00:30 - >>WELCOME TO THE PENNSYLVANIA

00:31 - BAR ASSOCIATION YOUNG LAWYER

00:33 - DIVISION MOCK TRIAL STATE

00:34 - FINALS. WE WELCOME YOU HERE TO

00:37 - HARRISBURG PENNSYLVANIA TO THE

00:38 - DOLPHIN COUNTY COURTHOUSE.

00:40 - YOU 2 SHOULD BE PROBLEMS 2

00:41 - TEAMS SHOULD BE

00:42 - PROUD OF ACROSS THE 275 TEAMS

00:45 - THAT BEGAN THIS COMPETITION IN

00:46 - JANUARY. ACTUALLY IN NOVEMBER

00:48 - WHEN THE PROBLEM CAME OUT.

00:50 - YOU ARE THE FINAL 2 REMAINING.

00:52 - IT'S BEEN A GOOD HERE AND IT'S

00:53 - BEEN A LONG JOURNEY FOR YOU TO

00:55 - TEAM THAT WE HAVE YOUNG LAWYERS

00:56 - DIVISION.

00:57 - CONGRATULATIONS, MY NAME IS

00:59 - JOHN THE CALL TO ASH AND THE

01:00 - IMMEDIATE PAST CHAIR OF YOUNG

01:02 - LAWYERS DIVISION WITH THE

01:03 - GOVERNMENT OF KENNY, THE

01:05 - INCOMING CHAIR OF THE YOUNG

01:06 - LAWYERS DIVISION AND MORE

01:07 - IMPORTANT FOR DAY PROCEEDINGS.

01:08 - THE CO-CHAIRS OF THE

01:09 - COMPETITION. BEFORE WE BEGIN I

01:11 - WOULD LIKE TO JUST ON BEHALF OF

01:13 - THE ASSOCIATION. THANK A FEW OF

01:14 - OUR PARTNERS FIRST THE

01:16 - PENNSYLVANIA

01:16 - BAR FOUNDATION WHO GENEROSITY

01:19 - MAKES MAKE MUCH OF THIS

01:21 - WEEKEND POSSIBLE TO THE

01:23 - HONORABLE CAROLYN MCCALL CHAIR

01:25 - US DISTRICT MAGISTRATE JUDGE

01:27 - HERE IN THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF

01:28 - PENNSYLVANIA. AND MOST NOTABLY

01:29 - ONCE A MOCK TRIAL COACH WHOSE

01:31 - TEAM MADE IT TO THIS ROUTE.

01:33 - SO YOU HAVE A GOOD HAND YOU

01:34 - HAVE A A SERIOUS DEDICATED

01:37 - DOCTOR HOUR ON THE BENCH.

01:39 - THIS YEAR.

01:41 - THE PARENTS THE VOLUNTEERS, THE

01:43 - HUNDREDS OF VOLUNTEERS THAT

01:44 - MAKE THIS COMPETITION RUN.

01:46 - THROUGHOUT THE COMMONWEALTH,

01:47 - THE STUDENTS THE TEACHERS IN

01:49 - THE SCHOOL DISTRICT YOU SHOULD

01:50 - ALL BE VERY PROUD OF ALL THE

01:52 - WORK THAT YOU DO.

01:53 - FOR THOSE WATCHING AT HOME I'LL

01:55 - GIVE YOU A LITTLE BACKGROUND ON

01:56 - OUR CASE.

01:57 - THIS CASE IS THE COMMONWEALTH

01:59 - OF PENNSYLVANIA, THE RE

02:00 - SCHAEFER. IT CAN

02:03 - BE UNRELENTING IT CAN DESTROY

02:05 - LIVES AND YET IT LEAVES NO MARK

02:07 - AND IT'S NO OBJECTIVE MEASURE

02:08 - OF ITS EXISTENCE. ONE PERSON

02:11 - CALLS PAIN AND 8 ANOTHER CALLED

02:13 - IT BEFORE WHO IS

02:14 - SUFFERING MORE WHAT LEADS

02:16 - GREATER RELIEF OR LONGER.

02:18 - AT THE FRONT OF THE FRONTIERS

02:19 - OF MEDICINE. DOCTORS AND

02:21 - PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES ONCE

02:22 - THOUGHT THEY HAD

02:23 - AN ANSWER DERIVE FROM THE SAME

02:25 - CHEMISTRY, THE GAME MORPHINE

02:26 - IT'S LIFE CHANGING POWER ON THE

02:27 - BATTLEFIELDS OF ANTIETAM TO

02:29 - NORMANDY OPIATE PAINKILLERS

02:31 - CAME INTO THE SCENE IN THE

02:32 - EARLY 1990'S AND THE DREAM OF

02:34 - THEY'RE ALL JUST AND PAIN

02:35 - MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST SEEMS THE

02:37 - INFORMATION. THE DREAM TODAY

02:39 - HAS BECOME OUR NIGHTMARE.

02:40 - THE BEST ESTIMATES SUGGEST THE

02:42 - OPIATE PAINKILLERS WERE

02:43 - RESPONSIBLE FOR 60,000 DEATHS

02:45 - LAST YEAR ALONE. THIS IS MORE

02:47 - THAN TRAFFIC DEATHS MORE THAN

02:48 - FIREARM DEATHS AND MORE THAN

02:50 - COCAINE AND HEROIN PUT TOGETHER

02:52 - FOR THE PAST

02:53 - 2 DECADES BILLS HAVE NOT HAD

02:55 - THE SAME REPUTATION AS OTHER

02:56 - STREET DRUGS AND THE WIDE

02:57 - AVAILABILITY AND LEGITIMATE

02:59 - USES FOR PAINKILLERS

03:00 - BECAUSE THEY REFUSE TO SPREAD

03:02 - ITS FEW OTHER ILLEGAL

03:03 - SUBSTANCES HAVE AS THE OPIATE

03:05 - EPIDEMIC IS A WIDE RANGING AS

03:07 - IT IS DEVASTATING RURAL AREAS

03:09 - ARE HIT JUST AS HARD IN THE

03:10 - INNER CITIES. TODAY IS THE

03:12 - COMMUNITIES COME UNDER SIEGE.

03:14 - THIS YEAR'S CASE TAKES PLACE IN

03:16 - THE BLEEDING EDGE OF THE OPIATE

03:18 - CRISIS IN THIS COUNTRY.

03:19 - HADLEY MCADOO A BELOVED MEMBER

03:21 - OF THE WHISTLE WE PENNSYLVANIA

03:22 - COMMUNITY HAS DIED ON THE EXAM

03:24 - ROOM TABLE AT THE OFFICE OF

03:26 - SCHAEFER A LOCAL PAIN

03:28 - MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST THAT

03:29 - CAUSE OF DEATH THE EMPTY

03:31 - SYRINGE OF HYDRA MORPHINE A

03:33 - POTENT OR OUT THE CAR CAUGHT

03:35 - IT, MIXED WITH XANAX

03:37 - ALREADY AND THAT IS BLOCKED THE

03:39 - QUESTION FOR TRIAL ARISES

03:41 - SCHAEFER IT MINISTRY SHAPERS

03:43 - ADMINISTRATION OF THE

03:44 - PAINKILLER AN ACT OF MERCY TO A

03:46 - LOCAL HERO IN CRIPPLING PAIN OR

03:48 - WAS IT A CRIMINAL ACT OF A

03:49 - DOCTOR DRIVEN TO DESPERATION BY

03:51 - FINANCIAL RUIN. FAR BEYOND THE

03:53 - BOUNDS OF ACCEPTABLE MEDICINE

03:54 - IN A WORLD WHICH HAD

03:56 - AT LAST RECOGNIZE THE RIGHT NOW

03:58 - IS THE DANGERS POSED BY THE

03:59 - OPIUM.

04:00 - THE COMMONWEALTH CALL 3

04:02 - WITNESSES TO PROVE

04:03 - THEIR CASE FRANKIE'S ALL A

04:05 - NURSE PRACTITIONER WHO OBSERVE

04:06 - SHAPERS PRACTICE IT FIRSTHAND

04:08 - JJ TO A LOCAL BUSINESS PERSON

04:10 - AND FRIEND OF HAVING MCADOO AND

04:12 - WHILE COPELAND,

04:13 - A DIVERSION INVESTIGATOR FOR

04:14 - THE UNITED STATES DRUG

04:15 - ENFORCEMENT ADMINISTRATION.

04:17 - SHAME RESPONDS IN HIS OR HER

04:19 - OWN DEFENSE AND CALLS AN EXPERT

04:21 - OF HIS OR HER OWN

04:22 - RE HEIGHT AND ONE OF BACK OF

04:24 - HIS CLOSEST FRIENDS

04:24 - INCOMPETENCE SOW ABBOTT TRIAL

04:27 - IT IS ABOUT TO BEGIN. YOU MAY

04:29 - BRING THE JURY ARE NOT

04:30 - AVAILABLE.

05:15 - >>WELCOME

05:15 - TO TODAY'S FINAL ROUND OF THIS

05:19 - MIKE TROUT COMPETITION.

05:22 - >>VERY EXCITING PRESIDE OVER

05:24 - THIS TODAY. AND I AM AND.

05:28 - YOU ALL SHOULD BE SO PROUD TO

05:29 - HAVE TO BE HERE.

05:32 - THIS IS GOING TO BE A EXCITING

05:34 - ROUND. AND IT SHOULD BE FUN

05:36 - TOO. AND THIS IS A DAY

05:38 - THE EXPERIENCE THAT IS TO HELP

05:40 - YOU GET A GREATER UNDERSTANDING

05:42 - OF OUR GREAT LEGAL SYSTEM

05:44 - WHICH.

05:47 - TRULY BELIEVE IS THE BEST WE

05:48 - HAVE IN THIS WORLD SAID THANK

05:50 - YOU FOR PARTICIPATING IN THIS

05:51 - TODAY. I WANT TO START

05:53 - BY THERE

05:53 - AND FIRST WE YOU CAN AND IF YOU

05:55 - HAVE SEEN I HAVE THE TEAMS THAT

05:56 - ARE HERE TODAY.

05:58 - AND THEN ASK YOU TO BRIEFLY

06:00 - INTRODUCE YOURSELF AND WHERE

06:01 - YOU'RE FROM.

06:04 - >>BUT IT IS JOE HAS THE BAR

06:08 - ASSOCIATION. AND CIVIL

06:10 - LITIGATOR THAT

06:18 - >>LITIGATION LAW FIRM AND

06:26 - >>WHERE ALL THAT'S THE NATION.

06:59 - PART OF THE LAW FIRM WILLIAMS

07:00 - AND 3 BIRDIES JONES.

07:02 - >>IN POTTSVILLE PENNSYLVANIA.

07:03 - AND ALSO YOUR MEMBER OF THE

07:05 - PENNSYLVANIA BAR FOUNDATION,

07:07 - WHICH IS ONE OF THE FINANCIAL

07:09 - SPONSORS OF THESE WERE

07:13 - >>GOOD MORNING. I'M JUST DON'T

07:15 - YOUNG AND THE JUDGE OF THE

07:17 - COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF THE

07:18 - FIRST EDITION MISTER PRESIDENT.

07:23 - >>MY NAME IS LISA ON THE FAMILY

07:25 - COURT ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE

07:26 - 23TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT AND

07:28 - ARBOR SAYS HAITIANS, MIKE TROUT

07:30 - ORDINATOR.

07:32 - >>THE MORNING WHEN SHE AND

07:36 - LITIGATOR AND HERES FOR FRONT

07:38 - THE PHILADELPHIA FOR IT

07:39 - GENERAL COUNSEL TO THE GOVERNOR

07:41 - AND GENERAL COUNSEL HAS SCHOOL.

07:44 - >>THE

07:45 - U K.

07:48 - >>AT THIS

07:48 - TIME I'M GOING ASK EVERYONE TO

07:50 - VERIFY THAT YOUR PHONES AND ANY

07:51 - OTHER ELECTRONIC DEVICES HAVE

07:53 - BEEN SHOT OR SILENCED.

07:55 - AND IT MUST USE ONE OF YOUR

07:57 - ELECTRONIC DEVICES THESE LEAVE

07:59 - THE COURTROOM TO DEUCE OUT.

08:03 - PLEASE ALSO TRYING TO LIMIT THE

08:04 - NUMBER OF TIME AND SAY YOU

08:05 - ENTER AND EXIT THE COURTROOM AS

08:07 - IT DOES DISRUPT

08:08 - THE PROCEEDINGS. I ONLY DO SO

08:10 - IF YOU HAVE TO TRY TO LIMIT

08:12 - THOSE INTERRUPTIONS TO BREAKS

08:14 - WHEN YOU NEED HIM.

08:17 - AT THIS TIME WE ASKED THE

08:18 - TEAM'S INTRODUCE THEIR PURCHASE

08:20 - PAIN MEMBERS BY NAME AND ROLL

08:22 - THAT PLEASE I WANT TO REMIND

08:23 - YOU DO NOT IDENTIFY OR GENE.

08:25 - SO STARTING WITH THE

08:25 - PROSECUTION.

08:27 - >>MORNING YOUR HONOR WHEN HE

08:29 - WAS IN THE SINAI I'LL BE

08:30 - PERFORMING THE OPENING

08:31 - STATEMENT, THE DIRECT

08:32 - EXAMINATION OF J J T VA AND THE

08:34 - CROSS EXAMINATION OF RACIAL

08:36 - FRONT.

08:37 - >>GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR MY

08:38 - NAME IS TRUE IN SPIRIT I'LL BE

08:40 - PERFORMING THE DIRECT

08:41 - EXAMINATION OF AGENT ROYAL

08:42 - COPELAND AND THE CROSS

08:43 - EXAMINATION OF DOCTOR WRITE IT.

08:46 - GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR MY

08:47 - NAME IS CLOSE BUT FRANK I'LL BE

08:49 - PERFORMING THE DIRECT

08:50 - EXAMINATION OF FRIEND KELSEY.

08:52 - >>THE CROSS EXAMINATION OF CELL

08:53 - AT IT AND THE CLOSING ARGUMENT.

09:11 - >>WE'RE ALSO JOINED BY A

09:12 - TIMEKEEPER GOOD MORNING AND

09:14 - THANK YOU.

09:18 - >>THE THERE ARE ITEMS OF R B I

09:20 - WOULD REX OUT OF IT AND COST

09:22 - AND KELSEY ON WITH GIVE THE

09:23 - CLOSING ARGUMENTS.

09:24 - >>THE MORNING WHEN THERE'S

09:26 - NICHOLS KLEIN NOW BE DOING THE

09:27 - DIRECT EXAMINATION OF DOCTOR I

09:29 - HATE AND THE CROSS EXAMINATION

09:30 - OF OIL

09:31 - COAL PLANT.

09:32 - >>GOOD MORNING ON IN BE

09:34 - DELIVERING OPENING STATEMENT,

09:36 - DIRECTING RE SCHAFFER AND

09:37 - CROSSING J J T THAT.

09:56 - >>BECAUSE OF THIS TIME THAT HE

09:58 - I'LL PROVIDE YOU AN OPPORTUNITY

09:59 - AT THE FIRST BREAK TO VERIFY

10:01 - THAT YOU

10:01 - ARE WITHIN 15 SECONDS OF EACH

10:03 - OTHER IN TERRY PROBLEMS BE

10:05 - SHARING THAT CHECK THAT POINT.

10:08 - IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE THAT WE

10:10 - NEED TO DO BEFORE UNITED

10:11 - PARTY'S ANY PERCEIVED AT THIS

10:12 - TIME.

10:14 - >>HAVE A FEW BRIEF ENCOUNTERS

10:16 - THAT WE ASK YOUR PERMISSION TO

10:17 - MOVE FREELY ABOUT THE WELL.

10:19 - I HAVE NO PROBLEM

10:19 - WITH THAT AND THE LIKES OF HER

10:21 - FRIENDS FOR APPROACHING

10:22 - WITNESSES AND OPPOSING COUNSEL

10:23 - TABLE. I'M SORRY WE ASKED ARE

10:26 - ON PREFERENCES FOR POACHING

10:27 - WITNESSES AND OPPOSING COUNSEL

10:28 - TABLE.

10:29 - >>I MEAN YOU CAN I KNOW PROM

10:31 - WITH THE APPROACHING WHEN IT'S

10:31 - WHEN IT'S TIME.

10:34 - WHEN IT'S

10:34 - APPROPRIATE AND DURING

10:35 - QUESTIONING SO THAT'S THAT'S

10:37 - FIRE TO EXTRA INNINGS AND IT IS

10:38 - SOMETHING LIKE THAT I

10:39 - APPRECIATE THAT AND THE SAME

10:40 - WITH PROVIDING ANYTHING THE

10:41 - COUNCIL TABLE. YOU'RE NOT YOU

10:43 - DON'T HAVE TO ASK EVERY TIME.

10:44 - >>YES, I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO

10:46 - VOTE RULES OF COMPETITION,

10:47 - 4.7 WHICH STATES THAT ALL

10:49 - WITNESSES ARE CONSTRUCTIVELY

10:50 - SEQUESTERED WITH THE EXCEPTION

10:52 - OF PARTY REPRESENTATIVES.

10:53 - >>ANY OBJECTION TO THAT.

10:57 - THAT THAT THE COMMONWEALTH'S

10:58 - ATTORNEY FOR SEAT, YOU MAY

11:00 - PROCEED.

11:13 - >>MY NAME IS EVA SINAI AND

11:14 - ALONG WITH MY CO-COUNSEL THEY

11:16 - REPRESENT THE COMMONWEALTH OF

11:17 - PENNSYLVANIA.

11:18 - >>WE'RE HERE TODAY TO PROVE TO

11:20 - THE DEFENDANT DOCTOR

11:21 - RAY SCHIEFFER IS GUILTY OF DRUG

11:24 - DELIVERY RESULTING IN THE DEATH

11:25 - OF HOW THE MCADOO WE'RE GOING

11:28 - TO SHOW TO THE DEFENDANT WAS A

11:29 - DOCTOR WAS UNDER TOO MUCH

11:31 - PRESSURE PRESCRIBING TOO MANY

11:33 - OPIOIDS AND TAKING TOO FEW

11:35 - PRECAUTIONS. OUR STORY BEGINS

11:38 - WITH A DIFFERENT.

11:39 - A DOCTOR WHO OPENED UP THE PAIN

11:41 - TREATMENT CLINIC CALLED PAIN

11:42 - AWAY AND IT WAS WEAK AND

11:43 - SYLVANIA IN 2010. ORIGINALLY

11:46 - DESIGNED TO PROVIDE THE MEMBERS

11:48 - OF THE SMALL TOWN BUT THE

11:49 - HOLISTIC METHOD TO TREATING

11:50 - PAIN. THE CLINIC QUICKLY LOST

11:52 - ITS FOOTING DO THAT

11:53 - CATASTROPHIC FLOOD DAMAGE.

11:55 - AS A RESULT, THE DEFENDANT

11:57 - DEVELOPED A RECKLESS PERSONAL

11:58 - HABITS AND OVERPRESCRIBING

12:00 - OPIOIDS. IN

12:03 - 2014. THE DEFENDANT BEGAN

12:04 - TREATING A WOMAN DIDN'T HAVE

12:06 - THE BACK AT YOU COMMONLY

12:07 - REFERRED TO AS COACH. THE

12:09 - DEFENDANT WAS PRESCRIBING THE

12:10 - HIGHLY ADDICTIVE OXYCODONE TO

12:12 - COACH MCADOO FOR NEARLY 3

12:14 - YEARS. ON DECEMBER,

12:17 - 1620 16. THE DEFENDANT GAVE

12:19 - COACH MCADOO A STRONG SHOT OF

12:21 - HYDROMORPHONE WITHOUT TAKING

12:23 - THE TIME TO CHECK AND SEE WHAT

12:25 - OTHER MEDICATIONS SHE MIGHT BE

12:26 - ON.

12:28 - COACH MCADOO WAS FOUND DEAD IN

12:30 - HER HOME. IT

12:31 - IS STIPULATED THAT SHE WAS

12:33 - KILLED BY A COMBINATION OF

12:34 - OPIOIDS SHE'S RECEIVING THE

12:36 - DEFENDANT AND XANAX.

12:39 - NOW AS THE COMMONWEALTH WE HAVE

12:40 - THE BURDEN OF PROOF TO DATE

12:42 - WHICH MEANS THAT WE HAVE TO

12:43 - PROVE TO YOU BEYOND A

12:44 - REASONABLE DOUBT THE DEFENDANT

12:45 - IS GUILTY. IF AT THE END OF

12:47 - STAGE TRIAL. YOU FIND THAT

12:49 - EITHER THE DEFENDANT DID NOT

12:51 - ACT IN GOOD FAITH

12:52 - OR THAT SHE FAILED TO ACT IN

12:54 - ACCORDANCE WITH TREATMENT

12:55 - PRINCIPLES ACCEPTED BY

12:56 - RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF THE

12:57 - MEDICAL PROFESSION. YOU MUST

12:59 - FIND HER GUILTY. ONLY ONE OF

13:01 - THESE IS NEEDED FOR CONVICTION.

13:04 - NOW A RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF

13:05 - THE MEDICAL PROFESSION DOES NOT

13:07 - MEAN EVERY LICENSED DOCTOR.

13:09 - IT JUST MEANS THAT GOOD

13:10 - JUDGE AND DOCTORS WOULDN'T

13:12 - AGREE WITH THE DEFENDANT'S

13:13 - ACTIONS.

13:15 - WE'RE GOING TO CALL 3 WITNESSES

13:16 - BEFORE

13:16 - YOU TODAY WITH YOUR GIRLFRIEND

13:18 - KELSEY NURSE PRACTITIONER PAIN

13:20 - WEIGHT WHO WILL TELL YOU HOW IN

13:22 - THE CLINIC HAD FINANCIAL

13:23 - TROUBLES. THE DEFENDANT BEGAN

13:24 - PRESCRIBING MORE AND MORE

13:26 - OPIOIDS AND THE VERY SAME TOWN

13:28 - WHERE SHE WAS ONCE PRACTICED A

13:29 - HOLISTIC LEE. AT THE

13:31 - SAME TIME THE DEFENDANT WAS

13:32 - SPENDING LESS AND LESS TIME

13:34 - WITH HER PATIENTS.

13:37 - THERE'S YOUR FROM J J T THAT

13:38 - THEY CAN PLAY IN CONCERT WITH A

13:40 - DEPENDENT. WE'LL TELL YOU HOW

13:41 - THE DEFENDANT'S MENTAL STATE

13:43 - WAS DRAMATICALLY AFFECTED BY

13:44 - THE DA PAUL P LIGHT AND ASHLEY

13:46 - BEGAN DRINKING. MISTER TITO

13:48 - WILL ALSO TELL YOU. COACH MACK

13:50 - AND HIS MENTAL HEALTH WAS

13:51 - VISIBLY DECLINING. HE TRIED TO

13:54 - WARN THE DEFENSE AND UP THIS HE

13:55 - RECEIVED NO RESPONSE.

13:58 - IT WAS YOUR SUNDAY, A

14:00 - SPECIAL AGENT IN OUR COMICS

14:01 - INVESTIGATOR WILL COPE WITH IT.

14:03 - AGENT COPELAND WILL TESTIFY TO

14:05 - THE RED FLAGS HE FOUND IN

14:06 - HIS INVESTIGATION, INCLUDING

14:08 - HELPING LAY SKYROCKETED ABOVE

14:10 - THE NATIONAL AVERAGE. BOTH IN

14:12 - THEIR OPIOID PRESCRIPTION RATES

14:14 - AND THE POTENCY OF THESE

14:15 - PRESCRIPTIONS. ASIAN CUP AND

14:18 - ALSO TELL YOU HOW THE DEFENDANT

14:19 - COULD AND SHOULD HAVE KNOWN THE

14:22 - COACH MCADOO WAS TAKING XANAX

14:24 - THE DEFENDANT COULD HAVE

14:25 - LEARNED THE SIMPLE FACT BUT

14:27 - MINISTER IN A URINE TEST OR BY

14:29 - CHECKING THE DATABASE IS

14:30 - SUCCESSFUL TO ALL PENNSYLVANIA

14:32 - DOCTORS. THE DEFENDANT DID

14:35 - NEITHER.

14:36 - NOW THE DEFENSE ALSO CALLED

14:38 - THROUGH AN ASSIST TODAY.

14:39 - BUT IF YOU LISTEN CLOSELY TO

14:41 - THE TESTIMONY. YOU'LL HEAR THAT

14:42 - THEY TO PAINT A PICTURE OF A

14:44 - DOCTOR WHO'S UNDER TOO MUCH

14:45 - PRESSURE PRESCRIBING TOO MANY

14:47 - OPIOIDS AND TAKING TOO FEW

14:50 - PRECAUTIONS.

14:52 - AFTER HEARING THE FACTS OF

14:53 - STATE'S CASE. IT WILL BE CLEAR

14:55 - THAT WE WILL HAVE MET OUR

14:56 - VERDICT AND SHOW TO DEFEND IT

14:58 - DID NOT ACT IN GOOD FAITH THAT

15:00 - SHE DID NOT ACT ACCORDANCE WITH

15:02 - TREATMENT PRINCIPLES ACCEPTED

15:04 - BY RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF THE

15:05 - MEDICAL PROFESSION.

15:09 - WAS UNDER TOO MUCH PRESSURE

15:10 - BETWEEN THE BANKRUPTCY OF HER

15:11 - CLINIC AND A MEDICAL

15:12 - MALPRACTICE SUIT. THE DEFENDANT

15:15 - WAS A DOCTOR WHO IS PRESCRIBING

15:16 - TOO MANY OPIOIDS YOU'LL HEAR

15:19 - HOW HER PRESCRIPTION RATES

15:20 - STARTED AROUND 10% BUT CLIMBED

15:23 - TO OVER 80%. THE DEFENDANT WAS

15:27 - A DOCTOR WHO IS TAKING TOO

15:29 - FEW PRECAUTIONS. SHE NEVER USE

15:31 - YOUR TESTING AT HER CLINIC.

15:33 - SHE FAILED TO CHECK

15:34 - THE DATABASE AND SHE DIDN'T

15:36 - EVEN ASK COACH MCADOO WHETHER

15:37 - SHE WAS TAKING XANAX.

15:40 - AT THE CONCLUSION OF TODAY'S

15:41 - TRIAL COUNCIL POLICE

15:43 - MET FRANK WILL COME BEFORE YOU

15:45 - AND ASK THAT YOU FIND IN FAVOR

15:46 - OF THE COMMONWEALTH AND FINE

15:48 - DOCTOR RAY SCHIEFFER GUILTY

15:50 - OF DRUG DELIVERY RESULTING IN

15:52 - THE DEATH OF HOW THE MCADOO

15:54 - THANK YOU.

16:08 - >>THE PROCEED.

16:18 - MAY IT PLEASE

16:18 - THE COURT OPPOSING COUNSEL

16:21 - MEMBERS OF THE JURY. WHEN

16:23 - FIREFIGHTERS RACE INTO A

16:24 - BURNING BUILDING. THEY USE

16:26 - THEIR TRAINING AND EXPERIENCE

16:28 - TO ASSESS THE SITUATION AND

16:30 - THEY FORM THE BEST JUDGMENT ON

16:31 - HOW TO PROCEED.

16:34 - PATROL STREETS AND FOREIGN

16:35 - COMBAT ZONES, THEY USE THEIR

16:37 - TRAINING AND EXPERIENCE TO

16:40 - ASSESS THE SITUATION AND THEY

16:42 - FORM THEIR BEST JUDGMENT ON HOW

16:43 - TO PROCEED.

16:46 - ENCOUNTER DANGEROUS FLYING

16:47 - CONDITIONS. THEY USE THEIR

16:49 - TRAINING AND EXPERIENCE TO

16:51 - ASSESS THE SITUATION AND THEY

16:53 - FORM THEIR BEST JUDGMENT ON HOW

16:54 - TO PROCEED. ON

16:56 - DECEMBER, 1620 16. DOCTOR A

16:59 - SHIP WAS FACED WITH A

17:00 - DIFFICULT SITUATION. USING HER

17:03 - MEDICAL TRAINING

17:04 - AND EXPERIENCE SHE ATTEMPTED TO

17:06 - RELIEVE HER PATIENTS PAIN.

17:09 - WAS COMPASSION

17:10 - HEARD JUDGMENT WAS CONSISTENT

17:13 - WITH THE STANDARDS SET BY HER

17:14 - MEDICAL PROFESSION. BECAUSE THE

17:16 - ULTIMATE OUTCOME WAS

17:18 - UNFORTUNATE. THE PROSECUTION

17:20 - HAS CHARGED. SCHAEFER WITH A

17:22 - CRIME.

17:24 - GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE

17:25 - JURY MY NAME IS LAURA PALMER.

17:27 - >>I ALONG WITH MY CO-COUNSEL

17:28 - NICHOLAS CLIMB, MILITANT R B

17:30 - REPRESENT THE DEFENDANT

17:31 - TONIGHT'S CASE. DOCTOR A SHAPE.

17:35 - THE PROSECUTION BEARS THE

17:37 - BURDEN OF PROVING THEIR CASE TO

17:38 - YOU BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT,

17:40 - THIS MEANS THE MUST PROVE

17:41 - BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT, BUT

17:42 - ON DECEMBER 16TH,

17:44 - 2016. DOCTOR A SHAPER EITHER

17:46 - FAIL TO ACT IN GOOD FAITH

17:48 - OR FAIL TO ACT AND ACCORDING TO

17:50 - THE TREATMENT PRINCIPLES

17:51 - ACCEPTED BY RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT

17:53 - OF THE MEDICAL PROFESSION.

17:54 - THAT MEMBERS OF THE JURY.

17:56 - DO NOT JUDGE MY TIME WITH THE

17:58 - BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. JUDGE

18:00 - DOCTOR SAFER AND THE

18:01 - CIRCUMSTANCES THAT EXISTED WITH

18:03 - HER ENCOUNTER WITH COACH HAVING

18:05 - MCADOO ON THE AFTERNOON OF

18:06 - DECEMBER 16TH, 2016.

18:10 - THERE'S NO BURDEN OF PROOF

18:11 - TONIGHT AND THE DEFENSE

18:13 - DOES NOT NEED TO CALL A SINGLE

18:15 - WITNESS TO THE STAND. BUT.

18:18 - WE INTEND TO CALL 3 WITNESSES

18:19 - TO PROVE TO YOU. MEMBERS OF

18:21 - THE JURY THAT DOCTOR SHAFER

18:23 - ACTED IN BOTH

18:24 - GOOD FAITH AND WITHIN THE

18:26 - TREATMENT PRINCIPLES EXCEPT

18:27 - ABOUT RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF

18:29 - THE MEDICAL PROFESSION. OUR

18:31 - FIRST WIN TONIGHT AS

18:33 - SCHAEFER SHE WOULD TELL YOU

18:34 - ABOUT HER EXTENSIVE EDUCATION

18:36 - AND TRAINING TO BECOME A

18:38 - PHYSICIAN SPECIALIZING IN PAIN

18:39 - MANAGEMENT. DOCTOR SHAFER WILL

18:41 - TELL YOU THAT YOU OPENED A

18:42 - CLINIC CALLED PAIN WAY HERE IN

18:44 - WHICH THE 2010. AND SHE WILL

18:46 - TELL YOU THAT COACH HEAVY

18:47 - MCADOO A 73 YEAR-OLD WHO SUFFER

18:50 - FROM CHRONIC AND AT TIMES THE

18:52 - BELLA TAKING PAIN BECAME HER

18:54 - PATIENT 2014. DOCTOR SHAFER

18:58 - TELL YOU THE ON THE AFTERNOON

18:59 - OF DECEMBER 16TH, 2016.

19:02 - THE COACH SHOWED UP AT HER

19:04 - OFFICE SHOWING SIGNS OF EXTREME

19:06 - PAIN. I ASK YOU

19:09 - TO PAY CLOSE

19:11 - ATTENTION. THE TESTIMONY ABOUT

19:13 - COACHES. PRESENTATION ON THIS

19:16 - DAY.

19:17 - UNFORTUNATELY COACH NOT PROVIDE

19:19 - ACCURATE INFORMATION DOCTOR

19:20 - SHAFER WHEN ASKED WHAT AT A

19:22 - MEDICATION SHE

19:23 - WAS TAKING. COACH FAIL TO SAY

19:25 - THAT SHE WAS TAKING XANAX THE

19:27 - FACE WITH A PATIENT IN EXTREME

19:29 - AGONY. AND NOT

19:31 - KNOWING THAT THAT PATIENT HAD

19:32 - BREACHED THE TRUST RELATIONSHIP

19:34 - WITH HER PHYSICIAN. DOCTOR

19:36 - SHAFER HUGE MEDICAL TRAINING

19:38 - AND EXPERIENCE IN MINISTERING

19:39 - PAIN RELIEF MEDICATION. OUR

19:42 - SECOND ONE IS TONIGHT IS

19:43 - MISSILE AT IT, SHE'S PAID TO

19:44 - HIS ACCOUNTANT SHE WAS TIED UP

19:46 - BY 2016. ANY FINANCIAL PROBLEMS

19:49 - CITED BY THE PROSECUTION.

19:53 - BUT WAS ALSO VERY

19:54 - CLOSE FRIEND. COACH

19:55 - HAVING ACTED AND SHE REALLY

19:57 - SOME INTERESTING OBSERVATION

19:58 - SHE MADE ABOUT COACH. SHORTLY

20:00 - BEFORE HER DEATH. AND OUR

20:02 - 3RD WIN TONIGHT. THE DEFENSE

20:04 - EXPERT DOCTOR BY HATE.

20:09 - THE DEFENDANT HERSELF.

20:11 - DOCTOR RAY SHAPER AND THE

20:13 - DEFENSE EXPERT DOCTOR RIGHT HEY

20:16 - ARE THE ONLY 2 DOCTORS THAT

20:18 - WOULD TESTIFY BEFORE YOU

20:19 - TONIGHT. AND

20:20 - DOCTOR HE WOULD LATER TELL YOU

20:21 - THAT DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S JUDGMENT

20:23 - AND ACTIONS. ON DECEMBER

20:25 - 16TH 2016. WE'RE FULLY WITHIN

20:28 - THE TREATMENT PRINCIPLES EXCEPT

20:29 - THE VIRUS POSSIBLE SEGMENT.

20:31 - THE MEDICAL PROFESSION.

20:40 - >>THE CIRCUMSTANCES SURROUNDING

20:41 - COACH MCADOO STACKED.

20:46 - WHAT

20:46 - THE CIRCUMSTANCES TELL YOU

20:48 - ABOUT HER DEATH.

20:50 - THAT CONCLUSION OF THIS CASE MY

20:51 - CO-COUNSEL ELIZABETH R B.

20:53 - WE'LL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO

20:54 - PRESENT A CLOSING ARGUMENT TO

20:56 - YOU AND SHE WOULD TELL YOU AS I

20:58 - WILL TELL YOU RIGHT NOW AT THE

20:59 - PROSECUTION'S CASE IS PLATE

21:02 - WITH A REASONABLE DOUBT AND

21:04 - DOCTOR SHAFER WAS UNFAIRLY

21:05 - TARGETED.

21:08 - WE ASK YOU TO FIND THIS

21:09 - POSITION THE USE OF MEDICAL

21:10 - TRAINING AND EXPERIENCE, NOT

21:13 - GUILTY OF THE CHARGE AGAINST

21:14 - HER. THANK YOU.

21:33 - >>THE PROSECUTION OR A PROCEED.

21:36 - A LOST CAUSE FRIEND KELSEY TOOK

21:38 - THE STAND.

21:50 - >>THE TESTIMONY YOU'RE ABOUT TO

21:52 - GIVE WILL BE FAITHFULLY IN

21:53 - TRUTHFULLY AND IN ACCORDANCE

21:55 - WITH THE RULES LOOK TRIAL

21:56 - COMPETITION.

22:12 - THEY PROCEED YOUR HONOR

22:13 - YOU MAKE. GOOD MORNING THIS

22:15 - KELSEY GOOD MORNING. HE PLEASE

22:17 - INTRODUCE YOURSELF TO THE

22:18 - MEMBERS OF THE JURY AND FRAN

22:20 - KELSEY I WAS THE NURSE

22:21 - PRACTITIONER PAIN AWAY, DOCTOR

22:23 - SHAPERS PAIN MANAGEMENT CLINIC.

22:25 - HOW DID YOU COME TO BEGIN

22:26 - WORKING AT PAIN AWAY. I'M A

22:28 - DOCTOR SHE FRONT I

22:30 - WAS FINISHING MY MASTER'S OF

22:31 - SCIENCE IN NURSING AND SHE WAS

22:32 - FINISHING

22:32 - HER RESIDENCY, SHE CAME TO ME

22:34 - WITH AN IDEA FOR A NEW TYPE OF

22:36 - CLINIC. ONE FOCUSED ON

22:37 - EASTERN MEDICINE. WHAT WAS THE

22:39 - BUSINESS LIKE WHEN YOU FIRST

22:41 - BEGAN WORKING THERE AT FIRST

22:43 - THINGS ARE QUIET. IT WAS JUST

22:44 - DOCTOR SHAFER AN EYE AN OLD CAR

22:46 - DEALERSHIP RIGHT OF WAS WE

22:48 - TRYING TO SAVE THE WORLD ONE

22:49 - PATIENT A TIME. WE

22:51 - BELIEVED THAT A HEALTHY MIND

22:53 - COULD HELP COST TO HEALTHY

22:55 - BODY. SO WE DIDN'T RUN IN THE

22:56 - URINE TESTS. DID

22:58 - THE BUSINESS EXPANDED ANY POINT

23:00 - WHILE YOU WORK THERE. YES,

23:02 - WE KEPT GETTING MORE PATIENTS

23:03 - WE DECIDED TO EXPAND TO A

23:05 - LARGER SPACE TO BETTER

23:06 - ACCOMMODATE OUR PATIENTS.

23:07 - HOW DID THAT EXPANSION

23:08 - GOMIS KELSEY THINGS IN THE NEW

23:10 - SPACE WENT WELL AT FIRST BUT

23:12 - THEN THE FAMOUS NASCAR DRIVER

23:15 - DANICA FILED A LAWSUIT AGAINST

23:17 - THE PRACTICE.

23:18 - AND SUPERSTORM SANDY ABSOLUTELY

23:21 - DEVASTATED PRACTICE. WHAT

23:24 - HAPPENED WAS PAIN AWAY AFTER

23:25 - THAT.

23:28 - DOCTOR SHAFER REALIZE THAT WE

23:30 - DIDN'T HAVE FLOOD INSURANCE SO

23:32 - SHE WAS FORCED TO DECLARE

23:33 - BANKRUPTCY IN CLOSE THE CLINIC.

23:35 - DID YOU EVER WORK WITH THE

23:35 - DEFENDANT AGAIN. YES, ABOUT

23:38 - HALF A YEAR AFTER PAIN AWAY

23:39 - CLOSED. DOCTOR SHAFER CALLED ME

23:41 - AND SAID THAT SHE WANTED TO

23:43 - OPEN PAIN AWAY AGAIN. IT

23:45 - COULDN'T BE LIKE IT WAS BEFORE.

23:47 - AND IT WASN'T. WE STARTED

23:49 - SEEING MORE PATIENTS FOR

23:50 - SHORTER TIMES. DOCTOR SHAFER

23:52 - STARTED PRESCRIBE THE MORE

23:53 - OPIOIDS AND OUR PATIENTS

23:55 - STARTED PAYING IN CASH. BUT WE

23:57 - STILL DIDN'T DO ANY URINE

23:58 - TESTING.

23:59 - THIS CALL SAID LIKE TO ASK YOU

24:01 - A FEW QUESTIONS RELATING TO

24:03 - GENERAL MEDICAL PRACTICE

24:04 - ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH THE

24:05 - PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING

24:07 - PROGRAM. YES, THE PRESCRIPTION

24:09 - DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM.

24:10 - FOR THE PMP IS A DATABASE

24:12 - WHICH ALLOWS DOCTORS TO SUE

24:14 - PRESCRIPTIONS THAT PATIENTS ARE

24:15 - WRONG. ALL RIGHT.

24:17 - NOW MISS KELSEY WHILE YOU WORK

24:19 - TO PAY NO WAY DID YOU HAVE

24:20 - OCCASION TO INTERACT WITH

24:21 - HADLEY MCADOO I DID HAVE THE

24:23 - MCCABE WERE COACHES MOST OF US

24:25 - IN YOUR CALDER CAME IN OF

24:27 - JANUARY OF 2014. SHE CLAIMS SHE

24:30 - WAS SUFFERING FROM CHRONIC

24:31 - PAIN. DOCTOR SHAFER VAN A

24:33 - SERIES OF C T SCANS AND X-RAYS

24:35 - BUT FOUND NO EVIDENCE OF MUSTER

24:36 - TENDON DAMAGE. SHE

24:38 - DETERMINED COACH TO BE

24:39 - SUFFERING FROM CHRONIC EYE.

24:41 - PHANTOM PAIN INTO KNOWLEDGE

24:43 - MUST KELSEY HOW DID THE

24:44 - DEFENDANT TREAT THIS PHANTOM

24:46 - PAIN. DOCTOR SHAFER VOTE CROAK

24:48 - COACH, A SCRIPT FOR HUNDREDS OF

24:50 - DOSES OF OXYCODONE AND.

24:53 - COACH WAS ALWAYS AROUND.

24:56 - EVEN SAW COACH GIVING

24:58 - DOCTOR SHAFER A LOT OF $100

25:00 - BILLS.

25:02 - MORE PREJUDICIAL THAN PROBATIVE

25:03 - THE SITUATION WHICH NURSE

25:04 - KELSEY IS

25:05 - LYING TO IS AN ALLEGED EVENT IN

25:07 - WHICH DOCTOR SHAFER AND COACH

25:08 - MCADOO ARE OUTSIDE OF THE PAIN

25:10 - OF THE CLINIC THERE FOR NOT

25:11 - REFERENCING.

25:12 - >>ANYTHING TO THE DAY IN

25:13 - QUESTION TO SOME

25:14 - DECEMBER 16. ALSO THIS IS AN

25:16 - ELECTION THAT NOBODY IS ABLE TO

25:18 - TESTIFY TO THE EXACT AMOUNT OF

25:19 - MONEY THAT WAS IN THIS A LOT OF

25:21 - CASH HAS ALSO MORE PREJUDICIAL

25:22 - BECAUSE IT IS IN FORCING A

25:24 - DIFFERENT IMAGE IN THE MINDS OF

25:25 - THE JURY SAYING THAT THIS WAS

25:26 - SOME OF THE LEGAL ACTION

25:27 - HAPPENING OUTSIDE OF PAIN WAY

25:29 - THEREFORE ITS MORE PREJUDICIAL

25:30 - AND IRRELEVANT. GOT TO FIND

25:32 - THEY MISS KELSEY IS NOT SHOWING

25:33 - ANY LEGAL CONCLUSION AS TO THE

25:35 - EXCHANGE OF THIS MONEY.

25:37 - >>IN ADDITION, THE PROBATIVE

25:38 - VALUE OF MISS KELSEY VISION OF

25:41 - THIS EXCHANGE

25:42 - SUBSTANTIALLY OUTWEIGHS ANY

25:43 - PREJUDICE MIGHT CAUSE THE JURY.

25:45 - ONE OF THE PROBLEMS THE

25:46 - COMMONWEALTH HAS TO PROVE TODAY

25:48 - IS AN ABSENCE OF GOOD FACE.

25:50 - AND THE INTERACTIONS, A DOCTOR

25:52 - HAS WITH THEIR PATIENTS WHILE

25:54 - TREATING THEM GOES DIRECTLY TO

25:56 - THE FACE OF THE DOCTOR DURING

25:57 - THAT TREATMENT ADDITIONALLY AS

25:59 - MISS KELSEY PREVIOUSLY

26:00 - TESTIFIED MORE AND MORE

26:01 - PATIENTS AT PAIN AWAY HAD BEGUN

26:03 - PAYING IN CASH AND THIS IS

26:05 - SIMPLY ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF THIS

26:07 - OCCURRING THEREFORE IT'S

26:08 - EXTREMELY RELEVANT TO DOCTOR

26:10 - SHAFER TREATMENT OF

26:11 - HAPPY MCADOO THERE ARE IF I MAY

26:13 - YET AGAIN THE PREJUDICIAL VALUE

26:14 - SUBSTANTIALLY ALWAYS THE

26:15 - PROBATIVE VALUE.

26:16 - >>SAYING THAT A DOCTOR AND THE

26:17 - DOCTOR'S PATIENTS ARE OUTSIDE

26:19 - THE FACILITY WHICH IS NOT AN

26:20 - HAPPENING IN THE DAY IN

26:21 - QUESTION DECEMBER 16TH, IT'S

26:23 - NOT IRRELEVANT TO

26:23 - THAT DAY. IT'S CHANGING WADS OF

26:26 - CASH IN WHICH NO ONE CAN

26:27 - TESTIFY TO NOT EVEN THERE'S

26:28 - KELSEY I CAN TELL YOU THE EXACT

26:29 - AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT WAS THERE

26:31 - FOR EXAMPLE IT COULD HAVE BEEN

26:32 - ONES. HUNDREDS FOR ALL WE KNOW,

26:34 - BUT THE FACT THAT NOBODY CAN

26:35 - TESTIFY TO THE

26:36 - EXACT AMOUNT AND IS INSET

26:37 - INSINUATING DIFFERENT IMAGES,

26:39 - THE MINDS OF THE JURY IS MORE

26:40 - PREJUDICIAL BETWEEN A DOCTOR

26:42 - AND THE DOCTOR'S PATIENTS

26:43 - OUTSIDE THE PACE STILL A T

26:44 - EXCHANGING MONEY. OUR THE

26:46 - AMOUNT OF MONEY IN THIS CASE IS

26:48 - NOT A QUESTION HERE IS THE

26:50 - ISSUE IS.

26:51 - >>WHETHER OR NOT DOCTOR SHAFER

26:52 - WAS INTERACTING WITH HER

26:53 - PATIENT DURING HER TREATMENT IN

26:55 - A WAY THAT CONSTITUTED GOOD

26:57 - STATES AND ANY INTERACTION

26:58 - BETWEEN THE DOCTOR AND PATIENT

27:00 - SPECIFICALLY RELATING TO

27:01 - MONETARY PAYMENTS GOES DIRECTLY

27:03 - TO THE FACE OF THE DOCTOR WHEN

27:05 - TREATING THE PATIENT. YEAH, I'M

27:07 - A DAD AGAIN THIS HAPPENED

27:08 - OUTSIDE OF THE CAMPUS OT, NOT

27:10 - ON THE DAY IN QUESTION

27:11 - DECEMBER 16TH, THEREFORE IT IS

27:13 - COMPLETELY AROUND THAT AND MORE

27:15 - PREJUDICIAL BECAUSE IT IS IN

27:16 - FORMING THE

27:16 - JURY THAT SOME LEGAL ACTION AND

27:18 - OR NOT APPROPRIATE ACTION THAT

27:20 - COULD HAPPEN INSIDE THE

27:21 - FACILITY WAS HAPPENING BEHIND

27:22 - US BEHIND THE CURTAINS.

27:25 - >>THING KEEPING ARGUMENT ON

27:26 - THAT I'M GOING A LOT OF

27:27 - QUESTIONS TO ANSWER THE

27:28 - QUESTION THIS OUT WOULD YOU

27:29 - LIKE ME TO RE ASKED THE

27:30 - QUESTION. YES, POLICE

27:32 - WHAT DID YOU OBSERVE ABOUT

27:33 - DOCTOR, SHE FIRST TREATMENT US

27:35 - HAVE BEEN MCADOO

27:36 - DOCTOR SHAFER WROTE COACH A

27:37 - SCRIPT FOR HUNDREDS OF DOSES OF

27:39 - OXYCODONE AND AFTER THAT IT WAS

27:42 - ALWAYS AROUND.

27:45 - I SAW COACH GIVING DOCTOR

27:46 - SHAFER A LOT OF $100 BILLS

27:49 - MISS KELSEY OVER THE COURSE OF

27:51 - COACH MACK AND HIS TREATMENT.

27:53 - WHAT DID YOU OBSERVE ABOUT

27:54 - DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S USE OF THE

27:55 - PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING

27:56 - PROGRAM DOCTOR SHAFER

27:59 - TO MY OBSERVATIONS HAD NOT

28:00 - CHECKED THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG

28:01 - MONITORING PROGRAM

28:02 - FOR COACH. I'D LIKE TO ASK YOU

28:04 - A FEW QUESTIONS ABOUT THE DAY

28:05 - OF COACH MCADOO STAFF DECEMBER

28:07 - 16TH, 2016.

28:09 - >>WHAT DO YOU REMEMBER ABOUT

28:10 - THAT DAY. JUST TERRIBLE.

28:13 - COACH CAME IN. SHE WAS SWEATING

28:15 - SHE WAS SHAKING AND YOU CAN

28:17 - MOVE YOUR LEFT ARM BECAUSE OF

28:18 - THE PAIN. I FELL OVER AND TAKE

28:20 - SHEET AND WAS IN THE PROCESS OF

28:22 - ASKING HER IF SHE SAW ANYTHING

28:23 - ABOUT CHECKS APD M P WHEN

28:26 - DOCTOR SHAFER CALLED COACH AND

28:27 - TOLD ME TAKE A BREAK IN ALL OF

28:29 - THE YEARS THAT I'VE BEEN

28:30 - WORKING FOR

28:30 - DOCTOR SHAFER SHE HAS NEVER

28:32 - TOLD ME TAKE A BREAK WHILE

28:33 - TREATING A PATIENT BEFORE.

28:35 - DID YOU TAKE THAT BREAK.

28:37 - HE DID AND DID YOU CHECK THE

28:39 - PDM PEOPLE FOR GOING ON THAT

28:40 - BREAK. I DIDN'T I WISH

28:43 - I HAD BUT HE DIDN'T

28:45 - WHY NOT BECAUSE I ASSUME THAT

28:47 - DOCTOR SHAFER WE DO THE RIGHT

28:48 - THING AND THE RESPONSIBLE THING

28:50 - AND CHECK THE PMP

28:52 - THIS KELSEY WHY DID YOU THINK

28:53 - THE CHECKING THE PD MP WAS THE

28:55 - RESPONSIBLE THING FOR DOCTOR

28:56 - SHAFER TO DO THIS COACH WAS AN

28:58 - OLDER PATIENT. SO THE RISK

29:00 - FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH HER AND

29:01 - BECAUSE CHECKING PDM PEAK ONLY

29:03 - TAKES SECONDS TO

29:05 - YOUR KNOWLEDGE HOW DID THE

29:06 - DEFENDANT TREAT COACH MCADOO ON

29:08 - THE DAY OF HER DEATH.

29:09 - DOCTOR SHAFER A KEY UP COACHES

29:11 - OR

29:11 - LOCALLY PRESCRIPTION AND GAVE

29:14 - FOR A SHOT OF HYDROMORPHONE

29:16 - WHICH IS THE STROKE STRONGEST

29:17 - DOSE IV NARCOTICS SHE IS

29:19 - EVER GIVEN TO ONE OF OUR

29:20 - PATIENTS AND WHAT WAS THE

29:22 - OUTCOME OF THAT TREATMENT COACH

29:23 - DIED. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS YOUR

29:25 - HONOR.

29:39 - THIS KELSEY I'D LIKE TO CLARIFY

29:41 - A FEW THINGS THE JURY ON

29:42 - DECEMBER 16TH 2016 IT WAS

29:44 - PERFECTLY LEGAL FOR

29:45 - DOCTOR SHAFER.

29:46 - >>TO PRESCRIBE OPIOID WITHOUT

29:48 - REFERRING TO THE PMP PRACTICE.

29:49 - IT WAS LEGAL MUCH.

29:51 - >>IN.

29:53 - AROUND 3 WEEKS WOULD NOT BE BUT

29:55 - IT'S STILL PERFECTLY. IT WAS

29:57 - LEGAL, BUT.

29:58 - THAT CHECKING THE PNP AS

30:00 - MANY TORY.

30:01 - >>WOULD BE LAW AND WE STILL SEE

30:03 - WAS ALSO A PERFECTLY LEGAL

30:04 - INJECTION DOSE SAID DOCTOR

30:05 - SHAFER AND MINISTER TO COACH

30:07 - HAVING MCADOO ON THAT DAY

30:08 - CORRECT LEGAL BUT ON THE HIGHER

30:10 - END OF THE FDA GOT NOW IT

30:12 - STRAIGHT DESCRIBE PAIN AS A

30:13 - FUNNY THING CRACKED.

30:15 - THAT'S TRUE, YOU SAY IT'S FUNNY

30:16 - BECAUSE SOMEONE CAN BE IN PAIN

30:17 - WITH NO ACTUAL INJURIES

30:19 - AND PATRICK. JUST YOU WAIT ANY

30:21 - PAIN CLINIC, CORRECT. I AM IN

30:23 - YES AS A NURSE PRACTITIONER.

30:25 - I AM A NURSE PRACTITIONER NOW

30:27 - YOU'D AGREE WITH ME THAT THERE

30:27 - ARE CERTAIN LIMITATIONS YOU

30:28 - HAVE TO TREATING A PATIENT PANE

30:30 - CRACKED THAT'S TRUE YOUR MONEY

30:32 - SHE'S IN PAIN IS DIFFICULT

30:34 - BECAUSE AS YOU SAID BEFORE ONE

30:37 - PERSON'S PAIN.

30:38 - BUT WE CAN'T REALLY MEASURE

30:39 - PAIN OBJECTIVE LEE YOU'RE

30:41 - UNABLE TO PRESCRIBE OPIOIDS TO

30:42 - A PATIENT BRINGING PAIN ISN'T

30:43 - THAT TRUE KNOW I LEAVE THAT TO

30:45 - THE DOCTOR RAY SHAFFER IS IN

30:46 - FACT A DOCTOR ISN'T SHE.

30:48 - YES SHOT OR A SCHAEFER'S ABLE

30:50 - TO PRESCRIBE OPIOIDS TO A

30:51 - PATIENT IMPORTING PAIN ISN'T

30:52 - THAT TRUE. YES, SHE IS SHAPERS

30:55 - ABLE TO DO SO BECAUSE SHE

30:56 - FURTHER EDUCATION MUST FIELDS

30:58 - OF STUDYING THOSE MEDICATIONS,

30:59 - BUT THE ABILITY TO DO THAT IS

31:01 - IN

31:01 - FACT TRUE AND IT'S TRUE THAT

31:03 - ISIS THE PREVIEW DOCTOR'S

31:05 - EDUCATION. NOW LIKE TO DISCUSS

31:06 - 24 TEAM AND COACH MAC TO CAME

31:08 - TO THE PAIN WITH CLINIC.

31:09 - SHE CAME BECAUSE OF A SHOOTING

31:10 - PAIN IN HER ARM IS IN FACT

31:11 - TRUE. SHE WAS IN

31:14 - TERRIBLE PAIN

31:15 - AND INITIALLY THERE C T'S AND

31:16 - LIES AND EVEN X REASON TO

31:18 - PINPOINT THE PRECISE LOCATION

31:20 - OF THE SPACE. YES AS WE DO WITH

31:22 - ALL OF OUR PATIENTS WHO COME IN

31:23 - WITH PAIN THAT THEY CAN

31:24 - IDENTIFY WE TRY AND FIND OUT

31:27 - WHAT THEY IDENTIFIED THE CAUSE

31:28 - OF THE PAIN WOULD NEW DEGREES

31:30 - AND THERE WAS NO MUSCULAR

31:31 - TENDON DAMAGE REAL ON ANY OF

31:32 - THOSE STANCE NOW SO IT IS

31:34 - TRUE THAT COACH MCADOO IN 2014

31:36 - COULD BE IN PAIN WITH NO ACTUAL

31:38 - INJURY CORRECT. SHE WAS

31:39 - SUFFERING FROM PHANTOM PAIN

31:41 - YES, LIKE TO DISCUSS 12/16/2016

31:43 - WITH YOU.

31:44 - COACH MATT WHO CALLED FIRST

31:46 - THING IN THE MORNING BECAUSE OF

31:47 - THIS CRIPPLING PAIN IS IN FACT

31:48 - TRUE SHE DID

31:49 - AND YOU REALLY SHOULD NOT HAVE

31:51 - FOSTERED IN A PHONE CALLS AND

31:52 - THAT RUSSIA DID SOME FLUSTERED

31:53 - BY USING PAIN. BUT

31:54 - YOU DIDN'T WANT TO IMMEDIATELY

31:55 - GO TO A SURGEON CARE DID YOU.

31:58 - NO I DID NOT EVEN TOLD THE

31:59 - COURT AMBULANCE FOR THIS

32:00 - CRIPPLING PAIN EITHER

32:01 - DID YOU. NO EXACT YOU'VE

32:03 - SCHEDULED HER AS A TACK ON

32:05 - PATIENT. ALL THE WAY AT THE END

32:07 - OF THE WORKDAY IS IN FACT TRUE.

32:09 - YES BECAUSE WE HAD A

32:10 - PARTICULARLY BUSY DAY. WE HAVE

32:11 - A LOT OF PATIENCE FOR PAIN

32:12 - CLINIC, SO ALL OF OUR PATIENTS

32:14 - ARE COMING TO US IN PAIN AND

32:16 - ALL OF THEM HAVE A GREAT NEED

32:16 - TO SEE DOCTOR SHAFER YOU AGREE

32:18 - THAT THAT THIS SITUATION WAS

32:20 - RATHER URGENT. YES, A LOT OF

32:22 - HER SITUATION IS URGENT BECAUSE

32:23 - WE'RE PAIN CLINIC AND WHEN

32:24 - COACH FINALLY CAME IN

32:26 - YOU NOTICE THAT SHE WAS

32:27 - SWEATING PAIN WASN'T SHE.

32:29 - SHE WAS SHE WAS SHAKING PAIN

32:31 - WAS IN SHAPE. SHE WAS IN FACT

32:32 - SHE COULDN'T MOVE HER ARM TO

32:34 - WIPE THE SWEAT OFF YOUR

32:35 - FOREHEAD ISN'T

32:36 - THAT TRUE. NOW SHE CANNOT AS A

32:38 - TERRIBLE AT THIS MOMENT YOU

32:40 - START ASKING HER WHAT

32:40 - MEDICATION SHE WAS ON A CRACKED

32:42 - I DID I WAS FEELING UNDER INTO

32:43 - SHE LIKE I DO WITH ALL MY

32:44 - PATIENTS AND YOU'RE READING

32:45 - THESE MEDICATIONS TOWN ISN'T

32:46 - THAT TRUE EILIS BUT COACH NEVER

32:48 - TOLD YOU SHE WAS ON XANAX

32:49 - DITCH. NO SHE'S NOT BUT SHE WAS

32:52 - ALSO IN A PRETTY BAD CONDITIONS

32:54 - SO SHE MAY NOT HAVE REMEMBERED

32:55 - AT THIS POINT DOCTOR SCHIEFFER

32:57 - TOOK HER PATIENTS ACTUALLY ROOM

32:58 - CRACKED AFTER ORDERING ME TO

33:00 - TAKE A BREAK.

33:01 - YES, AND YOU ARE NO LONGER

33:03 - PRESENT FOR THE SITUATION

33:04 - DOCTOR SCHIEFFER FACE IN THAT

33:05 - ROOM FOR YOU NO I WAS NOT

33:07 - DOCTOR SHAFER HAD ORDERED ME

33:09 - TAKE A BREAK. WHAT YOU DO KNOW

33:10 - IS THAT

33:11 - 20 MINUTES LATER. COACH MCADOO

33:13 - OF THAT VERY SAME DIDN'T SHE.

33:15 - SHE DID. SHE WAS NO LONGER

33:17 - SWEATING AND PAIN WASHING.

33:18 - I DON'T KNOW IF SHE WAS IN PAIN

33:19 - OR NOT SHE WAS NOT SWEATING TO

33:21 - MY OBSERVATIONS SHE WAS NO

33:22 - LONGER SHAKING WASHING. NOW, IN

33:24 - FACT SHE WALKED OUT OF THAT

33:25 - ROOM, SMILING BECAUSE SHE WAS

33:28 - PAYING TREAT ONE SUGARY SWEET.

33:30 - SHE WAS SMILING, YES. AND NOW

33:33 - ONE LAST QUESTION UNLIKE

33:35 - DOCTOR SHAFER YOU HAVE NEVER

33:37 - HAD TO MAKE THE DECISION

33:38 - WHETHER OR NOT TO

33:39 - PRESCRIBING OPIOID TO A

33:40 - PATIENT. ACCORDING IN CRIPPLING

33:42 - PAIN HAVE YOU KNOW BECAUSE I'M

33:44 - NOT A DOCTOR AND I LEAVE THOSE

33:45 - DECISIONS TO THE DOCTOR, NO

33:47 - FURTHER QUESTIONS YOUR HONOR.

34:03 - >>HE MAKES IT DOWN THINKING.

34:11 - I JUST ASK AT THIS TIME A

34:13 - CEILING COME ON NEWS BENEATH

34:14 - THE TIME HE WAS BE CHECK WITH

34:15 - EACH OTHER TO VERIFY.

34:22 - I WILL NOT BE ASKING AGAIN.

34:24 - SO JUST IF INTEREST TO US AND

34:26 - TOP OF THAT THANK YOU.

34:32 - >>BECAUSE MISTER J J T THAT'S

34:34 - THE STAND. THANK YOU.

34:46 - GOOD MORNING. MISTER T THE

34:47 - COULD YOU PLEASE INTRODUCE

34:48 - YOURSELF TO THE JURY.

34:49 - >>OF GT THE COMMERCIAL PER

34:51 - SALOON ENERGY AT FIRST WAS WE

34:53 - BANK.

34:53 - >>COULD YOU EXPLAIN YOUR JOB AT

34:55 - THE BANK.

34:56 - >>I'M ACTUALLY QUITE IMPORTANT

34:57 - YOU SEE I DECIDE WHO GETS MONEY

34:59 - AND WHO DOESN'T IT'S UP TO ME

35:00 - IF YOU CAN OPEN A BUSINESS OR

35:02 - BUY A HOUSE.

35:03 - >>CAN YOU EXPLAIN IT CAME TO

35:04 - KNOW THE DEFENDANT.

35:06 - SO FUNNY STORY YOU SEE BACK IN

35:08 - 2010 SHAPE. THAT'S WHAT I CALL

35:10 - HIM HER

35:11 - CAME TO ME FOR A $100,000 LOAN

35:14 - TO OPEN UP A PAIN CLINIC AND

35:15 - WAS WEAK. BUT

35:16 - ON PAPER THE BUSINESS PLAN WAS

35:18 - TRASH, I ME SHE WANTED TO OPEN

35:19 - UP SOME TOUCHY FEELY PAIN

35:21 - CLINIC OUT OF AN OLD CHEVY

35:22 - DEALERSHIP DID YOU GET FOR THE

35:24 - LOW. WELL, YOU KNOW THERE IS NO

35:26 - THIS BUT I SEE A TENNIS

35:28 - CHAMPION IN MAY YOU.

35:30 - BUT MY CAREER WAS CUT SHORT

35:31 - WHEN I GOT A BAD CASE OF TENNIS

35:33 - ELBOW. SO I TOLD SHAPE IF SHE

35:35 - COULD FIX MY TENNIS SO I GIVE

35:36 - HER THE LOVE AND IT WORKS SO I

35:38 - GAVE HER TWICE BUT YES, WHAT.

35:40 - >>CLOSE YOUR RELATIONSHIP LIKE

35:41 - WITH THE DEFENDANT AFTER THIS.

35:43 - >>WELL IT STARTED TO GROW I

35:45 - STARTED RECOMMENDING HER LEFT

35:46 - AND RIGHT AND WE BECAME PRETTY

35:48 - GOOD FRIENDS.

35:49 - >>FROM YOUR JOB AT THE BANK YOU

35:50 - HAVE A CHANCE TO PAIN WAY WAS

35:52 - DOING OVER TIME.

35:53 - >>CHET REALLY TOOK OFF. AND

35:56 - THEY EVEN HAVE TO MOVE INTO A

35:57 - BIGGER PLACE, ALTHOUGH SHE DID

35:59 - HAVE TO LEVERAGE HER HOME WITH

36:01 - A SECOND MORTGAGE AND OPEN A

36:03 - LARGE FROM EQUITY LINE OF

36:04 - CREDIT.

36:04 - >>FOSUN DEFENDANT LIKE AS HE

36:06 - WAS GROWING. AZA.

36:08 - >>BIG PLACE SHOES STRESSED OVER

36:10 - WOUND, HOW COULD YOU TELL THE

36:12 - SHOE STRESSED NEVER OUT.

36:14 - EARLIER ON THEIR FRIENDSHIP SHE

36:16 - HAD CONFIDED IN ME THAT SHE

36:18 - DIDN'T DRINK AND NOW SHE

36:19 - STARTED DRINKING.

36:23 - >>SHE FIRST

36:23 - PASSED DRINKING.

36:25 - >>YOUR HONOR NOT TO SAY THIS IS

36:26 - A BAD ACTOR CHARACTER EVIDENCE

36:27 - ANYWAY. WE'RE SIMPLY OUTLINING

36:30 - A CHANGE IN BEHAVIOR OF THE

36:31 - DEFENDANT WHICH

36:33 - GOING TO STRESS THAT SHE'S

36:34 - DOING AT THE TIME BECAUSE OF

36:35 - HER FINANCIAL PROBLEMS.

36:37 - >>IN THE PROSECUTION CANNOT FOR

36:38 - THE DOCTOR A SHEEP OR WAS UNDER

36:39 - THE INFLUENCE ON DECEMBER,

36:41 - 1620 16, THEREFORE BRING UP THE

36:43 - TESTIMONY ABOUT ALCOHOL IS MORE

36:44 - PRECIOUS PREJUDICIAL THAT IT IS

36:46 - PROBED IT.

36:46 - >>YOUR HONOR WE'RE NOT USING IT

36:48 - FOR FOR PENCE THE PURPOSES

36:49 - WE'RE NOT TRYING TO SAY THAT

36:50 - DOCTOR SCHIEFFER WAS

36:51 - INTOXICATED WHILE TREATING

36:52 - COACH MCADOO HOWEVER THIS

36:54 - CHANGE IN BEHAVIOR ISN'T

36:55 - BECAUSE OF THE STRESS WHICH

36:56 - COULD BE A MOTIVE FOR ACTING IN

36:57 - BAD FAITH

36:58 - AND THE ATTEMPTS TO GAIN MONEY

37:01 - WHILE

37:01 - TREATING PATIENTS.

37:02 - >>THERE I SEE A PROSECUTION IS

37:04 - TRYING TO PROVE THAT THIS

37:05 - CHANGE THIS CHANGE OF BEHAVIOR

37:06 - INCLUDED THE OUTCOME THAT'S

37:08 - WHAT I'M SAYING ITS MORE

37:09 - PREJUDICIAL THAN IT IS PROBED

37:10 - IT DRINKING NOW CAUSE AN

37:12 - INFLAMMATORY TERM IN THIS

37:13 - SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED IN COURT

37:14 - TODAY AND IS NOT RELEVANT TO

37:15 - DECEMBER 16TH 2016.

37:18 - >>I'M GOING TO SUSTAIN THE

37:20 - OBJECTION AS THE ALCOHOLICS

37:21 - HISTORY TESTIFY MUCH CHANGE

37:22 - IN BEHAVIOR.

37:23 - >>AND YET YOUR INTRO 06:11AM A

37:25 - DISTRICT THE TESTIMONY.

37:30 - TO PALEY FACING CHALLENGES

37:32 - OVER TIME. YEAH IN

37:35 - 2012 THAT ALL STARTED TO FALL

37:37 - APART. WHAT HAPPENED IN 2012.

37:39 - WELL THAT'S WHEN HURRICANE

37:39 - SANDY HIT IT, DAN THE STATED

37:41 - THE CLINIC SHE EVEN TOLD ME SHE

37:43 - DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT FLOOD

37:44 - INSURANCE AND NOW SHE WAS $3

37:46 - MILLION IN DEBT.

37:47 - >>AND DECLARED BANKRUPTCY.

37:49 - >>HOW DID THE DEFENDANT RESPOND

37:50 - TO THE BANKRUPTCY OF HER

37:51 - CLINIC.

37:52 - SEE THAT'S WHERE I SAW

37:54 - SOMETHING WEEK. I LOOKED INTO

37:56 - HER FINANCES STILL HER LINE

37:57 - MANAGER AND HER SPENDING HABITS

38:00 - HAD STAYED THE SAME FROM WHEN

38:01 - SHE WAS A SUCCESSFUL DOCTOR

38:03 - GETTING PATIENTS FROM AROUND

38:04 - THE COUNTRY. 2 WHEN SHE WAS

38:06 - BANKRUPT. NOW I'D LIKE TO

38:08 - DIRECT YOUR ATTENTION TO COACH

38:09 - MCADOO DID YOU KNOW HER.

38:13 - NEW COACH MCADOO HAVE

38:14 - EARNED IT. I RECOMMEND IT OR

38:16 - SHE CAN 2014. DO YOU HAVE ANY

38:19 - CONCERNS ABOUT HER BEING A

38:20 - PATIENT OF DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S.

38:23 - NOT AT FIRST, BUT.

38:26 - THE IN SHAPE GOT INTO A PRETTY

38:28 - BIG SITE AND SHE

38:30 - SAID THAT COULD MCADOO WAS A

38:32 - CASH FLOW. ONE OF HER OWN

38:34 - PATIENTS, A CASH FLOW.

38:36 - WHAT DID YOU DO AFTER DOCTOR

38:38 - SCHIEFFER CALLED COACH MCADOO A

38:39 - CASH FLOW

38:40 - OF COURSE I THOUGHT WHICH HAD

38:42 - TO KNOW THE US. I MEAN IT WAS

38:44 - INSANE. SO

38:46 - I CALLED HER UP AND I HEARD

38:48 - SOMETHING EVEN WORSE COACH TOLD

38:50 - ME THAT SHE GOT HERS AND I GET

38:53 - MINE. YOUR HONOR AND ARE

38:55 - YOU FROM FOR

38:56 - THE 3. THIS IS A STATEMENT

38:58 - AGAINST INTEREST WITH THE

38:59 - DECLARE IT WAS UNAVAILABLE TO

39:01 - DEATH.

39:01 - >>IN A STATEMENT AGAINST

39:02 - INTEREST HAS A TENDENCY TO

39:04 - EXPOSE COACH MCADOO TO COME A

39:06 - LIABILITY SOME SHE'S ADMITTING

39:07 - TO

39:07 - MISHANDLING OPIOIDS.

39:09 - >>I MEAN THIS IS NOT A

39:10 - STATEMENT AGAINST INTEREST HAS

39:11 - PUSHED BACK. HE SAID

39:12 - I GET MINE AND SHE GETS HERS

39:13 - AND IT'S FOR HER OWN INTERESTS.

39:15 - I FAIL TO SEE HOW IT IS AN

39:16 - EXCEPTION

39:17 - TO HEARSAY BECAUSE IT EXPOSES

39:19 - HER CALL HIM A LIABILITY SHE IS

39:21 - ADMITTING TO A CRIMINAL ACT IN

39:22 - THE STATEMENT IT IS A STATEMENT

39:23 - AGAINST INTEREST. RESPONDED

39:26 - TO IT I DON'T FEEL AS THOUGH IT

39:28 - HAS A CONNOTATION OF LEGAL

39:30 - RIGHT INSIDE THE EAGLE.

39:32 - TROUBLES FOR THE STATEMENT

39:33 - SAYING THAT SHE IS SHE GETS HER

39:35 - OPIOIDS AND I DON'T KNOW

39:36 - WHETHER STUDENTS MOST

39:37 - IN NEED THAT DEAL WAS HE STILL

39:38 - HAS A STATEMENT AGAINST

39:39 - INTEREST.

39:41 - >>I'M GOING TO DIE REALLY OF

39:43 - ACTION ON STATEMENT YESTERDAY

39:45 - TO START WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO

39:46 - ASK CHECKED.

39:47 - >>WHAT DID YOU DO AFTER DOCTOR

39:49 - SHAFER CALLED COULD NOT DO A

39:50 - CASH FLOW.

39:51 - >>THE SENATE CALLED HER OUT

39:53 - THAN I HEARD SOMETHING WORRYING

39:54 - THAT SHE GETS HERS AND I GET

39:57 - MINE.

39:58 - >>DID YOU EVER SEE COACH MCADOO

40:00 - IN PERSON AFTER THE DAY

40:01 - RECOMMENDED HER DOCTOR SHAFER.

40:05 - >>2015 ROTARY CLUB ANNUAL GALA

40:08 - WITH SHAPED.

40:09 - >>WELL AS COACH BACK IN HIS

40:10 - BEHAVIOR LIKE OUT BACK OUT.

40:13 - >>COCO HAPPENED YEARS BEFORE

40:15 - COACH MACK OF HIS DEATH.

40:16 - YOUR HONOR WHEN THEY WITNESS

40:17 - YOU GOT TO CONTINUE HERE WE GO

40:19 - TO TESTIFY ABOUT HOW COACH

40:20 - MCADOO WAS VISIBLY ABOUT STATE.

40:22 - GIVEN THE DOCTOR SCHIEFFER WAS

40:23 - PRESENT AT

40:24 - THIS GALA SHOW US THAT YOU HAVE

40:26 - OBSERVED THIS TEA AND THEN

40:27 - CONTINUE TO A COACH MCADOO

40:29 - LATER KNOWING HER DECLINING

40:31 - MENTAL HEALTH. THIS GOES

40:32 - DIRECTLY TO THAT FAITH WHICH IS

40:34 - ONE OF THE PROBLEMS WE HAVE TO

40:35 - PROVE AND STATE'S CASE.

40:36 - >>IT BAD FAITH ONLY HAPPENED ON

40:38 - DECEMBER, 1620

40:39 - 16 PROSECUTIONS BURDEN. IT'S

40:41 - ONLY FOR THAT SPECIFIC DAY THE

40:43 - ROAD TO COME GALA HAPPENED

40:44 - YEARS BEFORE PUSH BACK OF HIS

40:46 - DEATH. IT WAS DURING THE

40:46 - BEGINNING OF HER TREATMENT WITH

40:48 - SCHIEFFER SO I FAIL TO SEE HOW

40:49 - ISRAEL IN COURT TONIGHT.

40:51 - IF I MAY YOUR HONOR THE SENSES.

40:53 - CLAIMING THAT DOCTOR SHE FIRST

40:55 - KNOWLEDGE ABOUT COACH NOT TO

40:56 - DO.

40:56 - >>URSULA COMING INTO THE INTAKE

40:58 - SHEET FROM THE WORD OF THE

40:59 - PATIENT HERSELF. HOWEVER, THIS

41:01 - GOES TO SHOW THAT DOCTOR SHE

41:02 - FOR HAD KNOWLEDGE ABOUT COACHES

41:04 - CONDITION. THESE OFFICE GALA

41:06 - WHICH WOULD GO TO THE KNOWLEDGE

41:07 - THAT DOCTOR SHE WAS USING ONE

41:08 - TREATING COACH MCADOO ALL THAT

41:10 - IN QUESTION AND HOW

41:11 - HOW LINE.

41:12 - >>HOW ON THE WAS AT THE GALA

41:14 - PRIOR TO THE DATE OF DEATH

41:15 - ABOUT A YEAR.

41:19 - NO YOUR EYES ON

41:20 - THAT ACTION. I'M GOING

41:22 - ALLOW THE A LOT OF THE

41:24 - QUESTIONS THAT'S 9 YESTERDAY.

41:25 - OVERRULED YES, SIR. WELL, AS

41:28 - COACHES BEHAVIOR LIKE AT THE

41:29 - SCALA.

41:31 - >>SHE CAME IN UNANNOUNCED

41:34 - AND UNINVITED.

41:35 - >>SET THE SPEAKER'S CHAIR

41:38 - AND STARTED PLAYING WITH THE

41:39 - CUPS AND FORKS LIKE THEY WERE

41:40 - SILENT PHONES. SIDE LOVE

41:43 - SO THIS. I WAS HORRIFIED AND OF

41:46 - COURSE IS CONCERN FOR COACH,

41:48 - I MEAN THIS JUST WASN'T LIKE.

41:50 - DID YOU DO ANYTHING ABOUT HIS

41:51 - CONCERNS. YEAH RIGHT HALL

41:54 - I SENT SHAPE THE MESSAGE AND A

41:56 - STERN WARNING HER ABOUT MY

41:57 - CONCERNS AND.

42:00 - DECLINING SEA BUT I GOT NO

42:02 - RESPONSE, NOT THANK YOU YOUR

42:05 - HONOR, NO FURTHER QUESTIONS.

42:11 - PRICES EMISSION YES, YOUR

42:12 - HONOR.

42:17 - GOOD AFTERNOON. MISTER T TO

42:18 - MISS CAN ASK A FEW QUESTIONS.

42:20 - YOU KNOW A PHYSICIAN I AM.

42:22 - AND AS LITTLE MANAGER

42:24 - NEVER HAD TO MAKE THE DECISION

42:25 - WHETHER TO PRESCRIBE OPIOIDS TO

42:27 - A PATIENT POINT PAIN ACTUALLY

42:29 - THAT'S NOT TO SAY THAT YOU

42:30 - YOURSELF HAVE EXPERIENCE IN

42:31 - PAIN. IT'S NOT RIGHT. AS I

42:34 - SAID EARLIER SHERIFF JIM

42:36 - ANTENNA SO IN FACT THAT SOMEONE

42:38 - HAS EXPERIENCED PAIN. IT CAN

42:39 - BE QUITE CRIPPLING CANTON YET

42:42 - THEY CAN THAT MISTER T BUT YOU

42:44 - CAN TYPE ON A KEYBOARD WITHOUT

42:47 - EXPERIENCING EXTREME PAIN NOW

42:48 - IS NOT RIGHT YET SOME POINTING

42:50 - ARE REAL THAT SO YOU SOUGHT

42:51 - TREATMENT FROM DOCTOR A SHAPER

42:53 - CORRECT YET AND WHEN YOU ASKED

42:55 - HER TO HEAL YOUR PAIN. SHE DID

42:57 - SO CORRECT YET WITH

42:59 - SOME ACUPUNCTURE AND SOME

43:01 - WEIRD OINTMENTS I DON'T KNOW

43:03 - EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED BUT IT

43:04 - WAS GONE WITHIN A DAY OR 2 FOR

43:06 - THE FIRST TIME IN A DECADE.

43:08 - BECAUSE OF DOCTOR A SHAPER HE

43:10 - FINALLY FELT SOME RELIEF

43:12 - ACUPUNCTURE FEEL IT. AND THE

43:14 - TEAM I WANT TO MOVE TO EARLY

43:16 - 2014. IT WAS ON THE BUTTON TO

43:18 - PUSH BACK INTO THE MARKET

43:19 - CORRECT.

43:21 - AND HE MADE SOME PERSONAL

43:22 - OBSERVATIONS ABOUT HER CRACKED

43:24 - YEAH, I DID SHE SEEM TO AWFUL

43:27 - I MEAN SHE SEEMS SAD AND

43:29 - DESPERATE MISTER T THAT YOU

43:31 - THOUGHT COACH MCADOO LOOKED

43:33 - DEPRESSED THEN YOU

43:35 - YET IT WAS AWFUL

43:37 - TO SEE THE AND I SAW THE CHIEFS

43:39 - TREATMENT WAS DOING NOTHING FOR

43:41 - MISTER TENET'S FOR WORSE THIS

43:43 - IS BEFORE A COURT ACTUALLY SAW

43:44 - DOCTOR SHAFER CRACKED.

43:46 - AND THAT IS HER CHOICE IN A

43:47 - MARKET WHICH ONE ARE YOU

43:48 - EXPLAIN THE FIRST TIME IN 2014

43:50 - MISTER TITO FOR CERTAIN MANAGER

43:51 - AND SHE WAS DEPRESSED THEN

43:53 - CRACKED.

43:55 - IN FACT COACH MATTHEW TOLD YOU

43:56 - THEN THAT SHE WAS IN TON THE

44:00 - PAIN IS NOT RIGHT.

44:02 - THE END AND THAT'S WHY

44:03 - RECOMMENDED YOU TO CHANGE I

44:05 - THOUGHT THAT SHE WOULD GET SOME

44:06 - ACUPUNCTURE TREATMENTS LIKE I

44:08 - DID.

44:09 - >>AND END UP FEELING BETTER

44:10 - THAN EVER.

44:11 - >>THE MATTER TO YOU BUT I WANT

44:12 - TO MOVE TO THE SUMMER OF 2016 6

44:15 - MONTHS BEFORE COACHES DEATH.

44:17 - ONCE AGAIN, BUT IN THE COACH

44:18 - CORRECT. YES AND ONCE AGAIN

44:20 - MADE TO OBSERVATIONS ABOUT HER

44:21 - RIGHT. YEAH THAT'S WHAT I WAS

44:23 - TALKING ABOUT BEFORE

44:24 - SHE LOOKS MORE DEPRESSED THAN

44:26 - EVER SHE WAS.

44:28 - SHE LOOKED COMPLETELY DESTROYED

44:31 - AS SHE WAS ASKED TO USE LEE OR

44:32 - ANXIETY MEDS. MISTER TAYLOR

44:35 - 2 YEARS LATER. YOU STILL

44:37 - THOUGHT SHE LOOKED TERRIBLE IS

44:39 - NOT RIGHT. YES, SO MUCH WORSE

44:40 - THAN THE 4 OF US.

44:46 - COACH MCADOO

44:46 - TOLD YOU. SHE WAS SUFFERING

44:48 - FROM DEPRESSION IS NOT RIGHT.

44:52 - THIS TIME COACH TOLD YOU.

44:54 - SHE WAS SUFFERING FROM ANXIETY

44:56 - IS NOT RIGHT. YEAH AND THEN SHE

44:57 - ASKED ME TO HELP HER FEEL

44:59 - ANXIETY MINUTES AND YOU TOLD US

45:00 - SHE WAS SUFFERING FROM ALL THIS

45:02 - ON TOP OF HER PAIN. THAT'S NOT

45:04 - RIGHT. IT'S PEOPLE. YEAH, I

45:06 - CAN'T I COULDN'T BELIEVE IT.

45:08 - EVEN WITH ALL THAT REMAINED

45:09 - CHASE HAD DONE NOTHING

45:11 - AND THE CITY THAT WAS 6 MONTHS

45:12 - FOR COACHES OVERDOSE THAT SHE

45:13 - TOLD YOU SHE WAS DEPRESSED

45:14 - CORRECT. YET AND YOU SAID HE

45:16 - SAT FACE OF MESSAGE DOCTOR A

45:18 - SHAPER CORRECT. YES, THE SENATE

45:19 - TO AN AD SERVICE ACCOUNT.

45:21 - IT'S

45:21 - NOT RIGHT. I TRIED CALLING HER

45:23 - AND TEXTING YOUR BEFORE AND I

45:25 - GOT NO RESPONSE OF THE CITY

45:26 - THAT DIDN'T LAST RESORT.

45:28 - >>YOU HAVE NO WAY OF KNOWING

45:30 - THAT MY CLIENT EVEN SAW THIS

45:31 - MESSAGE. IT'S NOT RIGHT.

45:33 - I HAD

45:34 - CENTER.

45:35 - >>MESSAGES BEFORE I GOT NO

45:37 - RESPONSE I SHOULD TRY TO

45:38 - REDIRECT IT BACK TO MY QUESTION

45:39 - YOU HAVE NO IDEA.

45:41 - >>IF SHE FIRST SAW THE MESSAGE

45:43 - IS NOT CORRECT.

45:48 - YOU BELIEVE THAT

45:49 - SCHAEFER AS WELL MEANING IS NOT

45:52 - RIGHT.

45:54 - TO BE INNING YET TO SAY YOU'RE

45:56 - SWORN AFFIDAVIT, A DOCTOR

45:57 - SHAFER IS WELL-MEANING RIGHT.

46:02 - THANK YOU DONNA FOR THE

46:03 - QUESTION. YOU CAN'T.

46:39 - THE PROSECUTION'S NEXT WITNESS.

46:42 - WELL LET'S CALL IT BROKE OPEN

46:44 - TO STAND. TAKE IT.

47:00 - >>GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER COUPLE

47:01 - MARRIED A SAY AFTERNOON.

47:03 - HE PLEASE INTRODUCE YOURSELF TO

47:05 - THE JURY.

47:05 - BUT IN THIS WORLD CUP AND THE

47:07 - SPECIAL AGENT WITH THE DRUG

47:08 - ENFORCEMENT ADMINISTRATION AND

47:10 - CAN YOU TELL THE JURY THAT

47:11 - ABOUT YOUR EDUCATIONAL

47:12 - BACKGROUND CERTAINLY. I

47:14 - RECEIVED MY BACHELOR'S IN

47:15 - CRIMINAL JUSTICE FROM THE

47:16 - UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT

47:17 - CHICAGO. AND THEN I RECEIVED MY

47:19 - MASTER'S IN PUBLIC HEALTH

47:20 - UNIVERSITY OF PHOENIX

47:21 - THIS WAS NO SMALL FEAT COME

47:23 - FROM PUBLIC HOUSING IN THE

47:24 - SOUTH SIDE AND WHAT WORK

47:25 - EXPERIENCE YET. WELL BELIEVE IT

47:27 - OR NOT AFTER I GRADUATED

47:28 - ACTUALLY WORKS TO CHICAGO PD A

47:30 - COUPLE YEARS. A COUPLE MORE IN

47:32 - MAJOR CRIMES AFTER THAT IT WAS

47:33 - NOTICED BY THE D E A

47:35 - THEY ASKED JUST THAT JOINT TASK

47:37 - FORCE INVESTIGATING THE ROBERT

47:38 - TAYLOR HOMES THAT'S PUBLIC

47:39 - HOUSING OVERRUN WITH DRUGS

47:41 - AND GANGS ANYWAY HAVE A STRESS

47:43 - TEST WILL NOT ACTUALLY WAS A

47:45 - FURTHER PROMOTED TO JEFFERSON

47:46 - INVESTIGATOR. WHAT A WHAT IS

47:48 - DRUG

47:48 - DIVERSION EXACTLY. WELL, IT'S

47:51 - ACTUALLY A DIVERSION

47:51 - INVESTIGATORS JOB TO STOP LEGAL

47:54 - DRUGS BEING USED IN A WAY OTHER

47:56 - THAN HOW THEY WERE PRESCRIBED

47:57 - TO DO THIS DIVERSION.

47:58 - INVESTIGATORS

47:59 - RELY ON HISTORICAL DATA

48:01 - STATISTICAL ANALYSIS. IT'S ALL

48:02 - ABOUT THE NUMBERS YOU SEE

48:03 - DIVERSION INVESTIGATION.

48:05 - THERE IS NO SMOKING GUN.

48:07 - I DON'T AT THIS OF COFFEE AGENT

48:09 - COPELAND IS AN EXPERT IN

48:10 - NARCOTICS INVESTIGATION WITH A

48:11 - SPECIALTY IN DRUG DIVERSION.

48:14 - >>YOU'RE RIGHT TO HAVE AN

48:15 - OBJECTION TO THE SPECIALTY IN

48:16 - DRUG DIVERSION. I HAVE NO

48:18 - OBJECTION TO THE WITNESSES

48:19 - QUALIFICATIONS AS A DIVERSION

48:21 - INVESTIGATOR I HAVE TO HAVE AN

48:22 - OBJECTION TO THE RELEVANCE OF

48:23 - THE DIVERSION TESTIMONY IN THIS

48:25 - CASE. THE CHARGE IS ABOUT

48:27 - WHETHER OR NOT DOCTOR SHAFER

48:28 - ACTING IN GOOD FAITH OR IN

48:29 - ACCORDANCE WITH A RESPONSIBLE

48:30 - SEGMENT OF THE MEDICAL

48:31 - PROFESSION ON 12/16/2016 AS

48:34 - OPPOSING COUNSEL TO STATE A

48:35 - DRUG DIVERSION IS ABOUT

48:37 - YOU ABOUT ILLEGAL DRUGS BEING

48:39 - USED FOR PURPOSES OTHER THAN

48:40 - WHICH THERE PRESCRIBE THAT IS

48:41 - NOT THE CHARGE IN THIS CASE AND

48:43 - THAT IS NOT THE PROSECUTION'S

48:44 - BURDEN TO PROVE.

48:45 - >>I YOUR HONOR IF I MAY BE

48:47 - HEARD THE DRUG DIVERSION AS

48:48 - WELL AS THE GENERAL PATTERN OF

48:50 - THE PAIN AWAY CLINIC AND A

48:51 - FAITH AND IN WHICH THE DOCTOR

48:53 - SHAFER ACTED THROUGHOUT

48:55 - HIS TREATMENT, NOT ONLY COACH

48:56 - HAVING MCCABE BUT ALSO ALL THE

48:57 - OTHER PATIENTS

48:58 - GO DIRECTLY AND ARE HIGHLY

49:00 - RELEVANT TO THE TREATMENT HE

49:01 - ADMINISTERED ON THE DAY IN

49:02 - QUESTION.

49:04 - >>THEIR MARRIAGE SPAWN IT'S THE

49:05 - ONLY DEFINITION THAT OPPOSING

49:07 - COUNSEL IS PROVIDED FOR DRUG

49:08 - DIVERSION IS LEGAL DRUGS BEING

49:09 - USED FOR PURPOSES OTHER THAN

49:10 - WHICH THERE PRESCRIBE WHICH IS

49:11 - NOT THE QUESTION

49:12 - AHEAD TODAY IF OPPOSING COUNSEL

49:14 - WOULD LIKE TO SAY THAT INVOLVES

49:15 - ALL THE DIFFERENT SCENARIOS

49:16 - SURROUNDING DOCTOR SHIPPERS

49:17 - CLINTON ASKED THAT THEY LAY

49:18 - THAT FOUNDATION BEFORE HE BEAT

49:20 - TEAM. AN EXPERT IN THIS FIELD.

49:26 - >>THEY USE A LEGALLY PRESCRIBE

49:28 - DRUGS AND ILLEGAL OR IMMORAL

49:30 - FACTION IS HIGHLY RELEVANT TO

49:32 - THE TREATMENT THE COACH MCADOO

49:34 - RECEIVED NOT ONLY ON DECEMBER

49:35 - 16TH BUT ALSO THROUGHOUT AGAIN

49:37 - HER WHOLE 10 YEAR THAT PANEL.

49:40 - >>SO I'M CLEAR THE OBJECTION IS

49:41 - NOT THAT AS AN EXPERT JUST INTO

49:44 - SPECIALTY AS A NARCOTICS

49:45 - DIVERSION. YES, EUROPE.

49:51 - AND WAYNE TO CONDITIONALLY

49:53 - SUSTAIN THAT EJECTION AND ALLOW

49:55 - COUNCIL TO MORAL ISLAND.

49:59 - THERE'S NOT JACKSON TO THIS ONE

50:01 - IS BEING POP AS AN EXPERT

50:02 - GENERALLY. IN TERMS OF THE

50:05 - NARCOTICS DIVERSION THING I

50:06 - THINK THAT'S MORE FOUNDATION

50:07 - WOULD BE NECESSARY. IT'S AN

50:09 - ISSUE THAT WILL ALLOW FOR

50:10 - PUSHING ON THAT.

50:14 - >>DID DRUG DIVERSION PERTAIN TO

50:16 - A PAIN AWAY NOT ONLY.

50:19 - RELEVANT TO COACH KELLY MACK

50:20 - ABUSE TREATMENT, BUT ALSO

50:21 - THROUGHOUT.

50:24 - I DID NOT IMPLY AN ANSWER IS AN

50:25 - OPEN ENDED QUESTION.

50:29 - >>SENIOR OVERRULED AN OBJECTION

50:31 - YOU CAN ASK A QUESTION. YES,

50:32 - SIR.

50:34 - >>AGAIN AGENT COPELAND DOES

50:35 - DRUG DIVERSION PERTAIN TO

50:37 - DOCTOR SHAFER STREAMING OF NOT

50:38 - ONLY COACH ALLEY MCADOO BALL.

50:40 - SO ALL HER PATIENTS UP

50:41 - INTO IT.

50:42 - >>IT MOST CERTAINLY DOES SHE

50:43 - SEE A DRUG DIVERSION TALKS

50:45 - ABOUT THE GOOD FAITH OF THE

50:46 - DOCTOR OVER THE COURSE OF AN

50:47 - ENTIRE TREATMENT AND TREATMENT

50:49 - OF MULTIPLE INDIVIDUALS

50:51 - WHETHER OR NOT DOCTORS ENGAGING

50:52 - IN DRUG DIVERSION GOES DIRECTLY

50:54 - TO HOW THEY WOULD BEHAVE IN

50:56 - PARTICULAR IT WITH THE PATIENT

50:58 - AND TODAY. YOU'RE AT THIS OF TO

51:00 - COLON IS NOT AN EXPERT IN

51:02 - NARCOTICS INVESTIGATION AS I

51:04 - BELIEVE HE HAS ALREADY

51:04 - QUALIFIED BUT ALSO DRUG

51:05 - DIVERSION.

51:06 - >>NO OBJECTION. HE'S SO FAR

51:09 - THANK YOU TO BEGIN. IF YOU

51:10 - COMPLETED YOUR VIEW ALL

51:11 - RELEVANT INFORMATION IN TODAY'S

51:13 - CASE I DID AND ARE THESE THE

51:14 - DOCUMENTS MATERIALS YOU

51:15 - NORMALLY ARE VIEW WHEN A FARM

51:17 - IN YOUR EXPERT OPINIONS

51:18 - THEY ARE YOUR HONOR I'D I HAVE

51:20 - EXHIBIT ONE COMMISSION APPROACH

51:21 - THOSE ACCOUNTS ON THE WITNESS,

51:23 - YOU MAKE.

51:33 - ASIAN COPELAND NOW WHAT IS THIS

51:35 - DOCUMENT EXACTLY.

51:36 - >>THIS IS THE HISTORIC A LIST

51:38 - OF PRESCRIPTION CHART THAT

51:39 - COMPARES THE DATA PAIN WAYS

51:40 - PRESCRIPTION RATES DOSAGE

51:42 - AVERAGE ENEMY WITH THAT OF THE

51:43 - NATIONAL AVERAGE IS AND HOW DID

51:45 - YOU OBTAIN

51:45 - THIS DOCUMENT. THIS WAS

51:46 - OBTAINED BY A LAWFUL

51:48 - INVESTIGATION OF THE PAIN AWAY

51:49 - CLINIC, IT IS AN OFFICIAL PAIN

51:50 - AWAY CAPS DOCUMENT AND IS IT A

51:52 - FAIR AND ACCURATE COPY.

51:55 - AND AT THIS TIME OF 10 TO 2 TO

51:56 - ONE AND ADDITIVE TO PUBLISH THE

51:58 - ANY OBJECTION.

51:59 - >>YOU'RE RIGHT TO HAVE AN

52:00 - OBJECTION LONG AWARE OF THE

52:01 - AUTHENTICITY OF THIS DOCUMENT

52:03 - AND THE STIPULATIONS I BELIEVE

52:04 - THAT ANY OF THE YEARS ON THIS

52:06 - DOCUMENT THAT DO NOT INCLUDE

52:07 - THE YEARS THAT COACH HAVING

52:09 - MCADOO WAS BEING TREATED AT

52:10 - DOCTOR SHE WAS CLINIC ARE

52:12 - IRRELEVANT IN THIS CASE.

52:13 - FOR INSTANCE. COACH MAGGIE

52:15 - DIDN'T START RECEIVING

52:16 - TREATMENT OF PAIN AWAY UNTIL

52:18 - 2014. AND SO ANY YEARS BEFORE

52:20 - THAT WOULD HAVE CLEARLY NOTHING

52:21 - TO DO WITH THE CASE AHEAD TODAY

52:22 - WHETHER SHE ACTED IN GOOD FAITH

52:24 - WHEN TREATING COACH

52:24 - MACK IV.

52:25 - >>YOUR HONOR FROM IT DOESN'T

52:27 - COUNT OF MAKING A GENERAL

52:28 - RELEVANCE ARGUMENT I WOULD LIKE

52:29 - TO FIRST STATE THAT THE BAR FOR

52:31 - RELEVANCE IS INCREDIBLY LOW

52:32 - ANYTHING THAT WILL EITHER MAKE

52:33 - A FACT MORE OR LESS LIKELY IS

52:35 - CONSIDERED RELEVANT IN THE

52:36 - COURT OF LAW FOR THE MARK AND

52:37 - LIKELY

52:38 - PREVIOUSLY ESTABLISHED WE'RE

52:39 - USING THIS TO SHOW THE PATTERN

52:41 - AN INCREASE IN OPIOID

52:42 - PRESCRIPTIONS OF DOCTOR PHIL

52:44 - SHAFER WHICH WOULD GO DIRECTLY

52:46 - TO HOW HE IS TREATING COACH

52:48 - HADLEY MCADOO ON THE DAY SHE

52:49 - DIED. AND THEY RESPOND.

52:51 - THIS IS NOT JUST A GENERAL

52:53 - RELEVANCE OBJECTION I

52:54 - UNDERSTAND THAT THIS COULD

52:55 - ENCOMPASS MORE THAN JUST ONE

52:56 - DAY.

52:57 - >>ALLOW EVIDENCE IN THAT

52:58 - ENCOMPASSES TREATMENT OUTSIDE

52:59 - OF COACH HAD THE MCADOO

53:01 - STREAMING UP INTO IT WOULD BE

53:02 - COMPLETELY IRRELEVANT BECAUSE

53:03 - COAT COACH MAGGIE WASN'T EVEN A

53:05 - PATIENT OF PAIN AWAY AT THE

53:06 - TIME AND THAT IS WHAT THIS CASE

53:08 - IS ABOUT IT'S ABOUT WHETHER

53:09 - DUCHSCHERER ACTED IN GOOD FAITH

53:11 - WHEN TREATING COACH MCADOO EVEN

53:12 - IF IT INVOLVES MORE TIME THE

53:14 - JUSTICE CENTER 16TH.

53:17 - >>YOUR HONOR IF I MAY I'D LIKE

53:18 - TO READ IN RULE FOR A ONE THE

53:19 - TESTER RELEVANT EVIDENCE

53:21 - EVIDENCE IS CONSIDERED RELEVANT

53:22 - IF IT HAS ANY TENDENCY TO MAKE

53:24 - A FACT MORE OR LESS PROBABLE

53:26 - THAT IT WOULD BE WITHOUT THE

53:27 - EVIDENCE AND THE FACT IS OF

53:29 - CONSEQUENCE IN DETERMINING THE

53:30 - ACTION. DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S

53:32 - TREATMENT BEFORE AND AFTER SHE

53:34 - BEGAN PRESCRIBING MORE AND MORE

53:35 - OPIOIDS GOES DIRECTLY TO BOTH

53:37 - THE PRACTICE. AGAIN OF IN HER

53:40 - TREATMENT COACH PAT MCADOO AND

53:42 - THE TREATMENT OF ALL HER

53:43 - PATIENTS RIGHT. MARY SPOT, YOU

53:45 - MAKE.

53:45 - >>THAT EVIDENCE DOES NOT MAKE

53:47 - AFFECTING THIS CASE MORE OR

53:48 - LESS LIKELY UNDERSTAND WILL 4.1

53:50 - THAT IS IF IT PERTAINS TO THE

53:52 - CASE A HAND IF IT DOES NOT

53:53 - INVOLVE THE CHARGING QUESTION.

53:54 - IT CANNOT BE RELEVANT TO THE

53:55 - KIDS THIS IS THIS WILL NOT MAKE

53:57 - A FACT IN THE CASE ANYMORE

53:58 - LESS LIKELY. IT IS CLEARLY JUST

54:00 - MORE PREJUDICIAL PROTO TO USE

54:02 - EVIDENCE FROM THE FOREHAND.

54:04 - IN IN DETERMINING DOCTOR

54:05 - SHIPMAN'S PRACTICE.

54:08 - >>I'M GOING TO OVERRULE

54:09 - THE OBJECTION A LOT OF THESE IT

54:10 - SHOULD AND NEEDED AND PUBLISH

54:13 - THE JURY, YOUR ARGUMENTS.

54:16 - I THINK ANY FURTHER DID NOT

54:17 - CROSS EXAMINATION IF HE SHE

54:18 - SEES AS USUAL. THANK YOU

54:20 - PERMISSION PUBLISHER YOU MAKE.

54:24 - >>AGING COPELAND'S

54:25 - IN PLAIN LANGUAGE WHAT JUMPS

54:26 - OUT AT YOU DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S

54:28 - PRESCRIPTION RATES ON

54:29 - DOCUMENTS.

54:32 - CAN YOU GIVE A MOMENT THE

54:33 - JURY TO SEE THIS PERSON COMPANY

54:35 - CAN BE TRUSTED.

54:40 - ALL RIGHT I CAN SUMMARIZE THIS

54:42 - DOCUMENT FOR YOU A LOT JUMPS

54:43 - OUT BUT IF YOU LOOK IN THE 4TH

54:45 - COLUMN PAYNE WAYS PRESCRIBING

54:47 - RATE PER 100 PATIENTS. IN

54:50 - 2016 THAT PRESCRIBING RATE HAS

54:52 - HIT 84.3%

54:55 - THAT MEANS THAT MORE THAN 8 OUT

54:56 - OF EVERY 10 PATIENTS TO WALK

54:57 - THROUGH THE DOORS OF PAIN AWAY

54:59 - ARE WALKING OUT THE

54:59 - PRESCRIPTION FOR PILLS.

55:01 - I MEAN NO MATTER THE CLIENTELE

55:02 - YOU'RE SERVING THAT THAT NUMBER

55:03 - IS JUST ABSURD

55:04 - ADDITIONALLY IT SIGNIFICANTLY

55:06 - GREATER THAN THE

55:07 - NATIONAL AVERAGE. THIS IS ALSO

55:08 - DURING THE COURSE OF HAVING

55:09 - MAQDIS TREATMENT AND HOW DOES

55:11 - THIS COMPARE TO THE ORIGINAL

55:12 - PAINTING A CLINIC. IT'S NIGHT

55:14 - AND DAY. IF YOU LOOK AT THE

55:15 - FIRST COLOR, THE FIRST ROW IN

55:17 - 2010. 2.6% THE PAIN WAS

55:20 - PATIENTS ARE BEING PRESCRIBED

55:21 - OPIATES AND THIS IS DESPITE THE

55:22 - FACT THAT THEY WERE SERVING THE

55:24 - SAME COMMUNITY AND THE SAME

55:25 - PEOPLE.

55:27 - THANK YOU KNOW IT YOU'RE GOING

55:28 - TO GET THE DOCUMENTS I GOT A

55:29 - COMMISSION APPROACH WITH WHAT

55:30 - HAS PREVIOUSLY BEEN MARKETED TO

55:31 - 10. YOU MAKE.

55:42 - NOW ASIAN COPELAND'S WHAT IS

55:44 - THIS DOCUMENT.

55:45 - THESE ARE THE PHYSICIAN TO

55:46 - PATIENT PRESCRIPTION RECORDS

55:48 - FOR 20 16 FROM THE WIZ WE

55:50 - PHARMACY INTO THE OCEAN AND HOW

55:51 - DID YOUR TEAM THIS DOCUMENT AND

55:53 - ITS DOCUMENTS OBTAINED BY

55:54 - SUBPOENA. IT'S ACTUALLY LEGAL

55:56 - REQUIREMENT FOR PHARMACIES

55:57 - DISPENSE RECORDS FROM THESE 2

55:58 - YEARS AND IS THIS A FAIR AND

55:59 - ACCURATE COPY. YES, IT S AND AT

56:02 - THIS POINT I MOVED TO ENTER ITS

56:03 - ATTENDANT EVIDENCE PUBLISHED

56:04 - TODAY. ANY ADDITIONAL

56:05 - OBJECTION, YOUR HONOR THANK YOU

56:06 - THAT WAS IT YOU MAKE.

56:22 - NO ASIAN CUP COPELAND'S WHAT

56:24 - JUMPS AT YOU ABOUT

56:24 - THIS DOCUMENT THEY GET QUITE A

56:26 - BIT JUMPS OUT BUT I'LL TRY TO

56:27 - SUMMARIZE IT IN THE INTEREST

56:29 - OF TIME. YOU SEE OVER THE

56:30 - COURSE OF 2016 DOCTOR SHAFER

56:32 - HAS A CLEAR AND OBVIOUS PATTERN

56:34 - OF PRESCRIBING A HIGH DOSAGE OF

56:36 - A POWERFUL NARCOTIC TO THE

56:37 - DECEASED HAVING MCADOO

56:38 - ADDITIONALLY OVER THE COURSE OF

56:40 - 2016 THE AMOUNT OF PILLS BEING

56:42 - PRESCRIBED DOUBLES FROM 60 TO

56:45 - 120.

56:47 - THANK YOU CAN PUT THAT

56:47 - DOCUMENTS CITE MARRIAGE AND

56:49 - COPE AND HOW DO YOU FURTHER

56:50 - INVESTIGATE

56:50 - THE DEFENDANT. SAW THESE

56:52 - NUMBERS AND YOU HAD TO DO SOME

56:53 - MORE DIGGING.

56:54 - SO I CONTINUE TO LOOK INTO

56:55 - THEIR FINANCIAL RECORDS AND TO

56:57 - CLOSELY MONITOR THEIR

56:58 - PRESCRIPTION PRACTICES. I CAME

56:59 - AWAY WITH 3 KEY PIECES

57:01 - OF INFORMATION. FIRST I NOTICED

57:03 - THAT THE MAJORITY OF PATIENTS

57:05 - 2015 16 WERE PAYING IN CASH.

57:07 - SECOND. I NOTICED THAT THEY

57:08 - WERE SEEN A GREATER NUMBER OF

57:10 - PATIENTS THAN THEY EVER HAVE

57:11 - BEFORE YOU ARE REALLY REACHING

57:12 - IN AND OUT WITH THE ASSEMBLY

57:13 - LINE 3RD, MORE PREJUDICIAL THAN

57:16 - PROBATIVE TO USE THE WORDS

57:17 - ASSEMBLY LINE.

57:19 - >>AND IF I MAY TO PICK A LOCAL

57:20 - TERM USED BY THIS AGAIN EXPERT

57:22 - IN THE HE WOULD KNOW SORT OF

57:24 - ANY RED FLAGS LIKE THESE.

57:26 - REFERRING TO AN END FOR THE

57:27 - MART ASSEMBLY LINE IT'S NOT

57:29 - TAKEN TO BE IT SHOULD BE TAKEN

57:30 - LITERALLY OF COURSE IT'S SIMPLY

57:32 - A SORT OF COMMON ANALOGY USED

57:34 - TO IT. SO IT COMMUNICATE.

57:36 - WE HONOR.

57:37 - >>REFERRING TO PAIN WAYS

57:38 - ANYTHING OTHER THAN A PAIN

57:39 - CLINIC IS INFLAMMATORY TO THE

57:40 - JURY TO SUGGEST

57:41 - THAT IT'S LIKE AN ASSEMBLY LINE

57:43 - WOULD BE SUGGESTING THAT DOCTOR

57:44 - SHE WOULD NOT CONDUCT COULD

57:46 - PRACTICE AT THE CLINIC AND THIS

57:47 - IS JUST SIMPLY INFLAMMATORY

57:48 - SAYS THEY CANNOT LAY FOUNDATION

57:49 - FOR

57:50 - THIS TERM.

57:50 - >>YOU'RE OUT OF TIME AT BELIEVE

57:52 - THE JURY IS I'M NOT GOING TO I

57:54 - WOULD HOPE AT LEAST THAT THE

57:55 - TAKE THIS LITERALLY TO MEAN THE

57:56 - PAIN AWAY WAS AN ACTUAL

57:57 - ASSEMBLY LINE SIMPLY AGAIN TO

57:59 - COMMUNICATE

57:59 - FACT THAT PATIENTS ARE GOING

58:01 - TOO FAST AND MANY WERE GETTING

58:02 - A SIMILAR TREATMENT.

58:03 - >>AND WAYNE TO SUSTAIN THE

58:04 - OBJECTION.

58:05 - >>AND I.

58:07 - >>STRAIGHT FACE ASSEMBLY LINE

58:08 - FROM THE RECORD. I THINK THAT

58:10 - YOU CAN GET YOUR POINT WITHOUT

58:11 - USING A PRIEST.

58:12 - YES, SIR.

58:13 - >>CAN YOU SAYING HOW YOU

58:15 - FURTHER INVESTIGATE THE

58:15 - DEFENDANT SURE SO I LIKE I SAID

58:17 - I SAW THAT THEY WERE SEEING A

58:18 - GREATER NUMBER OF PATIENTS THAN

58:20 - EVER BEFORE. AND 3RD, I NOTICED

58:22 - THAT SEVERAL OF THEIR PATIENTS

58:23 - WERE ACTUALLY FILLING THEIR

58:24 - PRESCRIPTIONS AT PHARMACIES UP

58:26 - TO 150 MILES AWAY.

58:28 - ALL 3 OF THESE BANKS WERE MAJOR

58:30 - RED FLAGS IN MY BEST AGAIN.

58:31 - IT CAN COPE AND ARE YOU

58:32 - FAMILIAR WITH THE TERM PILL

58:34 - MILL. YES, I AM OR PRODUCE THEM

58:36 - PROVE IT. YOUR HONOR I WITNESS

58:38 - WAS LIKE EXPLAIN HE WOULD START

58:40 - TELL THE JURY HOW THIS IS A

58:42 - TERM OFTEN USED IN DRUG

58:43 - DIVERSION.

58:43 - >>WHICH I HE IS A FIELD IN

58:45 - WHICH IS A QUALIFIED AS AN

58:46 - EXPERT FOR THEM OR AGAINST THE

58:47 - COLLOQUIAL TERM AND AS YOU

58:50 - WILL HEAR. USE IT'S USED OFTEN

58:53 - IN A

58:53 - NARCOTICS INVESTIGATION.

58:55 - >>YET IF I'M A PILL MILLS EVEN

58:56 - MORE INFLAMMATORY THAN ASSEMBLY

58:58 - LINE THIS IS NOT AN EXPERT

58:59 - TERMINOLOGY RATHER JUST SOME

59:01 - TERM THAT THEY USE GOING AROUND

59:03 - AT THE D A THIS IS SIMPLY

59:04 - TRYING TO INFLAME THE PASSIONS

59:05 - OF THE JURY AGAIN CALLING

59:06 - ANYTHING OTHER THAN A PAIN

59:07 - CLINIC WOULD BE UNFAIRLY

59:09 - PREJUDICING THE JURY TOWARDS MY

59:11 - CLIENT DOCTOR SHAFER YOU'RE

59:14 - >>TERMINOLOGY THIS EXPERT USES

59:16 - AND BELIEVE BECOMES EXPERT

59:17 - TERMINOLOGY REGARDLESS AGAIN

59:19 - SIMPLY A COLLOQUIAL TERM BUT AN

59:21 - IMPORTANT ONE IN

59:21 - DRUG DIVERSION. YOU KNOW

59:23 - THERE'S BEEN HUMAN EVEN IF THEY

59:24 - CONSIDER KILL NO EXPERT

59:25 - TESTIMONY YOU COULD STILL BE

59:27 - INFLAMMATORY TO THE JURY

59:28 - TO HEAR.

59:29 - >>SAYING CONSIDERING THAT THERE

59:30 - CAN CALLING DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S

59:32 - PAIN CLINIC, A PILL MILL THERE

59:33 - HAS BEEN NO FOUNDATION LAID AS

59:35 - TO HOW THEY COME TO THIS

59:36 - CONCLUSION, AND IT'S JUST

59:37 - COMPLETELY INFLAMMATORY AND IF

59:38 - I MAY IF I WAS LIED TO CONTINUE

59:40 - THIS WITNESS WOULD EXPLAIN HOW

59:41 - HE CAME TO THIS CONCLUSION AND

59:42 - GOING REALLY DIRECTION AT THIS

59:44 - TIME.

59:45 - >>AND GET THE WIN A SNAPPY TO

59:46 - ANSWER THAT QUESTION EXPLAIN

59:48 - THE POLICE AND FOUNDATION OF

59:49 - POSSIBLE YOU'RE FREE TO RAISE

59:50 - AND ACTION AGAIN. IF NECESSARY,

59:53 - YES, TRUMP HE CAN PROCEED.

59:54 - >>THE COUPLE ARE YOU FAMILIAR

59:55 - WITH THE TERM UNTIL NOW.

59:57 - IT'S AN BILL KNOWS A TERM USED

59:59 - 760 BY INVESTIGATORS SUCH AS MYSELF

01:00 - 02.260 IT'S VERY COMMON DESCRIBES A

01:00 - 04.150 PRACTICE DISTRIBUTES POWERFUL

01:00 - 05.710 NARCOTICS IN A MATTER THAT IS

01:00 - 07.180 NON-MEDICAL OR UNPROFESSIONAL

01:00 - 08.620 IN PRACTICE AND BASED ON YOUR

01:00 - 09.880 INVESTIGATION AND EXPERT

01:00 - 11.130 KNOWLEDGE THAT PAIN AWAY BECOME

01:00 - 12.300 A PILL MILL AND CERTAINLY

01:00 - 13.510 RESEMBLED ONE WHAT FURTHER

01:00 - 15.060 EVIDENCE TO HAVE SUPPORT THAT

01:00 - 16.890 CONCLUSION. WELL ONCE ACTUALLY

01:00 - 18.240 OBSERVE DOCTOR SHAFER AND

01:00 - 19.910 HAVING MCADOO EXCHANGING CASH

01:00 - 20.780 IN THE PARKING LOT.

01:00 - 22.440 NOW MOVING ON TO COPE AND ARE

01:00 - 24.730 YOU FAMILIAR WITH THE PM P YES,

01:00 - 25.970 I AM THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG

01:00 - 27.820 MONITORING PROGRAM. AND WHAT

01:00 - 29.210 EXACTLY DOES THE PMP DO.

01:00 - 31.610 WELL, IT GIVES DOCTORS WAIT YOU

01:00 - 32.990 KNOW ALL THE DRUG TO PATIENTS

01:00 - 34.310 BEING PRESCRIBED BY DOCTORS

01:00 - 35.410 OTHER THEMSELVES, IT'S

01:00 - 37.210 INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT TO ENSURE

01:00 - 38.130 THEY DON'T PRESCRIBE ANYTHING

01:00 - 39.740 CONFLICTING AND AND THE PATIENT

01:00 - 41.470 AND HOW ACCESSIBLE WAS THE PMP

01:00 - 42.320 TO DOCTOR SHAFER

01:00 - 44.340 INCREDIBLY ACCESSIBLE YOU CAN

01:00 - 45.340 EVEN DO IT ON YOUR PHONE THESE

01:00 - 46.990 DAYS, YES, LESS THAN A

01:00 - 48.870 FEW SECONDS AND THROUGHOUT THE

01:00 - 49.870 COURSE OF MS. MACKIE'S

01:00 - 51.130 TREATMENT TO ANYONE UP IN A WAY

01:00 - 53.060 NEVER CHECKED THE PNP NOW

01:00 - 54.930 NOBODY DID DESPITE THE FACT

01:00 - 55.880 THAT IT WAS GOING TO BE MADE

01:00 - 57.960 LAW IN 2 WEEKS IT WAS NO SECRET

01:00 - 58.840 THIS IS THE NEW NORMAL.

01:00 - 01.200 AND WERE THERE ANY OTHER WAYS

01:01 - 02.300 FOR DOCTOR SHAFER TO FIND OUT

01:01 - 04.060 ABOUT IS HAVING BACK IS

01:01 - 05.810 OTHER PRESCRIPTIONS. YES, THERE

01:01 - 07.710 WERE SHOULD FOR WHATEVER REASON

01:01 - 09.200 THE DOCTOR ELECTS NOT TO CHECK

01:01 - 10.500 THE PDI-P THERE'S ALSO THE

01:01 - 11.690 TRIED AND TRUE METHOD OF URINE

01:01 - 13.510 SCREENING. I DID DOCTOR SHAFER

01:01 - 14.490 ADMINISTER YOUR ON SCREEN.

01:01 - 17.080 NO DOCTOR SHAFER DID NOT AND

01:01 - 18.570 FINALLY AGING COPELAND BASED ON

01:01 - 19.760 YOUR EXPERT KNOWLEDGE AN

01:01 - 20.750 OPINION AS WELL AS

01:01 - 22.270 INVESTIGATION OF THIS CASE AND

01:01 - 23.350 REVIEW OF ALL RELEVANT RECORDS

01:01 - 24.450 HAVE YOU COME TO A CONCLUSION

01:01 - 25.610 WITHIN A REASONABLE DEGREE OF

01:01 - 26.670 PROFESSIONAL CERTAINTY ABOUT

01:01 - 28.250 THIS CASE HERE TODAY. YES,

01:01 - 30.050 I HAVE IT'S MY EXPERT OPINION

01:01 - 31.330 IN TODAY'S CASE THAT DOCTOR

01:01 - 32.630 SHAFER ENGAGED IN DRUG

01:01 - 34.040 DIVERSION DURING THE CARE OF

01:01 - 35.810 HAVING MCADOO THANK YOU NOTHING

01:01 - 37.000 FOR THANK YOU.

01:01 - 46.160 CROSSING THE NATION, YES, YOUR

01:01 - 46.380 HONOR.

01:01 - 54.320 THEY'RE FUSSY MAKE GOOD

01:01 - 55.950 AFTERNOON IN CHICAGO. YOU'RE

01:01 - 56.750 NOT A PHYSICIAN ARE YOU.

01:01 - 59.250 A DIVERSION INVESTIGATOR AND SO

01:01 - 00.020 YOU DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO

01:02 - 00.920 PRESCRIBE MEDICATION.

01:02 - 03.370 NO I DON'T AND YOU NEVER HAD TO

01:02 - 04.360 MAKE THE DETERMINATION WHETHER

01:02 - 05.460 OR NOT TO PRESCRIBING OPIOIDS

01:02 - 07.040 TO PATIENTS BEEN PAID FOR IT.

01:02 - 09.370 NO I HAVE NOT BUT YOU'D AGREE

01:02 - 10.600 THAT SOME PATIENTS TO HAVE REAL

01:02 - 10.970 PAY

01:02 - 13.410 FOR IT FOR SOME PATIENTS TO AN

01:02 - 14.390 EFFECTIVE WAY OF DEALING WITH

01:02 - 15.660 THAT CAN SOMETIMES TREATED WITH

01:02 - 20.080 LID SORRY POWERFUL THAT IN SOME

01:02 - 21.300 CASES YOU SLEPT

01:02 - 23.280 AND SOME PATIENTS ARE SIMPLY

01:02 - 24.370 LINE TO GET MEDICATION OR

01:02 - 25.930 DOCTOR SHOPPING RIGHT CIRCLE TO

01:02 - 27.420 BE DONE SOME PATIENTS ARE LYING

01:02 - 28.870 TO GET MEDICATION OR DOCTOR

01:02 - 29.910 SHOPPING CORRECT.

01:02 - 32.100 >>THAT IS A COMMON PRACTICE

01:02 - 34.130 AMONG CLINICS AND IT'S

01:02 - 35.400 ULTIMATELY A JUDGMENT CALL TO

01:02 - 36.730 BE MADE BY THE DOCTOR TO ASSESS

01:02 - 37.700 WHAT SITUATION THEY'RE DEALING

01:02 - 38.360 WITH RIGHT.

01:02 - 41.510 >>AND YOU SAID IN YOUR WORDS

01:02 - 42.440 THAT A DOCTOR CAN MAKE AN

01:02 - 43.570 HONEST MISTAKE WHEN ASSESSING

01:02 - 44.670 THE SITUATION IS RIGHT.

01:02 - 47.530 THIS IS FROM A

01:02 - 48.340 WITNESS STATEMENT.

01:02 - 49.640 >>YOUR HONOR JUST BECAUSE

01:02 - 50.540 SOMETHING WAS SAID THE WITNESS

01:02 - 51.850 STATEMENT DOES NOT NECESSARILY

01:02 - 52.620 MAKE IT ADMISSIBLE

01:02 - 53.990 IN COURT THE OTHER PERSON'S

01:02 - 55.520 REAL 7 OH 3 THIS WITNESS IS AN

01:02 - 57.230 EXPERT IS LOVE TESTIFY ABOUT

01:02 - 58.430 INFORMATION, BUT THEY'RE NOT.

01:02 - 59.670 >>IT BE DEEMED ADMISSIBLE.

01:02 - 01.550 >>YOUR HONOR I HAVE NO PROBLEM

01:03 - 03.310 WITH THE EXPERT TESTIMONY

01:03 - 05.080 RATHER 2 OPPOSING COUNSEL IS

01:03 - 06.730 CALLING FOR THIS WITNESS TO

01:03 - 07.520 TESTIFY TO WHAT HE HAS

01:03 - 09.080 PREVIOUSLY SAID OUT OF COURT.

01:03 - 11.660 >>YET AGAIN TO SORT ALL 73.

01:03 - 13.140 AN EXPERT IS ALLOWED TO TESTIFY

01:03 - 14.350 TO EVIDENCE THAT MAY NOT BE

01:03 - 15.700 DEEMED ADMISSIBLE REGARDLESS OF

01:03 - 17.090 IF THEY CONSIDERED HEARSAY YOUR

01:03 - 18.440 HONOR FOR MY 73 IS NOT AN

01:03 - 19.510 EXCEPTION TO HEARSAY.

01:03 - 21.660 YOU ARE UNDER FOR EXPERTS IT IS

01:03 - 22.840 YOUR HONOR EVEN IF AN EXHIBIT

01:03 - 23.990 WAS HEARSAY AN EXPERT WOULD BE

01:03 - 25.120 ABLE TO TESTIFY TO THIS IF

01:03 - 26.400 THERE IS REASONABLY RELY ON THE

01:03 - 27.530 INFORMATION IN ORDER TO FORM

01:03 - 28.500 THEIR CONCLUSION. YOU'RE ON

01:03 - 29.650 EARTH OPPOSING COUNSEL IS ABLE

01:03 - 30.960 TO POINT TO ME WHERE AND WILL

01:03 - 32.220 73 THERE'S ANYTHING ABOUT

01:03 - 33.870 HEARSAY I WOULD APPRECIATE THAT

01:03 - 35.000 YOU'RE OUT OF THE RULE SAYS THE

01:03 - 36.430 EXPERTS ARE ALLOWED TO TESTIFY

01:03 - 37.370 TO INFORMATION THAT THEY WOULD

01:03 - 38.820 REASONABLY RELY ON IN THAT

01:03 - 40.260 PARTICULAR FIELD, WHETHER OR

01:03 - 41.580 NOT IF YOU DIDN'T MISS A BEAT.

01:03 - 42.620 I DON'T BELIEVE THAT'S WHAT

01:03 - 43.580 THIS QUESTION WAS BEING ASKED

01:03 - 44.340 TO BELIEVE THIS QUESTIONS

01:03 - 47.740 CONTROVERSY. WHY ASK THE

01:03 - 48.340 QUESTION AGAIN.

01:03 - 50.000 YES I WAS THINKING AND A DOCTOR

01:03 - 51.310 CAN MAKE AN HONEST MISTAKE WHEN

01:03 - 52.390 ASSESSING THE SITUATION.

01:03 - 57.130 >>I SUPPOSE IN CERTAIN

01:03 - 58.650 CIRCUMSTANCES, A DOCTOR COULD

01:03 - 59.690 MAKE AN HONEST MISTAKE.

01:03 - 00.970 >>NOW LET'S TALK ABOUT YOUR

01:04 - 02.180 INVESTIGATION INTO DOCTOR

01:04 - 04.090 SHAFER YOU WOULD AGREE THAT FOR

01:04 - 05.910 YEARS YOUR INVESTIGATION

01:04 - 07.390 INVOLVES SITTING IN YOUR CAR IN

01:04 - 08.970 PAIN WAS PARKING LOT LOOKING

01:04 - 09.880 FOR EVIDENCE AGAINST DOCTOR

01:04 - 10.790 SHAFER DONE THAT.

01:04 - 12.490 >>BOTH ENDEAVORS INVESTIGATION

01:04 - 13.800 OF A SUDDEN DIRECT HITS.

01:04 - 15.290 ALL ABOUT THE NUMBERS JUST A

01:04 - 15.550 CULT

01:04 - 17.810 RENT SO A LOT OF THE OTHERS

01:04 - 18.970 INVESTIGATION PROCESS IS

01:04 - 19.890 SITTING AND WAITING AND

01:04 - 21.220 COLLECTING DATA AND AGAIN 4

01:04 - 23.360 YEARS. YOU JUST COULDN'T MAKE

01:04 - 24.390 ANYTHING STICK THOSE ARE YOUR

01:04 - 27.610 GOT TO GET THIS IS GOING

01:04 - 29.030 DIRECTLY TO THE INVESTIGATION

01:04 - 30.790 BY A TICK OVER NIGHT 2 AS IT IS

01:04 - 32.230 CLEARLY RELEVANT IN THIS CASE

01:04 - 33.520 AND AGAIN PURSUED WILL 7 OH 3

01:04 - 34.880 IS ALLOWED TO TESTIFY TO THIS

01:04 - 36.000 YOUR HONOR IF I MAY IF THOSE

01:04 - 37.150 ACCOUNTS LIKE TO ASK WHETHER OR

01:04 - 37.850 NOT HE COULD MAKE

01:04 - 40.370 >>ANY IF WHETHER OR NOT THIS

01:04 - 41.540 WITNESS COULD MAKE ANYTHING

01:04 - 42.480 STICK. I'VE NO PROBLEM WITH

01:04 - 44.240 THAT. BUT WHEN HE SAYS THE EU

01:04 - 45.960 SAID THAT IS ASKING FOR AN OUT

01:04 - 47.760 OF COURT STATEMENT USED PROVE

01:04 - 48.470 THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER

01:04 - 50.380 ASSERTED IT, IT'S HIS OUT OF

01:04 - 51.800 COURT STATEMENT. YES.

01:04 - 53.800 >>LANG THE WITNESSES AVAILABLE

01:04 - 55.260 AT THE FIESTA. DYLAN IS THE

01:04 - 58.550 QUESTION. MR. THAT AND SO YOU

01:04 - 59.520 BELIEVE THAT.

01:05 - 04.210 DOCTORS ARE TIGER OK YOU'RE AN

01:05 - 05.290 EXPERT IN THIS CASE, CORRECT

01:05 - 06.780 AND AND SO YOU COMPLETE A

01:05 - 07.590 THOROUGH REVIEW OF ALL THE

01:05 - 08.700 MATERIALS IN ORDER TO FORM YOUR

01:05 - 10.430 CONCLUSIONS. I CERTAINLY DID SO

01:05 - 11.470 YOU'D BE FAMILIAR WITH THE

01:05 - 12.740 AMBIENT SUPPORT CHIEF UNITED

01:05 - 14.910 COACHES DEATH 12/16/2016,

01:05 - 16.280 WRECK. YES, I WOULD YOU ARE

01:05 - 18.030 AWARE THAT COACH MACK IS FOUND

01:05 - 19.590 UNCONSCIOUS AND UNRESPONSIVE IN

01:05 - 21.440 HER CHAIR. YES, AND THERE ARE

01:05 - 22.540 MULTIPLE PILL BOTTLES FOUND

01:05 - 24.270 AROUND HER. YES, SOME LOSERS,

01:05 - 25.330 MULTIPLE PRESCRIBERS

01:05 - 26.590 ALL RIGHT.

01:05 - 27.820 >>DON'T KNOW EXACTLY THE

01:05 - 28.850 PRESCRIPTION PATTERNS AND

01:05 - 29.860 EILEEN O OF HIS REPORTING

01:05 - 31.350 MEMBERSHIP SHE WAS NOT THERE IS

01:05 - 32.580 SOME OF THOSE PILL BOTTLES WERE

01:05 - 33.020 EMPTY THOUGH.

01:05 - 35.000 BELIEVE THAT WAS WHAT WAS

01:05 - 35.880 REPORTED TO US AND THERE IS

01:05 - 37.620 ALSO ON THE AND ITS REPORT SHE

01:05 - 38.790 A TROPHY FROM MEXICO TO THE

01:05 - 39.090 BODY.

01:05 - 42.450 THAT THERE'S A TROPHY IN THE

01:05 - 44.710 ROOM, YES, THE YES,

01:05 - 47.100 MY QUESTION. I SUPPOSE NOW

01:05 - 48.150 LET'S TALK ABOUT COACHES

01:05 - 49.290 MEDICAL TREATMENT, YOU'D AGREE

01:05 - 49.450 WITH

01:05 - 51.230 ME THAT DOCTOR COACH MAGGIE WAS

01:05 - 52.000 RECEIVING TREATMENT FOR

01:05 - 53.410 MULTIPLE PHYSICIANS, CORRECT.

01:05 - 55.190 YESTERDAY, DIFFERENT KINDS OF

01:05 - 56.530 TREATMENT DOCTOR SHAFER FOR THE

01:05 - 58.650 PAIN BY MARGARET HAMBURG FOR A.

01:05 - 01.100 >>THE UNFORTUNATELY FOR HIS

01:06 - 02.210 ANTICS GOT A COMMISSION UP

01:06 - 03.070 FIRST THE WITNESS WOULD HAVE

01:06 - 04.220 BEEN PREVIOUSLY MARKED EXHIBIT

01:06 - 04.560 11.

01:06 - 05.970 >>NIC WHAT ARE LIKE A COPY.

01:06 - 07.130 I HAVEN'T THINK IT WOULD OPPOSE

01:06 - 09.190 A COUPLE OF CUP. YES.

01:06 - 12.440 THIS IS A COPY OF THE ONLY

01:06 - 13.390 SHOWS THE WITNESS.

01:06 - 23.310 ASIAN CUP AND THIS IS

01:06 - 25.210 THE PMP LARGER COACH MCADOO

01:06 - 26.160 FROM OCTOBER FIRST TO

01:06 - 28.100 12/16/2016 CORRECT.

01:06 - 31.440 AND HERE IT READ THIS DOCUMENT

01:06 - 33.380 ITSELF. YES, THERE AT THIS TIME

01:06 - 34.870 OF 2 MINUTES 11 AND EVIDENCE

01:06 - 36.560 ANY OBJECTION THAT STIPULATION

01:06 - 38.240 22 NO OBJECTION HERE. THANK YOU

01:06 - 39.970 SIGN IT. COMMISSION OPPOSED TO

01:06 - 40.790 THE JURY YOU MAKE.

01:07 - 05.540 IT'S A GOAL THAT WE CAN AGREE

01:07 - 06.770 THAT DOCTOR HAMBURG PRESCRIBE

01:07 - 09.190 XANAX TO COACH IN 11/30/2016

01:07 - 09.640 CORRECT.

01:07 - 11.900 YES, AND IF DOCTOR HAMBURG

01:07 - 13.300 CHECK THE PMP BEFORE

01:07 - 14.640 PRESCRIBING A COACH SHE WAS

01:07 - 15.990 SEEN EARLIER PRESCRIPTION FOR

01:07 - 17.430 OXYCODONE BUT DOCTOR SHAFER.

01:07 - 21.500 IF YOU'RE UP IN THE DESERT THAT

01:07 - 23.040 IS A QUESTION IF DOCTOR HAMBURG

01:07 - 24.500 CHECK THE PMP BEFORE

01:07 - 25.380 PRESCRIBING A COACH.

01:07 - 26.380 SHE WOULD HAVE SEEN THAT

01:07 - 27.310 EARLIER PRESCRIPTION FOR

01:07 - 28.610 OXYCODONE BUT DOCTOR SCHIPPER

01:07 - 30.750 CORRECT. THEORETICALLY, YES AND

01:07 - 32.180 YOU'RE AWARE THAT MUCH INVENTED

01:07 - 33.490 HAS BEEN SUCH AS AN EXTERNAL

01:07 - 34.840 VIEW IT CAN CAUSE DEATH RATE.

01:07 - 36.780 IT CAN YES SO DOCTOR HAMBURG,

01:07 - 37.850 OBVIOUSLY NEVER CHECKED THE PDA

01:07 - 39.320 PEOPLE THAT YOU JUST GOT YOUR

01:07 - 40.640 HAMBURGER IS NOT PRESENT TODAY

01:07 - 41.930 IN COURT NOR DOES DOCTOR

01:07 - 42.370 HAMBURG HAVE

01:07 - 45.040 ATTORNEY PRESENT AND SO I DON'T

01:07 - 46.530 BELIEVE THAT THIS ATTACK ON

01:07 - 47.950 DOCTOR EVER TO AGAIN IS NOT

01:07 - 49.230 PRESIDENT WERE CRIMINAL

01:07 - 50.340 CRIMINALLY LIABLE.

01:07 - 50.840 >>FOR THE

01:07 - 52.840 FOR THE DEATH OF COACH MCADOO

01:07 - 54.070 IS AT ALL APPROPRIATE. YEAH,

01:07 - 55.700 I'M NO WAY CLAIMING THAT DOCTOR

01:07 - 56.870 HAMMERS CRIMINALLY LIABLE IN

01:07 - 57.840 THIS CASE AS I'M AWARE

01:07 - 58.600 STIPULATION NUMBER

01:07 - 59.600 9 SAYING THAT.

01:08 - 01.470 >>DOCTOR HAMBURG PRESCRIBE

01:08 - 02.920 APPROPRIATELY PRESCRIBE XANAX

01:08 - 03.770 TO COACH MCADOO.

01:08 - 06.170 HOWEVER, IT DOES NOT SAY

01:08 - 07.340 WHETHER OR NOT DOCTOR HAMBURG

01:08 - 09.160 CHECK THE PMP WHAT I'M ASKING

01:08 - 10.800 HIM TO COPE AND IS IF THIS CAME

01:08 - 12.310 ACROSS IN HIS INVESTIGATION.

01:08 - 13.970 >>YOUR HONOR IN THAT CASE I

01:08 - 15.770 SUCH A PROJECT INTO RELEVANCE

01:08 - 17.020 WHETHER OR NOT DOCTOR HAMBURG.

01:08 - 18.400 CHECK THAT PMP I BELIEVE IS

01:08 - 19.990 WHOLLY IRRELEVANT TO GET DOCTOR

01:08 - 21.020 SCHAEFER'S TREATMENT OF MS.

01:08 - 22.370 MACK KNEW ON DECEMBER, 16 GOT

01:08 - 23.480 RESPONDING WITH THE

01:08 - 24.540 PROSECUTION'S BURDEN IN THIS

01:08 - 25.840 CASE IS THE SHOW THAT DOCTOR

01:08 - 27.150 SHAFER DIDN'T ACT IN GOOD FAITH

01:08 - 28.000 OR IN ACCORDANCE WITH A

01:08 - 28.950 RESPONSIBLE STATEMENT, THE

01:08 - 30.400 MEDICAL PROFESSION. THIS

01:08 - 31.410 DOCUMENT IS SHOWING THAT THERE

01:08 - 32.730 WAS MULTIPLE OTHER PHYSICIANS

01:08 - 34.660 TREATING COACH MCADOO WHO MAY

01:08 - 35.840 HAVE ACTED IN THE SAME EXACT

01:08 - 37.160 WAY THAT DOCTOR SHAFER DID

01:08 - 38.690 GOING AGAINST THE BURDEN OF THE

01:08 - 40.460 PROSECUTION THAT SHOULD ENACT A

01:08 - 41.730 COURTS WERE RESPONSIBLE SAYING

01:08 - 41.790 THE

01:08 - 43.810 MEDICAL PROFESSION, YOUR HONOR

01:08 - 45.000 AS WELL AS MY PREVIOUS

01:08 - 45.910 OBJECTION, I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO

01:08 - 47.340 POINT OUT THAT THIS DOCUMENT IS

01:08 - 48.870 NOT THIS SPECIFIC DOCUMENT.

01:08 - 51.560 >>DOES NOT WHO CHECKED THE PMP

01:08 - 52.890 NOR THE RECORDS OF THE PNP

01:08 - 54.520 MARGARET HAMBURG MAY AS WELL

01:08 - 55.790 HAVE CHECKED THAT THE MP FOR

01:08 - 57.400 ALL WE KNOW, BUT AGAIN THAT IS

01:08 - 59.820 JUST NOT RELEVANT MOST

01:09 - 00.830 JOSHAN SHOULD

01:09 - 01.430 BE ADMISSIBLE.

01:09 - 03.550 >>I'M GOING OVERLY OBJECTION

01:09 - 04.840 YOU A PERSISTENT QUESTION.

01:09 - 06.690 >>AND SO DOCTOR HAMBURG OBVIOUS

01:09 - 07.840 NEVER CHECKED THE PMP THAT

01:09 - 09.610 DITCH. I DIDN'T INVESTIGATE

01:09 - 11.090 DOCTOR HAMBURG I DILIGENT THE

01:09 - 12.050 CIRCUMSTANCES OF.

01:09 - 12.950 >>OR TREATS SO YOUR

01:09 - 13.950 INVESTIGATION DIDN'T COME

01:09 - 14.830 ACROSS THAT SHE CHECKED THE

01:09 - 15.990 PIMP YOU'RE NOT CORRECT.

01:09 - 17.900 FOR DOCTOR HAMBURG, YES, THAT

01:09 - 19.630 WAS NOT OF INVESTIGATION OF

01:09 - 19.910 DOCTOR

01:09 - 21.460 SHAFER NOTE, YOU'RE AWARE THAT

01:09 - 23.950 ON 10/30/2016 DOCTOR HARRISON

01:09 - 25.220 PRESCRIBED OXYCODONE THE COACH

01:09 - 25.450 MAC

01:09 - 25.930 TO CORRECT.

01:09 - 27.330 >>YES AND AND IF DOCTOR

01:09 - 28.810 HARRISON TO CHECK THE PMP FOR

01:09 - 30.020 COACH BEFORE PRESCRIBING

01:09 - 31.100 HE WOULD HAVE SEEN EARLIER

01:09 - 32.130 PRESCRIPTION FOR XANAX BUT

01:09 - 33.130 DOCTOR HAMBURG RIGHT.

01:09 - 36.160 >>PMP LAWS WERE NOT PLACED A

01:09 - 38.510 POINT AND ALSO MY QUESTION.

01:09 - 40.520 COUNCIL IT UNDERSTAND QUESTION

01:09 - 41.680 I'M ASKING IF HE WOULD HAVE

01:09 - 42.800 SEEN THIS PRESCRIPTIONS, A

01:09 - 44.570 SIMPLE QUESTION. AGAIN I WAS

01:09 - 45.990 NOT INVESTIGATING DOCTOR HARRIS

01:09 - 46.780 AND SO I CAN NOT

01:09 - 48.020 MAKE AN ASSUMPTION ABOUT WHAT

01:09 - 49.240 HE WOULD OR WOULD NOT HAVE DONE

01:09 - 50.500 SO AGAIN IN ADDITION IS ABOUT

01:09 - 51.670 DOCTOR SHAPE. SO AGAIN IN YOUR

01:09 - 52.800 INVESTIGATION. YOU DIDN'T COME

01:09 - 54.330 ACROSS DOCTOR HARRISON CHECKING

01:09 - 55.320 THE PFA CORRECT.

01:09 - 56.990 BECAUSE WHEN THIS A GEISHA

01:09 - 58.310 WASN'T OF DOCTOR HARRIS.

01:09 - 00.080 YES, WE'RE AWARE THAT IT WOULD

01:10 - 01.240 HAVE BEEN LEGAL FOR ALL 3 OF

01:10 - 02.470 THESE DOCTORS NOT TO CHECK THE

01:10 - 02.770 P A

01:10 - 05.060 FEW TIMES MOST REQUIRED FOR AT

01:10 - 06.340 LEAST ONCE EVERY 3 MONTHS AND

01:10 - 07.670 IT WASN'T PUT IN PLACE EXACTLY

01:10 - 09.570 UNTIL 26 IT WASN'T LEGAL AT IT

01:10 - 11.160 WAS AMENDED AT THE TIME CORRECT

01:10 - 12.260 AT THE TIME IT WAS NOT

01:10 - 14.050 AND YOU COME TO COURT TODAY

01:10 - 15.730 CLAIMING THAT DOCTOR SHAFER TO

01:10 - 17.100 NECK, ACCORDING TO RESPONSIBLE

01:10 - 18.180 SAYING THE MEDICAL PROFESSION

01:10 - 20.560 CLAIM THAT THAT WAS NOT THE

01:10 - 21.920 CONCLUSION HE GOT HE MADE

01:10 - 23.510 TONIGHT OR TODAY EXCUSE ME OUT

01:10 - 24.730 OF THE WITNESSES WHO TESTIFIED

01:10 - 26.110 FOR THE PROSECUTION TO IS GOING

01:10 - 27.200 TO TESTIFY TOWARDS THEIR

01:10 - 30.370 QUESTION AS THE WITNESS YOUR

01:10 - 31.280 HONOR FOR ME HE HAS NOT

01:10 - 31.730 TESTIFIED TO

01:10 - 32.900 ITS BURDEN. THEY ARE THE

01:10 - 33.970 FOUNDATION OF THE WITNESSES

01:10 - 35.790 LATE ON DIRECT EXAMINATION WENT

01:10 - 37.270 TO GO TO SHOW THAT THEY WERE

01:10 - 38.310 TRYING TO MEET THEIR BURDEN.

01:10 - 39.910 I'M JUST SIMPLY ASK A FOLLOW-UP

01:10 - 40.930 QUESTION ON THIS THEY OPEN THE

01:10 - 42.370 DOOR ON DIRECT EXAMINATION BY

01:10 - 43.810 ASKING HIM QUESTIONS ABOUT

01:10 - 45.150 DRUG DIVERSION AND WHETHER OR

01:10 - 46.310 NOT THIS WAS IN ACCORDANCE WITH

01:10 - 47.440 OTHER DOCTORS YOU'RE IN A

01:10 - 48.810 FAMILY SMACK DRUG DIVERSION

01:10 - 50.170 WHICH HE'S AN EXPERT IN THIS

01:10 - 51.410 QUITLINE QUESTION IS ASKING

01:10 - 52.440 ASIAN CUP AND A DRY LEGAL

01:10 - 54.470 CONCLUSION WHICH IS NOT HIS JOB

01:10 - 55.470 NOR IS HE AN EXPERT

01:10 - 57.090 >>I BELIEVE THAT'S THE JOB OF

01:10 - 58.620 THE CHERRY NOT NECESSARILY COME

01:10 - 59.530 FROM VERY SPOTTY.

01:10 - 01.230 ALL I ASKED WAS IF YOU BELIEVE

01:11 - 02.520 THAT HE CAME IF HE CAME TO

01:11 - 03.350 COURT TODAY TO CLAIM THAT

01:11 - 04.280 DOCTOR SHEPPARD AND NECK,

01:11 - 05.310 ACCORDING TO THE RESPONSIBLE

01:11 - 06.550 SAYING THE MEDICAL PROFESSION

01:11 - 06.900 THAT'S ALL

01:11 - 07.750 ASTRONAUT IF.

01:11 - 08.940 >>HE BELIEVES THAT DOCTOR

01:11 - 09.900 SCHIPPER ACTED IN ACCORDANCE

01:11 - 10.970 WITH THEIR SPONSORS SAY MADE IT

01:11 - 11.870 SIMPLY SAY THAT.

01:11 - 13.250 >>THE SISTINE THE OBJECTIONS,

01:11 - 14.460 THEY SAY YOU'RE ASKING FOR

01:11 - 15.870 LEGAL CONCLUSION HE CAN ANSWER

01:11 - 16.230 IT.

01:11 - 18.850 AS AN EXPERT IN MAJOR DIVERSION

01:11 - 19.360 COACH THEIR

01:11 - 22.330 >>ASIAN CUP AND YOU DID NOT

01:11 - 23.940 INVESTIGATE ANY OTHER MEDICAL

01:11 - 25.280 PROFESSIONALS IN THIS CASE

01:11 - 26.310 OTHER THAN DOCTOR SHAFER

01:11 - 26.900 CORRECT.

01:11 - 28.820 >>IN THE CASE OF DOCTOR SHAFER

01:11 - 30.160 I DID NOT INVESTIGATE SOMEONE

01:11 - 31.220 OTHER THAN DOCTOR SHAPE.

01:11 - 32.500 THANK YOU I HAVE NO FURTHER

01:11 - 33.380 QUESTIONS THANK YOU.

01:11 - 43.910 IF YOU'RE A REDIRECT

01:11 - 45.820 EXAMINATION OF BRIEFLY ON THIS

01:11 - 47.070 IT CAN COPE AND ARE YOU

01:11 - 48.400 INVESTIGATING EITHER DOCTOR

01:11 - 49.710 HARRISON OR DOCTOR HAMBURG.

01:11 - 51.380 HOLMES, NOT AND

01:11 - 54.530 DID DOCTOR HARRISON'S OPIOIDS

01:11 - 56.850 KILL METHOD NO THEY DID NOT.

01:11 - 59.340 AND FINALLY IF DOCTOR SHAFER

01:11 - 02.190 HAD CHECKED THIS PD MP IN THE

01:12 - 03.720 LAST 3 MONTHS AGAIN, WHAT WOULD

01:12 - 04.000 DOCTOR

01:12 - 05.760 SHAFER FOUND DOCTOR SHAFER

01:12 - 06.980 WOULD HAVE FOUND HIS ANTICS

01:12 - 08.040 THAT WAS BEING PRESCRIBED BY

01:12 - 09.040 DOCTOR MARGARET HAMBURG.

01:12 - 10.250 A GOOD THING FOR

01:12 - 20.130 >>THE THING THAT CAN BE CURED.

01:12 - 35.420 >>THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE THE

01:12 - 37.740 PROSECUTION'S YES, YOUR HONOR,

01:12 - 38.800 THE COMMONWEALTH PRESS,

01:12 - 39.930 ALTHOUGH WE DO ASK FOR A BRIEF

01:12 - 41.560 TIME CHECK BEFORE MOVING ON TO

01:12 - 42.810 THAT THIS CASE IN CHIEF THEY

01:12 - 43.230 CAN'T.

01:12 - 48.100 >>COMMONWEALTH HAS 14 MINUTES,

01:12 - 50.260 36 SECONDS REMAINING.

01:12 - 56.360 >>BY MY CALCULATION I DON'T

01:12 - 58.460 KNOW IT. WE

01:12 - 00.640 PRAY, OKAY BY MY CALCULATION

01:13 - 03.490 THAT OFFENSE HAS 17 MINUTES 43

01:13 - 04.690 SECONDS REMAINING.

01:13 - 14.600 >>THIS IS FOUND IN HARRY REID'S

01:13 - 17.440 SEAT. THAT WAS SCHIEFFER TO

01:13 - 18.360 STAND THINK IT.

01:13 - 32.150 PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

01:13 - 34.900 COURT. MY NAME IS SCHIEFFER AND

01:13 - 36.760 WHAT IS YOUR OCCUPATION, I'M A

01:13 - 38.070 PAIN SPECIALIST THEM UP INTO

01:13 - 39.870 A CLINIC. I ATTENDED TEMPLE

01:13 - 41.270 UNIVERSITY FOR MEDICAL SCHOOL

01:13 - 42.870 AND COUNTY UNIVERSITY FOR MY

01:13 - 45.180 MEDICAL RESIDENCY. DOCTOR TELL

01:13 - 47.220 US. WHY DID YOU BECOME A PAIN

01:13 - 47.950 SPECIALIST.

01:13 - 50.820 I ASKED MYSELF THAT QUESTION A

01:13 - 52.260 LOT AND I ALWAYS COME BACK TO

01:13 - 54.280 THE SAME ANSWER BECAME A

01:13 - 55.890 PAIN SPECIALIST BECAUSE I

01:13 - 56.830 BELIEVE IN TREATING THE WHOLE

01:13 - 58.590 PATIENT, NOT JUST THEIR PAIN.

01:13 - 01.210 I'M NOT TREATING JUST A LAKE OR

01:14 - 02.820 AN ELBOW. I'M TREATING A

01:14 - 04.050 PATIENT'S MIND AND BODY.

01:14 - 06.290 I JUST LOST HIS HEALTHY MINDS,

01:14 - 07.460 HEALTHY BODY. AND

01:14 - 08.820 I FEEL THIS BY CREATING A

01:14 - 10.210 MUTUAL TRUST BETWEEN MYSELF

01:14 - 12.010 MY PATIENTS DOCTOR CAN YOU

01:14 - 13.610 EXPLAIN WHAT YOU MEAN BY A

01:14 - 16.320 MUTUAL TRUST. YES, IT SIMPLY

01:14 - 17.400 MEANS THAT I HAVE TO TRUST MY

01:14 - 18.750 PATIENTS AND THEY IN TURN HAVE

01:14 - 19.450 TO TRUST ME.

01:14 - 21.450 A DOCTOR CAN ONLY KNOW SO MUCH

01:14 - 22.420 ABOUT HOW THEIR PATIENTS

01:14 - 24.300 FEELING. THEY HAVE NO OTHER WAY

01:14 - 25.290 OF KNOWING THE PATIENTS

01:14 - 27.220 INDICATION. WHAT MAKES PEN AWAY

01:14 - 28.580 SO EFFECTIVE IS THAT MY

01:14 - 29.980 COWORKERS AND I NEVER CAME TO

01:14 - 31.190 THE IDEA THAT WE CANNOT TRUST

01:14 - 33.580 THEIR PATIENTS. DOCTOR HOW DO

01:14 - 35.340 YOU TREAT THE PAIN THAT LIES

01:14 - 36.100 YOUR PATIENTS.

01:14 - 38.110 >>WELL, I HAVE ONE PRIMARY

01:14 - 39.590 APPROACH THIS LIST, IT'S

01:14 - 40.940 SIMILAR TO EASTERN MEDICINE.

01:14 - 42.470 I TREAT MY PATIENTS WITH

01:14 - 43.740 METHODS SUCH LOOK YOU

01:14 - 46.380 ACUPUNCTURE. NOW IF THIS ISN'T

01:14 - 47.300 WORKING TO THE BEST OF ITS

01:14 - 49.670 ABILITY. I DO TO IT DO TURN

01:14 - 50.970 TOWARDS PRESCRIPTION MEDICATION

01:14 - 52.260 AS MUCH SECONDARY OPTION

01:14 - 53.320 OF TREATMENT.

01:14 - 55.240 >>DOCTOR WHEN DO YOU DETERMINE

01:14 - 56.230 IF YOUR PATIENTS NEED

01:14 - 57.600 PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS.

01:14 - 59.770 >>WELL IF MY PATIENTS STILL

01:14 - 01.170 CLAIMS TO BE IN PAIN AFTER THIS

01:15 - 02.610 WAS A TREATMENT TREATMENTS.

01:15 - 03.670 I DO HAVE TO MOVE ON TO OTHER

01:15 - 05.300 OPTIONS. AND THIS IS AGAIN

01:15 - 06.520 WHERE THAT MUTUAL TRUST FOR

01:15 - 07.590 SUCH A LARGE ROLE

01:15 - 08.920 BECAUSE I ONLY PRESCRIBE HIS

01:15 - 10.080 PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS WHEN

01:15 - 12.330 ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY. DOCTOR

01:15 - 13.730 WAS THEIR COMMON PROCEDURE PAIN

01:15 - 14.600 WAY FOR CHECKING WHAT

01:15 - 15.800 MEDICATIONS, YOU'RE PATIENTS

01:15 - 16.380 WERE TAKING.

01:15 - 18.920 >>MINERS KELSEY WOULD

01:15 - 20.050 INTERVIEWED THE PATIENT AND

01:15 - 21.820 FILL UP AND TAKE SHEET WHICH

01:15 - 23.360 WOULD LESS CURRENT MEDICATIONS

01:15 - 25.360 PAIN LEVELS AND STUFF

01:15 - 26.890 LIKE THAT. THIS IS HOW IT'S

01:15 - 28.580 BEEN AROUND SINCE 2010 WHICH

01:15 - 30.360 WHEN CAN WE OWN IT.

01:15 - 31.910 >>WHAT ABOUT CHECKING THE PD M

01:15 - 34.340 P WELL THE PMP HAD JUST BOUGHT

01:15 - 36.700 INTO THIS 2015 SO IS RELATIVELY

01:15 - 37.370 NEW AND NOT A

01:15 - 38.940 LEGAL REQUIREMENT. BUT IT WAS

01:15 - 40.450 SOMETIMES HELPFUL SO I DELEGATE

01:15 - 41.870 AND THEY'RE STILL SEE THE DA

01:15 - 43.560 END OF THE CAMPAIGN. THANK YOU

01:15 - 45.020 DOCTOR. AND I WANT TO TALK

01:15 - 45.800 ABOUT THE REASON WE'RE HERE

01:15 - 48.210 TODAY COACH HAVING MCADOO HOW

01:15 - 49.240 DID YOU MEET THIS PATIENT.

01:15 - 51.150 I WAS FIRST INTRODUCED TO

01:15 - 52.780 COACHELLA MCADOO IN JANUARY

01:15 - 55.410 2014 WHEN JJ TO EVEN REFER TO

01:15 - 57.030 MY CLINIC. IT CAME TO MY

01:15 - 57.960 ATTENTION THAT SHE WAS

01:15 - 59.430 SUFFERING FROM A VERY SERIOUS

01:15 - 00.970 FOR MCCAIN, SO SHE BECAME A

01:16 - 02.990 NATION. AND WHAT KIND OF PAIN

01:16 - 04.190 WAS COACH MCADOO SUFFERING

01:16 - 06.390 FROM. WELL IT'S CALLED PHANTOM

01:16 - 07.810 PAIN AND NOT A LOT IS KNOWN

01:16 - 08.940 ABOUT ACTUALLY AT LEAST HAD A

01:16 - 10.400 TREE THAT IT HAS NO

01:16 - 12.040 IDENTIFIABLE CAUSE SO CANNOT BE

01:16 - 13.850 TARGETED TO X-RAYS OR C T

01:16 - 15.670 STANCE AND ALTHOUGH IT HAS NOW

01:16 - 17.040 IDENTIFIED BECAUSE IT IS STILL

01:16 - 18.940 A VERY SERIOUS VERY REAL FOR

01:16 - 20.670 PAINT. SO HOW DID YOU HELP

01:16 - 21.760 COACH MCADOO WITH

01:16 - 23.980 HER PAIN. I FIRST STARTED

01:16 - 24.890 TREATING COACH WITH THE

01:16 - 26.470 COMBINATION OF ACUPUNCTURE

01:16 - 28.100 MIGHT CAN. NOW THIS IS

01:16 - 29.240 EFFECTIVE IN REDUCING HER

01:16 - 31.040 DISCOMFORT BUT I DECIDED TO

01:16 - 32.490 PRESCRIBE A LOW DOSE MIDDLE

01:16 - 33.730 OPIATE PRESCRIPTION TO

01:16 - 34.790 SUPPLEMENT THE ONGOING

01:16 - 36.430 TREATMENT. THE DOCTOR WANTED

01:16 - 37.510 SOMETHING CLIFF THE MEMBERS OF

01:16 - 37.990 THE JURY.

01:16 - 39.290 DID YOU USE A LIST OF

01:16 - 40.790 TREATMENTS ON COACH MACK DO

01:16 - 41.930 BEFORE DESCRIBING HER

01:16 - 43.190 PRESCRIPTION MEDICATIONS.

01:16 - 45.520 YES, AND THE DIAGNOSIS A SOUND

01:16 - 46.640 AND THESE TREATMENTS WERE

01:16 - 47.970 EFFECTIVE IN REDUCING HER

01:16 - 49.680 DISCOMFORT. THANK YOU DOCTOR.

01:16 - 50.940 I WANT TO FAST FORWARD TO

01:16 - 52.660 DECEMBER, 1620 16.

01:16 - 54.400 DID YOU HAVE AN APPOINTMENT

01:16 - 55.550 WITH COACH MCADOO ON A

01:16 - 57.600 SPECIFIC DATE, YOU KNOW THAT I

01:16 - 58.760 DID NOT IT WAS AT THE END OF

01:16 - 59.990 THE WORKDAY WAS PUTTING ON MY

01:16 - 01.230 COULD LEAVE THE OFFICE

01:17 - 02.430 AND THEN ALL THE SUDDEN ARE

01:17 - 03.970 STILL SHE BURST INTO THE OFFICE

01:17 - 05.320 PRACTICALLY JEN COACH BEHIND

01:17 - 07.000 HER. DOCTORS TO

01:17 - 08.460 YOUR KNOWLEDGE. WHY WAS

01:17 - 10.370 NASHVILLE SEE DRAGGING COACH

01:17 - 10.610 INTO

01:17 - 12.190 YOUR OFFICE, YOU KNOW, I ASKED

01:17 - 13.350 MYSELF THE SAME THING THAT I

01:17 - 14.520 GOT A GOOD LOOK AT COACH.

01:17 - 17.040 SHE WAS SWEATING SHAKING AND

01:17 - 17.150 COULD

01:17 - 19.820 BARELY SPEAK. DOCTOR TELL US

01:17 - 21.220 WHAT WERE YOU THINKING IN THIS

01:17 - 23.350 EXACT MOMENT. I WAS JUST

01:17 - 24.340 THINKING ABOUT HOW URGENT THE

01:17 - 25.690 SITUATION WAS I JUST RUSHED TO

01:17 - 27.390 HELP. I SCANNED OVER THE INTO

01:17 - 28.270 SHE THE NURSE TELLS THE

01:17 - 29.340 PREVIOUSLY FILLED OUT

01:17 - 31.230 AND XANAX WAS NOT ONE OF THE

01:17 - 32.640 CURRENT LIST OF MEDICATIONS.

01:17 - 34.270 YOU HAVE ANY OTHER INQUIRIES

01:17 - 34.820 ABOUT COACHES

01:17 - 36.900 CURRENT MEDICATIONS. YES, I

01:17 - 38.460 SPECIFICALLY ASKED NURSE KELSEY

01:17 - 39.540 IS COACH ON ANY OTHER

01:17 - 41.070 MEDICATIONS, AND THEY'RE STILL

01:17 - 41.590 SHE SAID NO.

01:17 - 43.710 DOCTOR CAN YOU FOR THIS TRACK

01:17 - 44.990 COACH MACK IS CONDITION WHILE

01:17 - 46.230 SHE WAS IN YOUR OFFICE

01:17 - 48.680 LIKE I SAID SHE WAS SWEATING

01:17 - 50.510 SHAKING AND COULD BARELY SPEAK

01:17 - 52.710 THEN HER FACE FOR THEIR TWISTED

01:17 - 54.530 IN AGONY. SHE BEGAN PULLING OUT

01:17 - 56.050 HER OWN HAIR AND YOUR BREATHING

01:17 - 57.380 BECAME VERY RACKET

01:17 - 59.120 DOCTOR WHAT DOES THIS KIND OF

01:17 - 00.810 PRESENTATION ME TO A PAIN

01:18 - 01.560 SPECIALIST.

01:18 - 04.330 SIMPLY PUT SHOESHINE CLEAR

01:18 - 05.640 DIAGNOSTIC SIGNS OF

01:18 - 08.120 OVERWHELMING PAIN. SO WHAT DID

01:18 - 08.910 YOU DO NEXT.

01:18 - 11.120 I DECIDED TO INJECT COACH THE

01:18 - 12.550 SHOT OF HYDROMORPHONE WHICH IS

01:18 - 13.630 A FORM OF THE NIGHT

01:18 - 15.050 AND THEN THIS INJECTION APPEAR

01:18 - 16.450 TO HELP COACH MCADOO IN

01:18 - 18.900 ANY WAY. YES AS SOON AS I GET

01:18 - 20.420 TO THE SHOT COACHES PAINS HIM

01:18 - 21.830 TO BE LIMITED. THANK

01:18 - 23.430 YOU DOCTOR. NOW AS THEY WERE

01:18 - 24.520 PUSHED BACK TO SAUDI PASSED

01:18 - 25.520 AWAY LATER THAT EVENING.

01:18 - 27.130 CAN YOU TELL THE MEMBERS OF THE

01:18 - 28.940 JURY. WELL, YOUR SPONSOR LIST

01:18 - 31.430 OF THIS. COACH KILL ME BECAUSE

01:18 - 31.730 SHE WAS

01:18 - 33.780 IN PAIN. THE PAIN SHE WAS IN

01:18 - 35.340 HAD NO IDENTIFIED THE CAUSE.

01:18 - 36.960 THE FACT IN THE OFFICE TOLD ME

01:18 - 37.860 HER PAYMENTS REAL.

01:18 - 40.240 I ALWAYS DO WHAT IS IN THE BEST

01:18 - 42.530 INTEREST OF MY PATIENTS TO HEAL

01:18 - 44.500 THEIR MIND AND BODY. LIKE I

01:18 - 45.470 SAID THAT'S WHY I BECAME A

01:18 - 47.710 DOCTOR. I'M A HEALER AND I

01:18 - 49.100 WORKED HERE MY PATIENTS PAIN.

01:18 - 51.910 DOCTOR HAS ANYTHING LIKE THIS

01:18 - 53.240 EVER HAPPENED IN PAIN WITH

01:18 - 54.530 HISTORY. YOU KNOW,

01:18 - 56.300 THIS IS THE FIRST TIME ANYTHING

01:18 - 57.840 LIKE THIS OR ANY OVERDOSES EVER

01:18 - 59.060 HAPPENED IN US HISTORY.

01:18 - 02.230 DOCTOR ON DECEMBER 16TH 2016.

01:19 - 04.130 AFTER COACH MCADOO HAD LEFT HER

01:19 - 07.030 OFFICE ARE YOU CONFIDENT IN THE

01:19 - 08.230 TREATMENT TO USED ON HER.

01:19 - 11.010 YES I BELIEVE I DID WHAT ANY

01:19 - 13.200 OTHER DOCTOR DO. I USE MY

01:19 - 15.100 MEDICAL TRAINING MY EXPERIENCE

01:19 - 16.220 IN MY BEST JUDGMENT

01:19 - 18.080 TO ASSESS THE SITUATION AND

01:19 - 19.150 DETERMINE WHAT WAS BEST FOR

01:19 - 20.940 COACHING HER PAIN. THANK YOU

01:19 - 21.760 YOUR HONOR, NO FURTHER

01:19 - 22.950 QUESTIONS THE.

01:19 - 44.600 NOW

01:19 - 45.480 DOCTOR SCHIEFFER

01:19 - 47.290 WHEN YOU OPEN TO PEEL AWAY YOU

01:19 - 48.340 OPENED IT WITH CLOSE TO

01:19 - 50.270 CONTENTIONS CRACKED. YES

01:19 - 52.340 AND SO AS A PART OF LIST A

01:19 - 53.690 TREATMENT UNIT MINISTER URINE

01:19 - 55.190 TEST YOUR PATIENTS RIGHT.

01:19 - 56.810 >>NO I DID NOT I THOUGHT IT WAS

01:19 - 58.540 A SOMEWHAT INVASIVE AND I

01:19 - 00.100 WANTED TO PORTRAY THIS MUTUAL

01:20 - 02.040 TRUST TO MYSELF MY PATIENTS AT

01:20 - 03.410 THIS POINT AS HIS SON DIRECT

01:20 - 04.670 YOUR PRESCRIBING OPIOIDS AS A

01:20 - 04.970 LAST

01:20 - 05.860 RESORT RIGHT.

01:20 - 07.370 >>I WOULD DESCRIBE IN MY

01:20 - 08.930 PATIENTS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING

01:20 - 10.420 RIGHT IN YOUR OKAY PRESCRIPTION

01:20 - 11.890 RATES WERE BELOW 10% WHEN YOU

01:20 - 13.980 FIRST OPENED CORRECT. YES.

01:20 - 16.050 AND THEN HURRICANE SANDY AT

01:20 - 17.950 YOUR CLINIC TINTED YES AND

01:20 - 19.610 THAT'S OUR BANKRUPTCY RIGHT.

01:20 - 21.310 YES, WE HAD A LOT OF FLOOD

01:20 - 22.790 INSURANCE AND EVERYTHING NOT

01:20 - 24.630 COMPLETELY DEMOLISHED THE PLACE

01:20 - 26.340 WHERE AT ALL THE EQUIPMENT AND

01:20 - 27.650 WE UNFORTUNATELY HAD TO DECLARE

01:20 - 29.180 BANKRUPTCY RIGHT THEY ARE ABLE

01:20 - 30.590 TO REOPEN THE CLINIC AGAIN IT

01:20 - 32.190 WAS CRACKED. YES, YOU KNOW,

01:20 - 33.130 SHE'S HAPPY TO PRACTICE

01:20 - 34.650 MEDICINE AGAIN AT THIS POINT

01:20 - 36.120 YOU'RE BOTH PRESCRIPTION RATES

01:20 - 37.420 WERE SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER THAN

01:20 - 38.990 NATIONAL AVERAGE FOR THAT.

01:20 - 40.700 YES, NOT BECAUSE MY PRACTICE

01:20 - 42.450 CHANGE BECAUSE OF THE SHEER

01:20 - 43.730 VOLUME OF PATIENTS WHO NEEDED

01:20 - 44.030 THEM I

01:20 - 46.150 WAS TREATING PEOPLE WHO NEED TO

01:20 - 47.230 GET RIGHT BACK TO WORK YOU

01:20 - 48.530 COLLAR WORKERS PEOPLE WHO

01:20 - 49.970 DIDN'T HAVE THE TIME TO GO DO

01:20 - 51.240 ACUPUNCTURE MIGHT A CANE

01:20 - 52.720 PEOPLE WHO NEED THESE OPIOIDS

01:20 - 53.970 TO SUPPLEMENT THEM THINKING

01:20 - 55.690 DOLLAR SHIP FOR NOW JUST TO BE

01:20 - 57.300 CLEAR. THIS ISN'T THE SAME

01:20 - 58.820 TOWN. WE'RE HOPE YOUR

01:20 - 00.520 PRESCRIPTION RATE WAS 10%

01:21 - 02.030 CORRECT. IT'S AROUND THE SAME

01:21 - 03.190 AREA BUT I WAS STILL TREATING A

01:21 - 04.830 VERY DIFFERENT CLIENTELE BASIS.

01:21 - 06.450 EVEN THOUGH YOU ARE NOW

01:21 - 08.570 PRESCRIBING ALMOST 80% OF YOUR

01:21 - 10.670 PATIENTS OPIOIDS YOU STILL ARE

01:21 - 12.330 RUNNING YOUR TEST CORRECT.

01:21 - 14.610 WHEN THE PRACTICE TO WHEN

01:21 - 15.870 EVERYTHING HAPPENED I STILL

01:21 - 17.110 WANTED TO KEEP THE SAME IDEALS

01:21 - 18.470 I WAS STILL PAIN AWAY.

01:21 - 20.000 SO WANTED TO HAVE THAT MUTUAL

01:21 - 21.200 TRUST BETWEEN MYSELF AND MY

01:21 - 22.780 PATIENTS. THANK YOU NOW, LET'S

01:21 - 23.900 TALK MONEY THAT COULD AFFECT

01:21 - 25.530 YOU. YOU SAID YOU PRESCRIBE

01:21 - 26.600 OPIOIDS AS A LAST

01:21 - 28.330 RESORT, CORRECT. I SAID I

01:21 - 30.030 PRESCRIBE THEM WHEN NECESSARY.

01:21 - 32.070 SO IT WAS NECESSARY TO BE

01:21 - 33.330 PRESCRIBING ROCKS A COAT AND

01:21 - 33.760 FOR NEARLY

01:21 - 37.570 3 YEARS. COACH TO SUFFER FROM

01:21 - 39.230 PHANTOM PAIN AND I STARTED OFF

01:21 - 41.220 WITH A CONCUSSION LIKE A CANE

01:21 - 42.620 AND BECAUSE PHANTOM PAIN A

01:21 - 43.970 SNOWMAN TO PAIN AND THERE'S NO

01:21 - 45.370 IDENTIFIED THE CAUSE IT

01:21 - 46.440 TECHNICALLY CANNOT BE TREATED

01:21 - 47.620 WITH ACUPUNCTURE AND I BECAME

01:21 - 49.060 SO I DID SEE OPIOIDS IN A

01:21 - 50.460 SERIOUS SITUATION THAT SHE

01:21 - 51.690 COULDN'T IS HIGHLY ADDICTIVE

01:21 - 53.510 ISN'T IT. IN CERTAIN CASES IT

01:21 - 55.090 CAN BE AND YOU'RE PRESCRIBING

01:21 - 57.090 CONTRACT TO FOX TO CUT IT FOR 3

01:21 - 59.170 YEARS RIGHT. BUT YES BECAUSE I

01:21 - 01.150 STOPPED AND SITUATION. NOW

01:22 - 02.590 LET'S TALK ABOUT DECEMBER, 16

01:22 - 04.780 COACH MAC AND YOU CAN CORRECT.

01:22 - 07.480 YES AND YOU HAD YOUR STARTED IN

01:22 - 07.710 TAKE

01:22 - 09.280 SHE CRACKED. YES, IT IS

01:22 - 10.240 STANDARD PROCEDURE AT THE

01:22 - 11.810 OFFICE AND THIS IS WHAT YOU

01:22 - 13.510 RELIED UPON BEFORE TREATING

01:22 - 14.720 COULD NOT DO CRACKED,

01:22 - 16.330 I'VE RELIED UPON THEIR SKILLS

01:22 - 17.780 GOING UP INTO SHE AND ALSO

01:22 - 19.320 NURSE KELLY THERE'S COUNTY

01:22 - 20.960 CHECKING THE PD AND GET BUT AS

01:22 - 22.350 YOU SAY IN YOUR DRAFT COACH

01:22 - 24.050 MCADOO COULD BARELY SPEAK

01:22 - 26.690 COUNTRY. SHE WAS SWEATING AND

01:22 - 28.160 SHAKING AND COULD BARELY SPEAK

01:22 - 29.610 RIGHT WHEN YOU SLIDE IT IN TAKE

01:22 - 31.050 SHE THE PATIENT

01:22 - 32.760 SPEAKS TO THE NURSE ABOUT WHAT

01:22 - 33.860 IS GOING TO BE FILLED OUT AND

01:22 - 35.290 TAKE SHE IS NOT RIGHT, YES, AND

01:22 - 36.210 THAT'S WHY EXPECTING NURSE

01:22 - 37.600 TELLS YOU TO DO IS YELL THIS

01:22 - 38.870 DOESN'T CHECK THE PNP TO

01:22 - 39.200 CONFIRM

01:22 - 40.940 THESE MEDICATIONS. BUT YOU

01:22 - 42.160 GREETED HIS COUSIN THERE WASN'T

01:22 - 43.640 TIME TO CHECK THE PDA P ON THAT

01:22 - 45.480 DAY CORRECT AND NOT THAT THERE

01:22 - 47.470 WASN'T TIME TO CHECK THE WHEN

01:22 - 49.020 THE WHOLE SITUATION SAID WENT

01:22 - 50.280 DOWN. SHE SAID WE DON'T HAVE

01:22 - 52.150 TIME AND TIME FOR THIS NIGHT TO

01:22 - 53.590 THAT AS YOU DON'T HAVE TIME FOR

01:22 - 54.600 THIS CONVERSATION YOU HAVE TO

01:22 - 55.840 TRUST ME TO DO MY JOB.

01:22 - 57.180 WELL YOU TAKE THE PATIENT BACK

01:22 - 58.640 IN THE TREES ARE SO YOU HAVE

01:22 - 00.240 TIME FOR THIS THE YOU HAD TIME

01:23 - 01.910 TO STOP AND HAVE THE PATIENTS

01:23 - 03.590 SIGN A WAIVER THAT LEAVES

01:23 - 05.600 YOU LIABILITY. IT IS GENERAL

01:23 - 06.890 PRACTICE BECAUSE OF THE DOSAGE

01:23 - 09.740 OF THE. SHOT BUT WHILE SHE WAS

01:23 - 11.330 SIGNING THIS WEAVER, YOU KNOW

01:23 - 12.360 THAT SHOULD BE UP HE WASN'T

01:23 - 13.340 GETTING CHECKED CRACKED.

01:23 - 15.160 I RELY ON THEIR SKILLS TO DO

01:23 - 17.480 SO. SO JUST TO BE CLEAR TO

01:23 - 19.540 THE JURY. YOU GAVE PUSH BACK

01:23 - 21.210 INTO A STRONG SHOT OF

01:23 - 23.790 HYDROMORPHONE CRACKED YES TO

01:23 - 24.520 RELIEVE HER PAIN

01:23 - 26.210 HAVING NEVER MINISTER URINE

01:23 - 27.610 TEST IN HER ENTIRE COURSE OF

01:23 - 29.310 TREATMENT CRACKED AGAIN I

01:23 - 30.850 THOUGHT IT WAS INVASIVE AND I

01:23 - 31.450 WANT TO COME

01:23 - 33.450 KEEP THAT MUTUAL TRUST BETWEEN

01:23 - 35.210 MYSELF MY PATIENTS AND RELYING

01:23 - 36.780 ON YOUR NURSE AND THE WORD OF

01:23 - 37.960 THE NOT THE PATIENT COULD

01:23 - 39.960 BARELY SPEAK THE FORMER TO

01:23 - 41.860 TREATMENT I RELIED ON NURSE

01:23 - 43.150 KELSEY FILLING UP THE INTAKE,

01:23 - 44.480 SHE'S SPEAKING TO THE PATIENT

01:23 - 45.700 AND THEN HER FURTHERMORE

01:23 - 48.010 CHECKING THE PNP TO CONFIRM THE

01:23 - 49.590 CURRENT MEDICATIONS JUST

01:23 - 52.020 BE CLEAR. YOU ARE IN CHARGE OF

01:23 - 53.060 PAINT WHITE CORRECT.

01:23 - 54.890 YES, I AM IN CHARGE AND BEING

01:23 - 56.400 IN CHARGE ME AND I CAN DELEGATE

01:23 - 57.510 CERTAIN RESPONSIBILITIES TO

01:23 - 58.980 PEOPLE WHO ALSO WERE CAMPAIGN

01:23 - 00.030 OF COURSE, BUT IN THE END OF

01:24 - 01.470 THE DAY YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR

01:24 - 02.760 HAPPENS AT YOUR CLINIC IS

01:24 - 04.080 NOT RIGHT. YES, I AM

01:24 - 05.830 RESPONSIBLE BUT I CAN STILL

01:24 - 07.080 DELEGATE RESPONSIBILITIES TO

01:24 - 08.880 PEOPLE WHO WORK AT MY CLINIC OF

01:24 - 10.700 COURSE OUT COACH MCADOO DIED OF

01:24 - 12.850 A COMBINATION OF OPIOIDS AND

01:24 - 15.240 XANAX CRACKED. YES, HE THAT IS

01:24 - 16.200 SHOE BUT WHEN I LOOKED A

01:24 - 18.230 TOXICOLOGY REPORTS LOVE IS A

01:24 - 19.460 MEDICATION THAT ARE PRESCRIBED

01:24 - 20.180 TOO MUCH HIGHER

01:24 - 21.820 SO REGARDLESS THESE ARE OPIOIDS

01:24 - 23.480 THAT YOU ARE PRESCRIBING FOR 3

01:24 - 25.270 YEARS TO COACH MCADOO CRACKED

01:24 - 26.400 YES, BUT THEY WERE MUCH HIGHER

01:24 - 27.600 THAN WHEN I FIRST GOT IT,

01:24 - 28.570 THANKS YOUR HONOR FOR

01:24 - 29.690 QUESTIONS. THANK YOU.

01:24 - 46.400 THE PARTNERSHIP FOR WHOSE JOB

01:24 - 47.660 WAS IT TO CHECK THE P A P

01:24 - 49.280 IT WAS ALWAYS NURSE TELLS HIS

01:24 - 50.920 JOB TO CHECK THE PNP AND PHIL

01:24 - 51.700 CAN TAKE SHEET AT

01:24 - 53.710 THE OFFICE DOCTOR WHO PUT UP

01:24 - 55.320 THE INTAKE SHE ON DECEMBER 16TH

01:24 - 57.340 2016. THEY'RE STILL SEE THAT

01:24 - 58.400 THANK YOU ARE NO FURTHER

01:24 - 59.340 QUESTIONS HERE.

01:25 - 04.860 AFTER SHE FOR HIS NAME IS ON

01:25 - 06.020 THE PRESCRIPTIONS THAT YOU

01:25 - 07.740 PRESCRIBE DOES NOT CUT IT, I

01:25 - 09.280 PRESCRIBE THEM. THANK YOU FOR

01:25 - 10.340 THE QUESTIONS THANK YOU.

01:25 - 25.590 THE DEFENSE CALLS MUST SOW

01:25 - 26.430 ADDED TO THE STAND.

01:25 - 37.970 THEY STAND IN FOR

01:25 - 40.450 THE JURY SAL AT IT THIS AD IT

01:25 - 41.190 WHAT IS YOUR CURRENT

01:25 - 42.800 OCCUPATION. WELL I AM A

01:25 - 44.340 CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER A

01:25 - 46.160 CERTIFIED ACTUARY AND CERTIFIED

01:25 - 47.800 PUBLIC ACCOUNTANT AND WHERE YOU

01:25 - 49.200 CURRENTLY EMPLOYED OUT AT THE

01:25 - 50.550 PAY TO A CLINIC WIND THE DE

01:25 - 52.150 FACTO ACCOUNTANT WHAT ARE YOU

01:25 - 53.430 ABLE TO DO AS THE DEFACTO

01:25 - 55.230 COUNTER PAIN AWAY. WELL I'M

01:25 - 57.970 ABLE TO REVIEW ASSESS ANALYZE

01:25 - 58.830 AND DETERMINE WHETHER THE

01:25 - 00.410 BUSINESS IS FINANCIALLY STABLE

01:26 - 00.790 OR NOT.

01:26 - 02.050 >>AND WHAT WAS THE FINANCIAL

01:26 - 03.400 STATUS OF THE PAIN TO A CLINIC

01:26 - 03.490 IN

01:26 - 07.010 2016. I'M A 2016 THE CLIENTELE

01:26 - 09.150 HAS SHIFTED FROM CELEBRITIES TO

01:26 - 10.240 BLUE COLLAR WORKERS.

01:26 - 11.770 >>AND DOCTOR SHAFER IS WORKING

01:26 - 13.010 REALLY HARD AND ALL THE

01:26 - 14.330 FINANCIAL PROBLEMS APPEAR TO BE

01:26 - 15.100 IN THE REARVIEW MIRROR.

01:26 - 16.690 >>IS IT THROUGH EMPLOYMENT THAT

01:26 - 17.760 YOU MET DOCTOR SHAFER

01:26 - 20.720 NO ACTUALLY I HAD A BAD FALL OF

01:26 - 22.890 SKIING IN WYOMING IN TUSCANY I

01:26 - 24.480 BROKE MY COLLARBONE SEPARATED A

01:26 - 25.970 SHOULDER EVEN TO MY ROTATOR

01:26 - 28.430 CUFF FOR 3 YEARS NOTHING WORK

01:26 - 30.330 TO ALLEVIATE MY PAIN. I WAS IN

01:26 - 31.530 AN OCEAN OF PAIN

01:26 - 32.710 AND THAT'S WHEN I STARTED TO

01:26 - 33.750 SEEK OUT OF PAIN MANAGEMENT

01:26 - 35.150 SPECIALIST AND I DECIDED ONE

01:26 - 37.000 DOCTOR SHAFER WELL WHAT MADE

01:26 - 38.320 YOU SELECT DOCTOR SHAFER HAS

01:26 - 40.010 YOUR PAIN MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST

01:26 - 41.700 DOCTOR SHAFER HAD A REALLY GOOD

01:26 - 43.190 REPUTATION FOR USING HOLISTIC

01:26 - 43.860 METHODS TO TREAT

01:26 - 45.860 THEIR PATIENTS. ASSAULT ALSO

01:26 - 46.980 RECOMMENDED TO SOME OTHER

01:26 - 48.180 DOCTORS SUCH AS DOCTOR

01:26 - 50.160 PHIL HARRISON BUT I DO NOT WANT

01:26 - 51.310 TO ATTEND SAYS HE HAD A

01:26 - 52.630 REPUTATION FOR JUST GIVING OUT

01:26 - 53.870 PILLS OF THE FIRST AS IT

01:26 - 55.730 HOW LONG DID YOU THEN SHE WITH

01:26 - 57.370 DOCTOR SHE FOR 4. FOR

01:26 - 58.810 4 MONTHS. DOCTOR

01:26 - 59.720 SCHIEFFER SHE ME WITH

01:26 - 01.870 EVERYTHING FROM ACUPUNCTURE

01:27 - 04.640 TOPICAL CREAMS TO EVEN A VERY

01:27 - 06.330 LOW DOSE OPIOID MEDICATION

01:27 - 08.340 AND AFTER THOSE 4 MONTHS I WAS

01:27 - 10.680 COMPLETELY PAIN FREE. I HAD MY

01:27 - 12.290 LIFE BACK. I WAS EVEN BACK TO

01:27 - 14.240 PLAY BASKETBALL. TO DOCTOR

01:27 - 15.990 SHAFER WAS THE BEST DECISION I

01:27 - 17.750 EVER MADE. NUMBNESS ATTA AND

01:27 - 19.030 LIKE TO SHIFT YOUR ATTENTION TO

01:27 - 20.250 ANOTHER PATIENT OF THE PAIN WE

01:27 - 22.250 CLINIC COACH HAVING MCADOO DID

01:27 - 24.150 YOU KNOW COACH MCADOO YEAH

01:27 - 25.420 COACH WASN'T JUST MY FRIEND,

01:27 - 27.350 SHE WAS MY ROLE MODEL. WELL HOW

01:27 - 28.160 LONG DID YOU KNOW YOUR ROLE

01:27 - 30.150 MODEL FOR I KNEW COACH THAT

01:27 - 32.170 ENDED WITH THE HIGH SCHOOL AND

01:27 - 33.260 DURING THEIR FRIENDSHIP SHE

01:27 - 35.310 TAUGHT ME SO MANY LIFE VALUES.

01:27 - 36.700 WELL CAN YOU FORM THE JURY OF

01:27 - 37.930 SOME OF THOSE LIFE VALUES THAT

01:27 - 39.090 YOUR ROLE MODEL HAD TAUGHT YOU.

01:27 - 41.920 COACH I EST YOU WORK HARD AND

01:27 - 42.510 YOU PLAY HARD.

01:27 - 44.400 HE TAUGHT US TO BE TOUGH AND HE

01:27 - 46.320 NEVER HAD ANY REGRETS AND THIS

01:27 - 47.620 IS HOW SHE LIVED EVERY MINUTE

01:27 - 48.250 OF HER LIFE

01:27 - 50.030 AT LEAST UNTIL HE LEFT WITH THE

01:27 - 51.920 HIGH SCHOOL AT THE END OF 2013.

01:27 - 53.710 WELL WHAT CHANGES DID YOU

01:27 - 56.080 OBSERVE IN 2013 WITH ACCIDENT.

01:27 - 57.690 WELL AFTER SHE LEFT HER JOB.

01:27 - 59.540 HER HUSBAND HAD DIED OF CANCER.

01:28 - 01.760 AND SHE STARTED TO COMPLAIN YOU

01:28 - 02.970 MORE AND MORE ABOUT

01:28 - 05.440 HER PAIN. SHE EVEN START USING

01:28 - 07.220 A WALKER SOMETIMES SHE LOOKS

01:28 - 09.200 ROUGH. SHE BECAME A DIFFERENT

01:28 - 12.080 PERSON, A SATURN PERSON, ALMOST

01:28 - 14.010 A MOROSE PERSON. WELL DID YOU

01:28 - 15.240 DO ANYTHING TO HELP HER OUT OF

01:28 - 17.110 THIS STAGE OF COURSE

01:28 - 19.400 I DID I TOOK HER OUT TO EAT AND

01:28 - 21.010 OVER WHEREVER SHE NEEDED TO GO

01:28 - 22.960 LIKE TO DOCTOR TO THE PHARMACY

01:28 - 24.370 IS IT THROUGH THESE PHARMACY

01:28 - 25.480 VISITS THEY LEARNED FROM COACH

01:28 - 26.040 IS TREATING WITH.

01:28 - 28.700 YES, LIMIT COACHES CHEATING A

01:28 - 30.230 DOCTOR THAT THE HAIRS AND THE

01:28 - 31.850 SAME DOCUMENT NOT WATCHING MY

01:28 - 33.880 PAIN. SO WHEN I HEARD THIS I

01:28 - 34.930 KNEW THINGS HAVE GOTTEN BAD.

01:28 - 36.120 DID YOU EVER AND

01:28 - 37.550 DOCTOR SHAFER OF ANY YOUR

01:28 - 40.210 CONCERNS WITH COACH MCADOO NO

01:28 - 42.130 THAT WAS NOT MY PLACE AT ALL I

01:28 - 43.170 LOVE TO COACH THE TELLER

01:28 - 44.600 POSITION WHAT SHE HAD TO KNOW.

01:28 - 46.510 I RESPECTED HER PRIVACY AND I

01:28 - 47.830 AM NOT A MEDICAL EXPERT.

01:28 - 49.850 NOW I'D LIKE TO SHIFT ATTENTION

01:28 - 50.870 BACK SHARE PERSONAL

01:28 - 51.680 RELATIONSHIP WITH

01:28 - 54.060 COACH MCADOO CAN YOU FORM A

01:28 - 55.950 JURY OF YOUR LAST INTERACTION

01:28 - 57.610 WITH YOUR ROLE MODEL COACH

01:28 - 58.080 MCADOO.

01:28 - 01.000 >>JUST A FEW DAYS BEFORE SHE

01:29 - 02.870 DIED. I WALKED INSIDE HER

01:29 - 05.470 APARTMENT AFTER FOR THIS IT AND

01:29 - 07.640 IT WAS A MESS. THERE WERE DIRTY

01:29 - 09.710 DISHES STACKED IN SYNC AND

01:29 - 10.790 THERE'S GARBAGE ALL OVER THE

01:29 - 12.900 FLOOR. THERE IS PILL BOTTLES

01:29 - 14.650 EVERYWHERE AND HALF OF HER

01:29 - 16.030 TROPHY CASE WAS JUST

01:29 - 18.470 SCATTERED AROUND. SHE KICKS

01:29 - 20.080 SOME DEGREE ASIDE AND JUST

01:29 - 21.810 COLLAPSED INTO A CHAIR NEXT THE

01:29 - 25.470 TV. SHE TO ME OUT AND WAS OFTEN

01:29 - 26.740 YOUR OWN WORLD. NO

01:29 - 28.100 MATTER WHAT I WOULD SAY OR WHAT

01:29 - 29.810 I WOULD DO SHE JUST WENT

01:29 - 30.660 RESPOND TO ME.

01:29 - 32.800 I HATE THIS IS THE LAST IMAGE

01:29 - 34.420 OF COACHING, MY MIND. NO

01:29 - 35.440 FURTHER QUESTIONS YOUR HONOR.

01:29 - 56.890 TAKE THE SEAT

01:29 - 58.300 YOU MAKE GOOD AFTERNOON THE

01:29 - 59.430 SOUTH THAT IF YOU CAN

01:29 - 02.110 SO DO YOUR CLOSE RELATIONSHIP

01:30 - 03.810 WITH COACH MCADOO YOU ARE ABLE

01:30 - 05.260 TO OBSERVE A CHANGE IN HER

01:30 - 07.510 BEHAVIOR AROUND 2012 IS THAT

01:30 - 08.070 CORRECT.

01:30 - 10.720 >>IT WAS MORALLY 2013 AFTER SHE

01:30 - 12.050 LEFT HER JOB AND THEY'RE ON THE

01:30 - 13.160 SAME TIME HER HUSBAND HAD

01:30 - 16.310 PASSED AWAY IN IN 2013. YOU

01:30 - 18.470 FOUND HER PASSED OUT OUTSIDE A

01:30 - 20.500 BAR. THAT'S CORRECT. YES, A

01:30 - 22.430 BIT. AND MORE PREJUDICIAL

01:30 - 24.390 THAN PROBATIVE THIS INCIDENT IN

01:30 - 25.700 WHICH CO COUNSELS REFERRING TO

01:30 - 27.230 HAPPENED YEARS PRIOR TO THE

01:30 - 28.670 DEATH OF COACH HAVING A CANOE

01:30 - 29.950 AND IT'S A RELEVANT AND MORE

01:30 - 31.100 PREJUDICIAL IN PROGRESS AND THE

01:30 - 31.350 FACT

01:30 - 33.330 THAT IT PROBABLY THAT IS

01:30 - 34.710 SUBSTANTIALLY NOT OUTWEIGHED BY

01:30 - 35.550 THE PREJUDICIAL VALUE.

01:30 - 38.710 IT HAS. YOU NOTICE, CAN ALLOWED

01:30 - 39.760 TO CONTINUE WITH THIS LINE OF

01:30 - 41.350 QUESTIONING. IT WILL BECOME

01:30 - 43.710 CLEAR THAT SCHAEFER HAD AMPLE

01:30 - 45.160 OPPORTUNITY TO KNOW THAT THIS

01:30 - 46.270 INCIDENT HAD OCCURRED

01:30 - 47.980 AND THEN PROCEEDED TO PRESCRIBE

01:30 - 49.920 OPIOIDS TO SOMEONE WHO HAD BEEN

01:30 - 51.710 UNCONSCIOUS OUTSIDE A BAR,

01:30 - 53.420 THIS GOES DIRECTLY TO THE FACE

01:30 - 54.880 OF DOCTOR SHAFER IN TREATING A

01:30 - 56.710 PATIENT WHO WAS CLEARLY NOT IN

01:30 - 58.080 A GOOD MENTAL OR EMOTIONAL

01:30 - 00.080 STATE. I MADE THIS INCIDENT IS

01:31 - 01.240 NOT RELEVANT IN THE FACT THAT

01:31 - 01.930 HAPPENED MANY

01:31 - 03.320 YEARS PRIOR ALONG WITH THE FACT

01:31 - 04.650 THAT DOCTOR SHAFER IS THE PAIN

01:31 - 05.850 MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST FOR

01:31 - 07.640 COACH MCADOO THAT SHIP IS NOT

01:31 - 08.980 HER PSYCHOLOGIST OR THERAPIST

01:31 - 09.910 WHO SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF

01:31 - 10.880 THIS CERTAIN SITUATION THAT

01:31 - 12.140 HAPPENED OUTSIDE OF THE PAIN

01:31 - 13.190 AWAY CLINIC THAT COULD BE

01:31 - 14.380 AFFECTED HER TREATMENT

01:31 - 15.740 THEREFORE ITS MORE PREJUDICIAL

01:31 - 16.830 AND IRRELEVANT.

01:31 - 18.650 THERE ARE THIS IS RELEVANT

01:31 - 19.690 BECAUSE THIS IS RIGHT AT THE

01:31 - 21.140 BEGINNING OF DOCTOR SHE FIRST

01:31 - 23.120 SHIPMENT OF COACH MCADOO AND

01:31 - 24.920 ANY TREATMENT BY DOCTOR SHAFER

01:31 - 26.990 OF COACH MCADOO IS RELEVANT TO

01:31 - 28.290 THE TREATMENT OF HER ON THE DAY

01:31 - 28.890 OF HER DEATH.

01:31 - 30.350 ADDITIONALLY THIS IS NOT

01:31 - 31.920 PREJUDICIAL NOT ONLY IS COACH

01:31 - 33.820 MCADOO NOT ON TRIAL OR EVEN IN

01:31 - 35.440 THE COURTROOM TODAY. BUT THIS

01:31 - 36.690 GOES DIRECTLY TO DOCTOR

01:31 - 38.190 SCHAEFER'S KNOWLEDGE OF COACH

01:31 - 39.960 MACK AND HIS MENTAL STATE WHILE

01:31 - 40.260 TREATING

01:31 - 41.810 THE PATIENT WHICH AGAIN GOES

01:31 - 43.310 DIRECTLY TO DOCTOR. SHE FIRST

01:31 - 44.250 FAITH WHILE TREATING

01:31 - 45.000 COACH MCADOO.

01:31 - 46.860 >>I'M DOING A REALLY INJECTION

01:31 - 49.080 THE SCENE BECAUSE YES RIGHT.

01:31 - 52.250 >>YOU SOUND COACH MCADOO

01:31 - 53.770 UNFORTUNATELY UNCONSCIOUS

01:31 - 55.590 OUTSIDE A BAR CRACKED. YES,

01:31 - 57.140 THEY DID SHE WAS IN HER CAR AND

01:31 - 58.200 THIS WAS IN DECEMBER OF

01:31 - 01.340 2013. YES AND DOCTOR SHAFER TO

01:32 - 02.470 YOUR KNOWLEDGE BEGAN TREATING

01:32 - 04.060 COACH MCADOO IN JANUARY OF

01:32 - 06.400 2014. YES TO MY KNOWLEDGE THAT

01:32 - 06.800 IS TRUE

01:32 - 08.820 AND YOU THOUGHT MISS ABBOTT

01:32 - 10.620 THAT IT WOULD BE REASONABLE FOR

01:32 - 12.080 PEOPLE IT WAS A WEEK TO KNOW

01:32 - 13.000 THAT THIS HAD HAPPENED.

01:32 - 15.910 I NOTICE IS

01:32 - 17.050 CHANGING COACH AND I WANT TO

01:32 - 18.060 SEE IF OTHER PEOPLE HAVE

01:32 - 19.200 NOTICED I'M SORRY MAY'S

01:32 - 20.460 MISUNDERSTOOD YOU THOUGHT IT

01:32 - 21.850 WOULD BE REASONABLE FOR PEOPLE

01:32 - 23.730 TO KNOW THAT COACH MCADOO HAVE

01:32 - 25.120 BEEN UNCONSCIOUS, CORRECT.

01:32 - 28.210 YES, I WAS CONTENT THAT FINALLY

01:32 - 30.080 MISS ABBOTT AS THE COUNTER THAT

01:32 - 31.880 PAIN AWAY. YOU HAVE ACCESS TO

01:32 - 32.050 THEIR

01:32 - 34.630 FINANCIAL RECORDS. YES, THEY DO

01:32 - 36.500 YOU HAVE ACCESS TO SOME OF

01:32 - 37.700 DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S FINANCIAL

01:32 - 39.170 DECISIONS ABOUT PAIN AWAY.

01:32 - 40.200 YES, I DO.

01:32 - 42.700 AND WELL DOCTOR SHAFER WAS

01:32 - 44.040 SITTING COACH MCADOO

01:32 - 45.780 COACH MCADOO WAS RUNNING FOR

01:32 - 47.280 REELECTION FOR CITY COUNCIL

01:32 - 50.110 RIGHT. YES THAT ISSUE AND THIS

01:32 - 51.440 AT IT YOU ARE UNDER THE

01:32 - 53.240 IMPRESSION THAT COACH MCADOO

01:32 - 54.840 WOULDN'T WIN BECAUSE HER

01:32 - 56.880 CONDITION WAS SUPPORT RELEVANCE

01:32 - 58.540 TO COACH MCADOO AND RUNNING FOR

01:32 - 01.320 REELECTION. THEY ARE. PUSH BACK

01:33 - 02.580 AT HIS CONDITION WHILE RUNNING

01:33 - 03.740 FOR CITY COUNCIL,

01:33 - 05.170 ISRAEL'S AND BECAUSE DOCTOR

01:33 - 06.400 SHAFER WOULD HAVE BEEN AWARE OF

01:33 - 07.420 HER CONDITION AS

01:33 - 08.800 MISS OUT AND IT JUST STATED

01:33 - 10.370 PEOPLE WAS WE ARE AWARE OF EACH

01:33 - 12.550 OTHER'S LIVES. AND SO ASSAD THE

01:33 - 13.210 EXCUSE ME

01:33 - 15.220 IS MCADOO WAS RUNNING FOR CITY

01:33 - 16.790 COUNCIL AND HER CONDITION WAS

01:33 - 17.820 KNOWN TO BE POUR

01:33 - 19.120 THAT GOES DIRECTLY TO HOW

01:33 - 20.550 DOCTOR SCHIEFFER CHOSE TO TREAT

01:33 - 22.240 HER WITH KNOWLEDGE OF HER POOR

01:33 - 25.000 TIME A COUNCIL CANNOT ESTABLISH

01:33 - 26.400 WHAT THESE FACTORS WERE THAT

01:33 - 27.670 APPLIED TO THE REASON THAT

01:33 - 28.900 SHE'S ACTING OUT THEY COULD

01:33 - 30.080 HAVE BEEN STRESSED DUE TO HER

01:33 - 32.260 REELECTED DUE TO ELECTION FOR

01:33 - 32.780 CAMPAIGN.

01:33 - 34.070 >>ALONG WITH THE FACT THAT THIS

01:33 - 36.050 HAS NO DOES NOT MAKE ANY FACT

01:33 - 37.210 IN TONIGHT'S CASE MORE OR LESS

01:33 - 38.210 LIKELY AND IT'S

01:33 - 40.000 NOT RELEVANT. YOU KNOW FOR ME I

01:33 - 41.270 DIDN'T STATE THAT COACH MCADOO

01:33 - 43.150 WAS ACTING OUT I DIDN'T IN FACT

01:33 - 44.450 STATE ANYTHING ABOUT THIS MAC

01:33 - 44.540 AND

01:33 - 46.670 HIS BEHAVIOR SIMPLY ASKED MISS

01:33 - 47.860 ABBOTT WHETHER OR NOT SHE WAS

01:33 - 49.260 UNDER THE IMPRESSION THE COACH

01:33 - 50.380 MCADOO IS CONDITION WAS

01:33 - 53.140 DETERIORATING AND SINCE SHE'S

01:33 - 54.290 ALREADY STATED THAT

01:33 - 55.450 IT WOULD BE REASONABLE FOR

01:33 - 56.890 DOCTOR SHAFER TO KNOW THAT SHE

01:33 - 58.090 HAD BEEN PASSED OUT OUTSIDE A

01:33 - 59.310 BAR. IT WOULD THEN BE

01:33 - 00.750 REASONABLE FOR DOCTOR SHAFER TO

01:34 - 01.710 KNOW THAT HER CONDITION

01:34 - 04.150 WAS DETERIORATING. THE ARGUMENT

01:34 - 05.410 THAT I'D SWITCH MY OBJECTION TO

01:34 - 06.600 THIS QUESTION IS CALLING FIRST

01:34 - 07.720 CLEAR SPECULATION BY MY

01:34 - 09.330 WITH US THE HONOR SINCE

01:34 - 10.720 OBJECTION HAS BEEN SWITCHED, I

01:34 - 11.590 WOULD ARGUE THAT

01:34 - 13.010 SINCE THIS HAPPENED JUST SAID

01:34 - 14.140 THAT PEOPLE IN WAS THAT WE ARE

01:34 - 15.290 AWARE OF EACH OTHER'S LIVES,

01:34 - 16.210 THIS IS NOT CALL FOR

01:34 - 17.930 SPECULATION THAT'S A VERY

01:34 - 18.980 DETAILS CALLING FOR

01:34 - 20.490 SPECULATION, IT'S VERY DETAIL

01:34 - 22.330 AND A PRECISE ACCUSATION TO

01:34 - 23.780 MAKE THEIR FOR THE SPECULATION

01:34 - 25.450 IS NOT ACTUALLY BASED ON ANY

01:34 - 27.030 PERCEPTION BE HONEST. I'M VERY

01:34 - 28.280 DETAIL WHETHER OR NOT COACH

01:34 - 29.440 MACK AND HIS CONDITION WAS

01:34 - 30.840 KNOWN TO BE DETERIORATING,

01:34 - 32.470 ESPECIALLY BY SOMEONE WHO HAD A

01:34 - 33.900 CLOSE RELATIONSHIP WITH MISS

01:34 - 34.470 MCADOO.

01:34 - 35.860 >>THEY'RE GOING TO SUSTAIN THE

01:34 - 38.890 OBJECTION NOW YOU'RE FREE TO

01:34 - 40.670 DEVELOP FOR TRYING TO SOW MUCH

01:34 - 42.350 MORE FOUNDATION AND ASK AGAIN.

01:34 - 44.340 WITHOUT PREJUDICE. YOU

01:34 - 45.590 REASON THAT DIRECTION AGAIN AND

01:34 - 46.980 YOU ARE PERCENT TO 6. LET ME I

01:34 - 48.090 ASKED TO STRIKE ANY TESTIMONY

01:34 - 50.410 OR FRONT WAS GRANTED THINK YES,

01:34 - 53.750 >>COACH MCADOO RAN FOR

01:34 - 55.420 REELECTION FOR CITY COUNCIL

01:34 - 56.680 WHILE SHE WAS BEING TREATED BY

01:34 - 58.410 DOCTOR SHAFER IS THAT CORRECT.

01:34 - 59.950 >>YES THAT IS CORRECT AND THIS

01:34 - 01.490 OF IT YOU'RE UNDER THE

01:35 - 03.350 IMPRESSION THAT COACH MCADOO

01:35 - 05.320 WOULDN'T WIN BECAUSE HER

01:35 - 07.460 CONDITION WAS SO BAD IS

01:35 - 09.170 THAT CORRECT THE RUSSIAN PROBE

01:35 - 10.780 OF AND RELEVANCE WE JUST

01:35 - 12.820 ESTABLISHED THAT ANY FACTOR OF

01:35 - 13.910 THE STRESS THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN

01:35 - 15.470 EXHIBITED BY COACH MCADOO FOR

01:35 - 17.070 THIS ELECTION IS NOT RELEVANT

01:35 - 18.250 TO MAKE THE CASE NOT A LOT OF

01:35 - 19.480 SUFFERING TO COACH MCADOO

01:35 - 20.710 STRESS AND THE FRONT OF HER

01:35 - 21.740 CONDITION THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN

01:35 - 23.540 WELL KNOWN TO THE PEOPLE OF WAS

01:35 - 25.430 A WEEK DURING THE TREATMENT OF

01:35 - 26.780 HER BY THE DEFENDANT.

01:35 - 28.770 >>AND A QUESTION OVER THE HEAD

01:35 - 31.760 ASKED THE QUESTION JUST POLICE

01:35 - 32.270 SO.

01:35 - 34.200 >>YOU WERE UNDER THE IMPRESSION

01:35 - 36.030 THAT COACH MCADOO WOULDN'T WIN

01:35 - 37.630 BECAUSE HER CONDITION WAS SO

01:35 - 38.590 BAD CORRECT.

01:35 - 40.670 >>YES WHEN SHE WAS ELECTED SHE

01:35 - 42.140 WAS THE OLD VERSION OF COACH

01:35 - 44.650 AND SHE HAD THIS PERSONALITY

01:35 - 46.160 SWITCH AND AS SHE WAS RUNNING

01:35 - 47.690 AND IT THIS NEW COACH

01:35 - 49.830 SHE WAS NOT AS SHE USED TO

01:35 - 51.640 BE RIGHT AND THIS WAS WHILE

01:35 - 53.350 DOCTOR SHAFER WAS TREATING HER

01:35 - 55.100 CORRECT. YES, THIS IS ALSO

01:35 - 56.300 AFTER SHE LEFT HER JOB AND HER

01:35 - 57.780 COST OF A HIT BUT JUST TO BE

01:35 - 58.760 CLEAR MISS ABBOTT.

01:35 - 00.110 >>YOU ALREADY SAID THAT IT

01:36 - 01.470 WOULD BE REASONABLE FOR PEOPLE

01:36 - 02.740 WHO WAS A WEEK TO KNOW A FAIR

01:36 - 03.730 AMOUNT ABOUT EACH OTHER'S

01:36 - 05.030 LIVES, CORRECT. IT'S A

01:36 - 06.610 THEN ANSWERED, IT'S BEEN LONG

01:36 - 08.250 ESTABLISHED THIS FACT THAT I'M

01:36 - 09.440 JUST CLARIFY FOR THE CHURCH.

01:36 - 12.840 IT'S A FAIRLY SMALL TOWN SO

01:36 - 13.640 EVERYONE KIND OF KNOWS

01:36 - 15.490 EVERYBODY ELSE NOTHING FURTHER

01:36 - 16.320 YOUR HONOR. THANK YOU.

01:36 - 47.630 >>YES YOUR HONOR THE DEFENSE

01:36 - 48.880 CALLS DOCTOR RIGHT HEAT, THE

01:36 - 49.210 STAND.

01:37 - 04.210 THEY SIT RUNNING FOR

01:37 - 04.650 THE JURY.

01:37 - 05.960 >>GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS

01:37 - 06.540 RIGHT HEAT.

01:37 - 07.810 >>AND ARE YOU A MEDICAL DOCTOR.

01:37 - 09.850 >>YES, AND PACKS A PHYSICIAN

01:37 - 11.520 SPECIALIZING PAIN MANAGEMENT.

01:37 - 12.850 >>ROUGHLY SUMMARIZE YOUR

01:37 - 13.960 EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND TO

01:37 - 14.380 THE JURY.

01:37 - 15.850 >>I RECEIVED A BACHELOR'S

01:37 - 17.250 DEGREE IN BIOLOGY FROM HARVARD

01:37 - 19.310 IN 19 89 IN BOTH AN MD AND A

01:37 - 21.410 PHD UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA

01:37 - 21.530 IN

01:37 - 22.350 1995.

01:37 - 23.830 >>AND HAVE YOU RECEIVED ANY

01:37 - 24.820 SPECIALIZED TRAINING THROUGHOUT

01:37 - 25.270 YOUR CAREER.

01:37 - 27.470 YES, POLLEN INTERNSHIP AND

01:37 - 29.110 RESIDENCY ARE PARTICIPATED IN

01:37 - 30.250 THE FELLOWSHIP YOUR KNOWLEDGE

01:37 - 31.440 IN PAIN MANAGEMENT.

01:37 - 32.830 >>HOW MANY YEARS DID YOU STUDY

01:37 - 33.590 FROM THE BEGINNING OF YOUR

01:37 - 34.770 COLLEGIATE CAREER TO THE END OF

01:37 - 35.410 YOUR FELLOWSHIP.

01:37 - 36.540 >>16 YEARS.

01:37 - 38.620 >>DOCTOR HE PLEASE EXPLAIN PAIN

01:37 - 39.820 MANAGEMENT FOR THE JURY.

01:37 - 41.260 >>WELL PAIN MANAGEMENT IS A

01:37 - 42.570 MEDICAL APPROACH THAT USES

01:37 - 44.540 SCIENCE AN ALTERNATIVE HEALING

01:37 - 45.800 TO STUDY THE PREVENTION

01:37 - 47.110 DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT OF

01:37 - 47.450 PAIN.

01:37 - 48.850 >>YOU KNOW DOCTOR WE TALKED A

01:37 - 50.020 LOT ABOUT YOUR EDUCATIONAL

01:37 - 51.570 BACKGROUND. WE BRITISH SUMMERS,

01:37 - 52.680 YOUR PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

01:37 - 53.110 FOR THE JURY.

01:37 - 54.970 >>I'M THE FOUNDER AND DIRECTOR

01:37 - 56.450 OF THE SACKLER CLINIC MEDICAL

01:37 - 58.280 PAIN MANAGEMENT. I'VE ALSO BEEN

01:37 - 59.430 A CLINICAL PROFESSOR OF

01:37 - 00.980 MEDICINE SINCE 2001.

01:38 - 02.410 >>AND YOU'RE ITCHING TO MAKE

01:38 - 03.770 DECISIONS ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT

01:38 - 04.790 TO PRESCRIBE OPIOIDS TO

01:38 - 05.790 PATIENTS WHO PORTING

01:38 - 06.390 IN PAINT.

01:38 - 07.900 >>YES, I'VE DEALT WITH THESE

01:38 - 09.490 DECISIONS A COUNTLESS NUMBER OF

01:38 - 10.960 TIMES THEIR MAJOR PART OF

01:38 - 11.620 PAIN MANAGEMENT.

01:38 - 13.670 >>AT THIS TIME OUT FOR DOCTOR I

01:38 - 14.740 HE IS AN EXPERT IN PAIN

01:38 - 15.940 MANAGEMENT IN THE PRESCRIPTION

01:38 - 16.980 OF OPIATE MEDICATION.

01:38 - 19.660 >>ANY OBJECTION, I KNOW JACKSON

01:38 - 21.140 YOUR THIS WITNESSES AND WE CALL

01:38 - 23.120 IT THEY GET SO IN 8. YES.

01:38 - 25.150 >>DOCTOR HEY, YOU'RE AN EXPERT

01:38 - 26.270 IN PAIN MANAGEMENT WOULD YOU BE

01:38 - 27.640 ABLE TO GIVE THE JURY A PLAQUE

01:38 - 29.120 AND WHAT IF A MISSION OF PAINT.

01:38 - 29.970 NO

01:38 - 30.730 I CANNOT.

01:38 - 32.470 >>PAIN IS SUBJECTIVE AND

01:38 - 34.100 UNFORTUNATELY EVEN WITH ALL THE

01:38 - 35.190 ADVANCEMENTS. THE MEDICAL

01:38 - 36.570 PROFESSION HAS MADE OVER THE

01:38 - 38.620 YEARS. WE STILL KNOW MACHINES

01:38 - 40.460 ARE DEVICES, SECOND OBJECT WE

01:38 - 42.550 MEASURE PAIN IF WE SUSPECT THAT

01:38 - 44.300 A PATIENT HAS A BROKEN ARM.

01:38 - 46.220 WE CAN X-RAY AN OBJECTIVE WE

01:38 - 47.450 SEE IF THERE'S A FRACTURE OR

01:38 - 49.120 NOT IF WE SUSPECT THAT A

01:38 - 49.480 PATIENT

01:38 - 52.100 HAS CANCER. WE ORDER ECT SKIN

01:38 - 53.420 AN OBJECTIVE WE SEE IF THERE'S

01:38 - 55.690 A TUMOR OR NOT. BUT THIS NOT

01:38 - 56.620 ALWAYS THE CASE

01:38 - 58.560 OFTEN TIMES WE POSITIONS THE

01:38 - 00.340 PATIENTS WERE CLEARLY IN PAIN.

01:39 - 02.020 WE ARE UNABLE TO IDENTIFY

01:39 - 03.990 PERSONS COSTS. WE CALL THIS A

01:39 - 05.700 NEW TACTIC OR PHANTOM PAIN.

01:39 - 07.900 >>WHAT ROLE DO OPIOIDS PLAN

01:39 - 08.740 TREATING THIS PAIN.

01:39 - 10.970 >>OPIOIDS ARE VERY POWERFUL

01:39 - 11.680 MEDICATION FOR

01:39 - 13.460 TREATING PAIN. WELL, I RESPECT

01:39 - 14.490 AGENT CALLED WHEN HIS

01:39 - 15.690 COMMITMENT TO ENDING THE

01:39 - 17.470 OPIOID EPIDEMIC. THERE ARE MANY

01:39 - 19.090 CASES MUCH OPIOIDS ARE

01:39 - 20.330 ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY.

01:39 - 22.800 MEDICATIONS LIKE OXYCODONE ALL

01:39 - 24.420 PEOPLE IN CRIPPLING TO FILL

01:39 - 26.550 TEACHING PAIN TO FUNCTION AGAIN

01:39 - 27.810 AN ATTEMPT TO RETURN TO THEIR

01:39 - 28.620 NORMAL LIVES.

01:39 - 30.350 >>WHO IS IN THE BEST POSITION

01:39 - 31.420 TO MAKE THE DETERMINATION

01:39 - 32.510 WHETHER OR NOT TO PRESCRIBE AN

01:39 - 33.920 OPIOID TO PATIENT IN PAIN.

01:39 - 35.570 THE TREATING PHYSICIAN.

01:39 - 36.990 >>THEY'RE THE ONES WHO SPEND

01:39 - 38.440 THE MOST TIME WITH THE PATIENT

01:39 - 39.920 AND UNDERSTANDING THE BEST.

01:39 - 41.340 THEY HAVE THE TRAINING AND

01:39 - 42.780 EXPERIENCE TO MAKE INFORMED

01:39 - 43.300 DECISION.

01:39 - 45.440 >>DOCTOR EXPLAIN SOME OF THE

01:39 - 46.930 OBSTACLES A PHYSICIAN MIGHT

01:39 - 47.820 FACE WHEN TREATING WITH

01:39 - 48.370 OPIOIDS.

01:39 - 50.520 >>WELL AS A PROFESSOR AS WELL

01:39 - 51.270 AS THE DOCTOR.

01:39 - 52.460 I KNOW THAT THERE'S A

01:39 - 53.800 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN HEAD THE FED

01:39 - 55.850 A CALTEX BOOK SITUATIONS AND

01:39 - 57.160 REAL WORLD EXPERIENCES.

01:39 - 59.180 IT'S EASY FOR ME TO STAND IN

01:39 - 00.660 FRONT OF A CLASSROOM AND TEACH

01:40 - 02.200 THAT DIFFERENT SCENARIOS BUT

01:40 - 03.910 THAT'S NO SUBSTITUTE FOR REAL

01:40 - 06.250 WORLD SITUATIONS. OFTEN TIMES

01:40 - 07.680 DOCTORS HAVE TO MAKE SNAP

01:40 - 09.310 JUDGMENTS WHEN A PATIENT COMES

01:40 - 10.910 IN A CHAIR INTO THEIR CLINIC IN

01:40 - 11.750 OBVIOUS PAIN.

01:40 - 12.980 AND THAT'S WHY IT'S SO

01:40 - 14.650 IMPORTANT FOR A DOCTOR AND A

01:40 - 16.110 PATIENT TO BE HONEST AND

01:40 - 17.910 TRUSTING RELATIONSHIP THAT'S

01:40 - 19.070 SOMETHING THAT GOES SO FAR

01:40 - 20.410 BEYOND WHAT CAN BE TAUGHT IN

01:40 - 21.940 THE CLASSROOM AND ITS DECISION

01:40 - 22.830 THAT ONLY THE DOCTOR

01:40 - 23.380 CAN MAKE.

01:40 - 25.100 >>DOCTOR WHAT MATERIALS HAVE

01:40 - 26.250 YOU REVIEWED IN THIS CASE IN

01:40 - 26.730 ORDER TO FORM

01:40 - 27.440 YOUR CONCLUSIONS.

01:40 - 29.180 >>I REVIEWED ALL THE CASE

01:40 - 30.750 MATERIALS INCLUDING THE INTAKE

01:40 - 31.260 SHE FROM

01:40 - 34.780 12/16/2016 THE PMP LOG AND THE

01:40 - 36.250 STATEMENTS OF FREE SHE FOR

01:40 - 37.850 FRANK KELSEY AND ROEKEL PLAN.

01:40 - 39.790 >>DOCTOR IN YOUR PROFESSIONAL

01:40 - 41.170 MEDICAL OPINION WAS IT

01:40 - 42.510 APPROPRIATE FOR DOCTOR SHAFER

01:40 - 43.790 TO ADMINISTER AN INJECTION OF

01:40 - 44.930 HYDROMORPHONE ON

01:40 - 46.940 12/16/2016.

01:40 - 48.410 >>YES, THIS WAS THE RIGHT

01:40 - 50.050 CHOICE MEDICATION BECAUSE COACH

01:40 - 51.550 HAD EXHIBITED A NEW LEVEL OF

01:40 - 53.390 PAIN KNOWN AS BREAKTHROUGH PAIN

01:40 - 55.000 OR PAYMENT IS BREAKING THROUGH

01:40 - 56.290 HER OTHER MEDICATIONS.

01:40 - 57.570 >>WELL IN YOUR PROFESSIONAL

01:40 - 59.300 MEDICAL OPINION WAS THE DOSAGE

01:40 - 59.600 OF THIS

01:40 - 00.750 INJECTION APPROPRIATE.

01:41 - 03.140 >>YES, THIS DOSAGE WAS A 100%

01:41 - 03.740 LEGAL AN

01:41 - 04.620 FDA APPROVED.

01:41 - 06.620 >>WAS DOCTOR SHAFER REQUIRED TO

01:41 - 08.070 CHECK THE PMP BEFORE

01:41 - 08.890 PRESCRIBING A COACH.

01:41 - 11.010 >>YOU KNOW THIS WAS NOT ILLEGAL

01:41 - 12.650 CRIME AND AT THE TIME AND FROM

01:41 - 13.910 THE START DOCTOR SHAFER WAS

01:41 - 15.490 DISADVANTAGE BECAUSE COACH DID

01:41 - 16.950 NOT MENTION THAT SHE WAS I ANY

01:41 - 18.740 OTHER JOBS LIKE A BENZ AND S P

01:41 - 19.200 ALSO KNOWN

01:41 - 21.580 AS XANAX AND FROM IVY THIS CASE

01:41 - 23.100 I'VE SEEN THAT NURSE KELSEY DID

01:41 - 23.990 NOT MENTION ANY

01:41 - 25.830 OTHER DRUGS. COACH WAS TAKING

01:41 - 27.720 OTHER THAN MOSES NIANTIC CHEAT.

01:41 - 29.230 >>HAVE THE PHYSICIANS

01:41 - 30.530 REQUIREMENTS WHEN TREATING WITH

01:41 - 31.980 OPIATES CHANGED OVER RECENT

01:41 - 32.560 YEARS.

01:41 - 34.600 >>YES, OF COURSE THE WORLD OF

01:41 - 36.230 OPIOIDS AND THE MONTANA LEAST

01:41 - 37.900 DRUGS HAVE BEEN IN A STATE OF

01:41 - 39.490 CONSTANT CHANGE OVER THE LAST

01:41 - 41.660 FEW YEARS. WHAT MAY BE ILLEGAL

01:41 - 43.400 CRIME 8 TODAY MAY NOT HAVE BEEN

01:41 - 44.980 LESS THAN A YEAR AGO THAT WAS

01:41 - 45.780 THE CASE WITH THE PD

01:41 - 46.170 M P.

01:41 - 48.080 >>WELL AT THE TIME WAS DOCTOR

01:41 - 49.460 SHAFER REQUIRED TO ORDER YOUR

01:41 - 50.690 IN SCREENING FOR COACH BACK

01:41 - 51.120 TO THAT.

01:41 - 52.880 >>YOU KNOW AND TO THIS DAY,

01:41 - 54.470 IT'S STILL NOT A LEGAL OR CRIME

01:41 - 55.410 IN A PHYSICIAN'S.

01:41 - 56.790 IN ADDITION TO THIS THERE IS

01:41 - 58.180 NOT MANY SIGNIFICANT RISK

01:41 - 59.590 FACTORS. PRESIDENT COATS SUCH

01:41 - 00.230 AS FAMILY HIS

01:42 - 01.190 SHIP ABUSE.

01:42 - 02.620 >>DOCTOR IN YOUR PROFESSIONAL

01:42 - 03.990 MEDICAL UP IN IT IN YOUR

01:42 - 05.240 PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL EXPERIENCE

01:42 - 06.930 TO PATIENTS NORMALLY EXHIBIT

01:42 - 08.370 PHYSIOLOGICAL SIGNS OF PAIN.

01:42 - 10.540 >>YES PATIENTS WHO ARE IN PAIN

01:42 - 12.380 EXIT, TYPICAL SIGNS OF THIS

01:42 - 14.850 INCLUDING PANIC TO ME NEAR SWAY

01:42 - 16.400 SKIN OR THE EVEN REDUCED

01:42 - 18.470 TO TEARS. MY VIEW THIS CASE

01:42 - 20.120 COACH EXHIBITED MANY OF THE

01:42 - 21.510 TYPICAL SIGNS WITH PATIENTS IN

01:42 - 23.770 PAIN AND 12/16/2016.

01:42 - 25.520 >>DOCTOR HE HAVE YOU FORMED AN

01:42 - 26.900 OPINION TO REASONABLE DEGREE OF

01:42 - 27.870 MEDICAL CERTAINTY

01:42 - 29.540 AS AN EXPERT IN PAIN MANAGEMENT

01:42 - 30.560 IN THE PRESCRIPTION OF OPIATE

01:42 - 32.270 MEDICATION AS TO WHETHER OR NOT

01:42 - 33.310 ALL OF DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S

01:42 - 34.510 ACTIONS AND HER TREATMENT WITH

01:42 - 36.110 COACH MCADOO ACCORDING TO

01:42 - 38.140 BE ACCEPTED MEDICAL STANDARDS

01:42 - 40.050 AT THE TIME. YES, I HAVE AND

01:42 - 41.470 WHAT IS YOUR OPINION. DOCTOR

01:42 - 42.710 SHAFER WAS NOT REQUIRED TO

01:42 - 43.840 CHECK THE PDA PEOPLE FOR

01:42 - 45.050 PRESCRIBING MEDICATION.

01:42 - 46.730 >>SHE WAS NOT REQUIRED TO

01:42 - 47.940 CONDUCT DURING TESTING,

01:42 - 49.270 ESPECIALLY BECAUSE THERE'S NOT

01:42 - 50.060 MANY SIGNIFICANT

01:42 - 51.990 RISK FACTORS AND SHE MINISTER

01:42 - 53.580 AN INJECTION OF HYDROMORPHONE

01:42 - 54.800 THOSE FDA APPROVED.

01:42 - 56.540 ALL THESE ACTIONS BY DOCTOR

01:42 - 58.080 SHAFER INCLUDE JUST CASE WERE A

01:42 - 59.640 100% APPROPRIATE MEDICALLY

01:42 - 01.270 ACCEPTABLE. THANK YOUR HONOR,

01:43 - 02.990 NO FURTHER QUESTIONS THE GIFT.

01:43 - 11.810 >>I GUESS YOU NEVER

01:43 - 14.920 SEE UNIT. AFTERNOON DOCTOR

01:43 - 16.120 HARRY DIDN'T AFTERNOON.

01:43 - 17.590 NOW I'D LIKE TO TALK BRIEFLY

01:43 - 18.590 ABOUT A FEW THINGS HE SAID ON

01:43 - 20.610 FOR STUFF YOU SAID THAT YOU

01:43 - 21.750 WERE EDUCATED IN PAIN

01:43 - 24.310 MANAGEMENT FOR 16 YEARS, BUT

01:43 - 25.330 THAT'S NOT TRUE IS IT.

01:43 - 26.490 >>WELL THAT INCLUDES MY

01:43 - 28.580 FELLOWSHIP IN MAJOR CHIPS, I'M

01:43 - 30.000 SORRY BUT I BELIEVE YOU

01:43 - 31.400 ACTUALLY INCLUDING THAT YOU'RE

01:43 - 32.810 ONLY AS GOOD FOR 12 YEARS IS

01:43 - 33.250 NOT TRUE.

01:43 - 36.770 >>WHAT OPPOSING COUNSEL

01:43 - 39.620 REFERRED TO OF THIS ONE IS

01:43 - 42.250 MARKED UP, BUT. I

01:43 - 44.520 VIEW IT. IT'S A EXHIBIT 9 KNOW

01:43 - 45.750 THAT WHEN WE HAVE A COPY JUST

01:43 - 46.540 ONE OF THEM THAT

01:43 - 48.610 THANK YOU. SO ISN'T IT TRUE

01:43 - 50.210 THAT WERE ACTUALLY ENGAGED IN

01:43 - 50.270 THE

01:43 - 50.780 12 YEARS.

01:43 - 52.080 >>WELL THAT INCLUDES MANY

01:43 - 53.770 INTERNSHIPS MY FELLOWSHIPS IN

01:43 - 55.510 ANY OTHER JOBS AND INSTRUCTION

01:43 - 57.340 I COMPLETED MY EDUCATION,

01:43 - 59.570 12 YEARS NOT 16 THAT WELL I

01:43 - 01.260 INCLUDE FELLOWSHIP LAND CATION

01:44 - 02.740 THAT'S INCLUDED IN THE 12

01:44 - 04.030 YEARS. I DON'T MEAN TO GET HUNG

01:44 - 05.690 UP ON THIS, BUT IT THAT'S

01:44 - 07.170 AN ANSWER. I DON'T BELIEVE IT

01:44 - 08.440 WAS ANSWERED FOR IT.

01:44 - 12.440 >>THE AND DON'T BELIEVE

01:44 - 14.140 IT'S BEEN ASKED AND ANSWERED

01:44 - 16.090 CLEARLY AT AND WILLING

01:44 - 17.510 TO OVERRULE YOUR OBJECTION TO

01:44 - 18.590 ASK THAT YOU REPHRASE YOUR

01:44 - 21.440 QUESTION AS WELL TO CLEAR YOU

01:44 - 22.520 THAT JUST TO CLARIFY

01:44 - 25.400 >>YOUR EDUCATION HARVARD BEGAN

01:44 - 27.420 IN 1989, AND YOU COMPLETED YOUR

01:44 - 29.150 FELLOWSHIP IN NEUROLOGY AND

01:44 - 30.770 PAIN MANAGEMENT IN 2001 THAT'S

01:44 - 32.140 TOLD US THAT YES AUGUST,

01:44 - 33.470 INCLUDING EDUCATION, BUT I

01:44 - 35.150 INCLUDE MY JOB INSTRUCTION ANY

01:44 - 37.080 OTHER RECEIVED IN THAT YEAR

01:44 - 38.330 THAT JUST GOT BACK FROM INJURY

01:44 - 40.120 NEXT YOU SAID SOMETHING ON

01:44 - 40.470 DIRECT YOU

01:44 - 43.480 SAID THAT MEDICATION DOCTOR

01:44 - 44.540 CHIEF ARE PRESCRIBED YOU

01:44 - 46.010 BELIEVE WAS THE RIGHT CHOICE.

01:44 - 47.340 YES I DO, BUT DON'T YOU BELIEVE

01:44 - 48.200 THAT THAT INJECTION WAS A

01:44 - 50.410 MISTAKE. WELL IT WAS PROBABLY

01:44 - 51.670 NOT THE BEST PRACTICE AT

01:44 - 53.910 THE TIME. BUT SINCE IT WAS FT

01:44 - 55.330 PROVED IT WAS WHEN WITHIN THE

01:44 - 56.860 LEGAL LIMIT HER PRESCRIBING THE

01:44 - 58.050 MEDICATION WAS CERTAINLY NOT

01:44 - 00.090 CRIMINAL OR BAD IT ACTUALLY BE

01:45 - 01.290 BELIEVE WAS A MISTAKE RIGHT.

01:45 - 03.510 YES, BUT AGAIN IT WAS NOT

01:45 - 04.650 CERTAINLY NOT CRIMINAL FOR HER

01:45 - 05.920 TO DO THIS BECAUSE IT WAS FDA

01:45 - 07.600 APPROVED. NOW A DECADE. I'D

01:45 - 08.720 LIKE TO BRIEFLY TALK ABOUT SOME

01:45 - 10.080 OF FROM SOME OF YOUR WORK

01:45 - 11.220 EXPERIENCE, I KNOW YOU'VE GIVEN

01:45 - 11.830 A TALK

01:45 - 13.400 PREVIOUSLY ADVOCATING AGAINST

01:45 - 14.180 THE RESTRICTION OF THE

01:45 - 15.240 PRESCRIPTION OF FENTANYL

01:45 - 17.160 CRACKED. YES AT A NEW SPONSOR

01:45 - 19.210 THAT TALK THAT WAS PRODUCED FOR

01:45 - 20.700 US TO TICKLES BUT THEY ONLY

01:45 - 22.800 SPONSORED THIS TALK I'M

01:45 - 24.410 IT WAS THEY ASKED ME TO COME

01:45 - 25.840 AND GET MY UNBIASED OPINION I

01:45 - 27.240 WAS NOT PAID FOR THIS TALK IT

01:45 - 28.400 WAS JUST ME INFORMING THE

01:45 - 29.980 COMMUNITY OF OPIOIDS BUT THEY

01:45 - 31.280 DIDN'T ONLY SPONSOR FOR YOU

01:45 - 32.440 THAT TALK THEY'VE SPOTTED YOU

01:45 - 34.150 AND OTHER OCCASIONS. CRACKS YES

01:45 - 35.470 THEY HAVE, BUT I WAS NOT PAID

01:45 - 36.690 FOR THESE TALKS I WAS ASKED TO

01:45 - 38.040 GIVE THEM BIASED OPINION YOUR

01:45 - 40.040 RESPONSE OR TRACKED. YES, BUT

01:45 - 41.950 NOT PAYDAY JUST SPONSORED THE

01:45 - 43.420 EVENT YOU'RE SPONSORED THE NOT

01:45 - 45.550 PAID. THEY SPONSOR THE EVENT AT

01:45 - 46.970 ME, OK AND FOR THE MURRAY

01:45 - 48.510 GIVING A TALK ADVOCATE

01:45 - 50.850 TO CITY OPINION THAT OPIOIDS

01:45 - 52.430 ARE TOOL MALIGNED UNFAIRLY.

01:45 - 54.640 YES. THANK YOU. NOW ON TO THE

01:45 - 54.820 DAY

01:45 - 56.790 IN QUESTION. KELLY MACK YOU

01:45 - 58.260 WALK INTO PAIN AWAY FROM ACTING

01:45 - 58.860 WITH EXTREME

01:45 - 00.420 PAIN, CORRECT. YES, SHE DID SHE

01:46 - 01.600 EXHIBIT MANY OF THE TYPICAL

01:46 - 03.160 SIGNS LIKE SWEATY SKIN AND

01:46 - 04.320 SHAKING GRIP OF THE SIGNS OF

01:46 - 05.480 EXTREME PAIN ARE SIMILAR TO

01:46 - 06.950 THOSE OF WITHDRAWAL EXCUSE ME

01:46 - 08.750 WITHDRAW OR DRUG ABUSE CRACKS

01:46 - 10.340 YES, THEY ARE, BUT AGAIN THIS

01:46 - 11.900 IS FOR THE DOCTOR TO DETERMINE

01:46 - 12.890 THEY USE THEIR TRAINING AND

01:46 - 14.280 EXPERIENCE IN DOCTOR SCHIEFFER

01:46 - 15.960 CONCLUDED ON THIS DAY WITH THE

01:46 - 17.740 SCIENCE THAT COACH PRESENTED

01:46 - 19.230 THAT IT WAS IN FACT PAIN

01:46 - 20.380 BECAUSE THE SIGNS ARE VERY

01:46 - 21.570 SIMILAR THREAT. THE DOCTOR THAT

01:46 - 23.160 THEY WERE RISK FACTORS THAT IS

01:46 - 24.740 MCADOO ABUSING DRUGS SCRIPT.

01:46 - 26.370 YES, BUT AGAIN THIS IS FOR THE

01:46 - 26.980 DOCTOR TO

01:46 - 29.980 ASSESS IT. THESE RISK FACTORS

01:46 - 31.260 IT'S A COST BENEFIT AND NOW

01:46 - 32.600 STARTED OUT THESE RISK FACTORS

01:46 - 34.320 IN WITNESSES A LOT OF THINGS TO

01:46 - 35.230 ANSWER YOUR OWN OF THE

01:46 - 36.260 WITNESSES UNTIL A BRIEF

01:46 - 37.630 EXPLANATION THAT POLICE UNITS

01:46 - 40.070 JOY OUT OF IT. I'M

01:46 - 41.100 WAY TOO.

01:46 - 42.440 >>ISIS EVOLUTION THAT HER

01:46 - 43.650 FINISH YOUR SENTENCE WE CAN

01:46 - 45.150 REVISIT THIS IT BECAUSE I KNEW

01:46 - 45.970 ONE ANOTHER ISSUE.

01:46 - 48.350 >>IS A COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS

01:46 - 49.820 AGAIN IT'S FOR THE DOCTOR TO

01:46 - 51.390 DETERMINE IF THE RISK FACTORS

01:46 - 52.660 ARE WORTH PRESCRIBING OPIATES

01:46 - 54.430 OR NOT AND THESE RISK FACTORS

01:46 - 54.850 INCLUDE THE

01:46 - 56.290 FACT THAT MS. MACKIE WAS A

01:46 - 58.000 LONG-TERM OPIATE USE AIRCRAFT.

01:46 - 59.470 YES, IT DID. BUT DOCTOR

01:46 - 00.720 SCHIEFFER DID DETERMINE WITH

01:47 - 01.340 HER TRAINING IN

01:47 - 03.010 THIS CASE THAT THE BENEFITS

01:47 - 04.370 THAT OPIOIDS WOULD OUTWEIGH

01:47 - 05.520 THIS RESPECT IT RIGHT AND THE

01:47 - 06.410 FACT THAT HIS BACK HE WAS

01:47 - 07.550 PAYING CASH, CORRECT.

01:47 - 09.120 WELL SHE DID NOT PAYING CASH

01:47 - 10.300 ALL THE TIME SHE DIDN'T USE HER

01:47 - 11.950 INSURANCE HAS INDICATED AN APD

01:47 - 13.110 I'M FEELING THAT HER PAYING IN

01:47 - 14.840 CASH, HOWEVER, OFTEN HAPPENED

01:47 - 16.240 WAS A RESPECTED CORRECT.

01:47 - 17.730 YES, IT WAS BUT SHE DIDN'T DO

01:47 - 19.010 IT ALL THE TIME YOU DESPITE

01:47 - 20.040 THESE RISK FACTORS DOCTOR

01:47 - 21.740 SHAFER NIGHT OR CHECK THE PMP

01:47 - 23.290 NOR DID A URINE TEST CORRECT.

01:47 - 25.190 NO SHE DID NOT SHE DID CONDUCT

01:47 - 26.610 IN TAKE SHE AND AGAIN SHE

01:47 - 28.570 BELIEVED IN THAT TRUST IN BOND

01:47 - 29.620 BETWEEN THE PATIENT AND THE

01:47 - 31.170 DOCTOR AND SINCE ALL THESE

01:47 - 31.950 THINGS WENT OUT WE WERE

01:47 - 33.460 PREGNANT AT THE TIME HER NOT

01:47 - 35.070 DOING SO CERTAINLY NOT CRIMINAL

01:47 - 36.280 RIGHT THEY WERE LEGAL, BUT YOU

01:47 - 37.360 BELIEVE THAT IT WAS NOT GOOD

01:47 - 38.700 PRACTICE TO DO NEITHER OF THESE

01:47 - 40.030 THINGS CORRECT YOU KNOW IT'S

01:47 - 42.030 PROBABLY NOT THE BEST BUT

01:47 - 43.860 AGAIN, A SENSE ALL THESE THINGS

01:47 - 45.330 WERE LEGAL CRIME AND DOCTOR

01:47 - 46.680 SHAFER WAS ABLE TO DO THESE

01:47 - 48.210 MANY OTHER FISH ISN'T POSITIONS

01:47 - 49.630 TO DO THIS. SO CERTAINLY NOT

01:47 - 50.690 CRIMINAL FOR HER NOT TO DO

01:47 - 51.780 THESE THINGS RIGHT NOW WITH

01:47 - 53.160 REGARDS TO THE PMP YOU BELIEVE

01:47 - 53.790 IT'S ONE OF THE MOST

01:47 - 55.240 SIGNIFICANT MEDICAL INNOVATIONS

01:47 - 56.760 OF THE PAST 10 YEARS, CORRECT.

01:47 - 58.330 YES I DO TELL THE DOCTOR WHAT

01:47 - 59.440 OTHER PRESCRIPTIONS A PATIENT

01:47 - 01.480 HAS GOT YES AND HAD DOCTOR

01:48 - 03.320 SHAFER CHECKED THE PMP HE WOULD

01:48 - 04.720 HAVE FOUND THAT MS. MCCABE WAS

01:48 - 05.010 ONS

01:48 - 07.180 AN EXTRACT. YES, SHE WOULD HAVE

01:48 - 08.390 BUT SINCE IS A VERY NEW

01:48 - 09.600 TECHNOLOGY DOCTOR SCHIPPER

01:48 - 11.100 STORYLINE HERE IN TAKE SHEETS

01:48 - 12.490 WHICH WAS VERY COMMON PRACTICE

01:48 - 14.190 FOR THE PMP CAME INTO PLACE IN

01:48 - 16.470 2015 RIGHT NOW DOCTOR HATE

01:48 - 18.140 WE'VE ESTABLISHED THAT

01:48 - 19.400 DOCTOR SHAFER NEITHER CHECK THE

01:48 - 21.410 PMP NOR DID THE YEAR IN SPAIN,

01:48 - 22.630 BUT THE DOCTOR SHE FOR AT LEAST

01:48 - 24.260 ASKED DIRECTLY WHETHER OR NOT

01:48 - 25.950 MS. MCCABE WAS ON XANAX

01:48 - 28.370 NO BUT SHE DID REVIEW AND TAKE

01:48 - 29.950 SHE AND WAS SHE A DELEGATE TO

01:48 - 31.380 HER NURSE AND NOTHING WAS

01:48 - 32.460 LISTENING IN TAKE SHE AND

01:48 - 33.540 DOCTOR HE HAD YOU MADE A

01:48 - 34.740 MISTAKE LIKE NOT ASKING

01:48 - 36.240 DIRECTLY ABOUT BENZODIAZEPINE

01:48 - 37.810 HE WOULD BE HORRIFIED WOULDN'T

01:48 - 39.960 YOU. YES, I WOULD, BUT I DON'T

01:48 - 41.150 BELIEVE THIS IS DOCTOR SHE

01:48 - 42.310 FIRST FAILURE IN THIS CASE

01:48 - 43.410 BECAUSE SHE HAD REVIEWED THE

01:48 - 44.530 ANTIQUE SHEET WHICH YOU DON'T

01:48 - 46.440 GET TO AN AIRSTRIP UPI HARF I

01:48 - 48.650 HAD YOU MY MISTAKE. YES, BUT I

01:48 - 50.160 DON'T PUT THIS ON DOCTOR SHAFER

01:48 - 50.890 IN THIS CASE

01:48 - 53.310 AND FINALLY DOCTOR HATE AS

01:48 - 54.680 DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S PRESCRIPTION

01:48 - 55.800 RATES TRENDED ABOVE THE

01:48 - 57.280 NATIONAL MEDIAN YOU BELIEVE

01:48 - 58.720 THAT IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO RULE

01:48 - 59.900 OUT EXPLANATIONS THAT ARE

01:48 - 01.990 CRIMINAL ACTS. YES, BUT IT'S

01:49 - 03.530 ALSO IMPOSSIBLE TO RULE OUT

01:49 - 06.420 EXPLANATIONS THAT ARE NOT

01:49 - 06.940 INCLUDING

01:49 - 09.080 THAT HER. THE PRESCRIPTION RATE

01:49 - 10.030 WENT UP BECAUSE SHE WAS

01:49 - 11.290 CHEATING BLUE COLLAR WORKERS

01:49 - 12.710 WHICH ARE WORKPLACE INJURIES

01:49 - 13.930 THAT THE MORE OPIATES OR JUST

01:49 - 14.820 TO BE CLEAR DOCTOR HAD IT'S

01:49 - 16.490 IMPOSSIBLE TO RULE OUT CRIMINAL

01:49 - 18.690 EXPLANATIONS CRACKED. YES AS

01:49 - 20.320 WELL AS SHE WAS CHEATING BLUE

01:49 - 21.830 COLLAR WORKERS NOTHING FOR THE

01:49 - 22.820 HONOR. THANK YOU.

01:49 - 29.590 >>THE ONLY DIRECTOR ON THE

01:49 - 47.820 THAT CONCLUDED.

01:49 - 49.880 DEFENSE CASE. YES, YOUR HONOR

01:49 - 50.810 AT THIS TIME, THE DEFENSE

01:49 - 51.330 RESTS.

01:49 - 57.080 HER A DAME SEEN POSING.

01:50 - 09.750 >>OPPOSING COUNSEL. MEMBERS OF

01:50 - 10.160 THE JURY.

01:50 - 11.830 YOU MAY RECALL THAT IN HER

01:50 - 13.440 OPENING STATEMENT MY CO-COUNSEL

01:50 - 15.080 MORE IN PALMER SPOKE ABOUT

01:50 - 16.550 PEOPLE FACING VERY

01:50 - 18.550 DIFFICULT SITUATIONS. USING

01:50 - 19.990 THEIR TRAINING AND EXPERIENCE

01:50 - 21.320 TO ASSESS THEIR SURROUNDINGS

01:50 - 22.600 AND FOR THE BEST JUDGMENT ON

01:50 - 23.320 HOW TO PROCEED.

01:50 - 26.690 WHO AMONG US IS GOING TO SECOND

01:50 - 27.960 GUESS THE DECISION OF A

01:50 - 30.020 FIREFIGHTER. RACING INTO A

01:50 - 32.710 BURNING SKYSCRAPER WHO AMONG US

01:50 - 34.040 IS GOING TO SECOND GUESS THE

01:50 - 35.850 DECISION OF THE SOLDIER DRIVING

01:50 - 37.530 A VEHICLE. DONNA FOREIGN WROTE

01:50 - 39.190 WHO AMONG US IS GOING TO SECOND

01:50 - 41.200 GUESS THE DECISION OF A PILOT

01:50 - 43.590 FLYING OBJECT THAT LOSES ENGINE

01:50 - 45.090 POWER. ON DECEMBER

01:50 - 47.630 16TH, 2016 DOCTOR SHAFER FACED

01:50 - 49.060 A VERY DIFFICULT SITUATION.

01:50 - 50.710 USING HER MEDICAL TRAINING AND

01:50 - 52.440 EXPERIENCE SHE TENDED TO REALLY

01:50 - 54.180 BE A TO PATIENTS PAIN. HER

01:50 - 55.730 MOTIVE WAS COMPASSION HER

01:50 - 57.690 JUDGMENT WAS CONSISTENT

01:50 - 59.100 WITH THE STANDARDS ACCEPTED BY

01:50 - 00.290 RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF THE

01:51 - 02.360 MEDICAL PROFESSION. THE DEATH

01:51 - 04.130 OF COACH MCADOO IS VERY

01:51 - 05.720 UNFORTUNATE AND WE MAY DEBATE

01:51 - 07.090 WHETHER OR NOT DOCTOR SHAFER

01:51 - 08.560 PROVIDED THE BEST CARE.

01:51 - 10.420 DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S ACTIONS ARE

01:51 - 11.600 CLEARLY NOT CRIMINAL.

01:51 - 13.630 NOW MEMBERS OF THE JURY

01:51 - 14.880 FAIRNESS DICTATES THEY SHOULD

01:51 - 15.760 NOT JUDGE MIKE LINE WITH THE

01:51 - 16.080 BENEFIT

01:51 - 17.850 OF HINDSIGHT. EXAMINE DOCTOR

01:51 - 18.840 SCHAEFER'S ACTIONS UNDER THE

01:51 - 20.530 CIRCUMSTANCES THAT SHE FACED AT

01:51 - 22.380 THE TIME AND A CERTAIN MEDICAL

01:51 - 24.200 LAWS AND PROCEDURES AS THEY

01:51 - 25.320 EXISTED AT THE TIME.

01:51 - 27.150 NOW THE PROSECUTION HAS THE

01:51 - 28.460 BURDEN OF PROVING TO BEYOND A

01:51 - 29.380 REASONABLE DOUBT THAT CRIMINAL

01:51 - 31.090 CHARGE THINK OF REASONABLE

01:51 - 31.830 DOUBT IN THIS WAY

01:51 - 33.630 AS YOU'RE LEAVING YOUR HOUSE IN

01:51 - 34.820 THE MORNING AND YOU'RE PULLING

01:51 - 35.000 OUT OF

01:51 - 37.020 YOUR DRIVEWAY. YOU QUESTION

01:51 - 38.570 WHETHER OR NOT YOU BROUGHT THAT

01:51 - 40.070 CAN DO IN YOUR KITCHEN. YOU

01:51 - 41.930 STOP YOU HESITATE, BUT

01:51 - 43.630 ULTIMATELY YOU GO BACK IN JUST

01:51 - 45.140 A DOUBLE CHECKED THAT IS

01:51 - 46.630 REASONABLE DOUBT AND AFTER THAT

01:51 - 47.790 IT'S NICE DELIBERATIONS YOU

01:51 - 49.790 HAVE ANY RESULTS OUT YOU MUST

01:51 - 51.410 FIND OUT SHE FOR NOT GUILTY.

01:51 - 53.560 THE MILITARY. LET'S LOOK AT

01:51 - 54.830 WHAT EVIDENCE THE PROSECUTION

01:51 - 56.020 FAILED FRESH TONIGHT,

01:51 - 57.580 THE PROSECUTION HAS THE BURDEN

01:51 - 58.760 OF PROVING TO BEYOND A

01:51 - 00.030 REASONABLE DOUBT, THE DOCTOR

01:52 - 01.390 SHAFER EITHER ACTED IN BAD

01:52 - 03.100 FAITH OR NOT WITH ACCORDING TO

01:52 - 04.140 SPONSOR A SEGMENT OF THE

01:52 - 06.670 MEDICAL PROFESSION PROVIDED NO

01:52 - 09.220 TESTIMONY FROM ANY POSITIONS.

01:52 - 11.280 THE ONLY 2 DOCTORS WHO

01:52 - 12.870 TESTIFIED HERE TONIGHT WHAT THE

01:52 - 14.860 DEFENSE EXPERT DOCTOR, I HATE

01:52 - 16.710 AND THE DEFENDANT HERSELF.

01:52 - 19.460 SCHIEFFER THE PROSECUTION ALSO

01:52 - 21.140 FAILED RIDE WITH AN AUTOPSY

01:52 - 23.130 REPORT WITH ANY BLOOD TESTING.

01:52 - 25.240 NOW IT IS UNDISPUTED AND WE

01:52 - 26.650 AGREE THAT COACH MCADOO

01:52 - 27.890 DIED DUE TO AN ADVERSE

01:52 - 28.940 INTERACTION BETWEEN IS AN

01:52 - 30.530 EXPERT TRY BY DOCTOR HAMBURG

01:52 - 32.090 AND OPRAH'S PRESCRIBED BY

01:52 - 33.700 DOCTOR SHAFER THE MEMBERS OF

01:52 - 35.080 THE JURY ASK YOURSELF.

01:52 - 36.440 WHAT ARE THE LEVELS OF THE

01:52 - 37.810 DRUGS FOUND IN COACH MAC THESE

01:52 - 39.090 BODY WHEN SHE'S DECEASED.

01:52 - 41.710 NOW THE DEFENSE HAS NO BURDEN

01:52 - 43.580 OF PROOF. WE PRESENTED 3

01:52 - 45.440 WITNESSES TONIGHT. FIRST YOU

01:52 - 47.320 HEARD FROM SCHAEFER WHICH WAS

01:52 - 49.210 ON DECEMBER 16TH 2016.

01:52 - 50.990 COACH MCADOO CAME TO SHOWING

01:52 - 52.970 EXTRA GREEN SIGNS. A

01:52 - 55.000 BREAKTHROUGH PAIN SWEATING

01:52 - 56.810 SHAKING AND EVEN POINT OUT HER

01:52 - 58.930 HAIR IN PAIN. HER MOTIVE WAS TO

01:52 - 00.280 ALLEVIATE HER PATIENTS PAIN.

01:53 - 02.530 NEXT YOU HEARD FROM SAO ADDED

01:53 - 04.340 WHO TOLD YOU DOCTOR SHE PURRS

01:53 - 06.080 FINANCIAL PROBLEMS BUT READ BY

01:53 - 07.760 THE PROSECUTION HAS SOME SORT

01:53 - 10.280 OF EVIL FORCE COMPELLING HER

01:53 - 12.940 FOR CASH FLOW. WE'RE WELL

01:53 - 14.300 BEHIND HER BY THE 2ND HALF OF

01:53 - 16.540 2016. AND LAST, BUT NOT LEAST

01:53 - 17.950 YOU HEARD FROM DOCTOR I HATE A

01:53 - 19.020 LEADING PAIN MANAGEMENT

01:53 - 20.010 SPECIALIST FOR THE

01:53 - 21.570 COMMONWEALTH. BUT WHAT YOUR

01:53 - 22.890 DOCTOR SCHAEFER'S ACTIONS WERE

01:53 - 24.680 PERFECTLY LEGAL AND WITHIN A

01:53 - 25.860 RESPONSIBLE SEGMENT OF THE

01:53 - 28.830 MEDICAL PROFESSION. NOW MEMBERS

01:53 - 30.330 OF THE JURY. I ASK YOU.

01:53 - 32.510 PAY CLOSE ATTENTION TO

01:53 - 34.540 THE CIRCUMSTANCES SURROUNDING

01:53 - 36.560 THE DEATH OF COACH MCADOO ON

01:53 - 39.020 DECEMBER, 1620 16, PUSH BACK

01:53 - 40.540 AND WAS FOUND IN HER APARTMENT

01:53 - 42.160 THE SLUMPED OVER IN HER CHAIR.

01:53 - 44.280 SURROUNDING HER BODY WERE PILL

01:53 - 45.190 BOTTLES, DIFFERENT

01:53 - 46.700 PRESCRIPTIONS BY DIFFERENT

01:53 - 48.560 DOCTORS. MOST OF WHICH WERE ALL

01:53 - 50.910 EMPTY. BY HER BODY,

01:53 - 53.000 A TROPHY, A SYMBOL OF HER

01:53 - 55.790 FORMER, YET DISTANT FOR IT.

01:53 - 58.890 WHAT DO THESE CIRCUMSTANCES

01:53 - 00.110 TELL YOU ABOUT THE DEATH OF

01:54 - 00.840 COACH MCADOO.

01:54 - 04.150 THE OPIOID CRISIS IN AMERICA

01:54 - 06.340 CAN NOT BE SOLVED BY UNFAIRLY

01:54 - 07.510 TARGETING A WELL-MEANING

01:54 - 09.940 POSITION LIKE A FIREFIGHTER, A

01:54 - 11.860 SOLDIER AND A PILOT DOCTOR

01:54 - 13.560 SHAFER USE TO MEDICAL TRAINING

01:54 - 15.500 AND EXPERIENCE TO RELIEVE HER

01:54 - 17.600 PATIENT'S PAIN. AN ACT OF

01:54 - 19.930 COMPASSION IS NOT A CRIME AND

01:54 - 21.060 THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED TO

01:54 - 23.300 TONIGHT COMPELS YOU TO RETURN A

01:54 - 25.810 VERDICT OF NOT GUILTY. THANK

01:54 - 25.960 YOU.

01:54 - 48.220 OPPOSING COUNSEL MEMBERS OF THE

01:54 - 50.070 JURY. THEY HAVE FACED COURT.

01:54 - 52.750 TODAY YOU HAVE HEARD THE CASE

01:54 - 52.990 OF

01:54 - 53.760 RAY SCHAEFER.

01:54 - 56.010 >>A PAIN MANAGEMENT SPECIALIST

01:54 - 57.720 CHARGED WITH DRUG DELIVERY

01:54 - 58.980 RESULTING IN THE DEATHS

01:54 - 00.860 ABOUT OF A BELOVED HIGH SCHOOL

01:55 - 02.460 BASKETBALL COACH WON'T HAVE THE

01:55 - 03.090 MCADOO.

01:55 - 05.300 NOW THE COMMONWEALTH HAVE THE

01:55 - 06.590 BURDEN OF PROOF AND TODAY'S

01:55 - 08.420 CASE WHICH MEANS WE NEEDED TO

01:55 - 10.150 PROVE TO YOU BEYOND A

01:55 - 11.850 REASONABLE DOUBT THAT IN

01:55 - 13.410 TREATING MS. MCADOO THE

01:55 - 15.460 DESCENDANT EITHER DID NOT ACT

01:55 - 16.420 IN GOOD FACE.

01:55 - 17.240 >>OR.

01:55 - 19.060 >>ACTED IN A MANNER NOT

01:55 - 21.450 ACCEPTED BY RESPONSIBLE SECTION

01:55 - 21.640 OF THE

01:55 - 22.810 MEDICAL PROFESSION.

01:55 - 24.580 >>AND WE ARE CONFIDENT THAT

01:55 - 25.750 WHEN YOU REVIEW THE EVIDENCE

01:55 - 27.550 PRESENTED TODAY. YOU'LL

01:55 - 28.790 CONCLUDE THAT WE HAVE MET THAT

01:55 - 30.520 BURDEN SHOWING THAT THE

01:55 - 31.970 DEFENDANT WAS UNDER TOO MUCH

01:55 - 34.010 PRESSURE PRESCRIBING TOO MANY

01:55 - 36.060 OPIOIDS AND TAKING TOO FEW

01:55 - 38.130 PRECAUTIONS. LET'S REVIEW THAT

01:55 - 38.930 EVIDENCE.

01:55 - 41.360 YOU HEARD MISS KELSEY TELL YOU

01:55 - 43.150 THAT DESPERATE TO RESTART HER