00:14 - >>THAT'S A NEW THING THE JUDGES

00:15 - OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF

00:16 - PENNSYLVANIA. OH YEAH, OH YEAH,

00:19 - OH YEAH, ALL FOR HAVING

00:21 - BUSINESS BEFORE THE

00:21 - COMMONWEALTH COURT

00:22 - OF PENNSYLVANIA. THEY'RE

00:23 - DRAWING NEAR AND GIVE THEIR

00:25 - PENSION FOR THE COURT IS NOW

00:26 - BIDDING. I THINK THE

00:27 - COMMONWEALTH WITH HONORABLE

00:29 - COURT. PRESIDENT

00:30 - JUDGE MARY HANNAH LEAVITT

00:32 - PROVIDED.

00:35 - >>AND WELCOME TO THE

00:36 - COMBAT ACTION OF THE

00:39 - OIL OR TODAY MARK, THE FIRST

00:42 - DAY OF THE COURT, 50 PER YEAR.

00:45 - YESTERDAY THE COURT CALIBRATED

00:47 - THE FDA ANNIVERSARY

00:50 - AS UNIQUE.

00:53 - THAT APPELLATE COURT IN THE

00:55 - UNITED STATES. NAMELY OUR

00:57 - DIRECT ACTION WHICH HERE

00:59 - ONLY IT WILL APPEAL INVOLVING

01:01 - BAY AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT.

01:05 - WE HAVE.

01:10 - BACK IN THE MORNING. SO I'M

01:12 - GOING TO KEEP A LAWYER MOVING

01:13 - THROUGH THEIR ARGUMENT.

01:16 - BECAUSE THIS IS A TIME BOMB

01:17 - FASHION WE ALLOW.

01:20 - A HALF AN HOUR FOR THE ARGUMENT

01:22 - THAT 15 MINUTE

01:23 - FOR FRIDAY. IF YOU ARE THE

01:25 - APPELLANT OR THE PETITIONER YOU

01:27 - MAY RECUR SOME OF YOUR 15

01:29 - MINUTES

01:30 - FOR REBUTTAL. PLEASE LET THE

01:32 - COURT KNOW AT THE BEGINNING OF

01:33 - THE YEAR ARGUMENT. HOW

01:35 - YOU WISH, OR IF YOU WISH REPAIR

01:39 - SOME OF YOUR TIME AND WITH THAT

01:41 - WE CALL THE FIRST CASE WHICH IS

01:43 - VERY

01:44 - THEY WERE. AGAIN THE CITY

01:47 - OF GRAHAM. THE CITY OF SCRANTON

01:50 - HAS APPEALED TO RID OF HER AND

01:52 - CREAM AND THEY WERE THOSE THE

01:55 - CITY BY THE COURT OF COMMON

01:56 - PLEAS OF LACKAWANNA COUNTY

01:59 - UPON APPLICATION OF GARY THING

02:01 - FOR IN AND OTHER TAXPAYERS.

02:04 - THE COURT HERMAN THE FROM OF

02:06 - THE CITY TAXES SUCH AS THE

02:08 - EARNED INCOME AND BIG BUSINESS

02:10 - PRIVILEGE TAX HAD EXCEEDED THE

02:12 - AGGREGATE PACK LIMITATION SET

02:15 - FORTH AND THE LOCAL TAX

02:16 - ENABLING ACT.

02:18 - THE DIFFICULTY THE COURT

02:19 - DETERMINED THAT PROTECT HERE

02:21 - 2015 TO 2018. THE COURT HAD

02:25 - THE CITY

02:25 - HAD COLLECTED 50 MILLION

02:27 - DOLLARS IN EXCESS OF THAT

02:29 - AGGREGATE LIMIT THE WRIT OF

02:32 - MANDAMUS DIRECTED THE CITY TO

02:34 - ADOPT THE TAX RATE AS NECESSARY

02:36 - TO KEEP WITH THEM BUT THAT

02:37 - RECOVERY PATH.

02:39 - THE CITY OF SCRANTON OF THE

02:41 - HOME

02:41 - RULE MUNICIPALITY. THEY ARGUE

02:44 - THAT AS OF TODAY AT A HOME IN

02:46 - RURAL MUNICIPALITY IN

02:48 - ARE PERMITTED THE ACT FREE OF A

02:50 - STATE LAW I GOT ALL APPLY IN

02:53 - EVERY PART OF PENNSYLVANIA.

02:55 - THE LOCAL TAX ENABLING ACT IS

02:57 - NOT THAT'S THE LAW.

03:00 - ON THE OTHER HAND THE HOME RULE

03:01 - OF LAW LIMITS, THE SCOPE OF THE

03:03 - CITY

03:04 - TAXPAYERS HIM THOUGH THE

03:05 - ACTIVITY LIFTED HIM THE LOCAL

03:08 - TAX ENABLING ACT.

03:10 - HOWEVER, THE GETTING OUT THE

03:12 - ATTACK. GREAT THE BATTLE HYMN

03:14 - THAT THAT YOU'RE NOT APPLY.

03:16 - THE HOME RULE MINUTE THE

03:18 - PALATE.

03:19 - THE GREAT INVENTIONS INCLUDE

03:22 - THE AGGREGATE A WOMAN. THEY DID

03:24 - IN THE LOCAL TAX ENABLING ACT.

03:27 - ADDED

03:28 - TO BE AND FOR OTHER ARGUMENT IS

03:31 - A NEW BATCH OF THAT BUT KIND

03:33 - AND LAW THIS YEAR BY

03:37 - GOVERNOR WILL AND THE COURT

03:39 - LOOKED AT THE PARTY, YOU KNOW

03:41 - THE DRAFT. HE APPLICATION OF

03:43 - THAT LAW TO THE FIELD

03:45 - AND WITH THAT WE CALL MATURE

03:47 - BEEN ASKING YOU WHO ARE HERE ON

03:48 - BEHALF IT.

03:52 - >>GOOD MORNING RUNNERS.

03:54 - A NASTY AND I'M PRIVILEGED TO

03:56 - REPRESENT THE CITY OF

03:57 - SCRANTON MAYOR AND THIS

04:00 - BUSINESS ADMINISTRATOR IN THIS

04:01 - OF PEOPLE US

04:03 - SIGNIFICANT CONSEQUENCE, NOT

04:05 - ONLY THIS GOING TO LOOK AT

04:07 - THEIR CITIES ACROSS THE

04:09 - COMMONWEALTH AND TO

04:11 - CITIES IN THE STATUS OF BEING A

04:14 - DISTRESSED CITY GOVERNED BY THE

04:15 - NEWS ABOUT HIS FINANCIAL.

04:17 - RECOVERY LAW.

04:19 - I SAID

04:19 - SPRINGS WITH A DISASTROUS

04:20 - CONSEQUENCE YOU HAVE WITH YOU

04:23 - LIKE TO RESERVE ANY TIME EARLY

04:25 - BATTLE.

04:26 - >>THANK YOU VERY MUCH LIVE AND

04:28 - I WOULD LIKE TO PRESERVE 2

04:29 - MINUTES OR ABOUT.

04:36 - >>THEY'RE MAKING A ROOKIE

04:37 - MISTAKE AFTER ALL

04:38 - THESE YEARS.

04:45 - >>THE

04:45 - >>CONSEQUENCES ARE DISASTROUS A

04:47 - MESS THAT CELL PHONE. SO ONE

04:50 - WOULD

04:50 - HAVE TO SINCE I SOMEHOW

04:52 - 50 MILLION DOLLARS IN TAX

04:54 - REVENUES, ONE IS ALREADY

04:55 - OPERATING AS A

04:56 - STRESS CITY AND AS A JUDGE TO

04:59 - LET SUMMARY INDICATED THAT PLAY

05:02 - HERE ARE THE

05:03 - THIS THIS INVOLVES AND SECTION

05:05 - OF 3. AND SO

05:06 - THE STATUTES THERE'S A

05:08 - WHOLE WHO ANOTHER HOME LAW

05:11 - AUTHORIZES S WAS IT

05:13 - AUTHORIZATION, THE HOME

05:15 - HOMEOWNERS ABOUT THESE TO

05:17 - IMPOSE TAXES ON CERTAIN

05:19 - SUBJECTS THOSE ON THE SUBJECT

05:21 - OF OPTICS OF TAXATION MENTION

05:23 - THEY'RE NOT 5.11 THE LOCAL THAT

05:26 - BUT IT IS EXPLICIT

05:28 - IN SAYING. CITIES ARE

05:30 - NOT LIMITED. THE RATES OF ACTS

05:33 - THE NAME.

05:35 - AND THERE IS NOTHING IN THE

05:36 - HOME LAW THAT SAYS THAT

05:38 - THERE ISN'T A MAXIMUM THAT

05:41 - CANNOT BE EXCEEDED. BUT THE

05:43 - HOME. I MISS ABOUT HIM. THE

05:45 - SECOND STATUE ZACH KLEIN 11

05:48 - AND YOU AGAIN A FUN SUBJECTS OF

05:50 - TAXATION. BUT IMPORTANTLY IT

05:52 - SETS 3 MINUTES AN ON

05:55 - HOME VALUES IT CAN SEE THOSE

05:57 - RATES AND IT SETS NOT OUT

06:00 - OF REVENUES THAT NEED BE

06:02 - A LOOK THERE'S NOTHING THAT

06:04 - MAKES IT ACCEPTABLE. THE HOME

06:06 - WILL MISS

06:06 - A BALANCE THE STATUE THAT'S AN

06:09 - ISSUE HERE IS AK 40 SEVENS

06:11 - CLOUD IS FINANCIAL. THE

06:12 - COMPANY LAW THAT ALSO ALLOWS

06:15 - THOSE CITIES IN DISTRESS

06:17 - STATUS IMPOSE RAISE TAX

06:20 - RATES ON SUBJECTS OF

06:21 - VACCINATION IN EXCESS OF THOSE

06:23 - AFTER ICE, THE LOCAL TAX

06:25 - ENABLING THEM.

06:27 - WE THERE ARE 3 FUNNEL THAT 400

06:30 - YEARS AND HOW ONE SCHOOL IS

06:32 - NOT.

06:33 - WHO KNEW WARD'S RANK AND STATUS

06:35 - AS A HOME RULE CITY. THAT'S A

06:38 - MATTER OF GREAT SIGNIFICANCE.

06:40 - SECOND IT SAID THAT THERE

06:42 - LOCAL TAXI. CLEARLY IN THIS NEW

06:46 - CLIENTS

06:47 - TO SPEND. WE KNOW THERE'S

06:48 - ALWAYS THIS FOOD AND THERE'S

06:50 - NOTHING THAT MAKES IT HAPPENED

06:52 - WHEN THE SCRANTON SO FAR

06:53 - AS THESE ARE ARE CONCERNED AND

06:56 - SO FAR HAS A MAXIMUM MAY BE

06:58 - CONCERNED.

07:04 - COLLECTED NOT THE AUTHORITY.

07:06 - IT'S LIKE A LEVEL BUT ON THE

07:08 - AUTHORITY OF ACKLEY'S 7 AS THE

07:11 - HEART

07:11 - OF THE WELL YOU MENTIONED THE 2

07:14 - OPERATIONS FROM MAXIMUM AMOUNT.

07:17 - TAXES THAT CAN WE THE LEFT.

07:20 - AS I SAID THIS LAW HAVE AQUATIC

07:22 - ONE OTHER GOOD MORNING.

07:25 - >>IN ONE.

07:27 - >>WE'RE IN THE

07:28 - TRIAL COURT. MAKE THE AIR AS

07:30 - FAR AS THING THAT ACT 5.11 WITH

07:34 - WHERE THE THE BASIS FOR WHY THE

07:36 - TAXES WERE IMPOSED AS OPPOSED

07:38 - TO THE HOME. WE'LL

07:40 - CHART OR WE'RE READY TO GO OFF

07:42 - COURSE AND WHERE THE EVENING

07:44 - COME UP WITH THING THAT

07:45 - ACT 5.11 CONTROL OVER THE HOME

07:48 - RULE CHARTER.

07:51 - >>I BELIEVE THAT ONE OFF COURSE

07:53 - WHEN

07:53 - A HORSE IT HAS A LOOK

07:56 - AT VARIOUS OTHER DOCUMENTS AND

07:58 - LOOKED AT THE ENABLING

07:59 - LEGISLATION EVEN ORDINANCES

08:01 - WHOSE BY THE WAY EVERY

08:03 - ORDINANCE SAYS

08:04 - THE THIS IS AN ACTIVE UNDER THE

08:07 - AUTHORITY OF THE HOME LOVED

08:08 - ONES AS AND ANY OTHER

08:10 - APPLICABLE LAW.

08:11 - THIS THAT DOESN'T MAKE AT 5.11

08:13 - HAPPENED WELL

08:14 - AS SAYING ACTING ON YOU FOR NOT

08:17 - ONLY AT HOME BUT RIGHT OF ANY

08:18 - OTHER OUT. I THINK IT

08:20 - ALSO WENT OFF COURSE IN TERMS

08:22 - OF LOOKING LOOKING AT

08:25 - >>THERE IS

08:26 - INTERNAL DOCUMENTS AND EXTERNAL

08:28 - DOCTRINES OF THE CITY'S GRAND

08:30 - WHO PASSES AS THAT 5.11 BUT WAS

08:32 - NOTHING WRONG ABOUT THOSE

08:33 - LABELS. IT PASSES. TOPICS OF

08:36 - TAXATION ARE FOUND IN ATHENS

08:38 - 5.11 THE AUTHORITY TO IMPOSE

08:41 - THE RATES IT GENERATES REVENUES

08:43 - AND FROM THE WHOLE LAW AND

08:45 - COMING FROM THE 7.

08:49 - >>WELL AGAIN THE TRIAL COURT

08:51 - THE FAMILY.

08:56 - EVERY GAME. TAX LIMITATION.

09:00 - >>FOR THE TRIAL COURT OR EVEN

09:02 - BETTER OKAY, YOU'RE NOT PROJECT

09:04 - UH THE TAX RATE THAT ARE UP FOR

09:07 - AND ACT 5.11 OR THE LOCAL TAX

09:09 - ENABLING ACT.

09:12 - A LIMITATION AND.

09:17 - PART OF THE.

09:20 - LIMITATION ARE PART OF THE TAX

09:23 - RATE AND THE AIRPORT IN A 5 IN

09:26 - A HI TO

09:28 - THE SUBJECT OF TAXATION.

09:32 - >>YOUR HONOR AND

09:32 - I BELIEVE YOU ACCURATELY

09:34 - SUMMARIZE THE REASON THE OF THE

09:36 - TRIAL COURT. THE PROBLEM WITH

09:39 - THAT REASONING YEARS THAT ONCE

09:41 - YOU SAY IN

09:42 - THE STATUTE, THE GOVERNING BODY

09:44 - CELL NOT BE SUBJECT TO

09:46 - LIMITATIONS ON THE RUN TO ACT

09:47 - IS IMPOSED AND THEN YOU IMPOSE

09:49 - A MAXIMUM HE WAS ACTIVELY

09:51 - IMPOSE A RATE IN THE CASE.

09:54 - SO THE RATES ISLAND MAKES NO

09:56 - SENSE. IT'S A WRAP.

09:58 - THE TAXES OF THE NOT THE

10:00 - SAME BY READY YOU ARE TO STREAM

10:03 - BY HIS TOP ANOTHER ONE. THE

10:04 - COURT WENT OFF COURSE HERE IS

10:06 - HE SAID FIRST WE POINTED OUT

10:09 - THAT IN THIS THIS COURT SAID

10:12 - THAT.

10:14 - 5.11 IS NOT A STATUTE THAT IS

10:16 - APPLICABLE IN EVERY PART OF

10:18 - THIS COMMONWEALTH. THAT'S THE

10:20 - LIMITATION ON THE WHOLE WAR

10:22 - CITIES HOUR IT HAS TO BE A

10:24 - STATUTE THAT'S APPLICABLE IN

10:26 - EVERY PART AND AT 5.11 SEASON.

10:28 - BECAUSE IT APPLIES ONLY TO

10:30 - SPECIFICALLY GRADY

10:31 - CLASSIFICATIONS OF

10:33 - MUNICIPALITIES HOME WAS A

10:35 - CLASSIFICATION WHOSE POLITICS

10:37 - AIR HIS HOME RULE, THIS

10:39 - APOLOGIES SUBJECT SUBJECT

10:41 - TO THE LOCAL TAX ENABLING WENT

10:44 - OFF WITH THE MEN IN BLUE

10:46 - MARRIAGE DECISION. THEY'VE GOT

10:49 - THAT ONE IN CONNECTION WITH

10:52 - PROBLEM IS IT IS IMMATERIAL

10:54 - WHETHER IT APPLIES IN EVERY

10:57 - PART OF THIS COMMONWEALTH.

10:58 - WELL THE LAST OF THE AREA

11:00 - THAT'S THE LISTING

11:01 - OF LANGUAGE AND HE SAID IT'S IN

11:02 - THE PRESENT CLEARLY IN HIS

11:05 - REPLIES TO SPEND AND THERE'S

11:07 - NOTHING TO SUPPORT THAT THAT

11:10 - THAT ASSERTION THAT IS

11:11 - IN THE CIP IN THE COURT BUT THE

11:14 - COURT ALSO REQUIRED TO.

11:17 - >>ABSOLUTELY LOOK AT AK

11:19 - 47.

11:20 - >>AND MAKING A DETERMINATION

11:22 - WHERE THE TRIAL COURT TEAM TO

11:23 - APPEAR. THE PLAYED A LOT OF

11:25 - EMPHASIS ON ACT

11:27 - 5.11 AND REALLY DISREGARDED

11:29 - AK 47 WHAT YOU CAN DO IN YOUR

11:31 - PARTICULAR CASE BECAUSE THE GUN

11:33 - TO SHOOT IT

11:34 - THAT GRANTON FALLS UNDER A

11:36 - DISTRACTED.

11:38 - >>YES, YOUR HONOR YOU

11:39 - ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO LOOK THAT UP

11:41 - 47 AND I KNOW 47 WASN'T

11:43 - EVEN MENTIONED IN THE APP

11:46 - ROAD RESPONSIBLY IN THIS MATTER

11:49 - AT 47 ALLOWS THE CITY

11:51 - OF SCRANTON WHO IMPOSED TAX

11:54 - RATES IN EXCESS OF THAT

11:55 - OTHERWISE AUTHORIZED. MY ASS,

11:58 - 5.11.

12:00 - I FIND 11 SAYS HE TURNED TO

12:02 - DETERMINE WHETHER THAT UP AS WE

12:04 - SEE IT THAT ONLY THE TAXES

12:07 - LEVIED AND COLLECTED ON THE

12:09 - AUTHORITY OF THAT HIGH LEVEL

12:11 - NOW THERE'S NO THIS YOU KNOW

12:13 - THIS TOO THAT'S GOOD THAT SAYS

12:16 - LET ME AND

12:17 - COLLECTED AS A DISTRESSED

12:18 - MUNICIPALITY OR NOT UNDER

12:20 - THE AUTHORITY AND THAT'S WHY WE

12:22 - LOVE YOU AND THE WORDING OF THE

12:24 - NEEDS OF VALUES THE KNIGHTS

12:25 - WOULD COVER A LOT AND YOUR

12:26 - HONOR WHEN THE SCHOOL OF THE

12:29 - TAXES THAT ARE AUTHORIZED.

12:31 - I LOT. AND IT DOESN'T EVEN

12:33 - COME CLOSE THAT

12:35 - ACTIVITY LIMIT IT DOESN'T

12:37 - VIOLATE DEVELOPMENT.

12:41 - >>THE COUNCIL THAT WE HAVE A

12:42 - PROBLEM IN THE SAND BAGS.

12:44 - SCRANTON NEED

12:46 - PART OF 5.11 AND TIME ONE TO

12:50 - WALK AWAY WHICH I WOULD AGREE

12:52 - UNDER HOME RULE YOUR ALLOW IN

12:55 - YOUR MARK UNTIL TAX YOUR MUSE

12:57 - YOU PACK, DON'T YOU CARRY THAT

12:59 - IN THE TUB, YOU GRIN AS

13:01 - DEFINED. UNDER 5.11 FOR WHAT

13:04 - THOSE FACTORS ARE ALLOWED NOT

13:06 - FOR THE RAID.

13:07 - BUT WHAT THE DEFINITIONAL BACK

13:09 - TO 5.11 FOR HILLARY PAC TO THE

13:13 - SCRANTON HAVE.

13:15 - >>I BELIEVE YOU'RE CORRECT IN

13:16 - TERMS OF THE PURPOSES FOR WHICH

13:23 - THE IMPORTANT POINT HERE IS

13:25 - THAT IT'S THE WHOLE LAW

13:27 - THAT SAYS MAY

13:29 - IMPOSE TAXES AND ANY TOPICS

13:31 - AUTHORIZED BY 5.11. SO CRIME

13:35 - IS LIMITED THOSE TOPICS AND I

13:38 - WOULD SUBMIT THEY USE THOSE

13:40 - REVENUES GENERATED FROM THOSE

13:41 - TOPICS FOR THE PURPOSES WHO WAS

13:43 - THERE WHO WAS THERE COULD BE A

13:45 - FIGHT. BUT ONE LOOK AT OTHER

13:47 - THINGS LIKE THE EARNED INCOME

13:48 - TAX IT'S THE RESULT OF IT IN

13:51 - THE AX ISLAND ON YOUR INCOME

13:53 - TAX THERE'S NO LIMIT AND

13:56 - SCRANTON WHEN IT COMES TO

13:57 - EARNED INCOME TAX FOR

13:59 - PURPOSES OF LET THE REVENUES

14:01 - THAT CAN BE USED FOR

14:02 - ANY PURPOSE IN JUST ONE MOVES

14:04 - TO THE LEFT OF THE VOTE.

14:07 - WE RELIVE IT IN THE LOCAL THAT

14:09 - WE CAN PASS WHO ARE WELL BELOW

14:12 - THAT MAX.

14:18 - I WANT TO SAY IN TERMS

14:20 - OF POTENTIAL HAVEN'T MENTIONED

14:22 - ACT. 76 OF 2020 WE WANTED TO

14:25 - ADDRESS THAT. SO

14:27 - WITHIN MONTHS IN THE MIDDLE OF

14:30 - THE PANDEMIC THE GENERAL

14:35 - 76 OF 2020. WHY IT CLARIFIES

14:39 - WAS THEN IT WAS HIS FIRST

14:40 - DECISION WAS A TRIAL COURT'S

14:42 - RULING IN SPACE.

14:44 - THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MADE CLEAR

14:48 - IN 76

14:49 - THAT THAT WAS GENERATED BY

14:52 - HOMOS IN. AND NOT TO

14:54 - BE OUTDONE WHO DOESN'T HAVE

14:56 - AN APP IN SECTION CREAM 20.

14:59 - IT WAS AND 5.11. IT

15:02 - ALSO SAID THAT REVENUE

15:04 - COLLECTED BY SPECIALLY.

15:06 - UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE NEWS

15:08 - FOR A CRASH WITH NEWS OF THE

15:09 - NATIONAL COMPANY LAW. I'M NOT

15:11 - HOW YOU USE THAT. SO IT'S CLEAR

15:14 - THAT AT A MINIMUM. PROSPECT OF

15:17 - LEE SPEAK. REALLY AWARDED BY

15:20 - THE TRIAL COURT. IT CANNOT

15:21 - BE SUSTAINED. AS A

15:23 - RESULT IN A SICK TO DIE AND I

15:25 - UNDERSTAND THAT THE EFFECTIVE

15:27 - DATE IS NEXT WEEK.

15:28 - >>THE CAPE IS ALREADY IN

15:30 - PROCESS. AND HAVE BEEN

15:32 - DETERMINED SO ARE WE FEEL

15:34 - BOUND. BY THE NEW LAW THAT

15:40 - >>YOU'RE NOT BOUND IN TERMS OF

15:42 - THE SIDING.

15:43 - THE RETROSPECTIVE APPLICATION

15:45 - OF THE STATEMENTS ARE EXPECTED

15:47 - ASPECT OF THIS CASE AND WHAT I

15:49 - WOULD SAY IS A MATTER THAT WE

15:51 - CAN THE NOTICE OF THIS

15:53 - LEGISLATION HAS PASSED THERE

15:55 - WILL BE GOING INTO EFFECT.

15:58 - AND I'M

15:58 - SAYING THAT IT DOESN'T REFLECT

16:00 - A CHANGE IN THE LAW OFTEN TIMES

16:02 - AND MEMBERS OF OUR VISIT TEAMS

16:04 - OF LAW. IT'S NOT ALWAYS

16:06 - THE CASE AND WE SIDE OF THE

16:08 - POOR IN A SUPPLEMENTAL.

16:10 - THAT SAID THERE ARE PATIENTS

16:12 - WHEN THE

16:12 - LEGISLATURE ACTS, IT'S CLEAR

16:14 - WHAT A FRIEND OF ALL ALONG.

16:16 - AND I SUBMIT TO YOU THAT THAT

16:18 - IS EXACTLY WHAT

16:19 - A YEAR IN THE PASSING OF AT 76.

16:24 - IN I WAS LIKE NO UPON THEM.

16:26 - THEY WANTED TO MAKE CLEAR THAT

16:28 - WHEN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY SAID

16:30 - THERE'S NO LIMITS ON THE RATES

16:31 - THAT

16:31 - CAN HOLD. HOMES OF THE FAMILIES

16:34 - OF THIS TOO. REVENUE LIMITS OF

16:37 - THE LTA OR NOT A COUPLE TOO.

16:41 - AND AS I SAID IT'S ONLY FOR

16:43 - A STATUE. IT CLEARLY EXPRESSES

16:46 - A DIRECT CONFLICT. THE

16:48 - NOT ME. THE $2 BN THERE'S A

16:51 - PRESUMPTION AND SOME OF THE

16:52 - HEAT.

16:53 - ON AND HE ASKED TO BE A

16:56 - STATUTE. THAT'S NOT GOOD

16:57 - MORNING EVERY PART OF THE

16:58 - COMMONWEALTH AND IT'S ALREADY

17:00 - BEEN DECIDED,

17:00 - BUT WE A HIGHLANDS, NOT

17:02 - APPLICABLE IN EVERY PART OF

17:04 - WELL I WOULD MENTION THAT.

17:07 - THE SUPREME COURT REMAND IT.

17:11 - >>WE WE SHOULD AND KNOWLEDGE

17:13 - THAT THE LEGISLATURE HAVE

17:15 - ACTIVE WHICH MAY BE

17:17 - AND AND FRESH WHAT IT HAD HAD

17:19 - INTENDED ALL ALONG AND WE KNOW

17:21 - REALLY NEED

17:22 - THAT BATHROOM TO RULE IN FAVOR

17:25 - OF THE CITY OF GRAHAM DO IT.

17:27 - I MEAN I

17:29 - THE HOME RULE CHARTER LAW READ

17:31 - TOGETHER WITH THE LOCAL PACKED

17:32 - IN A BOWLING THATCHER AS WELL.

17:35 - THE REST OF THE LAW IS ALL WE

17:38 - HAVE TO LOOK AT.

17:41 - >>AND THAT'S ALL YOU HAVE TO

17:42 - LOOK AT. IT IS CLEAR FROM THE

17:44 - HOME LAW.

17:45 - THE CITY.

17:47 - >>HAS ACTED PROPERLY IN SETTING

17:49 - ITS TAX RATES AND COLLECTED 7.

17:53 - >>I SEE MY TIME IS ALMOST

17:54 - EXPIRED I WILL RESERVE MY

18:05 - >>WE WILL HEAR NEXT FROM MISTER

18:06 - MCGOVERN ON

18:07 - BEHALF OF THE SAME COLOR AND

18:09 - THE TAXPAYER.

18:24 - AND WHAT WENT ON THAT WE CAN'T

18:25 - REALLY HEAR INCURRED OR YOUR

18:58 - >>A QUARTER TURN BEEN ASKED I

19:00 - AM ROAD. THE FIRST TIME IN

19:02 - FRONT OF THIS COURT I THINK FOR

19:03 - THE OPPORTUNITY. I ALSO THINK

19:06 - COURT IT IS I DID BATTER.

19:14 - IT'S OUR BELIEF THAT IT REALLY

19:16 - DOESN'T MATTER WHETHER.

19:23 - IF THE COURT LOOKS AT THE

19:26 - RECORD.

19:30 - THE COURT WILL

19:30 - SEE IT IF HE ACTUALLY IN FALL

19:34 - IS ANY WAY AND THEY TREATED

19:36 - EVERYTHING IS AT 5.11 ATTACKS.

19:41 - HOW THE CITY.

19:44 - FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.

19:47 - I GO TO THE AGE

19:49 - MATTERS REPORT IN

19:50 - A LETTER EVERYTHING A GOOD

19:52 - POINT OF FACT 5.11. IT'S LATE

19:55 - IN THIS RECORD ITEM

19:57 - NUMBER 27 TONIGHT ON NUMBER 29,

20:00 - A 27. I ACTUALLY DID.

20:04 - HOWEVER THE PUBLIC HEARING.

20:06 - SOME EVIDENCE THE WORST PART

20:08 - THE YEARS OF AUDITS.

20:13 - ADDITIONALLY PRESENT ITEM

20:15 - NUMBER 29.

20:21 - IN ONE OF THE DEFENDANTS.

20:24 - START ONE OF THE PLAINTIFFS

20:25 - AFTER THE CASE, I'LL AND ONE

20:27 - THAT RETURNS.

20:32 - CLEARLY BEING AN ACT 5.11.

20:37 - I WANT TO POSE QUESTIONS.

20:40 - CITY ACTUALLY

20:41 - IN IT THERE'S GREAT EARLY ON

20:44 - PRODUCED AN APP FOR IT. THIS

20:46 - HAS BEEN A GREATER AND AT THAT

20:48 - POINT THE PARK.

20:58 - EVEN AFTER THIS

20:59 - WOW WHAT DOWN THE ROAD IS OPEN

21:02 - TO US AN AFFIDAVIT SAID IT WAS

21:04 - 5.11.

21:07 - THE GOVERNOR AND MISTER

21:07 - MCGOVERN

21:08 - IF IF.

21:09 - >>IF I'M UNDERSTANDING WHY ARE

21:10 - SPENDING SO MUCH TIME ON THE

21:12 - COURT IT BACK.

21:15 - SUGGESTING THAT BECAUSE THEY

21:18 - LABELED THE PACT OR UNDER ACT

21:20 - 5.11 THAT WE MUCH.

21:23 - IT COULD HAVE A MATTER OF LAW

21:25 - THAT THEY ARE AND COULD ONLY BE

21:27 - IMPOSED UNDER 5.11 COMPATIBLE

21:29 - WAIVER ARGUMENT OR POWERFUL

21:30 - ARGUMENT. UNIFY YOU

21:33 - KNOW 5 PUT A BOW AROUND MY DOG

21:36 - THAT I'M A DOCTOR THAT ME MY

21:38 - DOG, THE DOCK.

21:40 - >>THIS WAS THE SAME ARGUMENT,

21:48 - IN JUNE. THE LATEST ON

21:49 - ATTACKS BY IT TAUGHT IN SCHOOLS

21:52 - BY SIMPLY PUTTING UP.

21:57 - IT DOESN'T CHANGE WHAT YOU GET.

22:01 - THE FRONT DOOR WHAT DID THEY DO

22:02 - WHAT TODAY I GET IT I REALLY

22:04 - DID WHAT THEY DID.

22:07 - >>SO FAR YOU TOLD ME THEY SAY

22:08 - THEY'VE LABELED IT IS THERE

22:10 - SOMETHING PARTICULARLY UNDER

22:12 - 5.11 THAT

22:13 - THEY DID TO ENACT THE STATUTE,

22:15 - THE FACTORS THAT MAKE THEM

22:17 - EXCLUSIVELY 5.11 ATTACK THAT

22:19 - AND NOT BACK TO BACK TO BE

22:20 - ISSUED UNDER THE HOME RULE

22:21 - CHARTER LAW OR DID THEY JUST

22:22 - SIMPLY LABEL COME THAT WAY.

22:24 - WELL THEY WERE ABLE TO THAT

22:26 - WAY ALSO ARE THEY ALL ACT.

22:29 - >>ITS REGULATIONS ITS RULES.

22:32 - NOT ONLY COLLECT THE TAX

22:34 - ELECTED.

22:38 - LACKAWANNA COUNTY TAX

22:40 - COLLECTION.

22:43 - WHICH WAS UNDER 5.11 ONLY

22:45 - THEY'RE ONLY AUTHORIZED.

22:47 - 5.11 ATTACKS THAT'S WHAT IT'S

22:48 - LIKE TO BE ON THAT. WE HAVE

22:51 - ROUGHLY 50 YEARS.

22:54 - FOR THE CITY COLLECTED THE TAX.

22:57 - FORCE THAT ACTS.

23:00 - THEY ASKED

23:00 - ANNUAL RESOLUTION BORDERS IS

23:02 - READY. ALL THAT AT 5.11 AND

23:05 - SOME OF THE TAX.

23:07 - THE ONLY THING THEY SAY IS

23:09 - GOING BACK HARD.

23:17 - THAT WE'RE DEALING WITH

23:19 - TAXATION ERIC IF YOU LOOK AT

23:21 - THAT BROOKHAVEN IT IS. THERE'S

23:24 - ANY OF YOUR ORDER

23:25 - ANY ISSUE. THE WORKS ARE FORCED

23:28 - OR AGAINST THE PASSING OF OUR

23:30 - DEAR.

23:32 - >>BUT THEN THE

23:32 - PEOPLE ARE READY TO BE MOVED IN

23:34 - IN THAT THAT WE WANT TO BE A

23:35 - HOME RULE CHARTER AND THEREFORE

23:37 - THERE IS NO LIMITATION.

23:40 - >>OUR BIG BIG DEVELOPMENT, 76

23:43 - OR 7 TO 9, 1,

23:46 - ARE SOME OF THE TAX ISSUE.

23:47 - IT'S TYPICALLY THE AK 47 TAX

23:50 - THEY EVEN EXIST BACK.

23:52 - AND AK 47 INCOME IN THE

23:54 - FIGHTING FOR IT WAS ELSE IN

23:57 - THE FIRST ON PURPOSE.

24:00 - 47 SEPARATELY SAYS.

24:04 - THEY CAN HAVE A LOCAL SERVICE

24:06 - PACK. YOU KNOW. ACTS.

24:09 - THE CHAPTER

24:10 - 3 DECEMBER 31ST, BUT KNOWN AS

24:12 - THE LOCAL TAX ENABLING ACT

24:14 - GREAT THE AK 47 SAYS YOU CAN

24:17 - HAVE AN ACT 5.11.

24:20 - DOESN'T SAY FOR CREATING A NEW

24:21 - TACK TO

24:22 - SIMPLY BAN JUST LIKE THE HOME

24:24 - RULE CHARTER DOES IT JUST

24:25 - REMOVES A HALF.

24:28 - ALONG THE WAY IT IS THERE WERE

24:30 - TO HAPPEN AT 5.11 GREAT PASS.

24:34 - AND WE HAVE NO OBJECTION AND

24:36 - THE OVERALL CROWN.

24:41 - AS WE WENT ALONG

24:42 - WITH HER.

24:43 - >>IF YOU'RE GOVERNED AM.

24:46 - IN YOUR DISCOVERY OR I DON'T

24:49 - KNOW WHAT I IN YOUR EVERYDAY

24:50 - INJURY. HEY YOU.

24:55 - UNCOVER ANY EVIDENCE FOR

24:56 - PREVENTING ANY OTHER OF

24:58 - THE CITY. AT ONE TIME BELIEVED

25:00 - THAT THE AGGREGATE LIMITATIONS

25:02 - THAT APPLY TO THOSE TAXES THAT

25:05 - IMPAIR HER EYE AND 5.11 TAXES.

25:12 - >>WELL WE WERE ABLE TO AIM FOR.

25:23 - IT WAS RIGHT AROUND THAT TIME

25:25 - WHEN.

25:34 - >>I GOT MY QUESTION ABOUT

25:36 - WHETHER OR NOT THE CITY KNEW

25:37 - IT. IT WAS SAYING WITHIN THE

25:39 - 50 WITHIN THE AGGREGATE TAX

25:41 - LIMITATION BEGUN IN TERMS OF

25:44 - WELL, MEL. WHATEVER.

26:03 - I'M BACK THOUGH JADY EXCEEDED

26:05 - THE AGGREGATE LIMIT WAS IN

26:06 - 2015.

26:08 - >>NO NO YOUR HONOR THAT'S THE

26:09 - FIRST YEAR THAT WE.

26:10 - >>IT BROUGHT

26:11 - YOU CALLAN OKAY NOW IT'S THE

26:12 - RIGHT FOOT AND IN OUR RESEARCH

26:14 - IT LOOKS LIKE SOME TIME AROUND

26:15 - THE HOUSE.

26:26 - HOPE THE CITY GET TO THIS POINT

26:28 - OVER THAT. THAT WAS INITIALLY

26:31 - WAS NEVER ISSUE.

26:42 - THE TAXPAYERS CHALLENGE

26:43 - THE RATE THAT'S ALL WITH THE

26:46 - CATHOLIC.

26:53 - IN THIS BUSINESS. QUICK.

27:06 - INTO THIS GUY. 26.

27:11 - REALLY ONLY TALKING.

27:20 - >>IF THE GOVERNOR CAN YOU

27:22 - DIRECT YOUR POSITION A LITTLE

27:24 - BIT CLEARER ON WHAT TO DO.

27:26 - ON HOW THE TEAM REFLECTS ON AK

27:29 - 47. CLEARLY

27:31 - THAT WAS I UNDERSTAND IT WITH

27:33 - AFTER THEY ADOPTED HOME

27:34 - TO BUY. IT WOULD SEPARATE

27:37 - PEOPLE LEGISLATION IT WAS A

27:39 - SEPARATE LEE ALLOWED LEVY

27:41 - ON A CERTAIN TYPE OF ACTION

27:45 - AND I'M JUST

27:47 - WONDERING WHETHER YOU WHAT YOUR

27:48 - POSITION ON THAT AS IT RELATES

27:51 - TO THE CAP ISSUE HERE YOU'RE

27:53 - CHALLENGING.

27:56 - >>AND I BELIEVE AK 47,000 IT.

27:58 - THEY HAVE A PURPOSE IS.

28:04 - IT WAS A MISTAKE, A GIRL.

28:10 - WHEN THEY PASSED AK 47.

28:14 - CHARTER SAYS IF THE RATE.

28:19 - SO THIS YEAR.

28:26 - AFTER OVERCOMING 5.

28:29 - >>I UNDERSTAND MISTER

28:29 - GOVERNMENT

28:30 - BUT BUT YOU'RE MAKING THE FOUND

28:33 - LIKE THAT THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

28:34 - GAVE A GIFT THAT REALLY WANT

28:35 - THEM TO GET TO THE GRANT.

28:37 - IF YOU CAN APPLY THAT REVENUE.

28:40 - ONLY YOU CAN ONLY APPLY THAT

28:42 - REVENUE UP TO THE CAP.

28:44 - THEN I'M NOT QUITE SURE WHAT

28:45 - THE PURPOSE OF THE AK 47

28:48 - ALLOWED TO LIVE YOUR

28:49 - FLEXIBILITY ON THAT PACT WOULD

28:51 - BE IT WILL BE A FUNCTION THAT

28:53 - YOU'RE MAKING YOU. IT STILL HAS

28:55 - TO SQUEEZE UNDER THE CAP IN

28:56 - UNDER THE CASH.

28:59 - >>ISABEL POINT.

29:02 - I THINK THAT THE STATE IF IN

29:04 - FACT THEY MADE A MISTAKE WAS

29:06 - THAT THEY TAKE OVER THE NEXT

29:08 - 5.11.

29:13 - OF MONEY. THEY SPECIFICALLY

29:15 - CALL IT A TAX.

29:17 - A 100 LOCAL EMPLOYEES OF THE

29:19 - PUSH BACK ON HER.

29:23 - >>BUT ARE WE GETTING INTO THE

29:24 - LABELING GAME AGAIN.

29:26 - I MEAN THAT'S THE PROBLEM I

29:27 - NEED IS AN ACT BY 11 IN FIRED

29:30 - BACK IF YOU WILL BE COULD

29:33 - IT DEFINED THE CERTAIN SEGMENT

29:35 - IN WHICH BE AMOUNT CAN BE

29:38 - GREATER THAN IT WAS.

29:41 - >>AND THIS IS THIS THIS IS

29:43 - A MASS IF THROUGH DIFFERENT

29:45 - STATUTES AT ALL.

29:48 - WE HAVE THE CITY.

29:55 - EVERYTHING IN

29:57 - 5.11 POCKET. CAUSE OF ACTION.

30:01 - >>SO YOU'RE ALMOST BEING

30:02 - LIKE HERE. THE GREEN THAT

30:04 - POSSIBLY THE THING MADE A

30:05 - MISTAKE.

30:07 - THEREFORE CERTAINLY BE

30:08 - REVERSING THE TRIAL COURT.

30:16 - >>IT SHOWS ON THE

30:17 - OTHER FOOT. OUR PRAYER.

30:23 - IT WOULD BE A COMPLETELY

30:24 - DIFFERENT POSITION THE CITY

30:25 - WOULD GO AFTER THOSE.

30:33 - WHAT IS

30:33 - GOING TO COME FROM A GOVERNOR

30:35 - WHAT 4 PER PEOPLE WOULD PREFER

30:36 - FOR 1000 I MEAN I'M AWARE OF

30:38 - I'M AWARE OF

30:39 - THE GENERAL.

30:40 - >>THAT STREAK CONSTRUCTION

30:41 - PRINCIPLED REGARDING A

30:42 - TACTICIAN WAS AN EXEMPTION TO

30:44 - THE BIRTH OF EXCEPT MISTER

30:45 - TACTICIAN THINGS LIKE THAT.

30:49 - ARE YOU TRY TO EXTRAPOLATE THAT

30:50 - TO COME GENERAL PRINCIPLE THAT

30:52 - TO EVER MAKE THE MISTAKE LOSES.

30:58 - >>THEN THE AMBIGUITY AND

31:00 - EXHIBITIONS THAT'S.

31:03 - WELL WITHOUT TRUTH THOUGH

31:04 - YOU'RE YOU'RE ARGUING THE

31:06 - STATUTORY SCHEME OF AMBIGUOUS.

31:10 - FIRST I'M SAYING IT'S NOT

31:11 - AMBIGUOUS BUT IF THE COURT

31:13 - FINDS IT AND IS THAT IT HAS IT

31:15 - ALL.

31:17 - I DON'T BELIEVE IT WAS.

31:22 - IN ALL

31:23 - THE LANGUAGE. NOW BEEN SACKED 5

31:25 - LIVE. IF WE ONLY DEALT

31:27 - WITH RACE EVER DEALT WITH.

31:33 - >>IT WILL BE YOUR BUT THE

31:34 - FACT THAT SECTION THAT SECTION

31:36 - THAT YOU'RE SEEING RELIEF ON I

31:38 - BELIEVE REQUIRES IF IT APPLIED.

31:41 - CHOIR,

31:42 - THE CITY OF GRAND TO REDUCE THE

31:44 - RATE OF RAPE OR RAPE. OF

31:46 - THAT ACTOR TO LIMIT TO NEARLY 8

31:49 - MAY BE RIGHT.

31:52 - OKAY SO TO THE RELIEF THAT IS

31:54 - BEING CAUGHT IN THE RATE

31:55 - REDUCTION.

31:58 - >>AS THE RESULT OF IT, YOUR

31:59 - WORKERS.

32:00 - >>OKAY SO YOU'RE TRYING TO

32:02 - IMPOSE THE ACTUALLY THAT

32:03 - IMPOSES A RATE REDUCTION NOT

32:05 - THAT NOT WITHSTANDING THE FACT

32:07 - THAT

32:08 - THE HOME RULE CHARTER THAT THE

32:09 - GOVERNING BODY SOME NOT BE

32:10 - SUBJECT TO ANY LIMITATION ON

32:12 - THE RATE OF TAXATION IMPOSED

32:13 - ON RESIDENTS. HOW IS A STATUTE

32:16 - THAT REQUIRES A RATE REDUCTION

32:18 - NOT A LIMITATION ON THE RE

32:19 - PROTECT PATIENT POST ON REDDIT.

32:22 - >>IT'S THE IT'S

32:23 - A RESULT. THE WAY OUT THE WAY

32:25 - WE INTERPRET IT. THE RESULT OF

32:28 - VIOLATING THE OTHER.

32:30 - >>THE WAY I OR WHAT YOU'RE

32:33 - SAYING. WELL.

32:35 - SO NO DOOR TO FALL WITHIN THE

32:37 - AGGREGATE LIMIT.

32:43 - BACK PAY FROM THAT

32:44 - ARE PERMITTED UNDER THE HOME

32:46 - RULE CHARTER OR PERMITTED UNDER

32:47 - THE LOCAL TAX ENABLING ACT

32:49 - MIGHT BE DROPPED

32:50 - THE HERO AND OUR HECTOR THAT AT

32:53 - A HIGHER AMOUNT. BUT REGARDLESS

32:55 - OF HOW THEY.

32:59 - PLAY WITH THE NUMBERS THAT THEY

33:01 - CAN TO KEEP THE AGGREGATE

33:02 - LIMIT.

33:03 - >>THAT WAS THE WAY WE ALWAYS

33:04 - LOOK AT ALL OR THE HOME RULE

33:06 - CHARTER. HOW THE BUILDING.

33:12 - CERTAIN SUBJECTS AS THEY

33:13 - CHOOSE. I ASSUME IT WAS BASED

33:16 - ON. THE LOCAL

33:17 - ECONOMY OR WHAT WAS GOING ON

33:19 - WEATHER.

33:24 - BUT ESSENTIALLY THE LEGISLATURE

33:26 - SAID.

33:28 - WANT TO GET TO THIS

33:30 - THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT THE WORD ON.

33:33 - AGAIN BACK IN THE 70 SOMETHING.

33:39 - THIS IS SOMETHING THIS FALL THE

33:41 - 2000 AND IT'S ONLY A YEAR OLD.

33:44 - HOW THE.

33:46 - >>AND I CLEAR THAT UP WITH AK

33:48 - 47.

33:52 - >>THIS IS

33:54 - ONE OF THE COLLEGE IF THAT'S

33:55 - WHAT IT WAS IT WAS IT AND IF.

33:59 - WE DON'T DISAGREE WITH THAT.

34:02 - IS SO GREAT THAT IT WAS

34:05 - 5.11.

34:08 - A VIEW OF THE OVERALL.

34:12 - WHETHER YOU CALL IT

34:13 - THE ALREADY OR NOT.

34:22 - >>KNOW THAT 45 AM.

34:25 - ALLOW THE CITY TO ENACT

34:27 - OTHER FACTOR. NOT THOSE

34:30 - GOVERNED BY AT 5.11.

34:34 - IF THEY WERE GOING

34:35 - TO INCREASE 5.11 PIPE ACTUALLY

34:38 - THEY WERE FOUND BY AGGREGATE

34:39 - LIMIT.

34:43 - IF YOU WANT TO QUICKLY AND YOU

34:45 - ARE OVER YOUR TIME AFTER A AT

34:47 - 20.

34:47 - >>THE NEW YORK STOCK HERE.

34:49 - YES, YOUR HONOR IF YOU HAVE AN

34:51 - EFFECT ALL RIGHT.

34:55 - >>THE SIMPLY LOOK AT THE

34:56 - TIMELINE OF. THE GATES OF ALL

34:59 - THESE VARIOUS FACTIONS. THEY

35:00 - WERE ASKED. I WILL EVER WAS.

35:06 - AND

35:08 - THE CITY WANTS TO CLAIM WAS

35:09 - SIMPLY A CLARIFICATION IT WAS

35:11 - AN AMENDMENT THAT WAS THE END

35:12 - OF THE ROAD. THEY GOT CHALLENGE

35:15 - DINNERS COURT CASE. THE COLD OR

35:18 - ANYTHING ELSE. SENSE ACTUALLY.

35:22 - NO MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATURE.

35:28 - AND SOME OF THESE FACTS IS WHAT

35:30 - WE'RE TALKING ABOUT CREATED IN

35:32 - 2 YEARS AFTER I LIVE ALONE.

35:35 - >>MISTER GOVERNMENT TRIED A

35:36 - DIFFERENT WAY. IT.

35:38 - WHAT IS YOUR VISION TOWARD YOUR

35:41 - CORE OF YOUR ARGUMENT.

35:44 - MOST EFFECTIVELY IN LIGHT OF

35:46 - THE NEW LAW.

35:48 - >>HER CASE THIS IS AN EARLY

35:49 - LOOKING BACKWARD. AS OF

35:51 - NEXT WEEK. THE 26 TO WHATEVER.

36:01 - THE LEAST IN THE FIRST PLACE.

36:04 - YOU HAVE FOR YOUR WORK.

36:07 - ITALY BILLY OFFICE.

36:13 - >>IF YOU'D LIKE TO CONCLUDING.

36:17 - THEY'RE WELCOME TO DO THEM.

36:20 - >>POINT THE PROPERTY EVEN SAFE.

36:23 - AND AMBIGUITY.

36:24 - THOSE TAXPAYERS EVER. BUT

36:27 - AGAIN I AND JUST LIKE THAT.

36:35 - >>ALL RIGHT MISTER BEEN ASKING.

36:40 - >>QUICKLY MOVING REBUTTAL.

36:44 - PRINCIPLED

36:44 - LIBERAL CONSTRUCTION. IT ALSO

36:47 - THIS ALSO PRESCHOOL WILL

36:48 - CONSTRUCTION. IT'S SABER COMO

36:50 - CITIES JUST HORRIFIC. WELL IN

36:54 - THE GOVERNOR SAYS IN

36:55 - THE ROOM THAT'S A FUNDAMENTAL

36:57 - AT A FEW OF THE HOME A HOME

36:59 - CITY AND ITS POWERS ARE TO

37:02 - USED TO.

37:02 - >>AND THAT'S THE CITY OF HOUMA

37:04 - TRIBE IS NOT UP AND YOU KNOW

37:08 - IT'S ANOTHER SLATER'S.

37:12 - TOR NETWORK CONSTRUCTION AND

37:14 - THERE'S ANY AMBIGUITY HERE HE

37:16 - SHOULDN'T IT SHOULD BE THE

37:17 - STUDENTS DIRECTLY A CITY OF

37:20 - SCRANTON AND THE

37:21 - SECOND POINT. THE GOVERNMENT

37:23 - ABOUT HOW TAXES ARE COLLECTED

37:25 - THAT'S SIMPLY NOT RELEVANT.

37:27 - NOR IS IT

37:27 - THIS POSITIVE THAT SCRANTON HAS

37:30 - MADE.

37:32 - ELECTIONS AS AT 5.11 TAXES.

37:34 - IT'S NOT AS I SAID BEFORE IT'S

37:36 - AN ACCURATE DESCRIPTION

37:39 - TOPICS OF TAXATION OR

37:41 - AUTHORIZED BY ACT 5.11 THE RACE

37:44 - OR NOT. SO THESE ARE NOT

37:47 - AND THE LOCAL TAX

37:48 - ENABLING NOT ONLY APPLIES TO

37:50 - REVENUE IS COLLECTED ON WHO ARE

37:53 - THE BEST STEPS.

37:54 - SO WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT REVENUES

37:55 - COLLECTED ON THE 40 AND THAT'S

37:58 - WHEN 7.

38:00 - OF THE CALCULUS THAT SHOULD NOT

38:02 - BE INCLUDED. THE CALCULATION.

38:06 - FINALLY THE

38:07 - SPONSORSHIP MEMO THAT WAS

38:09 - PRESENTED AS PART OF OUR

38:10 - SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF. IT'S CLEAR

38:12 - THAT THE LEGISLATORS IN COLD

38:13 - BLOOD, THE STUDENTS SIMPLY A

38:15 - CLARIFICATION MAKES NO SENSE

38:17 - YOUR EYES. YOU SAY YOU'RE NOT

38:19 - LIMITED AS THE WINDS ARE REALLY

38:22 - FAST FOOD OUT AND YOU'RE ALSO

38:24 - IN CONCERT BECAUSE OF

38:26 - THE LEFT EXPRESS THERE'S NO ONE

38:29 - WAS A TIME. BUT I DO WANT TO

38:30 - EXPRESS

38:30 - MY GRATITUDE AND SAY IT'S AN

38:33 - HONOR FOR ME TO BE BACK IN

38:34 - FRONT OF THIS COURT. MY CAREER

38:36 - STARTED IN THE COMMONWEALTH

38:37 - COURT AS THE SUMMER COMES TO

38:38 - MIND WHEN I WAS IN IT'S IT

38:40 - WAS COOL. THE JUDGE ENTERED AND

38:42 - LEFT IT WAS A GAME CHANGER IN

38:44 - MY CAREER AND I JUST AND YOU

38:45 - MENTIONED JUST 11 OF THE 15

38:47 - ANNIVERSARY, THE FIRST

38:48 - ANNIVERSARY AND THERE'S A LONG

38:50 - TIME AGO I WAS HERE, IT WAS A

38:52 - SUMMER INTERN. BUT I'M A

38:59 - >>WELL ARGUED GENTLEMAN AND I

39:01 - THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.

39:03 - >>THE EYES OF THE

39:04 - NATION ARE ON PENNSYLVANIA AS A

39:06 - KEY INFLUENCER TO THAT 2020

39:08 - ELECTION. PCN HAS OVER 25 YEARS

39:12 - OF TRUSTED STATE GOVERNMENT

39:13 - COVERAGE. OUR NETWORK IS YOUR

39:15 - PLATFORM TO CONNECT DIRECTLY

39:17 - WITH PENNSYLVANIA VOTERS.

39:19 - WHETHER IT'S A PRESIDENTIAL

39:20 - RACE STATEWIDE CAMPAIGN MORE

39:22 - LOCAL CAUSE OUR VIEWERS ARE

39:24 - READY TO HEAR FROM YOU LOOK

39:26 - YOU'RE AT NOW

39:27 - PCN YOUR ACCESS TO

39:29 - PENNSYLVANIA, VOTERS.

39:36 - THE

39:36 - COMMONWEALTH COURT.

39:37 - >>BY THE AFTERNOON. THIS IS

39:39 - CASE NUMBER 20 FACT, I'VE HEARD

39:41 - HOLD AND ALL FOR NOTHING

39:44 - PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF

39:45 - ENVIRONMENTAL.

39:49 - WE HAVE 2 CASES THEY CONCERNED

39:51 - A PLAN BY ADELPHIA GATEWAY

39:54 - DIFFERENT TRUCK AND OPERATE A

39:56 - COMPRESSOR STATION. NOW THAT

39:58 - THE QUAKERTOWN COMPRESSOR

39:59 - STATION IN CONNECTION WITH A

40:01 - DINNER DATE NATURAL GAS

40:03 - PIPELINE. THE DEPARTMENT OF

40:05 - ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ISSUE.

40:09 - OR PLAN APPROVAL TO ADELPHIA

40:11 - FOR THE COMPRESSOR STATION.

40:13 - WEST ROCKHILL TOWNSHIP AND A

40:15 - NUMBER OF RESIDENTS, INCLUDING

40:17 - CORPORATE HOLE APPEALED THE

40:19 - DEPARTMENT ACTION TO THE

40:21 - ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD.

40:25 - LACKED OR FICTION THE APPEAL OF

40:28 - THE TOWN TRIP AND

40:29 - THE RESIDENT. IT HELD THE VR

40:32 - ACTED FOR FAILING TO A FEDERAL

40:34 - DELEGATION THE 3RD CIRCUIT

40:37 - COURT OF APPEALS

40:38 - THE EURO FICTION TO REVIEW THE

40:41 - MERITS OF THE YOUNG.

40:44 - IN THEIR APPEAL TO THEIR THE

40:46 - COURT.

40:50 - THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL

40:52 - I'M SHOWING MY AGE.

40:55 - THE DEPARTMENT AM RESIDENT AND

40:58 - PAM THAT BOARD AIR BEING P

41:00 - APPROVAL. WHY ISSUED UNDER

41:03 - AUTHORITY OF AND THE VAN

41:06 - AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ACT AND

41:08 - WELL IT'S ABOUT FEDERAL CLEAN

41:09 - AIR ACT AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL

41:11 - HEARING BOARD HAVE JURISDICTION

41:13 - OVER PERMIT ISSUED UNDER

41:15 - STATE LAW. THEY CONTEND THAT

41:17 - THE MACRO CALF ACTIVE NOT

41:19 - PREEMPT A LOT OF PUTTING FOOD

41:21 - IN A CREATIVE AGENCY REVIEW FOR

41:24 - THE APPROVAL BECOME BALLOT.

41:26 - THEY CONTEND THAT THE

41:27 - ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD TO

41:29 - HEAR THEIR APPEAL. BUT YOU CAN

41:30 - TURN THEY IF AFTER SOME

41:32 - REGULATION. WE HAVE A LOT OF.

41:37 - FOR THE

41:38 - TO APPEAL. 40 MINUTES, 20

41:41 - MINUTES

41:41 - FOR 5. THE PARTY FOR INFECTED

41:44 - TO ADVISE THE COURT HOW THEY

41:46 - WISH TO ALLOCATE THEIR TIME.

41:48 - SO I'M NOT.

41:50 - THAT TERM AFTER BLADE HE HAVE

41:53 - YOU ALLERGY SHARING YOUR TIME

41:55 - WITH YOUR CAREER HERE AND YOU

41:57 - KNOW.

42:01 - >>IF YOU HEAR ME NOW YOUR

42:02 - HONOR. YEAH, YES SHOW MICHAEL

42:05 - AND I ARE YOU

42:06 - PLAY THIS YEAR THEY 20 MINUTES

42:08 - 10 MINUTES EACH WE WOULD

42:09 - LIKE MR. THERE AND YOU KNOW TO

42:11 - GO FIRST AND I BELIEVE

42:13 - WE EACH ARE RESERVING ONE

42:14 - MINUTE BUT I'LL LEAVE THAT UP

42:16 - TO MICHAEL TO SAY WHAT HE

42:17 - WISHES TO RESERVE. WE ASSUME

42:19 - THAT'S ALLOWED. SO WE TRY TO

42:21 - CONCLUDE OUR THE RUCK MARCH IN

42:23 - 9 MINUTES WITH THEM IN A

42:32 - >>AND MISTER BACA HOW ARE YOU

42:34 - DIVIDING YOUR TIME.

42:40 - >>HE HAS PRESIDENT

42:41 - JUDGE WHO WILL BE PLAYING THEIR

42:42 - CLIMB 10 MINUTES EACH WITH

42:44 - GOING FIRST.

42:54 - >>MR.

42:56 - HERE AND YOU KNOW YOU HAVE THE

42:58 - OR. THANK YOU

43:00 - YOUR HONOR IN 9 MINUTES.

43:03 - THE MORNING, GOOD MORNING, I'M

43:04 - A CLEAN RECORD I REPRESENT THAT

43:07 - ALL CALL.

43:10 - OTHER WIRE

43:10 - BOOK VALUE. RESIDENTS IN

43:12 - PROXIMITY TO

43:14 - THE PROPOSED ABOUT 15 UP UNTIL

43:17 - IT GAVE WAY.

43:19 - WE BELIEVE THAT THE BOARD

43:20 - REPORT INCORRECT CONCLUSION

43:22 - THAT LOCKER

43:22 - KICKED IN THEY HEAR THE APPEAL

43:24 - UNDER THE JUDICIAL REVIEW FOR

43:26 - THE BIN ALL THAT WOULD PUT 7,

43:29 - 1, 7, R B ONE OF THE NATURAL

43:32 - GAS BACK AND 3RD PERFECT A

43:34 - FALL. THE MOST VISIBLE ASPECT

43:36 - OF HERE A LOT.

43:38 - WHAT THEY'RE MISSING HER

43:39 - PETITION UP FROM THE HULL AT

43:41 - THEM IN AN APPLE CAST BACK.

43:44 - AND 1, 7, RV ONE FAITH THE

43:47 - COURT WILL PUT THAT ORIGINAL

43:49 - AND EXCLUSIVE YOU'RE A VICTIM.

43:51 - OVER CIVIL ACTION FOR THE

43:53 - REVIEW OF IN THE ACTION.

43:56 - IT CAN PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW

43:58 - AND REQUIRED BY FEDERAL LAW AND

44:00 - WE BIGGER 0.2. THAT THE AND YOU

44:04 - SEE A DEAL. THE WHOLE ACT.

44:09 - EXAMINE THE QUESTION OF BIRTH

44:10 - DEFECT IN OVER A FIELD. A BP

44:13 - OFFICIAL CONCERNING INTERSTATE

44:14 - PIPELINE. IN 3 CONSECUTIVE YEAR

44:16 - OF 2015 TO 2018. IF THE BOARD

44:19 - THOUGH ARE RIVERKEEPER ONE 2,

44:21 - 3 FOR HIM. IF THEY PAY THE

44:25 - MONEY FOR RENT ON CLEAN WATER

44:27 - ACT THE 4, ONE WATER QUALITY

44:30 - HAHA A WRECK REQUIREMENTS OF

44:33 - THE CLEAN WATER ACT. THE RIGHT

44:34 - TO SAY IT AGAIN.

44:37 - NOW IN THE COURT NOW THAT THE

44:38 - WEATHER HAD THEIR EFFECT IN THE

44:40 - NEWS FOR YOU IT NEVER ACTUALLY

44:42 - FAMILY AND WHETHER AN APPEAL.

44:44 - WHAT THEY PEOPLE ACT OR NOT IT

44:47 - CONCLUDED THAT WHERE THEY

44:48 - FILED.

44:50 - IT CAN OR 2 BEFORE THE 3RD

44:52 - CIRCUIT.

44:53 - AFTER A 15 UNDER THAT PROVISION

44:55 - OF MASS DEATH THAT.

44:57 - THERE'S NO AGREEMENT THAT WOULD

44:58 - COST THE BLACK. WE'RE A FEEL

45:02 - FOR FILE 5.

45:05 - THE INVITE ON YOUR BOARD AND

45:07 - THE 3RD CIRCUIT.

45:11 - IT IS AND WHAT THE FINAL

45:13 - DECISION OR NOT THAT IT

45:15 - WAS FINAL THAT WAS BEFORE THAT

45:18 - THE BALLOT. THE 3RD THE 3RD

45:20 - VICTIM. 107 1000.

45:23 - AGAIN DID

45:24 - NOT ANALYZE. THE QUESTION OF

45:26 - WHETHER ANY THE HE'LL SELL.

45:29 - THE BLAST THEM. IT APPEARS

45:31 - THAT THIS WAS SIMPLY A BOOM

45:32 - DAUGHTER.

45:35 - I GAVE THE

45:37 - CRITERIA THEM, I'M JUST GOING

45:39 - TO PREVENT THEM. ALL THE EYE

45:41 - EXAMINATION OF THE 3RD A FAN

45:44 - FOREVER 5TH 2018 IN THE HOUSE

45:47 - BEFORE AND FOUND DEFICIENT.

45:49 - BRIEFLY ARE THAT WAS THE CASE

45:51 - FOR THE COUNT OF APPEALS FOR

45:52 - THE 3RD CIRCUIT DIRECTLY.

45:54 - THE NEW CURFEW DEPARTMENT

45:55 - TOMORROW BACK THEN

45:57 - IF YOU WILL BE RIGHT BACK IN A

45:59 - MINUTE CREATED HEARING. CALLING

46:01 - IT ONE, A WATER QUALITY PERMIT.

46:04 - THE AVENUE FOR KEEPING

46:05 - AN EYE. AND BACK HERE IN BAY

46:08 - FROM THE BELIEF THAT BUT I FEEL

46:10 - IT COULD ONLY BE HEARD IN THE

46:11 - 3RD CIRCUIT UNDER 7 ONE

46:13 - FAN ARE THE 3RD CIRCUIT IN

46:15 - BORDENTOWN AGREE IN FACT

46:18 - THE VICTIM BY THE PPP FUNDING

46:20 - BUT AFTER THE HEARING. ALSO

46:24 - FOUND THAT OUT APPEAL FOR

46:26 - A HEARING IN NEW JERSEY A FEW

46:28 - FEET WITH IMPROPERLY DENIED

46:30 - BECAUSE THE COURT NOT ONLY 7

46:32 - WHAT OUR BOARD. HOW THE THING

46:34 - WORKS OF ALL.

46:37 - >>HERE THE ENVIRONMENTAL

46:38 - HEARING BOARD CAN BE

46:41 - THE EFFORT FROM THE DEPARTMENT

46:42 - OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.

46:46 - AND WHAT MARTIN TOWN IN TURN

46:48 - WAS AN AND TROUGH IT CAN BE

46:51 - REVIEW. HERE WE'RE DEALING

46:53 - WITH.

46:55 - ONE AGENT YOU REVIEW OF ANOTHER

46:57 - AGENT.

47:00 - YES THERE ARE FACT THAT CROSS.

47:03 - >>BOY DO WE HAVE A LIFE IT IS

47:05 - BAD. WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH

47:06 - THE BOY IS THE QUESTION OF ALL

47:09 - THE FAITH IN HIM IN A

47:10 - TRADE IN. IN PENNSYLVANIA, YOU

47:12 - KNOW WE HAVE A LOT OF OUR FAITH

47:15 - ARRANGEMENT OF IN

47:17 - PREDICTING BETWEEN THE MARGINAL

47:19 - HEARING BOARD THE.

47:21 - ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY BOARD AND

47:23 - THE DEPARTMENT OF FINAL 4

47:24 - AFFECTED. THEY'RE ALIVE.

47:27 - IT MEANT A G-RATED.

47:31 - THE FELLA THING IN.

47:36 - BACK AT ALL REALLY BE REPEATED

47:37 - BY FEDERAL COURT. WE BELIEVE

47:41 - THAT.

47:42 - NOW THAT THE WEATHER GIRL FOR

47:44 - HIM FOR FRAUD. REALLY THE

47:47 - CRITICAL TO DO. THE QUESTION

47:53 - IF YOU IF YOU ARE NOT A

47:55 - CIVIL ACTION. IF AN APPEAL DO

47:58 - YOU THINK BP.

48:02 - ABOUT 4 THE FIELD BEFORE COURT

48:04 - TODAY. THE QUESTION IS IN A

48:07 - LOCKED IN AND I LOVE

48:09 - THE 5 WATER PER YEAR YOUR

48:12 - POSITION IS IT NOT.

48:13 - >>THE FEDERAL ACTION

48:16 - >>THE EHT RULED ON THE APPEAL.

48:24 - WE WE BASE

48:24 - THAT ON IF YOU LOOK TO THE

48:26 - BOARD FOUND NOW WHAT FROM CIVIL

48:28 - ACTING LIKE I'M GOING TO RIDE

48:30 - ON. AND NOW WHAT YOUR POSITION

48:32 - IS THAT YOUR POSITION THAT IT'S

48:34 - NOT BUT YOU AGREE FROM

48:36 - THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

48:38 - COMING WE AGREED WITH YOU THE

48:40 - APPEAL WOULD THEN GO TO THE 3RD

48:42 - CIRCUIT.

48:46 - THE COURT TO REMAND THE CASE

48:49 - BACK ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING

48:50 - BOARD AND CORRECT THEM TO HEAR

48:52 - THE MARRIAGE OF

48:54 - OUR FEEL. WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT

48:56 - THEY HAVE PHONE WHAT. INTO THAT

48:59 - WAS THAT THEY DID TO HAVE A 3RD

49:02 - VICTIM. HERE'S THE DEAL

49:04 - BECAUSE AND ENVIRONMENTAL

49:06 - HEARING BOARD. IT'S NOT BEEN A

49:07 - LOT OF FUN AT THE PORT BUT ON.

49:09 - 3RD CIRCUIT COURT

49:10 - AND ALIVE THE PEOPLE ACT IN

49:12 - EFFECT MEANING AND ONLY A

49:14 - MEETING THAT TAKES PLACE IN A

49:15 - COURT. A LOT

49:17 - DIRECTLY ONE BEFORE HIM IN A

49:20 - FOR AND AND IF YOU LOOK OR

49:22 - SOUND IN

49:23 - THEY HAVE GOOD AUTHORITY

49:25 - FOR THAT. I'VE OFTEN THERE ARE

49:27 - NO APPARENT THERE I THINK THAT

49:29 - I THINK THE PRESIDENT JUDGMENT

49:30 - SIMPLY ASKING YOU

49:32 - IF YOU HAVE YOUR WAY AND IT

49:34 - GOES BACK TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL

49:35 - HEARING BOARD A CHALLENGE TO

49:37 - THE AGE TO BE THE TERMINATION

49:39 - WOULD GO TO THE 3RD CIRCUIT

49:40 - UNDER YOUR THEORY IS CORRECT OR

49:44 - >>THE CORRECT THAT POINT

49:46 - WE WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO BRING

49:48 - AN APPEAL. THE COMMONWEALTH

49:50 - COURT. I WOULD IN FACT HE.

49:55 - HE WAS KNOWN FOR

49:56 - THE CAUSE OF AN APPLE

49:58 - FAST FACTS AND AND AND WHILE I

50:01 - HAVE YOU

50:04 - IN THESE

50:05 - TYPES OF PROCEEDING IN THE 3RD

50:07 - CIRCUIT WHERE THEY'RE REVIEWING

50:09 - THESE MATTERS DO THEY CREATE A

50:11 - RECORD.

50:14 - IN THE 3RD CIRCUIT.

50:18 - IF THEY ARE RELYING ON THE

50:20 - RECORD THAT WAS FOR YOU BELOW

50:23 - ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE

50:24 - IT FELL TO A PENNSYLVANIA THAT

50:26 - OFF IT WAS

50:28 - IT PROVIDES IF THEY CAN GET OFF

50:30 - A BIT OF FUN. BUT MOST OF THE

50:33 - PROPHET OF ALLAH BY THE

50:35 - GENERATION OF A RECORD. I

50:37 - DON'T DON'T DON'T ABOUT THE DUE

50:39 - PROCESS RAISED EVERY TIME

50:40 - SOMEBODY ACTION TO PROP UP THE

50:41 - DOOR TO GIVE ME ADEQUATE, BUT

50:43 - THE BOTTOM LINE IS THAT THE

50:44 - RECORD THE WAY THE WAY A RECORD

50:46 - OF CREATED IN PENNSYLVANIA ON A

50:48 - PERMIT

50:48 - APPLICATION CHALLENGE.

50:50 - >>IF NOT REALLY CREATING A

50:52 - FRONT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF

50:52 - ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.

50:54 - IT CREATED. FOR FROM A FALL

50:56 - FROM PUBLIC ADVERSARIAL RECORD

50:58 - IN FRONT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL

50:59 - HEARING BOARD AND I THINK THAT

51:01 - WE HAVE RIGHT.

51:06 - THANK YOU JUST VERY BRIEFLY

51:07 - GOT IT WITH MY REMAINING TIME

51:09 - I'M GOING TO GIVE YOU ONE QUOTE

51:11 - FROM THE BOARD AND FOUND THE

51:12 - VICTIM.

51:12 - >>THE FOREIGN BAD, AND DON'T

51:15 - RELY ON A WELL. THEY

51:18 - BELIEVE THAT BORDEN TOWN 55.

51:22 - HEARING BOARD. WE'RE FRUSTRATED

51:24 - BY THAT IN VOTING BY MAIL

51:26 - HERE BOARD 5 OR ABOUT BECAUSE

51:28 - IT IS THE MODEL 3 FENCE.

51:30 - THE MOST FREQUENT 3RD CIRCUIT.

51:33 - A STUDENT ON THE 53RD VICTIM

51:35 - AND THE COURT PHOTOS BACK

51:37 - WITH SATAN EVEN THOUGH IT COULD

51:40 - TAKE TO KNOW MIGHT HAVE THE

51:41 - RIGHT IMMEDIATELY COME AND

51:43 - COLLECT THEM IN THE 3RD CIRCUIT

51:45 - COURT IS THERE REALLY A BIG

51:48 - WAY. IF THEY'RE HURT ALL RIGHT

51:49 - IN BED

51:50 - IT READ. IT WILL BE AVAILABLE

51:53 - IN MINUTES PLAYED.

51:58 - AND YOU FEEL MAY NOT BE OPEN TO

52:00 - KEEP THE BUT IT IS IN FOR

52:03 - THE COMMON IN THE OFFICE IF NOT

52:05 - IF THEY LACKED THEM, IT IS NOT

52:07 - ENOUGH REALLY DO. AND A LOT

52:09 - OF OFFICE THAT 7, 1, 7, ARE YOU

52:12 - ON INFECTED PEOPLE CLOSE.

52:15 - ALL RIGTH OR MY TIME FOR

52:16 - REBUTTAL BACTERIA ON.

52:30 - >>THANK YOU WOULD PLEASE THE

52:31 - COURT MY NAME IS DOUG LAZY AND

52:33 - I REPRESENT WEST ROCKHILL

52:34 - TOWNSHIP BY FOR QUESTION ONE

52:36 - MINUTE REBUTTAL. I WILL GIVE

52:38 - FROM MY ARGUMENT DEATH. FOR A

52:40 - MOMENT DID TO SUGGEST THAT WERE

52:42 - THE QUESTIONS

52:43 - US MIKE. IS ADDRESSED DIRECTLY

52:46 - BY THE PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME

52:48 - COURT ENTIRE JOCKEY SERVICE FOR

52:50 - SAYS THE COMMONWEALTH

52:51 - DEPARTMENT OF

52:52 - ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.

52:54 - WE'RE TALKING ABOUT 3

52:55 - INDEPENDENT YET INTERRELATED

52:57 - BRANCHES THE TO BE THE B E T IN

53:00 - THE U

53:01 - H B.

53:02 - >>AND IT GOES ON TO SAY THE VHP

53:04 - Z ADMINISTRATIVE JUDICIAL

53:06 - BRANCH WHICH HAS THE POWER AND

53:08 - DO. JOINT ADMINISTRATOR BEEN

53:10 - PART OF.

53:13 - >>I WOULD TAKE A WHILE AND PUT

53:15 - A LITTLE VICTORY TO THE

53:16 - ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD UP

53:18 - UNTIL 1988 ACTUALLY WAS PART OF

53:21 - THE DEPARTMENT ENVIRONMENTAL

53:22 - PROTECTION. IT WAS

53:24 - IT PUSHED OUT TO THE TRULY

53:26 - INDEPENDENT AGENCY IN 1988, SO

53:28 - GET THERE THERE THERE ARE.

53:30 - STRINGS THAT ARE STILL SOME

53:32 - SOMEWHAT ATTACHED TO THOSE

53:33 - 3 DIFFERENT BODY.

53:35 - >>YES, YOUR HONOR YOU'RE

53:36 - GETTING TO MY CONCLUSION AND I

53:38 - I HAVE A GREAT HERE

53:40 - AND ENOUGH AND KEN YOU'RE IT IN

53:43 - THE PAST TO GO BACK TO THE

53:44 - O R AND BEFORE THE DVR THE

53:47 - DEPARTMENTS OF L'S MINES AND

53:49 - MINERAL INDUSTRIES.

53:52 - FORREST AND WATERS AND THERE

53:53 - WERE HEARING EXAMINER'S ANOTHER

53:55 - SHOW PART OF THE COMMONWEALTH

53:57 - LONG HISTORY ON THIS IT WAS

53:59 - LOOKING AT WAYS TO

54:01 - SEPARATE AND GIVEN MORE

54:03 - INTEGRITY AND AND INDEPENDENCE

54:06 - OF ACTION TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE

54:09 - PROCESS THEN USED TO BE IN THE

54:11 - CONSOLIDATED AGENCY WHERE THE

54:13 - SECRETARY WAS JUDGE JURY AND

54:15 - WE'LL MAKE OR IF YOU WILL ALL

54:17 - AT THE SAME TIME SO THE

54:18 - ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY BOARD WAS

54:19 - CREATED IN

54:20 - THE MAKING FUNCTION THE

54:22 - ORIGINAL HEARING BOARD WAS

54:24 - THERE AND THEN LATER SEPARATED

54:26 - FURTHER BY THE HEARING BOARD

54:27 - ACT BUT ALL INTENDED TO BE PART

54:30 - OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS

54:32 - JUST TO GIVE THEM OR INTEGRITY

54:33 - AND SEPARATION FROM A SINGLE

54:36 - EXECUTIVE CONTROLLING ALL ALL

54:39 - OF THEM, HAVING SAID THAT I I

54:41 - WOULD LIKE TO MAKE AN ANALOGY

54:43 - IF YOU WILL

54:43 - TO A BOOKSHELF AND LET'S ASSUME

54:45 - AND THIS BOOKSHELF IS ALL THE

54:47 - LAW WE NEED TO KNOW THE RESOLVE

54:49 - THIS MATTER

54:50 - AND I'M SUGGESTING THAT THE

54:52 - BOOKS AND THE BOOKSHELF OR ON

54:55 - EITHER AND BUY A

54:56 - BOOK END AND THE BORDEN TOWN

54:59 - CASES HERE IN THE MIDDLE AND

55:00 - WHAT WE'RE GOING TO LOOK AT.

55:02 - SO WHAT ARE THOSE WHO LOOK AT.

55:05 - ONE I BELIEVE IS IMPORTANT TOWN

55:07 - CASE WHICH WE WILL.

55:09 - IT DOES DISCUSSED NOW

55:11 - IN DETAIL AND IN THAT CASE WE

55:14 - THINK THE 3RD CIRCUIT HAS MADE

55:16 - IT ABUNDANTLY CLEAR THAT.

55:20 - IT WAS DOING IN THE RIVERKEEPER

55:22 - CASES WAS LOOKING AT WHEN IT

55:25 - HAD JURISDICTION, NOT WHETHER

55:27 - WE HAD OR WHETHER A PETITION I

55:29 - HAD A RIGHT TO GO TO THE

55:30 - ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY. SO THE

55:33 - RIVERKEEPER CASES WHICH WE'LL

55:34 - GET TO IN A MOMENT.

55:36 - WHEN A RECORD IS SUFFICIENTLY

55:38 - FINAL FOR FEDERAL PURPOSES TO

55:40 - BE SUBJECT TO REVIEW NOT

55:42 - WEATHER THE PETITIONER

55:44 - HAS THE RIGHT TO FINISH THE

55:46 - STATE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS

55:48 - AND IF WE LOOK AT DAMAGE SOME

55:50 - OF THE LANGUAGE IN THAT

55:52 - BORDENTOWN CASE. I THINK THERE

55:54 - ARE 3 THINGS THAT I KNOW I

55:57 - POINT OUT

55:57 - RIGHT NOW SAYS THE SUPREME

55:59 - COURT HERE MEETING UNITED

56:00 - STATES SUPREME COURT HAS LONG

56:02 - RECOGNIZED THAT ADMINISTRATIVE

56:04 - HEARINGS EVEN TO THE EXTENT

56:06 - THAT THEY IN SOME WAY MIRROR

56:08 - AND

56:08 - ADVERSARIAL TRIAL. DO NOT

56:10 - CONSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS IN

56:12 - COURTS OF LAW

56:13 - OR EQUITY AND AS YOU DO IN

56:15 - LIGHT OF BOTH FEDERAL AND NEW

56:17 - JERSEY AUTHORITY A HEARING

56:19 - BEFORE AN ADMINISTRATIVE BODY

56:21 - IS NOT A CIVIL ACTION.

56:23 - THE JOCKEY CATION

56:24 - PENNSYLVANIA ALL THE HEARING

56:26 - BOARD AT ALL OF THE SHOW IT TO

56:28 - THE

56:28 - ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY. WE ARE

56:30 - NOT IT'S NOT A CIVIL ACTION AND

56:32 - THE DEPARTMENT AT ONE POINT

56:33 - SAYS AN APPEAL TO THE HEARING

56:35 - BOARDS, A CIVIL ACTION,

56:36 - IT'S NOT IT'S PART OF THE

56:37 - ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS. THE

56:40 - CASE GOES ON TO SAY

56:41 - AS OPPOSED TO AFFIRMATIVELY

56:43 - INSTALLING FEDERAL COURTS TO

56:45 - OVERSEE THE ADMINISTRATIVE

56:47 - PROCESS. CONGRESS DID NOT

56:49 - INTERJECT FEDERAL COURTS INTO

56:51 - THE INTERNAL WORKINGS OF STATE

56:52 - ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES.

56:54 - NOW WHAT HAPPENS TO BE IN

56:56 - BORDENTOWN CASE, THE N J D P

56:59 - IT I'LL COME CALLING OR QUASI

57:02 - JUDICIAL COMPONENT IS WITHIN

57:04 - THE AGENCY. SO YES IN THAT CASE

57:06 - IS IN TRYING

57:07 - TO SAY THIS MAKES IT CLEAR THAT

57:10 - THE 3RD CIRCUIT IS

57:12 - BELIEVES THAT THE CONGRESS WAS

57:14 - INTENDING TO RESPECT ALL STATE

57:16 - ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESSES THE

57:18 - SHOW INCLUDES ARE HOLDING IS

57:20 - ONLY THAT INSTEAD OF BRINGING A

57:22 - CIVIL ACTION IN THIS COURT.

57:24 - THE PETITIONERS WERE ENTITLED

57:26 - UNDER NEW JERSEY LAW LEVEL

57:28 - TURNED DEADLY. FIRST SAW AND IN

57:31 - FRAUD. THE AGENCY DURING

57:35 - JUDGE WAS REFERRING TO EARLIER

57:37 - IS ONLY GROWING BEFORE THE

57:39 - ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD IN

57:40 - PENNSYLVANIA UNDER THIS

57:42 - TRADITION OF TRIED

57:43 - TO MAKE INTEREST PROCESS BE

57:45 - MORE INDEPENDENT NO MORE

57:47 - INTEGRITY THAT SHOULD NOT BE

57:48 - USED AS A AS THE REASON THE

57:50 - GOOD LIE. THE DISH OR

57:52 - JURISDICTION TO IT. IT'S A

57:54 - GREAT BOARD, BUT YOU CAN'T GO

57:56 - TO.

57:58 - AND IT SAYS NEW JERSEY THE

58:00 - VIOLATED NEW

58:01 - JERSEY LAW PLAN REASONABLY

58:03 - BENIGN PETITIONER'S REQUEST FOR

58:05 - SUCH A HEARING BASED ON

58:07 - ITS MISREADING AND THE NATURAL

58:09 - GAS ACT AND THIS COURT'S

58:11 - PRECEDENTS.

58:13 - I READ THAT TO

58:14 - CLEARLY SAY CITIZENS HAVE FULL

58:16 - ACCESS TO THEIR STATE

58:17 - ADMINISTRATIVE LAW PROCESS EASE

58:19 - AND NOTHING IN THE NATURAL GAS

58:21 - ACT PREEMPT THOSE RIGHTS.

58:23 - NO LESS IT CAN'T WE'LL JUST ONE

58:26 - QUICK QUESTION YOUR POSITION

58:28 - THEN.

58:29 - >>THAT THE PETITIONERS WOULD

58:31 - HAVE A CHOICE AND THEY COULD

58:33 - DECIDE ALTERNATIVELY TO EITHER

58:35 - PROCEED IN FRONT OF THE

58:37 - ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

58:39 - OR APPEAL DIRECTLY FROM THE

58:42 - DETERMINATION OF THE DEPARTMENT

58:44 - TO THE 3RD CIRCUIT. YESTERDAY

58:46 - IT IS. IF IT'S TRUE AND

58:49 - IT IS NOT COMFORTABLE

58:52 - TO US WHO

58:53 - PRACTICE JUST IN PENNSYLVANIA

58:54 - THAT THINK OH WE CAN BY

58:56 - FIERCELY HEARING BOARD GO RIGHT

58:57 - TO THE COMMONWEALTH COURT FOR

58:59 - REVIEW.

58:59 - >>THAT'S NOT. WHAT IS IT.

59:02 - AND THAT'S WHAT THE 3RD CIRCUIT

59:04 - IS SAYING AND THE REASON IS

59:05 - JUST I'M GOOD.

59:08 - IN THIS EXAMPLE, LET'S SAY THE

59:09 - RECORD ON THE RECORD CREATED

59:12 - THE DEPARTMENT IS IMPOSED

59:13 - THE CONDITION THOUGH THAT

59:15 - CONDITION MIGHT BE DISAGREEABLE

59:17 - TO US THE PETITIONERS

59:18 - IT COULD CONCEIVABLY BE

59:20 - DISAGREEABLE TO ADELPHIA THE

59:23 - APPLICANT SO BUT IF. THE

59:26 - POTENTIAL LIVE AGAIN.

59:28 - SO THE RECORD WAS SUFFICIENTLY

59:30 - CLEAR AS TO

59:31 - THE ISSUE THAT COULD BE

59:33 - REVEALED ON THAT RECORD.

59:35 - I DO BELIEVE THE NATURAL GAS

59:37 - ACT TO SAY THAT PETITIONER HAS

59:39 - THE CHOICE IT WAS THE HEARING

59:41 - BOARD PROCESS TO GO THROUGH IT

59:43 - OR TO GO DIRECTLY TO THE 3RD

59:45 - CIRCUIT.

59:46 - AND ARGUABLY HIS NOTHING

59:48 - COMPLETE ENOUGH TO BE REVIEWED

59:50 - AND ADJUDICATED

59:52 - THAT'S WHAT YOU WANT TO COUNT

59:53 - THE WATER WHERE ONE OF THE

59:55 - PARTIES DON'T AGREE ON THAT ONE

59:56 - OF THE PARTIES DON'T AGREE THAT

59:58 - THE RECORD IS.

59:59 - 360 >>AND A QUICK TO GET THE

01:00 - 02.500 ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

01:00 - 06.020 WHO KNOW CAN THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:00 - 06.560 BEN.

01:00 - 10.160 RE MANDATE OR TRANSFER IT OR

01:00 - 11.020 WHAT WOULD HAPPEN.

01:00 - 13.250 WE'VE GOT A VERY GOOD QUESTION

01:00 - 14.770 YOUR HONOR AND I DON'T THINK IT

01:00 - 16.520 YET BEEN ANSWERED AS ONE THAT'S

01:00 - 18.450 NOT THE ANSWER HERE IS MY SENSE

01:00 - 20.040 OF HOW THE COURT WOULD LOOK AT

01:00 - 20.180 IT.

01:00 - 23.260 I HAVE A BOYFRIEND THAT TIME I

01:00 - 24.330 WANT TO ASK YOU A QUESTION DO

01:00 - 25.860 WE HAVE THE AIRPORT IN THE CASE

01:00 - 28.010 BECAUSE I THINK HE I

01:00 - 28.440 THINK THERE'S BEEN A

01:00 - 30.140 CONTENTION. WELL WE HAVE GIVEN

01:00 - 30.880 TO DO WE HAVE TO GET INTO

01:00 - 32.670 WHETHER THERE'S AN OPTIONAL

01:00 - 33.320 REVIEW.

01:00 - 35.010 >>THE DIRECT APPEAL 3RD CIRCUIT

01:00 - 35.460 CAN WE JUST

01:00 - 37.860 DECIDE WHETHER THAT THE APPEAL

01:00 - 39.460 ARE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

01:00 - 40.830 IS A CIVIL ACTION.

01:00 - 43.410 >>WELL, IT'S ALSO CLEAR FROM

01:00 - 45.370 SAY BORDENTOWN THAT IF IT GOES

01:00 - 47.110 BACK TO THE END YOU REMEMBER

01:00 - 49.170 THE NATURAL GAS ACT PROVIDES

01:00 - 49.930 THAT FEE.

01:00 - 52.990 THE COURT CAN PUT A TIME LIMIT

01:00 - 54.210 ON THE STATE ADMINISTRATIVE

01:00 - 55.600 PROCEEDING SO THE WAY TO

01:00 - 57.260 CONTROL THE STATE FOR CHANGE OR

01:00 - 57.930 IS THIS A

01:00 - 00.030 WE HAVE A CONCERN THAT YOU ACT

01:01 - 01.880 ON THIS PROMPTLY. SO AT

01:01 - 04.650 SOME POINT IF THE TO GO UP

01:01 - 06.360 FOR ME. THE FEDERAL COURT TO

01:01 - 07.830 SAY THIS IS TAKING TOO LONG.

01:01 - 09.530 BUT WE'RE NOT IN

01:01 - 11.360 THAT SAID WE HAVE NOT BEEN

01:01 - 13.050 DILATORY WE PROCEED IT IS

01:01 - 13.760 PROBABLY AS WE

01:01 - 17.490 KNEW HOW SO IF YOU'RE COMING UP

01:01 - 18.980 AT THEIR OTHER.

01:01 - 21.040 >>HAVE THERE BEEN OTHER APPEAL

01:01 - 24.340 OF THAT NATURE. DIRECTLY FROM

01:01 - 26.860 THE E P PLAN APPROVAL

01:01 - 28.900 TO THE 3RD CIRCUIT AND

01:01 - 31.350 AND WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR

01:01 - 33.130 PUTTING TOGETHER THE RECORD AND

01:01 - 34.700 WHAT IS THE RECORD JUST

01:01 - 36.120 EVERYTHING IN ME.

01:01 - 39.810 GRANT HER FILE.

01:01 - 43.280 >>I THINK THAT'S 2 QUESTIONS

01:01 - 44.380 YOUR HONOR LET ME SAY GOOD.

01:01 - 46.340 THANK YOU I CAN THE ANSWER

01:01 - 48.960 THEM. THE I DIDN'T GET TO GO

01:01 - 49.170 INTO

01:01 - 50.600 THE ROOM WORKING FOR CASES IN

01:01 - 52.720 DETAIL, BUT THERE'S SOME DUAL

01:01 - 54.960 CHOICE THERE IN SOME CASES THE

01:01 - 56.590 RIVERKEEPER PETITIONERS.

01:01 - 58.590 IT SOUGHT HEARING BEFORE THE

01:01 - 00.310 HEARING BOARD AND WENT TO THE

01:02 - 02.230 3RD CIRCUIT. LET'S MAKE IT

01:02 - 04.870 CLEAR WE HAVE NOT COOL AND NEED

01:02 - 06.540 ANY OF IT. NEITHER OF

01:02 - 08.130 THE PETITIONERS I'M GOING TO

01:02 - 09.930 THE 3RD CIRCUIT IN APPEALED.

01:02 - 11.460 AND THE DECISION OF THE

01:02 - 13.260 DEPARTMENT, THE ONLY THING WE

01:02 - 15.080 DID WAS THIS A HEARING BOARD

01:02 - 17.710 REVIEW. SO THE THERE ARE 2

01:02 - 20.070 CASES WERE SAYING. WE THINK

01:02 - 21.550 THERE WAS A MISTAKE IN MAY

01:02 - 23.890 IN THE PUBLIC NOTICE IT WASN'T

01:02 - 25.470 PUBLISHED LONG ENOUGH IT WASN'T

01:02 - 26.810 CLEAR ENOUGH THERE WAS THIS OR

01:02 - 29.560 THAT GOING ON IN THE CASE AND

01:02 - 31.790 SO WHEN THEY FILED THE CIVIL

01:02 - 34.160 ACTION AND THE 3RD CIRCUIT THAT

01:02 - 34.880 WAS IN

01:02 - 36.880 THE RECORD AND THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:02 - 38.680 SAYS THAT LOOKS COMPLETE ENOUGH

01:02 - 40.500 FOR US FOR PURPOSES OF FEDERAL

01:02 - 43.520 LAW THE MAKE A DETERMINATION ON

01:02 - 44.500 THAT RECORD

01:02 - 46.310 THAT THE DEPARTMENT

01:02 - 48.680 WAS OK WE'RE IN VERY I THINK

01:02 - 50.120 ALL OF THE CASES SAID THE

01:02 - 52.030 DEPARTMENT ACTION WAS OK.

01:02 - 55.190 THEY HAVE BEEN SUSPENDED THE

01:02 - 56.570 PROCEEDING BEFORE THE HEARING

01:02 - 58.680 BOARD IN ONE CASE

01:02 - 01.120 THE PARTIES AGREE TO AN OUTCOME

01:03 - 03.130 SO THEY HEARING BOARD IN 2017

01:03 - 04.470 SAID WE ARE YOUR WORST DICTION

01:03 - 05.820 OVER THIS BUT WE'VE BEEN ASKED

01:03 - 07.620 TO DISMISS THE APPEALS IT

01:03 - 09.000 PARTIES HAVE COME TO AN

01:03 - 09.470 AGREEMENT

01:03 - 12.050 IN ANOTHER MATTER THAT THE

01:03 - 14.160 RIVERKEEPER HADN'T FILED BEFORE

01:03 - 15.350 THE HEARING BOARD AT ALL.

01:03 - 17.040 SO THEY DIDN'T HAVE ANYTHING

01:03 - 17.900 PENDING BEFORE THE

01:03 - 19.970 HEARING BOARD. SO THE PARTIES

01:03 - 22.230 IN THAT CASE WERE TAKING BOTH

01:03 - 23.900 SPOTS AT THE SAME TIME

01:03 - 26.220 AND THE 3RD CIRCUIT WAS SAY IF

01:03 - 28.280 YOU CALLED US WHERE WILL YOU

01:03 - 28.800 COME FOR

01:03 - 31.190 CIVIL ACTION AND WE THINK THAT

01:03 - 32.680 RECORDS COMPLETE ENOUGH WE CAN

01:03 - 33.440 GRANT RELIEF.

01:03 - 36.420 WE'RE NOT SAYING YOU DON'T HAVE

01:03 - 37.960 THE RIGHT TO GO TO THE 9TH WARD

01:03 - 38.660 AND THAT'S WHAT THEY

01:03 - 40.620 MAKE CLEAR IN THE BORDENTOWN

01:03 - 42.350 CASE THAT YOU CAN DO THAT

01:03 - 44.230 AND THAT THE CONGRESS INTENDED

01:03 - 45.810 TO RESPECT SUBTLE DIFFERENCES

01:03 - 46.470 IN STATE

01:03 - 47.910 ADMINISTRATOR PROCEDURE.

01:03 - 49.190 WE'RE NOT THE SAME IN

01:03 - 50.830 MASSACHUSETTS, NOT THE SAME AS

01:03 - 52.920 THE JERSEY BLAH BLAH AND THEY

01:03 - 54.950 WILL RESPECT THAT NOW WHAT

01:03 - 56.050 HAPPENS IF YOU DO

01:03 - 58.020 IF ONE PARTY WAS THE 3RD

01:03 - 59.910 CIRCUIT OR ITS SURROGATE MOTHER

01:03 - 01.980 WAS IN THE STATE PROCESS THAT

01:04 - 02.570 CAN HAPPEN

01:04 - 05.450 RIGHT NOW THAT'S WHAT IS WAS

01:04 - 07.170 GOING ON FOR THE TOWN WITH

01:04 - 09.680 RESOLVING CERTAIN FIRST ISSUES

01:04 - 12.540 BUT ST. THIS STATE PROCEEDING

01:04 - 14.050 ON THE AIR PERMIT NEEDS TO BE

01:04 - 16.370 INDEPENDENTLY RESOLVED. SO WHEN

01:04 - 16.640 THAT

01:04 - 19.480 WAS DONE. I WOULD BELIEVE THAT

01:04 - 21.860 LIKELY THAT APPEAL MUCH THEY GO

01:04 - 24.120 BACK TO THE 3RD CIRCUIT OF THAT

01:04 - 24.740 COMPONENT.

01:04 - 28.120 I I'M SORRY TO SAY IF YOU GRANT

01:04 - 28.630 US THE

01:04 - 30.960 THE GROUP. THE RIGHT WE WISH TO

01:04 - 32.440 APPEAR BEFORE THE AREA WORD IN

01:04 - 34.390 THE AREA BOARD RULE IN OUR

01:04 - 35.560 FAVOR OR

01:04 - 37.670 AGAINST US THE APPEAL FROM THAT

01:04 - 39.100 WOULD PROBABLY BE THE 3RD

01:04 - 40.820 CIRCUIT UNDER THIS LAW DID NOT

01:04 - 42.530 BACK TO THIS COURT. WE'RE

01:04 - 44.020 SIMPLY SAYING ARE ASKING

01:04 - 46.450 THIS COURT. NOT TO REVIEW ANY

01:04 - 48.000 RECORD OF THE DEPARTMENT THIS

01:04 - 49.630 IS NOT A SUBSTANTIVE REVIEW.

01:04 - 51.730 WE'RE ASKING ONLY FOR THE WORK.

01:04 - 54.610 >>I'M ASKING UP BACK TO

01:04 - 58.390 BEST BUY. GOOD PR. EXACTLY OR.

01:05 - 01.750 I SAY I'M OUT OF TIME.

01:05 - 04.270 SO I THINK I READ MOST OF THEM

01:05 - 06.340 HOW CAN YOU. THE REBUTTAL IS AN

01:05 - 07.300 IMPORTANT CASE.

01:05 - 10.130 >>AND A VERY INTERESTING ALL

01:05 - 11.430 RIGHT, WE WILL HEAR NEXT

01:05 - 12.070 FROM.

01:05 - 14.400 >>THE INTERVIEW WITH HER BOX.

01:05 - 16.550 GOOD MORNING RUNNERS UP IN THE

01:05 - 18.820 BAUCUS ON THE APP OF INTERVENER

01:05 - 19.840 ADELPHIA GATEWAY.

01:05 - 22.830 THAT ASSURES DEMAND FOR THE

01:05 - 24.680 FORM OF THEIR CHOICE SALES FOR

01:05 - 26.830 REASONS OF TEXAS, THE CONTEXT,

01:05 - 29.070 THE CONSEQUENCES, BUT FIRST AS

01:05 - 30.350 A MATTER OF TEX A NATURAL

01:05 - 32.250 GAS ACT, THE CHOIRS FINAL

01:05 - 34.040 AGENCY PERMITTING DECISIONS

01:05 - 35.780 TO BE SUBJECT TO THE EXCLUSIVE

01:05 - 36.710 REVIEW, A FEDERAL APPELLATE

01:05 - 38.830 COURTS AND THE CONTEXT REPORTS

01:05 - 40.530 THIS CONGRESS ENACTED THE

01:05 - 41.870 JURISDICTIONAL PROVISIONS OF

01:05 - 42.240 THE NATURAL

01:05 - 44.710 GAS TAX TO PUT OUT ALL

01:05 - 46.110 SUBSEQUENT STATES

01:05 - 48.500 ADMINISTRATOR REVIEW. WHAT'S

01:05 - 50.270 HER MEMORY IF YOU ARE THE DAY

01:05 - 51.490 YOU WERE THE DAY THAT

01:05 - 51.940 I MEAN.

01:05 - 54.000 >>IN PENNSYLVANIA WE HAVE IS

01:05 - 55.440 THAT PROCESS AND I DON'T

01:05 - 57.980 READ THE FEDERAL LAW AS THING

01:05 - 59.860 THAT YOU CAN ONLY HAVE PART OF

01:05 - 01.380 THAT PROCESS, YOUR LOVE YOU.

01:06 - 04.090 FOR PROFIT BEFORE THE 3RD

01:06 - 04.460 CIRCUIT

01:06 - 05.060 REPEAT THAT.

01:06 - 08.040 >>THE PATIENTS TO THAT THAT

01:06 - 09.850 QUOTE COMES FROM THE BERKSHIRE

01:06 - 11.020 CASE OUT OF THE FIRST CIRCUIT

01:06 - 13.800 IN WHICH SIMILAR BORDENTOWN A

01:06 - 15.530 MASSACHUSETTS TVP HAD ISSUED A

01:06 - 17.680 PERMIT. THE PETITIONERS IN THE

01:06 - 21.170 BERKSHIRE CASE ARGUED THAT THAT

01:06 - 22.630 MESSAGE TO 60 P HADN'T BEEN

01:06 - 23.510 ABLE TO GO THROUGH ITS

01:06 - 26.320 WHOLE PROCESS IN A CASE SIMILAR

01:06 - 28.150 TO WHAT WE FOUND. THE FIRST

01:06 - 29.200 CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS

01:06 - 31.130 SAID THAT MASSACHUSETTS THAT HE

01:06 - 32.620 STILL HAD SOMETHING LEFT TO DO.

01:06 - 34.770 SIMILAR TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY

01:06 - 36.020 CASE IN WHICH THERE ENSURE

01:06 - 39.500 THE PROCESS. FOR NEW JERSEY TO

01:06 - 41.870 CONCENTRATE ITS ACTION. THROUGH

01:06 - 43.030 AN APPEAL PROCESS.

01:06 - 45.860 >>WHY HAVEN'T THERE FROM THING

01:06 - 46.830 TO DO IN THAT CASE.

01:06 - 47.710 I

01:06 - 49.820 AND THEY'RE THEY'RE YOU KNOW

01:06 - 51.480 RECORD AND THERE ARE BIG

01:06 - 52.760 DIFFERENCES DEGREE ME

01:06 - 54.380 ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE FACT

01:06 - 56.170 THE FEDERAL AFTER THEM BE

01:06 - 57.670 ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCY LAW.

01:06 - 01.530 YOU KNOW WE WE MAKE RECORD MOM.

01:07 - 03.810 DIFFERENT WAY THEM

01:07 - 05.920 OTHER FAITH. AND

01:07 - 07.430 WE HAVE BACK TO

01:07 - 09.500 YOU A DIFFERENT APPEAL EVEN

01:07 - 10.820 WITHIN PENNSYLVANIA AND THERE

01:07 - 12.250 ARE MANY AGENCIES WHERE THE

01:07 - 13.800 APPEAL GOES DIRECTLY TO THE

01:07 - 15.350 AGENCY HAD. BUT IN

01:07 - 17.620 THIS CASE. YOU WOULD AGREE WITH

01:07 - 19.840 YOU NOT THAT UNDER BORDENTOWN

01:07 - 21.010 IF THE APPEAL WENT TO THE

01:07 - 23.710 SECRETARY OF THE U K OF

01:07 - 25.480 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION THAT.

01:07 - 28.020 IT WOULD BE ALLOWED TO PROCEED.

01:07 - 31.030 >>I THINK YOU ARE RIGHT IF IF

01:07 - 32.280 THE MINISTRY OF RULES WERE THAT

01:07 - 34.820 WAY IN OBVIOUSLY IN

01:07 - 35.680 PENNSYLVANIA. WE HAVE THE

01:07 - 36.930 GENERAL RULES OF THE MISSION OF

01:07 - 37.970 PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE

01:07 - 39.480 AND THERE'S A PROVISION THAT

01:07 - 42.890 BELIEVE IT SAID ONE 30 A 35 TO

01:07 - 44.570 20 I BELIEVE THAT ALLOWS FOLKS

01:07 - 47.240 TO THE FILE AN APPEAL. UP TO

01:07 - 47.970 THE AGENCY AT.

01:07 - 51.030 BUT NOTABLY IF YOU LOOK TO EASE

01:07 - 53.630 REGULATIONS. ONE VEHICLE 1.5.

01:07 - 55.040 THOSE GENERALS ARE NOT

01:07 - 57.070 APPLICABLE. IT IS A SEPARATE

01:07 - 59.590 STATE AGENCY DPS SAID IT'S GOT

01:07 - 01.370 TO GET TO KNOW WHY WE

01:08 - 01.990 UNDERSTAND.

01:08 - 03.560 >>ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

01:08 - 04.130 IF NOT.

01:08 - 08.500 >>THE SAME AGE AND HE HAS THE

01:08 - 09.820 DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL

01:08 - 11.340 PROTECTION. AND

01:08 - 13.860 EVERY AGENCY PICK THROUGH

01:08 - 16.930 WHICH OF THE RULE AND GRAPH IT

01:08 - 17.980 WISHES TO ADOPT.

01:08 - 23.670 HOW DO

01:08 - 25.840 YOU READ BORDENTOWN THE 3RD

01:08 - 27.020 CIRCUIT SAYING.

01:08 - 31.350 WHAT REALLY DEFINING

01:08 - 33.460 A LOT FOR PENNSYLVANIA

01:08 - 35.070 AND AND HAS A DIFFERENT

01:08 - 36.840 PROCEDURE THEM NEW JERSEY.

01:08 - 39.250 BUT IF WE'RE GOING OUR GUY.

01:08 - 43.890 MORE ON THE AIR

01:08 - 46.090 WITH THIS THE APPEAL WOULD BE

01:08 - 48.090 ALLOWED TO PROCEED. THE

01:08 - 48.770 ENVIRONMENTAL

01:08 - 50.900 HEARING BOARD AND THEN GO TO

01:08 - 52.180 THE 3RD CIRCUIT QUICK WRONG

01:08 - 52.550 WITH THAT.

01:08 - 55.890 >>A COUPLE OF DIFFERENT ONE IF

01:08 - 57.210 YOU LOOK AT THE THE RIVERKEEPER

01:08 - 58.560 LINES OF CASES.

01:08 - 00.200 >>I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR

01:09 - 02.780 THE RIVERKEEPER PETITIONERS DID

01:09 - 04.670 NOT WANT TO BE BEFORE THE 3RD

01:09 - 06.110 CIRCUIT THEY WANT TO BE BEFORE

01:09 - 08.190 THE HP THERE WAS A THERE'S A

01:09 - 09.500 REASON THIS CASE WAS LITIGATED

01:09 - 11.110 5 TIMES FOR THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:09 - 13.030 BECAUSE PETITIONERS DO NOT WANT

01:09 - 13.790 TO BE BEFORE THE

01:09 - 16.540 3RD CIRCUIT. AND IN FACT WHEN

01:09 - 17.780 THE 3RD CIRCUIT RULED THE WAY

01:09 - 20.020 IT ENDED 24 HOURS LATER.

01:09 - 21.800 ORTON COW CAME OUT THE

01:09 - 23.050 PETITIONERS AND HEAVIER IN

01:09 - 25.710 CASE, THE AIR AND 3. OR ASK FOR

01:09 - 27.650 A REHEARING ON FOX. BEFORE

01:09 - 29.560 THE SAME JUDGES OF THE 3RD

01:09 - 31.130 CIRCUIT WHAT 24 HOURS LATER

01:09 - 33.040 BISHOP BORDER TOWN AND THE

01:09 - 34.010 COURT TONIGHT REVEALING

01:09 - 34.960 AND ON TOP OF

01:09 - 36.920 THAT I THINK THEY SHOULD RETURN

01:09 - 38.680 MAY BUT EVEN THOUGH THEY DON'T

01:09 - 39.970 WANT TO GO BEFORE THE 3RD

01:09 - 41.940 CIRCUIT AT SOME POINT YOU DON'T

01:09 - 42.540 GET THERE.

01:09 - 44.620 >>BUT IT JUST WENT AND WITH

01:09 - 45.350 WHAT RECORD.

01:09 - 48.110 >>AND THAT THAT'S WHERE THE

01:09 - 49.670 NATURAL GAS ACT COMES INTO PLAY

01:09 - 51.900 HERE. WE SEE THROUGH THE 25

01:09 - 53.440 THAT 2005 AMENDMENT TO THE

01:09 - 54.270 NATURAL GAS ACT

01:09 - 57.020 CONGRESS'S INTENT TO CUT OUT

01:09 - 58.070 ALL OF THE SUBSEQUENT

01:09 - 59.380 ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW BECAUSE

01:09 - 01.400 OF THE DEATH BY A 1000 CUTS

01:10 - 03.010 THAT THESE PROCESSES CAN

01:10 - 05.260 CREATE. YOU KNOW THAT THIS

01:10 - 05.930 COURT IS FAMILIAR

01:10 - 07.760 WITH THE HD CASES YOU

01:10 - 08.990 UNDERSTAND THAT THESE CASES

01:10 - 10.240 HAVE A TENDENCY TO DRAG ON

01:10 - 12.520 FOR YEARS AND THAT'S FOR RIGHT

01:10 - 13.670 THERE THAT HE BEGAN HIS

01:10 - 17.180 OWN RECOGNITION. REPEATING A

01:10 - 17.460 THEME.

01:10 - 18.690 >>YEAH, YOU KNOW.

01:10 - 25.260 I MEAN IT'S A MATTER OF A

01:10 - 26.940 SEPARATE MATTER. HOW QUICKLY

01:10 - 29.730 YOU MATTER FROM WHETHER

01:10 - 31.650 OR NOT YOU HAVE A COMPLETE

01:10 - 33.670 RECORD BEFORE YOU GO TO THE 3RD

01:10 - 33.970 CIRCUIT.

01:10 - 36.250 >>AND YOU. WHAT WE'RE WRESTLING

01:10 - 36.760 WITH HERE.

01:10 - 38.220 >>I UNDERSTAND.

01:10 - 42.630 >>THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING

01:10 - 43.400 BOARD THEM.

01:10 - 46.910 ADELPHIA AND

01:10 - 49.550 HE HE SORT OF PUT TOGETHER AND

01:10 - 51.150 ARAFAT WHAT I WOULD CALL AN

01:10 - 53.180 ARAFAT. I'M AFFRAID APPEARING

01:10 - 53.330 RIGHT.

01:10 - 56.610 >>LET ME RESPOND TO THAT POINT

01:10 - 57.850 ABOUT ABOUT THE RECORD ALSO

01:10 - 59.570 FIRST THE QUESTION SAID ABOUT

01:10 - 01.490 HOW QUICKLY A COURT STUCK IN A

01:11 - 02.330 TRUST THIS

01:11 - 03.720 THEN AFTER GAS TAX SPEAKS TO

01:11 - 05.500 THIS IN TERMS OF REQUIRING

01:11 - 07.010 A FEDERAL COURT TO HEAR THESE

01:11 - 08.860 CASES AN EXPEDITED REVIEW THAT

01:11 - 10.190 OFTEN HAPPENS IN A PERIOD OF 5

01:11 - 12.310 MONTHS. HE CAN GET THROUGH

01:11 - 14.440 DISCOVERY. AT THE HPA PERIOD OF

01:11 - 16.060 5 MONTHS AND IN TERMS OF THE

01:11 - 18.980 AGAIN THIS TYPE OF CASE HAS

01:11 - 19.750 BEEN LITIGATED NUMBER

01:11 - 22.340 OF TIMES IF YOU LOOK TO DR.

01:11 - 23.180 AND NUMBER 5.

01:11 - 26.310 ITS SIDE ON A FOOTNOTE 4 OF OUR

01:11 - 28.010 BRIEF. THIS WAS A CASE

01:11 - 29.640 INVOLVING AND PBS FROM IT.

01:11 - 31.970 IN THIS WAS THE ISSUE ABOUT A

01:11 - 33.490 RECORD IN THE 3RD CIRCUIT FOUND

01:11 - 33.910 AT THE RECORD

01:11 - 35.770 IS SUFFICIENT AND IT'S LOCATED

01:11 - 37.340 AT THE RYDER CUP AND IT DEPENDS

01:11 - 38.720 ON THE ISSUE RIGHT. I MEAN LOOK

01:11 - 40.680 I MEAN I THINK I THINK HE'LL IF

01:11 - 41.790 IF THE COUPLE YOU DIDN'T

01:11 - 43.330 PUBLISH IT IN THE COMPANY

01:11 - 44.970 BOLTON WITH THE NUMBER OF BABY

01:11 - 45.940 NEEDED TO PUBLISH AND WE'RE

01:11 - 46.820 CHALLENGING THE COMMON

01:11 - 47.410 APP VAPING.

01:11 - 51.200 >>PRETTY.

01:11 - 52.840 >>THEIR RECORD THAT YOU NEED

01:11 - 55.380 THERE. BUT I THINK THE PROBLEM

01:11 - 56.270 IS THAT YOU ACTUALLY HAVE

01:11 - 56.890 OPPONENT.

01:11 - 01.220 A PERMIT. THEY DON'T HAVE

01:12 - 04.640 ANY ABILITY TO REALLY PROVE

01:12 - 07.200 THAT EVIDENCE CROSSING THEM AND

01:12 - 09.590 HAVE A HEARING ANYTHING AS PART

01:12 - 10.550 OF THE PERMIT.

01:12 - 14.270 REVIEW PROCESS. THAT AT ALL

01:12 - 15.680 BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT AND THE

01:12 - 17.770 APPLICANT. MAYBE THERE'S PUBLIC

01:12 - 19.210 COMMENT COMMITTED.

01:12 - 21.390 MAYBE YOU MIGHT HAVE IT

01:12 - 22.550 DEPENDING ON WHERE IT IS HUMID

01:12 - 24.180 THAT BP MIGHT CHOOSE TO HAVE A

01:12 - 26.360 COMMUNITY. THE HEARING.

01:12 - 29.800 ALL AGE WHERE PEOPLE CAN COME

01:12 - 30.970 OUT AND EXPRESS THEIR VIEWS

01:12 - 32.050 ABOUT THE PROPOSAL.

01:12 - 34.350 BUT THERE'S NO OPPORTUNITY AND

01:12 - 35.510 THAT PROFITS FOR TRUE

01:12 - 37.060 ADVERSARIAL DEVELOPMENT OF

01:12 - 39.220 A RECORD AND IF THE ISSUE

01:12 - 41.330 REQUIRES THAT DEPEND ON THAT IN

01:12 - 42.420 THE 3RD CIRCUIT WON'T GET WHAT

01:12 - 42.750 IT NEEDS.

01:12 - 45.070 >>THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION THAT

01:12 - 45.970 CROPS AND I THINK IT'S

01:12 - 47.520 IMPORTANT TO LOOK AT THE FACTS

01:12 - 49.490 OF THIS CASE AND THE STRUCTURE

01:12 - 52.010 OF THIS CASE IF THE REGULATIONS

01:12 - 52.860 TO ALLOW

01:12 - 54.900 FOR FOLKS WHO ARE OPPOSED TO A

01:12 - 56.240 PLAN APPROVAL TO FILE A

01:12 - 58.870 PROTEST. BEFORE IF HE MAKES

01:12 - 00.670 A DECISION. WE LIKE THE

01:13 - 01.300 REGULATIONS THAT

01:13 - 03.940 ARE FREE THAT WOULD ALLOW THE

01:13 - 05.680 PROJECT OPPONENTS TO CREATE

01:13 - 06.540 TRANSCRIPTS.

01:13 - 10.950 NONE OF THE PETITIONERS IN THIS

01:13 - 13.040 CASE FOLLOWED THAT PROCESS IN.

01:13 - 16.270 >>BUT WHAT ARE THEY REQUIRED

01:13 - 17.840 NOR ARE THEY REQUIRED TO IF

01:13 - 19.400 THEY CAN GO TO THE H B.

01:13 - 21.980 >>WELL LET'S ALSO KEEP IN MIND

01:13 - 24.550 THAT THE COURTS. THROUGHOUT

01:13 - 26.670 THE NATION HAVE NOT HESITATED

01:13 - 30.420 TO SEND. A FEDERAL ACTIONS BACK

01:13 - 31.750 TO STATES TO MAKE A DECISION.

01:13 - 34.220 ONE OF THE CASES LIKE TO POINT

01:13 - 35.920 OUT HE'S A CASE THAT IN THE

01:13 - 37.780 FIRST CIRCUIT OF US TO NOT MAKE

01:13 - 38.890 OUR PRIEST BECAUSE IT WAS TO

01:13 - 39.910 JUST DECIDED

01:13 - 41.780 IN JUNE. BUT IT'S A TOWN OF

01:13 - 43.170 WEYMOUTH VERSUS MASSACHUSETTS

01:13 - 46.210 TPP IT'S A NIGHT 61 ALL FEDERAL

01:13 - 49.520 3RD 34. IN IN THE NEXT CASE,

01:13 - 51.950 MASSACHUSETTS TVP ISSUED A PLAN

01:13 - 53.060 APPROVAL FOR A COMPRESSOR

01:13 - 55.340 STATION IN ON MINOR SOURCE,

01:13 - 56.680 THAT'S A CHOOSES AS ITS HAS A

01:13 - 58.160 SIMILAR THEIR PERMANENT

01:13 - 59.590 STRUCTURE AS PENNSYLVANIA.

01:14 - 02.200 IN THAT CASE, THE FIRST CIRCUIT

01:14 - 04.400 SAID WHAT BUT BASED ON ON THE

01:14 - 05.720 OBJECTIONS BY BY THE

01:14 - 06.760 PETITIONERS I DON'T THINK

01:14 - 07.810 THERE'S ENOUGH EVIDENCE IN THE

01:14 - 09.060 RECORD AND THEY SENT THE

01:14 - 11.160 CASE BACK TO MASSACHUSETTS TO

01:14 - 12.430 BP TO MAKE A DECISION WITHIN

01:14 - 13.760 75 DAYS.

01:14 - 15.050 >>BUT THROUGHOUT THE TRUSTING

01:14 - 16.130 THAT YOUR POCKET, BUT LET'S

01:14 - 17.600 TAKE BACK TO WORK TAKE THAT

01:14 - 19.780 FORWARD TO IT BUT THEY WEEKEND

01:14 - 21.120 DIRECTLY OUT WHICH WILL WE

01:14 - 22.450 DON'T DO IT THE LESS THEY WE

01:14 - 23.560 AGREE WITH YOU AND IT DOESN'T

01:14 - 24.580 GO THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING

01:14 - 26.450 BOARD AND THEY GO TO THE 3RD

01:14 - 30.370 CIRCUIT AND THEY ARGUE EXACTLY.

01:14 - 32.950 WE HAVE ISSUES HERE JUDGE IS

01:14 - 34.340 THE 3RD CIRCUIT THAT YOU CAN'T

01:14 - 35.650 BUY BECAUSE THERE'S NO RECORD

01:14 - 37.110 HERE ADEQUATE THAT WE PRESENTED

01:14 - 38.350 WE NEED TO PRESENT EVIDENCE WE

01:14 - 40.210 CAN WE YOU CAN'T DECIDE AN

01:14 - 41.840 ISSUE IN THE 3RD CIRCUIT THAT

01:14 - 43.000 YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY LIKE WE'RE

01:14 - 43.900 STANDING AT THE BACK.

01:14 - 46.940 KRAFT WE CAN'T REALLY SEND IT

01:14 - 48.490 BACK BECAUSE THEY CAME DIRECTLY

01:14 - 50.050 FROM THE BP THAT HAS NO HEARING

01:14 - 51.140 AUTHORITY THEY CAN HEAR IT

01:14 - 52.240 COULD BE PEOPLE TO CREATE A

01:14 - 54.130 RECORD THOUGH DO THEY TENDED TO

01:14 - 55.010 THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING

01:14 - 55.380 BOARD.

01:14 - 57.450 >>THAT THEY WOULD SEND IT RIGHT

01:14 - 00.380 BACK TO D C. YOU HAVE TO BE

01:15 - 01.150 CREATED A RECORD.

01:15 - 02.780 >>BP HAS NO POWER TO CREATE

01:15 - 03.240 A RECORD.

01:15 - 06.080 >>THE DPP CREATES A SIGNIFICANT

01:15 - 07.190 RECORD IN THIS CASE.

01:15 - 09.690 >>NOT NOT NOT A RECORD IN TERMS

01:15 - 10.950 OF AN EVIDENTIARY RECORD.

01:15 - 13.250 >>IT'S NOT WHY YOU GET HOME

01:15 - 13.710 RECORD.

01:15 - 17.510 ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW RECORDS.

01:15 - 20.290 >>IF YOU LOOK AT THE PROCESS

01:15 - 21.770 ARE PLAYED OUT IN ALL 5 HERE

01:15 - 24.500 IN CASES. DR. THAT THE EPA

01:15 - 26.300 CERTIFIED A RECORD OF THAT WAS

01:15 - 28.000 SOW SONS OF PAGES LONG BASED ON

01:15 - 29.500 PUBLIC COMMENTS AND AN AGENCY

01:15 - 31.220 REVIEW AND ON TOP OF THAT LET

01:15 - 32.630 ME BE CLEAR IT'S NOT JUST THE

01:15 - 34.130 PIECE RECORD. IT IS ALSO THE

01:15 - 36.570 FOR. UNDER THE NATURAL GAS

01:15 - 38.330 ACTUALLY ASKED TO CERTIFY ITS

01:15 - 39.930 RECORD TO THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:15 - 42.670 AS WELL AND IN A CASE LIKE THIS

01:15 - 44.290 IN WHICH TO SHARES OF ALSO

01:15 - 46.790 INTERVIEW WITH FOR THERE ARE

01:15 - 48.530 ISSUES I ARGUMENTS TOUGHER CALL

01:15 - 50.030 BEFORE THE COURT AS WELL.

01:15 - 55.080 >>BETWEEN THE

01:15 - 58.680 P A AND B FATE BEEN A TRUE THEY

01:15 - 58.870 DIDN'T

01:15 - 01.090 AND I THINK ONE KIND OF DRAFT

01:16 - 02.730 OR THE NATURAL GAS FACT THEY

01:16 - 04.010 WERE THINKING MORE IN TERMS OF

01:16 - 04.720 THE A P A

01:16 - 07.260 IT DOES

01:16 - 10.200 A COURT TO

01:16 - 12.820 IN A CRATE OF RECORDS THAT ARE

01:16 - 15.320 NOT MADE BEFORE A HEARING

01:16 - 17.560 BEFORE I BOUGHT BY JUDICIAL

01:16 - 18.130 RIGHT BILL.

01:16 - 19.890 >>LET ME WIN.

01:16 - 23.020 THE QUESTION THIS WAY THAT

01:16 - 23.770 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S LEAD

01:16 - 24.970 ATTORNEY. THE B

01:16 - 26.660 IN THIS CONTEXT, A PLAN

01:16 - 28.680 APPROVALS IN THE 50 P HAD NEVER

01:16 - 30.350 ADOPTED A STATE IMPLICATION

01:16 - 32.070 PLAN. WHAT YOU HAVE TO BE

01:16 - 33.790 FEDERAL ISSUANCE OF UP

01:16 - 35.840 PERMITS AND IF YOU LOOK TO THE

01:16 - 37.850 THE CLEAN AIR ACT. BUT

01:16 - 40.520 THOSE PERMITS IF THEY GO WITH A

01:16 - 41.880 DIRECT APPEAL TO THE CIRCUIT

01:16 - 43.740 COURT OF APPEALS AND

01:16 - 45.640 SO THAT THE NATURAL GAS

01:16 - 46.830 ACT IF YOU LOOK AT THE

01:16 - 47.450 PROVISIONS OF THE

01:16 - 49.640 JURISDICTIONAL ISSUES IT IS

01:16 - 51.680 DECIDING QUESTIONS WITH RESPECT

01:16 - 52.630 TO WHETHER OR NOT IT IS

01:16 - 54.940 INSISTENT WITH THE FEDERAL LAW

01:16 - 57.070 GOVERNING THOSE PERMITS SUGGEST

01:16 - 58.220 AS JUDGE HARDIMAN SAID IN THE

01:16 - 00.340 3RD CIRCUIT AND SYLVANIA CANNOT

01:17 - 02.390 DECLARE WHEN IT ISSUES

01:17 - 03.770 SUFFICIENTLY FINAL FEDERAL

01:17 - 05.540 REVIEW, THE SAME THING IS HERE

01:17 - 06.960 WE HAVE FEDERAL CONTROL BECAUSE

01:17 - 08.210 OF SCHNEIDER WHEN I'M IN ONE OF

01:17 - 09.330 CASES FROM THE U.S. SUPREME

01:17 - 10.730 COURT WHICH IS THAT WE HAVE AN

01:17 - 12.300 ADMINISTRATIVE SCHEME. THE

01:17 - 14.140 NATURAL GAS ACT THAT PREEMPTS

01:17 - 17.220 THAT STATE. MINISTRY REVIEW

01:17 - 18.470 AFTER THE AGENCY MAKES ITS

01:17 - 18.870 DECISION.

01:17 - 22.530 >>I THINK THAT YOU KEEP

01:17 - 23.260 REFERRING TO THE

01:17 - 25.450 FIRST CIRCUIT COURT CASES AS

01:17 - 27.110 OPPOSED TO RELYING ON BOARD AND

01:17 - 28.970 COUNTY REALLY I BELIEVE NEED TO

01:17 - 30.740 BE FOCUSING ON WHAT THE 3RD

01:17 - 32.380 CIRCUIT. THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:17 - 34.580 BELIEVE HOW IT SHOULD PROCEED.

01:17 - 35.960 AND IT APPEARS TO ME

01:17 - 38.430 IN BORDENTOWN THAT THE COURT

01:17 - 40.240 CONTINUED TO DATE ON THAT

01:17 - 42.960 THE PARTY IF IF DESIRED THEM

01:17 - 43.900 WE'RE NOT GOING TO GET INTO

01:17 - 45.030 WHETHER OR NOT GOING TO GET

01:17 - 46.530 OVER THAT THE AGE

01:17 - 48.900 BE BUT HAS THE RIGHT TO FULLY

01:17 - 50.470 UTILIZE THE ADMINISTRATIVE

01:17 - 52.380 PROCESS SET FORTH IN THE

01:17 - 53.280 PARTICULAR STATE.

01:17 - 56.520 I'M KIND OF A LOT OF WHY YOU

01:17 - 58.540 KEEP TO THE FIRST CIRCUIT WHEN

01:17 - 59.660 IT APPEARED THAT THE 3RD

01:17 - 00.660 CIRCUIT IS BROKEN.

01:18 - 02.970 >>I BELIEVE THAT THAT THE

01:18 - 04.020 CHURCH HAS SPOKEN.

01:18 - 05.960 IN IN OUR BRIEF SITES TO THE

01:18 - 08.330 3RD I REFERENCE THE FIRST

01:18 - 09.580 CIRCUIT BECAUSE WE HAVE IT

01:18 - 11.670 THE DECISION OUT OF HER CHILD

01:18 - 13.430 WHICH I THINK IT'S JUST A GAFFE

01:18 - 15.350 THAT JET COUNCIL BLASI

01:18 - 17.280 AS RAYS. BUT ALSO WE HAVE A

01:18 - 18.870 DECISION JUST 2 MONTHS AGO THAT

01:18 - 20.420 DEALS WITH AN ALMOST IDENTICAL

01:18 - 23.350 TYPOS ISSUANCE OF A PERMIT THAT

01:18 - 24.920 PLAN APPROVAL IN MASSACHUSETTS

01:18 - 26.360 OR PRESSURE STATION ASSOCIATE

01:18 - 27.510 WITH THAT PROJECT.

01:18 - 29.650 THESE ISSUES ARE BEING DECIDED

01:18 - 30.640 BY THE FEDERAL COURTS IN THE

01:18 - 31.500 FEDERAL COURTS ARE HAPPY

01:18 - 33.440 NO ISSUE TAKING JURISDICTION

01:18 - 35.650 OVER THIS AND POINTING OUT IT

01:18 - 37.030 REALLY WHERE THE STATE FOR A

01:18 - 37.950 FEW VOTES.

01:18 - 49.360 >>GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR MAY

01:18 - 50.280 HAVE TO USE THE COURT.

01:18 - 52.300 MY NAME IS JESSICA HUNT AND I

01:18 - 53.430 REPRESENT PENNSYLVANIA

01:18 - 54.660 DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL

01:18 - 57.090 PROTECTION. CONGRESS AND THE

01:18 - 58.100 NATIONAL GAS TAX

01:18 - 00.120 BECAUSE CIRCUIT COURT EXCLUSIVE

01:19 - 01.750 AND ORIGINAL JURISDICTION OVER

01:19 - 02.170 CASES

01:19 - 04.540 LIKE THIS. A LINE TO BE DRAWN

01:19 - 05.900 SOMEWHERE OVER THE SUPREME

01:19 - 06.920 COURT'S JURISDICTION OF

01:19 - 07.540 CAPTIVES.

01:19 - 10.370 IT HAS DRAWN THAT LINE AT THAT

01:19 - 12.840 POINT THE MEDIAN PENNSYLVANIA'S

01:19 - 19.030 COURT FOLLOWED IT'S COMMON

01:19 - 20.570 SENSE APPROACH WHICH SHE IS

01:19 - 22.460 CONGRESS'S GOALS AND AMENDING

01:19 - 24.350 THE ACT IT WAS MUCH MORE

01:19 - 25.740 CONSISTENT JUDICIAL PEOPLE.

01:19 - 29.100 AND WHOSE STUDENTS O'CONNOR AND

01:19 - 30.750 TO FIND A DIFFERENT PART

01:19 - 31.280 POWDER.

01:19 - 33.260 >>HOW DOES GOING THROUGH THE

01:19 - 34.820 ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING PROCESS

01:19 - 36.460 AFFECTED ALL 3RD CIRCUIT

01:19 - 39.010 ABILITY TO ENSURE CONSISTENCY.

01:19 - 44.830 >>THE 3RD CIRCUIT THAT

01:19 - 47.410 CONCLUSIVELY HEALTH. IN

01:19 - 48.700 ADDITION AS CAN FILE AN APPEAL

01:19 - 50.890 DIRECTLY TO IT AND SO THEN THE

01:19 - 52.680 QUESTION BECOMES CAN ALSO FILE

01:19 - 55.060 I KNOW FOR THE H B AND THEY

01:19 - 55.820 THINK IF YOU

01:19 - 58.730 ALLOW PETITIONERS TO CHOOSE FOR

01:19 - 00.010 YOUR PUTTING THE DEPARTMENT AND

01:20 - 01.440 THE DECISION WHERE YOU

01:20 - 03.330 CAN ACHIEVE THE SAME FOR WITH

01:20 - 04.940 INCONSISTENT RESULTS FOR THE

01:20 - 07.970 GUEST HOUSE. I THINK IN

01:20 - 08.530 ADDITION

01:20 - 08.990 TO THAT.

01:20 - 10.540 >>IF YOU MEAN IF YOU HAVE THE

01:20 - 11.880 SAME ISSUE THAT GOES DIRECTLY

01:20 - 13.190 TO THE CIRCUIT VERSUS THE ISSUE

01:20 - 13.700 COMING THROUGH THE

01:20 - 14.780 ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD.

01:20 - 17.590 >>MARY

01:20 - 20.610 >>BUT ULTIMATELY YOU CAN GO TO

01:20 - 21.290 THE CIRCUIT FROM THE

01:20 - 22.360 ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

01:20 - 23.860 THOUGH IT COULD END UP

01:20 - 25.350 IN THAT THEY'RE ABOUT TO

01:20 - 26.800 CONSISTENTLY CHECK RIGHT THERE.

01:20 - 28.970 >>IN ADDITION TO THAT

01:20 - 29.250 YOU'RE ON

01:20 - 31.410 FOR THE 3RD CIRCUIT PROVE YOU

01:20 - 34.330 WOULD THEN TH BE A DECISION ON

01:20 - 34.750 THE PART.

01:20 - 37.330 >>I UNDERSTAND THAT I

01:20 - 38.640 UNDERSTAND THAT CONCERNING

01:20 - 39.500 HAVING I HOPE

01:20 - 41.510 I SPENT 2 YEARS IN CONSHOHOCKEN

01:20 - 42.860 OR 2 WEEKS IN CONSHOHOCKEN

01:20 - 44.090 DOING IN A HEARING UP ON A

01:20 - 45.520 TRASH TRANSFER STATION SO I

01:20 - 46.590 KNOW HOW ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING

01:20 - 47.610 BOARD CAPE THE CONTRACT

01:20 - 48.360 COMPLICATED.

01:20 - 52.960 BUT. IF THEY CAN IMPORT PROCESS

01:20 - 53.060 WHEN

01:20 - 55.680 YOU HAVE IF YOU HAVE TO CREATE

01:20 - 56.970 A RECORD I'M STRUGGLING WITH

01:20 - 59.600 THIS RECORD IDEA THAT IT SEEMS

01:20 - 00.560 TO ME WHAT YOU'RE SAYING THE

01:21 - 02.550 TIME IS BOY WOULD BE GREAT FOR

01:21 - 03.570 THE DEPARTMENT WE DIDN'T HAVE

01:21 - 05.110 TO DEFEND OUR PERMIT DECISIONS

01:21 - 06.080 IN FRONT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL

01:21 - 07.060 HEARING BOARD AND WE DIDN'T

01:21 - 08.440 TAKE OUR RECORD THAT WE

01:21 - 09.530 COMPLETELY CONTROLLED IN

01:21 - 11.030 CREATED AND PUT IT UP IN FRONT

01:21 - 12.190 OF A TURKIC TO DEFEND OUR

01:21 - 13.040 PERMIT DECISION.

01:21 - 16.130 >>NO YOUR HONOR I THINK THAT

01:21 - 17.880 WELL CERTAINLY IF THE HARTMAN

01:21 - 18.830 FIRST OF ALL THE DELAWARE

01:21 - 20.260 RIVERKEEPER IS DUE TO

01:21 - 22.780 THE POSITION IF HE WOULD HAVE

01:21 - 23.870 JURISDICTION AND THE 3RD

01:21 - 25.530 CIRCUIT REPEATEDLY POKED FUN

01:21 - 27.170 THAT WE WERE WRONG AND

01:21 - 27.840 SO NOW.

01:21 - 29.810 >>WELL I FORGOT THAT NEED TO BE

01:21 - 31.610 CONFLICT WHAT BORDENTOWN BANK

01:21 - 33.010 NOW BEING MADE A 3RD CIRCUIT

01:21 - 35.810 MIGHT BE RETHINKING RETHINKING

01:21 - 37.010 THAT A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE

01:21 - 39.480 BECAUSE PERHAPS THEY DIDN'T

01:21 - 41.680 APPRECIATE THE UNIQUE

01:21 - 43.440 DUAL NATURE THAT WE HAVE A

01:21 - 45.610 SEPARATION OF THE ADJUDICATOR

01:21 - 45.900 FROM

01:21 - 48.550 THE REGULATOR. PROBABLY OF YOUR

01:21 - 49.830 TRADE THE HISTORY BACK ABOUT

01:21 - 51.250 WHY THAT HAPPENED WITH COLLIER

01:21 - 52.400 SOMETHING TO DO WITH WINE AND

01:21 - 53.180 EVERY TIME EVERY

01:21 - 55.510 EVERY TIME. EVERY EVERY KIND OF

01:21 - 56.770 THE SEPARATION YOU GET OKAY TO

01:21 - 57.870 POWER UP AND READY FOR A CAR

01:21 - 58.750 YOU THINK LINEUP.

01:21 - 00.850 SO MAYBE THEY'RE THINKING ABOUT

01:22 - 02.180 GETTING A BETTER APPRECIATION

01:22 - 03.970 OF THE DOOR THE SEPARATION

01:22 - 05.780 WE'VE CREATED BUT I GO BACK TO

01:22 - 06.690 THE POINT IT.

01:22 - 08.490 I CAN SEE WHY THE DEPARTMENT

01:22 - 09.700 WOULD LIKE DIRECTOR CIRCLE

01:22 - 11.430 REVIEW REVIEW THE RECORD YOU

01:22 - 12.770 CREATED THAT YOU CONTROL.

01:22 - 15.080 >>BUT CERTAINLY I MEAN AT THE

01:22 - 15.920 END OF THE DAY AT THE END OF

01:22 - 17.220 THE DAY YOU'RE DEFENDING YOUR

01:22 - 18.720 PERMITTING DECISIONS SO GOSH

01:22 - 19.860 WHEN THAT BE GREAT IF THE PARTY

01:22 - 21.130 WHO MADE THE PERMITTING

01:22 - 22.500 DIVISION CREATED

01:22 - 24.970 THE RECORD GOT TO USE THAT HOME

01:22 - 26.230 BASE WHEN THEY GOT TO THE 3RD

01:22 - 27.670 CIRCUIT IN THAT ATTEMPTING THE

01:22 - 29.510 RECORD A GET THAT ANSWER ABOUT

01:22 - 30.360 THE ME HB.

01:22 - 34.750 >>THE PINK RATING RECORD

01:22 - 36.830 INCLUDING OUR IN THE HOUSE WAS

01:22 - 38.760 LIKE YOU KNOW BACK. THE

01:22 - 40.590 DEPARTMENT DOES CREATE A RECORD

01:22 - 41.430 RELATED TO

01:22 - 44.310 WHAT RESPONSE. IT USED TO TAKE

01:22 - 46.200 AND IT THAT RECRUIT THAT

01:22 - 48.250 ULTIMATELY YOU SO

01:22 - 50.010 THE CRIME IS THAT THE CREATIVE

01:22 - 51.780 A RECORD IS INCOMPLETE LARGE.

01:22 - 54.380 IT IS THAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

01:22 - 56.360 ABOUT A ABOUT BUT IF

01:22 - 57.860 INVESTIGATIVE RECORD.

01:22 - 00.140 >>IF IF IF THE DEPARTMENT

01:23 - 01.300 INVESTIGATE CREATING AN

01:23 - 02.420 INVESTIGATIVE WRECK TO

01:23 - 03.510 DETERMINE WHETHER IT'S GOING TO

01:23 - 04.960 GRANT A CERTAIN APPROVAL OR NOT

01:23 - 06.310 YOU'RE IN COMPLETE CONTROL OF

01:23 - 07.150 YOU TO FIGHT.

01:23 - 08.430 >>WHAT'S GOING TO BE IN THE

01:23 - 09.030 RECORD YOU

01:23 - 13.100 NOTIFICATION REQUIREMENTS AND

01:23 - 14.560 PUBLIC COMMENT BUT IT'S BEEN A

01:23 - 15.890 RECORD THAT DRIVEN BY WHAT THE

01:23 - 16.730 DEPARTMENT WHY

01:23 - 18.450 MISTER BACA QUITE CAN'T EVEN

01:23 - 19.550 REALLY OTHER THAN OTHER THAN

01:23 - 20.690 SENDING IN WHAT

01:23 - 22.370 THEY HAVE 5 REQUIRE DEFENDED

01:23 - 23.220 THE PURPOSE OF GETTING

01:23 - 25.270 APPROVAL, HE CAN'T CONTROL WHAT

01:23 - 25.770 YOU PUT IN

01:23 - 28.050 BACK RECORD. SO YEAH YOU GET

01:23 - 29.100 THE PACK YOUR OWN RECORD YOU

01:23 - 30.220 HAVE TO WRAP YOUR PRESENT AND

01:23 - 31.230 THEN YOU GET THE OPEN UP IN THE

01:23 - 31.810 3RD CIRCUIT.

01:23 - 34.230 >>IT'S CERTAINLY A PETITIONER

01:23 - 35.490 HAS WORKED AT FILE AN APPEAL

01:23 - 37.100 BEFORE THE 3RD CIRCUIT. THEY

01:23 - 38.470 WOULD HAVE THE ABILITY TO SAY

01:23 - 38.600 THAT.

01:23 - 43.410 AND THEN WHERE WOULD IT GO.

01:23 - 47.430 THAT WOULD GO BACK TO

01:23 - 50.510 D P. TO YOU YOU HAVE NO POWER

01:23 - 51.910 TO CREATE YOU HAVE NO POWER TO

01:23 - 53.290 CREATE A RECORD BACK TO THAT

01:23 - 53.560 POINT.

01:23 - 55.300 >>IF YOU HAVE YOUR OWN PROBLEM.

01:23 - 59.810 >>I THINK THE PRESIDENT HAS OF

01:23 - 01.260 A NEW CREATION OF THE HOSPITAL

01:24 - 03.350 RECORD IS IT JUST THAT WE WOULD

01:24 - 04.750 HAVE THE POWER TO GO BACK.

01:24 - 08.220 WHAT THE DEPARTMENT DID AND WHY

01:24 - 09.360 THE DEPARTMENT DID WHAT IT DID

01:24 - 10.320 TO WHAT THE DEPARTMENT HAS

01:24 - 12.570 BEFORE ULTIMATELY IT WOULD GO

01:24 - 13.680 BACK TO HURT HER.

01:24 - 16.610 >>THEREFORE YOU GET TO PUT IN

01:24 - 18.570 THERE WHATEVER YOU DESIRE AND I

01:24 - 19.680 KNOW JOE BROUGHT THEM TO THE

01:24 - 21.360 MIKE TO PROCESS TO TALK ABOUT

01:24 - 23.750 TODAY BUT IT COMES BACK TO

01:24 - 25.620 IT DOESN'T THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:24 - 26.990 CAN'T BE CREATING THE RECORD

01:24 - 28.240 THEY WANT TO REVIEW ALL THE

01:24 - 29.490 INFORMATION IS THAT THE WHOLE

01:24 - 30.120 PURPOSE OF THE

01:24 - 31.730 JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND THE

01:24 - 33.590 APPELLATE COURT TO REVIEW WHAT

01:24 - 34.760 TRANSPIRED SO THEY

01:24 - 36.490 CAN MAKE THE BEST POSSIBLE

01:24 - 37.950 DECISION WITH ALL OF THE

01:24 - 40.080 RELEVANT INFORMATION WITH THEY

01:24 - 41.840 DON'T CURRENTLY HAVE THOUGH

01:24 - 44.670 BY SAYING AYE. GO AHEAD TO THE

01:24 - 46.470 3RD CIRCUIT. THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:24 - 47.520 PANTHER TIE

01:24 - 49.380 AND YOU ALL WANT THIS TO

01:24 - 51.060 PROCEED EXPEDITIOUSLY WITH A

01:24 - 52.430 NEW FAN A CHANCE OF IT ALL

01:24 - 54.680 BEING SENT BACK DOWN AGAIN AND

01:24 - 56.830 I DON'T SEE BORDENTOWN WITH

01:24 - 58.440 CONTRADICT A STATEMENT THAT

01:24 - 00.750 EVERY DAY TO BE ABLE TO FULFILL

01:25 - 03.120 THEIR ADMINISTRATOR. REMEDY

01:25 - 04.820 THEIR PROCESS AND ALLOW THAT TO

01:25 - 06.360 GO FORWARD AND THE 3RD CIRCUIT

01:25 - 07.390 REVIEW, EVERYTHING.

01:25 - 11.220 >>I THINK THAT IF THE ECB WERE

01:25 - 13.220 TO RENDER A DECISION ON.

01:25 - 15.710 AND ULTIMATELY GO FOR IT ON

01:25 - 17.690 LIKE 50'S AFFORDABLE HEALTH IT

01:25 - 18.960 JUST POURED IT ALREADY POINTED

01:25 - 19.790 OUT IS DIFFERENT

01:25 - 21.370 FROM ALL THE ADMINISTRATIVE

01:25 - 22.990 OFFICE OF PENNSYLVANIA. IT

01:25 - 24.420 WOULD BE BASED ON MAN IT WOULD

01:25 - 25.850 BE BASED ON ITS APPELLATE

01:25 - 27.340 COURT. IF YOU AND THAT WILL BE

01:25 - 29.510 REVIEWING THE KIDS HIS DECISION

01:25 - 31.190 NOT THE DECISION OF THE HEATED

01:25 - 32.890 ISSUE A PERMIT. IT WAS THE

01:25 - 35.690 INTENT BEHIND CREATING SECTION

01:25 - 37.950 7.17 ARE AND I UNDERSTAND

01:25 - 39.140 YOU'RE ALWAYS CONCERNED ABOUT

01:25 - 42.510 DUE PROCESS. HEY LET ME.

01:25 - 44.040 >>LET ME JUST FOLLOW UP ON THAT

01:25 - 46.190 YOU MADE THAT POINT SEVERAL

01:25 - 46.820 TIMES THAT.

01:25 - 50.990 THAT'S GOING TO BE REVIEWED

01:25 - 53.340 BY THE 3RD CIRCUIT IN BP FACT

01:25 - 54.800 AND NOT THE ENVIRONMENTAL

01:25 - 55.560 HEARING BOARD.

01:25 - 59.810 OR ARE YOU SAYING THAT BE

01:26 - 02.550 >>IT MAY BE MAY.

01:26 - 05.300 WHAT HAPPENED AT THE AGE WE

01:26 - 08.980 RULE AGAIN, THE CASE. NORMALLY

01:26 - 09.980 YOU WOULD APPEAL THE.

01:26 - 13.930 WHAT WOULD YOU

01:26 - 15.960 DO THEM BE ABLE TO HURT HER.

01:26 - 18.220 >>I BELIEVE SO

01:26 - 19.480 YOU'RE ON BASED UPON THE

01:26 - 21.410 CURRENT PRESIDENT HAS BEEN OUT

01:26 - 22.590 THERE THAT WE WOULD END

01:26 - 24.510 UP BEFORE THE 3RD CIRCUIT AND

01:26 - 26.300 THEN AT THAT POINT IT WOULD BE

01:26 - 27.810 THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD.

01:26 - 29.520 IT'S YOU THAT WILL

01:26 - 32.080 BE CREATED THESE LIGHTS FOR YOU

01:26 - 34.060 TRY THE RECORD.

01:26 - 36.260 >>HOWEVER YOU GET A FAIR.

01:26 - 38.310 HER CASE WOULD BE THE RECORD

01:26 - 40.010 BEFORE THAT YOU CREATE WHICH

01:26 - 41.160 COULD BE LARGER.

01:26 - 44.150 AND E P A MINUTE BREAK

01:26 - 46.530 A RECORD. BUT YOU'RE PAYING

01:26 - 48.590 YOU COULD APPEAL AN ADVERSE

01:26 - 50.400 RULING OUT THE 8 FEET TO THE

01:26 - 51.120 3RD CIRCUIT.

01:26 - 56.830 >>I BELIEVE THAT WE COULD BASED

01:26 - 57.750 ON BORDENTOWN.

01:26 - 59.680 AND I THINK THAT YOU KNOW FOR

01:26 - 01.130 COUNTING THE COST OF MANY OF

01:27 - 03.840 THE $2 RIVERKEEPER 3 IT

01:27 - 07.790 IS IMPORTANT. HE WAS YOU ONE

01:27 - 09.630 DAY FOR HELP TO FIND THEIR

01:27 - 09.850 DAUGHTER.

01:27 - 13.090 YOU KNOW 30 OR HIGHER.

01:27 - 15.010 EXHAUSTIVELY REVIEWED

01:27 - 16.710 PENNSYLVANIA SCHEME THAT TERM

01:27 - 18.720 AND BET IT DOES MATTER OUR

01:27 - 19.860 PURPOSE OF A SETUP.

01:27 - 21.760 I DON'T KNOW REVIEW IS

01:27 - 22.950 INCREDIBLE TO D

01:27 - 26.070 C S OR EXIT ORANGE FOR AGENCY

01:27 - 28.850 REVIEW. I THINK THAT IT'S CLEAR

01:27 - 29.440 HERE

01:27 - 31.710 ARE BASED. HE ENVIRONMENTAL

01:27 - 33.280 HEARING BOARD 8 SUMMIT MINISTRY

01:27 - 35.920 TO SEPARATE ADMINISTRATIVE IT

01:27 - 37.950 AND THAT DISTINCTION DOES

01:27 - 39.890 MATTER. I THINK IN THE MIDDLE

01:27 - 41.340 DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

01:27 - 43.450 INTERVIEW PENNSYLVANIA'S

01:27 - 44.670 ADMINISTRATIVE SCHEME AND

01:27 - 46.240 ULTIMATELY IN THE BACK

01:27 - 49.100 IT IS THEY DETERMINED IT WAS A

01:27 - 50.270 TENNIS YOU GET A LIFE.

01:27 - 52.900 THERE WAS NO ROOM FOR

01:27 - 54.390 THAT YOU NEED TO QUICKLY TOUCH

01:27 - 56.140 WITH YOU FOR THE FEELS IT'S THE

01:27 - 58.420 3RD CIRCUIT BASED ON HOW LIVING

01:27 - 00.640 IN THE STREETS IN IT'S SET UP.

01:28 - 04.450 3RD CIRCUIT HAS AN ADDITIONAL

01:28 - 07.810 OPPORTUNITY IN AUGUST OF 2019.

01:28 - 11.730 TO BE AN AUGUST OF 2000 A 3RD

01:28 - 13.110 CIRCUIT. THE ARGUMENT WAS

01:28 - 13.620 RAISED.

01:28 - 18.710 IT JUST SHOULD HAVE AN

01:28 - 20.270 OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO THE AGE

01:28 - 22.530 YOU FIRST FOR IT, THEY

01:28 - 23.980 ULTIMATELY TOOK AN APPEAL TO

01:28 - 26.470 CIRCUIT AND THE 3RD CIRCUIT AND

01:28 - 28.690 THAT WAS WRONG. AND YOU GET

01:28 - 30.970 DOWN TO THE 50'S OVER THE

01:28 - 33.680 FIELD. AND SO I THINK THAT.

01:28 - 37.640 ESPECIALLY IN

01:28 - 39.320 LIGHT OF THE NEW JERSEY ITS OWN

01:28 - 40.740 MILLION AHEAD OF NEW JERSEY

01:28 - 42.490 THAT WOULD MAKE THE DECISION

01:28 - 43.760 NOT. AND

01:28 - 46.180 IN PENNSYLVANIA. IF YOU OR I.

01:28 - 47.560 >>I WANT TO ASK YOU A PRETTY

01:28 - 49.580 BASIC QUESTION. WHAT HAPPENED

01:28 - 51.010 WHAT CAN I DO IF I DIDN'T AGREE

01:28 - 51.820 WITH THE 3RD CIRCUIT.

01:28 - 00.630 >>I THINK IF YOU DISAGREE WITH

01:29 - 01.500 THE 3RD CIRCUIT.

01:29 - 05.360 YEAH THIS PORT HOLES COVER IT

01:29 - 08.460 DOES HIM. I THINK ALL THE

01:29 - 08.870 OTHER.

01:29 - 19.140 3RD CIRCUIT DECISION. I THINK

01:29 - 20.260 THAT THE PURPOSE AND INTENT

01:29 - 21.000 BEHIND NOT

01:29 - 22.860 FAST FACTS. THE SPECIFICALLY TO

01:29 - 24.280 TRY TO AVOID SITUATIONS LIKE

01:29 - 25.460 THIS ONE WHERE YOU'RE GOING TO

01:29 - 27.100 BE PEAKING JURISDICTIONS IN

01:29 - 29.020 COMPETING DECISIONS ON THE SAME

01:29 - 31.390 ISSUE AND I THINK IS LIKELY WHY

01:29 - 32.370 CONGRESSMAN DID NOT.

01:29 - 36.700 >>I JUST HAVE ONE FINAL

01:29 - 38.370 QUESTION, I'M SORRY, I KNOW YOU

01:29 - 40.050 WILL OF YOUR TIME, BUT THE

01:29 - 42.200 NOTION OF THE CIVIL ACTION.

01:29 - 43.910 HOW WOULD.

01:29 - 48.230 >>HOW DO YOU ADDRESS

01:29 - 50.260 THE ARGUMENTS THAT THE

01:29 - 51.440 PETITIONERS OF

01:29 - 53.130 MADE HERE WITH REGARD TO THE

01:29 - 54.960 DEFINITION OF A CIVIL ACTION.

01:29 - 01.360 >>REALLY I THINK THE IMPORTANT

01:30 - 03.190 HOW THE SEIZURE. THE CLAIM TO

01:30 - 04.620 THE NOT ABOUT THAT THAT'S

01:30 - 07.350 REALLY WHO LIKE THIS AND SO

01:30 - 09.910 ULTIMATELY IT'S IS THE DECISION

01:30 - 11.300 WHY OR WHAT POINT DOES A

01:30 - 13.130 DECISION BECOME RIGHT. OUR 3RD

01:30 - 16.170 CIRCUIT IF YOU AND SO I PUT

01:30 - 18.450 IT BACK, YOU KNOW THE LANGUAGE

01:30 - 19.950 WHICH THE WHOLE IMPORTANT HOW

01:30 - 21.770 WAS LIMITED TO INTERAGENCY

01:30 - 22.320 REVIEW.

01:30 - 26.780 THE LANGUAGE IN THE PAST.

01:30 - 29.650 ALSO THE BOARD ON THIS IS YOU

01:30 - 30.600 KNOW THE NOVEMBER

01:30 - 32.840 4 SESSIONS ALL OF THEM TO GET

01:30 - 34.840 IN PLACE WHICH IS AT WHAT POINT

01:30 - 38.260 3RD CIRCUIT REVIEW AND IN

01:30 - 39.530 PENNSYLVANIA BASED ON THE

01:30 - 41.300 DOLLAR BEFORE HE SAYS.

01:30 - 44.250 AND I STARTED TO USE IT THEY

01:30 - 45.970 SAID THAT IF A COMPLAINT FROM

01:30 - 47.650 3RD CIRCUIT REVIEW. AND THE

01:30 - 48.950 POINT THAT HE CAN TAKE AN

01:30 - 50.150 ACTION WHICH IS DIFFERENT.

01:30 - 52.070 WELL, YOU KNOW IT'S IMPORTANT

01:30 - 53.990 TO HELP AND THEY SAID NO NEW

01:30 - 56.530 JERSEY, HE WORE IT ONLY BECOMES

01:30 - 58.660 FINAL POINT. THERE'S YOU KNOW

01:30 - 01.150 AFTER YOU HAVE MAYBE FOR HIM

01:31 - 02.210 FOR A YEAR.

01:31 - 04.980 AND THE HEAD OF THE HE

01:31 - 08.460 ULTIMATELY. ACTION IT ONLY

01:31 - 08.870 PICKS.

01:31 - 12.000 THE RECOMMENDATIONS PROVIDED TO

01:31 - 13.210 IT BY THE MINISTRY OF ALL.

01:31 - 19.840 IF YOU WANT TO HEAR NOW FROM A

01:31 - 20.870 PARENT, YOU KNOW.

01:31 - 24.160 >>AND REBUTTAL BACK HERE

01:31 - 26.330 I HOPE I CAN GET A LITTLE BIT

01:31 - 28.400 OF LEEWAY ON THE VERY IMPORTANT

01:31 - 29.890 IF THE RIGHT THING I'D LIKE TO

01:31 - 32.700 POINT OUT TO YOU I CAN MAKE IT

01:31 - 34.870 THROUGH WITH MY OPPONENT, THE

01:31 - 37.620 LYING ON. RIVERKEEPER FOREIGN

01:31 - 38.750 RIVERKEEPER 5.

01:31 - 41.550 I KNOW REPORT IT BEFORE WITH ON

01:31 - 42.870 THAT BILL IN THE 3RD CIRCUIT.

01:31 - 44.480 AND I'M PRETTY SURE RIVERKEEPER

01:31 - 46.580 5 WITH ALL THE NONPROFIT, I U

01:31 - 49.380 THE BETTER 5 THERE YOU RELATE

01:31 - 51.300 TO THOSE OPINIONS. ALSO A

01:31 - 53.280 PROBLEM WITH RIVERKEEPER ONE

01:31 - 55.400 THROUGH 3 BASED ON THE IT TOO

01:31 - 58.310 BAD. IF DEVELOP THERAPIES THEM,

01:31 - 59.070 INCLUDING

01:31 - 01.320 BIRTHS ARE THEY'RE BOTH THE 5TH

01:32 - 04.140 AND FAITH ON THE 2006 IF THE

01:32 - 07.290 ISLANDERS BEAT. THEY

01:32 - 08.880 PICKED UP. THERE ARE A VICTIM

01:32 - 10.380 UNDER THE AMENDED NOT ASKED

01:32 - 12.920 BACK. THE PROBLEM WITH IT IS

01:32 - 15.060 BAD. WHAT IS WHAT WE

01:32 - 17.720 LIVE ON THEY PUT MADE AT A

01:32 - 20.260 SYMPOSIUM BY. FOR BAFFERT

01:32 - 23.660 COMPLAINING ABOUT. HE'LL BE ANY

01:32 - 25.420 COMPLAIN ABOUT THE QUEST FOR

01:32 - 27.020 FEEL WHEN I'M IN A BETTER FORM.

01:32 - 29.180 BY

01:32 - 31.530 FEDERAL COURTS AND IN THE

01:32 - 33.820 IN THE THE MIDDLE OF THE DAY

01:32 - 38.200 ONLY REFERENCE THE PROBLEM WITH

01:32 - 40.290 I FEEL FOR THEM IN A FATAL FORM

01:32 - 42.080 THEY LEFT OUT THE REST OF THAT

01:32 - 43.450 STATEMENT BY THE FIRST FACTOR.

01:32 - 47.460 IN FACT THE LEAD PLAINTIFF IF

01:32 - 50.350 PEOPLE ARE RELYING ON. BUT

01:32 - 52.110 CONGRESS ALL THAT AND THOUGH

01:32 - 53.530 THEY CRAFTED THE LANGUAGE.

01:32 - 56.030 ALL 7, 1, 7, ARE HE

01:32 - 59.480 THEY SAY THEIR BELL, THE DOW

01:32 - 00.960 HAPPY A DOUBLE LOCK THEM.

01:33 - 02.630 OKAY THE PEOPLE

01:33 - 05.480 ACT IN IF YOU FIND VERY WELL BY

01:33 - 07.750 WARREN COUNTY COURT AND BY OUR

01:33 - 09.620 ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS. THE

01:33 - 11.250 CLEAN AIR CLEAN WATER. EVEN THE

01:33 - 14.470 A P A BUT IN A COURT. THE BEST

01:33 - 16.620 IN THE COURT. WHAT CONGRESS

01:33 - 19.290 COULD DO. WE TAKE OUT THE NAME

01:33 - 21.490 OF THE FIELD. A BIG COURT IN

01:33 - 23.470 THE FEDERAL COURT IF THAT BOTH

01:33 - 24.370 ARE GOING TO GO TO THE 3RD

01:33 - 26.950 CIRCUIT. THEY SAID NOTHING IN A

01:33 - 28.550 FATAL FORM IF CONGRESS HAD

01:33 - 29.740 WANTED TO DO THAT YOUR HONOR

01:33 - 31.910 THEY WOULD HAVE SAID THEY COULD

01:33 - 32.820 DO GOING BAD.

01:33 - 36.060 ANY APPEAL GO TO 3RD, BUT THEY

01:33 - 37.770 DIDN'T GO OFF IN THE 3RD

01:33 - 40.450 CIRCUIT AND FRANKLY TO TAKE IT

01:33 - 42.400 AWAY. THAT APARTMENT AND

01:33 - 43.710 ADELPHIA WANT TO TAKE IT.

01:33 - 45.590 THEY BELIEVE VIOLATE THE CLEAR

01:33 - 47.260 STATEMENT RULE. THE U.S.

01:33 - 49.060 SUPREME COURT REVERSED THE

01:33 - 49.340 BATH.

01:33 - 53.350 FOR 52 WHERE

01:33 - 55.110 CONGRESS INTEND TO TAKE POWER

01:33 - 57.120 FROM THE STATE IN MARCH TO FILL

01:33 - 58.550 IT WITH THE WEEK. IT DID

01:33 - 00.710 NOT HEAR IT'S NOT THE WAY THEY

01:34 - 03.080 WANT TO BE ON IN POWER.

01:34 - 05.680 A MINUTE LATER THEY DO WITH THE

01:34 - 07.820 STATE. IN THE PROVISION

01:34 - 10.970 OF LAW FRANKLY. I THINK

01:34 - 12.760 THE COURT UNDER THE

01:34 - 14.170 PENNSYLVANIA SUPREME COURT.

01:34 - 17.020 THE THE OKAY FROM THE MILLER

01:34 - 19.580 CASE. I WILL GET PEOPLE FIRED

01:34 - 21.050 THEY FOUND A 5TH OF THEM.

01:34 - 23.660 AGAIN BRIANNA THEM.

01:34 - 28.670 STATE YOUR VICTIM OVER THE

01:34 - 30.930 PEOPLE FEEL THE WE CAN DEVELOP

01:34 - 33.870 THE RECORD. ALL WE BE HEARD

01:34 - 35.860 3RD CIRCUIT. THANK YOU.

01:34 - 48.150 >>THANK YOU AND I'LL TRY

01:34 - 49.380 TO BE QUICK FIRST THE

01:34 - 52.110 PROTEST PROCEEDING IS NOT A DE

01:34 - 53.860 NOVO HEARING WE DON'T HAVE THE

01:34 - 55.540 RIGHT TO CALL AND VERSE

01:34 - 57.260 WITNESSES ETCETERA IT IS

01:34 - 58.750 THE LAB OR RATION OF THE

01:34 - 00.580 ADMINISTRATIVE INTERNAL BE

01:35 - 03.330 ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS. WE

01:35 - 04.970 CONSIDER THIS ART, IT'S NOT A

01:35 - 06.300 SUBSTITUTE FOR BE

01:35 - 09.080 PERCENT ONE. WHO I'D REFER YOU

01:35 - 10.520 TO OUR REPLY BRIEF.

01:35 - 13.440 ON PAGE 3 WERE WE TALK ABOUT

01:35 - 15.050 AGAIN BORDENTOWN BUT.

01:35 - 16.880 THEY'RE CLEARLY

01:35 - 18.960 RECOGNIZING STATE PROCEDURES

01:35 - 20.590 GIVING RISE TO ORDERS

01:35 - 23.840 REVIEWABLE UNDER 17. IT'S 7.17

01:35 - 25.570 ARGUE ONE MAY AND

01:35 - 28.350 UNDOUBTEDLY DO VARY WIDELY FROM

01:35 - 30.060 JURISDICTION TO JURISDICTION.

01:35 - 32.150 THEN IT GOES ON TO SAY AND

01:35 - 33.710 PERHAPS IN RECOGNITION OF

01:35 - 36.380 THIS DIVERSITY. THE ONE MERELY

01:35 - 38.180 ESTABLISHES THAT A PARTY WHO

01:35 - 40.170 SEES JUDICIAL REVIEW TO

01:35 - 42.130 OFFICIAL REVIEW OF THE STATE

01:35 - 44.170 AGENCY DECISION. WHY A

01:35 - 46.030 COLLATERAL CIVIL ACTION.

01:35 - 47.930 WE'RE SEEKING NEITHER WERE

01:35 - 50.570 SHAKING. BE CAUSING

01:35 - 53.090 ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW OF THIS

01:35 - 55.220 NOT IN A CIVIL ACTION AND

01:35 - 58.130 LASTLY THE LAST POINT NO COURT

01:35 - 58.720 SEVERAL

01:35 - 00.710 OR STATE. IT IS COLD AND VERY

01:36 - 02.160 BORED. IT DOES NOT HAVE

01:36 - 04.090 JURISDICTION OVER THIS IT'S

01:36 - 06.610 ASSUMED IT FROM INJURY. AND I

01:36 - 07.910 RESPECTFULLY SUBMIT

01:36 - 10.340 THE DISCORD IT CAN READ ALL

01:36 - 12.530 THAT LAW AND IN COMPLETE GOOD

01:36 - 14.230 FAITH CONCLUDE THE HEARING

01:36 - 15.910 BOARD HAS NOT BEEN DEPRIVED

01:36 - 17.460 JURISDICTION TO HEAR THIS

01:36 - 20.320 US AND THAT CLEANLINESS ISSUES

01:36 - 21.980 CAN BE RESOLVED IN THE FEDERAL

01:36 - 25.280 COURT UNDER. SUBJECTION FREE OF

01:36 - 28.730 1717 OR AND FOR SOME REASON WE

01:36 - 30.780 A NEW MISSION PERFECT ALONG THE

01:36 - 32.340 COAST AND THOSE PROMPTLY.

01:36 - 34.260 BUT UNTIL THAT TIME WE THINK

01:36 - 35.540 THE ENVIRONMENTAL HEARING BOARD

01:36 - 37.210 TO DO THE JOB THE SIDE TO IT BY

01:36 - 38.790 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AND THE

01:36 - 39.990 LAWS OF THE COMMONWEALTH.

01:36 - 40.500 THANK YOU.

01:36 - 43.160 >>FOR ONE QUICK QUESTION

01:36 - 46.930 IN THE PM P H B.

01:36 - 50.570 INTERPRETATION OF WHAT

01:36 - 53.290 THE ACTION. NOT ALLOW US TO

01:36 - 54.550 GIVE THEM SOME.

01:36 - 57.620 BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT ON WHAT

01:36 - 57.790 THEIR

01:36 - 01.030 INTERPRETATION YOU I'M NOT NEW

01:37 - 03.070 TO AGENT WHO'S WILLING TO GIVE

01:37 - 05.390 THEIR POWER AWAY. THEY USUALLY

01:37 - 07.870 COVER THEM. SO IN THIS CASE,

01:37 - 09.670 THEY'RE SITTING HERE TELLING UP

01:37 - 11.230 WITH THEIR INTERPRETATION

01:37 - 12.490 DEPARTMENT AT ANY

01:37 - 15.760 AGE CAN IN THEIR NEW THEY DON'T

01:37 - 16.660 HAVE POWER.

01:37 - 18.210 ESPECIALLY

01:37 - 19.650 THE AGE TO BE YOU COULD YOU

01:37 - 21.810 COULD MAKE THAT A LITTLE BIT P

01:37 - 24.500 P BUT WHY THEIR INTERPRETATION

01:37 - 26.570 NOT VALID OVER YOURS.

01:37 - 30.830 >>IT'S A IT'S A GOOD QUESTION

01:37 - 32.950 AND ONE I STRUGGLE TO ANSWER

01:37 - 34.100 YOUR HONOR I.

01:37 - 38.670 I THINK IT'S BECAUSE.

01:37 - 41.790 BEST OF FAITH AND MOST PEOPLE

01:37 - 43.600 THESE ARE AGENCIES I LOVE AND

01:37 - 45.020 RESPECT AND WORK FOR

01:37 - 48.880 SOMEHOW BELIEVE THAT. THE

01:37 - 49.810 FEDERAL COURT.

01:37 - 53.030 WE'LL PAY A RECORD INCLUDED

01:37 - 54.890 SUFFICIENT FOR PURPOSES OF A

01:37 - 58.150 FEDERAL REVIEW. THERE'S POOLS.

01:37 - 00.990 THE PROCESS WORKS THE

01:38 - 02.850 PETITIONERS OPTION NOT THE

01:38 - 05.090 DEPARTMENT'S OPTION, SOMEHOW

01:38 - 06.360 HAS REMOVED AT A TOURIST

01:38 - 08.450 DICTION I THINK THEY'VE BEEN

01:38 - 10.340 HEARING BOARD AND WHEN YOU

01:38 - 11.770 DON'T HAVE THAT DECISION BACK

01:38 - 13.540 IN 2017 DECIDED

01:38 - 15.790 IT HAD JURISDICTION THAT WENT

01:38 - 18.570 OVER THIS IT WAS RIVERKEEPER 3

01:38 - 20.050 I THINK THAT KIND OF A LOT OF

01:38 - 21.410 TO CONCLUDE WE DON'T HAVE

01:38 - 22.860 JURISDICTION ANYMORE.

01:38 - 25.630 AND IT'S IT'S MIND BOGGLING

01:38 - 28.070 THEY WERE TOLD THEY DIDN'T AND

01:38 - 28.810 I I

01:38 - 31.040 AND THEY ARE AT A CRITICAL PART

01:38 - 32.560 OF CREATING A FOOL

01:38 - 34.550 ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD. SO I

01:38 - 36.960 DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT TO SAY

01:38 - 39.160 OTHER THEM. SOME NOTION OF A

01:38 - 39.880 KIND OF ME.

01:38 - 42.070 JANE WE MIGHT BE DOING ONE

01:38 - 43.760 THING THE FEDERAL COURTS MAY BE

01:38 - 45.700 DOING ANOTHER I I I DON'T

01:38 - 47.720 UNDERSTAND I MUST SAY.

01:38 - 56.780 >>LADIES AND VERY WELL ARGUED

01:38 - 58.220 VERY INTERESTING CASE FROM

01:38 - 00.110 MATIC INCLUDE THE ARGUMENT FROM

01:39 - 02.640 NUMBER WHY PICK FROM 27.

01:39 - 40.910 THE CAPE NUMBER 28 PENNSYLVANIA

01:39 - 43.740 PHYSICAL THERAPY. ASSOCIATION

01:39 - 46.430 PURPOSE C HONORABLE CAROL.

01:39 - 50.120 THE ACTING SECRETARY OF LABOR

01:39 - 50.800 AND INDUSTRY.

01:39 - 52.970 PHYSICAL THERAPY

01:39 - 55.020 ASSOCIATION HELP BALANCE THE

01:39 - 55.910 1920

01:39 - 58.600 17 BEEF CATTLE FOR PHYSICAL

01:39 - 01.010 THERAPY ABOUT SHUN THAT WITH

01:40 - 02.110 THAT BY THE WORKERS

01:40 - 04.710 COMPENSATION HERO. THE BUREAU

01:40 - 06.210 THE FEDERAL DETERMINE THE

01:40 - 07.760 AMOUNT EMPLOYER MONTH

01:40 - 09.560 COMPENSATED PROVIDER FOR

01:40 - 12.100 MEDICAL TREATMENT UNINJURED

01:40 - 14.670 WORKER ON MEDICAL COMPENSATION.

01:40 - 17.350 PRIOR TO 2017 A

01:40 - 19.370 PHYSICAL THERAPY EVALUATION WAS

01:40 - 21.980 IDENTIFIED BY ONE CODE IN

01:40 - 25.040 JANUARY OF 2017. THE BUREAU

01:40 - 28.070 REPLAY ANGLE, A VALUATION CODE

01:40 - 28.870 WITH FREE

01:40 - 30.430 AND EVALUATION FOR LOW

01:40 - 32.860 COMPLEXITY MEDIUM COMPLEXITY

01:40 - 35.360 FOR HIGH TECH TODAY. THE BUREAU

01:40 - 37.460 SIMPLY ADOPTED THE CODES THAT

01:40 - 39.280 WERE DEVELOPED BY THE UNITED

01:40 - 40.680 STATES. THE DEPARTMENT OF

01:40 - 42.560 HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES

01:40 - 42.860 MARKET

01:40 - 45.680 PERMITTING PROVIDER FEE PER

01:40 - 47.800 PERSON BY MEDICARE OR MEDICAID.

01:40 - 50.480 THE BUREAU DECIDED THAT THE

01:40 - 53.030 FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. OR PHYSICAL

01:40 - 55.320 THERAPY EVALUATION REPRESENTED

01:40 - 58.540 ENTIRELY NEW FOR FOOD AND UNDER

01:40 - 01.090 THE DEPARTMENT REGULATION THAT

01:41 - 03.070 NEW BE AT A

01:41 - 05.710 LEVEL APPROXIMATELY 20% LOWER.

01:41 - 07.950 THEN WHAT PHYSICAL THERAPIST

01:41 - 09.040 FOR PAID AND 20.

01:41 - 12.190 THE PHYSICAL THERAPIST APPEALED

01:41 - 12.280 TO

01:41 - 14.090 THE SECRETARY LABOR AND

01:41 - 15.950 INDUSTRY AND FATHER DECLARED

01:41 - 18.040 TORY ORDER THAT EMPLOYER SHOULD

01:41 - 19.940 CONTINUE TO REIMBURSE PHYSICAL

01:41 - 22.570 THERAPIST FT CREATE 20,000

01:41 - 23.000 LEVEL.

01:41 - 24.500 THE

01:41 - 26.520 SECRETARY IN MY INTEREST IN A

01:41 - 28.010 FEW TO PATIENTS IN MIND, THE

01:41 - 29.570 PHYSICAL THERAPIST APPEAL.

01:41 - 32.320 BEFORE THIS COURT. THE PHYSICAL

01:41 - 33.840 THERAPIST ARGUE THAT THE

01:41 - 36.360 SECRETARY AIRED THAT'S THE NEW

01:41 - 36.950 CODE

01:41 - 39.370 OR NOT. THE NEW SERVICE BECAUSE

01:41 - 41.710 THEY SIMPLY REFINE THE FIRE

01:41 - 44.710 CODE FROM ONE AND TOOK 3.

01:41 - 51.370 THAT THE DEPARTMENT RIVER

01:41 - 53.620 SECRETARY ALTERNATIVELY THEY

01:41 - 55.400 ASKED THE COURT TO ENTER A

01:41 - 57.770 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT THAT

01:41 - 02.670 WHY 17 THE ARABIC OWED.

01:42 - 11.520 WHO IS

01:42 - 13.330 HERE ON THE HALF OF THE

01:42 - 14.960 PHYSICAL THERAPY OUT OF HERE.

01:42 - 21.170 WE PLEASE THE COURT COMING UP

01:42 - 23.930 ALL THE APP OF THE FIRST CALL.

01:42 - 25.080 >>YEAH AND FOR.

01:42 - 27.430 THAT'S WHERE YOU

01:42 - 29.970 AND ALL I'M PREPARED TO

01:42 - 31.650 ARGUE BOTH THE SUBSTANTIVE

01:42 - 34.380 ISSUE AND ISSUE OF THE FORMER

01:42 - 35.620 JACKSON MY UNDERSTANDING IS

01:42 - 36.710 THAT WE'RE ONLY HERE THIS

01:42 - 38.320 MORNING ON ME A LITTLE AIR

01:42 - 40.820 ACTIONS HAVE BEEN FILED BY THE.

01:42 - 48.010 >>I WOULD SAY THAT'S

01:42 - 48.740 MY UNDERSTANDING.

01:42 - 51.810 >>I APOLOGIZE, AND THE COURT WE

01:42 - 52.850 ARE HERE ONLY ON

01:42 - 56.040 SO THIS IS NOT A COMBINED

01:42 - 57.340 PETITION FOR REVIEW.

01:43 - 03.290 >>MAKE IT IF IT WAS A COMBINED

01:43 - 04.900 PETITION FOR YOU BOTH TO THE

01:43 - 06.160 COURT'S APPELLATE AND

01:43 - 08.470 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION. THE

01:43 - 10.260 COURT HOWEVER ONLY SCHEDULED

01:43 - 11.880 ARGUMENT THIS TIME ON THE

01:43 - 13.010 CLERGY ACTIONS THAT HAVE

01:43 - 15.890 BEEN FILED BY THE DEPARTMENT TO

01:43 - 18.270 THE REQUEST FOR THE COURTS.

01:43 - 19.780 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION.

01:43 - 23.040 >>OKAY, THEN I APOLOGIZE THE

01:43 - 24.860 COURT YOU ARE HERE

01:43 - 28.040 TO ARGUE THE MARRIAGE

01:43 - 30.390 OF YOUR AREA JACK COME HERE

01:43 - 32.440 ASKING THAT HAPPY THE METS.

01:43 - 35.530 >>AND YES AND THEY ARE WRITTEN

01:43 - 37.460 ON YOUR ACCOUNT BE THE MAP.

01:43 - 42.300 >>MY NAME IS DIFFERENT

01:43 - 43.000 IN SPORTS.

01:43 - 44.890 I REPRESENT THE RESPONDENT THE

01:43 - 46.900 HONORABLE W GERARD OLEKSIAK

01:43 - 48.270 SECRETARY OF DEPARTMENT OF

01:43 - 49.960 LABOR INDUSTRY. HOW AWFUL

01:43 - 51.840 PENNSYLVANIA. I RESPECTFULLY

01:43 - 53.360 REQUEST 3 MINUTES OF MY TIME

01:43 - 54.750 THE RESULT IS THEREFORE VITAL

01:43 - 56.510 IF NEEDED YOU HAVE TO PASS.

01:43 - 59.530 THIS MAN ABBAS PETITION HAS

01:43 - 00.110 ATTEMPTED.

01:44 - 02.460 KEMP TO SIMULTANEOUSLY

01:44 - 03.890 CHALLENGE FACING THIS COURT'S

01:44 - 05.820 APPELLATE JURISDICTION. ITS

01:44 - 07.410 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION. THE

01:44 - 10.460 12/6/2019 AND JUNE OCCASION AND

01:44 - 12.400 ORDER THE SECRETARY REGARDING

01:44 - 13.390 THE DEPARTMENT'S CASH THE

01:44 - 16.050 NATION OF THE 2017 FEE SCHEDULE

01:44 - 17.790 PURSUANT TO ITS REGULATIONS

01:44 - 19.210 THE DEPARTMENT FILED THESE

01:44 - 20.710 PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS HAS

01:44 - 22.500 CEASED DISMISSAL THIS POSITION

01:44 - 23.800 WITH REGARD TO THE ORIGINAL

01:44 - 25.880 JURISDICTION. L A FOR

01:44 - 27.770 3 REASONS FIRST OFF THE

01:44 - 30.340 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION. EDITION

01:44 - 32.120 IS IMPROPER TO THE EXTENT THAT

01:44 - 33.530 THE SAME ISSUES IN THE SAME

01:44 - 33.870 REALLY.

01:44 - 36.290 UNDER THIS COURT'S APPELLATE

01:44 - 37.660 JURISDICTION. ACTUALLY

01:44 - 39.110 CURRENTLY PENDING IN EVERY 7,

01:44 - 39.440 5,

01:44 - 42.290 AND THERE IS NO DISPUTE THAT

01:44 - 43.680 THIS COURT HAS APPELLATE

01:44 - 45.110 JURISDICTION OVER THIS MATTER.

01:44 - 47.370 IT'S IT IS A VERY CLEARLY IS

01:44 - 49.190 THIS 40 SCHOOLS ENJOY STATION.

01:44 - 51.430 OVER FINAL WORD AND GOVERNMENT

01:44 - 52.850 AGENCIES THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT

01:44 - 54.840 THIS IS HOWEVER BECAUSE UNDER

01:44 - 56.030 THE APPELLATE JURISDICTION.

01:44 - 57.990 IT DOESN'T COME UNDER THE

01:44 - 58.970 ORIGINAL STORE STATES

01:44 - 01.360 IN PENNSYLVANIA. SUPREME COURT

01:45 - 02.560 HAS LOOKED AT THIS ISSUE AND

01:45 - 05.120 LOOK AT THE SITE. THEIR MEAL

01:45 - 06.790 IN IT. RELATIVES OF THE

01:45 - 08.110 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION HAS

01:45 - 10.390 BASICALLY INDICATED THAT IRAN

01:45 - 11.680 AND THE APPELLATE JURISDICTION.

01:45 - 14.360 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION. I

01:45 - 15.520 BELIEVE THE WAY TO PHRASE IT

01:45 - 16.960 THEY SAID THAT MATTERS AND TO

01:45 - 18.680 BE RESOLVED OR EXTENSION ART.

01:45 - 20.880 WHAT ARE THOSE THAT ARE NOT

01:45 - 22.080 INCLUDED IN THE APPELLATE

01:45 - 23.890 JURISDICTION. HOUSE CALL.

01:45 - 25.510 >>COUNCIL WHAT IS THE STATUS OF

01:45 - 27.910 ME THE PELLET THAT MATTER NOW

01:45 - 30.370 IS IT IN OUR COURT IS THAT A

01:45 - 32.180 FRIEND. SORRY

01:45 - 34.830 APOLOGISTS IT IS A NEW FREEZE

01:45 - 36.590 HAVE BEEN FILED ON ALL THE U.S.

01:45 - 38.890 OF COURSE IN THE BALLOT

01:45 - 39.930 JURISDICTION.

01:45 - 44.720 BASICALLY WHAT THIS CASE IS

01:45 - 46.990 BASICALLY SAYS IS THAT THIS

01:45 - 48.480 JUST DON'T GET 2 BITES OF THE

01:45 - 49.890 SAME AT WE'LL TRY TO GET THE

01:45 - 50.660 RESULT THEY WANT.

01:45 - 52.920 CLEARLY WHAT THE DISHES ARE

01:45 - 55.370 TRYING TO DO HERE. AND IF YOU

01:45 - 55.660 LOOK AT

01:45 - 57.660 THE PETITION. THEY'RE CLEARLY

01:45 - 59.250 THE DISEASE AT SAFETY ISSUES

01:45 - 59.720 INVOLVED IN

01:45 - 01.340 THAT MATTERS WHEN THE

01:46 - 03.290 DEPARTMENT PROBABLY CALCULATED.

01:46 - 05.300 THE FEE SCHEDULE,

01:46 - 07.090 HUNDREDS REGULATIONS. THEY ARE

01:46 - 08.300 A MAJORITY ON THE COURT.

01:46 - 11.670 >>USUALLY USUALLY OFFICIAL

01:46 - 12.880 VIOLENT BUILDERS FICTION

01:46 - 14.090 PETITION FOR REVIEW.

01:46 - 16.750 >>WHEN THERE IS A CONCERN THAT

01:46 - 18.230 THE AGENCY IS GOING TO ATTEMPT

01:46 - 20.890 TO ARGUE THAT THE DECISION THAT

01:46 - 22.800 IS BEING APPEALED FROM IS NOT A

01:46 - 24.210 FINAL ORDER FOR PURPOSE OF THE

01:46 - 25.330 REVIEW UNDER THE ADMINISTRATIVE

01:46 - 26.770 AGENCY LAW OR THE

01:46 - 28.380 PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION.

01:46 - 30.350 BECAUSE OTHERWISE THEY BEAT

01:46 - 31.600 THEM BACK TO MISTER HALL WOULD

01:46 - 32.460 PROBABLY PREFER.

01:46 - 35.640 THE APPELLATE THE THAT

01:46 - 38.100 YOU'RE COMPETING THAT THEY MAY

01:46 - 38.740 APPEAL FROM THE

01:46 - 42.170 DIVISION BELOW. THE QUESTIONS

01:46 - 43.150 DON'T GO IN MAKING THAT

01:46 - 45.050 ESPECIALLY IN FEELING THAT

01:46 - 46.410 SWEET YOU'RE NOT CHALLENGING

01:46 - 48.140 ORDER TO CONTRIBUTE THE

01:46 - 49.040 DIVISION BELOW YOU'RE

01:46 - 50.020 NOT CHALLENGING.

01:46 - 51.800 >>THE JURISDICTION OF THE

01:46 - 53.040 OFFICER BELOW TO RENDER THE

01:46 - 54.190 DECISION THAT THE OFFICER

01:46 - 54.690 ISSUED.

01:46 - 56.450 >>THAT ALL THE THAT YOU CAN BE

01:46 - 57.910 FIRED WITHOUT OBJECTION FROM

01:46 - 00.170 THE DEPARTMENT IN OUR APPELLATE

01:47 - 00.760 JURISDICTION.

01:47 - 04.420 >>IF OR

01:47 - 05.970 YOUR COURT AND I BELIEVE IT WAS

01:47 - 07.230 A FINAL ORDER I BELIEVE IS

01:47 - 08.430 PROPERLY BEFORE YOUR COURT

01:47 - 09.640 UNDER THE JURISDICTION.

01:47 - 12.430 IT'S THE SAME

01:47 - 14.080 ISSUES AND IT SAID THE RELEASE

01:47 - 15.360 IS ALSO THE SAME IN BOTH

01:47 - 16.570 MATCHES THE CRIME SCENE IN

01:47 - 18.140 ORDER. ACCORDING

01:47 - 20.330 TO DEPARTMENT RELATED DIFFICULT

01:47 - 24.830 BOTH MATTERS THEY ARE SEEKING

01:47 - 26.810 AN ORDER ORDERING THESE SHORES

01:47 - 27.990 IN THE SELF-INTEREST OF PEOPLE

01:47 - 29.800 REACTING WE HAVE TO PAY AND THE

01:47 - 31.860 SEAS THE SCHEDULE, THE SINKING

01:47 - 33.500 IN ORDER TO RETROACTIVELY ORDER

01:47 - 34.900 THEM. OKAY BACK IN

01:47 - 36.110 2007 FORWARD.

01:47 - 38.250 >>HOW ARE YOU IN ANY WAY IS

01:47 - 39.940 ACTING TO THE FACT IS THEY'RE

01:47 - 41.330 REQUESTING A DECLARATORY

01:47 - 42.560 JUDGMENT WHETHER OR NOT WE

01:47 - 43.890 SHOULD BE ADDRESSING THAT NOR

01:47 - 44.970 APPELLATE JURISDICTION.

01:47 - 48.590 >>THE SECRETARY.

01:47 - 52.690 THE DISCRETION TO ISSUE A

01:47 - 54.100 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT THAT IS

01:47 - 55.670 CERTAINLY SUBJECT TO THE LAW I

01:47 - 57.100 BELIEVE IN THIS MARRIAGE DOWN.

01:47 - 59.370 IT WAS IF THE DISHES WERE JUST

01:47 - 01.820 NOT ENTITLED TO IT. YOU'LL FIND

01:48 - 03.270 EXACTLY CORRECTLY,

01:48 - 05.180 FRANKLY CALCULATED CITY

01:48 - 06.080 MOURNING AND TITLE TO THE

01:48 - 07.040 RELIEF THEY REQUESTED.

01:48 - 08.280 >>COUNCIL YOU'VE BEEN A

01:48 - 10.010 CHALLENGE ON THE CALL IT THE

01:48 - 11.270 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT ACT

01:48 - 12.170 BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T BRING IN

01:48 - 13.990 ALL THE NECESSARY PARTIES.

01:48 - 22.770 >>AND EVERY TIME WE DO YOU

01:48 - 23.450 BELIEVE YEAH.

01:48 - 30.430 >>WE

01:48 - 31.830 HAVE TO FIGHT FOR FREE WHICH

01:48 - 33.350 MAY BE PART OF THE CONFUSION

01:48 - 35.420 HERE. BOTH THE PILOT AND

01:48 - 36.040 THE ORIGINAL.

01:48 - 38.510 >>THAT'S THE THAT SECRETARY

01:48 - 40.090 DENIED THE REQUEST.

01:48 - 43.060 >>THE ON THE UP HIGH.

01:48 - 45.050 >>THEN I THINK THE REQUEST FOR

01:48 - 46.650 A DECLARATORY ORDER ON THE

01:48 - 48.790 THEORY THAT ALL THE RIDER.

01:48 - 50.170 AND ALL OF

01:48 - 52.080 THE EMPLOYER WERE NOT BEFORE

01:48 - 53.300 THE SECRETARY AND MAY HAVE BEEN

01:48 - 54.770 AFRAID FOR CREATING IS THAT

01:48 - 55.240 CORRECT.

01:48 - 58.290 >>I WOULD SAY THE INITIAL

01:48 - 59.920 REASON HE ALSO DENIED IT IS

01:48 - 00.940 BECAUSE OF THE SOUND OF THE

01:49 - 01.370 CRACK.

01:49 - 07.290 >>BUT HE HAS BEEN

01:49 - 10.310 >>THEY TOOK ME TO THE DEATH OF

01:49 - 12.080 RECORD CREATED BELOW IN TERMS

01:49 - 14.470 OF THE CODE AND THE NEW CODE

01:49 - 16.440 AND THE ARGUMENT OF WHETHER

01:49 - 17.970 IT'S 3 NUMBERING OR WHETHER

01:49 - 19.030 THEY'RE ENTIRELY NEW CODE.

01:49 - 20.370 THE THE RECORD

01:49 - 22.630 CREATED BELOW NO WAY TO BEAT

01:49 - 24.280 THE RECORD IS INADEQUATE FOR

01:49 - 25.320 APPELLATE REVIEW, CORRECT.

01:49 - 28.270 >>DURHAM POLICE AND NOW I HAVE

01:49 - 28.500 NOT.

01:49 - 30.990 THEY ARE GOING TO BE THE SECOND

01:49 - 32.730 SECRETARY BASICALLY FOR LIFE

01:49 - 34.660 PRETTY MUCH ON A STATUTORY

01:49 - 35.250 CONSTRUCTION.

01:49 - 37.660 >>AND WE CAN GRANT, BUT THEY

01:49 - 39.270 LEFT THEY LEFT THEY WE WE

01:49 - 40.470 COMPLETELY DISAGREE WITH THE IN

01:49 - 42.210 THE BATTLE PARTY ARGUMENT WE

01:49 - 43.380 CAN RULE ON THE MERITS OF THE

01:49 - 44.960 MATTER OF LAW WHETHER THIS WITH

01:49 - 46.570 THE NEW COATING ENTIRELY NEW

01:49 - 48.000 COATING OR SIMPLY REMEMBERING A

01:49 - 48.350 COATING.

01:49 - 50.420 >>AND THAT IS THE ISSUES THAT

01:49 - 51.080 ARE ACTUALLY UNDER

01:49 - 52.080 YOUR JURISDICTION.

01:49 - 54.710 >>AND FAIRLY AND AND IF WE FIND

01:49 - 56.180 THAT THERE IF WE FIND THAT

01:49 - 59.000 BIG AIRED IN

01:49 - 00.640 CATEGORIZING SOME OF THE NEW

01:50 - 01.990 BIRTH IS REORDERING ALL WE DO

01:50 - 02.940 IS REVERSE WE DON'T NEED TO

01:50 - 04.020 GRAB THE CLERK. WE'RE REALLY

01:50 - 04.770 JUST REVERSE.

01:50 - 09.400 >>I'M GOING TO SUSPECT WAS THE

01:50 - 10.590 WHOLE DISAGREE WITH THAT.

01:50 - 13.060 IF THIS POINT WITH REGARDS TO

01:50 - 14.960 US THAT THE BEST CHOICE.

01:50 - 18.960 >>THE QUESTION BEFORE US.

01:50 - 21.660 THE WEATHER OR NOT WE HAVE YOUR

01:50 - 23.170 PICK FROM UNDER THAT DECLARED

01:50 - 26.120 HER JUDGMENT. OVER

01:50 - 28.890 THE MATTER WHERE AN INVOLVED.

01:50 - 34.210 >>THAT HAS BEEN COMMITTED TO

01:50 - 35.440 AND I'M IN A GREAT OVATION.

01:50 - 38.680 NAMELY THE SECRETARY OF LABOR

01:50 - 42.200 >>AND CERTAINLY BE AN ISSUE ON

01:50 - 43.320 THE MERITS OF THIS POINTED TO

01:50 - 46.720 >>I'M JUST TALKING CURE.

01:50 - 48.110 AND WE

01:50 - 50.520 EVEN ENTERTAIN THE CLERIC RIGHT

01:50 - 51.950 JUDGMENT ORIGINAL INJURED

01:50 - 54.230 VICTIM. MATTER WHEN.

01:50 - 57.910 OF THE PETITION

01:50 - 59.970 FOR REVIEW. WHEN IT INVOLVED

01:50 - 01.660 THE CODE WHICH IS.

01:51 - 04.290 HAVE ALREADY BEEN THE SUBJECT

01:51 - 05.890 OF A FULL MINUTE FOR A HEARING

01:51 - 07.210 AND IN THE CASE.

01:51 - 10.710 >>AND THE RETURN TO THE STATION

01:51 - 11.530 BECAUSE IT'S A MOVIE.

01:51 - 21.670 >>WITHOUT THE 3RD DAY I MEAN I

01:51 - 22.810 CAN'T EVEN TELL YOUR ARGUMENT.

01:51 - 25.980 >>IS THIS LIST.

01:51 - 28.970 >>THE SECOND I WENT I WOULD I

01:51 - 30.210 WOULD QUIT AND ARGUE THE MERITS

01:51 - 31.790 HERE I I THOUGHT THE P OVER

01:51 - 33.200 FAIRLY STRAIGHTFORWARD I THINK

01:51 - 34.260 THAT THEY WERE I TO BE THEY

01:51 - 35.650 WERE PARTICULARLY COMPLICATED,

01:51 - 37.440 I'M NOT SURE HOW MUCH.

01:51 - 39.480 HOW MUCH THEY'RE OUT THERE THAT

01:51 - 41.540 DAY ON THAT BUT YOUR TIME.

01:51 - 45.350 >>IT WOULD LEAVE IT TO THE

01:51 - 46.620 SALES FOR A LEGAL IS

01:51 - 48.250 OFFICIALLY. IT IS OFFICIALLY

01:51 - 49.130 BECAUSE THE FACTS.

01:51 - 52.350 IT SHOWS THEY ARE ACTUALLY

01:51 - 53.300 ENTITLED TO THE RELIEF

01:51 - 55.800 REQUESTED. FIRST OFF THEY'RE

01:51 - 56.690 GOING TO THEY WERE

01:51 - 58.070 QUESTOR DECLARATORY RELIEF

01:51 - 59.970 AGAINST IS OR ISN'T IT. IT AIRS

01:51 - 00.590 THE PEOPLE ARE.

01:52 - 03.530 >>YOU YOU WANT TO THE 5

01:52 - 04.100 AMERICA.

01:52 - 07.410 ARE YOU KNOW YOUR

01:52 - 09.630 PICTURE MATTER YOU WANT TO MISS

01:52 - 11.390 ON GROUNDS THAT IT.

01:52 - 15.660 >>GOVERN.

01:52 - 16.800 >>IT COVERED BY THE

01:52 - 18.520 ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING BEFORE

01:52 - 18.990 THE FACT.

01:52 - 22.860 >>FRIENDS OF BIG BEAR CITY

01:52 - 23.710 ADMINISTRATIVE.

01:52 - 27.140 >>I'M SURE FICTION AND THAT HER

01:52 - 29.010 COMPOSURE WE CAN TO FIND HER.

01:52 - 31.400 >>IF YOU'RE GOING TO BE

01:52 - 32.680 REGULATORY STATIONARY.

01:52 - 36.830 THERE'S DICK CHENEY REJOIN THIS

01:52 - 37.110 HOUR.

01:52 - 39.150 PRELIMINARY TESTS IS TO BE

01:52 - 40.850 UPHELD AND IT MATTERS THIS.

01:52 - 43.020 >>YEAH NOT A BARRIER TO THE

01:52 - 44.600 PARTY DIRECTED THAT THE

01:52 - 46.940 ONLY PURPOSE THEIR ARGUMENT

01:52 - 48.580 TODAY WAS TO ADDRESS THE WOMEN

01:52 - 49.810 ARE DECKED IN CANNOT THE

01:52 - 50.160 MARRIAGE.

01:52 - 55.790 >>INDICATING EVERYTHING EVERY 3

01:52 - 57.160 ISSUES IT WAS OBVIOUSLY THE

01:52 - 58.350 INITIAL THING THAT INJURES

01:52 - 59.530 STATION UNDER THE BALLOT.

01:53 - 03.590 AND THE ORIGINAL THE SECOND WAS

01:53 - 04.900 LEGAL INSUFFICIENTLY DO NOT

01:53 - 07.160 LEAVE THE FACT. JUSTIFY.

01:53 - 10.090 BUT HE SURE THEY'RE ENTITLED

01:53 - 11.880 TO GAS THE CASE NOW

01:53 - 14.830 AND ALSO TODAY SAID IT AND IT

01:53 - 16.250 APPEARS THE MAN NAMED CHRIS AND

01:53 - 17.360 DIRECT US TO DO SOMETHING.

01:53 - 22.820 NO LEGAL RIGHT TO

01:53 - 24.440 REQUEST IS TO PERFORM SPECIFIC

01:53 - 25.680 DUTY, ESPECIALLY TO THE EXTENT

01:53 - 26.910 THAT WAS OUR INTERPRETATION THE

01:53 - 27.920 RATES THEY CAN'T THREAT TO

01:53 - 29.600 SPECIFIC ACTIONS. THEY HAVE

01:53 - 31.510 THEIR LEGAL RIGHT TO DUTY THAT

01:53 - 33.430 THEY HAVE THOUGH NO

01:53 - 34.960 CORRESPONDING INDEED.

01:53 - 39.210 TO INTERVENE THE WAY THEY WANT

01:53 - 41.620 AND BECAUSE THE GAME IT REALLY

01:53 - 42.310 IS AN IDIOT.

01:53 - 47.060 WE'VE GOT THE PATIENCE OF FANS

01:53 - 48.580 INTELLECT SPECIFICITY

01:53 - 51.000 IT CLEARLY THEY MADE NO ATTEMPT

01:53 - 51.060 TO

01:53 - 54.440 DISTINGUISH C ISSUES RELATED TO

01:53 - 55.230 THE REGIONAL,

01:53 - 56.610 THIS IS WHAT IT REALLY IS A

01:53 - 58.400 DEVELOPING A BILL INTENDED TO

01:53 - 59.740 STABILIZE A DIFFERENT TREAT THE

01:53 - 01.300 RELIEF THEY WANT FROM THE L A.

01:54 - 04.650 >>WELL AGAIN AGAIN THE SHORT I

01:54 - 06.110 THINK I THINK IT WOULD STAND OR

01:54 - 07.730 DID IT OFFEND OR PROPHYLACTIC

01:54 - 09.120 DOOR TO DOOR DURING FICTION

01:54 - 10.360 PETITION FOR REVIEW, WHERE YOU

01:54 - 11.750 DIDN'T KNOW WHAT THE AGENCY

01:54 - 13.310 WOULD GOING TO ARGUE IN TERMS

01:54 - 15.670 OF WHETHER THEY HAD AN BORDER

01:54 - 17.080 AND THINGS LIKE THAT THOUGH

01:54 - 18.860 IT'S NOT AN UNCOMMON THING TO

01:54 - 20.580 BASICALLY HAVE ONE PETITION FOR

01:54 - 22.760 REVIEW AND OUT

01:54 - 24.980 OF CONCERN PERMITTING AN APPEAL

01:54 - 26.660 THAT LINER OR SOMETHING ELSE.

01:54 - 28.270 YOU KNOW YOU WANT TO PRESERVE

01:54 - 30.170 VOTE. SO. I'M NOT SURE THAT YOU

01:54 - 31.560 HEAR THEY WERE I DON'T THINK

01:54 - 32.970 THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN

01:54 - 34.570 WHAT THEY'RE CLAIMING IN

01:54 - 35.940 THEIR APPEAL AND WHAT THEY'RE

01:54 - 36.930 CLAIMING AN ORIGINAL

01:54 - 37.870 JURISDICTION, THEY'RE JUST

01:54 - 40.060 TRYING TO INVOKE YOU KNOW

01:54 - 40.970 INCREASE THEIR ODDS THAT WE'RE

01:54 - 41.820 GOING TO KEEP THE CASE.

01:54 - 46.540 >>IT CLEARLY GAVE ME THE ENJOIN

01:54 - 47.940 US DOES SUPPORT THE FACT IS

01:54 - 48.930 CLEARLY UNDER YOUR PALATE

01:54 - 50.690 SERVICE STATION. THESE REASONS

01:54 - 52.650 THE WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOU

01:54 - 54.640 TO STARE FOR LIMON AREA.

01:54 - 56.610 JACKSON'S AND THIS IS THIS IN

01:54 - 57.730 ADDITION TO THE EXTENT IT IS A

01:54 - 59.000 NEW YEAR, IT'S A LOGISTICS.

01:55 - 05.840 >>I THANK YOU GUYS ARE

01:55 - 07.000 GOING TO COURT COMING HOME

01:55 - 08.380 BEHALF OF THE BEST POLITICAL

01:55 - 09.830 THEIR FEET THEY CATION ORDER

01:55 - 12.760 FOR THEIR FAITH. THE HONEST IF

01:55 - 13.270 I MAY

01:55 - 15.230 THIS IS A NICE STRAIGHT FORWARD

01:55 - 17.360 IT MAY HAVE SEEMED VERY

01:55 - 19.890 HELPFUL ARGUMENT. THEY'RE AND

01:55 - 21.520 TO TO JUDGE BROUGHT SOME POINT.

01:55 - 23.170 THE REASON THAT WE ACTUALLY

01:55 - 24.640 FILED THE ORIGINAL

01:55 - 27.080 JURISDICTION REQUESTS IT IS

01:55 - 28.660 ACTUALLY PLEADING IN CURRENTLY

01:55 - 29.240 THAN THIS.

01:55 - 31.770 IT'S IMPORTANT UNDERSTAND

01:55 - 33.330 THAT BUT FOR THE MATTER IN

01:55 - 35.050 WHICH THE SECRETARY MADE THE

01:55 - 37.360 DETERMINATION BELOW WE ACTUALLY

01:55 - 39.260 WOULD HAVE HAD TO MAKE THE

01:55 - 41.440 REQUESTS THIS ORIGINAL

01:55 - 43.460 JURISDICTION UNDER THE DECK FOR

01:55 - 46.160 A JUDGMENT THAT. BELOW

01:55 - 48.110 WE. REQUESTED THAT THE

01:55 - 49.760 SECRETARY MAKE DETERMINATION

01:55 - 51.200 UNDER THE GENERAL WAS IN

01:55 - 52.770 MEDICARE PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE

01:55 - 55.140 WHICH HAS A SPECIFIC MECHANISM.

01:55 - 57.580 THE PAR-FIVE DEKEL TORY REALLY.

01:55 - 59.540 IF

01:55 - 01.470 THIS COURT SHOULD DETERMINE

01:56 - 03.320 AN END AGREE WITH THE

01:56 - 04.990 PETITIONERS IN THIS INSTANCE

01:56 - 05.540 THAT.

01:56 - 08.760 THE SECRETARY WAS WRONG BELOW.

01:56 - 10.890 BUT THAT THE SECRETARY WAS

01:56 - 12.530 CORRECT THAT IT DID THE

01:56 - 13.560 SECRETARY DID NOT HAVE

01:56 - 15.810 THE AUTHORITY UNDER GRAFT

01:56 - 17.790 ISSUED AT TORREY BELIEVE IN

01:56 - 20.360 THAT INSTANCE WE COULD NOT SEEK

01:56 - 21.380 RELIEF BELOW

01:56 - 22.960 BECAUSE THE SECRETARY WOULD

01:56 - 24.510 HAVE THE AUTHORITY UNDER GRAPH

01:56 - 26.200 PROVIDED. SO WE PLAYED THE

01:56 - 27.650 ALTERNATIVE IN THIS INSTANCE TO

01:56 - 29.090 REQUEST THE COURT TO ENCOURAGE

01:56 - 29.900 OLDER FICTION.

01:56 - 31.610 IF WE SHOULD FALL INTO THAT

01:56 - 34.300 SCENARIO. SUCH THE COURT MADE A

01:56 - 35.760 SUBSTITUTE FIGHTING FAVOR OF

01:56 - 37.540 THE NEW YEAR NEW YOU WANT AND

01:56 - 38.090 ORDER.

01:56 - 39.420 >>GETTING BACK TO THE MARRIAGE.

01:56 - 41.130 YOU THINK THE NEW CODE.

01:56 - 50.790 PAYMENT REGULATE IF YOU WANT

01:56 - 53.610 CODE THE NEW CODE BETTER 5.

01:56 - 56.210 >>NOT

01:56 - 58.230 EXACTLY YOUR HONOR WHAT WE WANT

01:56 - 59.820 IS WHAT WE BELIEVE IS THAT

01:56 - 01.620 SECRETARY PROVE YOUR WORKERS

01:57 - 02.960 COMPENSATION MADE A

01:57 - 04.920 MISAPPLICATION OF A SPECIFIC

01:57 - 05.890 SECTION OF THE COFFIN

01:57 - 09.620 REGULATIONS TO. THOSE

01:57 - 11.470 THAT WORK. PREVIOUSLY NEWS BUT

01:57 - 11.730 THEN

01:57 - 13.770 RE NUMBER ESSENTIALLY WELL

01:57 - 14.870 THAT'S THE ISSUE RIGHT MISTER

01:57 - 16.810 HALL THE ISSUE IS IS FROM A

01:57 - 18.280 FROM A RAPE PERSPECTIVE FROM

01:57 - 18.880 REIMBURSEMENT

01:57 - 19.740 RATE PERSPECTIVE.

01:57 - 22.000 >>ENTIRELY NEW CODE ARE TREATED

01:57 - 23.090 DIFFERENTLY THAN THE CODE TO

01:57 - 24.430 GET BETTER JUST 3 NUMBER.

01:57 - 27.350 THAT THAT'S CORRECT YOUR HONOR

01:57 - 29.250 AN EXAMPLE THAT FOR A PHYSICAL

01:57 - 30.500 THERAPIST NICOLE THAT JUST

01:57 - 32.460 CAME OUT. WE'RE DRY NEEDLING IT

01:57 - 33.610 TO THE NEW PROCEDURE, THE

01:57 - 34.500 PHYSICAL THERAPIST YOU'RE

01:57 - 37.400 DOING. NATIONAL ORGANIZATION

01:57 - 39.170 ISSUED A NEW CODE

01:57 - 40.590 BECAUSE THAT HAD NOT BEEN A

01:57 - 42.040 SERVICE THAT HAVE BEEN PROVIDED

01:57 - 43.900 PREVIOUSLY SO UNDER THAT

01:57 - 45.640 SCENARIO THERE WOULD BE

01:57 - 48.590 GREAT APPLIED TO THAT CODE AND

01:57 - 50.080 THEN GOING FORWARD IT WILL BE

01:57 - 53.160 ADJUSTED IN THE IN THE AND THE

01:57 - 53.470 MARRIAGE.

01:57 - 57.340 >>BANG THE EVALUATION. WEATHER

01:57 - 57.880 DOWN UNDER

01:57 - 59.630 THE OLD THE GUYS WHO ARE THE

01:57 - 01.650 NEW IS THE SAME IN ABOUT THE

01:58 - 03.730 SAME AMOUNT OF WORK UNDER THE

01:58 - 06.900 QUOTE, NEW CODE IN 2017.

01:58 - 08.960 YOU CAN DO. AND THAT WAS A

01:58 - 10.140 DIFFERENT KIND OF REPORT.

01:58 - 13.480 THAT ULTIMATELY WILL AFFECT THE

01:58 - 14.010 PATIENTS.

01:58 - 18.420 WELCOME BACK TO THE MEDIUM OR

01:58 - 20.590 HIGH PARK CITY. BUT YOUR POINT

01:58 - 22.180 IS THAT NOT A NEW SERVICE.

01:58 - 24.430 IF JUST

01:58 - 26.450 5 PER 3RD, BUT WE FOUND A YEAR

01:58 - 28.040 OR IN TERMS OF TAKING A MEDICAL

01:58 - 30.010 HISTORY EVALUATING THE PATIENT

01:58 - 31.470 AND SO FORTH AND SO ON.

01:58 - 36.530 I GET BACK TO THE 4 FEET OR IF

01:58 - 38.110 WE AGREE WITH YOU AND

01:58 - 40.720 WE RIVER THE SECRETARY DUE TO

01:58 - 43.420 PATIENT ON A DEAL. THEN YOU GET

01:58 - 44.190 WHAT YOU NEED.

01:58 - 46.740 >>I KNOW YOU'RE ON IT BECAUSE

01:58 - 49.730 THE WHAT THE SECRETARY DID TOO.

01:58 - 51.830 WE WE DO IT IN ONE MAJOR

01:58 - 53.780 RESPECT. BUT WE ALSO REQUESTED

01:58 - 55.960 THAT HER REALLY BELOW AND IT'S

01:58 - 57.300 REPORTED PUT THIS IN CONTEXT.

01:59 - 01.500 DECO FOR RELIEF WAS

01:59 - 03.320 NECESSARY BELOW BECAUSE THE

01:59 - 04.910 MECHANISM FOR THE AMOUNT OF

01:59 - 06.790 REIMBURSEMENT FROM A PAIRED TO

01:59 - 08.000 A PROVIDER IS AN

01:59 - 10.400 ADMINISTRATIVE WANT. SO WITHIN

01:59 - 12.500 A CERTAIN TIMEFRAME THAT THE

01:59 - 13.830 PROVIDER RECEIVE THE

01:59 - 15.720 REIMBURSEMENT. THEY HAVE TO

01:59 - 16.200 FILE

01:59 - 19.410 AN APPEAL. A MEDICAL THE REVIEW

01:59 - 20.800 APPEAL TO THE BUREAU.

01:59 - 23.620 THAT TRULY IS NECESSARY BECAUSE

01:59 - 25.370 THE TIME FRAME TO GO BACK IN

01:59 - 27.800 AND THE TO FILE THESE APPEALS

01:59 - 28.890 HAS ALREADY PASSED.

01:59 - 31.070 SO IF THE COURT MADE THE SAME

01:59 - 34.530 DECISION TODAY THAT THE 2017

01:59 - 36.300 INTERPRETATION BY THE YEAR BY

01:59 - 38.500 THE DEPARTMENT WAS INCORRECT.

01:59 - 40.800 THAT WE WOULD HAVE LONG PAST

01:59 - 42.460 THE TIME PERIOD FOR PROVIDERS

01:59 - 44.800 TO BE REIMBURSED. FOR ALL

01:59 - 47.620 THOSE FEES GOING BACK TO 2017,

01:59 - 48.690 BUT THEY WOULD BE ENTITLED.

01:59 - 51.300 >>WHY DID ALL THESE INDIVIDUAL

01:59 - 52.770 PROVIDER WHEN I GOT THE

01:59 - 57.780 >>REMEMBER ABOUT. THE

01:59 - 59.420 REVIEW PETITION. THEY ARE

01:59 - 00.340 BECAUSE IT WOULD HAVE BEEN FEW

02:00 - 01.570 ON THAT INSTANCE BECAUSE

02:00 - 02.250 THE DEPARTMENT.

02:00 - 04.640 >>AND HAD MADE A DETERMINATION

02:00 - 06.390 AS TO WHAT IT THOUGHT TO BE

02:00 - 07.290 SHOULD BE.

02:00 - 10.070 >>QUICKLY

02:00 - 11.580 YOU FILED A DECLARATORY

02:00 - 13.470 JUDGMENT ACTION IN THE COURT

02:00 - 14.620 YOU WANT CHALLENGE.

02:00 - 17.810 THE AND PAYMENT REGULATION EVER

02:00 - 20.560 APPLY IN THE BIN. AND YOU'RE

02:00 - 21.740 SAYING THAT NOT.

02:00 - 25.740 THAT INQUIRY OF NOT

02:00 - 28.500 SOMETHING THAT REALLY AMENABLE

02:00 - 29.410 TO.

02:00 - 32.480 THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS

02:00 - 32.840 BEFORE

02:00 - 33.640 THE SECRETARY.

02:00 - 35.690 >>WELL NO YOUR HONOR IF THIS

02:00 - 36.980 COURT SHOULD DETERMINE THAT THE

02:00 - 39.080 SECRETARY HAD THE AUTHORITY TO

02:00 - 40.710 ISSUE A REPORT RELEASED.

02:00 - 41.590 THEN WE

02:00 - 43.890 WOULD AGREE THAT THE ORIGINAL

02:00 - 45.240 JURISDICTION ACTION WOULD

02:00 - 47.300 BE UNNECESSARY. BUT THE PROBLEM

02:00 - 49.160 BELOW IS THAT THIS MATTER WHICH

02:00 - 50.100 THE SECRETARY MADE THE

02:00 - 51.350 DETERMINATION ON THAT ARE

02:00 - 53.420 REALLY UNDER CRAFT WAS THAT HE

02:00 - 54.310 DIDN'T EVEN HAVE

02:00 - 56.830 THE AUTHORITY ISSUED EH QUICK

02:00 - 58.460 OR REALLY ANY DID SO FOR ALL

02:00 - 00.050 THE TROUBLE I E

02:01 - 02.010 I'M TRYING TO STAY AWAY KEEP

02:01 - 03.430 HARPING ON DECLARATORY RELIEF

02:01 - 04.870 AND FOUND ME LIKE A REASON WHY

02:01 - 05.960 YOUR HEART BE WHY YOU WANT THE

02:01 - 06.960 CLERK WE'RE REALLY THINKING

02:01 - 08.240 WHAT KIND OF A QUARTER OF

02:01 - 09.960 RETROACTIVE APPLICATION.

02:01 - 12.900 >>THAT WOULD APPLY TO PRYOR.

02:01 - 15.720 RONI HAS BEEN YOUR VIEW

02:01 - 17.440 CLASSIFICATION TO THE CODE AS

02:01 - 18.250 NEW BURST OF

02:01 - 20.580 3 NUMBER 8 THE PROPER WAY YOU

02:01 - 22.130 VIEW THE ABOUT PROPERTY OF THE

02:01 - 24.400 DECLARATORY RELIEF I THINK WHAT

02:01 - 26.630 YOUR WHAT YOUR ACTION WAS BELOW

02:01 - 27.650 WAS CHALLENGING THE

02:01 - 29.640 CLASSIFICATION OF THE CODE.

02:01 - 32.450 THE NEW MOM IS REMEMBERED THE

02:01 - 33.860 HEARING OFFICER OR THE

02:01 - 35.040 SECRETARY OF HEW TO KATE IT

02:01 - 36.350 BACK TO YOU THAT WAS YOUR

02:01 - 38.410 MARRIAGE YOU DECLARATORY RELIEF

02:01 - 40.370 OR SOMETHING IF WE WIN IN

02:01 - 41.540 AMERICA TO BE WE WANT YOU

02:01 - 43.340 TO ORDER THAT COULD BE AFFECTED

02:01 - 44.530 TO ALL THE PEOPLE WHO NEVER

02:01 - 45.840 APPEALED THE NEVER CHALLENGE.

02:01 - 47.820 I'M NOT SURE YOU GET ABOUT AN

02:01 - 48.160 HOUR. THE

02:01 - 51.390 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION. BUT BUT

02:01 - 53.100 THE BUT THAT THE MARRIAGE ISSUE

02:01 - 54.620 IS THE PROPER CLASSIFICATION

02:01 - 56.570 FOR THE RIGHT TO BE CODE OR

02:01 - 57.740 THEY KNEW WHERE THEY RE

02:01 - 00.680 NUMBERED AND IT TURNS OUT

02:02 - 02.950 THE SECRETARY, IT WAS WRONG.

02:02 - 05.070 AND HOW THAT WOULD DIVIDE.

02:02 - 07.210 WE REVERSED, WE'VE GOT THE

02:02 - 08.190 RECORD STRAIGHT OF WHAT THIS

02:02 - 10.060 COLD DARK AND YOU HAVE PRETTY

02:02 - 11.310 MUCH ALL THE RELIEF HERE AGAIN

02:02 - 13.460 ENTITLED TO IT THAT YOU WANT

02:02 - 15.760 THIS RETROACTIVE DECLARATORY

02:02 - 16.180 JUDGMENT.

02:02 - 18.860 THAT YOU'RE OR YOU'RE CORRECT

02:02 - 20.680 ON THAT POINT AND THE

02:02 - 21.650 RETROACTIVE A T.

02:02 - 26.190 BOY WAS NOT ADDRESSED BELOW

02:02 - 28.720 OR BY THE SECRETARY AGAIN

02:02 - 30.140 BECAUSE THE SECRETARY MADE FROM

02:02 - 30.670 A NATION THAT

02:02 - 31.810 IT DIDN'T EVEN HAVE THE

02:02 - 33.440 AUTHORITY TO ISSUE DEBT QUICKER

02:02 - 34.510 RELIEF IN THE FIRST PLACE HE

02:02 - 36.320 DOESN'T GET ON OUT THERE HOW DO

02:02 - 38.250 HOW DID HOW DID HOW DID MAJOR

02:02 - 40.220 BE OR EVEN THE COURT HAVE THE

02:02 - 42.560 ABILITY TO GRANT RELIEF TO

02:02 - 43.860 PARTIES WHO ARE PARTY.

02:02 - 47.010 WENDER APPEAL DEADLINE FOR THE

02:02 - 48.090 BEGINNING DOCTOR NEVER

02:02 - 48.750 CHALLENGE THEM.

02:02 - 51.800 THEY WANT THE PREEM

02:02 - 52.800 COURT ISSUED THE PROPER

02:02 - 54.210 DECISION THEY DIDN'T JUST SAY

02:02 - 55.790 OH AND IT IS NOW HERE BY

02:02 - 57.190 RETROACTIVE TO EVERYBODY WHO

02:02 - 58.370 NEVER APPEALED THEIR I R A

02:02 - 59.090 DETERMINATION.

02:03 - 02.790 >>I APOLOGIZE, I'M NOT FAMILIAR

02:03 - 03.750 WITH THE WITH THE SPECIFICS OF

02:03 - 04.900 THAT CASE BUT

02:03 - 06.920 IT I THINK IT GETS TO THE

02:03 - 08.620 QUESTION OF WEATHER.

02:03 - 11.320 ALL PARTIES WHO COULD HAVE

02:03 - 14.070 INVOLVED IN THE LITIGATION.

02:03 - 17.330 IT WOULD HAVE BEEN JOIN THIS

02:03 - 18.400 PARTY TO THE ACTION.

02:03 - 20.790 AND YOU KNOW ONE OF THE ONE OF

02:03 - 23.160 THE ISSUES THAT WE ADDRESS IN

02:03 - 25.470 OUR BRIEFS AND AND BELOW BEFORE

02:03 - 26.180 THE SECRETARY

02:03 - 28.610 IS THAT THERE WAS THERE WAS NOT

02:03 - 30.710 EVEN A MECHANISM BY WHICH WE

02:03 - 32.640 COULD HAVE JOINED THOSE PARTIES

02:03 - 34.570 TO THE LITIGATION AND WE

02:03 - 36.590 WANTED THEM. IT TOOK TO BE PART

02:03 - 37.460 OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE

02:03 - 39.160 PROCEDURES THE GRAB DOESN'T

02:03 - 41.090 EVEN PROVIDE FOR HER JOINED OR

02:03 - 43.350 OF OF INDISPENSABLE PARTIES

02:03 - 44.950 EVEN ASSUMING THAT WE WE COULD

02:03 - 46.430 HAVE JOINED THEM ALL NOW OUR

02:03 - 48.110 POSITION IS THAT IT WOULDN'T

02:03 - 49.710 HAVE BEEN NECESSARY TO JOIN

02:03 - 51.790 THEM ALL AND THAT WE WE LARGELY

02:03 - 53.400 RELY ON THE ME PHILADELPHIA,

02:03 - 56.050 THE COMMONWEALTH CASE. IN WHICH

02:03 - 56.330 YOU KNOW

02:03 - 58.550 THE COURT RECOGNIZE THAT AT

02:03 - 59.980 LEAST ON THE DECK FOR JUDGMENTS

02:03 - 01.530 ACT. THERE ARE REASONABLE

02:04 - 03.490 LIMITATIONS AS TO THE

02:04 - 04.380 INVOLVEMENT OF

02:04 - 06.370 ALL PARTIES WHEN YOU HAVE

02:04 - 07.900 HUNDREDS OF PARTIES THAT WOULD

02:04 - 08.980 BE NECESSARY PARTY TO

02:04 - 10.890 LITIGATION. IT WOULD BE

02:04 - 13.390 UNWIELDY TEAM TO TRY TO BRING

02:04 - 14.020 THEM ALL IN.

02:04 - 16.290 NOW FOR YOUR MISTER HALL MY GET

02:04 - 17.660 THE PROBLEM IS YOU'RE TRYING

02:04 - 19.360 FOR YOUR NEW ONLY REASON YOU'RE

02:04 - 21.230 SPEAKING TO CLEAR TO REALLY TRY

02:04 - 22.680 TO AFFORD REALLY TO.

02:04 - 24.930 >>PARTIES WHO

02:04 - 27.230 FAILED TO PRESERVE THEIR

02:04 - 27.760 CHALLENGES.

02:04 - 30.570 >>NO YOUR HONOR I DON'T BELIEVE

02:04 - 31.620 THEY DID FAIL TO PRESERVE THE

02:04 - 33.720 CHALLENGES BECAUSE IN ANY

02:04 - 34.300 CHALLENGE.

02:04 - 37.040 >>BECAUSE AND THE PROVIDER THE

02:04 - 37.330 GIFT.

02:04 - 39.780 >>REIMBURSEMENTS THE FIRE

02:04 - 40.630 BELIEVED THERE.

02:04 - 43.810 INADEQUATE INCORRECT AND THE

02:04 - 46.270 RIGHT. THE BIG REVEAL. AND THEN

02:04 - 48.220 THE COURT OF THAT REVIEW COULD

02:04 - 49.200 MAKE THE ARGUMENT

02:04 - 52.600 THAT THE WE GOT A CALL FROM

02:04 - 56.350 DAVID EUR. ONE AROUND IT.

02:04 - 59.690 IT WAS AROUND BECAUSE THE.

02:05 - 02.900 CREATED IT EMBATTLED HAITIAN OF

02:05 - 03.430 THE REGULAR.

02:05 - 07.140 >>YOU'RE CORRECT. LEON, OR THEY

02:05 - 08.940 CERTAINLY COULD COULD ATTEMPT

02:05 - 10.590 TO GO THAT ROUTE. MY

02:05 - 12.170 EXPECTATION IS THAT

02:05 - 14.590 IF YOU KNOW HAD THEY PURSUED

02:05 - 16.210 BEEFY REVIEW IT WOULD HAVE GONE

02:05 - 16.700 FIRST TO

02:05 - 18.180 THE DEPARTMENT THEN THERE WOULD

02:05 - 20.040 HAVE BEEN AN APPELLATE REVIEW

02:05 - 20.990 TO THIS COURT

02:05 - 23.200 IN FACT AND IN THAT SCENARIO.

02:05 - 24.370 MY EXPECTATION IS THAT THE

02:05 - 26.220 PARDON WOULD BE RIGHT BACK HERE

02:05 - 26.640 SAYING

02:05 - 29.630 THAT YOU FAILED TO APPEAL THE

02:05 - 31.440 AGENCY ACTION PROPERLY.

02:05 - 34.470 BECAUSE WE MADE A DECISION IN

02:05 - 35.140 JANUARY

02:05 - 38.340 2017 AS TO THE APPLICATION OF

02:05 - 39.860 THESE CODES THE

02:05 - 42.200 THE DEPARTMENT THAT THAT POINT

02:05 - 43.350 HAS DONE EVERYTHING THEY NEED

02:05 - 44.700 TO DO UNDER THE PEER REVIEW,

02:05 - 47.250 AND THE THE INSURER. IS IT

02:05 - 49.710 ACTUALLY PROPERLY PAYING THE

02:05 - 51.190 PROVIDER IN THAT SCENARIO

02:05 - 52.450 BECAUSE THE DEPARTMENT'S

02:05 - 55.950 DETERMINATION IS THAT BE AMOUNT

02:05 - 58.180 TO BE REIMBURSED IS ACTS.

02:05 - 59.340 NOW REGARDLESS

02:05 - 01.150 OF WHETHER WE FOUGHT FOR A

02:06 - 02.200 PROVIDER MAY THOUGHT THE

02:06 - 03.630 INTERPRETATION WAS IMPROPER.

02:06 - 05.450 UNDER THE FEVER REVIEW APPEAL

02:06 - 06.840 PROCESS THAT'S NOT THE

02:06 - 09.100 MECHANISM TO CHALLENGE THE

02:06 - 12.900 APPROPRIATE. YOU HAVE PATIENTS

02:06 - 13.200 GO.

02:06 - 17.950 ALTHOUGH THE VESSEL AND YOU OFF

02:06 - 19.810 AND THE MARRIAGE AND YOU ARE

02:06 - 22.610 PEELED BACK MERRITT THE MILE TO

02:06 - 23.280 THE COURT

02:06 - 24.900 AND THEN YOUR PETITION FOR

02:06 - 26.530 REVIEW AND THAT THE CLERK OR IT

02:06 - 28.970 GOT. HOW.

02:06 - 32.790 I THINK JUDGE DROPPED SOME RAIN

02:06 - 34.400 EARLIER AND I THINK THE CORRECT

02:06 - 35.830 YOU'RE REALLY CREATING THAT THE

02:06 - 37.280 CHOIR VERY GUN FROM.

02:06 - 41.170 A REMEDY OR

02:06 - 43.680 RETROACTIVE REALLY WHEN I THINK

02:06 - 45.260 BACK THAT MAY VERY WELL BE AN

02:06 - 46.350 ACTIVE VERY ALL YOUR

02:06 - 48.630 TO DO. WHEN YOU ADD THE

02:06 - 51.170 SECRETARY REALLY IS AFTER THE

02:06 - 54.200 FED WILL BE READ ON FOR 27.

02:06 - 57.410 AND YOU'RE CHALLENGING

02:06 - 59.800 THE SCHEDULE, NOT BE YEAH, NOT

02:06 - 01.880 I PARTICULAR REIMBURSEMENT.

02:07 - 03.880 THERE WERE PARTICULAR PROVIDER.

02:07 - 05.800 >>WE ARE CHALLENGING YESTERDAY

02:07 - 06.990 AFTER THE DECISION BY THE

02:07 - 08.980 DEPARTMENT OF LABOR INDUSTRY TO

02:07 - 10.220 APPLY A CERTAIN SECTION,

02:07 - 13.940 THE CODE OF CROSS TO CONTAIN

02:07 - 16.110 THE REGULATIONS. 2 PARTICULAR.

02:07 - 18.340 CODE NUMBERS.

02:07 - 20.080 BUT WE.

02:07 - 23.150 >>B THE ABILITY OF

02:07 - 24.450 ALL PROVIDERS.

02:07 - 26.310 >>IF IF IF THIS COURT'S MAKE

02:07 - 28.470 A DETERMINATION THAT THE

02:07 - 29.980 SECRETARY'S APPLICATION WAS

02:07 - 31.830 IMPROPER. THE ABILITY OF

02:07 - 33.980 PROVIDERS TO THEN GO CHALLENGE

02:07 - 35.330 THOSE 2017.

02:07 - 38.610 THE TEENS, THEY WERE REIMBURSED

02:07 - 39.660 IS ALREADY.

02:07 - 42.650 LONG PAST ITS A 90 DAY

02:07 - 44.990 AT MAX THE TIME PERIOD IN WHICH

02:07 - 46.370 PROVIDERS COULD CHALLENGE BUT

02:07 - 47.720 TUCKER STORY BUT BUT THAT'S

02:07 - 49.240 WHAT THE LAW PROVIDES A

02:07 - 50.630 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT CAN'T

02:07 - 51.450 RECREATE.

02:07 - 54.830 >>THE STATUTORY PROCESS IN TIME

02:07 - 56.630 PERIOD INVOLVED HERE THAT

02:07 - 59.000 YOU'RE ACTING FOR THE TO BRING

02:07 - 00.430 BACK A BRAND AND SHOULD BE TO

02:08 - 02.540 ACTUALLY REWRITE THE STATUTE IN

02:08 - 03.530 CREATING NEW REMEDY.

02:08 - 07.200 I WOULDN'T BE YOUR HONOR IT.

02:08 - 10.060 >>OUR POSITION IS THAT THE THE

02:08 - 11.590 DEPTH OF HER RELIEF PROVISIONS

02:08 - 13.680 IN GRAF OR EXACTLY FOR THIS

02:08 - 13.920 TYPE

02:08 - 16.750 OF SCENARIO WHERE YOU HAVE A

02:08 - 18.450 NUMBER OF DIFFERENT PARTIES

02:08 - 20.670 AND A DECISION HAS TO HAS HAS

02:08 - 21.670 AN IMPACT ON A NUMBER OF

02:08 - 22.620 DIFFERENT PARTIES THAT WOULD

02:08 - 24.460 WOULD YOU YIELD ESSENTIALLY ON

02:08 - 26.560 WILLIE LITIGATION AND A

02:08 - 27.860 DECISION HAS BEEN MADE THAT

02:08 - 30.180 APPLIES IN A NUMBER OF

02:08 - 32.710 PROCEEDINGS THAT WOULD INVOLVE

02:08 - 34.410 OTHERWISE HAVE TAKEN PLACE IN

02:08 - 35.900 THIS INSTANCE, IT EVERY SINGLE

02:08 - 38.230 PROVIDER CHALLENGE THAT THE.

02:08 - 40.760 THE REIMBURSEMENT THAT THEY GOT

02:08 - 41.800 ON EVERY SINGLE

02:08 - 44.020 EVALUATION. YOU WOULD HAVE

02:08 - 45.960 THOUSANDS BECAUSE RIGHT OR

02:08 - 47.990 WRONG. YOU DID THAT.

02:08 - 49.600 THAT'S WHERE I THINK YOU'RE

02:08 - 50.640 YOU'RE RUNNING INTO A LITTLE

02:08 - 51.320 BIT OF A PROBLEM.

02:08 - 53.780 >>THEY'RE COMING IN WITH THE

02:08 - 55.460 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

02:08 - 57.510 AND YOU'RE ASKING FOR RETRO

02:08 - 59.060 ACTIVITY ON THE PAYMENTS THAT

02:08 - 01.420 WERE MADE IN 2017

02:09 - 03.950 IN MY VIEW NOW YOU DO HAVE IN

02:09 - 05.920 THE VERY PARTY, THE PROBLEM

02:09 - 08.900 BECAUSE IT'S BEEN REALLY THE

02:09 - 11.620 DEPARTMENT MONEY. IT TO WORK TO

02:09 - 14.340 ENSURE WHO MADE THE PAYMENT IN

02:09 - 15.870 LIGHT OF THE DEPARTMENT.

02:09 - 18.560 DETERMINATION THAT WHAT I

02:09 - 20.160 UNDERSTAND THAT YOU DON'T AGREE

02:09 - 22.910 WITH. BUT THE PROBLEM IS WHEN

02:09 - 25.750 YOU SEEK REIMBURSEMENT IF YOU

02:09 - 28.440 FROM WHO AND THEN NOW

02:09 - 30.050 THAT YOU'RE LATE ON YOUR

02:09 - 31.570 ORIGINAL JURISDICTION.

02:09 - 34.940 I THINK THAT'S WHERE YOU YOU

02:09 - 35.730 YOU CLASH

02:09 - 38.590 A BIT WITH WHO IS ACTUALLY

02:09 - 40.360 GOING TO GIVE THE REIMBURSEMENT

02:09 - 41.890 IF YOU'VE GOT TO REALLY THAT

02:09 - 43.380 YOU THOUGHT AND THEY'RE NOT

02:09 - 44.190 BEEN THE FACTION.

02:09 - 46.820 THE ANGER WE RECOGNIZE

02:09 - 47.600 THAT ISSUE.

02:09 - 49.540 >>AGAIN I GO BACK TO FILL UP

02:09 - 50.750 YOU BECOME WELL CASE

02:09 - 52.180 IN WHICH YOU KNOW THE COURT

02:09 - 53.660 RECOGNIZED STREAM COURT

02:09 - 54.850 RECOGNIZED THAT THERE ARE

02:09 - 56.800 REASONABLE LIMITATIONS THAT

02:09 - 58.700 HAPPY PLACE IN THIS EXACT TYPE

02:09 - 00.270 OF SITUATION WHEN YOU BE

02:10 - 01.510 BRINGING IN HUNDREDS OF PARTY

02:10 - 02.560 TO LITIGATION HAS

02:10 - 04.400 AS TO YOUR POINT ABOUT THE

02:10 - 05.990 TIMELINESS OF NEW FORECLOSURES

02:10 - 08.110 DICK'S REQUESTS. MY EXPECTATION

02:10 - 09.350 IS IF WE HAD IMMEDIATELY COME

02:10 - 10.540 TO THE COURT AND THERE'S PEOPLE

02:10 - 11.900 OUT THERE TO SUPPORT THIS THE

02:10 - 12.910 REQUEST AND ORIGINAL

02:10 - 14.050 JURISDICTION THAT HER

02:10 - 15.900 JUDGMENT ACTION. THE DEPARTMENT

02:10 - 17.630 WOULD RAISE FAILURE TO STOP THE

02:10 - 19.510 STATUTORY REMEDY. A NUMBER OF

02:10 - 20.900 OTHER FILM OR ACTIONS.

02:10 - 22.580 SUCH THAT WE HAVE TO GO BACK

02:10 - 23.870 DOWN AND ONE OF OUR IN MISTER

02:10 - 25.420 APPEAL DEADLINE ON THE

02:10 - 26.360 MISAPPLICATION OF THE

02:10 - 27.160 REGULATIONS.

02:10 - 29.470 I SEE THAT MY TIME HAS PASSED I

02:10 - 30.180 B A

02:10 - 31.430 WELCOME TO ANSWER ANY

02:10 - 32.540 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS BUT

02:10 - 33.530 OTHERWISE I THINK THE COURT.

02:10 - 38.740 THANK YOU MISTER HALL. THE

02:10 - 39.240 SHORT.

02:10 - 42.490 >>TO THE

02:10 - 43.940 EXTENT THERE IS A DISCUSSION

02:10 - 45.170 ABOUT THAT BASICALLY THEM.

02:10 - 48.510 >>THE MERITS OF WHETHER TO

02:10 - 51.350 RELEASE. IS ELIGIBLE IN THIS

02:10 - 53.040 MANNER NOT THIS IS.

02:10 - 55.870 ALSO SUBJECT OF AN

02:10 - 57.320 APPELLATE REVIEW. THEY WERE

02:10 - 58.630 ADDRESSED BY THE SECRETARY'S

02:10 - 59.770 DECISION TO DRESS LIKE A

02:10 - 01.370 DEPARTMENT IS QUICK IN AND

02:11 - 02.610 PRETEND TO BE ABOUT MATTERS.

02:11 - 03.490 I DO BELIEVE THEY WOULD BE

02:11 - 04.880 INTERESTED IN IN THAT MATCH.

02:11 - 08.530 AND AGAIN BECAUSE I DO NOT

02:11 - 08.770 BELIEVE

02:11 - 12.640 >>WHY ON I FEEL ON

02:11 - 14.850 THE MARRIAGE. WE AGREE WITH THE

02:11 - 17.150 PHYSICAL THERAPIST THAT THE

02:11 - 19.250 SECRETARY MET WHY THE COST

02:11 - 20.620 CONTAINMENT REGULATION.

02:11 - 25.900 WHAT REALLY COULD

02:11 - 27.460 WE ARE THE GREAT DIRECTED

02:11 - 30.190 SECRETARY TO RE TO ME.

02:11 - 32.500 THEY'VE GOT HIM.

02:11 - 37.930 >>AND WHAT WOULD BE THE

02:11 - 39.220 EFFECTIVE DATE OF THAT

02:11 - 40.500 CORRECTED THE DEVIL.

02:11 - 42.880 >>OBVIOUSLY YOU KNOW WHAT THE

02:11 - 44.110 REVIEW THE END OF THE APOLLO WE

02:11 - 45.230 DO BELIEVE IT WAS STRICTLY

02:11 - 45.970 FOUND ON.

02:11 - 49.250 TO THE EAST AND HIS RHETORIC.

02:11 - 53.010 ISN'T THAT

02:11 - 55.720 IS AGAINST HAHA.

02:11 - 57.970 >>COMPAQ BUT WE ARE THE

02:11 - 00.030 SECRETARY TO REDO THE FEDERAL

02:12 - 00.980 WE THOUGHT IT.

02:12 - 04.170 ONE WAS THE RESULT

02:12 - 06.790 OF A IF APPLICATION OF THE COST

02:12 - 07.900 CONTAINMENT REGULATE.

02:12 - 13.310 >>HE SAID I'M NOT SURE MANY IT

02:12 - 13.830 COULD BE.

02:12 - 18.450 IT DOES IT WILL BE WAITING CARE

02:12 - 20.210 GOING HERE, TIMING.

02:12 - 21.870 >>OF THE RIVER HALL, I'M JEFF

02:12 - 24.500 AT I THINK CARD WE DIRECT THE

02:12 - 25.490 SECRETARY.

02:12 - 29.130 WHO BETTER TO TO TO ADOPT A NEW

02:12 - 30.040 THE BACKUP.

02:12 - 34.510 5 THE EFFECTIVE DATE.

02:12 - 39.920 >>YOU MAY LIVE IN YOUR LIFE

02:12 - 41.820 REALLY AND WE ORDER.

02:12 - 47.490 IF YOU AGREE TO YOU. CAN

02:12 - 48.180 YOU LOSE.

02:12 - 51.950 >>IF WE LOSE YOU IT WOULD BE

02:12 - 53.560 REJECTED AND AS SOON AS

02:12 - 54.420 EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE

02:12 - 54.980 INDECISION.

02:12 - 00.130 >>OKAY WE WOULD WE WOULD PREFER

02:13 - 01.880 WE WOULD REVIEW BURST THE CODE

02:13 - 03.320 THAT WE THINK WERE IRAN

02:13 - 05.910 IS CLASSIFIED. REVERSE THAT

02:13 - 06.800 PART OF THE SECRETARY'S

02:13 - 08.560 DECISION AND.

02:13 - 10.900 THAT WOULD PROBABLY PROMPT THE

02:13 - 12.800 SECRETARY TO REVIVE.

02:13 - 15.460 THE GUIDE WILL CONVICT HIM WITH

02:13 - 17.570 THE COURTS RULE AND AND THEN

02:13 - 19.490 THE QUESTION GOING TO BE WHAT

02:13 - 20.610 ABOUT THOSE

02:13 - 23.000 THE 2017 CASUAL THE QUESTION IS

02:13 - 24.120 GOING TO BE WHAT ABOUT THOSE

02:13 - 25.220 PAYMENTS THAT WERE MADE UNDER

02:13 - 26.420 THAT SCHEDULE BEFORE WITH

02:13 - 27.780 CORRECTED BY THE COURTS.

02:13 - 30.530 AND I GET THE QUESTION IS.

02:13 - 32.060 MISTER HALL WENT UP TO THE

02:13 - 34.540 BUYBACK QUESTION IN THE CONTEXT

02:13 - 36.830 OF THE CASE NOW YOU WOULD

02:13 - 38.120 PROBABLY PROJECT TO

02:13 - 40.800 BE DIVIDED. IF AND WHEN TO

02:13 - 41.820 LEARN HOW PROFIT

02:13 - 45.280 COMING OUT IF AND WHEN PROVIDER

02:13 - 47.280 BY TO FILE A NEW PETITION.

02:13 - 50.090 THE KING, THE REFINED THEM

02:13 - 51.110 WHERE TO GET IT OUT THAT WAY.

02:13 - 53.490 THEY'RE TAKING THE ADDITIONAL

02:13 - 54.580 PAYMENT AND LITIGATE IT OUT

02:13 - 55.010 THAT WAY.

02:13 - 57.360 >>THEY SEND OF AND THE PARTIES

02:13 - 59.290 AFTER. IS THIS IS THE PRESENT.

02:14 - 01.970 AND SO WE DON'T KNOW IF THE

02:14 - 03.380 SCENE WITH THE PROGRAM.

02:14 - 08.710 THAT'S ON EVERYBODY'S PART.

02:14 - 16.320 >>THAT CONCLUDES OUR TEAM AND I

02:14 - 17.060 ARE 28.

02:14 - 19.710 >>THE EYES OF THE

02:14 - 21.820 NATION ARE ON PENNSYLVANIA AS A

02:14 - 24.040 KEY INFLUENCER TO THAT 2020

02:14 - 27.290 ELECTION. PCN HAS OVER 25 YEARS

02:14 - 28.530 OF TRUSTED STATE GOVERNMENT

02:14 - 30.670 COVERAGE. OUR NETWORK IS YOUR

02:14 - 32.620 PLATFORM TO CONNECT DIRECTLY

02:14 - 33.940 WITH PENNSYLVANIA VOTERS,

02:14 - 35.640 WHETHER IT'S A PRESIDENTIAL

02:14 - 37.790 RACE STATEWIDE CAMPAIGN OR

02:14 - 40.040 LOCAL CAUSE. OUR VIEWERS ARE

02:14 - 41.770 READY TO HEAR FROM YOU IF

02:14 - 42.600 YOU'RE AT NOW

02:14 - 45.130 PCN YOUR ACCESS TO

02:14 - 46.560 PENNSYLVANIA, VOTERS.

02:14 - 55.790 >>NUMBER 29, WHICH IS THE

02:14 - 56.960 PENNSYLVANIA VIRTUAL

02:14 - 59.500 CHARTER SCHOOL THAT ALL 4 OF

02:14 - 00.980 THE PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF

02:15 - 03.640 EDUCATION AND SECRETARY RIVERA

02:15 - 07.460 EVER TOOL. CHARTER SCHOOL AND

02:15 - 08.720 OTHER CAR COOL

02:15 - 10.690 HAVE FILED AN ACTION IN THE

02:15 - 12.820 COURT REGIONAL PURE FICTION THE

02:15 - 16.280 TALENT TO $15 FEE IMPOSED BY

02:15 - 18.290 THE DEPARTMENT NOW OF EDUCATION

02:15 - 19.680 ARNE CHARTER SCHOOL.

02:15 - 23.190 I THINK THEY'RE FUN REDIRECTION

02:15 - 25.810 REQUESTS. THE

02:15 - 27.950 CHARTER SCHOOL. THE FEE IS

02:15 - 29.680 NOT AUTHORIZED BY THE CHARTER

02:15 - 31.100 SCHOOL LAW. IT FOUND

02:15 - 34.470 CONSTITUTIONALLY BAY AND THERE

02:15 - 35.310 FUNDING.

02:15 - 37.870 WHO WOULD THEY ARE ENTITLED

02:15 - 40.440 BY LAW. THE CHARTER SCHOOL AT

02:15 - 42.100 FORT HOOD WHERE THE BE

02:15 - 44.650 UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND TO ENJOY

02:15 - 45.870 THEM. HOW ELECTION.

02:15 - 48.920 THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION HAS

02:15 - 50.760 FILED A MOTION TO THE MAN.

02:15 - 53.710 THE ACTION AND LACKING ANY

02:15 - 55.650 LEGAL MERIT. THE DEPARTMENT CAN

02:15 - 57.610 PAN TO BE ADMINISTRATIVE PROBE

02:15 - 57.740 OF

02:15 - 00.820 1929 GET THAT AUTHORITY TO

02:16 - 03.270 IMPOSE REASONABLE FEES FOR

02:16 - 04.990 SERVICES THAT IT PROVIDES

02:16 - 07.010 AND THE CHARTER SCHOOL LAW DOES

02:16 - 08.450 NOT LIMIT THE DEPARTMENT

02:16 - 10.370 AUTHORITY. THEY RECOVERED.

02:16 - 13.540 IN KRAKOW THING REDIRECTION

02:16 - 16.260 REQUEST, THE DEPARTMENT ARGUED

02:16 - 17.570 THAT THE BE CLEARLY THE

02:16 - 19.670 BRIGHT CONDITIONS THAT TRIGGER

02:16 - 21.750 TO BE ABOUT IF NOT

02:16 - 25.240 UNCONSTITUTIONAL. WE'RE HERE ON

02:16 - 25.660 THE CAR.

02:16 - 29.470 PRELIMINARY OBJECTION, THE

02:16 - 31.920 MOTION AND A HALF. FROM YOUR

02:16 - 34.530 CORN. YOU THEY SAY.

02:16 - 38.740 >>IN MAY IT PLEASE

02:16 - 40.330 THE COURT. MY NAME IS

02:16 - 42.050 ALEX HORNE I'M A DEPUTY

02:16 - 43.070 ATTORNEY GENERAL IN THE

02:16 - 44.310 PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ATTORNEY

02:16 - 45.700 GENERAL AND I REPRESENT

02:16 - 47.480 RESPONDED TO THE CASE. THE

02:16 - 48.430 PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF

02:16 - 50.290 EDUCATION, THE SECRETARY OF

02:16 - 52.400 EDUCATION. MISTER RIVERA

02:16 - 54.430 BEFORE I BEGIN I WOULD LIKE TO

02:16 - 55.930 UNDER 2 MINUTES FOR REBUTTAL IF

02:16 - 56.240 I MAY.

02:17 - 04.050 ALREADY STATED THIS CASE

02:17 - 05.510 CONCERNING THE LEGALITY.

02:17 - 08.360 $50 IF THE DOCTOR BY THE

02:17 - 09.520 PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF

02:17 - 11.340 EDUCATION, THE REVIEW, THE

02:17 - 13.380 ADMINISTRATIVE OFF. SO GOOD

02:17 - 16.430 THAT HE CRIED THE THING BE

02:17 - 17.250 DIRECTION PAYMENT.

02:17 - 20.080 >>A UNITED

02:17 - 21.920 FRONT HAS BEEN IN A BIT BE

02:17 - 23.000 REALLY A FEE

02:17 - 25.660 FOR ACQUIRING ON THE CHARTER

02:17 - 27.230 SCHOOL AND OTHERWISE ENTITLE TO

02:17 - 27.710 REPEAT.

02:17 - 30.870 FOR TAKING MY YOU KNOW ARGUING

02:17 - 32.180 THAT IT IS VITAL TO RETHINK.

02:17 - 38.950 >>THE MISSION OF RESPONDENTS

02:17 - 41.560 SAID THAT HE IS OR FOR US.

02:17 - 44.310 THAT HE PROVIDES TO TRY IT'S

02:17 - 44.780 COOL.

02:17 - 50.070 IT HAS ONLY PROVIDED TO TRY TO

02:17 - 51.550 SCHOOL ALONE NOT WELL THAT.

02:17 - 54.380 >>IN THAT OUR SCHOOLS ARE

02:17 - 56.220 STRUCTURED DIFFERENTLY AND THEY

02:17 - 57.990 HAVE TOO OFTEN TIME

02:17 - 00.340 GO THROUGH A DIFFERENT PROCESS

02:18 - 02.180 IN ORDER TO RECEIVE THE FUNDING

02:18 - 03.060 THAT THEY'RE OTHERWISE

02:18 - 05.160 BEEN FILED TO REPEAT AND

02:18 - 06.200 THEREFORE YOU'RE ACTUALLY

02:18 - 08.220 REDUCING THE FUNDING BY HAVING

02:18 - 08.660 A GREAT.

02:18 - 12.080 >>I RESPECTFULLY HONOR AGAIN WE

02:18 - 15.170 DISAGREE. THE FUNDING

02:18 - 16.620 IS PROVIDED THE SCHOOL

02:18 - 18.290 DISTRICTS THAT STILL PROVIDING

02:18 - 19.500 PAYMENTS IN OUT

02:18 - 21.420 IN AN AMOUNT TO BE DEDUCTED

02:18 - 22.790 FROM THE ON STATE FUNDING THE

02:18 - 23.920 SCHOOL DISTRICT OTHER RIGHT.

02:18 - 27.320 C WITH THE FEE IS 4 IF THE EX

02:18 - 29.120 TRUMP ADMINISTRATION BIRD DID

02:18 - 31.400 HE HAVE IT

02:18 - 33.930 PROVIDED FUNDING. IT ONLY

02:18 - 35.480 REFORMS FOR CHARTERS.

02:18 - 37.730 >>AND FOR

02:18 - 40.220 IN THE GUN THE CUNANAN HAVE A

02:18 - 41.720 GENERAL ASSEMBLY SET UP THIS

02:18 - 42.080 POLL.

02:18 - 44.690 THE PROCESS THE CHARTER SCHOOL

02:18 - 45.760 HAD TO GO THROUGH THIS

02:18 - 48.300 ADDITIONAL STEP WHERE REGULAR

02:18 - 49.580 SCHOOL DISTRICTS DON'T.

02:18 - 52.670 YOU'RE OUT OF THAT IS THAT IS

02:18 - 55.060 CORRECT THAT IS BUT THAT SHOULD