00:05 - WE DO WELCOME EVERYONE TO A

00:08 - SESSION OF THE SUPREME COURT.

00:10 - IN LIGHT OF THE CURRENT PUBLIC

00:12 - HEALTH SITUATION WHO ARE

00:14 - CONDUCTING THIS SESSION,

00:16 - REMOTELY.

00:18 - THE COURT FOUND IT BEST PROCEED

00:20 - IN THIS MATTER.

00:22 - RATHER THAN CANCELING OR

00:23 - POSTPONING THE SESSION.

00:26 - BECAUSE IT IS VITAL THAT COURTS

00:27 - CONTINUE TO FUNCTION. EVEN IN

00:30 - THE MOST DIFFICULT. I'M.

00:33 - TRADITIONALLY ARE COURT DOES

00:35 - NOT IMPOSE TIME LIMITS ON

00:36 - COUNCIL.

00:38 - BUT DUE TO THE UNIQUE

00:40 - CIRCUMSTANCE.

00:42 - WE HAVE DEVELOPED A SPECIAL

00:43 - PROTOCOL WHICH HAS BEEN

00:45 - FORWARDED TO ALL COUNCIL WHO

00:47 - WILL BE PRESENTING TARGET.

00:50 - COUNCIL FOR A TALENT AND KELLY.

00:54 - WE EACH HAVE A MAXIMUM OF

00:55 - 20 MINUTES. WITH THE FIRST 3

00:58 - MINUTES RESERVED, WE'RE IN

00:59 - OPENING STATEMENT.

01:02 - YOU MANAGE THOSE REMARKS.

01:05 - WE WOULD ASK COUNCIL TO KEEP AN

01:07 - EYE ON THEIR WATCHES.

01:09 - BUT I WORKED IN THAT COMMUNITY

01:11 - MARK AND ASKED THEM TO PROPERLY

01:14 - HAVE CONCLUDED.

01:16 - THIS ISSUE OF QUESTIONS, WE'LL

01:19 - POSE THEM IN THEIR PRE SAID

01:20 - ORDER.

01:22 - SO THE ACTUAL MIGHT FOCUS

01:23 - THEIR ATTENTION IS ASKING THE

01:27 - QUESTION.

01:29 - BY MIA, AS YOU COSTUME. I WILL

01:32 - RESTATE THE CASE IN ORDER TO

01:34 - FRAME THE ISSUE BEFORE OR.

01:38 - MISTER MANNER WOULD YOU PLEASE

01:40 - CALL THE CAGE.

01:43 - DO YOU GET LESS.

01:49 - >>IS THERE OR

01:50 - A MISS. PRESENT WAS ON IT IS

01:53 - JUST WRONG.

01:57 - >>EVEN THE

01:58 - MORNING AGAIN. AT THE COURT

02:00 - HAS A EXERCISE AN EXTRAORDINARY

02:03 - FORMER JURISDICTION. WOULD YOU

02:05 - CONSIDER A CHALLENGE TO

02:07 - A POLICY PROHIBITING THE USE OF

02:10 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA BY

02:12 - INDIVIDUALS. UNDER THE

02:14 - SUPERVISION OF THE LEBANON

02:15 - COUNTY PROBATION SERVICE.

02:18 - >>YOU.

02:25 - >>GOOD MORNING TO YOU JUST AS

02:26 - MEMBERS OF THE COURT.

02:29 - JUST WANNA MAKE SURE EVERYONE

02:30 - CAN HEAR ME BEFORE IT BEGAN BY

02:32 - THANK YOU. MAY IT PLEASE

02:35 - THE COURT. THERE IS A PIECE OF

02:37 - THE PENNSYLVANIA WHERE THE

02:39 - PETITIONERS WHAT THE GAP

02:41 - ACTUALLY BANNED IT AND YOU

02:42 - COOK.

02:45 - THEY COME FROM AND SAYS THAT A

02:47 - TORY SKI. THAT'S PART OF THE

02:49 - QUALIFICATIONS TO USE MEDICAL

02:51 - MARIJUANA.

02:52 - AND GRANTS FOR A PROTECTION TO

02:55 - ENGAGE IN LAW WORKING.

02:57 - IT CONTAINS NO EXCLUSIONS BASED

02:59 - ON CRIMINAL HISTORY OR LESIONS

03:01 - THAT.

03:04 - PATIENT WITH ME

03:05 - JUST 3 CRITERIA BE A RESIDENT

03:07 - OF WHO SUFFERS FROM A SERIOUS

03:09 - MEDICAL CONDITION AND HAS

03:11 - RECEIVED A CERTIFICATION FROM A

03:13 - STATE REGISTER FISH.

03:15 - YEAH, NOT ONLY

03:16 - ALLOW INDIVIDUAL TO MEET

03:18 - REQUIREMENTS AND TAKE MEDICAL

03:20 - MARIJUANA CARD. A LOT WE USE

03:22 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA. BUT IT ALSO

03:24 - BRINGS IN THE SWEEPING

03:25 - IMMUNITY. IT CANNOT BE SUBJECT

03:28 - TO ARREST PROSECUTION OR

03:31 - PENALTY IN ANY MANNER OR DENY

03:33 - ANY RIGHT OR PRIVILEGE. ONLY

03:36 - FOR LAWFUL USING MEDICAL WATCH.

03:39 - THEN YOU CAN SAID THE GENERAL

03:40 - ASSEMBLY STATED INTEREST AND

03:42 - PROVIDING A PROGRAM OF ACCESS.

03:45 - THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

03:47 - WHILE BACK IN THE NEED TO

03:48 - PROMOTE THE ACCESS TO LEAD US

03:50 - TREATMENT TO PATIENTS 80.

03:54 - EACH OF THE ISSUES IN THIS

03:55 - CASE IS A MEDICAL MARIJUANA

03:57 - PATIENT WHO SUFFERS FROM A

03:58 - SERIOUS MEDICAL CONDITION.

04:02 - EXPERIENCED AND CHILL REALLY

04:04 - FROM THEIR SEPARATE. USE OF

04:07 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

04:08 - THE PASSAGE OF THE MEDICAL

04:09 - MARIJUANA

04:11 - 2016. ALLOWED THE PETITIONS

04:13 - AWFULLY ACCIDENT MEDICAL

04:15 - TREATMENT THAT COULD MEAN FOR

04:16 - THEIR LIVES.

04:18 - HEAR THAT LEAD TO THE

04:19 - LEGISLATORS HAD IN MIND WHEN

04:21 - THE HAT YET.

04:25 - 2019 THE SECOND JUDICIAL

04:27 - DISTRICT ADOPTED AT ALL.

04:29 - HITTING THE PETITIONERS FROM

04:30 - USING MEDICAL MARIJUANA SIMPLY

04:32 - BECAUSE THEY'RE ON PROBATION.

04:35 - THE POLICY APPLIES

04:36 - TO EVERYONE UNDER THE

04:38 - SUPERVISION OF THE LEBANON

04:39 - COUNTY PROBATION SERVICES

04:40 - DEPARTMENT AND PROHIBIT THEM

04:42 - FROM USING MEDICAL MARIJUANA

04:43 - EVEN IF THEY HAVE IN MEDICAL

04:45 - MARIJUANA CARD FROM THE STATES.

04:47 - YOU SHOULD JUST ACCEPT A PLEA

04:49 - AT AN EXCEPTION.

04:51 - THE POLICY THAT ALLOWS PATIENTS

04:52 - TO PETITION.

04:53 - THE COURT TO ESTABLISH THAT

04:55 - THEY'RE USING THE MARIJUANA

04:56 - DEBATE

04:56 - MEDICAL NECESSITY. THIS

04:58 - EXTENSION DOES NOT HERE IN THE

05:01 - NEXT CLIP. THE TEAM, HOW ABOUT

05:03 - YOUR OWN TO ME.

05:05 - FIRST INSERT

05:07 - A REQUIREMENT OF MEDICAL IS

05:08 - THAT SCIENCE AND NOWHERE IN THE

05:10 - ACT AND SECOND

05:12 - STRIPS MEDICAL MARIJUANA

05:13 - PATIENTS THERE YEAH, ITS

05:15 - SUBJECT IN THAT COUNTY. A BOMB.

05:22 - THE SECOND

05:22 - JUDICIAL DISTRICT OR BECOME

05:24 - FIRST A RESERVOIR DISCRETION ON

05:26 - LEBANON COUNTY WERE COMPLETE.

05:28 - THE SECOND PENN AND KIND OF USE

05:30 - THAT.

05:32 - AND PENALIZES THE

05:34 - BALLOT BOWL THAT I PLAY AND I

05:37 - THINK HE WAS IN WHICH THE

05:38 - MEDICAL CARE.

05:41 - >>THANK YOU. YEAH, WELL FIRST I

05:44 - TURNED IT JUST IS FAIR AND STOP

05:47 - MIGHT HAVE A QUESTION.

05:50 - THANK YOU CHIEF

05:53 - MY PRINCIPLE QUESTIONS I THINK

05:54 - FOR THE OTHER SIDE BUT SINCE I

05:55 - HAVE THIS OPPORTUNITY.

05:59 - ALL OF THE

06:00 - SWEEPING RIGHTS GRANTED THE

06:01 - CITIZEN ARE DIMINISHED.

06:03 - 4 SOMEONE INCARCERATED YOUR IN

06:06 - THIS SITUATION.

06:08 - >>AND BE

06:09 - ON PROBATION. THERE'S NO

06:11 - QUESTION THE PROBATION CONSENT

06:13 - CONDITIONS OF PROBATION.

06:14 - YOU AGREE WITH THAT.

06:17 - >>YES YOUR HONOR

06:19 - PROBATION CONDITIONS THAT MEET

06:21 - THEIR ARMS AND THEN TO GO.

06:23 - >>SO ASSUMING ARGUE FOR

06:25 - A SECOND. THAT THE OTHER SIDE

06:27 - AND WE DON'T HAVE REBUTTAL

06:28 - CAN SHOEHORN WHAT'S OCCURRING

06:31 - HERE IN ONE OF THE 13

06:32 - CONDITIONS OF PROBATION OR THE

06:34 - NATIONAL CONDITIONS OF

06:36 - PROBATION AND THEY DO IT.

06:39 - >>NO YOUR HONOR AND THIS IS

06:40 - WHY. GET

06:42 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA GRANTING THAT

06:44 - SWEEPING IMMUNITY MEDICAL

06:46 - MARIJUANA PATIENTS TAKES A

06:48 - DECISION ABOUT WHETHER THE USE

06:50 - OF MARIJUANA.

06:53 - >>THE CONTROL OF TIMES IN COURT

06:55 - WHICH ARE CONSTRAINED BY SENSE

06:56 - A COAT.

06:58 - AND OF COURSE IS BECAUSE THE

06:59 - PEEL STATUTE MILES EAST OR EVEN

07:01 - STRICTER. SO YOU'RE.

07:03 - >>I'M SORRY GO AHEAD AND

07:04 - FINISH.

07:05 - >>AND THEREFORE.

07:08 - YOU HAVE TO READ THIS AND THINK

07:09 - OH AND THE MET MEDICAL

07:10 - MARIJUANA TOGETHER AND WHEN YOU

07:12 - READ THEM TOGETHER.

07:14 - >>YOU.

07:15 - >>AND THAT ANY THE ANY

07:16 - PERMISSION FROM THE NATION THAT

07:18 - FALL UNDER THE CATCH-ALL

07:18 - PROVISION, HAPPY RECENTLY

07:20 - RELATED TO THE REHABILITATION

07:21 - OF THE DEFENDANT AND THEY CAN'T

07:23 - BUY LIKE OTHER LAWS BECOME

07:25 - WILL. THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

07:26 - ADOPTED

07:27 - AND HERE ANY CONDITION THAT WE

07:30 - DON'T HAVE THE SCENT

07:31 - IMPORTANT INSIDE WHO USE

07:33 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA WHICH LEFT

07:34 - AND MUCH OF OUR DNA AND TED

07:37 - WHITE PEOPLE DO YOU HAVE A

07:39 - MARIJUANA PROVISION CONDITION

07:41 - BY MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND NOW

07:43 - MAKING MISSION.

07:44 - >>SO YOU'RE RIGHT I DIDN'T MEAN

07:46 - TO INTERRUPT YOU BEFORE YOU'RE

07:47 - ALMOST ARGUING A

07:48 - CONFLICT PREEMPTION EXPRESS

07:51 - PREEMPTIONS THAT FAIR.

07:53 - >>I THINK IT'S A SIMILAR IDEA.

07:56 - I THINK IF YOU LOOK AT FOR

07:58 - EXAMPLE THIS COURT'S DECISION

08:00 - IN CONGO PERCENT.

08:01 - WELL, THEN WHERE THERE WAS A

08:03 - STATUTE THAT

08:06 - THE SEARCHES THAT COULD BE

08:07 - CARRIED OUT BY THE NATION

08:09 - OFFICERS IS CURRENTLY HELD AT

08:17 - >>A NURSE, CONSTRAINING THE

08:19 - TRIAL COURT'S ABILITY TO HOST A

08:21 - PROBATION CONDITION. WELL OUT

08:23 - TO BE WORTHLESS IF SHE WANTS I

08:26 - THINK THE SAME IS TRUE WITH

08:27 - RESPECT

08:28 - >>AND THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE.

08:31 - JUSTICE TIME.

08:33 - >>THANK YOU

08:34 - CHIEF JUSTICE, TURNING ROSE

08:36 - WOULD YOU DISTINGUISH BETWEEN

08:39 - THIS SITUATION INVOLVING.

08:41 - >>MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND

08:43 - INDIVIDUALS WHO MAYBE

08:45 - AN HOUR AND WHILST COURTS OR

08:49 - DUI COURTS ARE NOT WORDS WITH

08:52 - THE USE OF ALCOHOL BECAUSE AS

08:54 - YOU KNOW MANY OF THESE ARE

08:56 - TOOLS. DRINKING IS CERTAINLY

08:59 - LEGAL.

09:01 - MANY OF THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE

09:02 - NOT PERMITTED TO DRINK WHILE

09:04 - THEY'RE UNDERAGE AUSPICES OUT

09:06 - THE DRONE OR NOT MUELLER

09:08 - ACTUALLY.

09:11 - >>ABSOLUTELY WHAT

09:14 - >>A MARIJUANA. WE DO NOT.

09:17 - THE STATUE TO GRANT A SWEEPING

09:18 - COMMUNITY PEOPLE USE ALCOHOL.

09:20 - WE DO FOR

09:21 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA. YES FOR AN

09:23 - IMPORTANT REASON WHICH IS THAT

09:25 - IN A LITTLE SOMETHING TO EARN A

09:27 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA THE

09:30 - CONTROLLED

09:30 - SUBSTANCES ACT TO ENSURE THAT

09:32 - PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO OF COURSE

09:34 - IT WOULD NO

09:37 - AND HE IS NECESSARY TO ENSURE

09:39 - THAT PEOPLE ARE ABLE TO MEDICAL

09:41 - TREATMENT HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED

09:43 - BY THE

09:43 - FAMILY BY. EXPERTS IN THE FIELD

09:47 - HAS BEEN BRINGING PEOPLE WITH

09:50 - CERTAIN MEDICAL CONDITIONS

09:51 - AND SO I'M VERY DIFFERENT FROM

09:54 - ALCOHOL USE THEM, BUT IT'S BEEN

09:55 - PROTECTED BY STATUTE IN ITALY.

09:59 - AND IT IS A MEDICAL TREATMENT

10:01 - THAT IS RECOMMENDED BY A DOCTOR

10:03 - AND IT'S PART OF THE PROGRAM

10:05 - THAT IS AGAIN TO SWEEPING AND

10:08 - STRENGTH AND EXHAUSTIVE

10:09 - REGULATION BY THE STATE.

10:11 - >>WOULD YOU AGREE THOUGH MISS

10:13 - ROSE STAT IF AN INDIVIDUAL IS

10:15 - PERMITTED TO

10:16 - USE MARIJUANA AT MEDICAL

10:18 - MARIJUANA WHILE ON PROBATION OR

10:20 - KARNAL SUBJECT TO THE

10:22 - RESTRICTIONS OF THE

10:23 - DRUG COURT THAT THEY STILL MUST

10:26 - COMPLY WITH OTHER

10:28 - RESTRICTIONS SUCH AS THEY CAN'T

10:30 - DRIVE ALL THERE UNDER THE

10:31 - INFLUENCE OF IT AND THE LIKE.

10:34 - YES,

10:34 - YOUR HONOR.

10:36 - >>CERTAINLY WITHIN THEIR

10:37 - DISCRETION TO REQUIRE THE END

10:39 - OF OPERATION COMPLY WITH THE

10:41 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA ACT YOU CAN

10:43 - REQUIRE THAT THEY

10:44 - YOU KNOW HAPPENED PRODUCE A CAR

10:46 - THAT YOU CAN SEE SOME GREAT HE

10:48 - SAID THERE'S LOTS OF THING THE

10:49 - TRAVERSE YOU CAN CAN DO TO

10:51 - ENSURE AN INDIVIDUAL IS

10:52 - COMPLYING. WE NEED TO ACT BUT

10:54 - TRUMP NOT

10:55 - TO IT PROHIBIT INDIVIDUALS FROM

10:58 - DOING SOME LEGISLATION THAT WE

10:59 - LOVE TO DO AND I HAD TO

11:01 - DO BUT GRANTED AND HE'S BROUGHT

11:04 - PROTECTIONS TO ENSURE THAT

11:05 - THEIR ACCESS. THIS MEDICAL

11:07 - TREATMENT.

11:10 - >>I DONAHUE.

11:13 - >>GOOD MORNING TO YOU THANK YOU

11:15 - COUNCIL,

11:16 - RIGHT DOWN SO I KNEW I'D

11:18 - LIKE YOU TO FOCUS ON THE

11:20 - LEGISLATURE'S YOU SAID THE

11:22 - PHRASE

11:23 - ON SOLI FOR THE USE OF

11:26 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA. I'M AND IF

11:30 - HE CAN

11:30 - I NOT EXPLAIN TO ME YOUR VIEW

11:34 - OF THAT PHRASE IN THE CONTEXT

11:36 - AND TAKE FOR

11:37 - EXAMPLE, A IN A RESTROOM

11:40 - RECKLESS DRIVING.

11:42 - I'M NOT IF AND AND HIGH IS

11:45 - ARRESTED FOR RECKLESS DRIVING

11:47 - AND AT THE TIME.

11:50 - HE WAS UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF

11:53 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA. WHAT'S THE

11:55 - CONSEQUENCES IN NASSAR COME

11:57 - STANCE. I LIKE TO PLAY JERSEYS

12:00 - OF THE PHRASE CANNOT BE

12:02 - PROSECUTED OR ARRESTED SOLI FOR

12:05 - THE USE OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

12:09 - >>WELL YOU'RE CERTAINLY UNDER

12:10 - THAT SITUATION AND INDIVIDUAL

12:12 - COULD BE ARRESTED FOR RECKLESS

12:13 - DRIVING.

12:14 - AND THIS IMMUNITY IS NOT.

12:20 - BY THE OTHER PARTS OF

12:21 - THE CONOCO

12:22 - IT JUST PREVENTS PEOPLE FROM

12:24 - MAINE, SEN SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN

12:25 - A GUESS O IF HE COULD.

12:28 - THEY ARE.

12:29 - THEY LOVE THEMSELVES OF THE

12:31 - MEDICAL TREATMENT THAT IS NOT

12:32 - PERMISSIBLE UNDER. AND THAT'S

12:33 - THE ONLY GRANTS NOT NOT

12:36 - ANYTHING ELSE THAT

12:37 - WOULD KNOW OTHERWISE SUBJECT TO

12:39 - ARREST OR PROSECUTION FOR THE

12:41 - LOST MONEY.

12:43 - >>SO THAT THEN WOULD

12:44 - RESPONDS TO I I YOUR OPPOSING

12:48 - COUNSEL'S ARGUMENT THAT THIS

12:50 - IS NOT SOLIS FOR THE USE OF

12:52 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA AND THIS IS

12:54 - SOMEBODY

12:54 - WHO IS USING MARIJUANA AND

12:58 - DESIGNER OF H.

13:00 - DIFFERENT CONTEXT

13:01 - AND YEAH.

13:03 - >>YEAH LOOK I THINK THAT IF YOU

13:05 - IF YOU FOLLOW THE

13:08 - THE RESPONDENT THAT ANYONE

13:10 - COULD BE SUBJECT TO ANYONE WHO

13:12 - USES MEDICAL MARIJUANA USE

13:13 - OBJECT TO

13:16 - PRIVILEGED BECAUSE IF YOU'RE A

13:18 - TEACHER IN A SCHOOL THAT YOU

13:20 - COULD SAY WELL

13:20 - YOU'RE NOT JUST MARIJUANA TO

13:25 - TEACHER I WAS NOT SCARED

13:28 - TO PROTECT PEOPLE FROM

13:29 - RETALIATION FOR USING MEDICAL

13:31 - MARIJUANA SO TECHNICAL.

13:33 - >>THANK YOU. DAUGHERTY.

13:39 - I WANT TO FOLLOW UP FROM A

13:41 - JUSTICE TANI YOU JUST INDICATED

13:43 - FOR EXAMPLE TO THE LIKES OF

13:44 - JERRY GOING BACK TO THE WORD.

13:46 - ALL LEE. THE STATUES PERCENT

13:47 - DECREASE PANEL GOING FOR THE

13:49 - USE OF MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

13:51 - BUT HOW DO YOU GET AROUND THE

13:52 - FACT THAT IS NOT SO WE THAT THE

13:54 - UNDERLYING OF BANKS, THE

13:56 - CRIMINAL CONVICTION IS THE

13:58 - BASIS FOR THE IMPOSITION

14:02 - ANY RESTRICTIONS OF HIS OR

14:04 - HER FREEDOM. NOT THE USE OF

14:06 - MARIJUANA IN ANOTHER CELL AS

14:08 - FOR THE U N AND GENERAL SAM,

14:10 - HOW DO YOU DISTINGUISH.

14:12 - >>I THINK THAT IS NATURAL THAT

14:14 - ANY PREVIOUSLY WHICH IN THAT

14:18 - AND

14:18 - THE FACT THAT THE PERSON ON

14:20 - PROBATION DOES NOT ALLOW THEM

14:23 - IN COURT THE DISCRETION TO

14:25 - PREVENT THEM FROM USING

14:26 - MARIJUANA. HE HAD SENT HIM

14:28 - COURT IS CONSTRAINED BY FIRES

14:33 - IT'S THE LATEST REHABILITATION

14:35 - BUT ALSO BY THE MEDICAL

14:36 - MARIJUANA WHICH BROUGHT HIM IN

14:39 - INDIVIDUAL BE

14:41 - TO ARREST

14:45 - PRIVILEGE SO YOU COULD BE

14:46 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA STILL HERE

14:48 - AND THE PERSON OR ON PROBATION.

14:51 - AND WE'RE FOLLOWING EVERY

14:52 - SINGLE CONDITION EXCEPT THE

14:54 - MEDICAL

14:54 - MARIJUANA CONDITION. AND THERE

14:56 - IS NO INFORMATION ABOUT IT

14:59 - WOULD BE REMOTE SOLELY BECAUSE.

15:02 - AND THAT IS WHAT

15:02 - THE LEGISLATURE. TRYING

15:04 - TO PREVENT I THINK THANK YOU.

15:11 - WECHT THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE

15:14 - SIR, GOOD MORNING COUNCIL

15:16 - SUPPOSE A. PROBATION COURT.

15:22 - I HAD

15:23 - THE CIRCUMSTANCES BEFORE IT.

15:28 - THE HOLDER OF A PROBATIONER

15:30 - WITH A MEDICAL MARIJUANA CARD.

15:32 - ALL APPEARED TO BE.

15:36 - ABUSING THAT PRIVILEGE OR.

15:40 - USING THAT PRIVILEGE FOR

15:42 - PURPOSES WHICH WHICH RAN AFOUL

15:44 - OF THE PROBATION COURT'S

15:46 - SUPERVISION, ONE RECOURSE WITH

15:48 - THE JUDGE SHOW.

15:50 - >>SO I MEAN THE JUDGE WOULD BE

15:52 - ABLE TO IMPOSE ANY PENALTY

15:54 - THAT. THEM

15:56 - TO CODE, SOMEONE WHO BY MAKING

15:59 - CONDITION OF ONE OF THE

16:00 - CONDITIONS OF THEIR PROBATION

16:01 - IF YOU HAVE TO KEEP MY

16:02 - MARIJUANA. THE JUDGE AND YOU'RE

16:04 - NOT TO BUY INTO THAT AND YOU

16:06 - COULD BE

16:06 - SUBJECT TO COUNTY AND A RESULT

16:09 - IN ADDITION, THE MEDICAL STAFF

16:12 - IN ADDITION TO HAVING STARTED

16:13 - GETTING OUT OF THE STATE BY LES

16:15 - TIONS MAKE ANY VIOLATION OF THE

16:17 - ACT A MISDEMEANOR.

16:19 - SO YOU KNOW THE COURTS KIND OF

16:21 - LIKE THE SESSIONS FROM TO

16:23 - REQUIRE PEOPLE TO COMPLY WITH

16:25 - MOSSACK SOME INVITED MEDICAL

16:26 - MARIJUANA AND THERE. THEY

16:28 - HAD CRASHED AND I WOULD

16:30 - ALSO BE A QUARTER BASIS TO

16:32 - IMPOSE PENALTIES THAT IMPORTANT

16:34 - THING HERE IS THAT AS LONG AS

16:35 - THE PERSON OPERATING AS I'M IN

16:37 - THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

16:38 - THEN THE TRUMP DOES NOT HAVE

16:39 - DISCRETION TO PENALIZE THEM FOR

16:42 - THAT.

16:43 - >>THEN JUST A QUICK FOLLOW-UP

16:45 - WITH RESPECT TO THAT

16:46 - COMPLIANCE. O ALL

16:48 - HOW HOW DO YOU SEE THE THE

16:51 - HEARING. BEFORE THE JUDGE.

16:55 - DIFFERING FROM WHATEVER

16:56 - THRESHOLD SHOWING IS NEEDED TO

16:59 - GET THE CARD IN FIRST PLACE.

17:04 - >>IN TOMS AND BY THE FALL IN

17:06 - THE WRECKAGE.

17:07 - YES, SO THE HEARING THAT THE

17:08 - POLICY CONFLICTS LIKE A BIRD.

17:12 - HE SAID I'M I'M

17:14 - COURTNEY PERMISSION TO

17:15 - ESTABLISH HUGE THE COURT'S TEST

17:19 - MET ON THE SET. ANALYSTS AT

17:20 - CITI IT'S VERY DIFFERENT FROM

17:22 - WHAT AND THEY DON'T HAVE TO

17:24 - ESTABLISH TO OBTAIN A MEDICAL

17:26 - MARIJUANA CARD YEAH DOCTOR TO

17:29 - CERTIFY THAT THEY HAD ONE OF

17:30 - THE 20 LISTED IN SERIOUS

17:32 - CONDITION IN A STATUTE AND

17:34 - REGULATIONS AND THE DOCTOR

17:36 - HAS TO IF THE INDIVIDUAL MAY BE

17:40 - ABLE TO MAYBE SEE SOME BENEFIT.

17:44 - FROM THE USE OF

17:45 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA THAT IS A FAR

17:47 - LOWER

17:47 - THRESHOLD THEN IT'S TYPICAL

17:50 - WHICH IS TYPICALLY AM I THINK

17:53 - LAST RESORT.

17:55 - BUT WHEN IT

17:56 - COMES TO HEALTHY TO PLAY WHEN A

17:58 - PERSON HAS TO SHOW IN ORDER AND

18:02 - I GET IT FIRST, EVEN IF

18:07 - BURN COURT. THEY HAVE A MEDICAL

18:09 - NECESSITY THAT HURTS PEOPLE

18:11 - GAUGING IN THAT PROCESS.

18:13 - SO.

18:14 - >>THANK YOU FOR YOU.

18:17 - I'M GOING TO

18:17 - ASK A JUSTICE MIND IF SHE HAS A

18:20 - QUESTION AND HE DOES YOU GOOD.

18:23 - AND RESPOND TO THAT QUESTION

18:24 - AND THEN NOW CONCLUDED

18:27 - YOUR ARGUMENT. YES THIS MONTH.

18:35 - SO I HAVE NO QUESTIONS THANK

18:36 - YOU CHIEF. I APPRECIATE HIS DAD

18:38 - WOULD YOU LOVE

18:42 - SUMMARIZE YOUR ARGUMENT AT

18:43 - THIS.

18:49 - >>ESTABLISH ALL PATIENTS

18:51 - TO CUBA. AND THE HEAD. PATIENTS

18:54 - ONE

18:54 - AGENT LAW AND OPTING POLICY

18:57 - THAT ALLOWS THE COURT PLEASE I

19:00 - THINK WHAT I MEANT. IN SOME

19:03 - POLLS, HOW TO YOU

19:04 - PEOPLE DO. YOU

19:06 - WILL PROBABLY IF HE DID THIS OR

19:11 - TO ACT ALL OF THESE BE DECLARED

19:13 - TO BE ALL IN A JUDICIAL

19:14 - DISTRICT TO BE PERMANENTLY

19:15 - ENJOINED FROM OF COURSE.

19:17 - THANK YOU.

19:18 - >>THANK YOU MISTER UH HUH WHO

19:20 - HERE FOR MY IDEA. ON THAT.

19:27 - >>THANK YOU MISTER CHIEF

19:28 - JUSTICE SEEMED ASSOCIATE

19:30 - JUSTICES OF THE COURT MAY

19:32 - PLEASE THE COURT.

19:34 - RICK RANDALL WITH THE ABC

19:36 - LEGAL DEPARTMENT WE REPRESENT

19:38 - THAT 52ND JUDICIAL DISTRICT.

19:41 - THE CHIEF PROBLEM

19:43 - WITH PETITIONERS ARGUMENTS IS

19:45 - THAT WHAT THEY'VE DONE HERE IS

19:46 - THEY'VE REDUCED EVERYTHING

19:48 - ABOUT THEIR LIVES AND WHAT GOOD

19:50 - CITIZENSHIP ENTAILS TO THEIR

19:53 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA PRESCRIPTIONS

19:54 - AND WHAT THEY DO AS THEY

19:56 - ESSENTIALLY ARGUE

19:57 - THAT WELL YOUR DOCTORS IN NO

20:00 - ONE CAN INTERFERE WITH THE

20:01 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA

20:02 - PRESCRIPTIONS, A THING.

20:04 - IN ADDITION OR ZACH COUNCIL

20:05 - KEPT REFERRING OR ARGUMENT TO

20:07 - THE SWEEPING IMMUNITY AND THAT

20:09 - THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA.

20:11 - PERMITS.

20:13 - AND WHAT THEY'VE ESSENTIALLY

20:14 - DONE IS THEY'VE CLAIMED THAT

20:16 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA LAW HAS

20:17 - ESSENTIALLY BUILD AN

20:18 - ENTIRE WALL AROUND THIS PART OF

20:21 - THEIR LIFE SUCH DATA PROBATION

20:23 - IN THE PROBATION CONTEXT THE

20:25 - COURTS

20:26 - COULD NEVER UNDER ANY

20:28 - CIRCUMSTANCES EVALUATE WHAT'S

20:29 - GOING ON WITH THEIR HEALTH.

20:31 - BUT HERE'S

20:32 - THE THING A PERSON'S HOW FOR

20:35 - THEIR MEDICAL NECESSITIES IS

20:36 - NOT JUST SOME MATTER PRIVATE

20:38 - CONCERN. WHAT MY DOCTOR

20:40 - PRESCRIBED ME IS NOT JUST MY

20:42 - CONCERN, IT'S STATE REGULATED.

20:44 - AND THAT'S FOR MY SAFETY AND

20:46 - THE SAFETY OF OTHERS

20:47 - AROUND ME PRESCRIBING

20:49 - MEDICATIONS TO ANY ONE PERSON

20:50 - HAS AN EFFECT ON SOCIETY AT

20:52 - LARGE THAT'S WHY THE PRACTICE

20:54 - OF MEDICINE SO

20:54 - HIGHLY REGULATED. AND SO THIS

20:57 - ARGUMENT FROM THE PETITIONERS

20:58 - AND SAID THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA

20:59 - LAW SOMEHOW CHANGES THAT

21:01 - LANDSCAPE AND

21:02 - REDUCES EVERYTHING ABOUT THEIR

21:04 - LIVES AND GETTING OUT OF THE

21:06 - CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM HAS TO

21:07 - TO JUST SIMPLY RELATING TO

21:09 - THEIR PERSONAL HEALTH CARE.

21:10 - IF YOU'RE SIMPLY NOT CORRECT

21:11 - THAT WAS NOT WRITTEN THAT

21:13 - BROADLY. WHAT'S GOING ON RIGHT

21:15 - NOW IN THEIR LIVES FOR THE

21:16 - PETITIONERS AND THEY ARE ALL ON

21:18 - A POW TO BACK TO GOOD

21:22 - THERE BETWEEN THE COURT IS

21:23 - FOCUSED ON TRYING TO GET THEM

21:24 - REHABILITATED AND WHAT THEIR

21:27 - DOG RIDING THEM IS ONE PART OF

21:28 - THAT EQUATION THAT THE DOCTOR

21:30 - SHOULD BE TOTALLY FOCUSED ON

21:32 - THEIR HEALTH. THAT'S ONE PART

21:34 - OF THEIR LIVES.

21:36 - BUT THAT'S NOT THE ONLY

21:37 - CRITERIA HERE FOR GOOD AND IS

21:40 - NOT THE ONLY MATERIAL. YOU KNOW

21:43 - THESE ARE WORDS YOU THINK

21:44 - ABOUT IT. AT CITIZENS IF HEALTH

21:47 - WAS THE ONLY THING WE HAD A

21:49 - COMBINATION COURT HAS

21:50 - TO CONSIDER BUT A FULLY FORMED

21:52 - CITIZEN AND A GOOD CITIZEN IN

21:54 - ARE NOT ONLY MAKES GOOD

21:55 - HEALTHCARE

21:55 - DECISIONS DAY. WE FOLLOW ALL

21:57 - LAWS AND THE COURTS ARE CHARGED

21:59 - WITH A GREATER RESPONSIBILITY

22:01 - THAN JUST DOCTORS THE COURTS

22:02 - HAVE TO INSURE NOT

22:04 - THESE PETITIONERS GET OUT OF

22:06 - THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM A

22:07 - REHABILITATED AND DAY LIVE GOOD

22:09 - LIVES AND BECOME GOOD CITIZENS.

22:12 - BECAUSE

22:13 - THEY HAVE CLAIMED THAT THEIR

22:15 - HEALTH AND MEDICAL MARIJUANA

22:17 - LAW HAS ALL THE SWEEPING

22:18 - IMMUNITY. HE'S CREATED A LOT OF

22:20 - CONFUSING AND CONTRADICTORY

22:22 - ARGUMENTS THAT THE FIRST ONE IS

22:24 - THAT THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA LAW

22:26 - CREATED SOME SWEEPING IMMUNITY

22:27 - AND AND IF WE LOOK AT THE LAW.

22:30 - WE SEE THAT

22:31 - IT DOESN'T IN NOWHERE DOES IT

22:32 - SAY HI IN FACT THE VERY

22:35 - BEGINNING OF LAW SECTION 1, 2,

22:38 - AND THE CREATION OF POLICY

22:40 - GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS IS SENSE

22:43 - TIMIDLY MOVING MEDICAL

22:45 - MARIJUANA WE'VE ASKED YOU TO

22:49 - LIMIT YOUR.

22:50 - >>OPENING STATEMENT JUST 3

22:51 - MONTHS CERTAINLY BE EXCEEDED

22:53 - THAT SUPPORTING ACTRESSES VERA

22:54 - FIELD YOUR QUESTIONS. SURE

22:57 - THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE.

23:00 - MISTER CRANDALL.

23:02 - ASSUME HYPOTHETICALLY.

23:05 - THEY'RE ONE OF YOUR

23:06 - PROBATIONERS HAS CANCER.

23:09 - >>AND THEY STATIONS. SAYS YOU

23:12 - NEED CHEMOTHERAPY.

23:14 - LIVE. THE PROBATION DEPARTMENT

23:17 - HAVE THE RIGHT TO SAY.

23:19 - WE WILL CONTINENTS

23:21 - THE CHEMOTHERAPY. UNLESS YOU

23:23 - CAN PROVE IN A COURT ROOM

23:25 - MEDICAL NECESSITY.

23:27 - >>YOU KNOW I I DON'T THINK THAT

23:28 - ALL YOUR HONOR I

23:29 - THINK CHEMOTHERAPY IS A IS IS

23:32 - VERY DIFFERENT FROM MARIJUANA

23:34 - AND A FOR EXAMPLE CHEMOTHERAPY

23:36 - AS FAR AS

23:37 - I'M AWARE HAS NOT EVER BEEN

23:39 - TREATED AS A SCHEDULE ONE

23:40 - NARCOTIC UNDER STATE LAW YOU

23:41 - KNOW TIME IS LIMITED I

23:45 - APOLOGIZE FOR INTERRUPTING YOU,

23:46 - BUT I DON'T I DON'T WANT TO RUN

23:47 - OUT.

23:48 - >>I E

23:49 - YOU'RE YOU'RE YOU'RE NOT

23:51 - ACTUALLY BE A CHANGE MIGHT HAVE

23:52 - ASSUMED THAT THE CHEMO THAT

23:54 - THEY'RE GIVING IS EXPERIMENTAL

23:56 - AND INDEED HAS A SCHEDULE ONE

23:57 - NARCOTIC COMPRISE WITHIN.

24:00 - GOOD THING.

24:02 - >>IT IN AND THEN THAT CASE OF

24:03 - THIS INDIVIDUAL IS ON PROBATION

24:05 - FOR EXAMPLE.

24:06 - I THINK THE COURT WOULD HAVE TO

24:07 - BALANCE THAT YOU KNOW THAT YOU

24:08 - CONSIDER THAT WITH THEIR NEED

24:10 - AND THAT CASE, YOU KNOW YOUR

24:11 - HONOR THAT'S A GOOD EXAMPLE

24:12 - MAYBE THAT'S A SITUATION WHERE

24:13 - THE COURT

24:14 - LETS THEM YOU KNOW USE THE

24:15 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA IN

24:16 - BALANCE BUT.

24:19 - >>ONE WE'RE TALKING CANCER AND

24:21 - CHEMO IN YOUR

24:22 - ANSWER IS THAT DATA LEBANON

24:24 - COUNTY CAN

24:25 - PROHIBIT CHEMOTHERAPY. IF THE

24:28 - COCKTAIL CONTAINS A A SCHEDULE

24:30 - ONE DRUG IS

24:31 - THAT CORRECT.

24:32 - >>NOW THAT I THINK THAT'S I

24:33 - THINK THAT'S A CORRECT

24:34 - STATEMENT BECAUSE WITH THE

24:35 - COURTS DEALING IS NOT JUST

24:37 - TARGETING ONLY

24:38 - ONLY THAT THAT DRUG WITH THE

24:40 - COURT HAS THE LOOK AS THE

24:41 - ENTIRE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THAT

24:43 - PERSON'S LIFE. SO FOR EXAMPLE

24:45 - IS THIS PERSON

24:46 - A FEW. IN IN THIS EXAMPLE ARE

24:49 - WE TALKING ABOUT SOMEBODY WHO

24:50 - HAS A PROBLEM WITH

24:54 - OBEYING LAWS IS SOMEBODY THAT

24:56 - IS A HE'S

25:00 - ON PROBATION. I LIKE

25:02 - TO BE THE FACTS THE FACTS OF

25:04 - THIS CASE HE'S ON PROBATION

25:06 - COULD BE CONTRACTS CANCER AND

25:07 - I'M SURE THAT THAT HAPPENS

25:09 - ON OCCASION.

25:10 - >>RIGHT HERE IS GOING TO GET A

25:11 - COCKTAIL OF DRUGS TO SUPPRESS

25:14 - THE CANCER HO LEE

25:16 - AND THEN THOSE GOING TO CONTAIN

25:17 - A SCHEDULE ONE DRUG I DON'T

25:19 - KNOW IF THAT'S OUTLANDISH AND

25:20 - NOT NOT BEING A PHYSICIAN, BUT

25:22 - JUST UNDER

25:22 - THOSE FACTS AND I THINK WHAT

25:24 - YOU'RE SAYING TO ME NUMBER MY

25:25 - TIME THAT WHAT YOU'RE SAYING TO

25:27 - ME IS UNDER THOSE

25:27 - CIRCUMSTANCES, YOUR CLIENT

25:29 - DOESN'T NEED HAVE A RIGHT TO

25:31 - HAVE A HEARING TO DECIDE

25:32 - WHETHER OR NOT THE MOST NESTS

25:34 - THAT'S CORRECT YOUR HONOR LET'S

25:36 - GRAB A BEER. I GOT TO

25:40 - THANK YOU.

25:41 - >>JUST THANK YOU JUST HEARD

25:42 - JUSTICE ON.

25:45 - >>THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE.

25:47 - BUT TUCKER AND ALL IT'S YOUR

25:49 - ARGUMENTS STRONGER IN

25:52 - INSTANCES WHERE THE

25:53 - PROBATION IS.

25:55 - >>AS A RESULT OF SUBSTANCE

25:58 - ABUSE CRIME.

26:01 - >>I THINK THAT'S

26:02 - PROBABLY A FAIR

26:03 - ASSESSMENT THAN SUBSTANCE ABUSE

26:05 - IS IS IS PROBABLY MORE WHAT

26:08 - THIS IS TARGETED TO

26:10 - I AND THE POLICY

26:13 - ITSELF THAT YOU COULD CHECK OUT

26:14 - THE POLICY THE POLICY ACTUALLY

26:16 - DRAWS THIS CONNECTION BETWEEN

26:17 - SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND CRIME.

26:19 - SO I THINK THAT SUBSTANCE ABUSE

26:21 - IS SOMETHING THAT IS ON THE

26:22 - COURT'S

26:22 - MIND AND THE CONNECTION BETWEEN

26:26 - SUBSTANCE ABUSE IS CRIME SORT

26:27 - OF CERTAIN LAID OUT HIS

26:29 - CONCERNS OF THE NEW OPENING

26:30 - PART OF

26:31 - ITS POLICY. IT LAYS OUT HOW AND

26:33 - ON ALL 3 OF THE PROBATIONERS

26:35 - HERE HAVE BACK WE SHARE THAT

26:37 - IN COMMON AND YOU TO

26:38 - THEIR SITUATIONS. ILLEGAL

26:41 - POSSESSION WAS SOME COMPONENT

26:43 - IN FOR EACH OF THESE

26:43 - PROBATIONERS.

26:47 - >>I'M HAVING IS

26:48 - WE'RE NOT DECIDE THIS CASE JUST

26:51 - DOES STUFF.

26:52 - >>THESE 3 PROBATIONERS WE'RE

26:55 - GOING TO DECIDE THE CASE OR

26:57 - PENNSYLVANIA AS

26:58 - A WHOLE PROBATIONERS ARE

27:03 - ALLEVIATED ANY DRUG PROBLEM.

27:05 - I AGREE YOU ARE. BUT SOME

27:09 - DO YOU I THE DRUGS

27:11 - SOME ARE NOW SOME

27:14 - MAY BE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE THERE

27:16 - COULD BE A WHOLE HOST

27:17 - OF CRIMINAL INFRACTIONS THAT

27:19 - DID NOT AND ALL.

27:23 - SUBSTANCE

27:25 - I GUESS THAT'S WHAT I'M ASKING

27:27 - IS THERE A DISTINCTION IN YOUR

27:29 - MIND BETWEEN THE TIME THE CRIME

27:32 - AGAIN RISE TO THE PROBATION.

27:34 - AND THE MEHDI ARMY.

27:39 - >>YES, YOUR HONOR I THINK THAT

27:40 - COULD BE THE

27:40 - CASE BUT I THINK FOR ALL THESE

27:42 - PROBATIONERS LET'S SAY YOU KNOW

27:44 - A PROBATIONER HAS NO CONNECTION

27:46 - TO SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND THEY

27:47 - WANT TO USE

27:48 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA THEN THEY

27:50 - WOULD USE THE POLICY WOULD

27:51 - PETITION THE JUDGE AND SAY YOUR

27:52 - HONOR LOOK I MY

27:54 - CRIME HAS NO CONNECTION TO

27:55 - SUBSTANCE ABUSE I'VE NEVER HAD

27:56 - A HISTORY OF

27:57 - SUBSTANCE ABUSE. ALI'S RELIEVE

27:59 - ME FROM THIS GENERAL CONDITION

28:00 - AND I THINK YOU KNOW THAT

28:02 - SOMETHING THE JUDGE WOULD HAVE

28:03 - TO CONSIDER.

28:07 - THANK YOU JUSTICE

28:08 - DONE HERE.

28:09 - >>COUNCIL ON I'D LIKE TO FOLLOW

28:11 - UP ONE NIGHT YOUR LAST ANSWER

28:13 - TO JUST THIS HIGH.

28:16 - >>BUT IT WHO

28:17 - AND WHAT YOU DESCRIBED AND

28:20 - HOW A PROBATIONER WHO GET OUT

28:23 - FROM UNDER THE BURDEN BEING

28:25 - IMPOSED BY

28:25 - THIS POLICY IS NOT WHAT I

28:27 - UNDERSTAND THE POLICY TO BE MY

28:29 - UNDERSTANDING IS PROBATIONER

28:32 - WEEK AFTER CRUDE MEDICAL

28:34 - NECESSITY.

28:35 - AND I'M NOT CERTAIN

28:39 - WHAT THAT

28:42 - I DID THEN

28:43 - I BRINGING IN A PHYSICIAN WHO

28:45 - WASTE THE AUTHORIZING POSITION

28:47 - MET ALL OF THE EYE. I PROTOCOLS

28:51 - AND YOU

28:51 - THE STATUTE IS THAT IS THAT HOW

28:55 - ID ID DO SOME DISTRICT IN

28:57 - CANCER THIS TO WORK.

29:00 - >>NO YOUR HONOR I DON'T THINK

29:01 - SO I DON'T THINK IT'S IT'S IT'S

29:04 - NOT DEFINED BY THE PART OF THE

29:06 - PROBLEM WITH WITH THAT I CAN'T

29:08 - REALLY GIVE YOU A SOLID ANSWER

29:09 - ON THAT BECAUSE WE HAVEN'T SEEN

29:11 - POLICY IMPLEMENTED YET

29:12 - BECAUSE OF THE POSTURE OF THIS

29:14 - CASE BY COMING HERE AND KING'S

29:15 - BENCH JURISDICTION. YOU SIMPLY

29:18 - HAVE NO RECORD TO SAY HOW THE

29:19 - JUDGES OF THE

29:20 - 52ND JUDICIAL DISTRICT. WOULD

29:24 - LOOK AT THAT PHRASE MEDICAL

29:25 - NECESSITY I I DON'T THINK IT

29:27 - WOULD IT WOULD BE NOW NOT TO

29:29 - SHOW HIM.

29:32 - >>ALL. I

29:34 - YOU.

29:35 - >>THE DISTRICT CANNOT TELL A

29:37 - PROBATIONER WHEN HE OR SHE HAS

29:40 - TO ESTABLISH

29:41 - ISN'T THAT ITS FACE ENOUGH

29:44 - TO SAY THIS POLICY

29:46 - CAN STAND. I MEAN, YEAH IT'S A

29:49 - MOVING CAR. I'VE BEEN UP UNDER

29:52 - WHAT CIRCUMSTANCE.

29:54 - COULD ANYONE EVER EAT HIM TO ME

29:57 - AND THERE.

29:58 - IT'S COLI IN THE

30:00 - UNBRIDLED

30:02 - THE I FORMATION I DID DECIDE

30:06 - WHETHER OR NOT THE STANDARD HAS

30:07 - BEEN MET.

30:10 - >>AND THE MEDICAL NECESSITY UP

30:12 - COMPONENT OF IT THOUGH IF YOU

30:14 - THINK

30:14 - ABOUT IT I DON'T THINK JUST

30:16 - FOLLOWING THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA

30:17 - LAW THAT IT'S IT'S HARD TO GET

30:19 - INTO WHAT MEDICAL NECESSITY

30:20 - WOULD BE FOR THEM I THINK

30:21 - THEY'VE DONE A GOOD JOB IN THIS

30:23 - CASE OF LAYING OUT IN

30:24 - THEIR PETITIONS THEIR

30:25 - CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE LAY THAT

30:27 - OUT AND THEY THEY ONLY TOOK A

30:28 - COUPLE OF PAGES IN THEIR

30:29 - PETITIONS TO LATE NOW.

30:31 - NOW IS THAT WOULD NOT MEET THE

30:33 - STANDARD FOR WHAT THE JUDGE

30:34 - WOULD SAY IS ACCEPTABLE MEDICAL

30:36 - NECESSITY. I THINK THE PROBLEM

30:38 - HERE WOULD BE JUST

30:40 - LOOKING IN WHAT THEN LAY OUT

30:42 - ONLY IS WHAT THEY'VE LAID OUT

30:43 - IN NOT CONSIDERING ALL THE

30:44 - OTHER PARTS OF THEIR LIFE AS

30:45 - WELL SO IT'S. THEY'VE DONE A

30:49 - GOOD JOB OF LAYING OUT I THINK

30:51 - A CONVINCING ARGUMENT FOR WHY

30:52 - TO ME THEY MAY NEED EXCEPTIONS

30:54 - TO THE POLICY BUT WITH THE

30:55 - JUDGE IS NOT CONSIDERING IS NOT

30:57 - JUST THE MEDICAL NECESSITY.

30:58 - YOU KNOW THESE ALSO PROBATION

31:00 - CONSIDERING ALL THE OTHER

31:00 - FACTORS OF THEIR LIFE IN A VERY

31:02 - YOU HOLISTIC

31:03 - WAY SO I SEE YOU ARE SAYING,

31:06 - BUT BY LOOKING AT MEDICAL

31:07 - NECESSITY AND SAYING YOU KNOW

31:08 - WHAT YOU KNOW WHAT DOES THAT

31:10 - PHRASE MEAN BY.

31:12 - I JUST GOT TO GO BACK TO MY

31:13 - ANSWER BEFORE AS IT WILL FIRST

31:14 - OF ALL ARE

31:14 - YOU NOT INCE IT SEEMS TO BE

31:16 - APPARENT BASED ON WHAT THEY

31:17 - LAID OUT THEY LAID OUT SOME

31:19 - MEDICAL NECESSITY. IN THERE

31:21 - EVERY IN THEIR BRIEF AND SECOND

31:22 - OF ALL YOU KNOW WE JUST WE JUST

31:24 - HAVE TO SEE WHAT REPUBLICAN

31:25 - DISTRICT DOES. BEFORE WE BEFORE

31:27 - WE ROLL ON NOW.

31:39 - BACKING ON JUSTICE 10 YEARS IN

31:42 - THE POLICY. IT SPECIFICALLY

31:44 - INDICATE HEARD IN THE BONE, THE

31:47 - PETITIONER.

31:51 - LIKE THIS PROVIDE ELATION HERE.

31:54 - THE VIOLATION OF PROBATION

31:56 - HEARING THE BURDENS ON

31:57 - THE COMMONWEALTH. WHAT COURSES

31:59 - THE SHIFT IN BURDEN AND WHY

32:01 - SHOULD BE BANNED.

32:03 - EITHER ONE WHEN IN FACT THIS IS

32:06 - THE INCOMPETENCE OF THE

32:08 - COMMONWEALTH.

32:10 - >>YES, YOU'RE OR

32:12 - THE REASON I THINK IF YOU GO

32:13 - BACK TO THE FIRST PAGE OF THE

32:15 - POLICY THAT THE CONCERNS THAT

32:16 - THE COURT EXPRESS IS ON THE

32:18 - FIRST PAGE SORT OF ITS PLANE

32:20 - BACK ON THE SECOND PAGE WHY THE

32:22 - MEDICAL NECESSITY BURDEN WOULD

32:24 - BE ON THE PETITIONERS

32:25 - THE COURT LAYS OUT CONCERNS ON

32:27 - THE FIRST PAGE THAT ARE VERY

32:28 - CONSISTENT WITH THE

32:29 - GENERAL ASSEMBLY'S SECTION ONE

32:31 - OF THE DECLARATION IN THIS OUT

32:34 - THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TALKS

32:36 - ABOUT HOW THIS YOU KNOW MEDICAL

32:37 - MARIJUANA MIGHT

32:39 - BE SOMETHING THAT IS GOING TO

32:41 - HELP PATIENTS AND SUGGEST A

32:43 - MEDICAL

32:43 - MARIJUANA IS SOMETHING THAT MAY

32:46 - MITIGATE SUFFERING IN SOME

32:47 - PATIENTS AND COURT THEN FOLLOWS

32:50 - THAT UP WITH THE FIRST PART OF

32:52 - THE POLICY ON THE FIRST PAGE

32:53 - AND TALKS

32:54 - ABOUT HOW.

32:55 - >>MEDICAL MARIJUANA IS THE MOST

32:56 - FLOPS AT THE MOMENT, IT'S AN

32:58 - EVOLUTIONARY STAGE WHERE THE

32:59 - FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. THANKS IT'S

33:01 - STILL A SCHEDULE ONE NARCOTIC

33:03 - IT'S GOT A HIGH POTENTIAL FOR

33:04 - ABUSE

33:04 - AND DEPENDENCY AND I THINK THE

33:07 - FUELS THE SECOND PAGE, YOUR

33:08 - HONOR WE GET TO THE EARS WHY

33:10 - THE CONDITION. WE NEED TO COME

33:12 - FORWARD WITH A LITTLE BIT OF

33:13 - EVIDENCE AS TO WHAT'S GOING ON

33:14 - IN THEIR LIFE AND THEIR

33:15 - CIRCUMSTANCES.

33:17 - BE IT COLLECTS THE SOMETHING

33:20 - THE BEST IN THE NATION. HOST.

33:23 - $0.3 FROM GRACE.

33:29 - I AS TO WHY THEY WOULD NOT

33:30 - BE COLLECTED IN IN IN THE

33:33 - SENTENCING PROCESS POSE

33:34 - CONNECTION. AND I SUPPOSE

33:38 - SENTENCE INVESTIGATION. WHY

33:40 - WOULD THAT INFORMATION NOT TO

33:41 - CALL IT THAT.

33:43 - WELL THAT INFORMATION VERY WELL

33:44 - COULD BE AND MAYBE THAT'S WHAT

33:46 - THE PETITIONERS RELY ON MAYBE

33:47 - THEY JUST SIMPLY SAY LOOK YOUR

33:48 - HONOR, HERE'S MY A SENTENCING

33:50 - CONVICTION, YOU KNOW REPORT.

33:52 - HERE'S EVERYTHING RIGHT THERE

33:53 - IN MY LIFE,

33:54 - THOSE ARE VERY GOOD REPORT TO

33:56 - YOU KNOW YOUR HONOR AS YOU

33:57 - POINT OUT THE

33:59 - THEY GO INTO A LOT OF THINGS

34:00 - AND MAYBE THAT'S WHAT THEY RELY

34:01 - ON MAYBE THAT BECOMES A VERY

34:03 - EASY WAY TO HELP ESTABLISH THE

34:04 - MEDICAL NECESSITY.

34:06 - I THINK WHAT THE COURTS TRYING

34:07 - TO DO IS IT'S TRYING TO GO A

34:08 - LITTLE BIT FURTHER JUST TOO.

34:10 - YOU KNOW

34:11 - WHO'S NOT NOT REALLY DETERMINE

34:13 - THEIR MEDICAL NECESSITY

34:14 - BUT VERIFY WHAT'S GOING ON WITH

34:17 - THE AMERICAN MEDICAL MARIJUANA

34:18 - USE.

34:20 - AND IF I MAY BE MUCH LESS CAN I

34:21 - ASK ONE MORE QUESTION CHIEF

34:22 - QUICKLY SURE BEEN UNDERGOING

34:25 - YOUR REAL QUICKLY MEDICAL A

34:27 - MEDICAL NECESSITY

34:29 - HAS A NICE BUT IS THERE

34:30 - SPECIFIC TERM OF ART WHICH

34:33 - MONEY WHY ARE YOU KNOW IMPOSING

34:35 - ADDITIONAL BURDENS ON THEM

34:38 - WHEN YOU SAY HE OR SHE NOW

34:40 - BEARS THE BURDEN OF MEDICAL

34:41 - NECESSITY.

34:44 - WELL AGAIN YOU KNOW I DON'T I

34:45 - I'M NOT SURE THAT THE POLICY IS

34:47 - USING THE LEGAL TERMINOLOGY OF

34:49 - MEDICAL NECESSITY I DON'T THINK

34:50 - IT'S GOING FOR THAT I THINK

34:52 - LOOKING BACK TO THE FIRST PAGE

34:54 - OF THE POLICY

34:55 - SHOWS YOU I THINK WITH THE

34:56 - COURT'S CONCERNS OR I DON'T

34:57 - THINK IT'S USING THE LEGAL A

34:59 - LEGAL TERM, BUT AGAIN.

35:01 - YOU KNOW WE JUST DON'T HAVE A

35:01 - NEW RECORD TO MAKE THAT

35:02 - PREDICTION ON AT THIS 0.1 WAY

35:04 - OR THE OTHER I DON'T THINK THE

35:05 - COURT COULD

35:05 - SAY THAT THATS THE POLICY IS

35:07 - SAYING BECAUSE OF THE RECORD

35:09 - 7TH AND THIS POINT.

35:11 - THANK YOU. YES, THAT'S RIGHT.

35:14 - THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE GOOD

35:15 - MORNING COUNCIL. ABOUT 9 YEARS

35:18 - AGO THIS COURT IN WILSON SAID.

35:21 - TO CREATE PROBATION CONDITIONS

35:24 - THAT DIFFER WITH STATUTORY

35:25 - REQUIREMENTS. HOW IS THIS CASE

35:28 - ANY DIFFERENT WHAT IS IT

35:29 - ABOUT BE. NO PENALTY CAUSE OF

35:32 - THE STATUTE IS AMBIGUOUS.

35:36 - YES

35:36 - JUST LIKE I THINK THE NO 10

35:38 - WEEK LOSS IS THE FIRST THING

35:39 - YOU HAVE TO DO WITH THAT NO

35:41 - PENALTY COST SUIT SECTION 21 OF

35:43 - 3.

35:44 - >>THE FIRST THING YOU NEED TO

35:45 - ESTABLISH IS NOW.

35:46 - YOU KNOW PROBATION ISN'T A

35:48 - RIGHT OR A PRIVILEGE IN THE

35:49 - SENSE THAT I THINK THE STATUTE

35:52 - USING ITS THE RIGHT OR THE

35:53 - PRIVILEGE FOR ALL THESE

35:54 - INDIVIDUALS IS TO BE FREE

35:56 - FROM SEARCHES AND SEIZURES TO

35:58 - HAVE FREE SPEECH IN ALL THE

35:59 - RIGHTS THAT WE ENJOY AS

36:01 - CITIZENS WHO ARE NOT PROBATION.

36:03 - SO BUT THE QUESTION THEN

36:05 - BECOMES IS TO HEAR IN COURT

36:08 - LAWFULLY LOOK

36:10 - AT THERE. USE OF MEDICAL

36:12 - MARIJUANA IN THE NIGHT AND SOME

36:13 - RIGHT OR A PRIVILEGE. SO LEAVE

36:16 - FOR THE MEDICAL

36:16 - MARIJUANA AND THAT'S OUR

36:18 - ARGUMENT IS THAT BIG IT'S NOT

36:20 - IT'S THERE'S THERE'S NOTHING IN

36:21 - CONFLICT WITH THE MEDICAL

36:22 - MARIJUANA

36:22 - STATUTE BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT

36:24 - BEING INTERFERED WITH SOLAR

36:26 - BECAUSE OF THEIR THEIR THEIR

36:27 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA THEY HAVE

36:28 - THERE BEEN THIS MOMENT,

36:30 - THEIR RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES TO

36:31 - BE FREE TO TO STAY OUT AFTER 11

36:34 - TO HAVE PAGERS AND CELL PHONES

36:36 - AND OTHER THINGS. THOSE RIGHTS

36:37 - ARE BEING INFRINGED BECAUSE

36:38 - THEY'RE ALREADY ON PROBATION.

36:40 - THAT'S WHY THERE'S NO THERE'S

36:41 - SEE THERE SEEMS TO BE NO

36:42 - CONFLICT HERE WITH THE MEDICAL

36:44 - MARIJUANA ACTIVISTS PRINCE

36:46 - OPERATION POLICY.

36:51 - WHAT IN POLICY THAT LEBANON

36:53 - COUNTY HAS CRAFTED.

36:57 - THE POTENTIAL FOR REPEATED

37:00 - CONFLICTS WITH THE STATUTE

37:02 - GIVEN THAT THE

37:03 - JUDGES THERE. BUT IN SERIE

37:06 - AND TURN MEDICAL NON

37:09 - NECESSITY JUDGMENTS IN EACH AND

37:11 - EVERY CASE

37:13 - WHERE A PHYSICIAN ACTING UNDER

37:15 - THE STATUTE HAS ALREADY MADE

37:17 - THE JUDGMENT OF ELIGIBILITY FOR

37:19 - THE CAR AND THAT THE

37:20 - LEGISLATURE ADDRESSED.

37:24 - I DON'T KNOW YOUR HONOR BUT

37:26 - I THINK I THINK THIS MAY HELP

37:27 - ANSWER THE QUESTION IS NOT YOU

37:29 - KNOW JUST HAVING THE CARD IS

37:32 - NOT EQUIPPED IT'S NOT THE

37:33 - EQUATION OF LAW TO USE LAWFUL

37:35 - USE UNDER THE ACT IS

37:36 - SOMETHING DIFFERENT.

37:37 - >>AND IS THEY ARE THE CARD IF

37:40 - THEY ARE VERIFYING HOW THEY'RE

37:42 - USING THE PRESCRIPTION.

37:43 - THEN I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY

37:44 - KIND OF INTERFERENCE WITH WHAT

37:46 - THE WITH WITH IN YOUR HONOR'S

37:48 - EXAMPLE THERE.

37:54 - >>JUSTICE MONEY.

37:55 - >>I'M NO QUESTION. JER OWNER.

37:58 - >>OK AND YOU A VERY VERY BRIEF

38:01 - ACT.

38:03 - SOME ASIAN THEM MISTER

38:04 - RANDOLPH.

38:06 - >>SO THIS BE BRIEF IN MY

38:07 - CLOSING HERE. THIS POLICY IN

38:10 - THIS CASE REALLY MIRRORS THE

38:11 - DECLARATION OF POLICY THAT

38:12 - COMES OUT OF THE MEDICAL

38:13 - MARIJUANA ACT ITSELF, IT'S

38:15 - ENSUES POLICY RECOGNIZES THAT

38:17 - MEDICAL MARIJUANA HAS NOT

38:18 - SETTLED SCIENCE THE POLICY

38:19 - RECOGNIZES THE PATIENT PATIENT

38:21 - SAFETY IS A CHIEF CONCERN

38:23 - AND THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AGREES

38:24 - LAWLESS AND SECTION WANTED TO.

38:27 - THE POLICY RECOGNIZES THERE'S A

38:28 - POTENTIAL CONNECTION BETWEEN

38:29 - CRIMINAL VIOLATIONS AND

38:31 - SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND AGAIN I

38:32 - DON'T THINK THE

38:32 - GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THIS AGREES

38:34 - WITH THIS BECAUSE MARIJUANA IS

38:36 - IS JUST NOT PRESCRIBED LIKE ANY

38:37 - OTHER DRUG I DON'T GET A

38:38 - LICENSE. MY BACKING

38:40 - PRESCRIPTION

38:41 - FOR EXAMPLE. NO COURT WANTS TO

38:43 - OPERATE IMPORTANT. I THINK IN

38:44 - GUIDANCE TO THE DISTRICT'S ON

38:45 - HOW TO IMPLEMENT THESE POLICIES

38:47 - AND HELP STEER POLICY.

38:48 - I THINK THAT'S A A A REASONABLE

38:50 - APPROACH RATHER THAN THROW THE

38:51 - WHOLE POLICY OUT LIKE

38:53 - CONDITIONERS HAVE ADVANCED

38:54 - HERE. THANK YOU FOR HEARING ME

38:56 - TODAY.

38:59 - THAT CONCLUDES THE ARGUMENT IN

39:01 - THE

39:01 - FIRST CASE. WELCOME AND SO THE

39:04 - ARGUMENT IN THE NEXT 10 YEARS

39:05 - NOT 5 MINUTES.

39:09 - >>GET AN OVERVIEW OF THIS

39:10 - WEEK'S TOP STORIES AS STATE

39:12 - JOURNALISTS WEIGH IN ON TOPICS

39:13 - AFFECTING

39:14 - PENNSYLVANIA WATCH JOURNALISTS

39:16 - ROUNDTABLE THURSDAY NIGHT AT 7

39:18 - ON CABLE AND STRAIN WITH

39:20 - PCN SELECT VISIT PCN TV DOT COM

39:23 - TO SEE THIS WEEK'S TOPICS.

39:31 - >>NEXT ARGUMENT IS SOMEWHAT OF

39:33 - A NEW REPORT SAYS THAT IN

39:35 - MASON'S REPELLENT HIS JOB AND

39:37 - SEE HOW ARE YOU FOR POLLY IS

39:40 - DAVID EARHART.

39:43 - >>GOOD GUY

39:44 - GOOD MORNING. THIS APPEAL

39:46 - CONCERNS IT'S GOING TO WORK

39:50 - THE ADMISSIBILITY OF THE

39:51 - FOOTAGE CAPTURED BY A

39:53 - HIDDEN CAMERA. THERE WAS STORY

39:55 - OF A

39:55 - CHILDHOOD BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES

39:58 - OF MONITORING CHILDREN'S

40:00 - BABYSITTER.

40:03 - YOU CAN BEGIN YOUR ARGUMENT.

40:05 - HE'S MISTER PAST.

40:07 - >>THANK YOU YOUR HONOR MAY

40:08 - PLEASE THE COURT CHIEF DEPUTY

40:10 - DOES VARY. JOHN BASON BE

40:12 - AT ALL ISSUES IN BEFORE THE

40:15 - COURT THERE ARE 2 OF THEM

40:16 - THEY'RE FIRST IMPRESSION IN

40:19 - THIS COLUMN WILL THE FIRST

40:21 - BEING THAT WHETHER MS. MASON

40:23 - HAD A REASONABLE EXPECTATION OF

40:24 - PRIVACY IN THE CHILD'S

40:26 - SLEEPING. AND THE SECOND

40:28 - WHETHER

40:28 - IT BE SOUNDS THEY CAME FROM HER

40:31 - FORCE WE SLANDERING THE CHILD

40:33 - INTO YOUR CREDIT AND THEN GOING

40:35 - BACK.

40:40 - RECORD

40:40 - NO SOUNDS I'VE COVERED AND

40:42 - PENNSYLVANIA WIRE. WITH RESPECT

40:44 - TO THE FIRST ISSUE YEAR HONORS.

40:46 - I BELIEVE TO BE DONE.

40:50 - AIRED IN A SPECIFIC REBOUND

40:52 - NUMBER ONE, MS. MAY'S AND HAD A

40:55 - SUBJECTIVE EXPECTATION OF

40:56 - PRIVACY WHERE SHE HAD THE

40:58 - OPPORTUNITY. SHE DID TAKE THE

41:00 - STAND AND SHE DID NOT SAY I HAD

41:04 - I BELIEVE I WAS I

41:06 - BEING FOUND. I BELIEVED I WAS

41:08 - IN PRIVATE AND MY

41:10 - EMPLOYER'S HOME. THERE WAS ALSO

41:13 - OTHER SUBJECTIVE FACTORS SUCH

41:15 - AS THE B DALLY FAMILY CONTINUED

41:17 - TO QUESTION HER BODY

41:19 - SUSPECTED CHILD ABUSE WHY SHE

41:21 - DID NOT COME UP WITH ANY

41:22 - ANSWERS. THE SECOND PRONG MINE

41:24 - OUT OF MY NOW A SUSPECT

41:25 - RESPECTED THAT AT THE SECOND

41:27 - ELEMENT IS THERE EXPECTATION OF

41:29 - PRIVACY AND WHETHER IS

41:31 - REASONABLE

41:32 - IS THAT THE LOWER COURTS ERRED

41:35 - IN FINDING THAT SOCIETY AND THE

41:36 - COURT AS A WHOLE IS ACTUALLY

41:38 - READY TO RECOGNIZE

41:41 - THIS TYPE OF CLAIMED PRIVACY

41:43 - RIGHT AS REASONABLE.

41:45 - IN PENNSYLVANIA. THIS

41:46 - COURT NOR SOCIETY NOR SOCIETY

41:49 - AS A WHOLE SHOULD BE READY IS.

41:52 - WITH RESPECT TO THE

41:52 - SECOND ISSUE. YOUR HONOR.

41:56 - THESE SOUNDS COMING FROM IT.

42:02 - TRIAL BEFORE SWEET ORANGE A

42:04 - GRANT AND THEN BEING BEATEN

42:06 - OR NOT SOUNDS OR CONTEMPLATED

42:09 - WORLD COMMUNICATIONS BY THE

42:10 - WIRETAP ACT WAS ENACTED BY THE

42:12 - LEGISLATURE.

42:14 - I CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND THE

42:15 - ARGUMENT THAT YOU CAN.

42:21 - YOU CAN HAVE.

42:24 - A SOUND START.

42:27 - DIFFERENTIAL.

42:30 - THIS SPECIFIC.

42:33 - I WHERE'S THE ACE.

42:35 - AND THE JOBS FACE TO START

42:37 - WITH.

42:38 - AND THEN AFTERWARDS SHE WAS

42:39 - TALKING TO THE CHILD ABOUT

42:41 - SLEEPING SO THAT ESSENTIALLY

42:43 - AND THAT NO FURTHER MEETING

42:45 - I BELIEVE THAT THOSE SOUNDS

42:48 - FROM THE CHILD BEING FORCED TO

42:49 - LOOK. WE TRY AND. THE SOUNDS OF

42:53 - HER BEING BEATEN OR OR CAN BE

42:56 - SEPARATED ENOUGH FROM.

43:17 - >>I THINK WE'VE

43:18 - FOR SOME REASON MISTER FOUST

43:20 - SO. KEEP THE

43:22 - CASE GRUENING WERE GOT AND

43:24 - PERHAPS YOUR URINE IS SHOULD

43:25 - MOVE CROWDED JOSPIN.

43:28 - I THINK OR MISTER ERROR THE

43:30 - COUNCIL FOR THE RALLY. HE

43:32 - BACKED MR. FOSTER.

43:39 - AND YOU HEAR ME MR. YES SIR.

43:43 - WOULD YOU BUY IT WHEN YOU BEGIN

43:45 - YOUR ARE YOU MOVE.

43:47 - >>AH YES, THANK YOU. GOOD

43:49 - MONEY MISTY THERE HER HIM STEVE

43:51 - REISNER YES, TRY I'M GOOD.

43:53 - >>BEING GAY.

43:56 - >>WELL WE'LL GIVE ME A LITTLE

43:58 - TRY AGAIN MR. FAUST.

44:01 - IF DAD I CAN'T GET THIS SQUARED

44:03 - AWAY WERE YOU TRY AND THERE

44:05 - ARE.

44:11 - YEAH HE DISAPPEARED FROM THE

44:13 - SCREEN. SIR. GO AHEAD MISTER

44:15 - ERROR. THANK YOU SIR.

44:17 - >>A MOVE FORWARD ON BEHALF OF

44:18 - THAT NATION OF COURSE.

44:21 - >>I CERTAINLY DON'T WANT TO

44:22 - REITERATE MY ENTIRE BRIEF, I'M

44:24 - I'M CONFIDENT THAT THE COURT

44:25 - HAS

44:25 - REVIEWED IT. THE COUPLE POINTS

44:27 - KNOW THAT I THAT I LIKE TO MAKE

44:29 - A FIRST.

44:31 - THE ITS FREEZE IS A FAIRLY

44:34 - DISMISSIVE OF.

44:36 - >>BE.

44:37 - >>PERSUASIVE AUTHORITY AT LEAST

44:38 - WHAT I HOPE IS RECENTLY SOME

44:39 - AUTHORITY CITED BY THE SUPERIOR

44:41 - COURT FROM OUR SISTER STATES.

44:44 - AND IT SEEMS AS THOUGH THE

44:45 - BASIS OF THAT DISMISSAL

44:47 - HIS MATCH.

44:49 - >>THOSE CASES THAT DEAL

44:50 - SPECIFICALLY WITH BABY SITTERS

44:51 - AND THEIR EXPECTATION OF

44:52 - PRIVACY.

44:55 - >>OR IN THE CONTEXT OF

44:56 - GOVERNMENT SEARCHES AN

44:58 - ANNEXATION EXPECTATION OF

44:59 - PRIVACY FROM GOVERNMENT

45:00 - SEARCHES. I WOULD THAT

45:04 - AUTHORITY SHOULD STILL BE

45:05 - CONSIDERED PERSUASIVE IN FACT

45:07 - PERHAPS EVEN MORE SO UNDER THE

45:09 - CIRCUMSTANCES HERE WHEN WE'RE

45:11 - TALKING ABOUT

45:13 - CLANDESTINE RECORDINGS. FORMER

45:16 - PRIME ATTACK. I THINK

45:18 - IT'S REASONABLE

45:19 - TO THINK THAT PERSON WILL HAVE

45:22 - A FIRST NEW IS.

45:25 - SUSPECTED OF WRONGDOING EVEN

45:26 - BRATS IS GOING TO HAVE A

45:28 - HEIGHTENED LEVEL. SENSE

45:31 - OF PRIVACY WHEN THEY'RE DEALING

45:32 - WITH A PRIVATE ACT OR A FRIEND

45:34 - A FAMILY MEMBER OR EVEN

45:35 - EMPLOYED.

45:39 - BRANDON EMPLOYERS, NOT ALWAYS A

45:40 - FRIEND OR FAMILY MEMBER OF

45:41 - COURSE. BUT THEY'RE CERTAINLY

45:43 - NOT ALWAYS A GOVERNMENT ENTITY.

45:46 - I LOVE THE FDA.

45:48 - OF SOMEONE HAVING TO BE

45:49 - CONCERNED ABOUT THEIR PRIVACY.

45:52 - IS AT ITS PEAK WHEN THEY'RE

45:54 - DEALING WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT.

45:56 - SOMEONE WITH A SECRET

45:58 - WILL BE MUCH MORE INCLINED TO

45:59 - TELL THAT SECRET TO A FRIEND.

46:01 - WE'RE A FAMILY MEMBER OR AN

46:03 - EMPLOYER. ALL BEFORE THEY

46:05 - WOULD. BE SO INCLINED TO REVEAL

46:08 - IT TO A

46:09 - GOVERNMENT ACTOR. SO I DO ASK

46:12 - THE COURT TO CONSIDER THAT SEEM

46:13 - AUTHORITY THAT THIS APPEAR IN

46:14 - COURT SEEM TO FIND FORM DIDN'T

46:17 - PERSUASIVE.

46:20 - AN EXTRACT A

46:20 - PROMISE AND WILL LINGER ON IT

46:22 - BECAUSE THEY DO ADDRESS NO MORE

46:23 - ANGER TOO LONG AT ALL COULD YOU

46:25 - HAVE TO REACH A NEW YEAR WE'RE

46:26 - GOING TO TURN

46:27 - TO QUESTIONS.

46:28 - >>CERTAINLY THERE ARE MANY

46:29 - ASKED JUST THE START OF SHE HAS

46:30 - A CRUSH.

46:33 - >>THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE I DO.

46:36 - GOOD MORNING COUNCIL.

46:39 - IT SEEMS

46:40 - TO ME AT THIS CASE AS JUDGE

46:43 - NOW LAW ON THE SUPERIOR COURT

46:45 - KIND THIS CASE REALLY COMES

46:48 - DOWN TO WHETHER

46:50 - OR LIONS, REASONABLE

46:52 - EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY.

46:55 - >>IN.

46:55 - >>A HOME THAT SHE

46:57 - WAS WORKING AND SPECIFICALLY IN

47:00 - CHILDREN'S BEDROOMS AND

47:03 - I HAVE A HARD TIME

47:05 - UNDERSTANDING WOW SHE WOULD

47:08 - HAVE SUCH

47:09 - REASONABLE EXPECTATION OF

47:11 - PRIVACY IN THE ENTRANCE WHERE

47:13 - THE CHILDREN SLEPT.

47:15 - NOW THERE'S NO INDICATION THAT

47:16 - SHE WAS AN OVERNIGHT BLAZE THAT

47:19 - SHE WAS A NANNY WITH HER

47:21 - OWN ROOM. IF SHE WAS A STALE

47:24 - FOR DANNY. YOU HAD HER OWN

47:26 - BEDROOM AND BATHROOM,

47:27 - CERTAINLY. NO

47:29 - CONTEST HERE WITH HER

47:31 - EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY WITH

47:34 - RESPECT TO CHILDREN SLEEPING

47:37 - ROOMS. I CANNOT FATHOM

47:39 - HOW SHE WOULD HAVE A REASONABLE

47:41 - EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY AND I'D

47:43 - LIKE TO INDIA OPPORTUNITY TO

47:45 - DISSUADE ME A MOTION.

47:49 - SO IF I CAN BEGIN I JUST WANT

47:50 - TO MAKE SURE THAT I HEARD.

47:53 - >>ADVOCATE FOR FOR WHAT I

47:54 - BELIEVE IS ON THE RECORD.

47:57 - THE.

47:58 - >>THE REASON THAT THE AREA OF

48:00 - THE FLU IS TYPICALLY DESCRIBED

48:01 - AS THE CHILDREN SLEEPING AREA

48:03 - WITH IN A

48:04 - BEDROOM IS. THE RECORD DID NOT

48:08 - ESTABLISH THOSE THAT THE ROOM

48:09 - WAS ACTUALLY A CHILD

48:11 - EXCLUSIVELY.

48:15 - SETUP WAS THAT WHAT HAS TO BE

48:17 - THE NANNY CARE FOR LACK OF A

48:19 - BETTER TERM WAS PLACED ON THE

48:21 - LARGER BAD IN THE BEDROOM AND

48:23 - FACING A THE CHILD SCREAM

48:25 - NOW THAT POINT MAY NOT BE

48:26 - MOVING ON TO SOME PEOPLE.

48:29 - BUT TO ME I DO THINK IT MAKES A

48:30 - BIT OF A DIFFERENCE IN THAT IS

48:32 - NOT A ROOM EXCLUSIVELY USED FOR

48:34 - THE CHILDREN THERE WOULD BE

48:35 - ADULTS THAT WOULD BE TRAVERSING

48:37 - IN AND OUT OF THE BEDROOM, ANY

48:38 - POINT. I WAS

48:40 - OUT.

48:41 - >>SO THERE WAS NO RECORD

48:42 - EVIDENCE AT THE NANNY. SLEPT ON

48:46 - THE BED.

48:48 - >>WELL, I AGREE WITH THAT

48:48 - THAT'S CORRECT.

48:50 - BUT WHAT I WOULD

48:53 - JURORS THIS. THIS IS A HOME AND

48:55 - THIS IS A

48:55 - POLICEMAN ONE. THE HOME IS

48:58 - TRADITIONALLY THOUGHT OF THE

48:59 - BASHING OF PRIVACY, YOU KNOW IT

49:00 - WAS NOT MY CLIENTS WILL OF

49:01 - COURSE. BUT THAT DOESN'T CHANGE

49:04 - THE FACT OF IT IS A RESIDENCE

49:05 - AND IS NOT A PLACE FOR

49:07 - ADDITIONALLY THOUGHT TO

49:09 - HAVE CLANDESTINE SURVEILLANCE.

49:12 - IT WAS REPLACED OF EMPLOYMENT.

49:14 - AND CERTAINLY THERE ARE SOME

49:15 - PLACES OF EMPLOYMENT THAT WILL

49:17 - OVERTLY INFORM

49:19 - THEIR EMPLOYEES THAT THEY ARE

49:21 - BEING RECORDED. COURSE IT'S NO

49:23 - LONGER THEN SECRETLY RECORDED.

49:27 - AND ALL MY POSITION MAY JUST BE

49:29 - ONE THAT I DIFFER ON.

49:32 - THE CURRENT STATE

49:33 - OF SOCIETY WHICH IS THAT I

49:36 - DON'T THINK IT'S REASONABLE FOR

49:37 - A PERSON

49:38 - WHO IS ARGUABLY GETTING THE

49:40 - TRUST OF THE FAMILY SO MUCH SO

49:42 - THAT SHE'S REMAINED THEIR

49:43 - EMPLOYEE FOR SEVERAL MONTHS.

49:45 - SHE TAKES CARE OF THE CHILDREN

49:46 - ALL DAY INTO THE EVENING,

49:48 - 3 YOUNG CHILDREN. I DO NOT

49:51 - THINK THAT THE IDEAS ARE

49:52 - CRIMPING GREW INTO SHE WOULD

49:53 - BELIEVES SHE HAD. SUCH A HIGH

49:56 - LEVEL OF TRUST FROM THE PARENTS

49:58 - SLASH EMPLOYERS. I ALSO SUSPECT

50:01 - THAT PERHAPS THEY WERE SECRETLY

50:03 - RECORDING HER. SHOW.

50:07 - >>YES AS DONNIE YEAR.

50:09 - I CAN SO I'M.

50:11 - YOUR CLIENT I DIDN'T I

50:14 - TESTIFIED. YEAH,

50:16 - SHE BELIEVES THE AN EXPECTATION

50:20 - OF PRIVACY AND I'VE BEEN

50:22 - ANTICIPATE YOUR ANSWER YOU'RE

50:23 - GOING TO SAY.

50:25 - WELL I SHE CAN RELY ON

50:27 - CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE BUT FOR

50:29 - EVERY ARGUMENT THAT

50:31 - YOU JUST ME I AS TO WHY SHE I'D

50:34 - BE HAPPY EXPECTATION

50:36 - OF PRIVACY. I THIS RECORD

50:38 - I IS ALL I I'M BITS AND PIECES

50:41 - OF INFORMATION THAT WOULD

50:43 - SUGGEST OTHERWISE. I'M SHE WAS

50:45 - QUESTIONED BY THE FIBER ABOUT

50:47 - WHETHER OR NOT PHYSICALLY I USE

50:50 - THE CHILDREN, I'M THAT IN AND

50:52 - OF ITSELF, I YOU KNOW WE RAISE

50:54 - A DIFFERENCE AND I ISSUE SAW

50:57 - FROM THOSE THAT USE AT FORT SO

50:59 - IS

51:00 - IT CRITICAL. IN THIS

51:02 - CIRCUMSTANCE THAT YOUR CLIENT

51:05 - HAS TESTIFIED THAT SHE AND AN

51:08 - EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY.

51:09 - >>WELL, OF COURSE MY ANSWER IS

51:10 - NO I DON'T BELIEVE THAT THAT'S

51:12 - THE BUT WHY NOT

51:14 - SO I DON'T BELIEVE THE LAW

51:16 - REQUIRES HER TO TAKE THE STAND

51:18 - AND SAY THE MAGIC WORDS.

51:20 - BECAUSE ANYONE CAN

51:22 - DO THAT WHETHER REASONABLE OR

51:25 - NOT I DO THINK IT WOULD HAVE

51:26 - BOLSTERED OUR POSITION I WON'T

51:28 - ARGUE THAT IT WOULD HAVE AS SHE

51:30 - GOT ON THE STAND AND MADE

51:31 - THAT STATEMENT. HOWEVER, THE

51:33 - FACT THAT SHE WOULD THAT SHE

51:34 - HAS A KNACK FOR TEQUILA DID

51:35 - THAT I DON'T BELIEVE THAT'S

51:36 - FIELDS WHO ARE CASE.

51:38 - >>THE IDEA WE.

51:40 - >>REALLY HOPE THE COURT

51:41 - UNDERSTANDS IS THE

51:42 - CONFRONTATION ABOUT THE

51:44 - CHILDREN

51:44 - HAVING CRUISES THE RECORD THE

51:48 - CAMO SUGGESTS THAT AND ARGUES

51:49 - THAT ALMOST AS THOUGH IT'S A

51:51 - THE GOSPEL TRUTH.

51:53 - HOWEVER, IT IS NOT UNCOMMON FOR

51:55 - PARENTS TO HAVE A DISCUSSION

51:57 - WITH. BABYSITTER ABOUT WHERE

51:59 - MARKS ON CHILDREN ARE COMING

52:01 - FROM HIS. I'M GUESSING MANY IF

52:02 - NOT ALL OF YOU KNOW YOUNG

52:04 - CHILDREN OFTEN CHARGED YOU FIND

52:06 - THEMSELVES WITH MARKS

52:07 - AND BRUISES JUST BASED ON THEIR

52:09 - DAILY ACTIVITY.

52:10 - SO IT'S NOT UNCOMMON FOR MOM OR

52:12 - DAD TO COME HOME AT THE END OF

52:13 - THE DAY AND SAY A WISE THIS

52:14 - MARCH HERE IN THIS MARK THERE.

52:16 - AND YOU KNOW THE FACT THAT MY

52:18 - CLIENT COULDN'T EXPLAIN IT,

52:20 - DOESN'T MEAN THAT SHE FAILED A

52:22 - CONFRONTATION ABOUT

52:23 - HER SUSPECTED CHILD ABUSE AND I

52:25 - WOULD SUGGEST THE FACT THAT SHE

52:27 - REMAINED EMPLOYED. WHY THESE

52:29 - PEOPLE FOR 2 MONTHS BEYOND

52:32 - THE THIS. YOU KNOW THIS

52:34 - DISCUSSION OF THE MARKS

52:36 - SUGGESTS THAT THE FAMILY REALLY

52:38 - DIDN'T CONFRONT HER ABOUT CHILD

52:41 - ABUSE SPECIFICALLY

52:43 - AND THEN RECEIVE A MONTH

52:44 - SATISFACTORY ANSWERS. THEY

52:46 - CONTINUE TO KEEP HER IN THAT

52:48 - POSITION FOR A VERY SIGNIFICANT

52:50 - AMOUNT OF TURN.

52:52 - SO I I DO THINK FROM MY

52:55 - CLIENT'S PERSPECTIVE. SHE WOULD

52:56 - HAVE THOUGHT THAT THERE WERE NO

52:57 - ISSUES THAT IS THAT IT WAS AN

53:00 - ISSUE IN THE FIRST PLACE IT HAD

53:01 - BEEN SMOOTHED OVER WAR. THE

53:04 - PARENTS GONE BEYOND.

53:05 - >>SHE HAD TO SHE DID TESTIFY

53:07 - DID YOU NOT.

53:08 - >>VERY

53:08 - BRIEFLY S.

53:10 - >>BUT YOU DIDN'T TESTIFIED THAT

53:11 - HE HAD AN EXPECTATION OF

53:12 - PRIVACY. SHE DID NOT SAY THAT

53:15 - THAT'S CORRECT. THANK YOU.

53:17 - JUST THE START TREATY.

53:21 - >>THERE IS A

53:21 - CONFLICT BETWEEN YOU AND

53:23 - HOW WELL A DO YOU AGREE THAT

53:26 - THE FATHER TERMINATED HER

53:28 - EMPLOYMENT. AFTER HE OBSERVED

53:30 - THE VIDEO.

53:35 - >>SIR I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK OUT

53:37 - OF TURN I

53:38 - WILL ADMIT. I DO FIRST OF ALL I

53:40 - DO KNOW THAT TOOK PLACE WHEN I

53:42 - I CAN'T SPEAK TO WEAR EXACTLY

53:44 - THAT IS ON THE RECORD. IF

53:46 - AT ALL. BUT I DO KNOW

53:48 - THAT MY IT'S BECOME ALL

53:51 - REFERENCES IN THEIR BRIEF THAT

53:52 - THE FATHER AFTER OBSERVING THE

53:54 - VIDEO TERMINATOR.

53:55 - >>DOES THAT NOT PRESUPPOSE.

53:58 - >>AND SHE KNEW SHE WAS BEING

54:00 - I OBSERVED. SUCH THAT SHE

54:02 - MANIPULATED THE SUSPECT SHE HAS

54:05 - NO EXPECTATION OF CRIME.

54:09 - >>OH MY I DON'T THINK IT

54:11 - ONE FACTUAL DIFFERENCE THAT.

54:16 - I I I THINK THE MEDIA AND WE

54:17 - ARGUED AS THE RECORD DOES NOT

54:20 - ESTABLISH WHEN MY CLIENT IS

54:23 - IT ALL BECAME AWARE THAT

54:25 - ACTUALLY WAS

54:26 - ACTUALLY BEING RECORDED WITH

54:28 - THE AGAIN ALL SEEN AN ATM.

54:30 - THERE IS TESTIMONY THAT AT SOME

54:32 - POINT.

54:34 - >>SHE LOOKED INTO IT MAY PUT A

54:36 - FLASHLIGHT AND SHOOK AROUND.

54:38 - I WOULD SUGGEST THAT MEANS SHE

54:40 - CERTAINLY DID NOT KNOW IT WAS

54:41 - THE HAIR AND THE TERM OF THE

54:42 - INCIDENT ISSUE. I WOULD ALSO

54:44 - SUGGEST THAT THE.

54:47 - >>THE

54:47 - TRIAL COURT MADE A FACTUAL

54:49 - FINDING THAT THE THAT THE

54:50 - EVIDENCE WAS NOT ESTABLISHED

54:52 - WHO'S AWARE OF THE PRESENCE OF

54:54 - ANY G M BEFORE THE INCIDENT

54:56 - OF ISSUE US IN THE EXACT TIME

54:57 - OF HER TERMINATION US RIGHT

54:59 - THAT I CAN SPEAK TO APOLOGIZE

55:01 - FOR THAT

55:01 - DEFICIENCY BUT I DON'T READ THE

55:04 - TERM FOR TERMINATION WOULD BE

55:06 - TO BE VERY MEANINGFUL TO THE

55:07 - ARGUMENT THAT WE'RE HAVING TO

55:08 - THAT.

55:09 - >>THEY'RE NOT. THIS IS WHACKED.

55:12 - >>IT IS TO JUST THIS COUNCIL

55:14 - GOOD MORNING. MORNING HIGH

55:15 - WIRE. THE NONVERBAL.

55:20 - THE MOST MEMORABLE SOUNDS A

55:21 - HITTING SLAPPING

55:22 - ET CETERA. WHY ARE THOSE AN

55:26 - ORAL COMMUNICATION GEAR IN THE

55:28 - STATUTE DEFINES COMMUNICATION

55:31 - IS SOMETHING 100.

55:36 - WHEN WE LOOK AT THE STATUTE.

55:37 - IT TALKS ABOUT THE ELECTRONIC

55:39 - COMMUNICATION.

55:41 - >>IT ALSO COMES AS GENERAL

55:42 - CONTENT AND IT ALSO TALKS THE

55:47 - SOLUTION OF ANY EVIDENCE THAT

55:49 - IS DERIVED FROM ENROLLED

55:52 - PATIENTS. AND I THINK THAT IT'S

55:54 - MEANINGFUL FOR THE SAME REASON.

55:56 - SAME ARGUMENT OF THE

55:57 - COMMONWEALTH. ONCE THOSE WHO

55:59 - WISH TO BE HEARD WHAT I CAN

56:00 - ALMOST PROMISE YOU IS WHAT

56:01 - THEY'RE GOING TO ARGUE AT TRIAL

56:02 - RUNS. THE CONTEXT.

56:08 - OR STATES. MADE

56:10 - ME NON FOR MORE NON WORLD

56:13 - STATEMENTS VERY MEANINGFUL.

56:16 - AND I THINK YOU CAN DERIVE.

56:19 - FROM

56:20 - THE SOUNDS. WHAT'S BEING SAID

56:23 - BY THE DEFENDERS. SO THE

56:26 - PROBLEM IS IF YOU

56:28 - ELIMINATE THE VERBAL EARL

56:30 - COMMUNICATIONS HERE. AND YOU

56:32 - LEAVE THE OTHER SOUNDS IN

56:34 - THE EVIDENCE THE JURY CAN GLEAN

56:36 - FROM THE OTHER SENSES STILL

56:37 - THERE AND THAT'S AGAIN THE

56:39 - CLIPPERS PROBABLY WHY HIS SHOES

56:40 - BEFORE YOU RIGHT NOW.

56:42 - THE COMMONWEALTH IS

56:43 - ACKNOWLEDGING THERE'S VALUE IN

56:44 - SOUNDS AS THOSE THE STATUTE.

56:47 - SO CHARTER OF JUST TESTING YOUR

56:50 - POINT ON SUPPOSE THAT NOT A

56:53 - SINGLE WORD WAS UTTERED

56:55 - SUPPOSE THE AUDIO CONSISTED

56:57 - ONLY OF THE SOUNDS. WELL WHEN

56:59 - YOUR POSITION BE.

57:04 - A SURGE

57:05 - OF MONEY THAT

57:06 - EVIDENCE CAN BE DERIVED FROM

57:08 - THE CELLS IN A SECRET COURT.

57:11 - I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT WE

57:13 - ARE ASKING THE COURT TO SAY

57:16 - THERE MUST BE

57:16 - A NEXUS BETWEEN ORAL STATEMENT

57:22 - THE OTHER. MANUEL SOUNDS

57:24 - HOWEVER IN THIS PARTICULAR

57:25 - CASE. THE CONTEXT IS WHAT IS

57:28 - GOING ON. I CAN THROW SOME

57:30 - OTHERS EXAM OTHER EXAMPLES OUT

57:31 - THERE WE'RE CONSCIOUS OF THE

57:32 - NEED FOR

57:33 - SOME AREAS. BUT I THINK THE

57:36 - POINT IS PROBABLY MADE.

57:40 - SO YOU KNOW THE THE OVERALL

57:41 - SOUND HAS

57:43 - INCREDIBLE DOWN AND THERE SOON

57:46 - THE COMMON CORE KNOWLEDGE AS

57:47 - WELL. THANK YOU.

57:50 - >>I THINK YOU JUST AS MONDAY.

57:52 - HE JUST BOUGHT.

58:00 - >>I'M NOT SURE WHAT

58:01 - THE RECORD

58:01 - REFLECTS ON THE STATUS OF YOUR

58:04 - CLIENT WAS SHE AN OVERNIGHT

58:06 - BABYSITTER DIGIT BEDROOM IN US

58:08 - PRESIDENTS.

58:09 - >>SHE DID NOT AND WAS NOT A SHE

58:11 - WAS THERE

58:11 - OFTEN TIMES FROM VERY EARLY IN

58:14 - THE THROUGH SOMETIMES LATER IN

58:16 - THE EVENING OF BOTH OF THE

58:18 - CHILDREN'S PARENTS ARE EMPLOYED

58:20 - AND. SHE WAS IN QUITE A

58:22 - SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF TIME

58:23 - THERE. NOT AN OVERNIGHT GUEST,

58:25 - THOUGH AT LEAST

58:26 - I DON'T NOT ONLY THE RECORD

58:28 - REFLECTS ON ANY REGULAR BASIS

58:30 - IF IT ALSO LEAVES ISN'T THE

58:32 - VALUE OF THE CASES THAT YOU'VE

58:33 - CITED FROM TEXAS AND

58:35 - CONNECTICUT.

58:36 - >>MITIGATED SOMEWHAT BY THE

58:38 - FACT THAT BOTH OF THOSE CASES

58:40 - INVOLVED A BABYSITTERS WHO IN

58:42 - FACT HAD BEDROOMS IN THE HOMES

58:44 - AND STAYED OVERNIGHT.

58:45 - >>I WELL CONCEDED IT

58:49 - AND THEN IT GOES TO THE POINT I

58:50 - MADE EARLIER CERTAINLY WOULD BE

58:52 - INCONSISTENT IF I DIDN'T AGREE

58:54 - THAT IT'S THIS MISSION.

58:56 - >>BUT.

58:56 - >>IT IS A AND IT IS IS A BIT OF

58:59 - A HYBRID.

59:01 - FACILITY BEING RESIDENTS AND

59:03 - POLICE.

59:11 - GOOD MORNING

59:11 - COUNCIL MORNING.

59:12 - >>WHY WHY DO THEY CALL THEM

59:14 - MANAGE HIM.

59:18 - >>WELL JUDGE I THINK

59:19 - ARE SITTING JUSTICE. I THINK

59:21 - THAT DAY. WHEN THEY CAME

59:23 - TO LIFE. THIS HOME SURVEILLANCE

59:26 - THESE CAMERAS MADE A BIT OF A

59:27 - SPLASH.

59:29 - >>I HAD THIS SPECULATION ON MY

59:31 - PART

59:31 - OF COURSE. BUT I'M YOU KNOW I

59:34 - THINK WHEN THEY FIRST YOU KNOW

59:35 - LIKE THEY WERE HIDDEN IN TEDDY

59:36 - BEARS.

59:38 - THEY WERE. THEY DID COME INTO

59:41 - THE POPULAR CULTURE

59:43 - CONSCIOUSNESS BECAUSE OF THE

59:46 - IDEA BUT THESE WERE CLANDESTINE

59:48 - RECORDING CERTAINLY. HOMES ARE

59:50 - BUILT BILL. IT'S WAS NOT A

59:52 - SHOCKING

59:52 - NEW IDEA. THE APPROPRIATENESS

59:55 - OR ARE THEIR PREVALENCE ON

59:56 - SURVEILLANCE AND THIS IS

59:57 - ANOTHER ISSUE.

59:58 - 560 >>A KID CAN HIT MAN IRAQ AND

01:00 - 02.810 GIVEN AND I THINK I AGREE WITH

01:00 - 03.840 YOU GIVEN

01:00 - 06.380 THE PREVALENCE PREVALENCE TO

01:00 - 08.590 SUCH AN EXTENT THAT WE HAVE

01:00 - 10.480 WITHIN THE LAST AND YEARS I

01:00 - 12.630 WOULD GUESS GIVEN A NAME TO ME.

01:00 - 15.180 I WOULD JUST THIS TIME IT SEEMS

01:00 - 15.850 TO ME

01:00 - 17.780 THAT I WOULD HAVE AN

01:00 - 19.070 EXPECTATION THAT I AM

01:00 - 21.680 ON CAMERA. I WOULD EXPECT HERE

01:00 - 23.590 IS A NANNY CAM I WOULD QUESTION

01:00 - 24.850 APPARENTLY DOESN'T HAVE A

01:00 - 27.720 NANNY. SO IT SEEMS TO ME THAT

01:00 - 29.110 THAT YOUR CLIENTS.

01:00 - 32.070 ARGUMENT HERE AND THAT SHE HAS

01:00 - 34.600 AN EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY IS

01:00 - 37.290 BELIED BY SOCIETAL NORM.

01:00 - 38.740 MANY KIDS.

01:00 - 44.200 WE'LL JUST I I ACTUALLY

01:00 - 44.750 THINK THAT.

01:00 - 47.270 >>THE IDEA THAT THEY ARE SUCH A

01:00 - 49.870 KNOWN ENTITY AND SPEAKS TO THE

01:00 - 52.220 NOTION THAT THEY ARE SOMETHING

01:00 - 54.870 SPECIAL THAT PEOPLE ARE DO NOT

01:00 - 56.000 NECESSARILY ACCEPT.

01:00 - 59.660 WE DON'T HEAR ABOUT ANY OTHER

01:00 - 00.660 TYPE OF CAMERA

01:01 - 02.570 AND IT'S THERE'S NOTHING

01:01 - 03.480 OFFENSIVE TO

01:01 - 07.170 ME ABOUT A PERSON BABIES BORN

01:01 - 09.390 AND IT'S THE IT'S THE SECRET

01:01 - 11.830 SURVEILLANCE HERE THAT IS

01:01 - 13.670 PROBLEMATIC. THIS IS WHAT

01:01 - 16.270 I BELIEVE THIS ADAMS POSTED ALL

01:01 - 18.150 THOSE CONSUL ONE WOULD ASSUME

01:01 - 19.690 THAT THEY PUT A CAMERA UP IN

01:01 - 21.070 THE CORNER OF THE ROOM IT WAS

01:01 - 21.830 POINTED AT HER.

01:01 - 24.610 >>SHE WOULD PERHAPS. KEEP THE

01:01 - 25.890 BABY SOMEWHERE ELSE.

01:01 - 28.120 TO THE LOWER RIGHT OF THE

01:01 - 28.990 CAMERAS SCOPE.

01:01 - 32.740 >>SO HOPEFULLY THAT WOULD NOT

01:01 - 34.170 BE THE INTENT OF THE PEOPLE

01:01 - 36.210 STOPPING THE YEARS INTERNAL SO

01:01 - 37.130 THAT WE WOULD MAKE THAT

01:01 - 39.360 ASSUMPTION. WHAT

01:01 - 41.270 I THINK THE REAL FUNCTION OF

01:01 - 42.070 THAT WOULD BE IF THEY WERE

01:01 - 43.450 REPORTED IN PUBLIC SUPPORT OR

01:01 - 44.500 TO HER THE COURTESY.

01:01 - 45.910 THE COMMON COURTESY OF

01:01 - 47.060 NOTIFYING HER THAT THEY RECEIVE

01:01 - 48.640 THE RECORDING HER. WHAT I

01:01 - 50.510 THINK THAT IT WOULD DO IS I

01:01 - 51.370 THINK THE FUNCTIONAL MOST

01:01 - 52.390 SURVEILLANCE IS WHATEVER THE

01:01 - 52.780 CHART.

01:01 - 55.800 A FACT YOU ONE MORE QUESTION IF

01:01 - 57.870 I MAY BECAUSE MY TIME IS SHORT

01:01 - 58.440 GIVEN THE.

01:01 - 02.830 >>STRUCTURE OF THIS. AND OF

01:02 - 05.910 COURSE JUST WHAT. WE WRITE IS

01:02 - 07.500 AS YOU KNOW FOR ALL OF

01:02 - 09.250 PENNSYLVANIA FOR ALL SCENARIOS.

01:02 - 12.350 IF YOU PREVAIL HERE DOESN'T

01:02 - 14.820 THAT GIVE LICENSES AND THE LAW

01:02 - 16.260 OF PENNSYLVANIA THAT IS

01:02 - 18.250 INVITED. YES, THE SMOKE

01:02 - 21.350 LICENSEE IN IN A HOLE CAN

01:02 - 25.190 GO THROUGH. MEDICINE CHEST AND

01:02 - 26.540 UNDERWEAR DRAWER

01:02 - 28.970 ANYTHING ELSE AND TO THE EXTENT

01:02 - 30.280 IT'S PICKED UP ON ON A

01:02 - 32.330 CLOSED-CIRCUIT CAMERA AND

01:02 - 33.530 THAT'S THE EVIDENCE OF IT IT

01:02 - 34.420 CAN'T GET IN DEVON.

01:02 - 37.430 >>NO SIR AND I THINK THE COURT

01:02 - 41.090 HAS CLEARLY RULED THE VIDEO

01:02 - 42.110 COMES IN.

01:02 - 45.650 SO I DO THINK TO THE EXTENT

01:02 - 46.940 THAT YOU'RE CONCERNED ABOUT

01:02 - 48.370 PRIVACY CONCERNS NOT HOME.

01:02 - 50.490 THERE WOULD BE VIDEO

01:02 - 52.270 SURVEILLANCE THAT IT'S IS

01:02 - 56.160 ADMISSIBLE AND THEN MY I COULD

01:02 - 57.640 NOT A GOOD POINT I APPRECIATE

01:02 - 59.020 MY CONCERNS ACTUALLY GO THE

01:02 - 01.960 OTHER WAY WHICH IS TO SAY HAS

01:03 - 03.230 IS ARE THE FLOODGATES GOING TO

01:03 - 04.450 BE OPENED IN PLACE OF

01:03 - 06.470 EMPLOYMENT TO CLAIM TO START

01:03 - 07.180 AUDI A RECORD

01:03 - 09.030 CAN I WALK INTO THE DISTRICT

01:03 - 11.760 ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AND RECORD MY

01:03 - 12.770 CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM WHEN

01:03 - 14.910 I'M SITTING IN THEIR ROOM.

01:03 - 17.260 YOU CAN MY EMPLOYER AUDIO

01:03 - 18.840 RECORD MY CONVERSATIONS IN MY

01:03 - 20.480 DESK WITH MY STAFF OR OUR

01:03 - 21.100 CLIENTS.

01:03 - 23.410 >>SHE CAN.

01:03 - 25.140 >>SOMEONE COME INTO YOUR OFFICE

01:03 - 26.420 ISN'T REPORTER YOU'RE SAYING.

01:03 - 27.890 THE IDEA THAT.

01:03 - 28.650 >>E.

01:03 - 30.160 >>A SLIPPERY SLOPE EXISTS.

01:03 - 32.050 ISRAEL BECAUSE OF THE

01:03 - 32.850 PREVALENCE.

01:03 - 33.770 >>OF.

01:03 - 35.320 >>THIS RECORDING EQUIPMENT YOU

01:03 - 37.620 CAN GO ON AMAZON RIGHT ALLAN BY

01:03 - 39.610 AND REPORTERS AND I I

01:03 - 40.670 UNDERSTAND YOUR POINT THAT

01:03 - 41.400 WOULD SUGGEST

01:03 - 42.770 THE INCLUSION.

01:03 - 44.970 >>THERE'S A DISTINCTION IS IS

01:03 - 46.660 THAT SCOTT SAID IT IS I BEGAN

01:03 - 48.730 WHEN THE NANNY CAM IN THE PENN

01:03 - 49.780 QUARTER BUT THANK YOU FOR THAT

01:03 - 50.060 ANSWER.

01:03 - 54.570 >>WHO ARE TIME IS

01:03 - 57.370 UP BY BILL YOU IF YOU HAD A

01:03 - 00.080 SENSE OR 2. BY WHERE

01:04 - 02.290 SUMMATION NOW IF NOT MORE

01:04 - 03.220 INCLUDING ARE YOU.

01:04 - 05.620 >>THANK YOU SIR JUST TO FLUSH

01:04 - 07.450 OUT MY LAST ONE. IT IS A

01:04 - 09.710 REAL CONCERN INSIDE RIGHT NOW.

01:04 - 10.640 >>WHAT.

01:04 - 13.000 >>IF ANY PRIVACY WE HAVE

01:04 - 15.900 CITIZENS AND I DO UNDERSTAND

01:04 - 17.880 THAT THE OLD ADAGE SOME AS BAD

01:04 - 19.650 FACTS MAKE BAD ALL AND I WOULD

01:04 - 21.900 AGREE THE FACTS OF THIS CASE OR

01:04 - 23.100 CERTAINLY NOT WONDERFUL FOR THE

01:04 - 24.730 DEFENSE THAT HAVING

01:04 - 26.660 BEEN SAID THERE ARE SO MANY

01:04 - 28.240 DIFFERENT VARIATIONS OF THIS

01:04 - 30.060 FACT PATTERN WE'LL BE HARMFUL

01:04 - 31.310 TO THE FABRIC OF SOCIETY

01:04 - 34.160 JUST MOVING THE SECRET

01:04 - 37.340 RECORDING FROM CHILDREN SITTING

01:04 - 38.700 AREA INTO THE BATHROOM

01:04 - 40.750 INTO AN AREA WHERE CELL PHONES

01:04 - 43.040 IS TYPICALLY USED. WHAT HAVE

01:04 - 44.450 MONUMENTAL COMPLICATIONS.

01:04 - 46.100 I DO UNDERSTAND THAT THOSE ARE

01:04 - 46.810 NOT THE FACTS OF

01:04 - 48.830 THIS CASE. I AM CONCERNED ABOUT

01:04 - 50.290 THE DOOR BEING OPENED IN THE

01:04 - 51.760 U.S. AND OUR RIGHTS AS

01:04 - 53.990 CITIZENS. THE DEMOTION FOR THAN

01:04 - 55.630 THEY ARE NOW I THINK IT'S THEIR

01:04 - 56.790 TURN CONSIDERATION.

01:05 - 02.040 >>AND COULD WE SEE WHERE WE

01:05 - 02.830 ARE RECESSED

01:05 - 04.910 MISTER FAUCI ATTORNEY FOR THE

01:05 - 06.680 APPELLANT COMMUTERS WHO ASKED.

01:05 - 10.170 >>I CAN HEAR YOUR HONOR.

01:05 - 13.120 >>OKAY WHEN WE ENCOUNTER TO

01:05 - 15.350 TAKE THE GIRLS IF ACCORDINGLY.

01:05 - 19.040 YOU'RE STARTING YOUR

01:05 - 21.720 ARGUMENT SO WE'VE HEARD FROM

01:05 - 22.880 THE APP BARELY.

01:05 - 26.120 AND I THINK YOU'VE GOT A CHANCE

01:05 - 28.350 TO OPEN YOUR ARGUMENT SO.

01:05 - 30.770 WE DO UNDERSTAND YOUR ARGUMENT

01:05 - 33.400 BECAUSE SHE IS ALWAYS WE HAVE

01:05 - 35.690 REACH BOTH PARTIES IN.

01:05 - 38.630 WE WANTED TO GIVE YOU A CHANCE

01:05 - 40.590 TO RESPOND TO ANY QUESTIONS OR

01:05 - 42.920 MIGHT HAVE. SO WE'RE GOING TO

01:05 - 45.110 SEE A THREAT VERY MUCH AT THIS

01:05 - 46.850 TIME THAT SHE HAD A QUESTION.

01:05 - 49.640 >>I KNOW QUESTIONS JUSTICE.

01:05 - 51.540 THANK YOU JUSTICE TANI YEAR.

01:05 - 52.730 YES,

01:05 - 55.360 I COUNCIL ON ARE YOU ASKING

01:05 - 58.380 NICE TO AND GOT A ON BLACK

01:05 - 01.230 LETTERS SCHOOL. I IN THIS

01:06 - 03.750 CIRCUMSTANCE I INVOLVING

01:06 - 06.580 I I ORAL COMMUNICATIONS THAT

01:06 - 07.880 TAKE PLACE WITHIN A CHILD'S

01:06 - 08.350 BEDROOM.

01:06 - 12.460 >>NO YOUR HONOR I'M NOT ASKING

01:06 - 14.260 CERTAINLY FELT GREAT. I'M RULE

01:06 - 15.710 OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT. I

01:06 - 17.120 BELIEVE THE CASE LAW COMING OUT

01:06 - 19.490 OF THIS I SUPREME COURT IN THE

01:06 - 20.260 PAST AS IT

01:06 - 22.590 RELATES TO AS A PRIVACY IN

01:06 - 24.290 AREAS SUCH AS AND WHY

01:06 - 26.590 I WAS SPECIFICALLY SAY THAT IT

01:06 - 28.200 SHOULD BE BASED ON A CASE BY

01:06 - 30.630 CASE BASIS. OK SO YOU DISAGREE

01:06 - 31.550 WITH AND THAT'S WHAT I'M

01:06 - 33.830 ADVOCATING. YOU DISAGREE WITH

01:06 - 34.720 JUDGE NOW.

01:06 - 39.480 IT TOOK A POSITION AT.

01:06 - 41.690 ANYONE WHO'S IN THE

01:06 - 42.840 CHILD'S BEDROOM.

01:06 - 45.980 >>AND SINE NO EXPECTATION OF

01:06 - 47.100 PRIVACY NECKLINE.

01:06 - 49.750 >>I WOULDN'T I WOULDN'T SAY

01:06 - 51.560 THAT I NECESSARILY DISAGREE

01:06 - 54.360 WITH THAT. I HAVE CERTAINLY

01:06 - 56.210 UNDERSTAND OR AND.

01:07 - 01.800 AND BRIGHT LINE

01:07 - 02.220 RULE UH.

01:07 - 04.430 >>YEAH, MY COMPANY GRANDMOTHER

01:07 - 05.950 WHO IS BABYSITTING HER

01:07 - 06.550 GRANDSON.

01:07 - 10.130 YOUR NEXT VACATION OF PRIVACY

01:07 - 11.770 ON THE PART OF THAT GROUP MY

01:07 - 12.460 CHILD'S BEDROOM.

01:07 - 16.230 >>I BELIEVE ON

01:07 - 18.290 THE FACTS OF THE IT WOULD JUST

01:07 - 19.490 DEPEND ON THE FACTS OF THE

01:07 - 20.000 CASE.

01:07 - 22.880 IN A GRANDMOTHER TO BE THE SOLE

01:07 - 24.520 CARETAKER AND THAT WOULD BE

01:07 - 25.990 DIFFERENT WHETHER SHE WAS JUST

01:07 - 27.890 A PERSON WHO SEES THE CHILD

01:07 - 29.460 ONCE A YEAR OK SO YOU SURE

01:07 - 31.930 YOU'RE YOU'RE ASKING US IS

01:07 - 34.470 ESSENTIALLY A PRESERVE EXISTING

01:07 - 36.040 WHY WERE YOU LOOK AT FACTS ANY

01:07 - 37.170 CASE A SPACE.

01:07 - 41.980 >>THANK HERE ARE JUST

01:07 - 44.010 A TARDY NO QUESTION.

01:07 - 48.560 THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE.

01:07 - 50.690 GOOD MORNING COUNCIL. WATCHING

01:07 - 52.450 AT THE STATUE COUNCIL.

01:07 - 54.760 WHY SHOULDN'T WE BE

01:07 - 56.640 ASKING WHETHER MASON HAD A

01:07 - 58.660 JUSTIFIED EXPECTATION THAT HER

01:07 - 00.440 COMMUNICATIONS WERE NOT BEING

01:08 - 03.230 INTERCEPTED WHY ISN'T THAT THE

01:08 - 05.390 INQUIRY. WHY DO WE

01:08 - 08.130 CARE WHETHER THIS NANNY HAD A

01:08 - 09.640 BROAD EXPECTATION OF

01:08 - 14.110 PRIVACY IN NOVI HOUSE OR IN

01:08 - 16.540 MIND. CHILD'S BEDROOM. AS IN

01:08 - 17.820 THIS CASE ILLUSTRATES.

01:08 - 19.560 WE OUGHT TO BE THINKING ABOUT

01:08 - 20.720 THE WORDS OF THE STATUTE.

01:08 - 22.830 ABOUT THE EXPECTATION OF

01:08 - 24.770 INTERCEPTION RATHER THAN HER.

01:08 - 26.260 A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO

01:08 - 27.040 PRIVACY.

01:08 - 29.420 I

01:08 - 30.590 DO AGREE.

01:08 - 32.560 >>I'M GOING TO LEAVE THAT THOSE

01:08 - 34.780 2 THINGS ARE UPSET WITH HER I'M

01:08 - 37.420 IT THERE. JUNE HAS SAID WE CAN

01:08 - 38.890 SEPARATE THEM ARE.

01:08 - 46.300 >>I THINK YOU'RE JUST

01:08 - 48.530 AS MONDAY. NO QUESTIONS.

01:08 - 50.400 THAT'S THE SQUARE.

01:08 - 54.930 >>FOLLOWING UP ON JUSTICE

01:08 - 55.560 THOMAS WHO.

01:08 - 00.270 >>HOW IMPORTANT IS IT TO THIS

01:09 - 01.960 CASE THAT.

01:09 - 02.940 >>THE.

01:09 - 03.930 >>FATHER.

01:09 - 06.020 >>RECEIVED COMPLAINTS OF

01:09 - 08.090 CORPORAL PUNISHMENT FROM ME

01:09 - 11.000 RATHER OLDER BROTHER AND THEN

01:09 - 12.980 IN FRONT OF THE BABYSITTER

01:09 - 15.350 ARGUABLY PUTTING HER ON SOME

01:09 - 16.450 NOTICE THAT SHE WAS

01:09 - 18.530 A BIT DOES THAT MAKE ANY

01:09 - 20.920 DIFFERENCE OR AS I PAUSE IT

01:09 - 23.190 EARLIER IS THE FACT THAT WE ALL

01:09 - 25.650 KNOW WHEN A NANNY CAM IS WE BUY

01:09 - 27.550 THEM WE ALL HAVE THEM ENOUGH.

01:09 - 31.370 >>I BELIEVE THAT BOTH OF THOSE

01:09 - 32.960 FACTS ARE EXTREMELY IMPORTANT

01:09 - 34.910 TO THIS CASE, I'M MICHAEL

01:09 - 36.890 IN THAT THE GENERAL KNOWLEDGE

01:09 - 39.210 THAT MANY CAMERAS OR SO

01:09 - 41.150 GENERALLY ACCESSIBLE TO THE IN

01:09 - 42.290 THE GENERAL PUBLIC WE CAN GET

01:09 - 44.390 ON AMAZON OR ANY OTHER BLACK BY

01:09 - 45.630 ONE. THEY HAVE IT YOU'RE

01:09 - 48.050 NEXT DAY. BUT IN ADDITION TO

01:09 - 49.710 THAT YOU'VE GOT YOU THEN TAKE

01:09 - 51.010 THAT KNOWLEDGE WITH THE

01:09 - 51.820 KNOWLEDGE THAT THERE HAVE

01:09 - 53.750 ALREADY QUESTIONED US THIS

01:09 - 55.440 NEWS. I BELIEVE THAT PUTS IT

01:09 - 56.860 OVER THE BACK THAT THERE CAN BE

01:09 - 58.340 NO SUBJECTIVE EXPECTATION.

01:09 - 00.660 I HAVE NEITHER SECTION PRICE.

01:10 - 01.580 >>ALL RIGHT.

01:10 - 03.210 >>THANK YOU. JEANNE, THANK YOU

01:10 - 05.740 DO HAVE A WERNER TO BY WAY OF

01:10 - 06.520 SUMMATION.

01:10 - 09.380 >>JUST VERY

01:10 - 11.470 BRIEFLY YOUR HONOR I WOULD AS

01:10 - 12.800 THIS COURT TO REVERSE THE

01:10 - 14.010 EXPRESSION COURT.

01:10 - 16.860 >>I'M WITH RESPECT TO B

01:10 - 18.860 I'M REASONABLE EXPECTATION OF

01:10 - 20.730 IS MASON. I THINK IT'S CLEAR

01:10 - 21.820 THAT IN ON THE FACTS OF THE

01:10 - 22.230 CASE.

01:10 - 23.930 >>HE DID NOT HAVE A REASONABLE

01:10 - 25.200 EXPECTATION OF PRIVACY.

01:10 - 27.500 NOR SHOULD AND THE FACTS OF THE

01:10 - 29.350 CASE THIS COURT BE WILLING TO

01:10 - 31.440 I'M THAT COULD BE SIDE OF THE

01:10 - 33.780 EXCEPTION. AND SECONDLY HONOR

01:10 - 36.370 THE COURT RULINGS BEYOND THAT A

01:10 - 38.360 SPECIFIC ISSUE I WOULD ASK THE

01:10 - 39.590 COURT TO PERMIT

01:10 - 41.900 B. NOW I'M TERRIBLE NON

01:10 - 43.790 COMMUNICATION SOUNDS FROM HER

01:10 - 45.710 OR SIMPLY SIGN A JOB AND TO

01:10 - 47.110 GRAHAM AND THEN BEATING A

01:10 - 49.280 CHILD. THERE'S THE ADMISSIBLE

01:10 - 51.130 BECAUSE THOSE ARE I

01:10 - 52.980 THE STATE. HER WORK.

01:10 - 55.420 >>THANK YOU, THANKS TO BOTH OF

01:10 - 56.490 YOU AND THAT CONCLUDES YOUR

01:10 - 57.570 ARGUING THAT CASE

01:10 - 01.090 WILL STAND DOWN TILL 11 O'CLOCK

01:11 - 03.060 WHICH WILL I WILL COMMENCE

01:11 - 05.330 ARGUMENT A MEDIA. HER CASE TO

01:11 - 07.320 THE DAY JOHN Q. THANK YOU.

01:11 - 08.260 THANK YOU.

01:11 - 11.370 >>DURING THE UNCERTAIN TIMES

01:11 - 12.000 BROUGHT ON BY THE

01:11 - 13.980 CORONAVIRUS OUTBREAK PCN

01:11 - 15.510 REMAINS COMMITTED TO THE NEEDS

01:11 - 17.070 OF PENNSYLVANIA AND ITS PEOPLE

01:11 - 19.120 PC AND PROVIDES FREE DAILY

01:11 - 20.600 CORONAVIRUS UPDATES FROM

01:11 - 21.530 GOVERNOR WOLF AND THE

01:11 - 22.830 DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH SECRETARY

01:11 - 24.480 DOCTOR LEVINE LIVE

01:11 - 26.140 ON HERE AND STREAMING ON THE

01:11 - 27.280 APP AND ONLINE.

01:11 - 28.910 THESE UPDATES WILL BE AVAILABLE

01:11 - 30.590 TO WATCH IN THEIR ENTIRETY ON

01:11 - 31.600 DEMAND FOR FREE

01:11 - 33.940 BY DOWNLOADING THE PCN APP OR

01:11 - 36.110 AT PCN TV DOT COM

01:11 - 38.220 PCN COMMUNITY TO KEEPING

01:11 - 39.550 PENNSYLVANIA INFORM.

01:11 - 42.210 >>NEXT

01:11 - 44.440 ARGUMENT ISN'T IN RATES ALL THE

01:11 - 46.090 BILLS TOOK HER TESTER OAKLAND

01:11 - 48.220 SCHOOL BUSINESS. WHERE THE

01:11 - 49.370 MEDIA PALANCE IS

01:11 - 52.340 ROBERT FIRE IN PRESENTING ON

01:11 - 53.980 HOW WE TRY TESTER WAS DUMB

01:11 - 56.970 VOICE REPRESENTING DISTRICT ONE

01:11 - 58.430 IS IT. IT WILL BE IMPORTANT.

01:12 - 02.460 >>I DID MORNING AND MISTER

01:12 - 05.590 ISSUE IN THIS APPEAL IS WHETHER

01:12 - 08.010 THE INCOME GENERATED BY LAND.

01:12 - 09.950 ON WHICH WOULD GO BOARD

01:12 - 13.350 IS LOCATED MAY BE IN

01:12 - 16.100 THE CALCULATIONS A FAIR MARKET

01:12 - 17.630 VALUE FOR THE PURPOSES OR

01:12 - 19.490 PROPERTY TAX SHEP SMITH.

01:12 - 22.470 >>GOOD MORNING MISTER CHIEF

01:12 - 23.790 JUSTICE AND MAY IT PLEASE THE

01:12 - 25.610 COURT. SECTION

01:12 - 28.520 8.11 BEFORE OF THE CONSOLIDATED

01:12 - 29.960 CHANNEL TO ASSESS THE LAW.

01:12 - 32.370 US LEE MANDATES.

01:12 - 34.740 NO SIGN OR SIGN STRUCTURE

01:12 - 36.440 PRIMARILY USED TO SUPPORT OR

01:12 - 39.080 DISPLACE ON SHALL BE ASSESSED

01:12 - 40.280 THAT'S REAL PROPERTY.

01:12 - 42.430 THIS LANGUAGE MEANS THE

01:12 - 44.160 BILLBOARDS ARE NOT REAL ESTATE

01:12 - 46.530 AND CLUES ALL 3 METHODS OF

01:12 - 47.680 ASSESSMENT UNDER SECTION

01:12 - 50.440 8.42. IT DOES NOT CREATE AN

01:12 - 52.040 EXCEPTION ALLOWING THE INCOME

01:12 - 52.540 ROCHE.

01:12 - 55.340 ASSESSMENT ASSESSING LAND BASED

01:12 - 57.010 ON INCOME FROM BILL KORTZ

01:12 - 59.360 NECESSARILY ASSESSES THE VALUE

01:12 - 59.500 OF

01:12 - 01.920 THE WORKS. JUST AS AN INCOME

01:13 - 03.310 APPROACH ASSESSMENT OF LAND

01:13 - 05.700 WITH OFFICE BUILDING. JUSTICES

01:13 - 06.720 VALUE OF THE BUILDING.

01:13 - 08.890 THE COMMONWEALTH COURT'S

01:13 - 10.610 DECISION NOT ONLY ALLOWS WITH

01:13 - 12.680 THE STATUTE EXPRESSLY PROHIBITS

01:13 - 14.830 IT CANNOT BE SQUARED WITH THIS

01:13 - 17.250 COURT'S DECISIONS ISSUE FROM

01:13 - 19.030 BRULEE THIS COURT DECIDED THAT

01:13 - 20.250 THE MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT

01:13 - 23.180 EXCLUSION IN A T 11 BE ONE.

01:13 - 25.400 ROHIT INDIRECTLY

01:13 - 27.490 EXCLUDING IT ASSERTED

01:13 - 29.370 INDIRECTLY BEING EXCLUDED, I

01:13 - 31.230 GUESS. AND IF

01:13 - 32.500 THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS HERE WERE

01:13 - 35.020 CORRECT. IN THIS COURT'S 2002

01:13 - 36.720 DECISION IN INDEPENDENT OIL AND

01:13 - 37.930 GAS ASSOCIATION.

01:13 - 39.850 THESE MEETINGS BECAUSE THE

01:13 - 42.030 ASSESSMENT COULD BE ACE ON THE

01:13 - 44.420 INCOME TO THE LANDOWNER OIL AND

01:13 - 46.530 GAS LEASES EVEN THOUGH THE OIL

01:13 - 48.020 AND GAS VERSUS OF.

01:13 - 50.380 COMMONWEALTH COURT'S DECISION

01:13 - 52.040 CREATE SPLITS IN CONSISTENCIES

01:13 - 52.340 WITHIN

01:13 - 53.930 THE STATUTE. IN RED ARE

01:13 - 55.910 STATUTORY TEXAS SURPLUS.

01:13 - 59.090 THERE IS NO TEXTUAL BASIS

01:13 - 00.820 INCOME APPROACH ASSESSMENTS.

01:14 - 02.870 WE EXCLUDED PROPERTY AND ARE

01:14 - 05.840 ONLY SECTION 8.11 BEFORE.

01:14 - 08.070 AND NOT UNDER OTHER SUBSECTIONS

01:14 - 11.060 OF 8811 BE. BUT THIS COURT

01:14 - 12.840 SCHAFFER BREWING. ALREADY

01:14 - 14.000 ANSWERED THAT QUESTION FOR

01:14 - 15.880 MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT AND ARE

01:14 - 17.940 BEING WANT. AND THE SCHOOL

01:14 - 19.890 DISTRICTS WERE CORRECT. IT WAS

01:14 - 21.200 WHOLLY UNNECESSARY FOR THE

01:14 - 23.150 GENERAL ASSEMBLY. THE CRAFT

01:14 - 25.070 LANGUAGE EXPRESSLY ALLOW INCOME

01:14 - 26.540 APPROACH ASSESSMENT LAND.

01:14 - 28.530 IT'S ENDING WITH GENERATORS

01:14 - 30.500 UNDER SUBSECTION B FOSSE.

01:14 - 34.000 OUR POSITION DOES NOT RESULT IN

01:14 - 35.890 THE LAND ITSELF BEING EXCLUDED

01:14 - 37.690 FROM ASSESSMENT AS THE SCHOOL

01:14 - 38.860 DISTRICTS ARE OBVIOUSLY

01:14 - 40.900 CONTENT. OUR POSITION

01:14 - 42.790 IS THAT TO HIS BUSINESS SENSE.

01:14 - 43.850 THE GENERAL

01:14 - 45.990 ASSEMBLY REQUIRES BUT THE LAND

01:14 - 47.760 THE VALUE WITHOUT REPORTED

01:14 - 49.250 INCOME FROM THE COURT ON

01:14 - 49.630 PROPERTY.

01:14 - 53.210 WILL BEGIN

01:14 - 55.480 QUESTIONING WITH A JUSTICE TANI

01:14 - 55.760 HERE.

01:14 - 58.160 >>I THINK THE TEA. GOOD

01:14 - 59.490 MORNING. MISTER BUYER, GOOD

01:14 - 01.060 MORNING. I

01:15 - 03.250 I HAVE TO BE JUST STARTING OUT

01:15 - 06.270 BY SAYING ON I I DISAGREE WITH

01:15 - 07.540 YOU AND LET ME TELL YOU WHY.

01:15 - 10.460 I'M LOOKING AT THIS STATUTE.

01:15 - 11.830 THE EXCEPTION THAT WE'RE

01:15 - 13.440 TALKING ABOUT AND MAYHEM TO

01:15 - 15.830 READ IT TOO MANY TIMES. BUT IT

01:15 - 17.980 SEEMS CLEAR ON ITS FACE

01:15 - 20.560 THAT ONE IS EXCLUDED FROM

01:15 - 22.860 TAXATION OR WEIGHT IS EXCEPTED

01:15 - 24.330 FROM TAXATION COULD BE MORE

01:15 - 25.110 PRECISE.

01:15 - 28.120 OR IS THE SIGN OR THE

01:15 - 30.520 SIGN STRUCTURE. IT DOES

01:15 - 33.230 NOT SAY THE SIGN OR STAFF SIGN

01:15 - 35.470 STRUCTURE AND THE GROUND ON

01:15 - 36.010 WHICH IT

01:15 - 39.090 DOES PLACE AND YOUR YOUR

01:15 - 41.190 INTERPRETATION OF THE STATUTE.

01:15 - 43.860 DO WE NOT HAVE TO READ THAT

01:15 - 45.950 LANGUAGE AND A GROUND ON WHICH

01:15 - 47.250 TO DISPLACE THROUGH SOMETHING

01:15 - 49.050 SIMILAR TO THE EYE INTO THIS

01:15 - 51.610 EXCEPTION. AND IS IN YOUR

01:15 - 53.570 ARGUMENT IN DIRECT

01:15 - 57.530 CONTRAVENTION OF OUR LIKE

01:15 - 00.320 INCLUDING ONE COUNT. IN WHICH

01:16 - 01.460 WE HAVE NOW.

01:16 - 05.390 GRAHAM LEE SAYS NEED TO BE

01:16 - 07.840 TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT IN THE

01:16 - 10.780 VALUATION OF THE REAL PROPERTY

01:16 - 13.350 HELD BY THE CASKET. YOUR

01:16 - 15.790 HONOR THE LANGUAGE THAT YOU'RE

01:16 - 17.110 SUGGESTING THAT WE'RE NOT

01:16 - 18.170 SUGGESTING BE.

01:16 - 20.400 >>IN ALL IN THE STASH IT.

01:16 - 24.930 WE HAVE NO PROBLEM AND BEING

01:16 - 26.930 TAXED THE QUESTION IS HOW DO

01:16 - 28.450 YOU VALUABLE AND HOW TO USE A

01:16 - 32.170 SPOON. SECTION 11

01:16 - 34.260 THE IS AN EXCLUSION

01:16 - 35.480 PROVISION THAT SAYS THAT THE

01:16 - 37.200 BILLBOARDS CANNOT BE.

01:16 - 40.310 INCLUDED WITHIN THAT LAND EVEN

01:16 - 41.200 THOUGH THEY'RE ON THE WAY

01:16 - 43.500 YOU WOULD VALUE GOING TO BE

01:16 - 44.820 LISTENING TO THE EXCLUSION.

01:16 - 46.850 WE'RE NOT THERE. LET'S ASSUME

01:16 - 47.680 THAT YOU COULD

01:16 - 50.400 TAX LAND CONTINUE BILL WOULD

01:16 - 52.010 YOU DO IT PRECISELY THE SAME

01:16 - 53.960 WAY AS THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE

01:16 - 56.920 PROPOSING HERE. YOU KNOW AND HE

01:16 - 58.470 WOULD HAVE TO BILLBOARDS YOUTH

01:16 - 00.050 EMPLOYMENT INCOME APPROACH.

01:17 - 02.540 I'M IN THE SAME PROPERTY WHICH

01:17 - 02.960 IS WHY WE'RE

01:17 - 06.290 SAYING THAT BY EXCLUDING THE

01:17 - 07.680 BILLBOARDS. THE GENERAL

01:17 - 09.330 ASSEMBLY MEANT TO EXCLUDE THESE

01:17 - 11.330 AS REAL ESTATE, HE ASSESSED

01:17 - 12.800 AT ALL YOU CAN

01:17 - 14.600 ASSESS FULLY AND WITHOUT

01:17 - 16.240 ASSESSING THE INCOME OR THE

01:17 - 19.040 VALUE. THE BILLBOARDS WE THINK

01:17 - 22.490 1 ONE TO CASES THE STEERING

01:17 - 24.960 WHEEL BECAUSE THAT'S UNDER

01:17 - 26.000 EVERYTHING IS EVERYTHING THERE

01:17 - 26.380 IS UNDER

01:17 - 28.800 8811 DAY. OH AND HE WAS UNDER

01:17 - 32.790 AS IT WAS IN FACT IN ONE ATTACK

01:17 - 34.230 THE ONLY QUESTION WAS WHETHER

01:17 - 35.230 YOU COULD INCLUDE

01:17 - 39.610 WHO DOES WITHIN THE SCOPE WHAT

01:17 - 42.760 IS TAXABLE BUILDINGS OF COURSE

01:17 - 44.950 ARE ALSO INCLUDED WAS IN THE 80

01:17 - 46.670 LOOKING AT. SO WE SEE NO

01:17 - 49.100 CONFLICT BETWEEN THAT AND WE

01:17 - 50.050 THINK THAT THE CONFLICT

01:17 - 52.250 HISTORY. WHEN ONE READS THE

01:17 - 54.380 STATUTE AS A WHOLE WITH RESPECT

01:17 - 55.850 TO 8842

01:17 - 57.440 WHICH IN WHICH TELLS YOU YOU

01:17 - 59.380 CAN ASSESS USING 3 METHODS.

01:17 - 01.930 INCOME IS NOT ACCESSIBLE.

01:18 - 03.760 AS ANY COME THIS IS A REAL

01:18 - 05.410 ESTATE STATUTE. ONE OTHER NOTE

01:18 - 06.320 INCOMES THAT

01:18 - 08.670 SO INCOME IS JUST ANOTHER

01:18 - 10.190 METHOD OF THIS OF ASSESSING

01:18 - 12.010 LAND. IF YOU INCLUDE THE INCOME

01:18 - 13.870 FROM THE BILLBOARD 2 SINGLE

01:18 - 14.130 WORD.

01:18 - 20.550 >>I THANK YOU I STILL DISAGREE

01:18 - 21.290 WITH YOU BUT THANK YOU

01:18 - 23.360 FOR YOUR ANSWER NOTHING ELSE.

01:18 - 27.850 DOUGHERTY QUICK.

01:18 - 30.190 >>QUICK QUESTION IF PACKING

01:18 - 32.210 AUTHORITY CANNOT PACK, THE

01:18 - 35.300 RENTAL INCOME. IT AFFECTS MEN.

01:18 - 39.230 THEN HOW DO YOU SUPPOSE THAT.

01:18 - 40.700 THE

01:18 - 42.890 SUBJECT PROPERTY WOULD BE

01:18 - 44.250 ASSESSED FOR ITS ACTUAL VALUE.

01:18 - 46.250 >>WELL IT WOULD BE ASSESSED.

01:18 - 48.570 ACTUAL VALUE WOULD HAVE TO BE

01:18 - 50.040 THE VALUE OF THE ACTUAL VALUE

01:18 - 51.640 EXCLUDING THOSE THINGS GENERAL

01:18 - 52.660 ASSEMBLY IS DIRECTLY

01:18 - 55.840 EXCLUDED. SO YOU WOULD NEED TO

01:18 - 59.200 PRESERVE ASSESSOR THEY WOULD

01:18 - 01.130 VALUE THE PROPERTY ACCORDING TO

01:19 - 03.380 MS. FAIR MARKET VALUE THAT

01:19 - 04.030 BACKING OUT OF

01:19 - 06.690 THE CONSIDERATION. SIDE IT'S

01:19 - 07.420 TELL YOU HAVE

01:19 - 10.180 ANY AWARD OR A BILL OR

01:19 - 11.330 STRUCTURE ON IT

01:19 - 12.680 THAT WOULD BE A SUBJECT FOR

01:19 - 14.270 EXPERT TESTIMONY IN THE TRIAL

01:19 - 15.870 COURT OR NOT THE GUY SHE

01:19 - 17.830 STATES YEAR THAT'S SOMETHING

01:19 - 19.230 THAT THE TRIAL COURT DETERMINED

01:19 - 20.580 BASED CLINICS WERE JUST.

01:19 - 24.630 THAT'S RIGHT. THANK YOU

01:19 - 26.230 TO JUSTICE GOOD MORNING, MISTER

01:19 - 27.800 BUYER PREGNANCY LOOKING SO

01:19 - 29.570 HEALTHY. THANK YOU JUST FOR

01:19 - 32.830 I WONDER IF YOUR ARGUMENT.

01:19 - 35.490 THIS SORT OF A LITTLE BIT LIKE

01:19 - 37.040 PAIN IS ATTENTION TO THAT MAN

01:19 - 38.040 BEHIND THE CURTAIN.

01:19 - 41.010 SO WE HAVE THIS PARCEL OF LAND

01:19 - 42.570 SUPPOSEDLY A PARCEL OF LAND

01:19 - 45.260 THERE FOR. 75 YEARS.

01:19 - 46.750 HAS

01:19 - 48.450 BEEN USED FOR NOTHING THAT

01:19 - 48.990 BILLBOARD.

01:19 - 52.480 IT WOULD HAVE NO VALUE AT ALL

01:19 - 53.410 THAT OUT OF WORK.

01:19 - 58.560 THE GROUND RENTS RATHER THAN

01:19 - 01.940 TO BILLBOARD. CAN GENERATE.

01:20 - 05.930 HOW CAN IT BE CONSISTENT WITH

01:20 - 08.740 THE ECONOMIC REALITY. SNOW WE

01:20 - 11.700 WOULD ASK AND PRAISING ENTITY.

01:20 - 16.210 TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT

01:20 - 17.430 PROPERTY WOULD FETCH IN THE

01:20 - 17.950 MARKET.

01:20 - 21.710 WHERE THERE WAS NEVER GOING TO

01:20 - 22.970 BE A BILL ON THAT PROPERTY.

01:20 - 25.850 IN OTHER WORDS. THIS ISN'T YOUR

01:20 - 29.260 ARGUMENT. WHOLLY INCONSISTENT.

01:20 - 33.920 ECONOMIC REALITY WITH HOW THE

01:20 - 35.530 MARKET WORKS WITH THE REAL

01:20 - 37.470 WORLD. IT'S HIS

01:20 - 39.470 PASSION ALL. WELL YOU ARE FIRST

01:20 - 41.490 OF ALL SO GENERAL ASSEMBLY WHO

01:20 - 43.640 SET THE RULE DECISION SKATES

01:20 - 45.380 THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THE COURT

01:20 - 46.480 WOULD BE DOING IS NEED

01:20 - 49.070 SOMETHING NEW WHERE ARE AS A

01:20 - 50.380 LANDOWNER JUST TO CREATE

01:20 - 51.910 SOMETHING NEW. THIS WAS THE

01:20 - 53.530 GENERAL ASSEMBLY'S CONSTRUCT

01:20 - 55.480 AND THE A'S WE'VE TOLD THE

01:20 - 57.490 COURT REALLY JOE THE GENERAL

01:20 - 58.950 ASSEMBLY WAS COGNIZANT OF

01:20 - 02.030 THIS ISSUE. THE ECONOMIC

01:21 - 03.930 REALITY TEST YOUR HONORS FROM 4

01:21 - 05.620 UNTIL HE COMES OUT OF THIS IS

01:21 - 07.800 LIKE CHECK ONE. INDIA

01:21 - 10.290 MORE CASE AND A

01:21 - 12.330 POTENTIALLY A YEAH THAT'S

01:21 - 13.980 ECONOMIC REALITY IS VIEWED IN

01:21 - 15.300 THE CONTEXT OF WHAT THE GENERAL

01:21 - 16.840 ASSEMBLY HAS SAID IT

01:21 - 19.770 IS TAXABLE THE STATUE. THE

01:21 - 21.230 ROCKET IS ALL HURT.

01:21 - 24.630 HE WAS RESPECTED

01:21 - 27.010 88 WE TOO AUTHORIZES 3

01:21 - 28.510 DIFFERENT METHODS OF RACHEL

01:21 - 30.690 VERSUS 2. IN ADDITION

01:21 - 33.850 SOME SECTIONS OF 8.11 HAVE TO

01:21 - 36.590 BE IMPAIRMENT SYRIAN EACH OTHER

01:21 - 37.880 AND SO

01:21 - 41.520 IN 8811 BE 5 FOR EXAMPLE, THE

01:21 - 43.240 GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS SAID WHEN

01:21 - 45.430 IT IS YOU CAN TAKE

01:21 - 49.460 THE RENTALS YEAH PAYMENTS

01:21 - 51.410 INTO ACCOUNT INVOLVED IN A

01:21 - 54.910 GROUND LEASE OR WINTER BALL

01:21 - 56.660 THROWN INTO A GENERAL.

01:21 - 59.170 DOESN'T MEAN THAT THE GENERAL

01:21 - 00.570 ASSEMBLY SAID THAT ON ONE

01:22 - 02.320 SECTION AND NOT UNDER ENOUGH

01:22 - 04.100 SUBSECTION OF THE SAME STATUTE.

01:22 - 06.600 YOU HAVE TO READ THIS IS A

01:22 - 08.460 WHOLE IS THE WORK INSIDE OR

01:22 - 09.820 OTHERS AND.

01:22 - 12.850 THE REALITY IS THE REALITY OF

01:22 - 14.860 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY'S CREATE

01:22 - 17.310 AS TO WHO KNOWS.

01:22 - 20.380 IT SOMEONE HAS A QUIBBLE WITH

01:22 - 22.120 THAT RULE IT HAS TO COME THE

01:22 - 22.790 GENERAL ASSEMBLY.

01:22 - 26.410 YES AND MONDAY.

01:22 - 33.270 >>I'M I'M CURIOUS IF THE FACTS

01:22 - 33.460 OF

01:22 - 36.200 THE SPECIFIC. LEE SAYS IF THEY

01:22 - 38.480 EXIST TO THE EXTENT THEY EXIST.

01:22 - 39.810 IMPLICATE.

01:22 - 43.220 >>IT WAS IHSAN ON THIS MATTER.

01:22 - 45.820 FOR EXAMPLE I THINK THERE'S.

01:22 - 48.830 SIGNS THAT ARE BY POLICE.

01:22 - 49.760 I THINK THERE

01:22 - 51.680 MAY BE SIGNS THAT ARE IN

01:22 - 53.080 EXISTENCE BY EASEMENT.

01:22 - 57.640 AND IT OCCURRED TO ME THAT

01:22 - 58.740 PERHAPS SOME OF

01:22 - 02.930 THESE SIGNS THE LEASES ARE THEY

01:23 - 06.580 PURPOSE OF THE SIGN STRUCTURE

01:23 - 07.910 VERSUS A

01:23 - 10.180 IF AGO GROUND RENT SCENARIO

01:23 - 12.110 WHERE YOU'RE RUNNING THE.

01:23 - 15.290 >>EARTH THAT'S WHERE THE SIGN

01:23 - 17.450 HIS PLACE. IF YOU COULD JUST

01:23 - 19.770 BRIEFLY ADDRESSED THAT TELL ME

01:23 - 21.250 WHETHER I'M CRAZY OR WHETHER

01:23 - 22.510 THAT MIGHT HAVE SOME BEARING

01:23 - 24.230 YOU'RE NOT CRAZY OR.

01:23 - 32.840 THE QUESTION OF WHETHER IT HAS

01:23 - 33.060 ANY

01:23 - 34.010 BEARING UP.

01:23 - 36.200 >>IN RELAY STUDENT PROCEDURAL

01:23 - 38.240 AUSTER THESE CASES THERE ARE 26

01:23 - 40.120 CASES SOLID IT IN

01:23 - 42.860 A TRIAL COURT JUDGE FOR DEALT

01:23 - 44.370 WITH WHAT HE CONSIDERED TO BE

01:23 - 46.790 THE OVERARCHING OF LEGAL ISSUE

01:23 - 49.250 AFFECTING ALL THE CASES CAN YOU

01:23 - 51.090 TAKE THIS INTO ACCOUNT. EVERY

01:23 - 52.820 CIRCUMSTANCE KNOW THE

01:23 - 55.050 CIRCUMSTANCES OF THESE 26 CASES

01:23 - 56.860 INSURERS INDICATED THERE.

01:23 - 58.350 IN SOME OF THESE CASES

01:23 - 00.390 FOR EXAMPLE. THE BILLBOARD

01:24 - 02.500 COMPANY OWNS THE LAND ITSELF IN

01:24 - 04.500 SEA AND THE WAR ON ITS OWN

01:24 - 06.820 PROPERTY. IN SOME OF THESE

01:24 - 08.910 CASES THERE'S AN EASE SOME OF

01:24 - 11.180 THESE CASES IT'S A IT'S A

01:24 - 12.910 RENTAL OR A GROUND LEASE.

01:24 - 14.830 IN WITH JUDGE FOR

01:24 - 17.370 GOLD IN WHAT WE BELIEVE IS TO

01:24 - 18.470 BE A CORRECT READING THE

01:24 - 20.060 STATUTE EASE THE OTHER

01:24 - 20.890 SITUATIONS

01:24 - 22.430 REALLY MATTER IN ALL THE

01:24 - 24.000 SITUATIONS WHEN YOU'RE DOING

01:24 - 26.430 THE ASSESSMENT. YOU HAVE TO DO

01:24 - 27.610 IT WITHOUT REGARD

01:24 - 31.040 PRESENCE FOR THE POTENTIAL

01:24 - 33.100 PRESENCE. I WAS SIGN OR SIZE

01:24 - 35.700 STRUCTURE. ONCE YOU GET INTO

01:24 - 36.920 VALUATION BASED

01:24 - 38.770 ON THAT YOU'VE GOT TO THE AREA.

01:24 - 40.060 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY IS

01:24 - 40.600 DIRECTING

01:24 - 43.950 BE EXCLUDED. SO WE DON'T SEE

01:24 - 44.900 WHERE THAT COULD MAKE A

01:24 - 48.390 DIFFERENCE IN TERMS HOW THIS

01:24 - 49.300 COURT TO PROTEST THE

01:24 - 51.550 LEGAL ISSUE. THE ISSUE IS WHAT

01:24 - 53.350 CAN BE TAXED AND WHAT CAN BE

01:24 - 55.850 TAXED. YOU'RE A SECTION 8.11.

01:24 - 00.240 THANK YOU JUST DESPAIR.

01:25 - 04.850 GOOD MORNING, MR. BRIERLEY.

01:25 - 08.390 IN THIS IN THE SITUATION YOU

01:25 - 10.470 JUST DESCRIBED WHERE A

01:25 - 12.700 BILLBOARD COMPANY OWNS IN FEE.

01:25 - 13.940 THE REAL PROPERTY

01:25 - 16.320 IS THAT REAL PROPERTY TAX BILL

01:25 - 16.830 HAS SOME FAIR

01:25 - 19.530 MARKET VALUE LAND TO BE TAXABLE

01:25 - 20.610 YOU HAVE TO COME UP WITH A

01:25 - 22.510 VALUE WHETHER IT'S USING

01:25 - 24.630 COMPARABLE SALES OR THE

01:25 - 26.340 PROPERTY TO BE USED FOR ANY

01:25 - 27.890 OTHER INCOME PRODUCING PURPOSE

01:25 - 29.740 OTHER THAN A A SO I

01:25 - 31.090 BUT THERE WOULD BE A WAY THAT

01:25 - 32.510 ONLY AND COULD BE ASSESSED.

01:25 - 33.890 AND WHAT I CAN TELL YOU

01:25 - 36.780 OTHERWISE IF I OWN A PIECE OF

01:25 - 37.960 FARM PROPERTY

01:25 - 40.470 WHICH IS ADJACENT TO THE

01:25 - 42.950 PENNSYLVANIA OR HURT HIM BESIDE

01:25 - 44.310 THE PENNSYLVANIA TURNPIKE

01:25 - 47.460 AND IT'S WORTH A $100,000

01:25 - 50.120 THAT'S ITS VALUE. NOW A SIGN

01:25 - 52.380 COMPANY APPROACHES ME. THE

01:25 - 55.650 CREW RENTAL OR OTHERWISE PUTS 3

01:25 - 57.610 BILLBOARDS ON THERE AND I KNOW

01:25 - 58.930 THIS IS NOT YOUR CASE, I'M JUST

01:25 - 01.360 WORKING BY AN OUCH. AND DOES

01:26 - 02.290 THAT MAKE MY

01:26 - 05.450 REAL PROPERTY GO FROM A 100,000

01:26 - 05.560 TO

01:26 - 08.970 200,000. GUESS IN TERMS OF THE

01:26 - 10.470 VALUE BECAUSE THE SIGNS ARE

01:26 - 13.640 THERE IS THAT A INCREASE

01:26 - 15.640 IN VALUE. IT'S A VALUES

01:26 - 16.740 INCREASED BECAUSE OF

01:26 - 19.200 THE SONS, THE VALUE WE HAVE TO

01:26 - 24.260 CLIQUE IT'S A TIE. WITHOUT

01:26 - 25.340 REGARD SINCE

01:26 - 29.560 NAME MY PROPERTY WE REMAIN

01:26 - 30.880 WORTH A 100,000.

01:26 - 32.580 EVEN THOUGH I COULD SELL IT FOR

01:26 - 34.420 200,000 FROM SOMEBODY WHO

01:26 - 36.120 WANTED TO BUY MY PROPERTY AND

01:26 - 37.760 THE SITES. AND THAT'S THE

01:26 - 38.810 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE CELLS

01:26 - 40.520 PRICE IN ASSESSED VALUE

01:26 - 43.640 HE SAYS YES TO BE PURSUING TO

01:26 - 46.410 LEGISLATIVE TOOLS THERE IS

01:26 - 48.570 OFTEN A DIFFERENTIAL JUST AS

01:26 - 49.810 THERE IS AGAIN A

01:26 - 52.090 DIFFERENTIAL IN JURISDICTIONS

01:26 - 53.330 THAT WE'RE FAMILIAR WITH FOR

01:26 - 54.790 EXAMPLE ALLEGHENY TO CITY

01:26 - 57.330 THAT'S FOR WAR. PHILADELPHIA,

01:26 - 58.830 WHERE YOU SEE A SEPARATE

01:26 - 00.800 VALUATION FOR LAND AND

01:27 - 04.190 STRUCTURES. IN HERE AND UNDER

01:27 - 05.480 THE SCHOOL DISTRICT'S ARGUMENT.

01:27 - 07.660 THE LAND WOULD BE WITH THE SAME

01:27 - 08.830 WHETHER IT'S PAINTER HAS A

01:27 - 11.790 STRUCTURAL. TO BE THE CASE THE

01:27 - 13.600 ONLY REASON THE LAND IS BEING

01:27 - 14.770 INCREASED BY

01:27 - 16.660 THE INCOME. IT'S BECAUSE OF AL

01:27 - 18.470 EWING, THE ACTUAL THE ACTUAL

01:27 - 20.690 STRUCTURE SO THAT'S THAT'S WHAT

01:27 - 21.970 WE SAY THAT THIS CASE IS

01:27 - 23.140 SQUARELY CONTROLLED BY THE

01:27 - 24.080 TEXAS STATUTE.

01:27 - 27.930 THANK YOU JESS IS TIED.

01:27 - 30.720 >>IT'S JUST A SIGN THAT NO

01:27 - 31.220 QUESTION.

01:27 - 35.160 >>THANK YOU MR. FIRE IF YOU HAD

01:27 - 35.820 A A.

01:27 - 40.570 WEINER TO A WE'D APPRECIATE IT

01:27 - 41.660 AND THEN ROLL.

01:27 - 42.710 >>AIR FROM ME

01:27 - 43.790 EARLY.

01:27 - 45.340 >>THANK YOU MISTER CHIEF

01:27 - 47.460 JUSTICE. IN CONCLUSION.

01:27 - 49.530 THE COURT MUST CONSIDER WHETHER

01:27 - 49.640 THE

01:27 - 51.790 GENERAL ASSEMBLY ENACTING

01:27 - 54.430 SECTION 8.11 BEFORE EXCLUDING

01:27 - 54.870 SIGNS

01:27 - 57.080 INSIDE STRUCTURES. NEVERTHELESS

01:27 - 58.570 INTENDED INCOME FROM THE

01:27 - 00.260 EXCLUDED SIGNS INSIDE

01:28 - 02.330 STRUCTURES. WE CONSIDERED IN

01:28 - 03.820 MAKING A REAL ESTATE ASSESSED.

01:28 - 06.740 ROSE THE REASONS THAT SIMPLY

01:28 - 08.290 DOES NOT MAKE SENSE

01:28 - 09.760 IN LIGHT OF THE CRACKS OF THE

01:28 - 10.850 STATUTE AND ITS

01:28 - 13.490 OBVIOUS PURPOSE. DISTRICTS

01:28 - 15.350 ARGUMENTS RELATED TO THE INCOME

01:28 - 16.480 FROM THE BILLBOARDS.

01:28 - 18.470 THE FACT WE WOULD CONVERT A

01:28 - 19.970 REAL ESTATE TAX ASSESSMENT.

01:28 - 22.280 IN 2 ATTACKS ON REVENUE WERE

01:28 - 22.660 INCOME.

01:28 - 24.710 OF COURSE THAT ALSO WOULD BE

01:28 - 27.140 CONTRARY TO LAW. INSTEAD THE

01:28 - 28.140 REAL ESTATE HERE

01:28 - 31.030 WHEN MUST BE ASSESSED IS IT A

01:28 - 31.990 LAND WHERE THEY CAN

01:28 - 33.980 OR AT LEAST MODESTLY AND ON

01:28 - 34.950 WHICH BILLBOARD

01:28 - 36.680 THIS INCLUDES FOR THESE

01:28 - 39.600 REQUESTED THE COMMONWEALTH

01:28 - 41.000 COURT IS MAYBE

01:28 - 43.900 REVERSED AND THIS COURT REMAND

01:28 - 45.190 THE CASE TO THE TRIAL COURT.

01:28 - 47.090 FOOD PERCENT. THANK YOU.

01:28 - 48.320 THANK YOU.

01:28 - 51.700 >>OKAY WE HAVE THE 2 OF CALI

01:28 - 53.210 SCHOOL DISTRICT SHOULD THAT.

01:28 - 58.430 RESPECT YOUR ACCOUNTS OF

01:28 - 59.710 WHAT EACH IT WOULD

01:29 - 10.710 SO I THINK MISTER WEISS ARE

01:29 - 13.950 YOU GOING TO SAY FOR 4 YEARS

01:29 - 15.100 AGO FIRST YOUR HONOR.

01:29 - 16.790 >>YOUR MORNING YEAR MISTER

01:29 - 17.940 CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE AMA

01:29 - 19.510 JUSTICES OF THE COURT PLEASE

01:29 - 21.360 MY NAME IS DONALD J WEISS AND

01:29 - 22.670 I'M HERE ON BEHALF THE SCHOOL

01:29 - 24.590 DISTRICTS. I'M TRYING TO STIR

01:29 - 26.470 MANY SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE

01:29 - 28.350 DIRECTLY TO MR. LIKE THE

01:29 - 30.350 RESERVE 7 MONTHS FOR

01:29 - 32.900 MY CO-COUNSEL WHO ARE YOU THE

01:29 - 34.120 ISSUES OF UNIFORMITY

01:29 - 36.620 UNCONSTITUTIONAL. I HEARD MR.

01:29 - 38.120 BYERS ARGUMENT,

01:29 - 40.770 AN IDEA WITHIN THE STATUTE THE

01:29 - 42.750 WAY HE DOES WHEN I READ THE

01:29 - 45.680 STATUTE 8811 WE ARE

01:29 - 48.210 IS IT SAYS NO SIGN WERE SIGNS

01:29 - 50.420 STRUCTURE. EVEN IF IT'S A FIX

01:29 - 52.060 TO THE GROUND SHOULD BE TAXED.

01:29 - 53.910 NOW THE WAY I LOOK AT THAT AS A

01:29 - 55.950 SIGN THAT BILLBOARD CAN RANGE

01:29 - 58.740 IN COURSE ANYWHERE FROM 50,250

01:29 - 00.940 1000. SO I INTERPRETED THAT

01:30 - 03.180 INITIALLY THEY SAY I CAN'T TAX

01:30 - 04.940 THE SUN EVEN EVER TO FIX THE

01:30 - 06.270 GROUND AND

01:30 - 08.150 MOST BILLBOARDS REALLY DO

01:30 - 09.740 BECOME FIXTURES BECAUSE THEY DO

01:30 - 11.540 BECOME OR MENTALLY FIXED TO THE

01:30 - 12.860 GROUND. THEY'RE NOT EASY

01:30 - 15.020 TO MOVE. I'D LIKE TO JUST A

01:30 - 16.730 DIRECTOR TENSION TO JUDGE HANS

01:30 - 18.430 OPINION ON PAGE 13 OF HIS

01:30 - 19.470 OPINION. MURRAY SAYS

01:30 - 20.760 DOCTOR THEIR STRICT

01:30 - 22.140 CONSTRUCTION OF A STATUTE IN

01:30 - 24.330 FAVOR OF THE PARTIES. I ONLY

01:30 - 25.770 WEARS A REASONABLE DOUBT.

01:30 - 28.070 MEANING OF THE PROVISION.

01:30 - 29.990 HERE THERE IS NO DOUBT THAT

01:30 - 32.700 SECTION 88 11 BEFORE APPLIES

01:30 - 34.940 ONLY TO EXCLUDE THE VALUATION

01:30 - 36.340 OF AN ADVERTISING SIGN READ

01:30 - 38.400 SIGNS STRUCTURE AND DOES NOT

01:30 - 40.000 PROHIBIT THE VALUATION OF LAND.

01:30 - 42.370 ACCORDING TO THE CCL REPLY

01:30 - 43.430 COUPLE CASE LAW.

01:30 - 46.180 MISTER BUYER AND I THINK JUST

01:30 - 47.220 THIS MONDAY ASKED.

01:30 - 50.590 OF THESE 26 AND YOU'RE GOING TO

01:30 - 52.580 BE MORE. WE HAVE A COMBINATION

01:30 - 54.180 OF THE SHOOTING LEA SAYS WHICH

01:30 - 56.050 ARE GENERALLY TRIPLE NET LEASES

01:30 - 57.470 TRIPLE NET LEASE REQUIRES THE

01:30 - 59.480 LET LET'S SEE TO PAY ALL

01:30 - 01.870 THE TAXES. WE HAVE AN EASY

01:31 - 03.620 MONTHS THAT WE'RE VIA BILLBOARD

01:31 - 04.800 COMPANY BOUGHT THE

01:31 - 06.580 EASEMENT AND THE OWNER

01:31 - 08.110 CONTINUES TO OPERATE A BUSINESS

01:31 - 09.980 HERE AND WE ARE PROPERTIES OF

01:31 - 11.540 THE BILLBOARD ACTUALLY BOUGHT

01:31 - 13.070 THE GROUND. IF YOU FOUND A

01:31 - 13.350 LOWER

01:31 - 15.740 COURT'S DECISION I'M A RECENT

01:31 - 17.820 CASE SPECIFICALLY IN CHESTER

01:31 - 19.840 CITY. WE'RE BILLBOARD COMPANY

01:31 - 21.260 BOARD A VACANT PIECE OF GROUND

01:31 - 24.300 FOR $240,000. THEN THEY ARE

01:31 - 26.250 WRECKED IN A BILLBOARD ON IF

01:31 - 27.430 YOU FIND A LOWER COURT'S

01:31 - 29.240 DECISION AN OPINION

01:31 - 31.240 WHEN THEY BUY THE PROPERTY THE

01:31 - 32.580 PROPERTY SHOULD BE ASSESSED A

01:31 - 35.570 $240,000. WHEN THEY ARE WRECKED

01:31 - 37.270 A BILLBOARD ON IT THEN IT

01:31 - 38.350 SHOULD GO TO 0

01:31 - 39.800 BECAUSE ACCORDING TO LOWER

01:31 - 41.230 COURT'S DECISION WANTS A BILL

01:31 - 42.860 BOARDS PUT ON IT SHOULD HAVE

01:31 - 45.550 NO ASSESSMENT. IN A MINUTE AND

01:31 - 47.120 IF YOU FOUND IN THE YEAR BUHL

01:31 - 48.710 FOUNDATION CASE AND EVEN GOING

01:31 - 50.150 BACK TO THE RECRUITING TEXTS.

01:31 - 52.590 YOU HAVE TO VALUE PROPERTY

01:31 - 55.260 BASED UPON THE BEST USE THAT HE

01:31 - 56.920 CAN BE APPLIED TO AT THIS AT

01:31 - 59.080 THAT TIME. JOIN THE BEST USES A

01:31 - 00.990 BILLBOARD AND IT SHOULD BE 8

01:32 - 02.960 NOW YOU BASED UPON WHAT CAN BE

01:32 - 05.030 DONE. I THINK JUSTICE BARRIS

01:32 - 06.240 THE CREATION OF SUPPOSE YOUR

01:32 - 07.920 OWN BE SURE GROUND. IT'S ONLY

01:32 - 08.840 WORTH A 100 GRAND.

01:32 - 10.260 BUT THEN A BILLBOARD COMPANY

01:32 - 11.520 COMES ALONG BUYS IT TO PUT A

01:32 - 13.010 BILLBOARD TOP BILLBOARD ON IT

01:32 - 14.020 AND IT GOES TO 200.

01:32 - 16.270 IN MY OPINION THAT IS WORTH 200

01:32 - 17.130 MATCH WHAT IT SHOULD BE

01:32 - 18.750 ASSESSED FOR. THERE ARE CERTAIN

01:32 - 20.120 SITUATIONS WHERE THE BILLBOARD

01:32 - 21.420 COMPANY ACTUALLY BOUGHT A PIECE

01:32 - 21.900 OF GROUND

01:32 - 24.500 TO PREVENT. THE OWNER FROM

01:32 - 26.010 ERECTING A BILL BECAUSE THEY

01:32 - 27.750 DID NOT WANT ANOTHER BILLBOARD

01:32 - 29.500 RIGHT NEXT TO THEIR EXISTING

01:32 - 31.780 BILL. THE

01:32 - 34.770 RIGHT SHOT. JUSTICE JOHNNY OF

01:32 - 35.430 THE QUESTION.

01:32 - 37.260 >>I DO NOT THINK THE CHIEF.

01:32 - 44.180 >>THIS IS OUR KEY OF ANY

01:32 - 46.120 QUESTION I HAVE NO I DON'T.

01:32 - 50.610 THANK YOU TO JUST THIS

01:32 - 51.580 MORNING COUNCIL.

01:32 - 55.150 FOLLOWING UP SIR ON

01:32 - 57.540 MR. BYERS ARE YOU MAKE OF THE

01:32 - 59.080 WIND TURBINE PROVISION.

01:33 - 04.760 GIVEN KNOW WHAT THEY SEE WHAT

01:33 - 06.870 THE LEGISLATORS DID THERE WITH

01:33 - 09.090 INCOME CAPITALIZATION METHOD.

01:33 - 12.280 WOULD YOU AGREE AS A GENERAL

01:33 - 13.760 MATTER THAT THE GENERAL

01:33 - 17.150 ASSEMBLY. COULD IN EFFECT.

01:33 - 19.650 WHAT

01:33 - 22.080 THE ECONOMIC REALITY IS GOING

01:33 - 24.680 TO BE DEFINED AS PARTICULAR

01:33 - 26.370 KINDS OF PROPERTIES SUCH THAT.

01:33 - 29.560 ALL WE NORMALLY WOULD

01:33 - 31.540 THINK OF HIS MARKET VALUE WOULD

01:33 - 34.960 BE. INFECTED DISREGARDED

01:33 - 36.980 OR OBSCURED WITH RESPECT

01:33 - 38.670 EVALUATION OF A PARTICULAR KIND

01:33 - 39.290 OF PROPERTY.

01:33 - 41.700 >>I THINK THEY COULD AND I

01:33 - 42.970 THINK THEY CAN TRY I THINK IT

01:33 - 43.360 WOULD BE.

01:33 - 44.890 >>I THINK YOU'D BE LIKE OF

01:33 - 46.140 UNIFORM EAST I THINK IT'LL BE

01:33 - 47.570 UNCONSTITUTIONAL. BUT I

01:33 - 48.820 CERTAINLY DO THINK THEY THEY

01:33 - 50.800 COULD MAKE. DEFAMATION LIKE

01:33 - 52.020 THEY DID IN THE WINTER GOING

01:33 - 54.040 TAKES. IN THE WIND TURBINE

01:33 - 55.350 EXCEPTION. BUT THERE'S A

01:33 - 57.660 SPECIFIC EXAMPLE, THEY CARVED

01:33 - 59.550 OUT WIND TURBINES TRUCK HAS A

01:33 - 01.010 SPECIFIC WAY TO VALUE.

01:34 - 03.080 WHERE IS SOMETIMES AND

01:34 - 04.860 BILLBOARDS THEY DIDN'T WHICH TO

01:34 - 07.440 ME MEANS YOU'RE LEFT OPEN THE

01:34 - 09.430 OPPORTUNITY TO EVALUATE ALL 3

01:34 - 10.030 WAGE.

01:34 - 12.440 COMPARABLE SALES. AND INCOME

01:34 - 14.030 APPROACH AND CAUSE THE

01:34 - 15.240 SITUATION YOU NEVER USE

01:34 - 15.840 CAUTION.

01:34 - 20.740 JUSTICE THERE.

01:34 - 23.360 MISTER WEISS

01:34 - 25.800 LET'S LET'S YOU DID YOUR HYPO

01:34 - 27.200 PROMISED A MINUTE LET ME COME

01:34 - 28.000 BACK HERE RIGHT.

01:34 - 30.690 THE BILLBOARD COMPANY AND

01:34 - 31.900 FRANKLY I THINK IT'S A LITTLE

01:34 - 33.070 BIT OF A RED HERRING THAT IT'S

01:34 - 34.200 A BILLBOARD COMPANY PAYS

01:34 - 36.340 $240,000 FOR THE LAW.

01:34 - 38.330 >>THEN THEY PUT A BILLBOARD ON

01:34 - 40.150 IN YOUR SUGGESTION IS THAT THE

01:34 - 40.920 VALUE GOES

01:34 - 43.500 TO 0. MY SUGGESTION WOULD BE

01:34 - 45.310 THE VALUE DOESN'T GO ASSUMING

01:34 - 47.640 ITS A $100,000 BILLBOARD TO

01:34 - 50.090 4340. BUT IT REMAINS

01:34 - 51.980 TO 40 BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THE

01:34 - 53.640 WILLING BUYER PAID A WILLING

01:34 - 54.910 SELLER IN THE OPEN MARKET.

01:34 - 55.670 WHAT AM

01:34 - 57.560 I MISSING. YEAR AFTER YEAR

01:34 - 58.580 RIGHT ON POINT YOUR HONOR

01:34 - 00.100 THAT'S WHAT I AGREE I AGREE

01:35 - 00.520 WITH THAT.

01:35 - 02.380 >>I SAID THAT THE LOWER COURT.

01:35 - 03.590 YOU FOLLOW THE LOWER

01:35 - 05.730 COURT'S DECISION THEY WOULD SAY

01:35 - 07.420 ONCE YOU PUT A BILLBOARD ON IT

01:35 - 08.660 IT THEN SHOULD BE ASSESSED

01:35 - 10.800 AT 0 BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT WAS

01:35 - 11.830 INCLUDED THAT'S WHAT WAS

01:35 - 13.480 INTERPRETED HIS INTERPRETATION

01:35 - 16.110 OF THE YEAR EXCEPTION 9 AGREE

01:35 - 17.350 WITH YOU EXACTLY IT SHOULD ONLY

01:35 - 18.930 BE 2.40 AND EVEN THOUGH

01:35 - 20.170 BILLBOARD MIGHT INCREASE THE

01:35 - 21.860 VALUE. BUT ANOTHER 100 GRAND

01:35 - 24.540 IT, I'M NOT ALLOWED TO TAX THE

01:35 - 26.840 SIGN AND THE SIGN STRUCTURE BUT

01:35 - 27.830 I AM ALLOWED THAT ACTUALLY

01:35 - 30.640 GROUND. ALL RIGHT AND THE

01:35 - 32.260 LIFT BUT ALRIGHT, LET'S TRY

01:35 - 33.830 SOMETHING ELSE I KNOW I HAVE

01:35 - 34.440 LIMITED TIME.

01:35 - 35.700 >>I BARRED.

01:35 - 36.880 I DON'T KNOW WHY THIS CAME TO

01:35 - 39.660 MY MIND, OKAY AND IN A BARGE

01:35 - 41.940 WITH $50,000 AND SPINNER 100

01:35 - 44.090 YEARS MALE PATCH. CLOUDS

01:35 - 45.100 TOBACCO I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'RE

01:35 - 46.280 STILL IN BUSINESS BUT

01:35 - 48.170 I REMEMBER FROM MY YOUTH AND

01:35 - 49.910 IT'S ON THE SIDE OF EVERY BLOCK

01:35 - 51.410 SO THEY PUT THAT SIGN ON THE

01:35 - 52.900 SIDE OF THE BARN DOES THAT

01:35 - 54.330 CHANGE THE VALUE OF MY BARN.

01:35 - 56.490 >>IF YOU COULD YOUR HONOR IF

01:35 - 56.630 THE

01:35 - 59.100 BAR OWNER IS RANKED TEAM THE

01:35 - 01.340 SIDE AND THEN THE INCOME THAT

01:36 - 02.740 THE I'M SORRY THE PROPERTY

01:36 - 04.520 OWNER. THE PROPERTY OWNER IS

01:36 - 06.340 THEN GETTING MORE RANCH

01:36 - 08.300 OR HERE'S PARTICULAR PROPERTY

01:36 - 09.680 SOPHIE RENTS THE SIDE OF HIS

01:36 - 12.450 BUILDING FOR WHATEVER AN

01:36 - 13.790 ADVERTISEMENT A GETS A 100

01:36 - 14.870 BUCKS A MONTH MORE.

01:36 - 16.450 THEN ACTUALLY GOING TO WHAT

01:36 - 17.840 HE'S PUTTING IN HIS POCKET

01:36 - 19.290 EVERY MONTH IN RENT AND

01:36 - 20.410 THEREFORE IT COULD INCREASE.

01:36 - 22.560 AND IF THE BAR'S OWNER LAST

01:36 - 24.550 QUESTION GETS ANNOYED AT MAIL

01:36 - 27.810 POUCH IN HAYES-WHITE AGAIN THEN

01:36 - 28.410 YOU HAVE TO

01:36 - 31.100 REASSESS DOWNWARD. NOW THEN YOU

01:36 - 32.750 HAVE THE HIGHEST AND BEST USE

01:36 - 34.420 BECAUSE THEN THE HIGHS AND BEST

01:36 - 36.370 USE WOULD BE FOR HIM TO RAN IT

01:36 - 37.610 IF YOU CAN RENT,

01:36 - 38.860 SO THEREFORE WOULD BE A

01:36 - 40.030 QUESTION FOR THE APPRAISER

01:36 - 41.980 DETERMINE IF YOU CAN RENT IT.

01:36 - 45.060 HE HE AT LEAST IS IMPUTED WITH

01:36 - 46.310 THE INCOME THAT HE WOULD GET

01:36 - 47.140 FROM THAT RENTAL.

01:36 - 48.940 THANK YOU VERY MUCH INTERESTING

01:36 - 50.130 CASE PERCENT CURRENTLY.

01:36 - 52.250 >>THANK YOU RIDE AND I

01:36 - 53.780 INADVERTENTLY A BEST-EVER

01:36 - 55.830 JUSTICE MONEY SHOW I ASKED HER

01:36 - 56.820 IF SHE HAS ANY QUESTION.

01:36 - 58.460 >>NOTHING TO SAY.

01:36 - 01.170 >>AND I APOLOGIZE I SHOULD KNOW

01:37 - 01.380 THAT.

01:37 - 03.390 >>NOW THAT WAS MY FAULT JUSTICE

01:37 - 03.890 TIME.

01:37 - 07.320 >>THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE IN

01:37 - 09.290 A FOLLOW-UP TO JUST ITS AIR

01:37 - 12.320 SOFT. LAST YEAR. IN THE SUBJECT

01:37 - 13.430 OF ARMS

01:37 - 16.070 AND I THINK HE'S ARMED OR NOT

01:37 - 18.340 OR ESTA SIDE USE A BARN.

01:37 - 20.580 >>OH I'M SURE YOU'RE AND I

01:37 - 23.400 THINK YOU SAID BAR, IT'S INTO.

01:37 - 24.410 >>SO

01:37 - 26.290 OBVIOUSLY WE KNOW THERE ARE

01:37 - 29.110 MANY MALE POP SIGNS PAINTED ON

01:37 - 30.810 FARMS THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY

01:37 - 32.780 AND I ASSUME THEY STILL DO THAT

01:37 - 33.240 I STILL

01:37 - 36.090 SEE THEM DOES THAT MEAN UNDER

01:37 - 37.610 YOUR ANALYSIS SERVED

01:37 - 41.440 THAT TIME ANY ARMED WITH SIDE

01:37 - 42.100 FACING A

01:37 - 45.260 MAJOR HIGHWAY IS GOING TO BE

01:37 - 47.460 SUBJECT TO THIS ANALYSIS THAT

01:37 - 49.280 IF THEY WANTED TO THEIR VALUE

01:37 - 51.470 INCREASED BY READING TO YOU

01:37 - 52.970 COULD BE YOUR HONOR BECAUSE

01:37 - 54.840 EVERY MEMBER ON HIS I CAN'T

01:37 - 56.100 REMEMBER WHAT CASE IT SAYS YOU

01:37 - 56.710 HAVE TO LOOK AT.

01:37 - 58.420 >>WHETHER IT'S POSSIBLE

01:37 - 01.840 ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE LEGAL SO

01:38 - 03.500 IF THEY BOUGHT IT FROM THE HORN

01:38 - 04.580 OWNER WE'RE

01:38 - 06.900 BUILDING NOT. OWNER WE RUN INTO

01:38 - 08.190 IT AND PHILADELPHIA ARE IN EVEN

01:38 - 09.360 THE SUBURBS OF PHILADELPHIA

01:38 - 11.090 WHERE PEOPLE CAN PAINT THINGS

01:38 - 12.370 ON THE SIDE OF THE BUILDING IS

01:38 - 13.740 IN THE SHOOTOUT BUT IT'S

01:38 - 15.880 LEGALLY COULD BE DONE. YOU NEED

01:38 - 17.520 TO INCLUDE THAT INCOME

01:38 - 19.530 IN THE INCOME APPROACH

01:38 - 21.150 DETERMINE THE VALUE OF THE

01:38 - 22.700 PROPERTY SHOW IN MY OPINION IF

01:38 - 25.210 IT'S LEGAL AND FEASIBLE AND CAN

01:38 - 27.020 BE DONE AND IT NEEDS TO BE

01:38 - 28.340 TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION.

01:38 - 31.710 >>WELL IT WILL NOT HARM OR WHO

01:38 - 34.510 OWNS SUCH A BARN AND I WOULD

01:38 - 37.050 FIND IT SPEAK A WHOLE TO RUIN

01:38 - 39.090 THE BEAUTY OF MY BARN, I'M

01:38 - 40.020 PAINTING A SIGN

01:38 - 42.520 ON IT. WHY SHOULDN'T I AS A

01:38 - 45.500 FARMER HAVE TO HIM OR IS

01:38 - 46.380 TAXATION.

01:38 - 48.760 >>WELL, THAT'S TRUE YOU'RE

01:38 - 50.060 HONORED SHIP SUPPOSE I HAVE

01:38 - 51.550 THAT THEY CAN PIECE OF GROUND.

01:38 - 54.270 THEY COULD BE BUILT FOR A CBS

01:38 - 57.290 OR WAWA AND I DON'T WANT TO I

01:38 - 58.140 JUST WANT TO LEAVE IT IS A

01:38 - 59.720 PIECE OF GROUND. IT SHOULD

01:38 - 01.950 BE VALUED AS YOU WALK NOT

01:39 - 03.740 WORKED CBS WOULD WANT TO COME

01:39 - 04.860 ALONG AND BUILD A BUILDING

01:39 - 06.400 THERE. SO I SHOULD BE ALLOWED

01:39 - 07.580 TO SAY OH I DON'T WANT TO BUILD

01:39 - 09.010 A BUILDING HERE AND THEREFORE

01:39 - 10.080 ONLY HAPPENING SAYS THAT

01:39 - 12.520 $5,000. WHEN WHILE IT MIGHT

01:39 - 13.990 COME ALONG AND PAY A MILLION

01:39 - 16.340 DOLLARS SHORT. SO I UNDERSTAND

01:39 - 17.810 THAT IT SOUNDS DESPICABLE BUT

01:39 - 20.120 IT'S STILL IT'S IT'S NOT WHAT I

01:39 - 21.930 SAY IT'S WHAT THE LARSON.

01:39 - 27.170 >>I DIDN'T SAY THAT APPLICATION

01:39 - 28.900 WOULD GENERALLY BE DESPICABLE

01:39 - 31.640 JUST MY

01:39 - 33.600 HYPOTHETICAL WAS I AS

01:39 - 35.410 A FARMER MIGHT FIND IT

01:39 - 36.590 DESPICABLE DICTATE,

01:39 - 37.090 YOU KNOW.

01:39 - 39.190 >>YES AND I MIGHT INVITE A

01:39 - 40.240 PIECE OF GRANITE LIFE AND

01:39 - 42.020 PUNISH CBS THEIR DESPICABLE TO

01:39 - 42.360 YOUR.

01:39 - 49.300 >>WE'LL HEAR FROM A YEAR

01:39 - 52.040 CO-COUNSEL NOW THE. THEY

01:39 - 54.260 RESERVED THEIR BRIEF THAT THE

01:39 - 56.010 AREA. GOOD

01:39 - 57.270 MORNING. DAN.

01:39 - 00.120 >>CHIEF JUSTICE. AND JUSTICES

01:40 - 01.320 OF THE SUPREME COURT MAY IT

01:40 - 02.180 PLEASE THE COURT.

01:40 - 04.270 I DIDN'T THINK I HAD TIME FOR

01:40 - 06.170 OPENINGS THAT BASICALLY I'M

01:40 - 08.710 HEARING. ATTORNEYS BUYERS

01:40 - 10.560 ARGUMENT AND HEARING THE

01:40 - 12.760 JUSTICES SPEAK, I MEAN THEY'RE

01:40 - 15.270 QUESTIONING EXCUSE ME. I THINK

01:40 - 16.970 THE JUSTICES HAVE IT RIGHT.

01:40 - 18.890 WHAT WE HAD SEEN HER WITH THE

01:40 - 20.870 TAXPAYERS ARE SEEKING AND WHAT

01:40 - 21.910 THE TRIAL COURT'S

01:40 - 24.170 ORDER DOES IS IT TREATED

01:40 - 25.040 SIMILARLY

01:40 - 27.890 SITUATED TAXPAYERS. IN HER

01:40 - 29.870 OWNERS OF OF THAT INCOME

01:40 - 33.080 PRODUCING PROPERTY OR OWNERS OF

01:40 - 35.420 LANDS, LOTS OF GRANDIN GROUND

01:40 - 35.890 RUNS

01:40 - 38.340 DIFFERENT LEAGUE BASED SOLELY

01:40 - 39.960 UPON THE IDENTITY

01:40 - 41.280 CLASSIFICATION OF

01:40 - 43.620 THE TENANT WE'RE IN AFTER

01:40 - 44.530 GETTING A PRETTY GOOD WOODS

01:40 - 46.270 JUST YET SAID WHETHER THE OWNER

01:40 - 47.820 OF THE PROPERTY IS A BILLBOARD

01:40 - 48.110 NUMBER

01:40 - 50.930 AND THAT AJ LEADS ARE

01:40 - 53.120 UNIFORMLY CLAUSE OF THE

01:40 - 54.990 CONSTITUTION AND VIOLATES THE

01:40 - 56.730 EQUAL PROTECTION CLAUSE WHICH

01:40 - 57.770 THE UNIFORMITY CLAUSE

01:40 - 58.880 INCORPORATES WORSE

01:41 - 02.170 PENNSYLVANIA CONSTITUTION.

01:41 - 04.630 WHAT I DID WANT TO POINT OUT IS

01:41 - 07.540 THE SECTION 8011 A WANT AND

01:41 - 10.150 EXPRESSLY INCLUDES

01:41 - 13.200 AS TAXABLE REAL ESTATE LANDS

01:41 - 15.470 LOTS OF GROUND AND GROUND RENTS

01:41 - 18.600 AND SO WE HAVE HERE IS THE

01:41 - 20.960 TAXPAYERS IN HER ARGUMENT ARE

01:41 - 23.500 REQUESTING CLASSIFICATION

01:41 - 28.350 TO IGNORE GROUND RENTS WHEN

01:41 - 30.610 THE TENANT AND 3RD PARTY

01:41 - 32.630 COMMERCIAL TENANT IS IT A

01:41 - 34.330 BILLBOARD OWNER AND THAT

01:41 - 35.550 VIOLATES THE ECONOMIC

01:41 - 36.470 REALITIES.

01:41 - 39.310 ALL OF THE PRODUCTS SUBJECT

01:41 - 41.450 PROPERTY SEE AND MY LEADS THE

01:41 - 42.490 UNIFORMITY IN THAT

01:41 - 44.090 CLASSIFICATION HOT SOME

01:41 - 45.350 CLASSIFICATION IF YOU WILL IN

01:41 - 46.530 VALLEY FORGE TOWERS.

01:41 - 53.900 BEFORE THE.

01:41 - 59.150 >>WELL LET ME ASK THIS SINCE

01:41 - 00.950 EVERY GUEST IT'S A QUESTION

01:42 - 04.290 THAT THEY ARGUE WILL BE IT

01:42 - 06.460 VERY SIMILAR TO THAT OF MISTER

01:42 - 08.030 WEISS. AND

01:42 - 11.050 WHAT A IF ANY ANY JUSTICE AS

01:42 - 13.060 A QUESTION. DURING WITH THE

01:42 - 15.290 JUSTICE TANI RUN GOING DOWN ME.

01:42 - 18.430 A GUEST IS DOCTOR YES, RIGHT ON

01:42 - 21.060 ME. THIS IS PARADISE. ANYONE.

01:42 - 25.430 GO AHEAD CHRIS. GO AHEAD JUST

01:42 - 25.810 BEEN A.

01:42 - 28.240 >>I NEED TO THANK YOU. BUT I

01:42 - 29.210 DON'T HAVE ANY QUESTION.

01:42 - 29.680 THANK YOU.

01:42 - 31.190 >>OKAY WELL.

01:42 - 33.760 >>TAKE A SEAT IN THE COURTROOM

01:42 - 35.480 AND SEE THE REAL LIFE CASES

01:42 - 35.880 AFFECTING

01:42 - 37.690 PENNSYLVANIANS TODAY. HEAR THE

01:42 - 39.320 ARGUMENTS FROM BOTH SIDES WITH

01:42 - 41.710 FULL TRANSPARENCY EXCLUSIVELY

01:42 - 44.400 ON PCN WATCH THE COMMONWEALTH

01:42 - 46.380 SUPERIOR AND SUPREME COURTS ON

01:42 - 48.450 CABLE AND THE PCN SELECT

01:42 - 51.160 STREAMING SERVICE VISIT PCN TV

01:42 - 52.430 DOT COM FOR THE COMPLETE

01:42 - 55.520 SCHEDULE. PCN PENNSYLVANIA

01:42 - 57.210 POLITICS AND POLICY.

01:43 - 02.640 >>COURT IS BACK

01:43 - 05.840 IN SESSION. USE THE STATE IS

01:43 - 07.580 MIKE BOYD AND YOU KNOW THIS.

01:43 - 11.310 ARE YOU ON BEHALF OF THE CONE

01:43 - 12.710 IS START A FRIEND BOUGHT

01:43 - 14.410 ARE YOU ON BEHALF OF THE POLY

01:43 - 15.500 IS BEING A SINGER.

01:43 - 20.770 >>GOOD AFTERNOON.

01:43 - 23.470 >>THE OUTCOME. IN MEDIA.

01:43 - 26.200 >>COURSE OF THEIR DIVORCE.

01:43 - 27.970 HOW YOU ARE RIGHT HAND SIDE OF

01:43 - 29.350 AGREEMENT.

01:43 - 31.990 WHICH MIGHT LEAD TO WEIGH ALL

01:43 - 33.500 OF THEIR INTERESTS AND HOUSINGS

01:43 - 34.510 POLICE AND SHE.

01:43 - 37.390 I AND I PROBABLY BE COURSE

01:43 - 39.890 IS ONGOING IN HIS PENSION

01:43 - 42.400 CONTINUE TO BE A WIFE WHO

01:43 - 44.330 REFUSED TO TRANSFER THOSE

01:43 - 46.630 PAYMENTS AS CONTEMPLATED BY THE

01:43 - 47.420 TERMS E.

01:43 - 50.160 HAS BEEN SOME STATES SUCH

01:43 - 52.920 DAMAGE AND MORE. TWICE

01:43 - 55.590 ACTUALLY DIED. NEW YORK STATE

01:43 - 57.090 AND DID THE AGREEMENT WOULD NOT

01:43 - 58.970 BE ENFORCED. UNDER STATE

01:43 - 01.090 PENSION LAWS. WE'RE HAVING THE

01:44 - 04.680 ATTACHMENT OR TRANSFER. AND

01:44 - 06.960 SHOULD BENEFIT. THIS ARGUMENT

01:44 - 09.400 WAS REJECTED IN THE TRIAL IN

01:44 - 11.810 THE SUPERIOR COURT. AND THIS IS

01:44 - 13.390 SUBJECT TO THE COURTS.

01:44 - 15.120 PRESIDENT RATION.

01:44 - 19.320 ALSO MAY PROCEED.

01:44 - 31.040 THESE DAYS.

01:44 - 35.890 >>YOUR FAMILY. I DIDN'T

01:44 - 37.790 STOP CRIME. I WILL READ IT.

01:44 - 39.340 IT SHOULD BE.

01:44 - 42.360 >>IT ASSESSED IT A FELONY.

01:44 - 43.690 IT'S A PILL.

01:44 - 48.700 >>WORK TO REVERSE

01:44 - 49.420 A SECURE.

01:44 - 51.810 IT. THE

01:44 - 55.430 COURT HEARD ORDER MARCIA TOO

01:44 - 59.380 SLOW. TRANSFER. THE STATE.

01:45 - 00.690 EACH

01:45 - 02.790 MONTHLY PAYMENT. HE RECEIVED

01:45 - 03.620 ARE DOING.

01:45 - 07.970 BACK TO

01:45 - 09.920 THEIR CASE ARE SIMILAR TO

01:45 - 12.580 THOSE. THE CASE OF A GREAT.

01:45 - 17.260 THE STATE YESTERDAY. WORK

01:45 - 18.610 LAST YEAR.

01:45 - 22.690 HER ITS SEVERAL ROLLING THIS

01:45 - 24.890 NATION. IT'S THE FIRST OF

01:45 - 30.740 IF THEY PAY.

01:45 - 42.500 LOOTED

01:45 - 45.100 BY REACTION UNDER ARREST.

01:45 - 52.770 REACTION.

01:45 - 56.940 IS

01:45 - 58.970 LOW ORDER

01:45 - 02.940 WAS RIVETED ICE AGE. WELL THE

01:46 - 03.310 EAST.

01:46 - 08.590 UNLIKE EAST TODAY, WE'LL BE OF

01:46 - 11.290 COURSE. LITIGATED

01:46 - 13.130 IN PRAGUE OR OR OR.

01:46 - 15.530 AT ITS FIRST

01:46 - 19.110 IT ENTITLEMENT THAT FUN.

01:46 - 22.430 RUSSIA FROM THIS YOU SEE THAT.

01:46 - 23.870 IT'S

01:46 - 26.720 WELL BY THE STATE.

01:46 - 28.820 IN THE WRONG DECISION.

01:46 - 34.670 OF THE COMMON PLEAS OR.

01:46 - 38.410 PLEAS COURT THE WRONG CHANNEL.

01:46 - 40.670 YOUR WORK.

01:46 - 43.490 BERKS COUNTY.

01:46 - 44.890 TERROR.

01:46 - 49.990 THOSE TO OPEN. YES, STAY AND

01:46 - 52.020 WHO IS SHE READ A LETTER.

01:46 - 54.700 IT'S NOT THE SECOND.

01:46 - 57.940 WHAT ARE THE CIVIL COURT.

01:46 - 59.070 CHESTER COUNTY.

01:47 - 01.750 IF YOU

01:47 - 08.440 DIDN'T EVEN HAVE JURISDICTION.

01:47 - 11.100 ASH.

01:47 - 15.430 THE POLICE PENSION LAW.

01:47 - 19.470 ONE PROVISION WHICH.

01:47 - 22.550 FACED WITH.

01:47 - 30.070 2 PROVISIONS THAT'S A 76 OR.

01:47 - 33.900 IT'S NOT

01:47 - 34.850 ONLY LOSE.

01:47 - 38.660 ANY OTHER

01:47 - 41.040 LEGAL PROCESS. THE ACTUALLY

01:47 - 44.010 REALLY. HE ALSO.

01:47 - 53.730 DO I THE TRANSFER

01:47 - 54.210 OF A.

01:47 - 56.760 >>MISTER BIDEN WE'RE GOING TO

01:47 - 59.860 PROCEED NOW HSINCHU BY AN

01:47 - 01.540 OPPORTUNITY TO OPEN YOUR

01:48 - 02.220 ARGUMENT.

01:48 - 06.420 QUESTIONS BY

01:48 - 09.240 THE COURT. AND THAT'S STARTING.

01:48 - 10.480 YES JUST DAUGHERTY.

01:48 - 15.810 THANK YOU CHIEF COUNSEL.

01:48 - 17.870 LET ME ASK

01:48 - 18.330 YOU THIS.

01:48 - 20.590 I BELIEVE THAT YOUR VIEW THAT

01:48 - 21.990 THE LINE WOULD SHALL NOT BE

01:48 - 23.950 SUBJECT WAS SIMON OR TRANSFER

01:48 - 26.650 RUSHED. APPLIES TO THE BENEFITS

01:48 - 28.920 OR BY HOW DO YOU I MEAN

01:48 - 29.730 REPHRASE THIS RIGHT.

01:48 - 33.790 THANKS FOR STARTING ONE FOR YES

01:48 - 37.000 AND I THE BENEFICIARY PURSUANT

01:48 - 37.250 TO

01:48 - 40.020 THE STATUTE. HOW IS IT THAT YOU

01:48 - 42.200 CAN ARTICULATE THAT FACT IS NOT

01:48 - 43.700 SUBJECT TO ASSIGNMENT OR

01:48 - 45.090 TRANSFER SUCH THAT IS

01:48 - 46.240 RIGHTFULLY YOUR CLIENT.

01:48 - 49.210 DOES THAT MAKE SENSE TO YOU.

01:48 - 52.880 YEAH LISTEN.

01:48 - 59.320 >>HEATING OIL.

01:49 - 09.440 81.

01:49 - 11.590 ONE '02.

01:49 - 15.500 BUT HE.

01:49 - 17.810 THE

01:49 - 20.350 SURVIVOR ANNUITY AS THE FIRST

01:49 - 24.390 SEE I BUT AT LEAST A YEAR.

01:49 - 27.050 >>TO RECEIVE AND

01:49 - 28.900 WE ARE ITS DEBT.

01:49 - 31.730 SHE RECEIVED HER ONLY DO IT.

01:49 - 35.930 IT WAS A SURVIVOR ANNUITY OUCH

01:49 - 38.520 THAT HURT. THAT WAS

01:49 - 39.560 HER OWN.

01:49 - 46.530 >>WELL YOU KNOW VERSUS PALIN.

01:49 - 56.330 SURVIVOR ANNUITY PROPERTY

01:49 - 00.430 NEVER IN THE STATE MUST BE IT.

01:50 - 08.460 ALTHOUGH AS A RESULT YOU SEE

01:50 - 08.970 YOU.

01:50 - 13.830 SHE WAS ENTITLED TO YOU.

01:50 - 17.310 BECAUSE IT WAS ADDRESSED THE

01:50 - 17.860 CONTRACT.

01:50 - 23.150 >>I APOLOGIZE THE LAST PART YOU

01:50 - 24.710 HAD BROKEN OFF I COULD NOT HEAR

01:50 - 25.600 YOUR COMMENT.

01:50 - 29.780 >>ANNUITY BENEFIT.

01:50 - 33.560 HE WOULD RECEIVE IT.

01:50 - 36.930 TO INCREASE YESTERDAY. SURVIVOR

01:50 - 39.630 ANNUITY. AND HER A

01:50 - 41.330 NEW AD. IT'S HARD.

01:50 - 44.300 NOW VERSUS YOU KNOW WHICH

01:50 - 48.550 STATE IT. 13 8 TO 86 THAT'S IT.

01:50 - 50.330 IT'S JUST IN

01:50 - 52.900 SOME DETAIL. E H OR THE

01:50 - 55.480 SURVIVOR ANNUITY THAT IT SAYS

01:50 - 57.680 SPECIFICALLY THAT IS A RESTED

01:50 - 01.040 PROPERTY INTEREST. WAY. IT IS

01:51 - 02.870 SEPARATE AND DISTINCT. HER

01:51 - 06.630 HUSBAND BENCH. AND THAT

01:51 - 08.850 IS WHAT THAT'S AN 81

01:51 - 11.830 TOO WHICH HAS BEEN ISSUED.

01:51 - 17.960 IT'S A FIGHT. I HEARD YOU

01:51 - 19.700 AGAIN. MARCIA.

01:51 - 24.460 SHE IS I

01:51 - 25.850 TRUST THAT HE WAS

01:51 - 28.970 NOT RECEIVING. IT SPENT IT IS.

01:51 - 39.700 >>ARE YOU GOING TO TRY AGAIN I

01:51 - 40.980 DON'T KNOW I DON'T SEE A MAP IT

01:51 - 42.130 OR NOT YOU'RE SPEAKING. I CAN

01:51 - 42.520 HEAR YOU.

01:51 - 45.590 >>YEAH. YEAH I.

01:51 - 47.950 ARE YOU ABLE TO HEAR ME OUT.

01:51 - 51.340 >>SOMEWHAT I'M HAVING ALREADY

01:51 - 52.490 IN TROUBLE LISTENING TO YOU.

01:51 - 56.250 >>OUR SHOW WAS RECEIVING.

01:51 - 59.640 EACH AND EVERY MONTH.

01:52 - 02.760 I KNEW FROM A SURVIVOR

01:52 - 05.230 >>OK I GOT THAT OK, THANK YOU.

01:52 - 07.710 >>I JUST HAVE TO ACT.

01:52 - 11.140 THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE OR GOOD

01:52 - 14.130 AFTERNOON COUNCIL. I WAS IN THE

01:52 - 18.360 THAT HUSBAND AND WIFE SIGNED.

01:52 - 20.880 WIFE AGREED TO WAIVE

01:52 - 23.100 ALL RIGHT TITLE AND INTEREST IN

01:52 - 24.990 HUSBANDS POLICE PENSIONS, SO I

01:52 - 26.100 DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU'RE GOING

01:52 - 27.610 WITH THIS. WE WANT TO

01:52 - 29.260 DISTINGUISH ANNUITY OUT OF THAT

01:52 - 30.790 YOU YOURSELF JUST USE THE WORD

01:52 - 33.260 INTEREST. LET ME ASK YOU.

01:52 - 36.470 IN THAT SAME CUED ROW.

01:52 - 40.130 DIDN'T THE PARTIES.

01:52 - 42.920 FULLY UNDERSTAND AND

01:52 - 43.950 ANTICIPATE.

01:52 - 47.920 THE NON ATTACHMENT BAR OF THE

01:52 - 49.850 PENSION LAWS. WHEN

01:52 - 51.780 THEY WROTE IF THE PLAN

01:52 - 53.610 ADMINISTRATOR OF SAID PENSION

01:52 - 55.370 WILL NOT PERMIT A WAIVER ET

01:52 - 56.350 CETERA ET CETERA.

01:52 - 58.380 WIFE WILL AGREE TO

01:52 - 00.460 SIGN ANY NECESSARY PAPERWORK,

01:53 - 01.670 INCLUDING A STATEMENT IT

01:53 - 03.800 CENTERED CENTER. IF SHE WAVES

01:53 - 05.320 THE BENEFITS AND INSTRUCTS HER

01:53 - 07.790 ESTATE. TO MAKE PAYMENT.

01:53 - 10.490 DOESN'T THAT SHOW THAT THE

01:53 - 13.430 PARTIES UNDERSTOOD. THEY

01:53 - 16.240 MIGHT ENCOUNTER. THIS TRANSFER

01:53 - 18.210 ISSUE WITH THE PENSION LAW IN

01:53 - 20.040 CONTRADICTED AROUND THAT.

01:53 - 25.960 E.

01:53 - 29.000 OR IS IT THAT'S IT.

01:53 - 35.560 >>ANY OPPOSE THE SENTENCED AS

01:53 - 37.030 QUICKLY ARE YOU.

01:53 - 40.840 AND THE SENSE THAT YOU'RE FOR

01:53 - 41.110 IT.

01:53 - 47.350 WHETHER IT'S NOT SPEND IT.

01:53 - 48.810 IF THEY WILL.

01:53 - 53.260 >>ALLOW.

01:53 - 57.760 >>BELIEVE IT SAID. A

01:53 - 59.650 TO E. WE.

01:54 - 04.330 IT'S PRIOR SAID.

01:54 - 13.180 SOMETHING THAT WORKS HUH.

01:54 - 16.420 IT'S NOT OPEN TO.

01:54 - 19.370 YEAH WELL

01:54 - 22.230 PENSION PLAN IS THE BODY IN

01:54 - 25.960 THE STATUTE. ALL.

01:54 - 30.650 5060 80 ON.

01:54 - 35.130 WELL, NO 1, 1, OF US THAT 6 O

01:54 - 37.800 E TERMS OF

01:54 - 39.400 THE FENCE. AND.

01:54 - 43.680 THAT WAS USED IN THE CONTRACT.

01:54 - 44.630 A

01:54 - 47.360 SPECIFIC DEFINITION. UNDER THE

01:54 - 47.960 LAW.

01:54 - 52.040 IT IS NOT.

01:54 - 00.440 IS A

01:55 - 03.000 OR

01:55 - 07.650 MEMBERS IDOL. THEY LOVE

01:55 - 13.200 CONTRIBUTED BY HUGH LAURIE.

01:55 - 16.290 ITS PENSION.

01:55 - 18.140 IN THIS CASE

01:55 - 22.260 THE DIRECTOR OF THE YALE LAW

01:55 - 25.450 RESTS. PLUS TED. THERE WAS NO

01:55 - 26.000 VALUE.

01:55 - 31.240 THEY DID IT BY

01:55 - 34.280 WAS EURO BECAUSE SHE

01:55 - 36.960 COULD YOU ANY MONEY TO THAT.

01:55 - 40.900 >>I DO RECALL THAT I DO RECALL

01:55 - 42.250 THAT OUR COUNCIL.

01:55 - 45.650 IS IT IS A VENUE

01:55 - 48.520 ARGUMENT THAT BY REASON OF OF

01:55 - 50.110 THAT 0 NUMBER.

01:55 - 52.910 GET THE IS NOT THE RIGHT TITLE

01:55 - 53.770 AND INTEREST IN HER WAS

01:55 - 54.830 MISPLACED PENSION.

01:55 - 58.180 IN NEWLY.

01:55 - 59.960 >>IT IS.

01:56 - 09.930 WELL THE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE

01:56 - 13.850 DISCUSSED EXACTLY YEAH. IT SAID

01:56 - 16.490 THE IS LET'S DO IT.

01:56 - 18.940 AND IT IS SEPARATE AND THE

01:56 - 20.720 STATE MUST BE BETTER.

01:56 - 25.590 NEVER COME ABOUT OR DO WE EVER

01:56 - 28.020 COME UP AND SHE REALLY SEES IT.

01:56 - 31.310 AND IF SHE DID ACTUALLY COMPLY

01:56 - 32.250 WITH IT READ IT.

01:56 - 37.170 PERCENT SAID SHE WILL WEIGH

01:56 - 39.530 PEOPLE INTEREST IN THE BENCH.

01:56 - 41.740 IF SHE GAVE UP HER WISH.

01:56 - 45.610 WHAT HE UP TO SINCE THE STATE.

01:56 - 47.850 JUST DISAPPEAR.

01:56 - 52.510 SO WE SHE JUST GAVE IT UP AND

01:56 - 55.150 SAID I REALLY WAS CLAIM

01:56 - 58.520 I HAVE DO ANY BETTER. A NEW

01:56 - 59.850 OR OTHERWISE.

01:57 - 04.180 THEY WOULD GET NO BULL, THEY

01:57 - 05.750 WOULDN'T GET THE BEST.

01:57 - 08.970 IF SHE OR ANY CLAIM TO

01:57 - 13.990 EURO BUT IF YOU WORK WITH THAT.

01:57 - 16.960 WE HAVE GOT ME

01:57 - 21.580 EVEN THOUGH THE REACH OF

01:57 - 23.540 THIS AGREEMENT. THERE'S NO

01:57 - 24.840 DOUBT THE KIDS TO THEM.

01:57 - 28.820 THAT WAS FILED HERE.

01:57 - 33.040 WELL REALLY ONE OF THE BASES

01:57 - 36.010 LEAVING IT'S THE

01:57 - 40.160 REALLY THE REASON YESTERDAY WAS

01:57 - 40.510 ABLE

01:57 - 45.410 WILL WE. EACH

01:57 - 47.470 BECAUSE IT WAS PROPERLY FILED

01:57 - 50.160 IN NEW YORK. MONTGOMERY COUNTY.

01:57 - 55.000 THE TRIAL FOR BERKS COUNTY

01:57 - 55.490 WORKERS.

01:57 - 59.350 BELIEVES COUNCIL.

01:58 - 05.030 AND THE STAFF WILL STATE NO.

01:58 - 09.870 AS THE EAST

01:58 - 11.910 TODAY WHERE. CHECKS OF

01:58 - 14.990 3323. LET'S GO.

01:58 - 19.880 GROUND

01:58 - 21.690 FOR ESTABLISHED IN THIS.

01:58 - 21.930 HE

01:58 - 27.020 WELL EXIT 3320 FEET.

01:58 - 30.440 THE SHOOTING. YOUR BODY.

01:58 - 33.510 YES, ALL PEOPLE HOURS

01:58 - 36.450 THE OR THE FASHION A REMEDY.

01:58 - 38.640 WE'RE REALLY

01:58 - 44.140 IF COUNCIL. TAKING THIS TO THE

01:58 - 45.170 YORKERS WORK.

01:58 - 50.670 THEN FEEL THAT WOULD DOUBLE OUR

01:58 - 50.890 STATE.

01:58 - 55.570 BECAUSE IT WAS NO LONGER IN

01:58 - 56.340 FORCE.

01:59 - 05.060 PURSUER RIGHT. LOOK LET ITS

01:59 - 05.510 SHARE.

01:59 - 09.430 IT IT'S WHY

01:59 - 13.170 E EST IT IS NOT PURSUE.

01:59 - 14.990 >>WE.

01:59 - 17.740 >>ACTUALLY UNDER THAT'S WHY WE

01:59 - 19.630 LOVE IT TOO WHICH

01:59 - 23.070 SAVED HIM, IT GOES. IT SEEMED

01:59 - 26.260 TO WORK. AND THE GROUNDS FOR

01:59 - 30.200 NOT ESTABLISHED. HER E.

01:59 - 39.080 THEY THE

01:59 - 41.170 FAMILY WERE. BUT THIS SIMPLE

01:59 - 43.520 I'LL WORK WHICH BASICALLY TO

01:59 - 46.600 SAY. TRACK.

01:59 - 48.660 BUT THE LEADING

01:59 - 50.090 STATE ANYTHING.

01:59 - 56.410 >>SURE WILL. THE COURT IS

01:59 - 01.820 WHO HOUR. IT'S NATIONAL COUNCIL

02:00 - 09.990 OUR NATION IS THIS.

02:00 - 13.090 THE EQUITY. COW.

02:00 - 17.130 THE COURT THEN CAME HE SETS.

02:00 - 21.500 WHY. SAID.

02:00 - 27.830 HERE.

02:00 - 30.080 AND BY

02:00 - 32.250 THE WAY. THERE

02:00 - 35.110 WAS NO YOUR ROLE. YOU KNOW.

02:00 - 38.890 REALLY DO. THEY SPENT.

02:00 - 42.490 WHAT AGE YOU ARE A 100 OR SO.

02:00 - 46.260 LATER I 4 OH ONE.

02:00 - 53.760 BUT.

02:00 - 02.560 >>WELCOME TO 9 YOUR TIME LIMITS

02:01 - 04.190 ARE. WE MAY HAVE

02:01 - 06.640 TIME FOR BRIEF QUESTION BY

02:01 - 08.570 JUSTICE MONEY SHOULD SHE HAVE

02:01 - 09.310 WON IN LONDON.

02:01 - 11.380 WHEN YOU COMPLETE THAT WE'D ASK

02:01 - 14.350 YOU INCLUDE YOUR ARGUMENT HE

02:01 - 15.000 MIGHT STILL HAVE A

02:01 - 17.200 COUPLE QUESTIONS. BUT THAT'S

02:01 - 18.740 JUST DESPAIR. I SO THE QUESTION

02:01 - 19.530 I HAD A.

02:01 - 22.870 >>YOU CAN HAVE MY TIME

02:01 - 25.710 THAT'S UNNECESSARY. AND NO

02:01 - 27.140 QUESTIONS ASKED OF MONEY.

02:01 - 30.030 I ASKED HIM QUESTIONS COUNCIL

02:01 - 31.510 OF CHIEF JUSTICE THANK YOU FOR

02:01 - 32.480 FOR PERMITTING THIS

02:01 - 34.940 FIRST BOB WITH RESPECT YOUR

02:01 - 36.680 ARGUMENT APROPOS OF CHESTER

02:01 - 38.630 COUNTY DIVISION IS A NONSENSE.

02:01 - 40.240 CHESTER COUNTY AND IN THE PAST

02:01 - 41.650 MAY CAUSE BUSH HAS NO

02:01 - 43.210 DIVISIONS. IT'S A COURT OF

02:01 - 44.800 GENERAL JURISDICTION AND HAS

02:01 - 46.140 JURISDICTION OVER BOTH THE

02:01 - 47.450 PEOPLE IN THE SUBJECT MATTER.

02:01 - 49.800 SO DON'T WASTE MY TIME WITH

02:01 - 51.940 THAT. IF I UNDERSTAND

02:01 - 53.540 YOUR ARGUMENT. MORE

02:01 - 55.170 SPECIFICALLY THAT IT HAS

02:01 - 56.870 PERHAPS SOMEWHAT MORE RELEVANT.

02:01 - 58.780 YOU'RE TRYING TO DISTINGUISH

02:01 - 00.160 BETWEEN A DEATH BENEFIT.

02:02 - 02.620 IN A SURVIVOR INTO IT IS THAT

02:02 - 04.130 FAIR. YES,

02:02 - 06.680 OKAY IN A 5 LOOK AT THE

02:02 - 08.890 LANGUAGE OF YEAR CONTRACT.

02:02 - 10.140 IT SAYS

02:02 - 13.690 WIFE WILL SIGN ANY NECESSARY

02:02 - 15.660 PAPERWORK. SHE WAIVED ANY

02:02 - 16.330 BENEFITS.

02:02 - 19.570 SHE IS SHE'S TO RECEIVE

02:02 - 21.180 ANY BENEFITS DOES GO BY HOUSE

02:02 - 22.630 BUT ACCENTURE AND I UNDERSTAND

02:02 - 23.720 YOUR ARGUMENT THAT THE WORK

02:02 - 24.230 BEST AND

02:02 - 26.220 IT'S THERE. BUT ISN'T THE FAIR

02:02 - 27.890 INTENT OF THE PARTIES FROM THIS

02:02 - 30.310 CONTRACT. NOW WHAT SHE WAS

02:02 - 32.150 GOING TO GET FROM

02:02 - 33.650 THE HUSBAND AT

02:02 - 36.040 HIS DEATH. REGARDLESS OF WHAT

02:02 - 37.360 LABEL YOU WANT TO PUT ON IT.

02:02 - 40.070 SHE ASSIGNED TO THE BROTHER IN

02:02 - 40.420 LAW.

02:02 - 43.440 IN THAT WHAT SHE INTENDED.

02:02 - 45.710 I BELIEVE THAT FLOOD.

02:02 - 49.320 HIS COUNSEL

02:02 - 54.360 >>IF YOU'RE BEING A GOOD LAWYER

02:02 - 55.650 YOU'RE TRYING TO SNEAK OUT OF

02:02 - 57.710 IT FIND OUT WHAT YOUR CLIENT

02:02 - 58.850 INTENDED WHEN SHE DID IT.

02:03 - 02.350 I BELIEVE THAT WAS

02:03 - 05.060 EVERY DAY US THAT IF THE S I.

02:03 - 10.550 IT'S ILLEGAL.

02:03 - 14.420 AND IF YOUR CLIENT GETS THE

02:03 - 15.700 MONEY AND I DON'T CARE WHAT YOU

02:03 - 17.160 CALL IT THAT CENTER POCKETBOOK

02:03 - 19.450 CAN SHE. TAKE IT TO

02:03 - 20.980 VEGAS IN WAYS THAT WHEN SHE'S

02:03 - 21.330 GOT IT.

02:03 - 24.990 YES WHICH CAN BE SUBJECTED TO A

02:03 - 29.300 THE LEGAL PROCESS. COMPELLED TO

02:03 - 32.210 IT CAN IF YOUR KIDS SHE HAS

02:03 - 34.330 SIGNED IT WITH 3RD PARTY

02:03 - 35.220 BENEFITS YEAR.

02:03 - 38.480 NO I DON'T BELIEVE SHE CAN

02:03 - 40.540 WHY NOT SHE CAN GO TO VEGAS.

02:03 - 41.860 YOU CAN USE IT FOR TOILET PAPER

02:03 - 42.930 WHY CAN'T YOU SIGN IT.

02:03 - 46.690 IT'S HERS. BECAUSE THE STATUTE

02:03 - 49.320 SAYS IT'S AWESOME. IT'S A SITE

02:03 - 50.380 AND THIS IS WHAT MS.

02:03 - 53.360 MR. MR. CHRISTINE SAID I

02:03 - 54.640 COULDN'T TELL IF THE SHOT WAS A

02:03 - 56.270 MALE OR FEMALE NAME. IT WAS

02:03 - 58.120 A MESS. IT'S A MALE MISTER

02:03 - 00.140 CHRISTINE SAID ONE SITS IN HER

02:04 - 01.100 HANDS. WE DON'T CARE.

02:04 - 03.240 THAT'S THE PENNSYLVANIA

02:04 - 04.920 MUNICIPAL RETIREMENTS.

02:04 - 09.460 THIS CASE IN BUT THE LEAST ALL.

02:04 - 13.080 >>EMR L.

02:04 - 15.750 >>ALL RIGHT, NO EXCUSE ME FOR

02:04 - 17.050 INTERRUPTING, BUT MY TIME IS

02:04 - 17.560 ABOUT

02:04 - 21.260 TO RUN YOUR POSITION IS AND I

02:04 - 22.430 AGAIN I'M TRYING TO FERRET IT

02:04 - 23.610 OUT SO I CAN GO BACK AND LOOK

02:04 - 25.680 AT IT UNDER IN THIS BOOK LEAST

02:04 - 28.260 LAW EVEN AFTER ITS IN HER HANDS

02:04 - 29.040 EVEN THOUGH

02:04 - 31.000 I SHE CAN GO TO VEGAS WITH IT

02:04 - 32.460 SHE CAN USE IT FOR TOILET PAPER

02:04 - 33.890 SHE CAN'T DECIDED TO HER

02:04 - 34.580 BROTHER IN LAW.

02:04 - 38.710 >>LEAST

02:04 - 40.730 PENSION LAW. I GOT IT THANK YOU

02:04 - 41.290 VERY MUCH FOR

02:04 - 41.890 YOUR TIME.

02:04 - 44.130 >>I THANK YOU YOUR 20 MINUTES

02:04 - 45.960 WHICH WE ALLOWED USE UP THERE

02:04 - 47.160 WE'RE GOING TO HEAR FROM THAT

02:04 - 49.290 COUNCIL FOR A JOB KELLY.

02:04 - 57.780 >>THANK YOU MAY HAVE PLEASE THE

02:04 - 58.340 COURT.

02:05 - 01.750 OUR ARGUMENT IS AS

02:05 - 05.820 I WHO YOU ARE SIR.

02:05 - 08.330 I'M SORRY. DANIEL SAGER I

02:05 - 10.020 REPRESENT THE ESTATE OF MICHAEL

02:05 - 11.430 BANG THEM. THANK YOU.

02:05 - 14.890 ARGUMENT IS AS

02:05 - 17.890 FOLLOWS A AS MISTER BREIDENBACH

02:05 - 19.810 THE HOLY. THEY DID.

02:05 - 22.550 IN THIS ONE OFFENSE AT ONE

02:05 - 25.550 POINT WERE PROPERTY OF A ROOM

02:05 - 26.900 AT THE BOURSE, IT WAS MARITAL

02:05 - 28.070 PROPERTY AND THERE IS NO

02:05 - 30.550 AGREEMENT IT PROBABLY WOULD BE

02:05 - 31.630 PROPERTY OF THE.

02:05 - 34.010 >>PROBABLY IT WOULD BE THE KEY.

02:05 - 37.960 MS BEEN YELLEN ULTIMATELY TO

02:05 - 40.070 HER STATE OF IT. THE TEAM WHICH

02:05 - 41.290 IT DID NOT IN THIS CASE.

02:05 - 44.440 HOWEVER THE PARTIES ENTERED

02:05 - 45.340 INTO AN AGREEMENT.

02:05 - 48.810 I'M IN FOR DECADES, THIS COURT

02:05 - 50.870 HAS. THEY DID AS LONG

02:05 - 53.350 AS THERE. IS A HOT IF THERE IS

02:05 - 55.120 A CONTRACT IN LAW AS LONG AS IT

02:05 - 55.330 IS

02:05 - 57.800 NOT A THE CONTRACT OF ADHESION

02:05 - 59.380 COERCION THE REST FRAUD

02:05 - 01.650 MISREPRESENTATION IN CONTRACT

02:06 - 03.670 IS A CONTRACT. AND YOU STATED

02:06 - 05.900 THAT IN YOUR MOST RECENT HASAN

02:06 - 08.030 YESTERDAY AS WELL. LAST YEAR

02:06 - 09.390 WHEN YOU MADE THAT DECISION.

02:06 - 12.340 IF YOU READ BE.

02:06 - 15.920 4 CORNERS OF THE AGREEMENT AND

02:06 - 17.900 IF YOU READ AND IF YOU READ THE

02:06 - 20.240 TESTIMONY OF MS. BEN YOU AS

02:06 - 23.700 WELL IT IS INCONCEIVABLE THAT

02:06 - 26.850 THE PARTIES. ON THE NEWS BEN IF

02:06 - 28.400 MISTER BEN YOU WERE TO DIE,

02:06 - 31.160 WAS RECEIVED THE BENEFITS OR

02:06 - 32.480 SHE CAN JUST TERMINATE THE

02:06 - 34.140 BENEFITS AND IT WOULD NOT

02:06 - 36.920 GO TO MR. BENYON AS A STATE OR

02:06 - 39.080 HAS A PROBLEM ON ME AS THEY DID

02:06 - 40.900 IN THE AGREEMENT YOU READ THE

02:06 - 43.910 AGREEMENT AS A WHOLE THEY AND

02:06 - 45.690 IT IT. A REVIEW OF

02:06 - 47.290 THE RECORD. THEY ACTUALLY

02:06 - 48.530 FOLLOW THROUGH WITH THE

02:06 - 50.570 AGREEMENT IN ALL ITS ENTIRETY

02:06 - 52.320 INCLUDING A WHO DROVE FOR FOR

02:06 - 53.070 ONE K.

02:06 - 56.720 CHANGING RIGHT ON AN INTEREST

02:06 - 58.520 IN MARITAL RESIDENCE.

02:06 - 00.920 PERSONAL PROPERTY

02:07 - 02.740 AND BY THE WAY THEY COULDN'T DO

02:07 - 05.040 A FOOD SO AS THE BRIDE BLOCK

02:07 - 06.740 STATES BECAUSE A IT'S NOT UNDER

02:07 - 08.730 A SILENT READ IT CONCEDES SO

02:07 - 09.690 WOULD HAVE TO BE AT THE NEST

02:07 - 11.000 RELATIONS ORDER BUT SECOND OF

02:07 - 12.480 ALL BECAUSE

02:07 - 14.820 IT ALREADY WAS IN CASE. THAT'S

02:07 - 15.700 AND THAT'S WHAT MISTER

02:07 - 18.620 CHRISTINE STATES IN HIS

02:07 - 20.640 TESTIMONY. THEY WOULD NOT

02:07 - 23.010 EVEN ACCEPT OF A DOMESTIC

02:07 - 24.560 RELATIONS ORDER BECAUSE IT'S

02:07 - 27.150 ALREADY IN PLACE THAT THE ONLY

02:07 - 28.820 WAY YOU CAN GET THE INABILITY.

02:07 - 32.170 ANOTHER PERSON WOULD BE REALLY

02:07 - 34.120 AGREEMENT IN A STATE AND

02:07 - 35.110 THEREFORE THIS

02:07 - 37.350 WHAT THE A TRIAL COURT STATED

02:07 - 39.320 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT FIRMS.

02:07 - 41.460 IT SHOULD BE FOLLOWED BY THIS

02:07 - 41.760 COURT.

02:07 - 43.880 >>THANK

02:07 - 47.080 REVIEW SAGER THE MTA

02:07 - 48.850 QUESTIONING WAS JUST THIS TIME.

02:07 - 53.060 >>I HAVE NO

02:07 - 54.560 QUESTIONS ASKED.

02:07 - 56.210 >>THANK YOU JUSTICE SHOT

02:07 - 57.200 JUSTICE DONE HERE.

02:07 - 02.070 AFTERNOON COUNCIL. I'M I'D LIKE

02:08 - 03.460 TO FOCUS ON

02:08 - 05.510 WHAT I BELIEVE IS THE ONLY

02:08 - 07.760 ISSUE THAT WE GRANT LANDS OF

02:08 - 07.840 THE

02:08 - 10.320 PEEL ON WHICH IS THE

02:08 - 13.370 MEANING OF THE LANGUAGE OF THE

02:08 - 15.970 ICE STATUTE AT ISSUE HERE WHICH

02:08 - 18.180 IS SEEN AS THE WHOLE LOT THESE

02:08 - 19.530 PENSION LAW. SO.

02:08 - 24.910 THE THE I SECTION 7.64.

02:08 - 27.210 GROUP LOSE.

02:08 - 30.250 >>I DID YOU LET ME LET

02:08 - 31.930 ME FREE READ YOU BECAUSE IT'S

02:08 - 34.330 VERY SHORT AND I'D LIKE YOUR

02:08 - 35.510 INTERPRETATION OF WHAT

02:08 - 36.320 IT MEANS.

02:08 - 39.100 >>RETIREMENT ALLOWANCE HERE IN

02:08 - 42.180 GREW BY 4 SHALL BE PAYABLE ONLY

02:08 - 44.190 TO THE BENEFICIARY DESIGNATED

02:08 - 44.350 IN

02:08 - 46.650 THIS YEAH AND SHALL NOT BE

02:08 - 48.530 SUBJECT TO ASSIGNMENT OR

02:08 - 49.330 TRANSFER.

02:08 - 51.550 AND TELL YOU HOW I READ THE

02:08 - 54.270 STATUTE AND YOU TELL ME YEAH I

02:08 - 57.060 MISS SOMETHING OR LOSE

02:08 - 00.340 THE ON PLANNED ADMINISTRATOR

02:09 - 02.970 FROM MAKING PAYMENTS TO ANYONE,

02:09 - 03.170 BUT

02:09 - 05.880 THE BENEFICIARY AND PRECLUDE

02:09 - 07.800 SOME PLAN ADMINISTRATOR FROM

02:09 - 08.710 ACCEPTING

02:09 - 11.230 AN ASSIGNMENT. SO THAT IT

02:09 - 13.180 SHOULD AT YOU MAY EVEN BE

02:09 - 14.420 SOMEONE EITHER BEEN THE

02:09 - 16.650 BENEFICIARY. DO YOU AGREE WITH

02:09 - 18.820 THAT INTERPRETATION. YES I

02:09 - 19.300 AGREE WITH

02:09 - 20.540 THAT INTERPRETATION.

02:09 - 23.040 >>WHAT IT DOESN'T DO IS IT DOES

02:09 - 25.520 NOT PRECLUDE ONCE PAYMENT IS

02:09 - 27.090 MADE TO THE BENEFICIARY THE

02:09 - 30.100 BENEFICIARY OF SIGNING MONEY'S

02:09 - 32.310 THEY RECEIVE TO A 3RD PARTY OR

02:09 - 33.790 GO, DOES

02:09 - 36.140 THIS BEAR AND IT STATED TO LAS

02:09 - 38.190 VEGAS FAVORITE TOILET PAPER.

02:09 - 40.190 THERE'S NOTHING THAT PRECLUDES

02:09 - 41.920 ONE GOING OUT OR ENTERING INTO

02:09 - 43.360 AN AGREEMENT THAT STATE AND

02:09 - 45.390 MISTER CHRISTINE ALSO THAT'S

02:09 - 45.480 THE

02:09 - 46.110 5 OUTLOOK.

02:09 - 48.390 >>I RECEIVE YOU YOU'RE YOU'RE

02:09 - 50.360 IN AGREEMENT WITH ME AS TO

02:09 - 53.520 WHY THIS SECTION OF THE LET ME

02:09 - 55.510 TAKE IT ONE STEP FURTHER ICE.

02:09 - 57.450 THERE IS ANOTHER QUESTION

02:09 - 59.510 STATUTORY INTERPRETATION IN

02:09 - 00.660 THIS CASE IN

02:10 - 02.450 HE ONCE AGAIN THIS IS WHAT THE

02:10 - 03.770 CAPITAL LANSING THAT YOU DON'T

02:10 - 04.000 LIKE.

02:10 - 05.090 >>I'M.

02:10 - 08.300 >>I SECTION SNOWDEN 70 SEX.

02:10 - 09.740 I PROVIDE

02:10 - 12.500 10 MINUTES. I SYRIAN PROVIDED

02:10 - 14.710 SHALL NOT BE SUBJECT TO CASHMAN

02:10 - 16.990 EXECUTION. LEVY

02:10 - 19.110 GARNISHMENT OR OTHER

02:10 - 22.140 LEGAL PROCESS AND YOU KNOW YOU

02:10 - 22.500 WITH THAT

02:10 - 24.720 STATUTE. YES, AND IT GOES ON TO

02:10 - 26.740 SAY AND SHALL BE PAYABLE ONLY

02:10 - 28.780 TO THE MEMBER OR HIS DESIGNATED

02:10 - 31.230 BENEFICIARY. AND USES LANGUAGE

02:10 - 32.600 AND SHALL NOT BE SUBJECT TO

02:10 - 35.320 ASSIGNMENT OR TRANSFER. AS I

02:10 - 36.710 READ THIS STATUTE.

02:10 - 39.070 THIS PRECLUDES

02:10 - 41.790 ANY INTERFERENCE WITH

02:10 - 45.090 THESE FINES BEFORE AND FINDS

02:10 - 46.810 REACH THE BENEFICIARY.

02:10 - 47.840 >>CORRECT.

02:10 - 49.660 >>THAT'S ALL I READ THAT AS

02:10 - 50.660 WELL AND THAT'S WHAT I THINK

02:10 - 51.580 IT'S LAWS AS I

02:10 - 52.410 REVIEW SECONDS.

02:10 - 54.530 >>AND SO IN THE END OF PHRASE

02:10 - 57.300 AND OTHER LEGAL PROCESS.

02:10 - 00.020 >>THEREFORE REFERS

02:11 - 02.300 TO ANY OTHER LEGAL PROCESS

02:11 - 04.390 DIRECTED I NEED TO BE PLANNED

02:11 - 06.470 MANY STRAIGHTER OR FOR EXAMPLE,

02:11 - 09.470 THE BANK IN WHICH THE FINES ARE

02:11 - 11.890 IN DECLINE. HER FOR EXAMPLE

02:11 - 13.890 IN JUNCTION WE'RE DECLARATORY

02:11 - 15.670 JUDGMENT, IT'S PRIMARILY YOU.

02:11 - 17.580 >>READ IT FOR CREDITORS, THE

02:11 - 19.200 BANK CREDITORS FROM ABOUT YOU

02:11 - 22.240 WANT TO LOVE SO THE ANNUITY OR

02:11 - 23.670 THE PENSION BENEFIT THEM.

02:11 - 24.800 WE'RE GOING TO SHIP.

02:11 - 27.780 >>OKAY SO YES, IT DOES NOT

02:11 - 30.040 SPEAK AT ALL TO LAST

02:11 - 32.450 THE BENEFICIARY CAN DO WITH THE

02:11 - 33.940 FINES WHEN IT IN YOUR POCKET.

02:11 - 36.050 >>CORRECT OKAY. THANK YOU.

02:11 - 38.780 >>THANK YOU JUSTICE DAUGHERTY.

02:11 - 41.140 >>CLARITY

02:11 - 42.920 PURPOSES, YOU'RE INDICATIONS

02:11 - 43.770 THAT THEY'RE NOT THE ONLY

02:11 - 45.940 NATION 1000 I BECAUSE THE MONEY

02:11 - 47.570 WAS RECEIVED BY THE RIGHT

02:11 - 47.810 THING.

02:11 - 50.040 >>AND THEREFORE ANYTHING DONE

02:11 - 52.010 THEREAFTER WOULD BE SUBJECT TO

02:11 - 52.930 THE PROPERTY SEND

02:11 - 54.030 WAS IRAQ.

02:11 - 56.130 >>OKAY AS LONG AS IT DOES NOT

02:11 - 57.450 CONFLICT AND DOES NOT

02:11 - 59.030 LIKE THESE. PENNSYLVANIA

02:11 - 01.520 PENSION LAWS WHICH IT DID NOT.

02:12 - 02.950 US JUST

02:12 - 05.160 AS DONAHUE IT COULD NOT BE

02:12 - 06.780 GARNISHED DIRECTLY AS DID

02:12 - 08.760 MISTER KIRSTEIN FIRST. YES

02:12 - 11.400 RIGHT A GUY. THANK YOU YOU'VE

02:12 - 12.220 GOT TO ACT.

02:12 - 13.840 >>THANK YOU CHIEF JUSTICE

02:12 - 16.240 COUNCIL SO THAT AS LONG AS THE

02:12 - 18.310 BENEFICIARY HAS GOOD FUNDS.

02:12 - 23.300 ANY LEGAL PROCESS

02:12 - 24.270 COULD ENSUE

02:12 - 26.950 THEREAFTER IN OT BE IN

02:12 - 29.980 VIOLATION OF PENSION PROVISIONS

02:12 - 32.250 IS THAT CORRECT. HER. THANK

02:12 - 34.670 YOU. THIS IS MONEY.

02:12 - 39.790 NO PRESS. THANK YOU, THAT'S A

02:12 - 40.420 SPARE.

02:12 - 43.300 AND I'M FOLLOWING UP I GUESS

02:12 - 44.680 WE'RE ALL BEATING THE SAME DEAD

02:12 - 45.800 COURSE JUST BECAUSE OF THE

02:12 - 48.300 OTHER SIDE. YOU CAN SEE THAT

02:12 - 50.220 ONCE THIS MONEY HAS BEEN PAID

02:12 - 51.000 TO HER THE CITY

02:12 - 54.150 HAS SURVIVED IN PAID FORMER

02:12 - 55.870 WIFE DECEASED WIFE. WE CAN BE

02:12 - 56.540 GARNISHED.

02:12 - 00.430 THEY CAN BE ATTACHED WHATEVER.

02:13 - 01.910 FOR STARTERS IS THAT RIGHT.

02:13 - 03.470 CORRECT OKAY.

02:13 - 04.830 >>I I

02:13 - 09.750 YEAR AGREEMENT.

02:13 - 14.710 ENTITLES YOU TO COUNSEL FEES

02:13 - 16.130 AND I KNOW THE TRIAL COURT GAVE

02:13 - 16.240 YOU

02:13 - 17.860 COUNCIL SEATS. BUT YES, I'M

02:13 - 19.540 STAN SHULL COUNCIL SEES I WOULD

02:13 - 21.110 PRESUME IN PREPARING

02:13 - 25.120 TO US YOU WANT THIS CASE ME MAN

02:13 - 27.000 DID IF YOU PREVAIL MAJORITY THE

02:13 - 29.470 COURT SEES IT YOUR WAY TO

02:13 - 31.980 TO AH AND ADDITIONAL COUNSEL

02:13 - 33.060 FEES FROM THE

02:13 - 33.620 OTHER SIDE.

02:13 - 36.910 >>I I WOULD ASK THAT THE EFFECT

02:13 - 38.530 WHERE THE THE COURT'S

02:13 - 40.370 DECISION THAT THERE WOULD BE AT

02:13 - 42.400 THE TERMINATION OR OR TO TO

02:13 - 44.460 MAKE THAT. ADDITIONAL.

02:13 - 47.980 RELIEF WHAT THESE SYRIA COURT

02:13 - 50.220 THAT BECAUSE OF THAT WHO'S UP

02:13 - 50.540 AND YOU

02:13 - 53.610 ULTIMATELY DIES REMAINS IT TO A

02:13 - 55.240 LOWER COURT FOR CHANGE IN

02:13 - 56.910 DAMAGES ANYWAY BECAUSE

02:13 - 59.220 OBVIOUSLY THERE'S CHANGING IN

02:13 - 00.480 DAMAGES CELL.

02:14 - 03.180 >>SO YOU HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO

02:14 - 04.380 SEEK FEEL WE DON'T HAVE TO

02:14 - 06.410 SPECIFY THAT. LET'S GO BACK.

02:14 - 10.050 ID IF YOU PREVAIL HERE.

02:14 - 13.350 AND ONE OTHER QUESTION I CAN'T

02:14 - 14.720 REMEMBER CHEETHAM DONE THANK

02:14 - 14.840 YOU.

02:14 - 16.510 >>THANK YOU JUSTIN BIEBER JUST

02:14 - 20.730 AS TODD MEANY A. 4 NOTHING.

02:14 - 23.600 I THINK IT DOES THE HONEY YEAR.

02:14 - 27.100 OK WELL

02:14 - 29.380 THANK YOU. IF YOU'D LIKE TO SAY

02:14 - 29.970 A A.

02:14 - 32.790 WE'RE TOO BY WAY OF SUMMATION

02:14 - 34.230 WE APPRECIATE IA.

02:14 - 36.720 THE SAME IS YOUR ARGUMENT

02:14 - 37.550 MISTER SAGER.

02:14 - 39.760 >>I'M A VERY VERY BRIEF EDGES

02:14 - 41.900 THAT IS THAT THIS COURT FROM

02:14 - 43.490 THE DECISION OF THE SUPERIOR

02:14 - 45.220 COURT REMANDED TO THE LOWER

02:14 - 47.370 COURT RELATED TO THEM.

02:14 - 51.260 >>THANK YOU, THANKS TO BOTH OF

02:14 - 52.480 THEM IS A COMPELLING ARGUMENT

02:14 - 54.420 IN THAT CASE. FIRST READ YOUR

02:14 - 56.790 CIGARETTES ARGUMENTS. IN THE

02:14 - 59.060 FINAL CAY ONE 15.

02:15 - 03.040 >>THE PC AND FAMILY. OUR ROOTS

02:15 - 04.250 RUN DEEP. WHAT

02:15 - 05.970 A LOT OF A PLAN TO DISTRIBUTE

02:15 - 07.690 EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMMING HAS

02:15 - 09.410 GROWN INTO THE NATION'S LEADING

02:15 - 10.790 STATEWIDE PUBLIC AFFAIRS

02:15 - 11.970 NETWORK. SINCE

02:15 - 15.250 1979 PCN HAS BEEN SUPPORTED BY

02:15 - 16.950 CABLE OPERATORS ACROSS

02:15 - 18.550 THE STATE. IT IS BECAUSE OF

02:15 - 20.790 THIS GENEROUS SUPPORT THE PC

02:15 - 22.800 AND USES NO STATE OR FEDERAL

02:15 - 24.690 TAX DOLLARS REACHING MORE THAN

02:15 - 26.500 10 MILLION OF OUR NEIGHBORS.

02:15 - 28.130 THANK YOUR CABLE OPERATOR.

02:15 - 29.190 WE DO.

02:15 - 32.610 >>THE NEXT ARGUMENT IS A MATTER

02:15 - 35.140 OF CATHERINE. WHY HER SAYS THE

02:15 - 36.360 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH'S

02:15 - 37.710 POSITIONS YOU CAN SEE.

02:15 - 40.200 ARENA ON BEHALF OF APPELLANTS

02:15 - 41.960 IS MARCH MUNICH ARE YOU ON

02:15 - 43.740 BEHALF TELL YOU SAYS JOHNSON

02:15 - 44.140 CAUGHT.

02:15 - 48.680 >>I GET AFTERNOON NOT.

02:15 - 50.320 THE POWER

02:15 - 52.260 GOES OUT. INJURED IN THE

02:15 - 55.140 SHOOTING OF BOY DIED. QUESTION

02:15 - 55.960 THE NEXT ARGUMENT.

02:15 - 59.370 SHE AND HER HUSBAND SUED

02:15 - 01.110 VARIOUS MEDICAL ENTITIES.

02:16 - 02.590 AND YOU CAN'T TO

02:16 - 04.820 SHOOTER SITUATIONS. SCHUMER

02:16 - 06.390 TAKEN STEPS TO HAVE HIM

02:16 - 08.080 INVOLUNTARILY JAM.

02:16 - 10.690 AND THAT THEIR CARRIER TO DO SO

02:16 - 11.630 CONSTITUTED

02:16 - 14.630 GROSS NEGLIGENCE. JACKIE MEMBER

02:16 - 16.210 LIABILITY UNDER THE MENTAL

02:16 - 17.720 HEALTH PROCEDURES ACT.

02:16 - 20.850 THE TRIAL COURT GRANTED THE

02:16 - 22.730 MEDICAL ENTITIES, PLENTY OF

02:16 - 25.140 OPTIONS. AND THE SUPERIOR COURT

02:16 - 25.780 OF FROM.

02:16 - 28.190 CONCLUDING THAT THE POSITIONS

02:16 - 30.110 TREATED THE SHOOTER. ON

02:16 - 32.790 A VOLUNTARY I THINK THEY SHOULD

02:16 - 34.800 AND THAT SUCH TREATMENT FELL

02:16 - 36.370 OUTSIDE THE SCOPE OF THE ACT.

02:16 - 39.450 THE COURT ALLOWED APPEAL TO

02:16 - 41.110 REVALUE AGE THIS HOLDING.

02:16 - 46.940 >>THANK YOU YOUR HONOR MAY IT

02:16 - 48.030 PLEASE THE COURT. I'M

02:16 - 50.310 MARK AMINA AND AS YOU KNOW, I

02:16 - 51.610 REPRESENT CATHERINE LIKE THE

02:16 - 53.310 MOST SERIOUSLY YOUR EYES AND

02:16 - 54.080 YOUR MOTHER.

02:16 - 58.830 MENTALLY ILL PERSON WHO GOT TO

02:16 - 59.860 THE WEST AND SITE MASS

02:16 - 00.460 SHOOTINGS.

02:17 - 03.390 MRS. WHITE'S CLAIMS ARE

02:17 - 06.290 STRICTLY BASED ON. REACHES OF

02:17 - 08.350 DUTY IMPOSED ON THAT THE

02:17 - 10.060 SHOOTER'S POSITIONS BY STATUTE.

02:17 - 13.610 NO PROCEDURES ACT. FIRST

02:17 - 15.670 THE SESSION LOWER COURTS WORK

02:17 - 17.770 IN ERROR BECAUSE A SECTION 3,

02:17 - 20.720 2, INVOLUNTARY EMERGENCY,

02:17 - 23.270 MENTAL HEALTH EXAMINATION IS

02:17 - 25.040 OBVIOUSLY IN VOLUNTEER.

02:17 - 27.880 AN HPA SECTION 1, 1,

02:17 - 30.090 4 SPECIFICALLY ALLOWS FOR EVERY

02:17 - 31.810 IMAGE IS CAUSED BY DOCTORS.

02:17 - 34.200 PRESLEY NEGLIGENT PARTICIPATION

02:17 - 35.830 INVOLUNTARY EXAMINATION

02:17 - 36.360 DECISION.

02:17 - 39.640 IT HAS A SHE NOTED THE TRIAL

02:17 - 40.060 COURT.

02:17 - 43.390 SECTION 1, 1, 3, SKLOOT

02:17 - 45.450 VOLUNTARY OUTPATIENT MENTAL

02:17 - 47.490 HEALTH CARE MEDICAL CARE.

02:17 - 50.070 AND THEREFORE RULED TIMES

02:17 - 51.640 OUTSIDE THE SNOW NEWS.

02:17 - 54.140 THE OPERATIVE FACT SORT OF THE

02:17 - 55.830 DOCTORS DECIDED THEIR PATIENTS

02:17 - 57.440 REQUIRE SECTION 3 O TO

02:17 - 58.900 INVOLUNTARY EXAMINATION.

02:17 - 00.870 PREAKNESS BECAUSE OF THE

02:18 - 02.580 SEVERELY MENTALLY ILL PERSON

02:18 - 04.250 WHO WAS A CLEAR AND PRESENT

02:18 - 05.160 YOUR ARMS UP.

02:18 - 08.320 AS THE IMAGE PH FIRST STEP IN

02:18 - 09.630 THE END ZONE DURING THIS

02:18 - 10.040 PROCESS.

02:18 - 13.020 THE HERS FACTS ESTABLISHING

02:18 - 14.430 THOSE DECISIONS WERE GROSSLY

02:18 - 16.960 NEGLIGENT LEE EXECUTED. I WON

02:18 - 19.000 MY ELECTION. THE DOCTORS DID

02:18 - 21.110 TAKE STEPS. WHAT THEY DIDN'T

02:18 - 22.750 DO. THAT'S A HUGE THEIR

02:18 - 24.660 DECISION BECAUSE THE

02:18 - 26.570 INVOLUNTARY EXAM TO ACTUALLY

02:18 - 26.850 ARE.

02:18 - 30.010 UNDER THE ACCORD AND VIRAT SOLD

02:18 - 30.190 THEM

02:18 - 32.400 TO DO THAT DECISION STEPS AND

02:18 - 34.000 THE INSURGENTS INVOLUNTARY

02:18 - 34.720 MENTAL HEALTH.

02:18 - 38.580 INVOLUNTARY TREATMENT. UNDER

02:18 - 40.220 THE PLANNED MEETING OF THE NHP

02:18 - 41.460 A SECTION ONE OF THE GREAT

02:18 - 43.590 PLEASE ASK THE QUESTION ARE

02:18 - 46.140 NEEDED THERE ARE. THE SECOND

02:18 - 46.660 REASON THAT THE

02:18 - 49.020 TRIAL COURT USED TO DISMISSING

02:18 - 50.190 A COMPLAINT AGAINST

02:18 - 53.410 THE DOCTORS. LET'S TALK OR WIFE

02:18 - 55.360 BILITY FOR THEIR GROSSLY

02:18 - 56.760 NEGLIGENT EXECUTION OF THE

02:18 - 58.660 INVOLUNTARY EXAMINATIONS.

02:18 - 01.820 AND WHAT THEY CONSIDER UNLESS

02:19 - 04.030 AND UNTIL THE DOCTORS SIGN A

02:19 - 05.420 DOCUMENT THAT WOULD HAVE CAUSED

02:19 - 07.140 THE EXAMINATION. YOU HAVE

02:19 - 07.660 OCCURRED.

02:19 - 11.120 YES THAT'S WHAT I SAID.

02:19 - 14.140 I RESPECTFULLY IT SHOWS A