - QUESTION SORRY.

52:28 - >>ALL RIGHT WE WILL HEAR NEXT

52:30 - FROM MISTER EMMERICH.

52:32 - >>GOOD MORNING, YOU'RE OTHERS

52:33 - MAY PLEASE THE COURT AS HIS

52:35 - FRIEND CAMERA AND WE HAVE THE

52:36 - COUNTY CHESTER. IT JUST HURTS

52:39 - TO BREATHE PRACTICAL ALSO LIKE

52:41 - TO RAISE IF THE COURT IS THE

52:43 - CENTER. THESE ISSUES.

52:46 - BY

52:47 - THE CITY IN AUCKLAND USE A 5622

52:50 - ISN'T IT IS

52:51 - 5 5610 POINT. WHEN THEY NEVER

52:54 - EXPLAINED TO THE TRIAL COURT

52:56 - AND HAVE NOT EXPLAINED IN THE

52:57 - BRIEFING HERE AND HOW YOU CAN

52:59 - JUSTIFY THE LEGISLATIVE INTENT.

53:02 - 56

53:04 - ONE. IT DOES SEEM TO ME.

53:08 - ALREADY INTERESTS. LESS THAN

53:11 - 20% IN INTEREST IN THIS WITH

53:13 - OUR PIECE ON RATEPAYERS AND

53:15 - THEN IF YOU INCLUDED

53:17 - CONSIDERATION ALL. THE POLLING

53:19 - STATIONS WHERE THE WATER IS

53:20 - COMING FROM REACHING FROM ALL

53:22 - THAT ALL THOSE EXTRA THAT

53:24 - JURISDICTIONAL TO THE. TURNED

53:27 - TORY THE CITY OF CHESTER.

53:30 - IF THE 6 1 GIVES

53:32 - AN EQUAL

53:34 - GOVERNING RESPONSIBILITY ON THE

53:36 - BOARD ONE 3RD ONE 3RD ONE 3RD

53:38 - TO THE BOARD MISTER EMMERICH

53:40 - MISTER IT MAY BE THE

53:41 - LEGISLATIVE INTENT WAS THEY

53:42 - FORGOT ABOUT THE 22 AT.

53:47 - >>IT'S JUST PROCESS THAT IS

53:48 - PERHAPS THE MAY SHUN FOR HIM

53:52 - TO QUIT. I

53:54 - I THINK SO BECAUSE WHEN YOU

53:55 - ALSO CONSIDER WAY IS TEACHING

53:58 - SEE IS THAT. THERE IS ALSO

54:01 - A CHANGE

54:04 - 173.

54:05 - ANY CHANGES TO

54:08 - WANT AND SOMETHING I THINK IS

54:10 - IN POOR SUGGEST A LEGISLATIVE

54:13 - ALMOST ALL TO ITALY WHERE THE

54:14 - CITY AND WE'RE TRYING TO

54:16 - TAKE THIS. IT IS GOING TO GO

54:19 - THROUGH THE PROVISIONS OF DNA

54:21 - AND IT IS CLEAR THAT.

54:24 - THE ASSET IS IT IS THE RED

54:27 - HANDS ASSET. OKAY

54:29 - WITH THAT YOU LOOK AT YOUR OWN

54:30 - PROVISION THAT THEY SAY 5622 SO

54:33 - THEY RELY ON, YOU KNOW SOME

54:35 - SECTION D IT TALKS ABOUT

54:37 - RESERVE IS IT WAS A TALK A

54:39 - LITTLE RESERVED SAYS DAN.

54:41 - ANY MONEY AND THE AUTHORITY

54:42 - FOLLOWING THE TRANSFER

54:44 - THE PROJECT MOSTLY ME WITH SOME

54:46 - PROJECTS FOR THE PURPOSES OF

54:48 - OPERATING THE PROJECT

54:50 - AND THEN WE'VE BEEN TALKING

54:51 - ABOUT TODAY ABOUT 56 '07.

54:53 - AND YOU LOOK AT 39. AND ANY

54:56 - TRANSFER THERE AND AGAIN THE

54:58 - LEGISLATIVE INTENT IS CLEAR

55:00 - INSTEAD

55:01 - HIM, THE ASSETS HAVE TO FLOW

55:03 - DOWN TO PLANNING COMMISSION NOT

55:05 - THE SPENDING AND LAST ON BEHALF

55:07 - OF THE ENTIRE SERVICE YEAR.

55:10 - AND THEN YOU GET TO WEAR.

55:11 - IT'S THE CITY, YOU KNOW I WANT

55:13 - TO SAY WELL LEGISLATOR AND

55:15 - NO 10. NO FOCUS ON

55:19 - 5622 AND ALL THE CHANGE THE

55:21 - GOVERNING BOARD BUT BUT AGAIN

55:24 - 5612 ANYONE. ALSO REITERATE ITS

55:28 - PART OF THAT 73 REINTERPRETS

55:30 - THE FOCUS BUT THE MONEY THAT HE

55:32 - MAY NOT BE USED FOR

55:34 - ANY PURPOSE. I KNOW YOU'RE

55:36 - ACTUALLY REALLY TO MISSION AND

55:37 - PURPOSE AND YOU ARE.

55:39 - SO THE WOULD NOT

55:41 - BE EXPLAINED. HOW HE CAN AGAIN

55:45 - BE A

55:45 - MINORITY INTEREST. OKAY, ONE

55:47 - 3RD OF OUR PRESENTATION ON THE

55:49 - CUTTING BOARD. OK

55:51 - AND YET A

55:52 - UNILATERAL ABILITY TO SELL

55:55 - DISPOSE

55:55 - THE ASSET. THIS IS THE WORST

55:57 - THING YOU KNOW I USED TO TALK

55:59 - ABOUT TAKING THE BALL AND GOING

56:00 - HOME. THEY'RE TAKING THE GAME.

56:02 - IT MEAN FOR EVER.

56:04 - HOME WITH THEIR MOST ANIMALS IS

56:06 - ARTICULATED BY BUT COUNCIL FOR

56:08 - IRAQ WAS A 400 PLUS MILLION

56:10 - DOLLARS DEAN IN FOR IF THEY

56:13 - WANT TO TAKE HOLD.

56:15 - 956 22.

56:17 - SO PURPOSES OF OPERATING

56:18 - MAINTAINING AND IMPROVING HIS

56:20 - STANDING WITH PROJECT. NOT FOR

56:22 - 56 '07 D FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE

56:25 - ENTIRE

56:25 - SERVICE AREA. I'M THEY HAVE

56:28 - COULDN'T THEY HAVE ALWAYS DONE

56:30 - THAT I MEAN IF IF THE

56:32 - THE AUTHORITY.

56:33 - >>THE AUTHORITY HAD A CANDID

56:34 - SERVICE OUTSIDE OF THE CITY A

56:36 - CHAPTER PRIOR TO THE PASSAGE OF

56:38 - ACT 78.

56:39 - THEY ALREADY HAD ASKED THAT

56:40 - OUTSIDE OF THE CITY OF CHESTER

56:41 - PRIOR

56:42 - TO THAT. NOW IT YOUR POSITION

56:44 - THAT THE MINUTE THEY STARTED

56:45 - PROVIDING SERVICE TO RATEPAYERS

56:47 - OUTSIDE OF THE CITY OF CHAPTER

56:49 - THEY FORFEITED THEIR RIGHT

56:50 - UNDER 50 PICK 22.

56:53 - >>IF YOU DON'T THINK WE HAVE TO

56:54 - GO WITH THAT AND WITH IT

56:56 - THE CHASE. WHAT IS HAPPENING

56:57 - THE THE YOU KNOW IT'S A

56:59 - LEGISLATOR HAS

57:00 - COME IN. HERE IN THE

57:04 - LEGISLATURE DIDN'T COME AND I'M

57:05 - TRYING TO UNDERSTAND BECAUSE OF

57:07 - BEING THE FOCUS.

57:08 - >>OF YOUR MISTER CAN'T ARGUMENT

57:09 - IS WELL THEY'RE NOT PROVIDING

57:11 - SERVICE TO THE CITY OF CHESTER

57:12 - THERE'S MANY MANY

57:13 - MORE PEOPLE INVOLVED HERE AND

57:15 - THERE'S MANY MORE FACILITIES

57:17 - INVOLVED HERE OUTSIDE THE CITY

57:18 - OF CHESTER

57:18 - AND THAT THAT THE LEGISLATIVE

57:20 - INTENT AND THAT'S WHY THE EVENT

57:21 - WHEN THE BOARD WELCOME BACK WHY

57:24 - EVERYTHING HAPPENING

57:25 - NEXT 78. THEN THEN I I GO BACK

57:28 - TO MY QUESTION DOES THAT MEAN

57:30 - THAT LOOK WITH HIM BACK 78

57:31 - DIDN'T HAPPEN IN THE CITY FILED

57:34 - THAT PETITION TO TAKE BACK.

57:36 - THE AUTHORITY WHAT WOULD YOUR

57:37 - ARGUMENT BE AGAINST IT.

57:39 - >>WELL THAT POINT YOUR HONOR AS

57:41 - YOU GO BACK TO 5622, OTHERS

57:43 - KNOW 5610 A ONE.

57:45 - AND YOU HAVE TO WALK THROUGH OR

57:47 - ARE THEY A MUNICIPALITY WAS THE

57:49 - PRICE POINT IF I THAT GOVERNING

57:51 - BOARD HE'S HEALTHY CAN THEY

57:53 - MAINTAIN ESTABLISH AN OPERATING

57:55 - AND IF A CLIENT IN

57:58 - SITUATION UP WHERE WE ARE AT

58:00 - THAT TIME THE ABSENCE OF 5610.

58:03 - HE WOULD WALK THROUGH 56.2 8 BY

58:06 - YOUR HONOR THAT WOULD THAT

58:08 - STATUTORY PROVISION IN THERE TO

58:10 - WALK OUT

58:11 - IF YOU'RE

58:14 - ME.

58:15 - >>THE PROVISION OF SERVICE

58:16 - OUTSIDE OF THE AUTHORITY DID

58:18 - NOT FORFEIT THEIR RIGHT TO TAKE

58:20 - BACK 150 PICK 22 OF THEM IN

58:22 - THEY CAN BUY THE CRITERIA THAT

58:24 - COULD EXPLAIN TO YOU.

58:25 - >>I THINK YOUR HONOR BECOMES

58:27 - DIFFICULT FOR THEM TO SATISFY

58:29 - THE CRITERIA. 5622

58:32 - BECAUSE THERE'S A WHOLE

58:34 - DIFFERENT PROCEDURE WELL IT'S

58:37 - ALREADY OPERATING OUTSIDE OF

58:38 - THE STORIES THAT SHOW LIVES.

58:40 - SO THERE'LL BE A WHOLE OTHER

58:41 - LAYER THAT THAT I BELIEVE IN

58:43 - THAT INSTANCE IF HIS TEAM UP

58:45 - 10 YEARS AGO. OKAY THAT BACK

58:48 - TO YOU CITY WENT UP AND GO ON

58:51 - AND GO THROUGH

58:52 - OKAY SHOW THAT IT CAN OPERATE

58:54 - OUTSIDE THE CITY THAT'S A WHOLE

58:56 - DIFFERENT STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

58:57 - TO TO BE FROM ISSUE

58:59 - TO DO IT OUTSIDE SO I THINK YOU

59:01 - HAVE TO FIND OUT. LOOK AT

59:03 - 5622.

59:05 - YOU KNOW I I SUGGEST WHY NOT

59:08 - OUR ALLIES DON'T WANT TO

59:09 - MISLEAD THE

59:09 - COURT ON ONE YES, BUT BUT I

59:11 - BELIEVE IF YOU WALK THROUGH IT

59:13 - IS IT WOULD BE A ROADBLOCK.

59:16 - BY THE TEA TRYING TO DISPOSE OF

59:17 - THE ASSETS IN THE ABSENCE OF

59:19 - 5610. ANYONE.

59:22 - 156 22 BECAUSE IT WON'T BE ABLE

59:24 - TO ESTABLISH OPERATE AND

59:25 - MAINTAIN AND IT'S ALREADY THAT

59:27 - EXCEEDED ITS OWN CITY LIMITS

59:30 - WITHOUT DOING MORE WHICH HAS

59:32 - NOT DONE AND OVER THE COURSE OF

59:34 - THESE YEARS.

59:35 - >>DOES MISTER EMMERICH'S ANYONE

59:36 - HAVE THE AUTHORITY THEN UNDER

59:39 - 56.2 IN NEW YORK ARE DUE TO

59:41 - TAKE A LOOK AT THE PROJECT.

59:44 - DUKE WHERE THE PROJECT.

59:46 - >>IT NEEDS TO BE THE COUNTY'S

59:48 - POSITION IS THAT THE TRIAL

59:50 - COURT AND HE'S ACTUALLY RAIN ON

59:52 - ME. DECISIONS ON THE MOTION FOR

59:55 - JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS IS

59:56 - THAT IT BECOMES UNDER 5610 1 IN

59:59 - 350 DECISION IN EQUAL THE SOLUTION.

01:00 - 03.730 THE CITY IN

01:00 - 07.539 COUNTY IN DELAWARE COUNTY 3

01:00 - 09.089 MEMBERS. BUT THE GOVERNING

01:00 - 12.639 WORK. THE THE

01:00 - 15.190 GIRL POWER TO MAKE DECISIONS.

01:00 - 17.250 >>UNDER

01:00 - 19.609 THIS STATUTE. OF

01:00 - 21.499 GOVERNING BODY ALSO ALWAYS HAVE

01:00 - 22.989 THE STORY ALWAYS HAD THE POWER

01:00 - 24.499 TO MAKE DECISIONS BUT IT WAS

01:00 - 27.039 ALWAYS SUBJECT. TO THE POWER

01:00 - 29.949 AND THE 5622. IF YOU CAN LEAD

01:00 - 30.950 A.

01:00 - 34.299 ACQUISITION BY THE NEWS

01:00 - 35.300 CALENDAR.

01:00 - 37.429 SO WHO HAS A STORY NOW NOT

01:00 - 38.799 TALKING ABOUT THE STORY OF THE

01:00 - 40.719 BOARD WHO HAS THE AUTHORITY TO

01:00 - 41.780 CALL PROJECT.

01:00 - 45.380 >>THE SEASON IS MADE

01:00 - 47.319 YOUR HONOR. IT IS THE COUNTY'S

01:00 - 48.599 POSITION IS THE DECISION IS

01:00 - 49.669 MADE BY THE GOVERNING BOARD

01:00 - 50.670 OF CWA.

01:00 - 53.029 >>IF THE TRIPARTITE I CAN JUST

01:00 - 55.479 ASKING YOU 156 22 GIVES

01:00 - 58.109 YOU THAT IN JUST 5622 IS A

01:00 - 59.409 PROVISION THAT SAYS CONVENES

01:00 - 01.769 BY AUTHORITIES. JULES KELLY

01:01 - 02.889 SAYS SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN

01:01 - 04.270 ESTABLISHED PROJECTS.

01:01 - 07.099 SO YOU HAVE TO GO IN THE 56

01:01 - 09.159 TOLD TO DOPING TO FIND THAT

01:01 - 10.160 AUTHORITY.

01:01 - 12.749 >>NO AND EARLY 86 '07 AND THEN

01:01 - 14.350 AGAIN THE AUTHORITY HAS THE

01:01 - 18.669 THE ABILITY TO GETTING ARGUING

01:01 - 20.949 CERTAINLY CIRCLES BECAUSE THEY

01:01 - 21.370 ALWAYS HAVE

01:01 - 22.930 SO OKAY.

01:01 - 26.620 YOUR PILE.

01:01 - 28.419 >>AND YOU ARE WELL OVER YOUR

01:01 - 29.789 TIME SO IF YOU COULD PLAY OR

01:01 - 30.790 SUMMER.

01:01 - 34.729 >>SURE YOUR JUST 21 LAST

01:01 - 37.179 POINT IS IF YOU HAVE A RACE TO

01:01 - 38.649 THE COURTHOUSE HERE AND IT'S

01:01 - 39.640 BEEN BROUGHT UP SOMETHING

01:01 - 42.870 QUESTIONING. PREVIOUSLY IS THAT

01:01 - 44.989 HE'S YOU A FALL THAT

01:01 - 47.589 RESTITUTION. EXERCISED ITS

01:01 - 49.590 AUTHORITY UNDER 56 '07

01:01 - 51.889 THAT WAS DONE BY UNANIMOUS

01:01 - 53.559 DECISION OF THE GOVERNING BOARD

01:01 - 55.359 BOTH ALL THE REPRESENTATIVES

01:01 - 56.749 SAY THE REPRESENTATIVES OF

01:01 - 58.089 CHESTER COUNTY. A

01:01 - 59.519 REPRESENTATIVE WHO SERVED OUR

01:01 - 02.219 COUNTY MADE THAT DECISION TO GO

01:02 - 05.569 FORWARD WITH THAT. FACT THE

01:02 - 07.729 SOLUTION AND THAT IS REALLY

01:02 - 08.839 WHAT NEEDS TO DO TO BE

01:02 - 11.669 RESOLVED. AND THE TRIAL

01:02 - 13.679 COURT LEVEL WITH

01:02 - 15.889 THIS SO WITH THAT AGAIN WE

01:02 - 17.389 ASKED THE COURT ON BEHALF OF

01:02 - 17.830 THE COUNTY

01:02 - 20.329 AND CHESTER TO FROM THE

01:02 - 21.769 DECISION MADE BY THE TRIAL

01:02 - 24.559 WHO ARE IN ANY DECISIONS ON THE

01:02 - 25.150 JUDGMENT ON

01:02 - 27.489 THE PLEADINGS I'M HAPPY THE

01:02 - 29.129 MATTER GO BACK FOR A FINAL

01:02 - 31.039 DECISION ON THE REMAINING

01:02 - 32.740 ISSUES. THANK YOU FOR THE TIME.

01:02 - 37.759 >>ALL RIGHT MATT GOOD

01:02 - 39.779 MORNING EUROPE AND REMEMBER

01:02 - 40.100 DON'T YOU

01:02 - 41.479 REMEMBER HIM IF YOU'RE IN THE

01:02 - 42.689 PRO BONO FOR THE INTERVENING

01:02 - 43.779 YEARS WHERE RESIDENTS OF

01:02 - 45.599 DELAWARE COUNTY CHESTER COUNTY

01:02 - 46.090 AND THE CITY

01:02 - 47.869 OF CHESTER AS WELL AS YOU GIVE

01:02 - 49.539 YOU A RING MAYORS NAMED

01:02 - 51.159 BENEFICIARIES OF THE TRUST

01:02 - 53.689 CREATED BY ARTICLE ONE IN 27

01:02 - 53.770 THE

01:02 - 55.230 PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION.

01:02 - 57.279 A GENTLEMAN'S GRANTED THE

01:02 - 58.479 INTERVIEW THERE'S A LIMIT THEIR

01:02 - 59.649 ACTIONS IN THE NATURE OF THE

01:02 - 01.139 YEAR AND DISMISSED THE

01:03 - 02.319 COMPLAINT WHICH HAVE BEEN FILED

01:03 - 04.019 BY THE CITY. WHEN YOU MADE

01:03 - 04.310 UNDER THE

01:03 - 07.039 EXPRESS LANGUAGE SECTION 5, 6,

01:03 - 07.650 TO 2 OF

01:03 - 11.079 THE NBA AND ACTS 73 CITY COULD

01:03 - 12.829 NOT UNILATERALLY DISSOLVE THE

01:03 - 16.230 CWA IT IS RESPECTFULLY REQUEST

01:03 - 17.459 IF THIS COURT AFFIRMED

01:03 - 19.409 THAT RULING AND WE RELY UPON

01:03 - 21.359 THE POOR THING THEY'RE FREE TO

01:03 - 22.620 SUPPORT THAT REQUEST.

01:03 - 25.480 IN SEPTEMBER

01:03 - 27.929 27 QUARTER AND WHAT IF ANY

01:03 - 29.509 IMPACT THE CITY OF CHESTER TO

01:03 - 31.709 SEE THE SHIP MAY HAVE ON THE CW

01:03 - 34.379 A SALE BASSETT INNOVATORS WOULD

01:03 - 36.609 ARGUE THAT THERE'S NO IMPACT IF

01:03 - 36.880 THERE'S

01:03 - 39.439 NO ABILITY. IT BEAT THE CITY

01:03 - 41.139 THE RECEIVER WITH THE GOVERNOR

01:03 - 42.690 HIMSELF PUBLICLY ON.

01:03 - 45.819 RESOURCES SUCH IS THE OCTOBER

01:03 - 47.540 REGISTERED MORE ITS SURROUNDING

01:03 - 50.540 PRIVATE ENTITY.

01:03 - 53.429 CLOSE BY ONE SECTION 27

01:03 - 54.499 ESTABLISHED PUBLIC

01:03 - 56.619 TRUST DOCTRINE WITH RESPECT TO

01:03 - 58.239 PUBLICLY FROM THAT FULL

01:03 - 00.279 RESOURCES AND DOES IT NEEDS TO

01:04 - 01.820 COMMONWEALTH IS A TRUSTEE.

01:04 - 03.490 NOT THE PROPRIETOR

01:04 - 06.429 A DISASTER. BENEFICIARIES OF

01:04 - 08.239 ACTRESS FOR THE PEOPLE OF THIS

01:04 - 10.789 STATE INCLUDING GENERATIONS YET

01:04 - 11.790 TO COME.

01:04 - 13.569 THE PROPOSAL THE RECEIVER

01:04 - 14.969 HIMSELF PUBLICLY IN

01:04 - 16.979 NATURAL RESOURCES IN THE

01:04 - 18.899 SHAREHOLDERS OF AWFUL WOULD BE

01:04 - 20.319 AN OUTRAGEOUS VIOLATION OF THE

01:04 - 22.439 COMMONWEALTH DUTY TO CONSERVE

01:04 - 23.899 AND MAINTAIN THOSE PUBLIC

01:04 - 26.319 ASSETS WHICH BELONG TO ALL THE

01:04 - 28.039 PEOPLE AND WOULD CONSTITUTE A

01:04 - 29.639 BREACH OF THE SOCIAL CONTRACT

01:04 - 30.879 BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT AND THE

01:04 - 32.770 CITIZENS CREATED BY ONE

01:04 - 34.829 AND WOULD ALSO CONSTITUTE AN

01:04 - 37.359 UNCONSTITUTIONAL TAKING PASSAGE

01:04 - 40.039 CREATED BY THE COURT I THE

01:04 - 42.119 CITIZENS OF DELAWARE COUNTY AND

01:04 - 43.120 CHESTER.

01:04 - 45.799 BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE CWA

01:04 - 47.149 INCLUDING THE 3 MEN WERE

01:04 - 48.309 SUPPORTED BY THE CITY OF

01:04 - 50.099 CHESTER RECOGNIZE THESE

01:04 - 51.580 CONSTITUTIONAL ME EMPTY.

01:04 - 52.740 WHEN YOU

01:04 - 55.629 UNANIMOUSLY REJECTED. HIS OFFER

01:04 - 57.329 TO PURCHASE THE SEEDING GAMES

01:04 - 59.509 AND SAYS AND MOVED WITH THOSE

01:04 - 01.619 ASSETS INTO A TRUST UNDER THE

01:05 - 03.050 SUPERVISION OF PEOPLE PLEASE.

01:05 - 07.019 MY 2 MINUTES HAVING EXPIRED IF

01:05 - 08.610 THE COURT HAS NO QUESTIONS.

01:05 - 10.499 I THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY

01:05 - 12.040 TO ADDRESS THIS MORNING.

01:05 - 17.900 >>ALL RIGHT

01:05 - 22.930 FROM TIME.

01:05 - 24.479 >>YES, I DID THANK YOU VERY

01:05 - 24.660 MUCH

01:05 - 26.059 BECAUSE I IT'S BEEN VERY

01:05 - 27.219 PATIENT WITH US AND I

01:05 - 29.049 APPRECIATE THE FACT SO GIVE ME

01:05 - 30.050 MY WHOLE TIME.

01:05 - 33.839 IT POINTS TO MAKE. MISTER

01:05 - 34.850 PINSKY REMAIN.

01:05 - 38.289 WE CAN HEAR YOU HE HAD A GOOD

01:05 - 39.290 PERSON PLEASE.

01:05 - 40.900 >>TURN BACK ON THE CAMERA.

01:05 - 42.840 WE LOST YOUR VIDEO.

01:05 - 46.619 >>AND I'M HAPPY TO GO ALONG

01:05 - 47.860 WITHOUT THE VIDEO BEFORE

01:05 - 48.340 02:00PM.

01:05 - 50.130 >>IT IS ARE YOU OKAY WITH THAT.

01:05 - 55.580 JUST A FEW QUICK POINTS.

01:05 - 57.800 ONE. THE ISSUE OF APPLE.

01:05 - 59.070 THE SERVICE

01:06 - 02.249 AND RATEPAYERS OF THE FACILITY

01:06 - 04.699 BEING BEYOND. THE BORDERS OF

01:06 - 06.989 THE CITY OF CHESTER. THAT WAS

01:06 - 09.930 TRUE BEFORE BEFORE AT 73.

01:06 - 11.300 AND IT TO BE

01:06 - 13.369 THAT'S BEEN TRUE FOR YEARS WHO

01:06 - 14.589 HAS SAID THIS WEEKEND THAT

01:06 - 16.879 BEING AND THAT WAS COOL WHEN

01:06 - 18.670 THE CITY WAS HE.

01:06 - 20.979 SO LOW POINT OF THE BOARD OF

01:06 - 22.869 THE AUTHORITY. SO THERE'S NO

01:06 - 24.959 REASON WHY. THE CITY CAN'T

01:06 - 27.090 RETAIN THE AUTHORITY TO CREATE

01:06 - 29.469 1939. WHEN

01:06 - 31.649 IT WAS IT WAS OPERATING

01:06 - 33.469 HIS AUTHORITY THE RATE PAYERS

01:06 - 34.899 AND SILLY YOU ON THE BOARD

01:06 - 36.139 SINCE IT WAS DOING IS A LITTLE

01:06 - 39.319 MORE A SECOND. I DON'T THINK WE

01:06 - 41.489 CAN MINIMAL. THIS THAT'S MY

01:06 - 42.729 RESPECTFUL SUBMISSION TO THE

01:06 - 45.049 COURT THAT UNDER UNDER THE

01:06 - 46.829 SUPREME COURT. THE RISE IN THE

01:06 - 47.830 FINAL DECISION.

01:06 - 50.049 WHAT IS COURT THE SIDE AND THE

01:06 - 52.239 SECTION 18 IT BECAME

01:06 - 55.080 LEGISLATIVE INTENT. WHEN

01:06 - 59.349 5622 DAY WAS ENACTED IN 2001

01:06 - 01.039 THIS COURT'S DECISION AND

01:07 - 02.489 LEGISLATIVE INTENT. THE MOST

01:07 - 05.459 IMPORTANT BECAUSE PRESIDENT

01:07 - 07.939 JUST LET IT GO. THERE IS

01:07 - 11.210 NOTHING IN. IN FACT SOME LIVES.

01:07 - 12.430 WHICH

01:07 - 15.219 MIGHT FALL. IT IS THAT

01:07 - 16.819 THE COUNTY CHESTER COUNTY HAS

01:07 - 18.060 ADMITTED THAT IT ISN'T GREAT.

01:07 - 21.169 AND THEN SO THE ONLY WAY THEY

01:07 - 23.070 CAN ACTUALLY GET FOR THE SHIA

01:07 - 26.439 THE CITY'S RIGHTS AND THIS

01:07 - 26.570 IS

01:07 - 29.759 BY IMPLICATION AND THAT THEY

01:07 - 31.829 CAN DO NUMEROUS DECISION TO

01:07 - 33.779 SIDE AND UNDER THIS PRESSURE

01:07 - 35.919 THE STOCK. AND THEN AND

01:07 - 38.800 FINALLY. IT THIS

01:07 - 43.839 BEEN CLEAR THAT WAS ALWAYS

01:07 - 45.939 TALKING ABOUT THE AUTHORITY AS

01:07 - 48.880 IT WAS QUITE A BIT. A REGIONAL.

01:07 - 51.830 THE MUNICIPALITY.

01:07 - 53.979 THAT'S WHEN IT WAS ALWAYS THE

01:07 - 55.359 SIDING AND A CLEAR THOSE

01:07 - 56.670 FRIGHTENING THAT

01:07 - 59.039 THAT LANGUAGE ABOUT THE PROJECT

01:07 - 01.079 ESTABLISHED BY HIS PAL. THAT'S

01:08 - 01.820 ALWAYS BEEN THE LINE

01:08 - 05.059 UNDER SECTION 18 IT WAS ALWAYS

01:08 - 07.829 BAD, IT WOULD BE A FAR. IT WAS

01:08 - 09.050 ORIGINALLY CREATED.

01:08 - 13.249 SO THAT THEIR ATTEMPT TO CHANGE

01:08 - 15.419 THAT. FLIES IN THE FACE OF

01:08 - 17.549 THE COURTS. AND I MEAN THAT I

01:08 - 20.869 THINK THE COURT. THANK YOU VERY

01:08 - 21.870 MUCH.

01:08 - 24.730 CLOSED CAR. AN ARGUMENT.

01:08 - 27.740 >>AND OUR FIRST CASE NUMBER

01:08 - 31.199 2520, I THINK ALL

01:08 - 33.169 THE PARTY, A VERY IMPORTANT

01:08 - 34.910 CASE VERY INTERESTING ONE.

01:08 - 40.010 WELL WELL I COMMEND YOU.

01:08 - 44.290 >>THANK

01:09 - 18.489 >>ALL RIGHT THE NEXT CASE

01:09 - 20.079 NUMBER 27. IT

01:09 - 22.259 IS TRUE BYRD FOR 50 ON

01:09 - 24.019 EMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION BOARD

01:09 - 25.020 OF REVIEW.

01:09 - 28.349 CHALLENGES 3 ORDER BUT THE

01:09 - 30.379 UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION ORDER

01:09 - 34.030 REVIEW. IN JULY OF 2017.

01:09 - 37.039 THE YOU SEE SERVICE CENTER AND

01:09 - 39.829 3 KNOW THE IT FOR A BAITING BUT

01:09 - 40.560 YOU WOULD NOT

01:09 - 42.129 TITLE TO THE UNEMPLOYMENT

01:09 - 44.260 COMPENSATION SHE HAD COLLECTED

01:09 - 46.020 5 YEARS EARLIER

01:09 - 48.979 AND THOUGHT THE COMMONWEALTH

01:09 - 49.980 OVER

01:09 - 52.979 $7,000. NO THIS IS FATED THAT

01:09 - 55.139 MEANT FOR HAS 15 DAYS TO

01:09 - 57.939 APPEAL. THE NOTICES WERE SENT

01:09 - 58.690 TO AN ADDRESS

01:09 - 00.149 FROM WHERE THE CLAIMANT HAVE

01:10 - 03.289 MOVED IN 2015. AND

01:10 - 05.750 SHE MOVED THE GAME AND 2016

01:10 - 08.139 ACCORDINGLY SHE DID NOT RECEIVE

01:10 - 10.009 THE DETERMINATION AND DID NOT

01:10 - 11.010 APPEAL.

01:10 - 14.169 AND 2019 YOU'RE CONTACTED BY A

01:10 - 16.329 DEBT COLLECTION AGENCY THAT

01:10 - 18.559 THE COMMONWEALTH HAD A LEAN AIR

01:10 - 19.560 WITH HER KILLING

01:10 - 22.119 FOR THE REPAYMENT OF

01:10 - 23.859 UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS. SHE

01:10 - 26.690 RECEIVED IMPROPERLY AND 2012.

01:10 - 30.499 A 3RD TWENTY-NINETEEN MEDFORD

01:10 - 32.499 APPEAL. SHE HAD HEARD THAT SHE

01:10 - 34.489 HAD NEITHER APPLY FOR

01:10 - 36.669 NOR RECEIVED UNEMPLOYMENT

01:10 - 38.689 COMPENSATION BENEFITS AND QUITE

01:10 - 41.209 WELL, THERE WAS NOTHING FOR HER

01:10 - 43.459 TO RETURN. HE FURTHER OF HER

01:10 - 45.719 DID SHE DID NOT KNOW WHO YOU

01:10 - 47.410 ARE IDENTITY TO FILE THE

01:10 - 50.569 2012 CLIMB. BOARD DISMISSED HER

01:10 - 51.410 APPEAL HAD

01:10 - 54.029 BEEN TIMELY BEFORE THE COURT

01:10 - 56.929 MEDFORD ARGUE THAT SHE TITLE DO

01:10 - 57.680 NOT PRO

01:10 - 00.479 TRUMP REALLY. SHE ARGUES THAT

01:11 - 02.109 SHE HAD NO REASON TO BELIEVE

01:11 - 04.339 SHE HAD TO TAKE HER DRAFT WITH

01:11 - 07.069 THE DEPARTMENT A YEAR AFTER SHE

01:11 - 09.519 HAD REAPED THE BENEFIT. SHE

01:11 - 11.250 FURTHER ARGUE THAT THEM.

01:11 - 13.959 DEPARTMENT 5 YEARS DELAY AND

01:11 - 16.260 LOOKING INTO BENEFIT. PAID IN

01:11 - 19.009 2012 CONSTITUTED AND I'M IN

01:11 - 21.310 A GREAT BREAKDOWN THAT ALLOWED.

01:11 - 23.970 TO APPEAL KNOW PRO COME.

01:11 - 26.419 THE DEPARTMENT COUNTER THAT

01:11 - 28.590 THERE IS NO STATUTORY DEADLINE

01:11 - 29.919 FOR THE DEPARTMENT TO

01:11 - 32.559 REVISIT IT. THE TERMINATIONS ON

01:11 - 34.069 UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION

01:11 - 37.109 BENEFITS AND THEN THE HARM AND

01:11 - 39.370 ONE OF MEDFORD OWN MAKING

01:11 - 40.660 THAT SHE

01:11 - 42.979 COULD HAVE AVOIDED SIMPLY BY

01:11 - 44.639 KEEPING THE DEPARTMENT OF

01:11 - 47.110 PRIME. HER CURRENT ADDRESS.

01:11 - 51.589 HOW HER BOTH I KNOW THE RULES

01:11 - 53.729 OF THE ROAD FOR A MONK ARGUMENT

01:11 - 55.320 TO REACH HAVE PICKED A MENTOR.

01:11 - 58.790 THE A RICHER TIME MET.

01:11 - 01.509 IF I'M MICHELLE DO YOU WISH OR

01:12 - 02.510 OF HER TIME.

01:12 - 04.899 >>YES, YOUR HONOR RESERVED 2

01:12 - 07.559 MINUTES FOR A VOTE. YOU HAVE IT

01:12 - 08.560 AND YOU MAY BEGIN.

01:12 - 11.910 GOOD MORNING AND MAY IT

01:12 - 13.249 PLEASE THE COURT MY NAME IS

01:12 - 14.999 JULIUS I'M IN THE SHOWER THERE

01:12 - 17.169 REPRESENT PETITIONER MISS FROM

01:12 - 18.949 HER. HE'S

01:12 - 20.529 A FAIRNESS AND ACCESS TO

01:12 - 21.530 JUSTICE.

01:12 - 23.189 IT'S WHAT THE BOARD INTERVIEW

01:12 - 24.629 TONIGHT MY CLIENT WHEN HE

01:12 - 26.189 DISMISSED HER APPEAL AND ON

01:12 - 28.369 TIME. DESPITE THE FACT THE

01:12 - 30.050 DETERMINATION OF OVER PAYMENT

01:12 - 31.459 WITH ME NOW OVER

01:12 - 33.459 5 YEARS AFTER THE MINE AND

01:12 - 33.870 IMPLEMENT

01:12 - 36.460 CLEAN ENDED AND VERY DELIBERATE

01:12 - 39.060 YOU KNOW AS BE OVERCOME.

01:12 - 41.310 DURING THAT I MEAN YOU'RE DOING

01:12 - 43.320 MISS NOT MONTHS.

01:12 - 45.359 BUT WHY, AND ALTHOUGH SHE AND

01:12 - 46.959 SENATE WHO ARE READING IT WAS

01:12 - 48.070 NO LONGER IN EFFECT

01:12 - 50.779 IN 2017 WITH THE DETERMINATIONS

01:12 - 53.309 FINALLY ISSUE. TODAY TO

01:12 - 54.549 SNEER AT AFTER THE GREAT TO THE

01:12 - 59.149 COURT PRO TEM REALLY. EITHER

01:12 - 59.860 BASED ON THE FACTS

01:13 - 02.479 THAT WE JUST ARE NOT NEGLIGENT

01:13 - 04.490 CONDUCT WENT TO THE LEADER HEAL

01:13 - 06.999 OR THAT'S THE 5 YOU'RE DOING

01:13 - 08.179 ANY BY THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

01:13 - 10.259 AND INDUSTRY TO UNION STREET

01:13 - 12.589 A BREAKDOWN TO DRESS NOT

01:13 - 13.939 NEGLIGENT CONDUCT AND

01:13 - 15.599 THEN MINISTRY TO BREAK DOWN AND

01:13 - 17.169 THEN TOUCH ON THE BALL THAT

01:13 - 19.119 DOES NOT BELIEVE FROM THE BLACK

01:13 - 20.650 KEYS PLEASE IN THIS MATTER.

01:13 - 24.210 QUESTION OF WHETHER

01:13 - 27.289 YEAH YOU KNOW WAS LEE UNITED

01:13 - 28.980 WITH THE CONDUCT AND THE BACK

01:13 - 29.750 ON THE RECORD

01:13 - 31.999 ARE YOU. NEW BIRD WAS NOT

01:13 - 33.399 LIVING AT THE ASTOR STREET

01:13 - 35.089 ADDRESS WHEN THE DETERMINATION

01:13 - 38.019 GRIT ISSUED IN 2017. SHE DID

01:13 - 40.039 NOT RECEIVE. YEAH, THE BLUE

01:13 - 41.750 ROOM MY HOME WAS IN TIME.

01:13 - 43.510 ON THE MAILBOX

01:13 - 45.479 I ARGUE THAT NAME HAS NOT

01:13 - 46.539 OVERCOME THE PRESUMPTION

01:13 - 48.239 OF PERSONALLY ACTUALLY YOUR

01:13 - 50.469 HONOR GOING SO FAR AS TO SAY ON

01:13 - 52.349 PAGE 8 OF THEIR GRIEF. THE

01:13 - 53.599 CLAIMANTS RECEIVE OF THE

01:13 - 56.010 DETERMINATION IS HE REAL.

01:13 - 58.840 HOWEVER THE RECORD BELIE THAT.

01:13 - 01.749 THE NO BOX RULE IS A COURT HELD

01:14 - 03.430 IN HOME. IS

01:14 - 06.419 ONLY THEY ARE TOO I TO ALLOW

01:14 - 07.959 THE COURTS TO REVIEW NOTICE

01:14 - 10.279 WAS RECEIVED BUT THEN AS A

01:14 - 11.929 PROCEDURAL TOOL, THE BURDEN

01:14 - 13.739 SHIFTS TO THE AD RECEIVED THE

01:14 - 15.529 PRESUMPTION YOU WRONG. AND THE

01:14 - 17.159 MALE WAS NOT RECEIVE AND THAT'S

01:14 - 19.449 EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED NOT ONLY

01:14 - 20.730 DID PETITIONER CREW

01:14 - 23.529 THAT SHE HAD MOVED IN 2015 FROM

01:14 - 23.970 ASHTON

01:14 - 26.039 STREET ADDRESS BUT WITHOUT ANY

01:14 - 28.569 DOUBT IN 2017 WAS ACTIVE

01:14 - 29.610 THROUGH THE STREET ADDRESS

01:14 - 31.239 BASED ON THE TESTIMONY

01:14 - 33.319 UNCORROBORATED SHUN. I MEAN

01:14 - 36.380 POOR IN THIS RIGHT.

01:14 - 38.979 >>WHAT DID THE BOARD FINE WITH

01:14 - 41.180 PERFECT TOO. THAT POINT.

01:14 - 43.670 >>THE

01:14 - 46.179 AND THEN HE'S ON TO THE

01:14 - 47.180 FINDINGS OF FACT.

01:14 - 49.229 THE REFEREE DURING A SEPARATE

01:14 - 50.750 CRIME, THE FACT IN THIS CASE.

01:14 - 54.410 AND THOUGH IN MY BACK NUMBER 8.

01:14 - 56.999 IT WAS STATED THAT THE CLAIMANT

01:14 - 58.169 HAS BEEN RESIDING AT HER

01:14 - 00.799 ADDRESS OF RECORD SINCE 2016,

01:15 - 01.920 WHICH IS THE REALLY STRANGE.

01:15 - 08.469 >>ACTUALLY BUT SHE WAS NOT

01:15 - 10.870 LIVING AT THE ADDRESS. IF YOU.

01:15 - 13.919 AND WE KNOW THIS IS A

01:15 - 14.920 DETERMINATION.

01:15 - 19.860 FOR MICHELLE DO YOU

01:15 - 22.539 RECOGNIZE ANY LEGAL PRINCIPLE

01:15 - 24.850 OR ANY ANY PRINT FORGET

01:15 - 28.729 FOR A PERIOD OF TIME THAT A

01:15 - 29.550 PERSON WHO

01:15 - 31.519 HAS RECEIVED UNEMPLOYMENT

01:15 - 33.860 COMPENSATION BENEFITS REQUIRED

01:15 - 37.719 PER DAY. AGENCY OF ANY CHANGES

01:15 - 38.450 TO THE DRAFT IS

01:15 - 40.479 THERE SOME IS THERE ANY PERIOD

01:15 - 42.399 OF TIME AFTER REPEATED BENEFIT

01:15 - 43.829 THAT YOU BELIEVE THAT THAT

01:15 - 45.030 SHOULD BE A RULE.

01:15 - 48.899 >>IS THAT THERE IS NO

01:15 - 50.709 BASIS IN THE UNEMPLOYMENT

01:15 - 52.159 COMPENSATION MOM, WE'RE

01:15 - 53.729 REGULATIONS ENACTED BY THE

01:15 - 55.629 DEPARTMENT WILL BOARD THAT SAID

01:15 - 56.960 WE'RE GOING TO SORT OF STANDARD

01:15 - 59.469 IN TERMS OF WHEN SOMEBODY MUST

01:15 - 00.599 UPDATE THEIR ADDRESS WITH

01:16 - 02.839 THE DEPARTMENT AND THERE IS NO

01:16 - 04.519 NOTICE EVER GIVEN TO CLAIMANTS

01:16 - 05.700 THAT THERE'S ANY REQUIREMENT

01:16 - 07.609 FOR THEM TO BE THEIR ADDRESS

01:16 - 08.980 FOR A SPECIFIC PERIOD OF TIME.

01:16 - 10.709 I KNOW YOU'RE

01:16 - 12.819 UNDER THAT WE ARE GOING

01:16 - 15.079 TO DISCUSS AND TODAY THE ISSUE

01:16 - 17.349 OF THE NEW KING CAKE. AND HE

01:16 - 19.629 COULD OPEN ENDED. I MEAN

01:16 - 21.189 THAT IT THAT CLAIMANT MUST

01:16 - 23.739 UPDATE THEIR ADDRESS AGAIN I

01:16 - 24.969 THINK THAT'S NOT SUPPORTED BY

01:16 - 28.119 LAW AND IF THERE IS A QUESTION

01:16 - 30.249 OF NEEDING MORE IN THIS

01:16 - 32.049 MATTER AND IF THAT'S NOT

01:16 - 33.709 NECESSARILY THE CASE GIVEN THAT

01:16 - 34.090 WE EAT

01:16 - 34.990 ARE LOOKING AT

01:16 - 36.109 UNEMPLOYMENT CLAIMS IN THERE

01:16 - 37.119 ALL THE TIME WE HAVE AN

01:16 - 38.519 INDIVIDUAL BASIS AND NOT

01:16 - 40.009 RECOVERY LEAVE IS AN EQUITABLE

01:16 - 41.789 NOT TRUE THAT TO CONSIDER THE

01:16 - 42.950 FACTS OF EACH PIECE.

01:16 - 44.830 I DON'T BELIEVE IT WOULD BE

01:16 - 46.429 REASONABLE TO REQUIRE THAT A

01:16 - 47.430 CLAIMANT.

01:16 - 51.129 I THINK YOUR ONGOING GROUP HERE

01:16 - 52.529 AT THE TIME WITH NO CONTACT

01:16 - 54.029 WITH THE DEPARTMENT IF YOU WANT

01:16 - 55.030 TO HAVE IT.

01:16 - 57.299 DOES YOUR MUTT AND JEFF THAT WE

01:16 - 58.839 LOOK AT THE QUESTION OF IF THE

01:16 - 59.300 CLEAN

01:16 - 01.189 YOUR OPEN MEANING THAT THERE IS

01:17 - 03.069 STILL A RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN

01:17 - 04.629 THE CLAIMANT BEHIND THE

01:17 - 06.210 DEPARTMENT OF LABOR INDUSTRY.

01:17 - 08.879 OR THE QUESTION OF WHETHER WE

01:17 - 10.909 HAVE A PERMANENTLY NEED CONTACT

01:17 - 12.919 WITH THE DEPARTMENT. SINCE THAT

01:17 - 14.200 CLEAN YOUR HEAD.

01:17 - 18.539 AND I'D LIKE TO

01:17 - 20.650 BRIEFLY ADDRESS I DO OKAY.

01:17 - 23.069 A LITTLE BIT MORE DEEPLY SINCE

01:17 - 24.829 THAT WAS GREAT. I MEAN

01:17 - 26.849 CONTENTION BY AND THE BOARD OF

01:17 - 28.729 REVIEW AS TO WHY WE MUST

01:17 - 31.059 CONDUCT IN THIS MATTER WAS WAS

01:17 - 32.979 NEGLIGENT. NOW DO YOU THINK IS

01:17 - 34.630 FAIR ACTUALLY DISTINGUISHABLE

01:17 - 37.419 FROM THAT HE SAID ARE I'M NOT

01:17 - 40.409 MAD. THE CLAIMANT RAISE HAS

01:17 - 42.359 HEARD AND THE BACK OF

01:17 - 45.419 THE DEPARTMENT. DETERMINATION

01:17 - 47.219 TO THE WRONG ADDRESS, AND IT'S

01:17 - 48.500 NOT GOING TO HEAR

01:17 - 50.569 INTO THE CLINIC WASN'T LIVING

01:17 - 51.889 AT THE ADDRESS. IT DID NOT

01:17 - 53.290 RECEIVE THE DETERMINATION.

01:17 - 55.190 A SECOND AND MORE IMPORTANTLY

01:17 - 55.580 AND

01:17 - 58.309 NOT HER. THE CLAIMANT FALLS

01:17 - 00.399 WITHIN THE RULE THAT I PROPOSE

01:18 - 01.619 THAT SHE MADE A PERMANENT

01:18 - 03.120 CONTACT WITH THE DEPARTMENT.

01:18 - 04.909 I BELIEVE IT WAS 2 YEARS AFTER

01:18 - 06.899 HER PLANE HAD ENDED AND AT THAT

01:18 - 09.069 TIME HE ALREADY MOVED IN THE

01:18 - 10.429 FINDINGS OF FACT BEFORE THE

01:18 - 12.480 COURT AND HAD NOT.

01:18 - 15.029 AND I'M NOT HAPPY TO CURRENT

01:18 - 16.030 DRAFT AT THAT TIME.

01:18 - 21.880 IN

01:18 - 24.289 2019. WHEN SHE LEARNED THERE

01:18 - 25.719 WAS AN OVERPAYMENT BASED ON A

01:18 - 27.720 LEAN. SHE UPDATED HER ADDRESS.

01:18 - 29.690 SHE BEGAN HER PHONE NUMBER.

01:18 - 31.780 SHE TOOK THOSE CORRECTIVE STEPS

01:18 - 34.969 AND SO I KNEW THIS CASE IS VERY

01:18 - 37.219 DIFFERENT FROM YOU. I'D ALSO

01:18 - 38.670 NOTE THAT IN WALKER.

01:18 - 41.069 RECENTLY MET COMPENSATION WHERE

01:18 - 41.150 THE

01:18 - 43.099 GROUP YOU. THIS WORK REVEALS A

01:18 - 44.969 LOOK AT AN ISSUE WE'RE A CLEAN

01:18 - 46.209 DID NOT RECEIVE THE NOTICE

01:18 - 48.279 BECAUSE IN THE MORNING HE PUT

01:18 - 49.050 AND PLEASE DO

01:18 - 51.309 NOT WORK. NOT PEACE AGREEMENT

01:18 - 52.719 HAVE NOT BEEN ADDRESSED WITH

01:18 - 54.289 THE DEPARTMENT AND THERE WAS A

01:18 - 55.609 RECOGNITION THERE THAT THAT WAS

01:18 - 56.949 NOT AN ISSUE THERE IS NO PER SE

01:18 - 57.630 NEGLIGENT FOR

01:18 - 59.579 FAILING TO. I THINK YOU ARE

01:18 - 00.969 DRESSED WITH THE DEPARTMENT,

01:19 - 02.179 ESPECIALLY WHEN STEPS HAVE BEEN

01:19 - 04.109 TAKEN KNOW WHO ALREADY WHICH

01:19 - 05.309 AGAIN THAT THE CLAIMANT

01:19 - 06.879 DIDN'T HE AND IN THOSE

01:19 - 08.379 SITUATIONS YOU MAY HAVE HEARD A

01:19 - 09.380 MALE WHO WERE GOOD.

01:19 - 11.069 HOW MUCH TO THANK YOU

01:19 - 14.120 DOESN'T 15 AND THEN AGAIN IN

01:19 - 17.400 2016 IT WASN'T UNTIL 2017.

01:19 - 18.870 THE DETERMINATION. GRISHAM.

01:19 - 22.909 MY EXCUSE ME COUNCIL HOW MUCH

01:19 - 24.289 WE KNOW WE SPOKE TO GET TO THE

01:19 - 25.290 SOUTH.

01:19 - 29.129 >>THE ISSUE ABOUT WHETHER SHE

01:19 - 31.689 FILED A CLAIM FIRST PLACE ALONG

01:19 - 32.830 WITH THERE WAS FRAUD.

01:19 - 37.169 >>YOUR HONOR I IN THIS CASE,

01:19 - 38.260 THE CLAIMANT DAY.

01:19 - 40.950 ALLEGED THE HEARING. I

01:19 - 43.119 I BELIEVE THE BRIEF TO THE

01:19 - 44.369 COURT THAT THE UNDERLYING IN

01:19 - 45.609 ITSELF WAS FRAUDULENT AND IN

01:19 - 46.650 FACT, SHE'S NOT EVEN.

01:19 - 49.799 I WILL NOTE, HOWEVER THAT THERE

01:19 - 51.689 WERE NO FINDINGS OF FACT ABOUT

01:19 - 52.690 THAT ISSUE

01:19 - 54.369 IN THIS CASE BECAUSE THEY CAN

01:19 - 55.929 ACTUALLY REACH THE UNDERLYING

01:19 - 57.389 MERITS AND ALTHOUGH I WOULD

01:19 - 59.409 POSIT THAT CONSIDERATION THAT

01:19 - 00.599 SOMEBODY SAID THEY DO NOT EVEN

01:20 - 02.039 WHILE THE UNDERLYING CLAIM

01:20 - 03.130 WOULD CERTAINLY IMPACT

01:20 - 05.089 A REASONABLENESS WE DID NOT

01:20 - 07.069 UPDATE THEIR ADDRESS. WITH THE

01:20 - 08.319 DEPARTMENT I WAS GOING TO GIVE

01:20 - 09.320 A NUMBER OF YEARS.

01:20 - 11.940 >>WELL TO ME FINDING OUT.

01:20 - 13.500 THAT.

01:20 - 16.410 IT'S TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION.

01:20 - 18.950 NO YOUR HONOR I'M

01:20 - 21.029 THERE IS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE

01:20 - 21.710 ON THE RECORD

01:20 - 24.109 RIGHT NOW A GREAT IMPROVEMENT

01:20 - 25.570 REALLY EVEN WITHOUT A REFEREE.

01:20 - 27.899 >>THE UNDERLYING QUESTION

01:20 - 30.669 OF TIME BECAUSE EVEN TAKING

01:20 - 31.510 PUTTING PAYMENT IN THE

01:20 - 33.570 POSITION. I'M SOMEBODY WHO DID

01:20 - 35.949 WOW THE UNDERLYING CLAIMS STILL

01:20 - 37.400 DEALING WITH THE SAME PROBLEM.

01:20 - 38.769 I LOVE THE FACT THAT SHE

01:20 - 40.329 HAS ESTABLISHED THAT THERE WAS

01:20 - 41.280 NOT A RECEIPT OF THE

01:20 - 43.049 DETERMINATION AFTER DILIGENTLY

01:20 - 45.349 TO FILE AND THE FIVE-YEAR

01:20 - 47.189 DELAY, THIS REGARDLESS OF

01:20 - 48.929 WHETHER HE UNDERLINED CLEAN

01:20 - 50.430 ACTUALLY FILED BY THE CLAIMANT

01:20 - 52.360 UNTIL THE BOARD SAID IN COURT.

01:20 - 55.219 I KIND OF RAN REALLY FROM THE

01:20 - 57.379 TIME SHE WENT OUT. READING THE

01:20 - 58.439 QUESTION OF THE UNDERLYING

01:20 - 59.610 CRIME ALLEGATIONS.

01:20 - 02.799 >>AND COUNCIL IF WE DO SO MANY

01:21 - 03.800 WHO FIND.

01:21 - 06.899 CLAIMANT IT DOES MEET THOSE

01:21 - 08.339 STANDARDS FOR NON CREDIT TO

01:21 - 10.749 GREELEY WE BELIEVE THAT THE MAN

01:21 - 12.129 BACK TO THE TO

01:21 - 14.949 THE TO CONTINUE TO PROCESS THAN

01:21 - 16.489 THE DETECTIVE MEETING WHEN

01:21 - 18.839 THEY'RE ON THE MERITS. SHE

01:21 - 19.840 COULD IT'S

01:21 - 25.309 >>YOU AND IS ALWAYS NOT BEEN

01:21 - 26.449 FOR THIS COURT COULD NOT

01:21 - 27.270 BELIEVE THERE IS ENOUGH

01:21 - 28.510 EVIDENCE ON THE RECORD.

01:21 - 31.039 HOWEVER I DIDN'T BELIEVE THAT

01:21 - 32.669 THERE IS ENOUGH EVIDENCE FOR

01:21 - 35.299 THE RECORD 2 ON THE MERITS IN

01:21 - 36.990 RELIEF IS GRANTED ON THE TIME

01:21 - 39.989 AND IN SPECIFICALLY BE ON THAT

01:21 - 40.750 LITTLE DOCTRINE

01:21 - 42.919 OF LACI AND THAT IS WHERE THAT

01:21 - 44.399 COMES INTO THIS IS THAT IT

01:21 - 46.580 REALLY WAS GRANTED. THAT.

01:21 - 49.240 CLEMENT HAS

01:21 - 51.369 ESTABLISHED HERE THAT THERE WAS

01:21 - 53.509 A WANT AND DUE DILIGENCE WHEN

01:21 - 55.850 IT COMES INITIATING.

01:21 - 58.179 THIS DETERMINATION AND THERE

01:21 - 00.029 WAS NO EVIDENCE AND THAT COULD

01:22 - 02.029 EXPLAIN AWAY. THAT LACK OF

01:22 - 03.839 DUE DILIGENCE AND THAT SHE WAS

01:22 - 05.000 CREDITED, GIVEN THAT

01:22 - 06.529 YOU CAN SEE CLEARLY FROM THE

01:22 - 08.239 RECORD HER MEMORY HAS BEEN

01:22 - 10.779 AFFECTED BY THIS TIME THAT SHE

01:22 - 12.389 DOES NOT HAVE ACCESS TO THE

01:22 - 15.229 ADDRESS ANYMORE. WE'RE THE

01:22 - 16.879 FRAUDULENT CLAIM AND

01:22 - 18.339 SHE SAID I WHEN I LEFT RIGHT

01:22 - 20.199 AND WITH HELP FROM OUR DO YOU

01:22 - 22.349 BELIEVE THERE IS AND FROM THE

01:22 - 24.730 RECORD THAT YOU ON THE OTHER

01:22 - 29.740 IN OR NOT NECESSARY.

01:22 - 32.250 >>I'M SORRY FOR YOUR

01:22 - 34.130 ARGUMENT IS THAT.

01:22 - 38.369 BECAUSE THE DEPARTMENT WAITED

01:22 - 41.729 5 YEARS TO INVESTIGATE WHETHER

01:22 - 42.730 OR NOT.

01:22 - 44.969 THE BIRD WAS ENTITLED TO THE

01:22 - 45.970 CLAIMANT.

01:22 - 54.390 WE CAN RIVER ON THAT GROUND.

01:22 - 01.689 >>BASED WHAT ARE THE DAY AFTER

01:23 - 03.390 TERRI LYNE WORD THAT WE

01:23 - 07.160 IT DOES IF IT'S A 5 OH ONE K.

01:23 - 11.180 OR THE RIO 2 CASE.

01:23 - 13.590 >>THIS IS THE

01:23 - 15.359 FINAL ONE. I MEAN THEY

01:23 - 17.409 REPORTEDLY REQUEST REALLY HARD

01:23 - 20.559 TO. DEPARTMENT RECEIVED NOTICE

01:23 - 22.790 FROM THE 2012, BUT I'M IN THE

01:23 - 24.560 MINISTRY TO HEARD

01:23 - 28.149 FROM THE JUST SEE PRIVATE CLUB

01:23 - 30.499 DURING THE CLEAN AIR. THEN

01:23 - 30.810 FAILED TO

01:23 - 34.959 TAKE ACTION. I'M NOT FOR 5 THE

01:23 - 36.120 ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD.

01:23 - 38.669 AND THE CLEAN RECORD SEE

01:23 - 39.980 THERE'S JUST A THERE'S NOTHING

01:23 - 41.539 THERE'S NOTHING THERE DECIDED

01:23 - 43.850 TO HER SERVICE CENTER DEGREE.

01:23 - 47.219 AND IN THE

01:23 - 49.919 DOCTOR SHE AND ALLOW THE COURT

01:23 - 51.459 TO DO. TO VACATE THE

01:23 - 52.870 UNDERLYING DETERMINATION.

01:23 - 55.389 BUT WE'RE ALSO SAYING THAT SEE

01:23 - 56.830 ANY SNOW FLIES

01:23 - 58.479 ON THE JURISDICTION SIDE

01:23 - 00.329 BECAUSE IT RIGHT IN MANY WAYS,

01:24 - 02.170 I'M WITH HIM IN A TREE DOWN.

01:24 - 04.969 IT'S YOU IN THAT DEPARTMENT

01:24 - 06.450 DIDN'T HE. YEARS

01:24 - 10.119 TO INVESTIGATE THE

01:24 - 12.719 ISSUE THEY. AND BECAUSE IT TOOK

01:24 - 14.909 SO LONG CLEAN IT WAS NO LONGER

01:24 - 15.959 SIGNING AT THE ADDRESS THAT

01:24 - 17.649 THEY HAD ON RECORD AS YOU CAN

01:24 - 19.949 SEE THOSE THE TERMINATIONS AND

01:24 - 21.179 THIS IS AN ISSUE THE COURT HAS

01:24 - 24.189 SEEN MANY TIMES BEFORE. THE

01:24 - 25.529 DELAY DETERMINATIONS BUT IN

01:24 - 27.339 THIS CASE AND BELIEVE THEY'RE

01:24 - 27.570 THERE.

01:24 - 31.419 THERE. FIVE-YEAR DELAY ITSELF

01:24 - 32.669 IS NOT A MINISTRY TO BREAK

01:24 - 34.900 DOWN. ONE SECTION 5 OH ONE C

01:24 - 37.100 IMPOSING REQUIREMENTS FOR

01:24 - 38.180 EXAMINATION.

01:24 - 41.439 I'M GOING TO LEAVE YOU THERE

01:24 - 43.239 NOW ADMIT THAT 5 YEARS OF THE

01:24 - 45.249 CROP EXAMINATION. IN THIS

01:24 - 46.739 MATTER. COUNCIL

01:24 - 49.540 JUMP BACK THE ISSUE OF ON.

01:24 - 51.820 THE MEN MAY OR MAY

01:24 - 53.399 NOT HAVE WITH THE HARTMAN AND

01:24 - 55.149 YOU HAPPEN TO HAVE ON THE

01:24 - 56.250 REQUIREMENT TO.

01:24 - 59.150 >>PRACTICE WITH THE DEPARTMENT.

01:24 - 00.450 THERE

01:25 - 02.719 REFEREE FINALLY I BELIEVE THAT

01:25 - 05.039 THERE WAS A DISCUSSION WITH

01:25 - 07.289 YOU WE'RE IT'S RAINING RECEIVE

01:25 - 09.479 A PERMIT DOCUMENTS INCLUDE THE

01:25 - 10.480 CLEANING.

01:25 - 17.499 >>AND I SEE THAT I'M OUT OF

01:25 - 19.339 TIME MARY HAD A 3 TIME TO

01:25 - 20.340 REQUEST A QUESTION.

01:25 - 31.469 THE UNDERLYING ACTIVE

01:25 - 33.560 KNEW THIS IN THIS PIECE FOR 3

01:25 - 37.979 STATION WITH THE EMPLOYER,

01:25 - 39.090 THERE WAS NO CONTACT.

01:25 - 41.359 MY AGENTS AND SHE HAD NO

01:25 - 42.579 CONTACT WITH THE GOVERNMENT IN

01:25 - 44.310 THAT MATTER A ONE OFF

01:25 - 46.449 CONVERSATION WITH HER EMPLOYER

01:25 - 47.789 THAT YOU CAN ALSO SEE FROM THE

01:25 - 48.979 EVIDENCE IN THE RECORD CLEAN IT

01:25 - 50.129 DIDN'T SEEM TO UNDERSTAND IN

01:25 - 51.460 ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM.

01:25 - 55.499 BEFORE THE DETERMINATIONS WERE

01:25 - 56.500 EATING ISSUES.

01:25 - 58.939 SO IT COULD NOT HAVE GIVEN HER

01:25 - 00.259 ANY TYPE OF NOTE IS THAT YOU

01:26 - 01.689 NEED TO APPEAL THAT HE NEEDED

01:26 - 03.090 TO TAKE ACTION IN THAT WAY

01:26 - 05.669 AND MOST IMPORTANTLY THIS COURT

01:26 - 07.669 HAS ALREADY REJECTED EVEN

01:26 - 09.799 STRONGER EVIDENCE AND NOTICE

01:26 - 11.329 THE ALLEY FIRST DEPARTMENT OF

01:26 - 12.330 HUMAN SERVICES.

01:26 - 15.369 WE'RE THE GOVERNMENT ARGUED

01:26 - 17.419 THAT LETTER I THINK WE HAVE

01:26 - 19.780 RECEIVED AND GORE HIM THERE.

01:26 - 21.479 THE GOVERNMENT CONCLUDED THEIR

01:26 - 23.219 INVESTIGATION OF HOW HAVE YOU

01:26 - 24.710 FOUND IN THE HEATED REPORT.

01:26 - 26.949 IT WAS NOT IN TO WORK ON THE

01:26 - 29.250 BACK NEVER RECEIVED THE NOTICE.

01:26 - 31.369 IN THE REPORT BECAUSE

01:26 - 33.579 THE LATTER DID NOT GIVE ANY

01:26 - 34.909 INFORMATION ABOUT HIS RIGHT TO

01:26 - 37.109 APPEAL. AND FOR THOSE REASONS

01:26 - 38.499 BELIEVE THAT THE CONVERSATION

01:26 - 41.349 WOULD WHERE IS NOT THERE ON THE

01:26 - 42.550 GREAT RELIEF FROM THIS MATTER.

01:26 - 45.549 AND THERE ARE NO FURTHER

01:26 - 47.590 QUESTIONS. THAT

01:26 - 50.029 THE COURT. RANTANEN FIRST TIME

01:26 - 52.089 REALLY IN THIS MATTER. AND

01:26 - 53.159 REVERSE THE UNDERLYING

01:26 - 55.479 DETERMINATION. AND NOW LOOK FOR

01:26 - 56.570 SPEAKING YOU'RE ABOUT.

01:27 - 04.359 >>IT'S THE SUPPORT AND KAREN

01:27 - 09.239 HUGHES, FLORIDA MATTER ISSUE IN

01:27 - 11.119 THIS CASE IS WHETHER OR NOT AND

01:27 - 14.529 ACTED NEGLIGENTLY AN UPDATE FOR

01:27 - 15.760 A TEST. HARTMAN.

01:27 - 17.980 SHE WILL SEE BENEFITS IN

01:27 - 22.120 2012. AND SHE HAD NOTICED 2006.

01:27 - 25.859 IT TAKES SO 2017 FROM HER

01:27 - 26.860 LAWYER.

01:27 - 29.689 WE SEE JUST A QUESTION AND SHE

01:27 - 30.989 TOOK NO ACTION IF

01:27 - 32.929 THE CLAIMANT I CONTACTED THE

01:27 - 35.479 FIRE IN 2017 SHE WOULD SEE

01:27 - 36.480 NOTICE.

01:27 - 39.299 IN TRUTH SHE WOULD RECEIVE JUST

01:27 - 40.829 2 NATIONS SHE WOULD'VE BEEN A

01:27 - 42.570 BUSY PROGRAM HOYER.

01:27 - 45.969 >>HOW HER TO UPDATE HER ADDRESS

01:27 - 47.829 WHAT THE DEPARTMENT. YOU KNOW

01:27 - 50.389 THE MORE COLORS. CONTACT THE

01:27 - 51.390 DEPARTMENT.

01:27 - 55.049 >>THERE WE SEE THE BENEFITS IN

01:27 - 56.469 QUESTION IMPORTANT RECEIVED

01:27 - 57.430 QUESTIONNAIRES FROM THE

01:27 - 59.669 DEPARTMENT. THE CLAIM THAT TOOK

01:27 - 01.499 NO ACTION IS SHE HAD SHE HAD

01:28 - 02.710 BEEN ABLE TO FILE A TIMELY

01:28 - 05.990 AND CLAIM IT

01:28 - 07.599 HAS FACED THE ISSUE OF THE

01:28 - 09.289 LABOR DEPARTMENT FINED OVER AND

01:28 - 10.949 SEE JUST HOW CLOSE A TIME

01:28 - 13.959 LIMIT. ISSUING AND IT COMES

01:28 - 15.280 FROM A NATION ALSO

01:28 - 17.159 IF THEY DETERMINE NATIONS WAS

01:28 - 19.649 AN 8 OH OVERPAYMENT THERE'S A

01:28 - 21.690 10 YEAR STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

01:28 - 23.449 AND WHICH THAT THEY ISSUED THE

01:28 - 24.820 TERMINATIONS ON THAT ISSUE.

01:28 - 26.260 >>AND FOR

01:28 - 29.889 I'M I NEED YOUR YOUR STREAM

01:28 - 31.729 ISSUE THAT THE CLAIM HERE WITH

01:28 - 34.069 NEGLIGENT. BE NEGLIGENT ONE

01:28 - 35.160 MORE BREACH THAT DUTY.

01:28 - 37.459 THE DUTY I THINK THAT YOU'RE

01:28 - 39.250 IDENTIFYING THE BEAUTY TO

01:28 - 42.469 CONTACTED THE DEPARTMENT AND BY

01:28 - 44.049 THE DEPARTMENT OF AN ADDRESS

01:28 - 46.509 CHANGE WHERE AM I GOING TO FIND

01:28 - 48.839 THAT DUTY IN THE BACK CHUTE IN

01:28 - 50.219 THE REGULATIONS WITH THE VISION

01:28 - 51.629 AS A CORRIDOR DECISION OF THE

01:28 - 52.630 BOARD.

01:28 - 56.629 >>FOR EXAMPLE I WOULD SUPPORT

01:28 - 00.459 TO PAY THOSE CASES

01:29 - 02.779 WITH PRIDE. I'M SORRY SAID

01:29 - 04.059 THERE WAS A DUTY ON THE PART OF

01:29 - 05.060 THE CLAIM IT

01:29 - 06.959 TO AND FOR AN EMPLOYEE TO

01:29 - 08.729 UPDATE THERE ADDRESSING ALSO

01:29 - 10.969 POINT OUT YOU SEE HANDBOOK JUST

01:29 - 13.309 LAST STRUCK CLAIMANTS TO CHANGE

01:29 - 14.669 THEIR JUSTICE DEPARTMENT SO

01:29 - 15.899 THAT EVEN IF YOU'RE NOT GOING

01:29 - 18.019 TO BENEFIT IF THEY WILL RECEIVE

01:29 - 19.219 ALL CORRESPONDENCE FROM

01:29 - 20.220 THE DEPARTMENT.

01:29 - 21.759 >>IT WOULD HAVE BEEN HAPPY IN

01:29 - 23.269 WHICH EVEN A CLAIMANT AT THAT

01:29 - 23.550 POINT

01:29 - 24.550 IN TIME.

01:29 - 26.669 >>MORE CASES GOING WITH ACTIVE

01:29 - 28.159 ACTIVE CLAIMS ARE LITIGATED

01:29 - 29.160 CLAIMS WERE.

01:29 - 31.840 >>WHERE WHAT MADE HER CLAIM.

01:29 - 33.550 5 YEARS AFTER THE FACT.

01:29 - 37.239 >>SO IS DUE TO GIVE US A FIGHT

01:29 - 38.240 HERE.

01:29 - 40.280 WHEN WAS IT WAS

01:29 - 42.119 2010 THE CLAIM TO RECEIVE

01:29 - 43.419 BENEFITS SHE STOPPED BY THE

01:29 - 44.650 BENEFITS THE NEXT YEAR.

01:29 - 47.089 AND THE TERMINATIONS WERE

01:29 - 49.159 MAILED TO 2015 SHE DIDN'T SAY

01:29 - 51.130 IT'S A MICHIGAN LEE HILL BUT.

01:29 - 53.959 AND SHE HAD AN OBLIGATION TO

01:29 - 55.279 UPDATE YOUR ADDRESS AND SHE WAS

01:29 - 56.329 NEVER GET MY HANDS

01:29 - 59.219 ON THAT. IN THAT CASE THIS

01:29 - 01.079 QUESTION OF LOVE REALLY A

01:30 - 02.080 WEATHER THING. YEAH.

01:30 - 06.969 DELAY IS UNJUSTIFIED WAS NOT

01:30 - 08.420 DIRECTLY BEFORE THE COURT.

01:30 - 11.529 >>FIRST I NEED TO ASK YOU HOW

01:30 - 12.530 CAN YOU.

01:30 - 14.629 YOU SAY SHE DIDN'T RESPOND TO A

01:30 - 15.919 POSITION AS SHE DID BECOME

01:30 - 18.479 AWARE OF UNTIL SHE GOT SO HE

01:30 - 20.650 FILED AGAINST HER IF SHE EVER

01:30 - 24.399 NEW. CLAIMS SHE'S ALLEGED

01:30 - 26.579 THAT SHE. IT IS 5 HOMES IN THE

01:30 - 28.519 FIRST PLACE. BUT THE REFEREE

01:30 - 29.679 DIDN'T MAKE IN THE BOARD DID

01:30 - 31.919 NOT MAKE ANY FINDINGS ABOUT

01:30 - 32.920 THAT.

01:30 - 37.009 IT ALSO IN THEIR

01:30 - 38.809 CLAIMS OF FRAUD ISN'T IT DOES

01:30 - 40.269 HIM NO YOU KNOW THAT SOME CASES

01:30 - 42.329 IN THEIR CASE AND I'VE BEEN

01:30 - 44.649 REPORTED BUT IT'S INCUMBENT ON

01:30 - 46.040 THE BOARD TO SHOW THAT IT.

01:30 - 47.989 IT CAME IN ACTUALLY RECEIVE

01:30 - 50.909 PAYMENT. SO THOSE SAME SECURITY

01:30 - 52.179 I THINK THERE'S ANYTHING THE

01:30 - 53.760 RECORD. THE GOAL.

01:30 - 55.749 IT WAS ESTABLISHED THAT THE

01:30 - 57.979 CLEANING RECEIVE PAYMENT IF SHE

01:30 - 59.960 WERE FILED ACTUALLY CLAIMS.

01:31 - 01.879 THAT YOU

01:31 - 03.599 KNOW AN ISSUE I WOULD CLEAN WHY

01:31 - 04.789 WOULD SHE HAVE ANY DUTY

01:31 - 06.620 WHATSOEVER TO CONTINUE TO.

01:31 - 08.140 NO FLY.

01:31 - 11.289 HURT IN ANY OF THE CHANGE OF

01:31 - 12.869 ADDRESS ASIDE FROM WHAT SHE

01:31 - 15.760 ALREADY DID HE REGARD. SORTING.

01:31 - 18.969 MY QUESTION TO YOU AND KNOW

01:31 - 20.549 IS IN LIGHT OF ALL OF THAT WHY

01:31 - 22.119 SHOULD WE READ INTO THE COURT

01:31 - 26.450 STUDY'S FINDINGS AND TO APPLY.

01:31 - 30.070 STANDING

01:31 - 31.989 UNDER 43 PER WHOSE THAT SAYS

01:31 - 33.390 THE DEPARTMENT SHALL TRUMP.

01:31 - 36.449 EXAMINE EACH APPLICATION FOR

01:31 - 37.450 BENEFITS.

01:31 - 38.680 HOW DO WE

01:31 - 41.869 DEFINE TRUMP'S THIS FIRE AND

01:31 - 43.189 THERE'S A 10 YEAR STATUTE OF

01:31 - 44.879 LIMITATIONS DO YOU HAVE 10

01:31 - 46.310 YEARS TO ACT PROMPTLY.

01:31 - 48.459 ACCORDING TO THE STATUTE OF

01:31 - 49.460 LIMITATIONS

01:31 - 52.219 HOWEVER I WILL SAY IN THIS CASE

01:31 - 53.719 THE CLAIM RECORD ESTABLISHED

01:31 - 55.059 THAT THE CLAIMANT DID RECEIVE

01:31 - 56.060 THOSE BENEFITS.

01:31 - 58.809 IT'S FAR AS WE'RE CONCERNED

01:31 - 00.389 THIS NOTES THERE WAS ANY

01:32 - 01.390 FINDING MADE

01:32 - 04.619 WAS THERE. MAYBE THERE WAS SIC

01:32 - 06.189 FINDING THE TERMINATIONS OR

01:32 - 07.709 WHAT THEY BELIEVE IT WAS A TIME

01:32 - 08.580 IN THIS CASE YOU WEREN'T

01:32 - 09.699 LOOKING UNDERNEATH THAT WE'RE

01:32 - 10.879 LOOKING AT THE CONDITIONS

01:32 - 11.880 HAVING AN ISSUE.

01:32 - 15.309 >>WHAT YOU'RE PAYING AT THE

01:32 - 16.640 TIME CLAIRMONT MORE.

01:32 - 18.319 >>THE RIM AT A HEARING ON THE

01:32 - 19.320 MERITS.

01:32 - 21.259 >>NO THIS IS TRUE ONLY A

01:32 - 22.729 HEARING ON WHETHER OR NOT

01:32 - 24.499 JURORS AND PILED RENAULT PROTON

01:32 - 25.010 CROWLEY.

01:32 - 26.739 >>SO WHEN YOU SAY THERE WAS A

01:32 - 28.509 FINDING THAT SHE RECEIVED THE

01:32 - 29.959 BENEFIT OF WHAT YOU'RE SAYING

01:32 - 31.479 IS THAT WITHIN THE NOTICE OF

01:32 - 32.480 DETERMINATION.

01:32 - 36.179 47 EVER APPEALED ON AND ON WITH

01:32 - 37.270 THAT WOULD NEVER HEARING.

01:32 - 39.090 THERE WAS NEVER A TIME HE

01:32 - 51.460 >>THE TROUBLE HERE SAYING ANY

01:32 - 54.420 A CLAIMANT AND EVER HAVE.

01:32 - 57.899 BUT THE UNEMPLOYMENT

01:32 - 00.300 COMPENSATION SYSTEM. ON.

01:33 - 04.169 NOTIFY THE DEPARTMENT. ANY

01:33 - 06.099 CHANGE IN THE CRAFT A LOT AND

01:33 - 08.319 AFTER THAT INDIVIDUAL IS

01:33 - 10.040 COLLECTING A BETTER PATH

01:33 - 12.949 AND MOVED ON HAVE A NEW JOB MAY

01:33 - 15.199 BE MOVED TO A NEW DAY THAT

01:33 - 16.859 CLAIMANT MUST NOTIFY THE

01:33 - 17.860 DEPARTMENT.

01:33 - 20.690 AND THE CHANGE ON A DRAFT.

01:33 - 23.219 FOR AT LEAST 10 YEARS IS THAT

01:33 - 24.220 YOUR.

01:33 - 26.729 >>IF YOU KNOW YOU ARE I WOULD

01:33 - 28.289 GO THAT FAR AND I WOULD SAY THE

01:33 - 29.290 CASE LAST

01:33 - 30.500 THERE.

01:33 - 32.069 >>A 10 YEAR STATUTE OF

01:33 - 35.329 LIMITATIONS TO DOES EXIST.

01:33 - 36.939 YES THAT WOULD BE THE WAY TO GO

01:33 - 37.940 IF YOU WANT TO GO IN THAT

01:33 - 40.760 >>WHILE 5 YEARS.

01:33 - 42.930 >>YOU SAY IT'S NOT LONG ENOUGH.

01:33 - 45.220 HOW LONG IS LONG ENOUGH

01:33 - 47.419 AFTER YOU, RICK A PURE LIFE

01:33 - 48.420 BENEFITS TRACK.

01:33 - 51.279 >>I'D SAY WITH AT LEAST

01:33 - 53.039 10 YEARS SO IS IN DISPUTE CHINA

01:33 - 54.319 THAT'S WHY YOU SEE TAMPA

01:33 - 56.319 WARNS THEM. THE CLAIMANTS, I

01:33 - 58.040 MEAN TO UPDATE THEIR ADDRESS.

01:33 - 00.830 ONCE THEY RECEIVE BENEFITS.

01:34 - 03.300 IT'S ALWAYS GOING TO BE A RISK.

01:34 - 04.450 WE WANT TO BE

01:34 - 08.109 >>THE ONLY NOTICE THAT THE

01:34 - 10.349 CLAIMANT GET COVID DUTY TO

01:34 - 13.049 UPDATE AFTER A. IF IN THE

01:34 - 14.749 HANDBOOK AND MAC BUT WE'RE

01:34 - 17.419 QUITE SPECIFICALLY THAT YOU

01:34 - 19.060 MOCK UPDATE THE ADDRESS.

01:34 - 21.310 AFTER YOUR BENEFIT TERMINATE.

01:34 - 25.830 >>THIS CLIMATE IN WHICH

01:34 - 28.619 2017 THERE WAS A QUESTION ABOUT

01:34 - 30.329 TO RECEIVE THE BENEFITS IF SHE

01:34 - 31.819 HAD CONTACTED THE ALL RIGHT,

01:34 - 32.969 THEN WHAT YOU WISH FOR HER SON

01:34 - 33.970 WOULD HAVE DONE.

01:34 - 36.999 >>APPARENTLY I MEAN FOR THE

01:34 - 38.769 EMPLOYER MAKES AN OFFHAND

01:34 - 41.449 REMARK. I DON'T THINK THE PATH

01:34 - 45.070 OF UP TO 2, 4, FROM.

01:34 - 46.890 I THINK THEY CAN PAY.

01:34 - 48.810 >>BEFORE WHERE AM I GOING TO

01:34 - 50.779 FIND IN THE HANDBOOK WITH A

01:34 - 52.219 NOTICE WARNING

01:34 - 55.679 THAT DUTY. BACK TO YOU I THINK

01:34 - 57.119 YOU USE THE WORD WARNING ALL

01:34 - 58.259 USE YOUR WORD WE'RE GOING TO

01:34 - 00.900 FIND THAT THAT THAT THEY HAVE

01:35 - 01.700 UPDATE

01:35 - 02.180 THEIR ADDRESS.

01:35 - 04.419 >>I CAN SET YOUR SPECIFIC CASE

01:35 - 06.369 YOUR HONOR IT INSTRUCTS I WOULD

01:35 - 08.439 USE THAT WORD IF CLINTON AT 5

01:35 - 09.800 POINT OF A CHANGE OF ADDRESS.

01:35 - 11.940 IT'S NOT FILING FOR BENEFITS

01:35 - 13.659 AT THE TIME TO LOOK AT AGAIN

01:35 - 15.489 AGAIN I'M I'M WONDERING WHETHER

01:35 - 16.819 THAT INSTRUCTION WAS REALLY

01:35 - 18.669 DESIGNED TO ADDRESS A CLAIMANT

01:35 - 20.069 WHO IS ACTIVELY FILING FOR

01:35 - 21.429 BENEFITS ARE IN THE PROCESS OF

01:35 - 23.349 FILING FOR BENEFITS NOT ABOUT

01:35 - 24.689 WHAT MAKES THEM A CLAIMANT

01:35 - 25.799 MEANING THEY'RE IN THE PROCESS

01:35 - 26.800 THE CLAIM.

01:35 - 29.579 >>BUT I THINK WE'RE DEALING

01:35 - 31.149 WITH COMPLETELY SORT OF A

01:35 - 32.369 DIFFERENT MAN A LEADER WITH

01:35 - 33.690 SOMEBODY WITH A FORMER CLAIM

01:35 - 37.759 PGA VINDICATE HAS MOVED ON WITH

01:35 - 40.159 THEIR LIVES AND AND THAT

01:35 - 42.399 THEY'RE SORT OF THE ONGOING FOR

01:35 - 44.959 10 YEAR PERIOD. NO PROVISION IS

01:35 - 46.489 THERE ANYTHING IN HAND A BOOK

01:35 - 48.259 THAT TYPICALLY ADDRESSES VOTER

01:35 - 49.519 CAN STEP IN TERMS OF THE DUTY

01:35 - 51.509 TO WARN IF YOU DIDN'T HAVE TO

01:35 - 51.860 UPDATE.

01:35 - 53.559 >>AND IF YOU'RE NOT FILING FOR

01:35 - 55.159 BENEFITS THERE'S BAD THINK THAT

01:35 - 56.259 IF THEY'RE NOT BACK TO THE

01:35 - 57.469 CLAIMANTS THEY STILL HAVE TO

01:35 - 58.510 UPDATE THEIR ADDRESS.

01:36 - 01.100 >>WHEN YOU DON'T KNOW WHERE

01:36 - 02.140 THAT BUT FELL.

01:36 - 04.509 >>I CAN'T SECTOR SAID YEAH, I'M

01:36 - 05.510 SORRY.

01:36 - 14.960 SO WE'RE ASKING THE QUESTION

01:36 - 15.960 HOW A FAMILY.

01:36 - 17.950 >>THE TRIBUTE THAT

01:36 - 21.309 IS ONLINE A TRIBUTE IT IN PRINT

01:36 - 22.700 FORM EVERY CLAIMANT.

01:36 - 26.869 >>THEY THEY WILL RECEIVE IT ONE

01:36 - 28.159 WAY OR THE OTHER AND THEY ARE

01:36 - 29.450 EXPECTING THEIR INSTINCTS.

01:36 - 31.560 PHASE WE DID NOT JUST IN THIS.

01:36 - 35.309 THE SITUATION. 2 ISIS OUT OF

01:36 - 36.310 ALL THE WHOLE.

01:36 - 39.570 IT'S

01:36 - 41.269 FAR AS WE SEE THE BENEFITS IN

01:36 - 42.270 QUESTION ABOUT IT.

01:36 - 45.469 >>IF YOU HAVE A REFERENCE IN

01:36 - 47.010 YOUR BRIEF TO THE HANDBOOK.

01:36 - 48.540 NO I DON'T.

01:36 - 51.339 >>AND I HAD ASKED YOU EARLIER

01:36 - 52.320 AND I DON'T THINK YOU HAD A

01:36 - 52.720 CHANCE

01:36 - 55.579 TO ANSWER WILL SOMEONE CLAIMS

01:36 - 57.019 THAT THEY NEVER RECEIVED OR

01:36 - 59.569 APPLIED FOR THESE BENEFITS IF

01:36 - 01.420 THE BOARD THEY HAVE SOME DUTY

01:37 - 04.760 EXCEPT THE 2 NATIONS.

01:37 - 06.100 >>OR ALLOW FOR.

01:37 - 07.650 >>A HEARING TO DO SO.

01:37 - 10.409 NOT A 45 TO JURISDICTION BY THE

01:37 - 11.699 FACT THAT THERE'S AN UNTIMELY

01:37 - 13.269 APPEAL YOUR HONOR AND THAT WAS

01:37 - 14.270 THE CASE HERE.

01:37 - 16.299 IT WAS ONLY IN TIMELY BECAUSE

01:37 - 17.110 SHE SAID SHE DIDN'T

01:37 - 19.809 RECEIVE IT. SHE NEVER FILED ITS

01:37 - 21.639 FLEET WHICH TO BE TENSE FOR

01:37 - 22.900 SUCH ONLY A FEW

01:37 - 24.809 SHE DIDN'T SHE SAYS SHE DIDN'T

01:37 - 26.669 APPLY FOR THESE BENEFITS YOU

01:37 - 29.189 SEE THEM IN GETTING THE NOTICES

01:37 - 33.149 UNTIL. SHE FELL ON A TRULY NOT

01:37 - 34.919 WAS FILED AGAINST HER AND THEN

01:37 - 36.850 SHE TOOK PROMPT ACTION.

01:37 - 39.109 SO WITH THAT REPAVING THE

01:37 - 41.219 QUESTION TO SAY THAT SHE BODY

01:37 - 42.740 SHE SAYS SHE NEVER GOT IT.

01:37 - 45.639 SO AND SHE EVER APPLY FOR THEM,

01:37 - 46.659 I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THE

01:37 - 47.500 BOARD CAN MAKE ANY

01:37 - 50.199 DETERMINATION UNTIL ASSESSES

01:37 - 51.970 WHETHER THAT'S 2.

01:37 - 55.089 PLAN OUT YOUR HONOR THAT THE

01:37 - 56.469 CLAIMANT NEVER MADE A CLAIM OF

01:37 - 58.749 FRAUD OF ANY KIND SPORTS, NO

01:37 - 59.750 IDENTITY THEFT.

01:37 - 01.670 >>CLAY MOORE AND I SIMPLY SAID

01:38 - 03.170 I DIDN'T RECEIVE A.

01:38 - 06.420 SHE HAD CALLED CUMMINGS

01:38 - 07.090 SORRY.

01:38 - 09.330 >>THE ROUTE WILL FOCUS A LOT ON

01:38 - 12.149 A SO-CALLED NEGLIGENT OF

01:38 - 14.229 THE QUEEN IS THERE ANYTHING IN

01:38 - 16.940 THE RECORD THAT. THE POPE TOLD.

01:38 - 21.539 ON WHY IT TOOK THE DEPARTMENT 5

01:38 - 22.540 YEARS TO FIND.

01:38 - 26.770 OCCASIONAL FUN.

01:38 - 29.010 >>NOTHING IN THE RECORD 202.

01:38 - 32.329 >>AND I TO MAKE YOUR POINT

01:38 - 34.319 IS THAT THERE'S NO NEGLIGENCE

01:38 - 36.409 ON THE DEPARTMENT FOR WAITING 5

01:38 - 39.159 YEARS TO INVESTIGATE ANY CLAIM

01:38 - 40.660 THAT THEY THINK MIGHT HAVE BEEN

01:38 - 42.620 IN APPROPRIATELY GIVEN.

01:38 - 45.489 >>I'M ASSUMING YOU ARE AT THE

01:38 - 47.490 TIME IT HAD DUE DILIGENCE TO

01:38 - 49.519 UNDERCOVER ANY FACTS ABOUT

01:38 - 51.459 THIS PLAN AND I WOULD JUST GO

01:38 - 52.740 OUTSIDE AND SEE.

01:38 - 55.029 THERE'S NO STATUTORY TIME

01:38 - 56.389 LIMIT IMPOSED ON THE DEPARTMENT

01:38 - 58.289 AS FAR AS INVESTIGATING FOR US

01:38 - 59.410 TO DETERMINE NATIONS.

01:39 - 01.939 >>UNDERSTAND YOUR POSITION I I

01:39 - 03.959 JUST THINK IT'S A WAY OF WHAT

01:39 - 05.069 WE'RE TRYING TO PUT ON

01:39 - 06.989 THE CLAIMANT ALL THE WHILE

01:39 - 08.859 TRYING TO BUY THAT THE FACT

01:39 - 10.069 THAT THE DEPARTMENT SAT ON THIS

01:39 - 11.559 FOR 5 YEARS AND THEN WOKE UP

01:39 - 13.539 AND DECIDED THEY WANTED TO AND

01:39 - 15.240 WHERE THE INDIVIDUAL FOR.

01:39 - 17.469 IN THEIR OPINION AND

01:39 - 19.179 INAPPROPRIATE USE OF OR

01:39 - 20.180 GRANTING OF FUN

01:39 - 22.959 AND I THINK FROM MY PERSPECTIVE

01:39 - 24.150 THAT THE BALANCE OF THE 2.

01:39 - 25.340 IF WE'RE GOING TO THE

01:39 - 27.629 NEGLIGENCE ON THE CLAIMANT I

01:39 - 28.570 UNDERSTAND YOUR PAIN

01:39 - 30.569 YOUR PERMISSION. BUT THEY'RE

01:39 - 33.489 STILL GOING TO BE A LONG PERIOD

01:39 - 36.139 OF TIME WHERE NOTHING MOVE AND

01:39 - 37.719 YOU WOKE UP AND DECIDED TO GO

01:39 - 39.660 AFTER. I BELIEVE

01:39 - 43.179 $7,000. YOUR YOUR POSITION IS

01:39 - 44.619 WE CAN DO WHAT WE WANTED LONG

01:39 - 45.570 AS WE GET UNDER THE

01:39 - 48.159 10 YEAR. THAT'S A LIMITATION

01:39 - 49.570 BUT YOU CAN CALL IT THAT.

01:39 - 51.879 >>I WOULD GO THERE FOR YOU TO

01:39 - 53.989 SAY THAT PORTMAN ALWAYS ACTS AS

01:39 - 56.320 QUICKLY AS THEY CAN. IN THIS

01:39 - 58.750 SITE.

01:39 - 00.139 >>BUT YOU ARE PAYING NEAR THE

01:40 - 01.249 10 YEAR STATUTE OF

01:40 - 02.400 LIMITATION HER.

01:40 - 04.519 >>OVER THE OVERPAYMENT YES AND

01:40 - 05.599 THEY WERE WELL WITHIN THAT

01:40 - 07.180 STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.

01:40 - 11.690 >>EXAMINATION MEAN

01:40 - 14.850 SOMEWHERE BETWEEN VERO AND PAN

01:40 - 15.900 IN HERE.

01:40 - 19.369 >>I THINK THE MOST ANTICIPATED

01:40 - 20.679 THIS CASE THAT IT DOES TAKE

01:40 - 23.229 TIME FOR THE DEPARTMENT TOO BAD

01:40 - 24.230 THAT THERE'S A PROBLEM

01:40 - 28.330 AND THEN TO TAKE ACTION.

01:40 - 30.969 >>WHO MISSED WHAT I I MEAN I

01:40 - 31.200 DON'T

01:40 - 32.849 I DON'T I DON'T REALLY HAVE A

01:40 - 33.869 PROBLEM WITH YOU IF YOU'RE

01:40 - 35.539 TAKING THE 10 YEARS BACK TO GET

01:40 - 36.729 TO 10 YEARS OF THAT TO GIVE YOU

01:40 - 37.929 10 YEARS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT

01:40 - 38.850 HERE GIVING THE CLAIM IN AN

01:40 - 40.969 OPPORTUNITY TO BAT. AND THAT'S

01:40 - 42.019 REALLY ALL WE'RE TALKING ABOUT

01:40 - 42.470 HERE AND I'M NOT

01:40 - 43.470 SURE WHY.

01:40 - 45.439 >>IF THE DEPARTMENT OF GOING TO

01:40 - 46.539 THE MATTRESSES ON SOMETHING

01:40 - 47.540 LIKE THIS.

01:40 - 49.089 >>I WOULD JUST POINT TO COURT

01:40 - 50.279 TO THE FACT THAT SHE HAD 2

01:40 - 51.509 OPPORTUNITIES SHE COULD HAVE

01:40 - 53.130 UPDATED FORECAST OR

01:40 - 55.529 IN 2017 SHE SIMPLY PICKED UP

01:40 - 56.859 THE PHONE AND CALLED HIS HEART

01:40 - 58.929 AND SHE DID OPEN. WELL

01:40 - 59.410 CERTAINLY.

01:40 - 00.849 >>SHE 3RD I AGREE

01:41 - 02.889 WITH YOU SHE CERTAINLY WOULD

01:41 - 04.359 HAVE BUT YOU'RE ARGUING

01:41 - 06.539 NEGLIGENT WITH SUGGESTS SHE HAD

01:41 - 08.579 TO HAVE NOT THAT SHE COULD HAVE

01:41 - 09.889 BUT THAT SHE HAD A DUTY TO DO

01:41 - 11.399 IT. THAT'S WHY I'M TRYING TO

01:41 - 13.409 UNDERSTAND WHY THE DEPARTMENT

01:41 - 14.779 GOING TO THE MATTRESSES ON THIS

01:41 - 17.029 BECAUSE SHE COULD HAVE DONE

01:41 - 18.030 SOMETHING THAT NO DOUBT.

01:41 - 19.700 WHY DID SHE HAVE TO.

01:41 - 21.370 AND WE DON'T WANT THE

01:41 - 22.659 DEPARTMENT CARE WHETHER YOU

01:41 - 23.660 WANT TO GET AMERICA.

01:41 - 27.299 >>WE HAVE NO JURISDICTION,

01:41 - 29.229 YOUR HONOR. IT WAS UNTIMELY UP

01:41 - 31.139 YOU. WE HAVE TO GET PAST THAT

01:41 - 32.900 FIRST, WE CAN GET THE MERITS

01:41 - 34.020 AND THIS CASE.

01:41 - 37.709 WELL THEY CLAIM THEY DIDN'T

01:41 - 39.350 RECEIVE BENEFITS.

01:41 - 44.989 IF THERE'S A CLAIM THEY DID NOT

01:41 - 46.869 RECEIVE BENEFITS IN ADDITION,

01:41 - 48.299 NOT AND NOT HAVING FOUND THE

01:41 - 49.300 CLAIM.

01:41 - 52.029 ISN'T IT INCUMBENT ON THE BOARD

01:41 - 53.359 TO MAKE THAT IF THAT'S WHAT

01:41 - 54.670 LOOKED TO FOCUS FOR.

01:41 - 57.850 WE CAN SHOW THAT SHE WAS

01:41 - 00.050 NOT NEGLIGENT. BUT I THINK

01:42 - 04.450 THE COURT NOT SEE

01:42 - 06.699 THAT SHE HAD 2 OPPORTUNITIES TO

01:42 - 08.209 BE ABLE TO FILE A TIMELY APPEAL

01:42 - 09.479 AND SHE DIDN'T DO THAT AND I

01:42 - 10.600 SEE THEM OUT OF TIME

01:42 - 12.839 AND AND SO I'M OPEN TO ANY

01:42 - 14.100 OTHER QUESTIONS THE COURTHOUSE.

01:42 - 17.710 IF YOU LIKE THE SUMMER.

01:42 - 20.939 QUICK SO FAST BEFORE ITS

01:42 - 22.629 TERMINATION THE CLAIMANT WAS

01:42 - 25.320 NEGLIGENT IN THIS MESS.

01:42 - 32.440 >>ALL RIGHT FROM THE HEALTH.

01:42 - 35.280 >>THANK YOU

01:42 - 37.619 YOUR HONOR. UNFORTUNATELY WE

01:42 - 40.009 ARE OUT THE CLAIMANT HANDBOOK

01:42 - 42.769 THAT EXISTED IN 2012. AND THAT

01:42 - 43.970 WOULD BE WHAT WOULD HAVE QUIT.

01:42 - 45.830 CLINTON ANY FORM OF NO IT'S NOT

01:42 - 48.659 TO THE COUNCIL IS REFERRING TO

01:42 - 50.069 AND EVEN SOME FROM NOTICE THAT

01:42 - 50.430 YOU SHOULD

01:42 - 53.479 UPDATE YOUR WITH THE DEPARTMENT

01:42 - 56.130 TO DID NOT PUT ON NOTICE.

01:42 - 57.810 THAT'S INCUR TO A T

01:42 - 00.169 THE TERROR THREAT, NO MATTER

01:43 - 01.970 WHERE THEY LIVE. MY

01:43 - 06.009 ALSO NEW THIS SECTION YOU WHO

01:43 - 08.079 ARE. HOW THE 10 YEAR SENT

01:43 - 10.409 TO COLLECTIONS AND OVER PEOPLE

01:43 - 11.589 NEED THE DEPARTMENT CAN ONLY

01:43 - 13.240 MOVE TO WHO MY

01:43 - 16.439 10 AFTER THE INITIAL CLAIM WAS

01:43 - 18.230 FILED THAT WAS LATER DETERMINED

01:43 - 19.890 TO HAVE AN OVER PAYMENT.

01:43 - 21.859 BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY JUST

01:43 - 23.420 CROSSING TOUCHED ON THIS.

01:43 - 25.930 THIS IS NOT A CASE ABOUT.

01:43 - 28.989 WHETHER THE DEPARTMENT HAS A

01:43 - 30.789 TIME LIMIT ON WHEN HE ISSUED

01:43 - 32.870 THE DETERMINATIONS. IT IS ABOUT

01:43 - 35.930 WHETHER A 5 YEAR DELAY. IT

01:43 - 39.069 OPPORTUNITY TO CONTEST THE

01:43 - 40.969 MERITS OF THE OVERPAYMENT THE

01:43 - 42.890 DEPARTMENT HERE DID NOT ACT

01:43 - 44.689 FOR 5 YEARS AND THEN ALL OF A

01:43 - 46.659 SUDDEN WITH NO EXPLANATION AND

01:43 - 47.660 THERE CERTAINLY WAS

01:43 - 49.439 NO EVIDENCE ON THE RECORD THAT

01:43 - 51.359 THE DILIGENTLY AS INCLUDING HOW

01:43 - 53.129 TO CLAIM, AND THEY CAME

01:43 - 54.779 AFTER HER. THOUSANDS

01:43 - 57.219 OF DOLLARS PENALTY AMOUNT AND

01:43 - 59.080 FOR 39 TO BE.

01:44 - 02.019 5 YEARS AFTER THE CLAIM ENDED

01:44 - 03.440 WITH NO COMMUNICATION

01:44 - 05.839 IN BETWEEN AND SHE'S CLEARLY

01:44 - 07.049 SEE THAT HE DID NOT RECEIVE

01:44 - 08.679 THIS INFORMATION AND THE MOMENT

01:44 - 11.219 SHE LEARNED ACTUAL OVERCAME AND

01:44 - 13.459 SHE CALLED THE DEPARTMENT KEY

01:44 - 15.059 TO HER ADDRESS WHEN SHE WOULD

01:44 - 15.770 ADVISE OF HER

01:44 - 17.679 APPEAL RIGHT. SHE IMMEDIATELY

01:44 - 19.519 APPEALED ALL WITHIN A 12 DAY

01:44 - 21.859 PERIOD. AND WHEN SHE LEARNED OF

01:44 - 23.739 THE NOTICE OF LIEN I GUESS

01:44 - 25.509 YOU'RE FOR THIS OVERPAYMENT AND

01:44 - 26.620 FOR THOSE REASONS WE

01:44 - 28.539 I BELIEVE THAT THIS CASE CAN BE

01:44 - 31.209 GRANTED. RELIEF ON THE APPEAL.

01:44 - 32.599 THE TIME WAS THAT WE FEEL UNDER

01:44 - 34.229 EITHER THE NOT NEGLIGENT

01:44 - 36.419 CONDUCT. PROBLEM WHO ARE THE

01:44 - 37.680 MINISTRY TO BREAK DOWN PROP.

01:44 - 41.520 I JUST FROM CLEAR.

01:44 - 45.690 I UNDERSTAND THE

01:44 - 46.210 NOT TOO.

01:44 - 48.179 >>THE ADMINISTRATE BREAKDOWN

01:44 - 50.180 AND THE KNOT NEGLIGENT COM

01:44 - 53.019 CONDUCT. IT DOES GO PRO COME

01:44 - 54.599 YOU WANT TO RIVER TOLL ON THE

01:44 - 56.700 MARRIAGE. ON THE BASIS OF WHAT.

01:44 - 58.700 A DEPARTMENT DID

01:44 - 00.209 NOT UNDERTAKE PROMPT

01:45 - 01.210 EXAMINATION.

01:45 - 05.889 >>THIS UNDER THIS COURT'S PRIOR

01:45 - 08.289 PRECEDENT OF FLYING. THE

01:45 - 10.040 DOCTRINE OF LACKEYS TO.

01:45 - 12.079 GOVERNMENT AGENCIES THAT THERE

01:45 - 13.760 WAS A WANT AND DUE DILIGENCE.

01:45 - 16.569 IN. THE CONDUCT OF THE BOARD

01:45 - 19.459 AND THE CHEATING. THIS HE

01:45 - 22.349 THINK THAT THE TO THE PRESIDENT

01:45 - 24.969 BY THAT. LET WE BELIEVE THERE

01:45 - 26.439 IS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO MAKE

01:45 - 28.219 THAT DETERMINATION. FOR THE

01:45 - 29.220 COURT.

01:45 - 36.420 BACK CONCLUDE OUR ARGUMENT.

01:45 - 37.940 ON A

01:45 - 40.269 NUMBER 27 IMPORTANT PAY VERY

01:45 - 42.429 WELL ARGUED ON BOTH SIDES VERY

01:45 - 43.430 MUCH.

01:45 - 46.290 >>ACTIVE NUMBER 28.

01:45 - 48.490 NOVEMBER ON

01:45 - 51.159 BOND SESSION. I THINK COUNCIL

01:45 - 53.310 BOTH KNOW THE RULES OF THE ROAD

01:45 - 56.120 WE ALLOW 50 MINUTES PER FRY.

01:45 - 57.660 PERFECT.

01:45 - 00.339 INTERVIEW IF YOU ARE THAT WOULD

01:46 - 01.999 BE MISTER EICHEL YOU MAY READ

01:46 - 03.030 ARE SOME OF YOUR

01:46 - 05.819 15 MINUTES FOR REBUTTAL WE'VE

01:46 - 06.520 READ THE BRIEF.

01:46 - 09.429 WE RECOMMEND THAT YOU GO RIGHT

01:46 - 11.020 TO THE HEART OF YOUR ARGUMENT.

01:46 - 14.829 NUMBER 28 IS AN APPEAL THAT CAN

01:46 - 16.910 TURN THE APPLICATION OF GENPACT

01:46 - 19.569 CORPORATION. HER RESEARCH AND

01:46 - 21.300 DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT FOR THE

01:46 - 24.679 2016 TAX YEAR. A DEPARTMENT OF

01:46 - 26.650 REVENUE AND GENPACT THE LETTER

01:46 - 29.660 DAVID SEPTEMBER FOR 2017.

01:46 - 31.920 NO TO FIND AN IMPACT THAT

01:46 - 34.019 IF APPLICATION FOR THAT THAT

01:46 - 36.609 TAX CREDIT WAS DUE BY THE

01:46 - 40.379 NUMBER 15 2017. THE LETTER WAS

01:46 - 42.879 POSTMARKED SEPTEMBER 13 AND

01:46 - 45.289 JEN HACK RECEIVED THE LETTER ON

01:46 - 47.950 SEPTEMBER 8 CAME AFTER THE DATE

01:46 - 48.490 IT

01:46 - 51.129 WOULD DO IMPACT IMMEDIATELY

01:46 - 53.530 FILED A TAX CREDIT APPLICATION.

01:46 - 56.899 ON DECEMBER 1520 17 THE

01:46 - 58.209 DEPARTMENT ISSUED A LETTER

01:46 - 58.390 COULD

01:46 - 00.159 GAIN PACKED DENYING THE

01:47 - 02.250 APPLICATION HAS SOME TIMELY.

01:47 - 05.309 IMPACT APPEALED TO THE

01:47 - 07.250 DEPARTMENT BOARD OF APPEAL

01:47 - 08.869 ARGUING THAT IT BELIEVES THAT

01:47 - 10.740 IT APPLICATION DEADLINE

01:47 - 13.409 CORRESPONDED WITH A FEDERAL A

01:47 - 15.460 TAX RETURN EXTENSION DEADLINE

01:47 - 17.410 AND THAT THE DEPARTMENT NOTICED

01:47 - 19.999 WHAT AN ADEQUATE BECAUSE THAT

01:47 - 21.989 WOULD BAN ONLY DAYS BEFORE THE

01:47 - 22.990 DEADLINE.

01:47 - 25.799 UNDERLYING PAIN, 28 PAIN, THE

01:47 - 26.080 BOARD

01:47 - 28.439 OF APPEALS IN I'M JEN TAX

01:47 - 29.600 APPEAL FOR LACK OF

01:47 - 33.340 EXPLAINING

01:47 - 34.749 THAT THERE WAS NO PROVISION IN

01:47 - 36.279 THE TAX CREDIT LAW FOR AN

01:47 - 37.720 ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL.

01:47 - 40.529 THE BOARD OF APPEALS STATED

01:47 - 40.680 THAT

01:47 - 42.589 JAM PACKED YOUR PETITION FOR

01:47 - 44.749 THE PARK REVIEW WITH GENENTECH

01:47 - 45.750 DEAD.

01:47 - 47.879 THE FIRST ISSUE ON APPEAL

01:47 - 49.959 CONCERN JUST QUARTER FICTION

01:47 - 52.419 MORE TYPICALLY. WHETHER

01:47 - 55.909 THAT DEPARTMENT 12/15/2017,

01:47 - 57.600 LETTER DENYING JAM PACKED.

01:47 - 00.749 CREDIT APPLICATION HAS BEEN

01:48 - 02.589 TIMELY IS AN APPEAL

01:48 - 06.390 ADJUDICATION WEATHER

01:48 - 08.149 B. AT THE

01:48 - 09.789 DEPARTMENT ARGUED THE PETITION

01:48 - 11.769 FOR REVIEW TO COURT WITH ON

01:48 - 14.089 TIMELY BECAUSE IT WAS NOT FILED

01:48 - 15.619 WITH HIM 30 DAYS OF

01:48 - 17.869 A LETTER AND TURNING THE COURT

01:48 - 20.199 HAVE HER PICTURE AND UP THE 5

01:48 - 22.129 WHETHER THE DEPARTMENT AIR AND

01:48 - 23.590 DENYING JOHN PACK.

01:48 - 26.239 CREDIT APPLICATION APP ON

01:48 - 28.280 TIMELY AND WHETHER GENPACT

01:48 - 30.369 APPEAL AND GOVERNED BY THE

01:48 - 33.039 TAXPAYER. PHILIP RIGHT. THAT

01:48 - 34.040 YOU.

01:48 - 40.049 >>WOULD YOU LIKE TO READ OR

01:48 - 41.050 SOME TIME.

01:48 - 42.979 THANK YOU I'D LIKE TO RESERVE

01:48 - 43.980 ONE MINUTE.

01:48 - 49.590 MAY PLEASE

01:48 - 50.050 THE COURT.

01:48 - 51.649 MY NAME IS BEN MICHAEL FROM

01:48 - 53.059 ARCHER AND BRIAN ARE HERE TODAY

01:48 - 54.509 ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER

01:48 - 55.600 CENTEX CORPORATION.

01:48 - 58.169 AS JUDGE LET I EXPLAINED THE

01:48 - 59.530 FACTS I WILL NOT FORSAKE

01:49 - 01.470 THEY'RE LARGELY NOT DISPUTE.

01:49 - 05.099 WE'LL FIRST START WHAT JUST

01:49 - 06.639 LANDED ON A FIGHT AS THE FIRST

01:49 - 08.909 ISSUE AND THAT IS WHETHER THIS

01:49 - 10.580 IS AN APPEAL WANT YOU TO CATION

01:49 - 12.929 WHICH THIS COURT CAN YOU CAN

01:49 - 14.909 FORGIVE. AND I SUBMIT THAT IT

01:49 - 16.889 IS. THE DEA JUST

01:49 - 19.449 CAPITAL DECISION. FIRST

01:49 - 20.969 DEPARTMENT OF NEIGHBORHOODS IN

01:49 - 22.709 THE ASSISTANCE ADDRESS

01:49 - 24.220 DEVELOPED VERY SIMILAR SHIP.

01:49 - 27.830 IF THE PETITIONER THAT CASE.

01:49 - 31.159 SO APPEAL PLY A

01:49 - 32.160 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSISTANCE.

01:49 - 33.759 MANY THE DEVELOPMENT TAX

01:49 - 35.890 CREDIT. IT WAS GRANTED A NOT

01:49 - 37.580 $20,000.

01:49 - 40.270 IT IS THEN.

01:49 - 43.280 CHALLENGE THAT DECISION

01:49 - 45.019 INTENDING IT WASN'T AISLE TO

01:49 - 47.929 PROTECT. THE DEPARTMENT OF

01:49 - 49.010 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSISTANCE

01:49 - 50.729 INTENDED THAT THIS COURT DOES

01:49 - 52.509 NOT HAVE JURISDICTION BECAUSE

01:49 - 54.059 THAT WAS NOT AN EDUCATION

01:49 - 56.939 SUBJECT TO IT. HE DID JUST

01:49 - 58.719 CAPITAL PORT WENT THROUGH THE

01:49 - 00.150 ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY LAW

01:50 - 02.409 AND DETERMINED THAT THIS WAS IN

01:50 - 03.410 THE KITCHEN

01:50 - 06.099 IN DETERMINATION REGARDING TAX

01:50 - 08.019 CREDIT. IT IS AN EIGHT-TERM A

01:50 - 09.919 NATION REGARDING THE PROPERTY

01:50 - 12.010 RIGHT AND THEREFORE METHODIST

01:50 - 14.000 THE DEFINITION OF EDUCATION

01:50 - 17.509 UNDER THE ADMINISTRATIVE IN

01:50 - 20.239 REACHING THAT DECISION. THE IT

01:50 - 22.089 JUST HAPPENED A SHORT CHASE IN

01:50 - 23.090 THE CAPITAL.

01:50 - 25.629 WE'RE CHECKING SOME OF THE VERY

01:50 - 26.979 ARGUMENTS THAT THE DEPARTMENT

01:50 - 28.370 OF REVENUE HAS MADE HERE.

01:50 - 31.909 REJECTED THE ARGUMENT THAT THE

01:50 - 32.640 STATE UNDER

01:50 - 34.809 AN EXCEPTION. AND THAT IT WOULD

01:50 - 36.549 HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE

01:50 - 38.170 PROCESSES OF THE BOARD FEELS

01:50 - 40.929 FINANCE TO YOU AND THAT THE

01:50 - 43.129 DETERMINATION WAS THERE FOR AND

01:50 - 44.830 EDUCATION THAT COULD HEAR IT.

01:50 - 49.079 HE DIDN'T JUST CASE. A COURT

01:50 - 50.959 DID NOT HOLD THAT THE ONLY

01:50 - 52.960 REMEDY FOR THE TERMINATION.

01:50 - 56.299 NOW THE TAX CREDIT WAS TO

01:50 - 57.090 SIMPLY TAKE THE

01:50 - 00.059 TAX CREDIT AND TO THEN FILE AN

01:51 - 01.489 AMENDED RETURN THEM

01:51 - 04.099 TO CHOW IF THIS IS THE ARGUMENT

01:51 - 05.319 THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE

01:51 - 07.269 STRAIGHT YEAR. IF THE ONLY

01:51 - 09.569 MEANS OF CHALLENGING THE

01:51 - 12.119 DECISION ON A TAX CREDIT, ITS

01:51 - 14.659 TO 10 IN CREDIT. IF I HAD A

01:51 - 16.729 MEDICAL OR THE DEPARTMENT OF

01:51 - 18.090 REVENUE WITHIN CHALLENGE THAT.

01:51 - 20.109 AND WHEN THAT PROCESS WAS

01:51 - 21.110 CHALLENGE.

01:51 - 22.749 IT WOULD THEN GO THROUGH THE

01:51 - 23.850 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE'S

01:51 - 26.329 MISTER PROCESS I'M GOING TO THE

01:51 - 28.129 BOARD OF APPEALS AND THEN TO

01:51 - 29.450 THE FINANCE WILL GET.

01:51 - 31.789 >>WELL THE GOVERNOR SAID IN

01:51 - 34.560 PART FROM POSITION IS THAT IF.

01:51 - 36.539 YOU DO NOT

01:51 - 38.899 LIKE THE DETERMINATION ARE YOUR

01:51 - 39.390 TECH

01:51 - 41.849 CREDIT. WHETHER ON AMERICA HER

01:51 - 43.869 BECAUSE IT WAS ON TIMELY FILED

01:51 - 45.180 COURT IN THE DEPARTMENT.

01:51 - 47.270 >>YOU'RE ONLY GREAT FOR

01:51 - 50.469 IF THE TAKE THE TAX CREDIT WHEN

01:51 - 53.709 YOU FILE YOUR TAX RETURN AND

01:51 - 55.409 HOPE THAT THE CAMA WILL NOT

01:51 - 57.160 PURSUE YOU. 4.

01:52 - 03.989 HER CAREER TO PAY THE TAX AND

01:52 - 05.570 ALSO PURSUE YOUR PRE PENALTIES

01:52 - 08.649 >>CORRECT AS MY UNDERSTANDING

01:52 - 08.728 OF

01:52 - 09.729 APARTMENTS POSITION.

01:52 - 11.189 >>WELL THE THE WELL THE DOOR

01:52 - 12.749 AFTER THE FACT RIGHT HERE TO BE

01:52 - 13.210 THERE YOU WOULD

01:52 - 15.329 THEY DO IN FACT IT'S ALREADY

01:52 - 16.569 BEEN PAID WHAT YOU'RE APPLYING

01:52 - 17.759 FOR YOU TO ACTUALLY FILE AN

01:52 - 19.130 AMENDED RETURN FOR A CRACK.

01:52 - 21.139 THAT WOULD BE A FIRE ALL YEAR.

01:52 - 22.399 SO IT'S NOT THAT YOU'RE ASKING

01:52 - 24.179 FOR WITHHOLDING MONEY FROM THE

01:52 - 25.219 GOVERNMENT HERE TO THANK YOU

01:52 - 26.599 WANT TO CREDIT 100 PATRIOT ACT

01:52 - 27.640 THAT BECAUSE YOU OVERPAID.

01:52 - 30.070 >>THAT IS MY UNDERSTANDING

01:52 - 31.969 OF HOW THE DEPARTMENT HAS

01:52 - 33.129 SUGGESTED THAT WILL BE THE

01:52 - 34.250 CORRECT PROCEDURE TO FOLLOW.

01:52 - 36.749 >>NOW NOW GOING BACK TO THE

01:52 - 38.790 QUESTION OR OUR JURISDICTION.

01:52 - 40.919 YOU HAVE A DETERMINATION THAT

01:52 - 41.920 YOU'RE OUT OF TIME WITH THE

01:52 - 43.919 NUMBER 1520 17 WITHOUT AN

01:52 - 44.920 EDUCATION.

01:52 - 46.840 >>AND I BELIEVE THAT WAS AN

01:52 - 47.950 EDUCATION THAT'S.

01:52 - 49.480 >>IF THAT WOULD NEED YOU TO

01:52 - 51.249 CATION YOU HAD TO APPEAL THAT

01:52 - 52.250 WITHIN 30 DAYS.

01:52 - 54.509 >>CORRECT AND AND JEN

01:52 - 56.709 TAXES POSITION IN THIS CASE IS

01:52 - 57.949 THAT THE COURT SHOULD EXERCISE

01:52 - 00.309 JURISDICTION ON TOP. DESPITE

01:53 - 02.109 THE LATE FILING TO

01:53 - 03.729 THIS COURT WHICH WOULD MAKE IT

01:53 - 05.080 ACCESSIBLE 50 DAYS.

01:53 - 08.620 IF THERE IS NO CLEAR RULES

01:53 - 10.729 SUMMIT BY

01:53 - 12.799 THE TAXPAYER. IT'S A CLEAR

01:53 - 14.979 UNDERSTANDING OF HOW TO HEAL

01:53 - 16.530 THE NATION ON TAX CREDIT.

01:53 - 19.029 >>AND IF IT CONTINUED OCCASION,

01:53 - 20.099 THE ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY

01:53 - 21.120 LOCKOUT BEHIND A LOOK.

01:53 - 25.539 >>I AGREE THAT IT DOES HOWEVER

01:53 - 27.710 IN THE CASE OF THE TAXPAYER.

01:53 - 30.439 >>WHO RECEIVES IS ENTITLED TO

01:53 - 32.029 RECEIVE CLEAR COMMUNICATIONS

01:53 - 33.400 FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE

01:53 - 35.160 REGARDING ITS RIGHTS.

01:53 - 39.879 I BELIEVE IT NEEDS TO IT NEEDS

01:53 - 41.139 TO ACTUALLY BE NOTIFICATION

01:53 - 43.129 REGARDING IMPROPER WAY OF

01:53 - 44.290 TIMING OF THAT APPEAL.

01:53 - 46.679 AND THAT IS IF IT DEPARTMENT

01:53 - 48.779 TELL YOU IN THE IN THE IN THE

01:53 - 50.839 MEMBER 15TH, 2017 LETTER TO

01:53 - 52.969 TAKE YOUR APPEAL TO THE BOARD

01:53 - 53.470 OF FINANCE AND

01:53 - 54.470 REVENUE PROCESS.

01:53 - 56.439 >>IN THE DECEMBER 15TH WHERE A

01:53 - 57.320 SILENT ON WHAT

01:53 - 59.819 TO DO. IF THERE'S A SIMPLE SAYS

01:53 - 02.429 ITS THEMED WAY. AND THAT

01:54 - 03.430 IS IT.

01:54 - 06.539 THE WHEN THE JULY 2 LETTER CAME

01:54 - 08.889 DOWN THAT THAT WAS IN RESPONSE

01:54 - 10.249 TO THE PETITION TO THE COURT OF

01:54 - 12.179 APPEALS. IT WAS SUBMITTED IN

01:54 - 13.930 FEBRUARY AND THAT WAS WITH IN

01:54 - 16.059 THE 60 DAY PERIOD TO MAKE A

01:54 - 17.169 SUBMISSION TO THE COURT OF

01:54 - 20.129 APPEALS IMPORTANT JOB RESPONDED

01:54 - 21.130 WITH.

01:54 - 22.719 WE DON'T HAVE JURISDICTION OVER

01:54 - 24.029 THIS MATTER BECAUSE IT WAS

01:54 - 26.329 FILED LATE. IT IS A BIG

01:54 - 28.729 DECEMBER 15TH. A LETTER WAS A

01:54 - 31.179 5 TO TERMINATION AND THEREFORE

01:54 - 32.689 YOUR RECOURSE IS TO GO TO THE

01:54 - 34.309 COMMONWEALTH COURT BY A 5 TO

01:54 - 37.249 SHOOT IT. FOR YOUR POSITION AND

01:54 - 37.420 YOUR

01:54 - 38.450 POSITION IS.

01:54 - 40.849 >>IT'S THE ONLY WAY WE CAN

01:54 - 42.279 EXERCISE JURISDICTION OR SHOULD

01:54 - 43.629 EXERCISE JURISDICTION IN THE

01:54 - 45.780 CASE BY RANTANEN PRO PROPERLY.

01:54 - 47.949 >>AND YOUR BABY TURN ON

01:54 - 49.560 NEGLIGENCE OR CAN DANCE TO.

01:54 - 52.959 IT IS A DEPARTMENT IN TELL YOU

01:54 - 54.509 WHERE TO GO IN THE TOP 15

01:54 - 56.919 LETTER OR IT WAS UNCLEAR WHERE

01:54 - 57.920 TO GO.

01:54 - 01.409 >>IT IS MY POSITION IS

01:55 - 02.889 THAT IT IS UNCLEAR WHERE TO GO

01:55 - 03.959 FOR THE AVERAGE TAX THE

01:55 - 06.449 TAXPAYER IN THIS POSITION AND

01:55 - 08.020 GIVEN THE DEPARTMENTS,

01:55 - 10.789 A PRACTICE OF SENDING LETTERS

01:55 - 13.049 TELLING TAXPAYERS. I WOULD FEEL

01:55 - 13.870 THEIR RIGHTS WHICH IS

01:55 - 16.389 CONSISTENT WITH A TAXPAYER BILL

01:55 - 17.889 OF RIGHTS WHICH GUARANTEES

01:55 - 20.509 THEIR COMMUNICATION. I THINK

01:55 - 22.259 THAT THE ALLEGATION HAS TO BE A

01:55 - 23.240 PERMANENT FOR EVERYONE, THIS

01:55 - 25.009 TYPE OF CIRCUMSTANCE IS TO

01:55 - 28.209 PROVIDE. NATION AND I THINK

01:55 - 30.429 THAT BECOMES HIGHLIGHTED THE

01:55 - 31.719 UNCERTAINTY TO

01:55 - 34.349 THE TAXPAYER. IT WAS ON THE

01:55 - 35.939 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE'S OWN

01:55 - 37.159 ACTIONS IN THE CASE THEN

01:55 - 40.019 SHIFTING POSITIONS IN WHEN IT

01:55 - 41.660 FIRST RAISED THE

01:55 - 43.829 JURISDICTION, ALICIA. THE

01:55 - 45.429 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE STATED

01:55 - 47.589 THAT IT WAS SIMPLY A MATTER JEN

01:55 - 48.590 TEXTING WAIT

01:55 - 50.649 DECEMBER 15TH. A LETTER WAS AN

01:55 - 53.189 EDUCATION AT 30 DAYS THAT MISS

01:55 - 54.190 THAT.

01:55 - 56.309 IN RESPONSE TO A MOTION FOR

01:55 - 57.839 EVIDENTIARY HEARING IN THIS

01:55 - 58.840 CASE.

01:56 - 01.559 >>DRY COUGH. I'M SORRY TO

01:56 - 02.719 INTERRUPT I JUST WANT TO MAKE

01:56 - 03.680 SURE I UNDERSTAND THAT

01:56 - 05.259 TIMETABLE WHEN YOU GOT THE

01:56 - 07.150 LETTER IN SEPTEMBER.

01:56 - 09.329 BUT YOU'RE NOT GETTING THE PACK

01:56 - 10.999 CREDIT BECAUSE IT WAS TOO LATE

01:56 - 12.559 HERE THEM FILED WITH THE COURT

01:56 - 13.560 OF APPEAL.

01:56 - 16.489 >>KNOW THAT THAT'S YOU KNOW

01:56 - 17.490 THAT'S NOT CORRECT THE

01:56 - 20.280 SEPTEMBER LETTER IN SEPTEMBER

01:56 - 22.539 LETTER NOTIFIED

01:56 - 24.499 JEN TAX THAT APPLICATION.

01:56 - 25.709 THE RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT TAX

01:56 - 27.580 CREDIT IS DUE IN SEPTEMBER 15.

01:56 - 32.059 JENNER RESPONDED BY SUBMITTING

01:56 - 33.449 APPLICATIONS DEPARTMENT OF

01:56 - 34.899 REVENUE THAT WOULD NOT HAVE

01:56 - 35.900 BEEN SUPPORTIVE OF.

01:56 - 39.180 >>AND WHAT I'M

01:56 - 41.609 WHAT I'M BY 1215 LETTER WITH

01:56 - 42.739 THE LETTER FROM THE DEPARTMENT

01:56 - 44.679 DENY YOUR REQUEST FOR THE TAX

01:56 - 46.190 CREDIT IS ON TIME RIGHT.

01:56 - 47.320 >>CORRECT.

01:56 - 49.879 >>AND YOUR ARGUMENT IS THAT

01:56 - 50.880 THAT LETTER.

01:56 - 52.729 SHOULD HAVE INCLUDED A

01:56 - 54.369 STATEMENT ON WHERE THE

01:56 - 55.979 CHALLENGE THAT THE TERMINATION

01:56 - 57.669 OF UNTIMELY DEATH UNDER THE

01:56 - 58.670 TAXPAYER BILL OF RIGHTS.

01:56 - 00.430 >>YES.

01:57 - 05.009 >>WHAT YOU DID WHEN YOU GOT THE

01:57 - 07.699 DECEMBER 15 LETTER REPEALED TO

01:57 - 08.720 THE BOARD OF APPEAL.

01:57 - 10.749 IF YOU DIDN'T GET ANY CONTRARY

01:57 - 12.909 AND TRUCKS YOU APPEAL TO THE

01:57 - 13.910 BOARD OF APPEAL.

01:57 - 16.149 >>CORRECT AGENDA ACTS AS A HAT

01:57 - 18.379 WITH OTHER TAX MATTERS TO YOU

01:57 - 20.659 AND YOU GET THAT WITHIN 30 DAYS

01:57 - 21.660 OF RECEIPT.

01:57 - 23.590 >>IT WAS WITHIN 60 DAYS.

01:57 - 25.230 YOU ARE WHICH IS NOT THAT ONE

01:57 - 26.650 FOR MAKING SUCH A SUBMISSION.

01:57 - 30.460 OKAY, ALL RIGHT. I'M LIKE THAT.

01:57 - 32.889 THANK YOU. NO IT'S OKAY I HAVE

01:57 - 34.819 MYSELF GOTTEN, YEAH, THE

01:57 - 36.210 DIFFERENT FORMS CONFUSED.

01:57 - 39.369 AND SO WHAT YOU CAN TEXT A

01:57 - 40.819 PLACE IT FILED THE APPEAL

01:57 - 41.820 PROCESS.

01:57 - 43.949 BASED ON ITS OWN UNDERSTANDING

01:57 - 46.359 OF HOW TO APPEAL AND AT THAT AS

01:57 - 47.370 IT HAD IN THE PAST.

01:57 - 51.569 AND NOW WE WANT TO GO BACK TO

01:57 - 52.760 YOUR QUITE WAS WRONG.

01:57 - 59.449 AND SO IT IS NOT NEGLIGENCE

01:57 - 01.399 BECAUSE THERE'S NO CLEAR A

01:58 - 03.879 STATUE 2 STATUES RULE. IT

01:58 - 05.659 PROVIDED EXACTLY HOW TAXPAYERS

01:58 - 06.990 CLOSE TO HANDLE THE SITUATION

01:58 - 09.040 AND THAT IT WOULD REQUIRE.

01:58 - 12.749 AND HALEY AMERICA'S TYPICALLY

01:58 - 14.979 NOT HANDLED BY ATTORNEYS FIGHT

01:58 - 17.919 HAPPENS AND BUT BUT I. KNOWING

01:58 - 19.319 UNDERSTAND THE DECISION OF THE

01:58 - 20.769 CAPITAL. THIS WAS A

01:58 - 21.999 DETERMINATION THAT COULD ONLY

01:58 - 25.319 GO THROUGH. 2 TO 4 DECISION

01:58 - 28.299 FOR YOU AND WHERE IN FACT IS

01:58 - 28.770 THE DEPARTMENT

01:58 - 30.349 OF REVENUE. IT PROVIDES

01:58 - 31.859 INSTRUCTIONS TO PARTIES THAT

01:58 - 34.059 HOW TO PROPERLY FIELD AND JUST

01:58 - 35.420 A CHALLENGE TO THE NATION'S.

01:58 - 44.379 AND I SUBMIT THAT HE GRAB A NEW

01:58 - 45.929 POSITION IN THIS CASE, THE ONLY

01:58 - 50.019 REMEDY AND GO TO. I THINK THE

01:58 - 51.269 FISCAL CROWD. IT

01:58 - 53.719 SIMPLY IS NOT DOES NOT MAKE ANY

01:58 - 55.789 SENSE IT AND IT'S ON

01:58 - 58.390 TRACK TO A PROPER RESOLUTION.

01:58 - 00.540 HANDLING AT THIS TIME AT.

01:59 - 02.430 REGARDING THE

01:59 - 05.119 ISSUE OF WELL AS FOR JACKSON IS

01:59 - 06.449 PREPARING SOME ARE HIGH.

01:59 - 07.590 BUT THE DEPARTMENT.

01:59 - 09.410 >>WELL AFTER ALL RIGHT HERE.

01:59 - 14.529 >>FAME QUESTION. WHAT IS THE

01:59 - 16.259 TYPICAL COLD REMEDY, BUT THE

01:59 - 17.839 COMPARTMENT, THANKS YOU SHOULD

01:59 - 18.840 HAVE HURT HIM.

01:59 - 22.369 >>I WAS A LOUD COUNCIL TRACKING

01:59 - 23.890 MY UNDERSTANDING BASED ON THAT

01:59 - 26.310 FIRE GUTS IN THIS CASE IS THAT.

01:59 - 28.540 >>IRAN THAT HE WOULD HAVE BEEN.

01:59 - 32.119 >>EITHER FILE IN IT, SO THEN

01:59 - 34.529 AMENDED RETURN. BOARD AMENDED

01:59 - 36.539 REPORT OF SOME KIND WHICH WOULD

01:59 - 38.480 THEN INCREASE CREDIT ITSELF.

01:59 - 42.459 THE DEPARTMENT FOR THAT CONTEST

01:59 - 44.689 THAT. IT WILL NOT ALLOW

01:59 - 45.690 THE AMENDMENT.

01:59 - 49.009 GENENTECH'S WITH THAT SHOW

01:59 - 51.389 THAT DETERMINATION THROUGH THE

01:59 - 52.809 MORE TYPICAL THE PARTNER RATHER

01:59 - 54.129 THAN A STRAIGHT A PROCESS WHICH

01:59 - 55.340 WOULD BE THE BOARD OF APPEALS.

01:59 - 57.759 FINANCE FOR YOU AND THAT COULD

01:59 - 58.920 EVENTUALLY GET TO THIS POINT.

02:00 - 04.030 REGARDING

02:00 - 07.039 WEATHER TOO. A BRAND NEW PRO

02:00 - 08.969 TRUMP REALLY THE DEPARTMENT HAS

02:00 - 10.160 MADE THE ARGUMENT THAT

02:00 - 11.669 NO PERCENT BELIEVE IT IS NOT

02:00 - 14.250 APPROPRIATE IN TAX SITUATIONS

02:00 - 16.409 BECAUSE OF THE BRIDGE IS NATURE

02:00 - 18.049 OF THE STATUTORY CODE AND TO

02:00 - 20.479 ALLOW THIS PLANET AND I WANT TO

02:00 - 21.819 POINT OUT THAT THAT IS NOT THE

02:00 - 22.920 CASE AND THAT

02:00 - 25.479 IN PRIOR INSTANCES THAT SO MANY

02:00 - 26.250 PORTS, INCLUDING THE

02:00 - 28.079 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT AND

02:00 - 29.120 ALLOW FOR

02:00 - 30.869 GRANTING THE FIRST TIME REALLY

02:00 - 33.000 IN TAX MATTERS SPECIFICALLY

02:00 - 35.319 UNION ELECTRIC CORPORATION FOR

02:00 - 36.339 SUPPORTIVE OF PROPERTY

02:00 - 38.699 ASSESSMENT APPEALS ABOUT IN

02:00 - 42.350 COUNTY. AND IN THAT CASE LOCAL

02:00 - 44.199 PROPERTY BOARD ALLOWED FOR AN

02:00 - 45.519 EXTENSION OF TIME FOR A

02:00 - 47.269 CHALLENGE. STOPPARD

02:00 - 48.270 ASSESSMENTS.

02:00 - 50.769 THE ELEPHANT CHALLENGE

02:00 - 52.269 ASSESSMENT AND TOOK IT TO

02:00 - 53.799 TRIAL. THE

02:00 - 56.079 TRIAL COURT. THAT THE

02:00 - 57.289 LOCAL BOARD DID NOT HAVE THE

02:00 - 58.499 AUTHORITY TO EXTEND THE DEBT

02:00 - 00.109 CLOCK AND THAT'S THE CURE WAS

02:01 - 01.110 LATE.

02:01 - 02.539 THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

02:01 - 04.259 ARE HOLDING THAT WHILE THE

02:01 - 05.329 LOCAL BOARD DID NOT HAVE

02:01 - 07.059 THAT AUTHORITY. IT WOULD BE

02:01 - 09.129 PATENTLY UNJUST UNFAIR TO NOW

02:01 - 10.130 TO THE KNOT.

02:01 - 12.509 THAT AND SEE ITS RIGHT TO

02:01 - 13.810 CHALLENGE THAT DETERMINATION.

02:01 - 16.609 AND SO THIS THIS TYPE OF RELIEF

02:01 - 17.969 IS POSSIBLE IN THIS IN THE

02:01 - 19.879 INSTANCES OF THE TAX CODE AND

02:01 - 20.880 IT'S NOT.

02:01 - 23.310 A

02:01 - 24.310 COUNCIL ESTATE.

02:01 - 26.249 >>TERRIFIED BY UNDERSTAND THIS

02:01 - 27.250 ISSUE AND THEN.

02:01 - 30.499 YOU AGREE THAT THE SEPTEMBER

02:01 - 32.090 LETTER WAS AN EDUCATION

02:01 - 34.699 BUT BECAUSE IT IT TO TO SO

02:01 - 36.510 UNDER BILLIE JEAN C LAW.

02:01 - 39.329 IT WILL BE HERE TO

02:01 - 41.969 TELL COURT. BUT FOR THE FACT

02:01 - 43.719 THAT YOU'RE SEEING IT HAD TO

02:01 - 44.250 HAVE.

02:01 - 47.349 >>AND HE PARAGRAPH NOTIFY YOU

02:01 - 49.289 WHO WRITE TO HIM TO COME OFF

02:01 - 49.570 COURT.

02:01 - 51.119 >>SOME KIND OF LANGUAGE LIKE

02:01 - 53.530 THEY HAD IN NEED IN JULY.

02:01 - 57.760 >>ESSENTIALLY YES THAT WHERE

02:01 - 59.889 AND THERE'S THE TAXPAYER BILL

02:01 - 01.570 OF RIGHTS THAT PROVIDES FOR

02:02 - 02.809 SOME FORM OF CLEAR

02:02 - 05.419 COMMUNICATION. THE DECEMBER

02:02 - 07.089 LETTER IT PROVIDED NO

02:02 - 09.359 INFORMATION WHATSOEVER WHEN IT

02:02 - 10.180 IS THE PRACTICE OF THE

02:02 - 11.289 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE TO

02:02 - 12.660 PROVIDE THIS INFORMATION.

02:02 - 15.129 SO THAT APPEALS TO ME MADE AND

02:02 - 17.059 PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT IN THIS

02:02 - 18.829 TYPE OF INSTANCE BECAUSE

02:02 - 19.830 IT'S NOT

02:02 - 23.209 A TERMINATION THROUGH THE

02:02 - 23.630 DEPARTMENT

02:02 - 25.359 OF REVENUE'S TYPICAL

02:02 - 26.729 ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TO THE

02:02 - 29.179 STANDARD PROCESS. IT KIND OF

02:02 - 31.469 DETERMINATION BY THE DEPARTMENT

02:02 - 32.889 OF REVENUE IS THE BOARD OF

02:02 - 34.309 APPEALS COURT OF APPEALS AND

02:02 - 35.349 THE BOARD OF FIRE AND SMOKE

02:02 - 35.600 CRACK

02:02 - 37.839 A NUT IT'S SOMETHING OUTSIDE OF

02:02 - 39.279 YOUR MARRIAGE AND THEREFORE I

02:02 - 40.579 BELIEVE THE ALLEGATIONS SHOULD

02:02 - 42.939 NOT REVENUE. IT IS

02:02 - 44.379 DONE PROPERLY. IT SHOULD

02:02 - 45.620 PROVIDE SOME INFORMATION TO THE

02:02 - 49.219 >>DID YOU HAVE ANY OPPORTUNITY

02:02 - 50.649 REALLY HARD TO DEVELOP A

02:02 - 51.650 RECORD.

02:02 - 56.489 WE WERE GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY

02:02 - 57.290 TO DEVELOP THE RECORD YOUR

02:02 - 59.409 HONOR I INITIALLY THE

02:02 - 01.610 STIPULATIONS OF FACT THE TREE.

02:03 - 05.639 MY TIME IS NOW UP MOST OF ANY

02:03 - 06.640 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS.

02:03 - 08.719 >>IF YOU'RE COMMITTED THE 5TH

02:03 - 09.720 ELATION.

02:03 - 11.460 >>IF YOU WANT RIGHT NOW.

02:03 - 14.059 THAT WAS TO GET ON BOARD OF

02:03 - 16.330 APPEALS. THE STABILITY.

02:03 - 18.930 IT WAS

02:03 - 21.259 SUBMITTED TO THE TO

02:03 - 23.639 THE SCORE. FOR THE COURT THAT'S

02:03 - 24.640 RIGHT. IT'S OK.

02:03 - 30.899 >>ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU YOU HAVE

02:03 - 32.240 YOUR ALL RIGHT.

02:03 - 39.929 >>MADE THE COURT CAN YOU HEAR

02:03 - 40.930 ME.

02:03 - 45.949 I'M WITH THAT GENERAL IN HERE

02:03 - 47.059 ON BEHALF OF THE DEPARTMENT OF

02:03 - 48.060 REVENUE.

02:03 - 49.550 ALTHOUGH THERE ARE A

02:03 - 52.179 NUMBER THE BUT I WILL PRESENT

02:03 - 53.539 THEIR IP ONE THING THAT WE CAN

02:03 - 56.059 AGREE ON IS WHAT THE TAX BILL

02:03 - 57.930 OF RIGHTS SAYS IT SAYS THAT.

02:03 - 01.539 IF THE PARTY

02:04 - 03.699 DID THERE EAR BUT THE FAILURE

02:04 - 04.770 OF AN APARTMENT

02:04 - 09.750 THAT I EVER ANY BACK TO GO.

02:04 - 11.769 WE CAN'T FIND ANY OTHER EVEN TO

02:04 - 14.149 THE LAW IN SHALL NOT FOR ANY

02:04 - 15.439 PERCEIVED TO BE BACK IN A

02:04 - 16.940 MINUTE LATER THE CITY

02:04 - 21.549 IMPORTANT BECAUSE ITS NEXT

02:04 - 24.229 LEADER HAS SPOKEN TO GET BACK

02:04 - 25.230 HOME.

02:04 - 27.319 I MEAN YOU GO UP INTO THE

02:04 - 28.649 TERMINATION OF WHETHER OR NOT

02:04 - 30.410 THIS COURT HAS JURISDICTION.

02:04 - 35.460 I THINK ONE OF THE NET.

02:04 - 38.030 I DESERVE TO BE THAT.

02:04 - 43.469 WE NEVER HEAR THAT THE LAST

02:04 - 44.539 THING A LOT OF FACTS THAT ARE

02:04 - 45.689 HERE ALL THE PARTIES

02:04 - 47.369 STIMULATION IDENTIFIED YOU

02:04 - 49.439 COULD USE IT DOCUMENTS BAD

02:04 - 51.780 ACTUALLY IN EXCHANGE HERE.

02:04 - 54.360 IT TALKS ABOUT HOW THE.

02:04 - 56.879 APPLICATION FOR RESEARCH AND

02:04 - 58.800 DEVELOPMENT CREDIT. IT WAS NOT.

02:04 - 02.880 IF UNTIL SEPTEMBER 1820

02:05 - 05.019 I 70 AND THAT'S IMPORTANT

02:05 - 06.599 BECAUSE THE STATUTE. THE

02:05 - 07.830 DEPARTMENT'S REGULATION.

02:05 - 11.579 IF WE CAN DEVELOP CREDIT IN

02:05 - 11.810 EACH

02:05 - 15.020 OF THE IF YOU OR YOUR FAMILY,

02:05 - 17.079 IF SCHOOLS IN THE STATE THAT AN

02:05 - 18.460 APPLICATION MUST BE FILED.

02:05 - 21.099 I THINK THE KEY HERE THAT CAN

02:05 - 22.400 HAPPEN IN THAT FUNNY TO YOU.

02:05 - 24.830 THE TAXPAYERS NOW HOPING TO DO

02:05 - 26.170 IT IS YOU

02:05 - 29.880 AN ALLEGATION TO.

02:05 - 35.890 ITS SUCCESSOR CAN DO THAT TOO.

02:05 - 41.949 GRANT FROM OUR DO YOU NEED TO

02:05 - 43.749 SUBMIT THE APPLICATION ON OR

02:05 - 44.840 DEPARTMENT FORM.

02:05 - 48.650 >>AND BY THAT IS WHY BY THE.

02:05 - 51.390 A DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE

02:05 - 54.790 IN A POLICY UNDER 61 SECTION

02:05 - 56.230 9.1 7.

02:05 - 00.510 >>IF THEY DON'T HAVE

02:06 - 02.109 THE FORM HOW DO THEY GET THE

02:06 - 02.940 FORM THERE

02:06 - 03.940 ON TIME.

02:06 - 06.489 >>THE ONLY AVAILABLE ONE FROM

02:06 - 07.330 THE WEST SIDE.

02:06 - 09.959 IT ALSO. THE STATUE ITSELF

02:06 - 12.099 EXPLICITLY SAID THAT THEY HAVE

02:06 - 15.509 TO BUY ABOUT 15. SO IF THEY

02:06 - 17.329 DIDN'T HAVE BEFORE EXPECTING

02:06 - 18.330 THAT NO.

02:06 - 22.089 I LIKE WHAT HE DID BUT IT IS IT

02:06 - 23.260 DID NOT HAVE ONE

02:06 - 24.599 AND THEY WOULD STILL HAVE A

02:06 - 26.470 DUTY TO FILE THEIR APPLICATION.

02:06 - 28.120 I CAN'T GET IT DONE WITH IT.

02:06 - 31.069 YEARS PRIOR TO THAT. BUT I

02:06 - 32.339 THINK THAT HIGHLIGHTS ONE OF

02:06 - 33.340 THE ISSUES HERE

02:06 - 35.719 THAT ERECTING DOESN'T SUPPORT

02:06 - 36.859 THEIR CLAIMS WE HAD AN

02:06 - 38.799 OPPORTUNITY TO DEVELOP THOSE

02:06 - 39.969 BACK AND THEY'RE NOT PART OF

02:06 - 40.970 THAT.

02:06 - 44.910 WHILE THERE WAS

02:06 - 47.019 AN AFFIDAVIT THAT WAS SUBMITTED

02:06 - 48.689 TO THE COURT OF APPEAL THAT IS

02:06 - 49.879 NOT PART OF ACTING THERE ARE

02:06 - 53.249 SOME. WE CAN WHY DID YOU PUT

02:06 - 55.469 THAT ALL TO LEAVE. THAT IS

02:06 - 57.060 ENTIRELY IRRELEVANT.

02:06 - 00.089 A SUPREME COURT THEY DID IN

02:07 - 01.090 QUEST DIAGNOSTICS

02:07 - 03.659 2.16. BUT WHAT A BULL RACING

02:07 - 05.089 CANNOT BE USED TO EXTEND THE

02:07 - 08.269 TIME PERIOD IN AN AVERAGE OF

02:07 - 11.899 ONE POINT HAVE A HOLLY HUGHES

02:07 - 12.900 OUT HOW.

02:07 - 14.779 >>THERE HAS BEEN PRIOR CASES

02:07 - 16.389 THAT HE'S NOT FROM SOME

02:07 - 17.770 VARIATION TO EXTEND VIOLENT.

02:07 - 20.349 IN THE CASE IN OUR SIGHT OF

02:07 - 22.799 WHAT HE DECIDED HE DIDN'T WEAR

02:07 - 24.669 ALL RELATE TO LOCAL PROPERTY

02:07 - 25.670 TAXES.

02:07 - 26.170 >>I

02:07 - 28.349 MISTER BAUER. YEAH, THE

02:07 - 30.239 QUESTION YOU'RE A LOCAL PACK, I

02:07 - 31.380 MEAN THE THE ATTACK.

02:07 - 38.809 MY QUESTION IS NOT WHETHER OR

02:07 - 41.989 NOT A TAXPAYER IN

02:07 - 45.559 THE CASE. IN NEWS THAT AND FILE

02:07 - 46.600 AN UNTIMELY

02:07 - 49.929 APPLICATION TIME. MY QUESTION

02:07 - 51.400 YOU IS THAT

02:07 - 54.659 OR GIVE THE BENEFIT OF THE

02:07 - 57.169 TAX PAYER, THE REQUIREMENT OF

02:07 - 58.689 THE DEPARTMENT TO SET UP A

02:07 - 01.129 MINISTRY THAT WHEN THEY MAKE OF

02:08 - 02.650 THE NILE THE TYPE ATTACK.

02:08 - 07.399 MY UNDERSTANDING OF YOUR YOUR

02:08 - 09.329 QUIET CONDITION OF THE DO NOT

02:08 - 09.640 HAVE

02:08 - 11.789 THE POWER. YOU HAVE A MINISTRY

02:08 - 13.199 TO PROFIT FROM THE DEPARTMENT

02:08 - 14.789 OF REVENUE WHEN THEY DENY THE

02:08 - 16.269 TAX CREDIT IS

02:08 - 18.619 THAT FAIR EDITOR'S NATION OF

02:08 - 20.789 YOUR CLIENT'S POSITION. IT

02:08 - 22.509 ISN'T THERE AND REALLY I THINK

02:08 - 23.869 THE LEGISLATURE HAS SAID HE

02:08 - 25.290 NEEDED 3 TO 6.

02:08 - 26.480 >>PROCESS

02:08 - 32.560 MAY BE TOO GREAT NEWS OR TAKE

02:08 - 35.489 EARLY ON A NIGHT OF WITH I I I

02:08 - 37.309 I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU THINK THE

02:08 - 39.040 REMEDY YEARS WHICH I FIND.

02:08 - 42.399 >>A PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE YOU'RE

02:08 - 44.039 EITHER YOU'RE YOU'RE DEFYING

02:08 - 45.889 THE DEPARTMENT NO MATTER WHICH

02:08 - 46.300 PATH

02:08 - 48.579 YOU PICK THEY THEN USED THE

02:08 - 49.699 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE SENT A

02:08 - 51.169 LETTER AND SAID WE'RE NOT GOING

02:08 - 52.889 TO GIVE YOU THE TAX CREDIT AND

02:08 - 54.579 THEN YOU'RE AN IDIOT. THE

02:08 - 56.769 TAXPAYER HAS THE PIE. THE

02:08 - 58.689 DEPARTMENT ONE OF 2 DIFFERENT

02:08 - 00.939 WAYS EITHER SEEK A REFUND OR BY

02:09 - 01.940 THE TAX CREDIT.

02:09 - 04.939 ON AN AMENDED AND THEN MOVE

02:09 - 07.470 FORWARD AND THEN IF YOU FIT.

02:09 - 08.850 WITH THE

02:09 - 10.439 DEPARTMENT AFTER THE DEPARTMENT

02:09 - 11.839 HAS ALREADY SAID THEY'RE NOT

02:09 - 13.100 GOING TO GRANT TAX CREDIT.

02:09 - 16.109 MY REAL QUESTION IS WHY DID THE

02:09 - 19.669 TAXPAYER. NOT ALLOW

02:09 - 21.429 THE DEPARTMENT ALL SET

02:09 - 23.909 UP A PROCESS TO REVIEW THE TYPE

02:09 - 24.540 OF PLANE.

02:09 - 26.579 IF YOU CAN ADMINISTRATIVELY GO

02:09 - 28.159 THROUGH PROCESS. ONE THAT YOU

02:09 - 29.509 WOULD HAVE GONE THROUGH

02:09 - 32.089 IT YOU IF THE TAXPAYER WITH FOR

02:09 - 33.909 THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND GO ONE

02:09 - 35.459 OF 2 DIFFERENT WAY THAT I DO

02:09 - 37.879 THAT WHY CAN'T THE DEPARTMENT

02:09 - 40.689 HAD ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS BY

02:09 - 42.929 THE TAXPAYER BILL OF RIGHTS SET

02:09 - 44.609 THAT UP AND THEREFORE

02:09 - 46.990 THEN WE AND THEN WE CLEAN THAT

02:09 - 50.379 AND MY UNDERSTANDING FROM WORK

02:09 - 51.739 TO OTHER DEPARTMENTS THAT

02:09 - 54.109 ADMINISTER A TAX CREDIT TO THE

02:09 - 56.279 B B AND REGARDLESS OF

02:09 - 58.119 THE LEGISLATIVE INTENT THAT WAY

02:09 - 59.879 WE WOULD KNOW A FINAL

02:09 - 01.470 DETERMINATION FROM THE FOREMAN

02:10 - 02.969 WE WOULD THEN GET THE APPEAL

02:10 - 05.399 FROM THE COMMONWEALTH COURT AND

02:10 - 06.509 WE'RE NOT GOING TO HAVE THE

02:10 - 08.879 TAPE ON BATCH. GOING BACK

02:10 - 10.529 AND FORTH. I READ THE TAX

02:10 - 13.800 PAYER. IT WILL DRY. WOW

02:10 - 15.529 THE DEPARTMENT TO

02:10 - 17.819 HAVE THE SET UP PROCESS IN

02:10 - 19.639 ORDER TO BENEFIT THE TAXPAYERS

02:10 - 22.259 WHO WANTED TO YOU. A CLAIM ON

02:10 - 24.749 NOT GETTING. A GRANTING OF THE

02:10 - 25.750 TAX CREDIT.

02:10 - 28.750 >>IN I UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION.

02:10 - 31.389 I THINK IS WHETHER OR NOT IM

02:10 - 31.770 NOT GOING

02:10 - 34.159 TO DO. RATING BY THE ARMY HAS

02:10 - 35.559 THE AUTHORITY TO CREATE

02:10 - 37.130 ESSENTIALLY A TASK OR.

02:10 - 39.439 SHE WILL LIKELY NOT ATTACKED

02:10 - 41.059 ACCORDING TO THE MINISTRY TO

02:10 - 42.060 PROFIT.

02:10 - 44.479 GOVERNOR BROWN CAIN HAS JUST

02:10 - 44.830 BEGUN

02:10 - 45.210 ON A.

02:10 - 47.159 >>AND YOU WERE DO THEY TOOK A

02:10 - 49.089 REFUND AND WHEN PLAYED THROUGH

02:10 - 50.090 THAT ONE.

02:10 - 51.930 >>AND THAT MAY BE THE KEY

02:10 - 53.979 BECAUSE THE LEGISLATURE IS SET

02:10 - 55.229 UP TO PROCESS THE COURT OF

02:10 - 56.230 APPEALS IN THE

02:10 - 58.439 411. I THINK THE STATUTE THAT

02:10 - 59.969 THE LEGISLATURE SET UP AND THEY

02:10 - 01.699 SAID IT'S HIS HOUSE TO THE

02:11 - 04.079 BLAST. SO IT IS EXTREMELY

02:11 - 05.309 IMPORTANT ESPECIALLY IN THE

02:11 - 06.310 CASE BECAUSE.

02:11 - 09.099 IT WAS ALL TAXPAYERS

02:11 - 12.249 AND THAT IS GIVEN YEAR 1127

02:11 - 14.930 YEARS. I LIKE TO EAT

02:11 - 16.819 WITHIN 30 DAYS TO COME THE

02:11 - 18.360 REVENUE SIDE

02:11 - 20.249 WHERE HE'S RIGHT. IT'S GOING TO

02:11 - 21.469 GO TO THE LIMITED NUMBER OF

02:11 - 23.130 CREDIT YOU GET IN THIS YEAR'S

02:11 - 24.930 55 MILLION. IT WAS A

02:11 - 27.020 100 MILLION CREDIT SAW

02:11 - 29.279 SO THAT PERIOD HE SAID HE WOULD

02:11 - 31.990 SHOW THAT. WHY.

02:11 - 36.150 DUE PROCESS.

02:11 - 38.569 IT IS SO TALK BACK TO

02:11 - 39.889 THE LEGISLATURE BASE THAT IS

02:11 - 41.359 WHAT MISTER BOWERS DOESN'T THAT

02:11 - 42.619 DOESN'T THAT SORT OF TAKE THAT

02:11 - 44.239 CAME OUT OF THE STANDARD

02:11 - 45.879 EDITION FOR REFUND TO TAKE THE

02:11 - 46.880 CREDIT.

02:11 - 48.539 >>ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS THAT

02:11 - 50.879 THAT 15 IF MAKE A SPECIAL KIND

02:11 - 51.390 OF CREDIT.

02:11 - 54.369 >>SAD. YOU HAVE IT YOU HAVE

02:11 - 55.719 A TERMINATION OF THE MISSION OF

02:11 - 57.839 THE TERMINATION BEFORE YOU

02:11 - 58.879 WOULD FILE A PETITION FOR A

02:11 - 59.880 REFUND.

02:12 - 01.859 >>WE'RE CREDIT AND FOLLOW THAT

02:12 - 03.529 A NEW WAY TO PROCESS THE

02:12 - 06.349 PROCESS WAS OVER WHEN THE

02:12 - 08.279 DEPARTMENT BAD WE'RE NOT GIVING

02:12 - 09.729 YOU THE CREDIT FOR GIVING IT TO

02:12 - 10.979 SOMEBODY OUT THERE WITH NOTHING

02:12 - 11.980 TO REALLY.

02:12 - 13.869 FILE A PETITION FOR RELIEF

02:12 - 15.280 UNDER PETITION FOR CREDIT ON.

02:12 - 19.079 >>EXACTLY LIKE A CROSS IN AND

02:12 - 21.179 THAT HE IS THAT'S WHY THE

02:12 - 22.589 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE COURT OF

02:12 - 23.810 APPEAL AND

02:12 - 25.859 IT HAD THE FIRE WITHIN 30 DAYS

02:12 - 28.260 TO PUSH YOU TO THE AGENCY ALL

02:12 - 30.649 OTHER TAXES. RIGHT SO JUST

02:12 - 32.239 BEING OUT OF TOWN TO GET THAT

02:12 - 33.809 BACK UP AGAIN YOUR ARGUMENT

02:12 - 34.810 THAT

02:12 - 36.819 >>IT'S AN ATTACK BECAUSE IT IS

02:12 - 38.390 AN ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY LOCHTE

02:12 - 40.859 IT COULD BE ABOUT IT COULD BE

02:12 - 41.220 ABOUT

02:12 - 43.739 WITH YOU IF IT'S NOT A TAX CUT.

02:12 - 44.720 IT'S A QUESTION OF WHETHER

02:12 - 45.829 THERE WAS A TIME WE APPEAL OF

02:12 - 47.449 AN ADJUDICATION UNDER THE

02:12 - 48.729 ADMINISTRATIVE AGENT PEOPLE ON

02:12 - 50.119 THERE WASN'T WHAT AN

02:12 - 51.269 APPROPRIATE REALLY SHOULD

02:12 - 51.840 BE AFFORDED.

02:12 - 53.789 >>IN I AGREE WITH THAT THE

02:12 - 55.120 REASON THAT THAT I'D

02:12 - 58.370 IN THE END YOU HEARING AND THEN

02:12 - 00.020 IN 1 ONE.

02:13 - 03.759 >>BACK HE REMINI WHICH I'M

02:13 - 06.060 SEEING WHAT THEY'RE SAYING THAT

02:13 - 09.189 IN JULY 18 LETTER HE DID AND

02:13 - 10.680 HE'LL BE TOUCHING FROM

02:13 - 12.609 IN FACT THE CASE WITH SECOND

02:13 - 13.879 HE'S A YOUNG LIFE

02:13 - 16.050 TEAM DECISION IS IT HOT IS IT

02:13 - 19.939 I IT'S BECAUSE I DON'T

02:13 - 21.189 UNDERSTAND IT WOULD BE I I

02:13 - 22.000 DON'T UNDERSTAND THEY WERE

02:13 - 23.139 DEALING WITH THAT THERE WERE

02:13 - 24.809 APPEALING THE BOARD'S REFUSAL

02:13 - 26.129 TO EXERCISE JURISDICTION.

02:13 - 27.429 I THOUGHT THEY WERE APPEALING

02:13 - 28.819 PEOPLE DEPARTMENT TERMINATION

02:13 - 29.820 FOR THE VILE THE CREDIT.

02:13 - 33.149 >>IN FACT. I WOULD AGREE

02:13 - 34.779 WHOLEHEARTEDLY BUT I BELIEVE MY

02:13 - 36.310 RECOLLECTION FROM THE FIRE.

02:13 - 38.829 HEARING WITH THE POINT THAT I'M

02:13 - 39.830 JUST LOVE IT.

02:13 - 41.589 WHAT THAT THE APPEAL IN THIS

02:13 - 43.199 LIGHT THE LETTER AND THE REST

02:13 - 44.689 OF THE PACK IN THE CASE HERE

02:13 - 46.099 SAID IT WAS APPEALING THAT TO

02:13 - 46.540 LIGHT

02:13 - 48.859 THE DETERMINATION. ALSO WE

02:13 - 50.289 BELIEVE THAT LIKE YOU TO MEET

02:13 - 51.909 WITH THE RELEVANT BY RESPONDING

02:13 - 53.789 TO THE ARGUMENT AT LEAST IN MY

02:13 - 53.960 WORK.

02:13 - 55.320 YOU.

02:13 - 59.280 >>BUT I THINK THEY'RE

02:13 - 00.280 DIFFERENT.

02:14 - 02.409 >>I UNDERSTAND WITHIN THE

02:14 - 04.350 FISCAL CODE ARM ATTACKS.

02:14 - 06.879 ON THE OBLIGATION OF THE

02:14 - 08.650 TAXPAYER WITH HER BACK TO 5

02:14 - 10.770 RETURN AND APPEALING RETURN.

02:14 - 13.329 QUESTION IS IS THIS A LIKELY

02:14 - 14.330 DIFFERENT ANIMAL.

02:14 - 18.339 >>NAMELY THE I SHOULD SAY THE

02:14 - 20.729 DISAPPROVAL CREDIT THAT WOULD

02:14 - 21.730 BE IF THAT

02:14 - 24.479 SEPARATE FROM THE PROCEDURE IN

02:14 - 25.949 THE 5TH CALLS OUT AND THE

02:14 - 28.149 QUESTION IS IF THERE IS NO IF

02:14 - 29.339 IT DOES THAT BACK TO

02:14 - 31.659 PROPERTY RIGHTS AND THERE IS NO

02:14 - 32.660 REMEDY.

02:14 - 34.869 AND I UNDERSTAND YOU TO SAY

02:14 - 36.119 THERE IS NO REMEDY AND THE

02:14 - 38.809 BOARD OF APPEALS. LIKE YOU

02:14 - 39.810 FILE.

02:14 - 41.919 THE AMENDED RETURN A WAY FOR

02:14 - 43.079 THE DEPARTMENT TO COME AFTER

02:14 - 46.049 YOU. BUT THERE RAM MONEY ON THE

02:14 - 47.900 SCREEN ISSUE HAS BEEN DONE

02:14 - 52.619 IF WE CONCLUDE

02:14 - 53.849 THERE IS THE PROPERTY

02:14 - 55.919 INTEREST AFFECTED AND THERE IS

02:14 - 57.929 DOWN FACTOR CURRY REMEDY ON

02:14 - 58.550 THAT THE

02:14 - 59.240 TRADE ISSUE.

02:14 - 00.550 >>WHY WOULDN'T THE

02:15 - 03.209 ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY LAW BE

02:15 - 05.030 THE DEFAULT HER TEACHER.

02:15 - 06.949 >>SHE AND HERE AT THE

02:15 - 09.009 DEPARTMENT IT WOULD HAVE TO

02:15 - 11.969 EMPLOY E. ADJUDICATE BACK

02:15 - 13.769 WITH HIM BEFORE THE HEARING

02:15 - 15.099 OFFICER AND BEFORE THE

02:15 - 16.330 SECRETARY OF REVENUE.

02:15 - 20.889 >>YOU'RE IN. IF YOU RECOGNIZE

02:15 - 22.429 THAT IT WASN'T CLEAR THAT I

02:15 - 24.709 AGREE THAT THAT REMEDY IS TO

02:15 - 26.379 HEAL THE TERMINATION IN

02:15 - 28.209 THURSDAY TO THE COMMONWEALTH

02:15 - 29.210 COURT.

02:15 - 32.340 >>THE

02:15 - 34.289 QUESTION IS. PRESIDENT JUDGE OF

02:15 - 35.639 QUESTIONS RELATED TO THE ISSUE

02:15 - 36.979 OF WHETHER BACK THE TERMINATION

02:15 - 38.339 IN AND HELP WITH AN APPROACH

02:15 - 38.650 WITH A

02:15 - 40.050 PROPER EDUCATION.

02:15 - 41.839 >>BECAUSE IT DIDN'T WASN'T

02:15 - 43.739 ACCOMPANIED BY IT MAY HAVE BEEN

02:15 - 45.159 AN EDUCATION THAT YOU MAY BE

02:15 - 46.559 INVALID ONE BECAUSE THERE WAS

02:15 - 47.969 NOT A HEARING IN FINDING THE

02:15 - 49.560 BACK OF CONCLUSIONS OF LAW.

02:15 - 51.729 BACK KIND OF EFFECT AND SO

02:15 - 53.749 AND SO DO YOU AGREE WITH AN

02:15 - 55.119 ACUTE OCCASION IN THE FACT THAT

02:15 - 57.109 IT A PROPERTY RIGHT FOR DUTY

02:15 - 58.470 AND OBLIGATION PRIVILEGES.

02:15 - 59.919 HOWEVER, THE ADMINISTRATIVE

02:15 - 02.210 AGENT THROUGHOUT THE DICTATION.

02:16 - 04.529 >>YES I AGREE WITH AND I

02:16 - 05.799 BELIEVE HOW WOULD YOU ADDRESS

02:16 - 06.959 HOW WOULD YOU GOT THE PRESIDENT

02:16 - 08.669 JUDGE LEVEL QUESTION TOO ABOUT

02:16 - 09.869 WHETHER WITH THE BALLOT ACUTE

02:16 - 11.109 OCCASION. THE FACT THAT THE

02:16 - 12.889 ADMINISTRATIVE LAW REQUIRES ALL

02:16 - 14.259 ADJUDICATION TO BE ACCOMPANIED

02:16 - 15.260 BY HERE.

02:16 - 21.740 >>IF ANYTHING QUESTION.

02:16 - 23.090 >>THE

02:16 - 25.389 TO FEWER PROVIDE THAT IMMEDIATE

02:16 - 27.219 INDICATION IS ONLY VALID IF

02:16 - 28.559 THERE WAS NO TO AN OPPORTUNITY

02:16 - 30.899 TO BE HEARD A HEARING AND AND

02:16 - 31.989 USUALLY FIND THE FACT AND

02:16 - 32.510 CONCLUSIONS

02:16 - 35.169 OF LAW. OBVIOUSLY DIDN'T HAVE A

02:16 - 36.499 HEARING AND SO THE QUESTION IS

02:16 - 38.160 IS IT AN INVALID ADJUDICATION.

02:16 - 40.449 >>ONE THAT'S WHERE WE'RE

02:16 - 41.510 GETTING TO BE.

02:16 - 44.469 IMMEDIATELY I CARRIED BACK

02:16 - 45.260 BECAUSE WE HAVE TO

02:16 - 46.689 DEAL WITH IT COST THEM THE

02:16 - 48.459 BEFORE GOING BACK TO YOU KNOW

02:16 - 48.860 DEAL WITH

02:16 - 49.210 WHICH IT.

02:16 - 50.749 >>IT DEALS WITH THE WAY THAT

02:16 - 51.859 MISTER BOWERS WHO THEY WERE

02:16 - 52.780 WHERE WE'RE NOT DEALING WITH

02:16 - 53.780 BACK TO THE MORE WE DEAL WITH

02:16 - 54.280 THE MINISTRY OF

02:16 - 54.900 82 LAW.

02:16 - 56.589 >>AND THAT'S WHY IT'S IMPORTANT

02:16 - 58.629 BECAUSE IT'S WHERE

02:16 - 00.099 THE DEPARTMENT WHERE THE

02:17 - 01.419 LEGISLATURE PLACE THE 30 TO

02:17 - 02.889 MAKE THE DETERMINATION WHETHER

02:17 - 04.159 FROM THE COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC

02:17 - 05.809 DEVELOPMENT WHICH IS WHAT IF HE

02:17 - 07.529 JUST HAPPENED HE TALKED ABOUT

02:17 - 08.929 HERE WITH A 50 FOOT IN THE

02:17 - 09.930 DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE.

02:17 - 11.809 SO THAT'S WHERE THE OUTLOOK

02:17 - 13.789 PROBLEM AND THE LEGISLATURE HAS

02:17 - 14.140 BAD.

02:17 - 16.310 >>IN ORDER AND THAT PASSED.

02:17 - 18.379 NO AGENCY CAN ISSUE

02:17 - 19.560 AN ADJUDICATION.

02:17 - 21.519 >>THAT DOES NOT CONFORM TO THE

02:17 - 22.919 TERMS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE

02:17 - 25.360 AGENCY LAW. IF THERE IS A.

02:17 - 26.660 >>THE 5TH PICK 40.

02:17 - 31.100 BACK TO WORK FOR A FACT.

02:17 - 35.190 HER RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT.

02:17 - 37.159 THEN I BEEN ON

02:17 - 38.839 THE DEPARTMENT, THE FED UP OF

02:17 - 40.850 HEARING PROFIT JUMPED TO HEAR

02:17 - 43.969 03:30AM DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT

02:17 - 44.970 MILE.

02:17 - 47.519 THE TAXPAYER AN

02:17 - 50.479 OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A RECORD

02:17 - 51.780 AND THAT IT WOULD COME TO.

02:17 - 57.510 ON APPEAL.

02:17 - 00.420 IF YOU ARE TELLING HER.

02:18 - 03.169 >>IN MY RESPONSE TO THAT

02:18 - 05.289 IS YOU THAT WAS AN ISSUE

02:18 - 09.330 THAT WAS KIND OF EVALUATE IT IN

02:18 - 10.750 IF YOU WANT TO BUY.

02:18 - 14.539 THE DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, WHAT

02:18 - 15.270 COMPLYING WITH

02:18 - 17.429 WHAT THE A STATUE THAT WAS

02:18 - 19.219 NEVER AUTHORIZED TO DO IT AND

02:18 - 21.509 THE TAXPAYER MONEY UNIFICATION

02:18 - 23.009 IN NEED AND A LETTER ADVISING

02:18 - 24.449 THEM OF THE AMOUNT OF CREDIT IF

02:18 - 25.880 THEY WOULD YOU BELIEVE CREW FOR

02:18 - 27.429 BOTH OF THOSE DEATHS OCCURRED

02:18 - 28.430 HERE.

02:18 - 30.690 WHETHER THEY'RE IN

02:18 - 37.540 MIGHT BE PEOPLE TO THE

02:18 - 38.740 THE.

02:18 - 41.460 >>IT'S ABOUT IF YOU EXCUSE ME I

02:18 - 44.839 WHAT DID YOU THINK IT JUST IT

02:18 - 47.099 JUST WHY YOU DID NOT INCLUDE

02:18 - 48.970 THE NO ISSUE PUT INTO THE.

02:18 - 52.210 A JULY LETTER IN SEPTEMBER.

02:18 - 55.019 REGARDING TO THE COMMONWEALTH

02:18 - 56.020 COURT.

02:18 - 58.639 >>AND THE KEY IS WITH THAT

02:18 - 00.799 DECEMBER 15 LETTER THAT IS A

02:19 - 02.349 FORM LETTER THAT SO NOT

02:19 - 04.899 TO BE. IN THE HEAT BUT 1300

02:19 - 05.280 CATCH

02:19 - 08.119 A FLY AND HE USED THE SYSTEM IN

02:19 - 09.749 ORDER TO INSERT THE AMOUNT OF

02:19 - 12.569 THE CREDIT OR LATER BECAUSE

02:19 - 13.080 THIS ONE.

02:19 - 14.329 >>IT WAS ABOUT WHETHER THEY

02:19 - 15.939 QUALIFY THIS WAS THAT THEY WERE

02:19 - 16.940 LATE.

02:19 - 19.250 LIKE IT TO BE SUBMITTED

02:19 - 22.429 ONE IT IS A FORM LETTER WHERE

02:19 - 24.019 THEY INCLUDE THE ELEVATED

02:19 - 25.439 VARIABLE INFORMATION ALL THE

02:19 - 27.189 DIFFERENT TACT IS HIS LAST

02:19 - 29.589 KNOWN TO BE OKAY, THEN WHAT YOU

02:19 - 31.249 MEAN BY THE DECEMBER LETTER

02:19 - 32.670 SAYING THERE'S LOOK HEAL.

02:19 - 37.049 IT WAS A A NATION OF GOVERNMENT

02:19 - 39.239 UNIT. IF YOU NEED A

02:19 - 40.240 SEPTEMBER LETTER.

02:19 - 43.089 >>NO THAT'S NOT WHAT THE COURT

02:19 - 44.169 MIGHT HAVE IN THE CITY OF THE

02:19 - 46.089 SEPTEMBER LETTER IS WHAT THE

02:19 - 48.139 TIME A YEAR FILE AN ORDER TO

02:19 - 48.770 APPLY FOR

02:19 - 49.770 THE CREDIT.

02:19 - 53.509 >>LETTER I'M SORRY EXCUSE ME

02:19 - 54.660 DECEMBER LETTER SAID THAT.

02:19 - 58.089 IN R D TAX CREDIT IT CONTAINS

02:19 - 59.629 NO PROVISION FOR ADMINISTRATIVE

02:19 - 00.630 APPEALS.

02:20 - 02.439 >>IN THE END BACK WITH THE JULY

02:20 - 03.859 THE 2 LETTER SAID THAT'S NOT

02:20 - 04.959 WHAT THE DECEMBER LETTER SAID

02:20 - 06.620 NOT LIKELY THE RECORD

02:20 - 11.840 >>I KNOW WHAT MY POINT USE.

02:20 - 13.010 SO I.

02:20 - 16.920 LETTER HERE IN