00:10 - >>AND NOW THE HONORABLE JUDGE

00:11 - OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF

00:12 - PENNSYLVANIA. OH YEAH, OH YEAH,

00:15 - OH YEAH, ALL PERSONS

00:16 - HAVING BUSINESS BEFORE THE

00:17 - COMMONWEALTH COURT OF

00:18 - PENNSYLVANIA. DRAWING AND GET

00:20 - THEIR ATTENTION. THE COURT IS

00:22 - NOW DATING. I THINK THE KIND OF

00:24 - WELCOME AND HONORABLE COURT.

00:26 - PRESIDENT JUDGE MARY HAD 11

00:27 - PRESIDING.

00:35 - I'M ALL COURT.

00:38 - >>WE

00:38 - NORMALLY ALLOW 30 MINUTES.

00:41 - HER ARGUMENT WITH HIM DOUBLE

00:43 - THE USUAL A LOT OF TIME BECAUSE

00:46 - WE HAVE FROM COMPLICATED CASE

00:48 - OF THE MORNING.

00:49 - THE FIRST WHO WILL BE EXTENDED

00:52 - ARGUMENT.

00:59 - ON THE MOVING PARTY GUY

01:01 - MAY REPAIR. SOME OF THEIR

01:03 - ALLOTTED TIME FOR REBUTTAL.

01:06 - LEAVE LET THE COURT KNOW

01:07 - AND BAM AND WITH THAT WE WILL

01:11 - CALL THE HER ARGUMENT

01:12 - THE MORNING. I REMIND ALL

01:15 - COUNCIL THAT THE JUDGES HAVE

01:17 - READ THE BRIEF A VERY

01:18 - CAREFULLY.

01:20 - 30 MINUTES 40 MINUTES MAY FOUND

01:22 - LIKE A LOT OF TIME BUT IT GOES

01:24 - VERY QUICKLY PARTICULARLY WHEN

01:25 - YOU START GETTING QUESTIONED

01:27 - HIM. SO I BUT JEFF THAT YOU GET

01:30 - TO THE HEART OF YOUR LEGAL

01:32 - ISSUE JUST AS QUICKLY AS

01:33 - POSSIBLE. AND NOW WE WILL CALL

01:36 - HER CASE

01:37 - WHICH IS ALLEGHENY REPRODUCTIVE

01:39 - HEALTH CENTER AT ALL FOR THE

01:41 - PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF

01:43 - HUMAN SERVICES AND THE

01:45 - SECRETARY OF HUMAN SERVICE.

01:48 - IN THE CASE,

01:49 - WE CONSIDER A CHALLENGE TO THE

01:52 - FACTOR TORY BAN ON COVERAGE OF

01:53 - ABORTION SERVICES

01:55 - ARE WOMEN AND WORLD AND MEDICAL

01:57 - OF THE FILM WHICH PROVIDE

01:59 - HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE.

02:01 - THE LOW INCOME.

02:03 - A PETITION OR OR THE

02:05 - ALLEGHENY REPRODUCTIVE HELP

02:07 - CENTER AND OTHER MEDICAL

02:09 - PROVIDERS THAT PERFORM ABORTION

02:11 - SERVICES AND

02:12 - THE COMMONWEALTH. THEIR

02:13 - PATIENTS INCLUDE WOMEN ENROLLED

02:16 - IN MEDICAL

02:17 - OF THIS A PETITION OR CAN PAN

02:20 - BUT THE FACT OR TORY BAM

02:22 - ABORTION SERVICES AND THEN

02:24 - CAUGHT ON CONSTITUTIONAL.

02:27 - AND THE BAY AS ABORTION CONTROL

02:29 - ACT AND THE REGULATIONS

02:31 - PROMULGATED THEREUNDER I'M THE

02:33 - DEPARTMENT FOR HIM TO BE

02:35 - EXPENDITURE OF STATE AND

02:36 - FEDERAL FUND TO PROVIDE

02:39 - ABORTION SERVICES MEDICAL OF

02:41 - THEM, RICK 50 AM. LAUGH.

02:45 - ONE IN ARE NECESSARY TO AVERT

02:47 - THE DEATH OF THE PREGNANT WOMEN

02:49 - WOMAN. THE PREGNANCY RESULTING

02:53 - FROM RAPE OR TRADE

02:54 - THE PREGNANCY RESULTED FROM

02:57 - IN FACT A PETITION OR A 3RD.

02:59 - BUT THE COVERAGE FAN VIOLATE,

03:02 - PENNSYLVANIA, EQUAL

03:03 - RIGHTS AMENDMENT. BECAUSE THE

03:05 - MAN DENIED COVERAGE OF A

03:06 - MEDICAL PROCEDURE THAT CAN BE

03:08 - USED ONLY

03:09 - BY WOMEN ADDITIONALLY

03:11 - PETITIONER CONTEND THAT THE

03:13 - COVERAGE FAN

03:14 - BY LIFE AND FOR ME AND CUT THE

03:16 - PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION

03:18 - GUARANTEE OF EQUAL PROTECTION

03:20 - BECAUSE IT RESTRICTS THE

03:22 - ABILITY OF ENDING HAVE WOMEN

03:24 - EXTRA 5 THERE RIGHT. TERMINATE

03:26 - A PREGNANCY. HEARD REQUEST THE

03:29 - COURT TO DECLARE CAMPER VAN

03:31 - COVERAGE RAN ON COM OFFICIAL

03:33 - AND WHEN YOU'RE IN THE

03:34 - UNFORTUNATE.

03:37 - AND INTERVENE OR FROM THE

03:39 - PENNSYLVANIA. HOUSE AND SENATE

03:41 - HAVE FILED

03:42 - PRELIMINARY OBJECTION SEEKING

03:44 - TO HAVE THE PETITION FOR

03:45 - REVIEW, THE MATH. THEY

03:47 - ARGUE THE

03:49 - A PETITION OR COMPLAINT DOES

03:51 - NOT SAY THE CLAIM UPON WHICH

03:53 - RELIEF AND

03:54 - BE GRANTED. AND FISHER VERSUS

03:56 - DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WELFARE,

03:58 - A PENNSYLVANIA. SUPREME COURT

04:00 - HELD IN 1985 THAT THE ABORTION

04:04 - CAN PROACTIVE NOT VIOLATE

04:06 - PENNSYLVANIA, PEOPLE RIGHT

04:07 - AMOUNT AMENDMENT OR IF THERAPY

04:10 - OF EQUAL PROTECTION.

04:12 - BECAUSE DEPARTMENT AND

04:14 - INTERVENE OR CAMP AND THE

04:15 - RULING IN FISHER IS

04:18 - THE POSITIVE. THE COMPLAINT

04:20 - MUST BE MET. IN ADDITION

04:23 - THE DEPARTMENT AND SECRETARY OF

04:25 - HUMAN SERVICES IN TANDEM.

04:27 - SUGAR LACKED STANDING. WHAT OR

04:30 - THE RIGHT OF OTHER PERSON

04:32 - THAT IS JOE WOMEN AND

04:35 - WORLD AND MEDICAL THEM.

04:40 - I HOPE I MISS

04:44 - A

04:45 - BIG HURT ON BEHALF OF THE ROUGH

04:47 - ON THEM

04:47 - SEEKING TO HAVE THE PETITION

04:49 - FOR REVIEW.

04:54 - >>THANK YOU YOUR HONOR HIM AND

04:55 - PLEASE THE COURT.

04:56 - I AM JASON SNEIDERMAN FROM THE

04:58 - BLANK ROME LAW FIRM I REPRESENT

05:00 - THE 18 SENATE RESPONDENTS IN

05:02 - THIS ACTION.

05:05 - AS WE'VE ALREADY DISCUSSED

05:06 - WE'RE GOING TO SPLIT OUR TIME

05:07 - UNALLOCATED AMONGST EACH OF THE

05:09 - 3 DIFFERENT GROUPS OF

05:10 - RESPONDENTS AND I HAVE ASKED

05:11 - FOR 6 AND A HALF MINUTES

05:13 - RESERVING ONE AND A HALF FOR

05:14 - TROUBLE.

05:19 - PRESIDENT JUDGE LET IT JUST

05:20 - DESCRIBED THE FISHER CASE

05:23 - CONTROLS HERE AND IT FINDS

05:25 - THIS COURT. SURE INVOLVED THE

05:27 - EXACT SAME CASE THAT THE

05:29 - PETITIONERS HAVE

05:30 - FILED HERE A CHALLENGING THE

05:32 - EXACT SAME PROVISIONS OF THE

05:33 - EXACT SAME STATUE ON THE EXACT

05:35 - SAME BASE

05:36 - EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT

05:37 - VIOLATIONS WERE LEFT THERE.

05:39 - EQUAL PROTECTION VIOLATIONS

05:41 - WERE LEFT THERE

05:42 - AND BY UNANIMOUS DECISION OF

05:44 - THE SUPREME COURT OF

05:45 - PENNSYLVANIA. THOSE CLAIMS WERE

05:47 - PROJECTED. THAT CASE REMAINS

05:49 - GOOD IS THERE IS THERE A

05:52 - DIFFERENCE IN THIS CASE

05:53 - CONCERNING STANDING.

05:55 - >>THAT THE PETITIONERS ARE

05:56 - DIFFERENT.

05:57 - >>THERE IS IN SO FAR AS

05:59 - STANDING HAS BEEN ADDRESS

06:01 - MISTER MCCLEASE WILL HANDLE IN

06:03 - MORE DETAIL AS PRESIDENT JEFF

06:05 - LEAVITT SAID THAT'S BEEN RAISED

06:06 - SEPARATELY IN THEIR FREE.

06:08 - BUT MY MORE DIRECT ANSWER TO

06:09 - THE QUESTION IS

06:10 - STANDING WAS NOT CHALLENGE IN

06:13 - THE ORIGINAL FISHER CASE IN

06:15 - 1980.

06:16 - BUT AMONG THE PETITIONERS THERE

06:18 - WERE OTHER PETITIONERS THAT

06:19 - WE'RE NOT SITUATED LIKE PEOPLE

06:21 - PORTION CLINIC PROVIDERS THERE

06:22 - WAS ALSO A TAXPAYER TO FIX.

06:25 - IN THIS CASE YOU ONLY HAVE THE

06:27 - CLINIC PROVIDES. SO IN THAT

06:29 - RESPECT IT'S A LITTLE BIT.

06:31 - SO THE FISHER COURT BYNES IN

06:33 - CONTROL OF THIS COURT CAN DO.

06:35 - THERE COULD NOT BE A WORK ON

06:37 - GROWING PAINS TO FISHER THAN

06:39 - THIS ONE PETITIONERS

06:40 - ACKNOWLEDGE THIS IN FACT A PAGE

06:42 - 10 OF THEIR OWN FREE.

06:43 - THEY STATE QUOTE PETITIONERS

06:45 - ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS COURT

06:47 - CANNOT OVERTURN FISHER, A

06:49 - CLOSE CALL. THEY THEN GO ON FOR

06:51 - DOZENS OF PAGES WITH REASONS AS

06:53 - TO WHY THIS COURT SHOULD

06:54 - OVERTURN. BUT THEY ACKNOWLEDGE

06:56 - QUITE RIGHTLY THAT IT SIMPLY

06:57 - CANNOT DO SO

06:59 - AND THIS COURT HAS LONG

07:00 - ACKNOWLEDGED THAT IT IS BOUND

07:02 - BY PRECEDENT ON THE

07:03 - PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

07:04 - STATING THAT IT EVEN IF THIS

07:06 - COURT WALKING 2. IT IS

07:07 - POWERLESS TO OVERRULE THE

07:09 - DECISIONS FROM THE PENNSYLVANIA

07:10 - SUPREME COURT AND PETITIONERS

07:12 - OFFER NO. BASIS THAT THIS

07:15 - COURT COULD HOLD OTHERWISE

07:16 - WOULD DO OTHERWISE. AND PLEA.

07:20 - >>ONE POINT THEY MAKE.

07:22 - BUT I DON'T BELIEVE WITH THE

07:23 - DRAFT THEM FISHER ONE THOUGH,

07:25 - HOLDING A PAIR OF HER CROWD FOR

07:28 - OF SUPREME COURT CASE.

07:31 - INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH THAT WAS

07:33 - OKAY BUT. WAS.

07:36 - 3 DAVID. THE FISHER CASE BUT IN

07:39 - THAT CASE THE SUPREME COURT

07:40 - SAID THAT.

07:43 - WHEN PREGNANT WOMEN ARE SINGLED

07:45 - OUT AND PLAYED IN A CLASS THERE

07:46 - GET THE BANNER AND

07:49 - ARE THERE. JUST HEARD FROM

07:51 - EMPLOYMENT ON THE BASIS OF A

07:52 - PHYSICAL CONDITION, KILL YOUR

07:55 - 2. THEIR EFFECT. IN FACT

07:57 - THE TERMINATION PERHAPS THAT

07:59 - WAS OVERLOOKED AND PRESSURE BUT

08:00 - COULD YOU ADDRESS AFFECTED.

08:02 - >>I'D BE HAPPY TO YOUR HONOR

08:04 - AND JUST POINT OF CLARIFICATION

08:06 - SARAH WAS NOT OVERLOOKING

08:08 - FISHER IN FACT IT WAS

08:09 - SPECIFICALLY DISCUSSED IN THE

08:10 - FISCHER CANYON AND IT WAS

08:12 - DISTINGUISHED BY THE FISHER

08:13 - COURT. SARAH BRIGHTMAN LAW AND

08:16 - WOULD YOU LIKE AND STILL TO

08:17 - ANSWER THE SECOND PART OF YOUR

08:18 - QUESTION.

08:20 - >>IT'S A GOOD THING WITH HIM

08:21 - AND I MEAN LOOK

08:22 - AT THAT THEY MADE THE HEART OF

08:24 - THE ARGUMENT HERE IS THAT

08:25 - PREGNANT THEY ONLY HAPPEN WHEN

08:26 - I'M. READING THAT CONDITION.

08:30 - IT'S.

08:31 - APPARENTLY EFFECT.

08:33 - THE REMAINS.

08:34 - >>YEAH WELL THERE'S A

08:35 - DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SOMETHING

08:38 - THAT ONLY AFFECTS ONE SEX AND

08:40 - SOMETHING THAT IS NECESSARILY

08:42 - SEX DISCRIMINATION UNDER THE

08:43 - EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT IN

08:44 - SARAH. YOU HAVE TEACHERS

08:47 - AND THERE WAS A LOCAL

08:48 - REGULATION PASSED I BELIEVE BY

08:49 - THE COUNTY MONROE COUNTY THAT

08:51 - SAID. ONCE A WOMAN TEACHER

08:54 - SHOULD YOU 5 MONTHS OF HER

08:56 - PREGNANCY. SHE MUST RESIGN OR

08:58 - BE TERMINATED. SHE WOULD BE

09:00 - GOING TO BE TEMPORARILY

09:01 - DISABLED AND UNABLE TO DO HER

09:02 - JOB THEREAFTER AND THEREFORE

09:04 - HAS TO EITHER RESIGN OR BE

09:05 - TERMINATED. A SIMILARLY

09:07 - SITUATED MALE TEACHER

09:08 - THAT MIGHT HAVE SOME DISABILITY

09:10 - THAT WOULD PREVENT HIM FROM

09:11 - WORKING FACE NO SUCH RIGHT.

09:14 - AND SO THE SIMILARLY SITUATED

09:15 - PEOPLE WANT AND ONE WOMAN WHEN

09:17 - A WOMAN. WE'RE TREATED

09:18 - DIFFERENTLY BECAUSE OF THE SEX

09:20 - OF THE WOMAN AND NOTHING MORE

09:22 - AND THE SUPREME COURT AND SARAH

09:23 - SAID THIS WAS QUOTE ABSOLUTELY

09:25 - AND SOLD BECAUSE OF THE

09:27 - PREGNANCY AND CONDITION BASED

09:29 - SOLELY ON THE SEX OF THE WOMAN

09:31 - TEACH. IN THIS CASE UNLIKE

09:34 - IN SARAH AND THE FISHER COURT

09:36 - SO WELL. THERE IS NO

09:38 - DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF

09:39 - SEX HERE

09:40 - BECAUSE YOU CAN'T HAVE

09:41 - SIMILARLY SITUATED MEN AND

09:43 - WOMEN IN THE SAME SITUATION

09:44 - OF COURSE A MAN CAN'T GET

09:46 - PREGNANT SO A MAN CAN SEEK AN

09:47 - ABORTION AN IMMUTABLE

09:49 - CHARACTERISTIC UNIQUE TO WOMEN

09:51 - THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT THE

09:52 - STATUTE DISCRIMINATE ON THE

09:53 - BASIS OF OUR SETS AND

09:55 - SUPPOSED TO.

09:57 - TREATING THAT WOMEN DIFFERENTLY

09:58 - BECAUSE SHE CHOSE TO HAVE A

09:59 - VOLUNTARY ABORTION. SO HERE

10:02 - WHAT FISH ARE SET WAS THE

10:03 - DIFFERENCES, NOT THE WOMAN'S

10:05 - SET.

10:07 - THE FACT THAT SHE CHOSE TO HAVE

10:08 - A VOLUNTARY PORTION THAT'S WHAT

10:10 - TREAT HER DIFFERENTLY HERE AND

10:11 - BACK TO YOU THINK IT THROUGH

10:13 - FOR A MOMENT.

10:14 - WHAT'S REALLY AT ISSUE OPEN

10:16 - FISHER AND AGAIN IN THIS CASE

10:18 - IS NOT MAY HAVE

10:19 - VERSUS WALL. IT'S WOMAN WHO'S

10:21 - AN INDIGENT WOMAN THAT CHOOSES

10:23 - CHILDBIRTH VERSUS WOMAN WHOSE

10:24 - OF INDIGENT WOMAN THAT CHOOSES

10:26 - AND OF COURSE.

10:28 - SO THE DIFFERENCE IS THE BAND

10:29 - HERE TARGETS THE COMP IN THE

10:31 - DECISION TO HAVE THAT FOR OF

10:33 - COURSE THERE IS THE CAR AND AS

10:35 - YOU RECOGNIZE PRESIDENT JUDGE

10:37 - THAT MEDICAL ASSISTANCE HERE

10:39 - COVERS ABORTIONS IN THE PLACES

10:42 - WHERE THE LIFE OF THE MOTHER IS

10:43 - AT STAKE OR INCEST OR RAPE.

10:45 - IT DOESN'T COVER OTHER.

10:47 - SO IF THIS WERE DRIVEN SOLELY

10:49 - ON THE BASIS OF THE SEX OF THE

10:50 - INDIVIDUAL, NO RUSSIANS WOULD

10:52 - BE ALLOWED FOR INDIGENT WOMEN

10:53 - BUT IN FACT SOME ARE AND

10:56 - BECAUSE THE COMMONWEALTH HAS

10:57 - MADE A DECISION TO IMPLEMENT

10:59 - ITS REGULATIONS BASED NOT ON

11:01 - THE SEX OF THE BOEING IS

11:02 - SEEKING THE ABORTION AND ON HER

11:04 - DECISION TO ABORT AT ALL.

11:06 - IF IT WERE BASED SOLELY ON HER

11:08 - SEX, NO ABORTIONS WOULD EVER BE

11:10 - COVERED FOR INDIGENT WOMEN BUT

11:11 - THAT'S JUST NOT THE CASE HERE.

11:13 - IT'S THEIR DECISION TO

11:14 - VOLUNTARILY ABOARD OUTSIDE OF

11:16 - THOSE 3 EXCESS AND THAT HAPPENS

11:19 - IN LOTS OF CASES

11:20 - FOR EXAMPLE, MEDICAL ASSISTANCE

11:22 - DOESN'T COVER IN VITRO

11:23 - FERTILIZATION. I CAN ONLY BE

11:26 - AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT A WOMAN

11:27 - RECEIVED MEDICAL ASSISTANCE

11:29 - DOESN'T COVER I THOUGHT THIS

11:31 - FUNCTION THAT'S SOMETHING ONLY

11:32 - A MAN COULD RECEIVE.

11:33 - BUT JUST BECAUSE OF THE

11:34 - IMMUTABLE CHARACTERISTICS OF A

11:36 - MAN WHO WOMAN AND THAT THE

11:37 - IMPACT WILL BE FELT BY ONE OR

11:38 - THE OTHER DOESN'T MEAN THAT

11:40 - THAT'S DISCRIMINATION BASED ON

11:42 - THEIR SEX THERE COULD BE OTHER

11:43 - POLICY REASONS OR OTHER

11:45 - CONTROLLING STATE INTERESTS

11:46 - THAT DRIVE THAT OUTCOME LIKE

11:48 - THE INTEREST IN PROTECTING THE

11:49 - LIFE OF A CHILD IN THE CASE OF

11:51 - AN ABORTION. I SEE THAT ONE

11:53 - OVER MY TIME.

11:55 - SO WHAT I WOULD SIMPLY SOMEONE

11:57 - WITHIN SAY IS FISHER BINDS AND

12:00 - CONTROLS THE OUTCOME OF THIS

12:02 - COURT CANNOT HOLD OF US FOR

12:05 - THAT REASON ALONE. THE

12:06 - PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS MUST BE

12:07 - SUSTAINED. THANK YOU.

12:12 - ALL RIGHT, WE WILL HEAR NEXT

12:14 - FROM THAT GUY.

12:22 - MAY IT PLEASE

12:23 - THE COURT I AM DAVID I.

12:27 - AND I DO REPRESENT THE HOUSE

12:30 - RESPONDS IN THIS MATTER.

12:36 - >>AND

12:36 - MOVED TO THE ISSUES ALL

12:39 - EQUAL PROTECTION AND AND THE

12:42 - NEW YORK, I'M SURE THERE ARE WE

12:44 - CAN HANDLE THAT. IN

12:46 - THIS MATTER IS NO EQUAL

12:47 - PROTECTION VIOLATION. AND WE

12:51 - MAKE THAT CLAIM BECAUSE YOU'RE

12:52 - WRONG.

12:57 - THERE COULD

12:57 - BE DISCRIMINATION. THERE NEEDS

12:59 - TO BE

13:00 - A LITTLE EARLY TO 2 OF THE

13:02 - INDIVIDUALS AND HERE YOUR HONOR

13:04 - AND MISTER SADDAM HUSSEIN.

13:06 - THEY'RE SIMPLY ARE NOT

13:08 - SIMILARLY SITUATED INDIVIDUALS.

13:12 - PREGNANT WOMEN ARE NOT.

13:14 - SIMILARLY SITUATED MEN WHO

13:16 - CANNOT GET PREGNANT AND BECAUSE

13:18 - MEN CAN NOT GET PREGNANT.

13:20 - IT CANNOT BE WE REALLY SITUATED

13:23 - TO A PREGNANT WOMAN AND IN THAT

13:25 - PARKING BACK TO THIS AREA CASE

13:27 - BECAUSE IN THEIR CASE.

13:36 - THE TEACHER. WHAT THE COMMITTEE

13:39 - AGAINST BECAUSE SHE COULD GET

13:40 - PREGNANT AND THEN COULD NOT SHE

13:43 - WAS DISCRIMINATED AGAINST

13:44 - BECAUSE AND WERE ALLOWED TO

13:46 - KEEP A JOB.

13:48 - WHEN WE RETURN TO STABILITY AND

13:50 - WHEN

13:53 - WE CAN ENDURE THAT THERE IS NO.

13:56 - SIMILARLY

13:58 - WEIGHTED A SITUATION HERE AND

14:01 - THEREFORE WE ARE WE DON'T HAVE.

14:04 - 2 PEOPLE PROTECTION.

14:06 - ISSUE AND YOUR HONOR WE ALSO

14:08 - WANT TO POINT OUT THAT.

14:12 - WHAT WHY ARE WE REALLY TALKING

14:13 - ABOUT WE GO BACK

14:17 - TO THE.

14:18 - >>CLASSIFICATION ISSUE WHICH IS

14:20 - SOMETHING WE ALWAYS LOOK AT

14:24 - PEOPLE PROTECTION PAY FOR.

14:27 - DON'T WE IS THERE A CLOCK

14:29 - OCCASION BETWEEN INDIGENT AND

14:33 - NON HIM WOMEN. I KNOW YOU ARE.

14:37 - THE THERE IS NOT.

14:40 - NOT IN PENNSYLVANIA YOUR

14:42 - CURRENT CAR IN FRONT OF HIM.

14:44 - >>ALL IN THE BACK. THE CASE FOR

14:47 - MORE FOR HIS ROLE A SUPREME

14:50 - THIS IS A SIMPLE PLEA.

14:52 - A LOOK AT THIS ISSUE AND IN THE

14:55 - CAR. THE MODIFIED ACROSS THE

14:57 - NATION. AND THAT CONCEPT HAS

15:00 - REMAIN COOL. IN NEED.

15:05 - FOR 3 YEARS.

15:08 - AND IN FACT THERE ARE.

15:11 - PAST SEPTEMBER. THE 11TH

15:14 - CIRCUIT IN FLORIDA.

15:17 - COREY IS NOT A

15:18 - SUSPECT COM IN THE CASE OF JOAN

15:21 - PERSON TO COVER UP. THAT WAS

15:23 - THE CASE OR BOARDING. THE.

15:29 - WHO ARE EVEN CRACKED TIME.

15:32 - THE VOTING RIGHTS

15:32 - FOR FELONS AND THE DOLANS

15:35 - ARGUMENT WAS THAT. WELL

15:37 - THE FELONS THEY CAN AFFORD TO

15:39 - HAVE THEIR FINES PAID OFF AND

15:41 - GET THEIR VOTING RIGHTS BACK.

15:42 - AND WE JUST DON'T WANT CAN NOT

15:44 - AFFORD TO GET THERE THEIR

15:45 - FINES. THEY WILL AND GET

15:47 - THEY'RE GOING TO FIGHT BACK.

15:48 - SO.

15:49 - WHAT THEY ALL PART OF THE ISSUE

15:52 - THAT CREATED THEM.

15:55 - THE COURT.

15:59 - THEY SAY PARKING BACKED ROAD

16:01 - MAP. AND SO YOU KNOW

16:04 - POVERTY OR I BELIEVE THAT YOU

16:06 - WILL WORK. WELL A LOT

16:08 - OF THEM. WE DON'T HAVE AN ISSUE

16:12 - HERE YOU ARE.

16:15 - >>THE CLASSIFICATION BE TRAIN.

16:19 - AND

16:19 - AGAIN WOMEN. THOSE WOMEN THAT

16:21 - TO UNDERGO.

16:24 - TO TERMINATE THEIR PREGNANCY

16:26 - ARE TREATED DIFFERENTLY FROM

16:27 - ENDED YOUNG WOMEN

16:29 - WHO TO GO THROUGH A FULL TERM.

16:38 - >>WHILE THAT MAY BE A

16:39 - A DIFFERENCE. CHOICE

16:45 - WELL ONE

16:48 - BECAUSE ONE WOMAN.

16:53 - PAY FOR AND THE

16:55 - OTHER WOMAN.

16:56 - THE NOCATEE ABOARD THE NUMBER

16:58 - FELL PAY FOR. IT'S SIMPLY

17:00 - YOUR HONOR. MATTER THAT THE

17:02 - GOVERNMENT IS DECIDING TO PAY

17:04 - FOR ONE LIFE. BUT YOU ARE

17:05 - THERE'S NO.

17:09 - THE GOVERNMENT A WAR

17:12 - TERM OF LIFE THAT TO

17:13 - YOUR HONOR I CAME OUT OF MARBER

17:16 - SAYS ROE. THEY THEY LOOKED AT

17:18 - THAT VERY ISSUE AND THEY

17:20 - SAID NO. THE GOVERNMENT IS

17:21 - ALLOWED TO PICK AND CHOOSE.

17:24 - POLICY INFORMATIONS AND THE

17:27 - GOVERNMENT IS ALLOWED TO PAY

17:29 - FOR THE POLICY TERMINATION

17:31 - BETTER IT IS

17:33 - YOU ARE OUR VALUABLE AND

17:34 - VULNERABLE FOR SOCIETY AND IT

17:37 - DOESN'T HAVE I PAID FOR

17:39 - HOPEFULLY THE TERM NATIONS THAT

17:41 - IS REJECTED BEING ALL GOOD FOR.

17:47 - >>AND WHAT THE POLICY

17:48 - DETERMINATION HERE. WELL YOU

17:50 - ARE GOING TO KNOW.

17:53 - ABOUT THE TERMINATION IS

17:55 - YOUR HONOR THAT THIS IS THE

17:57 - PENNSYLVANIA.

18:04 - I ALWAYS CHOSEN TO

18:05 - NOT NEW. THEY ARE. ONE THING

18:09 - FOR ABORTION. I THINK

18:10 - THE POLICY I WOULD BE A LITTLE

18:13 - COMMON LOW.

18:15 - HE'S MAKING A PUB IN THE FISHER

18:17 - COURT GO FURTHER

18:18 - THAN THAT.

18:22 - COURT WENT FURTHER THAN THAT

18:23 - THEN AFTER

18:24 - BUYING THE.

18:25 - >>A GROUP NEW STANDARD THING

18:27 - THERE WAS NO FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT

18:28 - IN THERE. AND NO THE BACKLASH

18:31 - LOOK AT THE INTERMEDIATE

18:32 - SCRUTINY HAS BEEN SAID WHAT THE

18:34 - GOVERNMENTAL INTEREST.

18:36 - AND THE SUPREME COURT SAID THE

18:37 - STATED PURPOSE OF THE ACT OF

18:39 - THE PRESERVATION

18:40 - OF LIFE AND FURTHER IN THEIR OF

18:42 - THE COMMONWEALTH HAD MADE A

18:43 - DECISION TO ENCOURAGE THE BIRTH

18:45 - OF A CHILD IN ALL SITUATIONS.

18:47 - ACCEPTANCE WHERE ANOTHER LIFE

18:49 - WOULD HAVE TO BE SACRIFICED TO

18:51 - IT NOT JUST EVEN THE BUT

18:52 - THAT BUT THE POLICY ISN'T THE

18:54 - FUNDING QUESTION ALONE, THE

18:56 - POLICY OF THE PRESERVATION OF

18:58 - LIFE AND HAS THAT CHANGED IN

19:02 - A STATUE OR ACT. AND THE FISHER

19:05 - CASE.

19:10 - FOR HER BRAVERY THERE THAT THAT

19:12 - WOULD BE MY MY WELL.

19:16 - THE SUPREME COURT ALSO AND.

19:18 - I HAD THE PERMIT IN.

19:21 - THE PRESERVATION OF LIFE IS A

19:23 - VALUABLE BALL CONSIDERATION AND

19:25 - THAT HAS NOT CHANGE.

19:28 - IT'S BEEN IN THE PAST 3040

19:30 - YEARS AND TODAY AND HE'S STILL.

19:34 - BY 4. WE BELIEVE THE.

19:38 - WE WILL OF THE PEOPLE EXPRESS.

19:43 - AND I SEE

19:44 - THE EYE I SEE THAT MY PROBLEM.

19:51 - ALL RIGHT WE WILL

19:52 - HEAR NEXT FROM A CLUE. BEHALF

19:58 - >>THANK YOU GOOD

19:58 - MORNING BY THE BAKRIES I'M

20:00 - DEPUTY COUNSEL PART IN THE

20:02 - SERVICES THAT REPRESENT

20:04 - THE ARMY HUMAN SERVICES

20:06 - RESPONDED IN THIS MANNER.

20:07 - I'M NOT JUST IN TIME WHEN BO

20:09 - BY NAME. THE METS ARE IN FAR AS

20:12 - SOME IN THIS ROOM THAT MISTER

20:13 - KNIGHT HOME AND WHEN YOU

20:15 - RECALL.

20:17 - ALL RIGHT FIRST WE CAN WE CAN

20:20 - MAKE AN ARGUMENT OR THE MARINE

20:22 - PROTECTION CHALLENGING BECAUSE

20:24 - HER STANDING TO BRING

20:25 - THIS ACTION AND BEFORE THIS

20:27 - COURT REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE

20:28 - LAW.

20:31 - A STORY. WILL BE HIDDEN COSTS

20:34 - TO SHOOT THEIR OWN

20:35 - CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS IN THIS

20:37 - MATTER INSTEAD, WE'RE VERY

20:40 - CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS OF

20:41 - OUR NAME AND MANY KIDS, I'M

20:45 - WOMEN WHO MAY BE THINKING NOW

20:47 - MAYBE PEOPLE IN THE FUTURE.

21:11 - >>MOST RELATIONSHIP. A 3RD

21:13 - PARTY QUESTION THIS CASE.

21:16 - MAY NOT BE ELIGIBLE WOMEN.

21:21 - MY WAY THAT THAT RELATIONSHIP.

21:24 - THEY HAVE TO SHOW THAT

21:25 - THE ENJOYMENT OF THE RIGHT BY

21:27 - HER PARTY IN SHOULD WAIT

21:30 - FELL OFF. WITH ME YET TO BE

21:33 - THAT BE A PROVIDER WHICH IS TO

21:36 - ENGAGE. THE

21:37 - SECOND PIECE WE HAVE TO SHOW

21:39 - HIS GAME. THERE IS SOME KIND OF

21:41 - HURTS WHICH HAMPERS YOU'RE

21:44 - GOING THE OTHER 3RD PARTY AND

21:47 - TO BRING THIS ACTION ON THEIR

21:48 - OWN BEHALF.

21:52 - MY LIFE.

21:53 - >>AND MY MY CONCERN IS WHETHER

21:56 - OR NOT THERE.

21:57 - THE INDIVIDUAL.

22:00 - AND THEN

22:01 - THOSE BRING THAT BACK AND

22:02 - WHETHER THEY HAVE THE FINANCIAL

22:04 - MEANS THERE ARE YOU SAYING THAT

22:05 - THERE

22:05 - WERE INDIVIDUAL. WELL WITH THIS

22:08 - ACTION COME BEFORE THE COURT.

22:12 - AND THEN A FOLLOW-UP

22:14 - TO THAT IS THERE A DISTINCTION

22:16 - BETWEEN THE 2 ORGANIZATIONS AND

22:18 - THE POSITION THAT BROUGHT THE

22:20 - ACTION IN FISHER.

22:24 - >>I CAN GET INTO THE TRUE PART

22:26 - OF YOUR QUESTION. THE.

22:32 - IN 7 MONTHS. THERE HAVE BEEN

22:34 - CASES, I'M CASE A LOT

22:37 - BEFORE COURTS BY WINNING

22:39 - CHALLENGING ABORTION

22:40 - RESTRICTIONS.

22:42 - THESE PEOPLE ACROSS THE

22:44 - COUNTRY AND THE INCLUDING THE

22:45 - FISHER CASE WHICH WE'RE HERE

22:47 - WE'RE TRACKING HERE EARLIER

22:48 - TODAY AND THAT YOU WILL IN

22:51 - THESE CASES ARE DIGITAL SELF

22:53 - AND YOU KNOW, AND IN GROUPS.

22:57 - CAMPERS WOMEN. YOU WILL BE

22:59 - TOO BORING. IT IS ALL IT'S ALL

23:02 - ON THE ROOM. THE ARMY IN FACT,

23:05 - THE GREEN PARTY.

23:07 - AND A NEW AND PEOPLE ARE

23:09 - INTERESTED IN PRINCIPLE.

23:11 - THEY ARE THE

23:11 - RIGHT PARTY. THE BEEN PATIENTS

23:14 - OF THEIR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS.

23:23 - >>IF YOU DID YOU SAY THAT THERE

23:26 - WERE.

23:36 - I THANK YOU.

23:39 - >>COUNCIL IN

23:41 - SINGLETON TAKE THE UNITED

23:43 - STATES SUPREME COURT CASE

23:44 - DIRECTLY ON POINT IN THAT WE'RE

23:46 - WE'RE TALKING THERE ABOUT

23:48 - WOMEN PATIENTS DECISION THAT

23:51 - WAS CONCERNING ABORTION AS

23:53 - WELL.

23:55 - >>YOU GOT YOUR NUMBER ONE WITH

23:56 - WHAT YOU REGARD. THE STORM AND

23:59 - THAT SINGLE CASE

24:01 - WE LOOK AROUND WE GIVE AN

24:05 - FOUND ALL WILL BE IN THE

24:06 - MAJORITY PM AND

24:08 - THAT PROVIDERS I CAME TO HIS OR

24:11 - HER OWN CAR TO SHOW THAT THE

24:13 - MAJORITY OF BACKCOURT DID NOT

24:14 - ONLINE THAT.

24:17 - THEY ARE THE TEAM.

24:19 - WHINERS A SEARCH OF THE RIGHT

24:22 - TO THE HEART.

24:25 - >>FOR ITSELF IN NEED IN A

24:27 - GENERAL ASSOCIATION PERSIST FOR

24:29 - MENTAL HEALTH

24:29 - CASE CLEAR. WE ARE OUTSTANDING

24:31 - THROUGH SINCE THE SHUTDOWN OF

24:33 - COLLEGE YOU DISTINGUISH THAT.

24:39 - >>I AM BRITTANY LES. TIONS

24:41 - CORRECTLY THAT PROVIDES.

24:45 - MANDATED THAT

24:46 - THE PROVIDERS ON THE LINE TO

24:49 - YOUR INSURANCE CARRIERS.

24:51 - WHAT

24:51 - THEY ARE WHAT THEY CHARGE THEIR

24:53 - PATIENTS INCLUDED IN ANY

24:55 - INFORMATION THAT WOULD HAVE

24:55 - BEEN PRIVATE INFORMATION ALL OF

24:59 - THEIR PATIENTS.

25:03 - THE CO-OWNER RICK RANCH KEEN TO

25:05 - ASSERT THE

25:06 - PRIVACY RIGHTS OF THEIR

25:08 - PATIENTS IN THAT CASE THAT

25:09 - PRECEDE WHICH WILL WHAT YOU

25:10 - READ.

25:13 - AND REALLY WITH DIRECT

25:15 - THAT PROVIDERS

25:16 - THE RIVER PAID 10 NO IDEA THE

25:18 - REGULATION CAN JUST YOU KNOW I

25:21 - HEAR A THING YET TO A CERTAIN

25:23 - AND RUN SMEAR. THEY CAN'T

25:26 - REPLACE MISTER CRUZ I WAS TRIP.

25:29 - THE SECOND

25:29 - PIECE IS THAT WOULD BE.

25:33 - RIGHT ENJOYED BY 3RD PARTY, THE

25:35 - PRIVACY INTERESTS.

25:38 - IT'S STRICTLY DOWN ALL WITH THE

25:41 - PROVIDERS INTEREST

25:42 - AND PROTECT INFORMATION.

25:47 - THE PRIVATE INFORMATION OF THE

25:48 - PATIENTS. THAT'S NOT THE

25:50 - SITUATION HERE. HERE

25:53 - WE HAVE

25:55 - IT BE IF THE RATE BE EMPLOYED

25:57 - BY HER PARTY BEING PATIENT

25:59 - BEING. THERE PROTECTION FORCE.

26:03 - THERE IS NOTHING IT'S.

26:06 - BUILDUP

26:08 - WIRES ABILITY TO PROVIDE THE

26:09 - SERVICES THAT I NEEDED TO KNOW

26:12 - RESTRICTION. BY THE STATUTE

26:14 - CALLED HER A LIAR.

26:17 - >>AND PART OF WHAT THE

26:19 - PROVIDERS SAYING THAT, ALTHOUGH

26:21 - THEY ADMITTED THAT

26:23 - THEY'RE NOT LOOKING FOR ANY

26:24 - KIND OF FINANCIAL LAW

26:26 - AND THAT THEY DO PERFORM PROPER

26:29 - IN 95% OF THE THE ABORTION

26:31 - AND THEREFORE IT APPEARS ON THE

26:33 - FACE THAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR

26:36 - FINANCIAL SUPPORT BY BRINGING

26:37 - THIS ACTION AS OPPOSED TO

26:39 - REALLY SUPPORTING THE RIGHT OF

26:41 - THE WOMEN.

26:42 - >>YOU YES TRYING TO GET IT IN

26:46 - THE SENSE THAT AND WHAT THAT

26:48 - SHOWS IS THAT THEY ARE NOT NEW

26:51 - ZONE OF INTERESTS.

26:54 - >>THE GOOD

26:54 - THAT THESE CONSTITUTIONAL

26:56 - RIGHTS ARE SEEKING TO ATTACK

26:57 - NORTH KOREA KEPT GETTING

26:59 - FURTHER AGREE. WE'RE TOLD HE

27:01 - READ THAT THE JURY AND THE

27:02 - SUBSTANTIAL.

27:04 - THEY HAVE A DIRECT AND

27:06 - IMMEDIATE INTEREST IN

27:07 - THIS LITIGATION. WE HAVE IN THE

27:09 - COUNTRY, THE RICHEST CANNOT BE

27:11 - REMOTE END OF

27:12 - THE YEAR. IT CANNOT BE WITHIN

27:14 - THE ZONE OF INTEREST TALKING

27:15 - PROTECTED. A CONSTANT PARADE

27:18 - PERMIT THEY ARE PEOPLE BEING

27:19 - THE KEY. OBVIOUSLY THE TIME

27:21 - RESOURCES FOR ME OR NOT.

27:27 - INTERESTS WILL BE PROTECTED BY

27:28 - THE COURT ACTION PROVISIONS OF

27:30 - THE CONSTITUTION.

27:32 - I SEE THAT I AM OUR TIME IN

27:34 - SUMMATION OF THE QUESTION I

27:36 - BECAME THE REPORT WRITTEN US

27:38 - EARLY HOWEVER, THE JACK WITH

27:40 - YOUR GUEST JUST WITH YOU.

27:42 - THE PROPERTY BEST

27:44 - PARTY. SIR WHY LEASH AN

27:45 - OVERPOPULATED AND HIS WORK

27:48 - THROUGH LESLIE BEING VIOLATED

27:49 - IN THIS CASE AND THE OLD ONE

27:51 - ABORTION SIR.

27:54 - >>WHEN YOU WHAT THE DEPARTMENT

27:55 - OF HOME.

27:58 - THE REQUEST BY THE PETITIONER

28:00 - STORM AND THE PUCK HIT HIM.

28:02 - AND INDIVIDUAL WOMEN. WE WILL

28:06 - NOT DO BETTER.

28:14 - THE HALF OF THE TICKET.

28:16 - I'M NOT SURE THAT YOUR NAME.

28:24 - >>PLEASE THE COURT.

28:27 - WE ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS COURT

28:29 - CANNOT OVERTURN FISHER. WHAT

28:31 - THIS COURT CAN DO AND

28:33 - COULD DO. RIGHT AT THE CANYON

28:36 - EXPLAINING WHY FISHER WAS

28:37 - WRONG. WHEN IT OFF OR ON

28:40 - PENNSYLVANIA TO GIVE MORE

28:42 - COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH COVERAGE

28:44 - TO MADAM BUT NOT TO WOMEN AND

28:47 - THEY FOUND THE SCHOOL.

28:48 - >>COUNCIL JUDGE SAFELY HERE

28:49 - HAVE A QUESTION I NEED TO ASK

28:51 - YOU RIGHT UP SON. YOUR LINE IN

28:53 - YOUR. A

28:55 - NEW CLEANING. YOU

28:58 - SEQUEL LEAVE WHICH WILL

28:59 - INVALIDATE ROOM. THE COVERAGE

29:02 - BANS ABORTION LIMIT IN

29:04 - ITS ENTIRETY.

29:08 - IF YOU REQUESTED BELIEVE CAN

29:10 - PUT IN ALL THE EXPENDITURE OF

29:12 - THE

29:12 - STATE PLANS AND SHE SAID THAT

29:14 - EVERY 10 FOOT LOT

29:15 - MORE LIKELY WE'LL CHANGE OUR

29:20 - FOR HOME.

29:24 - NEITHER THE COURT NOR THE

29:26 - PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT.

29:28 - >>HAS

29:31 - INVALID THE FEDERAL LAW.

29:34 - AND SO THE HEIGHT OF THE WOMEN

29:36 - WHO STAY

29:37 - IN PLACE.

29:38 - >>BUT WHY BEST GOALIE FOR THE

29:39 - USE OF STATE FUNDS.

29:43 - >>REALLY FOR THE ENTIRE

29:44 - A SECTION 30 TO 15 SEASON J.

29:48 - BECAUSE IT ON THE PARADE HAS A

29:51 - NEW WORLD

29:52 - AND ELIMINATING THOSE

29:54 - PROVISIONS WOULD NOT BE IN ANY

29:56 - WAY HISTORY.

30:01 - FROM BEING USED FOR ABORTION

30:03 - OUTSIDE OF THE VERY NARROW

30:04 - CIRCUMSTANCES YOU MENTION.

30:08 - EVEN IS.

30:10 - WITH AN ARGUMENT THAT IT

30:12 - COULD BE A NEW BORE HOLE TO

30:14 - HOLE AFTER 3215 C N J

30:17 - OUR HEART, A BROAD

30:19 - SEVERABILITY CLAUSE AND THERE

30:21 - ARE 2 SEVERABILITY.

30:28 - THE STATUE

30:28 - CURRENT CONSTRUCTION.

30:30 - PRINCIPAL, BUT WITH SO POLICE

30:32 - EVER THAT PORTION.

30:36 - >>SEEKING MEDICAL.

30:38 - TO IN VALIDATE.

30:42 - WHICH IS JUST TO JUST DEAL WITH

30:44 - STATE FUNDING. YES.

30:46 - OKAY WAS THAT ANYWHERE YOU'RE

30:48 - LEAVING US. YOUR HONOR. I

30:51 - BELIEVE ARE FREE. CLEARLY

30:54 - FOCUSED ON AND IN

30:57 - I'M MARY I TRUST OF

31:00 - OUR FREE IS THAT WHERE FISHER

31:02 - WHEN WAS NOT LOOKING AT

31:05 - STATE LAW.

31:07 - WHAT FISHER DID WRONG WAS IN

31:09 - FOCUS AND YOU CAN

31:10 - HIRE ANALYSIS ON FEDERAL LAW

31:13 - AND MARCHING IN LOCKSTEP WITH.

31:17 - COURT'S

31:17 - INTERPRETATION OF THE FEDERAL

31:19 - CONSTITUTION. THAT WAS A REALLY

31:21 - BIG MISTAKE BECAUSE I SAY

31:25 - BECAUSE AFTER ALL THE

31:26 - PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

31:29 - I LAY IN RESPONSIBLE FOR THE

31:31 - CONSTRUCTION OF THE COUNTRY ARE

31:33 - COMPETITION.

31:34 - >>I CAN NOT ALL

31:35 - COMMON FOR THE PENNSYLVANIA

31:37 - SUPREME COURT TOO.

31:41 - COURT PRECEDENT 100 FAMILY.

31:44 - EARLY WHEN YOU'RE CONTROLLING.

31:46 - I'M TROUBLED THAT ARE COMMON

31:47 - TO VOTE COMPETITION BUDGET

31:50 - PEOPLE.

31:53 - >>IT WAS A MISTAKE AND WE KNOW

31:55 - THAT WHEN WE LOOK.

31:58 - TO THE LANDS OF THE

31:59 - GUNMAN'S FACTORS GREAT YOU KNOW

32:01 - NOW WE KNOW THAT IS HOW YOU

32:03 - LOOK AT WHETHER A STATE

32:05 - CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISION.

32:10 - PRODUCTION OF THE LITTLE BIT

32:11 - COOL RIGHTS AND IT'S FAIR.

32:13 - THE LAW. SO YOU LOOK AT THE

32:16 - PAST TO LOOK AT THE HISTORY.

32:18 - YOU LOOK AT THIS WASTE OF

32:20 - AUTHORITY FROM OTHER STATES

32:22 - AND YOU LOOK AT THE POLICY

32:24 - CONSIDERATIONS.

32:30 - THE PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION

32:32 - WHICH HAS BEEN HERE.

32:34 - IN WALKS THAT PUTS THE FEDERAL

32:36 - CONSTITUTION WHICH DOES NOT

32:38 - AND THE TEXT OF THE EQUAL

32:40 - RIGHTS AMENDMENT, VERY BROADLY

32:42 - AND WITHOUT LIMITATION. US

32:45 - WOMEN FULL EQUALITY UNDER THE

32:47 - LAW. THE LACK OF A FEDERAL

32:48 - COUNTERPART. THE EURO

32:51 - RENDERED WE ARE LOOKING FOR

32:53 - PROTECTION ANALYSIS AN APP

32:57 - PERRY I COUNT ONE.

32:59 - THANK YOU, I'M LOOKING AT THE

33:01 - FISHER CASE AND THERE

33:03 - ALMOST 2 PAGES OF

33:04 - ANALYSIS OF THE PENNSYLVANIA

33:07 - CONSTITUTION AND THE EQUAL

33:08 - RIGHTS AMENDMENT. SO I'M.

33:10 - >>KIND OF THAT A HEAR ARGUMENTS

33:13 - THAT THEY DID NOT ENGAGE.

33:15 - IN AN APPLE THAT REGARDING THE

33:17 - PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION.

33:24 - >>AND WE DO NOT.

33:33 - EARLY OVERLOOK THAT WOMEN'S

33:35 - REPRODUCTIVE CAPACITY IS AT THE

33:37 - ROOT OF SEX DISCRIMINATION

33:39 - WHICH IS WHAT THE YARRA US

33:41 - POSTED NEAR ADVOCATED THE

33:43 - CONSEQUENCE OF PICTURES

33:46 - IF THAT LEGISLATIVE

33:47 - CLASSIFICATIONS RELATED TO

33:49 - WOMEN'S REPRODUCTIVE CAPACITY.

33:52 - REMOVED FROM SCRUTINY UNDER THE

33:54 - E R.

33:57 - AND THIS WAS REFLECTED IN

34:00 - OPPOSING COUNSEL'S ARGUMENT.

34:03 - THEY SURE REASON.

34:05 - THE TREATMENT THAT WE RECEIVE

34:07 - UNDER MEDICAID CAN'T EVEN

34:10 - COMPARE TO THE TREATMENT OF MEN

34:11 - WERE SEEN. WHY BECAUSE MEN

34:13 - DON'T GET PREGNANT. BAKER SAYS

34:15 - PROGRAM I THINK IT HERE.

34:17 - >>IF YOU'RE TRYING TO 30 EQUAL

34:19 - RIGHTS AMENDMENT DOOR BY DICK

34:21 - RUTAN E YOU HAVE TO HAVE SOME

34:22 - KIND OF A RECOGNIZED RIGHT AND

34:25 - I BUT WITH THE PICTURE COURT

34:26 - WITH THING

34:27 - WITH THAT AND YET THERE THERE

34:29 - MAY BE A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO

34:30 - THE ABORTION, BUT THEY'RE NOT A

34:32 - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO

34:33 - GET FUNDING FOR ECTOR SIDE OF

34:35 - THAT FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT AND THAT

34:37 - THAT WAS THE THING CAN I

34:39 - THOUGHT THEY'RE MAKING IT BUT

34:40 - THEY SAID THE BASE OF THE

34:42 - THINKING HERE IN FACT THAT THE

34:44 - BOARD IF THE FUNDING.

34:47 - THAT THEY WANTED TO EXERCISE.

34:49 - RIGHT WHICH IS NOT

34:51 - WHAT THE COURT THAT WOULD NOT

34:52 - IN ITSELF A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.

34:55 - AND I THINK THE COURT DID

34:57 - ADDRESS THAT AND AND REBUILD

34:59 - IT. ALONG THE LINE THAT'S

35:01 - MY UNDERSTANDING. YOUR HONOR

35:04 - WE'RE NOT SAYING THAT WE HAVE A

35:07 - RIGHT FUNDED ABORTION.

35:10 - >>WE'RE NOT SAYING THAT WHAT

35:11 - WE'RE SAYING IS THAT

35:13 - IF THE COMMONWEALTH, THE FUNDS

35:15 - TO FUND THE HOME CARE. IT MUST

35:17 - DO SO

35:19 - IN ACCORDANCE GENDER EQUALITY

35:22 - PRINCIPLES THAT HAS TO DO

35:23 - SO FAIRLY AND WHO IN THE

35:26 - STATUTORY FRAMEWORK, A FAILURE

35:29 - TO COVER

35:29 - ABORTION EQUITABLY IS

35:31 - DISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF

35:33 - SEX. THE SAME AS A PART OF THE

35:35 - NEW YEAR WITH HER SON.

35:37 - >>CAN YOU ADDRESS THE ARGUMENT

35:39 - EARLIER MADE THAT MEDICAL WHO

35:40 - CANNOT COVER OTHER THINGS IN

35:42 - THE TROOPER DEPLETION OR OTHER

35:44 - MALE REPRODUCTIVE PROCEDURE.

35:47 - WHEN YOUR ARGUMENT

35:48 - ONLY WORK IF ALL OF THOSE WERE

35:50 - ALL OTHER WIFE COVERED.

35:57 - >>THIS IS MORE ANALOGOUS TO

35:58 - THE SITUATION IF MEDICAID

36:01 - COVERED TREATMENT.

36:03 - PROSTATE CANCER. BUT NOT

36:05 - UTERINE CANCER. THE OTHER SIDE

36:08 - THE JUSTICE WILL ARGUE THAT THE

36:09 - CATEGORY FOR MALE AND FEMALE.

36:12 - HERE BETWEEN DIFFERENT TYPES OF

36:13 - CANCER. THEY CAN SAY THAT'S NOT

36:15 - SEX DISCRIMINATION BECAUSE

36:17 - NOBODY'S UTERINE CANCER.

36:19 - THAT'S COVERED. MEN'S

36:21 - OR WOMEN'S. BUT THAT'S REALLY

36:22 - KIND OF

36:23 - EMPTY FORMALISM AND YOU ARE A

36:26 - DEMAND MORE SO THAN TO BE

36:28 - QUALITY THAN THAT. YOU

36:31 - HERE.

36:32 - >>IF YOU'RE MAKING IT

36:33 - SOUND LIKE. YOU KNOW ALL

36:35 - MEDICAL SERVICES SHOULD BE

36:37 - COVERAGE.

36:41 - OVERLOOKED ENTIRELY IS THAT

36:45 - WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT ANY

36:47 - KIND OF MEDICAL SERVICE.

36:49 - >>WE'RE TALKING ABOUT MEDICAL

36:51 - SERVICE THAT GOAL. TO

36:54 - MAKE PRODUCTION AND.

36:57 - A WOMAN'S

36:58 - REPRODUCTIVE CAPACITY HAS BEEN

37:00 - USED AS THE JUSTIFICATION FOR

37:02 - DISADVANTAGING WOMEN. CREW OUT

37:05 - HISTORY. IT'S ABOUT PREGNANT

37:07 - WOMEN THIS

37:09 - GILLETT OUR CAPACITY TO THANK

37:11 - OUR CAPACITY TO WORK AND TO

37:13 - PARTICIPATE IN SOCIETY HAS KEPT

37:16 - PUTTING OFF JURY HAS KEPT

37:18 - COULDN'T OUT OF LAW SCHOOL AND

37:19 - MEDICAL SCHOOL

37:21 - A FLORIDA FROM ALL KINDS

37:22 - OF OCCUPATIONS HAS PREVENTED US

37:26 - FROM GETTING AN EDUCATION HAS

37:27 - DENIED US THE RIGHT

37:28 - TO VOTE.

37:29 - >>THING THAT YOU THINK IT COULD

37:31 - BE YOUR THING THE PREGNANCY

37:32 - PRECLUDED WOMEN ENGAGING IN ALL

37:35 - OF

37:37 - WHO KNOW NO YOUR HONOR I'M

37:40 - QUICKLY THE OFFICE THAT WHAT

37:41 - I'M SAYING IS THAT WELL IT'S

37:44 - ABOUT

37:44 - THAT ABOUT.

37:46 - >>SEVERAL STEREOTYPE TO LEAVE

37:48 - SO THAT WHEN THE PRODUCTIVE

37:50 - CAPACITY.

37:51 - >>UNDERLIES A LOT.

37:54 - LEGAL DISCRIMINATION

37:56 - AGAINST WOMEN.

37:57 - >>INSTEAD BUT THAT HOWARD

38:00 - HOWARD.

38:01 - >>THAT RELATED TO GOVERNMENT

38:02 - FUNDING OF ABORTION.

38:05 - BECAUSE THAT COVERAGE AND.

38:07 - >>SINGLES OUT FOR LESS

38:09 - FAVORABLE TREATMENT. GENDER

38:11 - LINK CHARACTERISTIC. AND THAT'S

38:14 - GENERALLY TO WOMEN AND THE CUT

38:16 - A BAN IN PLACE ENORMOUS HARM

38:19 - ON WOMEN THAT IMPEDES

38:21 - THEIR ABILITY TO PARTICIPATE IN

38:24 - EDUCATION IN CIVIL SOCIETY

38:27 - IN HARLEM.

38:28 - >>AND NUCLEAR THING THAT MADE

38:30 - THE VERY THING THAT THE WOMAN

38:31 - TO GET PREGNANT AND THEREFORE

38:33 - BECAUSE YOU CAN'T HAVE AN

38:34 - ABORTION IS THERE FOR DENIED

38:36 - THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK OR BE

38:38 - EDUCATED.

38:45 - CHOSE TO

38:45 - GET PREGNANT.

38:47 - >>WE KNOW THE MANY

38:50 - WOMEN'S PREGNANCY OR NOT.

38:53 - VOLUNTARY

38:55 - OLD NOT.

38:57 - >>WAY YOU CAN NOT ON KERRY

38:58 - THING YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE

39:00 - EXCEPTION I THINK YOU NEED TO

39:01 - GET OFF OF THE BACK IF THERE'S

39:03 - SOMETHING ELSE OTHER THAN RAPE

39:05 - OR INCEST THAT I THINK YOU'RE

39:06 - FINE BUT MAYBE YOU'RE

39:08 - REFERENCING THE FACT THAT IT'S

39:09 - NOT PLANNED. AND THE SAME.

39:14 - MANY UNWANTED AN UNPLANNED

39:17 - PREGNANCIES.

39:18 - >>YES, YOUR HONOR.

39:19 - >>AND HOW YOU GET AROUND COUNT

39:21 - ON 3RD DOWN TO HOW DO YOU GET

39:23 - AROUND THEN THE QUESTION THAT I

39:24 - AM AND THE SENATE COUNSEL.

39:27 - JUST AGREE THEM NOT SURE.

39:32 - THAT THEY COURT RECOGNIZED THE

39:34 - STATED PURPOSE OF THE BACK.

39:37 - WE'RE NOT AT LIBERTY TO VIOLATE

39:39 - THAT PURPOSE AND THE COURT HAS

39:42 - BEEN RECOGNIZED BY THE

39:43 - LEGISLATURE HASN'T BEEN CHANGED

39:45 - IT RECOGNIZED BY THE SUPREME

39:46 - COURT IN THE

39:47 - 50 K THAT IS THE EVEN UNDER THE

39:50 - INTERMEDIATE SCRUTINY THAT

39:51 - NIGHT COMING. I DON'T I STILL

39:54 - DON'T UNDERSTAND WHERE THE U

39:55 - THAT WAS THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT

39:57 - IN YOUR STRICT NEW YORK HUMAN

39:59 - BUT.

40:02 - THE PURPOSE OF THE ACT IS THE

40:03 - PRESERVATION OF LIFE THE

40:05 - COMMONWEALTH MADE A DECISION TO

40:06 - ENCOURAGE THE BIRTH OF A CHILD

40:08 - IN

40:08 - ALL SITUATIONS EXCEPT FOR

40:10 - ANOTHER LIFE WOULD HAVE TO BE

40:12 - SACRIFICED. MEANING IN THE

40:16 - EVENT OF THAT

40:17 - A POSSIBLE DEATH OF THE MOTHER

40:19 - BECAUSE OF

40:22 - A PREGNANCY AND THE OTHER 2

40:24 - SECTION 3 AND IN THAT.

40:27 - HOW CAN YOU GET

40:28 - AROUND THE STATED PURPOSE OF

40:31 - THE ACT WHEN WHAT YOU'RE ASKING

40:33 - THE VIOLENT KIDS OF THAT.

40:36 - NO YOUR HONOR THE STATE'S

40:38 - INTEREST IN THE LIFE.

40:40 - >>RELIEVE IT OF THE UP WITH HIM

40:43 - TO PROVIDE EQUITABLE HEALTH

40:44 - CARE AND THAT INCREASE CAN

40:46 - NEVER OVERRIDE

40:48 - WOMEN'S HEALTH AND LYING WHEN

40:51 - MEDICAID COVERAGE AND THEY ARE

40:54 - READY FOR CARMEN LAKER IF WE

40:56 - COUNT THE LEGISLATURE ALREADY

40:59 - TOOK INTO CONSIDERATION.

41:01 - >>THE HELP OF THE MOTHER

41:03 - AND MADE THE FAKE EXCEPT TIONS

41:05 - THAT THOSE IN THOSE CASES WHERE

41:07 - THE DEATH OF THREATENED TO THEM

41:09 - THE MOTHER BUT THAT IT WOULD

41:11 - BE FUNDED. SO THERE IS FUNDING

41:14 - FOR IT. IN

41:15 - THE ROOM, THE 5TH PICK

41:16 - SITUATION DESIGNATED BY THE

41:18 - LEGISLATURE. YOUR HONOR THAT IS

41:20 - NOT CORRECT.

41:22 - >>A SECTION 30 TO 15 CMJ DOES

41:25 - NOT.

41:27 - ONLY THE VERY NARROW

41:28 - CIRCUMSTANCES OF A BURNING THE

41:31 - PREGNANT WOMAN'S DEATH AND RAPE

41:34 - AND INCEST WE NOW KNOW WHAT WE

41:36 - DIDN'T KNOW IN

41:37 - 1985.

41:38 - >>I WILL TELL YOU COMING WHAT

41:40 - HEALTH MEAN THEN. HELPING YOU.

41:48 - HELP WEAN PHYSICAL AND

41:50 - MENTAL HEALTH. IT WAS DEFINED

41:52 - IN THE ABORTION TO PROACTIVELY

41:54 - SECTION 32.

41:58 - >>TO INCLUDE A RANGE OF

42:00 - FACTORS.

42:03 - WE KNOW NOW THAT CHILDBIRTH IS

42:05 - 14 TIMES MORE DANGEROUS THAN

42:08 - ABORTION.

42:14 - ENORMOUS DAMAGE ON WOMEN'S

42:16 - HEALTH. EVEN WHEN THEY DO NOT

42:18 - HAVE AN UNDERLYING

42:20 - HEALTH CONDITION. WE KNOW THAT

42:22 - PREGNANCY IS A TIME OF

42:23 - VULNERABILITY FOR MANY WOMEN, A

42:26 - PHYSICAL AND MENTAL HEALTH.

42:28 - ONE

42:29 - IN 4 AND HAVING BODY OR I

42:32 - MEAN YOU'RE GIVING ME THE 5TH

42:33 - PICK THAT I DON'T KNOW THAT ARE

42:34 - PART OF THE RECORD BUT.

42:36 - >>I MEAN I.

42:39 - AND PHYSICAL HEALTH OF THE

42:40 - WOMEN WHO HAVE AN ABORTION IS A

42:41 - COMPROMISE THAT WELL SO I'M NOT

42:43 - SURE THAT.

42:45 - THAT'S YOUR STRONGEST ARGUMENT

42:46 - TO GET AROUND THE A SUPREME

42:48 - COURT CASE THAT THAT RECOGNIZED

42:50 - A PURPOSE AND THAT UNDER

42:52 - ALL 3 OF THE HAT TRICK

42:55 - SCRUTINY, INTERMEDIATE CRUDE, A

42:56 - RATIONAL BASIS. IT WENT THROUGH

42:59 - A THOROUGH.

43:00 - THE BOTTOM LINE IS I THINK

43:02 - YOU'RE ASKING US TO RECOGNIZE

43:03 - THE RIGHT OF FUNDING AS.

43:05 - A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT AND

43:08 - IF YOU COULD ANSWER THAT AND

43:09 - THEN JUST THEY WHAT IS YOUR

43:11 - HARM.

43:14 - DOING LEFT AND RIGHT TO TO

43:15 - FUNDING IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.

43:20 - >>UNDER THE ORDER.

43:22 - >>THE MEDICAID US.

43:27 - FOR MEN'S AND WOMEN'S

43:28 - HEALTH FOODS. I LOOK

43:32 - >>I WANT TO THANK YOU GET YOUR

43:34 - I'M A LITTLE CONFUSED WHY WE'RE

43:37 - DRESSING THAT HER I BELIEVE

43:39 - THAT FISH

43:40 - ARE ALREADY THAT AND THEY SAID

43:43 - THAT THE BASIS FOR THE THINKING

43:44 - HERE NOT SEX BUT ABORTION.

43:46 - THE MERE FACT THAT ONLY WOMEN

43:48 - ARE AFFECTED BY THIS STATUTE

43:50 - DOES NOT NECESSARILY MEAN THAT

43:52 - WOMEN ARE BEING DISCRIMINATED

43:53 - AGAINST BASED ON THE BASIS

43:55 - THAT EFFECT THE EURO DID NOT

43:57 - PROHIBIT DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT

43:59 - AMONG THE AFFECTED WHEN

44:00 - IT HERE. THE TREATMENT THAT IS

44:02 - REASONABLY AND ANNUALLY BASED

44:03 - ON PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS,

44:05 - UNIQUE TO

44:05 - ONE BACK. WE CAN'T GO BACK IN

44:08 - WHAT THE SUPREME COURT HAS

44:10 - ALREADY SAID. I DON'T

44:12 - UNDERSTAND HOW THIS ACTION IT'S

44:14 - DIFFERENT AND BEFORE YOU CLOSER

44:16 - WOULD LIKE YOU TO ADDRESS THE

44:17 - STANDING ISSUE.

44:20 - >>YES, YOUR HONOR.

44:25 - JUST

44:26 - QUICK NOTE. IF

44:28 - I LIKE. BE SURE DID NOT APPLY

44:31 - STRICT SCRUTINY. A FISHER

44:33 - R I RATIONAL BASIS AND THEN

44:36 - ALSO SAID IT WOULD SURVIVE IN A

44:38 - MEDIA SCRUTINY.

44:40 - THE RIGHT QUESTION IS THE RIGHT

44:42 - TO ABORTION WHICH YOU CAN FIND

44:44 - THEM AT ALL RIGHT. UNDER

44:45 - ARTICLE ONE OF THE

44:46 - PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION.

44:49 - THE RIGHT IS PART OF THE

44:50 - PRIVACY RIGHT.

44:51 - APPLIED TO MARY SEXUALITY

44:54 - AND PROCREATION YOU SEE THAT IN

44:56 - BUT NOT DOT HERE IN THE NEXT IN

44:59 - THIS IF A CLEAR REFERENCE

45:02 - JUST EARLIER THIS YEAR THE

45:03 - PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

45:04 - ACKNOWLEDGED THIS AND LAUGH.

45:07 - THIS IS REALLY THE COMMISSION

45:08 - WHICH I'M SORRY WE DID

45:10 - LIGHTNER GRIEF BECAUSE IT WAS

45:12 - ISSUED AFTER OR EVEN CLOSE.

45:15 - 30 TO 1096

45:17 - 11 '08 AND SIMILAR LANGUAGE CAN

45:19 - GET THIS ON A HOST OF GETTING

45:21 - IN FROM LEFT HERE DO NOT GO FOR

45:23 - 50 PM C ABORTION

45:25 - IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT UNDER

45:27 - PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION AND

45:29 - FORTUNE. ZANDI THEY'RE SUBJECT

45:31 - TO STRICT SCRUTINY, AND IT

45:33 - CANNOT TOLERATE THAT SCRUTINY,

45:35 - TURNING TO STANDING.

45:38 - >>YOU GET A STANDING BY I'M

45:40 - SORRY I I I'M HAVING TROUBLE.

45:43 - >>FOLLOWING YOUR EQUAL RIGHTS

45:45 - AMENDMENT ARGUMENT.

45:47 - YOU I HAVE ARGUED THAT ONE THE

45:50 - LEGISLATURE 100 K TO PROVIDE A

45:53 - MEDICAID PROGRAM. THEY MUST DO

45:56 - SO FAIRLY WITH RESPECT

46:03 - AND

46:03 - THEY CANNOT AND AND TO DO IT

46:06 - FAIRLY THEY MAY NOT THE THING

46:07 - WE'RE TRAINED MEN AND WOMEN.

46:10 - HOW DOES THE PROBLEM IS WHAT WE

46:12 - HAVE. HERE A GROUP OF

46:15 - PREGNANT WOMEN AND ROLLED

46:17 - AND MEDICAID. THOSE WOMEN WHO

46:20 - CHOOSE TO TERMINATE THEIR

46:22 - PREGNANCY ARE TREATED

46:23 - DIFFERENTLY FROM WOMEN WHO

46:25 - CHEW.

46:28 - NOT TO TERMINATE HER PREGNANCY

46:29 - BUT TO GO. I PLAYED THE

46:31 - PREGNANCY TO FULL-TERM.

46:37 - VIOLATE THE EQUAL RIGHTS

46:40 - ARE PICK YOUR LANE EXACTLY HOW

46:42 - THEY MET EQUAL RIGHTS

46:43 - AMENDMENT.

46:46 - LEAD TO ONE CONCLUSION THAT

46:48 - YOU BELIEVE IN MAINLY IT

46:50 - MIGHT PROVIDE. FUNDING FOR

46:52 - ABORTION AS WELL AS PILED

46:54 - LIVERY.

46:57 - >>MEDICAL SERVICE SAYING TO ME

46:59 - REALLY NEEDED BY WOMEN

47:01 - HAS BEEN CAR OUT OF OTHERWISE

47:04 - COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE.

47:07 - ON THE BASE IS THE REASON THE

47:09 - THE FISHER COURT DID THIS.

47:11 - THE CAUSE. FISHER SAID WELL

47:13 - THERE WE NEED PHYSICAL

47:15 - CHARACTERISTICS, ONLY WOMEN CAN

47:17 - BECOME PREGNANT.

47:21 - IF YOU CAN DISCRIMINATE AGAINST

47:23 - WOMEN BASED ON THE UNIQUE

47:25 - PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS, A

47:27 - VERY VERY PRODUCTIVE CAPACITY.

47:32 - WHAT MAKES THEM WOMEN

47:33 - AND IF YOU CAN GET LESS

47:35 - BENEFITS TO EVERYONE WHO HAS A

47:37 - UTERUS.

47:39 - HARD TO DISTINGUISH FROM SEX

47:41 - DISCRIMINATION PURE AND SIMPLE.

47:43 - I I.

47:49 - >>AND WE'RE ALL THE MEDICAID

47:51 - WELL I A CLASSIFICATION THEY

47:53 - FROM. SO YOU'RE SAYING ONE.

47:57 - AND THE

47:57 - GOVERNMENT PAPER PROGRAM

48:00 - OF HEALTH AND TURN MY PAPER

48:03 - EVERY FERVOR THAT IS RELATED TO

48:06 - A PERSON'S GENDER. I MEAN YOUR

48:09 - HONOR.

48:13 - >>SECTION

48:14 - 3215 OR DOING IS

48:17 - TAKING HOW CARVING HOW OF AN

48:20 - OTHERWISE COMPREHENSIVE SCHEME.

48:23 - A

48:23 - MEDICAL SERVICE CRITICAL TO

48:25 - WOMEN'S EQUALITY AND

48:29 - >>OKAY SO WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS

48:31 - ANY CAR.

48:33 - HE DEMANDED ONLY BY A WOMAN AND

48:36 - THE EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT THAT

48:38 - YOUR POSITION I WOULD NEED

48:40 - MORE FACTS.

48:40 - >>LET YOUR HONOR I WOULD NOT

48:42 - SAY AND I DON'T THINK I WOULD

48:45 - GO

48:47 - >>A PORTION OFFEND PEOPLE RIGHT

48:50 - AMENDMENT, I'M JUST HAVING

48:51 - TROUBLE PUTTING THEM ALL.

48:52 - GATHER. WELL YOUR THE CASE,

48:56 - OKAY SO.

48:59 - ABOUT 4 IN VITRO FERTILIZATION

49:01 - THAT IS UNIQUELY. YOU

49:04 - REQUIRED BY.

49:07 - >>WELL I'M JUST OUT.

49:11 - THAT'S OKAY AND IF THAT WERE TO

49:13 - COME BEFORE THE COURT THEN WE

49:15 - WOULD ENGAGE IN THAT SAME

49:17 - ANALYSIS AND WE DON'T HAVE

49:20 - THOSE FACTS BEFORE US TODAY.

49:23 - AND I'M VERY

49:24 - HOPEFUL MODEL A LOOK AT AND

49:27 - THIS GOES TO THE ARGUMENT THAT

49:29 - ACTORS IS NEW MEXICO RIGHT TO

49:31 - CHANGE VERSUS JOHNSON, THIS IS

49:33 - THE CASE.

49:34 - INVOLVING MEXICO'S EQUAL

49:36 - RIGHTS AMENDMENT. MEDICAID

49:38 - COVERAGE FAN THROUGH PORTION

49:40 - AND THE ANALYSIS THAT FAST TO

49:42 - COURT DID IS NOW ASSISTANT OUT

49:45 - COURTS

49:45 - SHOULD DO. AND THEY LOOKED AT

49:47 - WHETHER YOU ARE A GREATER

49:49 - PROTECTION THAN THE FEDERAL

49:50 - CONSTITUTION AND ANSWER THAT

49:52 - QUESTION. YES.

49:55 - THAT THE COVERAGE THAN THE LATE

49:56 - TO NEED PHYSICAL

49:57 - CHARACTERISTIC. GRAHAM. THE

49:59 - BAND FROM THE SEARCHING

50:01 - BEAUTIFUL INQUIRY. THE ANSWER

50:03 - THAT POINT YOU KNOW I'M LIKE

50:04 - THIS DOES THE COVERAGE BEGAN

50:06 - OFFERING THE DISADVANTAGE

50:08 - WOMEN. YES.

50:09 - IT WAS ALL THE PROGRAM THAT

50:11 - DOESN'T APPLY THE SAME. THE

50:13 - OTHER 2 MEN AND WOMEN, YES

50:15 - AND FINALLY IS THERE A

50:16 - COMPELLING JUSTIFICATION FOR

50:18 - TREATING MANY WOMEN

50:19 - DIFFERENTLY. NO, THE THAT

50:21 - AN ANALYSIS, THE TRULY.

50:26 - AGREE WITH

50:27 - THAT ANALYSIS AND WHENEVER

50:29 - WE'RE CAPPING A FACTOR AGAINST

50:32 - THE EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT.

50:33 - >>THE CONCLUSIONS ARE A LITTLE

50:34 - BIT DIFFICULT OF ALL I DON'T

50:36 - KNOW A CRIMINAL IN FAVOR

50:39 - OF MAN AND AGAIN WOMEN.

50:42 - DRAW A DISTINCTION BETWEEN.

50:49 - WHO CAN TO RESPOND TO THEIR

50:51 - PREGNANCY DIFFERENTLY. WHAT

50:53 - WE'RE TALKING ABOUT NOT MA'AM.

50:54 - >>I HAVE TO

50:56 - COUNCIL WHAT IS THE NAME OF

50:57 - THAT NEW MEXICO CASES IN YOUR

50:59 - BRIEF. IT IS YOUR HONOR NEW

51:01 - MEXICO RIGHT TO CHOOSE VERSUS

51:03 - JOHNSON JOHNSON OK, THANK YOU,

51:09 - >>COMMENT I I KNOW YOU HAD SAID

51:13 - THAT THE. FISHER COURT DID

51:15 - NOT ADDRESS.

51:16 - HI SCRUTINY THAN I GREATLY, BUT

51:19 - I THINK AND IF THEY BECAUSE IN

51:21 - FACT IT DID. BUT IF THE TERM

51:23 - AND THAT IT IN I

51:25 - DON'T THINK THAT THE COURT

51:26 - WOULD DISAGREE WITH YOU

51:27 - ABOUT THAT ABORTION IS A

51:28 - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT THAT FISHER

51:29 - COURT DID NOT. THE STATION WAS

51:33 - WEATHER THE RIGHT TO

51:34 - HAVE FUNDING IS A

51:36 - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT AND THEY SAID

51:38 - IT WAS NOT AND WHETHER THEY'RE

51:40 - IN THE GYM CLASS WITH THE FACT

51:42 - THAT CLASS AND THEY SAID THAT

51:44 - HAD NEVER BEEN I RECOGNIZE THAT

51:46 - THE SUSPECT CLASS. THERE GO

51:48 - THE HIGH. THE STRICT SCRUTINY

51:50 - STANDARD DID NOT APPLY WE DID

51:52 - IN

51:52 - FACT ENGAGE AND THAT ANNOUNCED

51:55 - THIS AND THAT WAS THE

51:56 - DETERMINATION WAS AN FAITH ON A

51:58 - RIGHT TO ABORTION

52:00 - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT FOR JEWISH

52:02 - WHETHER THERE WAS A FUNDAMENTAL

52:03 - RIGHT TO FUNDING FOR WHERE'S

52:06 - THE BOTTOM.

52:07 - >>SO YOUR HONOR WE ARE NOT

52:09 - ASSERTING IN IN SAYING THE

52:10 - PROTECTIVE CLASSIFICATION A

52:13 - 3RD OF THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE

52:14 - PROTECTION ANALYSIS FOR PUTTING

52:16 - FORWARD.

52:19 - ALL RIGHT NOW SINCE THEN THE

52:20 - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT IN QUESTION

52:22 - TO THE RIGHT TO ABORTION.

52:24 - UNDER OUR CONSTITUTION.

52:28 - >>RIGHT TO ABORTION FUNDING.

52:30 - GREAT JOB.

52:33 - YEAH.

52:33 - >>THERE ARE NO ONE IS SAYING

52:34 - THAT PENNSYLVANIA IS REQUIRED.

52:37 - OKAY FOR ABORTION CARE.

52:39 - WHAT WE'RE SAYING IS THAT IF

52:41 - THE STATE CREATES A

52:42 - COMPREHENSIVE.

52:45 - IT MUST FUND ABORTION, FAIRLY

52:48 - AND EQUITABLY AND 2.

52:51 - ACCORDANCE WITH THE GENDER

52:52 - EQUALITY PRINCIPLE IN OUR STATE

52:55 - YOU ARE. AND IF I MAY SAY JUST

52:58 - A MOMENT OF OUTSTANDING I

53:00 - REALIZE I'M OVER MY TIME.

53:06 - UNQUESTIONABLY HAVE STANDING TO

53:08 - BRING THIS ACTION UNDER WILLIAM

53:10 - PENN PARKING GARAGE AND UNDER

53:12 - AND IN FULL. VERSUS DEPARTMENT

53:15 - OF HEALTH. IT IS THE PATIENTS

53:17 - PRIVACY INTERESTS IN HAND AND

53:19 - PULL.

53:21 - THE SURGING 5 THE

53:23 - DENTAL ASSOCIATION. CAN WE TALK

53:27 - ABOUT WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE

53:29 - DISTINCTION BECAUSE I DON'T.

53:30 - >>MY RECOLLECTION

53:32 - IS THAT THE INDIVIDUALS WERE

53:35 - NOT EVEN AWARE OF THE

53:36 - INFORMATION THAT WOULD BE

53:38 - MANDATED FOR THEM. THAT IS

53:40 - TO PROVIDE. AND WHILE IT IS

53:42 - STARTING LINE THERE.

53:44 - >>YOUR HONOR THEY CERTAINLY

53:45 - COULD HAVE BEEN MADE AWARE.

53:51 - COMING TO COURT

53:52 - TO SUE

53:54 - HERE THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN

53:56 - OUR PROVIDERS AND PATIENTS.

53:59 - INEXPLICABLY BOUND UP.

54:01 - THE ACTIVITY THE PROVIDERS ARE

54:04 - SEEKING

54:04 - TO PURSUE. IT'S

54:08 - FREE ON KNOW IF I LIKE IT ON

54:10 - RAVEL THAT I MEAN THAT THE

54:11 - CONCLUDING VERY STATEMENT.

54:13 - >>HOW ARE THEY FOUND UP I MEAN

54:15 - WHY CAN'T THE INDIVIDUAL.

54:17 - THE DESIRE TO HAVE AN ABORTION

54:19 - COME FOR HIM.

54:22 - >>SEVERAL FACTORS HINDERING

54:23 - THAT YOUR HONOR UNIQUELY IN THE

54:25 - ABORTION CONTEXT IN THAT'S

54:27 - REALLY WHY HERE'S A HUGE BLUE

54:30 - LONG LINE OF ABORTION

54:32 - PRECEDENT.

54:34 - OVER THE PLACE AT THE STATE AND

54:36 - FEDERAL LEVELS IN WHICH

54:37 - MEDICAL PROVIDERS AND STANDING

54:39 - TO REPRESENT THE INTERESTS

54:40 - OF PATIENTS. MOST RECENTLY THIS

54:43 - ISSUE WITH PART OF JUNE MEDICAL

54:45 - SERVICES TO SCHOOLS, SO ONE OF

54:47 - THE QUESTIONS THE U.S.

54:48 - SUPREME COURT. THE SITTER WAS

54:51 - THE COOL THING ABOUT HOW THE

54:52 - SINGLETON I WILL SQUARE.

54:55 - THAT IS FORCING PROVIDERS DO

54:57 - HAVE STANDING TO ASSERT THE

54:59 - INTERESTS OF THEIR PATIENTS AND

55:01 - THE REASON WHY IS THAT.

55:04 - ORSON WELLES THE IN PERSON

55:07 - THESE KSAT MAY VERY WELL BE.

55:10 - >>AND APPROPRIATE INQUIRY BY

55:12 - NOT BEING WORRY THAT OUR

55:13 - SUPREME COURT AS DIRECTOR

55:16 - ENGAGE HIM WHEN FACED WITH A

55:19 - QUESTION ABOUT STANDING.

55:20 - I HAVE TO BE IN AN INTERIM HEY

55:23 - IT'S GOING TO BE. AND COME TO

55:26 - YOUR INTEREST.

55:31 - THE RIGHT OF AN INDIVIDUAL

55:32 - WOMAN WHO CAN'T HAVE AN

55:34 - ABORTION PAID FOR BY MEDICAL

55:36 - CENTER THAT INDIVIDUAL MEET THE

55:39 - PARKING PASS.

55:43 - THE THE SECRETARY IS BACK.

55:47 - YOU DON'T HAVE. AND THE MEDIA.

55:52 - I EARN A MEDIA IRREPARABLE

55:54 - HARM.

55:55 - WELL REPERTOIRE THAT RIGHT

55:57 - FOOT. YOU DO NOT MEET THE PAN.

56:02 - FOR FANNING NUMBER ONE AND

56:04 - NUMBER 2.

56:12 - THE INTEREST YOU

56:13 - FOR YOU

56:13 - KNOW IT AND PROVING YOU HAVE TO

56:16 - SCRAMBLE TO FIND MONEY TO

56:17 - PROVIDE. ABORTION FOR

56:20 - INDIGENT PATIENTS.

56:21 - DO NOT FALL WITHIN THE TOWN OF

56:24 - THE CONSTITUTIONAL PROTECTION

56:26 - BUT WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT.

56:30 - >>INTERESTS ARE DIRECT

56:31 - SUBSTANTIAL

56:32 - AND IMMEDIATE. IT'S DIRECT

56:34 - BECAUSE HER INJURIES ARE CAUSED

56:36 - 5 A CHALLENGE FOR HIM WE CAN

56:39 - GET REIMBURSED FOR THE MEDICAL

56:40 - CARE THAT WE PROVIDE

56:41 - SUPPORT PATIENTS. IT'S

56:43 - SUBSTANTIAL BECAUSE IT'S MORE

56:45 - THAN WE ARE TRACKING TRUTH AT

56:46 - ALL TO THIS IMPASSE. I'M SURE

56:49 - THAT WAS COMPORT WITH THE

56:50 - CONSTITUTION. WE CAN

56:52 - PUT PAID IT'S IMMEDIATE BECAUSE

56:54 - THE CAUSAL CONNECTION, YOU KNOW

56:56 - THE PROVIDERS DURING

56:57 - THE BRIDE.

56:58 - >>THERE ARE MANY PER FIGHTER

57:00 - THAT TURN PEOPLE AWAY. TO

57:03 - PROVIDE FOR HER.

57:11 - THAT IS WHAT THEY DO THEY

57:13 - PROVIDE ABORTION CARE, 95%.

57:16 - >>OF THE ABORTION CARE IN THE

57:18 - CAR WHO PROVIDED BY OUR.

57:20 - ABOARD THE PETITIONERS IN THIS

57:22 - CASE. THAT'S AN

57:25 - IMMEDIATE CAUSE CONNECTION

57:28 - OR INJURY AND THE

57:29 - CHALLENGE PROVISION THAT'S ONE

57:31 - SHORT STEP AWAY THE SAME WAY IT

57:33 - AND PARKING GARAGE. WE'RE NOT

57:35 - ELIGIBLE

57:36 - FOR COVERAGE, I'VE HEARD THAT

57:38 - WE CAN FEEL THE ABORTION CARE.

57:41 - OUR PATIENTS ARE ELIGIBLE

57:42 - FOR CARS HER JOB.

57:44 - IS THERE ANY

57:45 - CASE THERE AND WINNING HIS 8TH

57:47 - THERE ANY IS THERE ANY CAPEL

57:48 - OUT THERE IT SAYS THAT BECAUSE

57:50 - SOMEBODY'S GOING TO HAVE A

57:51 - FINANCIAL IMPACT.

57:54 - >>THIS WHERE THEY DON'T HAVE TO

57:55 - PROVIDE THEY PARTICULARLY

57:57 - SERVICE EAGLE STANDING.

58:01 - >>I DON'T SEE A

58:01 - DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AND IN THAT

58:04 - REGARD AND WILLIAM PENN PARKING

58:06 - REALLY

58:07 - I MEAN WELL YOU HAVE A PARKING

58:09 - DO HAVE TO SELL THEIR PARKING

58:11 - SPACES.

58:12 - I SUPPOSE IT'S UNREASONABLE TO

58:14 - EXPECT ABORTION PATIENTS TO BE

58:16 - THE ONES TO COME FORWARD TO TO

58:18 - PASS RESTRICTIVE ABORTION LAWS.

58:21 - THEY HAVE A STRONG PRIVACY

58:23 - INTERESTS AND NOT A PLAINTIFF

58:26 - IN LITIGATION. THE PREGNANCY.

58:28 - I'M LIMITED PREGNANCY AND

58:33 - WAS BEFORE THE CASE EVER GETS

58:35 - THE RESOLUTION.

58:37 - IMPORTANTLY WITH THIS COURT

58:39 - RECOGNIZED ABOUT A YEAR AGO IN

58:41 - A CASE CALLED CROC VERSUS

58:43 - DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. THERE ARE

58:44 - SAFETY AND SECURITY CONCERNS

58:47 - SURROUNDING THE WITH FEET OF

58:50 - ABORTION SERVICES THAT ARE YOU

58:53 - A UNIQUE AND NOT AMERICAN

58:56 - PROTECTION OF OUR LAWS.

59:07 - THANK YOU YOU'RE ON HIM.

59:09 - >>THANK YOU MAKE UP TO GIVE A

59:11 - CONCLUDING STATEMENT.

59:13 - >>SO WE ARE NOT SAYING THAT

59:14 - THERE'S NO UNIQUE PHYSICAL

59:16 - CHARACTERISTICS THAT COULD EVER

59:18 - JUSTIFY DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT.

59:21 - POSSIBLY THERE IS.

59:23 - I WOULD HAVE TO SURVIVE

59:25 - EXTREMELY

59:25 - FOR PROVIEW TO ENSURE THAT IT

59:27 - WASN'T JUST THE VERY HIGH IN

59:29 - THE SKIES. HERE THE UNIQUE

59:31 - PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE

59:33 - 2 WOMEN'S REPRODUCTIVE

59:35 - CAPACITY. BASICALLY A CAR.

59:37 - HE FORFEITED ABOUT THIS

59:39 - AND THE BASIS FOR MUCH IF NOT

59:41 - MOST OF THE DAY SAID BEEN PAID

59:42 - TO PREVENT THAT WOULD IMPACT

59:44 - THE STARKLY RECEIVED

59:46 - COVERING ALL A MAN'S MEDICAL

59:48 - CARE NOT COVERING ALL OF

59:49 - WOMEN'S

59:50 - MEDICAL CARE CAN BE EXCUSED BY

59:53 - SAYING THAT MANY WOMEN HAVE

59:54 - DIFFERENT.

59:56 - THEY BOTH NEED HEALTH CARE IN

59:58 - 980 ERIE MOVE ANYTHING. IT'S THE

01:00 - 03.060 HEALTH CARE CAN BE A PORTION.

01:00 - 05.890 I KNOW WAY THE DISADVANTAGES

01:00 - 08.320 WOMEN BECAUSE THEY ARE WOMEN.

01:00 - 10.370 WE WOULD ASK THAT THE

01:00 - 12.760 PRELIMINARY OBJECTION. THE

01:00 - 13.450 OVERALL.

01:00 - 18.750 ALL RIGHT AND MR.

01:00 - 23.440 >>I'LL TRY TO MOVE QUICKLY

01:00 - 24.880 THROUGH A FEW WHAT I THINK ARE

01:00 - 27.150 VERY KEEN AND MISSIONS THAT WE

01:00 - 28.420 JUST HEARD OF PETITIONERS

01:00 - 28.830 COUNCIL.

01:00 - 30.540 >>NUMBER ONE.

01:00 - 32.240 >>IT'S THE FIRST COUNCIL SAID,

01:00 - 32.340 AND

01:00 - 35.240 I QUOTE RIGHT IN QUESTION HERE

01:00 - 36.730 IS THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION.

01:00 - 38.330 NO IT

01:00 - 41.200 IS NOT. RIGHT IN QUESTION HERE

01:00 - 42.410 IS THE RIGHT TO WHETHER OR NOT

01:00 - 44.180 THE COMMONWEALTH MUST ON

01:00 - 46.230 AND ABORTION. AND THE MOST

01:00 - 47.770 IMPORTANT LINE AND THE ENTIRE

01:00 - 49.970 FISCHER CANYON IS IN FACT THE

01:00 - 52.840 VERY FIRST FLIGHT A COURT SAYS

01:00 - 55.220 THIS CASE DOES NOT A CONCERN.

01:00 - 56.510 THE RIGHT TO AN ABORTION.

01:00 - 59.740 THE FOCUS HERE PETITIONERS ARE

01:00 - 01.600 TRYING TO SKEW HERE TO MAKE

01:01 - 02.830 THIS CASE ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT

01:01 - 03.940 A WOMAN HAS A RIGHT TO AN

01:01 - 05.120 ABORTION IN PENNSYLVANIA.

01:01 - 08.670 AS YOU IN THE DEPLOYMENT SINCE

01:01 - 11.300 1985 AND STILL TODAY CAN HAVE

01:01 - 12.640 AN ABORTION THEY HAVE A RIGHT

01:01 - 14.160 TO AN ABORTION. BUT THEY DON'T

01:01 - 14.980 HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE THE

01:01 - 17.310 COMMONWEALTH. I 4 THAT IS THE

01:01 - 18.840 RIGHT IN COURT AND THEN

01:01 - 19.960 MISFORTUNE MADE ANOTHER

01:01 - 21.750 ADMISSION WHERE SHE SAID THE

01:01 - 23.680 RIGHT TO FUNDING IS NOT A

01:01 - 25.850 FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT. SHE IS QUITE

01:01 - 26.160 CORRECT.

01:01 - 28.410 BUT BECAUSE THIS CASE IS ABOUT

01:01 - 30.580 THE RIGHT TO FORM AND BECAUSE

01:01 - 31.680 FUNDING IS NOT A

01:01 - 33.370 FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT. AND THE

01:01 - 34.800 QUESTION ALSO ADMITTED THAT

01:01 - 36.120 INDIGENCY IS NOT A

01:01 - 38.850 SUSPECT CLASS. WE ARE SQUARELY

01:01 - 40.570 WITHIN THE RATIONAL BASIS

01:01 - 43.320 REVIEW HERE AND NO MORE AND

01:01 - 44.590 WHEN YOU'RE IN A RATIONAL BASIS

01:01 - 46.510 REVIEW. THE INQUIRY BECOMES

01:01 - 47.990 WHETHER OR NOT THE STATE HAS A

01:01 - 49.190 SUFFICIENT INTEREST TO

01:01 - 49.940 DIFFERENTIATE

01:01 - 52.910 SOCIAL POLICY. ENCOURAGE

01:01 - 54.400 BEHAVIOR, ONE WAY OR THE OTHER

01:01 - 56.220 AND HERE JUST MCCALL A STAND.

01:01 - 59.430 WHAT IS EXACTLY OF COURSE WHICH

01:01 - 59.750 IS THAT

01:01 - 02.160 INDIGENCY ITSELF CAN BE A

01:02 - 04.630 SUSPECT CLASS AND HERE

01:02 - 06.950 THE INTEREST IS THE COMPELLING

01:02 - 09.370 INTEREST IN PROTECTING WIFE OF

01:02 - 10.460 A CHILD FOR THAT

01:02 - 12.480 CHILD'S MOTHER. IT HAS LONG

01:02 - 13.710 BEEN HELD IN I DON'T THINK THAT

01:02 - 15.250 ANYONE ON YOUR SIDE WOULD

01:02 - 17.420 DISAGREE. AND THAT HAS BEEN

01:02 - 19.050 RECOGNIZED AS AN IMPORTANT

01:02 - 20.660 GOVERNMENT INTEREST. BOTH AT

01:02 - 22.160 THE FEDERAL LEVEL AND HERE AT

01:02 - 23.010 THE STATE LEVEL

01:02 - 25.540 AND WORRY ABORTION-RELATED CASE

01:02 - 27.380 SAID SO ROE V WADE.

01:02 - 30.140 MAYOR GREG HARRIS BEAT MCRAE

01:02 - 31.520 AND OF COURSE OF

01:02 - 32.430 THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC

01:02 - 33.870 WELFARE EVERY ONE OF THOSE

01:02 - 34.280 CASES

01:02 - 36.240 HAVE RECOGNIZED WHAT THEY DEEM

01:02 - 38.150 TO BE VALID AND IMPORTANT

01:02 - 40.130 SIGNIFICANT AND UNQUESTIONABLY

01:02 - 41.350 STRONG RIGHTS

01:02 - 42.980 TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF THE

01:02 - 44.500 UNBORN CHILD THAT'S THE

01:02 - 45.790 INTEREST THAT'S AT STAKE.

01:02 - 47.540 AND BECAUSE YOU DON'T HAVE A

01:02 - 48.860 FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT THAT'S

01:02 - 51.840 IMPLICATED AND INDIGENCY IS NOT

01:02 - 51.940 A

01:02 - 54.120 SUSPECT CLASS. SO LONG AS THE

01:02 - 55.350 GOVERNMENT HAS A SUFFICIENT

01:02 - 56.860 BASIS TO DIFFERENTIATE

01:02 - 59.090 AND WHAT SOCIAL POLICIES IT

01:02 - 00.170 WANTS TO ENCOURAGE AND WHAT

01:03 - 01.480 BEHAVIOR WANTS TO IMPAIRED

01:03 - 02.170 BECAUSE IT HAS A

01:03 - 04.230 SUFFICIENT BASIS INDY HERE IT'S

01:03 - 06.190 AN IMPORTANT INTERESTS AND

01:03 - 07.370 PROTECTING THE LIFE OF THE

01:03 - 09.770 UNBORN CHILD AND THEIR MOTHER.

01:03 - 12.980 THIS PASSES WHATEVER SCRUTINY

01:03 - 14.420 HE WOULD WANT TO TALK TO JEFF

01:03 - 16.530 MCCALL IS RIGHT THE COURT MADE

01:03 - 17.770 CLEAR NOT ONLY.

01:03 - 19.700 THIS CLEAR THE HURDLE FOR

01:03 - 22.160 RATIONAL BASIS THAT ALSO CLEARS

01:03 - 23.020 THE HURDLE FOR HEIGHTENED

01:03 - 24.840 SCRUTINY. SPECIFICALLY THE

01:03 - 27.190 COSTS THE OVERRIDING INTEREST

01:03 - 28.420 OF THE GOVERNMENT OF PROTECTING

01:03 - 29.930 THE LIFE OF THE UNBORN CHILD

01:03 - 31.980 AND ITS MOTHER IS SUCH AN

01:03 - 33.610 IMPORTANT I WOULD ARGUE A

01:03 - 34.700 COMPELLING INTEREST.

01:03 - 47.400 THIS TIME THE CHEMICALLY THAT

01:03 - 49.520 WHO ARE 30 SECONDS THE RUBBLE,

01:03 - 50.890 YOU KNOW LIKE THE BACK OF HIM

01:03 - 51.870 RIGHT NOW POLICE.

01:03 - 57.610 >>2 QUICK POINTS BUT JUST LIKE

01:03 - 59.040 MAKER KNOWN SPENDING ISSUE.

01:04 - 01.660 AND THERE'S MENTION BE

01:04 - 04.190 JUDE MEDICAL SERVICES CAPERS

01:04 - 06.960 RECENT SUPREME COURT CASE, I'M

01:04 - 11.910 IF THE HOLDING IN THAT CASE.

01:04 - 14.050 ONE. WHAT WAS THAT THE ENDING

01:04 - 15.760 WAS WAIVED BY THE STATE.

01:04 - 18.800 THE ISSUE WAS WE MIGHT BE THE

01:04 - 20.970 STATE TODAY NOT LEAVING YOU TO

01:04 - 23.150 STAND AND WE WORK REALLY

01:04 - 25.680 IMPORTANT GAME A COURT DOWN A

01:04 - 28.650 BIT. HARD DRIVE TO HIS HEAD AND

01:04 - 30.160 BEAT INTERESTS.

01:04 - 33.960 CHALLENGING AN ILLEGAL TAX.

01:04 - 36.560 AND IN THIS CASE THERE IS NO

01:04 - 39.040 THE INTEREST AND AT THAT TIME

01:04 - 39.920 WE EXPECT

01:04 - 42.180 A HIGH THE COLLIDER'S NOT

01:04 - 43.650 WITHIN THE ZONE OF PEOPLE TO

01:04 - 45.320 CLICK ON REPUBLICANS. THE

01:04 - 46.690 QUESTION. THANK YOU.

01:04 - 50.500 PLAYING A LITTLE MORE

01:04 - 52.410 ABOUT THE DOWN CONSTITUTION ALL

01:04 - 52.790 IN FOR.

01:04 - 57.330 >>YOU'RE STRONGER SO.

01:04 - 00.100 THE CASE COULD HAVE BEEN YOU IT

01:05 - 00.640 WAS.

01:05 - 04.170 BE IMMEDIATELY CANNOT BE TOO

01:05 - 06.550 LOW. IT HAS TO GO

01:05 - 09.410 TO TRY TO I'M JUST

01:05 - 12.630 SUPER TEXANS OUT OF A LOCAL

01:05 - 14.610 COFFEE CREATIONS. THEY'RE NOT

01:05 - 17.110 WE'VE BEEN INTERESTS ALL THE

01:05 - 18.700 COUNTRY NEXT IN THIS CASE,

01:05 - 21.150 WE HAVE A PERSON CAN PROTECTION

01:05 - 22.440 OF THE PEOPLE EQUAL PROTECTION.

01:05 - 23.530 I KNEW IT

01:05 - 25.620 AND LEGAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT ACT

01:05 - 27.100 OF THE CUP. HE SAID THE

01:05 - 28.800 CONSTITUTION. HOWEVER.

01:05 - 31.880 THERE ARE THEIR LOSS OF REVENUE

01:05 - 33.530 THE TIME THE RESOURCES.

01:05 - 36.240 ABSOLUTELY NOT WITHIN THAT ZONE

01:05 - 37.590 OF INTEREST SOUGHT TO PROTECT

01:05 - 37.740 YOU.

01:05 - 46.470 ALL RIGHT, IF YOU DIE.

01:05 - 51.720 MY BUDGET. HE POINTS TO TRY TO

01:05 - 53.810 GET THEM IN YOUR TEAM.

01:05 - 55.250 >>INITIALLY.

01:05 - 58.640 WE'RE ASKING THIS COURT TO

01:05 - 00.320 ISSUE AN ADVISORY OPINION.

01:06 - 02.850 IT'S OUR POSITION THAT THE

01:06 - 04.590 COURT DID NOT ISSUE AN ADVISORY

01:06 - 06.760 OPINION. THERE MUST BE A CLEAR

01:06 - 08.680 CASE OF CONTROVERSY WE MUST BE.

01:06 - 12.030 THERE MUST BE A CLEAR RIGHT TO

01:06 - 14.550 REALLY. THERE THERE IS

01:06 - 17.430 NOT SO WE WOULD GET THE COURTS

01:06 - 17.930 SHOULD NOT.

01:06 - 20.830 ENGAGING IN THE SHOOTING AND BY

01:06 - 22.460 THE REAL THING ON THE

01:06 - 24.210 STANDING ISSUE. HERE ARE

01:06 - 26.420 ARGUABLY THE PICTURE OR.

01:06 - 29.380 TRUDEAU ASSERTING THEIR OWN

01:06 - 30.830 REPORT LIKE TO GET PAID.

01:06 - 34.790 THEY THEY WANT. THEIR MOM I'M

01:06 - 36.090 SORRY I KNOW.

01:06 - 38.960 THAT PROVIDES STANDING EVEN IN

01:06 - 42.160 THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE. THE

01:06 - 46.380 PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE KID THAT.

01:06 - 51.080 I HELP NEEDS ARE FULLY FUNDED

01:06 - 53.400 AND THEIR CORE ALL OF WOMEN'S

01:06 - 54.920 HEALTH NEEDS SHOULD BE FULLY

01:06 - 57.280 FUNDED. YOU ARE THE SEARCH IS

01:06 - 00.410 JUST NOT TRUE. OF MENTAL

01:07 - 02.310 HEALTH ISSUES THAT ARE NOT

01:07 - 04.320 FUNDED UNDER MEDICAL ASSISTANCE

01:07 - 06.250 AND IN JUST BECAUSE OF ONE

01:07 - 10.390 ISSUE IN WIN AND JUST BECAUSE.

01:07 - 15.970 OKAY CAN ONLY GROW BEARDS.

01:07 - 19.940 AND THERE WERE RULES

01:07 - 21.990 THAT PROHIBIT AND HAPPY YEARS

01:07 - 23.100 OF A WORKPLACE SCHOOL.

01:07 - 27.510 THAT DOESN'T NECESSARILY IN 4

01:07 - 30.630 K. THE BR IT. SIMPLY BECAUSE

01:07 - 30.770 IT.

01:07 - 35.070 IT WAS SOMETHING IT WAS A GAME.

01:07 - 37.000 BOTH PARTIES ARE NOT SIMILARLY.

01:07 - 42.080 ABORTION IS NOT.

01:07 - 45.610 A FUNDAMENTAL WAY. IN ARTICLE

01:07 - 47.810 ONE SECTION ONE. IT IS NOT

01:07 - 48.630 FUNDAMENTAL WAY TO

01:07 - 49.810 PENNSYLVANIA. AND

01:07 - 51.930 IT WORKED I THINK YOU WILL NOT

01:07 - 53.980 BE ASKING FOR THAT AS A PORTION

01:07 - 54.670 OF THE WEEK.

01:08 - 08.120 AND WE WANT TO BE CLEAR

01:08 - 08.970 YOU'RE HERE.

01:08 - 11.310 >>YOUR POSITION IS THAT THERE

01:08 - 11.860 HAS NEVER BEEN

01:08 - 14.030 A HOLDING AND THE IMPACT OF THE

01:08 - 15.240 RIGHT TO ABORTION AS A

01:08 - 16.050 FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.

01:08 - 20.870 THAT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE

01:08 - 22.800 WHILE IT. IT IS.

01:08 - 24.570 >>PERCEIVED TO HAVE HELPED US

01:08 - 26.880 OUT AND GROW DID.

01:08 - 31.630 A STATEMENT TO THAT EFFECT.

01:08 - 38.600 PARTICULARLY I THINK CASEY.

01:08 - 40.920 PARTICULARLY THE CASE IN

01:08 - 43.530 THE SAME COMPARED WITH HEALTHY

01:08 - 45.680 BABY BIRDS. CASEY, WHO WAS

01:08 - 46.650 REALLY CLEAR.

01:08 - 49.410 OF ALL

01:08 - 50.340 THE BRUTALITY.

01:09 - 04.760 BUT THE FACT THAT IT WAS NOT

01:09 - 06.330 RECOGNIZING THAT WE ARE RIGHT

01:09 - 09.560 AND A SPECIFICALLY A COURT IN

01:09 - 10.750 JUST A FEW IN

01:09 - 13.680 ROAD CRASH. WOMAN TO TERMINATE

01:09 - 15.380 A PREGNANCY AS A FUNDAMENTAL

01:09 - 18.600 RIGHT. THAT COULD BE A LEAVE

01:09 - 20.370 THE MATTER WITH. HIS FIRST

01:09 - 20.650 SCHOOL.

01:09 - 25.930 AND CHIEF JUSTICE REHNQUIST

01:09 - 26.810 WHITE CLEAR

01:09 - 31.020 BUT THROUGHOUT THAT KP OPINION

01:09 - 34.490 AND IN SOME CASES SUCH A FOSTER

01:09 - 35.980 PARENT OF A NEW DOCKING.

01:09 - 36.770 THAT WAS

01:09 - 40.750 A GAME INVOLVING THE PEOPLE

01:09 - 41.470 REMAINS.

01:09 - 47.820 WELL BACKED THE

01:09 - 49.660 IDEA THAT ABORTION IS AN

01:09 - 51.020 ABSOLUTE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.

01:09 - 54.360 SO WE WOULD SUGGEST THAT

01:09 - 55.920 BECAUSE IT IS NOT SO.

01:09 - 59.570 WE DO NOT HAVE

01:09 - 02.250 A A NEED TO FALL IN LINE AND

01:10 - 04.790 THE EXCEPT THAT PROPOSITION AND

01:10 - 06.470 I WOULD SUGGEST THAT HE PUT HIS

01:10 - 07.340 PROGRAM. WE'RE ASKING

01:10 - 09.530 OR DECLARATION AND THE

01:10 - 11.120 FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT. THEY KNOW

01:10 - 12.350 FULL WELL THAT IS NOT THERE.

01:10 - 17.170 OCCASIONAL ON THAT ISSUE.

01:10 - 19.800 AND LASTLY ON IT.

01:10 - 25.410 PREGNANCIES IS UNIQUELY NEEDED

01:10 - 27.060 BY WOMEN. WELL YOUR HONOR.

01:10 - 30.500 THE CENTERS OF GREEN

01:10 - 32.520 AND THERE A COMPLAINT FOR WE

01:10 - 34.720 PLAY WE WOULD HAVE I'M GOING TO

01:10 - 36.580 CHANGE IT AND HOW THINGS ARE

01:10 - 38.250 DIFFERENT NOW. WELL, YOU ARE

01:10 - 39.460 THINGS ARE DIFFERENT NOW.

01:10 - 41.050 AND NOW WE HAVE MEN WHO ARE

01:10 - 42.920 OFTEN BECOME PREGNANT AND

01:10 - 44.940 YOUR HONOR. YOU WANT TO CONTROL

01:10 - 46.470 IT MAKES NO DIFFERENCE PEOPLE

01:10 - 47.060 BETTER WITH.

01:10 - 50.260 WELL YOU IDENTIFY THE FEMALE

01:10 - 51.460 EUROPE PORTION IS NOT GOING TO

01:10 - 53.370 GET PAID FOR IF YOU IDENTIFY AS

01:10 - 55.590 A MALE YOU'RE NOT GOING TO GET

01:10 - 57.340 PAID FOR OR WE

01:10 - 00.080 CAN JUST THAT THE ERIE DOES NOT

01:11 - 02.050 PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR THE

01:11 - 04.410 FIRST TIME I SEE MY TIME IS UP.

01:11 - 06.930 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.

01:11 - 08.530 >>VERY

01:11 - 10.510 INTERESTING CASE. I THANK YOU

01:11 - 12.490 ALL. VERY WELL ARGUE.

01:11 - 16.450 >>BRIGHT SIDE WAS LEFT INSIDE

01:11 - 35.580 >>THE PIAA FOOTBALL

01:11 - 38.390 CHAMPIONSHIPS LIVE ON PCN GET

01:11 - 40.850 MORE AT PCN TV DOT COM.

01:11 - 49.830 >>2 CASES ARE ENTITLED AND HER

01:11 - 52.260 FRIEND AT ALL FOR THE CITY OF

01:11 - 54.260 HER AND THE SECOND CAVE NUMBER

01:11 - 56.950 21 IN FIREARM OWNER RECOUNT

01:11 - 59.270 CRIME VERSUS THE MANY OF THE

01:11 - 59.530 BIRD.

01:12 - 02.760 THE NEXT FEW CASES OR FEEL THAT

01:12 - 04.790 ARE BROUGHT BY THE CITY OF 4

01:12 - 06.880 FROM WHO ORDERED OF THE COURT

01:12 - 07.870 OF COMMON PLEAS OF

01:12 - 09.970 ALLEGHENY COUNTY AND THOUGH THE

01:12 - 11.850 BORDER, THE COURT HELD THAT

01:12 - 14.490 FREE CITY ORDINANCE TO 4 POINT

01:12 - 16.850 AND 100 PORTABLE BECAUSE THEY

01:12 - 19.160 WERE PREEMPTED BY STATE LAW.

01:12 - 20.870 NAMELY THE UNIFORM

01:12 - 23.810 FIREARMS ACT. THE ORDINANCES

01:12 - 27.650 WERE PASSED AND 2019. ORDINANCE

01:12 - 28.380 REGULATES

01:12 - 32.480 THE U IN PUBLIC PLACES IN

01:12 - 35.380 THE CITY. A SECOND REGULATE THE

01:12 - 38.330 USE OF LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINE

01:12 - 40.830 AND PUBLIC PLACE A 3RD.

01:12 - 43.750 ALL THE EXTREME RISK ORDINANCE

01:12 - 45.700 ALLOWED COURT FOR HIM IT AND

01:12 - 47.500 THEN THE INDIVIDUAL FROM

01:12 - 48.990 POSSESSING A FIREARM

01:12 - 51.140 WHERE THAT INDIVIDUAL HAS SHOWN

01:12 - 52.460 UP OR DOWN OR IF

01:12 - 56.190 THE SUICIDE CAUSING AREA BODILY

01:12 - 58.130 INJURY TO ANOTHER PERSON.

01:12 - 01.320 APPEAL NUMBER 20 A ROW

01:13 - 03.220 FROM A CIVIL ACTION FILED BY

01:13 - 05.340 LAUREN JOSEPH ANDERSON AND

01:13 - 07.530 OTHER RESIDENTS HIT HER WHO

01:13 - 09.400 HAVE CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT.

01:13 - 10.210 THE

01:13 - 12.880 CHALLENGE THOUGH BACK IN ONLY

01:13 - 15.310 WHICH IS FEARED A REGULATOR, A

01:13 - 17.500 LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINE.

01:13 - 20.620 APPEAL NUMBER 21 ROAD FROM A

01:13 - 22.850 CIVIL ACTION FILED FI, AN

01:13 - 25.240 ORGANIZATION FIREARM OWNER

01:13 - 27.920 AGAIN I'M AND READ THEM

01:13 - 31.290 AND THE CHALLENGE WAS BROUGHT

01:13 - 34.250 ALL 3 ORDINANCES. AND IF

01:13 - 35.720 THE PEEL OF THE TRIAL

01:13 - 37.700 COURT ORDER THE CITY ARGUE THAT

01:13 - 39.670 THE ORDINANCES ARE NOT CRANFORD

01:13 - 41.570 BY THE UNIFORM FIREARMS BACK

01:13 - 43.580 BECAUSE THAT BACK TO OUR

01:13 - 45.950 COMMUNITY ROWDY FROM REGULATING

01:13 - 46.640 THE OWNERSHIP

01:13 - 48.930 THAT HIM TRANSFER OR

01:13 - 50.450 TRANSPORTATION OF

01:13 - 52.990 A FIREARM BY CONTRAST THE

01:13 - 55.110 ORDINANCE TO REGULATE YOU.

01:13 - 57.540 A FIREARM AND A FACTORY.

01:13 - 01.190 A LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINE ARE

01:14 - 03.880 NEITHER FIREARM NOR AM I AN AIR

01:14 - 06.230 FROM. THE CITY ARGUED THAT

01:14 - 08.990 HAS A HOMER ALL MUNICIPALITIES

01:14 - 10.090 CAN AN ACT AND HE

01:14 - 12.230 ORDERED THEM UNLIKE HER HIT BY

01:14 - 14.540 STATE LAW. FINALLY THE CITY

01:14 - 17.020 ARGUE THAT A FIREARM OWNERS

01:14 - 19.280 AGAINST CRIME LAB STANDING TO

01:14 - 21.990 BRING THEIR ACT THEM A CONDOM

01:14 - 24.000 AND CAN THAT THEY HAVE FANNING

01:14 - 25.460 AND THAT THE OR HIM.

01:14 - 28.350 OUR PREEMPTED BY STATE LAW

01:14 - 30.210 WHICH COMPLETELY OCCUPIED THE

01:14 - 32.910 FIELD. FIREARM REGULATION

01:14 - 34.780 AND CORRECTLY FOR HIM

01:14 - 38.440 MUNICIPALITY. RATE. FROM

01:14 - 41.070 ENACTING THEIR OWN REGULATORY

01:14 - 46.610 WE ON MR.

01:14 - 48.350 HER WELL.

01:14 - 51.590 ARE YOU ON BEHALF OF THE CITY.

01:14 - 54.790 >>THANK YOU MAYOR PLEASE THE

01:14 - 56.660 COURT US.

01:14 - 59.090 REMAINS ARE FIRST OF ALL I WAS

01:14 - 00.780 IN THE CITY OF PITTSBURGH WINS

01:15 - 03.150 CASE. WE ARE DOING ON BEHALF OF

01:15 - 06.950 ALL THIS. AND THEY'RE COOL OR.

01:15 - 08.730 AS WAS JUST

01:15 - 11.090 SUMMARIZE THE FIELD HE SENT 2

01:15 - 12.330 VERY DIFFERENT VIEWS ON THE

01:15 - 14.160 SCOPE OF FIREARMS, THE OPTION

01:15 - 15.330 AND SOMETHING.

01:15 - 18.380 AND YOU CAN'T FIND MY CLIENT

01:15 - 19.440 SIU ITS 3RD.

01:15 - 21.450 KNOWLEDGE IS THAT GENERAL

01:15 - 23.760 ASSEMBLY HAS STRAIN, YOU KNOW

01:15 - 25.860 HE WAS MISSING OUT IS TO PASS

01:15 - 27.530 LAWS. THEY WERE FIRED.

01:15 - 30.290 INTENSE OF THE SCOPE OF BACK

01:15 - 33.270 STRAIN. THE SPECIFIED

01:15 - 35.990 CATEGORIES REGULATION SO FOR

01:15 - 37.520 THE REACTION STATUTES.

01:15 - 41.530 ASKED BY THE FIREARM OWNERS AND

01:15 - 42.080 ANDERSON

01:15 - 44.350 I GUESS SO GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS

01:15 - 46.590 COMPLETELY ELIMINATE YOU HOW

01:15 - 46.900 THIS

01:15 - 49.850 HOW THESE AS LOCAL MANY BRAVELY

01:15 - 51.710 FIREARMS. SO I LIKE

01:15 - 53.760 TO BEGIN AND SUPREME COURT HAS

01:15 - 55.830 MADE CLEAR WE SHOULD BEGIN WHEN

01:15 - 57.200 YOU WANT TO STEP UP FOR

01:15 - 59.310 INTERPRETATION. AND THAT'S WITH

01:15 - 02.370 THE TESTS. SO

01:16 - 04.680 FIRST IS 18 SECTION

01:16 - 07.610 6120. OF COURSE WE REALLY ARE

01:16 - 08.520 THE TITLE IS

01:16 - 11.190 A LIMITATION ON THE REGULATION

01:16 - 12.760 OF FIREARMS AND AMMUNITION.

01:16 - 15.930 SO THE U.S.,

01:16 - 17.840 I'M QUOTING NO COUNTY

01:16 - 19.360 MUNICIPALITY OR TOWNSHIP.

01:16 - 21.840 AND ANY MANNER AND DOING THE

01:16 - 25.360 OWNERSHIP SESSION TRANSFER.

01:16 - 28.510 TRANSPORTATION, A FIRE US AND

01:16 - 29.130 IN ADDITION.

01:16 - 32.190 AMMUNITION COMPONENTS AND TERRY

01:16 - 33.950 WERE TRANSPORTED FOR PURPOSES

01:16 - 36.680 NOT FOR IT. LAWS IS CALM.

01:16 - 40.200 ALSO AT ISSUE HERE IS TITLED 53

01:16 - 42.000 SECTION 14 ISIS TOO.

01:16 - 45.880 SIMILARLY TITLED OCCASION ON

01:16 - 48.180 MUNICIPAL HOURS. AND SO

01:16 - 51.230 SECTION G IT'S ALL THE SAME FOR

01:16 - 54.140 THE EMPTY CATEGORIES. AND

01:16 - 55.040 MISS APOLOGY

01:16 - 57.080 SELL OUT IN THE NEW ORDINANCE

01:16 - 58.610 OR TAKE ANY OTHER ACTION

01:16 - 00.400 DEALING WITH THE REGULATION OF

01:17 - 01.420 THE TRANSFER

01:17 - 05.040 OR SHIP AS ASIAN SESSION IN

01:17 - 05.480 FIRE.

01:17 - 08.420 SO IF THIS STATUTORY TAX

01:17 - 10.840 THE MIND. I LIKE TO FOCUS FIRST

01:17 - 12.840 ON SALT WEAPON. I

01:17 - 15.230 ASKED YOU. MAGAZINE ORDINANCES

01:17 - 16.960 OF THE CITY OF PITTSBURGH PASS.

01:17 - 20.780 AND PAIRING THE FACTS SECTION

01:17 - 23.670 6140 2962.

01:17 - 26.340 EXPECT THIS BURNS ASSAULT

01:17 - 28.770 WEAPON MUCH PASS THE ORDINANCE

01:17 - 30.860 ACROSS MOST IN ORDER TO THIS

01:17 - 33.630 TO YOU INNING AND THE AND THE

01:17 - 34.480 ANNOUNCE.

01:17 - 37.730 STATUTORY TAX. 2 REACTION

01:17 - 41.080 WAS HERE. FIRST BEFORE MURRAY

01:17 - 42.710 HAD WAS PRETTY LACE

01:17 - 44.870 EITHER PREEMPTION LAW PROBLEMS

01:17 - 47.920 HAD A GREAT USE. CATEGORY

01:17 - 50.870 IS LEGALLY. MEANING 3 DISTINCT

01:17 - 53.030 FROM THE FOUR-YEAR 85 DEGREES.

01:17 - 55.360 THIS BIRD LIMITED THE ASSAULT

01:17 - 57.490 ORTON.

01:17 - 59.020 >>IF THE COUNCIL.

01:18 - 02.090 JUDGE CAME

01:18 - 04.470 IN HIS OPINION THE MADE CLEAR

01:18 - 05.540 THAT THERE ARE 2 TYPES OF

01:18 - 07.380 PREEMPTION EXPRESS AND FIELD

01:18 - 09.940 AND HE FOUND THAT THE CLOSE.

01:18 - 12.400 PREEMPTION AND THE GAME.

01:18 - 15.960 MORTON MORE THAN THAT AND YOUR

01:18 - 18.200 KIDS GAVE THE GREEN COURT SAID

01:18 - 20.660 THAT YOU WAS.

01:18 - 23.880 >>AND THAT THE COURT EXPLAINED

01:18 - 25.180 THAT HOME RULE TERRIFIC AND

01:18 - 26.840 CANNOT REGULATE THE OWNERSHIP

01:18 - 28.790 YOU THE BEST AND OR TRANSFER A

01:18 - 30.650 FIRE OF CERTAIN FIREARM THOUGH.

01:18 - 32.470 >>YOU HAVE TO

01:18 - 34.480 CRAM SHUN EDITION WHICH JUDGE

01:18 - 36.030 JAMES COOK WHICH MEANS

01:18 - 38.000 ONE THAT REGULATED YOU CAN'T

01:18 - 38.610 STEP IN AS

01:18 - 41.100 THE MUNICIPALITY AND FOR THE

01:18 - 43.690 REGULATED AND THEN THE ISSUE OF

01:18 - 45.690 THEM OR HIS COURT ALREADY THING

01:18 - 46.990 THAT YOU WOULD COVER COULD YOU

01:18 - 47.580 ADDRESS THOSE.

01:18 - 49.530 >>AND LET ME ADDRESS THOSE THAT

01:18 - 50.680 ARE NOW STARTING TO FEEL

01:18 - 52.990 PREEMPTION AND FROM UNC MET

01:18 - 55.370 HER. THAT YOU LOOK AT THE

01:18 - 58.350 OVERALL STRUCTURE. OF FIREARMS

01:18 - 59.590 LAWS IN PENNSYLVANIA.

01:19 - 01.140 INCLUDING A

01:19 - 05.440 PREEMPTION STATUTES. MENTION OR

01:19 - 06.440 IT TURNS OUT TALK ABOUT A

01:19 - 08.680 MINUTE. THERE'S NOT FEEL THE

01:19 - 10.730 ACTION AND NOT JUST JAMES I

01:19 - 12.930 WAS INCORRECT. AND

01:19 - 15.150 I START WHERE I'M JUST SORT OF

01:19 - 16.600 LEFT OFF WITH THE TAX TO

01:19 - 18.320 SECTION 6128,

01:19 - 23.340 2962 YOU JIM. THE ARGUMENT THAT

01:19 - 23.850 WE MADE

01:19 - 27.280 STAT I BELIEVE WE STILL GOT

01:19 - 29.780 HERE TO THE SPECIFIED FOR THEM,

01:19 - 30.710 I'M NOT

01:19 - 32.750 USING AMONG ALL GET

01:19 - 34.930 TO SEE MOSTLY DRY WEATHER

01:19 - 36.070 GENERAL ASSEMBLY OR

01:19 - 37.540 LEGISLATURES ACROSS THE COUNTRY

01:19 - 39.430 AND THEY WANT TO EXPRESS

01:19 - 41.720 YOUR REACTION. USE WORDS THAT

01:19 - 43.030 ARE VERY DIFFERENT BUT FOR

01:19 - 45.070 SPECIFIC I ONCE

01:19 - 47.900 AND WHY I'M GOING TO REGULATE

01:19 - 49.620 THE WHOLE FIELD OR AN ENTIRE

01:19 - 51.870 MEAL WORK. A PENNSYLVANIA

01:19 - 54.010 EXAMPLE, UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:19 - 57.280 HAS SAID I WILL HAVE ITS USES A

01:19 - 59.160 FIRST EDITION OF CO-SLEEPING

01:19 - 00.440 OPERATIONS. YOU KNOW SEE

01:20 - 01.060 TURNOUT.

01:20 - 03.640 >>HOW DO WE GIVE ME FOR WHAT

01:20 - 05.050 YOU'RE SUGGESTING IS THAT THE

01:20 - 06.020 LEGISLATURE.

01:20 - 09.350 DID NOT INTEND TO REGULATE THE

01:20 - 12.770 WHOLE A GUN REGULATION

01:20 - 15.980 AND THEY PLAY AMID THE WORD

01:20 - 16.370 YOU.

01:20 - 19.960 >>WHAT I'M SUGGESTING YOUR

01:20 - 22.090 HONOR IS THAT BY PLEADING FOR

01:20 - 23.730 SPECIFIED CATEGORIES.

01:20 - 27.400 IS IN KANSAS STATUTORY

01:20 - 29.320 CONSTRUCTION CELLS TO LOOK NOT

01:20 - 31.200 ONLY AT WHAT WAS INCLUDED WE

01:20 - 33.200 WILL BE 5 BIRDIES AND ALSO WE

01:20 - 35.920 ASKED ME IF I WAS I WAS I WAS

01:20 - 36.610 SO WHAT.

01:20 - 37.870 I DID.

01:20 - 40.000 >>YOU SAID THERE WHAT ELSE IS

01:20 - 42.280 NOT THERE. AND HOW DO YOU GOT

01:20 - 43.550 UP YOU DON'T HAVE ETHICS.

01:20 - 46.020 >>WHAT WHAT OTHER CATEGORY THAT

01:20 - 48.460 WE ARE SAYS IT WAS FOR THE

01:20 - 50.150 FIRE. AND YOU

01:20 - 50.550 LOOK AT

01:20 - 53.680 FIREARMS LAWS AND OTHER STATES

01:20 - 55.880 BY FIRST NAME SEE THAT IN OTHER

01:20 - 58.560 STATES IN 2. THIS AND

01:20 - 01.050 SPECIFY USE I KNOW A STORY.

01:21 - 03.590 I WAS LEGISLATION IS INTENDED

01:21 - 05.620 TO HAVE THOSE BAD LOANS AND SO

01:21 - 06.590 THEY KNOW HAS NOT

01:21 - 09.440 I'M BACK. AND YOU

01:21 - 11.160 THINK THAT THAT'S WHAT YOU NEED

01:21 - 13.720 TO CALL IN A HOUSTON. AS YOU

01:21 - 14.490 ARE NOW.

01:21 - 17.590 OTHER STATUTES SO NOT

01:21 - 19.950 BEING REPEAL US WE WERE WE

01:21 - 21.360 SUBMITTED 5 WEEKS.

01:21 - 26.930 POWER TO REGULATE THE AREA ARE

01:21 - 29.480 TALKING ABOUT HOW THE SECTIONS

01:21 - 31.510 23 1.31 AND

01:21 - 35.270 37 OF 3. SPECIFICALLY YOU SEE

01:21 - 36.370 THESE PAROLE,

01:21 - 38.820 DEREGULATING FIRE ON TO THE SET

01:21 - 40.510 WITH A LOUSE YOU THINK HOW ARE

01:21 - 43.440 CITIES REGULATE TO HER EVENTS

01:21 - 45.670 IS CHARGED IN THIS AREA FIRE

01:21 - 47.760 HIM A DOZEN PUBLIC PLACE.

01:21 - 50.470 SO THIS HOUSTON HIGH SCHOOL FOR

01:21 - 50.850 YOU.

01:21 - 53.740 >>A DRAFT, THE FIRST REGULATING

01:21 - 56.230 THE USE OF SALT WEAPON. HOW

01:21 - 59.320 WOULD YOU DO THAT. AND THE

01:21 - 00.500 PUBLIC OR PRIVATE PLANE

01:22 - 01.520 WITHOUT.

01:22 - 07.850 AND A PUBLIC PLACE.

01:22 - 11.390 >>WE'RE SO USE THESE IS TO

01:22 - 15.860 FIND HIM. 2 IN THE ORDINANCE

01:22 - 16.440 SO.

01:22 - 19.840 INCLUDES FRIEND THE SCENE

01:22 - 22.330 WHEN TEEN, OWNING AN ASSAULT

01:22 - 23.880 WEAPON IN PUBLIC. AND

01:22 - 25.800 THE PUBLIC. WE'RE ACTIVELY

01:22 - 29.140 DISPLAYED IN PUBLIC. AND HIS

01:22 - 31.120 CONCEPT OF USE AS

01:22 - 33.310 DISTINCT FROM SESSION

01:22 - 35.480 ARE CARRYING. WELL ESTABLISHED

01:22 - 36.670 IN THE LAW WE POINT TO THE

01:22 - 37.610 UNITED STATES

01:22 - 39.680 IN COURT. SEASON AND THE DAILY

01:22 - 41.510 CASE FOR BY JUSTICE O'CONNOR

01:22 - 43.600 AND WHO ARE EXPLAINED THAT

01:22 - 44.680 USING A FIREARM.

01:22 - 46.850 LEGALLY DISTINCT FROM

01:22 - 49.340 POSSESSING OR CARRY IT. I WANT

01:22 - 52.210 TO WORK. SIDE USING A SIMPLE

01:22 - 54.650 DICTIONARY DEFINITIONS SO USING

01:22 - 56.050 THE FIRE. FIRES

01:22 - 59.450 ABSOLUTELY AND ALL THE EXAMPLES

01:22 - 01.820 WE THIS BIRD IS ALL UP IN

01:23 - 03.510 ORGANS ARE CONSISTENTLY BACK

01:23 - 04.990 AND WHAT THE CITY NEEDS

01:23 - 05.810 REGULATING

01:23 - 08.710 IS NOT YOUR POSSESSION MAY BE

01:23 - 10.470 THAT MOST TIMES YOU USE A

01:23 - 12.430 FIREARM YOU ALSO POSSESS

01:23 - 12.940 BUT.

01:23 - 15.810 >>SEEMS YOUR YOUR DOG TO GO.

01:23 - 17.490 >>IT WILL BE OR DONE, BUT THEY

01:23 - 18.040 GO AGAIN.

01:23 - 20.110 THE PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION

01:23 - 21.630 THE RIGHT TO TO TO TO TO BEAR

01:23 - 23.320 ARMS IN DEFENSE OF THEMSELVES.

01:23 - 26.430 >>A LOT OF WE DON'T THINK THAT

01:23 - 28.130 HE DOES A PENNSYLVANIA

01:23 - 31.220 CONSTITUTION. CLEARLY PROTECTS.

01:23 - 32.050 A

01:23 - 34.050 CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT AND

01:23 - 34.760 KEEPING THEIR

01:23 - 36.830 ARMS FIRE AND THAT FOR US TO

01:23 - 39.510 TRY TO STOP ANY YEAR. FIRST OF

01:23 - 39.900 ALL.

01:23 - 42.670 THIS THESE WITNESSES ARE

01:23 - 44.560 TELLING YOU YOU I VISIT THE

01:23 - 45.020 CITY

01:23 - 46.160 LIMITING HOW.

01:23 - 48.250 >>IT'S BEING USED AND THE

01:23 - 50.640 CONSTITUTION BIG DIRECTLY THAT

01:23 - 53.200 YOU MAY BE USED IN DEFENSE A

01:23 - 53.790 CITIZEN.

01:23 - 56.530 >>SO FIRST OF ALL SELF-DEFENSE

01:23 - 58.940 IS IS OUR COUTTS OFFENSE IS NOT

01:23 - 00.800 USE THOSE REGULATING THAT SINCE

01:24 - 03.310 FIRST THE SET OR IN ORDINANCES.

01:24 - 07.660 AND THE SECOND AMENDMENT AND

01:24 - 08.300 THERE'S NO.

01:24 - 10.360 INDICATION THAT HE

01:24 - 11.570 IS ALL I'M SAYING THAT ALL

01:24 - 13.420 ALONG SECTIONS ON MARCH BECAUSE

01:24 - 15.650 ANYMORE CALL THEM. SECOND

01:24 - 17.750 AMENDMENT IS IN SCREW AND THE

01:24 - 20.000 CASE LAW IS ALMOST UNIFORM

01:24 - 21.140 ACROSS THE COUNTRY THAT EVEN

01:24 - 23.580 COMPLETELY A NAME

01:24 - 24.820 ASSAULT WEAPONS OR

01:24 - 26.640 LARGE-CAPACITY MAGAZINES.

01:24 - 28.320 IT'S NOT INFRINGING ON THE

01:24 - 29.880 RIGHT TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS AND

01:24 - 31.830 HERE. SO HE HAS DONE SOMETHING

01:24 - 34.250 MUCH MUCH NARROWER HAS

01:24 - 36.420 ONLY LIMITED USE OF THOSE

01:24 - 37.440 WEAPONS AND ONLY

01:24 - 39.790 IN PUBLIC AND LISTEN BECAUSE

01:24 - 41.440 OUT SELF-DEFENSE LOW BEFORE A

01:24 - 44.600 RUN NEAR VIOLATION ON SECTION.

01:24 - 49.600 JUST A COUPLE MORE POINTS ON

01:24 - 50.740 THE QUESTION NOTES.

01:24 - 53.770 YOUR REACTION IN ADDITION TO

01:24 - 55.680 THE FACT THAT CITIES HAVE BEEN

01:24 - 58.340 EXPRESSED GIVEN POWER STATUTES

01:24 - 00.320 LIKE A MATCH THEM.

01:25 - 04.230 IT'S ALSO THE CASE WAS BEING OR

01:25 - 06.630 IN THE MY DECISION

01:25 - 08.800 WHICH IS ISSUE AFTER

01:25 - 11.970 40'S. WELL AS ACROSS THE STATE

01:25 - 13.600 THERE ARE ONLY 3 AREAS

01:25 - 15.570 AND WHICH IS RECOGNIZED YOU THE

01:25 - 17.850 ACTION IN THE STATE ARMS

01:25 - 19.050 IS NOT ONE

01:25 - 22.170 OF THEM. MINING IS ALSO MAKES

01:25 - 22.540 CLEAR THAT

01:25 - 24.800 JUST BECAUSE. THE GENERAL

01:25 - 26.500 ASSEMBLY HAS LEGISLATED EVEN

01:25 - 27.780 EXTENSIVELY IN THE AREA

01:25 - 30.360 FIREARMS. IT'S NOT YOU I YOU

01:25 - 32.250 KNOW WE HAVE DONE AND LAST I

01:25 - 34.070 WOULD POINT TO THE SPORTS ZONE.

01:25 - 37.220 IT'S DECISION WHICH IS NOT

01:25 - 37.980 IN.

01:25 - 41.150 WAR THIS WHOLE THAT THERE IS

01:25 - 43.060 SOME ROOM FOR LOCAL REGULATION

01:25 - 44.790 OF FIRE US PORT

01:25 - 47.950 OF L A LOCAL LAW YOU

01:25 - 50.450 KNOW MALL. SO ITS FIREARM

01:25 - 52.370 COURTHOUSES AND YES, IN

01:25 - 54.540 FACT CASE THIS PLACE WAS IT'S

01:25 - 56.190 ALREADY ILLEGAL UNDER

01:25 - 58.750 STATE LAW. POINT IS AND THE

01:25 - 00.520 CASE STANDS FOR THE PROPOSITION

01:26 - 01.340 THAT THERE STILL IS

01:26 - 03.830 SOME ROOM CITIES TO REGULATE

01:26 - 05.200 MOST AREAS SO IF YOU PUT ALL

01:26 - 07.300 THAT TOGETHER THOSE 4 AND

01:26 - 08.450 BECAUSE OF WORRIES ME THE

01:26 - 09.870 OPTION STATUTES.

01:26 - 12.570 I KNOW THERE ARE OTHER STATUTES

01:26 - 14.060 ON HOPES THAT EXPRESS THE 2

01:26 - 17.800 HERE. AND THE

01:26 - 21.360 HOLDINGS IN COAL MINING STATE

01:26 - 22.970 OF MIND. IT'S GREAT

01:26 - 24.040 THEY'RE NOT

01:26 - 27.560 PREEMPTION LET YOU KNOW IT MANY

01:26 - 28.620 MANY YEARS HERE ANOTHER

01:26 - 30.130 QUESTION DID AND THE

01:26 - 31.480 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT IN

01:26 - 32.710 COMMONWEALTH FOR THE PICK.

01:26 - 34.630 >>A STATE THAT CONSISTENT WITH

01:26 - 34.710 THE

01:26 - 36.860 GENERAL ASSEMBLY RESERVATION OF

01:26 - 38.850 THE BLUE THE PREROGATIVE TO

01:26 - 40.560 REGULATE FIREARMS IN

01:26 - 41.230 THE COMMONWEALTH.

01:26 - 43.270 >>AND THE SUPREME COURT VERY

01:26 - 44.260 BROKEN ON THE ISSUE.

01:26 - 49.720 CERTAINLY I THINK WAS THE

01:26 - 51.840 LANGUAGE OF A FOOTNOTE IN ITS

01:26 - 53.810 I WOULD SUBMIT RESPECTFULLY THE

01:26 - 56.250 FACT IS IT DOES VERY GENERAL

01:26 - 58.490 STATEMENT. THERE WAS NO ISSUE

01:26 - 00.250 IN THIS CASE. WELL WHAT WE

01:27 - 03.440 SPOKE OF PREEMPTION IS PICKS

01:27 - 04.430 FOR HER BACK

01:27 - 07.060 TO YOU ORTIZ CASE AND THAT'S

01:27 - 08.470 ACTUALLY WHERE I WANT HER.

01:27 - 09.820 TALK BRIEFLY ABOUT

01:27 - 13.110 MURPHY'S CASE SHE'S OBVIOUSLY I

01:27 - 14.720 DIDN'T I DIDN'T BRING COURT HAS

01:27 - 16.330 DONE IT BEFORE THEY HAD BIG

01:27 - 17.570 KNOW EXACTLY WHERE THEY'RE

01:27 - 19.850 GOING BY MAKING REFERENCE TO

01:27 - 19.950 IT.

01:27 - 22.210 >>AND A FOOTNOTE AND I BELIEVE

01:27 - 23.080 THAT THE COURT HAS

01:27 - 26.010 AN OBLIGATION TO RESPECT EVERY

01:27 - 27.140 PART OF THE SUPREME COURT

01:27 - 27.740 DECISION.

01:27 - 30.190 >>I DON'T DISAGREE WITH THAT

01:27 - 32.330 YOUR HONOR BUT WHAT I WOULD SAY

01:27 - 33.910 IS THAT ULTIMATELY YEAR.

01:27 - 36.780 PLUS YOU NAMES. I'M READING THE

01:27 - 38.380 STATUTE SPEAKING THE REACTION

01:27 - 41.740 STATUTES. TODAY WE CREATED

01:27 - 43.740 THIS AREA OR ARE THEY.

01:27 - 46.970 NOT ALL I'M FOCUSED ALTERNATELY

01:27 - 48.810 THE QUESTION IS STATUTORY

01:27 - 49.740 CONSTRUCTION ONE OF THE

01:27 - 51.850 GENERALS HAVE TO DO HERE AND I

01:27 - 53.180 THINK IF YOU GO BACK TO YOUR

01:27 - 56.390 TEASE, SUSAN. THIS IS WHAT IT'S

01:27 - 58.090 WAS SIGNING A VERY

01:27 - 00.260 GENERAL SENSE. YEAH, YOU MIGHT

01:28 - 01.340 NOT EASY ISSUES THAT WE'RE

01:28 - 02.640 TALKING ABOUT HERE TODAY.

01:28 - 05.090 RAISE YOUR SPIRITS I WAS REALLY

01:28 - 07.580 THE SORT OF A PASSING COMMENT.

01:28 - 10.830 ABOUT. ABOUT A

01:28 - 12.230 DIFFERENT ISSUE. BUT IF YOU GO

01:28 - 14.770 BACK TO THE ORTIZ DECISION A

01:28 - 16.730 WHOLE THING ABOUT IT I THINK

01:28 - 18.650 IT'S SORT OF LIKE LAST A LONG

01:28 - 19.950 WAY FROM ANY SUBSTANCE

01:28 - 22.600 STURGEON'S TALKING ABOUT IS SO

01:28 - 24.180 IT WAS HE LEAVES WHO

01:28 - 26.870 RECENTLY ABOUT LIVE IN. I

01:28 - 29.160 STATE PREEMPTION.

01:28 - 32.650 AND AND THE QUOTE THAT IS

01:28 - 34.830 OFTEN REPEATED. CERTAINLY

01:28 - 36.680 INCREASE IN THIS CASE AND

01:28 - 38.700 THOUSANDS OF TIMES AND YOU KNOW

01:28 - 40.990 HE DID I HOPE YOU'LL DO IN THIS

01:28 - 42.430 SPORT, SUBSEQUENT DECISIONS

01:28 - 44.110 THAT REGULATION OF FIREARMS.

01:28 - 45.860 I WAS MARRIED CONSERVING

01:28 - 48.310 ALL PENNSYLVANIA, NOT MERELY IN

01:28 - 49.780 PHILADELPHIA AND PITTSBURGH.

01:28 - 51.320 AND THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, NOT

01:28 - 54.020 CITY COUNCILS. COPPER FOR THE

01:28 - 55.830 IMPOSITION OF SUCH REGULATION.

01:28 - 00.590 IT REALLY IS ARE YOU SURPRISED

01:29 - 03.150 TO A LOT OF ASSAULTING THEM.

01:29 - 04.950 APPLAUSE STATEMENTS

01:29 - 07.570 ABOUT REACTION. RESPONSE TO AN

01:29 - 09.060 ARGUMENT THAT YOUR T'S COURT

01:29 - 12.280 REJECTED. THE IN THAT CASE

01:29 - 14.020 REGULATION OF FIRE WAS NOT A

01:29 - 16.490 MATTERS LIKE THIS. SO LOCAL

01:29 - 16.910 HIMSELF

01:29 - 20.010 AND THEREFORE, AND ALSO WE HAVE

01:29 - 21.200 THE CONSTITUTIONAL POWER.

01:29 - 22.270 WE HAVE

01:29 - 24.630 MARY A AUTHORITIES CLEARLY

01:29 - 26.250 RESOUNDINGLY REJECTED THE

01:29 - 26.880 PROPOSITION.

01:29 - 28.210 THAT

01:29 - 30.060 SECTION ENTIRE SEXUALLY AND YOU

01:29 - 31.660 KNOW ALL THOSE ARE DONE NOTHING

01:29 - 34.000 TO DO WITH YES AND

01:29 - 35.890 THE REASON ORTIZ DOESN'T SPEAK

01:29 - 38.110 TO THIS POLL BE OPTIONAL TERMS

01:29 - 39.900 OF ITS HOLDING BECAUSE IT WAS

01:29 - 41.760 ON THE SPEEDING THERE A FEW

01:29 - 43.410 ORDINANCES REGULATING IT

01:29 - 46.840 OWNERSHIP. SESSION AND

01:29 - 49.600 TRANSPORT IN ADDITION TO USE SO

01:29 - 50.950 3 OF THE 4 CATEGORIES WERE

01:29 - 52.750 CLEARLY WITHIN THE SNOW SECTION

01:29 - 55.110 6140 AND IMPORTANT NEED TO

01:29 - 56.660 RAISE A SHRINE TO ACTUALLY LOOK

01:29 - 57.350 AT WHAT YOUR

01:29 - 59.770 T'S WORKS ABOUT SPOKE OF

01:29 - 02.770 61 POINT. ON LOOKING FIRST AT

01:30 - 05.260 PAINS 3 THEY SAID GENERAL

01:30 - 06.810 ASSEMBLY HAS DENIED ALL HE DOES

01:30 - 08.430 OF THESE I WERE

01:30 - 09.260 TO REGULATE

01:30 - 12.100 OWNERSHIP POSSESSION. TRANSFER

01:30 - 13.340 THAT I THINK IS A MISTAKE IN

01:30 - 14.490 THE TRANSCRIPTION FOR

01:30 - 15.900 POSSESSION OF A CITY GONNA

01:30 - 18.010 FIREARMS VOTE SESSION TWICE.

01:30 - 21.070 FOCUSING ON THE

01:30 - 22.480 4 CATEGORIES AND THEN THE NEXT

01:30 - 23.180 SENTENCE ON

01:30 - 25.870 THESE 24. INCLUSION OF A CITY

01:30 - 27.630 AND ITS PEOPLE WHO LOSE HIM

01:30 - 28.170 WEST

01:30 - 30.420 THERE'S MORE AND THIS IS HOW

01:30 - 33.130 THESE 10 AND THE SESSION,

01:30 - 35.090 CERTAIN PARTS OF FIREARMS.

01:30 - 37.410 PROSTITUTION FROM HER. SO IF

01:30 - 39.280 YOU LOOK AT ORTIZ AND YOU LOOK

01:30 - 40.860 AT FUTURE PARTS OF UNION

01:30 - 42.710 SEPARATELY WHAT ABOUT THE

01:30 - 44.420 VALIDITY OF THE GENERAL

01:30 - 47.350 ASSEMBLY. ACTING THE ACTION

01:30 - 49.460 REALLY REJECT THOSE MARKETS

01:30 - 51.640 WHEN IT CAME TO SPELL. WELL

01:30 - 53.470 RIGHT BACK TO WORK OUT FOR US

01:30 - 55.130 AND NEVER SAID ANYTHING

01:30 - 56.070 SPECIFIC.

01:31 - 05.170 FIREARMS AND THAT IS THE CASE

01:31 - 06.040 THAT WE HAVE.

01:31 - 08.790 SPENT TO USE ALL OF THEM ON

01:31 - 10.620 PAST MAGAZINE ORDINANCE THAT'S

01:31 - 12.590 WHAT DISTINGUISHES THIS CASE

01:31 - 13.340 AND EVERY

01:31 - 15.480 OTHER CASE IS DISCUSSED

01:31 - 16.830 IN GREECE THAT THIS BOARD HAS

01:31 - 18.540 DECIDED THAT IT'S A PERSON'S

01:31 - 20.490 BEFORE YOU SIGN UP BEFORE YOU

01:31 - 21.920 SIGN OFF CAN YOU TALK ABOUT

01:31 - 24.070 >>ACCORDING TO THE ORDINANCE

01:31 - 25.490 THAT SAYS IT'S NOT AN OPERATIVE

01:31 - 26.900 UNTIL THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

01:31 - 29.150 IN BLACK THING.

01:31 - 34.520 >>HE SAID THE ASSAULT WEAPON OF

01:31 - 36.570 OUR PAST THAT AND MORE AS THIS

01:31 - 39.260 2 SEPARATE PROVISIONS SIU

01:31 - 42.550 IS FOR A NICE UNDER CURRENT

01:31 - 43.710 LAW, IT'S NOT.

01:31 - 46.880 HIT US ALL UP AND SMART CLASSY

01:31 - 49.690 MANNEQUINS SO ONE SECTION OF

01:31 - 50.960 EACH ORDINANCE.

01:31 - 53.700 ACTUALLY WHO HOPE TO GET MORE

01:31 - 55.420 POSITIVE MAGAZINES AND ASSAULT

01:31 - 57.730 WEAPONS. AND IT'S CLEAR THAT IT

01:31 - 59.520 ONLY WILL TAKE EFFECT YOU CAN

01:31 - 02.740 LEARN THAT DECISION FROM THE IN

01:32 - 05.100 OR WHO ARE I CHANGED FROM

01:32 - 06.190 GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:32 - 08.560 ALLOWS THAT SO THAT FOR EACH

01:32 - 09.760 ORDINANCE THAT DOES IS THAT

01:32 - 12.090 UNDER ARTICLE YOU DO THAT AND

01:32 - 13.540 THERE'S A SEPARATE PORTION OF

01:32 - 15.810 EACH ORDINANCE HAS LIMITED ONLY

01:32 - 18.380 TO STRIPPING USE ALL

01:32 - 20.380 THE PLACES ASSAULT WEAPONS AND

01:32 - 20.630 LARGE

01:32 - 22.630 CAPACITY MAGAZINES. I WORE

01:32 - 24.440 THOSE ORDINANCE MOST PARTS OF

01:32 - 26.400 EACH ORDINANCE TAKE IMMEDIATE

01:32 - 28.550 EFFECT ALTHOUGH I AGREEMENT.

01:32 - 30.680 WHILE THE CASE WAS PENDING IN

01:32 - 32.900 THE LOWER COURT. C SPAN

01:32 - 34.490 FORSMAN

01:32 - 37.060 OBVIOUSLY IT'S WAS CITED HAS

01:32 - 38.110 BEEN OF COURSE.

01:32 - 40.640 >>THERE IS NOT AN

01:32 - 42.380 OPERATIVE SECTION IS THERE

01:32 - 44.050 CONTROVERSY IN FRONT OF A THERE

01:32 - 45.230 ANYTHING THAT WE ARE TO

01:32 - 45.640 ADDRESSED.

01:32 - 47.610 >>WE DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY

01:32 - 49.750 CASE OR CONTROVERSY THERE YOUR

01:32 - 51.880 HONOR BECAUSE A CLOSE.

01:32 - 55.310 PORTIONS OF THE ORDINANCE ONLY

01:32 - 58.500 8% WHEN THERE'S CHANGE THE LAW.

01:32 - 02.570 GENERAL SO SO ARE YOU. THERE IS

01:33 - 04.270 NO CASE OR CONTROVERSY THERE.

01:33 - 05.920 AND SNOW.

01:33 - 08.850 YOU DON'T THINK PORT NEEDS TO

01:33 - 09.910 MAKE A DECISION ABOUT THAT WE

01:33 - 11.990 DO THINK THAT JUDGE JAMES AND A

01:33 - 14.350 LITTLE TOO FAR, I'M JUST SAYING

01:33 - 17.300 EVERY ASPECT ALL THE ORDINANCES

01:33 - 18.280 SPOT DOWN.

01:33 - 21.420 CAUSE WAS THAT YOUR

01:33 - 22.900 HONOR JUST REFERENCED ARE NOT

01:33 - 26.420 OFFERED IN HIS SENATE RACE TO

01:33 - 26.790 RENDER

01:33 - 28.460 A DECISION. NOW THERE ARE SOME

01:33 - 29.760 OTHER PORTIONS OF THE WORDS

01:33 - 29.930 THAT

01:33 - 32.540 WERE CHALLENGED. I'M GOING TO

01:33 - 34.520 SAY THIS WHOLE TIME.

01:33 - 38.250 >>YOU'RE WELL ON YOUR TIME.

01:33 - 39.910 YOUR HEART.

01:33 - 43.090 >>YES THANK YOU. RON. SO.

01:33 - 45.060 I WOULD JUST COME BACK TO WHERE

01:33 - 45.800 I STARTED.

01:33 - 48.990 AND SAY AND ULTIMATELY THE

01:33 - 51.720 QUESTION HERE. IS.

01:33 - 52.950 IS.

01:33 - 56.030 WHAT DO THE YELTSIN STARCHY

01:33 - 58.330 STATE WHAT IS YOUR SCHOOL AND

01:33 - 00.940 IN GENERAL, SO WE DO HERE AND

01:34 - 03.230 RECOGNIZE CERTAINLY AND THEY'RE

01:34 - 04.710 CALLING REACHING THE NUMBER OF

01:34 - 06.630 DECISIONS THIS OR YOU CAN FROM

01:34 - 09.720 THIS BEFORE THE SUN AS BACK TO

01:34 - 12.190 YOU THAT I LOOKED AT CLOSELY

01:34 - 13.720 ALL OF THOSE DECISIONS CONTROLS

01:34 - 15.720 THE OUTCOME YEAR OF THOSE

01:34 - 17.390 DECISIONS AS THEY ARE REACHED

01:34 - 19.500 THE ISSUE OF OVER REGULATION.

01:34 - 23.190 THE NARROW STARTED ALREADY USE.

01:34 - 24.380 FIREARMS.

01:34 - 27.030 I HEAR LIKE PAST RISING

01:34 - 29.170 AS WELL. HE'S OUTSIDE THE

01:34 - 31.730 SCHOOL OF MEDICINE AT THE NEWS

01:34 - 33.720 OF HIS POSSIBLE. AND YOU ARE.

01:34 - 37.520 >>ALL RIGHT, WE WILL HEAR

01:34 - 38.450 NOW FROM.

01:34 - 42.340 >>THANK YOU YOUR HONOR IT

01:34 - 43.680 PLEASE THE COURT I BRIAN BARNES

01:34 - 46.850 TO ANDERSON SEARCHERS WILL

01:34 - 47.410 BEGIN HIS

01:34 - 50.000 REMARKS BY SAYING THAT THE

01:34 - 51.540 PLACE TO START IN STATUTORY

01:34 - 52.940 INTERPRETATION CASES THAT

01:34 - 55.260 TESTED STACHE AND HE'S OF

01:34 - 56.490 COURSE RIGHT ABOUT THAT IN A

01:34 - 57.420 CASE WHERE.

01:34 - 02.170 NOVEL WHERE THE BEARS.

01:35 - 03.400 NO BINDING.

01:35 - 05.520 THIS OF A NEW SUPREME COURT

01:35 - 08.340 PRECEDENT AND ALREADY IN USE

01:35 - 09.910 THE STATUTORY TAX ISSUE.

01:35 - 12.050 BUT THAT'S NOT THE CASE THAT

01:35 - 14.350 THE COURT HAS BEFORE. THERE WAS

01:35 - 15.570 DISCUSSION A MOMENT AGO

01:35 - 17.600 HIS CASE I THINK THAT THE

01:35 - 19.330 FOOTNOTE HERE I JUST MAKES

01:35 - 20.550 CRYSTAL CLEAR THAT

01:35 - 22.730 THERE IS HE'LL REVIEW IT IN

01:35 - 25.510 THIS AREA AND. THAT'S A

01:35 - 27.270 CONCLUSION THAT THE KIDS.

01:35 - 29.880 IS REITERATING WHAT WHAT.

01:35 - 31.780 WHAT HE SAID IN AND

01:35 - 36.380 >>AND IN INCORRECT. THAT.

01:35 - 39.320 >>IN THE WORDS, HE'S CASE THAT

01:35 - 39.650 THERE

01:35 - 42.730 WAS A. STEPS BEFORE THE

01:35 - 44.050 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT THAT

01:35 - 45.820 REGULATED AMONG OTHER THINGS

01:35 - 48.060 THE USE OF FIREARMS

01:35 - 50.950 THE THE COURT THERE SAID THAT.

01:35 - 53.670 THE REGULATION OF THE USE OF

01:35 - 54.700 FIREARMS IS SOMETHING

01:35 - 57.080 THAT ONLY I COULD BE DONE BY

01:35 - 58.630 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY THAT THIS

01:35 - 59.680 WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS GRANTED

01:35 - 00.280 BY SECTION

01:36 - 04.670 YOU KNOW MISTER FIRST ROLE SAID

01:36 - 05.290 THAT WELL.

01:36 - 07.570 THE THE FOCUS OF THAT CASE WAS

01:36 - 08.550 REALLY OVER THE

01:36 - 10.770 CONSTITUTION NOW OF SECTION

01:36 - 13.440 GOING RATHER GRIM. IT'S THE

01:36 - 15.260 SCOPE OF MENTION OF THAT STATUE

01:36 - 17.980 IN ONE THING I WOULD SAY ABOUT

01:36 - 19.150 THAT IS THAT.

01:36 - 20.750 REALLY

01:36 - 23.650 UNDER 61 THAT THE UH -14 SAME

01:36 - 25.570 SERIES STARTING POINT YOU KNOW

01:36 - 26.930 ALL SAYS WAS

01:36 - 28.570 I THINK THE FIRST SENTENCE OF

01:36 - 30.020 THE COURT'S OPINION IN WHICH HE

01:36 - 30.770 SAYS THIS.

01:36 - 32.980 THE THE ORDINANCE IS THAT

01:36 - 33.430 BEFORE THE

01:36 - 35.910 COURT THERE WHO IN CONFLICT TO

01:36 - 37.850 AN END WHERE DOGS WE HAVE SENT

01:36 - 40.740 THE TEXT OF 6128. AND THIS

01:36 - 42.160 COURT IS OBVIOUSLY NOW

01:36 - 44.670 BY I'M HOLDING

01:36 - 47.660 I THINK YOU KNOW IF THERE WERE

01:36 - 47.830 ANY

01:36 - 51.920 >>BUT IN OR TEAM, THE SUPREME

01:36 - 52.980 COURT WOULD NOT.

01:36 - 55.970 GIVING A

01:36 - 57.500 SPECIFIC CONSTRUCTION OF

01:36 - 59.540 OWNERSHIP POSSESSION TRANSFER.

01:36 - 02.260 GRAHAM. AND THEY JUST USING THE

01:37 - 04.180 WORD YOU I WANT

01:37 - 06.780 TO PLAY TO THE CRIME. WHAT WHY.

01:37 - 10.420 WELL YOUR HONOR I

01:37 - 10.930 THINK B.

01:37 - 12.490 >>THE PHILADELPHIA BOARD AND

01:37 - 14.710 CITY ISSUE NOR TEASE ITSELF.

01:37 - 17.920 A REGULATED QUOTE THE NOOSE OF

01:37 - 21.450 FIRE AND SO. AGAIN IT'S IT'S

01:37 - 24.050 TRUE THAT THE THE LOCUS OF THE

01:37 - 25.680 BRIEFING IN THAT CASE WAS

01:37 - 27.050 FOCUSED ON THIS CONSTITUTIONAL

01:37 - 28.720 QUESTION THAT THE ONLY WAY YOU

01:37 - 29.950 GET TO THE CONSTITUTIONAL

01:37 - 32.580 QUESTION OR IN ORTIZ OFF FIRSTS

01:37 - 35.060 STARTING FROM THE PREMISE THAT.

01:37 - 38.020 AND SENT INCLUDING THE

01:37 - 39.100 PROVISION OF THE ORDINANCE THE

01:37 - 42.600 REGULATED USE. AND ONCE THAT

01:37 - 44.690 WAS PREEMPTED BY RONDO HAS WITH

01:37 - 47.250 THE JETS TO SECTION AND SO

01:37 - 49.790 FOR THAT REASON I THINK 40'S IS

01:37 - 52.540 REALLY DIRECTLY TO ONE EVEN

01:37 - 54.700 WITH RESPECT TO PITTSBURGH'S

01:37 - 57.120 REGULATIONS IN IF THERE ARE ANY

01:37 - 59.000 QUESTION ABOUT THAT I WOULD

01:37 - 01.330 POINT TO THIS COURT'S DECISIONS

01:38 - 03.170 WHICH HAVE REPEATEDLY CONSTRUE

01:38 - 05.970 WORKS IT IS. REACHING THE KIND

01:38 - 07.560 OF ORDINANCE THAT WE HAVE IN

01:38 - 10.340 THIS THERE'S THAT THE JEALOUSY

01:38 - 11.090 CASE SAID

01:38 - 12.530 OPINION FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS

01:38 - 13.610 AGO, I BELIEVE THE CHANGE IN

01:38 - 14.350 HOLLOW ROAD

01:38 - 17.880 OPINION THERE SAYS THE NEW

01:38 - 20.360 STUFF. PERSONAL PROTECTION

01:38 - 23.850 A PROPER SUBJECT TO REGULATION

01:38 - 24.890 BY MUNICIPALITIES.

01:38 - 28.160 THERE'S THE DOING HE'S DOING

01:38 - 29.510 AGAIN CITY OF THE YEAR IN AND

01:38 - 31.610 THEY SEE THE SCHOOL. I WEAR

01:38 - 33.290 THIS COURT DID THAT.

01:38 - 35.640 A LOCAL ORDINANCE

01:38 - 37.500 AGAIN REGULATED AMONG OTHER

01:38 - 39.260 THINGS THE USE OF FIREARMS IN

01:38 - 41.630 PUBLIC PARKS IS BRAND NEW IT

01:38 - 43.600 SAID QUOTE SECTION 61 POINT

01:38 - 46.170 GAME RIOS ALL FIRE REGULATION

01:38 - 47.290 BY BY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS

01:38 - 49.330 AND SO AND THERE AGAIN YOU SEE

01:38 - 53.240 THE COURT MAKING CLEAR WHICH IS

01:38 - 54.470 USE THAT OF COURSE THERE'S THE

01:38 - 56.640 CLARK CASE WHERE. THE SPORT

01:38 - 58.110 COURT PERHAPS DAVID ITS MOST

01:38 - 01.250 EXTENSIVE CONSTRUCTION BUT

01:39 - 02.980 AGAIN JUST FOLLOWING THE

01:39 - 04.170 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT'S

01:39 - 05.550 LEE AND WHAT HE'S SAYING THAT

01:39 - 07.320 THE REGULATION AND SOMETHING

01:39 - 09.650 THAT BOTH SECTION 61 20 AM

01:39 - 11.710 BINDING PRESS. I THINK REST.

01:39 - 14.210 MADE I HAVE MADE CLEAR IS AN

01:39 - 16.880 AREA SATELITE SOON WHICH THE

01:39 - 18.280 GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS A SIN,

01:39 - 20.440 SEOUL REGULARS BREAK OUT.

01:39 - 23.950 THIS COURT CASES HAVE JUST BEEN

01:39 - 25.860 REPEATED AND VERY CLEAR THAT

01:39 - 27.940 THIS IS AN AREA LOCAL

01:39 - 28.990 GOVERNMENTS JUST CAN'T

01:39 - 32.310 AND I THINK IT'S WORTH GIVING

01:39 - 34.420 THAT THE EXTENT TO WHICH HE.

01:39 - 36.130 CITIES ARGUMENTS ARE

01:39 - 38.400 INCONSISTENT WITH THE DECISIONS

01:39 - 39.450 OF THIS COURT I THINK IT'S

01:39 - 41.230 WORTH PAUSING TO REFLECT THE

01:39 - 43.180 REASONS WHY WE HAVE STARTING

01:39 - 44.550 PRICES AND PARTICULARLY.

01:39 - 53.010 >>ISSUE A FIELD 03:00AM.

01:39 - 56.510 I WOULD THINK OR TO PICK

01:39 - 58.240 CATEGORY. A DRAFT.

01:39 - 01.860 IMPLY A LIMITATION ON THE

01:40 - 06.420 SO OF THE 3 M. WELL I I

01:40 - 07.440 >>IT'S

01:40 - 10.420 ARE YOU WITH RESPECT TO EXPRESS

01:40 - 11.810 CREATION, BUT I THINK IT'S

01:40 - 12.550 IMPORTANT TO.

01:40 - 14.810 FOCUS ON THE DISTINCTION

01:40 - 16.220 BETWEEN THOSE 2 CATEGORIES

01:40 - 17.670 FIELD AND BREAST REDUCTION AND

01:40 - 17.720 A

01:40 - 19.330 FOCUS ON WHAT DID THE

01:40 - 21.080 LEGISLATURE SAY IN THESE 4

01:40 - 22.530 CATEGORIES AND WE'RE TALKING

01:40 - 25.680 ABOUT OWNERSHIP THE TRICK IS TO

01:40 - 27.460 TRANSPORTATION. THESE

01:40 - 29.410 VERY BROAD TERMS THAT ARE

01:40 - 31.050 BROUGHT I I WOULD SUBMIT TO

01:40 - 33.180 REALLY HOLD THE WATER. THAT'S

01:40 - 34.690 NEARLY HALF OF THE HARBOR.

01:40 - 35.270 STUART.

01:40 - 39.260 I THINK IT THAT'S THAT'S A

01:40 - 40.570 MANNER IN WHICH SOMEONE.

01:40 - 43.920 POSSESSES THEIR FIREARM YEAH,

01:40 - 46.200 HOW DO YOU STORE YOUR FIREARM.

01:40 - 49.180 IS WE CAN TO GROW AS A SUBSET

01:40 - 51.640 OF POSSESSION ROOM. IS I THINK

01:40 - 53.350 WAS WAS A VERY 2 OF THEM.

01:40 - 54.740 A LITTLE EARLIER ALL

01:40 - 56.700 THE SAME GOES FOR USE IT'S VERY

01:40 - 58.230 DIFFICULT TO USE A FIREARM

01:40 - 59.720 ABOUT THIS AND.

01:41 - 02.050 SO YOU KNOW I THINK MOST

01:41 - 03.420 NATIONAL READING OF THE TEXT

01:41 - 07.420 IT COVERS USE IN THE OTHER

01:41 - 08.300 THINGS THAT PITTSBURGH IS

01:41 - 09.380 TRYING TO REGULATE HERE.

01:41 - 10.070 BUT.

01:41 - 13.370 I MAKE THE POINT THAT.

01:41 - 16.520 IT WOULD BE A MISTAKE FOR THIS

01:41 - 18.780 COURT TO VISIT IT'S REPEATED

01:41 - 20.930 STATEMENTS ON ON THIS ISSUE I

01:41 - 23.520 AND THE REASON. I WOULD SUBMIT

01:41 - 24.530 FOR THAT IS THAT.

01:41 - 27.280 THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF

01:41 - 28.560 RELIANCE THAT HAS BUILT UP

01:41 - 30.140 AROUND THE CASE ON THE

01:41 - 32.450 SYRIAN HIM I WENT TO COURT IN

01:41 - 33.630 PARTICULAR TODAY AND THAT IS

01:41 - 35.080 FREE FROM THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:41 - 37.410 HOUSE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS, WE'RE

01:41 - 39.360 UP TO THAT AND THE DISTRICT

01:41 - 41.050 GOES THROUGH EXPLAINS TELL.

01:41 - 42.760 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:41 - 45.650 HAS HAS LEGISLATIVE BACKDROP

01:41 - 46.540 UNDERSTANDING THAT.

01:41 - 49.460 GUN REGULATION IS SOMETHING

01:41 - 51.170 THAT THEY'RE SOLELY RESPONSE

01:41 - 54.810 DONORS AS WELL OR AND

01:41 - 57.030 LANCE ON I UNDERSTOOD

01:41 - 58.840 YOU KNOW WHEN SOMEONE DECIDES

01:41 - 00.760 WE'RE LIVE DECIDES WHAT FIREARM

01:42 - 02.640 TO TO PURCHASE THAT AND THEY'RE

01:42 - 05.330 YOU KNOW RESPONSIBLE FOR

01:42 - 06.970 FOLLOWING STATE LAW AND

01:42 - 08.770 THE INTENT. WE SEARCHED A

01:42 - 10.550 PATCHWORK OF LOCAL ORDINANCES

01:42 - 12.390 ABOUT. YOU

01:42 - 14.990 KNOW WHAT CAN IT BE POSSESSED

01:42 - 17.420 AND OR USE IN ONE JURISDICTION

01:42 - 18.270 VERSUS THEM.

01:42 - 21.310 AND IT'S ALSO WORTH REFLECTING

01:42 - 25.100 THE REASONS WHY COURTS APPLY A

01:42 - 27.420 PARTICULARLY STRONG A SCHOOL

01:42 - 28.840 STARTS ISIS AND STASHED TO

01:42 - 30.490 INTERPRETATION CONTACTS IF

01:42 - 32.860 THE LEGISLATURE THAT THE WAY TO

01:42 - 34.840 SCORE AND THE CONSERVATIVE

01:42 - 36.350 SUPREME COURT IN ORTIZ IT COMES

01:42 - 39.670 TO 1661 20 DAYS, MOM.

01:42 - 41.990 THAT IT'S TAKEN AS A POLICY

01:42 - 43.390 MATTER THE LEGISLATURE COULD

01:42 - 45.340 EASILY CHANGE THAT YOU KNOW

01:42 - 46.860 THIS ISN'T A SITUATION REALLY

01:42 - 47.670 POROUS.

01:42 - 49.850 REVISITING PERHAPS A

01:42 - 51.120 CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTION THAT

01:42 - 52.570 ONLY WERE THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:42 - 54.100 SUPREME COURT COULD LEAVE HIM.

01:42 - 56.030 AND THE ONLY THING TO NOTE

01:42 - 57.740 IS THAT ANY TIME WE'RE TALKING

01:42 - 59.890 ABOUT THIS STORY IS A STATUE

01:42 - 02.410 OR CERTAINLY. REVISITING HOW

01:43 - 03.960 STATUE HAS BEEN CONSIDERED AN

01:43 - 04.670 ASS.

01:43 - 07.590 THERE'S NECESSARILY AND YOU

01:43 - 09.280 REDUCE A POLITICALLY OF A

01:43 - 11.570 POLICY-MAKING SPECTRUM THAT HAD

01:43 - 13.440 TO BE EXERCISED THERE AND

01:43 - 14.570 THERE'S A SERIOUS SEPARATED

01:43 - 16.050 POWERS FROM WHEN.

01:43 - 18.740 OVERTURNS IS PART OF

01:43 - 21.350 CONSTRUCTIONS OF OF SHEEP.

01:43 - 23.750 BASICALLY ON A PERIOD OF

01:43 - 24.470 UNINTERRUPTED

01:43 - 26.890 >>CAN YOU CAN YOU ADDRESS THAT

01:43 - 29.040 PART OF THE ORDINANCES THAT ARE

01:43 - 30.790 NOT OPERATIVE AND WHETHER WE

01:43 - 32.630 SHOULD BE ADDRESSING BACK TO

01:43 - 33.370 THE ORDINANCES.

01:43 - 36.600 >>SURE YEAH AND AND THIS IS AN

01:43 - 39.170 >>WHO KNEW CLASS OF THE LAW.

01:43 - 42.980 WE NEED TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN

01:43 - 46.090 THE DISCO. THE CHALLENGE THAT

01:43 - 47.310 WE BROUGHT HIM IN WHICH

01:43 - 48.430 PROVISIONS OF THE ORDINANCE WE

01:43 - 50.240 HAVE STANDING TO CHALLENGE ON

01:43 - 52.710 THE ONE HAND VERSUS THAT THE

01:43 - 54.160 APPROPRIATE SEVERABILITY NOW

01:43 - 54.940 SAYS SOME THE OTHER.

01:43 - 56.240 AND AND

01:43 - 59.730 THE WAY I WOULD THINK ABOUT IT

01:43 - 00.750 I THINK THE RIGHT WAY TO LOOK

01:44 - 02.620 AT THE SITE THESE PROPOSITIONS

01:44 - 05.090 STILL HE THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:44 - 06.180 SUPREME COURT DECISION.

01:44 - 10.940 WHAT'S THE COURT CONCLUDES THAT

01:44 - 12.930 SOME PORTION OF THE ORDINANCE

01:44 - 15.480 IS INVALID. YOU KNOW AS

01:44 - 17.730 IS PREEMPTED THEN THE INQUIRY

01:44 - 19.720 BASICALLY BECOMES NOT WHAT'S

01:44 - 21.260 THE SCOPE OF THE CHALLENGE AND

01:44 - 23.320 YOU KNOW WE THROW OUT EVERY

01:44 - 24.590 TEACHER OF THE ORDINANCE IS THE

01:44 - 25.800 LATEST CHALLENGE INSTEAD THE

01:44 - 28.400 QUESTION IS. ARE THERE OTHER

01:44 - 30.270 FEATURES OF THE ORDINANCE THAT

01:44 - 32.570 ARE THEMSELVES NOW

01:44 - 34.690 I WITHOUT SO REALLY REFERENCE

01:44 - 37.390 TO DISCO. THE CHALLENGE OF THE

01:44 - 38.850 PLAINTIFFS WHO BROUGHT IN HERE.

01:44 - 41.280 I THINK JUST SEEMS WAS EXACTLY

01:44 - 43.300 RIGHT LENA BECAUSE THERE'S 2 OF

01:44 - 44.860 THEM SHOULDN'T SYRIA. IT

01:44 - 45.540 NECESSARILY

01:44 - 47.530 FOLLOWS THAT ALL THESE

01:44 - 48.550 DIVISIONS, INCLUDING AN

01:44 - 49.810 OPERATIVE ONES BECAUSE THEY

01:44 - 52.110 REGULATE FIRE I WAS IN AN AREA

01:44 - 53.290 THE PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL

01:44 - 54.210 ASSEMBLY IS RESERVED

01:44 - 56.650 TO ITSELF. THEY'RE THEY'RE NOT

01:44 - 59.710 AND SO I THINK IT JUST REALLY

01:44 - 01.280 REWARDING THIS IS EXACTLY

01:45 - 01.690 CORRECT.

01:45 - 08.340 I SEE THAT I COULD SEE MY TIMES

01:45 - 09.840 ALL OVER BRITAIN, THIS

01:45 - 10.500 DIFFERENCE.

01:45 - 16.920 GOOD MORNING MAY PLEASE THE

01:45 - 18.900 COURT ON THAT JET FOR PRINCE

01:45 - 20.320 AND I REPRESENT THE PELLYS

01:45 - 22.020 FIREARM OWNERS AGAINST CRIME AT

01:45 - 24.880 ALL IN DOCKET NUMBER 1754 CD

01:45 - 26.330 2019.

01:45 - 28.560 >>BREVITY I'LL TRY NOT TO

01:45 - 29.970 REHASH THE ARGUMENTS THAT HAVE

01:45 - 31.740 ALREADY BEEN MADE OBVIOUSLY TO

01:45 - 33.450 THE EXTENT ANY AND YOUR HONOR'S

01:45 - 34.680 HAVE ANY QUESTIONS I'M MORE

01:45 - 37.590 THAN HAPPY ADDRESS THOSE, BUT I

01:45 - 39.620 WOULD LIKE TO START IN RELATION

01:45 - 40.440 TO STANDING.

01:45 - 43.000 ABOUT WANT TO MAKE CLEAR THAT

01:45 - 45.080 THE APPELLANTS HAVE CONCEDED

01:45 - 46.610 THAT FARM OWNERS AGAINST CRIME

01:45 - 47.190 AT ALL

01:45 - 49.560 HAVE STANDING TO CHALLENGE ALL

01:45 - 50.930 THE ORDINANCES WITH ONE

01:45 - 52.770 EXCEPTION OF THE EXTREME RISK

01:45 - 54.790 PROTECTION ORDER ORDINANCE

01:45 - 57.260 WHICH WAS IN 2018 DASH 12,

01:45 - 59.270 ONE KEY. AND WE HAVE ADDRESS

01:45 - 00.990 THAT EXTENSIVELY IN OUR

01:46 - 02.840 BRIEFING. IF YOU ACTUALLY LOOK

01:46 - 04.980 AT THAT ORDINANCE IT PROVIDES 8

01:46 - 07.550 AS THE AS THE APPELLANT'S CLAIM

01:46 - 08.660 NON DISPOSITIVE

01:46 - 11.480 CRITERIA FACTORS TO WHICH

01:46 - 13.770 A COURT CAN'T MORE AN EXTREME

01:46 - 15.670 RISK PROTECTION ORDER WHEREBY

01:46 - 16.890 IT WOULD DISPOSSESS THE

01:46 - 18.880 INDIVIDUAL OF ALL THEIR

01:46 - 21.820 FIREARMS. ALL OF CRITERIA.

01:46 - 23.430 ONE IS THE FACT THAT AN

01:46 - 25.340 INDIVIDUAL RECENTLY PURCHASED A

01:46 - 28.060 FIREARM THE OTHER IS THE FACT

01:46 - 29.970 THAT THE INDIVIDUAL UTILIZES A

01:46 - 32.370 FIREARM IN HIS OR HER

01:46 - 34.340 EMPLOYMENT. SO LET'S THINK

01:46 - 35.500 ABOUT THAT FOR A SECOND.

01:46 - 37.830 THE EXERCISE OF A

01:46 - 41.230 CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT IS A BASIS

01:46 - 43.360 TO STRIP AN INDIVIDUAL. ALL

01:46 - 45.120 THAT SAME EXACT A

01:46 - 47.470 CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT. THAT IS

01:46 - 48.200 OBSCENE.

01:46 - 51.420 AND AS ALL OF OUR INDIVIDUAL

01:46 - 53.820 PLAINTIFFS HAVE AVERAGE AND AS

01:46 - 56.000 THE TRIAL COURT FOUND. THEY

01:46 - 57.870 EACH PURCHASED A FIREARM

01:46 - 00.040 RECENTLY AND ONE OF OUR

01:47 - 01.930 INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS IS

01:47 - 03.980 EMPLOYED IN THE CAPACITY WERE

01:47 - 05.710 YOU MUST POSSESS FIREARMS.

01:47 - 11.090 COMPREHENSION HOW THE

01:47 - 13.180 3 INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS WHO ARE

01:47 - 14.480 ALSO MEMBERS OF THE

01:47 - 15.940 ORGANIZATIONAL PLAINTIFFS IN

01:47 - 18.290 THIS CASE DO NOT HAVE STANDING

01:47 - 19.810 TO CHALLENGE THE EXTREME RISK

01:47 - 22.190 PROTECTION ORDER AND IN FACT A

01:47 - 23.790 SIMILAR PROVISION WAS ALREADY

01:47 - 25.050 ADDRESSED BY THIS COURT.

01:47 - 26.800 IT'S FOR HER SON'S HOUSE OF

01:47 - 29.260 REPRESENTATIVES, THERE. THE

01:47 - 31.500 CITY OF PHILADELPHIA HAD PASSED

01:47 - 32.810 AN ORDINANCE THAT WOULD

01:47 - 34.650 DISPOSSESSED INDIVIDUALS OF

01:47 - 36.420 THEIR FIREARMS. IF IT WAS A

01:47 - 38.290 LEDGE THEY POSED A RISK TO

01:47 - 40.610 THEMSELVES OR OTHERS. THIS.

01:47 - 42.130 STRAW THAT

01:47 - 44.420 ORDINANCE DOWN FINDING THAT IT

01:47 - 46.630 VIOLATED PREEMPTION AND THE

01:47 - 48.130 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

01:47 - 50.180 WITH GREATER AFFIRM THAT

01:47 - 52.030 DECISION SO I DON'T BELIEVE

01:47 - 52.540 THERE CAN BE

01:47 - 56.440 ANY DISPUTE THAT ORDINANCE 2018

01:47 - 57.610 DASH 1220

01:47 - 00.370 IS VILE OF PREEMPTION BASED ON

01:48 - 02.140 BINDING PRECEDENT FROM THE

01:48 - 03.580 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT AS

01:48 - 05.580 WELL AS THIS COURT. FURTHER

01:48 - 07.400 AS WE DISCUSS IN OUR BRIEF

01:48 - 10.710 BATTLING. IN RELATION TO USE AS

01:48 - 11.320 THIS COURT HAS

01:48 - 13.690 ALREADY NOTED THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:48 - 15.350 SUPREME COURT IN COMMONWEALTH

01:48 - 18.780 BE ORTIZ ALREADY ADDRESSED USE

01:48 - 19.250 AS

01:48 - 22.630 WELL AS RESTRICTIONS ON ASSAULT

01:48 - 24.300 WEAPONS AND LARGE CAPACITY

01:48 - 25.220 MAGAZINES AND

01:48 - 27.040 FIREARM ACCESSORIES WHAT'S

01:48 - 29.160 INTERESTING IS THOUGH HELENS

01:48 - 30.730 HAD ACKNOWLEDGED THIS IN THEIR

01:48 - 32.540 TRIAL COURT BRIEF AND WE POINT

01:48 - 34.240 THAT OUT IN OUR BRIEF. THEY

01:48 - 36.070 FAILED TO ADMIT THAT BEFORE

01:48 - 37.780 THIS COURT. BUT IT IS

01:48 - 40.420 ABUNDANTLY CLEAR THAT WHEN THE

01:48 - 41.480 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME

01:48 - 44.340 COURT ADDRESS. THE PHILADELPHIA

01:48 - 46.000 AND PITTSBURGH ORDINANCES IN

01:48 - 48.260 ORTIZ THEY WERE ADDRESSING

01:48 - 50.930 USE NOW THERE'S BEEN A NUMBER

01:48 - 53.200 OF QUESTIONS RAISED IN RELATION

01:48 - 54.430 TO BOTH FIELD AND

01:48 - 56.070 EXPRESSED PREEMPTION AND MY

01:48 - 57.690 CLIENTS CHALLENGE BOTH UNDER

01:48 - 59.620 FIELD AND EXPRESSED PREEMPTION

01:48 - 01.680 I BELIEVE THE DIFFERENCE WITH

01:49 - 03.430 ALL THOSE ARGUMENTS IS REALLY

01:49 - 06.210 DEPENDING UPON HOW YOU VIEW THE

01:49 - 08.480 CASE AND THE DIFFERENT STATUTES

01:49 - 10.150 AND CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS

01:49 - 12.250 THAT ARE IN PLAY FOR

01:49 - 13.580 EXPRESSED PREEMPTION

01:49 - 16.970 WE TURN TO 18 P A C S SECTION

01:49 - 19.980 6120, 53 P A C S

01:49 - 23.350 2962 AS WELL AS ARTICLE ONE

01:49 - 25.490 SECTION 21. THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:49 - 27.830 CONSTITUTION. WHEREAS WHAT WE

01:49 - 30.640 TURN TO FEEL PREEMPTION WE'RE

01:49 - 30.940 NOW

01:49 - 33.360 LOOKING AT THE UNIFORM FIREARMS

01:49 - 35.580 ACT WHICH IS FOUNDED 18 P A C S

01:49 - 38.870 SECTION ONE ITS ACT AS WELL AS

01:49 - 40.730 OTHER STATUTES, INCLUDING.

01:49 - 42.600 DISCHARGE OF FIREARMS, IT

01:49 - 44.770 RANGES IN SUCH LIKE THAT THAT

01:49 - 46.030 THE COMMONWEALTH THROUGH THE

01:49 - 48.280 GENERAL ASSEMBLY AS AN ACTIVE.

01:49 - 49.580 AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE

01:49 - 51.660 UNIFORM FIREARMS ACT IT BECOMES

01:49 - 53.960 CLEAR IF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:49 - 56.230 INTENDED OCCUPIED THE ENTIRE

01:49 - 58.430 FIELD. A FIREARM REGULATIONS

01:49 - 00.370 AND IS A POINT OF FACT

01:50 - 01.770 WE SEE AGREE THAT SECTION

01:50 - 04.420 6115 FOR THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:50 - 05.760 GAVE THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE

01:50 - 07.180 POLICE THE AUTHORITY TO

01:50 - 09.760 REGULATE UNDER UNIFORM FIREARMS

01:50 - 12.490 ACT IN SECTION 61 O 9 WHICH IS

01:50 - 14.400 ARE LICENSED TO CARRY FIREARMS

01:50 - 16.320 STATUTES. WE SEE THAT ONCE

01:50 - 18.010 AGAIN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

01:50 - 20.210 LIMITED WHO COULD REGULATE

01:50 - 22.370 THE APPLICATION FOR A LICENSE

01:50 - 24.270 TO CARRY IN SPECIFIED ONLY THAT

01:50 - 26.080 THE PENNSYLVANIA STATE POLICE

01:50 - 28.110 COULD PROMULGATED THAT FORM

01:50 - 30.480 SO WHEN WE LOOK AT THE FIELD

01:50 - 31.720 PREEMPTION THAT EXISTS. IT

01:50 - 32.840 SEEMS THE BEEN DONE REALLY

01:50 - 35.270 CLEAR THE UNIFORM FIREARMS ACT

01:50 - 37.890 USE IN FACT FIELD

01:50 - 40.500 PREEMPTION STATUTE MOREOVER

01:50 - 41.200 WHEN

01:50 - 44.030 THE OPPONENTS SAY THAT IN

01:50 - 45.380 HOFFMAN MINDING THE

01:50 - 46.670 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

01:50 - 49.310 DIDN'T MENTION FIELD PREEMPTION

01:50 - 51.260 IN RELATION TO THE UNIFORM

01:50 - 52.690 FIREARMS ACT AND THEREFORE IT

01:50 - 54.560 MUST NOT BE THE CASE THAT

01:50 - 57.270 IT EXISTS. ONE IGNORES THE FACT

01:50 - 58.480 THAT THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME

01:50 - 00.440 COURT HAD ALREADY FOUND EXPRESS

01:51 - 02.320 PREEMPTION EXISTS PURSUANT TO

01:51 - 05.380 ARTICLE ONE SECTION 2118 UPI

01:51 - 08.550 ACS SECTION 6140. ALSO IF

01:51 - 09.960 WE WERE TO TAKE THE APPELLATE

01:51 - 11.570 ARGUMENTS AT FACE VALUE

01:51 - 12.690 THAT WOULD MEAN THE

01:51 - 14.130 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT'S

01:51 - 15.480 MORE RECENT DECISION IN

01:51 - 20.050 2019 IN PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES

01:51 - 20.670 COMPANY.

01:51 - 24.010 THAT DID YOU SEE THE PUBLIC

01:51 - 25.130 UTILITY COMMISSION.

01:51 - 29.110 WAS A FIELD PREEMPTION STATUTE

01:51 - 31.350 WOULD BE NULL AND VOID BECAUSE

01:51 - 33.420 HOW IF THEY DIDN'T SPECIFY THAT

01:51 - 36.290 THE P YOU SEE WAS IT PREEMPTION

01:51 - 38.600 STATUTE BACK. YOU DO WHEN IT

01:51 - 40.170 DECIDED HOFFMAN MINING COULD

01:51 - 41.870 THEY FIND THAT AND WE

01:51 - 43.230 BELIEVE THAT TO THE EXTENT IT

01:51 - 45.190 EVEN BECOMES NECESSARY TO

01:51 - 47.440 ADDRESS FIELD PREEMPTION THE

01:51 - 48.600 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT

01:51 - 49.860 WOULD LIKEWISE FINE

01:51 - 51.690 THE UNIFORM FIREARMS ACT AND

01:51 - 53.330 OTHER STATUTES THAT EXISTS

01:51 - 54.680 SIMILAR IN NATURE TO IT.

01:51 - 56.600 A RELATIVE TO REGULATING

01:51 - 58.850 FIREARMS CONSTITUTE ABSOLUTE

01:51 - 00.320 FIELD KOREAN SHIP THAT'S

01:52 - 00.870 CONSISTENT.

01:52 - 03.700 >>THAT WOULD BE RIGHT NOW AS I

01:52 - 04.510 UNDERSTAND IT.

01:52 - 09.110 UNDER HOCHMAN MINING. PHIL

01:52 - 14.290 LIVE ONLY WITH PERFECT. A HOT

01:52 - 18.760 MINING AND BANKING. WOULD

01:52 - 19.440 THAT BE.

01:52 - 22.590 ADDING A WHOLE NEW CATEGORY.

01:52 - 24.410 >>THAT IS CORRECT AGREE

01:52 - 26.100 WITH THAT. YES YOUR HONOR, NO

01:52 - 27.300 DIFFERENT THAN THE PENNSYLVANIA

01:52 - 29.280 SUPREME COURT DID IN PPL

01:52 - 31.310 ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION

01:52 - 34.120 IN 2019 AND WE ADDRESS THAT IN

01:52 - 34.540 OUR BREAK.

01:52 - 37.120 BECAUSE AGAIN THAT YOU SEE WAS

01:52 - 38.420 NOT MENTIONED IN HOFFMAN

01:52 - 38.740 MINING.

01:52 - 41.670 NOW I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO

01:52 - 42.960 ADDRESS THE ONE ISSUE.

01:52 - 45.540 THAT THE APPELLANTS RAISED IN

01:52 - 47.040 RELATION TO THEIR ALLEGED

01:52 - 49.270 SELF-DEFENSE PROVISION THERE

01:52 - 51.530 TRULY IS NO SELF-DEFENSE

01:52 - 53.030 PROVISION IN THIS ACT AS WE

01:52 - 54.590 ADDRESS IN OUR BRIEF ALTHOUGH

01:52 - 56.730 IT DOES MENTION SELF-DEFENSE

01:52 - 58.710 WHEN YOU ACTUALLY LOOK AND WHAT

01:52 - 00.770 MUST OCCUR FOR ONE TO BE ABLE

01:53 - 02.500 TO BE ELIGIBLE FOR

01:53 - 04.730 THAT DEFENSE. THEY MUST BE

01:53 - 06.510 ACTIVELY ENGAGED IN AN ACT

01:53 - 08.300 OF SELF-DEFENSE SO IF ONE

01:53 - 10.530 ACTUALLY HAS A LOADED MAGAZINE

01:53 - 12.590 IN THEIR FIREARM FOR PURPOSES

01:53 - 14.400 OF SELF-DEFENSE THAT IS NOT

01:53 - 16.630 SUFFICIENT TO EXEMPT THEM UNDER

01:53 - 18.300 THE SELF-DEFENSE PROVISION.

01:53 - 24.060 LANGUAGE OF THE ORDINANCE DOES

01:53 - 26.370 NOT INCLUDE LARGE CAPACITY

01:53 - 28.410 MAGAZINES OR FARM ACCESSORIES

01:53 - 29.300 FOR DIFFERENT FORMS

01:53 - 31.580 OF AMMUNITION. IT SAYS THE

01:53 - 33.760 DEFENSE ONLY APPLIES TO A FIRE

01:53 - 36.130 OR AND AGAIN WE ADDRESS THIS

01:53 - 38.120 EXTENSIVELY IN OUR BRIEFING AND

01:53 - 40.830 THIS IS CLEARLY IN VIOLATION OF

01:53 - 41.970 THE CV HELLER

01:53 - 44.720 IN THERE. THERE ARE CLEARLY THE

01:53 - 46.000 COURT TO FIND THAT KEEP AND

01:53 - 47.880 BEAR ARMS INCLUDED BEING ABLE

01:53 - 49.800 TO KEEP THE FIREARM LOADED IN

01:53 - 51.880 ONE'S POCKET FOR PURPOSES OF

01:53 - 54.070 ARMED CONFLICT AND AGAIN THAT'S

01:53 - 56.210 BEEN ADDRESSED IT WAS SENSIBLY

01:53 - 57.880 IN OUR BRIEFS.

01:53 - 00.310 THE OTHER ISSUE I WOULD LIKE TO

01:54 - 00.630 TOUCH

01:54 - 03.540 ON BRIEFLY IS THE SPRING

01:54 - 05.600 PROVISION OF SOME OF THESE.

01:54 - 08.110 ORDINANCES AND I BELIEVE THEY

01:54 - 10.100 YOU NEED TO BE STRUCK DOWN IN

01:54 - 11.630 THE COURT DOES HAVE STANDING TO

01:54 - 13.170 DO OR WE HAVE STANDING TO DO

01:54 - 13.470 THAT IN

01:54 - 15.900 THE COURT. CAN AFFIRM THAT

01:54 - 17.230 DECISION AS THIS COURT HAS DONE

01:54 - 19.320 THAT IN THE PAST IN RELATION TO

01:54 - 21.280 CLARK AND AS I WELL I BELIEVE

01:54 - 22.450 ALSO A NATIONAL RIFLE

01:54 - 24.310 ASSOCIATION. THERE WERE THESE

01:54 - 26.790 SPRING PROVISIONS PUT BEYOND

01:54 - 28.090 THE COURT HAVING THAT

01:54 - 31.100 AUTHORITY THE ISSUE WITH IT IS

01:54 - 31.200 THE

01:54 - 33.290 CHILLING EFFECT THAT IS CAUSED

01:54 - 35.130 BY THE EXISTENCE OF THOSE

01:54 - 37.150 PROVISIONS BECAUSE IF SOMEONE

01:54 - 39.620 ATTEMPTS TO REVIEW THE LAW AND

01:54 - 41.650 SEIZE THOSE PROVISIONS IT

01:54 - 44.210 DOESN'T SAY IMMEDIATELY THERE

01:54 - 46.360 IT ONLY BECOMES EFFECTIVE WHEN

01:54 - 48.200 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AUTHORIZES

01:54 - 49.610 IT YOU HAVE TO GO A COUPLE

01:54 - 51.070 PAGES LATER ON.

01:54 - 52.240 AND YOU HAVE TO HAVE A LAW

01:54 - 53.960 DEGREE TO UNDERSTAND WHICH IT

01:54 - 55.630 APPLIES TO BE ABLE TO

01:54 - 57.610 UNDERSTAND THE LAW MOST PEOPLE

01:54 - 59.020 READING THAT I WOULD

01:55 - 01.620 THIS IS PREEMPTED THEIR BIRTH

01:55 - 04.160 THIS IS WHO DID I KNOW I HAVE

01:55 - 06.690 THIS TYPE OF WEAPON IN THE CITY

01:55 - 08.620 AND WOULD END THERE AND THE

01:55 - 10.240 CITY NOTES THAT THAT'S THE

01:55 - 12.260 REASON WHY THE INACTIVITY AND

01:55 - 13.980 LET'S NOT FORGET THEY

01:55 - 16.800 OR REGULATING IN ENACTING THAT

01:55 - 20.310 PROVISION. RESTRICTIONS ON

01:55 - 21.930 FIREARMS AND AMMUNITION

01:55 - 24.340 AND I SEE HIM ABOUT OUT OF TIME

01:55 - 25.790 SO IF YOU'RE ON OR HAVE ANY

01:55 - 27.910 QUESTIONS I'D BE HAPPY TO WE

01:55 - 29.330 WOULD JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK

01:55 - 29.500 THAT

01:55 - 31.870 THE COURT AFFIRMED THE TRIAL

01:55 - 33.470 COURT'S DECISION THANK YOU ARE.

01:55 - 43.470 A FULL YEAR

01:55 - 46.330 A FEW POINTS I LIKE TO RESPOND

01:55 - 48.530 TO FIRST WITH RESPECT TO EASE.

01:55 - 51.630 >>ONE THROUGH 2 DIFFERENT

01:55 - 52.330 SECTIONS

01:55 - 54.560 OF THAT OPINION THAT I THINK

01:55 - 55.930 THAT'S CRUCIAL. I JUST WANT TO

01:55 - 57.070 UNDERSCORE THE POINT.

01:55 - 00.770 I DISAGREE WITH MY COLLEAGUES

01:56 - 01.840 ON THE OTHER SIDE,

01:56 - 05.660 A TEASE I MISS OR NECESSARY.

01:56 - 07.850 I HOPE YOUR T'S DECISION.

01:56 - 10.760 SO IF I MEAN AND USE THE

01:56 - 12.620 N WORD. YOUR THIS

01:56 - 15.690 IS AIR. PRESLEY REGULATED

01:56 - 16.990 OWNERSHIP POSSESSION AND

01:56 - 17.880 TRANSFER ALL

01:56 - 20.430 3 OF THOSE ARE YOU ARE A BIG

01:56 - 23.160 CATEGORIES BOTH SECTION 61 ON E

01:56 - 26.440 AND 20 NIGHTS. AND WHEN THE

01:56 - 29.300 COURT LATER TALKS ABOUT OH YEAH

01:56 - 31.650 AS I MENTIONED EARLIER IT E

01:56 - 34.760 WORD USE KNOCKING P SO I

01:56 - 36.880 THINK IT'S SIMPLY NOT CORRECT.

01:56 - 38.000 STAY

01:56 - 40.970 A COURT TO DECIDE THE ISSUE WAS

01:56 - 43.240 NOT JUST SO YOU DECIDED ON USE

01:56 - 44.290 IN FACT HE WASN'T

01:56 - 48.110 >>BUT IN OR HEAD WAS IN

01:56 - 49.560 A LIVE VIEW ORDINANCE THAT

01:56 - 51.400 BANNED CERTAIN TYPES OF ASSAULT

01:56 - 53.330 WEAPONS IN PHILADELPHIA COUNTY.

01:56 - 55.820 WELL AS IN FOR BILL.

01:56 - 58.790 NOW AND RE CODE PAIR FOR THE

01:56 - 00.030 THING THAT YOU ARE THAT IS

01:57 - 00.370 HERE.

01:57 - 02.870 AND THEN HOW YOU'RE TRYING

01:57 - 03.420 TRYING TO

01:57 - 05.190 SEPARATE THEM AND WHEN WE'RE

01:57 - 06.600 LOOKING AT THE ISSUE IS WHAT

01:57 - 08.540 WAS THE UNDERLYING ORDINANCE

01:57 - 09.510 THAT WOULD BEING ADDRESSED.

01:57 - 12.410 >>YOU ARE EXACTLY RIGHT THAT

01:57 - 13.250 WAS BANNED IN

01:57 - 15.370 THAT CASE AND THIS IS A BAND

01:57 - 16.890 THAT INCLUDED THE OWNERSHIP

01:57 - 17.460 POSSESSION

01:57 - 19.980 OR TRANSFER AS WELL AS USE THIS

01:57 - 22.030 CASE IS LIMIT IS NOT A FAN.

01:57 - 25.780 THE CONSTITUTIONAL ARE ON

01:57 - 27.690 SECTION 21. AND THE SECOND

01:57 - 29.410 AMENDMENT AND HELLER ON THE

01:57 - 30.790 K.

01:57 - 33.750 >>OR K K TALKED ABOUT THE U

01:57 - 36.200 WHICH IS RIGHT. THE ORDINANCE

01:57 - 37.210 TALKED ABOUT HERE.

01:57 - 39.990 >>I RESPECT YOUR HONOR YOUR T'S

01:57 - 42.500 CASE COLLEGE KIDS THEY USE.

01:57 - 44.360 ONE OF US AS

01:57 - 47.150 A WORD. AND YOU'RE DONE SINCE

01:57 - 49.360 WHEN IT GOES ON TO DISCUSS.

01:57 - 52.910 SHE ISSUES EVER HOLD. THAT WAS

01:57 - 54.630 SAYS REPORT NEVER SAYS

01:57 - 57.640 USE THEY PREEMPTED CATEGORY IT

01:57 - 59.050 SIMPLY ACKNOWLEDGES THAT IT WAS

01:57 - 01.170 UNDISPUTED AND THE ORDINANCE

01:58 - 02.570 THERE. A HARVARD

01:58 - 05.190 USE YOUR USE AS WELL AS

01:58 - 07.760 OWNERSHIP POSSESSION TRAPS

01:58 - 10.900 AND SO OUR MISSION AS WE READ

01:58 - 12.900 THE CASE THERE IS NO HOLDING

01:58 - 14.750 THERE'S NO SENTENCE, NO FLAWS

01:58 - 18.230 AND CIVICALLY HOLES AND USE IT

01:58 - 23.150 ON THE TOPIC OF CHARITABLE

01:58 - 24.540 REASONS SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT

01:58 - 25.550 STURRIDGE HAS

01:58 - 28.120 ANOTHER COURT AND MY MY

01:58 - 29.350 COLLEAGUES ON THE OTHER SIDE

01:58 - 30.850 SAID YES THAT'S AND THEN AS

01:58 - 32.140 WELL AND I THINK THAT REALLY

01:58 - 35.290 THOSE TRAITS THE PROBLEM.

01:58 - 38.500 I CAUSED THIS EITHER OR ASKING

01:58 - 39.680 PEOPLE LEAVE THIS COURT

01:58 - 42.350 TO AND WORDS INSTEAD OF ORTIZ.

01:58 - 44.140 YES AND STATUTES

01:58 - 46.870 GENERAL ASSEMBLY CITING NOT

01:58 - 48.190 THERE AND AGAIN IF YOU LOOK AT

01:58 - 49.070 OUR PRIEST LOOK

01:58 - 51.790 AT WHAT. STATE LEGISLATURES IN

01:58 - 53.260 OTHER STATES LIKE DOZENS OF

01:58 - 55.580 STATES HAVE FIRE. YES, THE BOSS

01:58 - 58.340 AND LOTS OF THEM DO YOU SLOW

01:58 - 59.800 THE CAT, DO YOU HAVE

01:58 - 02.180 OR STORAGE AND USE AND OTHER

01:59 - 06.050 STATE LEGISLATURES KNOW HAS SAY

01:59 - 06.350 WHAT

01:59 - 08.300 THEY NEED. THEY MEANT TO

01:59 - 10.390 PREEMPT YOU SEE A MATCH TO THE

01:59 - 13.120 APP QUESTION THAT.

01:59 - 14.420 >>I THINK IN THE BACK OF A

01:59 - 16.060 QUESTION THAT THE PRESIDENT

01:59 - 17.190 DOES GET THE BEGINNING OF

01:59 - 18.920 ARGUMENT AND BECAUSE I'VE BEEN

01:59 - 20.270 STRUGGLING WITH THIS AS WELL.

01:59 - 23.800 SO IF I PURCHASED IT. A GUN OR

01:59 - 25.580 USE A GUN A FIREARM.

01:59 - 28.310 BUT THEN SOMEBODY TELLING ME

01:59 - 29.770 AND I HAVE A RIGHT TO DO THAT

01:59 - 30.990 IN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS THE

01:59 - 32.840 RIGHT KID REGULATE THE

01:59 - 35.290 POSSESSION. AND THE TRANSFER

01:59 - 38.470 THE OWNERSHIP. BUT THEY CAN'T

01:59 - 40.350 TELL ME HOW TO USE IT. BUT THE

01:59 - 43.000 CITY A PITTSBURG KAN I MEAN IT

01:59 - 44.560 IS A REAL DISCONNECT HERE THAT

01:59 - 46.350 I HAVE A RIGHT OF OWNERSHIP.

01:59 - 48.350 BUT THEN SOMEBODY ELSE IS GOING

01:59 - 49.590 TO TELL ME HOW I USE THAT

01:59 - 50.350 OWNERSHIP RATE.

01:59 - 53.790 >>I UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION

01:59 - 55.000 HERE ARE AND I THINK THAT THE

01:59 - 56.450 KEY DISTINCTION HERE.

01:59 - 00.100 THAT THESE ORDINANCES. A

02:00 - 02.880 FOCUS ON A NARROW SET OF

02:00 - 05.220 THE INTERESTS USES IN

02:00 - 08.380 PUBLIC PLACES. LIMITED TONIGHT

02:00 - 10.040 TELLING ME I CAN ONLY BE

02:00 - 11.600 REGULATING ONLY CERTAIN POINT

02:00 - 13.180 THE GUN BUT THEN REALLY GOES

02:00 - 14.480 AGAINST THE CONSTITUTIONAL

02:00 - 14.710 RIGHT.

02:00 - 17.060 >>WELL,

02:00 - 19.290 I RESPECT, LEON IT'S IT'S

02:00 - 20.820 ACTUALLY QUITE THE OPPOSITE BY

02:00 - 21.550 LIMITING THESE

02:00 - 24.050 RESTRICTIONS TOO, SALT WEAPONS

02:00 - 26.040 AND LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINES.

02:00 - 27.010 THIS IS IN

02:00 - 29.320 ALMOST UNIFORMLY HELD

02:00 - 30.240 THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY BY

02:00 - 31.310 FEDERAL COURTS OF APPEALS IN

02:00 - 33.230 OTHER COURTS. THERE IS NO

02:00 - 34.590 SAINTS MAY NOT HAVE THE RIGHT.

02:00 - 38.280 THERE ARE LOTS OF LOTS OF ALL

02:00 - 40.170 THE FIRE. AND LOTS OF LOTS OF

02:00 - 42.280 MAGAZINES THAT HOLD AND ROUNDS

02:00 - 44.110 OR FEWER, BETTER STILL FULLY

02:00 - 45.500 OF L SO THERE

02:00 - 48.130 REALLY IS NO AND GET ALMOST

02:00 - 50.020 NOUNS CONSENSUS ACROSS THE

02:00 - 51.180 COUNTRY THERE IS NO

02:00 - 52.870 INFRINGEMENT ON A RESTRICTION

02:00 - 54.430 THAT THAT'S NARROW AND IS THAT

02:00 - 57.210 THERE ARE THAT WE'RE TALKING

02:00 - 58.280 ABOUT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT

02:00 - 59.600 WHETHER THE CITY OF PITTSBURGH

02:00 - 00.420 HAS THE RIGHT.

02:01 - 03.590 >>TO REGULATE THIS PARTICULAR

02:01 - 07.400 AREA. YES, AGAIN BACK

02:01 - 09.930 TO YOU. TEXT OF THE STATUTE OF

02:01 - 11.890 ALL IS THAT THE FACT THAT E.

02:01 - 14.520 >>GENERAL ASSEMBLY DID NOT SAY

02:01 - 16.480 THIS IS STARTING TO LOSE ITS

02:01 - 18.180 FIRST ACTION IT DID NOT SAY

02:01 - 20.270 YEAH THE ENTIRE FIELD TO THE

02:01 - 22.270 EXTENT THAT THE DECISIONS OF

02:01 - 24.840 THIS COURT. I HAVE GONE BEYOND

02:01 - 27.290 WORDS STATUE. WHAT GENERAL

02:01 - 28.410 ASSEMBLY ACTUALLY

02:01 - 30.130 ENACT IT. HE WOULD SUBMIT

02:01 - 31.810 RESPECT TO THAT SPORT SHOULD

02:01 - 34.090 TAKE A FRESH LOOK AND SOME OF

02:01 - 36.290 THEIR OWN LANGUAGE. SOME OF

02:01 - 37.500 THAT ON MY BACK

02:01 - 39.850 AND SHOULD HOLD OFF LINE AND

02:01 - 40.970 FORCED THE ACTION

02:01 - 43.210 ABSOLUTELY FULLY TO THE EXTENT

02:01 - 44.660 THAT THE LEGISLATURE HAS

02:01 - 47.060 ENACTED. I'M NOT AS TIME THE

02:01 - 49.390 SMOKE HAD WORRIES A YEAR

02:01 - 52.980 AGREES. A COUNCIL I DID.

02:01 - 55.150 IF YOU COULD CLARIFY WHAT.

02:01 - 58.010 >>HOW YOU'RE ATTEMPTING TO USE

02:01 - 59.260 THE WORD. HE IS.

02:02 - 03.030 >>YES WE HAVE TO DO THAT YOU

02:02 - 04.370 ABOUT THE AMMUNITION.

02:02 - 06.980 IT SAYS IT DOESN'T MEAN

02:02 - 08.020 POSSESSION OWNERSHIP

02:02 - 10.630 TRANSPORTATION OR A TRANSFER.

02:02 - 11.160 BUT

02:02 - 13.300 IT MEAN OKAY DID START

02:02 - 14.930 CHARGING, BUT THEN IT GOES ON

02:02 - 17.610 THEY LOADING IT INTO A FIREARM

02:02 - 20.790 OR MAGAZINE. AND THE LOADING IT

02:02 - 22.410 WITH AMMUNITION. A

02:02 - 24.230 FITTING IN OR INSTALLING IT

02:02 - 25.600 INTO A FIREARM.

02:02 - 32.430 CAN YOU CLARIFY WHAT HERE

02:02 - 33.150 INTENT

02:02 - 33.720 IS THERE.

02:02 - 36.150 >>YES, ABSOLUTELY AND WHAT THE

02:02 - 37.570 CITY OF PITTSBURGH HAS SAID

02:02 - 39.170 THROUGHOUT THIS LITIGATION ALL

02:02 - 40.200 GOES BACK TO.

02:02 - 44.550 >>SO UNITED STATES

02:02 - 46.980 IMPORTANT VALLEY ABOUT THE

02:02 - 49.190 COMMON SENSE WHICH VARY A

02:02 - 50.850 COMMISSION MEETING OR USE

02:02 - 53.560 THAT USING A FIREARM HERE ARE

02:02 - 55.250 ASKING RESIDENTS IN CONCEPT,

02:02 - 58.120 AYERS ACTIVELY PLAYING IT

02:02 - 59.910 SOMEWHAT. SO EACH OF THE

02:02 - 01.480 EXAMPLES HERE I JUST CLARIFY

02:03 - 03.840 ONE THING ALL THE COVID IN THE

02:03 - 04.370 TEMPLES

02:03 - 06.130 OF USE A LARGE CAPACITY

02:03 - 07.540 MAGAZINES THAT YOU ARE JUST WAS

02:03 - 09.330 ACTIVELY EMPLOYING IT IN

02:03 - 11.650 SOME WAY. YES, AT ONE POINT.

02:03 - 13.110 SO THEY'VE COME UP WITH A

02:03 - 14.650 DEFINITION OF WHAT THAT MEANS

02:03 - 16.400 IN THAT YOU AND YOUR GUN.

02:03 - 17.010 >>RIGHT.

02:03 - 21.830 AND YOU'RE ACTIVELY EMPLOYING

02:03 - 24.580 IF YOU LOVE IT. YOU LOAD IT IN

02:03 - 25.050 PUBLIC.

02:03 - 27.480 >>YES, THIS IS ALL IN THE 2 IN

02:03 - 27.900 PUBLIC.

02:03 - 32.990 SO IF YOU ARE

02:03 - 35.000 IN PUBLIC. A FIREARM.

02:03 - 38.110 >>YOUR MAGAZINE

02:03 - 41.000 IN PUBLIC. AMMUNITION OR WITH A

02:03 - 43.110 LARGE CAPACITY MAGAZINE THAT

02:03 - 45.420 GOES TO ALL OF US STARING AT.

02:03 - 49.500 CECI IT DOING SOMETHING

02:03 - 50.940 THAT SUGGESTS.

02:03 - 54.390 >>BUT EVEN IN EVEN IN ABOUT 2

02:03 - 55.610 SOMETHING THAT STATUTE.

02:03 - 58.330 >>EVEN IN 5337 '03.

02:03 - 01.470 THEY QUALIFIED UNNECESSARY

02:04 - 03.860 FIRING IN CHARGE YOU'VE GONE

02:04 - 04.890 WELL BEYOND THAT

02:04 - 07.080 THIS IS AN UNNECESSARY FIRING

02:04 - 09.050 AND DISCHARGES BUT YOU CAN EVEN

02:04 - 11.220 LOADED YOU CAN KERRY CAN

02:04 - 12.320 PEOPLE TOGETHER.

02:04 - 16.600 >>TO BE CLEAR YOU'RE GOING INTO

02:04 - 19.860 A FIREARM AND I'M NOT VERY

02:04 - 21.920 GOOD CHARGE. OR YOU TAKE THE

02:04 - 24.510 LEAD ON THAT DEFINITION AND HE

02:04 - 26.280 YOU CAN.

02:04 - 27.870 >>YOU KNOW YOU CAN DO ALL OF

02:04 - 29.800 THOSE THINGS WHEN YOU LEAVE

02:04 - 32.310 YOUR HOUSE. DO ALL

02:04 - 33.410 THOSE THINGS. WELL YOUR

02:04 - 34.960 ADMISSIONS YOUR MAGAZINE YOU'RE

02:04 - 36.010 HOLDING BACK TO AN INCH.

02:04 - 38.740 >>THE SAME WOULD ANYBODY KNOW

02:04 - 40.250 WHETHER IT HAPPENED IN PUBLIC

02:04 - 42.310 OR AT THEIR HOUSE. AND

02:04 - 44.390 THAT'S IT. AND CAN BE ARRESTED

02:04 - 46.090 BECAUSE THEY HAVEN'T VOTED IN

02:04 - 47.620 THE PRESUMPTION THEY DID IN

02:04 - 48.880 PUBLIC WHO WOULD KNOW.

02:04 - 50.330 >>THEN YOU HAVE TO PROVE THAT

02:04 - 52.850 NO YOU DID AT HOME AND YOU CAN

02:04 - 55.520 READ IT REALLY OK. YEAH POINT

02:04 - 57.070 HERE YOUR HONOR IS THAT IT'S.

02:04 - 58.710 >>AND LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER

02:04 - 00.290 SAW SOMEBODY.

02:05 - 03.200 BEING THERE ARE ASKING THAT

02:05 - 05.310 EASY. A PUBLIC PLACE.

02:05 - 08.530 >>NOW WOULD AND IT

02:05 - 10.310 WOULD SUGGEST, AND THERE MAY BE

02:05 - 11.800 REASON TO INVESTIGATE WHAT'S

02:05 - 13.250 GOING ON HERE AND ALSO JUST

02:05 - 14.650 TO CLARIFY. THESE ARE NOT

02:05 - 16.650 CRIMINAL OFFENSE IS STILL ABOUT

02:05 - 18.000 SO NOBODY GETS A LOOK AT THE

02:05 - 19.530 CRIME CODE ALREADY ADDRESSED

02:05 - 21.530 THE 5TH CHARGING YOU AND THAT

02:05 - 23.510 WOULD BE ON THE COUNCIL ABLE TO

02:05 - 25.700 PREEMPT IT. SO OK THANK YOU.

02:05 - 31.930 >>OUR NUMBER

02:05 - 34.060 2021. THANK YOU.

02:05 - 38.920 >>TAKE A SEAT IN

02:05 - 40.470 THE COURTROOM AND SEE THE

02:05 - 41.810 REAL LIFE CASES AFFECTING

02:05 - 43.610 PENNSYLVANIANS TODAY. HEAR THE

02:05 - 45.220 ARGUMENTS FROM BOTH SIDES WITH

02:05 - 47.620 FULL TRANSPARENCY EXCLUSIVELY

02:05 - 49.640 ON PCN I WATCHED THE

02:05 - 51.240 COMMONWEALTH SUPERIOR AND

02:05 - 53.270 SUPREME COURT ON CABLE AND THE

02:05 - 54.360 PCN SELECT

02:05 - 57.080 STREAMING SERVICE. VISIT PCN TV

02:05 - 58.360 DOT COM FOR THE COMPLETE

02:05 - 01.450 SCHEDULE. PCN PENNSYLVANIA

02:06 - 03.110 POLITICS AND POLICY.

02:06 - 09.120 >>WE WILL

02:06 - 11.710 CONSIDER NUMBER 22 PITTSBURGH

02:06 - 13.720 WATER AND SEWER AUTHORITY.

02:06 - 16.000 THE UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION.

02:06 - 17.520 A REVIEW.

02:06 - 20.680 FOR WATER AND SEWER AUTHORITY

02:06 - 21.990 APPEAL THE UNEMPLOYMENT

02:06 - 23.990 COMPENSATION BOARD OF REVIEW.

02:06 - 26.030 GRAHAM A BENEFIT TO AN

02:06 - 29.060 EMPLOYEE. PARA UBER AFTER

02:06 - 30.760 STARTING EMPLOYMENT WITH THE

02:06 - 32.260 FOR FOOD OR

02:06 - 34.780 A CLAIM WHEN PRIME MEDICAL

02:06 - 38.730 MARIJUANA, A TREE. CORRECT

02:06 - 39.800 THE BORDER WHEN

02:06 - 42.090 THEY AUTHORITY SELECTED HIM FOR

02:06 - 43.610 RANDOM DRUG TESTS. HE

02:06 - 45.880 FAILED IT. THE AUTHORITY DRUG

02:06 - 47.680 AND ALCOHOL FREE WORK LIFE

02:06 - 49.660 POLICY PROVIDES THAT IF AN

02:06 - 51.210 EMPLOYEE TESTED POSITIVE.

02:06 - 54.170 HE HAS 3 DAYS FOR A VALID

02:06 - 55.770 PRESCRIPTION FOR THE DRUG.

02:06 - 57.330 THE CAPPING A TIME.

02:06 - 00.930 FOR HIS MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:07 - 02.550 PATIENT INFORMATION CARD.

02:07 - 03.130 I

02:07 - 05.220 NEVER LAUGHED AUTHORITY

02:07 - 06.730 DISCHARGE CLAIMANT FOR THE

02:07 - 08.840 STATE AGREES HIM THAT MARIJUANA

02:07 - 11.220 YEAR THE ILLEGAL. UNDER FEDERAL

02:07 - 11.590 LAW.

02:07 - 14.030 THE BOARD RAMPANT CRIME AND

02:07 - 15.990 UNEMPLOYMENT. COMPENSATION

02:07 - 17.840 BENEFITS HOLDING THAT THE

02:07 - 19.130 AUTHORITY DID NOT

02:07 - 21.310 THE CLAIMANT INTENTIONALLY

02:07 - 23.800 VIOLATED A COURT FIGHT POLICY

02:07 - 24.890 ON CRIME.

02:07 - 27.090 THE AUTHORITY ARGUE THAT THE

02:07 - 29.810 BOARD ERRED FROM SOME OF THE

02:07 - 31.270 UNEMPLOYMENT. LA

02:07 - 33.780 WHICH AUTHORIZES THE DENIAL OF

02:07 - 36.870 BENEFITS. WHEN A

02:07 - 37.990 DRUG TEST. IT

02:07 - 40.790 WILL FAIL. A LOT OF NOT BURDEN

02:07 - 42.370 THE EMPLOYER WITH HAVING TO

02:07 - 44.200 PROVE THAT THE EMPLOYEE DRUG

02:07 - 46.400 TEST FAILURE WITH NOT KNOWING

02:07 - 49.770 OR AND HOW IT. A GOOD MAN AND

02:07 - 51.030 INTENTIONAL.

02:07 - 58.970 BOTH SIDES BY THE WAY.

02:08 - 01.430 I MEAN

02:08 - 04.510 GRAHAM AND MISTER DION ARE

02:08 - 05.810 GOING TO DIVIDE THEIR 15

02:08 - 06.090 MINUTE.

02:08 - 09.310 YOU'RE GOING TO DIVIDE EVENLY.

02:08 - 12.740 >>YES, YOUR IF IF IF TIME IF I

02:08 - 13.890 MAY I WOULD LIKE TO PROCEED

02:08 - 15.810 BEFORE MISTER DION. RESERVE THE

02:08 - 17.740 REST THE TIME FOR. I MISSED A

02:08 - 18.230 GAME.

02:08 - 22.500 >>THAT CRIME YOU LEAVING I HAVE

02:08 - 22.940 7 AND A

02:08 - 25.520 HALF MINUTE. MISTER THOMAS YOUR

02:08 - 27.290 15 MINUTES IN A RIVER FROM

02:08 - 29.170 ABOUT 15 MINUTES FOR REBUTTAL.

02:08 - 32.550 >>AN EARLY TO RESERVE 2 MINUTES

02:08 - 32.990 REBUTTAL.

02:08 - 40.430 AND MAYBE WE SUPPORT MY NAME IS

02:08 - 41.390 JIM THOMAS, I

02:08 - 43.570 REPRESENT PETITIONER PITTSBURGH

02:08 - 45.640 WATER AND SEWER AUTHORITY AND

02:08 - 46.700 YOU MAY HEAR ME REFER

02:08 - 48.410 THROUGHOUT THIS PRESENTATION AS

02:08 - 48.500 THE

02:08 - 51.150 BECAUSE A REPRESENTATIVE FOR

02:08 - 52.670 SOME TIME AND THAT'S HOW WE

02:08 - 53.190 REFER TO.

02:08 - 56.600 I APPRECIATE YOUR RECITATION OF

02:08 - 58.530 THE FACTS. THERE IS A COUPLE

02:08 - 00.020 POINTS THAT WOULD LIKE TO ADD

02:09 - 02.710 TO THE RECITATION OF THE MOST

02:09 - 04.520 SIGNIFICANTLY WITH REGARD TO BE

02:09 - 07.250 PW ESSAYS DRUG AND ALCOHOL

02:09 - 07.830 POLICY.

02:09 - 11.420 A NEW LEGAL DRUG AS A

02:09 - 13.440 CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE PROHIBITED

02:09 - 14.100 UNDER

02:09 - 16.350 FEDERAL RULES OR STATE LAW THAT

02:09 - 18.060 SPECIFICALLY SET FORTH IN

02:09 - 18.590 POLICY.

02:09 - 21.580 AND IT'S

02:09 - 22.970 UNDISPUTED IN THE COURT CAN

02:09 - 24.270 TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE OF THE

02:09 - 25.550 FACT THAT ALL MARIJUANA,

02:09 - 26.250 INCLUDING

02:09 - 28.450 MEDICAL MARIJUANA. A STORE

02:09 - 30.000 SCHEDULE ONE CONTROLLED STOPS

02:09 - 30.810 IN SOME OF THE FEDERAL

02:09 - 31.870 CONTROLLED STOP THIS.

02:09 - 34.560 THEREFORE IT'S STILL ILLEGAL

02:09 - 36.210 UNDER FEDERAL LAW AND THERE CAN

02:09 - 38.490 BE NO VALID A PRESCRIPTION FOR

02:09 - 39.570 UNDER FEDERAL LAW.

02:09 - 42.090 THE POLICY

02:09 - 43.770 SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFIES

02:09 - 46.310 MARIJUANA AS ONE OF THE DRUGS

02:09 - 48.550 FOR WEEKS EMPLOYEES MAY BE

02:09 - 50.140 TESTED PURSUANT TO IT.

02:09 - 53.220 >>I'M TALKING ABOUT THE POLICY

02:09 - 54.620 DOES THE WRITTEN POLICY

02:09 - 57.360 CONTAIN ANY EXCEPTION FOR

02:09 - 59.100 SOMEONE WHO HAS A PRESCRIPTION.

02:10 - 00.920 >>IT DOES IT

02:10 - 03.560 IT STATES THAT

02:10 - 06.160 IN THE CLINTON TESTIFIED IN

02:10 - 08.620 THE BOARD FOUND THAT

02:10 - 10.980 THE CLAY MOORE WHEN HE WAS

02:10 - 12.050 BEING ARMED BORDER, THIS

02:10 - 13.610 PARTNERS ORIENTATION WAS IN

02:10 - 16.210 FACT. BRIEF ON THAT PARTICULAR

02:10 - 18.360 PROTOCOL AND THAT IS IF THERE

02:10 - 21.050 IS A VALID PRESCRIPTION FOR

02:10 - 23.480 A DRUG. THAT CAME BACK AS

02:10 - 25.440 POSITIVE AND TO THE TESTS AN

02:10 - 27.150 EMPLOYEE HAS THE ABILITY.

02:10 - 29.530 PERCENT AND OUR PRESCRIPTION

02:10 - 31.430 WITHIN 3 DAYS. IF IT'S

02:10 - 32.430 DETERMINED THAT ABOUT

02:10 - 34.420 PRESCRIPTION AND THAT WAS BEING

02:10 - 35.750 USED WITHIN THE CONFINES OF

02:10 - 37.520 THAT PRESCRIPTION AND THE

02:10 - 39.500 RESULT WOULD NOT GET REPORTED

02:10 - 41.810 TO WEAR SO ESSENTIALLY THE

02:10 - 43.480 SENATE IF THERE'S ANY CONFUSION

02:10 - 43.920 BY.

02:10 - 45.010 >>NI HIM.

02:10 - 46.650 >>FOR YOU IT WOULD SEEM TO BE

02:10 - 47.930 UNDERSTANDABLE THAT THEY WOULD

02:10 - 48.130 BE

02:10 - 50.830 CONFUSION THAT HEARING THIS THE

02:10 - 52.410 IMPORT OF THE THINGS JUST GET

02:10 - 54.150 AN APOLOGY CONTAIN THE LANGUAGE

02:10 - 55.030 THE SAME

02:10 - 57.290 AND ANY EVERY HEWITT YOUR

02:10 - 59.110 COMPUTER BE SURE TO GET THE

02:10 - 59.760 EMPLOYER.

02:11 - 02.320 >>YOU KNOW I WILL HOW WOULD HOW

02:11 - 04.640 HOW WOULD BE EMPLOYEE KNOW

02:11 - 06.450 AND AFTER READING OF ALL IF

02:11 - 07.250 YOU'RE HEARING WHAT WAS

02:11 - 09.500 EXPLAINED THAT IF THERE HAD A

02:11 - 11.230 PRESCRIPTION CARD FROM A

02:11 - 13.810 MEDICAL PHYSICIAN AND THAT IS

02:11 - 16.270 THEY WERE TESTED. THEN HE AS HE

02:11 - 18.000 DID YOU JUST SHOWED HIM A

02:11 - 18.360 MEDICAL

02:11 - 19.160 MARIJUANA CARD.

02:11 - 20.830 >>AND THAT THAT'S A VERY GOOD

02:11 - 22.560 QUESTION AND I WAS JUST GETTING

02:11 - 24.190 INTO THE HEART OF THE DRUG AND

02:11 - 26.630 ALCOHOL, A POLICY THAT SPEAKS

02:11 - 26.790 TO

02:11 - 29.630 WEIGH IN. SOMEBODY IS TAKING A

02:11 - 32.120 PRESCRIPTION MEDICATION THAT

02:11 - 33.070 THEY ARE TOO

02:11 - 36.200 ESSENTIALLY NUMBER ONE GOAL IN

02:11 - 38.220 IN CONSULT WITH THE PRESCRIBING

02:11 - 39.920 DOCTOR TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY

02:11 - 41.510 RESTRICTIONS ON THE ABILITY TO

02:11 - 43.620 USE THAT ON TOP OF THAT RIGHT,

02:11 - 44.190 WE'LL CHECK.

02:11 - 45.980 >>SO LET'S JUST GO THROUGH THIS

02:11 - 47.990 THOUGH HE DOES THAT DOCTORS

02:11 - 49.430 PRESCRIBE MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:11 - 52.000 CARD. EXPLAIN TO THEIR PATIENTS

02:11 - 54.250 AND THE IMPACT FROM THE TAKING

02:11 - 56.060 A MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND THEN

02:11 - 57.130 MET THAT CRITERIA.

02:11 - 00.390 >>OKAY I WAS GOING TO GET INTO

02:12 - 02.050 THE NEXT PART OF THE OF THE

02:12 - 05.880 POLICY WHICH IS TO THE PWS

02:12 - 07.000 SAVE THEM.

02:12 - 09.670 IT STATES THAT EMPLOYEE MAY

02:12 - 11.500 CONTINUE TO WORK WHILE TAKING A

02:12 - 13.480 LEGAL DRUG WHICH A MAN WHO ONCE

02:12 - 14.690 IN THE CONFINES OF A

02:12 - 16.820 VALID PRESCRIPTION AND WHY DID

02:12 - 18.640 THE PWS A DETERMINED

02:12 - 21.280 THAT EMPLOYEES BUT YOU CAN USE

02:12 - 22.790 OF THE DRUG DOESN'T POSE A

02:12 - 24.890 SAFETY THREAT. OR JOB

02:12 - 26.820 PERFORMANCE DOESN'T BACK DOWN

02:12 - 28.610 TO ITS JOB PERFORM STORM

02:12 - 29.920 PARAPHRASING RIGHT THERE, BUT

02:12 - 31.800 YOU CAN FIND THAT PARTICULAR

02:12 - 37.250 THE APPENDIX AT ONE 74 1.75.

02:12 - 38.160 AND THAT'S

02:12 - 41.070 SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE HAD THE

02:12 - 42.200 IMPORTANT TO CLEAN IN

02:12 - 44.520 THIS CASE ACTUALLY DONE WITH

02:12 - 46.250 THE POLICY PROVIDES AT THAT

02:12 - 47.570 POINT IN TIME

02:12 - 49.690 ACQUIRED ACTUALLY USING THE

02:12 - 52.160 WORKING WALK TAKING MEDICAL

02:12 - 54.350 MARIJUANA. THE AUTHORITY COULD

02:12 - 56.140 HAVE CLARIFIED WITH HIM

02:12 - 57.720 THAT YOU CANNOT USE MEDICAL

02:12 - 59.890 MARIJUANA BECAUSE OUR POLICY

02:12 - 01.820 FOLLOWS BOTH FEDERAL AND

02:13 - 04.280 STATE LAW AND MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:13 - 05.650 IS STILL ILLEGAL UNDER

02:13 - 08.090 FEDERAL LAW. ON TOP OF THAT THE

02:13 - 09.620 EMPLOYEE HE AT ALL.

02:13 - 11.720 SHE SPECIFICALLY WHY DOES THIS

02:13 - 13.260 DOES DOES THE EMPLOYER THAN

02:13 - 14.470 ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THERE

02:13 - 15.600 IS CONFUSION.

02:13 - 17.860 >>AND THAT THE EMPLOYEE SHOULD

02:13 - 19.970 COME FORWARD AND ASK FOR AN

02:13 - 21.030 EXPLANATION FROM

02:13 - 21.740 THE EMPLOYER.

02:13 - 23.790 >>WELL HE REPEATEDLY SAY

02:13 - 24.640 DOESN'T ACKNOWLEDGE THAT

02:13 - 26.200 THERE'S A CONFUSION BECAUSE

02:13 - 28.740 IT IS IT IS CLEARLY ILLEGAL

02:13 - 29.860 UNDER FEDERAL LAW.

02:13 - 33.010 >>THOMAS MANNER.

02:13 - 35.860 IN LIGHT OF THAT.

02:13 - 39.570 THE EMPLOYEE HERE AND THE

02:13 - 41.320 MEDICAL MARIJUANA PRESCRIPTION

02:13 - 41.800 CARD.

02:13 - 45.210 WAS IN THE POLLS AND SAID HEY

02:13 - 47.780 YOU MAY HAVE THIS DESCRIPTION

02:13 - 48.910 OF PENNSYLVANIA LAW.

02:13 - 50.580 WE STILL CONSIDER HIM. THE

02:13 - 53.200 MEDICAL MARIJUANA BE LEGAL IS

02:13 - 54.290 THIS SIMPLY I LIKE

02:13 - 57.060 MEDICAL MARIJUANA IS AN

02:13 - 58.590 EXCEPTION TO THE PRESCRIPTION

02:13 - 59.590 POLICY BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT IT

02:13 - 00.330 SOUNDS LIKE YOU

02:14 - 00.790 ARE GO.

02:14 - 03.460 >>I'M NOT ARGUING THAT IN THERE

02:14 - 05.260 IS NO SPECIFIC VISION IN THE

02:14 - 06.880 POLICY. THEY WERE FIRST

02:14 - 08.990 MARIJUANA AND THE FACT THAT IT

02:14 - 10.800 WAS ILLEGAL UNDER FEDERAL LAW.

02:14 - 14.530 >>IT DOES CONFUSION HERE.

02:14 - 18.750 YOU CAN'T REALLY

02:14 - 20.250 GO DRUGS BUT YOU CAN ADD A

02:14 - 21.380 PRESCRIPTION SO.

02:14 - 24.610 I THINK JUST CALL THESE ON TO

02:14 - 26.090 SOMETHING HERE THAT THERE'S A

02:14 - 26.920 YEARLY.

02:14 - 29.950 YOUR POLICY EASILY COULD HAVE

02:14 - 31.470 RECTIFIED BY JUST SAYING

02:14 - 33.560 YOU KNOW MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:14 - 35.190 GROWS PRESCRIPTION IS ILLEGAL

02:14 - 36.690 UNDER OF ALL THIS AND YOU

02:14 - 38.980 >>LOOKING IN THE REARVIEW

02:14 - 40.990 RECKON CLEARLY KNOWS THAT YOU

02:14 - 41.250 KNOW.

02:14 - 43.150 >>IF THE POLICY SAID

02:14 - 45.330 MEDICAL MARIJUANA IS STILL

02:14 - 46.010 PROHIBITED UNDER

02:14 - 48.190 FEDERAL LAW AND THEREFORE IS

02:14 - 49.800 ALSO PROHIBITED UNDER OUR POLLS

02:14 - 51.150 BECAUSE OF FOLLOWS FEDERAL LAW.

02:14 - 52.950 WE WOULD BE SITTING HERE TODAY.

02:14 - 53.870 I KNOW JET WITH

02:14 - 54.690 THE COURTS.

02:14 - 55.990 >>HOWEVER, EVEN KNOW THAT YOU

02:14 - 57.050 AND I DON'T EVEN KNOW THAT YOU

02:14 - 58.150 WOULD HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO

02:14 - 59.970 DO THAT BECAUSE AREN'T YOU A

02:14 - 02.220 PUBLIC BODY NOT YOUR REQUIRED

02:15 - 03.820 YOU'RE HERE TO PENNSYLVANIA

02:15 - 05.930 LAW. NOW WE ARE WHY WHY ARE YOU

02:15 - 07.470 WHY ARE YOU OBLIGATED TO FOLLOW

02:15 - 08.960 FEDERAL LAW NOT PENNSYLVANIA

02:15 - 09.280 LAW.

02:15 - 11.100 >>WE ARE UNMISSABLE

02:15 - 13.640 FOR YOU AND AGAIN THIS WILL

02:15 - 16.500 40'S ACT. WE ARE NOT A BRANCH

02:15 - 18.150 OF THE STATE GOVERNMENT LIKE

02:15 - 19.940 THIS FOR A DRESS IN THE GAS

02:15 - 21.940 FIRST THE 57 HERE IN.

02:15 - 23.440 >>AND PALATE E.

02:15 - 29.240 AUTHORITIES

02:15 - 31.740 ARE IN KALIHI UP RIGHT HERE AND

02:15 - 32.910 PURSUE A FEW MINUTES BOTH

02:15 - 34.270 ALREADY THAT THAT IS CORRECT

02:15 - 36.500 HOWEVER, WE STILL WARM.

02:15 - 38.260 >>AND IF WE COULD JUST GO BACK

02:15 - 39.680 TO THE POLICY FROM IT.

02:15 - 46.430 AN EMPLOYEE WAS PERMITTED TO

02:15 - 48.110 BOARD THEM A PRESCRIPTION.

02:15 - 50.770 IF YOU NEVER INTENDED TO ALLOW

02:15 - 53.740 ANY EMPLOYEE. A PRESCRIBE

02:15 - 56.720 MEDICAL MARIJUANA REMAIN A JOB.

02:16 - 03.370 >>I'M OLD I'M NOT QUITE

02:16 - 05.930 SURE I UNDERSTAND YOUR IT WAS

02:16 - 08.640 ALWAYS OUR INTENT. IF ALL OVER

02:16 - 09.730 TO PROHIBIT ANY

02:16 - 11.720 A DRUG THAT IS ILLEGAL UNDER

02:16 - 13.980 FEDERAL OR STATE LAW SO WAS

02:16 - 15.320 ALWAYS OR 10.

02:16 - 17.990 NOT TO PERMIT THE USE OF

02:16 - 19.370 MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND I WOULD

02:16 - 20.920 LIKE TO TAKE THIS OFF YOU KNOW

02:16 - 23.010 SO SO THE EMPLOYEE HAD TO

02:16 - 23.570 GUESS.

02:16 - 25.660 >>AND THE EMPLOYERS IN HAND,

02:16 - 27.560 ALTHOUGH IT WAS THE EMPLOYER

02:16 - 28.830 WHO HAD THE ABILITY

02:16 - 30.750 TO WRITE THE POLICY AND THE

02:16 - 32.710 EMPLOYEE HAD NO ABILITY TO

02:16 - 32.960 WRITE

02:16 - 33.660 THE POLICY.

02:16 - 36.170 >>I DISAGREE THAT THE EMPLOYEE

02:16 - 37.750 WAS REQUIRED TO GUESS

02:16 - 39.740 THE EMPLOYEE ALWAYS HAD YOUR

02:16 - 41.150 OWN GOOD. BUT HOW DOES THE

02:16 - 42.480 POLICY DAY.

02:16 - 45.260 >>THAT WE WILL NOT ALLOW ANY

02:16 - 46.860 KIND OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:16 - 48.590 BECAUSE WE CONSIDER IT TO BE

02:16 - 50.200 ILLEGAL UNDER FEDERAL LAW.

02:16 - 52.110 YOU THAT TOO AND

02:16 - 52.860 THE POLITICS.

02:16 - 55.040 >>NOW AS I STATED POLICY DOES

02:16 - 57.200 NOT MENTION A MEDICAL MARIJUANA

02:16 - 59.650 ITALY WAS DRAFTED BEFORE THE

02:16 - 00.990 MEDICAL MARIJUANA ACT.

02:17 - 02.810 BUT.

02:17 - 04.600 >>BUT THE IMPLICATION THERE

02:17 - 06.610 THAT THERE ARE NUMBER. OPIOID.

02:17 - 07.990 THAT.

02:17 - 13.510 WE'LL BE SEEING TO IT THAT

02:17 - 15.730 IT DOES SAY IF YOU PREVENT A

02:17 - 17.480 PRESCRIPTION WITHIN 3 DAYS.

02:17 - 19.960 THEN THE CASTING AGENT WILL NOT

02:17 - 20.990 REPORT FEE.

02:17 - 32.760 IT'S THE

02:17 - 34.710 SAFE HARBOR FOR THAT EMPLOYEE

02:17 - 35.790 AND YOU'RE SAYING THAT'S NOT

02:17 - 36.540 WHAT THE POLICY

02:17 - 37.090 AND HANDED.

02:17 - 39.910 >>NOT NECESSARILY IN ANY CLEAR

02:17 - 41.570 FOR I AGREE THAT THERE ARE MANY

02:17 - 43.740 CREATES THERE ARE IN FACT THIS

02:17 - 45.950 CRIME, HOWEVER YOU CAN

02:17 - 47.510 HAVE A VALID PRESCRIPTION FOR

02:17 - 48.830 THOSE UNDER

02:17 - 51.420 FEDERAL LAW. MAYOR WARREN IS

02:17 - 52.800 STILL A SCHEDULE ONE CONTROLLED

02:17 - 54.760 SUBSTANCE UNDER FEDERAL LAW YOU

02:17 - 56.270 CAN NOT HAPPY ABOUT THE SCRIPT

02:17 - 56.690 FOR IT.

02:18 - 01.780 >>AND THE CAPE

02:18 - 04.140 WHERE IT. IT UNDER FEDERAL LAW

02:18 - 05.670 I GOT THERE AND THAT'S WHERE A

02:18 - 07.510 LOT OF ALL OUT CORRUPTION FOR

02:18 - 09.660 MARIJUANA AND YOU KNOW IT'S

02:18 - 10.710 KIND OF LIKE AN OLD

02:18 - 13.210 GOT YOU, I MEAN HOW IS AN

02:18 - 14.710 EMPLOYEE BUT THEY FORCED TO

02:18 - 15.230 HAVE A LAW

02:18 - 16.800 DEGREE NOW IN ORDER TO

02:18 - 18.710 INTERPRET THE EMPLOYER'S POLICY

02:18 - 20.400 BECAUSE THE YOU HAVE TO

02:18 - 22.840 ADMIT THE APOLOGY IS NOT

02:18 - 24.860 PARTICULARLY CLEAR THERE IS A

02:18 - 26.780 HEAD-ON CONFLICT AND AN

02:18 - 28.180 EMPLOYEE THINKING I HAVE A

02:18 - 30.060 PRESCRIPTION CARD. MY DOCTOR

02:18 - 31.550 TOLD ME I MEDICALLY NEEDED.

02:18 - 33.680 I QUALIFIED COURT IT'S

02:18 - 36.490 REGULATED BY THE STATE. AND HOW

02:18 - 37.650 DID THE EMPLOYEE KNOW THAT

02:18 - 39.010 THAT'S GOING HE

02:18 - 40.830 MET HEAD ON AND GET THE FEDERAL

02:18 - 42.560 LAW THAT BE AND COY ARE

02:18 - 44.040 GETTING COMMUTE. CLEARLY

02:18 - 45.000 COMMUNICATE WITHIN THE

02:18 - 45.820 POLITICS.

02:18 - 47.820 >>YOUR HONOR THAT'S WHERE THE

02:18 - 49.350 EMPLOYEE DOES WE HAVE AN

02:18 - 51.970 OBLIGATION UNDER THE POLICY IF

02:18 - 52.130 THEY

02:18 - 54.480 ARE TAKING A PRESCRIPTION DRUG

02:18 - 55.620 AND LIKE I SAID BEFORE I NEVER

02:18 - 59.740 WON 74 ONE THE APPENDIX THEY DO

02:18 - 01.740 HAVE AN OBLIGATION TO BRING

02:19 - 03.590 THAT TO THE ATTENTION I'M THE

02:19 - 04.710 SO

02:19 - 06.520 THEY CAN UNDERTAKE THE RIGHT

02:19 - 08.290 THING I THINK I THINK THAT I I

02:19 - 09.380 DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY YOU

02:19 - 11.230 BELIEVE IN THE EMPLOY A

02:19 - 12.360 RESPONSIBILITY.

02:19 - 15.010 >>ONE OF THE EMPLOYER. THAT HAS

02:19 - 17.190 THE OBLIGATION CLEARLY

02:19 - 19.560 COMMUNICATE ITS POLICY IN ANY

02:19 - 21.460 AMBIGUITY WILL BE RESOLVED

02:19 - 23.110 AGAIN THE PERSON DRAFT IN THE

02:19 - 23.680 WHOLE THING.

02:19 - 25.990 >>WELL THE POLICY DOES CLEARLY

02:19 - 27.580 STATE THAT MARIJUANA IS

02:19 - 28.820 PROHIBITED. THAT'S

02:19 - 31.200 CLEARLY STATE. MY POINT IS IN

02:19 - 33.840 TERMS I HEARD EXCUSE ME

02:19 - 36.210 COUNCIL, BUT THERE ARE 2

02:19 - 37.510 DEFINITIONS THERE'S A

02:19 - 40.090 DEFINITION FOR AN ILLEGAL DRUG

02:19 - 41.550 WHICH YOU MENTION. BUT

02:19 - 42.960 THEN THERE'S A DEFINITION OF

02:19 - 45.830 ILLEGAL DRUGS. A DRUG MEANS

02:19 - 47.080 PRESCRIPTION MED OF

02:19 - 49.030 MEDICATIONS. THEY HAVE BEEN

02:19 - 49.530 LEGALLY

02:19 - 52.320 A HOME AND WHAT I'M LOOKING AT

02:19 - 55.620 PAGES ONE 74 1.75 IT TALKS

02:19 - 56.150 ABOUT.

02:19 - 59.700 THE SESSION OR USE OF

02:19 - 02.650 ILLEGAL DRUGS DURING WORK HOURS

02:20 - 04.840 OR EVEN PERFORMING BUSINESSES

02:20 - 07.260 IS PERMITTED. PROVIDED THAT IT

02:20 - 08.080 DOESN'T AFFECT THEIR

02:20 - 10.170 PERFORMANCE IS LEGAL DRUG IS

02:20 - 12.240 PRESCRIBED DRUG. THIS WAS A

02:20 - 13.240 PRESCRIBED DRUG.

02:20 - 18.080 WITHIN THE DEFINITION OF

02:20 - 20.560 ILLEGAL DRUGS. YOUR HONOR THAT

02:20 - 21.320 WAS MY POINT.

02:20 - 23.320 >>HAD THE CLAIMANT BELIEVED

02:20 - 25.370 THAT HE WAS USING A LEGAL DRUG

02:20 - 27.790 UNDER THE POLICY. YEAH OWNER HE

02:20 - 27.960 HAD

02:20 - 30.590 AN OBLIGATION BRING THAT TO THE

02:20 - 32.760 ATTENTION OF THE SO THEY CAN

02:20 - 34.230 UNDERTAKE ITS OWN ASSESSMENT.

02:20 - 36.560 >>AND SAY THAT WHERE DOES IT

02:20 - 37.750 SAY THAT IS LOCATED

02:20 - 41.100 ONE 75. I'M SORRY, YEAH, OR THE

02:20 - 42.740 OF THE APPENDIX ONE 75.

02:20 - 45.880 AND IT SAYS THE EMPLOYEE MAY

02:20 - 47.570 CONTINUE TO WORK WHILE USING

02:20 - 49.220 ILLEGAL DRUGS PROVIDED THAT THE

02:20 - 50.140 PWS A

02:20 - 52.120 5TH TERM MEANS THAT EMPLOYEE

02:20 - 53.810 DOES NOT POSE A THREAT TO HIS

02:20 - 54.770 HER OWN SAFETY

02:20 - 56.720 FOR THE SAFETY OF CO-WORKERS

02:20 - 57.580 CUSTOMERS OF

02:20 - 59.780 A PROBLEM OR THAT AN IMPORTANT

02:20 - 01.160 JOB PERFORMERS WILL NOT

02:21 - 02.710 SIGNIFICANTLY BE AFFECTED BY

02:21 - 02.790 THE

02:21 - 05.580 ILLEGAL DRUG. SO MY TERMINATION

02:21 - 07.200 MADE FOR THEIR INVESTIGATION