00:13 - >>THE FIRST MATTER IS

00:16 - JONATHAN PETERS FORCES, THE

00:17 - WORKERS COMPENSATION

00:18 - APPEAL BOARD. SOME COST

00:19 - CORPORATION REPRESENTING

00:21 - GENERAL COMPUTERS, HIS ATTORNEY

00:23 - DANIEL DANIEL J SIEGEL

00:25 - REPRESENTING KELLY SUNPASS

00:26 - CORPORATION IS PRETTY KATHLEEN

00:29 - PEOPLE PICKING UP.

00:33 - GOOD

00:35 - EVERYONE.

00:36 - >>ALL OF YOU YOUR SUMMER

00:38 - SESSION. IM A REMOTELY.

00:42 - IN LIGHT OF THE CONTINUING

00:44 - PUBLIC HEALTH GUIDANCE. THE

00:46 - COUNCIL I THINK OF THEM.

00:49 - 3 OF THE PROTOCOL. THIS

00:52 - FASHION. IT REMINDS EVERYONE.

00:59 - NUMBER 2 THEY BE ISSUES IN THE

01:01 - CASE OF THE ARMY FOOTBALL.

01:04 - THAT WILL BE FELT FROM THE

01:07 - PAVEMENT.

01:10 - THE JUSTICES HAVE ENOUGH IN THE

01:13 - FIRST QUESTION TO YOU. ENDEAVOR

01:16 - IN MY REMOTE. THAT'S THE

01:23 - AND AS

01:25 - I REMEMBER THAT WE HAVE A

01:28 - YOU'RE FREE. A

01:30 - FULLY COM. ALL THE ISSUES.

01:38 - THE FIRST CASES IN CALL.

01:43 - IN WHICH CLAIM TO REPRESENT IT

01:47 - REQUIRED TO TRAVEL FOR WORK.

01:49 - IF YOU'RE GOING INTO THE MOTOR

01:51 - VEHICLE ACCIDENT. THE PLANE

01:57 - THE CASE PRESENTS UNIQUE BACK

01:59 - TO MARY.

02:01 - WHICH MADE FOR A FINE

02:02 - CIRCUMSTANCE.

02:04 - IN WHICH IT PROBABLY BOY WILL

02:06 - BE DOING THE ACTING THE GOAT

02:16 - >>NO MORNING MEMBERS OF THE

02:17 - COURT MAY PLEASE

02:18 - THE COURT AND THEN SAY GO ON

02:20 - BEHALF OF JONATHAN PETERS ALSO

02:22 - PRESENT WITH ME IS THE LEXUS

02:24 - BIRD WHO WOULD HANDLE THE

02:25 - MATTER IN THE LOWER COURTS.

02:27 - THIS CASE IS SOMEWHAT UNUSUAL

02:30 - ANIMALS. SOME WERE NOT UNUSUAL

02:32 - IN THE SENSE THAT FEELING WITH

02:34 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES

02:35 - EMPLOYEES AS. YOUR HONOR

02:38 - INDICATED DO NOT HAVE A FIXED

02:39 - PLACE OF WORK IS A VERY

02:41 - COMMON SITUATION. I THINK

02:44 - PENNSYLVANIA AND THROUGHOUT THE

02:45 - COUNTRY. THIS COURT HAS NEVER

02:47 - HAD

02:47 - THE OPPORTUNITY TO DETERMINE

02:50 - THE STANDARDS HOWEVER UNTIL

02:52 - THIS CASE 4 TRAVELING EMPLOYEES

02:55 - IN TERMS OF WHAT IS THE

02:57 - DEFINITION OF THE TRAVELING

02:58 - EMPLOYEE. WHAT ARE THE

03:00 - STANDARDS THAT APPLY.

03:03 - TO DETERMINE WHAT IS A PENCIL

03:05 - INJURY, TRAVELING EMPLOYEES ARE

03:08 - SOME WHAT YOU NEED IN THE SENSE

03:10 - THAT UNLIKE TYPICAL WORKERS WHO

03:13 - WORK FROM ANY LOCATION AND IN

03:16 - SUFFERED INJURIES,

03:17 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES ARE THOSE

03:19 - EMPLOYEES WITHOUT A FIXED PLACE

03:22 - OF BUSINESS AND

03:23 - THE STANDARDS I HAVE BEEN

03:25 - APPLIED TO THIS TIME BY THE

03:28 - COMMONWEALTH OR.

03:30 - NOW ALL FOCUSED ON THE

03:32 - FACT THAT ONCE AN EMPLOYEE HAS

03:34 - A TRACK WHO IS A TRAVELING

03:35 - EMPLOYEES. IT IS BEGIN HIS

03:38 - OR HER. TRAVELS THAT THAT

03:41 - ENTIRE PROCESS IT CONTINUES AND

03:44 - IS FURTHERING THE EMPLOYER'S

03:45 - BUSINESS ACTIVITIES WEATHER.

03:48 - THEY ARE A TRAVELING SALESMAN

03:49 - SOMEONE WHO ASKED TO TRAVEL OUT

03:51 - OF TOWN

03:52 - AND CETERA. THIS CASE PRESENTS

03:55 - THE SITUATION WHERE AN EMPLOYEE

03:57 - WAS INJURED WHEN HIS

03:59 - WAY HOME FROM A SOCIAL

04:01 - OF RAMPS AND ALLOWS THIS COURT

04:04 - HAS HEARD THE QUESTIONS THAT

04:05 - HAVE BEEN. THE RAYS

04:08 - HAS TO WHAT CONSTITUTES A

04:10 - BRANDON MAN OF EMPLOYMENT.

04:12 - WE HAVE GONE AND WHAT WE

04:14 - HAVE PROPOSED THIS COURT

04:16 - ARE ESSENTIALLY 3 CONCURRENT

04:19 - STANDARDS THAT WOULD CREATE A

04:21 - CONSISTENT ANALYSIS WHETHER IN

04:23 - THIS PARTICULAR CASE

04:25 - OR IN ANY OTHER CASE INVOLVING

04:27 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES. WE SUGGEST

04:30 - THAT THE COURT FIRST, THE

04:32 - FLYING TRAVELING EMPLOYEES AS

04:35 - ANY EMPLOYEES WHO WEARS WHO HAS

04:37 - TO TRAVEL FROM PLACE TO PLACE

04:39 - AWAY FROM TYPICALLY A PERMANENT

04:41 - RESIDENTS OR THE EMPLOYERS

04:43 - PLACE OF BUSINESS WHERE AND

04:45 - SUCH.

04:46 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES. IT WOULD

04:48 - INCLUDE FROM WHEN THEY BEGAN

04:50 - THEIR TRIP UNTIL THEY

04:52 - ARRIVED HOME, UNLESS

04:54 - THERE IS WHAT HAS BEEN CALLED

04:57 - IN A BAND OF MEN OF EMPLOYMENT

04:58 - AND THAT'S REALLY THE CENTRAL

05:00 - ISSUE HERE. WE PROPOSE

05:02 - THAT AND CONSISTENT WITH MANY

05:05 - OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT CASES

05:07 - THAT ABANDONMENT OF EMPLOYMENT.

05:09 - WE HAVE TO BE A DISTINCT BREAK

05:13 - RAHM THE ACTIVITIES THAT WOULD

05:15 - BE GONE BY THE EMPLOYEE AS

05:18 - OPPOSED TO TEMPORARY DEPARTURES

05:21 - 4. THEY ANTICIPATED THING

05:24 - SECTOR PERSONAL COMFORTS ON

05:27 - EMPLOYMENT

05:28 - RELATED EVENTS AND ALSO WHERE

05:31 - YOU ARE ATTENDING EMPLOYER

05:33 - SPONSORED EVENT WHETHER

05:34 - VOLUNTARY OR NOT AND THEN AS

05:38 - HAS BEEN A FLIGHT TYPICALLY IN

05:40 - THE COMMONWEALTH COURT AND IN

05:41 - OTHER JURISDICTIONS AS SET OUT

05:43 - IN NOT JUST DRUG TO BILLY OR

05:45 - SIDE OF THE CENTER OF THE

05:47 - COMMONWEALTH COURT. AN EMPLOYER

05:49 - WOULD HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO

05:50 - REFINE THE PRESUMPTION THAT

05:53 - IT'S WORK-RELATED BY

05:55 - DEMONSTRATING THAT IT WAS SUCH

05:57 - A GREAT IN THE.

05:59 - ACTIVITY AS TO REMOVE THE

06:01 - EMPLOYEE PROM THE FORCE OF

06:07 - THIS IS JUST THERE.

06:13 - >>QUIET TRAVEL WASN'T

06:15 - TRAVELING. IT MEANS.

06:18 - I THINK WE'LL LOOK FOR QUESTION

06:21 - IS WHETHER THE TO COOL IT WON'T

06:23 - BE AND THE DUMPS. OR IN SCHOOL

06:27 - THE MAYOR, THE TYPICAL.

06:30 - IF YOU SAY THAT NONE OF OUR

06:31 - TAPE REPORT RECORD OF EVERY

06:33 - WHERE.

06:36 - WHO CAN SEE YOUR

06:38 - HOME FREE. THAT'S THE

06:40 - UNDERLYING PURPOSE OF THE BOX.

06:42 - WHY WHEN THE EMPLOYEE WHO WAS

06:44 - THE SEATS.

06:45 - >>THEY COULD NOT TESTIFY

06:46 - THEIR MOTIVATION. THE POLLS ON

06:49 - THE ROAD BY THE FAIRNESS TO

06:50 - THEM BECAUSE THEY WOULD TRAVEL.

06:52 - HERE ARE YOUR EMPLOYEES,

06:54 - THE VIBE BE ABLE TO PARK

06:58 - THE BUS THAT I WAS NOT GOING

06:59 - HOME, THE FED OFF THE GOOD OF

07:04 - OUR PLAY THAT I FELT LIKE GOING

07:06 - TO GET A DRINK OR DRIVE

07:07 - INCLUDING NOT GOING TO SAY OR

07:09 - WE WOULDN'T BE HERE.

07:10 - THOSE WHO HOLD THE PRISON

07:12 - INMATE ONLY SAID.

07:15 - THE EMPLOYEE WHO IS

07:17 - WHO GOES TO SEND THE CELL

07:18 - WITHOUT FOOD HERE.

07:21 - >>I KNOW

07:22 - YOUR HONOR. THE TRAVELING

07:24 - EMPLOYEE DOCTRINE SHOULD APPLY

07:26 - REGARDLESS WHETHER IT IS A

07:28 - FATAL PLANE WHO CLAIM SUCH AS

07:31 - THIS THE RATIONALE BEHIND THAT

07:34 - IS WHEN

07:35 - TROUBLE IS AND THE CENTRAL PART

07:38 - OF THE EMPLOYMENT SUCH AS IN

07:40 - THIS CASE FOR A SALESMAN.

07:42 - THE RISK OF INJURY. OF

07:46 - BEING INJURED WEATHER IN

07:48 - WHATEVER MEANS IS INCIDENT

07:50 - THAT EMPLOYMENT AND AS LONG AS

07:53 - THE EMPLOYEE IS STILL

07:56 - WITHIN THE CONTINUUM OF

07:57 - PERFORMING FOR ON THE TRAVEL

07:59 - FOR THE EMPLOYER SHOULD APPLY.

08:01 - WE DON'T

08:02 - BELIEVE THAT THE STANDARD OR

08:04 - THE SUGGESTION THAT IT MUST BE

08:06 - A FATAL PLANE

08:07 - IS APPROPRIATE.

08:08 - THERE'S NO SUCH SUGGESTION IN

08:11 - THE ACT AND IN FACT SECTION

08:13 - KOREA ONE OF THE ACT.

08:14 - IT SPECIFIES THAT INJURIES CAN

08:17 - OCCUR OFF PREMISES IN MAKES NO

08:19 - DISTINCTION MOREOVER TO ACCEPT

08:22 - THE EMPLOYERS

08:23 - ARGUMENTS THIS CORE WOULD ALSO

08:25 - BE CREATING THE TRAVELING

08:27 - EMPLOYEE DOCTOR AND

08:29 - CREATING THE TEST THAT APPLIES

08:31 - TO AN OFFICE BASED EMPLOYEE

08:33 - WHICH IS SIMPLY FOR THE RAMS OF

08:35 - AN EMPLOYER'S BUSINESS

08:37 - WHEN COURTS HAVE LOOKED AT

08:39 - PRIMARILY THE COMMONWEALTH

08:40 - COURT THAT STANDARD

08:42 - THEY HAVE DETERMINED THAT WALL

08:44 - YOU'RE IN THE CONTINUUM BEING

08:46 - YOU'RE TRAVELING EMPLOYER E ALL

08:48 - OF THOSE ACTIVITIES ARE

08:50 - FURTHERING THE EMPLOYER'S

08:51 - BUSINESS UNLESS THERE IS

08:53 - SUCH A GREAT GUESS THE CONCHS

08:56 - CAN I FOLLOW UP THEIR SECOND

08:57 - YOU GET TO YOU WELL YOU'RE

08:59 - YOU'RE ALWAYS

09:00 - WITH YOU.

09:01 - >>REPRESENTED THE AT THE W THE

09:04 - DAY THE CHP IS THAT IS THAT

09:06 - ACCURATE. YES, I KNOW

09:09 - A NEW GUIDE IN THE TRAVELING

09:12 - EMPLOYEES ARE CONTINUING.

09:14 - I WORK.

09:16 - THERE'S ON I THOUGHT THAT WAS

09:17 - INTERESTING BECAUSE WE PRESUME

09:19 - THAT THEY HAVE.

09:21 - IN THIS MATTER

09:23 - AND DOES OUR 4TH OF THE

09:24 - COMMONWEALTH COURT AND HERE OR

09:26 - ANY INSIGHT. IT

09:28 - IS IT WASN'T NOT RATE DO NOT

09:30 - RAISE IT THE OTHER SIDE NOT

09:32 - RAISED TODAY WILL BE QUICKLY

09:34 - REJECTED. WHAT HAPPENED HERE

09:36 - THAT NEITHER OF THOSE.

09:39 - YOU KNOW THE TIME.

09:42 - >>IN COOL HAND FROM DEPENDENCE

09:44 - TO PAGE 10 YOU WILL SEE THAT

09:46 - THE FIRST COMPENSATION JUDGE IN

09:49 - HIS FINDING

09:50 - THE BACK SAID AND I'LL QUOTE IT

09:52 - IS ACKNOWLEDGED THE CLAIM IS

09:54 - CONSIDERED A TRAVELING

09:55 - EMPLOYEES AND THEREFORE

09:57 - CONSIDERATION IS GIVEN TO THAT

09:59 - PRESUMPTION THAT CETERA ET

10:00 - CETERA, THE. THERE YOU SEE

10:03 - A B

10:04 - ALSO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT HE WAS A

10:07 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEE.

10:09 - AS DID COMMONWEALTH COURT THAT

10:11 - WAS THE CENTRAL DISTINCTION.

10:13 - THE PROBLEM WAS THAT THERE WAS

10:15 - AN ANALYSIS GONE THAT PRIMARILY

10:18 - LOOK AT SOCIAL

10:20 - EVENT CASES OTHER THAN

10:22 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEE CASES BUT

10:24 - CLEARLY WHEN YOU LOOK

10:25 - AT THE MATTER BEFORE THE W C J

10:28 - THE WC DAY AS I QUOTED

10:30 - ACKNOWLEDGED THAT HE IS

10:31 - CONSIDERED A TRAP THAT WAS NOT

10:33 - IN BEFORE.

10:34 - >>WHEN I STARTED MY MY MY

10:36 - FIRST QUESTION THEY SAID LISTEN

10:39 - TO ME OR PERFECT 50 TO TRAVEL,

10:41 - I'M 40 THE ISSUE WHETHER HE

10:43 - GETS HE. IT WAS ON IF

10:46 - THE SCREEN. FROM THAT IT COULD

10:48 - BE IS I 5 AND ALL THAT.

10:55 - AND HE COULD BE A TRAVEL

10:57 - FOR HE, NOT A. NOT TO SEE

11:01 - BECAUSE IN THE BACK.

11:02 - THANK GOODNESS AND THEREFORE

11:04 - NOT ABLE TO THE PRISON. OR

11:06 - CONVERT FLEE A BESIEGED TRAVEL

11:09 - FOR A LITTLE BIT LIKE THE DEAD

11:10 - MAN'S WORLD

11:11 - WHO CAUSE WE CAN'T COACH PASSED

11:14 - THE 5. WELL I'VE BEEN

11:15 - AWFULLY GOOD. GO TO THE

11:19 - YOU KNOW I 2 '05 MY

11:21 - MY EXES BECAUSE I WAS TRYING TO

11:23 - GET YOUR BEST AS I COULD AND ON

11:25 - AND ON AND ON

11:26 - SO BECAUSE YOU GET YOU ARE

11:29 - GETTING FOR CREDIBILITY

11:30 - DETERMINATION ON WHETHER THIS

11:32 - IS A FALL BEFORE OR CONTINUING

11:35 - TO WORK. YOU DON'T NEED IT.

11:37 - THE LAST AT YEAH, I THINK THE

11:40 - CENTRAL POINT THE CASE. WELL I

11:42 - THINK.

11:42 - >>THE PRESUMPTION SHOULD APPLY

11:44 - AND THAT'S THE TASK THAT WE

11:46 - PROPOSED TO

11:47 - THE COURT THAT THE PRESUMPTION

11:49 - APPLIES AND THEN MAYBE

11:50 - EVERYBODY.

11:52 - BECAUSE AS MUCH AS YOU CAN HAVE

11:54 - A TASK IT WILL ALWAYS COME DOWN

11:56 - TO A DETERMINATION BY THE JUDGE

11:58 - IS THE FACT FINDER WEATHER.

12:01 - IT'S BEEN IS WHETHER

12:02 - THE EMPLOYER, EVERYBODY THAT

12:04 - PRESUMPTION WHETHER THE

12:06 - EVIDENCE

12:06 - IS SUFFICIENT BUT THE

12:07 - DISTINCTION BETWEEN WHETHER AN

12:09 - EMPLOYEE LIVES OR DIES.

12:13 - >>IS IS A DISTINCTION THAT IS.

12:17 - WHAT IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH.

12:21 - >>ANY OTHER

12:21 - CASE LAW OR ANY OTHER STATES

12:24 - THAT HAVE ADDRESSED THIS THEY

12:26 - LOOK AT IT AS THE EMPLOYEE.

12:28 - ONCE

12:29 - A TRAVELING SALESMAN ONCE I

12:31 - LEAVE MY HOUSE

12:32 - TODAY TOO THOUGH ON MY ROOF AND

12:35 - STOP OF THE DIFFERENT

12:36 - BUSINESSES.

12:38 - STILL PRESUMED TO BE TRAVELING

12:41 - EMPLOYEE UNTIL LIGHT YET HOME

12:43 - AN END. MY NOW YOU BRING

12:46 - THE TIME.

12:47 - I DECIDE TO ABSCOND AND GO TO A

12:50 - MOTEL WITH SOMEONE OR SOMETHING

12:52 - LIKE THAT.

12:54 - DIS COREY GREAT RAHM

12:57 - THE WORK THAT WOULD

12:59 - NORMALLY BE BUT THE REBUTTAL

13:01 - THAT THE EMPLOYER WOULD

13:03 - PRESENT. BUT IT IS.

13:05 - >>MISTER SIEGEL, IT'S JUST THIS

13:06 - TIME. YEAH.

13:19 - >>MAKING HIM HAVE A GREAT DEAL

13:22 - OF HIS EMPLOYMENT.

13:23 - IT DOES NOT MAKE SENSE IN A

13:25 - SITUATION WHERE AND HERE THE

13:28 - EMPLOYER WAS IN A SENSE

13:30 - SPONSOR, THE SOCIAL GATHERING.

13:40 - IT'S A VERY CLEAR

13:41 - DISTINCTION THERE IT THAT

13:44 - DISTINGUISHES THIS CASE FROM

13:46 - ANY CASE WHERE YOU KNOW AND

13:48 - JUST STUFF.

13:49 - >>YES, YES, YOUR HONOR THAT'S

13:51 - THAT'S THE POINT IN THIS

13:53 - PARTICULAR CASE. WELL

13:55 - THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF

13:57 - DISCUSSION ABOUT WHETHER IT'S

13:58 - VOLUNTARY

13:59 - OR INVOLUNTARY ON THE DESCENT

14:02 - ADDRESSES AS WELL IN THE

14:03 - COMMONWEALTH COURT THAT IT WENT

14:05 - TO AN EVENT THAT WAS.

14:08 - AN EMPLOYER EVENT

14:10 - WHETHER IT WAS MANDATORY OR NOT

14:12 - THE EMPLOYER. THE SUPERVISOR

14:14 - WAS THERE. HE WENT DIRECTLY

14:17 - FROM WORK. THE CAUSE. THE

14:19 - COMPANY PAID FOR ALL OF THE

14:22 - REFRESHMENTS WHO DRINK,

14:23 - WHATEVER IT WAS

14:25 - USE ON A COMPANY CREDIT CARD

14:28 - AND

14:29 - FROM THERE. HE BEGAN HIS

14:31 - TRAVELS HOME WHEN HE GOT INTO

14:33 - THE ACCIDENT. THAT'S ALL WITHIN

14:35 - THE CONTINUUM SORT OF THE

14:37 - REASONABLE CONTINUE ON THAT HAS

14:40 - ALWAYS BEEN DONE WHAT'S

14:42 - HAPPENED HERE. IT IS

14:45 - STANDER.

14:46 - WITH ADDED ESSENTIALLY BY

14:48 - COMMONWEALTH WORKERS AND HE

14:49 - PASSED HIS EXIT FROM HIS HOUSE.

14:51 - WELL IF HE HAD NOT PASSED

14:53 - THE EXIT BECAUSE HE LIVED

14:54 - 20 MILES FURTHER. IRONICALLY IT

14:57 - WOULD HAVE BEEN CAN PENCIL

14:58 - THAT'S NOT A THIS BEING SHIPPED

15:00 - IT HAS AND HE SORT OF

15:01 - RATIONAL BASIS. I'M NOT.

15:05 - >>QUITE UNDERSTANDING THIS

15:06 - IN TERMS OF THE COMMONWEALTH

15:08 - COURT'S ANALYSIS REGARDING THE

15:10 - EXIT.

15:19 - CHANGE

15:19 - JUST FLOWS AND THEN ONE OR

15:21 - 2 EMPLOYER SPOT.

15:29 - MAKE A DIFFERENCE, IT'S STILL A

15:30 - LOT OF.

15:32 - >>I DON'T BELIEVE IT IS IT'S NO

15:34 - DIFFERENT

15:34 - THAN YOU. SOMEONE IF HE DID

15:36 - THAT WORK WELL AND ON MY DAY OF

15:38 - WORK SO I'M GOING TO TAKE MY

15:40 - SUIT OFF ON A SWEATER

15:41 - ITS IMPACT. I DON'T BELIEVE

15:44 - THAT

15:44 - TAKES HIM AS A RATE FROM

15:46 - EMPLOYMENT THAT IS DISCREET AND

15:49 - THIS THING.

15:51 - AS OPPOSED TO THE EXAMPLE I

15:52 - GAVE HER MANY OTHERS WE CAN

15:53 - CREATE AGREE ON.

15:58 - >>BREAKING THIS

15:59 - CONTINUUM RATHER IT DOESN'T FIT

16:01 - IN. I THINK AGAIN

16:04 - DOESN'T IT IN RELATIONSHIP TO A

16:06 - RISE IN YEAH.

16:10 - CHANGING HIS CLOTHES, OKAY,

16:12 - YEAH.

16:17 - >>YES, IT DOES I AGREE.

16:19 - >>COUNCIL THIS IS JUST

16:20 - A FACT. NOW YOU INDICATED THAT

16:23 - THE EMPLOYER PAY FOR ALL THE

16:24 - TRAINS, BUT MY UNDERSTANDING OF

16:26 - THE RECORD WAS THAT THE

16:27 - EMPLOYER ONLY PAID FOR ONE

16:29 - DRINK AS WELL AS THE APPETIZER.

16:31 - THE FIRMING THAT THE EMPLOYER

16:33 - ONLY PLAYED PAID FOR ONE DRINK.

16:36 - AND MORE. AND YOUR CLIENT

16:39 - REMAIN.

16:41 - YOU FIND THAT TO BE A

16:42 - DISTINCTION SUCH BECKY A BAND,

16:45 - THE WORKS. HE NOW

16:47 - AS LAKHDAR REMAIN AND A CAR

16:51 - SEPARATE AND APART FROM AND WHY

16:53 - JUST THIS TODD, ALL PAY A WORK

16:56 - FUNCTION.

16:58 - >>NO I THE FACT THAT WHETHER HE

17:00 - STAYS

17:01 - OR NOT. THERE IS NOT A A BRIEF

17:04 - FACTOR HERE HE WAS AT THE WORK

17:07 - OF AND IN IS THE COURSE OF HIS

17:10 - WORK AND THEN PROCEED AT HOME

17:12 - WHETHER HE STAYED.

17:15 - OR ANYTHING ELSE DOES NOT

17:16 - CONSTITUTE A BREAK

17:18 - AND CERTAINLY WOULDN'T BE

17:19 - ENOUGH TO END A MINUTE IS A

17:21 - POINT THAT WHICH HAS

17:23 - TRADITIONALLY BEEN VIEWED AS

17:24 - SOMETHING VERY DISTINCT AND

17:26 - SEPARATE AND THAT'S NOT THE

17:27 - CASE HERE.

17:29 - >>YAHOO I COULD DO ME

17:32 - A FAVOR AND TELL ME WITH THE

17:35 - RESULT HERE WOULD BE

17:37 - IN NEWS. DEATH A WHILE YOU INTO

17:40 - PLAY UNIT CREATED

17:41 - A VAN. ALL RIGHT YOU BE

17:43 - EMPLOYEE I PROBABLY EMPLOYEE

17:46 - THAT HE CAN WIN BY 3 TO ME.

17:49 - I DON'T FEEL GATHERING IN

17:51 - WINONA AND WHEN THE NECK.

17:56 - >>NOT A TRAVELING IMPLORE YOU.

18:00 - AND HERE SHE IS INJURED AT THE

18:02 - EVENT THAT IS COMPETITIVE.

18:05 - BUT IF THEY'RE NOT TRAVELING

18:07 - EMPLOYEES THEY ARE SUBJECT TO

18:08 - WHAT'S BEEN CALLED THE COMING

18:10 - AND GOING WHICH ESSENTIALLY IS

18:12 - YOU'RE NOT BUT YOU'RE GETTING

18:14 - INJURIES NOT COMPATIBLE WHILE

18:16 - COMMUNITY. SO VERY ANGRY OR NOT

18:18 - AND THAT'S.

18:19 - >>INSISTENT THAT THING AND THEN

18:22 - DOES IT NOT THAT DAFT WHY

18:24 - JEFFREY B THEY'VE GOT INFLATED

18:27 - THE

18:27 - CRITICAL ROLE. IT'S THE WAY

18:30 - EVEN IF YOU'RE TRAVELING

18:32 - EMPLOYEES BACK TO

18:33 - ITS HOME. THE FLOOR IS WORKDAY

18:36 - IS INCLUDED IN MY ENDING AT

18:39 - CORRECTLY. THE PRESUMPTION

18:42 - IS DIFFERENT AND ESSENTIALLY

18:44 - MORE EXTENDED BECAUSE OF THE

18:46 - NATURE OF THE EMPLOYMENT AS A

18:48 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES YESTERDAY.

18:49 - >>THEY GET BACK HOME.

18:51 - YES, BUT NOT THE PERSON WHO

18:53 - DOES GO BACK THERE AND TWITTER.

18:56 - >>COUNCIL QUESTION THE

18:57 - FOLLOW-UP.

19:00 - WHERE WE MAY BE NECESSARY TO

19:02 - EXPLORE.

19:06 - THIS INTRO

19:07 - TO LEFT. AFTER THAT AT WAS UH

19:10 - THEY LEFT.

19:14 - YOUR CLIENT STUCK AROUND.

19:18 - THE RECORD. IT DOESN'T SEEM TO

19:20 - SPEAK TO WHAT WAS GOING ON IN.

19:24 - PERHAPS THAT AND WARNED THAT

19:26 - LOOK COOLER THERE IT WARMED ME.

19:29 - COURT'S FINDING

19:31 - IT WILL BE IN.

19:34 - IT IS WITH THE CUP WHEN

19:35 - THE TIME IN TRAVEL EMPLOYEES

19:39 - STAYING ON AT THE BORDER.

19:41 - BREAKING A FEW MORE ROUNDS FOR

19:43 - EXAMPLE, OR EVEN GOING TO SOME

19:45 - OTHER BOARD. IN AND HAVE A

19:47 - COUPLE MORE DRINKS.

19:52 - >>WELL I I DON'T BELIEVE A ROOM

19:54 - AND IS NECESSARY THERE THERE

19:55 - WAS AN AMPLE THE ACTUAL RECORD

19:58 - THE DEVELOPED BY COUNCIL IN

20:00 - BOTH PARTIES AS TO WHAT

20:01 - HAPPENED FROM WHICH THE JUDGE

20:03 - ME THE WORKERS COMP AND THEY

20:05 - CAN DIRECT MAKE FINDING.

20:06 - THERE'S SIMPLY NOTHING IN THE

20:08 - RECORD. THERE'S ANY

20:10 - BY ANYONE. THE EVIDENCE IS AND

20:13 - BRANDON MEN OR OTHER CONDUCT

20:15 - THAT WOULD TAKE THIS

20:16 - OUT OF BE ARE TRAVELING

20:20 - EMPLOYEE IS GOING TO LEAVE YOU

20:21 - NEED TO DREAM AND I BELIEVE IT

20:23 - WILL BE A REVERSAL HERE.

20:25 - HER TOWARD A BATH.

20:26 - >>THIS SINGLE JUSTICE I GUESS

20:28 - YES FOLLOWED UP AND ASKED A

20:30 - QUESTION. HOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO

20:33 - READ THAT IN THAT THE MEDICAL

20:35 - SCENARIO CLEAR.

20:42 - IT STAYED ANOTHER.

20:46 - IT WILL BE VERY GOOD.

20:51 - >>OR IT IS POSSIBLE DEPENDING

20:53 - ON THE FACTS. YES, ON BUT THOSE

20:56 - FACTS ARE HERE.

21:01 - >>ITS STAFF, THERE CAN'T BE

21:03 - AFRAID. IT PLAYED.

21:07 - >>WELL THERE COULD BE I MEAN IN

21:10 - BOTH

21:10 - PARTIES BREEZE HIGHLIGHT ALL

21:11 - THE DIFFERENT CASES WITH ALL

21:13 - THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF RAKES IN

21:15 - ADVANCE THAT COULD HAPPEN THIS

21:17 - IS FAR MORE TRADITIONAL THAT

21:20 - YOU KNOW THERE'S AN EMPLOYER OF

21:21 - GRANTS. THE EMPLOYEE GOES TO

21:23 - WIN AND THEN FROM THERE.

21:24 - IT GOES HOME. THIS IS

21:27 - ALL MOST THE SIMPLEST SCENARIO

21:30 - BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE ALL

21:32 - OF THOSE WHAT HE IS OUT OF THE

21:34 - TYPES OF THINGS THAT WOULD MAKE

21:36 - ALL OF US SAY

21:37 - WELL MAYBE THERE THERE'S

21:38 - NOTHING HERE THAT CREATES THAT

21:40 - MAY BE MORE THAT CONCERN OF

21:42 - A GRATEFUL. AND WE'RE NOT GOING

21:45 - TO SAY NO DOUBT THERE AGAIN ON

21:47 - FOLLOWING UP ON THAT.

21:48 - >>AND JUST CAUSE.

21:50 - AND I DON'T TYPICALLY LIKE TO

21:52 - DO THAT WE'RE GETTING INTO THE

21:53 - FACTS WE'RE WHO ARE COURT THE

21:55 - CRISIS. ESTABLISH LEGAL.

22:00 - AND AGAIN I COME BACK TO WHERE

22:01 - I LIVE IN AN EFFORT

22:03 - TO PAIR IN YOUR CLIENT LIVE

22:05 - HERE LIVE AT 5 WITH. IN W

22:09 - T J.

22:11 - WHO THE NAME FOR THIS

22:13 - OF ALL AS TO WHEN YOUR CLIENT

22:16 - THE RIDE. WHEN WHEN THE THE 4

22:19 - YEARS. IT

22:21 - PROVIDES LEFT. I

22:22 - THINK THIS 45 MINUTES BEFORE

22:25 - YOUR CLIENTS ARE ALL I'VE HOW

22:26 - LONG I'D SAY IT

22:28 - SAID THAT MAKE THE FAST

22:30 - FOOD NATION THAT YOUR CLIENT

22:33 - WAS THERE. NOT IMPROPERLY.

22:35 - BUT HAVING A PERSONAL HEARING.

22:38 - WITH SOME FRIENDS WATCHING

22:40 - MONDAY NIGHT FOOTBALL. NOT

22:42 - THERE FOR THE WORK

22:43 - FOR PROGRAM. THE WCC REALLY HAS

22:47 - THE RIGHT TO DO THAT ON FEB

22:49 - THAT CAN OVERCOME THE PRISON.

22:52 - >>I DON'T BELIEVE IT DOES

22:54 - YOU'RE OKAY THE HERE IT IS.

22:57 - SITUATION WHERE

22:59 - THE EAST STILL WITH FACT AND

23:01 - THEN YOU WILL AND WHAT IS

23:03 - HAPPENING HERE MORE SO IS THAT

23:05 - THE GOVERNMENT IS SENIOR E IF

23:07 - NOT PROPERLY APPLY THE LOT

23:10 - WHERE THE WAR AS WE ARE

23:12 - SUGGESTING THIS COURT SHOULD

23:14 - CLARIFY TO THESE FACTS BUT THE

23:17 - FACTS REMAIN OF THAT RIGHT

23:20 - THERE.

23:20 - THERE IF THERE WAS NOW UP 3 AND

23:23 - A MEMBER OF EMPLOYMENT THERE

23:24 - WAS NO DISCREET RATE

23:26 - THAT TOOK HIM OUT OF ANYTHING

23:27 - THAT WOULD BE FORESEEABLE

23:29 - PEOPLE THOUGH THE RESTAURANTS

23:30 - AND BARS ALL THE TIME AND WHO

23:33 - YOU KNOW WHEN SOCIAL

23:34 - GATHERINGS. THEY DON'T

23:36 - TYPICALLY EVERYONE LEAVE AT THE

23:37 - SAME TIME SOME LINGER ON FOR.

23:40 - AND THAT'S PART OF

23:42 - THE DESIRE OFTEN OF AN EMPLOYER

23:44 - THAT YOU BUILD COLLEGIALITY

23:47 - OR THAT SONG WAS JUST GRASPING

23:49 - AT THE END OF A LONG DAY MIGHT

23:50 - WERE ARRESTED AND WATCH A GAME.

23:53 - BUT IT DOESN'T COME TO THE

23:54 - BREAK.

23:55 - >>A YEAH. HOW YOU

23:59 - LATE GUYS

24:00 - HE DEFYING ON

24:02 - THE FATE OF AGAIN THAT'S

24:04 - NECESSARY IN ORDER I HAVE THE

24:08 - OF EMPLOYMENT. I THINK YOU WERE

24:10 - WHEN IT BE ME HE REFERRED TO

24:13 - BY AND EMPLOYERS NEED TO GO

24:16 - AGAIN IS THAT AFTER WE DID TRY

24:20 - I'D BE QUITE HAPPY.

24:22 - I THE I'VE YOU KNOW TYPE O BY

24:26 - GATHERING THAT WOULD QUALIFY AS

24:29 - NOT

24:29 - AN ABANDONMENT.

24:31 - >>YES, THEY WOULD NOT BE AN

24:32 - ABANDONMENT THIS THIS THING.

24:38 - >>LIBYAN OKAY IT IF IT'S.

24:43 - >>MAYOR

24:43 - >>IF HE DIDN'T START THE GAME.

24:45 - WE THINK YOU FOR CORRECTING ME

24:46 - EMPLOYER INITIATED

24:49 - SOCIAL GOOD IS THAT WE CAPTURED

24:51 - THE SITUATION WE'RE TALKING

24:53 - ABOUT.

24:54 - >>YES THATS THIS SITUATION

24:56 - HERE.

24:57 - >>AND.

24:58 - >>THAT'S.

24:59 - >>WHAT WE HAVE HERE IS VERY

25:01 - DIFFERENT FROM IF LET'S SAY I

25:03 - AND 3 COLLEAGUES DECIDE AT THE

25:04 - END OF THE DAY WE WANT TO GO

25:05 - OUT AND HAVE A A DRINK OR GO

25:08 - WHERE HAVE YOU KNOW.

25:09 - DINNER THAT'S NOT AN EMPLOYER'S

25:12 - MAN. IF YOU'RE GOING

25:13 - TO END.

25:14 - >>I'M TRYING TO I'M TRYING TO I

25:16 - HAVE TO REVIEW APPROPRIATE

25:18 - SUSPECTING ANY EMPLOYER AND

25:20 - INITIATED

25:21 - SOCIAL EVENT. IT HAS NOTHING TO

25:23 - DO WITH LONG AREA THERE IN LONG

25:26 - HEARING. IT'S THAT BAD. YEAH,

25:28 - THE EMPLOYERS AND YOU TO BE A

25:30 - VAN. YEAH I I IT'S A CRITICAL

25:33 - POINT.

25:34 - >>YES, YOU ARE.

25:36 - MISTER SIEGEL, IT SEEMS TO ME

25:38 - THAT THAT.

25:40 - STANDARD THAT DOES JUSTICE I DO

25:42 - IS ASK YOU ABOUT IT REALLY

25:44 - A SUBSET A SUBSTANDARD OF ONE.

25:49 - WE'RE SENDING HER TO SEND AND

25:51 - SHE RESTATED C YOU KNOW.

25:56 - WELL UNDERSTOOD STANDARD THAT

25:58 - THE EMPLOYEES ACTIONS WERE SO

26:00 - COOL AND TO REMOVE FROM HIS

26:03 - USUAL EMPLOYMENT. THEY

26:04 - CONSTITUTE AND THE FANS ISN'T

26:06 - THAT IMPORTANT IS THAT THE

26:08 - STANDARD

26:09 - STILL APPLY.

26:10 - >>I BELIEVE I WOULD SUGGEST HE

26:12 - ASKED MY BELIEVE THAT THIS AND

26:14 - WAS CORRECT. AND HAD IT BEEN

26:17 - THE MAJORITY. WE WOULD LIKE

26:19 - OBVIOUSLY GOT OUT THE CAR.

26:23 - >>THANK YOU MISTER

26:27 - IT'S A PRETTY

26:28 - A PROBLEM. THE FLA.

26:36 - >>MAY IT PLEASE THE COURT MY

26:38 - NAME IS KATHLEEN KOCH AT T NOW

26:40 - AND I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE

26:42 - FAMILY. SOMETIMES CORPORATIONS.

26:49 - KIND OF AFRAID THAT DISCUSSION

26:51 - AND READING A BOOK. WE

26:54 - START OUT CHAPTER ONE OF THESE

26:56 - ARE THE FIRST CHAPTER, THE

26:58 - FIRST CHAPTER. IT ALL

27:00 - IT IS SECTION 3 O ONE C ONE OF

27:03 - THE WORKERS COMPENSATION ACT.

27:06 - AND THAT

27:07 - PROVIDE THAT FOR AN EMPLOYEE TO

27:09 - BE AND THE COURSE AND SCOPE OF

27:10 - EMPLOYMENT MICE, THE INFERENCE

27:13 - OF THE EMPLOYERS WHO ARE THERE.

27:17 - STARTING OUR ANALYSIS OF OUR

27:18 - DISCUSSION AS TO WHETHER OR NOT

27:21 - AND THAT AND HELEN WAS A

27:22 - TROUBLING EMPLOYEES IS STARTING

27:25 - HER BOOK IN CHAPTER 6.

27:28 - THEY

27:29 - SHUN ACT IS ALWAYS WHERE WE

27:30 - START OUR NOW SAYS HIS CASE

27:32 - SAYS AND THAT'S WHY

27:35 - THE WCHA WCA BE STARTED THEIR

27:39 - HOUSES THERE.

27:40 - WHAT WAS THE APPELLANT DOING AT

27:42 - THE TIME OF THE INJURY WHILE IN

27:44 - THE INCIDENT THAT I THE RIGHT

27:47 - TO THAT ACTUAL. HE

27:50 - WAS TRAVELING, COMMUTING

27:53 - NON MANDATORY, SOCIAL AND BAD.

27:57 - I THINK JUST CALL IT EMPLOYEES

27:58 - FATHER. IT WAS JUST ANOTHER WAY

28:01 - OF SAYING.

28:04 - I IMPLORE SPONSOR THAT THE

28:06 - EMPLOYER PAID THE TAB.

28:09 - I GET THESE HUGE, I WAS BAD.

28:12 - THIS WAS NOT MANDATORY. IT

28:15 - WAS VOLUNTARY. IT WAS A

28:16 - BUSINESS NEED IT WAS NOT A GOOD

28:18 - THING. IT WAS A GATHERING FOR

28:20 - CHITCHAT AND MINE DOWN AT THE

28:22 - END OF THE WEEK. WHEN YOU TAKE

28:24 - THOSE FACTS AND THE

28:25 - CONSIDERATION AND STARTING IT

28:27 - SECTION 3 O ON THE LINE OF THE

28:29 - WORKERS

28:29 - COMPENSATION ACT. YOU GET THE

28:32 - BLUES AND HE WAS OUTSIDE THE

28:33 - SCOPE OF EMPLOYMENT.

28:39 - I CAN DESCRIBE THAT SECTION OF

28:40 - THE ACT.

28:43 - THE COURT HAS COME UP WITH

28:45 - VARIOUS DESCRIPTIVE TERMS.

28:48 - ALTERNATELY AT THE HEART OF IT

28:49 - IS WEATHER. THE YEAR.

28:53 - IN FURTHERANCE OF THE EMPLOYERS

28:55 - THAT WAS UNFAIR. COMMUTING OR

28:57 - DRIVING HOME FROM A SOCIAL THAT

29:00 - IS NOT WITHIN THE PERSON SPOKE

29:01 - OF EMPLOYMENT.

29:06 - DONE WITH THE PARADE.

29:08 - >>THE MINUTE NOW. AND THE

29:11 - DIFFICULTY IF YOU KNOW WHAT IT

29:13 - IS TO MAKE SURE I GET THAT

29:15 - THERE IT IS THAT YOU ARE A

29:17 - FACTOR.

29:18 - THAT'S REALLY NOT OUR CORE

29:20 - FUND.

29:21 - IN IN WHEN ARE WE GETTING BACK

29:25 - A COP. WE HAVE CREWS

29:27 - ON SCENE WHETHER THE

29:28 - PRESUMPTION IS THAT WITH THE

29:30 - WAR HERE. THE PRESUMPTION

29:32 - CONTROLS NOTWITHSTANDING THE

29:34 - FACT HERE THEY WONDERED IF YOU

29:36 - COULD TURN YOUR ATTENTION TO

29:38 - THAT IN NOT

29:39 - NOT IT HAS GOT TO GET INTO

29:42 - QUITE THE WEATHER

29:43 - NOT THE ABC GAVE WPA VEER OFF

29:46 - COURT HEARD. THERE HAVE BEEN.

29:50 - >>SO THE ANALYSIS AND THAT'S

29:53 - WHERE

29:53 - YOU ARE THAT'S A TINY

29:56 - STATE LAW WHO YOU KNOW WHY

29:58 - W C J THE GAME HE HAVE A

30:00 - DIFFERENT FOCUS IN THEIR

30:02 - OPINION COURT AND I THINK THAT

30:04 - THAT THE HEART OF THIS CASE.

30:06 - YOU DON'T GET TO THE

30:07 - PRESUMPTION THAT SOMEONE IS A

30:09 - TRAVELING IN 40 AND YOU MAKE A

30:11 - DETERMINATION AS TO THE FACTS

30:13 - SURROUNDING THE INCIDENT.

30:17 - NOW 24 HOUR CONTINUE ON THAT

30:20 - ONCE YOU LEAVE YOUR HOUSE.

30:22 - THAT YOU'RE CONTINUING WORKING

30:24 - AND YOU CAN SEE THAT AND HE

30:26 - SAYS THAT THIS PASS BUSINESS

30:28 - TRIPS OUT OF TOWN BUSINESS

30:29 - TRIPS. SO.

30:33 - CARLING EMPLOYEE TO A CAR.

30:35 - AFTER THE FIRST TO DETERMINE

30:37 - NATION HAS TO OFFER SINCE

30:38 - POKEMON POINT AND IT COMES BACK

30:40 - TO SECTION. THEY'LL WANT TO BE

30:42 - YEAH. SO. HE

30:44 - WAS COMMUTING, IT WASN'T

30:46 - WORKING HE WASN'T DRIVING FROM

30:48 - THE CARS AND DRIVING FROM A

30:50 - BUSINESS MEETING HE WASN'T

30:51 - DRIVING FROM A SALES CALL.

30:53 - HE WAS COMMUTING FROM THE

30:54 - SOCIAL THAT.

30:57 - IT GOES BACK TO A COMING AND

30:58 - GOING ALL WHICH EXCLUDING THE

31:00 - MEETING AND. IN READING THE

31:04 - CASES.

31:06 - IN USING THE TERM TROUBLING

31:08 - EMPLOYEE OR ABANDONMENT

31:09 - OF EMPLOYMENT. I THINK THEY'RE

31:11 - JUST 5 WORDS ARE

31:12 - DESCRIPTIVE TERMS TO GET REALLY

31:14 - INTO THE HEART OF THE ISSUE IS

31:16 - IN FURTHERANCE OF BEING WHERE

31:18 - THEY ARE THERE.

31:25 - AGAIN I HATE THIS IS JUST A

31:27 - VERY GOOD FOR US.

31:29 - >>AND I TAKE IT FROM IF YOU'RE

31:32 - CONSIDERING A FEW OF THE CASE.

31:38 - READING

31:39 - VERY CAREFULLY. I ALWAYS POST

31:41 - ARGUMENT THE RECORD OF THE

31:43 - CASE.

31:46 - HE WAS UNDER SOME COME CALL IN

31:49 - IT'S HORRIBLE CAN CALL FROM

31:51 - CLICK ON THE EVENT BECAUSE

31:53 - OF THIS WELL IT WAS WHO BY THE

31:55 - BY.

31:57 - I DON'T KNOW YOUR BOY YOU'RE IN

31:59 - A LARGE. THE

32:00 - LAW FIRM AND YOUR SENIOR MOST

32:02 - PART WHEN WE GO TO BREAK

32:04 - TONIGHT, YOU KNOW FEEL FREE SAY

32:07 - NO TO THAT.

32:09 - IF YOU DIDN'T WANT TO

32:11 - RESPECTFULLY GO THERE YOU GO IN

32:14 - THAT KIND OF SCENARIO IF WE

32:16 - DECIDE THAT THEN

32:18 - YOU WILL SEE THAT YOU DON'T

32:20 - HAVE A LIVE REPORT.

32:25 - BECOMING A GOING ROLL IN

32:28 - APPLICABLE AND THAT HE WAS.

32:33 - FORD DURING THAT HAD NOTHING TO

32:35 - DO WITH WORK IS THAT CORRECT.

32:41 - >>AND A HOME THAT HAD NOTHING

32:43 - TO DO WITH PARK.

32:48 - I'M GOING TO GET THIS DONE YOU

32:49 - CAN I FOLLOW UP ON THAT AND YOU

32:52 - WOULD IN OUR VIEW AGAIN.

32:55 - AND THIS COURT.

32:58 - HOLDING YEAH IN THE

33:00 - U N 3RD THERE OF BUILDING,

33:03 - GOOD RELATIONSHIPS, THE QUEEN

33:05 - THE EMPLOYERS AND EMPLOYEES.

33:08 - IT IS SO I FURTHER IN THAT

33:10 - THE INCREASE AND THE EMPLOYER

33:13 - NEAR FOR BIN.

33:17 - >>THE WC JANG NOTED IN HIS HEAD

33:20 - AND BAD, THERE IS A SEPARATE

33:22 - AND

33:23 - HE SAYS WE'RE ONLY INTO THOSE

33:25 - SOCIAL EVENT CAN BE FOUND TO BE

33:27 - WORK RELATED. THANK W

33:31 - DIFFERENT CASE.

33:34 - >>NOW THAT WITHOUT THAT WHEN

33:35 - THE PATIENT.

33:40 - DO YOU AGREE OR DISAGREE WITH

33:41 - THAT PROPOSITION.

33:45 - AND UNDERSTAND WHAT HE SAID

33:48 - I AND THE CASE THAT YOU CITED

33:49 - THE NOTION THAT IF THE ACTIVITY

33:51 - IS IN FOR THE RAIN HAS BEEN

33:53 - LATE TO GET AND I YOU DUI.

33:57 - >>I'VE BEEN

33:57 - HEALTHY WORKPLACE. IF THAT IS

34:00 - INDEED FURTHER IN THE INTEREST

34:02 - OF THE EMPLOYEES WITHIN.

34:07 - >>ALL THIS HER NATION THAT

34:08 - THE WCHA MAKES US WONDER THAT

34:10 - SOCIAL EVENT AND WERE RELATED.

34:15 - >>IF YOU'RE YOU'RE STATING IT

34:16 - DIFFERENTLY. I MEAN IF WE SAY

34:19 - THAT

34:19 - EVENT IS WHY DO I THE BOY EAR

34:23 - AND EYE AND BEGIN TO PROMOTE

34:26 - THEIR RELATIONSHIP EMPLOYER AND

34:28 - THE EMPLOYEE IN THE WORKPLACE.

34:30 - THE END. THEY WERE TAKING GUY

34:33 - WOULD HAVE BEEN WRONG.

34:35 - IT WEIGHS INITIATED BY THE

34:37 - EMPLOYER LIKE A LOT.

34:41 - >>MISTER CENTER ON THE MATTER

34:43 - AT THE TIME DID INVITE THE

34:45 - OTHER EMPLOYEES TO GATHER AT

34:49 - THAT'S HELPING COUNT ON THIS

34:50 - AFTERNOON AND ON THAT IN THAT

34:53 - CRASH.

34:55 - IN MAKING A DETERMINATION AS

34:58 - TO YOU WEATHER.

35:02 - IS WORK EARLY TODAY.

35:04 - MULTI-FACTOR ALL SORT OF IN

35:06 - ADDITION PAST AND THE

35:07 - UNDERLYING CASES THAT MAKE THAT

35:10 - DETERMINATION. AND BOTH CASES.

35:15 - RELATED INJURIES.

35:20 - INJURIES THAT OCCUR

35:21 - ACTUALLY YEAH. MISTER SIEGEL

35:23 - COMMENT ON THAT

35:25 - NOTING THAT ONLY THOSE INJURIES

35:27 - IN A CRASH. YEAH, IT'S SO

35:29 - SMALL THAT OR WITHIN THE COURSE

35:30 - AND SCOPE OF THEIR EMPLOYMENT

35:32 - AND NOT NEXT YEAR.

35:34 - >>THE COUNT. SO THAT'S WHY

35:35 - THERE COULD BE SOMETHING FOR

35:37 - TRAVELING EMPLOYEES THAT

35:38 - THEY'RE WORKING UNTIL THEY GET

35:40 - HOME AT THE BY WHATEVER THE DAY

35:43 - IN 5 CITIES, INCLUDING IM

35:45 - PLAYER.

35:46 - WHY BARRY. SO AGAIN OR I SHOULD

35:48 - SAY

35:49 - EMPLOYER INITIATED. THAT'S

35:52 - WHERE THE BEST THING IN GETTING

35:53 - THAT 50 YEARS I THINK.

36:00 - >>SOMEONE IS AND FOR OTHER END

36:03 - OF THE EMPLOYER'S BUSINESS OR

36:04 - FAIR.

36:06 - >>AND THEN WHAT IF YOU.

36:09 - THANK YOU CAN I GET ASKED THAT

36:10 - QUESTION THE.

36:13 - THE WORLD GOT TO DO TO GET THIS

36:15 - ABOUT ME GO HOME.

36:21 - >>IT TURNED INTO FOR THE

36:28 - THEY HAVE BEEN DOING. SHOWING

36:31 - IT'S AN EMPLOYEE OF THEM.

36:32 - THEY GET THERE IF YOU DO.

36:37 - THE COMMONWEALTH ARE OUTLINED

36:39 - IN US AND NOW THE GUARDIAN AND

36:41 - YET BAD IN RETURN FOR IT IS

36:44 - PART OF THE BUSINESS TRIP AND

36:46 - THEY WERE ALL I

36:47 - HOUR. TO SAY THAT THE RETURN

36:51 - FROM THE BUSINESS OF US IS

36:53 - STILL WITHIN THE COURSE OF ONE

36:54 - POINT LEAD.

36:56 - FOR STRICTLY APPLYING BUT THE

36:57 - DOOR TO DOOR PRINCIPLE.

36:59 - THEY'RE

37:00 - TRAVELING FRIEND HE HAD PASSED

37:02 - HIS HOME IN THE LONGER A

37:05 - EMPLOYMENT.

37:10 - AND I THINK OTHER.

37:16 - >>SORRY MY QUESTION WAS

37:17 - ANSWERED CHIEF, THANK YOU.

37:20 - >>BRIEFLY FOLLOW UP ON THE TUBE

37:22 - JUSTICE'S QUESTION WITH REGARD

37:24 - TO THE EXIT. A COMMENT BY.

37:30 - I ALSO DON'T SEE HOW THAT

37:31 - ACCOUNTS FOR THE POSSIBILITY

37:33 - THAT HE WAS SIMPLY.

37:35 - TRAVELING TO A GATHERING FOR

37:36 - THE WORDS OF HIS

37:37 - EMPLOYERS AFFAIRS. IT SUGGESTED

37:40 - TO ME A HUG OR AN ENTIRELY

37:42 - GRATUITOUS COMMENTS JUST AS

37:44 - GRATUITOUS WAS THE COMMENT THAT

37:45 - IS WIFE WAS OUT OF TOWN IS

37:47 - CHILDREN WERE HOME. I MEAN.

37:51 - POSSIBLY HAVE

37:51 - TO DO THE QUESTION BEFORE US

37:54 - WHICH WAS WHETHER THIS EVENT

37:56 - WAS IT FURTHER IS OF HIS

37:58 - EMPLOYER'S SHARE.

38:05 - >>THEY CASE VAN DER

38:06 - LEYEN HE SAW ON THE APPLICATION

38:10 - IT'S HIGHLY RATIONAL.

38:12 - AND YOU CAN SEE THAT WHEN

38:14 - REVIEWING ALL THOSE CASES THAT

38:15 - FACTS MATTER I UNDERSTAND THAT

38:17 - THIS POURED IN HERE TO ALL OF

38:19 - THE FACTS BY AND APPLICATION OF

38:21 - THE LAW. PEOPLE MATTER BECAUSE.

38:28 - THE BUSINESS RELATIONSHIPS.

38:30 - OR NOT YOU KNOW YOU'RE CAUGHT

38:32 - ON LATELINE WILL FALL APART.

38:35 - IT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT TO

38:37 - CONSIDER ALL OF

38:38 - THOSE FACTS AND SO WHEN LINE TO

38:40 - FALL THE COMMON LAW. I

38:43 - KNOW THAT AND THE STATION WAS

38:45 - ME THAT THE RETURN TRIP WAS

38:47 - PART OF THE BUSINESS TRACTOR

38:48 - RETURN TRIP AND.

38:50 - >>I REALLY DID YOU AGREE WITH

38:52 - ME THAT. IF

38:55 - WE DETERMINE

38:56 - THAT THIS GATHERING TO SHOW.

39:00 - ORGANIZED BY MISTER CENTER OWN

39:02 - HAIR LEE

39:03 - WAS IN FOR THE WORDS OF CITY

39:05 - TOSSES AFFAIRS. IT DOESN'T

39:07 - MATTER HE DROVE PAST UNITED

39:08 - STATES DOESN'T MATTER THERE

39:10 - WERE 20 KIDS AT HOME, IF HIS

39:12 - WIFE WAS IN MADAGASCAR, IF YOU

39:13 - AGREE WITH ME.

39:21 - >>I AGREE WITH

39:21 - YOU BECAUSE I THINK THAT THE

39:23 - SEAT CJ FOUND THE FACT AND

39:26 - THEY'RE NOT ON APPEAL AND THE

39:27 - FACT.

39:28 - I REMEMBER IS NO MATERIAL

39:30 - BENEFITS THE EMPLOYER.

39:33 - WELL BECAUSE HE WANTED TO GO

39:35 - THE

39:35 - VOLUNTARY MANDATORY. THERE WERE

39:38 - NO ONE REALLY TO DISPATCH AND

39:40 - THAT WAS JUST CHITCHAT WIND

39:41 - DOWN.

39:43 - >>YOU SUGGEST WE

39:44 - PRESCRIBE THAT TEST THAT WE GET

39:46 - THE W C J STAFF TO GO OUT AND

39:48 - MEASURE WHETHER THERE'S A

39:49 - MATERIAL BENEFIT TO AN

39:51 - EMPLOYER. HOW ARE THEY GOING TO

39:52 - POSSIBLY MEASURE THAT.

39:59 - >>LOOKING AT THE FACTS OF THE

40:00 - CASE AND WEATHER.

40:04 - >>IS BASED ON THE APPELLANTS

40:07 - TESTIMONY AND THE EMPLOYER

40:09 - WITNESS TESTIMONY AND IN THIS

40:11 - CASE YOU TAKE ALL THOSE FAT.

40:14 - TOGETHER AND COME TO THE ACTION

40:16 - BY ABOUT A 5TH PLAYER, THE VERY

40:19 - PURPOSE OF THESE TYPES

40:20 - OF GATHERINGS.

40:21 - >>NOT A MATERIAL BENEFIT, BUT

40:23 - INTANGIBLE BENEFIT MY

40:25 - COLLEAGUES SUGGESTED IN THEIR

40:27 - QUESTIONS. BUILDING

40:29 - COLLEGIALITY.

40:33 - IT DON'T YOU THINK THAT'S

40:34 - CERTAINLY A POSSIBILITY BUT

40:35 - THAT WASN'T THE

40:36 - CASE HERE. THERE WASN'T ANY

40:38 - EVIDENCE OR FINDING A BAG.

40:49 - KEEP AN EYE OUT JUST FILL OUT

40:53 - VERY QUICKLY.

40:54 - >>IF YOU MAKE YOUR ORAL

40:56 - ARGUMENT.

40:58 - AIR WITH TERRY COURT CASE OF A

41:00 - COLLEGE COURSE

41:01 - THEY CORRECT CLEARLY CORRECTLY

41:03 - DECIDED IN YOUR ESTIMATION.

41:09 - >>THE ULTIMATE HOLDING A

41:10 - RATIONALE.

41:18 - JUST

41:18 - STARTED CORRECTLY BECAUSE I

41:21 - OUTLINED IN MY 40.

41:24 - AT ALL I FEEL CLAIM TO SEIZE

41:26 - AND THERE IS A RELIANCE ON THIS

41:28 - BOTH OF OUR PRODUCTION. ALL

41:31 - SIMILARLY. I THINK TWICE.

41:44 - ON HIS RETURN TRIP HOME.

41:46 - FROM HIS BUSINESS.

41:49 - >>THANK YOU FOR THAT VERY MUCH

41:50 - KEEP US. THANK YOU.

42:06 - >>THE EYES OF THE NATION ARE ON

42:08 - PENNSYLVANIA AS A KEY INFLUENCE

42:10 - OR TO THE 2020 ELECTION.

42:12 - PCN HAS OVER 25 YEARS OF

42:15 - TRUSTED STATE GOVERNMENT

42:16 - COVERAGE. OUR NETWORK IS YOUR

42:18 - PLATFORM TO CONNECT DIRECTLY

42:20 - WITH PENNSYLVANIA VOTERS.

42:22 - WHETHER IT'S A PRESIDENTIAL

42:23 - RACE STATEWIDE CAMPAIGN MORE

42:25 - LOCAL CAUSE OUR VIEWERS ARE

42:27 - READY TO HEAR FROM YOU IF

42:29 - YOU'RE AT NOW

42:30 - PCN YOUR ACCESS TO

42:33 - PENNSYLVANIA, VOTERS.

42:37 - >>THE

42:37 - NEXT MATTERS IN RE APPEALS

42:39 - COATESVILLE AREA SCHOOL

42:40 - DISTRICT.

42:43 - REPRESENTING POLAND COULD STILL

42:44 - AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT AND JUST

42:46 - AND PEOPLE ARE BETTER

42:47 - REPRESENTING THE BOARD OF

42:48 - ASSESSMENT APPEALS IS

42:50 - JONATHAN LONG REPRESENTING

42:52 - KELLY HOUSTON PROPERTIES IS

42:54 - JOHN CEREAL.

42:58 - A RACE YOU TO CONDUCT PRECLUDE

43:00 - THE RELITIGATE OF ISSUES.

43:02 - >>THE CREWS HAVE BEEN DECIDED

43:05 - FOR THAT AGAIN. THE ONE CERTAIN

43:07 - CONDITIONS HAVE BEEN SATISFIED.

43:10 - ACCORDING TO A LOT OF PEOPLE IN

43:11 - THIS MATTER TO CONSIDER WHETHER

43:13 - THE CALM BEFORE. THEY'RE DOING

43:15 - THE FLYING

43:16 - THE DOT IN THE MIDST OF THE

43:18 - FEEL BOUND BY THE COATESVILLE

43:20 - AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT.

43:25 - >>THANK TO JUST A SAILOR.

43:28 - GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR.

43:30 - MISTER MISTER LONG MAY IT

43:31 - PLEASE THE COURT.

43:34 - FROM OUR DOT AND I DO REPRESENT

43:35 - THEIR PART IN THIS MATTER THE

43:36 - CRITICAL AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT.

43:39 - THIS MORNING. I WILL BE ARGUING

43:40 - POINTS RELATED TO A TECHNICAL

43:43 - OR A SHOOTER CONNOR AND

43:44 - COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL AS WELL AS

43:46 - POINTS RELATED TO THE BACKDROP

43:49 - OF THE TAX ASSESSMENT APPEAL

43:51 - ALL THE PENNSYLVANIA. I DID

43:53 - WANT TO MAKE THE COURT AWARE

43:54 - THE FACT THAT I WILL BE

43:55 - SUPPORTING TIME TOO LONG

43:58 - WHO WILL BE MAKING POINTS ARE

44:00 - RELATED TO JUDICIAL ECONOMY.

44:04 - WE APPROXIMATELY 100 YEARS OF

44:07 - THERE IS POTENTIAL GUIDANCE

44:09 - FROM THIS COURT RELATED TO

44:10 - TECHNICAL RACE TO THE PRODUCT.

44:12 - THE COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL.

44:15 - THERE'S REALLY 2 MAJOR POINTS

44:17 - THAT COME OUT OF THAT GUIDANCE

44:20 - DATING ALL THE WAY BACK TO 1920

44:22 - AND

44:22 - STATE HOSPITAL. FOR THE

44:24 - CRIMINALLY INSANE CASE THAT WAS

44:25 - CITED IN OUR BRIEF.

44:29 - FIRST AND FOREMOST THE

44:31 - RECLUSIVE EFFECT OF BOTH

44:33 - TECHNICAL RACE TO THE PRODUCT

44:34 - AND COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL THERE'S

44:36 - ALWAYS BEEN MAN TOO

44:39 - WHO. PREVENT THE HARM OR

44:42 - THE EVIL, I'M A LIVING AGAIN.

44:45 - I IN ONE CASE COMING

44:48 - BACK BEFORE THE TRIAL COURT IN

44:50 - A

44:50 - SECOND CASE INITIATING SOME

44:53 - TYPE OF A PROCEEDING WHETHER

44:54 - BECAUSE OF ACTION A BILL.

44:58 - 4 PETITION. AND IN

45:00 - THIS CASE THAT IS ABSOLUTELY

45:03 - NOT WE HAVE AS THE MATTER.

45:05 - IT WAS THE SMITHS.

45:09 - PERFECTLY APPEALED IN THE

45:11 - COMMONWEALTH COURT.

45:13 - ANOTHER POINT THAT COMES OUT OF

45:15 - INJURED DENTAL GUIDANCE THAT WE

45:16 - HAVE IN BOTH.

45:19 - THE TECHNICAL RACE TO THE

45:20 - PRODUCT AND BOTTLES TOPPLE.

45:27 - THE COURT HAS ALWAYS CONSIDERED

45:29 - THE APPELLATE PROCESS. TO BE

45:32 - PART OF THE LITIGATION AND IF

45:35 - AN

45:35 - ONLY CAT THAT APPELLATE PROCESS

45:37 - IS CONCLUDED AT THAT POINT IN

45:39 - ONE RACE YOU TO PONDER OR

45:42 - COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL WHEN

45:43 - ATTACKING HAVE A PURPOSE.

45:48 - I DON'T HAVE MUCH TO SAY OTHER

45:50 - THAN THAT. THE CASES CITED BY

45:52 - BOTH PARTIES.

45:54 - ALLUDING TO THE BOTH OF THESE

45:55 - POINTS THAT I'M MAKING TO YOU

45:57 - AND THIS.

45:59 - AS IT RELATES TO THE DOCUMENTS

46:01 - RELATED TO THE BACKDROP.

46:03 - AND THE FACT THAT A POINT WAS

46:06 - MADE THAT THE BACKDROP

46:08 - OF ME. THE FACT ASSESSMENT LONG

46:10 - PENNSYLVANIA NECESSITATES

46:11 - APPLICATION. RACE CHICAGO ARE

46:14 - COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL. I WOULD

46:16 - RELY PRIMARILY ON THE BRIEFS

46:18 - THAT I FILED BUT THE JUDICIAL

46:20 - CODE SECTION.

46:22 - 76 AND THE RULES OF APPELLATE

46:24 - PROCEDURE, 2591. DO PROVIDE

46:28 - GUIDANCE ON WHAT. IT IN TRIAL

46:31 - COURT THIS SUPPOSED TO DO.

46:34 - UPON ISSUANCE OF AN ORDER FROM

46:37 - THE PUBLIC.

46:43 - THANK YOU ANY QUESTION.

46:45 - >>IN FACT GET IT DONE TO YOU.

46:49 - IF RIGHT KNEE YOU'RE IN GOOD

46:52 - STANDING.

46:55 - WHAT ARE THE

46:57 - THIS FIELD AT YEAH THAT

47:00 - WAS TAKEN ON THE

47:02 - OTHER MATTERS. I IN THE LOWER

47:05 - COURT THAT DEAL WITH THIS I

47:07 - BELIEVE IT'S A SET.

47:10 - >>WELL WHAT I CAN TELL YOU YOUR

47:11 - HONOR IS THAT.

47:12 - THE BE WHAT I CALL THE SCHOOL

47:15 - DISTRICT DOCKET.

47:21 - THE COURT

47:21 - IN AND WHAT I CAN ALSO SAY BACK

47:24 - THE RACE TO DAKOTA. SHOULD

47:26 - NOT HAVE A POSITIVE EFFECT ON

47:28 - THAT APPEAL AND LATERAL STOP IS

47:30 - NOT HAVE IT BECAUSE OF THE FACT

47:31 - I'M NOT APPEALING BECAUSE.

47:33 - THE FACT THAT IN ACCORDANCE

47:35 - WITH THE RULES OF PROCEDURE.

47:39 - THERE

47:40 - IS ANOTHER TRIAL COURT DOCKET

47:42 - THAT EXISTS. WELL THAT WAS NOT

47:46 - A FIELD AND THE NAME PARTY IN

47:48 - THAT CASE CITY COUNCIL CHOSE

47:51 - NOT TO APPEAL THAT.

47:52 - >>YEAH WHEN THE ACTOR

47:54 - WRITER DIRECTOR BECAUSE I THINK

47:56 - THERE IS SIGNIFICANT

47:57 - RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN.

48:04 - EITHER PENDING CASES INVOLVING

48:06 - THE SAME ASSESSMENT. STILL

48:08 - SITTING IN THE CROWD OR NOW I'M

48:11 - THE GUY INFO MY QUESTION TO

48:13 - YOU THAT IN IT BY ONE THING IS

48:17 - ALREADY OF AN ASSESSMENT.

48:20 - AND HEAL AND TO ALL CAFFEINE

48:23 - ALREADY GET TOGETHER.

48:26 - >>THE END RESULT WOULD BE THAT

48:29 - ALL TAXING AUTHORITIES.

48:32 - IT WOULD BE IMPACTED BY BY THE

48:34 - RESULT, I'VE BEEN UP HERE.

48:36 - >>I CAN GO BUY A LITTLE BIT

48:39 - MORE TECHNICAL THAN THAT

48:41 - CHAIR, WHAT I FEEL IS FILED BY

48:44 - ONE. SEEING IT ALREADY IN THAT.

48:52 - BY ALL 8 YARDS.

48:55 - YOU'RE GETTING IN YOUR PRE

48:56 - SEEMS TO

48:57 - BE DAD. WELL, I BELIEVE IT OR

49:00 - OR THE COMMONWEALTH COURT WOULD

49:02 - DECIDE AT THE CROSS FOR WE

49:04 - THINK ARE APPLE IBM WE

49:06 - ALL OF THE CASES ARE GOING TO

49:08 - BE CONTROLLED BY THAT.

49:10 - MORE PRECISELY

49:12 - LIKE YOU'RE ARGUING THAN A

49:13 - MINUTE PEELED BY ONE CAPPING

49:15 - AUTHORITY IN AN APPEAL HAS 2

49:18 - ALL THAT YOU ALREADY.

49:20 - THAT ALSO AND 3 IF

49:22 - I CAN I

49:23 - MEAN I FEEL IT IS MY IN THE

49:27 - 50'S AND

49:28 - HE'LL BUY GREAT IF I DID MY

49:30 - ROLE STOP WILL NEVER ENTERED

49:32 - INTO

49:32 - THE EVENING OR ARE THE MOST

49:35 - MAKE THE PLANE FLYING IT HEALED

49:37 - BY ONE

49:37 - CAPPING AUTHORITY AND ANY DEAL

49:41 - AT ALL CAPPING AUTHORITY SAID.

49:58 - >>FRANKLY I MEAN THE

50:01 - >>THE OPPORTUNITY TO TO FILE AN

50:03 - INTERVENTION.

50:08 - AND THAT'S WORTH NOTING FOR THE

50:09 - COURT THAT.

50:12 - ONE OF THE ARGUMENTS IS THAT

50:14 - BECAUSE THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AT

50:16 - ONE POINT. INTERVENTION IN

50:19 - CITIES CASE.

50:21 - THEY VARY BY HAD SOME

50:22 - OBLIGATION AN APPEAL THAT BACK

50:24 - AND WELL. I WOULD NOTE FOR

50:26 - THE COURT. THAT PURSUANT TO THE

50:28 - LOCAL RULE THAT WAS AN UNTIMELY

50:30 - APPEAL HER INTERVENTION IN

50:32 - FIRST PLACE. AND I DID

50:34 - REFERENCE AND THE CHURCHILL

50:36 - CASE IN MY BRIEF. REGARDING

50:38 - FACT THAT.

50:42 - CIVIL PROCEDURE DO NOT

50:44 - THE FLY IN THAT ACCESS TO THE

50:46 - WORLD. WHAT THAT TELLS ME AN

50:49 - ANSWER YOUR OWN QUESTION.

50:54 - IN

50:54 - THIS CASE. THERE'S 2 SEPARATE

50:57 - DOCKETS WITH 2 SEPARATE

50:58 - ENTITIES. I LISTED AS HAS BEEN

51:01 - PARTY IN

51:01 - THE DOCKET AND EACH OF THOSE

51:04 - ENTITIES HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO

51:06 - FILE THEIR ON APPEAL.

51:08 - AND IN OUR DOCKET AND SCHOOL

51:10 - DISTRICTS DACA KIDS. WHAT I CAN

51:13 - TELL YOU IS THAT.

51:16 - BECAUSE OUR PEOPLE ARE

51:17 - AFFECTED. WE SHOULD NOT

51:19 - BE BARRED. FROM HAVING THE

51:21 - DECISION MADE ON THE MERITS IT

51:23 - COULD BE DID NOT FILE AN

51:24 - APPEAL. IN THE CITY.

51:34 - >>OKAY THANK YOU MR. ABOUT A

51:36 - WORKER FROM THE THE LAW.

51:42 - >>IF YOU CAN RUN HERE.

51:46 - MAY PLEASE THE COURT MY NAME

51:47 - SHOPS ALONG AND I REPRESENT THE

51:48 - CHESTER COUNTY BOARD OF

51:49 - ASSESSMENT APPEALS.

51:51 - >>THE ARGUMENT PRIMARILY.

51:53 - >>ADDRESSES THE ISSUE OF

51:54 - JUDICIAL ECONOMY. IT'S OBVIOUS

51:57 - FROM THE LONG DRAWN-OUT NATURE

51:58 - OF THIS MATTER.

52:00 - THAT THEIR STRONG DISAGREEMENT

52:01 - AMONGST THE PARTIES REGARDING

52:03 - THE MERITS OF THE PLAYING

52:06 - FOR EXEMPTION AND DUE TO THE

52:08 - NATURE TAX ASSESSMENT APPEALS

52:10 - IF THIS MATTERS NOT ALLOWED TO

52:11 - PROCEED TO THE COMMONWEALTH

52:13 - COURT TO BE DECIDED ON THE

52:14 - MERITS. IT'S A VIRTUAL

52:15 - CERTAINTY THAT IS GOING TO END

52:17 - UP BACK BEFORE.

52:18 - OUR BOARD AND THEN WORK ITS WAY

52:21 - THROUGH THE APPELLATE PROCESS

52:22 - AGAIN. SO THEREFORE IT MAKES

52:24 - SENSE THAT. IT SHOULD BE

52:27 - ALLOWED TO PROCEED TO THE

52:29 - MERITS OF THE COMMONWEALTH

52:30 - COURT AND THEY WERE THERE.

52:33 - PROVIDE SOME FINALITY IN THIS

52:35 - MATTER IT'S BEEN PENDING FOR 70

52:37 - BEFORE THE COURTS

52:39 - ON THE MATTER IS FULLY BRIEFED

52:40 - ON THE MERITS IT WAS PREPARED

52:42 - TO BE ARGUED ON THE MERITS

52:43 - BEFORE THE COMMONWEALTH COURT.

52:45 - ALSO IMPORTS POSITION IS THAT

52:47 - IT SHOULD BE ALLOWED. IT COMES

52:49 - OF IT.

52:51 - >>MISTER ROTH. JUST THERE

52:55 - RESPECT WE.

52:58 - I'M NOT SURE I CARE MUCH ABOUT

53:01 - WHY ISN'T THE FIRST SCHOOL

53:02 - THERE. IT WILL END UP THAT IF

53:05 - YOU'RE BORED. I THINK THE

53:07 - COMMONWEALTH COURT WAS TRYING

53:09 - TO.

53:11 - ENGAGE PEOPLE ECONOMY

53:13 - BY SAYING THIS CASE IS IS OVER

53:15 - BY THE APPEAL WAS A TIME IN

53:18 - PART BY THE CALL OF A COUP.

53:21 - TO WHAT WAS TO COME BACK.

53:25 - >>EVERY TIME THE

53:26 - TAX ASSESSMENT. EVERY YEAR

53:28 - BASICALLY IT COMES BACK UP AND

53:29 - EVERY PARTY

53:30 - OR THE VARIOUS PARTIES HAVE THE

53:32 - OPPORTUNITY TO APPEAL AND

53:33 - THE ASSESSMENT AND THEN GOING

53:36 - THROUGH THE FINAL 4 HELLISH

53:37 - PROCESS. THE.

53:41 - THE

53:41 - PARTIES WOULD THEN AGAIN FOR

53:42 - THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING IT

53:43 - BACK FOR THE TRIAL COURT AND IF

53:45 - THEY DON'T LIKE WHAT THE

53:46 - TROPICS AND IN THAT REGARD.

53:47 - THEY COULD THEN AGAIN APPEAL.

53:49 - SO IN BEING ALLOWED TO GO ON TO

53:51 - THE COMMONWEALTH COURT IN THE

53:52 - COMMONWEALTH COURT. I THINK YOU

53:56 - KNOW OUR POSITION IT'S OUR

53:57 - POSITION ABOUT PROVIDE MUCH

53:58 - MORE FINALITY ON THIS AND THEN

54:00 - SORT OF GUIDANCE TO OTHER

54:01 - WORKS.

54:03 - >>SO YOU COULD COME TO COURT

54:04 - SIDE.

54:10 - WHO IS TO SAY FOR 20,000 THE

54:13 - 2000. IT.

54:17 - IN QUARTERLY, IF YOU'RE

54:19 - NOT SUGGESTING THAT THERE'S

54:20 - GREAT CLOUD OR LATERAL TOP OF

54:22 - THE YEAR 2016 1718 19

54:25 - 20 IF SOMEBODY WANTS THEY CAN

54:27 - DO BITE AT THE APPLE. OUR COLD

54:29 - CASES.

54:32 - >>TECHNICALLY IN IN A WAY THEY

54:34 - ARE HOWEVER

54:35 - IF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT HAS

54:37 - GOTTEN TO THE MERITS OF WHY

54:38 - WHETHER OR NOT THIS PERSON

54:40 - REALLY DESERVES AN EXEMPTION.

54:42 - IT BECOMES MUCH HARDER FOR ONE

54:43 - OF THE PARTIES TO COME BACK AND

54:44 - SAYING WELL YOUR HONOR YOU KNOW

54:47 - TO THE TRIAL COURT. WE SHOULD

54:49 - GET THIS AGAIN OR WE SHOULD NOT

54:50 - WHERE THEY SHOULD NOT GET SICK.

54:52 - IT'S THERE OF EID SOME

54:53 - GUIDANCE. OK THANK YOU.

54:58 - AND

54:58 - WE DID A FEW POINTS ON RACE YOU

55:00 - TO COMMENT COLLATERAL STOP

55:02 - BASICALLY OUR TO THE BOARD'S

55:04 - POSITION IS THAT YOU KNOW

55:05 - IN ORDER FOR THOSE DOCTRINES TO

55:07 - APPLY JUDGMENT HAS TO BE FINAL.

55:10 - YOU KNOW THE PRONGS

55:11 - OF THE WHILE THE PRONGS AND

55:13 - WILL RESTOCK ITS SEEM TO BE

55:15 - MOST ON THIS CASE.

55:16 - ALL RIGHT. AS THIS QUARTER SAID

55:19 - JUDGMENT NEEDS TO BE FINAL THAT

55:20 - MEANS THAT THE AND THE PROCESS

55:22 - MUST HAVE GONE THROUGH.

55:24 - AND THERE NEEDS TO GET FINAL

55:25 - CONCLUSIVE A DETERMINATION

55:27 - REGARDING EVERY FACT WHICH IS

55:28 - THAT WAY.

55:30 - AND THE POLICY BEHIND THESE

55:32 - DOCTRINES IS NOT REALLY A

55:33 - CLICKABLE HERE AS MISTER OF OUR

55:34 - BETTER COVER BRIEFLY.

55:36 - THIS IS NOT THAT PROVERBIAL

55:37 - BITE SECOND BITE OF THE APPLE,

55:39 - THIS IS NOT A CASE IN WHICH A

55:40 - LITTLE GAME TRYING TO BRING

55:41 - BACK THE SAME EXACT CASE.

55:44 - BUT JUST COLORING IT HAS A

55:45 - DIFFERENT CAUSE OF ACTION OR

55:47 - SOMETHING OF THAT NATURE.

55:48 - ALSO THERE FOR THAT REASON AS

55:51 - WELL AS THE JUDICIAL ECONOMY

55:52 - ARGUMENTS THE BOARD WILL

55:54 - RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT THIS

55:55 - COURT.

55:57 - REVERSE THE COMMONWEALTH

55:58 - COURT'S DECISION AND REMANDED

55:59 - BACK TO COME AND WORK FOR

56:03 - WHO CAN TELL YOU.

56:06 - THAT COULD SOON AT THE

56:07 - COMMONWEALTH COURT.

56:09 - >>REVERSING ANY ICE ESTIMATE

56:11 - FROM A NATION IS

56:12 - MY FIGHT. WHAT DO YOU THINK

56:14 - IMPACT ON THE OTHER CASES THAT

56:17 - ENDING IN NEED BE WITH THEIR

56:20 - FINAL CASE.

56:23 - >>IF I DARE YOU TO BASICALLY

56:25 - GETTING AT THE QUESTION YOU

56:26 - ASKED FOR MISTER BY WHAT

56:27 - HAPPENS TO THE

56:28 - OTHER WARNER. IT'S BASICALLY

56:30 - THE BOARD'S POSITION THAT IT'S

56:31 - IT'S ONE ASSESSMENT. SO

56:33 - THEREFORE IT'S

56:35 - IT INFECTS THE COMMONWEALTH

56:37 - COURT DECISION WOULD AFFECT

56:38 - THAT ASSESSMENT. SO WE'RE GOING

56:40 - TO IMPACT ACROSS

56:41 - THE 2.

56:43 - >>DAY ISN'T IT IS AN APPEAL BY

56:46 - POINT CAPPING AUTHORITY AND

56:48 - APPEAL HAS 2 ALL CASTING

56:50 - ALREADY.

56:52 - I THINK 30 FEET DOWN BY WHAT

56:54 - HAPPENED IN

56:55 - THAT APPEAL.

56:56 - >>AND YET WE WOULD AGREE WITH

56:58 - THAT BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT

56:59 - IT IS ONE ASSESSMENT OF

57:01 - THAT PROPERTY. THEREFORE THAT

57:03 - COMMONWEALTH COURT DECISION

57:04 - WOULD HAVE THAT EFFECT ON THOSE

57:05 - OTHER. THERE'S

57:07 - OTHER AUTHORITIES.

57:08 - >>IT'S GOING IN YOU

57:10 - FROM YOUR BACK IT'S NOT

57:12 - NECESSARY FOR EVERY CAPPING

57:14 - AUTHORITY TO APPEAL IF ONE

57:16 - FEELS IN A DEGREE. I WITH A

57:19 - PREDICATE FOR TAKING THE FIELD.

57:21 - >>YES AND THAT'S OUR POSITION

57:22 - HERE IS ESSENTIALLY THAT THE

57:23 - SCHOOL DISTRICT TO GET TIMELY

57:25 - APPEAL OF THE ORDER THAT WAS A

57:27 - CLICKABLE DIRECTLY TO THAT.

57:33 - >>IF YOU WILL HEAR FROM A.

57:43 - >>REPRESENT THE PELLEY HE

57:44 - SOME PROPERTIES. OBVIOUSLY THE

57:48 - USE OF PROPERTIES AGREES

57:49 - THE PLEA WITH THE COMMONWEALTH

57:51 - COURT'S DECISION THE RATIONALE

57:53 - SET FORTH THEREIN.

57:55 - THIS IN ITALY. THIS CASE IS

57:57 - SOMEWHAT UNIQUE.

58:00 - >>IN THAT ORDINARILY.

58:02 - >>THERE IS ONE OF APPEAL IN

58:03 - WHICH ALL THE TAXING

58:04 - AUTHORITIES TO INTERVENE IN THE

58:07 - CASE IF THEY DESIRE TO DO SO.

58:13 - THE TAXING THAT THERE WERE 2

58:14 - APPEALS ONE INITIATED BY CITY

58:16 - ONE INITIATED BY THE.

58:22 - AND HEARD YOUR APPEARANCE

58:24 - INTERVENE IN. WE THE OTHERS

58:27 - CASES. AS THE WHO OR WHERE.

58:31 - AND WHAT YOU ARE HAVE ALL

58:33 - RIGHTS OF APPEAL. THE

58:35 - PARTICIPATE IN THE ACTION.

58:38 - AND FROM

58:38 - THE BEGINNING THE CASES WERE

58:40 - CONSOLIDATED ONLY FOR TRIAL.

58:43 - THEY PROCEED.

58:47 - FORWARD TO THE TRIAL TO THE

58:48 - COUPLE WHO WANTS THERE

58:50 - THEY REMAINED AND EVERY MAN

58:54 - TRIAL COURT REISSUE WATER.

58:57 - BORDERS IN EACH CASE, THE ONLY

58:59 - DIFFERENCE BETWEEN.

59:05 - AND

59:06 - CASES RING IT CHASES MAINTAINED

59:09 - THEIR SEPARATE IDENTITIES.

59:12 - INTERESTINGLY THE SCHOOL

59:13 - DISTRICT. IT WAS

59:15 - VERY ACTIVE. IN THE CITY'S

59:17 - CASE, THE 28 DOCUMENTARIES THEY

59:20 - WERE FULLY

59:21 - INVESTED IT REALLY HAD THE

59:22 - OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT TODAY.

59:24 - THE DAY THAT DESIRE. WE DID NOT

59:27 - THE ONE GOOD. SAYS

59:29 - A RESULT. THERE'S A FINAL

59:30 - ORDER.

59:32 - THE CORONER FOR L A DAY.

59:36 - GREAT YOU KNOW

59:37 - CARTER WEEK.

59:38 - >>THE LITIGATION THE NATION ARE

59:40 - FINALLY LET IT GO.

59:42 - A HOUSTON NONPROFIT STATUS

59:44 - BECOME FINAL.

59:46 - >>YES.

59:50 - IT HAS ONE OF

59:51 - THE CARS IN THE CITY'S APPEAL.

59:54 - THE TRIAL COURT ISSUED

59:56 - AN ORDER THAT ORDER WOULD

59:58 - 240 NOT APPEAL. SO THERE IS THE

01:00 - 01.150 FINAL BORDER.

01:00 - 03.960 DEALS

01:00 - 06.370 WITH THE EXEMPTION STATUS OF

01:00 - 07.680 THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION.

01:00 - 10.840 THAT IS CURRENTLY A RECORD.

01:00 - 11.830 IN

01:00 - 13.410 CHESTER COUNTY. NO WONDER

01:00 - 15.030 PEOPLE THAT WERE IN HIS FINAL

01:00 - 18.490 DISPOSITIVE SO WHAT IF IT IF.

01:00 - 20.860 THE SCHOOL

01:00 - 22.470 DISTRICT'S APPEAL. THERE WERE

01:00 - 24.650 ANYTHING ELSE OTHER THAN ENOUGH

01:00 - 26.070 FOR US IT WOULD

01:00 - 27.330 HAVE BEEN HE WOULD HAVE

01:00 - 29.440 CONFLICTING ORDERS ON THE SAME

01:00 - 31.080 PROPERTY WITH RESPECT TO THE

01:00 - 34.110 TERRIBLE COUGH.

01:00 - 41.580 >>IT. IN FACT MY HAVE LIVED

01:00 - 42.470 HERE HAS BEEN.

01:00 - 47.190 HOW COULD IT BE OTHERWISE SAID

01:00 - 48.740 GIVEN THAT YOU'RE DEALING WITH

01:00 - 52.090 ONE ASSESSMENT. IN ALL OF THE

01:00 - 52.750 CASES.

01:00 - 55.190 OPERATION OF

01:00 - 56.090 THE STAFF THE

01:00 - 00.840 IF YOU'RE 18 YOU FEEL HUMID AND

01:01 - 01.940 PARTIES AND THINGS OF THAT

01:01 - 04.480 NATURE AND THAT LED TO THE

01:01 - 06.960 DAYS. YEAH IN READING GOOD AT

01:01 - 09.450 TAKING OFF. THE DAY ENDED HEAL

01:01 - 10.940 BY ONE PASSING

01:01 - 13.860 IT ALREADY IS AN APPEAL HAS ALL

01:01 - 16.110 HAPPENED BEFORE. I MEAN YOU CAN

01:01 - 17.370 NEVER CASTING YOU ALREADY

01:01 - 18.930 DISAGREE WITH THE FACT THAT

01:01 - 20.770 MANY FEEL WAY THEY CAN THEY

01:01 - 21.490 CLAIM THEY

01:01 - 23.540 COULD DIE. I GUESS YOU COULD BE

01:01 - 25.570 HEAL AND GET EXCITED TO BE IF

01:01 - 28.110 THEY DON'T. I MEAN IN THE CASE

01:01 - 29.870 IN EVERY WILLING TO BE BANNED

01:01 - 31.780 BY THE OUTCOME OF THE APPEAL

01:01 - 33.080 THAT HAS BEEN A FUN

01:01 - 35.900 AND YOU. THE FBI BACK TO YOU

01:01 - 37.460 ALREADY SUCCESSFUL IN THEIR

01:01 - 39.610 APPEAL. IT. THE IMPACT

01:01 - 42.340 ALL OF THE OTHER END BE CASES

01:01 - 43.620 BECAUSE THERE'S ONLY ONE HE

01:01 - 43.860 SAID.

01:01 - 48.670 >>WITH THAT THE JUSTICE WHO YOU

01:01 - 51.350 ARE. HONOR THE UN AND THAT'S

01:01 - 53.530 THE KEY THAT IS THE CASE IN

01:01 - 54.140 THIS INCIDENT.

01:01 - 59.070 IT WAS INITIATED BY THE CITY.

01:02 - 01.590 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT HAD THE

01:02 - 01.900 RIGHT.

01:02 - 04.940 SO DID THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT.

01:02 - 07.410 THESE ARE LONG GONE. THEY DO

01:02 - 07.740 NOT.

01:02 - 11.070 SO THEREFORE THEY THEY DID NOT

01:02 - 12.210 AVAIL THEMSELVES OF GREAT

01:02 - 13.590 THERE'S A FINAL ORDER.

01:02 - 16.620 >>YEAH, I MEAN YOU'RE COMING TO

01:02 - 18.690 EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE CONCLUSION

01:02 - 21.100 KNOW WHAT I AM COATESVILLE AREA

01:02 - 23.810 SCHOOL DISTRICT IN EILEEN HEAL.

01:02 - 25.970 YEAH PEOPLE CAN

01:02 - 26.950 BE AYE.

01:02 - 28.910 I THINK YOU KNOW TAKING THE

01:02 - 30.800 CONCLUDING AND YOU'RE GOING TO

01:02 - 33.450 BE IN INCRIMINATION OF WHETHER

01:02 - 35.870 OR NOT THE SAME THING I NEED IS

01:02 - 37.720 STEPHANIE ANY EXEMPTION WOULD

01:02 - 38.110 REACT.

01:02 - 40.940 THAT AND HE'LL FIND OUT WHEN WE

01:02 - 44.490 GET BACK. IT'S GOING TO IMPACT.

01:02 - 46.670 HE SAYS THAT

01:02 - 49.920 ARE IN IT'S NOT NECESSARY AS I

01:02 - 51.940 READ THAT I CAN BE

01:02 - 54.780 4 EVERYONE TO APPEAL OR FOR

01:02 - 55.510 EVERYONE

01:02 - 57.930 TO INTERVENE THEY CAN SAY ONE

01:02 - 59.480 THING BUT IT WON'T FEEL WE'VE

01:02 - 01.420 TAKEN BY ANY OF THE ACT

01:03 - 04.040 THE AUTHORITY IT'S GOING TO BE

01:03 - 07.000 BINDING AND TO ALL OF THE OTHER

01:03 - 08.010 PENDING CASES.

01:03 - 10.940 >>IN IN I AGREE

01:03 - 13.040 WITH THAT IF YOUR HONOR SAID

01:03 - 15.300 HOW EVER ISSUE

01:03 - 17.220 IN THIS APPEAL. THE SCHOOL

01:03 - 18.170 DISTRICT APPEALED AND THE

01:03 - 19.070 CITY'S APPEAL

01:03 - 21.290 FOR IDENTICAL. THERE IS A TAX

01:03 - 23.640 EXEMPTION STATUS AND THERE IS A

01:03 - 26.300 FINAL ORDER. WITH RESPECT TO

01:03 - 28.730 THAT. AND IF YOU GO THROUGH

01:03 - 31.280 THE ELEMENTS. PRESSURE TO CUT

01:03 - 36.140 SATISFIES EVERY SINGLE ELEMENT

01:03 - 40.410 TO THE STATE. THE

01:03 - 41.520 SCHOOL DISTRICT AND THE

01:03 - 43.310 OPPORTUNITY IS THE SAME

01:03 - 44.660 PARTIES. IT IS THE

01:03 - 47.110 SAME ISSUE. AND RIGHT NOW THERE

01:03 - 49.800 IS AN ORDER SO THEY SO THERE

01:03 - 50.740 ISN'T FINALLY.

01:03 - 54.430 IN CHESTER COUNTY IT WHEN YOU

01:03 - 55.570 WHEN YOU REFER TO IS PENDING.

01:03 - 00.160 IT'S HARD.

01:04 - 02.340 >>NO I'M SORRY JUST WANT TO

01:04 - 03.730 FOLLOW UP ON THAT THOUGHT IT

01:04 - 06.150 WAS COOL FOR YOU THAT'S.

01:04 - 08.720 A PERMISSIBLE THAT JUST THE

01:04 - 09.660 THOUGHT OF THE DAY.

01:04 - 14.740 5 YOU ARE.

01:04 - 16.860 DRESS FRANKLY BECAUSE THE

01:04 - 17.920 LEGISLATIVE SIDE

01:04 - 20.260 OF THIS THE 53 PENNSYLVANIA

01:04 - 24.370 HOLIDAY DEBT. 8847. WHICH IS

01:04 - 26.200 PART OF. OF

01:04 - 27.800 THIS PLOT. HOLIDAY COUNTY

01:04 - 30.580 ASSESSMENT LAW. IT SAYS THAT IF

01:04 - 31.670 THERE'S ENOUGH. HE'LL.

01:04 - 35.340 THAT BECAME THE SET IN

01:04 - 37.760 COMPUTING BACK IMPOSED NEXT

01:04 - 39.900 FISCAL YEAR. WE'LL BE BY THE

01:04 - 41.800 CAUSE. ALL PARTS.

01:04 - 44.330 SO AT THE OVAL OFFICE

01:04 - 49.700 THAT BOTH SIDES OF THE CORRECT

01:04 - 56.250 >>SHE DIDN'T CALL RULE LED THE

01:04 - 56.570 COST

01:04 - 58.570 OF FIGHTING. THE LOCAL FOCUS

01:04 - 00.820 FELL ONE POINT THEY FEEL WOULD

01:05 - 02.810 OFTEN HAVE DISPARATE SET TO

01:05 - 04.020 MARRY A BATH AND BODY.

01:05 - 09.260 >>HE THE ASSESSMENT. PROVIDED

01:05 - 11.790 BY THE HIGH. IT RIGHT. THE

01:05 - 13.490 SIDE. IS

01:05 - 15.720 NOTHING INCONSISTENT. IF THE

01:05 - 17.310 SCHOOL DISTRICT TO SEND THE

01:05 - 18.950 CASE BACK THAT'S HOW THE

01:05 - 20.690 QUESTION SEEMED TO BE ENDED AND

01:05 - 22.170 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT FAILED.

01:05 - 24.730 THERE'S NO PROBLEM WHATSOEVER.

01:05 - 26.120 THE ONE MINUTE.

01:05 - 29.770 >>THERE IS A FINAL COURT OF

01:05 - 30.220 APPEAL.

01:05 - 35.730 IT'S WHY WE AT LEAST KNOW WHAT.

01:05 - 43.860 EXEMPTION STATUS HAS ALREADY

01:05 - 45.520 BEEN ESTABLISHED IT STARTS.

01:05 - 48.180 THE CASE IS OVER AND IF YOU GO

01:05 - 49.320 THROUGH THE ELEMENTS

01:05 - 51.000 A RAZOR TO CUT A THERE'S

01:05 - 51.980 NOTHING PREVENTING SCHOOL

01:05 - 53.340 DISTRICT. FOR THE COUNTY

01:05 - 55.190 REPORTED THIS HAS BEEN FROM

01:05 - 56.250 FROM DOING A DEAL.

01:05 - 59.170 CITIES CASE THE CASE OF A

01:05 - 00.740 MORNING THE

01:06 - 02.860 ENTIRE PARTY UNTIL THE MOST

01:06 - 05.470 RECENT QUARTER. AND SO WHAT

01:06 - 06.190 WILL HAPPEN IS.

01:06 - 08.080 >>LET'S ASSUME, LET'S ASSUME

01:06 - 10.730 THAT BECAUSE BACK AND THERE'S

01:06 - 12.100 SOMETHING OTHER THAN ENOUGH FOR

01:06 - 12.640 MONTHS.

01:06 - 20.100 IN CASE THAT SAYS. THE SCHOOL

01:06 - 21.000 DISTRICT'S APPEAL.

01:06 - 24.750 >>IT SET AT 50%

01:06 - 26.840 AND SAYS 75% OF EXEMPTION WE'RE

01:06 - 28.220 WE'RE NOT EXEMPT, BUT WHENEVER

01:06 - 29.860 SOMETHING DIFFERENT. SO YOU

01:06 - 31.690 HAVE EVENTUALLY A FINAL ORDER

01:06 - 32.800 THAT THE COMBAT WILL BECOME

01:06 - 34.910 FINAL. THEY HAVE A FINAL ORDER

01:06 - 36.210 THE NEXT CASE.

01:06 - 38.120 AND THEN YOU HAVE THE FINAL

01:06 - 38.800 WORD IN THE

01:06 - 41.150 OTHER CASE, THE PARTIES READY.

01:06 - 42.980 IT CREATES A RUCKUS I WILL

01:06 - 44.550 CLEAN TOO.

01:06 - 46.400 >>AND I THINK THAT THE BEST

01:06 - 47.710 SHOT OF YOU AND I BOTH THAT

01:06 - 49.240 MAYBE MAYBE YOU'VE ANSWERED.

01:06 - 50.940 THE BUT CERTAINLY DON'T WANT TO

01:06 - 53.310 BE ADAMANT ABOUT IT. BUT

01:06 - 54.380 IT SEEMS AS IF THERE IS NO

01:06 - 55.850 CONFLICT COMMONWEALTH COURT.

01:06 - 58.570 THE CITY YOU WIN UNLESS WE.

01:06 - 00.230 THANKS AND WE WOULD HAVE THE

01:07 - 01.640 RIGHT TO STEP IN ALLOWING THE

01:07 - 02.170 APPEAL AND

01:07 - 05.500 A CHANGE. IN THE GO TO GUY WHO

01:07 - 06.890 CAN THEN THAT QUICKLY.

01:07 - 09.880 >>RESPECTFULLY TO THE RUNNER.

01:07 - 11.680 THERE ONCE IN THE WATER IS

01:07 - 14.120 FINE. YOU'RE GOING

01:07 - 17.230 BACK IN AND WHAT ARE YOU IN IN

01:07 - 19.090 ANOTHER CASE. WELL

01:07 - 20.830 ON THAT. I'M SORRY GOING

01:07 - 23.560 FISHING AND DRY THAT AND I

01:07 - 25.910 DO MEAN AND THEN I DID.

01:07 - 33.600 >>INSTEAD THE WAY

01:07 - 35.280 I SEE AND I APPRECIATE YOU'RE

01:07 - 37.240 GOING TO DISAGREE YEAR FIND OUT

01:07 - 38.970 WHO THE JOB. BUT I WANT YOU

01:07 - 40.940 TO KIDS IF THERE IS NO PRIOR

01:07 - 42.520 DAY WHEN THE CHIEF JUSTICE AND

01:07 - 44.800 PEACE AND WHEN WE ALL HEARD

01:07 - 46.010 ABOUT IT. FIRST.

01:07 - 48.720 APPROPRIATE LAW SCHOOL.

01:07 - 52.030 COURT FOR PRECLUDES AN

01:07 - 54.370 PRINCIPALS FULL 5 THEY HAD A

01:07 - 56.330 PRIOR CASE. AND IN

01:07 - 58.360 SOME CASE IT SEEMS TO

01:07 - 01.140 ME HAVE 2 SIMULTANEOUS CASES IN

01:08 - 02.640 THERE FOR THE MOST BASIC

01:08 - 04.800 ELEMENT OF THESE PRINCIPLES IS

01:08 - 06.030 IS NOT PRESENT.

01:08 - 09.260 >>AND RESPECTFULLY I

01:08 - 10.640 BELIEVE THAT IN JUNE WITHOUT A

01:08 - 12.280 DIFFERENCE IN THIS CASE.

01:08 - 16.570 REALLY THE OTHER CASE THAT WAS

01:08 - 19.520 GOING TO CAN HIM IS NOW A PRIOR

01:08 - 21.720 CASE. SO THAT'S ASSUMING GET

01:08 - 24.070 FREE MAN FOR SOME REASON FOR IT

01:08 - 26.110 TO THE TRIAL. RECORD AS IT

01:08 - 27.320 TAKES THEM, IT IS A MESS

01:08 - 29.650 TESTIMONY WHO ARE WE TRYING IT

01:08 - 32.140 AGAIN. HE IT IS.

01:08 - 34.570 THERE'S ALREADY BEEN A DECISION

01:08 - 36.790 SO THERE IS RIGHT NOW A PRIOR

01:08 - 38.870 DECISION OR UNDER COLLATERAL

01:08 - 41.190 ESTOPPEL. IT'S ALREADY

01:08 - 43.630 BEEN DECIDED ISSUE BEFORE

01:08 - 45.720 THE COURT. IT'S ALREADY BEEN

01:08 - 48.190 DECIDED AND IN A CAR.

01:08 - 53.000 IT'S WHETHER A SHOOTER CONNOR

01:08 - 53.480 WAS A TIME.

01:08 - 56.780 BUT FOR THE COURT.

01:09 - 03.180 IT'S RESIDENT GOT IT AND WE'RE

01:09 - 04.540 COLLATERAL ESTOPPEL

01:09 - 06.070 SO IF THE

01:09 - 07.020 ISSUE DECIDED.

01:09 - 09.130 >>YOU BOIL RACE TO THE TOP OF

01:09 - 10.490 THE BLOCK SOMEONE BREAK INTO

01:09 - 10.660 THE.

01:09 - 13.820 >>BECAUSE THEY HAD E

01:09 - 17.050 SAME RIGHT. THE GOLD OR PARTIES

01:09 - 19.050 THE DEAL. THE CITY'S APPEAL.

01:09 - 20.790 IT'S THE SAME ISSUE THE

01:09 - 22.440 SAME PARTY, THE ACTIVELY

01:09 - 25.420 PARTICIPATE. THE INTERVENER IN

01:09 - 27.250 THE CASE HAS THE SAME RIGHTS

01:09 - 29.610 AND BACK TO SPORT. THEY GET

01:09 - 32.370 SO BORED. PEOPLE DID THIS IN

01:09 - 33.570 THE MUNCIE CASE.

01:09 - 37.850 PEOPLE WHO IT'S A

01:09 - 39.870 VERY PEEL IF THE ALLEY OF

01:09 - 41.710 PENN HILLS, WHAT'S AN

01:09 - 43.230 INTERVENTION IS ALLOWED TO

01:09 - 44.820 INTERVENE OR SUPPORTED ALL

01:09 - 47.030 RIGHTS. WELL THE PARTY TO THE

01:09 - 48.950 ACTION. THE LESS OTHERWISE

01:09 - 50.450 SPECIFIED IN THE INTERVENING

01:09 - 51.560 RIGHT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE

01:09 - 53.640 FIELD IS NOT THE POND. IT

01:09 - 55.260 CONTINUED PARTICIPATION OF THE

01:09 - 55.940 ORIGINAL PILOT.

01:09 - 57.990 SO THAT IF THE CITY DECIDED NOT

01:09 - 59.430 TO DO IT NOT TO GO FORWARD.

01:09 - 00.790 THEY HAD THE RIGHT TO PICK IT

01:10 - 02.970 UP THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS I

01:10 - 03.880 DON'T KNOW WHY THEY COULDN'T

01:10 - 05.690 COMMUNICATE. WHEN THEY DID BUT

01:10 - 07.310 THEY DIDN'T THEY HAVE THE RIGHT

01:10 - 08.770 TO DO IT SO AND THIS

01:10 - 10.090 COURT'S JURISPRUDENCE

01:10 - 11.450 STRETCHING ALL THE WAY BACK IS

01:10 - 13.220 VERY CONSISTENT. IT'S NOT

01:10 - 15.790 CONSOLIDATED ENTIRELY. THE

01:10 - 17.760 CASES RETAIN THEIR SEPARATE

01:10 - 19.330 IDENTITIES FOR PURPOSES OF AN

01:10 - 21.670 APPEAL. SO NOW YOU HAVE TO FIND

01:10 - 23.840 WATER IN ONE CASE AND THAT ONE

01:10 - 25.840 CASE ESTABLISHES THE THE ISSUE

01:10 - 28.120 THAT IS IN THE OTHER CASE.

01:10 - 32.150 I THINK RIGHT NOW IT'S GETTING

01:10 - 33.520 THAT GETTING A SECOND POINTED

01:10 - 33.730 OUT.

01:10 - 36.180 FOR SOMETHING THEY DIDN'T DO

01:10 - 37.090 WHAT HE SHOULD HAVE DONE.

01:10 - 39.370 THEY HAD A LARGE EVENT.

01:10 - 41.380 >>NOW THE GOVERNMENT REPETITIVE

01:10 - 41.720 SHOW.

01:10 - 46.320 IT'S A MAJOR MUCH OR SOME

01:10 - 47.840 OTHER QUESTIONS. IT WILL

01:10 - 48.880 CONCLUDE THE ARGUMENT.

01:10 - 53.040 HEARING NONE WE THANK YOU.

01:10 - 54.090 >>THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

01:11 - 04.090 ONCE YOU TO BE PREPARED TO VOTE

01:11 - 05.780 WHETHER THROUGH THE MAIL OR IN

01:11 - 07.690 PERSON, EVERYONE NEEDS TO GO.

01:11 - 09.200 IF YOU'RE DIRECTLY FROM

01:11 - 10.640 CANDIDATES DURING PC ENDS

01:11 - 12.360 COMPLETE IMPARTIAL COVERAGE OF

01:11 - 14.700 DEBATES TOWNHOMES RALLIES AND

01:11 - 14.940 MORE.

01:11 - 17.690 MORE ABOUT THESE EVENTS AND PC

01:11 - 18.740 ENDS ON PARA LITTLE BE

01:11 - 21.160 ELECTION COVERAGE A BILL TO PCN

01:11 - 22.390 TV DOT COM.

01:11 - 25.650 THE PCN A PENNSYLVANIA POLITICS

01:11 - 26.560 AND POLICY.

01:11 - 33.290 >>THE COMMONWEALTH OF

01:11 - 34.270 PENNSYLVANIA VERSUS

01:11 - 36.450 ERICK YALE REPRESENTING ERICA

01:11 - 37.470 HILL IS MISTER

01:11 - 39.380 JULES EPSTEIN REPRESENTING THE

01:11 - 40.800 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA IS

01:11 - 42.980 MISTER MCMONAGLE JUNIOR.

01:11 - 46.010 GOOD

01:11 - 50.710 IF YOU IS ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL

01:11 - 51.330 CASE.

01:11 - 53.300 >>CONSIDER THE TEST FOR

01:11 - 54.100 DETERMINING WHAT ARE

01:11 - 00.050 3RD PARTY. THE COMMAND OF THE

01:12 - 01.670 OFFENSE FOR WHICH THE DEFENDANT

01:12 - 02.470 HAS BEEN CHARGED.

01:12 - 09.150 >>MISTER CHIEF JUSTICE MAY IT

01:12 - 10.130 PLEASE THE COURT.

01:12 - 14.620 YALE'S JURY A SINGLE QUESTION

01:12 - 16.550 TO RESULTS. NO

01:12 - 18.690 ONE DISPUTED AND IT COULD NOT

01:12 - 20.730 BE DISPUTED. THAT'S A

01:12 - 23.100 METHAMPHETAMINE PARAPHERNALIA

01:12 - 25.900 FOUND IN HIS HOUSE, IT WAS THE

01:12 - 27.410 RESPONSIBILITY OF FLOWERING

01:12 - 29.660 TOME SUS, THE MAN NAMED IN THE

01:12 - 31.730 SEARCH WARRANT. THE MAN HIDING

01:12 - 34.060 FROM POLICE IN THE CLAUSE, THE

01:12 - 36.060 ONLY OTHER QUESTIONS WAS IT

01:12 - 39.640 MISTER AILES ALSO. HE TESTIFIED

01:12 - 40.560 NO IT WASN'T.

01:12 - 43.220 BUT HE WAS DEPRIVED OF THE

01:12 - 44.670 RIGHT TO PRESENT THE TYPE

01:12 - 47.430 OF EVIDENCE THIS COURT HAS SAID

01:12 - 50.510 FOR 99 YEARS. IT IS ABSOLUTELY

01:12 - 51.000 ALLOWED.

01:12 - 53.790 WELL THE EVIDENCE AND YOU TO

01:12 - 54.160 SHOW.

01:12 - 58.490 THEIR SON COMMITTED ON. WELL

01:12 - 00.620 THE EVIDENCE THAT IS MANDATED

01:13 - 04.040 AND THE CONSTITUTION. WHAT WAS

01:13 - 08.290 NOT ONE. BUT 2 PRIOR INSTANCES,

01:13 - 09.680 A LOTTERY THOMPSON.

01:13 - 13.600 THE VAN CHANGE OF BEING AT

01:13 - 16.000 SOMEONE ELSE'S HOUSE AND USING

01:13 - 16.480 NOT IS

01:13 - 19.590 A SUBTERFUGE TO OPERATE IS

01:13 - 22.240 METHAMPHETAMINE IS NEXT.

01:13 - 24.710 THE AVERAGE HERE ARE SIMPLE.

01:13 - 27.510 THE SUPERIOR COURT APPOINTED

01:13 - 29.800 TESTS THIS COURT HAS ALREADY

01:13 - 30.590 REPUDIATION.

01:13 - 34.030 SAYING THE OTHER ACTS LIKE A

01:13 - 34.970 SEA CREATURE.

01:13 - 38.310 THE COMMON WILL TEACH BETTER

01:13 - 41.220 AND MAKES 2 MORE. IT SAYS

01:13 - 43.350 IN PENNSYLVANIA AND THERE'S NO

01:13 - 44.660 SUPPORT FOR THIS.

01:13 - 47.640 WHO WILL FOR BEING MUST BE

01:13 - 49.880 EQUALLY APPLIED TO THE COLD

01:13 - 51.580 WELL AND THE DEFENSE.

01:13 - 53.870 THE COMMONWEALTH COMPLETELY

01:13 - 55.760 MISREADS THE CONSTITUTIONAL

01:13 - 58.570 MANDATE TO HOMES AND THE OTHER

01:13 - 59.870 UNITED STATES SUPREME

01:13 - 02.170 COURT CASES AND WHAT THIS IS

01:14 - 04.070 NOT A CONSTITUTIONAL CLAIM.

01:14 - 07.210 OBVIOUSLY AND SO WHEN YOU HAVE

01:14 - 08.470 PEOPLE WHO DID THIS.

01:14 - 11.080 THAT FLIES IN THE FACE OF A

01:14 - 12.670 CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO PRESENT

01:14 - 13.560 A DEFENSE.

01:14 - 17.100 AS I EXPLAINED THE PROBLEM THEY

01:14 - 19.500 COME INTO TRIAL AND BASED ON

01:14 - 21.810 A SINGLE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE

01:14 - 25.080 THAT OLD RELICS IT WAS HOW THE

01:14 - 27.140 AGE OF THE 2 POLICE OFFICERS.

01:14 - 31.030 SOUND MISTER THOMPSON DOING

01:14 - 32.490 THIS SAME THING BEFORE

01:14 - 35.760 ESSENTIALLY SAYING IT'S AND

01:14 - 36.780 THAT IT WAS

01:14 - 39.300 IT MIGHT. WHAT IS HIS COURT

01:14 - 39.690 CASE.

01:14 - 44.160 99 YEARS AGO IN A CASE CALLED

01:14 - 46.990 NEXT. THIS COURT SAID IT.

01:14 - 50.240 THAT TYPE OF EVIDENCE IS

01:14 - 52.860 ADMISSIBLE IF IT MEETS THE ROAD

01:14 - 54.260 IN STAND YOUR AND

01:14 - 56.460 SUPPORTS THEM AND YOU SEE THE

01:14 - 58.910 CREW BOYLE THE

01:14 - 01.480 RELEVANCE STANDARD. THE WAR

01:15 - 05.470 1992. WELL THINGS AND AS

01:15 - 08.360 PERTAINS TO THE CASE ADMISSIBLE

01:15 - 11.090 IT SUPPORTS THE DEFENDANT'S

01:15 - 16.220 1993. A GALLON,

01:15 - 18.940 THE RELEVANCE. I WILL ASK THIS

01:15 - 20.770 COURT TO PERMIT ME TO DISCUSS

01:15 - 22.470 MIGUEL FOR ONE MOVE ON.

01:15 - 25.350 IT CAUSED NICK ALLEN ABSOLUTELY

01:15 - 27.300 CONTROLS THIS CASE IN

01:15 - 29.850 TERMS OF WHEN ALL OTHER ACTS

01:15 - 31.670 SUFFICIENTLY SIMILAR.

01:15 - 34.950 TO MANDATED HIS ABILITY.

01:15 - 37.480 THE EASTERN LEAGUE ALLEN WAS

01:15 - 39.570 CHARGED WITH THE ROBBERY OF THE

01:15 - 40.210 FORMS.

01:15 - 44.410 WELL HE WANTED TO SHOW WITH

01:15 - 50.210 NO SIGNATURE. NOTHING LIKE

01:15 - 50.390 THAT.

01:15 - 54.570 HE HAD BEEN IDENTIFIED. THE

01:15 - 56.080 EVIDENCE WAS ITS LEAD.

01:15 - 59.830 CONVICTION WAS OVERTURNED.

01:16 - 03.220 THAT IS AS HIGH OR LOW TO

01:16 - 04.580 THIS CASE AS ONE

01:16 - 06.980 COULD IMAGINE. THERE WERE OTHER

01:16 - 09.960 CRIMES OF THAT HELP. AND HERE

01:16 - 12.350 OF COURSE THERE IS MORE.

01:16 - 15.990 I

01:16 - 18.300 WILL CONFESS THIS COURT HAS

01:16 - 20.190 USED THAT MARINE TERMINAL

01:16 - 20.520 LEGIT.

01:16 - 26.200 HIGHLY DETAIL SUBSTANTIAL

01:16 - 30.690 GOING BACK

01:16 - 33.800 TO WAR. AS LONG AS THE EVIDENCE

01:16 - 34.490 IS RELEVANT.

01:16 - 36.850 AND SHE JUST ONE WE WILL

01:16 - 39.030 CONTINUE THAT THEY'RE ALL

01:16 - 41.240 THE SAME. THEY ARE THE RULES

01:16 - 44.760 ONE RELEVANT STANDARDS OF TEENS

01:16 - 45.400 TO SHOW.

01:16 - 49.040 AS I SAID AT THE BEGINNING

01:16 - 51.230 THE SUPERIOR COURT JUDGE WAS

01:16 - 52.980 SIMPLE. THEY DEMANDED

01:16 - 55.730 SIGNATURE. WE ALREADY KNOW THAT

01:16 - 59.160 AND THIS ALSO GOES TO THE POINT

01:16 - 00.190 OF THE COMMONWEALTH

01:17 - 04.800 EQUATING 4 '04. AS

01:17 - 07.220 THE EQUAL. THE DEFENSE AND THE

01:17 - 08.110 PROSECUTION.

01:17 - 12.460 IN 2016 THIS COURT DECIDED ITS

01:17 - 13.140 CASE.

01:17 - 16.490 PROSECUTION

01:17 - 20.390 AGAINST HIM TO THANK YOU.

01:17 - 22.940 WHAT DID THE COURT SAY AND

01:17 - 23.800 THESE SIGNATURE.

01:17 - 25.690 IN

01:17 - 29.510 2018 I ARGUED THIS COURT DECIDE

01:17 - 30.070 YOU GAYLE.

01:17 - 32.640 AND WE'LL DEAL WAS

01:17 - 34.630 ULTIMATELY DECIDE ON THE

01:17 - 36.210 GROUNDS OF THE USE OF

01:17 - 38.840 DISCRETION. THIS COURT MADE

01:17 - 39.780 A STATEMENT.

01:17 - 43.410 THAT WE'VE ALREADY ACCEPTING A

01:17 - 44.870 LOWER STANDARD.

01:17 - 51.120 THIS IS STATE CHILL SIMILARITY

01:17 - 52.060 TESTS.

01:18 - 01.670 YOU MAKE THE CASE.

01:18 - 05.230 YES, SIR I APOLOGIZE, I DROPPED

01:18 - 07.300 IT. HE SAYS THAT'S OKAY YOU

01:18 - 09.050 READY TO GO. YES, ABSOLUTELY

01:18 - 09.720 THANK YOU.

01:18 - 13.050 >>IF YOU MAKE 40 OFFICES, THEY

01:18 - 14.720 SHOULD KNOW FROM WHAT I THOUGHT

01:18 - 17.370 CONFIDENCE IT SEEMED TO ME THAT

01:18 - 18.950 STARTED THE BASES WITH GAINS.

01:18 - 21.760 AND I LOOKED AT HIS PEERS

01:18 - 22.020 COURT'S

01:18 - 24.600 REALLY AND I THOUGHT IT WAS A

01:18 - 25.600 VERY QUICK DECISION ON THE

01:18 - 27.820 BALLOT. AND I THOUGHT WE HAD A

01:18 - 28.030 4.

01:18 - 32.220 IT PALED IN THE

01:18 - 34.020 LETTER G STAND FOR

01:18 - 36.750 SIMILARITIES. A SIGNATURE

01:18 - 39.540 CRIME. THE LAST IN IN

01:18 - 45.620 2013. PATTERSON HIS FATHER 48,

01:18 - 47.040 MINUTELY WITHOUT ONE OUT.

01:18 - 48.950 BUT I THOUGHT THAT THE WEIGHT

01:18 - 50.300 OF PENNSYLVANIA LAW

01:18 - 52.680 THEN YOU THE YEARS OF TESTING

01:18 - 54.270 THAT BIG STRONG WAY TO IMPROVE

01:18 - 57.080 A LOT IT WITH YOU IN HERE WE

01:18 - 58.370 JUST HEARD IN THIS CASE.

01:18 - 00.680 >>SO THERE IS CASE AND GIVE

01:19 - 02.800 ME SERIOUS OF CASES A COUPLE OF

01:19 - 04.620 THINGS REALLY WAS A SUPERIOR

01:19 - 07.420 COURT CASE. CAN YOU GO THROUGH

01:19 - 08.690 THE BREACH. THE

01:19 - 11.450 NEW ORDINANCE DIFFERENT CASES

01:19 - 14.150 DIFFERENT TESTS. BUT JUST AS

01:19 - 16.180 THEY ARE RESPECTFULLY YOU WANT

01:19 - 17.580 TO KILL CASE.

01:19 - 20.250 AND YOU BROUGHT UP LIKE HIS

01:19 - 21.500 SIGNATURE TESTS.

01:19 - 25.190 YOU MADE IT CLEAR THE SIGNATURE

01:19 - 27.330 TESTS DO NOT APPLY HERE.

01:19 - 30.780 THE YUAN I SAY THIS MOST

01:19 - 31.590 RESPECTS WHAT.

01:19 - 33.660 THIS COURT

01:19 - 35.440 VARIES TIMES HAS WE USE

01:19 - 37.470 DIFFERENT TERMS SUBSTANTIAL

01:19 - 39.770 SIMILARITY HIGHLY DETAILED

01:19 - 42.740 SULEIMAN IT IS NEVER SAID

01:19 - 43.410 SIGNATURE.

01:19 - 47.110 AND ONE HAS TO BE THOSE WORDS

01:19 - 49.270 BECAUSE RESPECTFULLY IT'S LIKE

01:19 - 51.460 COMMUNITY. I THINK DETAIL

01:19 - 53.860 SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR IT'S IN

01:19 - 54.960 THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER.

01:19 - 58.830 SO WHAT WE NEED TO IF I MAY

01:19 - 00.410 RESPECT WE

01:20 - 02.740 WHAT WE NEED TO DO IS LOOK AT

01:20 - 04.590 HOW HAS THAT BEEN LIKE.

01:20 - 08.300 AND THAT'S WHY SHE IS LOOK AT

01:20 - 11.330 THE FACTS OF THE DOW. A

01:20 - 13.290 GALLON AGAIN. IT IS A

01:20 - 14.170 SUBSTANTIAL

01:20 - 16.740 SIMILARITY TESTS BUT ALL THE

01:20 - 18.400 NEEDED FOR SUBSTANTIALLY

01:20 - 21.430 SIMILAR WAS OTHER ROBBERIES OF

01:20 - 28.690 GUESS THE GUY YOU ARE.

01:20 - 32.430 >>YES THE CAPI OR IN A GALLON.

01:20 - 33.530 I AGREE WITH

01:20 - 35.450 THE FACT THE GATES ARE WHAT

01:20 - 37.400 THEY ARE WITH THE BE NOTHING

01:20 - 39.890 EVER BEEN. SO RIGHT.

01:20 - 44.940 FREE FLOW.

01:20 - 49.130 BY ADOPTING THE WAY FROM RAINY

01:20 - 51.520 WEEKEND NOTHING TO DO WITH THE

01:20 - 52.290 FACT THAT MAY

01:20 - 55.640 BE OUT. BECAUSE THE GUY AND HE

01:20 - 56.840 NOTED WITH APPROVAL OF THE

01:20 - 58.770 COURT KNOW GET RID OF THE GUY

01:20 - 00.650 WE EAT YOU KNOW, LARRY THE

01:21 - 02.570 STANDARD AND I THINK THAT'S

01:21 - 04.570 WHAT STARTED THE DAMNED IS FREE

01:21 - 06.390 FLOATING MY QUESTION TO YOU

01:21 - 06.760 YET.

01:21 - 09.660 WHY WOULD ANYBODY HAVE

01:21 - 13.500 TO HAVE. I SIMILARITY OR THAT

01:21 - 14.460 YOU CAN WEAR

01:21 - 16.940 A T IF THE ONLY PATH IS WHETHER

01:21 - 19.330 OR NOT HE HAS A TENDENCY

01:21 - 21.910 IMPROVED THAT SOMEONE ELSE MAY

01:21 - 22.440 HAVE COMMITTED

01:21 - 22.810 THE CRIME.

01:21 - 25.110 >>SO I HAVE A NEW AGREEMENT

01:21 - 26.880 THAT I WILL EXPLAIN THAT I

01:21 - 28.670 THINK GOT LANGUAGE ACTUALLY

01:21 - 30.460 COMES UP TO DISTINGUISH HIM

01:21 - 32.330 FROM SOMETHING THAT IS SO

01:21 - 35.260 REMOTE OR TANGENTIAL IF I MAY

01:21 - 36.460 JUSTICE TANI NEW

01:21 - 38.530 THE UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT

01:21 - 40.420 ACTUALLY GRAPPLE WITH THAT IN

01:21 - 41.740 THE HOLMES CASE.

01:21 - 43.710 AGAIN THIS IS THE

01:21 - 45.690 CONSTITUTIONAL CASE HERE TODAY

01:21 - 47.800 BUT OF COURSE AND INFORMS.

01:21 - 51.030 WHEN THE UNITED STATES

01:21 - 52.840 SUPREME COURT THIS WAS JUSTICE

01:21 - 54.960 ALITO WRITING FOR THE COURT

01:21 - 57.660 UNANIMOUS COURT TALKED ABOUT

01:21 - 00.730 THIS IN THE HOMES. HE WENT ON

01:22 - 03.530 TO WELL FROM TRADITIONAL.

01:22 - 05.350 TREE

01:22 - 08.850 PORN BOOKS AND WHAT IS

01:22 - 11.350 SUFFICIENTLY SIMILAR IN A

01:22 - 12.740 HOMICIDE CASE.

01:22 - 15.090 AND YOU'RE EVIDENCE TENDING TO

01:22 - 16.860 SHOW THE COMMISSION. WELL I

01:22 - 17.940 HAVE ANOTHER PERSON OF THE

01:22 - 20.150 CRIME MAY BE INTRODUCE

01:22 - 21.810 UNLESS IT'S

01:22 - 24.830 SO REMOTE OR LACKING IN SUCH

01:22 - 27.260 CONNECTION. SO TO ME THAT'S

01:22 - 29.730 REALLY IT. WELL 6 THE

01:22 - 32.340 SIMILARITY JUST WEEKS IT HAS TO

01:22 - 33.940 PASS THE RELEVANCE.

01:22 - 36.850 TESTS THE OTHER LANGUAGE THEY

01:22 - 40.000 USE IS THE ISSUES MAY INCLUDE

01:22 - 43.700 IN NEED LEGAL EVIDENCE TENDING

01:22 - 46.100 TO PROVE THAT ANOTHER PERSON

01:22 - 47.540 MAY HAVE COMMITTED THE CRIME

01:22 - 49.750 AND THE ONLY TIME IT MAY BE

01:22 - 52.300 EXCLUDED. THIS IS

01:22 - 54.860 FOR BAIT IS WHERE THE EVIDENCE

01:22 - 57.950 IS SPECULATIVE OR WE LOVE.

01:22 - 00.960 3RD CIRCUIT IN THE CASE

01:23 - 05.850 SAID IT HAS TO BE SUFFICIENTLY

01:23 - 07.740 SIMILAR. TO THE

01:23 - 10.240 CRIME FOR SO THAT IT IS

01:23 - 13.000 RELEVANT AND YOUR 4 O ONE AND

01:23 - 13.850 FOR THAT.

01:23 - 19.520 GOOD MORNING. SIR WE UNDERSTAND

01:23 - 21.030 THAT OUR CABLES ALL OVER

01:23 - 21.750 THE PLACE.

01:23 - 23.630 >>HOW WOULD YOU DEFEND WITH THE

01:23 - 24.560 STANDARDS WITHOUT THE

01:23 - 25.920 CONTRACTUAL LANGUAGE OF THE

01:23 - 27.410 FACT THAT BETWEEN 3RD PARTY

01:23 - 29.780 CAN DEFEND UNDERSTANDING THAT

01:23 - 31.850 THE FACTOR FOR FOR BEING HERE

01:23 - 32.840 TO FIND HER CREDIBLE.

01:23 - 37.460 >>MY POSITION

01:23 - 39.790 IS 2 PARTS ONE HIS BOOKS

01:23 - 41.610 THERE'S A QUESTION IS WHETHER

01:23 - 44.070 IT SHOULD BE FOR THE OR SIMPLY

01:23 - 45.060 FOR WON.

01:23 - 48.200 FOR THE WHITE

01:23 - 50.020 AND GRAY IT NEEDS TO BE

01:23 - 52.350 FILTERING THROUGH 4 OH ONE.

01:23 - 55.030 WHEN IT IS THE SENATE BECAUSE

01:23 - 57.660 CLEARLY THERE IS AN ASYMMETRY

01:23 - 01.140 WE RUN INTO 4 O 4 DAYS.

01:24 - 03.680 WELL WE HAVEN'T NOTICED

01:24 - 05.550 FOR PATIENTS. ONLY FOR THE

01:24 - 08.570 PROSECUTION. WELL I WE HAVE A

01:24 - 10.920 PREJUDICE ANALYSIS, THE

01:24 - 12.430 PREJUDICE THAT COOL

01:24 - 14.450 HISTORICALLY WAS DEVELOPED FOR

01:24 - 16.770 WAS PREJUDICE TO THE ACCUSED.

01:24 - 19.500 IN CAUSE OBVIOUSLY WHEN A

01:24 - 22.030 JURY HEARS THE CUBANS DID

01:24 - 22.780 SOMETHING GO

01:24 - 24.840 WRONG BEFORE. IT WAS A

01:24 - 26.170 CHARACTER MESSAGE

01:24 - 28.180 NOTWITHSTANDING ANY NON POWER

01:24 - 30.260 TO HURT. THAT'S THERE IS NO

01:24 - 32.490 CALL LIST READ YOU THIS TO

01:24 - 34.660 THE GOVERNMENT. SO I HOPE I'M

01:24 - 35.990 ANSWERING YOUR QUESTION I THINK

01:24 - 38.240 I UNDERSTAND YOU JUST STOP THAT

01:24 - 41.430 IN THE REGION AT WHO. IS

01:24 - 42.370 ANY SYMMETRY

01:24 - 45.240 AND AGAIN IT'S WHICH IS A

01:24 - 47.030 RECALL THE EURO WHICH ARE YOU

01:24 - 48.870 CAN YOU NEED WAS THE SIGNATURE

01:24 - 51.420 TESTS JUST AS BAD FROM THE

01:24 - 54.200 DEFENDANT WAS THE LOWER TAX SO

01:24 - 55.880 THAT'S IN OUR CASE LOAD ALL.

01:24 - 57.920 SO WHETHER YOU CALL THIS A

01:24 - 59.710 COOL. 4 '04.

01:25 - 02.330 HAYES IT WAS SOME BASIS

01:25 - 04.020 FOR IT OR YOU CALL

01:25 - 08.600 2, 4, 1, 2, POINTS FOR THE U.S.

01:25 - 10.380 TO BE INTERPRETED. WHEN THE

01:25 - 12.550 RELEVANCE

01:25 - 14.950 AND THE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO

01:25 - 16.590 PRESENT A DEFENSE IN THIS

01:25 - 18.860 COMMONWEALTH, COMMON LAW RIGHT

01:25 - 21.790 TO PRESENT A DEFENSE FOR HIM TO

01:25 - 23.790 BE RIGHT THERE. IT'S ONE OF

01:25 - 24.730 DEATH.

01:25 - 29.510 >>I'M SORRY TO BE DONE. HIGH

01:25 - 29.990 HUMIDITY.

01:25 - 33.110 IF YOU'RE ON YOUR PROFESSOR HAD

01:25 - 36.050 FOR SECOND. AND IT WAS GREAT TO

01:25 - 37.230 BE BACK TO YOU KNOW THAT.

01:25 - 39.990 IT'S FAR LESS IMPORTANT IF YOUR

01:25 - 42.630 CLIENT PREVAIL OR NOT THEN IF

01:25 - 44.080 WE STRAIGHTEN OUT PENNSYLVANIA

01:25 - 45.520 LAW THAT'S OUR PRINCIPAL

01:25 - 46.850 FUNCTION TO THAT SEVERAL

01:25 - 49.410 >>IF WE

01:25 - 51.940 CHANGE THAT I BELIEVE HE KILLED

01:25 - 54.730 SIMILARITY IN CRIME BY CONDOM.

01:25 - 55.770 TO

01:25 - 58.550 SUFFICIENTLY SIMILAR HAS TO BE

01:25 - 58.960 RELEVANT.

01:26 - 01.950 OR WE CAN SAY THAT WITH ALL YOU

01:26 - 02.900 HEAR THE CASE.

01:26 - 05.530 >>ABSOLUTELY OKAY FAIR ENOUGH.

01:26 - 06.940 MY

01:26 - 09.480 RECOLLECTION HILL AND ALL GO

01:26 - 10.480 BACK AND LOOK AT IT.

01:26 - 13.310 PEOPLE OUT. BUT A GREAT JOB OF

01:26 - 14.350 THAT NOW THAT I HAVE TO READ

01:26 - 16.720 IT. BUT THAT IS THAT WE CAN GET

01:26 - 18.890 THE TESTS THAT WE GOT THE CALL

01:26 - 21.160 LOCKDOWN INCLUDED IN

01:26 - 23.400 MY WORLD, IF YOU ARE CORRECT,

01:26 - 25.810 OKAY, WELL, THEY ARE IF I MAY.

01:26 - 29.100 >>FOOTNOTE FOR JUSTICE. WHEN

01:26 - 31.760 YOU'RE KIND THANK YOU AND SHE

01:26 - 32.170 NEVER.

01:26 - 38.530 PEOPLE ALREADY MADE CLEAR WHAT

01:26 - 41.490 THE TESTS IT'S. AND IT

01:26 - 44.000 WAS NOT SIGNATURE THAT'S ALL

01:26 - 46.460 I'M SAYING AND IMMEDIATELY DID

01:26 - 48.460 IN THE CASE IN A

01:26 - 56.240 THANK YOU VERY MUCH, I GOT IT.

01:26 - 57.680 THANK YOU. MISTER

01:26 - 00.680 WE'RE FROM THE COMMONWEALTH.

01:27 - 08.900 THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO

01:27 - 10.900 PRESENT A DEFENSE THAT RIGHT IS

01:27 - 13.210 NOT ABSOLUTE. THE U.S. SUPREME

01:27 - 14.360 COURT HAS RECOGNIZED THAT THE

01:27 - 16.020 CONSTITUTION PERMITS JUDGES TO

01:27 - 17.150 EXCLUDE EVIDENCE THAT IS

01:27 - 17.670 REPETITIVE.

01:27 - 19.530 >>OR MARGINALLY RELEVANT.

01:27 - 21.410 THE DEFENDANTS FUNDAMENTAL

01:27 - 23.030 RIGHT RESENTMENT IS NOT A RIGHT

01:27 - 24.400 TO PRESENT ANY EVIDENCE THERE

01:27 - 26.620 IS LIMITS THE QUESTION THIS

01:27 - 27.940 CASE IS WHAT THOSE LIMITS ARE

01:27 - 29.330 LIVE IN IS CLAIMING SOMEONE

01:27 - 30.410 ELSE COMMITTED THE CRIME.

01:27 - 32.370 THE COMMONWEALTH BEGINS WITH

01:27 - 35.010 THE RULE. COOL FORCES

01:27 - 36.820 THAT GENERAL EVIDENCE OF

01:27 - 38.180 SOMEONE ELSE'S CRIME OR BAD

01:27 - 39.400 ACTIONS, NOT ADMISSIBLE TO

01:27 - 40.700 PROVE THEIR CHARACTER ORDER TO

01:27 - 41.980 SHOW THEY ACTED IN ACCORDANCE

01:27 - 42.290 FACT

01:27 - 44.310 CHARACTER TRAIT HOWEVER IF THE

01:27 - 45.540 CRIME OR BAD ACTORS BEING

01:27 - 47.010 PROFFERED TO PROVE MOTIVE WERE

01:27 - 48.730 COMMON PLAN OR SIGNATURE CRIME

01:27 - 50.070 IT MAY BE ADMISSIBLE

01:27 - 52.330 INTERESTINGLY THE RULE STATES

01:27 - 53.480 ONLY ONE STANDARD

01:27 - 55.290 FOR ADMISSIBILITY IT DOES NOT

01:27 - 56.400 PROVIDE A DIFFERENT STANDARD

01:27 - 58.060 BASED ON HE IS PROFFERING THE

01:27 - 59.700 EVIDENCE IF THAT IS WHAT THE

01:27 - 00.910 DEFENDANT IS ASKING FOR.

01:28 - 03.290 THE COMMONWEALTH SUMMIT IN ITS

01:28 - 04.880 REQUESTS TO ESTABLISH A

01:28 - 06.250 DIFFERENT STANDARD IS WRONG.

01:28 - 08.440 THE CALM ALSO MEANT THERE'S NO

01:28 - 10.460 SUCH THING AS REVERSE FOR BE

01:28 - 12.800 EVIDENCE IT IS SIMPLY FOR BE OF

01:28 - 14.360 THIS THAT IS HOW THE RULES

01:28 - 16.060 WRITTEN SUCH EVIDENCE IS

01:28 - 16.970 ADMISSIBLE IF IT IS

01:28 - 17.650 ESTABLISHED.

01:28 - 19.770 THAT ONE OF THE EXCEPTIONS TO

01:28 - 21.690 THE GENERAL RULED ADMISSIBLE IN

01:28 - 23.290 ADMISSIBILITY APPLIES IN THIS

01:28 - 24.680 CASE, IT IS THE COMMON PLAN OR

01:28 - 25.150 SIGNATURE

01:28 - 27.320 CRIME EXCEPTION. THAT EXCEPTION

01:28 - 28.640 REQUIRES OFFERING PARTY TO

01:28 - 30.110 PROVE SUFFICIENT SIMILARITIES

01:28 - 30.510 BETWEEN THE

01:28 - 32.440 ALLEGED CRIME, ANOTHER BAD ACTS

01:28 - 33.720 TO BE SO SIMILAR TO BE A

01:28 - 35.620 SIGNATURE CRIME. THE DEFENDANT

01:28 - 36.730 SAYS THAT IS A STANDARD THAT

01:28 - 38.350 VIOLATES THE RIGHT TO ASIANS OF

01:28 - 40.270 RAISING DEFENSE. HOW ARE THE

01:28 - 41.560 U.S. SUPREME COURT SAYS A DUE

01:28 - 43.110 PROCESS CLAUSE ALLOWS SOME

01:28 - 44.040 LIMITS ON THE RIGHT IS

01:28 - 45.970 AN EVIDENCE IT'S A GOOD JUMP

01:28 - 47.660 BIG NIGHT TOGETHER THEY

01:28 - 48.380 CERTAINLY ARE.

01:28 - 49.250 >>THE TIME.

01:28 - 57.030 PRIME STANDARD, IF YOU WANT US

01:28 - 58.050 TO USE.

01:29 - 02.970 A LINE OF CASES, THE SUPERIOR

01:29 - 04.660 COURT DEVELOP OR

01:29 - 07.750 4 OR THE CASES.

01:29 - 11.300 WHY DOES

01:29 - 13.120 4 OH 04:00PM IN THE

01:29 - 15.980 APPLICATION. TO.

01:29 - 19.220 >>A CASE LIKE THIS. I WORRY,

01:29 - 21.160 GAYLE IS TRYING TO GET IN.

01:29 - 26.560 >>LOOKING AT 4 OR B.

01:29 - 34.530 THE PROPENSITY SUGGESTION THE

01:29 - 36.870 CARER THEIR SUGGESTION. WHY ARE

01:29 - 38.100 WE HEAR ANYTHING

01:29 - 40.470 ABOUT MISTER THOMPSON'S

01:29 - 42.080 PROPENSITY OR CHARACTER HAS

01:29 - 43.780 NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS CASE

01:29 - 47.360 SUCH SUGGESTING THE 4 WERE KEY

01:29 - 49.090 IS A COMPLETE RED HERRING YOU

01:29 - 51.570 FOLLOW MY YOU'VE ALL MY MY IN

01:29 - 53.560 OTHER WORDS, THIS IS NOT THE

01:29 - 55.660 EVIDENCE OF MR. YALE'S THERE.

01:29 - 58.270 MR. GALE PROPENSITY WHICH IS

01:29 - 59.820 THE CONCERN OF FOUR-FOUR BEAT.

01:30 - 03.030 TRYING TO CRAM BEFORE THE

01:30 - 05.150 PARADIGM WATCHING THIS CASE

01:30 - 06.120 SEEMS

01:30 - 08.390 ILL FITTING. GIVEN THAT WE ARE

01:30 - 10.000 WE DON'T CARE AT ALL ABOUT 3RD

01:30 - 11.850 PARTIES ABOUT MISTER THOMPSON

01:30 - 13.190 OR ANY OTHER.

01:30 - 17.410 WE WANT TO SAY.

01:30 - 20.910 COMMITTED THIS CRIME WERE COULD

01:30 - 22.050 HAVE COMMITTED THIS CRIME.

01:30 - 25.090 >>WHERE WOULD I WOULD SAY IS

01:30 - 27.220 THAT FOR BE CLEARLY THE

01:30 - 30.100 DEALS WITH EVIDENCE OF PRIOR

01:30 - 32.110 CRIMES WRONG OR OTHER ACTS.

01:30 - 34.080 SO MISTER GALE WAS TRYING TO

01:30 - 36.690 INTRODUCE SOMEONE ELSE'S.

01:30 - 38.870 >>PRIOR CRIME OR PRIOR BAD ACT.

01:30 - 41.370 >>SO RULE FOR BE DOES APPLY.

01:30 - 48.670 >>THAT MISTER THOMPSON ACTED IN

01:30 - 49.620 ACCORDANCE.

01:30 - 53.140 THE TOSS

01:30 - 55.500 AND PROPENSITY TO ENGAGE IN

01:30 - 57.500 BAD ACTS IT IS WHOLLY

01:30 - 59.110 IMMATERIAL AND ARE RELEVANT TO

01:30 - 00.590 A CASE AGAINST MISTER YALE

01:31 - 01.230 ISN'T IT.

01:31 - 03.500 >>WELL THEN WHY IS MISTER YO

01:31 - 05.290 INTRODUCING ITS NOT RELEVANT.

01:31 - 07.460 IT'S NOT RELEVANT. IN A BIG

01:31 - 07.760 DEAL.

01:31 - 12.590 >>IN A GATE IS YOU KNOW ISN'T

01:31 - 14.670 THAT WHAT THE THE HOLMES CASE

01:31 - 17.860 THE MR. STEIN WAS DISCUSSING.

01:31 - 20.230 I WOULD SUGGEST IF YOU ARRIVE

01:31 - 21.350 AND THE BODY IS CHARGED WITH A

01:31 - 24.050 CRIME. IT'S OBVIOUSLY HIGHLY

01:31 - 25.650 RELEVANT IF WE CAN PRESENT

01:31 - 27.620 EVIDENCE IF MISTER SMITH OR

01:31 - 29.700 MISTER JONES IT WAS ACTUALLY

01:31 - 32.020 THE PERSON WHO COMMIT THE CRIME

01:31 - 32.670 THE LAW HAS

01:31 - 34.990 NO CONCERN ABOUT WHETHER WHAT

01:31 - 36.460 HE SAYS ABOUT MISTER SMITH'S

01:31 - 38.280 FOR MISTER JONES CHARACTER IS

01:31 - 39.620 THE JURY IS NOT WAITING.

01:31 - 44.570 >>NO THE JURY IS NOT WEIGHING

01:31 - 45.800 THEIR CHARACTER TO PREJUDICE

01:31 - 47.640 THE JURY IS STILL DECIDING

01:31 - 50.240 WHETHER OR NOT. SOMEONE ELSE

01:31 - 51.070 IS ALLEGED

01:31 - 52.460 CRIME OR BAD ACTS IS

01:31 - 54.040 SUFFICIENTLY SIMILAR TO SAY

01:31 - 55.880 THAT MISTER YELL ISSUES MISTER

01:31 - 57.750 YELL COMMITTED THIS CRIME,

01:31 - 59.560 IT'S NOT ENOUGH TO SAY THAT

01:31 - 00.990 THERE WERE 4 OTHER BURGLARIES

01:32 - 02.550 IN THE JURISDICTION YESTERDAY

01:32 - 04.200 ON THE SAME DAY, I'M IT USED A

01:32 - 06.260 CHIMNEY MY BURGLARY. WHAT'S

01:32 - 07.420 REALLY BEEN ABOUT JUST FOR

01:32 - 09.810 OTHER BURGLARIES GENERICALLY.

01:32 - 11.520 >>THIS ONE MORE JUST ONE MORE

01:32 - 12.410 QUESTION ON THAT.

01:32 - 14.830 IT WOULD CERTAINLY KNOWLEDGE

01:32 - 16.770 WITH YOU NOT TO BE THE

01:32 - 18.400 EVIDENTIARY HER TO GET TO THE

01:32 - 19.350 FACT FINDER.

01:32 - 21.850 >>FOR ONE RELEVANT IS IS

01:32 - 23.210 CONSIDERABLY LOWER.

01:32 - 25.130 >>THEY'RE NOT IT'S BEEN SET UP

01:32 - 26.230 BY HIS PEERS, THE COURT AND

01:32 - 28.760 OTHER COURTS, THE 4 '04 P

01:32 - 32.010 SIGNATURE, CRIME EVIDENCE WOULD

01:32 - 32.580 YOU AGREE WITH THAT.

01:32 - 34.990 >>I WOULD AGREE WITH THAT JUDGE

01:32 - 36.440 THERE YOUR HONOR AND I WOULD I

01:32 - 37.060 WOULD SAY THAT

01:32 - 39.740 FOR ONE IS THE GENERAL RELEVANT

01:32 - 41.950 RULE AND YOU WORK FROM AS EVERY

01:32 - 43.580 LAW STUDENT IS CAUGHT FROM

01:32 - 45.490 GENERAL TO SPECIFIC. SO WE'RE

01:32 - 46.900 DEALING WITH THE SPECIFIC

01:32 - 48.710 TYPE OF EVIDENCE SUCH AS A

01:32 - 50.410 PRIOR CRIME OR PRIOR BAD ACT.

01:32 - 52.880 YOU LOOK TO FOR BE BECAUSE THAT

01:32 - 54.720 DEALS WITH DEMIS ABILITY OF

01:32 - 56.780 THAT TYPE OF EVIDENCE SO

01:32 - 58.430 THE DEFENDANT WHETHER IT'S

01:32 - 59.790 MISTER YES, MISTER SMITH AND

01:32 - 02.050 MISTER JONES NEEDS TO SHOW

01:33 - 03.900 SOMETHING MORE THAN JUST WELL

01:33 - 06.320 THERE WAS 2 OTHER JURISDICTION

01:33 - 06.930 LAST NIGHT.

01:33 - 09.000 ON THE DAY I WASN'T TOO SO IT

01:33 - 10.860 MUST NOT BE ME, I'M INNOCENT

01:33 - 13.430 THAT IS THAT WAS BIG, BUT YOU

01:33 - 13.560 LOOK

01:33 - 15.590 >>ONE THING WE GET TO CALAIS

01:33 - 17.070 IT'S NOT MISTER HARBERT AS

01:33 - 18.370 EVERYBODY KNOWS HE'S GUILTY.

01:33 - 22.590 >>COUNCIL

01:33 - 24.220 GOT THERE I.

01:33 - 27.600 BUT I'M NOT ASSUMING THAT YOUR

01:33 - 30.090 CLIENT OF THE COMMONWEALTH, WE

01:33 - 32.330 SHOULD GAZA THAT'S AN

01:33 - 33.690 APPLICATION THE FACTS OF THE

01:33 - 36.000 CASE, I'M INTERESTED IN WHAT

01:33 - 39.380 YOU THINK THE TEST THE COUPLE

01:33 - 40.540 SAYS THAT THEY WOULD BE.

01:33 - 42.870 >>I'M SATISFIED WITH THAT

01:33 - 44.470 WE'RE GOING TO GO AWAY FOR A

01:33 - 46.410 SIGNATURE CRIME HIGH PEOPLE

01:33 - 48.910 SUMMER. WITH WITH WHAT I

01:33 - 50.850 SUGGESTED TO MISTER EPSTEIN

01:33 - 52.770 WHICH HE SAID IT WAS OKAY WITH.

01:33 - 53.740 IS

01:33 - 56.300 SUFFICIENTLY SIMILAR HAS TO BE

01:33 - 58.040 RELEVANT. WHAT YOU THINK IN

01:33 - 58.700 THAT SENSE.

01:34 - 02.560 >>QUITE HONESTLY, YOUR HONOR.

01:34 - 06.240 I THINK IT'S A LITTLE LOVE A

01:34 - 06.970 POLL, ONE

01:34 - 09.130 OF 2. ONE OF MY POSITIONS AND

01:34 - 10.520 THERE'S I THINK IN THE SENATE

01:34 - 11.730 FOR MY BRIEF IS.

01:34 - 14.310 SOMETIMES

01:34 - 15.980 DEFENDANTS USED THE DUE PROCESS

01:34 - 17.690 CLAUSE AS US WORK TO TRY TO

01:34 - 19.760 AVOID GENERALLY APPLICABLE

01:34 - 20.690 RULES TO EVERYBODY.

01:34 - 22.960 >>ALL WE KNOW WE UNDERSTAND IT.

01:34 - 24.790 >>THE RULE SHOULD BE THE SAME

01:34 - 26.030 FOR WHETHER THE COMMONWEALTH IS

01:34 - 26.370 ADMITTING

01:34 - 28.610 THE EVIDENCE OR THE DEFENDANT

01:34 - 29.880 IS ADMITTING YOU HAVE TO COME

01:34 - 31.100 WILL SUBMITS TO THE MAIN

01:34 - 32.540 PURPOSE OF THE MAIN DIFFERENCE

01:34 - 34.320 COULD BE THE AMOUNT OF PURCHASE

01:34 - 36.310 OBVIOUSLY THIS TYPE OF EVIDENCE

01:34 - 37.790 TO BE VERY PREJUDICIAL TO THE

01:34 - 38.320 DEFENDANT.

01:34 - 40.800 AND JUST AS REP INDICATED IF

01:34 - 41.160 IT'S A

01:34 - 43.810 3RD PERSON THAT REPORT THAT

01:34 - 45.970 REVVING JERRY TO THAT PERSON.

01:34 - 47.720 BUT THERE'S STILL A COMMON IS

01:34 - 48.940 STILL A QUESTION OF PREJUDICE

01:34 - 50.180 TO THE COMMONWEALTH WHICH MAY

01:34 - 50.850 BE A DIFFERENCE

01:34 - 53.570 IN DEGREE BUT NOT AND SAID NO

01:34 - 55.310 BUT NOT IN WHAT TYPE OF

01:34 - 56.540 EVIDENCE SHOULD BE ADMISSIBLE

01:34 - 59.140 TO THE JURY ONCE YOU GET PAST

01:34 - 59.760 THE SIGNATURE.

01:35 - 01.780 ALL RIGHT IS IT THEN TO

01:35 - 02.630 PREJUDICE WILL FOR THE

01:35 - 03.850 COMMONWEALTH WILL BECOME WILL

01:35 - 05.070 BE ABLE TO REACH COMPLETION TO

01:35 - 08.120 REBUT THAT EVIDENCE TRUE OR NOT

01:35 - 09.950 IS IT TOO PREJUDICIAL IN THAT

01:35 - 11.950 SENSE AND AGAIN TO GO BACK JUST

01:35 - 14.070 TO SAY WELL THERE WAS A I READ

01:35 - 15.480 THE OTHER NIGHT, THE SAME NIGHT

01:35 - 16.550 I COMMITTED THE ROBBERY.

01:35 - 19.260 THAT REALLY DOESN'T HOW AWESOME

01:35 - 20.590 IT DOESN'T EVEN GET TO THAT

01:35 - 24.380 THE GENERAL MOVEMENTS WELL I

01:35 - 26.050 THINK ARGUABLY THAT WOODS.

01:35 - 27.050 >>NOT BE RELEVANT.

01:35 - 27.820 BUT AGAIN.

01:35 - 29.840 >>WHO YOU GONNA CALL YOU REALLY

01:35 - 31.340 KNOW THE APPLICATION LOOKING

01:35 - 33.080 BETTER SUITED TO TRIAL.

01:35 - 36.770 IT WILL GET OUT OF THIS

01:35 - 38.930 THE CREATIVE THINKING OUT LOUD

01:35 - 41.400 IF WE HAD THEY WILL COME

01:35 - 44.530 OR 2. YOU CAN CALL IT IN

01:35 - 48.300 THE PAST. IF ONLY YOU AT THIS

01:35 - 50.770 MOMENT IN TIME FOR A SET OF 5.

01:35 - 52.150 >>A

01:35 - 55.500 IN PREJUDICE IS ALREADY IN THE

01:35 - 55.930 ROOM.

01:35 - 58.550 IF YOU'RE IN DOES IN A CRIMINAL

01:35 - 59.540 CASE THIS EVIDENCE IS

01:35 - 01.060 ADMISSIBLE ONLY OF THE PROBLEM

01:36 - 05.130 SEPARATE. SO THAT'S ALREADY

01:36 - 07.020 PART OF THE TESTS THIS IS WHAT

01:36 - 08.540 WE'RE QUIBBLING OF OUR HERE IS.

01:36 - 14.140 WHEN IS

01:36 - 15.990 THE EVIDENCE A SUFFICIENT

01:36 - 17.770 ENOUGH TO EVEN GET TO THE JURY

01:36 - 19.280 OR BE IN A DEAL TO THEM.

01:36 - 21.850 PART OF THE PRESIDENT. AND

01:36 - 25.560 AGAIN AS I SAID. ASK

01:36 - 27.390 YOU THERE THE 2 AS

01:36 - 29.000 I SAID THERE HAS TO BE MORE

01:36 - 30.020 THAN JUST WELL THERE WAS

01:36 - 32.470 ANOTHER ROBBERY LAST NIGHT AND

01:36 - 33.210 EVEN IN.

01:36 - 35.830 MCGOWAN I THINK THE MAIN ISSUE

01:36 - 37.000 THERE WAS THE DEFENDANT WAS

01:36 - 38.750 MISSED IDENTIFIED NOT SO MUCH

01:36 - 39.760 THAT THE QUESTION WAS THERE

01:36 - 41.280 WERE OTHER CRIMES AT DEALERS.

01:36 - 43.620 THE MAIN ISSUE WAS A

01:36 - 45.620 MISIDENTIFICATION AND IN THE

01:36 - 47.510 HOLMES CASE, HOW MOST OF ITS

01:36 - 50.040 DEBT. THE SUPREME COURT QUOTED

01:36 - 51.580 WITH APPROVAL. THE GRAND

01:36 - 53.400 JURY CASE WHERE THE GREGORY

01:36 - 54.850 CASE FROM SOUTH CAROLINA SAID

01:36 - 55.300 THERE NEEDS

01:36 - 57.410 TO BE. SO THE TRADE WORKS OR

01:36 - 59.480 CIRCUMSTANCES AS 10'S CLEARLY

01:36 - 01.680 TO POINT OUT SUCH OTHER PERSON

01:37 - 02.670 IS THE GUILTY PARTY.

01:37 - 04.940 SO THERE NEEDS TO BE MORE THAN

01:37 - 06.460 JUST WELL IT'S A BURGLARY.

01:37 - 08.880 WHAT ABOUT THE BIRD. AND AGAIN

01:37 - 11.170 IS AS YOU SUGGESTED, AND YOUR

01:37 - 12.470 HONOR IT MIGHT BE

01:37 - 13.490 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE

01:37 - 15.140 APPLICATION IN THE TRIAL COURT

01:37 - 16.370 BUT THERE NEEDS TO BE SOME.

01:37 - 18.750 THE SIMILARITIES TO THE CRIME

01:37 - 20.910 PROBLEM SUMMIT TO BE THE SAME.

01:37 - 22.590 THE SIGNATURE CRIME.

01:37 - 25.200 >>SO I ASK YOU A FOLLOW-UP ON

01:37 - 27.210 THAT YOU MENTIONED THE RESPONSE

01:37 - 29.590 TO ONE OF MY COLLEAGUES, IT IS

01:37 - 32.790 EVIDENCE. MISTER YALE OR A.

01:37 - 35.960 I MEAN SOME

01:37 - 38.260 OTHER CASE. WOULD BE OFFERED AS

01:37 - 40.170 A SHIELD I THOUGHT THAT WAS I'M

01:37 - 41.480 SORRY IS SORT OF THOUGHT THAT

01:37 - 41.610 WAS

01:37 - 44.030 INTERESTING BECAUSE THE SECOND

01:37 - 46.480 CIRCUIT IN THE MUSLIM CASE.

01:37 - 48.390 ACCORDING TO THE WITH MORE BY

01:37 - 51.360 THE WAY. SAID WELL WE BELIEVE

01:37 - 52.750 THE STANDARD OF THE DISABILITY

01:37 - 52.960 WHEN A

01:37 - 54.820 CRIMINAL DEFENDANT. OFFER

01:37 - 56.600 SIMILAR ACTS OF EVIDENCE AS

01:37 - 58.700 A SHIELD NEED NOT BE AS

01:37 - 59.920 RESTRICTIVE AS WHEN A

01:37 - 02.030 PROSECUTOR USES SUCH EVIDENCE

01:38 - 04.420 AS THEY SOAR. ISN'T

01:38 - 06.300 THIS CASE. ONE IN

01:38 - 08.370 WHICH MISTER YALE IS SEEKING TO

01:38 - 09.780 USE THE EVIDENCE OF MR.

01:38 - 11.820 THOMPSON'S BAD ACTS AS

01:38 - 14.070 A SWORD FOR THE DEFENSE OF

01:38 - 15.930 MISTER GALE IN THIS CASE RATHER

01:38 - 17.780 THAN THE 4 '04

01:38 - 19.070 BIG CASES WHERE THE

01:38 - 20.700 COMMONWEALTH SEEKS TO USE THE

01:38 - 22.520 FORUM FOR THE EVIDENCE IS A

01:38 - 24.440 SWORD AGAINST THE DEFENDANT

01:38 - 25.370 BEING PROSECUTED.

01:38 - 28.910 >>I WOULD SAY YES, BUT

01:38 - 30.240 MISTER YELLS USING IT AS A

01:38 - 31.760 SWORD AGAINST THE COMMONWEALTH.

01:38 - 33.740 TO CLAIM THE COMMONWEALTH IS

01:38 - 36.150 NOT TERRY DITTES BURDEN OR 2

01:38 - 38.040 POINT BLAME TO SOMEONE ELSE FOR

01:38 - 39.430 THAT. A JURY TO FIND A

01:38 - 40.540 REASONABLE DOUBT AND MISTER

01:38 - 44.040 YELLS GUILT. INTO

01:38 - 45.790 TO MIR. QUITE HONESTLY, DON'T

01:38 - 47.400 KNOW SEEMS TO BE A DIFFERENCE.

01:38 - 48.690 A DISTINCTION WITHOUT A

01:38 - 50.770 DIFFERENCE. MISTER YELL STILL

01:38 - 52.950 USING EVIDENCE TO COMBAT

01:38 - 54.940 THE COMMONWEALTH'S PRESENTATION

01:38 - 56.250 OF EVIDENCE IN THE EVIDENCE

01:38 - 58.260 AGAINST HIM AND THERE MUST BE

01:38 - 00.370 SOME LEVEL OF SIMILARITY IT

01:39 - 01.530 GIVES THE JURY SOMETHING TO

01:39 - 02.480 HANG THEIR HAT ON.

01:39 - 04.880 AND JUST TO SAY WELL IT'S THE

01:39 - 06.680 SAME ONE HOT MESS AND WELL ONE

01:39 - 07.890 PART MESSAGES LIKE BAKING A

01:39 - 09.260 CAKE. ALL THAT

01:39 - 10.950 INGREDIENTS OF THE CAKE GOING

01:39 - 12.200 ALL THE INGREDIENTS OF THE ONE

01:39 - 14.550 MESSAGE GOING. AND LEST YOU

01:39 - 15.610 KNOW JUST LIKE MANY OF OUR

01:39 - 16.630 GRANDMOTHERS MAY HAVE HAD

01:39 - 18.130 THAT'S SECRET INGREDIENT IN THE

01:39 - 19.700 CAKE TO MAKE THINGS BETTER THEN

01:39 - 23.040 AND JAMES. MAKING A CAKE BAKING

01:39 - 24.690 A CAKE MAKING A MESS OF MAKING

01:39 - 26.060 A MESS IF YOU'RE USING THE ONE

01:39 - 27.100 PART MESSAGE. SO THERE WAS

01:39 - 29.200 REALLY NOTHING ALL THAT SIMILAR

01:39 - 30.210 IN THIS CASE.

01:39 - 33.070 EAR SO THE TRUMP-KIM ON YOU.

01:39 - 37.350 WE CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND YOUR

01:39 - 38.140 ARGUMENT. OK.

01:39 - 45.620 WE HAVE

01:39 - 47.520 THE CASE SURE ANY OTHER

01:39 - 48.400 QUESTIONS.

01:39 - 56.220 >>IF ALL THANK YOU, THANK YOU

01:39 - 57.860 OPT IN. WE'RE

01:39 - 00.940 GOING TO THE RECESS UNTIL 1

01:40 - 02.220 O'CLOCK WE'RE GOING TO TRY TO

01:40 - 02.710 HAVE THAT.

01:40 - 04.900 COUNSEL FOR THE NEXT DAY

01:40 - 07.470 TRADING AT 1 O'CLOCK THE AND

01:40 - 08.930 WITH THAT WILL HER BREAK.

01:40 - 10.570 >>THANK YOU YOUR HONORS.

01:40 - 15.150 THIS WEEK ON

01:40 - 16.260 PA BOOKS.

01:40 - 17.730 >>THIS AND THE LIBERTY OF THE

01:40 - 20.270 COUNTRY FAMILY. WHAT MADE IT

01:40 - 22.430 SPECIAL TO QUOTE FROM HIM THEY

01:40 - 23.540 GO TO THE CONVENTION WITH

01:40 - 25.590 GOLDEN EAGLE. BECAUSE THEY KNEW

01:40 - 26.820 THAT THE OTHER KINDS OF PEOPLE

01:40 - 28.320 WHEN THEY COME IN WE'RE ALL

01:40 - 29.660 GOING TO BE. WELL THE

01:40 - 32.010 YEAR BEFORE IT WOULDN'T PAY HIS

01:40 - 35.110 IDEAS ANY. LET ME LOOK MORE

01:40 - 35.610 LIKE.

01:40 - 38.310 >>TOM JACKMAN AUTHOR OF THE

01:40 - 40.590 FOUNDING FORTUNES, SUNDAY AT

01:40 - 41.470 07:00PM.

01:40 - 44.780 >>THE NEXT

01:40 - 47.390 MATTER IS RASHEENA A SOLUTION.

01:40 - 50.570 THESE PEOPLE. REPRESENTATIVE.

01:40 - 54.080 SHE'S GOT SOME IS ROBERT

01:40 - 56.460 AZLE I'M REPRESENTING MURRAY'S

01:40 - 58.300 EAGLE IS JUST A WHOLE MAYORS.

01:41 - 03.730 >>AND FOR SEVERAL DAYS.

01:41 - 06.770 THE FINDINGS SHE ACTION WHICH

01:41 - 07.770 PLAN YOU.

01:41 - 09.820 >>THE RISING FROM THE VOTERS.

01:41 - 13.480 HOWEVER THE DEFENDANT COULD NOT

01:41 - 15.550 BE LOCATED AND NOTIFIED WITHIN

01:41 - 16.970 THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.

01:41 - 21.460 THE CASE WITH. THE CRASH.

01:41 - 22.270 THE FORMAT.

01:41 - 27.440 THE GROUND WITH THE PLAYERS

01:41 - 29.160 AFTER NOTIFY THE DEFENDANT.

01:41 - 57.820 >>TURNING

01:41 - 01.480 SENIOR EVERYONE I'M SEEING HERE

01:42 - 02.480 WHEN THERE IS SOME

01:42 - 04.880 BACKGROUND NOISE. I JUST SHOT

01:42 - 06.860 IT AND I KNOW A LITTLE TROUBLE

01:42 - 10.610 HEARING. SHE JUSTICE BUT I

01:42 - 11.530 CAN'T HEAR US.

01:42 - 12.940 >>WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO RESTATE

01:42 - 13.630 THE CASE.

01:42 - 18.880 >>I HEARD IT WAS CORRECT.

01:42 - 19.320 YES, SIR.

01:42 - 24.010 WITH THAT YOU OPEN YOUR

01:42 - 24.520 ARGUMENT.

01:42 - 28.910 IT PLEASE THE COURT.

01:42 - 31.840 THIS MATTER COMES BEFORE YOU A

01:42 - 33.750 RESULT OF THIS OF COURSE THERE

01:42 - 35.120 ARE GUNS FROM THIS

01:42 - 37.200 COURT'S PRECEDENT SPECIFICALLY

01:42 - 39.130 ON THE ISSUE SERVICE OF PROCESS

01:42 - 39.950 HAS RELEASED A

01:42 - 41.940 IT CONSTITUTES IT COULD SAVE

01:42 - 43.500 TIME AND EFFORT TO SERVE A

01:42 - 43.980 COMPLAINT.

01:42 - 48.280 IT'S A WAY TO SAFELY

01:42 - 50.080 CONSTITUTES GOOD FAITH EFFORT

01:42 - 51.560 TO SEXUALLY SERVICE.

01:42 - 53.790 THEIR LAP IN THE FRONT HE

01:42 - 55.630 BURIED IN THE CREASE THIS COURT

01:42 - 57.260 HAS ESTABLISHED PRESIDENT

01:42 - 59.370 CURRENTLY GOVERNS WE CONDUCT

01:42 - 00.620 CONSTITUTES A GOOD FAITH

01:43 - 02.730 EFFORTS REALLY THE SERVICE

01:43 - 05.430 OF PROCESS INACTION IS NOT THE

01:43 - 06.790 CREEK TO INTENSE.

01:43 - 08.400 IN SEVERAL RECENT

01:43 - 10.360 DECISIONS INCLUDING A MATTER OF

01:43 - 11.760 YOUR YOUR CORE WORK TO

01:43 - 13.010 UNDERMINE THE SPIRIT AND

01:43 - 13.620 PURPOSE OF THIS

01:43 - 15.830 COURT'S PRECEDENT THE POLLING,

01:43 - 17.480 NON-TRADITIONAL MISSTEPS

01:43 - 19.150 AMOUNTS WE SHOULD CONDUCT

01:43 - 21.320 INSTALL THE FISHERY THE

01:43 - 22.350 JUDICIAL MACHINERY.

01:43 - 25.860 IT CREATES SOME GREAT LINES

01:43 - 26.350 PASS.

01:43 - 29.310 SOMEHOW DISAPPEAR COURT RANIYA

01:43 - 30.970 RELY ON IN THE MEDIA.

01:43 - 33.540 WE'RE CITIZENS WE'RE TOLD THAT

01:43 - 35.520 AN INTENTIONAL CONDUCT FILM A

01:43 - 36.460 DEFENDANT KNOWS

01:43 - 39.290 CLAIM CONSTITUTE A LACK OF GOOD

01:43 - 41.400 FAITH ESPECIALLY SERVICE.

01:43 - 44.540 IN THOSE MATTERS. THIS CASE

01:43 - 46.170 DISAPPEAR COURT, PARTLY

01:43 - 46.780 UNDERMINES

01:43 - 48.940 ESTABLISH PRECEDENT THE LAST

01:43 - 50.620 LINE OF CASES CLEARLY STANDS

01:43 - 51.510 FOR THE PROPOSITION

01:43 - 53.620 THAT MISTAKE. AN INTENTIONAL

01:43 - 55.190 CONDUCT DOES NOT RISE TO THE

01:43 - 57.640 LEVEL THAT HAS STALLED JUDICIAL

01:43 - 58.230 MACHINERY.

01:44 - 02.600 SEVERAL BIG FAITH EFFORT TO

01:44 - 03.150 SERVE

01:44 - 05.520 YOU KELLY, AND NO WAY BACK IN

01:44 - 06.850 ANY MATTER THAT INTENDED

01:44 - 09.080 TO STALL INITIAL MACHINE RING

01:44 - 10.910 OR DENY NOTICE OF CLAIM.

01:44 - 14.050 THE SUPERIOR COURT IN THE 5TH.

01:44 - 15.460 WE FLY THE

01:44 - 18.150 COURTS UNDER. IT RAN FROM THE

01:44 - 19.450 HEAT AND THE CREASE REAMY

01:44 - 22.010 PRESIDENTIAL CLEARLY HOLD NO

01:44 - 23.810 LIGHT NO BRIGHT LINE TEST THAT

01:44 - 26.040 EXISTS FOR A GOOD FAITH EFFORT

01:44 - 27.540 TO SPECIALLY SERVICE

01:44 - 29.750 RATHER SIMPLY A PARTY MUST ACT

01:44 - 32.140 IN GOOD FAITH NOT TO ATTEND TO

01:44 - 34.330 START TO GET FROM HERE. THEY'RE

01:44 - 35.920 SUING THE LAMP AND FROGGY.

01:44 - 38.830 RESPECTFULLY REQUEST, A

01:44 - 40.750 DESIRABLE COURT KIND YOU DON'T

01:44 - 42.450 NEED A GOOD FAITH EFFORT TO

01:44 - 44.170 SERVE IN A TIMELY FASHION.

01:44 - 46.490 AND CREAM AND THE SNOW.

01:44 - 53.090 JUST SIT THERE.

01:44 - 57.960 FIRST THE PHILADELPHIA ON THE

01:44 - 58.860 COURT. YEAH.

01:44 - 01.520 IN PREPARING FOR THIS CASE, I'M

01:45 - 02.930 NOT CONVINCED THAT I DID NOT

01:45 - 03.270 MAKE THEM.

01:45 - 06.920 >>WHICH I MADE THE RIGHT

01:45 - 07.420 CORRECT.

01:45 - 11.360 IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THIS IS

01:45 - 13.230 NO QUESTION INLAND FROM THE

01:45 - 15.210 PROTEIN ME IF YOUR BIRD.

01:45 - 22.240 IS THAT THERE WAS NO INTENT FOR

01:45 - 24.520 THE DELAY OR THE LIKE. IF YOU

01:45 - 25.220 AGREE WITH THAT.

01:45 - 31.380 IT SEEMS TO ME TO BE SOMEWHAT

01:45 - 33.750 CONNOR TO DO THE HEAD YOU

01:45 - 35.870 PROVING A NEGATIVE THAT YEAR

01:45 - 38.420 COOL THERE WAS NO IN 10 THE

01:45 - 40.670 MORE THEY PLAY THAT WAS

01:45 - 43.350 THE CRITERIA. IT WOULD FALL ON

01:45 - 45.380 THE DEFENDANT PROVE THAT YOU

01:45 - 46.910 INTENDED TO DELAY OR THE LIKE.

01:45 - 48.510 AND NUMBER ONE

01:45 - 50.740 NUMBER WELL, LET ME WELL, NO

01:45 - 52.640 AND NUMBER 2 IN THE MEDIA

01:45 - 54.070 CRITIC WITH ARGUABLY

01:45 - 55.450 INCONSISTENT WITH THE LAND.

01:45 - 57.090 THE DIARY OF ANNE.

01:45 - 01.410 THE GREAT KID TO BE WHO YOU

01:46 - 03.340 BELIEVE THAT WE CAN SERVE.

01:46 - 05.970 IF THE BILL WILL LEAVE THEM

01:46 - 06.770 THERE THEN.

01:46 - 09.940 MAYBE THE IMPORTANT CORLEYYOU

01:46 - 11.200 CORLEY YOU KNOW.

01:46 - 15.200 IN KENT BY ANY OF THAT I THINK

01:46 - 16.360 IT WOULD BE THE BEST SO

01:46 - 16.940 QUICKLY.

01:46 - 19.480 IT MAKES SENSE TO YOU THAT YOU

01:46 - 20.690 HAVE THE BURDEN OF PROVING THE

01:46 - 22.190 NEGATIVE BEFORE THAT WE CAN

01:46 - 24.280 DELAY SECONDLY IN THE CRAIG

01:46 - 25.820 COOLEY AND BE DILIGENT. THE

01:46 - 26.530 CAMPUS ARE.

01:46 - 36.170 >>JUST TO RESPOND HERE FIRST

01:46 - 37.170 FOR YOUR QUESTION.

01:46 - 40.620 IT SHOULD BE THAT THE THAT THE

01:46 - 40.960 YEAR.

01:46 - 45.600 THE L A SHOULD HAVE THE BIRD

01:46 - 48.370 CREW TO SHOW THAT WE DID NOT

01:46 - 50.300 MAKE IT FEEL EVEN WORSE.

01:46 - 51.500 NEVERTHELESS.

01:46 - 53.940 THE MOTION

01:46 - 56.100 FOR RECONSIDERATION AND OUR

01:46 - 57.730 BRIEF TO THE SUPERIOR COURT.

01:46 - 59.860 WE SET FOR ALL.

01:47 - 03.490 WE TOOK IN OUR TEMPS TO NOT

01:47 - 06.600 ONLY IT SERVES. BUT ALSO YOU.

01:47 - 09.530 THE LINE. THE ORIGINAL

01:47 - 12.580 DEFENDANT. THE EAGLE. 2 WHOSE

01:47 - 13.680 WHEREABOUTS WERE.

01:47 - 16.760 ON UNKNOWN UNTIL SERVICE WAS

01:47 - 17.190 ACTUALLY

01:47 - 20.110 A FACTUAL. IT MAY BE IMPORTANT

01:47 - 22.420 TO POINT OUT IN THAT PART OF MY

01:47 - 23.950 ANSWER TO YOU. YEAH.

01:47 - 27.510 I MEAN TO THE FACTS OF THE

01:47 - 29.030 UNDERLYING MATTER REALLY

01:47 - 31.610 IMPORTANT IN THAT COUNCIL HAD

01:47 - 33.930 UNDER HIS APPEARANCE. POOR

01:47 - 36.300 MISTER SIEGEL. PRIOR TO OUR

01:47 - 37.430 MEETING SERVICE,

01:47 - 40.120 THEREFORE THE HEART OR THE LINE

01:47 - 42.460 OF CASES UNDER LAND AND ITS

01:47 - 44.870 PRIME. THERE'S

01:47 - 48.570 THERE'S NO THERE THERE WAS THE

01:47 - 49.030 LACK

01:47 - 51.040 OF NOTICE PROVIDE TO THE

01:47 - 52.870 DEFENSE THE DEFENDANT KNEW THE

01:47 - 55.450 FAMILY. KNEW ABOUT THIS CASE

01:47 - 57.830 CLEARLY AS HIS COUNSEL HAS

01:47 - 00.640 ENTERED WITH US ISN'T LETTING

01:48 - 02.860 THEM EAT THIS. TO MAKE SURE WE

01:48 - 04.920 GET THIS CLEAR. IT HAS APPEARED

01:48 - 06.650 CENTER WHERE AFTER THAT THE

01:48 - 07.320 PATIENTS ARE YOU.

01:48 - 10.870 THE STATUE OF LIMITATIONS RAN

01:48 - 15.800 ON JULY 25TH 2018 THE HEARINGS.

01:48 - 16.580 WELL AS

01:48 - 20.090 AUGUST 13. SO IT WAS RIGHT

01:48 - 20.990 AFTER THE STATUTE OF

01:48 - 22.840 LIMITATIONS. COURT

01:48 - 24.390 AND OF COURSE THAT MAY BE

01:48 - 26.550 TACTICAL THAT HE SO I MEAN WE

01:48 - 28.250 HAVE TO LEAVE THE RECORD THAT

01:48 - 31.010 THAT THAT MAYBE I'M NOT I'M NOT

01:48 - 32.240 READING THE MIND'S EYE OF WHAT

01:48 - 33.770 COUNCILS BUT YOU GOT TO KNOW

01:48 - 36.170 THAT'S CORRECT. NEVER LEFT.

01:48 - 41.110 THE ENTRY OF

01:48 - 43.700 APPEARANCE CAME. WE CONTINUE

01:48 - 45.640 TO MAKE THE DILIGENT EFFORTS TO

01:48 - 47.950 LOCATE. MISTER HALL

01:48 - 49.630 AND THEN AFTER DOING EFFORTS

01:48 - 51.430 WERE MADE TO THE TABLE.

01:48 - 55.160 SERVING 10:00PM FOR GENIA TEAM

01:48 - 57.370 BACK TO US AND THEN IN A NEW

01:48 - 59.580 YORKER. RIGHT PRIOR

01:49 - 02.210 RIGHT AFTER. WELL,

01:49 - 05.500 THE BANK THEN COUNCIL GOES AND

01:49 - 09.810 AND AFTER THE PARADE CATCH AND

01:49 - 11.990 RUN WELL. WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE.

01:49 - 15.410 HOPEFUL, I'M GOING TO INTERRUPT

01:49 - 18.290 BUT YOU'RE DONE. NOW THAT WE'VE

01:49 - 19.980 GOT A DIFFERENT FIND HER ON

01:49 - 21.930 COURT ONE. NEVERTHELESS I DO

01:49 - 23.510 BELIEVE THAT IT IS ACTUALLY A

01:49 - 25.700 MEDIA ONLY TO PROVE THAT WE DID

01:49 - 27.880 NOT IF YOU IF YOU

01:49 - 29.980 TELL US IF YOU GREEN UNDER

01:49 - 31.820 LAND. THE HOPE IS THAT.

01:49 - 38.150 WE DO NEED TO PROVE THAT WE

01:49 - 39.020 DILIGENTLY

01:49 - 41.100 TO SERVICE NOT GETTING INTO ANY

01:49 - 42.470 MET THAT BURDEN THEY'RE NOT

01:49 - 43.900 APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT

01:49 - 46.270 PROVIDED IS THAT THAT IS

01:49 - 47.730 STARTING POINT FOR THIS CASE TO

01:49 - 50.040 TEACH YOUR CREDIT. YOUR

01:49 - 51.180 BIRD PLACES

01:49 - 54.480 IN IN IN IN IN SERVING THE

01:49 - 55.960 DILIGENTLY TEMP SERVICE.

01:49 - 58.360 >>SIMPLE ANSWER, YES, OKAY,

01:49 - 59.220 THANK YOU SO MUCH.

01:50 - 02.250 THE HIGH COURT TO

01:50 - 05.630 A QUESTION AND I N.

01:50 - 10.430 I MADE I DON'T KNOW, BUT I MISS

01:50 - 12.770 PORTER TO YOU ALL THEY NEED TO

01:50 - 13.740 RESPOND TO.

01:50 - 16.850 AND TONIGHT. I THINK YOU

01:50 - 19.040 PROBABLY HAS TO DO WHAT I THAT

01:50 - 19.700 SEPARATELY.

01:50 - 21.510 >>IS WHETHER OR NOT YOUR BIRD

01:50 - 23.470 IF CONFIRMED FOR ME GOING FROM

01:50 - 26.930 IT IS INCONSISTENT WITH

01:50 - 28.260 IMPOSING A

01:50 - 31.830 INTENTIONAL MISCONDUCT. IF YOU

01:50 - 32.230 WANT TO.

01:50 - 34.700 THEY'VE ALREADY SAID A GOOD

01:50 - 36.420 YEAR VERY DILIGENTLY CREW.

01:50 - 37.250 THE FACT THAT

01:50 - 39.650 THE SERVICE BUT IT NEVER SHOWED

01:50 - 40.990 THAT YOU INTENTIONALLY TRY TO

01:50 - 43.800 DELAY THE AX. YEAH, I'M NOT

01:50 - 44.390 SURE HOW THOSE.

01:50 - 47.620 IT'S A PRETTY PLACE IN WORK.

01:50 - 49.490 IF YOU WANT TO LEVERAGE TO GET

01:50 - 50.720 OUT OF THE FIGURE IT OUT.

01:50 - 57.700 THAT'S IT. IT'S VERY TOUGH

01:50 - 59.560 BECAUSE I THINK THEY'RE IN A

01:50 - 59.890 SACK.

01:51 - 04.110 WE LOOK AT THE LINE OF KIDS IT

01:51 - 06.560 WILL BE PRETTY LOW LAND AND

01:51 - 10.500 WHAT WE'RE REALLY LOOKING AT

01:51 - 10.770 HOW

01:51 - 13.060 THE CIRCUMSTANCES AND WAS THERE

01:51 - 14.870 ANY KIND OF INTENT ON OUR

01:51 - 15.510 PURPOSE

01:51 - 18.630 OR IT LEAH ON ON THE PLANE.

01:51 - 19.770 A PURPOSE INITIALLY.

01:51 - 21.510 >>THE STALLED AND IF YOU GET

01:51 - 23.110 FROM HERE. WHEN WE LOOK

01:51 - 25.170 AT LAND. WE HAVE THE CLEAR

01:51 - 27.770 INTENT OF THE COUNCIL TO NOT

01:51 - 29.620 SERVE THE COMPLAINT. IT'S NOT

01:51 - 30.740 WHAT OCCURRED HERE UNDER.

01:51 - 35.010 AND WHEN WE LOOK AT AND CREATE

01:51 - 35.520 YOUR HONOR.

01:51 - 38.250 IF THEY THINK

01:51 - 40.630 THE PURPOSE. ULTIMATELY BEING

01:51 - 42.500 HIGHER WITH THAT THERE IS NO

01:51 - 45.180 BRIGHT LINE TEST AND THAT WE'RE

01:51 - 47.020 LOOKING TO SEE THE LONG AS

01:51 - 49.320 YOU DIDN'T. ALL OF THE SCENERY.

01:51 - 50.190 YOU ARE

01:51 - 52.330 YOU'RE ACTING PROBABLY UNDER

01:51 - 53.790 THE RULES BECAUSE RULE WHO

01:51 - 54.430 WROTE ONE.

01:51 - 57.600 STATE YOU HAVE

01:51 - 00.250 TO CONTINUOUSLY REINSTATE IT

01:52 - 02.270 JUST SAYS THE ORIGINAL SERVICE

01:52 - 03.660 PROCESS NEEDS TO BE MADE WITHIN

01:52 - 05.530 30 DAYS AFTER THE ISSUANCE OF

01:52 - 07.010 THE RIVER FALLING IN PLACE

01:52 - 08.830 WHICH IS PRECISELY WHAT

01:52 - 11.160 OCCURRED IN THE MATTER FOR YOUR

01:52 - 17.330 I BELIEVE THEN IT IS OUT IN

01:52 - 19.720 THAT POSITION THAT THE.

01:52 - 22.210 THE NEW CARS, YOU KNOW

01:52 - 24.780 GREAT LINE. SO LONG AS THE

01:52 - 25.890 PLAINTIFF IN THIS CASE WAS

01:52 - 28.230 TAKING STEPS TO MOVE THE BALL

01:52 - 30.710 FORWARD TO SPEAK THAT THEY WERE

01:52 - 32.710 ACTING IN GOOD FAITH AND NOT

01:52 - 34.100 INTENDING TO STALL THE SHOW

01:52 - 39.190 IF IT IS DONE HE CAN I FOLLOW

01:52 - 41.580 AT FLY AGAIN THE BEER LINE OF

01:52 - 42.050 THINKING.

01:52 - 47.890 >>ACTUALLY VERY GOOD.

01:52 - 49.150 IS THAT

01:52 - 51.880 WE'VE BEEN 30 B AND B IS DOING

01:52 - 54.080 SAYS THE RECIPE OR BE IN PLAY.

01:52 - 56.440 IF YOU'RE CONTEMPLATING HERE.

01:52 - 00.020 I'M TRYING TO GET BECAUSE

01:53 - 01.380 PART OF THE PROBLEM WITH OUR

01:53 - 03.340 PARK A FIVE-DAY SOMEWHAT

01:53 - 04.260 IMPRECISE.

01:53 - 06.230 SO LET

01:53 - 08.040 ME LET ME ASK YOU THIS QUESTION

01:53 - 10.100 LET'S SAY THAT YOU MENTION

01:53 - 10.650 AFTERNOON.

01:53 - 13.870 ON BE 20.

01:53 - 16.520 A 28 DAY GET 30 DAYS TO THEIR

01:53 - 19.130 CRAFT. OKAY, 20 AND

01:53 - 21.710 28 DAYS. YOU'RE SO GREAT IF

01:53 - 22.950 YOU'RE YEAH PARTY.

01:53 - 26.800 AND AS A RESULT OF THAT THERE'S

01:53 - 29.120 NO CAN DO IS GET GREAT SERVICE.

01:53 - 31.280 WITHIN THAT 30 DAY PERIOD.

01:53 - 33.590 I WOULD SAY AND LAND.

01:53 - 38.010 YEAH, YOU KNOW AND THEY'RE ALL

01:53 - 40.880 THE GET GO ON. I

01:53 - 42.580 APPRECIATE EVERY I

01:53 - 44.760 WAKE UP AND UNFORESEEN

01:53 - 46.060 CIRCUMSTANCE THAT OCCURRED

01:53 - 47.500 THERE YOU CAN BE DEADLY IN

01:53 - 50.110 SECOND CHANCES AND HER. I KNOW

01:53 - 52.170 THAT THERE'S NO I AM AT

01:53 - 54.500 SERVICE OUT. I'M JUST NOT VERY

01:53 - 56.390 PROOF

01:53 - 58.250 THAT THERE WAS NO COUNT AND

01:53 - 00.220 SURVEY DURING THAT 30 DAY

01:54 - 02.350 PERIOD GET YOU WHERE YOU NEED

01:54 - 04.000 TO GO AND THE LAND LAY STILL

01:54 - 05.000 PINK OUT GAME

01:54 - 07.310 ESTABLISHED IN KENT WHERE THE

01:54 - 09.860 DEFENDANT DOUGLAS I INTEND

01:54 - 12.860 TO CALL IN MY RIGHT I MEAN BY

01:54 - 14.650 THINKING REAGAN MR. -8

01:54 - 17.540 SOMETHING I I I COULDN'T

01:54 - 19.990 GET MY I REALLY FEEL HAPPENS.

01:54 - 26.340 IT LET ME SEE YOU.

01:54 - 30.520 CREATE WAYS A

01:54 - 32.690 VERY CLEAR STATEMENT OF WHAT

01:54 - 34.960 LIFE IS LIKE I'M

01:54 - 37.600 FOR LAST AND YOU WHY WE

01:54 - 38.230 CONTINUE TO

01:54 - 41.680 SEE CASES IT'S EITHER GOING TO

01:54 - 43.960 STALL THE FILM WE SEE EVERY.

01:54 - 47.910 BREAKING NEWS EVENT AND I AM I

01:54 - 50.790 CORRECT. YES IF YOU'RE FOR

01:54 - 53.100 THE SKIES. RIGHT I MEAN YOU

01:54 - 53.710 KNOW WHEN YOU

01:54 - 55.560 BE ON FRIEND OF THE

01:54 - 57.600 COURT HE GUESTED THAT WE CAN

01:54 - 00.410 SEND IT TO OR CIVIL WHO MADE IN

01:55 - 02.100 ORDER TO GET SOME CLARITY AND

01:55 - 03.050 TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.

01:55 - 05.770 UNLESS YOU'RE A WOMAN SAYS

01:55 - 08.400 FOLLOW MCREE. IN 2 WAYS.

01:55 - 11.000 I YOU KNOW I MEAN I I'M A

01:55 - 13.730 LITTLE BIT. I AM CURRENTLY FROM

01:55 - 15.690 WANT I MEAN BECAUSE YOU KNOW

01:55 - 17.570 THIS THIS WHY HAD YOU KNOW

01:55 - 20.380 9, 4, 1, BUT IT SEEMS TO ME

01:55 - 21.600 THAT THEY'RE NAPPING.

01:55 - 25.450 WHERE WE DAY DOT FOR A LITTLE

01:55 - 25.840 BIT HERE.

01:55 - 36.110 THEY ARE POINTING ABUSE IN FACT

01:55 - 37.880 IN GANDER US AND

01:55 - 40.390 LEAVE US IF NO STAND NEXT AND

01:55 - 45.770 THE U.S. I WAITED AND WHETHER

01:55 - 48.480 OR NOT. YOU KNOW YOU CAN FIND

01:55 - 50.440 WHAT PLAN AND HERE IF

01:55 - 52.980 THERE'S A IN THE EVENING, A

01:55 - 54.610 FRIEND, A CLEAR STATEMENT THAT

01:55 - 55.270 A MAN

01:55 - 57.590 AND THEN INCREASE WITH ALL DUE

01:55 - 59.030 DEFERENCE TO GET IN THERE WITH

01:55 - 00.490 I THINK IT'S PERFECTLY CLEAR.

01:56 - 04.330 I FEAR NAPPY THAT YEAH. CREATED

01:56 - 07.140 A LITTLE ODD. YOU KNOW. I THINK

01:56 - 09.340 THEY ARE WE'RE TAKING YOU AGREE

01:56 - 10.840 WITH THAT. I WOULD

01:56 - 13.150 AGREE WITH I ALSO ASKED.

01:56 - 15.030 >>THE CREASE AND BEAT IT

01:56 - 16.250 BECAUSE IT'S REALLY THE

01:56 - 16.970 CURRENTS.

01:56 - 21.190 >>LONG RUN. NO QUESTION BUT THE

01:56 - 23.760 SUPERIOR COURT SOMEHOW IT'S

01:56 - 24.510 GOING DOWN.

01:56 - 28.340 1986 STATEMENT THAT WE'VE

01:56 - 31.230 REALLY I MEAN IF YOU DO IT BACK

01:56 - 32.840 IN AND THEY'RE VERY BASIC

01:56 - 33.540 STATEMENT OF WHAT

01:56 - 36.740 WHY BUT IF WE JUST FOLLOW THE

01:56 - 38.880 CREEK WE HAVE A PROBLEM.

01:56 - 42.110 >>IT'S AN ISSUE IN THE MATTER

01:56 - 44.310 BEFORE YOUR COURT. BEFORE OUR

01:56 - 44.790 WE'VE GOT SOME.

01:56 - 49.550 >>IN YOUR CASE.

01:56 - 52.990 TAKE MY TO MY KIDS AND FIND

01:56 - 54.870 FACT MY FACE TO THE CREASE.

01:56 - 56.930 I BELIEVE THAT THIS CASE SHOULD

01:56 - 59.500 BE SENT BACK. BECAUSE I THINK

01:56 - 00.030 THAT THERE'S

01:57 - 02.200 BEEN NO IN FIRST OF ALL YOU

01:57 - 04.800 CAN'T SHOW THE TANKS THE STOLEN

01:57 - 06.610 THE HEARING AND SECOND OF ALL

01:57 - 09.160 THERE'S NO CRIME HERE AND.

01:57 - 12.180 AND BASED ON THE FACT IS WHEN

01:57 - 14.980 I WAS I MEAN JUST AS FAIR.

01:57 - 15.950 THEY.

01:57 - 20.750 WHO ARE THE DEFENDING CHOSE

01:57 - 22.900 TO ENTER THEIR APPEARANCE

01:57 - 25.080 AND ALSO FILED EMERGENCY ACTION

01:57 - 27.170 ON THE ISSUE IN PART.

01:57 - 34.560 THERE'S NO RIGHT HERE ON THE ON

01:57 - 35.930 THE RUN AND.

01:57 - 47.310 FROM THIS FROM THIS POINT FORTH

01:57 - 48.690 FROM THIS FROM THIS POINT.

01:57 - 53.380 I RESPECTFULLY. LOOK

01:57 - 55.420 FOR SOME GUIDANCE THAT SAYS

01:57 - 57.980 THERE IS NO BRIGHT LINE TEST OF

01:57 - 00.180 THE RESTATEMENT EVERY 30 DAYS

01:58 - 02.560 AND THAT THE NO

01:58 - 04.880 HOLDING IT VERY CLEAR THAT HE

01:58 - 05.000 IS

01:58 - 07.040 ALL ABOUT THE INTENT OF THE

01:58 - 08.570 PARTY THE STALLED JUDICIAL

01:58 - 11.040 MACHINE. SO THIS IS JUST A

01:58 - 12.830 STARKER D WITH REGARD TO

01:58 - 15.990 FOR INACTION THE CASE REQUIRES

01:58 - 17.590 A JUDICIAL DETERMINATION OF

01:58 - 18.100 GOOD FAITH.

01:58 - 20.310 >>THAT WOULD APPEAR IN EFFECT

01:58 - 22.490 YOU WAITED PIRATES ARMED WITH

01:58 - 24.200 MARY JACKSON CHALLENGES.

01:58 - 28.750 YEAH YOUR CLIENT. IF YOU FAIL

01:58 - 30.350 TO REACH FAR WHY

01:58 - 32.250 YOUR BAND FROM YOUR VALUE TO

01:58 - 34.020 RESPOND FOR COURT TO MAKE A

01:58 - 35.710 DETERMINATION WHETHER IN FACT

01:58 - 36.580 THERE WERE 4.

01:58 - 40.430 >>IT WAS FUN

01:58 - 43.730 TO BE TO BE CLEAR AND YES YOU

01:58 - 44.010 YOU.

01:58 - 47.790 IF YOU LOOK

01:58 - 50.640 DIRECTLY AT THE ORDER THAT WAS

01:58 - 53.660 ENTERED JOY AFTER IT IN THE

01:58 - 56.620 COMMON PLEAS COURT. JOINING

01:58 - 58.870 PATRICK DID THE 9,

01:58 - 01.740 ONE OR INJECTION BASED UPON OUR

01:59 - 04.880 LACK OF FAITH, AN EFFORT TO TO

01:59 - 07.100 TO MAKE SERVICE AND IN

01:59 - 09.620 DOING SO. HE REVIEWS

01:59 - 12.270 THE DOCKET HAS FILED.

01:59 - 17.340 ALSO WHEN YOU LOOK AT

01:59 - 17.910 HER ORDER.

01:59 - 19.920 SHE RELIES HEAVILY ON THE

01:59 - 22.550 ANGLER IN THE LINE I CASE

01:59 - 26.000 LINE BASIS, NOT THE THE CASES

01:59 - 28.640 OF LAND AND HIS PRIME. SO.

01:59 - 32.700 I'M NOT THE ISSUE FIRST

01:59 - 34.310 AND FOREMOST IT WOULD ENTER

01:59 - 35.810 HER. IT WAS AN INADVERTENT

01:59 - 38.280 MISTAKE THAT SHOULD NOT BE HELD

01:59 - 38.610 TO.

01:59 - 41.210 BUT IT WAS NEVER IN THE STATE

01:59 - 42.640 COUNCIL THAT WE THINK THAT

01:59 - 43.830 SHOULD NOT SELL TO YOU.

01:59 - 48.490 PENALIZE THE PLAN

01:59 - 51.310 ON THE ISSUE OF SERVICE AND I I

01:59 - 52.900 JUST I JUST BOUGHT THEM.

01:59 - 54.580 >>IN OTHER WORDS YOU PROBABLY

01:59 - 57.160 HEARD JACKSON THE CONTESTING

01:59 - 58.350 THE SERVICES.

01:59 - 01.530 AND YOU KNEW YOU CAN TEST THAT

02:00 - 03.060 ARE RESPONDING NEW IN YOUR

02:00 - 04.830 JACKET. IF YOU DIDN'T DO THAT.

02:00 - 07.380 IF YOU KNOW WHAT

02:00 - 09.760 I KNEW I WOULDN'T BET. PASTOR.

02:00 - 17.230 WE FILED A MOTION

02:00 - 18.510 FOR RECONSIDERATION.

02:00 - 19.750 >>I UNDERSTAND THAT BUT

02:00 - 22.370 I'M HOPING IF YOU EVER SERVICE

02:00 - 23.510 HOW YOU TESTED YOU FILE A

02:00 - 24.890 MOTION TO DISMISS THE COMPLAINT

02:00 - 26.500 FOR LACK OF SERVICE, THE

02:00 - 28.150 POPULAR ACTION. WE NEED YOUR

02:00 - 29.810 CASE THEY CAN'T JUST IGNORE THE

02:00 - 30.590 CORE.

02:00 - 34.260 IT WAS I THOUGHT WE ARE NOT

02:00 - 35.610 THERE AFTER THAT I BEGAN TO

02:00 - 37.530 WORSEN. THE GREATEST MYSTERY

02:00 - 38.810 PREJUDICE, RICK PERRY TO MAKE

02:00 - 40.840 GOOD AT THE PAPER SERVICE TO

02:00 - 42.530 FROM YOU. IT WAS SOMETHING FROM

02:00 - 46.490 IT. THE. PATRICK WENT HOME WITH

02:00 - 48.950 MEN. IN

02:00 - 49.790 THE FOLLOWING.

02:00 - 51.720 >>WHAT WAS WHAT WAS FILED BY

02:00 - 53.860 THE DEFENDANTS AND AT THAT TIME

02:00 - 54.700 AND ALSO WHAT

02:00 - 58.110 WE THOUGHT IN WOMEN'S ACTION

02:00 - 59.100 AND BE BEHIND

02:01 - 02.260 THE DOCKET AS IT REFLECTED AT

02:01 - 04.350 THAT TIME UNFORTUNATELY WHEN

02:01 - 06.920 THE FORMER JUDGE OR UNDER THE

02:01 - 08.960 DOCKING OF THE POLLS, MR.

02:01 - 10.580 WE HAD MANY SERVICE ON

02:01 - 13.540 SEPTEMBER 29. BUT UNFORTUNATELY

02:01 - 15.510 THAT SERVICE DID NOT STOP IT IS

02:01 - 17.190 A LOT TO OVER 10 THE

02:01 - 19.660 ORDER DENYING BEFORE GRANTING

02:01 - 22.050 THE PRIMARY OBJECTION. WITH

02:01 - 23.050 ENTER ON OCTOBER.

02:01 - 25.940 THAT'S WHERE IN OUR MOTION FOR

02:01 - 28.800 RECONSIDERATION WE FILED IT ON.

02:01 - 33.530 WE OUTLINE THAT TIMELINE AND.

02:01 - 36.730 AND AND TO SHOW THAT

02:01 - 38.830 THEIR DAY IN FACT BEHIND A

02:01 - 42.930 THAT THERE WAS NO THERE WAS NO

02:01 - 45.250 SERVICE ISSUE AT THAT POINT

02:01 - 47.700 AND HOW WE RESPONDED TO THE

02:01 - 49.430 AREA AND THIS IS WHAT WE WOULD

02:01 - 49.900 HAVE SAID

02:01 - 52.300 THE MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION

02:01 - 54.570 WITH NOT ONLY LESS TO THIS

02:01 - 55.800 IDEA. THE

02:01 - 58.580 SUPERIOR COURT. WHO WANT TO

02:01 - 59.640 HEAR WHAT YOU WOULD HAVE SAID

02:01 - 01.000 THE STUFF YOU DIDN'T RESPOND

02:02 - 01.250 TO.

02:02 - 04.290 >>IT'S I'M SORRY I CAN WHY

02:02 - 05.550 WOULD WE LIKE OR WANT TO HEAR

02:02 - 06.820 WHAT YOU WOULD HAVE SAID IN

02:02 - 07.800 SOMETHING YOU DIDN'T EVEN

02:02 - 09.140 RESPOND TO THAT THAT THE WAY.

02:02 - 15.720 WE ALSO SET FOR A WE ALSO SET

02:02 - 16.710 FORTH THE

02:02 - 19.250 ISSUE THAT WE DIDN'T RESPOND IT

02:02 - 20.560 WAS AN INADVERTENT MISTAKE.

02:02 - 22.410 IT WAS NOT YOU KNOW RECENTLY

02:02 - 26.140 IGNORING OR ATTEMPTING TO TO.

02:02 - 28.770 TO HER THE KNOT AND.

02:02 - 35.500 ACCOUNT FOR JUST A VERY

02:02 - 37.490 GOOD BECAUSE AND WHY DO IN

02:02 - 39.620 ANSWERING THEM. IN YEARS.

02:02 - 41.940 COLLOQUY WITH JUST THE THOUGHT

02:02 - 43.420 OF THE YOU CONFUSE ME A LITTLE

02:02 - 45.130 BIT. I THOUGHT YOU SAID YOU

02:02 - 48.080 NEED IT WITH YOUR BIRD. IT'S A

02:02 - 49.900 RELIGION. EVER SERVED.

02:02 - 52.070 MY QUESTION TO YOU

02:02 - 54.500 IS WHERE IT IN THE COMMERCIAL

02:02 - 56.180 WOULD BE THE CREASE THAT

02:02 - 58.080 THERE'S NO PREJUDICE IS NOW IN

02:02 - 59.000 HAS NO LEGS.

02:02 - 01.260 >>AGAIN APROPOS LITTLE BIT WITH

02:03 - 02.990 THE KEY TO THAT WILL SOON

02:03 - 04.490 HYPOTHETICALLY IT'S NOT YOUR

02:03 - 06.680 FACTS, I KNOW. BUT I'M LOOKING

02:03 - 07.390 FOR A TEST

02:03 - 10.700 HYPOTHETICALLY THAT PLAYED HIS

02:03 - 12.280 COLLEGE 1000 PLAY.

02:03 - 15.930 AROUND THE WORLD.

02:03 - 17.850 THE GETTING ABOUT THE

02:03 - 20.080 COMPLAINTS COME BACK A YEAR

02:03 - 22.460 LATER IT WORKS. I NEVER SERVED

02:03 - 26.770 THERE'S NO CRAIG YOU THIS

02:03 - 29.540 THE DEFENSE THEIR BACK TO

02:03 - 31.920 SCHOOL THERE. AND I CERTAINLY

02:03 - 33.680 WOULD SIMPLY IN A BIRD,

02:03 - 35.840 THEIR NEIGHBOR AND THEY FORGOT

02:03 - 37.090 ABOUT THAT BEFORE I TAKE IT

02:03 - 39.290 THEIR CREWS, THERE'S A POINT TO

02:03 - 41.570 COME IN AND GO FORWARD FOR THE

02:03 - 42.010 WAY THROUGH.

02:03 - 46.610 >>UNDER THE BACK TO CLEAN UP IS

02:03 - 47.590 PERMITTED TO GO FORWARD.

02:03 - 48.680 OKAY,

02:03 - 50.780 THEY'RE NOT SO YOU'RE LOOKING

02:03 - 52.610 FOR IN PASSION OF DELAY OR

02:03 - 54.330 PREJUDICE AND THE CRITERIA.

02:04 - 03.660 THANK YOU WILL HEAR FROM A.

02:04 - 13.540 THE PACIFIC TONIGHT THAN I KNEW

02:04 - 14.110 MYSELF NOW.

02:04 - 21.040 >>GOOD AFTERNOON AGAIN TO JUST

02:04 - 25.820 COURT. WHETHER YOU

02:04 - 27.540 WILL CAUSE WHO HARM OR

02:04 - 30.260 KILL HER OR YOU APPLY TO

02:04 - 33.180 FORCIBLE FROM FOX IN THIS CASE.

02:04 - 35.340 WE'RE ONLY GOING TO NEED ALL

02:04 - 41.030 FIRM IN ALL. SO GOVERNMENTS PAY

02:04 - 43.290 ANY MISTAKES ACCORDING TO FEC

02:04 - 44.530 SERVICE ON YOUR OWN.

02:04 - 48.230 THE FIRST REPORT THAT THOSE WHO

02:04 - 49.450 ARE CURRENT ON ME FOR.

02:04 - 51.600 AND THEY'RE REINSTATING THE

02:04 - 55.750 COMPLAINT ON 8/22/2002. THERE

02:04 - 57.640 WAS A PERIOD AGO EYE

02:04 - 01.540 TIME FRAME. THE STATUTE OF

02:05 - 02.910 LIMITATIONS HAS RUN.

02:05 - 05.630 WELL SERVICE AND WITH ALL THAT

02:05 - 08.270 HOMEOWNERS. DESPITE THIS OFFER

02:05 - 08.880 TO ALL

02:05 - 10.680 ALL THE BIRDS WILL PROVE THAT

02:05 - 12.740 THE TRIAL ALL ONCE THE HOME

02:05 - 13.880 WHERE YOU GET GOALS.

02:05 - 16.860 WELL, HELLO. IT NEVER RESPONDED

02:05 - 18.170 TO THOSE WOMEN ARE YOUR JOB.

02:05 - 20.590 AND THOSE WHO HAVE A QUESTION

02:05 - 23.340 OR 2 AND I KNOW AT THIS POINT A

02:05 - 25.590 LOT. WE BELIEVE THAT THAT WAS A

02:05 - 25.870 WAY

02:05 - 28.620 FOR LONG. NOT BELIEVE THAT THE

02:05 - 30.350 MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION

02:05 - 31.880 PRESERVE THESE ISSUES ON

02:05 - 33.930 APPEAL. ALL RELY ON

02:05 - 35.820 OUR BRIEFS. WELL FROM ALL OF

02:05 - 36.730 THOSE ARGUMENTS.

02:05 - 40.140 YOU KNOW CONSIDERING THE MOTION

02:05 - 41.950 FOR RECONSIDERATION WAS FILED

02:05 - 43.750 BY THE HOMES THERE

02:05 - 46.790 WAS WELL HUSSEIN OFTEN I'M

02:05 - 48.030 GONNA FALL ALMOST

02:05 - 50.780 100 HOME RUNS BEFORE THE STATUE

02:05 - 53.440 OF LIMITATIONS EXPIRED. WHO ALL

02:05 - 55.180 400 AND PROBATION REQUESTS.

02:05 - 55.730 WELL, NO

02:05 - 57.520 INTERNET SEARCHES THERE WERE NO

02:05 - 59.220 IT COMES TO LOCAL THE FORMER

02:05 - 59.940 YOUR NEIGHBORS

02:05 - 01.830 OR EMPLOYERS THERE WAS NO

02:06 - 03.820 SOCIAL MEDIA INVESTIGATION.

02:06 - 06.010 WELL, NO HARM TO HIRE A PRIVATE

02:06 - 08.090 INVESTIGATOR, I'M ALMOST

02:06 - 10.110 MORE FREQUENTLY, A PENNSYLVANIA

02:06 - 12.130 OR SO THE SECRET FOR 30.

02:06 - 14.380 IT WAS MORE HARM TO FILE.

02:06 - 17.040 MOTION FOR THE SPECIAL ORDER

02:06 - 17.990 FOR FOR ALL PART OF THE

02:06 - 18.780 SERVICE.

02:06 - 20.880 WHAT I THINK IS IN SPOTS FOR

02:06 - 23.530 THIS COURT. IT'S ALL ON OUR

02:06 - 25.440 KNEES AND THERE'S NO WORD ON

02:06 - 28.230 WHAT CAUSED THE NEEDS OF CASE.

02:06 - 30.380 ONE EXAMINES THE MOST

02:06 - 32.370 THE COUNCIL WILL ALSO SEE THE

02:06 - 35.090 4.30. THERE'S A WORLD STRAIGHT

02:06 - 37.720 TO WHAT CAUSED THE 2 WHO FACE.

02:06 - 47.450 >>DID YOUR CLIENT RE USE THE

02:06 - 49.200 CERTIFIED MAIL IN VIRGINIA.

02:06 - 53.510 >>NOT TO MY ALL.

02:06 - 55.190 MY

02:06 - 57.010 ALL THAT THERE WAS SOME CRUISE

02:07 - 02.350 YOU GO OUT WITH MY SON AGAIN.

02:07 - 04.200 >>AND GOOD JOB.

02:07 - 08.070 DID YOUR CLIENT GET NOTICE FROM

02:07 - 09.030 HIS INSURANCE CARRIER.

02:07 - 12.660 >>I DON'T BELIEVE THERE'S ANY

02:07 - 14.990 RECORD FACT THAT JUST AS WELL,

02:07 - 15.400 BUT MY

02:07 - 17.930 UNDERSTANDING, YES THAT ONE

02:07 - 20.220 HOUSEHOLD FILED BY THE PARENTS

02:07 - 22.710 ON ALL THIS WHO WHO WAS YOUNG

02:07 - 24.860 THE STATUE WILL CLOSE ONES IT

02:07 - 26.090 WAS BASED ON

02:07 - 28.940 ALL CRAWLING ALSO ADVISE AND

02:07 - 31.170 WARN PARENTS HOME FOR THE

02:07 - 33.870 REFORM. ALL WE OF

02:07 - 35.740 THE LAWSUIT AND THE POINT

02:07 - 36.510 COUNCIL AGREED

02:07 - 38.510 THEIR APPEARANCE IT WASN'T AS

02:07 - 40.340 YOU KNOW WE WERE STORMS BUT TO

02:07 - 41.780 SIMPLY MAKE SURE

02:07 - 43.680 THEY'VE GOT MORE WITNESSES EACH

02:07 - 46.880 >>AND JUST ONE MORE QUESTION

02:07 - 48.090 ONE JUST ONE MORE QUESTION

02:07 - 50.510 DISCREETLY UP IS THE BURDEN

02:07 - 51.680 WHEN YOU'RE IN YOUR JUDGMENT.

02:07 - 53.990 >>THIS IS A WALK WITH THE

02:07 - 55.380 BURDEN ON THE

02:07 - 57.980 PLANE DID TO ESTABLISH GOOD

02:07 - 58.260 FAITH.

02:08 - 01.730 THE DEFENDANT

02:08 - 05.500 TO ESTABLISH. IN THE ABSENCE OF

02:08 - 06.820 GOOD FAITH IN THE WORKPLACE.

02:08 - 09.620 >>AND THE JUDGE JUST AS WELL

02:08 - 11.620 WITH HER LEGAL BURDEN IS ON IS

02:08 - 13.890 ON THE PLANE. AND I THINK THAT

02:08 - 16.030 WILL SELL FOR WHO ALONG WITH

02:08 - 18.110 HIS SUPPORT. THE FOREIGN OFFICE

02:08 - 20.670 TOO I BELIEVE SO FOR JUSTICE

02:08 - 24.540 I DON'T REALLY WANT TO GO OUT

02:08 - 26.560 ABOUT THAT IT IS A LAW SCHOOLS

02:08 - 29.160 TODAY. THAT MEANS WE HOMES

02:08 - 38.850 >>IT SEEMS TO ME WHAT WE HAVE.

02:08 - 42.680 OR TO

02:08 - 45.110 QUOTE HERE THAT'S THE GREAT

02:08 - 46.290 PERIOD. YOU SIR

02:08 - 49.150 IS THAT THE CLAY THAT HAS THE

02:08 - 51.040 BURDEN OF PROOF. HE

02:08 - 51.710 DEMONSTRATES

02:08 - 53.620 GOOD FAITH ITS EFFORTS TO

02:08 - 55.460 ACTUALLY SERVE THAT'S A PRETTY

02:08 - 56.890 FAIR APPROXIMATION OF WHAT YOU

02:08 - 59.440 SAID TO BE GOOD AND TO BARNSLEY

02:08 - 59.610 I

02:08 - 02.820 THINK THAT HERE YOU'RE HOLDING

02:09 - 04.820 RIGHT AROUND TO THE IDEA AND

02:09 - 05.970 WHEN HE ANSWERED MY LAST HIGH

02:09 - 08.080 POSE SPECIAL. BUT GENERALLY.

02:09 - 12.540 THEY FEEL LIKE THE PENSIONS OFF

02:09 - 13.700 THE HOOK. THE CASE

02:09 - 15.820 SHOULD BE WAS THERE IN HOPES

02:09 - 17.800 YOU KNOW THE LAY AN EGG IN THE

02:09 - 21.070 LEG. AND IT WAS THERE ANY I DO

02:09 - 23.390 THE FED. IT SEEMS TO

02:09 - 29.290 PROBABLY PREVAIL IN UNDER THE

02:09 - 30.710 POSTS THAT HE.

02:09 - 35.930 YOU MAY WANT

02:09 - 36.950 TO GO I DON'T KNOW THE

02:09 - 39.480 NAME BY OR WHETHER THE PRACTICE

02:09 - 40.340 IN THIS CASE.

02:09 - 43.030 AND YET YOU MAY NOT THEY'LL

02:09 - 44.750 PLAY THE ARGUMENT. THE TRIAL

02:09 - 45.580 COURT FOR THE SET.

02:09 - 48.660 IS WHAT I MADE WITH THE CREW

02:09 - 49.860 THAT THEY'VE BEEN PLACED IN

02:09 - 52.300 KABUL AP TO NEGLIGENCE THERE

02:09 - 55.420 WAS NO ONE HAS A NEW WHO PREFER

02:09 - 56.450 TO GET TO THE MERITS OF THE

02:09 - 58.820 CASE SO ON. I THINK IT WOULD BE

02:09 - 02.900 HELPFUL TO US. IF YOU PLAY WAS.

02:10 - 04.470 IT WAS

02:10 - 09.060 WE NOT AND WE'RE GOING AWAY

02:10 - 10.630 FROM THAT BUT WE CAN DO THAT IN

02:10 - 12.680 THE 5TH YEAR, OKAY. THE WIFE.

02:10 - 13.680 A DAD.

02:10 - 17.070 IT'S QUICKLY PROVIDE DID NOT

02:10 - 20.040 INTENTIONALLY DELAY. AND IS IN

02:10 - 22.030 NO CREDIT AT ALL THAT

02:10 - 23.200 WILL GET TO THE MERITS OF THE

02:10 - 24.360 CASE SAID A BAR.

02:10 - 27.240 >>IT'S A GOOD

02:10 - 30.460 QUESTION ROGER. WE RESPOND TO

02:10 - 30.900 THIS WELL.

02:10 - 35.390 THE STANDARD OF THE HOME.

02:10 - 39.070 AND THEN STABBED THE PURPOSE OF

02:10 - 40.280 THE STOPS ALONG THE COAST.

02:10 - 42.870 AND THE RULES THAT WILL FORCE

02:10 - 44.740 THEM SERVICE ON YOUR VIEW.

02:10 - 49.940 WHO POSSIBLE

02:10 - 52.790 WHO DIDN'T. THERE WERE ONLY A

02:10 - 54.290 HYPOTHETICAL THAT NO LONGER

02:10 - 57.010 POSE WHERE YOU FOLLOW YOUR

02:10 - 59.690 COME HOME. SO THE WORLD FOR

02:10 - 02.130 NEAR THE STATUTES FIRES AND YOU

02:11 - 02.790 COME BACK

02:11 - 06.630 THAT COINCIDED WITH THE PURPOSE

02:11 - 07.950 OF THE STOPS ALONG THE COAST

02:11 - 12.990 GOOGLE SQUARED AWAY AND THE

02:11 - 15.110 CROWS AND COASTAL SCHOOL BUS.

02:11 - 17.230 ALMOST ALL PUBLIC POLICY

02:11 - 19.410 IN FAVOR OF THE STORM STRUCK

02:11 - 20.760 THE HOPEFULS ALL THE STOPS

02:11 - 22.860 ALONG THE COASTS A LOT OF

02:11 - 23.620 POINTED OUT

02:11 - 28.470 THAT ONCE THE SUN HAS OWNS

02:11 - 32.840 FROM HIM, THERE WERE FOR THE

02:11 - 34.020 PURPOSE OF THE STATUTE OF

02:11 - 36.590 LIMITATIONS FOR FALL. SO HIGH

02:11 - 41.930 WITH A TWO-YEAR STATUTE OF

02:11 - 42.710 LIMITATIONS.

02:11 - 45.350 IT. ALL IN THIS PARTICULAR

02:11 - 48.200 CASE FILE THEIR FIRST FALL IN

02:11 - 49.990 ONE DAY AFTER THE SMALL LITTLE

02:11 - 52.830 TOKENS IT'S CLEAR THEY'RE CLOSE

02:11 - 54.940 TO CALL THOUGH THERE'S NO

02:11 - 57.150 CREDIBLE STRONGER FOR THAT IN

02:11 - 58.840 MOST SPOTS WILL IMPOSE ONE'S

02:11 - 01.100 BEEN FALLING HOME, THE CLOSE TO

02:12 - 01.430 CALL.

02:12 - 08.490 WHO'S STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS AS

02:12 - 10.940 YOU MONITOR WITHOUT THESE LAST

02:12 - 13.630 FALL AND COOL THIS SUMMER.

02:12 - 18.560 FRIEND WHO WAS DEALT TO LOCAL

02:12 - 22.360 POLICE. HOW'S IT POSSIBLE FOR.

02:12 - 26.820 TO BE ON

02:12 - 28.130 THE BALL TO

02:12 - 30.480 THAT SCENARIO. A LOT OF THE

02:12 - 34.420 YOU FILE THE YOUNGEST AT A

02:12 - 35.690 LOCAL SCHOOLS WERE HERE FIRST

02:12 - 40.860 HOME RULES ITS OWN POLL WHO WAS

02:12 - 43.050 THE FOREMAN FOR EVERY 2 TO

02:12 - 45.630 ESTABLISH WHO HARM. HOW IS THAT

02:12 - 46.920 POSSIBLE WHO

02:12 - 49.220 WE GOT AND WITH REGARD TO THE

02:12 - 51.050 PRESIDENT OR EVEN TO BE DONE

02:12 - 52.720 CASES WHERE SOMEBODY WITH

02:12 - 54.950 DOLLARS YOU'RE NOT SERVICE.

02:12 - 59.270 >>SECOND DAY. LONGVIEW FOUND

02:12 - 00.740 WITHIN THE STATUTE YOU HOLD THE

02:13 - 04.750 JUST AFTER. THANK TO POLLING BY

02:13 - 06.490 BALLOT SERVICE IN THE RAF, SO

02:13 - 08.160 YOU CAN YOU CAN PROTECT THE

02:13 - 09.290 STATUE BY FOULING.

02:13 - 11.620 THE PRESS BEFORE THE RED ONE

02:13 - 14.740 DAY BEFORE THE STATUE. FOR SO

02:13 - 16.340 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT WHAT

02:13 - 19.250 HAPPENED AFTER THAT. BUT I

02:13 - 20.530 GUESS I KNOW.

02:13 - 24.680 IS THERE A LIE.

02:13 - 28.110 OF COURSE WE'RE TOLD

02:13 - 29.850 THAT ONCE I KNEW IF THE CASE

02:13 - 31.260 SHOULD YOU DISH ACROSS S.

02:13 - 33.850 THE PLANE HAS BEEN ON SHIFTING

02:13 - 35.220 THE BURDEN TO KEEP MOVING THE

02:13 - 37.380 CASE FORWARD THROUGH THE

02:13 - 39.750 THROUGH THE SYSTEM AND NOT.

02:13 - 42.520 LOT BE

02:13 - 44.750 DELAYED BECAUSE THIS UP I KNEW

02:13 - 46.460 THAT JIM BECAME THE RESOURCES

02:13 - 47.190 OF OUR JUDICIAL.

02:13 - 50.210 AND SO YOU JUST

02:13 - 51.980 DESPAIR HYPOTHETICAL, IF YOU

02:13 - 53.330 FILE A COMPLAINT YOU PROTECT

02:13 - 54.720 THE STATUTE AND NEARLY

02:13 - 56.230 FOUR-YEAR IN DOUBT DO ANYTHING.

02:13 - 59.010 THE SERVER THAT SERVICE I WOULD

02:13 - 01.660 TEND TO AGREE WITH YOUR

02:14 - 03.740 POSITION OR NOT THE EYE OF THE

02:14 - 04.170 HIGHLY.

02:14 - 07.060 >>AND THEN THE FUNDING OF ONE

02:14 - 08.780 OTHER ONE OTHER POINT ON

02:14 - 20.410 WELL AND THIS ISN'T FOR.

02:14 - 23.380 THE GIRLFRIEND WHO HAS NOT BEEN

02:14 - 25.110 PROVIDED WITH THAT STORM KNOWN

02:14 - 26.160 AS SOME CALL IT WAS

02:14 - 29.770 PURPOSE OF THE STATUE ON

02:14 - 32.940 THE OCEANS IS TO PROVIDE WHO

02:14 - 36.490 THE HOME. ONCE A LOT OF COUPLES

02:14 - 38.920 WHO HAS LONG WHAT WAS THEIRS.

02:14 - 40.880 THOSE RESIDENTS AND I WOULD

02:14 - 42.570 SUGGEST WE WILL ALSO PRACTICAL

02:14 - 42.880 MATTER.

02:14 - 45.430 THE DEFENDANT FILES ON THE

02:14 - 48.210 MEMORIAL WALL. ALWAYS

02:14 - 48.760 A FARM

02:14 - 51.150 THAT GOFUNDME HAS HOLDS HIS

02:14 - 51.790 POLLS HOLD

02:14 - 54.200 THE MARKET TO DETERMINE THE

02:14 - 59.990 HOMES FILE. IT'S THE FIRST MOVE

02:15 - 03.870 THE FAMILY DOESN'T KNOW WHERE

02:15 - 05.960 THE WEAKNESSES ARE WHO FROM

02:15 - 08.210 DOESN'T KNOW WHO WITNESSES ALL

02:15 - 10.560 MEMORIES HAVE FADED THE FORMAL

02:15 - 12.200 STILL NO EVIDENCE

02:15 - 16.130 KNOW IF IT'S A CAR ACCIDENT

02:15 - 18.020 HOLES WHERE THE WORK OF ART.

02:15 - 21.520 SO BY REQUIRING BULL'S EYE VIEW

02:15 - 23.840 OF ALL THIS THE COURT

02:15 - 24.400 WILL BE.

02:15 - 30.500 THAT HOLD BOTH TO HIRE HOLDS OF

02:15 - 32.330 HIS FATHER AND BEFORE WHO

02:15 - 33.970 HARMAN WELL BECAUSE IT WAS

02:15 - 36.420 ACTUAL FIRE. ALWAYS SOMEONE WHO

02:15 - 38.770 WERE ON A SCHOOL BUS CONTRARY

02:15 - 40.700 TO HER WHO WAS BOSS WILL IMPOSE

02:15 - 43.000 TOLLS IT'S ALSO CONTRARY TO OUR

02:15 - 45.240 RULES BOTH WHO WAS ON THE STAFF

02:15 - 47.070 SOME CLOSE CALLS ON SO.

02:15 - 51.070 >>I'M KIM POSEY GET IT DONE YOU

02:15 - 55.120 SITUATION IN REALLY I NEVER GOT

02:15 - 56.910 TO HEAR YOUR GET HIM BACK.

02:16 - 02.000 >>WE NOT KNOW WHERE THE MOTIVE

02:16 - 04.370 MOTOR VEHICLE CURRENTLY IS THE

02:16 - 05.510 BEFORE THE STATUTE OF

02:16 - 06.210 LIMITATIONS.

02:16 - 10.660 >>IS IT SOME OF IT REALLY IS

02:16 - 13.110 A MOVING PARTY IN. I'M

02:16 - 15.860 GOOD AT IF YOU ARE TAKING AWAY.

02:16 - 20.270 WHAT YOU BELIEVE WILL BE IN

02:16 - 22.540 ORDER TO IMPORTS.

02:16 - 26.690 WHAT EVERYBODY IS TAKING QUICK

02:16 - 27.480 WHICH SHOULD BE COOL.

02:16 - 31.210 >>WELL I THINK OFF LITTLE SO I

02:16 - 32.810 THOUGHT THAT WELL WE WILL

02:16 - 37.360 NOT TO

02:16 - 41.580 HOPEFULS WAR FOLLOWS A CRUISE.

02:16 - 44.240 I'D ALSO LIKE THE OUTCOME OF

02:16 - 46.970 THIS CASE IS ON THIS. THE CREW

02:16 - 47.420 SET UP.

02:16 - 50.920 >>THE

02:16 - 53.390 SITUATION WHERE IF OR WHEN THAT

02:16 - 54.560 WILL MOST WHO

02:16 - 57.350 WERE OFFENDED. ALL WE CAN START

02:17 - 02.470 WHO WHO WERE THERE WAS

02:17 - 06.740 COLD FOR ONE SUPPORT THIS

02:17 - 11.950 WHO ALSO YOUR QUEST TO

02:17 - 12.350 THE LEFT.

02:17 - 17.300 WE FOR SCHOOL AND ARE BOTH FOR

02:17 - 18.480 HOME COURSE ON

02:17 - 22.050 THE FORMS ALL WE A SCHOOL

02:17 - 25.100 COURT WANTS

02:17 - 27.000 THAT FALLS TO LOCAL CIVIL

02:17 - 30.170 COZENS AND WHO HOME SCHOOLS AGO

02:17 - 31.950 IN JUNE. THE PROSECUTION WILL

02:17 - 33.760 HOLMES A COURT'S LEGAL FUND

02:17 - 36.490 WILL GAIN SCHOOL HOMES AND I

02:17 - 39.000 FOR A LONG AND FOR HIM NOT TO

02:17 - 41.570 HOLD SCHOOLS ALLOW US IN HEART.

02:17 - 52.110 WORK ON

02:17 - 54.250 POACHED ALL FOR ALL OF I'VE GOT

02:17 - 56.720 THAT WHOLE NOTICE AND I THINK

02:17 - 58.130 A LOT ALL AS I

02:17 - 00.880 WAS SAYING FORWARD FROM BAR TO

02:18 - 02.630 A HOME LOAN MOVE FOR 30.

02:18 - 06.030 I WAS FOR A STORM OF GOALS,

02:18 - 08.100 THOSE ITEMS WHICH CAUSED HIM TO

02:18 - 09.750 THE FOLD. ALL OF

02:18 - 11.720 THOSE SORTS OF COURSE THIS WILL

02:18 - 14.470 HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH PEOPLE FOR

02:18 - 16.390 WEEKS IN RESPONSE TO THE

02:18 - 17.990 HOMEOWNER AND YES,

02:18 - 20.960 THE COLUMN. SO LITTLE TO COURT.

02:18 - 24.710 FOR MORE INFORMATION MORE

02:18 - 27.510 COSTS. ALL ALL HOMES

02:18 - 30.440 TO ALL. THE SOCIAL MEDIA

02:18 - 32.180 SEARCH WARRANTS. ALL THESE

02:18 - 37.390 POST POLLS, HARD OUT NOT TO BE

02:18 - 39.270 SUCCESSFUL WHO FILED WITH THE

02:18 - 39.600 COURT

02:18 - 41.780 FOR SPECIALS A SPECIAL WORD FOR

02:18 - 43.370 ALL PART OF THE SERVICE.

02:18 - 45.600 I WOULD SUGGEST THAT SERVICE

02:18 - 47.270 WILL BE ACCOMPLISHED. A LOT

02:18 - 49.610 WILL FOR US ALL AND I HOPE THE

02:18 - 52.350 FOOD SIDE JUST RESPOND TO THIS.

02:18 - 55.230 WELL THERE ARE NO HARM TO ALL

02:18 - 57.310 THERE HAS BEEN A VOCAL SAFE.

02:19 - 03.380 TO FIND THE CAUSE OF OUR HOME

02:19 - 07.130 WHO WANTS TO HAVE ACTUAL THE

02:19 - 14.650 >>IF YOU DO THAT YOU'RE STAYING

02:19 - 15.940 WITH THE CREASE.

02:19 - 23.250 >>AND I THINK

02:19 - 24.920 I THINK I THINK

02:19 - 27.130 PEOPLE JUST BEFORE THE JUSTICE

02:19 - 31.490 PHONE. IT WAS JUST A SPARE ONE

02:19 - 34.170 WHOM HE SPOKE OF LA CRUZ

02:19 - 37.580 WAS NOT LOOKING OWN GOALS.

02:19 - 41.570 MY WHOLE ALL OF YOU. ALL WERE

02:19 - 43.870 ON BOTH FRONTS LOCAL ALL TOO.

02:19 - 47.260 AND I THINK PEOPLE WHO SAY MORE

02:19 - 49.020 FOOTBALL TO IS WHAT

02:19 - 52.550 SCHOOL WHOLE WORLD TO ALL OF

02:19 - 54.560 THOSE WORDS, REASONABLE HOMES

02:19 - 57.270 AND TO ALL HOMES ON WHEELS.

02:19 - 00.320 ALL ONLINE ON OUR SOURCE A

02:20 - 05.390 SO SCHOOL ZONES ARE NOT YOU OR

02:20 - 05.560 MORE.

02:20 - 10.230 >>THANK YOU ON THAT.

02:20 - 12.900 GOOD JOB. THAT WAS THE.

02:20 - 17.410 FOR BEING HERE ON.

02:20 - 19.820 IT'S A

02:20 - 24.640 >>IF YOU'RE ON A NUMBER

02:20 - 27.350 4 WOULD BE ARGUING REMOTELY 5

02:20 - 29.110 THE SUPREME COURT PUBLIC SCHOOL

02:20 - 30.880 LIFE. HOW.

02:20 - 32.690 >>WE'RE VERY WELL IT'S NOT US.

02:20 - 34.990 THE IDEA HAS BEEN THE SAME

02:20 - 36.330 FOR HIM THAT'S WE

02:20 - 38.010 CAN DO UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES

02:20 - 39.220 WE REACH A YEAR.

02:20 - 42.380 >>IT'S LIKE A FOOTBALL GAME

02:20 - 43.520 WITH OFFENSE.

02:20 - 49.430 >>A BREAK AND THEN IT COULD BE

02:20 - 49.850 ARGUED.

02:20 - 55.300 >>IS COMMITTED TO KEEPING

02:20 - 56.840 PENNSYLVANIANS INFORMED THROUGH

02:20 - 58.600 THIS DIFFICULT TIME. JOIN US

02:20 - 00.290 FOR CORONAVIRUS IMPACT,

02:21 - 01.800 THE DISCUSSION WAS CIVIC

02:21 - 03.500 BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENT LEADERS

02:21 - 05.400 ON COVID-19 IMPACT IN

02:21 - 07.540 PENNSYLVANIA. WATCH EPISODES ON

02:21 - 09.420 DEMAND PLUS LIVE UP TO THE

02:21 - 10.590 MINUTE INFORMATION FROM THE

02:21 - 11.660 GOVERNOR AND DEPARTMENT OF

02:21 - 13.570 HEALTH A PC AND TV

02:21 - 16.560 DOT COM. WATCH PCN ON CABLE AND

02:21 - 18.940 STREAMING FREE ON THE PCN APP.

02:21 - 24.410 >>IN THE NEXT

02:21 - 26.410 MATTER IS CHESTER WATER

02:21 - 27.960 AUTHORITY VERSUS THE CUTS BEING

02:21 - 29.300 PERMANENT COMMUNITY AND

02:21 - 30.320 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

02:21 - 32.080 REPRESENTING THE WATER

02:21 - 34.610 AUTHORITY IS. MISTER KEVIN GO

02:21 - 36.820 WE CAN REPRESENTING THE

02:21 - 38.860 DEPARTMENT IS MISTER JUSTIN A

02:21 - 39.270 SUMMER.

02:21 - 43.970 >>GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS CASE

02:21 - 45.230 INVOLVES A PROVISION IN

02:21 - 46.910 PENNSYLVANIA RIGHT TO KNOW LAW.

02:21 - 48.150 WHICH IS

02:21 - 49.480 THIS CLOSURE

02:21 - 51.180 INFORMATION RELATED TO THE

02:21 - 52.300 AGENCY'S INTERNAL

02:21 - 53.210 DELIBERATIONS.

02:21 - 56.760 THE PRIMARY COMMUNICATION.

02:21 - 58.690 BETWEEN NATIONS.

02:21 - 01.550 AND SOME CONTRACTORS HIRED BY

02:22 - 02.960 THE AGENCY CONTRACT.

02:22 - 06.700 THIS CLOSURE AND THE STAFF.

02:22 - 09.790 ADDITIONALLY A FEW CONCERNS

02:22 - 11.070 WHETHER EXCEPTIONS TO THE

02:22 - 12.070 MOVEMENT DOCTOR.

02:22 - 14.800 IF I WOULD REGARD TO DISCLOSURE

02:22 - 16.880 OF CERTAIN DOCUMENTS. THEY WERE

02:22 - 18.970 INITIALLY WITHHELD BASED ON A

02:22 - 21.010 PLANE TICKET CLIENT PRIVILEGE

02:22 - 23.430 AND THE WORK. PRODUCT DOCTOR.

02:22 - 28.040 THEY INCLUDE

02:22 - 28.510 THE COURT.

02:22 - 31.040 >>I'M KEN KEN CONNOR BRIAN YOU

02:22 - 32.770 KNOW I REPRESENT JUST THE WORLD

02:22 - 34.620 ARE IN LARGE REGIONAL WATER

02:22 - 35.780 AUTHORITY SHOULD BE OVER

02:22 - 37.780 200,000 RESIDENTS THROUGHOUT

02:22 - 39.470 CHESTER LOWER COUNTIES.

02:22 - 42.080 SHE ALWAYS ENGAGED

02:22 - 44.080 IN EXISTENTIAL FIGHT WHEN

02:22 - 45.850 POSSIBLE TAKEOVER OF THE SYSTEM

02:22 - 47.660 ITSELF TO A PRIVATE IN THE

02:22 - 49.540 AFTER CWA REJECTED AN

02:22 - 51.060 UNSOLICITED PURCHASE OFFER

02:22 - 54.140 2017. IT IS IN THIS CONTEXT,

02:22 - 55.590 IT'S YOU KNOW YOU AMY GREAT

02:22 - 57.560 TO CLASS THE BLOCK AND IT'S AN

02:22 - 59.000 EASY THESE POSSESSION,

02:22 - 01.520 INCLUDING COMMUNICATIONS ALONG

02:23 - 02.330 THE C B.

02:23 - 05.750 THE AK 47 RECOVERY FOR NEW YORK

02:23 - 07.470 CITY CHESTER, THE CONSUL.

02:23 - 10.000 THE COUNCIL'S FINANCIAL ADVISOR

02:23 - 12.720 FEMA CAPITAL. MANY COUPLES LAW

02:23 - 14.360 FIRM, NICE WALLACE.

02:23 - 16.710 JUST AS FAIR IN YESTERDAY'S

02:23 - 19.540 FIRST ARGUMENT IS TELLING WHAT

02:23 - 20.990 WILL THE COMMONWEALTH COURT.

02:23 - 22.240 WHAT ARE YOU TO

02:23 - 24.650 SUPPORT YOU. WELL ALL I WANT IS

02:23 - 26.950 YOUR QUESTION NOW IN THIS CASE.

02:23 - 28.630 THE COMMONWEALTH COURT'S

02:23 - 30.700 I WAS USING POLICY

02:23 - 32.430 CONSIDERATIONS FROM A SEPARATE

02:23 - 32.970 STATUTE.

02:23 - 35.300 NAMELY

02:23 - 38.030 AK 47 TO OVERRIDE THE PLAIN

02:23 - 39.530 LANGUAGE OF THE DECISION TO

02:23 - 41.520 LEAVE THE GENTIAN RIGHT TO KNOW

02:23 - 43.570 LAW WHICH IS WE ARE IN THE

02:23 - 45.280 LIVER HAS TO THE CATEGORIES

02:23 - 47.110 INCLUDED IT WASN'T THROUGH TO

02:23 - 49.470 THE AGENCY AND JUST AS CLEAR

02:23 - 50.540 MISSION OTHER

02:23 - 52.930 COUNTY CLERKS THE CALL FOR

02:23 - 54.480 LEGISLATIVE INTO POLICY

02:23 - 55.320 REGARDING WHAT SHOULD BE

02:23 - 57.090 SHIELDED FROM PUBLIC VIEW AND

02:23 - 00.130 BY DOING SO WHO NEEDS IN TERMS

02:24 - 00.900 THAT ARE NOT THERE.

02:24 - 03.460 LIKE CONTRACTORS THEN THERE'S

02:24 - 04.790 THE CONTRACTORS OR

02:24 - 06.990 SUBCONTRACTORS, THIS COURT

02:24 - 08.750 SHOULD REVERSE AND HOLD THESE

02:24 - 10.820 ACTION IS NOT IT'S TIME

02:24 - 13.830 TO PARTY IN THE SUBCONTRACTORS

02:24 - 16.170 OF THE COURTHOUSE CONTRACTORS.

02:24 - 19.710 2 SHORT YEARS THE CLEAN ROOMS,

02:24 - 21.820 THE GENERAL WILSON WHO CHOSE IT

02:24 - 23.580 WAS VERY NARROW EXEMPTIONS.

02:24 - 26.170 WHO CAN ALL STOP AND FOR

02:24 - 27.430 WHATEVER QUESTIONS.

02:24 - 36.580 APPRECIATE THE ALEUTIAN THE

02:24 - 37.690 YESTERDAY IT SEEMED LIKE A

02:24 - 38.520 LIFETIME AGO.

02:24 - 49.830 >>IT'S MY PERIOD.

02:24 - 52.770 IT HAPPENS RARELY THE MEN AND

02:24 - 55.320 THEY DO HAVE EXPECT A COREY

02:24 - 56.760 PERCEPTION OF OPEN THIS.

02:24 - 58.670 THEY LIGHT OFF.

02:25 - 02.840 YOU COULD FIT IN THE ORDER.

02:25 - 14.120 IT NEEDS. A LOT OF WORK

02:25 - 17.360 47 CASE.

02:25 - 20.600 BECAUSE THE DEPARTMENT.

02:25 - 23.960 IN ECONOMIC IN ELEMENTS

02:25 - 29.230 NEVER ASKED WHO EMPLOYEES OR

02:25 - 31.610 THE LIKE THE WAY AK 47 IS

02:25 - 34.210 CONSTRUCTED YOU POINTING AT 40

02:25 - 37.690 CORRIDOR IN HIGH AS HE SENT ME

02:25 - 39.420 HERE THE THE LAW FIRM

02:25 - 42.760 AND THE FAIRMONT THAT CAPITAL

02:25 - 43.350 ADVISORS.

02:25 - 47.070 AND THEY FORMED THE AT 2017 IT

02:25 - 49.970 WORKS IS. THE GUARD IS CALLED

02:25 - 50.770 QUOTE 5.

02:25 - 55.670 WHO OR THE LIKE A DAY AT THE

02:25 - 55.870 HALF.

02:25 - 00.780 IF WE'RE GOING TO SAY THAT

02:26 - 01.290 WHEN.

02:26 - 06.940 NEW COMMUNICATIONS THE QUEEN WE

02:26 - 09.570 HAVE 47 A COORDINATOR

02:26 - 11.860 AND ITS IT'S SMALL.

02:26 - 13.990 WE

02:26 - 16.200 7 DIVERTING AND AND I KNEW WE

02:26 - 16.970 COULD ARGUE THAT THE

02:26 - 17.520 LEGISLATIVE

02:26 - 20.000 FIX IT. THE EARLY 70, MAYBE A

02:26 - 22.600 HANDFUL LEGISLATURE. TO A LOT.

02:26 - 25.210 WHEN 7 RECOVERY GO FORWARD

02:26 - 28.340 WITH IT AND HE STAND IN A

02:26 - 30.380 COUPLE FAITH AMONG THE 15.

02:26 - 38.230 >>IN HERE. I THINK YOUR

02:26 - 39.700 QUESTION IDENTIFIES THE

02:26 - 41.140 FUNDAMENTAL PROBLEM WITH THE

02:26 - 43.110 WATER FORTUNATELY ALL WAS IN.

02:26 - 45.320 >>IF YOU START WITH THE PREMISE

02:26 - 47.660 OF THE POLICIES ONLINE ACT FOR

02:26 - 49.340 THE SHOW THAT'S A SEPARATE

02:26 - 50.780 STATUTE WHO LIKELY WILL.

02:26 - 53.330 IN HERE IN TERMS OF

02:26 - 57.860 LAW IS VERY CLEAR AND.

02:26 - 59.260 >>THE B B.

02:26 - 01.230 >>LEGISLATION COULD HAVE

02:27 - 04.100 REALLY UNCERTAIN. ENTITIES THAT

02:27 - 05.330 SHOULD BE SUBJECT TO THIS

02:27 - 07.560 EXEMPTION. THE WHITE. I

02:27 - 10.420 4740 YEARS OR CONTRACTORS.

02:27 - 13.660 WELL. THE THE DEPARTMENT

02:27 - 16.140 IN IT WROTE IN CERTAIN

02:27 - 18.810 CATEGORIES LIKE EMPLOYEES THE

02:27 - 21.700 NEXT NO ONE. SO I I.

02:27 - 25.050 JUST AS A MONEY.

02:27 - 27.830 I GUESS I TAKE I TAKE ISSUE

02:27 - 30.110 WITH THE MEDIA. WHAT NUMBER YOU

02:27 - 32.630 PROVIDED HOW TO WALK. 2 IN THE

02:27 - 35.960 OLD LAW OR 2 TO AK 47.

02:27 - 37.420 AS

02:27 - 39.000 A WAY FOR PUTTING THE RIGHT TO

02:27 - 41.710 KNOW LAW IN THE FIRST. AND I

02:27 - 44.590 YOU KNOW THAT'S THAT'S A BIG

02:27 - 46.980 ISSUE IN THIS AND ONE OF THE

02:27 - 48.830 FUNDAMENTAL AND I THINK THAT

02:27 - 51.950 WAS MADE. SO MY QUESTION TO YOU

02:27 - 52.360 THANK YOU.

02:27 - 58.120 CENTRAL ARGUMENT OF THE

02:27 - 00.830 STATUTORY LINE. DO YOU NOT HAVE

02:28 - 02.040 THE RIGHT TO KNOW LAW.

02:28 - 04.710 IT SAYS THE JOBS FROM

02:28 - 07.200 THIS CLOSURE. COLONEL LEADERS

02:28 - 08.630 SAY OF THE LIBERATION OF THE

02:28 - 09.340 DAY TOO.

02:28 - 12.450 >>ITS MEMBERS EMPLOYEES ARE

02:28 - 12.860 FACING.

02:28 - 14.690 IT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT

02:28 - 17.170 CONTRACTORS LOVE STUFF THAT

02:28 - 17.490 CORRECT.

02:28 - 27.340 A SUMMIT THAT WE HAVE TO READ

02:28 - 28.980 WORDS IN THE BACK.

02:28 - 32.110 >>SHE JUST AS YOU ARE

02:28 - 33.580 EXACTLY RIGHT THAT IS OUR

02:28 - 34.970 ARGUMENT YOU WOULD HAVE TO

02:28 - 36.720 LEAVE WORDS INTO THAT STATUE

02:28 - 38.790 AND WE THINK THAT WOULD BE

02:28 - 40.480 ENTIRELY INAPPROPRIATE IN THIS

02:28 - 41.340 CONTEXT THAT'S THE

02:28 - 43.910 LEGISLATURE'S JOB TO DO.

02:28 - 55.980 AND ONE

02:28 - 57.630 POINT I WOULD POINT OUT TO

02:28 - 59.470 JUSTICE IF YOU LOOK AT THIS

02:28 - 01.330 COURTS. THE KENYAN GOVERNMENT

02:29 - 03.600 VERSUS WANTED TO TAKE YOU WHICH

02:29 - 04.910 ISN'T RIGHT. NO DECISION.

02:29 - 07.790 THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT THIS COURT.

02:29 - 10.950 SUGGESTED NOT BE DONE BY THE

02:29 - 12.160 COURSE OF THIS COMMONWEALTH

02:29 - 14.700 WHICH IS WE TURN INTO THE HANDS

02:29 - 15.930 OF THE RIGHT TO KNOW LAW THAT

02:29 - 17.970 SIMPLY ARE NOT THERE IN THAT

02:29 - 19.900 CASE IT WILL SECTION 9 OH ONE

02:29 - 21.290 THAT HAD TO DO WITH.

02:29 - 25.120 BY.

02:29 - 29.940 RECORDS OFFICER. OF AN AGENCY

02:29 - 31.330 AND IN THAT TIME FRAME

02:29 - 34.420 THAT TRIGGERED. AND THE COURT

02:29 - 35.280 SHOULD RULE YOU

02:29 - 37.150 NEED THIS THE COURTS NEED TO

02:29 - 38.930 STAY CLEAN FORMS A RIGHT TO

02:29 - 40.730 KNOW LAWS THAT ARE PRETTY THEY

02:29 - 43.090 REJECTED POLICY CONSIDERATIONS

02:29 - 45.640 ALSO CAN CONSIDERATIONS CASE,

02:29 - 45.950 WE'RE

02:29 - 48.590 TIED DIRECTLY TO WEIGHT LOSS

02:29 - 49.630 OFF THE STATUE BEING

02:29 - 52.360 INTERVIEWED. HERE I THINK THE

02:29 - 54.160 ARGUMENT THAT'S BEING MADE BY

02:29 - 56.450 THE C D THOSE

02:29 - 58.710 EVEN FURTHER AND THIS IS

02:29 - 59.040 LOOKING

02:29 - 02.370 AT 47. AND THE POLICIES ONLINE

02:30 - 04.000 SEPARATE STATUTE EASY TO

02:30 - 06.050 INTERPRET INSERT WORDS LIKE

02:30 - 07.470 CONTRACTOR INTO THE RIGHT TO

02:30 - 07.790 KNOW.

02:30 - 10.920 THERE

02:30 - 13.200 AGAIN SO AND I THINK YOU DID

02:30 - 14.600 ANSWERED MY QUESTIONS HERE

02:30 - 14.930 WELL.

02:30 - 18.360 >>I THINK WITH THE COMMONWEALTH

02:30 - 20.800 COURT WAS SAYING IS THE MUCH

02:30 - 22.740 FOR THE YEAR BEFORE. BUT LOOK

02:30 - 22.860 AT

02:30 - 25.290 LEGISLATIVE INTENT AND WHO

02:30 - 26.690 UNDERSTAND THE LEGISLATIVE

02:30 - 29.200 INTENT. THE HIGH DASH 47.

02:30 - 31.440 AND THE LEGISLATURE

02:30 - 34.850 ARE NOT THINK OF ALL THE

02:30 - 37.740 VARIOUS PLACES WHERE. THE OPEN

02:30 - 39.080 RECORDS IN THE RIGHT TO KNOW

02:30 - 41.510 LAW. WE'RE GOING TO INTERSECT

02:30 - 42.290 WITH OTHER LAW

02:30 - 43.800 IF THEY HAD THOUGHT OF THE

02:30 - 45.080 LEGISLATION THAT

02:30 - 47.950 WOULD BE TO ALLOW AT 7 TO BE

02:30 - 49.490 AFFECTED. THE GARDEN.

02:30 - 53.050 THE COMMUNITY TO ALLOW THE AK

02:30 - 54.860 47 CAME TO WORK ON BEHALF OF

02:30 - 55.400 THE APARTMENT.

02:30 - 58.920 IT IS THAT THEY DO NOT RATE IS.

02:31 - 02.260 >>THEY SAY THAT THEY'VE BEEN

02:31 - 02.770 SENT THERE.

02:31 - 08.540 >>I DON'T THINK IT'S OUTRAGEOUS

02:31 - 10.620 KNOW, BUT I THINK IT IS

02:31 - 14.110 CONTRARY TO THIS COURTS.

02:31 - 16.910 THEY'VE BEEN AND WHAT I MEAN BY

02:31 - 18.090 THAT IS IF YOU LOOK AT THE

02:31 - 20.320 COMMON LAW COURTS CAN YOU.